Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Record Average Car Payments, VinFast Dealer Count Shrinks, The Social Media Anti-Trend
Transcript
- 0:01Wednesday, December 10th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm with these two guys again. We got Michael Serwack- Michael on my left... Kyle Rock- Kyle now is here on my left...
- 0:08on my left And we are in Syracuse- And we are in Syracuse- New York... New York for some very important- For some very important- Very important... very important- It's so important. We're- I'm, I'm- It's so important...
- 0:16struggling with the fact- It's so important... I'm struggling with the fact that- Did I get the, did I get the date wrong? The minute you said, "With these two guys," both Michael and I went.
- 0:23[laughs] I did realize you were struggling. You can't see us. It was like, it was so identical. You know what the funny part is, is that, like, this close, this close. It was this close to being Goons, not Guys.
- 0:34Ah, if we would've done that- And now, based on your reaction, I probably should've- We- sh- you probably should've said Goons... I probably should've said Goons It's okay. We're here for some important meetings.
- 0:41We are hanging out with our team, and we're setting the intention for the entirety of 2026. The More Than Cars team obviously means so much to the industry. We hope, we believe.
- 0:49Um, and we're calling people to this More Than Cars mindset. Uh, but it also means calling our team, and so we're setting intention.
- 0:55We got to celebrate yesterday, uh, be with the team, eat food, do presents, play games, all of that. But, uh, I'm excited about today and, and getting this team ready to serve the industry well, so yeah.
- 1:07You're supposed to say something now, Michael. Yeah, that's the one, two, now you say stuff. Okay. We're, we, we come in, uh- You think the guy's a professional. [laughs] He's done more podcasts than us.
- 1:16I was like, "They said it all." Yeah. "They said it all." Well, you know what it, it has me thinking about is the level of intentionality you need to put into team meetings to make sure that everybody's aligned. Yeah.
- 1:25Uh, often what happens in organizations is you like to think you're the tip of a spear, but really you're, you, you scatter. It's like somebody sets an intention and then everyone goes.
- 1:35So I'm looking forward to being here with the team today to make sure that we are all coming together, that all roads are aligned- Mm...
- 1:41and that everybody understands the purpose and the mission of what we're about to accomplish in 2026. Yeah, but we have some news to talk about today. Let's get into it.
- 1:49We're gonna talk about car payments, topic of conversation. VinFast, uh, shrinking their dealer count, and, uh, a little, little, uh, little PDF that we've been paying attention to- Yeah...
- 1:58from VaynerMedia talking about trends in 2026. But first, uh, we wanna thank our friends at Mia for being the sponsor of today's show. Uh, there are few things in life that are worth- worse than dealership hold music.
- 2:09You know it, I know it. Somewhere Neil Diamond knows it. [laughs] That's why Mia exists. She answers every call instantly. No menus, no trees, no pan flute covers of Sweet Caroline. I think Michael could do that.
- 2:21[laughs] With under two seconds of latency, Mia is the fastest, most human-sounding AI in the industry.
- 2:26She integrates with over 35 dealer systems, books appointments, checks inventory, and helps real customers in real time, all without putting anyone on hold. We've all heard it. "Can you hold for just a moment?" Oh. No.
- 2:39Oh. [laughs] Dealers can lose up to 50% of their inbound calls due to missed calls, long hold times, and overwhelmed staff, and Mia fixes all of that. Your CSI goes up, your stress goes down, and the pan flute retires.
- 2:51Doo, doo, doo, doo, doo. Doo, doo, doo, doo. And copyright. Done. No, no, we're not getting flagged for that. Can't copyright that. We're not getting flagged for that. [laughs] Okay, let's talk about some news.
- 2:59New vehicle payments hit a November record at $760, but underneath the headlines, several affordability pressures are actually starting to ease. Uh, we haven't said that in quite a year. Wow.
- 3:10Softer interest rates, new strong, uh, used car values are helping c- cushion buyers as the market normalizes. Rates dipping to 6.1%. Robust used car values are keeping trade and equity near historic highs now. Mm.
- 3:23Buyers paid just 89% of sticker on average, which is an improvement from last year's 90%. Dealers' profits stay steady at $2,161 per vehicle, showing some stability.
- 3:35However, negative equity rose to 27% of all trades, and lease expirations are down 15% year over year, and 50% since 2023. Wow. Here's JD Power's, uh, Thomas King.
- 3:48He said, quote, "How aggressively manufacturers choose to adjust discounting and promotional activity during December will be critical in shaping the close of 2025," and we are just about 20-ish days away. Wow.
- 4:01I mean, the, the big one here for me is the lease expirations that are dropping. Uh, we, we knew that this was coming. This time was coming- Dude, like Santa's here...
- 4:11when the lease, when the leases went through the roof, when rates went through the roof, when residuals weren't hanging, hanging on strong.
- 4:19Um, and we knew we were gonna have a disparate used car market, but now we've got, uh, an aggressive new car market where supply hasn't really caught up, um, where pricing incentives haven't caught up.
- 4:28However, you know, Q4 has meant a lot to, to manufacturers in the fact that it hasn't been at the pace that really Q1 and Q2, Q3 saw the benefit of EVs.
- 4:39And, and earlier reports on, on those October numbers are showing like, "Hey, we might need to pace up incentives." So it'll be interesting. Haven't heard a lot about incentives the first part of December.
- 4:49It'll be interesting to see if some of those m- uh, manufacturers that like to put in- Go on Santa's bags... those, those, those kind of second, uh, second half of the month incentives do that.
- 4:57Yeah, they're gonna be dropping soon. Yeah. Right? It's the 9th. Right. So if we're gonna see them, we're gonna see them in the next seven days. Yeah. Will be interesting. Yeah. Michael?
- 5:05I got nothing, except for- [laughs] This is the theme of today's show. Here comes the pan flute. I got nothing except for. Doo, doo, doo, doo.
- 5:12Um, the word, the words that I say to my teenage boys are coming to my mind right now. Pay attention.
- 5:20[laughs] Because, you know, the, the ability that we have to shake and move when we are paying attention far, i- is far greater and far, far more advantageous than when we're not paying attention, and it's incumbent upon every dealer.
- 5:35Every business has the opportunity, if paying attention, to say, "What would we do if we experience X? What would we do if we experience Y?"
- 5:43And so you have a market that's, like, doing this, and you don't know what, what are the OEMs doing? What are politicians doing? What is our market doing?
- 5:52To sit down, I guess a full circle moment to what we're doing here, um, a- as a company, to say, "If we experience this, what will our response be?" Yeah. "If this, what's our response? If this is our response."
- 6:04And you look at some of the operators in our industry who-...
- 6:08are paying attention, who do have response plans, and the way in which they navigate, or almost the grace in which they navigate these types of, you know, wishy-washy markets, is far more inspiring to, to observe than those that are saying, "Well, what do we do?"
- 6:21Well, what you're talking, what you're talking about is being proactive about your planning, right? Sure. That it's not a, it's not singular plans. It's, like, modular plans. That's right.
- 6:30Things that can, can pivot on a, on a dime. If we're only creating reactivity in our businesses- Yeah... uh, then, then you're definitely behind, and paying attention requires some future p- Yeah...
- 6:40some level of future planning. Speaking of reactivity. Yo. Segway time. [upbeat music] When Nathan comes on and says, "Hey- Got him.
- 6:48And look, when Nathan, like, drops his, like, hits his fingers like that- Like, here it is... you know, you know he's on. It is- Yeah, it's emotion... art in motion.
- 6:56VinFast retreat from the US market is accelerating as its retail network falls below two dozen active stores.
- 7:02Falling sales, product deadlines, and shifting global priorities are prompting dealers to exit while the brand refocuses on markets where demand is stronger.
- 7:10VinFast's North Carolina store, which was VinFast's first US franchise, ends sales December 31st, marking the third dealer exit in six months. Wow. US registrations fell 57% through October.
- 7:22Even, even after, as overall EV sales are growing 11% in the same period. High import tariffs and the loss of the $7,500 EV tax credit have further eroded their US competitiveness.
- 7:34Several listed stores now show no inventory or coming soon, and many active rooftops have 15 or fewer vehicles on the ground. Here's a quote from VinFast chairwoman, uh, uh, Thuy... This is too early for me. Thuy Le.
- 7:49Thuy Ty Le. There you go. "Given the tariff situation and the instability of the E- in the EV market, we just need to see how this settles before we push hard in the US." Okay. Controversial opinion of the day, EV fans.
- 8:01[laughs] He was ready for this. Ah, man. Hit him. Some- sometimes, okay, sometimes I wish, I just wish chair people would keep their mouth shut for a while. [laughs] Why? Well, let's look at EV Auto Alex, our friend.
- 8:16Alex Lawrence. He specifically says you need to be all in on EVs if you're gonna be in on EVs at all. You can't be a little bit in on EVs.
- 8:25So now you have VinFast, which should be all in on EVs, but most of the dealers that are buying them are buying them with historical or traditional franchise dealer models, and I don't think they're prepared yet in- Mm...
- 8:39in their own infrastructure to be like, "Okay, but what does it actually mean to be all in on EVs?" Mm-hmm. Yeah. We can't sell these things the way that we would sell any other vehicle.
- 8:47And you look at some of the franchise stores who have, uh, uh, EV lineups, Hyundai or, or, you know, Kia. Mm-hmm. It actually requires a shift in process- Massive shift, yeah... for them to wrap their head around it.
- 9:00And so, you know, I, I have so many questions. I'm not saying anybody's doing anything right or wrong or indifferent. What I am saying, though, is it's one thing to be like, "Well, it didn't work."
- 9:10I would really want to examine the operational structure of the dealers- Who and why it didn't work with. E- Yeah. Exactly, because, I mean, there's obviously a model for it.
- 9:18I was picked up in an Uber last night in an EV and the guy was like, "I own three EVs." Yeah. In, in Syracuse. Mm-hmm. Yeah. In the winter. It's 10 degrees out right now.
- 9:27So I, I just, I keep coming back to Alex Lawrence, our pal, and he's like, "You gotta be all, all, all in." All in. "It's a different way to sell." Hm. It's a different way to sell. It's a different consumer base.
- 9:39I, you know, the interesting thing for me is I haven't seen VinFast advertising a- at all. It's gone dark.
- 9:44It's gone, it seems like it's gone dark, so I don't know if they're trying to do, like, micro-trend type stuff or, or very, very hyper-localized.
- 9:52Um, but for a brand like that trying to enter a market where Rivian and Tesla, and even Scout now, have taken the bull by the horns and gone very, very fast into, like...
- 10:03I mean, VinFast was nowhere, nowhere to be found at LA Auto Show, right? That's right. Hm.
- 10:07Yeah, so- And you would think that that would be a great market to- That's the place to go and, and, and put your brand front and center.
- 10:12So they either don't have the capital or the understanding of what it takes to aggregate attention in a market like the US. Um, and so that's, uh, I mean, it's why- I think, I think they have the capital.
- 10:21They're a very well-capitalized company. Right. Um, I, I think they've just lost, lost the plot or- Yep... maybe they're just like, it's, it's... You know, sometimes you make decisions because
- 10:31it's hard here, but you make decisions because if you allocate those resources where it's much easier- Sure...
- 10:36it makes a lot more sense, and I think that's, that's- I would also challenge to, to, to Michael's point, if you're a dealer or a dealer group that still has one of these franchises, ask yourself, "Am I doing business in a way that, like, am I following Alex Lawrence- Yeah...
- 10:51on, o- on these channels," right? A- am I understand- am I following a Jimmy Douglas that understands- Right... the EV market? Am I watching what those people are posting about?
- 11:00Am I doing content in a similar way so that I can aggregate the attention, at least hyper-localized, to sell through the inventory that I have, right? In consideration, yeah. It's a simple decision from there.
- 11:10If the answer is, "I'm all in," cool. Then do what it's gonna take to be all in because you look at Alex, I think he's a beacon of light. You know, we talked about that. Mm.
- 11:18A- as a beacon of light, he's like, "Okay, $7,500 tax credit went away. I'm selling used EVs." Yep. "And you know what? Let's just throw, let's open up another store there." Mm-hmm.
- 11:27"And let's open up another store there." So there's obviously a path. If your answer is, "Yeah, I don't know. I, I just kind of wish it was easier," pull the plug and get out. See ya. Yeah.
- 11:38That's my, that's my two cents for what it's worth. Tells how you really feel. Tells how he really feels. Two cents Canadian is, like, uh, uh- 0.8 cents It's like 0.8 cents in the US. It's like nothing.
- 11:46It's struggle, man. Three US is 25 bucks Canadian. [laughs] We don't make, we don't make cents anymore. We stopped making pennies. Well, speaking of making cents. There you go. Oh. Segway time. Segway.
- 11:57[upbeat music] A, uh, a-massive agency that we know and follow, uh, is making a ton of sense with their new anti-trend report.
- 12:05VaynerMedia came out with it and is arguing that social trends are c- collapsing faster than ever, making 2026 the year that brands stop chasing virality and start purtuing, pursuing genuine relevance.
- 12:17Let's talk about it. With algorithms fragmenting attention, emotional connections becomes the new competitive advantage. The report says that trend fatigue is accelerating.
- 12:25Trends now fade 14 times faster than they used to, and one third of consumers think brands jumping on viral trends is, quote, "embarrassing." I think my kids would say cringe. Cringe.
- 12:36Uh, platforms are borrowing TikTok layouts show up on Instagram, Facebook style text posts appear everywhere, meaning content format matters more than platform identity.
- 12:45Audience are expecting authenticity, not broadcasts. Brands must create two-way social conversations, not passive content streams.
- 12:53Uh, Alan Blair, SVP and Head of Strategy at VaynerMedia said, "In 2026, the brands that win won't be those who shut, shout the loudest, but those who show up the most real." Oh, okay. Listen to me.
- 13:05If you're watching this, if you are not ready to disrupt yourself and reinvent your social media strategy, you will lose. Okay. That's our- That's true Um, does this mean...
- 13:16What does this mean for the Drop It Like It's Hot videos that all the 43-year-olds are doing? Um, six, seven- Don't do it. Stop.
- 13:21Well, look, maybe where you did it like a year ago, but they're saying now when you jump on a trend, it's over before it began.
- 13:28And if you're in retail automotive, chances are we caught onto the trend a little bit later, so it is over. Can I just toot a horn real quick? [laughs] Uh, I don't know how to respond to that. Uh, here's...
- 13:42Have we not been saying this for years now? That the n- the, the actual viral is authenticity? Yeah. I'll see myself out. Okay, goodbye. All right, he's leaving. But, um, I think we've done enough damage here.
- 13:55You've done enough. Here today. Why don't we roll the outro music? We have a team meeting to get to as well. And we're gonna tell it to you the same way we just told him.
- 14:02We're telling you the same thing we just told him. Same exact thing. We have to disrupt ourselves before somebody else disrupts us. Disrupt ourselves before somebody else disrupts us. That is our encouragement to you.
- 14:08That is our encouragement to you. And, um- Um, we're here for you... we're here for you. Yeah. Have any more thoughts, ideas, uh, whatever. Thoughts, ideas, uh, whatever. Disrupt or be disrupted. Disrupt or be disrupted.
- 14:23Bottoms up. Bottoms up. We'll see you here. I am one. [upbeat music] [laughs] I am on