Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Therapy Ruts, The Bridge, Children on YouTube, and Other Things
Transcript
- 0:00Pages listeners. It's just me today. I thought I would answer some patron
- 0:04emails upper to your patron. This email is from anonymous highest tier patron from
- 0:08Minneapolis. He writes, I was hoping you could share your thoughts on this.
- 0:13I have been in therapy on and off for about ten years. However,
- 0:17I have an issue where I find myself regularly switching therapists. I generally
- 0:22work with someone for about a year or so before I start becoming dissatisfied with
- 0:25my therapist. I often feel like I'm not being challenged enough or making any
- 0:29progress. Now I am finding myself in the same situation where I want to
- 0:33switch therapist, but I'm not sure if I should. On one hand,
- 0:37working with different people may provide me with exposure and experience with many different types
- 0:41of modalities and techniques. On the other hand, this may just be me
- 0:46being unwilling to confront issues with my current therapist. Any insight into regularly switching
- 0:52therapists would be greatly appreciated. Thank you and of email. Well, I
- 0:55can't know for you in particular, anonymous higher tier patron from Minneapolis, but
- 1:00that is these are the questions I would ask myself if I were in your
- 1:03shoes. And I've experienced this myself. I mean not to that degree,
- 1:07but I've had times in therapy myself where i feel like I feel like I'm
- 1:12not really being challenged enough, or i feel like I'm not making any progress.
- 1:17It feels like I'm just coming in and we're talking about the same things,
- 1:21and I kind of know what my therapist is going to say for me
- 1:26when I get there. I'm like, well, there's a lot that I'm
- 1:32avoiding. There's a lot that I could be talking about in therapy that I
- 1:37don't naturally go to and I sit down on the couch. But if I
- 1:41really thought about it, I mean there's some deeper, perhaps more vulnerable things.
- 1:46So I don't know highest your patron, but if you are on the
- 1:49avoidant side of the spectrum attachment wise, then in all likelihood, this is
- 1:55a worthy exploration for you. What vulnerable, embarrassing, deeper issue are you
- 2:02avoiding? And when you get to the point where it would be natural to
- 2:07start talking about that, you bolt. You know. An analogous situation that's
- 2:13more common is in romantic relationships with avoidant people, where I've worked with people
- 2:19who have a deep amount of avoidant attachment style due to childhood emotional neglect,
- 2:27and they will be convinced that their relationship is pointless. You know, they'll
- 2:34be married and they'll just be like, yeah, I think I just I'm
- 2:36just not in love anymore. I don't feel that. I just feel like
- 2:38I should. There's nothing really terrible about the relationship. But you know,
- 2:42I have my complaints, but I just every day I just think I need
- 2:46to leave. I need to leave, I need to leave, and so
- 2:47I really feel like I need to break up. So as a therapist,
- 2:51I will absolutely support them if they want to break up. It's not my
- 2:55life that I'm that they're living, So there's that. But if I have
- 3:00an inkling or at best a full assessment of the individual as being avoidantly attached,
- 3:07then I will explore with them the possibility that what they're doing is actually
- 3:12avoiding going deeper or when in doubt, they run rights. And the longer
- 3:19a relationship sustains itself, the more vulnerable it just inherently becomes. That's why
- 3:23all of us, in the beginning of a relationship, we have a much
- 3:27easier time not being triggered. Typically, but as a relationship lengthens and time
- 3:32and deepens and becomes more a part of our neurons, you know, our
- 3:38brain becomes more used to these individuals, and we start to attach to them
- 3:42in some very deep, primordial ways. All of those triggers and transferences and
- 3:47distortions and worries and schemes start to emerge. And so with avoided people,
- 3:53the conscious thought will be I'm not in love, I need to leave again.
- 3:58If they want to leave, I support that. But I've been with
- 4:00avoidant clients where they will leave after we explore it fully, and even after
- 4:06the client is on board with it, like, yeah, maybe I am
- 4:10avoiding. Let's look at that, Maybe I should be vulnerable, maybe I
- 4:12should dig deeper. Do I actually am I running away like I always do?
- 4:16And then let's say they do leave after six months of exploration and therapy,
- 4:21and then fast forward another another few months and the client comes back to
- 4:26me. It says, I've made a terrible mistake. I never actually should
- 4:29have left my spouse because I am deeply in love and I miss my partner
- 4:34and I want to be back with them. And it's clear now that it
- 4:39was my avoidant tendencies. I was fully consciously thinking that I need to leave,
- 4:45but subconsciously clearly I was still love and wanting to be vulnerable, but
- 4:49I couldn't because of my relational traumas, and I can't stop thinking about my
- 4:55partner. All I want to do is get back with them. So I've
- 4:59been with avoiding people as they do that, and it's possible that that's what's
- 5:03happening with these therapists. Now, if you're not on the avoidant end of
- 5:06the spectrum, then none of this applies to an anonymous higher type patrons.
- 5:11So it could be I mean, not the specifics of it, it could
- 5:15regardless of your attachment style tendencies. It could absolutely be this phenomenon of wanting
- 5:21to avoid deeper things. I mean, just think about make a list,
- 5:25Maybe write out ten things that you tend not to talk about with your therapist
- 5:30that you feel like maybe aren't necessarily super relevant because it's possible that they are,
- 5:36Or just go into your therapist and say, you know, normally I
- 5:41want to bolt, but I'm wondering if there's something that I'm avoiding. Can
- 5:45you help me explore that because I don't want to just terminate with you like
- 5:48I've done in the past and end up in the same cycle. So can
- 5:54we explore that, you know, something like that. But it's also possible
- 5:57that you benefit from a therapist for a while and then it's over. You
- 6:00know, it's not common that it's usually that amount of time, that brief
- 6:03amount of time of about a year, but it's very common, in fact,
- 6:09almost universal, that after a certain amount of time, clients will find
- 6:15that unless they're really needing that attachment figure of the therapist, it is often
- 6:19helpful to switch therapist because of the reasons that you laid out. Maybe it's
- 6:24three years or five years or something, but eventually you just sort of learn
- 6:30all the different things that your therapist has to say. You've internalized all the
- 6:33things that they have to give, and you know you're looking for a different
- 6:39a fresh point of view, a new point of view, And there's nothing
- 6:43pathological about that at all. But really this question applies to all y'all out
- 6:46there in therapy, or if you're thinking about starting therapy again, is what
- 6:53are you avoiding? Because I guarantee you, in all likelihood, I guarantee
- 6:57you, in all likelihood, there's a very strong likelihood that all of you
- 7:00are avoiding something in therapy, there's something that is too deep, that is
- 7:06too vulnerable, that's too scary, that's too embarrassing, that you think is
- 7:11too shameful. Now, it doesn't mean that you're you're supposed to talk about
- 7:15it right away, but definitely identify that as a target to move towards something
- 7:20that you can shoot for to eventually talk about, because you deserve that.
- 7:27There can be a lot of growth and material in that discussion, particularly if
- 7:31you find your sessions to be kind of bland and not super eventful. And
- 7:38if you're a therapist, and of course you know this, but if you're
- 7:41a therapist and you have clients that seem to just skip along the surface,
- 7:46particularly if this is well into the therapeutic relationship, you know, six plus
- 7:50months, then there are techniques as a therapist to introduce the idea with your
- 7:57clients that maybe there's other things to talk about, you know, Like,
- 8:00I'm just trying to think of what I There's a million different ways that I
- 8:03might do it. But I might start out a session, I might think
- 8:05about a client in between sessions and think, you know, I feel like
- 8:09we've kind of hit a rut or a stagnation. So I might at the
- 8:13beginning of session and say it's likely like, look, I've been thinking a
- 8:15lot about you and you're the course of your therapy, and I don't know,
- 8:20but it feels like we've kind of hit a plateau and therapy. But
- 8:26I don't know. I don't know how you feel, so I'd like to
- 8:28hear how you feel about it. So i'd ask them, and then i'd
- 8:31hear from them, and then I'd say, well, there's a possibility that
- 8:33we've hit a plateau because you are scared of revealing something, or your normal
- 8:41mode is to avoid even acknowledging that these things are important to you, or
- 8:46you downplay them, or you think that I'll shame you or something. Does
- 8:48anything come to mind when I bring that up? And I might also say,
- 8:54look, you don't have to bring I don't want to push you to
- 8:56bring something up you're not ready to bring up, but I just want to
- 8:58throw it out there as something to talk about. We can talk about talking
- 9:03about something that you don't want to talk about, or you could just tell
- 9:07me and we could experiment and see how that goes. But I'm really curious
- 9:11as to the full you and all your glory, even the parts of you
- 9:16that you think are embarrassing or shameful or uninteresting or unworthy or something. You
- 9:22know, I'm really interested in all that. I want to know the full
- 9:26you, So you know, I might say something like that. Okay,
- 9:28So the sext email is going to talk about suicide in kind of a graphic
- 9:33way, So I would skip forward by fifteen minutes if that is triggering for
- 9:37you, all right. The sext email is from Annual Apertier Patron Kim from
- 9:43Arizona. Good old Kim. She says, have you ever seen the documentary
- 9:48film called The Bridge by Eric Steele? Heavy trigger warning by the way,
- 9:52about suicide. It is an extreme, intense, emotional and controversial film,
- 9:58But I also found it deeply moving and one I watch every two or three
- 10:01years. A filmmaker filmed the Golden Gate Bridge for one year and captured many
- 10:07suicide jumps. The filmmaker displays footage of the suicides and interviews the families.
- 10:11There is so much there that you could react to, like the stories of
- 10:16the deceased or family perspectives, etc. Just chiming in here. Yeah,
- 10:20I saw the movie back when it came out two thousand and six, and
- 10:26apparently it's on Amazon Prime right now, and it's a fascinating movie. It
- 10:31is just as you describe a filmmaker for a year, because I think statistic
- 10:37something like a few hundred or more back then people would complete suicide by jumping
- 10:43off the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco. And so he got a camera,
- 10:50a few cameras and would just film with these really long lenses, very
- 10:54zoomed in, and so there was a lot of ethical questions about it because
- 11:03he didn't intervene, And so you would think that you should, right,
- 11:07if you see someone that looks like they might kill themselves, shouldn't you run
- 11:11out there and try to help them. Shouldn't you try to stop them,
- 11:16or call the authorities, or call a therapist or a mental health professional to
- 11:22go out there and try to prevent them from doing that. Maybe they did
- 11:24that sometimes, but at the very least there were many times when they didn't.
- 11:31And watching The other ethical question is just watching the documentary to begin with,
- 11:37because why are you watching, right? Are you watching just to watch
- 11:41people die? You have some sort of sick pleasure on watching people kill themselves.
- 11:46So there's that, But the message of the movie to me when I
- 11:50watched the documentary called The Bridge, is it's not exploitative of the individuals.
- 11:56And sure they could have made a documentary video where they actually try to stop
- 12:00people, and that would have been fine as well. But one of the
- 12:03experiences or the realities of suicide, which happens all the time. You know,
- 12:07the amount of worry that we all have about gun deaths in our country,
- 12:13the most frequent use of a gun is not to kill another person,
- 12:16it's to kill the self. It's it's used in suicide. So all of
- 12:20the news coverage and all the paranoia and all the political ups and downs of
- 12:26guns and murder and police and the problem pales in comparison to suicide in our
- 12:33society. And it's getting worse suicide for people of all ages, by the
- 12:37way. So it's it's a problem, and to ignore it, which is
- 12:41what we usually do, is part of the problem. So what this documentary
- 12:46he does is it really exposes people. It's a rare document that really,
- 12:52you know, in a very observer oriented way, provides an audience with the
- 12:58reality of what it is to kill oneself. It doesn't show the graphic details,
- 13:03but it does show the people contemplating. You know, there's these long
- 13:07shots of someone kind of walking back and forth on the bridge, and then
- 13:11they climb over the rail and then they kind of think about it for a
- 13:15while, and then maybe half an hour later, you see them jump and
- 13:18then they if they pan well enough, they see that the body splash into
- 13:24the water below. And this movie is obviously very triggering, so you shouldn't
- 13:28be watching it if you're at risk of being traumatized by this or just negatively
- 13:33affected by it. But when I watched it, it was very affecting and
- 13:39very gripping at watching. So one message that the movie is putting forth is,
- 13:45look, this is the reality. This is happening all the time,
- 13:48and we tend to ignore it. So I know, let's look at it.
- 13:52We need to see it first and understand it before we can actually face
- 13:58it and do something about it. Right. The second message that is clear,
- 14:03at least from my memory of watching the documentary almost twenty years ago,
- 14:07is that people, if you give them the help that they deserve and need,
- 14:11they actually don't want to kill themselves. Like there was one individual that
- 14:16survived had jumped from the bridge and had injured themselves severely upon landing on the
- 14:22water, but had survived and been rescued or something, and they interviewed him,
- 14:26I think it was him, and he talked about how he no longer
- 14:31wants to kill himself, and he talked about how as he was falling he
- 14:35regretted having jumped or something like that. And the message that I got from
- 14:41it was that people who are even at that stage of wanting to take their
- 14:48own life, wanting to die by suicide, are salvageable. Are savable these
- 14:54individuals if they have a connection, if they're given some way out of the
- 15:00way that they feel, then they won't do this. And it's the isolation,
- 15:05it's the demoralization, it's the lack of treatment that will lead to this
- 15:11behavior. Right now, having said all that, I can absolutely imagine this
- 15:13documentary prompting people to attempt and complete suicide. The documentary is so matter of
- 15:20fact and so just a document of suicide that I know absolutely that this documentary
- 15:28could absolutely prompt someone if they were thinking about suicide, because it's a known
- 15:35phenomenon that when people are at risk of suicide and they hear about suicide or
- 15:41they watch a suicide, they learn about a suicide, it can motivate them
- 15:45to take that final step to actually attempting because there's a normalization or an inspiration
- 15:52of it. And we do this in all aspects of life, Like if
- 15:56you watch a YouTube video of someone and making an interesting dinner, that could
- 16:02inspire you that day to go out and buy ingredients and make dinner. Right,
- 16:06we are inspired by watching other humans do things that we're on the cusp
- 16:10of doing ourselves. So there's that. Also, videos like this can make
- 16:17it seem like it's an answer, right if someone isn't even necessarily even thinking
- 16:22about suicide, but when they watch these individuals dying, it can prompt someone
- 16:26to be like, well, maybe that's an answer for me. So I'm
- 16:30not going to say that this documentary is one hundred percent a good for society.
- 16:33But the problem is in our society is that we just ignore the topic
- 16:37altogether anyway. And in order for us to help people and work on helping
- 16:45others and also eliminating the antecedents the causes of suicide, we have to face
- 16:51this and we have to look at it. Now. In a perfect world,
- 16:53if someone was at risk of suicide, they wouldn't watch this documentary before
- 16:59they knew that it wasn't going to push them over the edge. They would
- 17:03have a number of clinicians, at least one good solid clinician that they're working
- 17:07with. They would have a lot of support in their systems, their families,
- 17:11their job, their medical field, that kind of thing. And thus
- 17:15this documentary wouldn't just be floating out in space ready for some isolated individual to
- 17:22become motivated to take their own life, you know what I mean. So
- 17:26when we look at this documentary and we're like, hey, documentary, don't
- 17:29do this, well, the documentary is, it's not the problem. The
- 17:34problem is our society. And if our society was different, this documentary wouldn't
- 17:40threaten as much as it does. Right, But having said that, it
- 17:44still threatens a lot. It's the point. It's sort of like with the
- 17:48TV show Thirteen Reasons Why right, the Netflix show. And this was my
- 17:52position when that came out, and full disclosure, a good friend of mine
- 17:56wrote that show Brian Yorkey, so you could take that into account. But
- 18:02and he got I'm pretty sure he caught a lot of flak for this.
- 18:04But the show depicts a suicide or the show is all about suicide, right.
- 18:11The show is about a young woman, a teenage girl, who kills
- 18:17herself, and before she does it, she records all these cassette tapes,
- 18:21and on each side of each cassette is one of the thirteen reasons why she
- 18:27killed herself, and it has to do with for my memory, it had
- 18:30to do with like one of the kids at school or something like that,
- 18:34so on, you know, one of the sides of the cassettes is the
- 18:38story of how some other girl bullied her or something like this. The protagonist
- 18:42is listening to the tapes and sort of being pulled through the story like this.
- 18:47Anyway, So the TV show in a sense glorifies suicide because the girl
- 18:56who kills herself is in a really bad situation before she dies, she's traumatized
- 19:02and bullied and confused and isolated and sad, and then she kills herself.
- 19:08She records these tapes, and then these tapes proceed to cause this total change
- 19:14in the school because everyone that is on the tape has to face the reality
- 19:19that they were a factor in this girl dying. And so people are given
- 19:25a chance to learn or be called out or identified or shamed for their abusive
- 19:30behavior of her or something. And this is for some people, this is
- 19:34their dream of a suicide. This is why they kill themselves, is because
- 19:40they hope that it will vindicate them and it will shame other people. And
- 19:45of course we don't want that message to be out there. We don't want
- 19:48that to be glorified. We don't that, we don't want to put that
- 19:52head that idea in people's heads, or we don't want to encourage people to
- 19:56do that. And at first, when the TV show came out, I
- 20:00actually did an episode about it years ago, and I saw that initial criticism
- 20:06like, hey, you can't have a TV show that glorifies suicide. And
- 20:10what my position was at the time was that I actually was appreciative of a
- 20:15show like this because it highlighted something that has rarely talked about. And I
- 20:19thought it was just overblown paranoia and panic around oh my god, what are
- 20:25we going to do? Someone's talking about suicide, and I'm like, look,
- 20:27this is a reality in my world. This is happening all the time.
- 20:30People are thinking about it, attempting, completing all the time in my
- 20:33world, and this is one of those stories. And if you can't handle
- 20:37it, like I don't know what to tell you, like how many how
- 20:40many things have you watched that involved that have involved violent death in war?
- 20:45All the Marvel movies and stuff, like how many people die? How much
- 20:49violence happens in those movies? Like you seem extremely okay with watching literally people
- 20:56depictions of people dying, or documentaries about people dying by murder or riot or
- 21:02war or something, and yet when there's one story about suicide, suddenly the
- 21:07world is falling apart. Like, if you're really concerned about your kids,
- 21:11what about all the violence that they watch anyway? So at first I'm like,
- 21:15come on, people, But then the data came out and showed we
- 21:21can't know if it's causal. Of course, it's just a correlation. But
- 21:22there was a bump in teenage suicide following the months after that TV show came
- 21:30out, and it does stand to reason that the show could have inspired people
- 21:34who were thinking about it to complete or attempt. That does raise a concern,
- 21:40and so we need to think about that and we need to be careful
- 21:42about that. And just having a disclaimer at the beginning of the TV show
- 21:48that says, hey, if you're thinking about suicide, call this hotline.
- 21:51That's not enough, right, that's not going to solve the problem. But
- 21:53in my head, this is not the fault of a TV show or a
- 21:56documentary. This is the fault of our society. If we had a different
- 22:00society with different systems in place and different levels of or you know, no
- 22:07level of stigma about this sort of thing and resources available, then a TV
- 22:12show like this, a documentary like The Bridge, it wouldn't pose the threat
- 22:18that it does, and it would just be like, well, yeah,
- 22:22we know lots of stories with suicide, We know lots of we acknowledge lots
- 22:26of suicides happen, and here's our full fifteen step approach as a society as
- 22:36how we're dealing with that and how we're trying to reduce it. So I
- 22:40feel like these TV shows, these documentaries become kind of the scapegoat for us.
- 22:45We as a society are ignoring it and we don't want to acknowledge it
- 22:49to begin with, and then someone comes out with some kind of story like
- 22:52this and we're like, hey, suicide is your fault, and it's like,
- 22:56no, suicide is our fault. It's our fault that we as a
- 23:02society are ignoring it. We're not voting for politicians that allocate tax dollars to
- 23:07raise awareness, to spend in public health, to have it so that everyone
- 23:12has access to mental healthcare very quickly, very easily, so that social workers
- 23:17and public health workers are not overworked. We would want to hire like ten
- 23:22times the amount of social workers and ten times the amount of CPS workers and
- 23:27public health people so that they would have the time and the resources to actually
- 23:32reach out and educate and help and change society. You know, that's it's
- 23:37our fault that that isn't in place. It's our fault that we have this
- 23:42epidemic of so many houses with guns that are potentially not even locked up,
- 23:49and there are people in those homes who are wanting to kill himself and a
- 23:53gun is in the drawer of their dad's desk, you know. And it's
- 23:57a problem, and we're not doing anything to change that. And so it's
- 24:03not thirteen reasons why fault. It's not the bridge fault. It's our fault.
- 24:06And if you want to change it, vote, raise awareness, write
- 24:10your representative, talk about it, get the word out there. If you're
- 24:14in a position of power, you know, if you're a teacher, talk
- 24:18about that you know this with your school, how can you start integrating this
- 24:21more? And I know some of you are obviously doing these things and I
- 24:23applaud you. All Right, that's second break. Can we get back more
- 24:26emails? All right, we're back from the break. This email is from
- 24:34Upper to your patron, Hannah from Indiana. Hannah from Indiana, She writes,
- 24:40I know you've talked on the podcast about child content creators and kids growing
- 24:45up with content creator parents, and I also have heard you talk about how
- 24:49the criticism you've received on YouTube has impacted you. I'd be interested in hearing
- 24:53your thoughts on my experience with being a YouTuber when I was a child and
- 24:59how that might compare to your experience as adult content creators and the experience of
- 25:03kids today. I began creating videos for YouTube in two thousand and nine at
- 25:07the age of eleven years old. I made vlog style videos right as vlogging
- 25:11was becoming popular. Just share me in here. Yeah, I kind of
- 25:15forgot about that that YouTube in the beginning was mainly geared towards vlogging, towards
- 25:21personal vlogging, right, people would just be like, So I went to
- 25:23the store today and this, and and I remember people would really make fun
- 25:27of YouTube and the beginning, like who would want to watch that stuff?
- 25:30And of course now it's something that we would all totally understand us why people
- 25:34would want to watch it. Also, I think it's in the name YouTube.
- 25:38Right now, YouTube has major corporations right all the main studios and TV
- 25:47channels, cable channels, TV shows, big TV shows, they all are
- 25:52on YouTube. So I remember thinking when YouTube was invented that it was the
- 25:56name was geared towards look. This is supposed to be a look to your
- 26:00life. It's supposed to be very amateur and very unproduced. And of course
- 26:03YouTube now even people who are still just them doing a video at home,
- 26:10they're highly produced. They're better than Like for me, when I sit down
- 26:14at night to veg out and just watch random stuff. I don't watch TV.
- 26:18I watch YouTube. There's so many different quality YouTube channels and videos on
- 26:23the Internet that they're just way better than stuff that's on regular TV in my
- 26:27opinion, aside from drama obviously, you know, like The Last of Us,
- 26:33which I just find to be an amazing show. Okay, going on
- 26:37here. I made vlogstyle videos as just right as vlogging was becoming popular.
- 26:41Today, many eleven year olds have social media or make tiktoks. As a
- 26:45result, there are many more protections in place for minors on the Internet,
- 26:49and there is more awareness and social support for people who get hate online,
- 26:53which wasn't present when I was young. At the age of eleven and two
- 26:57thousand night, I remember getting tons of hate comments on my videos. Many
- 27:02comments would be calling me ugly, telling me to kill myself. In one
- 27:07comment I vividly remember that said, I hope you die a painful death and
- 27:11a bloody death. I was also bullied in school for making YouTube videos.
- 27:15Despite this, I continued making videos on a few different channels until twenty seventeen.
- 27:22I've also struggled with suicidal aviation since I was nine year olds since I
- 27:26was nine years old, and I struggle with self harm since I was eleven.
- 27:30Today, I still struggle with suicidal adiation and have had massive issues with
- 27:34self esteem. I know that many of these issues predate my YouTube channel,
- 27:38and I experienced many traumas in my life that impacted my development. However,
- 27:42I do think that my exposure to internet criticism so early must have had an
- 27:47impact I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on how this early exposure to internet
- 27:51criticism can negatively impact development. I'd also be interested to hear if you think
- 27:56that the normalization of children creating content can actually be protective, since it has
- 28:00led to more robust regulations and offers more social support with shared experience and of
- 28:04email. Yeah, so that last bit, I don't know if I'd thought
- 28:08about that so much, but I do think that that the advent of more
- 28:14children and themselves or being in these family YouTube videos has caused more scrutiny,
- 28:22and there have been some bad cases. Actually, So I'm recording this,
- 28:29you know, in what is what's the date? Mid March, and this
- 28:33episode will probably come out like Mida Proole. I'm guessing, I'm not sure,
- 28:37but around this time in early March, there was a really famous case
- 28:41of this family YouTuber where they wrapped their kid looks maybe like three four years
- 28:49old, and looked to be like plastic or saran wrap, and so he
- 28:55looked he was just like a plastic burrito, if you will. And the
- 28:59dad is picking him up and standing him up on the bed and then pushing
- 29:03him down and standing him up, pushing down. The kid didn't look happy.
- 29:06It didn't look horrific, but it did not look good. And the
- 29:10dad was also kind of making fun of the kid as he was pushing him
- 29:12down, and CPS was called because from my understanding in the viewers were so
- 29:21outraged that and they knew where the family lived, so they called the local
- 29:25CPS of that family, and CPS came to the house and actually took the
- 29:30kid away, which I found to be extremely strange. So in the video
- 29:36it didn't look good, But in my experience with child protective services, they
- 29:41need a lot of data to justify taking a kid out of a home.
- 29:47There's a lot of there's a lot of myths about child protective services, and
- 29:51one of the myths is that they're just champing at the bit to take kids
- 29:55out of homes. The fact is, as they're not child protective services,
- 29:57they're interested in the child. They're not interested in punishing parents. They're interested
- 30:03in the best case scenario for the kid. So they're two scenarios. One
- 30:07is that the child wasn't really being that abuse, There wasn't a pattern of
- 30:11abuse, and the parents made a really bad choice with this one video,
- 30:15and CPS arrived and they for whatever reason, overreacted, maybe because of the
- 30:22internet scrutiny, they were worried of being accused of underreacting, or they were
- 30:30particularly outraged by the video, or they had some kind of bone to pick
- 30:33with YouTubers or something. So that's one possibility. It's not unheard of,
- 30:37but that could have happened. And the other scenario is that they arrived and
- 30:42they investigated and found a lot more allegations and reasons to temporarily take the kid
- 30:51out of the home to protect the child the reason. So that's another scenario
- 30:55that's possible. The mother went online and made this very tiery apology video and
- 31:03took full responsibility, and the dad, to my knowledge, might not have,
- 31:07but the parents were obviously very distraught that the kid was gone and they
- 31:10couldn't get the kid back. I think the kid was in custody for a
- 31:12couple of days or something. You know, it's pretty awful for a parent
- 31:15to go through the shame and the worry of the kid. But CPS generally
- 31:22doesn't want to do this for a number of reasons unless it's justified. The
- 31:26reasons are that one, they don't have a lot of places to put kids.
- 31:30That costs money. You have to because you can't charge the parents,
- 31:33right, you have to use tax dollars to pay for these foster homes to
- 31:38foster the kids, and it can be expensive and there's only so much money
- 31:42to allocate to this sort of thing, so they don't have unlimited resources to
- 31:48pay for homes to take kids in. The second reason is that CPS workers
- 31:53are generally rational, intelligent, wise people who will weigh the pros and the
- 32:00cons. So they might have if it was that first scenario where there wasn't
- 32:06other reasons to believe there was other abuse happening to the kid, then the
- 32:08CPS workers would come in and say, look, you need to make some
- 32:14changes, but we're not going to take the kid out of the home because
- 32:17we believe that by doing that that would harm the kid. Because just imagine
- 32:21for the kid to be forty eight hours ish in this random home and you
- 32:27know, God knows what he's going through emotionally. I mean, that could
- 32:30permanently scar a child And is that really what you want as CPS Because so
- 32:35you're always weighing those pros and cons. Well, even if the kid is
- 32:39being abuse in that home, it might actually be worse for the kid to
- 32:44take him out of the home. Instead, maybe we should actually try to
- 32:49get the parents to stop doing what they're doing. I did this work all
- 32:52the time. I would actually be called by these CPS workers, by the
- 32:57state workers, and they would say, the kid is being left in the
- 33:00home, but we need you to immediately go to this house, evaluate this
- 33:04situation, and fix this family so they stop abusing their kid. It was
- 33:08much less expensive to do this, even though I wasn't exactly cheap, but
- 33:14it was a lot more expensive to take kids out of the home, and
- 33:17it also lent itself towards the greater good because most kids, when they're taken
- 33:22out of the home, it's not permanent, and it's better to try to
- 33:28work with the situation right and change it than to just rip it all apart.
- 33:31So I don't know what happened there, But why don't you get on
- 33:35that topic? So yeah, So here's my point is that you were wondering
- 33:40if that the normalization of children being on the internet on YouTube, TikTok,
- 33:45this kind of thing has led to more rational approaches and regulations around this sort
- 33:52of thing, and we're far from that. Actually, at this point.
- 33:55From my understand I don't know the laws specifically, but understanding there are laws
- 34:01about having kids on like a television show. On a regular television show,
- 34:06like if you're going to have kids on Star Trek, for example, there
- 34:09are very strict laws and regulations around labor, around consent, around all that
- 34:15kind of stuff. But when it comes to making a YouTube video, it's
- 34:20not considered to be like Star Trek. It's considered to be like your own
- 34:23private Facebook page or something. Right, it's just apparent taking video of their
- 34:30kid and posting it. They have the right to do that in most jurisdictions,
- 34:34right, But what's the difference between Star Trek having a child actor and
- 34:40these very lucrative YouTube channels with families that have kids and the families make their
- 34:49money from these videos, you know, that kind of thing, or at
- 34:53least it's in that direction. So it should they should there be laws around
- 34:58it, and I would argue absolutely there should be. And I think reality
- 35:01TV shows might also kind of be off the hook in some ways I can't
- 35:05remember. But the point is is that children need to be protected. In
- 35:09my general policy, and it's kind of case by case, but generally speaking,
- 35:14my policy is don't do it. Don't have kids and your videos.
- 35:19Don't have kids on reality TV. You can certainly have kids as child actors
- 35:22at times, but there needs to be heavy regulations because there are so many
- 35:29stories that we hear about kids being exploited in various different ways for labor or
- 35:34sexuality, being traumatized right, being taught that they're only worth is how famous
- 35:40they are, how good they look, or this sort of stuff. So
- 35:44there needs to be more regulation, and I don't know exactly how that would
- 35:46look, but generally speaking, when in doubt, no, just don't.
- 35:52We don't need kids to be on YouTube, We don't need kids to be
- 35:54in reality television shows. The TV shows will be fine without the kids.
- 36:00Don't take the risk is that that's just flat out What they'll say now is
- 36:04like, well, we have consent of the kid, the kids sign in
- 36:07the dotted line. Well, my position is, and it's obvious that can
- 36:12you really know that a ten year old child or even a fifteen year old
- 36:15child knows what they're consenting to? Really do we really know that they know
- 36:22what they're signing off on? And the answer is absolutely not. There's no
- 36:25way that a kid understands what the consequences will be down the line if they
- 36:30actually consent to being on a show like this, right, and you dangle
- 36:35money out front of them and fame, and you have a parent that's pressuring
- 36:37them to do it. You know, there's a lot of reasons why you
- 36:42would make up justifications for it. And again, like I said, there's
- 36:45no reason to do it. We don't have to have it, and there
- 36:49carries a risk that we all understand, so it just should Now, I
- 36:52don't think that the majority of kids in situations like this are being traumatized.
- 36:57We hear about the I think the out seem the outliers, but it's hard
- 37:01to know, right, It's hard to know. And like I said,
- 37:04it's just it's not worth it. We don't need it. So is this
- 37:07normalization of this sort of content raising awareness and thus there are more protections of
- 37:13place, both legally and maybe socially. Yeah, but I think we're far
- 37:17from it. The other thing you ask is might this experience that you had
- 37:23as an early vlogger, might it have traumatized you? And the answer is
- 37:29absolutely yes. As someone myself, I've been traumatized to this day. I
- 37:36have behaviors in my life that are out of fear and terror that I went
- 37:43through, particularly during the trial, but it predates that, like one of
- 37:47the things, and it's kind of a good or I don't know as a
- 37:50pronocount. One of the things that I am doing now that I didn't do
- 37:54before is I'm much more heavily editing my videos and by my audio episodes.
- 38:01And of course that's a good thing because I'm spending more time making sure it's
- 38:07a good product, and I see it that way. But sometimes I'm spending
- 38:12way too much time editing everything because I'm terrified, not necessarily because I'm trying
- 38:17to make a better product, but because I'm I've been terrorized by the trolls
- 38:25and by the haters and by the mobs of people who are trying to get
- 38:29me. I'm living in a state of fear, and that is not a
- 38:32place anyone deserves to be, and it's also not a good place to be
- 38:37as a content provider. And I went through the traumas in my forties and
- 38:42fifties. I have a lot more support, a lot more power, a
- 38:46lot more resilience than a young person would. So if I was traumatized by
- 38:52it. Then yeah, at the age of eleven, when you're going through
- 38:54this. So it sounds like from your story that you were traumatized a lot
- 39:00as a child, and then you turn to the Internet as either a creative
- 39:04endeavor or maybe a therapeutic endeavor, maybe both, and then you get some
- 39:07support and maybe some gratification, but you also get these horrific comments that I'm
- 39:14hoping you saw them as just being trolls, but it's hard not to let
- 39:17it get under your skin. And now you're like, well, I have
- 39:22this problem with my self esteem and other kinds of issues. How much of
- 39:28it is YouTube and how much of it was predated YouTube. It's impossible to
- 39:32know, but absolutely it could be affecting you. And it's just like any
- 39:37other trauma, Like when you are verbally abused by one of your parents for
- 39:44five years or ten years. We all understand that that's a lifetime of struggle
- 39:49from that, that that internalized voice will be with you the rest of your
- 39:52life, and maybe even the tendency to be verbal abuse of yourself will be
- 39:55with you the rest of your life, or to tolerate verbal abuse your partner
- 40:00when you're raising kids or something you know, it's just we all understand that
- 40:02that it's stuck in there to some extent, we can become aware of it.
- 40:07Awareness is power. We can work on it, we can heal from
- 40:10it, we can have corrective experiences around it, we can get lots of
- 40:13therapy for it. But we're never going to have fully become a person that
- 40:17didn't go through that and the same ghost for this sort of stuff. I'm
- 40:22personally probably always, I guess, I don't know if I ever really admitted
- 40:27this out loud or thought of it is. I'm permanently damaged by the fourteen
- 40:34years of horrific, hateful comments. Now, I'm not talking about people who
- 40:38have criticisms, so I'm not talking about people who have constructive feedback. I'm
- 40:44not people. I'm not talking about people who occasionally lose their temper with me
- 40:47but then apologize or whatever. That's not I'm talking. I'm talking about some
- 40:52just really awful things, just messages that give the idea that some one just
- 41:00absolutely hates you, someone just absolutely knows and believes that you are an evil,
- 41:07horrific human being. And not only that, but they band together with
- 41:12other people and they work against you. You know, it's I consider myself
- 41:15a pretty confident I would like to think of myself as a healthy person,
- 41:20and I do everything I can to protect myself from whatever sort of negative effects
- 41:24there have been from that. You know, I do a lot of emotional
- 41:27regulation. I do a lot of support, I do a lot of reaching
- 41:30out. I have full systems. I mean. So here's another thing that
- 41:34I hired Elena on the podcast. Probably a good sixty percent of the reason
- 41:39why I hired Elena my brother's kid is because of this reason. Because I
- 41:45want to be able to interact with the comment section and with emails and stuff,
- 41:50but I also cannot handle being traumatized, you know, like I would
- 41:55have this experience where I don't know if I ever talked about this micro but
- 42:00I would say, look at the comments of a YouTube video or I would
- 42:05go into my dms on Instagram or something, and you know, ninety nine
- 42:09times out of one hundred it's neutral or positive. And I would go in
- 42:15there and i'd you know, start looking around and reply or just read or
- 42:20whatever, and then every once in a while, boom, this thing would
- 42:22happen. And I work basically twenty four seven, So you know, if
- 42:28I have something to do on the podcast, and it's like midnight, I
- 42:32don't not do it because it's off business hours. Like I'm basically just occasionally
- 42:38always checking and maybe you know that's a problem, but but I, you
- 42:42know, I'll check it out. You know, I'll just have a wild
- 42:45hair at midnight on a random Wednesday and I'll be like, oh, I
- 42:50wonder what is going on in the comments section of that one video? Did
- 42:53I wonder where people thought of it? So, you know, I go
- 42:55look at it and again, most of time, everything's fine. But every
- 42:59once in a while, boom, and then I can't sleep that night because
- 43:01of some very angry, hurtful comment. And when I think about it,
- 43:07it's the comments where people make super you know, if someone says something like,
- 43:10oh my god, what he just said? That was so stupid,
- 43:15Like those kind of comments. They're not great, but they don't really get
- 43:17under my skin because I'm like, well, yeah, I mean they thought
- 43:21one thing was stupid that I said. I you know, I say stupid
- 43:23things or whatever. But it's the comments that are just like like I saw
- 43:28one recently where people were fighting with each other. I think it seemed like
- 43:32it was and one person was accusing the other people for being like cult members
- 43:42of mine or something, and that got under my skin clearly because I saw
- 43:45it, I don't know, a long time ago, and it's still kind
- 43:47of rattling around in my head. It's not a direct observation to me.
- 43:51I mean, they're mainly attacking another listener to the podcast. But what I
- 43:54took away from it was, Wait, this person thinks that I have a
- 43:59cult and that I'm a cult leader, and that what I'm manipulating people to
- 44:05be in my cult so that I could control people, and this malicious,
- 44:08horrific like what and it's it's that, and that's just one of a million
- 44:15kinds of things. But anyway, point is is that that would happen to
- 44:19me, and then I would pull away from the oh you know, I
- 44:22would start putting it in my calendar and reminding myself, don't look at the
- 44:25comments section because I would be tempted. And this would happen hundreds of times
- 44:30where I would be lulled into a state of being okay with the comments,
- 44:36and so I'd go back into the you know, a month later, after
- 44:38I kind of forgot about how horrible it was for that week when that comment
- 44:43got out of my skin, I go back to the comments section, and
- 44:45for a few weeks everything's fine, and then boom, this one comment will
- 44:50come out of the blue and it'll knock me off my feet and my week
- 44:54is ruined or my day is ruined, and it'll affect the content that I
- 44:59make. You know, I'm I'll be more tentative, or I'll I'll spend
- 45:01ten times the amount of hours editing everything making sure that there's nothing in there
- 45:06that could be criticized. Or I feel like I don't have the motivation to
- 45:12even make content because it just doesn't feel good to worry about being slapped across
- 45:16the face metaphorically or emotionallything like that. So I won't I won't feel good
- 45:22about making content, you know, it really it's rough. And then so
- 45:28I hired Elena to actually do a lot of things, but also to look
- 45:35at the comments and let me know if a comment section is actually okay for
- 45:38me to look at, which sounds just ridiculous, but you know, it
- 45:44is what it is, and maybe it's something to do with me and my
- 45:46OCPD and my insecurities. It does, obviously, but I contend that it's
- 45:52it's universal to all content providers. You know, everyone has different levels of
- 45:57tolerance. But you know, a good example of this is that Umbardo,
- 46:01for example, he comes across as a very carefree, very confident person,
- 46:05and he would say that he is. And in the beginning, he I
- 46:07would ask him like, because he would get bad comments every now and then,
- 46:10and I would ask him how he deals with it. He'd just be
- 46:14like, well, you know, I just don't really care. I just
- 46:15let it roll off my back. And I always admired that and try to
- 46:19figure out, like, okay, how do I get like that? But
- 46:22over time, I've actually seen the comments get under his skin. I think
- 46:25for him, in the beginning, he just hadn't experienced much of what I
- 46:29had experienced. And over time now he's he's different. Now I see him
- 46:36and he'll play it down. He'll say like, yeah, I'm fine,
- 46:38but I can tell and I've asked him point blank and he'll confirm that he
- 46:44has. He has a similar reaction that I do, even though he comes
- 46:46across like he's care free and confident and above it all. You know,
- 46:52I don't think anyone is a prime example of this is I'm a big fan
- 46:57of Conan O'Brien, and years and years ago I remember him talking about how
- 47:00he doesn't read reviews about him. He doesn't read any comments about him.
- 47:05Ever, he has a super famous, big podcast now similar he doesn't read
- 47:09any of the reviews. He doesn't read comments, and people love ConA and
- 47:15Bryan, so you'd think, well, why wouldn't you read it. Well,
- 47:16he's talked about it. It's not the same, but as similar kind
- 47:21of experience for me. So all this is to say that when you were
- 47:24eleven, and you were and you were probably experiencing it sounds like a hundred
- 47:30times of toxicity that I have ever experienced. Yeah, that is going to
- 47:34get in your skin. It's going to Even though it's the same when we're
- 47:38being yelled at by our parents or our boss at work, there's a part
- 47:43of us that knows that the other person is irrational and unfair and ridiculous.
- 47:46No, I'm not a stupid idiot. That person is wrong. But we
- 47:52are not computers. We're not able to completely cut that out. We are
- 47:57affected by the way we're treated, were affected by how people treat us,
- 48:01at what people say about us, how people think about us, what we
- 48:05think they think about us in both positive and negative ways. You know,
- 48:08if if I know that people accept me and don't reject me, that gives
- 48:15me self esteem. It gives me fuel to take on the world. And
- 48:17the opposite is true as well. If I think that people are against me,
- 48:22it sucks the fuel out of me, you know. So. Yeah,
- 48:25and for you, when you were eleven, should you have been on
- 48:30the internet? I would say no. I mean, maybe you could make
- 48:32an argument because he didn't tell the full story, that it was an overall
- 48:37good for you. But you know, and maybe that was true. But
- 48:39at the very least, you should have had someone by your side who cared
- 48:45about you and loved you, who could mentor you and protect you, someone
- 48:49who could moderate your comment section before you looked at it, or something like
- 48:52that. You know, you deserved that. You should have had your own
- 48:54Alina. All right, let's take a break, we get back questions.
- 49:04All right, we're back from the break. Let's do an oppe, y'all.
- 49:07These people became patrons all the way back in twenty twenty and have stayed
- 49:09patrons as loyal listeners to the podcast. We have a petier annual patron Jessica
- 49:15from Vineyard, Utah. We got annual patron Victoria from Seattle, Washington,
- 49:21I know that place. We have annual patron Melissa from Australia. We have
- 49:27Jessica from Tennessee. We have Lisa Shaden, Sarah, Greg Meghan from god
- 49:34knows where. We have Annette A Petier annual patron Annette from I believe Latvia.
- 49:38In fact, I think I read one of your emails recently. We
- 49:42have I think it's Latvia, LV. We have Kristen from Maryland. We
- 49:46have Brenna from California. We got Danielle from Virginia. We got annual patron
- 49:52Katie from Redmond, Washington, another place that I know a lot about grew
- 49:57up right by there. We have toma Us from Australia. We got Elaine
- 50:01carl And and Patreon Duck from god knows where. We have Kayla from California.
- 50:09We got Nomi it knowing me from Ohio. We got JV from Saskatoon,
- 50:17Sastoon, Canada. Right, almost said California because it was Cia,
- 50:21but Saskatoon that's Canada, right. We got annual upperture patron Petia from Bulgaria.
- 50:27We have Nina from Seattle, and we have annual patron Alexandra from Irvine,
- 50:34California, which is where my uncle used to live. Thank you for
- 50:37being a patron y'all and staying at patron through thick and thin. Truly,
- 50:43patron numbers have been dipping a little bit lately. Full disclosure so freaks me
- 50:49out. So for the people that have stuck around, it makes me feel
- 50:57a lot more secure in my future to pay my bills. All right,
- 51:00This next email is from anonymous up to your patron. She says, Hi,
- 51:04Kirk, I know you have talked about this many many times, but
- 51:07here I am confused about my own attachment style. My therapist seems to agree
- 51:10with me that I have disorganized attachment style, but she's not someone who guides
- 51:14me a lot, so I thought I would ask you. I know you
- 51:16can't diagnose me, but I'd like to hear your thoughts. I have an
- 51:20extensive history of childhood neglecting trauma, and there wasn't a single adult who was
- 51:24able to be a safe attachment to me when I was young. Both my
- 51:28mother and my father were abusive to me. As a result, I seem
- 51:30to not ever be able to trust other people, but also not ever be
- 51:34able to trust myself, and I have a lot of self hatred. So
- 51:37just champing in here. Yeah, that's straight down the middle disorganize attachment.
- 51:40You're very self aware, by the way, and the way it's conceptualized by
- 51:45the experts dating back fifty years is that the working models are such that you
- 51:51both have a negative working model of others and a negative working model those self,
- 51:55which you describe. You don't trust other people and you also don't trust
- 51:59the self. That's the configuration for disorganized attachment. You go on to say,
- 52:04I surely do exhibit both anxious and avoidant traits. I fear vulnerability,
- 52:08but sometimes I can get extremely close to people and then I get this vulnerability
- 52:12hangover after and I'm terrified of what I have done. I tend to push
- 52:15and pull people away. I have been called hot and cold many times.
- 52:20I can feel both preoccupied and avoidant at exactly the same time, and this
- 52:23inner conflict leads to tremendous amount of fear and confusion. It's like I'm not
- 52:29sure whether I should lean forward or run away, so I just mentally freeze
- 52:32and often panic. Would you consider my description as a sign of having disorganized
- 52:37attachment style, and to Vimao, yes, the short answer is you're describing
- 52:42a quintessential textbook example of disorganized attachment. And I understand that when you hear
- 52:50descriptions of both preoccupied and avoidant attachment and you're like, well what about that.
- 52:54No, you're describing straight down the middle textbook And I'm sorry that you're
- 53:00going through this. It is a rough condition. I'm glad you're in therapy.
- 53:04So, yeah, you feel vulnerability one hundred percent, but sometimes you
- 53:08get extremely close to people, right and then you have a vulnerability hangover and
- 53:13after you're terrified of what you've done. That's kind of a key to disorganized
- 53:16and fearful attachment is that you are desperate for closeness. You will get close
- 53:22and then immediately in the moment or afterwards, you feel tremendous fear and terror.
- 53:28People with preoccupied attachment and avoidant they don't necessarily feel that amount of terror.
- 53:34They could, but that's that description right there, is indicative one hundred
- 53:38percent of disorganized attachment. You say you tend to push and then pull people
- 53:44away. You're hot and cold, you feel preoccupied and avoidant at exactly the
- 53:47same time. And then here's kind of the key you say. It's like
- 53:51I'm not sure whether I should lean forward or run away, so I just
- 53:53mentally freeze and often panic. That is quintessential disorganized, fearful attachment. When
- 54:00I describe it to students and to clients, that's basically the phrasing that I
- 54:06use that when the child was young, they wanted for you. In all
- 54:12likelihood, this is true for you, that children have an instinct to run
- 54:15towards their attachment figures, which is often their parents, their caregivers, because
- 54:21that is the secure base, that is most often the place where they will
- 54:24be taken care of and attune to and protect it and safe and secure.
- 54:29And the child moves away from the caregivers to explore the world in various different
- 54:34ways mentally and physically, to grow and individuate and experience and learn. And
- 54:39then something scary happens, as inevitably well, and the child runs back to
- 54:44the parent, and then rooms away from the parent, runs back wrote rooms
- 54:47away, and this process happens throughout the lifespan. An eighteen year old will
- 54:52go off to college, but when things go bad, she'll call home and
- 54:58cry and say she had a bad time in class or something like that.
- 55:00That's move away, explore, learn, individuate, comeback, secure base.
- 55:06And when the child is very young, they do this in a very obvious
- 55:12way, visible way. But when the child is being abused by the parents,
- 55:17the child is stuck between a rock and a hard place because they are
- 55:22instinctually wanting to run away from the threat and run toward the parent a caregiver.
- 55:29But what if the parent is the threat? So the child doesn't know
- 55:31what to do. Instinctually, they have no idea what to do. Emotionally,
- 55:35they have no idea what to do. They have no physically, they
- 55:37have no idea how to behave where to run, So they want to run
- 55:44towards the parents because the parents are the safe haven supposedly, but the parents
- 55:47are the threat. The parents are the ones being the scary monster. So
- 55:52the child freezes and shuts down or freaks out or something because they also don't
- 55:59want to run away from the parent because instinctually they understand they feel as though
- 56:04running away from the parent is even more of a threat. But they can't
- 56:07run away from the parent, but they but they need to run away from
- 56:10the parent because the parent is the threat, so they don't know what to
- 56:13do. So when you say I'm not sure whether I should lean forward or
- 56:16run away, so I just mentally freeze an off to panic. Yeah that's
- 56:21straight down the middle, disorganized, feeling preoccupied and avoiding exactly the same time.
- 56:24Yeah, that's preoccupied or that's disorganized, right. The next emails from
- 56:30Annual Apertier Patron, anonymous patron from Beirut. She says, I saw the
- 56:34video you posted about the abuse of Amaranth. This was a hard one to
- 56:38watch as I have a cycle of entering unhealthy relationships. My ex once swerved
- 56:44his car towards the edge of a mountain because I was scared of his speeding.
- 56:47I always worry that I'm going to trigger my therapist with the stuff I
- 56:51have gone through. My therapist doesn't disclose for their own ethical reasons, but
- 56:55out of curiosity. How do therapists who have been abused have a gate clients
- 57:00describing the details of their own abuse? Do they ever get triggered in the
- 57:02middle of session? If so, what are the go to strategies they used
- 57:06to soothe themselves in that moment? Is this covered in graduate school and of
- 57:09email? Yeah? A good question. Well, the first thing is that
- 57:15you shouldn't be worrying about triggering your client. That is, sorry, you
- 57:19shouldn't be worried about triggering your therapist. That is your therapists responsibility one hundred
- 57:22percent. So you and if you're particularly concerned, just to ask your therapists
- 57:29you'd be like, so, do I ever trigger you? I'm sorry,
- 57:30you know you can ask that question, but that is not your responsibility.
- 57:36And therapists need to work on their own stuff to be able to handle this
- 57:39and maybe not take clients that have traumas like this because of their own vulnerabilities,
- 57:45because you know, a lot of people have triggers, a lot of
- 57:47people have PTSD. Have you said that, does it ever happen in the
- 57:52middle of session? Yeah? Absolutely therapists. Like I said, can't all
- 57:55of us have our own relational traumas. It's just a matter of degree,
- 58:00and absolutely therapists can become triggered in the middle of session. And then you
- 58:06say, is it covered in grad school? My first answer to that is,
- 58:09yeah, of course it's covered in grad school. But then when I
- 58:12think about it, and of course I only have my own experience and the
- 58:16little bit of research I've read in this area to guide me. But yes,
- 58:22it's covered in graduate school. But I would imagine that a lot of
- 58:27people graduate from graduate school having very little contact and education in this area.
- 58:35I would like to think that that's not true, but it could be true.
- 58:38I'd like to think for myself, like there's no specific class on this
- 58:44topic or even an umbrella class. Like in my program, we have kind
- 58:49of a rare class that's based on family of origin work, and you would
- 58:53potentially discuss that vulnerability in that class. Hopefully you would, but it's not
- 59:00a guarantee. I mean, if the student doesn't bring it up, then
- 59:01the professor doesn't know how to highlight it, right. So that's one class,
- 59:07but there's not usually just a class of just like how to handle vicarious
- 59:12trauma or how to handle your own PTSD and how to avoid being triggered in
- 59:16session. Now, hopefully when you start practicing, your supervisor gets into that
- 59:21with you, and you, as a trainee, share that with your supervisor,
- 59:25but it's not a guarantee, and your supervisor might not be very good
- 59:29at guiding people on that. So I'm going to take a guess and say
- 59:34that most therapists are not trained well enough. Having said that, I would
- 59:38like to think that at least by the time people start getting into their bid
- 59:45career, they would have come across literature or knowledge or understanding that would guide
- 59:50them to work on this and take care of themselves so that they can one
- 59:53just protect themselves from their clients traumas, but also they could stay present and
- 59:59helpful to their clients if they are potentially at risk of being triggered or triggered.
- 1:00:05So, I don't know, but I would guess that most therapists understand
- 1:00:12what's going on. I would at least like the hope. So then you
- 1:00:15ask, you know, what are the go to strategies to soothe the self
- 1:00:17in the moment. It's complicated. There's a lot of different things one could
- 1:00:22do. I mean there's thousands of things, differentiation techniques, relaxation techniques,
- 1:00:28self awareness, emotional regulation, maybe even just kind of checking out for a
- 1:00:34bit. I've done that before. I'll I don't have PTSD, but something
- 1:00:38might happen that might kind of shock me or be a distraction, and I'll
- 1:00:45go inward and for maybe a couple of minutes, I consciously know that I'm
- 1:00:51not being the best listener, but I'll be nodding my head as the client
- 1:00:55is talking or something. But I'm kind of pushed off kilter, and I
- 1:01:00am trying to gather myself and return to empathy and listening again. And maybe
- 1:01:07I don't hear that well or retain the information that well for those two minutes
- 1:01:13that can happen. That's not great, but sometimes it's better than just stopping
- 1:01:17the session altogether and being Okay, hold on, I need to take a
- 1:01:21break for five minutes because I was just triggered. You know, it's it's
- 1:01:23always a cost benefit analysis and so, but that doesn't happen. I can't.
- 1:01:30I literally can't remember the last time that happened to me. I don't
- 1:01:32even know if it ever happened to me, honestly when I think about it.
- 1:01:36But if it had, it would have been maybe ten, fifteen years
- 1:01:39ago or something. Actually, I do remember one client that might have done
- 1:01:45this to me, might have made me go inward a little bit like,
- 1:01:47oh huh. Interesting. This next emails from a page in Jeremy from California.
- 1:01:52He says, Dear doctor Kirk, do you have any guidelines for people
- 1:01:55who have crushes on their friends? Or other unable people. What are the
- 1:02:00rules for behaving ethically, acknowledging one's emotions, managing friendships, and leading a
- 1:02:06healthy romantic life while crushing on someone who already has a partner. End of
- 1:02:10question. He Jeremy literally included end of question at the end of at the
- 1:02:15end of this question, which is great. So end of question and of
- 1:02:20email. Yeah, it's complicated. So you're asking guidelines for people who have
- 1:02:24crushes on their friends or other unavailable people. It depends on everyone involved.
- 1:02:30And in some scenarios, you could tell your friend or your co worker or
- 1:02:35something. Well, co worker, you could tell your friend because you knew
- 1:02:39that they would react well about it. You'd be like, by the way,
- 1:02:42I've always had a crush on you, and your friend could be like
- 1:02:47totally fine with that. It could not affect them negatively. But there is
- 1:02:52a risk, right, and you want to err on the side of caution.
- 1:02:55But you know, telling someone about it could really concern them, could
- 1:03:00scare them, could make them feel awkward around you, and if you But
- 1:03:06it also depends on the situation, like if you're totally in love with someone
- 1:03:08and you just can't bear it. That's one version of a crush and another
- 1:03:14crush is just like I'm lonely and I sure wish that she would date me,
- 1:03:19but she has a boyfriend. But maybe one day she'll date me.
- 1:03:22You know that That's different, So case by case, but generally speaking,
- 1:03:29the overall solution is that you fix your attachment life such because like I don't
- 1:03:36know, I don't know if there is research on this, but in my
- 1:03:38anecdotal experience, if you are having problematic crushes, it's because there's a hole
- 1:03:45in your heart that needs to be filled with attachment and romance and companionship and
- 1:03:52love, and in lieu of that, you'd rather crush on someone. But
- 1:03:58if you have that whole filled by someone that is actually there for you and
- 1:04:01loves you back, then anecdotally, you're not going to crush on other people,
- 1:04:06at least to degree, maybe not at all. If you had someone
- 1:04:11in your corner that made you feel loved, that made you feel attractive,
- 1:04:14that made you feel accepted and stable over time, and it was a mutual
- 1:04:19relationship, then there's not room in your heart to crush on other people.
- 1:04:25So that's one of the rules, is that you take care of yourself and
- 1:04:30do what you gotta do to make sure that you're at least heading down the
- 1:04:32road to have that happened for you. The other thing is to not entertain
- 1:04:39the ideas, because if the person is unavailable, they're unavailable, and you're
- 1:04:43just harming yourself, particularly the other person, by entertaining the idea. You
- 1:04:47know, some people, if you've ever been the target of an unwanted crush,
- 1:04:53especially if it's happened more than once, it feels bad. You know,
- 1:04:59there are a lot of women out there and people, but I know
- 1:05:01a lot of women out there who have had that experience where a lot of
- 1:05:05strange crushes will just emerge or literally every guy or many of the men that
- 1:05:13they interact with, whether it's at work or friends or even like their friends
- 1:05:17boyfriend, they will, for whatever reason their vibe or something, they will
- 1:05:21get a lot of crushes from people. And over time it can feel like
- 1:05:27is that all I'm worth to men? Is that all I am to men
- 1:05:30is just a potential romantic and sexual partner, Like can I can't I just
- 1:05:34be a friend? Can't I just be a co worker? So it can
- 1:05:38harm a lot of people, and the way you can try to curb it
- 1:05:42is to just not entertain it in your mind. You have the feelings,
- 1:05:45you know, I'm just thinking about for myself, I imagine I can't remember
- 1:05:51specific but I can remember feeling this emerging feeling of just like, oh,
- 1:05:58a little bit of an attraction or romantic curiosity. But in those situations that
- 1:06:03I'm talking about, I will quickly just discount it and be like, well,
- 1:06:09you know, stop that. It's not helpful to go down that road.
- 1:06:12And for me anyway, it just ends. You know, maybe it's
- 1:06:15sort of lingering in the background, but I don't entertain it. I don't
- 1:06:20let it drive my behavior. I don't let it rattle around in my brain.
- 1:06:25I don't start fantasizing or imagining what it would be like with them,
- 1:06:30And as a result, I think it just dissipates, or it just kind
- 1:06:33of fades into the background and the primary relationship, the real relationship, comes
- 1:06:39to the forefront. So I think those are some ethical rules to follow.
- 1:06:44But again, those are hard things to do, and if you're lonely and
- 1:06:46you don't have someone, then it's going to be hard to modulate those feelings.
- 1:06:50And the solution is to have a companion, have someone that you're that
- 1:06:56crushes back on you right, all right, well that is a that episode.
- 1:07:00Slowly working my way through at least the upper tier patron emails and everyone
- 1:07:05out there, Please take care of yourself because they deserve it. You really,
- 1:07:08really really do