Latest / Consumerpedia / 103 - Shady Home Improvement Financing
Transcript
- 0:02Your furnace dies during a polar vortex or your AC goes kaput
- 0:06during a summer heat wave. You need a replacement and you
- 0:09need it now. A new furnace or air conditioner
- 0:12can cost thousands of dollars. Many homeowners don't have that
- 0:15much cash on hand, which creates a big financial problem.
- 0:19Maybe you can charge the purchase.
- 0:20If you can handle the added debt or have that much credit
- 0:23available. Maybe you can get a home equity
- 0:25loan or a home equity line of credit from your bank.
- 0:28You may also be able to get financing through your
- 0:31contractor working through a third party lender.
- 0:33But beware, a recent Consumers Checkbook investigation found
- 0:37that many contractors use these repair emergencies to push
- 0:40really bad loans on their stressed out customers.
- 0:44I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 0:47checkbook.org. Welcome to Consumerpedia at
- 0:51checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:53consumers select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:57Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 1:00any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 1:03completely independent and objective.
- 1:06Now here's the host of Consumerpedia America's Consumer
- 1:10expert, the Consumer Man Herb Weispom.
- 1:13Checkbooks Executive Editor Kevin Brassler is here with what
- 1:16you need to know, plus advice on what to do when the HVAC system
- 1:20goes on the Fritz. Hey, Kevin.
- 1:22Hey, Herb. So you have been investigating
- 1:24these plans for some time now and you found some really
- 1:27extraordinarily bad deals. With some of these plans, it's
- 1:30hard to even describe like the horribleness of them, especially
- 1:35one contract we looked at which is a lease.
- 1:38It's a lease for furnaces and air conditioning equipment.
- 1:42They also are leasing water heaters.
- 1:45And when we actually dug into the details of these plans, I
- 1:47mean, basically concluded that these leasing deals for HVAC
- 1:51equipment is the worst deal I've seen.
- 1:54And 30 years of doing this stuff, I mean, they're just so 1
- 1:57sided in terms of, you know, the costs incurred by the homeowner
- 2:01and in terms of, you know, the lack of the rights that the
- 2:04homeowner has in these contracts.
- 2:07So installing a new furnace or air conditioning isn't something
- 2:09most of us do more than maybe once.
- 2:11If we're a homeowner. It's easy to get ripped off.
- 2:13High interest loans are common. But I got to understand this bit
- 2:16about people leasing their HVAC system like we used to lease
- 2:19telephones. Yeah.
- 2:21I mean, so there's almost 2 separate problems that can occur
- 2:25when you need to essentially borrow money or finance an
- 2:28expensive purchase like a new air conditioner, heat pump or
- 2:31furnace. So 1 is that, you know, they
- 2:33have these 0% financing deals that aren't 0% financing loans
- 2:38at all. They're really high interest
- 2:40loans and we'll talk about those in a minute.
- 2:43But it was brought to my attention last year that some
- 2:45companies are now offering leasing for HVAC equipment.
- 2:49This started, you know, last year.
- 2:51There's a, a consumer reporter, he works out of Cincinnati and
- 2:54he's, he's also the station he he works for his owned by
- 2:57Scripps. And so his stuff does end up
- 2:58going to lots of stations nationally.
- 3:01John Matarese, he's a great guy. Yeah, John Matarese.
- 3:03And so he, he emailed us and said, you know, I have this
- 3:06homeowner and he signed this lease for a furnace and an air
- 3:10conditioner. And he didn't realize it was a
- 3:12lease and he's, he can't get out of this.
- 3:14And I was wondering if, you know, I could interview you
- 3:16about it. John's very good at what he
- 3:18does. My first reaction was, well,
- 3:19this must be some kind of mistake.
- 3:20I've never even heard of this before.
- 3:22And this is what we do, cover this kind of stuff.
- 3:24So that I reached out to this homeowner.
- 3:26His name's Tim Pride. He's just a very good guy.
- 3:29He's a retired firefighter out in Cincinnati.
- 3:32What happened was in 2019, his central air conditioning unit
- 3:35died. He called out a company.
- 3:37The company is Knockelman Heating and Air Conditioning.
- 3:40And he says the Rep for that company told him that he needed
- 3:43not just a new air conditioner, but a new furnace because it
- 3:46would just be better to replace them all at once.
- 3:49And so this Knockelman outfit, they quoted him a total price to
- 3:53do that work plus put in like, I don't know, a new UV filter or
- 3:56something like that, a total price of $22,000 to supply and
- 4:00install this equipment. And so Tim says, you know, he's
- 4:03kind of surprised by this high price.
- 4:05It was it was a lot of money. And so he just asked about, you
- 4:07know, do you have any payment options?
- 4:09And he says that the HVAC company's Rep told him they had
- 4:13a way where he could spread out his payments over many months.
- 4:17He never mentioned the word lease.
- 4:19He just said, Oh no, we have a plan where you can spread out
- 4:21your payments. And so he gave Tim this contract
- 4:26and the contract had on there the amount of money he was
- 4:29spending on the equipment was 22,000 and $50.
- 4:33And that, you know, he can make monthly payments of $288.00 / 10
- 4:38years. And it had a total payments
- 4:40entry of like $33,700. And so Tim did some quick math
- 4:46and said, OK, well that basically equates to an interest
- 4:48rate of somewhere between 12 and 14%.
- 4:51I can't remember what it was. And he decided at, you know, at
- 4:53that time that that seemed like a reasonable interest rate.
- 4:56And so he went ahead and signed. And he didn't know he was
- 4:59signing a lease. No, he thought he was signing a
- 5:02loan. So the document did say, you
- 5:04know, he, he sent me this lease and it does say this is a lease
- 5:09and then it's front and back and it's tiny tight, but it does say
- 5:13lease on there. But Tim didn't realize this
- 5:16until five years later. He and his wife were thinking
- 5:18about selling their home. And so they were, you know, you
- 5:21know, before we put the home on the market, before we take in
- 5:24offers, we probably should go ahead and pay off, you know,
- 5:27this loan that we have for our furnace and air conditioner.
- 5:29You know, it's going to be basically a lien on the home
- 5:31that we need to satisfy before we can sell it anyways.
- 5:33So we dugout this form that he had signed and his wife said you
- 5:37can, this isn't even a loan, it's a lease.
- 5:39And I mean, he was stunned by this.
- 5:41He says, you know, he would never lease anything.
- 5:44If he had known it was a lease, he never would have signed it.
- 5:46He wouldn't lease a car even he told me.
- 5:48So he's really now just still, he says he's just kicking
- 5:51himself over not seeing this. But the salesperson, he says,
- 5:55you know, slid this contract across to them and pointed out
- 5:58what his monthly payment would be and pointed out that that
- 6:00would be the monthly payment for 10 years and this would be the
- 6:03payoff amount. And you know, again, they went
- 6:05over the interest rate and he seemed thought it was
- 6:07reasonable, so he signed it. So a couple of questions.
- 6:09If he were not to make a payment, they could take the
- 6:12HVAC system out of his house because they they own it.
- 6:15Yeah, this is the big problem. So if you read the contract
- 6:18right and, and really you have to dig into it to understand
- 6:21what all the details are. But if you read the contract, it
- 6:24says first of all Tim never owns the furnace or air conditioner
- 6:29that was installed by this company and he never will own it
- 6:32unless he pays a big termination penalty.
- 6:35So the contract says essentially his monthly payment, yes is
- 6:38around $288 and that covers the 1st 10 years, the lease.
- 6:43But even after those 10 years, he still doesn't own the furnace
- 6:48or the air conditioner. The contractor continues to own
- 6:51it. And if he wants to keep using
- 6:52this stuff, even though he's paid for it over 10 years plus
- 6:55interest, he has to keep paying this company $288.00 a month to
- 7:01keep that equipment. Oh my goodness.
- 7:03So the 10 year length of this lease, it's nearly meaningless.
- 7:07The only thing that 10 years really means at all is that
- 7:11during those 10 years, Nachman agrees to maintain the
- 7:15equipment. And so that's one of their
- 7:16selling points is a lot. We found that a lot of these
- 7:19reps, when they talk to their customers, they say, oh, we have
- 7:22a membership plan, or it's a plan where you pay us each month
- 7:25and then we'll take care of all maintenance.
- 7:28And to the company's credit, Tim says his air conditioner did
- 7:30breakdown within the first few years, and Nachman came out and
- 7:33dealt with it. It was an expensive repair.
- 7:35But even after 10 years, if he was to keep using his furnace
- 7:39and air conditioner, he's got to keep paying this monthly
- 7:42payment, even though he's already essentially paid for the
- 7:45equipment plus a lot of interest.
- 7:47He's got to keep paying during the course of the 10 years and
- 7:50even afterward, if he says, look, I don't want to pay this
- 7:53$288 anymore, if he stops paying, the company has the
- 7:57right to remotely disconnect his furnace or air conditioner until
- 8:01the balance is paid. And during those 10 years, if
- 8:05Tim says or says right now, yeah, I want to terminate, I
- 8:09don't want this, I want to get rid of this deal.
- 8:11I don't want to do this anymore. He has to pay a termination fee.
- 8:14And on top of that, he has to be a $500 cancellation fee.
- 8:18And the problem is the termination fees are
- 8:20ridiculously high. Even after he's been paying for
- 8:2410 years, he'll have paid really $34,000 for this furnishing air
- 8:29conditioner. And even after then his only
- 8:31options are to keep paying the $288.00 a month forever I guess.
- 8:36Or after 10 years he can pay a termination fee.
- 8:39So he'd say well you've already paid for this stuff plus
- 8:42interest. The termination fee, at that
- 8:43point it can't be that much money.
- 8:46No, the termination fee even after 10 years is 61% of the
- 8:50original cost of his equipment. So he'll have paid for the
- 8:54equipment plus interest, and if he wants to quit, he still has
- 8:58to come up with another $13,000 to pay it off at that point to
- 9:03get out of this lease. So here's his math after 10
- 9:06years, right? He thought he was signing a 10
- 9:07year financing agreement. The math on this is after 10
- 9:11years, there's actual cost to own the equipment to buy it.
- 9:14Essentially at the end of this lease from the company that's
- 9:17been leasing to him is going to be $47,000.
- 9:22So it's $22,000 to lease the equipment plus $11,700 in
- 9:27finance charges over those 10 years.
- 9:29Plus it wouldn't have to cough up another $13,000 plus just to
- 9:34end the lease after 10 years. I mean, it's more than double
- 9:37what he would paid upfront if he had just cut them a check, you
- 9:40know, originally for $22,000 to buy this stuff from them.
- 9:44Oh my goodness, you're blowing my mind here with us.
- 9:47This is unbelievable. Is Tim a one off or are there
- 9:50other Tim's floating around out there?
- 9:51Well, that's the thing. So I'm like, well, you know,
- 9:53he's not just the only one who's complaining about especially not
- 9:57knowing what he was getting into.
- 9:59We looked at complaints against this company with the Better
- 10:02Business Bureau, this Knuckleman Heating and Air Conditioning,
- 10:05it's owned by a larger outfit called Service Experts.
- 10:08And Service Experts in turn is owned by this company called
- 10:11Brookfield, which is like this big venture capital investment
- 10:14company that that also owns like the Colonial Pipeline.
- 10:17Most people have heard of that in the news, right?
- 10:20So it's this multi billion dollar company that owns Service
- 10:24Experts and Service Experts in turn is buying up a lot of HVAC
- 10:27and plumbing outfits and that's the company that's writing these
- 10:31leases. But other companies are writing
- 10:33these HVAC leases too. But the common thread when you
- 10:37look at complaints against these companies about these leases is
- 10:40that the homeowners didn't know that that's what they were
- 10:43getting into. They didn't know that they were
- 10:45signing a lease. It was described to them as a
- 10:48membership program or a payment plan or even like a maintenance
- 10:52plan. But the membership plan is often
- 10:54what they're sold on. You have a monthly payment
- 10:57that's reasonable and won't take care of all the maintenance.
- 10:59What they don't realize is that it's a lease.
- 11:01And a lot of cases, what we found is that the complaints say
- 11:05I was just handed a tablet or an iPad and told just to, you know,
- 11:09click here, click here, press this button, digitally sign this
- 11:13thing. And it was never, ever described
- 11:16to them that this is a lease, not a purchase.
- 11:18They were just told, oh, you know, here's the price for the
- 11:20stuff. It'll be this much a month if
- 11:22you want to join our membership plan.
- 11:24And they say, well, that sounds great because I don't have
- 11:25$22,000 sitting around. And so they've given these iPads
- 11:29and they've digitally signed these leases.
- 11:31And then some of the complaints said, you know, they were for
- 11:33parents, older homeowners, where in some cases the parents had
- 11:38passed away. And then the heirs are, you
- 11:40know, basically trying to sell this house.
- 11:42And they find that, well, they can't sell this house because
- 11:44they have to disclose to buyers that there's this lease that
- 11:47nobody even owns this heating and air conditioning equipment.
- 11:50And then they're like, well, my parent never would have been
- 11:52able to digitally sign that or they wouldn't have, you know,
- 11:54done this DocuSign arrangement. There's lots of accusations
- 11:57about basically these companies signing for homeowners, signing
- 12:01them up for plans without really even realizing what they were
- 12:03getting. We found the same thing when we
- 12:05looked at scams with solar installations.
- 12:07The same thing with a pad. You clicked in things so you
- 12:09don't know what you're doing. So it seems like the lesson here
- 12:12from the story is A you need to shop around, which you should do
- 12:15for a purchase this big and B maybe you get a printed document
- 12:18and read it before you sign anything.
- 12:20It's really key. I mean, you have to read
- 12:21everything before you sign. And, and that's why Tim's
- 12:24kicking himself because I guess the Nachleman's credit right
- 12:28there on the lease, it does say it's a lease.
- 12:30You flip it over and it even has the payment schedule for these
- 12:33termination penalties. Or if you cancel within the
- 12:36first two years, for example, you have to cough up the total
- 12:39cost of the furnace and air conditioner.
- 12:41But it also says if you want to quit after 10 years, you still
- 12:45owe them 60% of the original cost.
- 12:48But when it's an iPad and it's an older homeowner, again, these
- 12:52service reps are often telling homeowners, oh, you know, we can
- 12:56spread out these payments, which is what Tim says happened.
- 12:58The guy just mentioned spreading out the payments.
- 13:00He didn't mention a lease. And when it's an iPad, you know,
- 13:03often they're just like it's got a highlighted thing, you know,
- 13:06just press here and enter your initials and it's digitally
- 13:09signed for them. Yeah, and they're working on
- 13:11Commission, so they're they're encouraged to oversell the
- 13:13thing. Well, that's the really the big
- 13:15problem here is that a lot of these companies, especially ones
- 13:18that have been bought up by these investment companies, you
- 13:21know, the people they're sending out, they're not even
- 13:23technicians, they're salespeople.
- 13:25And if they are technicians, even if they are technicians,
- 13:28they're on Commission now. And it's not just that they're
- 13:31on Commission, it's that they have sales targets to hit.
- 13:33And there's no way these technicians can hit these big,
- 13:37big sales targets by doing, you know, $800 repairs.
- 13:40They got to sell a lot of new installs and they got to sell a
- 13:44lot of new furnaces, air conditioners, you know, water
- 13:46heaters and inflated prices. And, and even in Tim's case, you
- 13:50know, I looked at what he bought and he probably did overpay.
- 13:53They probably did overcharge him for the equipment he bought.
- 13:55Not as much as what I've heard. I mean I've heard of people
- 13:57being sold $12,000 water heaters and really it's more of a $2000
- 14:02job by. The way Kevin contacted
- 14:04Knuckleman about this story, but the company declined to comment
- 14:08straight ahead. If you do buy a new furnace or
- 14:10air conditioning system and go with a loan from the contractor,
- 14:13you could wind up paying a staggering amount of interest.
- 14:16There are better ways to pay. We'll talk to Kevin about that
- 14:20next. Checkbook has customer ratings
- 14:22and evaluations for heating and air conditioning contractors in
- 14:25these 7 metro areas, Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle,
- 14:31San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC.
- 14:35If you live in or around one of these seven cities and haven't
- 14:38joined Checkbook yet, check us out.
- 14:40Get a free 30 day subscription to all our ratings by going to
- 14:43checkbook.org/consumerPDF. You've got to be really careful
- 14:50if you're going to install a H FAC system and get financing
- 14:53from the contractor. A lot of gotchas it can have in
- 14:55here. Kevin, tell us about those.
- 14:57Yeah. So we, we've talked about
- 14:58leasing which you know, I think even though more and more
- 15:00companies tend to be offering, it is still somewhat rare.
- 15:04But what's more common is that the company will say, well, we
- 15:07do have financing and it's usually almost always through a
- 15:11a third party. They're specially basically bank
- 15:14set up to issue these loans. And the problem is a lot of
- 15:17times HVAC companies especially and and roofers to say, well, I
- 15:22can offer you 0% financing for two years.
- 15:26If you don't have all this money sitting around or you don't want
- 15:28to sell stock or whatever to come up with this money because
- 15:31often you have to come up with this money, especially for a new
- 15:33furnace. If you're in the middle of a,
- 15:35you know, cold snap or air conditioner in the middle of the
- 15:37heat wave, you got to come up with it pretty quickly, right,
- 15:39right. Well, the problem is, is that a
- 15:40lot of times these zero interest loans that they tell you about,
- 15:44they're not no interest. OK, so this happened to me a few
- 15:47years ago. I needed a new heat pump for my
- 15:49house. The heat pump's going to cost
- 15:51about $8000. This isn't some sketchy company.
- 15:54I mean, I'm the editor of Checkbook.
- 15:55I'm not going to have lousy companies out to my house.
- 15:58But they said, oh, no, you can finance this.
- 16:01You know, we can offer you 0% financing for two years.
- 16:04And so you don't have to come up with those money today.
- 16:06The problem is that they installed the heat pump and then
- 16:09I got the loan paperwork, and it's not really a 0% loan at
- 16:13all. The terms had me paying about
- 16:16$200 a month. So that's about $4800 total for
- 16:20the first two years. But here's the catch.
- 16:23If I didn't then pay the remaining balance of the loan,
- 16:27which is about $3000 within those first 24 months.
- 16:31And I wouldn't have just making this $200 a month payment,
- 16:34right? If I did it, pay off the loan,
- 16:37essentially make a balloon payment at some point during
- 16:39these two years, then that loan would have converted to a
- 16:42standard five year loan. The APR on that loan would have
- 16:47been about 18%, which 4-5 years ago was a lot, right?
- 16:52The total payments I would have had to make on this $8000 heat
- 16:56pump would have really been about $12,000 because I would
- 16:59have gotten hit with this interest rate and it would have
- 17:01been deferred interest. So for those two years where I
- 17:04was just, you know, making these $200 payments, Oh, no, they
- 17:07would have then gone back and charged me interest even for
- 17:10those two years. And even if it is a basic
- 17:13deferred interest plan without a balloon payment attached as
- 17:17yours was, if you are late by 1 penny making the final payment,
- 17:21you pay the interest backwards. So it's not really no interest,
- 17:24it's deferred interest and people really have to find out
- 17:27and understand that because you get clobbered if you screw up
- 17:29somewhere along the line. Correct that in the contract
- 17:32that they sent me, the loan terms they sent me also stated
- 17:35that if I was late making a payment or missed a payment,
- 17:38well, boom, then this deferred interest program, it
- 17:41automatically flipped over to this conventional 5 year loan.
- 17:45So the good news is a few weeks after the work was completed, I
- 17:49got paperwork from this financing company and the
- 17:51paperwork clearly stated what I'd signed up for that, you
- 17:55know, my payment was going to be this much.
- 17:57If after two years I hadn't paid it off, then I was going to hit
- 18:00with this extra cost and I was going to end up paying, you
- 18:02know, another $4000 essentially for this $8000 heat pump.
- 18:06That's how much extra it was going to cost me.
- 18:07But the lesson is this, I mean, it's an important lesson that
- 18:10you just have to carefully assess these financing offers,
- 18:14including reading all the fine print.
- 18:17The problem is, as we've learned here, right, in some cases and
- 18:20in Tim's case with that lease, the company never really gave
- 18:24him anything but the contract that he signed, which he kind of
- 18:27stashed away or these iPads are being slid across the counter to
- 18:32us. So just initial here and we'll
- 18:33take care of all this. And you, you know, they may
- 18:35e-mail you this contract or not. That's another complaint we got
- 18:39about, you know, these service experts leases is that people
- 18:42say they never even got a copy of it.
- 18:43They signed off on the iPad. And then, oh, they must have
- 18:46sent the wrong e-mail address or something like that.
- 18:48That was the excuse. Well, in my book, you look at
- 18:51the contract first, you see if it's terms you agree to, and
- 18:54then you sign the contract and live by it.
- 18:55It's not the other way around. You sign up for it and then get
- 18:57the deal. Well, this and so it's another,
- 18:59the other lesson is, and we've often said this in this podcast,
- 19:02we often write about it. If anyone's ever rushing you,
- 19:05it's a big red flag. Yep.
- 19:07So I wasn't rushed in my heat pump purchase at all.
- 19:10They just said, oh, you know, we have this financing deal through
- 19:12this other company. You can sign up for this and get
- 19:140 interest finance through two years, which was in essence what
- 19:18I got. It's just that I was going to
- 19:19have to pay that thing off within two years or I'd get hit
- 19:22with all this interest. But in Tim's case, did he feel
- 19:25like he was being rushed? Yeah, he kind of did.
- 19:28And a lot of the complaints we get about these companies it
- 19:31involves, yeah, I don't have hot water, I don't have heat, I
- 19:34don't have air conditioning. This company came right out, you
- 19:37know, maybe even during off hours said, hey, we can take
- 19:39care of this right now. You know, tomorrow just sign
- 19:43here and it oh, here's going to be your payment.
- 19:45And they never really give the homeowners a chance to back out
- 19:49of the deal. When people solicit business in
- 19:51your home, in most states, you have three days to cancel the
- 19:54contract. Basically you have this cooling
- 19:56off period. But in the case of out of my
- 19:58furnace isn't working, the air conditioner isn't working.
- 20:00I signed this thing. They did show up later that day
- 20:02or the next day and installed new stuff.
- 20:04They didn't really get the chance to look it over and
- 20:06cancel it. So let's look at some other ways
- 20:08to pay that may be better. If you have enough limit on your
- 20:11credit card, you can always charge it.
- 20:12Yeah. And we've talked about this
- 20:14before. The nice thing about using a
- 20:15credit card is you get certain protections against bad service
- 20:19or against overcharging you, right?
- 20:20If they overcharge you for that furnace or charge more than you
- 20:23agreed to or something goes wrong, you can dispute that
- 20:26charge. So that's one way to do it.
- 20:28Although you know a lot of us don't have credit limits.
- 20:30Available credit on our credit cards of $12,000.
- 20:33What about a loan from the bank? Maybe either a home equity loan
- 20:36or a HELOC? A home equity line of credit.
- 20:38Yeah. So, you know, essentially you
- 20:40can go to the bank, you get a home equity loan and what these
- 20:42are, they're essentially second mortgages that offer fixed rates
- 20:46and terms. So it's it's using, you know,
- 20:48any equity you have in your home as collateral for paying back
- 20:51that loan. And the problem is, you know,
- 20:54they require applications and credit checks and they may even
- 20:57have to do an appraisal of your home.
- 20:59Others closing costs, I mean, they're easier, a lot easier to
- 21:03arrange than mortgages. And they typically offer lower
- 21:06interest rates than, you know, what the contractors are
- 21:08offering, you know, 17 to 25%. But there is a lot more
- 21:12paperwork, there are closing costs.
- 21:14It's going to take more time. I mean, if you're in a hurry,
- 21:17you may not have enough time to go out and get one of those
- 21:19loans. There's also Helocs, you
- 21:21mentioned those. I mean, these are similar to
- 21:22home equity loans, but they basically just give you a line
- 21:26of credit that you can borrow against as needed.
- 21:29So a lot of people, they take out these loans for big
- 21:31remodeling jobs. So I don't really know, you
- 21:33know, I think it's going to cost us much, but it's always more
- 21:35expensive than you thought. These loans, HELOC loans, they
- 21:38usually carry variable interest rates, so it may be not as good
- 21:41as a fixed interest loan, but interest like home equity loans,
- 21:45it's tax deductible. It's just in general home and
- 21:48equity loans usually are easier to get faster to get than than
- 21:51home equity loans. You know, when I first got my
- 21:54home, I was suggesting to me that I take out a HELOC.
- 21:56They were free at that point in time.
- 21:57So I had this money sitting around if I ever needed it for
- 22:00something like the furnace goes bad or something like that.
- 22:03And you know not may not be a bad idea for homeowners who are
- 22:06able to do that kind of thing and have that money available if
- 22:08you ever have a situation where you need it.
- 22:10Yeah, I think it's way better, definitely a better than
- 22:13contract tractor backed financing.
- 22:15You know these offers that contractors offer that's through
- 22:17a third party they're going to Commission for selling that loan
- 22:22just simply because you usually home equity loans and lines of
- 22:25credit, the interest rates far lower and the payment terms are
- 22:28better. I mean, you just know what
- 22:29you're getting into in advance compared to what most homeowners
- 22:33are complaining about with contractor backed financing, so.
- 22:36Bringing this all home, based on everything you learn from your
- 22:38investigation, what are the one or two takeaways you have for
- 22:41folks listening if you find yourself with a heater that
- 22:44doesn't work, or an air conditioning that goes on the
- 22:46Fritz, or you're desperate to have some kind of HVAC system
- 22:49installed or big repair taking place?
- 22:51I mean, it is a big problem if your air conditioner is dead and
- 22:53it's going to cost, you know, six, $7000 to replace it or your
- 22:57furnace is dead, it's going to be 4 or $5000 replace it.
- 23:00You said a lot of homeowners don't have that money sitting
- 23:02around. And that's why even when people
- 23:04sign these leases and know they're signing the lease,
- 23:07that's why they're at all appealing because they still
- 23:10might do a credit check when selling you one of these leases.
- 23:13But the marketing materials I've seen from the leasing companies
- 23:16to contractors trying to get them to sell these leases
- 23:20basically say here's a way for you to increase your business
- 23:23because some of your customers, they won't have the money on
- 23:26hand to pay for this work or they may not have enough room in
- 23:29their credit cards to pay for this work.
- 23:31Or, and this is key, they may not have the credit scores that
- 23:34are good enough to get contractor backed financing or
- 23:38bank financing from a HELOC. So these leasing programs,
- 23:42here's a way for you to sell more stuff because they're going
- 23:45to have less trouble getting approved for these leases.
- 23:48And of course they're not going to have much trouble getting
- 23:50approved for these leases because they never own their
- 23:52furnace to the air conditioner. I mean, that's the collateral of
- 23:55this non loan, right? They stop paying.
- 23:58If Tim stops paying $288.00 a month, they'll just shut off his
- 24:02stuff or come get it. Now he's back to trying to
- 24:05figure out a way to heat and cool his home.
- 24:07And really what's happening with these leases, I think is at the
- 24:10end of the 10 years, these companies come out and they say,
- 24:12well, the lease is up. You can keep paying us $288.00 a
- 24:16month or whatever it is, or we'll install all new equipment
- 24:19and you can start all over again on a different lease, right?
- 24:23It's just perpetual payments. It's a source of income for
- 24:25these companies, but it's not good for consumers at all.
- 24:28If you want to read more about this, you'll find Kevin's full
- 24:31story on our website, checkbook.org.
- 24:33Kevin, eye opening stuff, Stuff I didn't know.
- 24:36Thanks for doing the digging and letting us know about this.
- 24:39Yeah. It's just really disappointing
- 24:41essentially that these companies are abusing people like this,
- 24:43and especially in the way that they are where most people who
- 24:46are taking out these leases, as far as I can tell, don't know
- 24:48what they're signing. Before we go, a few other
- 24:50consumer PDA episodes you might want to check out #30 HVAC,
- 24:55Finding Good Contractors, and Choosing new equipment #44
- 24:59should you repair or replace a broken appliance.
- 25:02And number 87, don't get burned by solar scammers.
- 25:05And with that, we're out of time.
- 25:07We hope you'll rate this episode.
- 25:09It's really helpful. And follow us on Apple Podcasts,
- 25:12Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
- 25:15Remember, we release new episodes every other Thursday.
- 25:18Another way you can support this show is to follow us at
- 25:21Consumerpedia on Facebook and Instagram, at consumerpedia.org
- 25:25on Blue Sky, and at My Consumer Pedia on X.
- 25:29You'll find me at consumerman.com.
- 25:32I'm her wise mom, always looking out for you.
- 25:35Until next time, be smart and shop wisely.
- 25:39Consumerpedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 25:42We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 25:45smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 25:48help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 25:51ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 25:53If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 25:56Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 26:01Minneapolis, Saint Paul, Seattle, San Francisco, and
- 26:04Washington DC. To get your free 30 day
- 26:06subscription, go to checkbook.org slash Consumer
- 26:09Pedia Consumer Pedia. Empowering consumers to save
- 26:13money and make smarter choices.