Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Romeo and Juliet (1936)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:19I'm Kyle. And I'm Ryan. And not a joke, I was
- 0:22literally two seconds before you started speaking
- 0:26singing New Kids on the Block. I think it's important
- 0:28to ask, who is everybody's favorite Wahlberg?
- 0:32Yeah, and we just talked about how... Now, we
- 0:34didn't say favorite. No. We said the best. But
- 0:37I'm asking now. Who my favorite is? Who's your
- 0:39favorite? God. I feel like there's only one right
- 0:43answer. Sophie's Choice. No, here's the thing.
- 0:45I like a Mark Wahlberg movie. Okay. But I do
- 0:49think it's Donnie. Donnie Wahlberg is my favorite
- 0:52Wahlberg. I think it's Donnie. Because Donnie,
- 0:53I think, did the best performances in his movies.
- 0:57But I just told you this. I think he embraces
- 0:59the C -list. He's like, I'm comfortable where
- 1:02I am. I don't need to achieve higher status.
- 1:04I'm good right here. To me, Donnie Wahlberg is
- 1:07an actor. And Mark Wahlberg is a celebrity. Oh,
- 1:11I might fight you on that. I think Mark Wahlberg
- 1:13has the ability to do good performances. He just
- 1:16chooses not to. Do you think Mark Wahlberg could
- 1:18have been standing in Bruce Willis's bedroom
- 1:20in his underwear crying? I think he could have.
- 1:24I think it would be a different movie, but I
- 1:25think he could have. I don't think he could have
- 1:27pulled it off, if I'm being honest. Say hey to
- 1:29your dead wife for me. Donnie, come here. We
- 1:32got to torment and haunt Bruce Willis. Hey, right
- 1:36at the top, kind of. Thank you for listening.
- 1:41Once Upon a Time at the Oscars. I've been Ryan.
- 1:44We wanted to start at the top here. You can email
- 1:46us at outaopodcast at gmail .com. Available on
- 1:51Spotify, Apple, iTunes, or wherever you get your
- 1:54podcasts. Check out the Patreon. Obviously, we
- 1:58appreciate any and all subscriptions. You get
- 2:00a lot of great stuff for that. Episodes early,
- 2:02as well as the Horror of the Overlooked episodes
- 2:05that we drop every 13th of the month. Today,
- 2:08we are talking not about Donnie Wahlberg, not
- 2:10about Mark Wahlberg, and not about The Sixth
- 2:13Sense. We are talking about a tale as old as
- 2:15time and not Beauty and the Beast, because, you
- 2:18know, we'll get there, too. But we're talking
- 2:21about a well -known adaptation, something that's
- 2:25been adapted. Boy, if you had to venture a guess
- 2:28on how many times this has been adapted to movies,
- 2:31stage, you think we're in the hundreds? Probably
- 2:35three and a half. 100 or three and a half? Three
- 2:38and a half. Well, you're wrong in terms of movies,
- 2:41maybe five. Yeah. And those are like direct.
- 2:46I mean, we're talking like inspiration and stuff,
- 2:49you know, like this is one of the big ones. This
- 2:51is one of the big ones. We returned to Shakespeare
- 2:54and it's kind of funny that we got to Shakespeare.
- 2:58Like we've already talked about Shakespeare on
- 3:00this podcast. Didn't start here. Because I do
- 3:02think that this is the one that when you say
- 3:04Shakespeare, everyone thinks this. Yeah. You
- 3:06think so? Yeah, it's so interesting because it
- 3:09is Max Reinhardt. Reinhardt sounds right. You
- 3:14know, he did his stage performance of A Midsummer
- 3:17Night's Dream, and it was so successful that
- 3:19then they made the film out of it. Right. So
- 3:22it was almost like a circumstantial first appearance
- 3:25of Shakespeare at the Academy Awards. But yeah,
- 3:28this is kind of the most well -known, I would
- 3:31say. This is the one that kind of crosses over
- 3:34from the stage and becomes like a pop culture
- 3:37referenceable story. In the adaptations that
- 3:42you were talking about, film at least, do you
- 3:45count Gnomeo and Juliet? Yeah, absolutely. Do
- 3:48you count Sherlock Gnomes as a Romeo and Juliet
- 3:52adaptation? Probably not. You should, because
- 3:55it's a sequel to Gnomeo and Juliet. It focuses
- 3:58on Sherlock gnomes. So it really showed your...
- 4:02I told you, I'm not a Shakespeare guy. And neither
- 4:05am I. And with that said, let's talk about Romeo
- 4:08and Juliet, which is the movie that we're covering.
- 4:10As we mentioned, there are many, many adaptations
- 4:13of this. So we are talking about the 1936 version.
- 4:16This one had four nominations for it. The first
- 4:21is Art Direction. A couple names with this. We
- 4:23have Cedric Gibbons. someone we're very familiar
- 4:26with, Frederick Hope and Edwin B. Willis. Best
- 4:29Supporting Actor, another name that's returning
- 4:32to the podcast here, Basil Rathbone. And he brought
- 4:35his sword. As Tybalt. Yeah. Well, I did pretty
- 4:38good on that. You did. You did very good. Last
- 4:40minute, I just threw a little accent on Tybalt.
- 4:43Best Actress, Norma Shearer has returned as well.
- 4:47She's back. She's back as Juliet. An outstanding
- 4:51production on behalf of Metro -Goldwyn -Mayer,
- 4:54MGM. That's the one directed by George Cukor,
- 4:58who we've talked about quite a number of times
- 5:00on this show. A number of returns here. Yeah,
- 5:02I'm still kind of waiting for my heavy -hitting
- 5:05George Cukor movie. I think we're getting there.
- 5:07Yeah, I think we're getting close. I have an
- 5:09idea of at least, if not a milestone, the end
- 5:11destination. Yeah, yeah, I think so too. So with
- 5:15this movie, when I saw the cast list, you know,
- 5:18I saw Shakespeare and I was like, okay. I struggle
- 5:21a little bit. We know this. We've talked about
- 5:23this. But I saw the cast list and I was like,
- 5:25now wait a minute. Yeah. You have Norma Shearer
- 5:27as Juliet. Leslie Howard as Romeo, which I'm
- 5:31unfamiliar with. But then one of the Barrymore
- 5:34brothers shows up here. John Barrymore as Marcuccio.
- 5:38Marcuccio. You got it right. Dude. Marcuccio.
- 5:42Yeah, I got mush mouth going into that. Basil
- 5:44Rathbone as Tybalt, as you said. And Andy Devine
- 5:47as Peter. was listed as one of the main cast
- 5:50members, and boy, he gets on my nerves in this
- 5:52movie. So that's interesting. Screenplay was
- 5:56written by Tabolt Jennings, and of course, this
- 5:59is the adaptation of the Shakespeare play. Yeah,
- 6:03perhaps you've heard of it. You may have. I'm
- 6:05just going to stop real quick. John Barrymore.
- 6:08Yeah. Lionel Barrymore. If you had to assign
- 6:11one Donnie and one Mark, who do you think is
- 6:15who? John is Donnie and Lionel is Mark. Oh, I
- 6:21disagree. Oh, yeah? I think that John Barrymore
- 6:24is Mark and I think Lionel Barrymore. Because
- 6:26Lionel Barrymore was in Grand Hotel, right? John
- 6:30Barrymore was. Yeah, John Barrymore was. Oh,
- 6:33no, they both were. That's the problem is they
- 6:35show up all the time together. But John Barrymore
- 6:37was the lead. And Lionel Barrymore was like down
- 6:40on his luck and needed money and everything,
- 6:42right? He was like the guy who was drunk. John
- 6:44Barrymore was the Baron. Yes. Lionel was Otto.
- 6:48So I stand by that I think Mark Wahlberg is John
- 6:51and Lionel is Donnie. I think the character work
- 6:54that comes out of Donnie is the most closest
- 6:56to Lionel. I can get behind that. I'm a John
- 7:00boy. Good night, John boy. I just now need to
- 7:05hear John Barrymore say hi to your mother for
- 7:07me. Yeah. Lionel, get in here. We've got to take
- 7:10this guy out. I'm just going to keep doing that.
- 7:13So if you need a synopsis for Romeo and Juliet,
- 7:15why weren't you paying attention in class, really?
- 7:19You shouldn't pay attention in class. That's
- 7:20what it is. And if you're 12 and you haven't
- 7:21covered it yet, pay attention in class. Yeah.
- 7:23They're going to be telling you. Open your textbook
- 7:25right now and listen, okay? I will give you the
- 7:28shortest of synopses on this. Despite being born
- 7:32into rival families, two star -crossed lovers
- 7:35attempt to live life together. Yes. Done. The
- 7:39two families, what is it, the Capulets? It is
- 7:41the Capulets and the Montagues. Montagues, thank
- 7:43you. So, yeah, I mean, this is a tale that I
- 7:46feel like, finally, we're talking about Shakespeare,
- 7:49that I don't have to, I still have to interpret,
- 7:53like, the language, but as far as the plot goes,
- 7:56I'm like, I know what's going on. I'm familiar
- 7:58with this. And that helps a little bit. We both
- 8:02struggled a lot in Midsummer Night's Dream because...
- 8:04I don't think either one of us was familiar with
- 8:06the play, but then you also have that, okay,
- 8:09what exactly are they even saying? Yeah, so let's
- 8:13go ahead and tackle the, in terms of the adaptation,
- 8:16how they handled it. We've talked about things
- 8:19like Hamnet that take the loose adaptation, but
- 8:23kind of show you what happened behind the scenes.
- 8:25I talked about Much Ado About Nothing, the Joss
- 8:28Whedon. Right. adaptation that he made that used
- 8:31the original text, the original writing, and
- 8:35made it in a more modern background. This continues
- 8:39the trend of what we saw in Midsummer Night's
- 8:40Dream, where they use the exact verbiage, text,
- 8:44and everything from the paper. But I think the
- 8:46difference here is that in Midsummer Night's
- 8:48Dream, everything was so airy and fantastical,
- 8:51and there's so much going on that you really
- 8:53can't decipher what's going on, even using that
- 8:56original text. And in this adaptation of Romeo
- 8:59and Juliet, I think that the surroundings and
- 9:03the setting is so grounded and the camera is
- 9:06less fantastical that even with the verbiage
- 9:09that is hard to keep up with sometimes, you can
- 9:11still piece together what's happening. So I think
- 9:14that Midsummer Night's Dream is near nonsensical.
- 9:17In Romeo and Juliet, you never lose sight of
- 9:20what's actually happening in that time. And I
- 9:21think Midsummer Night's Dream is near nonsensical.
- 9:24On purpose. Yes. That is what it's about. It
- 9:26is a fantasy film while this is a romantic drama.
- 9:30I think that there's more comedy in this than
- 9:32I anticipated. There is, but the way that Shakespeare
- 9:35is split into two. Correct. Comedy drama. This
- 9:38is definitely one of the dramas. But yeah, there's
- 9:40some comedy in here for sure. I got to say, I
- 9:43learned about Romeo and Juliet from Hey Arnold.
- 9:47Yes. That's my favorite version of Romeo and
- 9:50Juliet. So. My initial takeaway here, I said
- 9:55I was excited about the cast, right? Yeah. Leslie
- 9:58Howard, Norma Shearer, John Barrymore. Right.
- 10:01Basil Rathbone. I think this was miscasted. Yeah.
- 10:04Well, let's talk about that. So originally it
- 10:06wasn't supposed to be, or there was a chance
- 10:09that it wasn't going to be Leslie Howard as Romeo.
- 10:11Yeah. Who's it supposed to be? Do you know this?
- 10:13Actually, now that you don't know this, now that
- 10:16I know you don't know this, I'm interested in
- 10:17how you feel about this. Okay. So I want you
- 10:19to close your eyes. Norma Shearer as Juliet,
- 10:21right? And then as Romeo, actually, I take that
- 10:25back. It wasn't Leslie Howard. It was John Barrymore.
- 10:27Okay. So think about Mercutio. Gotcha. Mercutio.
- 10:29He did it to me too. Mercutio. Damn it. Mercutio.
- 10:33Instead of John Barrymore, what if it was William
- 10:35Powell? I mean, if he could pull it off, because
- 10:39Mercutio's like pretty flamboyant, pretty...
- 10:43You know, whimsical. Yep, buddy -buddy with Romeo.
- 10:46Yeah, he's almost like a bard -like character
- 10:49without the music in this. And that sounds like
- 10:52how I would describe William Powell in The Thin
- 10:55Man. Yeah. Kind of how I would describe him in
- 10:57Great Ziegfeld. He's a little boring in Great
- 10:59Ziegfeld, personally. He's still got the charm.
- 11:01He does. Yeah, that would have been interesting.
- 11:03I think John Barrymore is perfect casting here.
- 11:06Do you think it's Leslie Howard? I think it's
- 11:08Leslie Howard and Norma Shearer. Interesting.
- 11:11Real quick, William Powell turned down replacing
- 11:14John Barrymore because he was originally cast
- 11:16as Mercutio, and they asked William Powell to
- 11:19play him. He actually turned it down because
- 11:21he was really good friends with John Barrymore,
- 11:24and he wanted to be loyal to their friendship.
- 11:26What a nice guy. It was because I think he was
- 11:28showing up drunk or something like that, and
- 11:29he was like, no, no, I can't do that to him.
- 11:32William Powell was showing up drunk? No, John
- 11:34Barrymore was. So he was going to take over his
- 11:36spot. Correct. I see. But then when he found
- 11:38out it was replacing John Barrymore, he was like,
- 11:40no, I can't do that. I see. I got you. So I thought
- 11:42that was interesting. Okay. So I can speak to
- 11:45Leslie Howard. Norma Shearer, I think I'm going
- 11:49to need a little selling from you on. I will
- 11:51say the big hair piece with the tiara, it's not
- 11:56for me. Yeah. I love Norma Shearer. And I think
- 11:58divorcee specifically, she looks. Breathtakingly
- 12:02beautiful. She does. I mean, let's not kid ourselves.
- 12:04She's still breathtakingly beautiful. Always
- 12:06will be. But something in this character with
- 12:08that, like, tiara and the big hair didn't do
- 12:09it. But with Leslie Howard, I think he's just
- 12:14very, and I mean this lovingly, I think he's
- 12:16a little more vanilla of a performance than I
- 12:19would want. And don't get me wrong. I think both
- 12:21of them citing the original Shakespeare, it works.
- 12:24And it doesn't sound weird coming out of their
- 12:26mouths or anything. It's just when you think
- 12:28about this romance, you're not really invested
- 12:30heavily in Leslie Howard. And I think with Juliet,
- 12:35because it's Norma Shearer, I was like, I wonder
- 12:36what Norma's up to. But I'm not really thinking
- 12:38about Juliet. So I kind of see what you're saying,
- 12:41but I feel a little more strongly about Leslie
- 12:42Howard. In terms of miscasting. Sure. Norma Shearer
- 12:46of the two, I think like her best actress nomination
- 12:50here is warranted. I think that she is doing
- 12:53solid Shakespeare. It doesn't feel like high
- 12:56school for her. And it feels like she is acting
- 13:03in this movie. Whereas Leslie Howard to me. It
- 13:08does feel kind of amateurish in a way. He feels
- 13:12a little bit like a high school play level. And
- 13:15there's a few characters that do that. Andy Devine
- 13:17as Peter, it very much feels like he was given
- 13:19his lines and he's reciting them to the best
- 13:22of his ability, but his abilities are at a much
- 13:25lower level than Norma Shear is kind of how I
- 13:28took it. Yeah, I think that's right. A big blockade
- 13:31for me as well with this movie is you telling
- 13:34me these guys are 16? All right. Let's get into
- 13:38it. Leslie Howard is 43 years old in this movie.
- 13:42Yeah, that's... Norma Shearer is 34. Sure. There
- 13:46is a nine -year gap between these two people.
- 13:48And even if you look at the youngest age and
- 13:51they're supposed to be 16, she's 34. Right. That
- 13:54is 18 years above. She is further away to that
- 13:58age than she is closer. Yeah. And, you know,
- 14:02it's acting. You know, sure, you don't have to
- 14:05cast a 16 -year -old. I get that. I do want to
- 14:08cite my favorite Letterboxd review. Oh, I like
- 14:11this. You know it? I think I know this. I will
- 14:13give credit where it's due. This is from Cody.
- 14:16The quote is, How doubt thou do thy fellow kids?
- 14:20Oh, that one. Yeah, that one's good. Not that
- 14:23I want to turn the show into reciting Letterboxd
- 14:25quotes, but man. Tybalt, isn't that masked person
- 14:29our foe? Romeo, who is 16 years old? Capulet.
- 14:33Yes, I recognize him by his receding hairline.
- 14:37The key takeaway from these two reviews, which,
- 14:39by the way, one is two stars and the other is
- 14:41three and a half. So we're split. But the key
- 14:46takeaway here is that this is a movie that is
- 14:49supposed to be portraying young love, and it
- 14:51is closer to midlife crisis. Yeah, they just
- 14:55got, you know, the best for the job, I guess.
- 14:59care about the age and you know there's a couple
- 15:01of things you can say about that I mean Leslie
- 15:03Howard not much that I know behind the scenes
- 15:05but one thing that we know about Norma Shearer
- 15:08is that she is married to Irving Thalberg you
- 15:10got it and Irving Thalberg sought out this film
- 15:13specifically Romeo and Juliet to be a showcase
- 15:15for his wife so What better showcase than a titular
- 15:20character like Juliet and reciting Shakespeare?
- 15:22Yeah. And again, this isn't to be like, you know,
- 15:24oh, well, this rich guy got his wife a role and
- 15:27she's not very good. It's Norma Shearer. It is.
- 15:30She's very good. And I think she does well as
- 15:33Juliet in reciting those lines. But this is where
- 15:35things get difficult is that it's not just about
- 15:37memorizing and reciting those lines, but it's
- 15:39in feeling those lines as well. Like it's one
- 15:43thing to like know your lines. It's another to
- 15:44communicate the emotion behind it while you're
- 15:46saying it. And Shakespeare makes this difficult
- 15:49because it's basically another dialect, right?
- 15:52Right. So this makes things really difficult.
- 15:55It's also difficult for modern audiences to be
- 15:58engaged in if you're not fully understanding
- 16:00what they're saying. Yeah. Again, way better
- 16:03and easier in this than it was in Midsummer Night's
- 16:05Dream, but still something that's a little more
- 16:07difficult when it's like a fast -paced dialogue,
- 16:10which it can be. But I will say that of the adaptations
- 16:13that we've seen, I enjoyed a portion of this,
- 16:17a good bit. It came in waves. I think that the
- 16:20acting between... It's interesting. I think Leslie
- 16:25Howard and John Barrymore have better scenes
- 16:29than I think Leslie Howard and Norma Shearer
- 16:31do. I think that Leslie Howard and Basil Rathbone
- 16:33have better scenes than Leslie and Norma do.
- 16:36I think that Norma Shearer has better scenes
- 16:39with other people than she does with Leslie Howard.
- 16:43There's something about the two of them together,
- 16:46and maybe it's Leslie for me, I don't know, but
- 16:48something about the two of them together that
- 16:50just doesn't click. Yeah, there's not a chemistry
- 16:52there at all. I agree. Like, they're both performing
- 16:55well, I just don't see the chemistry. Yeah, I
- 16:58definitely am not a Leslie Howard fan in this
- 17:01movie, but I do agree that, like, all of his
- 17:04scenes that I am a little more hot on do not
- 17:07involve Juliet. So, I don't know. And that's
- 17:10kind of a big deal when you're talking about
- 17:12Romeo and Juliet. You know what I think it is,
- 17:14too, is you're taking a story that's been told
- 17:18for, at this point, centuries. Correct. Right?
- 17:22So that core text has stayed the same for hundreds
- 17:27of years now. So if you're performing it in 1850,
- 17:31you're performing the same exact story as you
- 17:34are in 1936, as you are in 2026. I think my time
- 17:38to perform that in 1850 and 1936 is well past,
- 17:41but I appreciate that. You know, I do what I
- 17:43can for you. But I think because the source has
- 17:48stayed the same, you're really looking at the
- 17:51way acting existed in that time period. And I
- 17:56think... When you watch like, I don't know, any
- 17:59other movie we've covered from the 30s, It Happened
- 18:01One Night, The Informer, anything at all that
- 18:05takes place or isn't a story that was written
- 18:09hundreds of years ago, that style of acting makes
- 18:13sense for those movies. Whereas when you're looking
- 18:16at Romeo and Juliet, this hundreds of year old
- 18:19story, you start to get more critical of the
- 18:21acting because you're seeing A story that maybe
- 18:26you've seen performed, or at least excerpts performed
- 18:28in modern day with that modern day style of acting.
- 18:33So you're like, oh, they're not doing a good
- 18:34job, but it's because it's not really for you.
- 18:37This in a way is more for an audience of the
- 18:4030s than any other movie we've watched, I think.
- 18:44Do you think it could also be a movie for an
- 18:46audience of scholars? Like if you studied Shakespeare,
- 18:49is this like the... I think that exists always
- 18:51with Shakespeare. Sure. Because again, you've
- 18:54got to kind of know, for example, do you bite
- 18:59your thumb at us, sir? I do bite my thumb, but
- 19:01not at you. Yeah. If you don't know what that
- 19:04means, the whole time you're rolling your eyes,
- 19:07you're like, what is going on? Why do we care
- 19:09about thumb biting? Because I think there's even
- 19:11an audience of people who hear him say this and
- 19:13like laugh at him when he says that. Right. And...
- 19:16All it is, it's the equivalent of like giving
- 19:19somebody the bird is what biting your thumb is.
- 19:22But if you're not a Shakespeare fan and you're
- 19:25not familiar with that, then that doesn't work
- 19:26on you. So I think there's always that element
- 19:29with Shakespeare where like you have to kind
- 19:31of be a researcher or a studier or an enjoyer
- 19:35of Shakespeare. An inferrer, at least. Yes. But
- 19:38I do think that like... Because you are adapting
- 19:41a story, you're seeing it through a lens in a
- 19:44way that you're seeing it that way more so than
- 19:47any other movie you're covering in the 30s. So
- 19:49you're more critical of it. I know I certainly
- 19:52am. And you think you fall in that camp as well,
- 19:55right? You are more critical of it? Yeah. I think
- 19:57I like Romeo and Juliet, but I think I need to
- 20:00see kind of a modern version of it to really
- 20:02appreciate the acting in the movie. Right. You
- 20:06know, a great example of this is the Baz Luhrmann.
- 20:09romeo and juliet i never saw it in the boz lerman
- 20:12romeo and juliet he uses a different like time
- 20:15period to kind of convey this messaging so i
- 20:18think he adapted it in a modern way right obviously
- 20:21the score love fool um the song that we know
- 20:24love fool came from this movie so it's just like
- 20:27there's a lot of man you need to watch yeah i
- 20:30don't know what's happening uh you got a great
- 20:31uh john lozano in this movie It's awesome. One
- 20:35of the rare performances where John Leguizamo
- 20:36is like, hey, this is great. My character needs
- 20:38a gun. And Baz Luhrmann was like, sure. Yep.
- 20:42Great. Designed him a gun and everything with
- 20:43a heart on it. It was awesome. Oh, okay. Is this
- 20:45the Leonardo DiCaprio one? It is. Okay. Yeah.
- 20:47Gotcha. That's why. So a couple things. I think
- 20:51you're right about in terms of adaptations and
- 20:53like how this lands back then and everything.
- 20:54I don't know why I put my book down and picked
- 20:56it right back up. But one of the reasons that
- 20:58this was so, I think, faithful to Shakespeare
- 21:01is that's by design. Right. Again, we talked
- 21:05about he wanted this movie to be a showcase for
- 21:07his wife, Norma Shearer. He wanted to make this
- 21:10as authentic production as possible. And in order
- 21:13to do that, he brought in famous Shakespearean
- 21:15intellectuals. He brought in John Tucker Murray
- 21:17of Harvard and William Strunk Jr. of Cornell.
- 21:21Those were researchers and they were sent out
- 21:23to on set to help out kind of like bring like,
- 21:27you know, well, this was the intention behind
- 21:29this. This was what they meant. So they're trying
- 21:31to communicate that to the actors to share those
- 21:33emotions. So they're kind of doing half the acting
- 21:35for them in that sense. Yeah. So at least they
- 21:37have like, you know, well, this is truly what
- 21:39it meant back then. This is what the times were
- 21:41like. So this was. This was, like, not a modern
- 21:43adaptation. This was truly, like, we're trying
- 21:45to make the core Romeo and Juliet. On top of
- 21:48that, researchers were sent to Verona to photograph,
- 21:51so they wanted to get as, like, much of the look
- 21:53of Romeo and Juliet back then as possible, while
- 21:55the art department studied the paintings of Botticelli,
- 21:59Bellini, Carpaccio, and Guzzali to try and capture
- 22:04as much of the art, look, feel, and sound of
- 22:07Shakespeare. Much respect Hollywood puts on Shakespeare
- 22:16because going back to Midsummer Night's Dream,
- 22:19you obviously had this very successful stage
- 22:21play that Max Reinhardt had put on. And that
- 22:24was kind of the in for Warner Brothers to be
- 22:27like, look, we're going to do justice to this
- 22:30play because obviously it's successful. So we're
- 22:32going to bring that guy in to do this. And with
- 22:35this, MGM is almost like. A perfect example of
- 22:39what we talked about in the last episode of studios
- 22:41seeing what works and trying to make more of
- 22:44that. So MGM sees how successful that was, nominated
- 22:47for Best Picture and all of that, and they say,
- 22:49well, let's do Shakespeare. And they really commit
- 22:52to being as faithful and as accurate as they
- 22:55can by bringing in these experts and things.
- 22:57Right. So I like what they're doing with Shakespeare,
- 23:02even if I don't love what I'm actually watching.
- 23:07I like the respect they're putting onto it. Well,
- 23:09the other thing I wanted to talk about with this
- 23:11is, is it kind of funny to you that we're talking
- 23:15about Romeo and Juliet that stars Norma Shear
- 23:18and that has a John Barrymore connection? Do
- 23:23you know what I'm getting at? No. The Hollywood
- 23:26Review of 1929 willed this movie to exist. Oh.
- 23:30If you recall, faithful listener. If you listen
- 23:34to our Hollywood Review of 1929 episode, there
- 23:36was a sketch in which they made Romeo and Juliet,
- 23:39but a studio head executive told them that they
- 23:44had to keep it modern. And they wanted to use
- 23:46a modern script of Romeo and Juliet. And Juliet
- 23:49was portrayed as an actress by Norma Shearer.
- 23:53And I believe, if I'm recalling correctly, the
- 23:55director behind the camera in that sketch was
- 23:59John Barrymore. I believe you are correct. So
- 24:02interesting that those two would reunite on the
- 24:05set for Romeo and Juliet. But the humor of that
- 24:08sketch is them using the modern language. It
- 24:11was Lionel Barrymore. Dang it. Well, it was A.
- 24:14Barrymore. That's pretty close. That's pretty
- 24:15close, though. Pretty close. It was A. Barrymore.
- 24:17But that they were using the modern language
- 24:21for this telling. of Romeo and Juliet, and then
- 24:25they just completely go in the opposite direction.
- 24:27Obviously, it was a joke. Yeah. So it makes sense.
- 24:29But I thought this was interesting, that Hollywood
- 24:31Review of 1929 almost kind of like shot its shot
- 24:35for seven years in the future. Yeah, that is
- 24:37funny. Of this happening. So very funny for this
- 24:40to happen. I think that this is an issue of the
- 24:44way that they handle the story. And I think that,
- 24:47well, I take that back. I think it's handled
- 24:49well. I think that I understand everything that's
- 24:52happening when it's happening. I like the humor
- 24:54of it just fine. I think it really is Leslie
- 24:58Howard and Norma Shearer's lack of chemistry
- 25:01that makes this so difficult. Because then the
- 25:04scenes that we know by heart of War Art Thou
- 25:08Romeo and what's the finale? The finale. I mean,
- 25:12of course. Yeah. But also what Romeo says of
- 25:16like Juliet is the East. The sun. Right. I don't
- 25:20know the whole thing. Anyways, there are lines
- 25:22that like we know and we know how this goes and
- 25:25we know like everything they're going to say
- 25:26to each other. It just kind of feels like, oh,
- 25:29this is a sequence we get past. OK, yeah, here's
- 25:31a scene that we have to like wait for. And it
- 25:33doesn't feel like I'm in the moment and I'm seeing
- 25:35their love and I really feel it. It just kind
- 25:38of feels like you're watching another like rehearsal.
- 25:40Yeah. And I think the scenes that are less well
- 25:44known. The scenes with Mercutio, the scenes with
- 25:47Tybalt, the chemistry between them, I think is
- 25:51pretty great. And like, that's where I think
- 25:53a lot of the humor and like comedy of the movie
- 25:55comes out. Relief, really the comedic relief.
- 25:58And then when that's gone, you're just kind of,
- 26:01I even like the father, the father who ends up
- 26:05giving the fake poison to Juliet. I like him
- 26:09a good bit. I like them. The potions master,
- 26:11basically? Well, isn't he like a... He's like
- 26:13a monk. He's like in Game of Thrones, the Meister
- 26:17or whatever. We'll call him Meister, yeah. So
- 26:20the Meister, he ends up giving her this potion
- 26:23that obviously is supposed to trick everyone
- 26:25into thinking that she's died. He sends a letter
- 26:27to Romeo to explain all of this so Romeo can
- 26:30come meet her and then, you know, they can run
- 26:33away and everything will be fine. Now, the problem
- 26:36is that this is the second movie in a row in
- 26:38which you and I have had to talk. About a note
- 26:41that has been communicated to someone but hasn't
- 26:43made it, and now this is going to cause trouble
- 26:45for everybody. Sure. It's not lost on me that
- 26:48we're doing that two times in a row. Yeah. And
- 26:50in this one, the way that they do this is that
- 26:55they send the messenger. He's about to go deliver
- 26:58the letter, but, oh, please help. There's someone
- 27:00who needs help in this building. Okay, let's
- 27:02check him out. Goes in there, and he's like,
- 27:04oh, he has... Do you remember what disease it
- 27:06was? No. This isn't a test. I actually forgot.
- 27:10He says something where he's like, he is encumbered
- 27:13or something. And everyone's like, encumbered!
- 27:15And just starts screaming. And they start boarding
- 27:18up the house in which this guy screamed this.
- 27:21And now he's trapped in the house and can't give
- 27:24the letter to Romeo. Wow. And Romeo doesn't get
- 27:28the letter. But guess what? He does stumble upon
- 27:31the funeral possession and sees her being carried
- 27:35away. So he knows that she has died or believes
- 27:39that she has died. And this is fine. I could
- 27:42probably like believe all of this completely
- 27:44fine. But then one of the next scenes is that
- 27:46we see that same Meister talking with the messenger
- 27:49and the messenger is like, yeah, sorry, man.
- 27:51I couldn't get the letter to him. They trapped
- 27:53me in this house. I was like, how'd you get here?
- 27:57Why don't you try and still deliver the letter?
- 27:58Yeah. But like, why don't you try and deliver
- 28:00the letter afterwards? The postal service wasn't
- 28:03reliable. He was the postal service. That's what
- 28:06I'm saying. The district did sleep alone. That's
- 28:09a reference for my wife and no one else. Perfect.
- 28:12It's a postal service song. I think that's the
- 28:15name of the song. Sorry if I butchered that,
- 28:17babe. So I was really just taken out of it by
- 28:21this. I was like, this just feels kind of flimsy.
- 28:23You don't even need to include this scene. It
- 28:25just kind of feels like, yeah, sorry, man. I
- 28:28couldn't get to it. I didn't really want to do
- 28:29it. That's how it felt. So here's the thing,
- 28:32then. You don't like Romeo and Juliet. Because
- 28:35that's the original text. Yeah. If you have an
- 28:37accurate adaptation, like a direct one -to -one
- 28:41here, and you don't like it, you do not like
- 28:44Romeo and Juliet. And I'm willing to make that
- 28:46sacrifice. That's okay. But my point is that
- 28:49this is the one scene that the way that they
- 28:51played it... did seem a little bit like a, duh,
- 28:54sorry, boss. Like, he comes across as a stumbling
- 28:57fool that couldn't do the job that his boss hired
- 29:00him to do. And in a scene that otherwise should
- 29:03be like, oh, no, I need to make sure that Romeo
- 29:05knows this as soon as possible, comes across
- 29:08as like, you fool! How could you do this? And
- 29:11it just fell out of place. So while the text,
- 29:13you're right, is from Shakespeare himself. The
- 29:17way the scene is played, there's something about
- 29:19it. It's almost like a little comedic of like,
- 29:21ah, yeah, sorry. I got caught in a house and
- 29:23everyone thought there was a disease and there's
- 29:25not. It just felt more like, I don't know. It
- 29:28seems like they played it more for laughs than
- 29:29like the severity of the situation. Yeah. I don't
- 29:33know if it's supposed to be. It may not. It may
- 29:35just be my reading of it. But yeah, that's solely
- 29:37on me. I mean, in the source, I don't know if
- 29:39it's supposed to be played comedically or if
- 29:41it's supposed to be. taken seriously well it's
- 29:44hard to say because i feel like the comedy of
- 29:45this movie is present in that text yeah so maybe
- 29:49yeah i don't know um it it's it's a weird thing
- 29:53i want to talk more about the movie and not just
- 29:55about the story but it is kind of the thing where
- 29:57like i don't think i like the story of romeo
- 30:00and juliet like ultimately the two families fighting
- 30:04i'm just like guys just get over it like deal
- 30:06with it Obviously, that's not the mindset to
- 30:09have when you're watching a movie. You've got
- 30:10to put yourself in the movie. But by the end
- 30:12of it, it's such I'm always annoyed by stories
- 30:16that are like, oh, we said like one word was
- 30:20misinterpreted and that causes the downfall of
- 30:23everything. Yep. That always bothers me. And
- 30:25that is just like the climax of this movie. Romeo
- 30:28sees a allegedly dead Juliet and then fights
- 30:32for her honor and wins. And then kills himself.
- 30:36And then she wakes up and she's like, oh, well,
- 30:39I guess I got to go too. Like all of that stuff
- 30:41is so ridiculous to me. And I know that like
- 30:45this is Romeo and Juliet, but I really think
- 30:47this is what it's boiling down to. I don't really
- 30:49like that story. So I'll see you. I'll meet you
- 30:53there, but I'll raise you. That doesn't happen
- 30:56once. That happens three times. So once is what
- 30:59you're talking about, which is, you know, he
- 31:01thinks that she's dead. Twice, he goes there
- 31:04and he's like, well, let me kill myself. And
- 31:05then she'll wake up. And then she wakes up and
- 31:07she's like, never mind. Or sorry, he takes the
- 31:09poison. She wakes up, sees he's dead. And then
- 31:11that happens. She kills herself with a dagger.
- 31:14That's two. The third time happens before that.
- 31:16And this is what I think was like, again, it's
- 31:19in the text. But it bothered me in a logical
- 31:22sense. Mercutio, I think. Gets killed by Tybalt.
- 31:26Yes. Right. And then to honor his fallen brother,
- 31:31Romeo goes out to fight Tybalt. Right. And they
- 31:34have an honorable fight, sword duel, and Tybalt
- 31:38loses and dies. Yeah. And then everyone's like,
- 31:41hey, Romeo killed Tybalt. Well, hold on. Who
- 31:44did Tybalt kill? Right. We're honoring the death
- 31:48that he... prot he brought on so it bothered
- 31:51me that they kept saying like yeah romeo killed
- 31:53this guy romeo killed this guy like but that
- 31:56you can't do that because look who what look
- 31:58what he did and look what the guy that he killed
- 31:59did before romeo is avenging mercutio's death
- 32:02that's what i'm trying to say avenging yeah and
- 32:04so it is silly but even even then when mercutio
- 32:07and tybalt are fighting it's very much like those
- 32:10two are having a conversation and mercutio is
- 32:13finally like all right i'm sick of this And the
- 32:27reason... that Mercutio dies in this is because
- 32:41Romeo jumps in and he's like, hey guys, why don't
- 32:44we just chill out and get along? And like blocks
- 32:48Mercutio's sword. So Tybalt stabs Mercutio. And
- 32:52you're like, dude, what are you doing? You just
- 32:54got your buddy killed. And then after Mercutio
- 32:56dies, he's like, I will have vengeance on Tybalt.
- 32:59He's like, no, you did this, Romeo. I do want
- 33:02to point out, we talked about how old everyone
- 33:05looks. Basil Rathbone. But I think Basil Rathbone
- 33:08can look old. He's like the older cousin of Juliet.
- 33:12Okay, that makes sense. But yeah, he's not 16
- 33:15by any means. It's like the beginning of Spider
- 33:17-Man when you're like, Toby, Toby, we can tell,
- 33:23man. It bothers me so much when everyone's like,
- 33:25Spider -Man's always at his best when he's in
- 33:27high school and like a little high schooler.
- 33:29I was like, do you like Spider -Man? The first
- 33:31one? They're like, yeah. I was like, then you're
- 33:32wrong. Right. Because you cannot tell me this
- 33:35kid is in high school. And even if that is true,
- 33:38like five minutes of that movie take place in
- 33:41high school. And then the rest of the trilogy,
- 33:43he's in college. Right. So don't tell me he's
- 33:46best in high school. Yeah. Even in the comics.
- 33:47You can say that. That's like 25 issues. But
- 33:49you better feel that across all the movies. Right.
- 33:52And not just, you know, this one. Anyways, you
- 33:55know, Spider -Man, Romeo and Juliet, we're getting
- 33:56there. You know, how hard do you think it is
- 34:00to like this movie when I think that arguably
- 34:03the best scene, my favorite scene in this movie,
- 34:06is the opening? What is the opening? It's a tapestry.
- 34:09There is a tapestry that has moving actors on
- 34:12it. Yes. And the movie closes on this tapestry
- 34:16as well. But the opening shows characters moving
- 34:19on the stage, but it is revealed to be a tapestry.
- 34:22And it honestly makes me think of kind of the
- 34:25opening of... hang on here, hereditary. Yeah.
- 34:29When it shows like the model house and everything
- 34:31and it like zooms into it. And when you first
- 34:34see like the door open and I think it's the father
- 34:36who walks in first, Gabriel Byrne, when he walks
- 34:39in, you're kind of thinking this is like dolls
- 34:42of them. Yeah. But it's the actual actors. It
- 34:44reminds me of that. And it was a very cool like
- 34:46camera trickery. I really like this. And I was
- 34:50like, oh man, I'm going to be really into this.
- 34:51This is how they're adapting this idea of the
- 34:53story. Right. And then that's kind of just like
- 34:55thrown to the wayside. Yeah. There's nothing
- 34:56else camera trickery or otherwise that kind of
- 34:59goes back to this original scene. Right. So I
- 35:02just want to point out, this is not like, hey,
- 35:04the movie's bad because it doesn't do this the
- 35:06whole time. It's more, I was so taken by this
- 35:09moment and thought that was beautiful, and I
- 35:11was willing to give everything up to production
- 35:12design and cinematography for that. And then
- 35:15it just didn't happen again, and that was kind
- 35:16of a bummer. Then it just becomes a movie. Right.
- 35:19So I say that less to say, hey, Romeo and Juliet
- 35:21is bad because of this, and more like, you should
- 35:23see this opening tapestry, because it is beautiful.
- 35:25Yeah. I really liked that moment. It's just a
- 35:27shame we didn't see much like that beyond it.
- 35:30I think that the standout in this movie is the
- 35:33production design. 100%. I think everything is
- 35:37gorgeous in this movie. And it really pays off
- 35:39that they went to Italy, was it? Verona, you
- 35:42said? Verona, yeah. Yeah, they went out there
- 35:44and they got their photos so that they could
- 35:45really replicate the scenery in Romeo and Juliet
- 35:49accurately. Yeah, and study those paintings and
- 35:51everything to make sure you're getting the artwork
- 35:52similar. You can really feel that here. And I
- 35:55think what's cool about this movie is... We talk
- 35:58all the time about how you adapt a stage play
- 36:00to the screen and you don't want to just sit
- 36:03there and put on the play. And I think that building
- 36:07these recreations of, you know, what allegedly
- 36:12is the set in Romeo and Juliet, who really knows.
- 36:16But you make like an accurate visual representation
- 36:19of the story and you don't allow the camera to
- 36:22just sit in one place. I don't think this should
- 36:25have been nominated for cinematography, but it
- 36:27is enjoyable to watch from like a visual perspective.
- 36:31I think about the balcony scene with Romeo and
- 36:35Juliet, and while that does kind of fall flat
- 36:37because I don't think Leslie Howard or Norma
- 36:39Shearer have that chemistry together, it is gorgeous.
- 36:43It looks like this massive garden outside of
- 36:46her window, and you can see the moon and the
- 36:47stars in the back. Yeah, that's the standout
- 36:51of the movie to me. Kind of similar to what I
- 36:54felt on Midsummer Night's Dream, where there
- 36:55was a lot of cool visual effects and things with
- 36:58the little creatures coming out of the fog and
- 37:02all of that. And James Cagney turning into a
- 37:05donkey. Yeah, there's some really cool visual
- 37:07stuff that I think warrants the move from the
- 37:12stage to the screen. And that's really what I
- 37:16want to see from any stage to screen adaptation.
- 37:19Yeah, I think that's right. Do you think that
- 37:22the Art Direction nomination here is a stand
- 37:26-in for production design not being in a category
- 37:30just yet? Yeah, I think Art Direction is kind
- 37:32of the precursor to that. And we just haven't
- 37:35gotten there yet. Yeah, I agree. I mean, obviously,
- 37:38these are the individuals that studied those
- 37:40paintings that we talked about. Cedric Gibbons,
- 37:43Frederick Hope, and Edwin B. Willis being the
- 37:46nominees behind this award nomination. So I really
- 37:51did like the art direction here. I agree with
- 37:52you. The production design is really the appeal
- 37:54in this, kind of the takeaway. And it's unfortunate.
- 37:59I think sometimes you don't like a movie, and
- 38:01it's kind of easy to be like, yeah, I just don't
- 38:03like it because of this. This one feels like
- 38:05I want to like it so bad because I do admire
- 38:09the production design. I do admire the art design.
- 38:12I do admire the lengths that they went to to
- 38:16make this as authentic as possible. I wonder
- 38:19if that's just the problem. I wonder if they
- 38:21did such a good job in making it authentic that
- 38:24it just feels like, well, yeah, that's just Romeo
- 38:26and Juliet, and I've heard that a million times.
- 38:29This is really what it's going to boil down to?
- 38:31We're not Romeo and Juliet fans. We're not Shakespeare
- 38:33fans. I think that if you, just like I said with
- 38:37Midsummer Night's Dream, with the exception of
- 38:39Mickey Rooney, like, if you like— Is your blood
- 38:43pressure up just mentioning his name? A little
- 38:44bit. A little bit. If you like these Shakespearean
- 38:48plays, like, you're going to like these because
- 38:51they are faithful adaptations. And I think the
- 38:54only thing you might be criticizing would be
- 38:56the acting, which I would argue is what most
- 38:59people— criticize when they go see these on a
- 39:02stage as well right you have to be a certain
- 39:05caliber of an actor to do this in a believable
- 39:09and a convincing in an enjoyable way so that's
- 39:12kind of what i assume differentiates the different
- 39:15performances of romeo and juliet but if you're
- 39:18if you're putting on like a one -to -one version
- 39:20of that play if we go see that together it doesn't
- 39:25matter who's in it we're going to struggle a
- 39:26little bit because we're not Shakespeare guys.
- 39:29So when we criticize the movie this way, I think
- 39:32that needs to be at the front of everything we
- 39:35say, where it's just not for us, but everything
- 39:38that it's doing, I think it does really well.
- 39:40Well, and we'll get into it when we talk about
- 39:42our ratings, but this movie is rated at a 3 .1
- 39:46on Letterboxd. So this isn't out of the realm
- 39:50of criticism. Even people who enjoy and watch
- 39:53this movie are still not as keen, not as high
- 39:56on it. I will say it looks like there's just
- 39:59about as many five and four and a half stars
- 40:01as there is 0 .5 and one. Yeah. So it's pretty
- 40:04split. Based on the reviews I saw, though, I
- 40:07think a lot of that comes from the acting. Yeah,
- 40:10no, that makes sense. I mean, the acting is easily
- 40:12what you can point at, but I think it's just
- 40:15the chemistry. Norma Shearer is a great actress.
- 40:17This is actually a great segue. She's a great
- 40:19actress, but does she have chemistry with Leslie
- 40:21Howard, and does that affect the way you see
- 40:23her performance? And this is my question for
- 40:25you. Best actress, nomination goes to Norma Shearer
- 40:28as Juliet. Do you think... that she should have
- 40:32been nominated for this role. Well, let me take
- 40:35that back. Do you think her performance should
- 40:36have been nominated for this role, or do you
- 40:38believe that Norma Shearer was in a movie so
- 40:40she was nominated? Kind of the latter. It's the
- 40:42latter for me. Because she's good in this, and
- 40:44honestly, I think that where she really is doing
- 40:47her best work is after she wakes up from her
- 40:49slumber and sees that Romeo has taken the poison
- 40:53and has died. And I think the whole, you know,
- 40:55sweet dagger, give me the release. That's not
- 40:59what she says. But, you know, that whole sequence,
- 41:02I think she's great in that. Yeah. And I think
- 41:04that's her best work in this movie. And again,
- 41:06she's good. I just think that like for a movie
- 41:09like Romeo and Juliet, the chemistry between
- 41:11your two leads really has to be the appeal. And
- 41:14there just isn't any here. No, I agree. But the
- 41:17other side of this, too, is if we're going to
- 41:19talk about best actress with Norma Shearer, we
- 41:21also talk about the best supporting actor. nomination
- 41:23for Basil Rathbone as Tybalt. Yes. This one was
- 41:28interesting. I do want to point out that you
- 41:30mentioned very eloquently that Basil Rathbone
- 41:34is kind of a world -renowned sword fighter. He
- 41:38actually, among Hollywood, is some of the best,
- 41:41if not the best. This is interesting because
- 41:43in Romeo and Juliet is the only time that he
- 41:45actually wins an on -screen sword fight. Like
- 41:50factually? Factually. Oh, really? Not just what
- 41:53we've seen? No, not just what we've seen. That
- 41:55is in general, it is the only win that he has
- 41:57on screen as a villain. Which I think is funny
- 42:00because even the one that you're like, yeah,
- 42:02he won. Let's watch that scene. The end is him
- 42:04running away with his crew. Like, yeah, let's
- 42:06get out of here, man. And he technically wins,
- 42:09but he doesn't know that he's killed Tybalt,
- 42:12right? He kind of like got him in the chest and
- 42:15even, or sorry, he hasn't killed Mercutio. He
- 42:18gets him in the chest, and Mercutio wakes up,
- 42:20and he's like, yeah, you know, it's just like
- 42:21a flesh thing. Like, don't worry, it's a scratch.
- 42:23Like, we're all dead. Just but a flesh wound.
- 42:25And he starts bleeding out and, you know, dies.
- 42:27Yeah. So Tybalt may not even know that he killed
- 42:29Mercutio. But still, this is the only time that
- 42:33he wins. Basil Rathbone, to me, just doesn't
- 42:35do enough, I think, to warrant this nomination.
- 42:37I think I would rather give it to, like, Mercutio.
- 42:41John Barrymore. John Barrymore, I think, gets
- 42:43a little bit more screen time and a little bit
- 42:45more of a chemistry. He gets to be silly. He
- 42:50gets to be silly. But he draws more attention
- 42:52to the chemistry between him and Leslie Howard
- 42:54than I think anyone else in this movie. So I
- 42:57would have liked to have seen a nomination from
- 42:59him. I'm not saying Basil Rathbone doesn't deserve
- 43:01it, because he is good. And I mean, when you're
- 43:04that good, it's sword fighting. Like, come on,
- 43:06man. Of course. But that was one where I was
- 43:09just kind of surprised to see him nominated for
- 43:11Best Supporting Actor. And how, I don't want
- 43:13to say little, but not involved in the majority
- 43:15of the story, Tybalt is. Yeah, I think he's a
- 43:18standout performance for sure. I do think if
- 43:22I was going to choose a best supporting actor,
- 43:24it would be John Barrymore. But I like what Tybalt's
- 43:29doing. It's so hard for me to look. I think that
- 43:32the theory I had at the beginning of the episode
- 43:34of, you know, you're looking at an acting style
- 43:37that we don't really follow now, but from a story
- 43:42that we have replicated time and time again.
- 43:46I'm overly critical of the acting in this movie.
- 43:49So I didn't love Norma Shearer in this. I didn't
- 43:53love Basil Rathbone. I like John Barrymore quite
- 43:58a bit because I think anytime I get to see him
- 44:00just kind of be a little bit of a weirdo, I'm
- 44:03all for it. The Barrymores, I have a lot of respect
- 44:06for just the vast variety of characters that
- 44:10they play. And this is no exception. I mean,
- 44:13John Barrymore was doing, Rasputin and the Empress,
- 44:17you know, it's just, they're, they're, they're
- 44:20odd guys. And I love it. Our namesake. Yeah.
- 44:23That's the one. So yeah, I don't know, man. I'm,
- 44:28you know, I think, I think I just realized something
- 44:30and I'm, I'm willing to kind of like, let this
- 44:33be one of my last thoughts on it. I think this
- 44:35is just a really good stage play. Yeah. I think
- 44:38this is a good stage play of Romeo and Juliet.
- 44:40I don't think it needs to be filmed. I don't
- 44:42think it needs to be in theaters. I think this
- 44:45version, at least. It just feels like I went
- 44:48to a high school adaptation and was like, yeah,
- 44:50it was really good. It's just not what I expect
- 44:51from a movie. If that makes sense. The open tapestry
- 44:55scene, I was like, oh, this is going to be really
- 44:56interesting the way they present it. And it just
- 44:58wasn't. So maybe it was like a false start. So
- 45:01if you went to go see this on Broadway with the
- 45:03same cast. Oh, I didn't say that. But if you
- 45:05did. Okay. Do you think you would like it more
- 45:08than the movie version? Probably. Interesting.
- 45:11I think so. Very interesting. Because I think
- 45:13like you're going a little bit more for, you
- 45:16know, it doesn't have to worry what the camera
- 45:18is or anything. It's just everything's right
- 45:20in front of you. And if I think about this movie
- 45:22and I think about like the shots outside of that
- 45:24tapestry scene, there really isn't anything where
- 45:26it's like, well, I need to see this and I need
- 45:27to see that. Like it can just be better adapted
- 45:30for in the round than on a camera, if that makes
- 45:32sense. Yeah. So maybe it's just something that
- 45:35works better on stage than it does on screen.
- 45:38Maybe. Depending on the way that you tell it.
- 45:41Again, there are exceptions to the rule. I think
- 45:44that what Baz Luhrmann does in his adaptation
- 45:46of Romeo and Juliet is really, really interesting.
- 45:48And he's taking chances on it. And it's a way
- 45:50to remember this. But when you are, I don't want
- 45:53to say regurgitating because that sounds like
- 45:55a negative connotation of it, but when you are
- 45:57just reciting the text of it and you are keeping
- 45:59it as authentic as possible, great job. Is it
- 46:02interesting? Yeah. And I don't know if it is.
- 46:04And again, you're right. We're not like diehard
- 46:06Romeo and Juliet fans or even Shakespeare fans.
- 46:09So that makes it a little more difficult to say,
- 46:11like, you know, is it us or is it the movie?
- 46:12But I think it's easy to say that about Marvel
- 46:15stuff too, right? Like, well, hey, if you don't
- 46:17like the comics, you're not going to like the
- 46:18movie. But you need to find something that you
- 46:20can enjoy outside of that, like loyalty to the
- 46:23core text. do a direct adaptation to the screen
- 46:37it wouldn't be good nobody would enjoy it because
- 46:39comics get kind of weird right and i don't know
- 46:42if that's the equivalent here because i think
- 46:44most people go to shakespeare with the hopes
- 46:48of seeing like a pure adaptation of that story
- 46:53i'm sure there are some people that see superhero
- 46:55movies the same way but Well, and book adaptations
- 46:58are so popular now. Sorry, movie adaptations
- 47:00of books are so popular now. But I think even
- 47:03that has its, you know, some people are like,
- 47:05yeah, I want to be exactly like the book. And
- 47:08others are like, well, I'm interested in you
- 47:09taking some chances. But maybe it's like how
- 47:12close we are to it, right? It almost seems like
- 47:14the further we are away, I just want to see an
- 47:16exact adaptation of that. Like, I want to see
- 47:19that movie. But the closer we are, I'll give
- 47:21you a comparison, The Housemaid. uh by frederick
- 47:25mcfadden um the the novel yeah taylor went to
- 47:28go see it in theaters and i was like so how was
- 47:30it she's like well it's pretty much exactly like
- 47:32the book and it's like and is that good and she's
- 47:34like i just the acting is just kind of it's very
- 47:36campy and it makes the movie very campy but the
- 47:38the book is not very campy so it's it's like
- 47:42it's doing the same thing but it just feels different
- 47:44on screen yeah and i think if it was different
- 47:47i don't know if she would have liked that so
- 47:49i don't know it's almost like it depends on the
- 47:51person now I think you're right. I think it depends
- 47:54on the person. And that's why for me personally,
- 47:57and I've thrown both our names under this every
- 48:00time I brought it up, but I think for me personally,
- 48:01I can only like Shakespeare, like one -to -one
- 48:05Shakespeare adaptations so much. No, you can
- 48:08throw me in that bus. Yeah, I think that's really
- 48:10what it boils down to. I'm with you on that.
- 48:11So I will be very curious to one day watch Baz
- 48:15Luhrmann's... Romeo and Juliet to see if maybe
- 48:18that adds a little bit to it. Or maybe I need
- 48:20something like cheeky and silly and funny, like
- 48:23watching Hey Arnold do Romeo and Juliet. I'm
- 48:27glad you brought up Hey Arnold again. I do want
- 48:29to shout out my buddy Chase in the band. He wore
- 48:32a shirt on Friday. Yeah. And it was the cover
- 48:35of Birdman, the Alejandro Iñárritu film. Yeah.
- 48:40But it was for Pigeon Man. Oh, nice. And it was
- 48:43just a Hey Arnold Birdman reference. And I was
- 48:46like, that is so niche and so perfect. That is
- 48:48very niche. So shout out to him. Great shirt.
- 48:51That's a good episode, too. I thought you'd like
- 48:53that. Do you want to get into ratings? Yeah,
- 48:54let's do it. So we both are met here. We talked
- 48:58previously on our Anthony Adverse episode that
- 49:01we wanted to take that down a half a star. We
- 49:04were at two and a half. We went down to two.
- 49:06I will say that we're both at two and a half
- 49:08stars here. And I think that's right. I don't
- 49:12think I'd go lower because it's not a terrible
- 49:14movie. It's not even a bad movie. It's just one
- 49:18that was kind of uninteresting to me. The things
- 49:20that kept me interested were in waves and eventually
- 49:23died because it was Mercutio, really. But the
- 49:27chemistry between some characters is great. But
- 49:30when you're missing chemistry. That is so needed
- 49:33between the title characters. That just brings
- 49:36the movie down to a halt to me. And even though
- 49:39Norma Shearer looks fantastic and they're both
- 49:41giving good performances, something isn't clicking
- 49:44about the two of them together. And that kept
- 49:46me from really enjoying it. And we pointed out
- 49:49the age differences, right? Both trying to be
- 49:5116 year old or portraying 16 year olds. Leslie
- 49:54being 43 years old and Norma 34. I don't think
- 49:57that's the issue. It's a weird little thing,
- 49:59but that can work if your chemistry is good.
- 50:02It just wasn't there. Yeah, I think that's really
- 50:04what it is. My rating is lower because it's Shakespeare
- 50:09for a guy that doesn't really like Shakespeare.
- 50:11But then it's also dropped even lower because
- 50:13the chemistry between our leads is not great.
- 50:16So, I don't know. I think even if you're a big
- 50:18Shakespeare fan, that element is going to limit
- 50:21you a little bit on how much you enjoy this movie.
- 50:24It's going to cause problems. Getting into our
- 50:26double features. I went with just the romance.
- 50:30I went with the romance of something told over
- 50:33time and also what keeps people from being together
- 50:37and the strengths, or sorry, the difficulties
- 50:41they have in getting together, whether they come
- 50:43from different backgrounds or different families.
- 50:45I went with the Nick Cassavetes 2004 film, The
- 50:48Notebook. Oh. I actually had to look this up
- 50:51to make sure it wasn't nominated for Best Picture
- 50:53because I know there's just a lot of talk, but
- 50:54it was all pop culture. Of course, Ryan Gosling
- 50:57and Rachel McAdams, the Nicholas Sparks adaptation,
- 51:01another film adaptation of a book or popular
- 51:04writing. What can you say about The Notebook
- 51:07that isn't already known? If not known for the
- 51:10movie, certainly known for the MTV Movie Awards
- 51:14Best Kiss. Oh, man. Yeah. And then The Kiss reenacted
- 51:18on stage. Yowza. Maybe that's what Leslie Howard
- 51:21and Noah Sheeran needed. They just needed a MTV
- 51:24opportunity to run up on stage and kiss each
- 51:27other. Yeah. I think even like at its core, Romeo
- 51:31and Juliet doesn't have enough Romeo and Juliet
- 51:33in it. Are you saying like the core text? Yeah.
- 51:36Like just that story as a whole. They're not
- 51:39together enough for me to be like, wow, they
- 51:41do really love each other. And you know what's
- 51:43crazy about that? He's usually very literal.
- 51:45Midsummer Night's Dream. That's one Midsummer
- 51:48Night. Yeah. Could be a dream. Who knows? Could
- 51:50be a nightmare. Certainly for you it is. No,
- 51:54the notebook's great. It's one of the best modern
- 51:57romance stories, I think, ever. And it does have
- 52:01that we cannot be together for whatever reason.
- 52:05A happier ending, I think, overall, than Romeo
- 52:08and Juliet. More positive? I guess I'd say more
- 52:12positive. I don't know if I'd use the word happier.
- 52:14People always talk about the ending of the notebook
- 52:16and they're like, oh, it's so sad. No. That's
- 52:19what people do when they get old. Spoiler alert,
- 52:21they die. Yeah, but it's not just dying. It's
- 52:25like holding her in the bed. Yeah, but that's
- 52:27not sad. It's sweet, but it's depressing. I don't
- 52:31know. Hey, if that's how you want to go, dog.
- 52:34I think that's a great way to go. Okay. I don't
- 52:37think that's wrong. I'm not going to take the
- 52:38opposite opinion. I'm just saying I'm not like...
- 52:40Can you imagine Taylor and I watching The Notebook
- 52:43and the last scene is him holding her in the
- 52:45bed while she's dying and I lean over to Taylor
- 52:46and I say, us. Can you imagine her reaction?
- 52:50I think that's great. Okay. All right. Maybe
- 52:52it's just like, it's sweet. She just doesn't
- 52:55want to think about it. I like the idea of you
- 52:57watching the notebook and seeing the most romantic
- 53:00ending to a couple who have gotten, like, had
- 53:03the opportunity to live their whole life together.
- 53:05Yeah. But in your version of a perfect ending
- 53:08to the notebook, Allie dies in bed and he's holding
- 53:12her and he's like... And then he goes and becomes
- 53:16a monster truck driver and flips his truck and
- 53:19it blows up. And, like, Lynyrd Skynyrd is playing
- 53:23while it's happening and there's fireworks going
- 53:25on. And people are just like, yeah, Noah, we
- 53:28love you forever. Can I say something? Huh? Hell
- 53:31yeah. And, you know, there it is. The Hillbook,
- 53:34ladies and gentlemen, by Nicholas Thunderbolts.
- 53:38To be serious for a second, there's a real...
- 53:41There's a real question that I have about that
- 53:44that would determine whether I'm interested.
- 53:46Which Lynyrd Skynyrd song? The Gimme Two Statsman.
- 53:49Hell yeah, brother. Hell yeah, man. No, I'm back
- 53:54on board. As long as it wasn't Sweet Home Alabama.
- 53:56I think that for me is, yeah. And you won't see
- 53:59me no more. That's exactly what I put in third
- 54:03gear. Yeah. You go flying over like 16 school
- 54:07buses. You know what? When I go over, when it's
- 54:10like, give me two stamps, give me two stamps.
- 54:12That's when it's like the fireworks would be
- 54:15like, go off to the tune of it. Yeah. No, I think
- 54:19Taylor would be like, he went out the way he
- 54:20came in. Yeah, that's how you came in. He lived
- 54:23life a quarter mile at a time. Boy, I want that
- 54:25Anthony adverse story. That's sick. Where it's
- 54:27like you grew up from a rough beginning and it
- 54:29just shows a baby in a monster truck like, ah.
- 54:31They would have to call that Anthony Awesome.
- 54:34Yeah. Maybe Stefan Sick. Anthony All -Star. Stefan
- 54:38Sick. Stefan Sick is hell. It's sick hyphen as
- 54:44hyphen hell. This is just Ghost Rider is all
- 54:47it is. And you know what? That's the notebook.
- 54:51That's the tie -in to the notebook. Yeah, you're
- 54:53right. So just to clarify, Ghost Rider Spirit
- 54:56of Vengeance, that is your double feature for
- 54:58this movie? Yeah, that's the one. I went with
- 55:01an example of Shakespeare adapted in a way that
- 55:05I think adds a little razzle -dazzle and a little
- 55:07style. It's still very much a one -to -one comparison,
- 55:10but the production design adds a little bit.
- 55:13And that's the tragedy of Macbeth. Oh, the Joel
- 55:16Cohen. Yes, with Denzel Washington. I think it
- 55:19at least brings something to the screen that
- 55:22makes you say, oh, this is different. This is
- 55:24new. And I think maybe that's like a little bit
- 55:28of an aid for somebody like me to be like, okay,
- 55:30this is more than just going to see it. The black
- 55:34and white, the camera work, and the production
- 55:36design I think goes a long way in keeping interest
- 55:38in that movie. Also the performances. Yeah, absolutely.
- 55:41So everything. Those are the ones. I'll say it
- 55:45one more time. If you have thoughts on this version
- 55:47of Romeo and Juliet, shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 55:51at gmail .com. We cover the Patreon at the top
- 55:53of the show. Any and all contributions and subscriptions
- 55:56are greatly appreciated. But next episode, we
- 56:00will be covering Dodsworth, which I believe is
- 56:04our introduction to William Wyler. Oh, yeah,
- 56:07which we'll be talking about him for a while.
- 56:09Yes, we will. So I'm pretty excited for that
- 56:11one. You missed what I just did. We'll be talking
- 56:15about him for a while. I see, I see. I caught
- 56:18it. I got you. I did miss it. But yeah, thank
- 56:21you guys for listening. As always, I'm Kyle.
- 56:24I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the movies. Nailed
- 56:28it.