Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Suing the Treasury, High EV Repair Costs, Tesla Hires Geico Exec
Transcript
- 0:00[gentle music] Hey, Wednesday, June 4th, Kyle's back in his seat. It's- so- feels so good to be in your own studio.
- 0:06Today we're talking about automakers suing the Treasury, high EV repair costs, and Tesla hiring [upbeat music] an insurance person. So those two things probably go together somehow. They, they work, actually.
- 0:19That's, like, right in line. It's a big conversation. Every once in a while we get lucky with a show and the things work. Uh, it's intentional. [laughs] Uh, all right, Kyle. You're so- You were out- You're so smart...
- 0:30you [laughs] you were at a DMSC for a couple of days with a lot of really- Yeah... progressive marketers, marketing focus.
- 0:37Um, you know, some new friends, some old friends, a lot of great industry partners, a lot of great dealers. What's your takeaway? What are, what are the hot topics?
- 0:43Yesterday you talked about, you know, um, larger groups having trouble implementing a CDP. It's not as easy as you think. Uh, but final thoughts.
- 0:51You had a little time to contemplate, a flight home, a night's sleep in your own bed. How are you feeling?
- 0:55Yeah, I mean, you know, y- you see this in marketing, in automotive, and, and probably in every vertical where kind of there's a hot topic every one to two years, and everybody's trying to figure out the solution.
- 1:05And we've obviously gone into this, like, targeted addressable marketing, identity resolution, CDP segmented audiences type of conversation, and they all, like, they all wrap around each other in some way and, and, and, and feed off of each other.
- 1:21Um, but it is... It's, it's... I- I think what's hard for me about it is it's really iterative off of what we've done for, um, the last five to seven years, but we're talking about it in a new way.
- 1:36And my fear is that we forget, like, some of the basics in marketing of, like, oh, we should send these one-to-one emails to particular people. But I think the s- the most- Mm-hmm...
- 1:48exciting part of the CDP, and particularly not just the CDP, but the identity resolution and data cleanup, um, conversation, is just reducing the marketing waste overall, where customer doesn't own car, uh, you know, we've, we've got a new car in the driveway, or new email, different phone number.
- 2:09Y- you know- Yeah, we're not spending-... marketing... our money where we shouldn't be spending our marketing. Exactly. Like, same old stuff.
- 2:13And I, I think that that's, like, as an industry, figuring out how to not just, like, overextend ourselves, specifically on Google and Facebook, which is what we've been doing over the last six to seven years, is just going, "Need more leads, add more budget.
- 2:26Need more leads-" Dump money in the bucket... "add more budget." Yep. How do we, how do we make that bucket right-sized?
- 2:30One of the things that, that concerns me is that, and this is general, this isn't just about this situation, is that often when there's, like, a new hot topic, there's new vernacular, there are new words and phrases around it, and a couple things happen.
- 2:45One, people feel like because they become familiar with the terminology, that they're actually doing something. Right. But they're not.
- 2:53Um, number two is that, the, the lie that you just said is that maybe, like, the new shiny thing is actually not even as much...
- 3:02It doesn't make as much change as you could if you focused on the things that you already know. So, um, but if you get 'em- Well, and I just- If you get 'em right, though...
- 3:08I just would say as an industry, like, over the last, you know, I don't know, I'm gonna call it eight years, our, uh, desire to define a class of technology so rigidly- Oh, yeah...
- 3:22or by automotive standards, is extremely dangerous. AKA digital retailing. Digital retailing. [laughs] AI, CDP, right? Mm-hmm.
- 3:31We have to look more broadly, cross-vertically, to understand what the actual, like, what the actual technology is, and then draft on that in auto instead of, like, redefining it for auto. Yeah.
- 3:45Because then we get, then we get super dangerous when trying to, trying to go to, uh, multi-vertical technologies, um, which are entering auto at a rapid pace. Mm-hmm.
- 3:54And then we're misunderstanding the, the necessity to, like, bring those technologies into auto because we've, we've kind of, like, misinterpreted the terminology. So that's my, that's my biggest lookout.
- 4:06I had that conversation a bunch this week. I love it. I love it. Well, there you go. There we go. A little bit of a marketing intro. We had marketing things.
- 4:12Thanks to the Pasches for always being so good to us, um, and putting on great events and, like, caring about and serving their audience well. We're all about that. Hey, um- Yep...
- 4:21one of the ways you can help educate yourself and learn about all these types of things, uh, is our YouTube channel, because we just uploaded all the sessions from ASOTU Con.
- 4:30You go to ASOTU, A-S-O-T-U.B-E and see all of the sessions. If you were there, you could see all the ones you missed. If you weren't there, you could see all of them because you missed them all. So you get to see them.
- 4:41A lot of topics. A lot of topics like this, where you hear some of the sharpest people discussing them, um, you know, live on stage. It's a lot of fun. And, um, yeah, so we'll do that. Also, we have a webinar coming up.
- 4:52I don't h- I don't know if we have any details on that right now. But we do have another webinar. Um, who's it with? Is it Activator? Uh, Activator, yeah. I'm really excited about that.
- 5:01Activator's like a, a, a little sleeping startup inside of a giant, inside of a giant.
- 5:05And, uh, so I'm i- interested to see what the conversation a lot around the CDP and, uh, the use of that data for marketing automation. And you can... You go to our website, asotu.com. You can, uh, just sign up for that.
- 5:16It's free. It's fast. It's a lot of fun. Free, fast, and fun. There you go. ASOTU Edge webinars. [laughs] That's pretty much what they are. [laughs] Uh, all right, let's get into some news here. That's great.
- 5:24What a value prop.
- 5:25US Senator Joe Manchin has urged manufacturers to sue the Treasury Department over its implementation of local content rules for clean energy tax credits under the Inflation Reduction Act, I- AKA the IRA.
- 5:39Say that 10 times fast. Boy. Go. That was a mouthful. So basically, you know, the, the rules that tell you where you need to get battery materials from and whether or not you'd be a- applicable for credits.
- 5:47Layman's terms. Uh, Manchin, who has recently left the Democratic Party and is now a, a full independent, has criticized both major parties- Wow...
- 5:56for partisan extremism and claims the Treasury's final rules have the original content requirements in the legislation-That do actual harm to the US manufacturers because of the reliance on Chinese materials and the requirements of what happens under the act to get credits.
- 6:12Basically, he said the rules permit automakers to use Chinese critical minerals for another year, which he says breaks the law. So there was this law in place- Hm...
- 6:21and they just implemented rules that basically stretched the terms. And so basically he's saying now automakers can use Chinese materials in EV batteries longer than the law actually is in place.
- 6:36So it's like, he's like, "Oh, you just we- weaseled your way out of having to be accountable to the rules that you just laid on automakers," and they made investments to try to get US materials.
- 6:45So basically, um, he said just directly to, to Janet Yellen, "I'm encouraging every manufacturer to sue you, and I will even do the amicus brief on their behalf, and you'll lose every suit." Wow.
- 6:59He's- That is like- Somebody-... my man... somebody invite him to that Ford thing that's happening this weekend. Yeah. [laughs] This weekend, he'll come. We'll- He's- they're gonna pull him up on stage with Eminem.
- 7:10Well, th- this, this right here, like, for me, this is the story that I, I, I wish we could, like, in the political landscape drive home is partisan extremism is dangerous for our political climate and for our business climate.
- 7:27Like, anyth- anytime you go extreme to one side or the other, it is extremely dangerous because you stop to consider the other side's possi- the, the, the impact that the other side has as kind of a desire for. Mm.
- 7:39And so I love that he's calling that out. Interesting that it's coming from Manchin, uh, right? With kind of everything that he was a part of really in 2023. Um, but man, to come out- He shoots it straight, man.
- 7:50He shoots it straight... to come out and shoot it straight like that, like, uh, like snaps for that dude. Yeah. You know? Yep, yep. Speaking of things snapping. Stop. Segway. Kinda like that one.
- 8:00[upbeat music] [laughs] Love that. Uh, repairing an EV is on average 30% more expensive than repairing an internal combustion vehicle according to Q1 2024 insurance data, and here's why.
- 8:12Average EV repair claim in Q1 was $6,066 compared to only $4,703 for ICE vehicles. Basically, EVs declared total losses at the same rate of ICE vehicles, though. So it was about just under 10% EVs and ICE.
- 8:28The biggest cost driver on repairs is mechanical labor hours. Uh, three point hour- 3.04 hours for EVs versus 1.66 hours for ICE vehicles.
- 8:37Uh, extra labor als- often involves maintaining, managing the high-voltage battery situation, including de-energizing the battery, removing it so you can safely do repairs without, you know, anyone getting electrocuted.
- 8:50Um, EVs also rely more on OEM parts. This makes sense. Right. Newer vehicles, proprietary parts, there's not a lot of aftermarket solutions.
- 8:58Um, so, like, 90% of EV repairs need an OEM re- uh, part versus 65% of an ICE vehicle. Tesla Model 3 and Model Y are the top vehicles for repair claims, followed by the Ford Mustang Mach-E. No surprise there.
- 9:11They're just more of them on the road. Yeah, so if you're not familiar with the actual, like, n- necessity whenever you start working on one of these EVs, right? [laughs] It involves multiple people and a gaff.
- 9:23Yes, exactly, yeah. You, y- you essentially have to completely disarm the elect- the, the battery, right?
- 9:31Sometimes even, like, removing it completely from the vehicle frame and setting it to the side in order to even work on it just for safety reasons.
- 9:41But then, like, the, the, the one thing, and I have a buddy that works for GEICO, he said the one thing that gets them in the most trouble is you get, like, a simple fender bender that would typically be a few hundred bucks or something like that on an ICE vehicle, um, or really anything, like, 2021 prior.
- 10:00Um, and, and one of the big impact pieces is not just the EV battery, but it's the technology required for things that include, like, lidar, right?
- 10:09Yeah, sensor calibration and all that stuff Where the wiring harness has to completely be re- uh, taken off- Mm-hmm... and then reconnected and then painstakingly tested within a, like m- Very small tolerance, yeah...
- 10:22nano micro whatever of tolerance, uh, in order to- A nano micro... put it back on. That's perfect Yeah. That's, that's exactly- Nano mi- That's the new word. [laughs] That's perfect. I know exactly what you meant.
- 10:30[laughs] Yeah. So- Really, really, really small...
- 10:33yeah, between, between what you have to do with the EV battery and what you, just in labor alone, but then they pointed obviously to, uh, the OEM parts not having a ton of aftermarket on this stuff.
- 10:43Like, it's, it's, it's one of those things where I think, you know, with the affordability on the actual purchase price, it's similar to like, oh, we got OL- OLED TVs for $3,800- [laughs]... and now they're 900, right?
- 10:59Yeah. You just see, like, both things needing to get scale, get aftermarket, get efficiency in the purchase side and the, the, the repair side.
- 11:08So, um, not a big surprise, but still, like, a consideration that people that are buying an EV today- Affordability... need to be thinking about. Ties back to affordability- Mm...
- 11:17and I think the insurance can be a surprise on what an EV costs. Um, speaking of trying to lower insurance costs for EVs- Stop. Segway Time [upbeat music] And GEICO. You had a friend who worked for GEICO. Yeah.
- 11:29We can use that as a segue too. Look at that, man. Just, we're just leaning right in.
- 11:32[laughs] So Tesla's taking a strategic step to actually reduce these high insurance costs because of high vehicle repairs, um, for its vehicles by hiring a longtime GEICO executive.
- 11:42Uh, so the 20-year veteran of GEICO's name is Alan Lieben. He's joining Tesla as the head of insurance partnerships.
- 11:48Um, their goal, Tesla, is to make vehicles easier, more economical to insure by partnering with insurance companies and collision shops.
- 11:56Um, so his goal will be to lower the total cost of Tesla ownership and support the transition into, to sustainable energy as well. Um, Tesla, if you don't know, also has their own insurance product. Yes, they do.
- 12:09They launched in California in 2019. Um, and it actually uses real-time driv- driving data, which some other, uh, insurance companies have had, uh, with, like, their- Get a little plugin or a little-...
- 12:20QB2 things- Yeah... uh, to determine insurance rates. Um, the insurance product, though, has been controversialDue to the reliance on the real-time driving data and safety scores.
- 12:29So, um, here's a quote from Alan, "My goal is to make Tesla vehicles easy and economical," there it comes back, "to insure." I mean, they're going, they're going vertical. There you go.
- 12:38I mean, but I, this is interesting- Yeah... that they're hiring him to lean into the partnership side of it. You know, they tried to go it alone, they tried to go vertical.
- 12:45That's probably an okay product in certain scenarios, but obviously- Right... uh, it's getting more complex and costs are going up. So they, they brought him in. Like, I trust the guy from Geico. Wouldn't you?
- 12:56Well, I would trust, and also you think about all of the people that are buying used Teslas from elsewhere, and so Tesla partnering with these insurance companies- Yeah...
- 13:07gives them more access to better data and m- more parts for the collision shops- Yeah... making it easier for them to also insure the used side of the market. Yeah. That's a great point.
- 13:19Lowering expenses across- So, you know, if you think, like, long term, and you're thinking about retention, and you're thinking about getting people- Parts... in these used Teslas- Yeah. Mm-hmm...
- 13:25number of vehicles on the road, all of that's important. You know, they should have just hired Flo. [laughs] I would love to see a conversation between Flo and Elon Musk. That'd be amazing. We'll get AI.
- 13:38We'll get- Actually, that would be s- that would be stellar. [laughs] Just put them in a room and see who talks more. You know what I mean? Oh. [laughs] That would be unbelievable.
- 13:46Hey, we hope we, we sent you away with something to think about, something to smile about at the show. We know you have a lot of work to do.
- 13:52Go out there, love some people more than you love cars, but take care of the cars too.
- 13:55[upbeat music]