Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Episode 318 / Jason Hartley / PMG / Head of Media Innovation and Trust
Transcript
- 0:00Jason Hartley: I hear the expression data led a lot, and I
- 0:02say it, and people say it, and I think that's kind of a mistake.
- 0:05I think it needs to be data, informed, data, that challenges
- 0:08the assumptions that are most closely held. They're usually
- 0:12ignored, but that's probably when they're most valuable.
- 0:21Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie? Then defy snacks
- 0:23is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:26combined with functional ingredients, giving you as much
- 0:29as 26 grammes of protein per bag. So you can be both a little
- 0:32bit bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:36brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:39owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:42defy with an i snacks.com and follow us on social at defy
- 0:47snacks.
- 0:53Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:57My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of automated creative,
- 1:00the creative effectiveness ad tech platform, and this is a
- 1:03podcast about the future of data driven marketing. Every week or
- 1:06so I have the pleasure and the privilege of interviewing one of
- 1:08our industry's leaders about their vision for where this
- 1:11industry is going. And this week is no different. I am on a call
- 1:16with the lovely Jason Hartley, who is head of media innovation
- 1:20and trust at PMG, So Jason, for anyone who doesn't know who you
- 1:25are and what you do, could you give us a bit of background?
- 1:27Jason Hartley: Sure. Well, first of all, thanks for having me.
- 1:30It's very fun to talk about these topics. So this is great,
- 1:34but I should start with my title, because it sounds kind of
- 1:37made up and grandiose. But so media innovation and trust.
- 1:42Basically it is we're doing, trying to do cool, new things,
- 1:45but doing them the right way. You know, we're thinking about
- 1:47privacy, we're thinking about the ethical implications of AI
- 1:50and so on. And I feel really lucky to have that position,
- 1:53because, you know, for a lot of my career, it's been, can we do
- 1:56this, not should we do this? And it's nice to see the industry
- 2:00moving along. As well as the company I work for, I've been in
- 2:05paid search for about 20 years. I've been focusing on privacy
- 2:09the last several years. In my spare time, which is vanishingly
- 2:14small, I make music and I do yoga and lots of other things.
- 2:18Sort of try to take all of those experiences in my life and put
- 2:22it together and think about what the future might look like for
- 2:25for us marketers, and maybe beyond.
- 2:27Tom Ollerton: So what has been that moment in your career where
- 2:27Jason Hartley: There's so many of those that I could point to,
- 2:31you were incredibly red faced and you wanted the world to
- 2:34and of course, that's usually that's when you grow, when you
- 2:36swallow you up, but in retrospect, you're quite glad
- 2:40that it happened?
- 2:42learn, is when you make the biggest mistakes. But the one
- 2:50that always comes to mind to me was actually something that felt
- 2:54like a huge success and then turned into a failure. Years and
- 2:58years ago, at another job, I got the sense that we really
- 3:03understood the way paid search worked. We understood the rules.
- 3:07We understood what Google and Microsoft were telling us was
- 3:10what was the right thing to do. And it felt like, well, if I
- 3:14could describe this, then we could code something to see,
- 3:17were we doing it right? I was able to get a team together and
- 3:23pitch this to our CEO, and he was all into it, and we made
- 3:26this incredible product that would predict performance on
- 3:30your paid search account. This is long before opt to score and
- 3:33things like that. So there really wasn't a product out
- 3:35there that was widely known. I'm sure other people were working
- 3:37on it, but at any rate, I've took very great care to make
- 3:41sure that it looked good. I worked with our product
- 3:44developers and just said, like this should be we have to think
- 3:47about this as being an environment that people are
- 3:49going to spend hours in. So it should feel wonderful. They
- 3:52should get some pleasure out of it. It should work nicely. It
- 3:55should look beautiful. The thing that I thought about was, OXO
- 3:59Good Grips the way it feels to use their can opener compared to
- 4:03what it usually felt like to use a can opener, but any rate. So
- 4:07we did all that, we got really good feedback about it. And like
- 4:11I say, it felt like a real success, because it actually,
- 4:14when we tested, it worked out really well if it predicted that
- 4:17something was going to improve performance. And we did it, it
- 4:19actually did, but we missed something that ended up being
- 4:24fundamental, and that was it wasn't connected to the to
- 4:29AdWords at the time, so you couldn't actually make changes
- 4:32in this tool. You had to have your two monitors open and move
- 4:36from one to the other with your eyes. And it turned out that
- 4:41people don't want to do that even though it works. They
- 4:45didn't want to do it because it wasn't seamlessly integrated.
- 4:48And I pushed and I pushed and I prodded and I cajoled and I did
- 4:52all the things that I could as a department head to try to get
- 4:55people to adopt it. And very good people, very smart people,
- 4:59just wouldn't. Never use it. And so all of this time and
- 5:03development and all these things, and we put it in pitches
- 5:06and everything, and it ended up just being an absolute flop,
- 5:09even though it worked. And so it's useful, because I learned a
- 5:15lot of things there. One was, you can't make assumptions,
- 5:19that's for sure. We did a lot of testing with people, and they
- 5:22were, they were on board, but we didn't ask always the right
- 5:24questions. We probably led people down the path. They
- 5:27probably didn't want to tell me, No, I don't like it, or it lacks
- 5:30this, or so on. So a little bit of humility and self awareness,
- 5:33I learned from that, but also just human nature. We have to
- 5:37think about the fact that, you know, people don't want their
- 5:39lives to be more complicated. They also don't want to feel
- 5:42like they're that someone's watching them. You know that
- 5:44this was a dashboard that I could look at as a head of
- 5:46department and see what accounts were doing what and even though
- 5:51I wasn't doing that to catch anybody, it was just so that I
- 5:54could easily tell our CEO this is how we're doing as a
- 5:54department. So at any rate, it was a total flop, but it was
- 5:59really good for me to think about, okay, well, when I think
- 6:02about things that are happening right now and try to extrapolate
- 6:06out into the future, you know what's going to work? What's
- 6:08going to be something that's going to connect with an average
- 6:11consumer who doesn't need a more complicated life, and they don't
- 6:14care about AI and they don't care about agents or any of
- 6:17these things, they just care about getting the thing that
- 6:19they want, or having a good experience, or seeing something
- 6:21that gives them pleasure, or whatever it is, and so all of
- 6:26that sort of wrapped into a worldview of human nature is
- 6:28undefeated. You know, I can tell you it's amazing, I can show you
- 6:31it's amazing. But if I'm not appealing to the humanity of
- 6:36someone and really thinking about their lives, then I'm
- 6:39probably going to miss some connections that I could have
- 6:41made otherwise.
- 6:48Tom Ollerton: Yeah, my thing for that is being right is not
- 6:51enough. I say it's you can be as right as you like, but um, was
- 6:57it? Was it? What? What did it? Was it? Thomas Aquinas say that
- 7:01convincing untruth is better than a unconvincing truth.
- 7:05Jason Hartley: It was crazy. I mean, I could show that it
- 7:07actually worked. It was really strange, because we are data
- 7:12driven people, you know. And it just seemed to me like, Well,
- 7:17gosh, this was a no brainer. Of course you would use this. But
- 7:20when it's Tuesday afternoon and you have to open up yet another
- 7:23thing, and you're trying to do things quickly, and you have to
- 7:26drill down into these things and find where the problems are, you
- 7:27know, you just people just not going to use it. And doesn't
- 7:28mean they're not smart, doesn't mean they're not dedicated or
- 7:28anything like that. It just means you've made a product that
- 7:30doesn't solve their needs in a way that they needed to be
- 7:38solved.
- 7:38Tom Ollerton: Yeah, and the problem you actually sold is
- 7:41your desire to be innovative, right? And sometimes that means
- 7:46you also have solved someone's problem. And boy, have I done
- 7:50many things in the count of like, well, I thought it was
- 7:53cool, so that's a lovely story. So have you got a specific bit
- 7:57of advice that you would give to someone to become a better data
- 8:01driven marketer?
- 8:02Jason Hartley: Yeah, I think so. Again, I bring so much humility
- 8:03after that experience and so many other ones that are
- 8:08probably more embarrassing, that one probably made me sound
- 8:11smarter than I really am. I could probably do some ones that
- 8:14really are embarrassing, but at any rate, I would say, look
- 8:20beyond the data, to be a better data driven marker. Or, you
- 8:24know, I hear the expression data led a lot, and I say it, and
- 8:27people say and I think that's kind of a mistake. I think it
- 8:30needs to be data informed instead of lead, because there's
- 8:34a larger world outside the data. And I think that sometimes we
- 8:39can measure ourselves into a corner, and get into that old
- 8:42problem of just thinking that if you can't measure it, it doesn't
- 8:44matter. And I think that as we see user behaviour and consumer
- 8:49behaviour changing so much and so rapidly with everything
- 8:53that's going on with AI, they're moving faster than we can
- 8:56measure them, and so we can decide, well, we're going to
- 8:59ignore it, because we don't have the data similar to what we did
- 9:01with mobile for years. Or we can say these, this is where
- 9:07consumers are, this is what they want. We need to be there. Now,
- 9:10let's try to think about, you know, signal, not certainty.
- 9:13What can we learn from what we have and make good decisions
- 9:18that way? But I think there is a, there is a, you know, there
- 9:22was almost a cult of data years ago where it felt like
- 9:25everything was an engineering problem, but we're dealing with
- 9:28people, and we're trying to connect with them in meaningful
- 9:31ways. And the data can help, for sure, but it shouldn't lead you.
- 9:35You know, I think that there's a combination of things that you
- 9:38have to put together, and then ultimately you put together what
- 9:41you're good at as a human with it, which is just like we have
- 9:45instincts that are right, but we need to look at data to confirm
- 9:48those. We also have to look at our biases. We have to look at
- 9:50the biases in the data and so on. So I think it is you don't
- 9:54just trust the data, but you do use it as a tool. And, you know,
- 9:59look at the data that challenges your assumption probably the
- 10:01hardest, because what, in my experience, it does seem that
- 10:06data that challenges the the assumptions that are most
- 10:09closely held, they're usually ignored, but that's probably
- 10:13when they're most valuable.
- 10:15Tom Ollerton: So going to move on now to your shiny new object,
- 10:19which is the Under net. And we've had 300 plus episodes of
- 10:23this podcast, and very rarely did people choose exactly the
- 10:27same, but we've definitely not had an under net before. So what
- 10:30is that? What is the Under net? And why is it your shiny new
- 10:33object?
- 10:33Jason Hartley: So the under net was something that we were
- 10:36talking about internally as we were thinking about the fact
- 10:40that increasingly the online experience is being powered that
- 10:44that by things that are kind of invisible to people. And so as
- 10:49we started to think about the emergence of agents and how llms
- 10:54work to sort of organise and summarise the world, and then
- 10:58give you what looks like a baked answer. It felt right, because
- 11:03the internet is there, and we live on it, and it's a surface
- 11:07level thing, and we don't really think a lot about what's going
- 11:11underneath. And so a lot of the pipes and things that we had
- 11:14built underneath there, the infrastructure of the internet,
- 11:17is now being used in a new way that's not really visible to us,
- 11:20we have these new, invisible influencers in our lives that we
- 11:24don't really recognise. And that's really the under net.
- 11:26It's all of those things together. And what's been
- 11:31interesting in just in the last few weeks, with AI browsers kind
- 11:35of popping up, that's almost I might have to have another name
- 11:38for that. We're considering the overnet for that, because
- 11:42there's this AI layer on top of what you do. So it's like this
- 11:45overlay. So you have this under net, underneath the Internet
- 11:48where all these things are happening, and machines are
- 11:50talking to machines, and they're influencing your experiences.
- 11:53You have the Internet where we're we're doing what we always
- 11:56did. And then there's the over net that has this assistant
- 11:59quality, where you can is, you know, you're not bound by the
- 12:04fact that you're in a website. You can go anywhere in the world
- 12:08while still being on that website. So it's a pretty
- 12:10profound shift, but the undernet is something we've coined, so
- 12:15we'll take a little credit for that. But I think, you know,
- 12:17just speaks to this larger movement where, you know, agents
- 12:21are more a part of our lives and so on. I know everyone talks
- 12:24about agents and what they can do, and there's a lot to be
- 12:28learned there. I think that we're a ways away. But as it is
- 12:31right now, the original idea about the undernet was just the
- 12:35fact that, you know, if you go to chatgpt and it doesn't have
- 12:37the answer in its data, it searches for you, and so it
- 12:40searches instead of you, and that's that's a profound shift
- 12:43that it's happening because you don't really see all the steps
- 12:46that it's taking, or you don't care about them so much, and
- 12:48you're just given a completed answer.
- 12:56Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 12:59brought to you in partnership with Madfest, whether it's live
- 13:02in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 13:06you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 13:09fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 13:12unconventional entertainment from Madfest events. You'll find
- 13:15me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 13:18podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 13:21people in marketing. Check it out at www.madfestlondon.com.
- 13:33What's your view on the commercials of the all of this?
- 13:36So there's a writer that I... his name completely escapes me.
- 13:41He does a brilliant podcast called Better offline, and he's
- 13:44been railing against Gen AI, what's his name? Ah, it will
- 13:49come back to me. Ed Zitron and great writer, don't know if you
- 13:53know him, and just week after week is his 13,000 words email
- 13:58newsletter talks about how no one's making any money out of
- 14:01this. People have revenue, but I don't know. I butcher these
- 14:06numbers, but Amazon's capital expend, expenditure on AI versus
- 14:10Gen AI, sorry, versus profit. It's like nine to one or
- 14:14something. It's crazy, like, and, you know, Meta up there,
- 14:18and so no one's making any money. So what's going to
- 14:22happen? Because there's yes agents, I get it. Yes, I am a
- 14:27huge user of these services, but, but at some point, if
- 14:31someone's going to get their money back, then they're going
- 14:33to be ineffectively expensive.
- 14:36Jason Hartley: Sure. Well, I think that, you know, we have to
- 14:39look at the bigger picture for sure. I think in general, one of
- 14:43the things we're guilty of, and again, kind of going back to
- 14:46that data driven marketer, you know, data is really good at
- 14:48telling you what happened in the past, but it can, it can sort of
- 14:52stick you in the past as well. I mean, we're, we are trying to
- 14:55impose these brand new things onto an existing or onto an
- 14:59existing. Sort of framework that we're comfortable with, I think
- 15:03that there's going to be new ways to monetize this stuff that
- 15:06are going to pop up. There's just too much opportunity here,
- 15:09I think, to ignore. And if you think about, you know, when
- 15:13Steve Jobs held up the iPhone for the first time, there
- 15:16weren't a whole lot of people thinking to themselves, Boy, I
- 15:18bet taxis are going to be in big trouble. You know, they weren't
- 15:21thinking that there was going to be this app ecosystem that was
- 15:24going to make it so that in New York you could get a car instead
- 15:26of, you know, come at when you needed them, rather than calling
- 15:29a car service and waiting for them to have a car available, or
- 15:33standing there in Manhattan at four o'clock, holding your hand
- 15:36up for hours waiting for a taxi to be free. So point is, is,
- 15:39like we're so early here. I think that there's a lot of
- 15:42different ways that this could go. You know, everyone's sort of
- 15:46waiting for, you know, will Open AI have ads and so on. I think
- 15:51that they have bigger aspirations than that. We'll
- 15:53see. I think their subscription service is definitely, you know,
- 15:56that's going to be a steady revenue driver. And to your
- 15:58point, it's maybe not making them any money. But, you know, I
- 16:01look back to what, what Amazon did for years and years they
- 16:04were, they could be a company for a really long time without
- 16:07making a profit, because everybody saw the vision.
- 16:10Everyone believed in it, and everyone could see where it was
- 16:12going. We're not advanced yet enough for that, I think, but
- 16:16everything's much faster now. It feels like that. I think
- 16:18we're... there's a general belief that, you know, Open AI
- 16:22is not going anywhere, and they have some runway to figure this
- 16:26out, to make sure that it's profitable when you so, so at
- 16:30any rate, so I don't see them sort of adopting that model
- 16:34anytime soon, or having to. I think, you know, the smaller
- 16:38players are probably going to have a little bit more incentive
- 16:42to try to monetize it more overtly. But subscriptions
- 16:46definitely are something that people are doing, but it's
- 16:49definitely, I mean, it will get cheaper to process. Models are
- 16:53going to be cheaper to build and so on. So I think, you know, if
- 16:56we, if we look back to the past and we sort of think about the
- 16:58future and how it might mirror that. I think it's going to be a
- 17:02combination of factors where someone's going to figure this
- 17:04out, because ultimately, how are we going to go backward from
- 17:08this? You know, what's going to happen, like is everyone just
- 17:11going to fold the generative AI tent and say, we can't make any
- 17:14money on it, so we're just going to go back. I don't see that
- 17:17happening, and it may be just that it's being built by
- 17:21companies that have really diverse revenue streams and then
- 17:24allowing them to figure out, some time, to figure out how
- 17:27they can actually make money on it. And ultimately, if Open AI
- 17:31decides they can't do it without ads, well, they will have
- 17:35billions of prompts every day. They have hundreds of millions
- 17:39of users already, and they can have extremely relevant ads
- 17:43within their platform for any kind of content that will be
- 17:47very personal and will be intent, will be at the heart of
- 17:51it. Same goes with Google. Same goes with perplexity and grok
- 17:54and all the rest. So if they want to pull that lever, it's
- 17:58there to be pulled. And I think if you do it the right way,
- 18:00that, certainly, you know, it's not, it doesn't take that much
- 18:03of imagination to see how it might look.
- 18:05Tom Ollerton: Yeah, there's a few ifs like, you know, the the
- 18:08Amazon model was this all kind of based on the fact that
- 18:11people, people are going to carry on buying more and more
- 18:13stuff online, right? That that was the, you know, that was the
- 18:17easy thing to follow, right? Obviously, in right respect, it
- 18:20was a it was the right horse to back. But I don't really see
- 18:23that with Gen AI in the same way it's like, oh yeah. People use
- 18:26Gen AI to sort of write emails quicker and, you know, like it's
- 18:30and, yes, I have many agents. Well I hate that expression, but
- 18:34I guess I have many gpts or projects, whatever you want to
- 18:38call them. Let's call them agents working. They don't work
- 18:41for me. I make it. It's a computer programme. Let's just
- 18:43call it what it is. We don't need to oversell it. But
- 18:47there's, I wonder, does it really what is the the man or
- 18:51woman on the street thing that they can't possibly live
- 18:54without? I think that's what I've not seen yet. And with your
- 18:57mobile phone, your so your iPhone, example, like the the
- 19:01economics always works, right? Like, we can have an app store
- 19:04and, like, Oh yeah, and so, and yes, you could throw up an app
- 19:07for 3040, 50 grand, or whatever it was, and then you can make
- 19:14revenue from it, whereas, if you're losing, you know, $9 for
- 19:14every dollar you spend. Then, then maybe it's a bit more of a
- 19:18Concord situation. You know, you could fly to New York for three
- 19:20hours from London, but it just didn't stack up financially. So
- 19:23they stopped doing it.
- 19:24Jason Hartley: Well, I guess the question is, what do you charge
- 19:26when all the best apps are in your platform? You know, if
- 19:29they, if they actually do, provide a lot of utility, I
- 19:32think what I immediately raised to when I started to think about
- 19:36agents, when they started to emerge, was no one will ever
- 19:39have to overpay again, you know, and that that is something
- 19:43that's pretty interesting, you know, where you can say, I know
- 19:47I want this toothpaste within this certain amount of time, go
- 19:50find it for me, and I never, and I don't have to think about it
- 19:52or expend any effort at all. If you use the AI browser now, you
- 19:56have a window right next to you. So if you go and you find and it
- 19:59navigates. To you, for you on the site, and gives you a bunch
- 20:03of options based on, you know, you're saying, I want the most
- 20:06trendy blah, blah, blah. And then you can say, well, is this
- 20:09the best price? And ask a lot of questions about and I think
- 20:12there's a lot of utility there. But, you know, to your point, I
- 20:14mean, the browser business is not a great business. You know,
- 20:17search has been propping that up in a lot of ways. It's something
- 20:21to watch. But again, I think that we're still so early. I
- 20:25think it's, it's certainly too early to dismiss anything. I
- 20:28think there are little, little bits and pieces to think, okay,
- 20:32you know, it may be more like Napster. You know, where Napster
- 20:35was like, okay, it broke the industry, and they had to figure
- 20:37out how they could do iTunes for 99 cents, and then streaming and
- 20:40so on. And it that was a shift in the business that ended up
- 20:45being okay for the labels, maybe, and for the platforms,
- 20:49but it did hurt artists, you know, because if you're not
- 20:54huge, then it's not great for you. So I think, you know, it
- 20:57could go in a lot of different directions, but I think that
- 21:00there are enough reasons to believe that this is going to
- 21:03stay and provide real value to people, that people will pay for
- 21:07it. And then you throw in the fact that this stuff is powering
- 21:11business as well. And if you look at, you know, all sorts of
- 21:14businesses are incorporating this technology, and they're
- 21:17getting it from the same platforms that we're talking
- 21:19about in a marketing context. That's why I say that the
- 21:23diversity of their revenue could keep them from having to do the
- 21:27types of things that Google and Facebook did when they were
- 21:32needed to make some money and really rely on advertising.
- 21:34They're just more options now that they can have and they can
- 21:38rely on so they might just focus on user experience and making as
- 21:42useful as possible, and then creating an ecosystem where they
- 21:47have developers that share revenue, or whatever it may be.
- 21:50So let's see how that
- 21:51Tom Ollerton: evolves, and what's your take on the
- 21:53environmental impact. I'm sure that most, once I hear they'll
- 21:57work out how to make it greener. But there's two quotes that made
- 22:02me think. The first was, every time you use chat GPT, a tree
- 22:05dies, which I thought, and then the other one was to write an
- 22:10email is the equivalent of boiling a kettle? Yeah, yeah,
- 22:14which is a really visceral amount of energy. I don't know
- 22:16how much energy that is, but it's like, if you know, you fill
- 22:19a full kettle and boil it. You know, there's energy's being
- 22:23used there. And, you know, I'm like, Oh, God help me. I don't
- 22:27want to read this brief just, you know, summarise it for me.
- 22:29Jason Hartley: Sure, sure. Yeah. I mean, that's definitely, I
- 22:33mean, it's something that we have to figure out. It's
- 22:35something that I've done a lot of presentations about, actually
- 22:40talking about the ethics of this, and that's a big part of
- 22:42it, for sure. I think that I do try to look at the big picture,
- 22:48kind of this is the theme, you know, let's have some humility.
- 22:51Let's not look at just this one data point. What is the, what is
- 22:54the greater context here? I agree that people need to not
- 23:00they need to be aware so they can make better decisions. There
- 23:02are ways to to, you know, batch your your requests and things
- 23:07like that, but if it's a working tool and you're expect to use
- 23:12it, you know, it's kind of hard to be strategic about when you
- 23:15use it, but it isn't that hard to be strategic about knowing
- 23:15that I can just, you know, search this on Google. But of
- 23:15course, if Google is going to take you into AI mode and use
- 23:18the same kind of technology, then you don't really have a
- 23:21whole lot of control over it. But I do think, you know, when I
- 23:24look at the at the full picture, you know, you'll see some people
- 23:28say, Okay, well, you know, you know, to your point, every time
- 23:32someone uses chat, GPT, an angel loses its wings, or whatever it
- 23:36may be there, they'll point out that there are five other things
- 23:41that may have gotten better, or the fact that they can use the
- 23:44same technology to make, you know, transportation more
- 23:47efficient, or factories more efficient, or whatever it may
- 23:50be. So I do think we have to look at the big picture, but at
- 23:53the same time, I think that we all need to keep talking about
- 23:56this and showing how important it is to us. And I think that we
- 24:03can all sort of take our own steps individually, if you're a
- 24:08part of a larger company, like in my role, you know, trust is
- 24:12in my title. So I get to talk to 1000 people about, look, we're
- 24:16doing everything we can as a company, but it will take
- 24:18individuals doing actions as well. But ultimately, it's
- 24:21really going to be up to the bigger companies who are making
- 24:25the biggest dent in this. You know, I think often we talk
- 24:28about environmental problems, we talk about our own personal
- 24:31responsibilities, and sort of leave out the fact that maybe
- 24:35bigger, bigger forces are at work here. And it does have to
- 24:38be a collective action, complete with consumers saying or people
- 24:44saying, you know, this is important to me. You need to fix
- 24:46this and and see where it goes. So it's another thing where it's
- 24:51like, gosh, I would love to come back and talk to you two years
- 24:53from now and see, see where we are there is, is it going to be
- 24:56much more efficient? Are we going to be able to. Have models
- 25:01I saw recently that Deepsea had, I think it was 90% or 93% of
- 25:07Grok's intelligence at 15% of the cost. Is that the future,
- 25:12are we going to be able to do things much more efficiently,
- 25:15much more cheaply and so on? I don't know, but we'll see. But
- 25:20in the meantime, we should all be talking about it, making sure
- 25:23in our own actions. I think we have to be aware of it at the
- 25:26very least, and then make decisions based on what you
- 25:28know.
- 25:34Tom Ollerton: So to finish, which under net possibility,
- 25:40capability or agent do you think is being most overlooked by the
- 25:45marketing community?
- 25:46Jason Hartley: Interesting, I think, you know, for me, what I
- 25:50keep thinking about is everyone's now really talking
- 25:54about this, and this is something we've had around for a
- 25:56long time. So I you know, and plenty of people are so or have
- 26:00been for quite some time, but when I look at it, I don't hear
- 26:03a lot of conversation about the effects around this. You know
- 26:09about the fact that what we used to do is people are going to be
- 26:14changed, will be a machine doing it for us. And what is the
- 26:17effect does that have on programmatic on the open web.
- 26:21You know, all of these, all this inventory that used to have ads
- 26:24on it, if we're not looking at anymore, what happens to that
- 26:28and so, and also, just like, what does it have? What does it
- 26:32mean for us as human beings? You know, our brains are getting
- 26:36rewired again, and to abdicate the responsibility of doing
- 26:40these things or delegate it is really profound, I think. But
- 26:45we're still, you know, going back to the human nature thing,
- 26:48we still want that joy of discovery. We still want to feel
- 26:51like we've found things, you know, due to our cleverness or
- 26:54our connections or whatever, and and so when I think about this,
- 26:58I can't help but to start panning out and just looking at
- 27:01the entire picture and how it affects it, both in terms of
- 27:06human beings, the way we think and the way we work, the way we
- 27:09feel, the tools that we prefer, the experiences that we like,
- 27:13and how those are going to change. And I think it's really
- 27:18those sort of second order effects that are being not
- 27:21talked about by a lot, because I think people are still in this
- 27:25phase of, well, these, you know, this agentic search, or the AI
- 27:29browser, or whatever, just the actual facts of the thing and
- 27:32the capabilities of it. And, you know, I try to think a little
- 27:37bit beyond that. But if I had to choose one thing that's that's
- 27:41changed, that that, you know, is the thing that I don't hear
- 27:44people talking about it like I thought that they would, which
- 27:46is price comparison. That's, that's the thing that, to me, is
- 27:50just like that was the most obvious use, and I know it's a
- 27:54part of a lot of what we're doing, but the fact that we're
- 27:57empowering people to be able to do that, and not only online, I
- 28:01can use an assistant that's multimodal, and I can go into a
- 28:08flea market and show it this and say, what is that worth? So it's
- 28:12kind of profound to bring that information there, but as we've
- 28:15seen in the past, more information, more data, doesn't
- 28:18necessarily mean a happier, better world. So we'll see how
- 28:22that all pans out. But that was a bit of a long answer, but it's
- 28:26best I got for today.
- 28:27Tom Ollerton: Well, Jason, you're going to put a date in
- 28:28the diary for this time in two years, if not sooner. That was
- 28:32brilliant. Thank you. I remember we supposed to have a 15 minute
- 28:36prep call with guests, and we talked about an hour, I think,
- 28:39sort of something on a variety of different topics. But thank
- 28:42you. If someone wants to get in touch with you about the
- 28:45internet or anything else we've talked about, where's a good
- 28:48place and what makes a message that you will actually respond
- 28:51to.
- 28:52Jason Hartley: So LinkedIn is the best place to get me. That's
- 28:54something that will definitely get there. And look, if you're
- 28:59reaching out to me because you're genuinely interested, and
- 29:02you you thought that had something interesting to say, or
- 29:04you have something to add, or whatever it is, I'm listening,
- 29:07for sure. I always tell people, you know, I'm not spammable. I'm
- 29:11a voracious reader. I just want to learn, get as many
- 29:14perspectives as possible. If your goal is to try to sell in a
- 29:19service, then I'm probably gonna be a little less excited to
- 29:23respond, unless it is a service that is clearly going to be
- 29:28useful and can maybe, you know, deal with some of the things
- 29:31that we're talking about. So but generally speaking, I'm a nice
- 29:34guy, so you know, if you send me a note, I'm going to respond.
- 29:37But if you have some authentic connection to this, this topic,
- 29:42then you'll be my friend forever.
- 29:45Tom Ollerton: Jason, thank you so much for your time.
- 29:46Jason Hartley: Okay, thank you. I appreciate it.
- 29:54Tom Ollerton: Hi, just before you go, I'd really appreciate it
- 29:58if you could take the time. To write a review of the shiny new
- 30:02object podcast on Apple podcasts or iTunes, whatever it's called
- 30:05these days, or whichever podcast provider you use, we're an in
- 30:10your podcast. So it would go a long way for us if you could
- 30:13just share the Word and give us a bit of a support on those
- 30:15channels. That'd just be fantastic. If you haven't got
- 30:18time. That's also cool. And yeah, if you could tell your
- 30:20colleagues about the podcast, and also, if possible, don't
- 30:24forget to subscribe. And I'd love to hear your feedback. If
- 30:27you'd like to speak on the podcast or be a guest, or you
- 30:30think I'm asking the wrong questions, anything. I'd be
- 30:33super interested to hear what you think. So please email me.
- 30:36Tom at, automated creative.net, that's Tom at I'm not gonna
- 30:43bother spelling it anyway. You'll work it out. Thanks so
- 30:45much.