Latest / SHSMD Podcast Rapid Insights for Health Care Marketers, Planners, and Communicators / Essentials of Measuring Marketing Campaign Effectiveness and ROI in Health Care
Transcript
- 0:00Intro: The following SHSMD Podcast is a production of DoctorPodcasting.com.
- 0:05Bill Klaproth (Host): On this edition of the SHSMD podcast, we're talking about
- 0:08how healthcare marketing teams can better measure campaign effectiveness and ROI.
- 0:13Isn't it something we all want?
- 0:15Yes, it is.
- 0:16So, you know what we're going to be talking about?
- 0:17That's right, we're going to be talking dashboards, data transformation,
- 0:21data modeling, and how to set up your campaigns for success with Jason
- 0:25Miller, Executive Director of marketing insights and analytics; and Apoorva
- 0:31Gupta, Senior Digital Marketing Analyst, both from Johns Hopkins Medicine.
- 0:35It's all coming up on this SHSMD Connections Preview—that's right—rght now.
- 0:43This is the SHSMD Podcast, Rapid Insights for Healthcare Strategy Professionals and
- 0:48Planning, Business Development, Marketing Communications, and Public Relations.
- 0:54I'm your host, Bill Klaproth.
- 0:56Jason and Apoorva, welcome.
- 0:58Jason Miller: Thank you, Bill.
- 0:59Thank you so much for having us.
- 1:01Apoorva Gupta: Thank you, Bill.
- 1:02Host: Yeah, great to talk with both of you.
- 1:04I know this is going to be a great session at SHSMD Connections
- 1:07coming up in Baltimore.
- 1:09Jason, let me start with you.
- 1:11So, your workshop is called Essentials of Measuring Marketing Campaign
- 1:15Effectiveness and ROI in Healthcare.
- 1:18So, question for you, why is it so important right now for healthcare
- 1:23marketing teams to move beyond basic activity metrics and start
- 1:28measuring outcomes like patient acquisitions, appointments, and revenue?
- 1:34Jason Miller: That's a great question, Bill.
- 1:36And I think at this time, the evolution of marketing and
- 1:40measurement has continued to evolve.
- 1:42And many times marketers and the marketing team members and staff involved have
- 1:47measured those standard metrics for many years and they've had access to them.
- 1:51But as it continues to evolve in healthcare, both leaders of the
- 1:55healthcare organizations want to move beyond those standard metrics and
- 1:59really understand the ROI of their investments in any marketing initiatives,
- 2:04and the bottom line impact that they have to the healthcare organization.
- 2:08And as data becomes more readily available and the tools continue to
- 2:13advance, especially in this era of AI, I think most leaders will absolutely
- 2:18want to measure and have impact noted on any marketing initiatives that they
- 2:22have set off within their organization.
- 2:25Host: Absolutely.
- 2:25As you said at the beginning, people want to know where the money
- 2:29is going and how is it working.
- 2:31Is it working or isn't it working?
- 2:32So, I think that's really important.
- 2:35And good point about AI.
- 2:36With AI, it should give us more tools that we should be able to measure these things.
- 2:41Would that be right, Jason?
- 2:43Jason Miller: Yeah.
- 2:43Absolutely.
- 2:43AI continues to evolve.
- 2:45And it can aid us in developing and connecting data sets that maybe
- 2:50we previously had not had the time or programming time to connect.
- 2:55So, it gives us ways to use those algorithms, just as many AI prompts
- 3:00have today to give you answers quickly.
- 3:03That is the hope that that continues to evolve and applies
- 3:07in the marketing space as well.
- 3:09Host: Yeah.
- 3:09And Apoorva, a lot of campaign measurement starts long before the
- 3:15reporting dashboard, like making sure you get it set up properly.
- 3:19So, what are some of the most important campaign setup steps across platforms
- 3:24and tools that teams need to get right so they can measure performance accurately?
- 3:30Apoorva Gupta: Sure, Bill.
- 3:30So if you want to pull this off, there are really, I feel, five
- 3:34things you have to lock down before you spend a single ad dollar.
- 3:39First thing to start with would be get your campaign naming on lock.
- 3:44So, standardize all your UTM parameters in search, social, and
- 3:49every single click traces back to exact clinical service line.
- 3:53Second here would be to capture offline site, like use dynamic call
- 3:58tracking and even hidden form fields.
- 4:01So, phone calls and web forms keep their digital attribution in place.
- 4:06And then, third would be—this one is huge to protect patient privacy—so,
- 4:11making sure that you're not tracking any PHI, PII, hashing out and
- 4:17tokenizing all your first-party identifiers like phone numbers,
- 4:21emails before they touch databases.
- 4:24And then, fourth would be to map our ads that directly link
- 4:28to these clinical care lines.
- 4:31And then, we would want to track real patient care pathways,
- 4:34not just generic web traffic.
- 4:37And then, finally, testing and plumbing and making sure that all these pipelines,
- 4:43which is test call, form fills before we launch, making sure that the data
- 4:48actually flows into click to staging and ready for EHR matching, which
- 4:53we do using our Epic data platforms.
- 4:56Host: Okay.
- 4:57So, that's a great list, Apoorva.
- 4:58So, standardized, you said, UTMs across search and social,
- 5:02so everything is standard.
- 5:04Make sure you're capturing all of that offline activity.
- 5:08Three, always protecting patient privacy.
- 5:11That is so important.
- 5:13Four, make sure you're mapping the ads that are directly linked
- 5:16to that clinical care line.
- 5:18And then, as you said, testing the pipeline to make sure that
- 5:21all the data flows very properly.
- 5:24That's a great list, Apoorva.
- 5:25So, thank you for that.
- 5:27So Jason, one of the big challenges in healthcare is connecting leads
- 5:31or prospects to systems like Epic in a HIPAA-compliant way.
- 5:35We're just talking about patient privacy.
- 5:38What should marketing leaders understand about that process, and
- 5:41where do organizations often get stuck?
- 5:45Jason Miller: I think this ties right into what Apoorva stated previously,
- 5:49is it all starts in the beginning.
- 5:51And the key aspect is getting the naming conventions of your campaigns and your
- 5:56UTMs set up correctly so that you can track it along that patient's journey as
- 6:02they may travel from different systems and tracking mechanisms from your website
- 6:06to web form, all the way to when they schedule an appointment at your healthcare
- 6:11organization and receive services.
- 6:14So, I think that's the key starting point, and you definitely want to track many
- 6:19sort of demographic and attributes about a patient or consumer that is possible that
- 6:24falls within HIPAA and privacy guidelines.
- 6:27And again, that's why that naming convention and attribution is so important
- 6:31per campaign so that you can then use those lists and attributes to match to
- 6:36your EMR and determine if a match occurs.
- 6:40You know, for example, you have a campaign that's cardiology related.
- 6:43You target specific patients and geographies.
- 6:46Those patients then fill out a web form.
- 6:48Once they complete the web form, you'd have those patient demographics
- 6:51information that you would then want to utilize to match to your EMR
- 6:55and see if some of those patients actually came in for services related
- 6:58to cardiology at your organization.
- 7:01And I think often organizations do get hung up in just starting and,
- 7:05again, that attribution and naming.
- 7:07And if you don't do that correctly upfront, you often have challenges
- 7:11attributing those patients back to a specific campaign.
- 7:16And then, is it a new or return patient?
- 7:19Often patients within health systems come back for many services.
- 7:22So, how do you attribute it just to that specific service or campaign?
- 7:26So, that's another area where a lot of organizations maybe get hung
- 7:30up or challenged when you talk to different service line leaders.
- 7:34That patient was already with the organization.
- 7:36But often, again, they're targeted for a different service.
- 7:39Host: So, I know you're going to go in depth on all these
- 7:42things, right, in your session.
- 7:43So, we're just kind of touching the surface here.
- 7:46But these are really important things you're talking about, and I know you're
- 7:49going to discuss them more in length.
- 7:51So if you're like, "Man, I'm liking what Jason and Apoorva are saying," make sure
- 7:56you go to the session, because they're really going to get down deep into the
- 7:59weeds on all this stuff to help you out.
- 8:02And I know, Apoorva, your session also focuses on data transformation
- 8:06and data modeling, other things you're going to talk about.
- 8:09So for non-analytics leaders listening, what does that mean in practical
- 8:14terms, and why does it matter for measuring campaign effectiveness?
- 8:20Apoorva Gupta: So, both are very important ingredients in the recipe
- 8:23that we are trying to cook over here.
- 8:25In simple analogy, I would say data transformation is
- 8:29like prepping ingredients.
- 8:31So, raw data comes from all over the place, different ad platform,
- 8:35phone systems, clinical databases.
- 8:38And it's usually very messy and less formatted and
- 8:42full of different languages.
- 8:44So, data transformation, I would say, is basically like washing,
- 8:47chopping, and prepping your raw ingredients before you start cooking.
- 8:52So, you're basically standardizing these phone numbers, cleaning up
- 8:55campaign names, hashing any sensitive information into a clean as well as
- 9:00a very uniform format so that you can actually be ready to cook with it.
- 9:06And then, on the same time, I would say data modeling in simple analogy
- 9:11would be architecting this blueprint.
- 9:14How is it going to look like?
- 9:15So once your ingredients are prepped, you need a blueprint to build this meal.
- 9:21So, data modeling is like designing how all these separate pieces of
- 9:25clean data talk to each other.
- 9:28It's creating that structure, those rules.
- 9:31For example, like this ad click connects to this particular phone call or this
- 9:35form fill connects to this particular person who might have filled it, which
- 9:40links to this patient encounter and which connects to this net margin
- 9:45that we are trying to calculate here.
- 9:47So, it turns scattered prep data into a very clear map of customer
- 9:52journey and patient journey.
- 9:55Host: Yeah, I love that analogy.
- 9:57Data transformation is like prepping ingredients.
- 10:00Apoorva Gupta: Yep.
- 10:01Yeah.
- 10:02Jason Miller: If anyone that's worked with healthcare data, they
- 10:04understand some of the challenges.
- 10:05And healthcare organizations are very complicated, and often it's the
- 10:09processes that create challenges with the underlying data from the systems.
- 10:13And that's why it requires a lot of transformation often to what
- 10:18we maybe cleanse and have it ready to actually build models off of to
- 10:24either measure or predict services.
- 10:26It's just often challenging and I think that some folks don't understand
- 10:30just how much effort and time has to go into some of those processes.
- 10:34And then, once you've started to build processes and cleanse,
- 10:37you can scale them more broadly.
- 10:39And I think that's a key aspect of something we want to highlight is
- 10:42creating scalable processes that are not only just for one service line.
- 10:47It could be for N number of service lines.
- 10:50However, you build your data models out for measurement of your campaigns, you
- 10:55want to allow them to scale so that you can scale across your entire organization.
- 11:00Host: Well, it seems like that's such a necessary step, the data
- 11:02transformation, is getting all that data into the forms and the way you
- 11:06want it, like Apporva was talking about.
- 11:09Because if you don't get that step right, it's kind of garbage in, garbage out then.
- 11:12Is that right?
- 11:13Jason Miller: Absolutely.
- 11:14That's definitely correct.
- 11:15And that's part of why the focus is to almost map out all of your data sources
- 11:21for whatever campaign you're measuring, whatever platforms you have within your
- 11:25organization, and then to understand how can you set up the proper tracking
- 11:31and attribution in each one of those systems along that patient journey.
- 11:35And then, you can understand how you're going to get access to some of those
- 11:39systems to pull that data, extract it out, and what mechanisms will you need
- 11:43to perform to cleanse it, transform it, so that you have the ability to
- 11:47connect those disparate sources together.
- 11:51Host: Right.
- 11:51So once you cleanse it, you prep the ingredients, then you connect
- 11:54it into basically the data modeling.
- 11:57So, those two go hand in hand, would that be right?
- 11:59Apoorva Gupta: Yep.
- 12:00Just to summarize, I would say that if data transformation is taking
- 12:03raw, messy data from these different sources and translating it into clean
- 12:09language, data modeling, on the other hand, is taking those clean pieces
- 12:13and building the blueprint so they all fit together into this reliable
- 12:18ROI story that we try to present.
- 12:21Host: So now, you've got the clean data, then time for the
- 12:25data modeling, and that's where you ultimately get the results.
- 12:29Apoorva Gupta: Yep, absolutely.
- 12:30Host: So, could we say if we're prepping the ingredients, then
- 12:33we're cooking in data modeling?
- 12:34And then, when it's all finished, we have all the information and the data
- 12:38to help us make more informed decisions?
- 12:40Apoorva Gupta: Absolutely.
- 12:41Yeah.
- 12:42Jason Miller: Correct.
- 12:42Host: You must be a good cook, Apoorva.
- 12:44I mean, I like how you did chopping, the cutting, the washing.
- 12:47You guys, it was great.
- 12:48You got it all in there.
- 12:50Apoorva Gupta: Yeah.
- 12:50I mean, I love cooking.
- 12:53Host: Well, you put it in a way that was easy to understand, so I love that.
- 12:56So Jason, let's talk dashboards a little bit more.
- 13:00They can either clarify performance or overwhelm people.
- 13:03And you know this, and it's sometimes it's like, "Oh my God,
- 13:06okay, I love this dashboard.
- 13:08What do I do with it?"
- 13:09So, how do you decide which metrics belong on a marketing ROI dashboard?
- 13:14And this is the big one to me, how do you make those reports actionable for leaders?
- 13:19How can we actually make the informed right decisions from the data?
- 13:24Jason Miller: This again is a challenge.
- 13:25There's so much data that we're working with.
- 13:28And when you build dashboards, it's easy to start putting different metrics
- 13:32out there, different visualizations.
- 13:34And I think it all comes back to what are the questions you're trying to answer?
- 13:38So, framing it from that perspective and putting yourself sort of in the end user
- 13:43or whoever is going to be the recipient of those dashboards in the audience.
- 13:46Is that, you know, a senior leader?
- 13:48Is it a marketing manager, et cetera?
- 13:50You need to make sure the metrics that you put on there help them answer the
- 13:54questions that they're trying to answer, and that it's framed in a way that's
- 13:58easy for them to digest and understand.
- 14:00And again, it varies depending on the audience from a marketing standpoint.
- 14:04And often we always stay rooted in the funnel of understanding of each
- 14:09stage as a patient or consumer moves through that funnel, from the awareness
- 14:14stage to consideration to actually converting and becoming a patient.
- 14:18And we want to have metrics that yield results at each one
- 14:21of those stages of the funnel.
- 14:23The most important is coming all the way down to the bottom of the
- 14:26funnel and understanding did that patient convert, because that helps
- 14:30you better understand the bottom line performance of your campaign, any
- 14:33investment you've made in an ad spend.
- 14:35But you can again measure it at each stage and look at different metrics and
- 14:39depending who's involved in the workflow and the process, maybe the marketers want
- 14:43to just see, are we generating more leads?
- 14:46But maybe the service line leaders want to know, are we seeing new patients?
- 14:49Are they coming in for the service?
- 14:50Because that's helping keep our physicians busy and helping with
- 14:53the bottom line impact to some of the revenue targets we've set.
- 14:57Host: Yeah.
- 14:57So, there can be multiple questions that you're trying to answer
- 15:01along that funnel, if you will.
- 15:04So, I think that's so important.
- 15:05Isn't it a great moment, Jason and Apoorva, when you discover something, when
- 15:10that dashboard comes back and it either confirms something that you're like,
- 15:14"Aha, I knew it," or it gives you insight like, "Well, maybe I was wrong on that"?
- 15:18I mean, that's a great feeling, right?
- 15:20When you do all the data transformation, the data modeling, you get it out
- 15:24there and you get the answers back.
- 15:25That's a great moment, isn't it, Jason?
- 15:27Jason Miller: Oh, absolutely.
- 15:28And when you're able to tell a story from the data that's very compelling,
- 15:33it's very rewarding to know that all that work, and although it may look like
- 15:38very little on the surface, there's a lot behind the scenes that goes into gathering
- 15:42data, cleansing it, and getting the output to answer the various questions.
- 15:47But it is definitely rewarding to see difference to that depending
- 15:50on the audience, whoever you're producing data and metrics for, they
- 15:54can yield value out of what you've produced and continue to use it.
- 15:58That's another key fact that they continue to use it to evolve and keep
- 16:03informed decision-making and take action with what's being presented to them.
- 16:07Host: And then, refine it even more, right?
- 16:10Apoorva, then you're going to go back in.
- 16:11What'd you see what we learned?
- 16:12Okay, let's refine this a little bit more now, right?
- 16:15Apoorva Gupta: Yeah, definitely.
- 16:16I feel like honestly it feels game-changing.
- 16:19For a long time, even here, we were not able to do that.
- 16:23But for marketing and healthcare, it has been seen as cost center and
- 16:28you spend budget, hope it drives patient volume, and you have to prove
- 16:33to your senior leaders that what marketing is doing is actually working.
- 16:37So, with numbers, it becomes like finishing a report like
- 16:42this changes entire conversation.
- 16:44And especially for our marketing team members walking into a room with finance
- 16:49and executive leadership and showing that the ROI we've earned after spending XYZ
- 16:55amount, that transforms marketing into a clear growth driver for health system.
- 17:01And there's no like, "Okay, why are we doing it?
- 17:05Can you prove it is working or not?
- 17:07All those questions get answered by looking at those numbers instantly.
- 17:12Host: Yeah, I like how you said it can change entire conversations.
- 17:15Apoorva Gupta: Yep.
- 17:16Host: Right?
- 17:16Once that data comes back and be like, "Oh man, we were talking about this.
- 17:20We should be talking about this."
- 17:22So, what a great point that is.
- 17:24Well, I want to thank you both for your time today.
- 17:25This has been awesome.
- 17:26One more question I'm going to ask each of you the same question.
- 17:29I would like to get each of your individual insights on this.
- 17:33Jason, let me start with you.
- 17:34So when it comes to proving marketing's impact on business growth, very
- 17:40important, what is the most important thing healthcare marketers need to know?
- 17:45Jason Miller: This is really multifaceted, Bill.
- 17:47It's not just one sort of metric, and I think—
- 17:51Host: Cliff notes.
- 17:51Give me the cliff notes.
- 17:51Jason Miller: Yeah, I think to summarize it, it comes back to what
- 17:54we've discussed is you've really got to do your due diligence upfront
- 17:58with understanding your market.
- 18:00Do a market analysis with whatever data sources you have to understand
- 18:04which market you're targeting.
- 18:05Then, you want to set up your campaigns and have all the right naming conventions
- 18:09set up correctly so you can track and attribute to measure along the funnel.
- 18:13And then, have really strong ROI reporting so that you can justify the marketing
- 18:19spend that you may be putting forward for any specific campaign and understand
- 18:24that impact, the bottom line impact.
- 18:26As marketers and healthcare continues to evolve, I think the latest metric
- 18:30is lifetime value, and I think that's going to continue and something we
- 18:33aspire to have a very strong figure on to understand for every patient we bring
- 18:39in for certain service, it generates dividends in various specialties and
- 18:44areas to the entire organization.
- 18:45And we really want to get and measure that.
- 18:47And I think that is sort of the holy grail, so that you
- 18:50understand for every new patient.
- 18:52And other industries do this really well as, for certain products, they know
- 18:56they're going to display and that's how they display ads and other products that
- 18:59recommend because they know other shoppers that are purchasing similar products.
- 19:03And I think healthcare, we haven't got there yet.
- 19:05But I think as data and everything continues to evolve, we will be able to
- 19:09measure and have that similar approach.
- 19:12Host: Well, knowing that metric, that lifetime customer value
- 19:15really, really important.
- 19:16So, good point, Jason, on that.
- 19:18Apoorva, how about you?
- 19:19What is most important for healthcare marketers?
- 19:21What do they need to know now?
- 19:23Apoorva Gupta: I just feel first it moves you from cost
- 19:26center to a true revenue driver.
- 19:28They definitely need to know that.
- 19:30So, you are no longer like depending on ad budget.
- 19:33You are showing leadership exactly your financial returns with this.
- 19:38And then, secondly, I feel like it takes away the guesswork.
- 19:43So, there's like no more awkward meetings where people are asking, "Okay, but did
- 19:47those clicks turn into real patients?"
- 19:50So, like Jason mentioned, the math is right there on the screen.
- 19:54And honestly, it's just pure relief connecting marketing,
- 19:57finance, IT into one pipeline.
- 20:00It's a puzzle that stops most teams in their tracks.
- 20:04So, crossing that finish line with just solid data behind
- 20:08you is a huge victory for us.
- 20:11Host: Yeah, very well said.
- 20:12Well, this is going to be a great session at SHSMD Connections.
- 20:16Jason and Apoorva, thank you so much for your time today.
- 20:19Apoorva Gupta: Thank you, Bill.
- 20:20Jason Miller: Thank you so much, Bill.
- 20:21We really appreciate the opportunity, and we're looking
- 20:23forward to presenting at SHSMD.
- 20:25Host: Absolutely.
- 20:26It's going to be a good one.
- 20:27So, thank you again.
- 20:28Once again, that's Jason Miller and Apoorva Gupta.
- 20:31And if you want to see their session at SHSMD Connections, make sure you register
- 20:36at shshmd.org/education/annualconference.
- 20:41And if you found this podcast helpful, please share it on your social channels,
- 20:44and please hit the subscribe or follow button to get every episode.
- 20:48And to access our full podcast library for topics of interest
- 20:51to you, visit shsmd.org/podcasts.
- 20:55This has been a production of DoctorPodcasting.
- 20:59I'm Bill Klaproth.
- 21:00See ya!