Latest / Secrets of the Centuries / The Borgia Family | The Rise and Fall of a Renaissance Dynasty
Transcript
- 0:00You know, if someone were to hand you a sealed
- 0:02letter today and you saw the name Borgia pressed
- 0:05into the red wax, I mean, it would still feel
- 0:09a little bit like a 500 -year -old mafia warning.
- 0:11Oh, absolutely. It carries this immediate heavy
- 0:14weight to it. Right. Because it's one of those
- 0:17incredibly rare historical names that has just
- 0:19completely morphed into this total shorthand
- 0:22for ruthless corruption. Like you hear Borgia
- 0:25and you instantly picture an undetectable poison
- 0:28dissolving in this golden goblet of wine, you
- 0:31know? Yeah, the classic poison chalice imagery.
- 0:34Exactly. Four smiles across a dimly lit banquet
- 0:37table and a quiet knife slipping between your
- 0:40ribs in some dark Roman alley. It's very cinematic.
- 0:42It is. But here is the wildest part of the whole
- 0:45Borgia legacy, and the reason we're doing this.
- 0:48Almost everything you just pictured is a meticulously
- 0:51crafted lie. It really is. It was written largely
- 0:55by the people they defeated. So for our mission
- 0:57today in this deep dive, we are taking the source
- 1:00material we have here, which is this incredibly
- 1:02detailed historical breakdown of the Renaissance
- 1:04dynasty, and we are going to completely strip
- 1:08away... 500 years of fake news. And it is a phenomenal
- 1:12piece of historical propaganda, to be honest.
- 1:15Very few families have managed to cast a shadow
- 1:17quite that long. Yeah, Five Centuries is a good
- 1:19run for a smear campaign. I mean, for five centuries,
- 1:22their name has served as this byword for the
- 1:25absolute worst excesses of power, ambition, and,
- 1:28well, depravity. But when you actually dig into
- 1:32the contemporary records, like the actual letters,
- 1:34the financial ledgers, the diplomatic dispatches,
- 1:37a completely different reality emerges. Okay,
- 1:40let's unpack this, because we're tracking their
- 1:43entire arc today, you know, from a family of
- 1:45these obscure Spanish lawyers, all the way to
- 1:49becoming the absolute masters of Rome, and then
- 1:51looking at the mechanics of their sudden catastrophic
- 1:53collapse. Right, because the truth underneath
- 1:56all those legends of poison rings and wicked
- 1:59women is vastly more fascinating than the cartoon
- 2:01villain myth. And to set our analytical frame
- 2:04right at the outset here, The Borgias did not
- 2:07invent the vices of Renaissance Italy. They really
- 2:10didn't. They just perfected them. Exactly. They
- 2:13simply practiced those vices with more talent,
- 2:16more openness, and vastly more success than anyone
- 2:19else around them. They were playing the exact
- 2:22same geopolitical game as the Orsini, the Colonna,
- 2:25the Sforza, the Medici. All the big names. Right.
- 2:28But the only difference is the Borgias were better
- 2:30at it. And they were outsiders. And that combination
- 2:34being highly competent foreigners is what made
- 2:37their success completely unforgivable to the
- 2:39Italian establishment. Which makes sense. So
- 2:42to understand how they became these towering
- 2:44monsters in the history books, you really have
- 2:47to look at the guy who opened the door for them
- 2:49in the first place. And honestly, it's kind of
- 2:51hilarious because the founder of the most terrifying
- 2:53family in European history is shockingly boring.
- 2:56So boring. Like there are no warlords here. The
- 2:59story starts in the kingdom of Aragon. in eastern
- 3:02Spain with this minor nobility family in a town
- 3:04called Borja, who later settled near Xativa over
- 3:07by Valencia. And when we say minor nobility,
- 3:10we mean like they had a decent coat of arms,
- 3:13but they didn't have massive wealth. Right. No
- 3:15standing armies or leverage on the world stage.
- 3:18Yeah, they were nobodies, geopolitically speaking.
- 3:20Exactly. And in Spain, their name was Borja,
- 3:23spelled with a J, which only softened into the
- 3:25famous Borgia with a G later on just to accommodate
- 3:28Italian tongues. But the man who alters their
- 3:31trajectory, Alonso de Borja, born in 1378, he
- 3:36is the absolute antithesis of the dazzling Renaissance
- 3:39prince. He is not a flashy courtier at all. Not
- 3:43even a little. He is a quiet, cautious, intensely
- 3:47hardworking lawyer. Hold on, I need to stop you
- 3:50right there. A lawyer. You're telling me the
- 3:52ultimate architect of this blood -soaked Italian
- 3:54dynasty is a guy whose primary skill is drafting
- 3:57contracts? Precisely. I mean, he studied canon
- 4:00law at the University in Lieta. In an age where
- 4:03ambitious men made their names through this dramatic
- 4:06chivalric violence, Alonso made his name through
- 4:09relentless, bureaucratic reliability. That is
- 4:12amazing. He literally paperworked his way to
- 4:14the top. Basically, yeah. And to understand how
- 4:17he rose, you really have to understand the absolute
- 4:21chaos of the Western Schism. For decades, the
- 4:24Catholic Church was essentially split in two
- 4:26and sometimes three. It was a mess. A total geopolitical
- 4:30nightmare. You had rival popes in Rome and Avignon,
- 4:34France, each excommunicating the other, dividing
- 4:37the kingdoms of Europe into these fiercely competing
- 4:40factions. Alonso used his staggering legal brilliance
- 4:44to negotiate settlements and navigate the incredibly
- 4:48dense canon law required to heal this rift for
- 4:51the kings of Aragon. So he's basically like a
- 4:53high level diplomatic fixer. Yes. Okay. He smoothed
- 4:56over conflicts that had completely baffled armies
- 4:59and kings for years. The Aragonese crown noticed,
- 5:02the church noticed, and step by step, this modest
- 5:06Spanish jurist was elevated. Because he was just
- 5:09that useful. Right. He became a bishop in Valencia,
- 5:12and then crucially, in 1444, he was made a cardinal
- 5:16and brought to Rome. But when he gets to Rome,
- 5:18he is a total fish out of water. Like, put yourself
- 5:20in his shoes for a second. He shows up with this
- 5:22heavy Spanish accent. Which the Romans openly
- 5:25marked, by the way. Oh, I'm sure. And he doesn't
- 5:28have an ancestral Roman palace fortified with
- 5:31stone towers. He doesn't have a network of armed
- 5:34cousins patrolling the streets. He's elderly.
- 5:37He eats simple meals. He keeps quiet hours. He's
- 5:39basically a monk. Yeah. In a city that practically
- 5:42ran on charm, backstabbing, and these incredibly
- 5:45loud displays of wealth, Alonso's just this seemingly
- 5:48harmless foreign guy reading legal briefs in
- 5:50the corner. which is the exact profile that makes
- 5:52him incredibly valuable during a constitutional
- 5:54crisis. Right. The interim CEO situation. Exactly.
- 5:58So in 1455, the reigning pope dies. The cardinals
- 6:02lock themselves in the conclave to elect a successor,
- 6:05and they hit a massive, immovable deadlock. The
- 6:08powerful Italian factions, like the great Roman
- 6:11families, are at a total stand -by. Right. Neither
- 6:14side will concede a single vote because, you
- 6:16know, allowing a rival family to control the
- 6:18papacy means losing lands, revenues, and potentially
- 6:21your life. I look at this and I see that classic
- 6:24corporate board fight. You know, two massive
- 6:26egos are fighting to the death for the top job.
- 6:29The whole company is completely frozen. So what
- 6:32do they do? They look around the room and say,
- 6:35well, who is the oldest, most fragile, most forgettable
- 6:38person here? Let's just put him in charge for
- 6:4018 months to keep the seat warm while we regroup.
- 6:43And they picked Alonso de Borja, because he was
- 6:46almost 77 years old. Which was ancient back then.
- 6:49Oh, absolutely. He had no Italian faction. They
- 6:52assumed he would do absolutely nothing. And so
- 6:55he takes the name Pope Calyxtus III. And the
- 6:59Italian cardinals just congratulated themselves
- 7:01on securing this safe, brief, forgettable papacy.
- 7:04And they were right that it would be brief. I
- 7:07mean, Calyxtus only reigned for three years.
- 7:09But they fundamentally misunderstood the power
- 7:11dynamic they just created. big time. By picking
- 7:14a weak transitional leader, they accidentally
- 7:17handed the keys to the treasury to a man who
- 7:19had zero loyalties to the Italian establishment.
- 7:22Exactly. The interim CEO realizes he has absolute
- 7:25authority, starts bringing in all his own people
- 7:28and changes the entire DNA of the company. But
- 7:31before we get to the hostile family takeover,
- 7:34Calixtus actually initiates a massive foreign
- 7:36policy agenda of his own. Which is pretty surprising
- 7:39for a 77 year old lawyer. Right. In 1453, just
- 7:43two years before his election, Constantinople
- 7:46fell to the Ottoman Empire. And for Europe, this
- 7:48wasn't just a military feat. It was an existential
- 7:51shock. The capital of the Eastern Roman Empire
- 7:53is gone. Exactly. So, Calixtus becomes singularly
- 7:58obsessed with launching a crusade to take it
- 8:00back. He essentially liquidates the Vatican's
- 8:03assets. He goes all in. He really does. He pours
- 8:06out the church's treasury. sells off silver and
- 8:09art, and uses his failing elderly energy to build
- 8:13fleets and try to rally the European kings. Now,
- 8:16the monarchs of France and England largely ignored
- 8:18him, right? Because they were tangled up in their
- 8:20own domestic conflicts. Mostly, yes. But Colixtus's
- 8:24relentless funding did secure one highly significant
- 8:27victory, and that was the defense of Belgrade
- 8:29in 1456. Oh, this is the part I love. It's a
- 8:32great detail. The papal -funded forces. held
- 8:35the Ottomans back from pushing deeper into central
- 8:37Europe. And to celebrate that victory, Calixtus
- 8:40ordered all churches to ring their bells at noon.
- 8:43Which is just incredible to think about. When
- 8:45you hear church bells ringing at noon today,
- 8:47anywhere in the world, you are listening to a
- 8:50direct echo of the first Borgia pope. It's a
- 8:53wildly enduring legacy for a guy who's only in
- 8:56power for three years. It really is. And there
- 8:59is another detail in his papacy that I find so
- 9:01fascinating, especially given the family's later
- 9:03reputation for... Absolute darkness and corruption.
- 9:07Calixtus III is the pope who ordered the review
- 9:09of the trial of Joan of Arc. Yes. A generation
- 9:13earlier, the young French visionary had been
- 9:15burned at the stake as a heretic by English -aligned
- 9:17clerics. Calixtus authorized an appellate process.
- 9:21A very lawyerly move. Exactly. He approached
- 9:23it like a jurist. Her case was reopened, the
- 9:27original proceedings were found to be corrupt
- 9:28and politically motivated, the verdict was overturned,
- 9:32and her name was cleared. So the founder of this
- 9:35notoriously evil dynasty is the very man who
- 9:38restored the honor of one of history's most famous
- 9:41saints. It's a massive contrast. But, you know,
- 9:44Clixtus was a realist. He was in his late 70s,
- 9:47dealing with failing health, and he understood
- 9:50a cold mechanical truth about Renaissance Rome.
- 9:53Right. The nepotism problem. Or rather, the necessity
- 9:56of nepotism. Exactly. If a pope didn't legally
- 10:00entrench his relatives with land and titles while
- 10:02he was still breathing, his family would be violently
- 10:05stripped of everything the second his heart stopped.
- 10:07The Roman baronial families would sweep in and
- 10:10take it all back. They absolutely would. So to
- 10:12prevent this, he engages in a practice that literally
- 10:15gave us a modern English word. He brought his
- 10:18Spanish kin to Rome in large numbers, planting
- 10:21them in key military and administrative posts.
- 10:24stuffing the org chart with his family. Exactly.
- 10:27Most notably, he made two of his nephews cardinals.
- 10:31And this systemic practice of favoring your relatives,
- 10:33which was euphemistically called nephews in the
- 10:36church hierarchy, regardless of whether they
- 10:39were actual nephews or illegitimate sons, gave
- 10:42us the word nepotism. From the Italian word for
- 10:46nephew, nipote. Exactly. Nepotism, literally
- 10:49nephew -ism. And one of those nephews brought
- 10:52over from Spain was a young man named Rodrigo
- 10:54Borgia, born in 1431. And Rodrigo was, uh, he
- 10:59was everything his elderly uncle was not. Oh,
- 11:01completely. He was incredibly young, physically
- 11:04imposing, charming, radiating health. And his
- 11:08ambition was just boundless. Calixtus makes Rodrigo
- 11:11a cardinal when the kid is just 25 years old.
- 11:14Which is staggering. And he didn't stop at giving
- 11:17him a red hat. A year later, Calyxtus handed
- 11:20this 26 -year -old the single most powerful administrative
- 11:23office in the entire Catholic Church. The post
- 11:26of vice chancellor. The vice chancellorship,
- 11:28yes. We really need to explain the mechanics
- 11:31of the vice chancellor role because it sounds
- 11:33like a boring desk job, like, oh, you're the
- 11:35vice chancellor, you stamp papers. But it is
- 11:37actually the engine of the entire papal economy.
- 11:40It's the central nervous system of the church's
- 11:42wealth. The apostolic chancery was the bureaucratic
- 11:46heart. Every official papal document had to pass
- 11:49through this office. So, like, if a French duke
- 11:52wanted to marry his second cousin, he needed
- 11:54a papal dispensation. Right. Or if a wealthy
- 11:56merchant wanted to purchase an indulgence, or
- 11:59a priest wanted to be elevated to a bishopric,
- 12:02they needed official papal bulls. Rodrigo's office
- 12:05drafted, sealed, and dispatched every single
- 12:08one of these documents. And nothing is free.
- 12:12Absolutely nothing. For every single transaction,
- 12:14the chancery collected a fee. And a percentage
- 12:16of those massive fees went directly to the Vice
- 12:19Chancellor personally. Wow. Multiply that by
- 12:23every diocese, every royal court, and every wealthy
- 12:26abbey in Europe, and you begin to comprehend
- 12:28the revenue stream. He was operating a highly
- 12:31lucrative toll booth on the road to European
- 12:33salvation. He practically handed a 26 -year -old
- 12:36the keys to the printing press. It was an unimaginable
- 12:39fortune. But then, just three years into his
- 12:43papacy, old Callixtus dies. And the moment the
- 12:46news hits the streets, the Romans do exactly
- 12:48what Calixtus feared. They riot. Violently. They
- 12:52despise the Spanish. They hate that these foreigners
- 12:54have siphoned off so much wealth in just three
- 12:56years. So mobs attack cattle on properties, Spanish
- 13:00clerics are beaten in the streets, and most of
- 13:02the Borgia faction just flees Rome in sheer terror.
- 13:06The Borgia experiment is supposed to be over
- 13:08right there. But Rodrigo stays. Which makes no
- 13:11sense. I mean, why wouldn't he run? The mob is
- 13:14literally outside. Because he fundamentally understood
- 13:17the architecture of power in Rome far better
- 13:19than the mobs in the street did. He didn't panic.
- 13:21No. He was ice cold. He was young. He was vastly
- 13:26wealthy. And he held a constitutional office,
- 13:29the vice -chancellorship, that no incoming pope
- 13:31could easily strip away from him without causing
- 13:33a total bureaucratic crisis. He made himself
- 13:37too big to fail. Exactly. Rodrigo realized that
- 13:40permanent power wasn't won in a single dramatic
- 13:43conclave, or by writing the coattails of one
- 13:46uncle. It had to be built meticulously, over
- 13:49decades. Through extreme patience. Patience,
- 13:52the strategic lending of money, and through a
- 13:56vast invisible network of favors given and owed.
- 14:00Calyxtus opened the door by pure luck, but Rodrigo
- 14:03intended to construct an impenetrable fortress
- 14:05inside that door. It is the ultimate deep state
- 14:08bureaucrat maneuver. He makes himself the only
- 14:11guy in the building who knows how the servers
- 14:12work, so no matter who becomes the new CEO, they
- 14:15can't fire him. That's a perfect analogy. And
- 14:18to understand how he survives, we really have
- 14:21to look at the reality of the Renaissance Church,
- 14:23because if you are picturing, you know, a purely
- 14:25spiritual, prayer -focused institution, you are
- 14:28missing the mechanics of 15th century Italy completely.
- 14:31The Papacy in the 1400s was a territorial sovereign
- 14:35state. It was a country. Right. It commanded
- 14:37armies, levied taxes, and controlled territory
- 14:40stretching across central Italy. The College
- 14:43of Cardinals functioned less like a group of
- 14:45humble priests and much more like a Senate of
- 14:48secular princes. They were politicians. They
- 14:51held multiple bishoprics simultaneously, collecting
- 14:54massive revenues from dioceses they never even
- 14:56set foot in. They maintained private armies,
- 14:59kept mistresses, fathered children, and openly
- 15:02competed for geopolitical influence. They were
- 15:04cutthroat politicians wearing red silk. And Rodrigo
- 15:08Borgia sits right at the very center of this
- 15:10political machine for 35 years as vice chancellor.
- 15:1335 years. It's an incredible tenure. Four different
- 15:17popes come and go. Pius II, Paul II, Sixtus IV,
- 15:22Innocent VIII. And these men had wildly conflicting
- 15:25personalities and political agendas. Yet Rodrigo
- 15:28survives all of them by being endlessly adaptable.
- 15:31He was a complete chameleon. How did he manage
- 15:34that? Well, if a pope was a militaristic expansionist,
- 15:38Rodrigo funded his wars and organized his logistics.
- 15:41If a pope was a refined humanist scholar, Rodrigo
- 15:45patronized the arts and engaged in intellectual
- 15:47flattery. He never tied his political fortunes
- 15:50so tightly to one pontiff that he would fall
- 15:52out of favor when that pope inevitably died.
- 15:55There is an amazing dispatch from early in his
- 15:57career under Pope Pius II that I think highlights
- 16:01this perfectly. Oh, the Siena party incident.
- 16:03Yes. So Pius was a brilliant, highly cultivated
- 16:07scholar, and he catches wind that his young vice
- 16:10chancellor, Rodrigo, has attended a private party
- 16:12in Siena. A highly scandalous party. Very scandalous.
- 16:17There's dancing, women, the doors are locked
- 16:20and the husbands are explicitly barred from entering.
- 16:23Pius II was furious. He wrote Rodrigo a blistering
- 16:27formal letter of rebuke stating, unequivocally,
- 16:30that Rodrigo was shaming his sacred office and
- 16:33bringing the church into disrepute. It was the
- 16:35kind of letter that could end a career. Absolutely.
- 16:38But wait, look at how Rodrigo responds. He doesn't
- 16:41get defensive. He doesn't throw a tantrum or
- 16:43threaten to withhold chancery funds. He writes
- 16:46back with this incredibly smooth deferential
- 16:49apology. Just total submission on paper. Right.
- 16:51He says, I am deeply regretful. I was naive.
- 16:54I have seen the error of my ways. And I promise
- 16:56you, your holiness, it will never happen again.
- 16:58And then he just goes right back to doing exactly
- 17:01what he was doing. Yes. He changes absolutely
- 17:04nothing about his personal lifestyle. He understood
- 17:06that if you just give authority figures the precise
- 17:09words they need to satisfy their ego, you get
- 17:12to keep the power. This raises an important question
- 17:14about his core character, though. What made Rodrigo
- 17:17uniquely dangerous wasn't his vice. I mean, having
- 17:20mistresses was incredibly common among the Roman
- 17:23elite. What made him dangerous was his extraordinary
- 17:26discipline. He never lost his head. Never. Behind
- 17:29the lavish banquets and the legendary charm was
- 17:32a relentless calculating mind. While everyone
- 17:35else was partying, he was quietly lending massive
- 17:38sums of money to other cardinals. smoothing over
- 17:41violent disputes between Roman families and performing
- 17:44critical favors that he explicitly intended to
- 17:46call in during a future conclave. He was weaving
- 17:49a web? He was weaving a massive web. And part
- 17:52of weaving that web meant building a literal
- 17:54bloodline, because as a cardinal he is obviously
- 17:57forbidden by canon law to marry. Technically,
- 18:00yes. But starting in the 1470s, he begins a long
- 18:03-term relationship with a woman who becomes the
- 18:05cornerstone of the Borgia dynasty, Venuzza de
- 18:08Catenae. and together they have four key children
- 18:11who survive into adulthood, Cesare, Juan, Lucrezia,
- 18:15and Joffrey. And here we see Rodrigo's unique
- 18:18approach to his hidden family. While it was standard
- 18:22practice for cardinals to father children, they
- 18:24were usually kept completely in the shadows,
- 18:27referred to in documents as nieces or nephews.
- 18:30Right, that polite fiction again. Exactly. Rodrigo,
- 18:33however, took a different path. To maintain the
- 18:36polite legal fictions of the era, he arranged
- 18:38a series of respectable, compliant husbands for
- 18:40Venutza, ensuring she had a legitimate household.
- 18:44But he didn't really hide his children from the
- 18:46papal court. Not at all. He doted on them openly.
- 18:50He micromanaged their classical educations and
- 18:52secured them titles from a very young age. But
- 18:55the source material makes it clear this wasn't
- 18:57just a father's affection. He viewed these kids
- 19:00as vital instruments. They were the chess pieces
- 19:03for his grand strategy. If we connect this to
- 19:05the bigger picture, it reveals the central tragic
- 19:08driving force of Rodrigo Borja's life. His genuine,
- 19:12profound love for his children, and all historical
- 19:15accounts suggest he was a deeply affectionate
- 19:17father, and his towering political ambition were
- 19:21so tightly braided together that even he couldn't
- 19:24separate them. You couldn't tell where the ambition
- 19:26ended and the love began. Right. He wanted to
- 19:29elevate his children because he loved them. But
- 19:32he loved them precisely because they were the
- 19:33tools he would use to conquer Italy. So after
- 19:3635 years of waiting in the wings, of gathering
- 19:38Spanish silver, of grooming these children, the
- 19:41old pope, Innocent VIII, finally dies in the
- 19:43summer of 1492. A monumental year for history
- 19:46in general. Yeah. Columbus sails. And Rodrigo
- 19:50finally gets his shot. He is now nearly 60 years
- 19:53old, which is well past life expectancy for the
- 19:5615th century. His ultimate trap is finally ready
- 20:00to spring. Which brings us to the Conclave of
- 20:021492. And it is breathtaking in its mechanical
- 20:05cynicism. It really is. Like, just walk us through
- 20:09the reality of this conclave. Well, the 1492
- 20:13Conclave was quite literally a marketplace. The
- 20:16term conclave means a room locked with a key,
- 20:19cum clave, designed to isolate the cardinals
- 20:22from worldly influence so they can pray for divine
- 20:24guidance. That's the theory. In reality, it was
- 20:26a high stakes bazaar. Votes were openly traded
- 20:29for fortified castles, lucrative bishoprics,
- 20:31and massive sums of cash. Rodrigo walks into
- 20:34this locked room facing some massive heavyweights.
- 20:37He is up against Ascanius Forza, who is backed
- 20:40by the incredibly powerful military dynasty of
- 20:43Milan. A very dangerous rival. And he is facing
- 20:46Giuliano della Rovere, a cardinal who hates Rodrigo
- 20:49with a burning personal passion and has the treasury
- 20:53of the French king backing his bid. Delarovera
- 20:56is the ultimate nemesis in this story. He really
- 20:58is. So after several rounds of voting, the factions
- 21:01deadlock. Sforza and Delarovera completely cancel
- 21:05each other out. And Rodrigo looks around the
- 21:07room and realizes this is the exact mechanism
- 21:11that elevated my uncle. He sees the pattern repeating.
- 21:14This is the moment. And he had the deepest pockets
- 21:17and the most valuable assets to offer. We have
- 21:20to address the concept of simony here, the ecclesiastical
- 21:24crime of buying or selling church offices. Because
- 21:27following the election, Rodrigo's enemies furiously
- 21:29screamed that he had literally bought the papacy.
- 21:33Right. There were highly publicized rumors that
- 21:35four mule loads of silver were seen being transported
- 21:39from Rodrigo's palace over to Escanio's fort's
- 21:43palace in the dead of night. during the conclave.
- 21:45Wait, I have to ask about this. They are casually
- 21:49walking mules loaded with silver through the
- 21:52Vatican while they are supposedly locked in prayer?
- 21:54How is that even physically possible? Well, the
- 21:56logistics of a conclave were far more porous
- 21:58than the church liked to admit. Food, supplies,
- 22:02and communications constantly moved through the
- 22:04guarded doors via trusted servants. So a few
- 22:06mules slipped through. Exactly. But we have to
- 22:09view this historically, not morally. While Della
- 22:13Rivera used these accusations of simony to delegitimize
- 22:16the election forever, the truth is that vote
- 22:19-buying was standard operating procedure. Everyone
- 22:21was doing it. Almost every powerful man in that
- 22:23room was engaged in it. Rodrigo wasn't uniquely
- 22:26corrupt. He was simply richer, better prepared,
- 22:29and vastly more successful at it. To secure the
- 22:32final votes, he handed Descanio's Forza his own
- 22:35massive prize, the vice -chancellorship. Wow,
- 22:38he gave up his own golden goose. along with palaces
- 22:41and bishoprics. It was an undeniable offer. So
- 22:45on August 11, 1492, the doors open and Rodrigo
- 22:50Borgia emerges as Pope Alexander VI. He takes
- 22:54the name of a conqueror, Alexander, and the psychological
- 22:57shift in his behavior is immediate. As a cardinal,
- 23:00he was infinitely patient. He waited 35 years,
- 23:04but the second he becomes pope, the clock starts
- 23:06ticking. He flips a switch. He acts with this
- 23:09urgent terrifying ruthlessness to elevate his
- 23:12children before his own heart stops. Because
- 23:14he knows the rules of the game. A pope possesses
- 23:18absolute unquestioned power to enrich his family.
- 23:21But the instant he dies, everything that hasn't
- 23:24been permanently nailed down, like real castles,
- 23:28legally binding titles, consummated marriages
- 23:31into royal houses, all of it can be instantly
- 23:34revoked by the next pope. Alexander is racing
- 23:37against his own mortality. Precisely. The nepotism
- 23:40goes into absolute overdrive. He immediately
- 23:43makes his teenage son Cesare a cardinal. He grooms
- 23:46his favorite son, Juan, for military command.
- 23:49He starts prepping his 12 -year -old daughter,
- 23:51Lucrezia, for a major political marriage. He
- 23:54wastes no time. And he even takes a new teenage
- 23:57mistress, Giulia Farnese, and promptly makes
- 23:59her young brother a cardinal. The Romans mockingly
- 24:02called him the petticoat cardinal because everyone
- 24:04knew exactly the mechanism of his promotion.
- 24:07This rapid, aggressive consolidation of power
- 24:10sent absolute shockwaves through the Italian
- 24:12peninsula. The other ruling dynasts and especially
- 24:16the old Roman baronial families like the Orsini
- 24:18and the Colonna suddenly recognized the existential
- 24:21threat. Like, put yourself in the shoes of the
- 24:24Orsini family for a second. For generations,
- 24:27they have bullied weak popes. They treat the
- 24:29agricultural lands and fortresses around Rome
- 24:31as their personal property. It was their playground.
- 24:34Suddenly... They look at the throne of St. Peter,
- 24:37and it's not a frail celibate theologian sitting
- 24:40there. It's a highly capable, ridiculously wealthy
- 24:43father with a private army, a network of ambitious
- 24:47children, and a desperate need to carve out a
- 24:50permanent kingdom. The old families realize he
- 24:53isn't just going to tax us, he is going to violently
- 24:57seize our ancestral lands to give to his kids.
- 25:00It fundamentally altered the balance of power.
- 25:02Alexander VI wasn't just administering his spiritual
- 25:05institution. He was attempting to forge a permanent
- 25:08secular dynasty right in the geographical heart
- 25:11of Italy. But before we dive into the blood -soaked
- 25:14drama of what those kids actually did to secure
- 25:17that dynasty, we have to look at the stage they
- 25:19were playing on. We really have to examine the
- 25:22physical reality of Rome in the 1490s. Because
- 25:25it is nothing like people imagine. Right. If
- 25:28you are picturing the pristine white marble,
- 25:31the glorious fountains and clean ruins you see
- 25:33on a postcard today, you are completely wrong.
- 25:36Rome in the late 15th century was a study in
- 25:39profound startling contrasts. It was not a grand
- 25:43sprawling metropolis. It held roughly 50 ,000
- 25:47people just rattling around inside massive ancient
- 25:50walls. They were originally engineered by the
- 25:53emperors to hold over a million. It was basically
- 25:55a ghost town in parts. A semi -abandoned, overgrown
- 25:59landscape. The details on the city's infrastructure
- 26:02are staggering from the source material. The
- 26:05Coliseum, the greatest arena of the ancient world,
- 26:09was essentially functioning as a local quarry.
- 26:12Yes. When nobles wanted to build a new palace,
- 26:14they didn't mine fresh stone. They just sent
- 26:16workers to pry loose the ancient marble from
- 26:19the Coliseum. And the Roman Forum, the former
- 26:22epicenter of the global empire, was buried under
- 26:25feet of dirt and used as a grazing pasture. The
- 26:28locals literally called it the Campo Vecino,
- 26:30the cow field. And the living conditions for
- 26:32the average citizen were brutal. The streets
- 26:35were largely unpaved mud, pigs rooted in the
- 26:38alleys for garbage. The Tiber River served as
- 26:41the primary source of drinking water, but it
- 26:43also functioned as the city's open sewer. That
- 26:46is just a recipe for disaster. It was. In the
- 26:49sweltering heat of late summer, those swampy,
- 26:52stagnant conditions bred devastating mosquito
- 26:54-borne fevers, malaria, that swept through the
- 26:57population, indiscriminately killing both the
- 26:59impoverished and the elite. And yet, this muddy,
- 27:04half -ruined, malarial city is the spiritual
- 27:06capital of the Western world. In the year 1500,
- 27:10Alexander organized a massive jubilee. A huge
- 27:13undertaking. Tens of thousands of pilgrims poured
- 27:16in from all over Europe to secure plenary indulgences.
- 27:19The mechanics of this are vital. Rome literally
- 27:22survived on the faith and the hard currency of
- 27:25distant millions. Alexander, utilizing his brilliant
- 27:28administrative background, managed the logistics,
- 27:31the crowd control, and the massive influx of
- 27:33money flawlessly. And the Jubilee highlights
- 27:36the extreme wealth inequality of the era. The
- 27:39daily life of the elite was almost unimaginably
- 27:42lavish compared to the commoners. The cardinals
- 27:45and great families wore fabrics dyed with incredibly
- 27:48expensive crimson and lapis lazuli blue. Just
- 27:51wearing those colors was a flex. The colors themselves
- 27:54were mechanical flexes of immense wealth because
- 27:57the dyes had to be imported from across the world.
- 28:00But the food is where you really see the disparity.
- 28:03The rich are throwing these banquets where they
- 28:05serve roasted peacocks that have been meticulously
- 28:08sewn back into their own feathers by master chefs
- 28:10just for the visual spectacle. It's pure theater.
- 28:13They are commissioning elaborate life -size sculptures
- 28:17out of sugar, which was so rare it was essentially
- 28:19treated like edible gold. They are pouring imported
- 28:22cinnamon and ginger over everything to prove
- 28:24their purchasing power. Meanwhile, the poor are
- 28:28surviving on coarse dark bread, lentils, and
- 28:31drinking watered -down wine, because drinking
- 28:33straight from the Tiber might give you a lethal
- 28:35infection. And navigating the social space between
- 28:37these two worlds was a very unique class, the
- 28:40courtesans. Yes, and we need to be clear about
- 28:44who they were. These were not common street walkers.
- 28:47They were highly educated, cultured companions
- 28:49to the wealthy and powerful. In a city where
- 28:52the most powerful men, the cardinals and bishops,
- 28:55were officially forbidden by canon law to marry,
- 28:58these women held a prominent legally recognized
- 29:00and surprisingly comfortable social position.
- 29:04They conversed about poetry, art, and geopolitics
- 29:07with the men who ran the Vatican. Here's where
- 29:09it gets really interesting for me. Think about
- 29:11the surreal visual of this city. You have thousands
- 29:15of devout, starving pilgrims crawling on their
- 29:19knees in prayer seeking spiritual salvation.
- 29:22And right next to them, you have goats climbing
- 29:25over fallen Roman temples. It's a wild juxtaposition.
- 29:28You have cardinals draped in scarlet silk walking
- 29:31past pigs rooting in the mud. You have this massive
- 29:35clash of ancient imperial ghosts colliding with
- 29:38gritty, cynical Renaissance capitalism. It is
- 29:41beautiful and it is disgusting all simultaneously.
- 29:44Into this world of stark contrasts and cutthroat
- 29:47politics stepped Alexander's children. And the
- 29:50tension that had been quietly brewing between
- 29:52his two oldest sons was about to reach a catastrophic
- 29:55breaking point. Let's look at the mechanics of
- 29:58this sibling rivalry, because Cesare and Juan
- 30:00are a recipe for absolute disaster. Cesare is
- 30:04the eldest. He is intellectually brilliant. He
- 30:07is physically imposing. He's cold, proud, and
- 30:11deeply calculating. And what does Alexander do?
- 30:13He forces him into the church. He makes him a
- 30:15cardinal. Cesare absolutely hates the priesthood.
- 30:17He doesn't care about theology or canon law.
- 30:20He wants to be a secular prince. He wants to
- 30:23command armies and conquer territory. Meanwhile,
- 30:26Juan... the second son, is Alexander's clear
- 30:29favorite. Juan is arrogant, deeply reckless,
- 30:32and frankly, far less competent than Cesare.
- 30:35But simply because he is the favorite, Alexander
- 30:38gives Juan exactly the secular power Cesare desperately
- 30:41craves. It's infuriating. Juan is appointed Captain
- 30:44General of the Papal Armies. He's granted the
- 30:47lucrative dukedom of Gandia in Spain. You have
- 30:49the genius brother forced to wear a dress and
- 30:51read Latin while the incompetent, flashy brother
- 30:54gets to put on armor and play with the military.
- 30:57The resentment must have been toxic. Beyond toxic.
- 31:00And all of this boils over in June of 1497. Yes.
- 31:04The events of June 14th, 1497 remain one of the
- 31:07great, meticulously documented, unsolved mysteries
- 31:10of the Renaissance. The two brothers, Cesare
- 31:14and Juan, attend a pleasant, seemingly normal
- 31:16family dinner at their mother -of -a -notes estate.
- 31:18Just a quiet family meal. Right. After dinner,
- 31:22they ride back toward the center of Rome together.
- 31:25At some point in the dark streets, Juan separates
- 31:28from the group, stating he has somewhere to be,
- 31:31most likely visiting a mistress, which was his
- 31:33standard habit. Right. He rides off into the
- 31:36night with only a single groom and a masked companion,
- 31:39and he vanishes. Just gone. The next morning,
- 31:44panic sets in at the Vatican. And the mechanism
- 31:46of how they discover his fate is incredibly chilling.
- 31:50The papal guards interrogate a timber dealer
- 31:52who was guarding his wood down by the Tiber River
- 31:54in the middle of the night. And his testimony
- 31:56is remarkable. He testifies that he saw a group
- 31:59of men come down to the riverbank, heave a body
- 32:01into the water, and throw stones on top of it
- 32:04to make it sink. And when the furious guards
- 32:06ask him, like, why on earth didn't you report
- 32:08this to the authorities? His answer tells you
- 32:10everything you need to know about Rome. calmly
- 32:13explained that he had seen bodies thrown into
- 32:14the Tiber on countless nights during his career
- 32:16and the authorities had never once cared before.
- 32:19So why would anyone care about this one? It speaks
- 32:22volumes about the casual desensitized violence
- 32:24of the city. Let's just stop and think about
- 32:26that. The son of the pope, the most powerful
- 32:29sovereign in Italy, is murdered and tossed into
- 32:31a river. And a guy watching thinks it's so routine
- 32:34he doesn't even bother telling the police. That
- 32:36isn't just a fun historical anecdote. That is
- 32:38a terrifying metric of how cheap life was in
- 32:41Borgia's Rome. They drag the river and pull one
- 32:43out. His throat is violently cut. He's been stabbed
- 32:46nine times. But his heavy gold purse is completely
- 32:50untouched. Which definitively rules out robbery.
- 32:53This was a targeted political assassination.
- 32:55How does Alexander react? With absolute devastating
- 33:00grief. He completely breaks down. The worldly,
- 33:04cynical pope locks himself in his chambers, refuses
- 33:07to eat, and weeps uncontrollably for days. He
- 33:10was crushed. In his despair, he actually proclaims
- 33:13to the consistory that this tragedy is God's
- 33:16direct punishment for his own corrupt, nepotistic
- 33:19life. And he promises sweeping radical reforms
- 33:22of the entire Catholic Church. But... The grief
- 33:27eventually fades, right? Yeah, it does. The reform
- 33:29promises vanish into thin air, and Alexander
- 33:32goes right back to business as usual. But what
- 33:35he does next, regarding the murder investigation,
- 33:38is the exact moment the Borgia myth is cemented
- 33:41in stone. He abruptly orders the investigation
- 33:43permanently closed. Shut down completely. He
- 33:46never names a killer. He just shuts down the
- 33:48entire police apparatus. Which immediately led
- 33:51to rampant unstoppable speculation across Italy.
- 33:54I mean, why would the grieving father stop the
- 33:56search for his favorite son's killer? The prime
- 33:59suspect in the eyes of the Roman public and in
- 34:02the whispers of history became Cesare himself.
- 34:05I mean, let's analyze the evidence or the lack
- 34:07of it. There is zero hard proof that Cesare ordered
- 34:10the hit. Juan was incredibly arrogant and had
- 34:13a million enemies. It could easily have been
- 34:15an insulted member of the Orsini family. It could
- 34:18have been a jealous husband. But Cesare had the
- 34:22precise motive. He had the cold, ruthless character
- 34:25capable of fratricide. And most importantly,
- 34:27look at the mechanics of who benefits. Follow
- 34:30the power. Exactly. The second Juan is dead,
- 34:34Cesare steps right into his shoes. He eventually
- 34:36takes the military role he always wanted. This
- 34:40raises an important question about how historical
- 34:42narratives are formed, though. Whether Cesare
- 34:44actually ordered the murder or not, and modern
- 34:47historians still debate it hotly, the belief
- 34:50that he did it became the cornerstone of the
- 34:52Borscht myth. It was the defining story. It cemented
- 34:55this terrifying idea of a family so thoroughly
- 34:58consumed by ambition that a brother would slaughter
- 35:00his own blood just for a promotion. It made Cesare
- 35:04the most feared man in Italy long before he even
- 35:07drew his sword in combat. While the sons were
- 35:09violently fighting over armies and red hats,
- 35:12we have to look at the only daughter, Lucrezia,
- 35:15because her story is the most wildly misunderstood
- 35:18of all. Without a doubt. She was being moved
- 35:20around the geopolitical chessboard by her father
- 35:22and she paid a terrible price for his ambitions.
- 35:25Lucrezia is almost always portrayed in pop culture
- 35:28as a wicked poisoner. An incestuous femme fatale.
- 35:32The Black Widow. Right. But the reality is far
- 35:35more tragic and ultimately far more triumphant.
- 35:39In 1493, when she is just 13 years old, a highly
- 35:44educated, graceful young girl who speaks multiple
- 35:46languages, her father marries her off to Giovanni
- 35:49Sforza. And the sole mechanism of this marriage
- 35:52is to secure a defensive military alliance with
- 35:54the powerful Duchy of Milan. Which, to be clear,
- 35:57was completely standard operating procedure for
- 35:59the nobility. Marriage wasn't about romance.
- 36:02It was a binding diplomatic treaty. But a few
- 36:05years later, the geopolitical winds shift. Alexander
- 36:09doesn't need the Milan Alliance anymore. In fact,
- 36:12it's becoming a liability. He has grander, more
- 36:15strategic plans for Lucrezia's hand, so he decides
- 36:18to dissolve the marriage. And the legal mechanics
- 36:22he uses to do it are just completely ruthless.
- 36:26Yeah, how does he actually pull that off? Well,
- 36:29the Catholic Church did not permit divorce, but
- 36:31it did permit annulment under very specific conditions.
- 36:36Alexander forces an annulment by claiming that
- 36:38the marriage was never physically consummated.
- 36:41He publicly, legally accuses Giovanni Sforza
- 36:44of being permanently impotent. Wait, how does
- 36:46a pope just legally declare someone impotent
- 36:48when the guy is loudly protesting that he is
- 36:51perfectly capable? Sforza was outraged. Yeah.
- 36:54He offered to prove his virility publicly. Oh
- 36:57my god. But he was a minor lord, facing the combined
- 37:00terrifying will of the pope and the rising military
- 37:03threat of Cesare Borgia. His own family, the
- 37:06Sforzas of Milan, basically told him to take
- 37:09the deal or face complete destruction. So he
- 37:12caves. Fearing for his life and his lands, Sforza
- 37:15was bullied into signing a humiliating, legally
- 37:18binding public confession of his own impotence,
- 37:22allowing the marriage to be annulled. It is the
- 37:2415th century equivalent of an orchestrated PR
- 37:27nightmare. Sforza's reputation as a man is utterly
- 37:30destroyed, so he strikes back using the only
- 37:33weapon he has left. He starts a rumor. A very
- 37:36dark rumor. Out of pure, humiliated spite and
- 37:39revenge, he whispers to diplomatic envoys that
- 37:41the real reason Alexander wanted Lucrezia back
- 37:44is that she is having incestuous relations with
- 37:47her father and her brother, Cesare. It was a
- 37:51monstrous, baseless lie. There is absolutely
- 37:54no historical evidence to support it. But it
- 37:56was so lurid, so profoundly shocking that it
- 37:59spread like wildfire across the courts of Italy.
- 38:02And it permanently stained Lucrezia's name in
- 38:04the history books. She did absolutely nothing
- 38:06to deserve it. She was just the collateral damage
- 38:08of a humiliated man's slander. Exactly. And her
- 38:11family just keeps using her as a pawn. Her second
- 38:14marriage is to Alfonso of Aragon. And this one
- 38:17is actually heartbreaking because Lucrezia genuinely
- 38:21fell in love with him. They even had a child
- 38:23together. But once again, the political alliances
- 38:26of Alexander and Cesare shift, this time aligning
- 38:29heavily with France, and a Spanish Aragonese
- 38:32husband becomes an active political liability.
- 38:35In this time, the solution wasn't a complex legal
- 38:38annulment. In the summer of 1500, Alfonso was
- 38:41attacked on the steps of St. Peter's Basilica
- 38:43by a gang of assassins. He is stabbed repeatedly,
- 38:47but barely survives. Lucrezia is utterly terrified.
- 38:50She locks him in a room in the Vatican, personally
- 38:53nurses him, and reportedly cooks all his food
- 38:55herself to prevent poisoning. But as he is slowly
- 38:58recovering in his bed, armed men loyal to Cesare
- 39:02burst into the chamber, physically drive Lucrezia
- 39:05and his sister away, and strangle Alfonso to
- 39:07death right there in his bed. And everyone in
- 39:10Rome knew it was Cesare who ordered the hit.
- 39:13He had his own sister's beloved husband murdered
- 39:15in his bed. Just because the guy was no longer
- 39:18useful to a treaty with France, it is unbelievably
- 39:21cold. Lucrezia is devastated, plunging into deep
- 39:24mourning. But the political machine never stops.
- 39:29She is eventually forced into a third marriage,
- 39:31this time to Alfonso d 'Este, the heir to the
- 39:34highly prestigious Duke of Ferrara. And this
- 39:37is where the narrative finally turns for her.
- 39:40She moves north to Ferrara, physically escaping
- 39:42the toxic, suffocating control of her father
- 39:46and brother. And she thrives. She really does.
- 39:49Once she is out of Rome, she proves everyone
- 39:52wrong. She becomes this highly capable, universally
- 39:55beloved, pious duchess. When her husband is away
- 39:58commanding armies, she effectively runs the state
- 40:01apparatus of Ferrara. She patronizes Renaissance
- 40:04artists and poets. She outlives both Cesare and
- 40:07her father by over a decade. She is the ultimate
- 40:11survivor of a toxic family dynamic. The world
- 40:14tried to brand her a monster. But given half
- 40:16a chance, she proved she was a brilliant, compassionate
- 40:19leader. Your survival and reinvention are remarkable.
- 40:23But we really have to look at why Cesare was
- 40:26so desperate to align with France and murder
- 40:28Lucrezia's second husband. Right. The bigger
- 40:31picture. The geopolitical shifts that made her
- 40:34marriages so dangerous were driven by a massive
- 40:36catastrophic earthquake in European politics.
- 40:40In 1494, the fundamental rules of war and power
- 40:43in Italy changed overnight. This is a huge turning
- 40:47point. 1494, the French storm. King Charles VIII
- 40:51of France looks at the map of Italy and decides
- 40:53he has a dynastic claim to the kingdom of Naples
- 40:56in the south. But why Naples? Why risk a massive
- 41:00invasion over it? Naples was critical. It was
- 41:03incredibly wealthy. It controlled the vital Mediterranean
- 41:06trade routes. And strategically, Charles viewed
- 41:08it as the necessary staging ground for a massive
- 41:11crusade to retake Jerusalem. So Charles marches
- 41:14a massive standing army over the Alps, 25 ,000
- 41:18professional soldiers. But more importantly,
- 41:20he brings a train of heavy mobile bronze cannons.
- 41:23Which changed everything. We really need to dive
- 41:26into the physics and mechanics of this because
- 41:28it explains why Italy collapsed so fast. Prior
- 41:31to 1494, how did Italian city -states actually
- 41:35fight each other? Italian warfare was conducted
- 41:37by mercenary captains called condottieri, and
- 41:40it was almost performative. performative war
- 41:43yeah it was a highly cautious low casualty game
- 41:47of maneuver where armies would posture cities
- 41:50would negotiate and pay ransoms and very few
- 41:53professional soldiers actually died in combat
- 41:55because mercenaries were expensive assets you
- 41:57didn't want to waste right if you kill my guys
- 42:00i can't rent them out next season exactly sieges
- 42:03could take months or years it was basically extreme
- 42:06bloodless chess and then the french show up and
- 42:09it's not a game anymore Think about the physical
- 42:12architecture of Italy. Medieval walls were built
- 42:15incredibly tall and thin, designed specifically
- 42:18to stop guys climbing up with ladders or siege
- 42:20towers. But when Charles VIII brings heavy bronze
- 42:23cannons, the geometry is completely wrong. A
- 42:26cannonball hitting a flat, thin, rigid masonry
- 42:29wall transfers all its kinetic energy, and the
- 42:32wall just shatters into dust in a matter of hours.
- 42:36The illusion of Italian safety was shattered
- 42:37instantly. Fortresses that had been deemed impregnable
- 42:40for centuries fell in an afternoon. City after
- 42:44city simply surrendered in sheer terror as the
- 42:46French marched south. And as this massive army
- 42:49approached Rome, Alexander VI faced the greatest
- 42:53existential crisis of his papacy. Charles VIII
- 42:56had Alexander's mortal enemy, Cardinal de la
- 42:58Rovere, riding right next to him, whispering
- 43:01in the king's ear, urging him to convene a council
- 43:04and depose this corrupt Spanish pope. But this
- 43:07is where Alexander's genius truly shines. He
- 43:10doesn't have an army that can beat 25 ,000 French
- 43:12professionals, so he uses pure unadulterated
- 43:15diplomatic judo. He locks himself inside the
- 43:17impenetrable Castel Sant 'Angelo, which is essentially
- 43:21a massive solid cylinder of ancient Roman concrete
- 43:24that cannons can't easily break. He stalls. He
- 43:28negotiates. He flatters Charles. And he eventually
- 43:31grants the massive French army safe passage right
- 43:34through Rome, supplies them with food, and somehow
- 43:36manages to keep his papal throne without firing
- 43:38a single shot. Charles eventually retreats from
- 43:41Italy after a broad coalition forms against him,
- 43:44but the psychological damage to the peninsula
- 43:46was permanent. The invasion birthed modern military
- 43:50engineering. Those tall, thin medieval walls
- 43:53were obsolete overnight. Engineers scrambled
- 43:56to design the trace Italian. these low, incredibly
- 44:00thick, earth -packed angled bastions shaped like
- 44:03stars. These angles could absorb or deflect cannon
- 44:07fire and allow defenders to mount their own heavy
- 44:09artillery. It fundamentally changed the physical
- 44:12architecture of European cities. I always think
- 44:15about what it feels like when the fundamental
- 44:16rules of your reality change overnight. It's
- 44:19like a modern industry suddenly getting entirely
- 44:22disrupted by a new technology and all your previous
- 44:25skills are worthless. Alexander realizes that
- 44:27the Papacy, which had relied on soft power, tradition,
- 44:30excommunications, and careful diplomacy, is completely
- 44:33defenseless in a world with professional standing
- 44:35armies and mobile artillery. Soft power isn't
- 44:39enough anymore. The Borgias realized they need
- 44:41their own hard military state to survive. And
- 44:45that desperate urgent need for a real centralized
- 44:47army gave Cesaro Borgia the exact excuse he'd
- 44:51been waiting for to cast off the scarlet robes
- 44:54of the church. So in 1498, Chesra makes history.
- 44:58He becomes the first person ever to officially
- 45:00resign the Cardinalate. How does that even work
- 45:03legally? He just quit. He essentially invoked
- 45:06the argument that he had been forced into the
- 45:08priesthood against his will. And his father,
- 45:11as Pope, conveniently granted a special dispensation,
- 45:15releasing him from his vows. Naturally. He literally
- 45:18walks in, hands back the red hat, and says, I'm
- 45:20done being a priest. Simultaneously, Alexander
- 45:23makes a massive diplomatic deal. with the new
- 45:26French king, Louis XII. The pope grants Louis
- 45:28a highly controversial marriage annulment that
- 45:30the king desperately needs. And in exchange,
- 45:33Louis gives Cesare French troops, a royal French
- 45:36bride, and elevates him to the Duke of Valentinois.
- 45:40And his famous nickname, Il Valentino. So Cesare
- 45:43trades his red robes for French armor. With a
- 45:46French army at his back and his father's bottomless
- 45:49papal treasury funding the logistics, Cesare
- 45:52launches a brutal, brilliant military campaign
- 45:55to conquer the Romagna. This is a region in central
- 45:58Italy. Theoretically, it was owned by the pope,
- 46:01but practically, it was ruled by fiercely independent
- 46:04petty lords who operated like mob bosses. Cesare's
- 46:08mission was to violently break them and forge
- 46:10his own centralized state. And his methods were
- 46:13shocking in their efficiency. He takes Imola.
- 46:16He takes Forli, besieging and defeating Caterina
- 46:19Sforza, who was this incredible, hardened warrior
- 46:23noblewoman. He takes Pissarro. He takes Urbino.
- 46:27But the way he governs the conquered territory
- 46:29is where the legend of Cesare truly takes shape.
- 46:32We have to examine the mechanics of his statecraft,
- 46:35particularly the story of his lieutenant, Ramiro
- 46:37de la Orca. No, this is the ultimate Machiavellian
- 46:41move. It really is. Cesare installs Ramiro as
- 46:44the governor to pacify the conquered region,
- 46:46and Ramiro is incredibly cruel. He uses terror,
- 46:50torture and mass executions to stamp out banditry
- 46:53and bring strict order. And structurally, it
- 46:56works. The roads become safe. But the local people
- 46:59absolutely despise Ramiro for the blood jet.
- 47:02Cesare observes this and knows that if the people
- 47:04hate the governor, they might eventually rebel
- 47:06against Cesare himself. So what does he do? Once
- 47:10Ramiro has done all the dirty work and restored
- 47:12total order, Cesare unexpectedly has him arrested.
- 47:16One morning, the people of the town wake up to
- 47:18find Ramiro's body cut completely in half, placed
- 47:21in the center of the public square, with a bloody
- 47:24executioner's knife resting on a block of wood
- 47:26beside him. Cesare executed his own loyal lieutenant
- 47:30just to show the people, I am the one who brings
- 47:32justice. The cruelty was his unauthorized fault.
- 47:36And the psychological effect was exactly what
- 47:38he intended. The people were simultaneously terrified
- 47:41of Cesare and deeply satisfied by his justice.
- 47:45It is the absolute pinnacle of ruthless pragmatism.
- 47:49And this is exactly the kind of move that attracted
- 47:51the attention of a relatively minor Florentine
- 47:55diplomat who was embedded in Cesare's camp, observing
- 47:57his campaigns. Golo Machiavelli. Machiavelli
- 48:00spent weeks at Cesare's court, meticulously observing
- 48:03his methods. He saw the execution of Amiro de
- 48:07Lorca, and he witnessed Cesare's most famous
- 48:09act of treachery, the trap at Senegalia. Explain
- 48:13the mechanics of Senegalia because it reads like
- 48:16a thriller. It's wild. Several of Cesare's own
- 48:19mercenary captains, fearing his growing power,
- 48:23formed a conspiracy and started a mutiny against
- 48:25him. Cesare was suddenly highly vulnerable. But
- 48:29instead of fighting them, he uses deception.
- 48:31He pretends to forgive them. He smiles, he negotiates
- 48:35a highly generous peace treaty, and he invites
- 48:38them all to a friendly dinner in the town of
- 48:40Senegalia to celebrate their reconciliation.
- 48:43Believing they have outsmarted him, the captains
- 48:46walk into the room. Cesare shuts the door, has
- 48:49his loyal guards surround them, and has the mutineers
- 48:52strangle to death that very night. Machiavelli
- 48:54literally wrote home calling it a beautiful piece
- 48:57of deception. He was mesmerized by Cesare's ability
- 49:00to completely divorce morality from statecraft.
- 49:04In his famous book, The Prince, Machiavelli immortalized
- 49:07Cesare as the ideal ruler, a man who did not
- 49:10let conventional ethics or mercy slow him down,
- 49:13who struck swiftly and decisively. He understood
- 49:16that it is far better to be feared than loved
- 49:18if you want to maintain order and hold a fractured
- 49:21state together. What is often lost in the myth
- 49:23of his cruelty, though, is that By the standards
- 49:25of the day, Cesare actually governed his newly
- 49:28conquered territories surprisingly well. He instituted
- 49:31uniform justice. He eradicated the violent bandits.
- 49:35He reformed the arbitrary tax codes. Many citizens
- 49:38in the Romagna actually preferred his harsh but
- 49:41stable centralized rule over the chaotic extortionate
- 49:45petty tyrants they had suffered under before.
- 49:47He wasn't just conquering, he was building the
- 49:49administrative mechanics of a real nation state.
- 49:52What's fascinating here is the speculation about
- 49:54what might have been. Machiavelli himself mused
- 49:58that if fortune hadn't intervened, Cesare Borgia
- 50:01might have possessed the strategic vision and
- 50:03the sheer terrifying will to drive out the foreign
- 50:06powers and unite Italy into a single nation,
- 50:09almost four centuries before it actually happened.
- 50:12But Machiavelli also noted the fatal flaw in
- 50:14the architecture of Cesare's power. Cesare's
- 50:17entire empire, his invincible army, his terrifying
- 50:19reputation, All of it rested on one incredibly
- 50:23fragile biological foundation. His father. It
- 50:27all required Alexander's endless papal treasury
- 50:30and diplomatic authority. Cesare was building
- 50:32a massive empire on the heartbeat of a man in
- 50:35his 70s. Which brings us to the deadly month
- 50:38of August 1503. Both Alexander and Cesare are
- 50:42in Rome. It's the absolute peak of summer. The
- 50:45air is sweltering. The tiber is low and stagnant.
- 50:49The swamps are breeding. millions of mosquitoes.
- 50:51And malaria is violently ravaging the city. In
- 50:55the exact same week, both the father and the
- 50:57son fall gravely ill with soaring fevers. Immediately,
- 51:01the rumor mills spun into overdrive, creating
- 51:04a myth that survives to this day. The poisoned
- 51:07wine story. Right. The popular story was that
- 51:10Cesare had intended to poison a wealthy cardinal
- 51:12at a dinner party so the pope could confiscate
- 51:15the dead man's fortune. But through a servant's
- 51:18error, The poisoned wine was accidentally served
- 51:20to Alexander and Cesare instead. It was the perfect
- 51:24poetic moral fable. The great poisoners, hoisted
- 51:27on their own petard, caught in their own wicked
- 51:30trap. But the historical reality is way less
- 51:33poetic and way more microscopic. It wasn't magic
- 51:36poison powder. It was mosquito ecology. They
- 51:40caught the Roman summer fever. But the physiological
- 51:42effects were catastrophic. Alexander VI, being
- 51:4572 years old, cannot fight it off. On August
- 51:4818th, 1503, the pope dies. And the contemporary
- 51:52accounts of his body are incredibly gruesome.
- 51:55His corpse rapidly blackened, swelled, and began
- 51:58to decompose almost immediately in the terrible
- 52:00summer heat. His enemies naturally seized on
- 52:03this horrifying visual as absolute theological
- 52:06proof of his corrupted soul physically manifesting
- 52:09in his rotting flesh. It was an incredibly undignified
- 52:13squalid end for a man who had reigned with such
- 52:16magnificent golden splendor. And Cesare survives
- 52:19the fever, but the mechanics of the illness ruin
- 52:22him. He is completely bedridden for weeks. He's
- 52:25flat on his back, delirious. At the exact moment,
- 52:29he needs to be the ruthless, terrifying conqueror.
- 52:31He's completely incapacitated. I compare it to
- 52:34a CEO who builds a massive corporate empire entirely
- 52:37on highly leveraged debt. The second the market
- 52:40crashes, or in this case, the second his father
- 52:42dies, the loans are called in, the liquidity
- 52:44dries up, and the whole empire vaporizes instantly.
- 52:48Chesery had planned for almost everything. He
- 52:50had anticipated his father's eventual death.
- 52:53He had bribed and schemed to ensure he could
- 52:56control the next conclave and install puppet
- 52:58pope. But as he later confessed to Machiavelli,
- 53:01the one contingency he never planned for was
- 53:04that he himself would be at death's door when
- 53:07that crucial moment arrived. Hold on, so Cesare
- 53:10literally planned out every geopolitical chess
- 53:12move for years, but just forgot to factor in
- 53:15getting a mosquito bite on the worst possible
- 53:17day? It is the ultimate meditation on human cunning
- 53:20versus blind fate. While he's stuck in bed, paralyzed
- 53:25by fever, the geopolitical vacuum collapses in
- 53:28on him. His enemies surge back into Rome. The
- 53:31Orsini, the Colonna, all the lords he violently
- 53:34kicked out of the Romagna, they all march back
- 53:36and reclaim their fortresses. Cesare's painstakingly
- 53:39constructed empire crumbles in a matter of weeks.
- 53:42And the final nail in the coffin comes with the
- 53:44election of the new pope. After a very brief
- 53:4726 -day interim papacy, Giuliano della Rovere,
- 53:51the Borgia's oldest, most bitter enemy, the man
- 53:54who had fought Alexander in the 1492 conclave
- 53:57and begged the French king to depose him, is
- 54:00elected as Pope Julius II. And Julius II systematically
- 54:05and ruthlessly dismantles Cesare. He strips him
- 54:08of his remaining titles, confiscates his cities,
- 54:10and throws him in prison. Cesare eventually manages
- 54:13this dramatic escape from a high -security Spanish
- 54:15prison, climbing down a rope from a tower in
- 54:18the middle of the night, and flees to the tiny
- 54:20kingdom of Navarre, where his brother -in -law
- 54:23is king. But his French army is gone. His father's
- 54:26wealth is gone. The myth of his invincibility
- 54:28is gone. The man whose personal motto was, au
- 54:32cesare a nihil, either Caesar or nothing. was
- 54:36reduced to fighting as a simple cavalry captain
- 54:39in an obscure, meaningless mountain skirmish.
- 54:42In 1507, at just 31 years old, Cesare Borgia
- 54:45was killed in an ambush. He fought fiercely to
- 54:48the end, but he was overwhelmed, stabbed multiple
- 54:51times, stripped of his expensive armor, and left
- 54:54naked and completely unrecognized in the mud
- 54:57of the battlefield. It is an unbelievable steep
- 55:00fall. The most feared man in Italy, dead in the
- 55:03dirt, stripped of everything. But the men were
- 55:06dead, and the enemies they made were still very
- 55:08much alive. And those enemies were the ones holding
- 55:11the pens, sitting in the Vatican archives, ready
- 55:15to write the history books. We have to look at
- 55:17the anatomy of the Borgia myth, the mechanics
- 55:20of poison, propaganda, and legacy. We really
- 55:24need to debunk the Cantarella myth. The pervasive
- 55:27idea that the Borgias possessed a secret, undetectable
- 55:30magic poison powder that they used to systematically
- 55:33murder wealthy cardinals at dinner parties is
- 55:36largely a fictional invention. When a wealthy
- 55:4070 -year -old cardinal died of poison in August,
- 55:43it was almost always an old man dying of malaria
- 55:46or dysentery. It is classic confirmation bias.
- 55:49The Borgias were ruthless, absolutely. Chesire
- 55:52definitely had political rivals murdered with
- 55:55swords and strangulation. So when an old rival
- 55:58dies of a sudden stomach fever after eating dinner
- 56:00at the Vatican, the public immediately attributes
- 56:03it to malicious intent rather than bad water.
- 56:06The legend of the Cantarella fed on itself until
- 56:08it became accepted historical fact. The legend
- 56:11was also meticulously fed by internal sources
- 56:14like Johann Bouchard's diary. Burchard was a
- 56:18highly precise German cleric, the master of ceremonies
- 56:21at the Vatican. He recorded the daily logistics
- 56:23of the Papal Court in dry, bureaucratic detail.
- 56:27He is the one who recorded the infamous banquet
- 56:29of chestnuts, a scandalous party supposedly hosted
- 56:32by Chesire inside the Vatican, featuring 50 courtesans
- 56:35crawling on the floor and open debauchery. Whether
- 56:38that specific event happened exactly as he wrote
- 56:40it or was wildly exaggerated by anti -Borgia
- 56:44factions, it permanently cemented their reputation
- 56:46for unimaginable depravity. And then you have
- 56:50external enemies like Gerolimo Savonarola, this
- 56:53fiery Dominican friar who basically took over
- 56:56the city of Florence, ruling it as a theocracy
- 56:58with these terrifying bonfires of the vanities
- 57:02where citizens were forced to burn their art,
- 57:04books, and fine clothes. Savonarola constantly
- 57:07thundered from the pulpit against the corruption
- 57:09of the church, singling out Alexander VI as the
- 57:13Antichrist. The conflict between the pragmatic,
- 57:16worldly pope and the puritanical friar ended
- 57:19with Savonarola being excommunicated. Eventually,
- 57:23the people of Florence, tired of his extreme
- 57:25rules, turned on him and burned him at the stake.
- 57:28But his vivid, apocalyptic denunciations gave
- 57:31the Borgia legend a powerful, enduring moral
- 57:34charge. The irony of their legacy is staggering,
- 57:37though. We remember them as these supernatural
- 57:40demons. But look at the actual historical end
- 57:43of their story. Venotza, the mother of the monsters,
- 57:48died a wealthy, highly respected old woman in
- 57:51Rome funding charities. Lucrezia died a universally
- 57:55beloved, highly capable duchess in Ferrara. And
- 57:58incredibly, Alexander's great -grandson, Francis
- 58:01Borgia, gave up his worldly titles, became a
- 58:04Jesuit priest, lived a life of immense piety
- 58:07and was actually canonized as a saint by the
- 58:10Catholic Church. Wait, there is a literal saint,
- 58:13Borgia. The bloodline produced a canonized saint.
- 58:16Exactly. The bloodline ran to sanctity as well
- 58:19as scandal. But the legend was just too useful
- 58:22to let go. It was weaponized by moralists during
- 58:25the Protestant Reformation to attack the inherent
- 58:28corruption of the Catholic Church. It was highly
- 58:30romanticized by 19th century writers like Victor
- 58:32Hugo, who turned Lucrezia into a theatrical femme
- 58:35fatale for entertainment. And it continues to
- 58:38be sensationalized in television and pop culture
- 58:40today because a family of beautiful, evil poisoners
- 58:44makes for great television. So what does this
- 58:48all mean? The Borgias weren't supernatural monsters
- 58:51with magic poison rings. They were extraordinarily
- 58:54gifted. deeply ambitious and violently ruthless
- 58:57human beings who perfectly embodied the golden
- 59:00cynical danger of the Renaissance. They understood
- 59:03the mechanics of power, bureaucracy and violence
- 59:06better than anyone else. They played the game
- 59:08to perfection. But when the foundation cracked,
- 59:12their enemies made sure they were remembered
- 59:14as the devil incarnate. History really is written
- 59:17by the survivors and the enemies left behind.
- 59:19Their true story is a master class in the absolute
- 59:22limits of power. Chesery did. everything Machiavelli
- 59:25said a prince should do. He was decisive, he
- 59:27was cunning, he was ruthless, he built institutions.
- 59:31But all his brilliance, all his cruelty couldn't
- 59:33save him from the simple mechanical fact that
- 59:36his power was built on borrowed ground. It relied
- 59:39on a biological foundation that crumbled in a
- 59:42single August fever. It's a sobering thought.
- 59:46It has been an incredible journey stripping away
- 59:48these myths today. the meteoric rise from a cautious
- 59:51Spanish lawyer navigating the schism to the absolute
- 59:54peak of geopolitical power and the catastrophic
- 59:57fever -induced fall. We have seen exactly how
- 1:00:00the mechanics of power operate and how quickly
- 1:00:03the grandest ambitions can dissolve into the
- 1:00:05mud. It's a truly timeless story. But I want
- 1:00:08to leave you with one final thought experiment
- 1:00:10to mull over on your own. Think about the most
- 1:00:12powerful political or business figures of our
- 1:00:14own time. the people dominating the headlines
- 1:00:17and shaping the geopolitical landscape today.
- 1:00:20Imagine if 500 years from now, their entire legacy,
- 1:00:25every single textbook written about them, every
- 1:00:27movie made about them, was sourced exclusively
- 1:00:30from the private diaries of their absolute worst
- 1:00:33enemies. That's a terrifying perspective. What
- 1:00:35kind of monsters would history remember them
- 1:00:38as? Would the complex mechanical truth of who
- 1:00:41they were even survive the legend? Something
- 1:00:45to think about. Thanks for joining us on this
- 1:00:47deep dive, and keep questioning the legends you
- 1:00:50read.