Latest / Reformed Thinking / The Radical Corruption of the Will: An Exegetical and Historical Defense of Total Depravity
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Reform Thinking. I'm your host and as always, we
- 0:03take a stack of source material and pull out the most vital
- 0:06insights to help you stay well informed.
- 0:08And I am your resident theology expert.
- 0:11Really looking forward to getting into our texts today.
- 0:13Yeah, me too. You know, to kick things off.
- 0:15If you ask the average churchgoer today, are people
- 0:19basically good? Well, the overwhelming majority
- 0:23will say yes. Oh yeah, they definitely will.
- 0:26Recent polling data backs that up, too.
- 0:28It shows a staggering majority of professing evangelicals
- 0:31believe human beings are born in a state of basic moral goodness.
- 0:35Which is pretty wild when you think about it.
- 0:38It really is. But according to the two
- 0:39theological texts we are doing a deep dive into today, the
- 0:43radical corruption of the will and total depravity, the
- 0:47biblical doctrine of human corruption, that assumption is
- 0:50not just slightly incorrect. Right, Those texts argue it is a
- 0:53spiritual misdiagnosis and honestly, a misdiagnosis that
- 0:56renders the entire Christian gospel useless.
- 0:58Yeah, we are looking at a doctrine that modern culture and
- 1:02a huge chunk of the modern church completely misreads.
- 1:06Now to set the table right away for you, the listener.
- 1:09Both of us approach this material strictly from a
- 1:12Protestant Christian framework. Yes, we adhere to the theology
- 1:15outlined in the Westminster Confession of Faith, right?
- 1:18So we are looking at this through a reformed lens, but we
- 1:23are going to look closely at what these specific authors are
- 1:26arguing. We want to understand the nuts
- 1:28and bolts of this doctrine. Because, you know, they suggest
- 1:31this modern sentimental idea that humanity just needs better
- 1:37education or maybe more equitable environments.
- 1:40Or a bit of therapy to reach its full potential.
- 1:42Yeah, they argue that idea is a complete illusion.
- 1:45The biblical reality presented in these texts is that humanity
- 1:48does not need therapy. Humanity needs a resurrection
- 1:52from spiritual death. That is a harsh truth for a lot
- 1:55of people to. Hear it is OK, let's unpack
- 1:57this, because starting from that Prentice changes everything
- 2:00about how we view the world. It really does.
- 2:03It changes the entire paradigm of how we understand our
- 2:06relationship with God. I mean, think about it like a
- 2:07medical situation. Right, like going to the doctor.
- 2:10Yeah, if a doctor gets the diagnosis wrong, the cure they
- 2:13prescribe will be entirely useless.
- 2:14And it could even be fatal. Spot on.
- 2:17So the doctrine of total depravity functions as this dark
- 2:20backdrop, and it is against that dark backdrop that the diamond
- 2:24of sovereign Grace shines the brightest.
- 2:26That is a great image because if we assume humans are basically
- 2:29good, then the grace of God just becomes like a helpful
- 2:34accessory. Yeah, it becomes like a
- 2:35spiritual vitamin supplement you take to give you an extra boost
- 2:38in the morning. But if humans are spiritually
- 2:40dead, then the grace of God is a defibrillator.
- 2:44It is life from the dead. Precisely the mission of our
- 2:47discussion today is to look strictly at the authoritative
- 2:50Word of God to understand our true condition.
- 2:53Because until a person understands the absolute ruin of
- 2:55the human condition, they will never cherish the absolute
- 2:59triumph of the rescue. And the authors of these texts
- 3:01make it very clear that defining this doctrine correctly is a
- 3:04vital correction to a church that has lost its grasp on the
- 3:08severity of sin. That brings up a massive hurdle
- 3:10right out of the gate. You know the phrase total
- 3:13depravity carries a huge amount of cultural baggage?
- 3:17Oh. Absolutely.
- 3:18It really does. When people hear that phrase,
- 3:21they almost always assume it means humanity is completely,
- 3:24100% evil in every possible way at all times.
- 3:27Right, they think of like the most notorious dictators in
- 3:31history. Yeah, and they assume that is
- 3:33what the doctrine claims we all are.
- 3:35But the texts draw a very sharp distinction here.
- 3:37They do. They make a sharp distinction
- 3:39between what they term utter depravity and radical
- 3:42corruption. Right.
- 3:43Having established that humanity is not basically good, we need
- 3:47to clarify precisely what depravity actually means in a
- 3:50reformed context. Because utter depravity would
- 3:53mean a person is as evil as humanly possible, committing
- 3:56every conceivable sin to the maximum degree.
- 3:59And the sources state plainly that this is not the case, not
- 4:01at all. Instead, total depravity means
- 4:04radical corruption. The word radical comes from the
- 4:06Latin word for root. It means sin has poisoned the
- 4:10very root of human nature. Think of it like this.
- 4:14Imagine you have a glass of crystal clear purified water.
- 4:19OK, I am picturing it. Now imagine a single drop of
- 4:23deadly, lethal poison falls into that glass.
- 4:27The water does not suddenly become 100% pure poison.
- 4:31Right, it still looks like water.
- 4:32It still has the properties of water, but every single molecule
- 4:36in that glass is now tainted by the poison.
- 4:39Yeah, you cannot safely drink any part of it.
- 4:41Exactly. I mean, absolutely.
- 4:43The corruption has extended to the totality of the glass.
- 4:46Your analogy gets us halfway there, but let's push it
- 4:48further, because the texts are very specific about how that
- 4:51poison operates. OK, how so?
- 4:52The corruption extends to the totality of a person's being,
- 4:56yes, but it is. It's not a passive taint, it is
- 4:59active. Active in what way?
- 5:01Sin is not an external blemish or a bad habit that a person
- 5:05picks up from their environment. It resides in the heart.
- 5:08And when the biblical authors speak of the heart, they are not
- 5:11talking about the organ pumping blood in your chest.
- 5:13Right, they're talking about the Control Center of human life.
- 5:16The mind, the will, the physical body and the affections are all
- 5:20dictated by this Control Center. And the sources clarify a very
- 5:24common misconception here. People do not become sinners
- 5:27because they commit sins. Wait, say that again.
- 5:30People commit sins because they are sinners by nature.
- 5:33The outward actions are the fruit of an inward root problem.
- 5:36Wow, so there is no pristine, untouched moral center inside a
- 5:41person that they can retreat to in order to generate their own
- 5:44righteousness? No, the whole inner disposition
- 5:47is bent away from God. When we understand depravity is
- 5:50this radical root level corruption, we see why cosmetic
- 5:54fixes cannot reconcile A Sinner to God.
- 5:57Yeah, if the core manufacturing plant of the human heart is
- 6:00defective, everything it produces carries that defect.
- 6:03OK, so if the root itself is corrupted, the obvious question
- 6:05is where did this poisoned root come from?
- 6:08Right. And the texts take us all the
- 6:09way back to Genesis 3. Yeah, the historical fall of
- 6:12Adam. This brings us to the origin of
- 6:14the ruin. And the sources are very careful
- 6:16to note here that humanity was originally created upright and
- 6:19good. I mean, God is not the author of
- 6:21evil. Right.
- 6:21Adam was made with true knowledge, righteousness, and
- 6:24holiness. But then the fall happened.
- 6:26Yes, the fall. Now I have to push back here on
- 6:29behalf of the listener, because this is where the modern mind
- 6:34completely rejects the biblical narrative.
- 6:36I know where you were going with this.
- 6:38Why should you or I be held guilty for something one guy did
- 6:41thousands of years ago in a garden, right?
- 6:43It feels completely disconnected from our daily reality.
- 6:47We were not there. We did not eat the fruit.
- 6:49No, we didn't. So how does his action legally
- 6:52and constitutionally poison our glass of water today?
- 6:56It feels unfair. That reaction is incredibly
- 6:59common, especially for modern Westerners.
- 7:01Yeah, for sure. We are raised in a culture of
- 7:04hyper individualism where we believe we are autonomous
- 7:07islands. And we think we should only be
- 7:09judged by our own individual actions.
- 7:11But the texts answer this objection by explaining the
- 7:14covenant of works and the theological concept of federal
- 7:17headship. OK, Federal headship, break that
- 7:19down well. The ancient mind, and
- 7:22specifically the biblical worldview, understood corporate
- 7:25solidarity, meaning Adam was not just a historical figure who set
- 7:29a remarkably bad example that the rest of us unfortunately
- 7:32copied. He was the representative head
- 7:34of the entire human race. In Reformed theology we look to
- 7:39Romans chapter 5, verses 12 through 19.
- 7:42That is where the Apostle Paul lays out this framework.
- 7:45Spot on. Adam acted as our federal head,
- 7:47much like an ambassador acts on behalf of a nation.
- 7:50Or like a CEO signs a contract on behalf of a massive
- 7:53corporation. Exactly.
- 7:54I mean, that is a perfect example.
- 7:56If an ambassador declares war, the entire country goes to war.
- 8:00Even if the citizens were sleeping in their beds at the
- 8:02time. Yes, when Adam was placed in the
- 8:05garden under the covenant of works, his perfect obedience
- 8:08would have secured eternal life for all his descendants.
- 8:10But his disobedience brought ruin to all his descendants.
- 8:14Because he represented us, his guilt was imputed or legally
- 8:18credited to his posterity. And with that imputed guilt came
- 8:21inherited corruption, which we call original sin.
- 8:24Right. That completely shifts the
- 8:26perspective. If we accept that representative
- 8:28framework, the legal guilt makes sense.
- 8:31It does, but the texts also point out that it is not just a
- 8:35legal status, it is an inherited condition.
- 8:38Yeah, they quote Psalm 51 verse 5, where King David confesses,
- 8:42Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin did my
- 8:46mother conceive me? And David is not suggesting the
- 8:48biological act of conception was a sin.
- 8:51No, he is acknowledging that from the very first moment of
- 8:54his existence in the womb, he possessed A sinful nature.
- 8:58The corruption is a congenital condition.
- 9:00We're not born morally neutral like blank slates waiting to
- 9:04decide if we will be good or bad.
- 9:05No, we are born alienated from God bearing the consequences of
- 9:10Adam's rebellion. Precisely.
- 9:11And to prove this inherited condition is an absolute
- 9:14reality, the authors do not just rely on theological concepts.
- 9:18No, they provide intense exegetical rigor.
- 9:20They look at the specific original languages used by the
- 9:24biblical authors to see how they described this ruin.
- 9:27Here's. Where it gets really
- 9:28interesting. Oh yeah, the linguistic side of
- 9:30things. Because we have to look at the
- 9:31precise words chosen under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit,
- 9:34Let's look at the Greek first. Yeah, the sources point to
- 9:37Ephesians chapter 2 verses one through 3 right?
- 9:40And the Apostle Paul uses the Greek adjective necros to
- 9:44describe the natural human state.
- 9:46Necros OK. And the authorial word choice
- 9:49here is entirely deliberate. I mean, Paul had other options.
- 9:53Like what? Well, he could have used the
- 9:54word aspenes, which translates to weak.
- 9:57Oh. OK.
- 9:58Or what else? Or he could have used the word
- 10:00camno which translates to weary or sick.
- 10:03And if he had used those words, you could argue that humanity,
- 10:06he just needs a little assistance.
- 10:08Right, like a spiritual crutch or a hospital bed.
- 10:11But he chose necros. He did, which translates
- 10:14literally to a lifeless corpse. A lifeless corpse.
- 10:17And the syntactical structure of that passage shows that being a
- 10:21lifeless corpse is a settled state of being for the natural
- 10:23person. OK, so if the New Testament uses
- 10:27the language of a physical corpse, you know, how does the
- 10:30Old Testament Hebrew language back up this concept?
- 10:33Well, we know the biblical witness has to be unified, so
- 10:36the sources take us to Genesis chapter 6, verse 5.
- 10:38Right, which assesses the human condition right before the
- 10:41flood. Yeah, and the text analyzes the
- 10:44Hebrew word yetzer, which is often translated in English
- 10:48Bibles as the intent or imagination of the heart.
- 10:51But there is more to it than just imagination.
- 10:53Right there is when you look at the Ancient Near Eastern, extra
- 10:56biblical usage of that word. It refers to a Potter framing or
- 11:01molding a clay vessel. Oh wow, so it's talking about
- 11:03the actual construction. That is right.
- 11:05The Holy Spirit is communicating that the very framing the
- 11:08manufacturing plant of the human heart is completely defective.
- 11:12And that sentence is modified by two absolute terms.
- 11:15Yes, RAC meaning only and Cole Hyom meaning continually.
- 11:20Every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only evil
- 11:23continually. It leaves zero room for
- 11:24occasional sparks of spiritual virtue.
- 11:26Not at all. We also see this in Jeremiah
- 11:28chapter 17, verse 9. OK, what does Jeremiah say?
- 11:31He uses the Hebrew words echob, meaning treacherous or
- 11:34deceitful, and anash, meaning incurable or desperately sick to
- 11:38describe the heart. So the prophets are diagnosing
- 11:41an incurable spiritual disease. Yes.
- 11:44Furthermore, in Romans chapter 3, verses 9 through 20, Paul
- 11:48strings together a series of Old Testament quotes.
- 11:51To create a forensic legal indictment against all of
- 11:54humanity. Right.
- 11:55He uses repeated absolute phrases like not one and no one
- 12:00seeks for God to stop every mouth.
- 12:02I want you, the listener, to consider what it means to be
- 12:05described as a spiritual corpse. It is a heavy thought.
- 12:09A corpse cannot cooperate with a doctor.
- 12:11A corpse cannot take medicine A. Corpse cannot even ask for help.
- 12:15A corpse requires a miracle of resurrection.
- 12:18The problem is not a lack of effort, the problem is a lack of
- 12:21life. Spot on.
- 12:23OK, so the ancient languages are painting a vivid picture of a
- 12:26spiritual corpse, but that's where I get stuck.
- 12:29Why is that? Because when I look around,
- 12:31people do not act like corpses. We think, we feel, we make moral
- 12:35choices. We build civilization.
- 12:37That is a very fairpoint. How do the sources reconcile
- 12:39this idea of death with the fact that we are walking, talking,
- 12:43functional human beings? They answer this by breaking
- 12:45down what they call the anatomy of the fall.
- 12:47Right, showing how this spiritual death manifests in the
- 12:51everyday faculties of a human being.
- 12:53Let's break this down into 3 distinct areas, OK?
- 12:55Let's do that. 1st The Mind and the Conscience.
- 12:59Based on Ephesians chapter 4, verses 17 and 18, the mind is
- 13:03darkened. Yeah, it actively suppresses
- 13:05divine truth. It is not neutral ground waiting
- 13:08for enough evidence to believe. The unregenerate mind actually
- 13:11uses its intelligence to build arguments against God.
- 13:14And according to Titus chapter one, verse 15, the conscience is
- 13:18defiled. We often think of our conscience
- 13:20as this perfect little compass pointing to true North.
- 13:22Right. But the sources point out that a
- 13:24defiled conscience is a highly unreliable moral guide.
- 13:28Why? Because it excuses what God
- 13:30condemns, and it condemns where God grants liberty.
- 13:33It is a broken compass. That leads directly to the
- 13:35second faculty, which is the affections.
- 13:38OK, the affections. In John chapter 3 verse 19, we
- 13:41see that the core issue is misplaced desire.
- 13:43The text says light has come into the world, but humanity
- 13:46loved the darkness rather than the light.
- 13:48So the affections are idolatrous.
- 13:50Yeah, people do not naturally love the true God of Scripture.
- 13:54They love the idols they create in their own minds.
- 13:57This brings us to the third and most highly debated faculty.
- 14:00Yeah, the will and the concept of moral inability.
- 14:05Oh, this is the big one. Right, and this is where I need
- 14:08to press you, because this is where the listener is likely
- 14:10raising a red flag. I am ready.
- 14:13Wait a minute. You and I make free choices
- 14:15every single day We do. We choose what to eat for
- 14:18breakfast, what books to read, how to act at work, and who to
- 14:21marry. Yeah.
- 14:22So how can the will be considered dead or enslaved if
- 14:26we're constantly making free choices?
- 14:27That is the most common objection to this doctrine, and
- 14:30the sources clarify it through the specific concept of moral
- 14:33inability. OK, break that down for us.
- 14:35Well, fallen humans do ACT voluntarily.
- 14:38No one is physically coercing them to sin against their
- 14:41desire. Right, there is no external
- 14:42force holding a gun to their head making them reject.
- 14:44God, absolutely. However, they are not morally
- 14:47free. The will is not an independent
- 14:49autonomous entity floating in a vacuum.
- 14:52It is tethered to something. Yes, the will is tethered to and
- 14:56enslaved by the corrupt nature. People choose what they desire
- 15:00most. And because their nature is
- 15:02corrupt, their greatest desire is always going to be rebellion
- 15:05against God's absolute authority.
- 15:07So they're free in the sense that they act willingly, but
- 15:10they lack the spiritual ability to choose Christ apart from
- 15:14regenerating grace. That is right.
- 15:16The hostility of the carnal mind means they cannot submit to
- 15:20God's law. They will not come to the light
- 15:23because their affections love the darkness.
- 15:25The inability is not mechanical. No, it is not as if they
- 15:28desperately want to come to God, but a physical barrier stops
- 15:31them. The inability is moral.
- 15:34They cannot come because they vehemently do not want God on
- 15:37His terms. I think a practical analogy
- 15:40helps solidify this concept. Imagine you take a hungry lion,
- 15:43right? OK.
- 15:44A hungry lion. And you put two plates of food
- 15:46in front of it. On one plate you have a pile of
- 15:49fresh green grass. Right On the other plate you
- 15:51have a massive slab of raw meat. The lion is going to choose the
- 15:55raw meat every single time. Yeah, without fail.
- 15:58Now, is the lion free to choose the grass?
- 16:01Yes, there is no physical cage preventing the lion from walking
- 16:06over and eating the grass. No one is forcing the lion's
- 16:09mouth onto the meat either. Precisely.
- 16:11But the lion's internal nature dictates that it will always
- 16:15crave the meat. Because it is a carnivorous
- 16:18animal by nature, yes. Its choice is determined by its
- 16:21appetite. That makes total sense.
- 16:23Similarly, fallen humans are presented with the things of God
- 16:26and the things of the flesh. And they will never choose God
- 16:29because their fallen, sinful nature dictates that they crave
- 16:33their rebellion. They cannot come to Christ
- 16:35because they will not come. Their will is entirely bound by
- 16:39their corrupt affections. You could dress the grass up to
- 16:41look like meat, but the lion's nose knows the difference.
- 16:45That analogy hits the nail on the head regarding the bondage
- 16:47of the will. And it leads us directly into a
- 16:50necessary section of clarification.
- 16:51Right, because when people hear this lying analogy and the
- 16:54concept of moral and ability, they might feel that this view
- 16:57is completely pessimistic about daily life.
- 17:00Yeah, they look around and see non Christians helping each
- 17:03other or artists creating beautiful masterpieces.
- 17:06Or parents loving their children sacrificially.
- 17:08Exactly. I mean absolutely.
- 17:11So we need to outline what Total depravity is not.
- 17:15OK, what do the sources say? They list several key caveats.
- 17:19First, as we established earlier, it does not mean humans
- 17:22are as wicked as possible. Because of common grace.
- 17:25Right. The concept of common grace
- 17:27explains why human society has not completely imploded into
- 17:31total anarchy. God, in his mercy, actively
- 17:34restrains human evil. He does.
- 17:37He allows unbelievers to perform acts of relative good,
- 17:40maintaining civic goodness so that the world can function.
- 17:43People can be law abiding citizens, brilliant doctors and
- 17:46loving family members. Total depravity does not deny
- 17:48the reality of civic virtue. Right.
- 17:50And it also does not mean that the image of God has been
- 17:52erased. The source would point out that
- 17:54the image of God in humanity is heavily marred and distorted,
- 17:57much like a shattered mirror. But it is not completely
- 18:00annihilated. Human beings still retain
- 18:02massive dignity worth and rational capacity.
- 18:06That is why murder and injustice are so grievous.
- 18:09They are a direct assault on God's image bearers.
- 18:11Yes, but we have to clarify the standard of righteousness.
- 18:15The difference between horizontal goodness and vertical
- 18:18goodness. Let's break that down.
- 18:20Horizontal goodness is what we see when people benefit society.
- 18:24Like donating to a charity, building a hospital or helping
- 18:28an elderly person across the street.
- 18:29Yeah, those are horizontally good and incredibly beneficial
- 18:32to human flourishing. However, vertical goodness is
- 18:35about pleasing a perfectly holy God.
- 18:38And outwardly good deeds that do not spring from saving faith and
- 18:41are not aimed specifically at God's glory fall drastically
- 18:45short of biblical righteousness. They are tainted by that drop of
- 18:48poison. If a person gives $1,000,000 to
- 18:51an orphanage, but does it to earn praise from their peers
- 18:54rather than to honor God, the action is horizontally helpful
- 18:57but vertically bankrupt. That distinction between
- 19:00horizontal and vertical is huge. And this leads to the concept of
- 19:04guilty inability. The listener needs to grasp that
- 19:07this moral inability does not remove human responsibility.
- 19:11Because the inability is self chosen in Adam and embraced
- 19:14willingly in our daily lives. We are choosing the raw meat
- 19:17because we love the raw meat, so we are held entirely
- 19:20accountable. We cannot blame God for a
- 19:22refusal to come to Him. Right.
- 19:24A debtor who squanders all his money at a casino cannot tell
- 19:27the bank I am unable to pay my mortgage, therefore I am no
- 19:31longer responsible for the debt. The inability to pay does not
- 19:34erase the obligation to pay. No it doesn't.
- 19:36Because this biblical definition is so specific and honestly so
- 19:40humbling to human, the texts show how easily the church has
- 19:44historically compromised on. It Oh, definitely.
- 19:46This brings us to the necessity of guarding the flock through
- 19:50holy polemics. There are several historical
- 19:53false refuges that attempt to soften the blow of total
- 19:55depravity. Let's look at the historical
- 19:58battles the sources bring up. First, there is Pelagianism,
- 20:01named after the British monk Pelagius from the 5th century.
- 20:04He claimed humans are born completely innocent.
- 20:07Yeah, essentially denying original sin entirely.
- 20:10He argued. Adam was just a bad example.
- 20:12And the Church universally condemned that as a heresy.
- 20:15Then you have the Roman Catholic Council of Trent in the 16th
- 20:18century which took a semi Pelagian approach.
- 20:22They claim the human will is not dead, but just wounded or sick,
- 20:25meaning it retains enough strength to cooperate with God's
- 20:29grace for salvation. But as we discussed with the
- 20:31Greek word necros, A corpse cannot cooperate with a
- 20:35physician, right? Finally, the texts firmly reject
- 20:38Arminianism's idea of provenient grace.
- 20:42What is that exactly? It is a theological concept that
- 20:44suggests God gives a universal grace to all people that
- 20:48neutralizes their depravity just enough to grant them a
- 20:52libertarian free choice. But the texts argue that this is
- 20:55a theological fiction. Yeah, it is attempting to give a
- 20:58spiritual corpse the ability to choose life before they are
- 21:01actually born again. Scripture simply does not grant
- 21:04fallen humanity that kind of neutral free will.
- 21:08The natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God.
- 21:11Exactly right. And how does this historical
- 21:14compromise show up in today's culture?
- 21:16Well, the authors of our sources take a very sharp turn here into
- 21:19modern cultural frameworks, right?
- 21:21They point out that modern secular theories, things like
- 21:25critical race theory or various forms of liberal sociology,
- 21:29conflict directly with this doctrine.
- 21:31And just to be clear for you, the listener, we are not taking
- 21:34a political stance on those theories right now.
- 21:36We are just reporting on what the authors of these texts are
- 21:39arguing. Absolutely.
- 21:40We are just laying out the arguments from the source
- 21:42material, and the texts argue that the secular frameworks
- 21:46attempt to locate the source of human misery entirely in
- 21:50external social structures or systemic issues.
- 21:53The secular argument is that if we just fix the systems,
- 21:56redistribute resources and reeducate society, we will fix
- 22:00humanity. But the authors of our sources
- 22:02assert that this framework completely denies the radical
- 22:05corruption of the human heart. It assumes the problem is
- 22:07outside of us rather than inside of us.
- 22:09Furthermore, the texts point out that we see this denial heavily
- 22:13in pragmatism and the modern seeker sensitive church
- 22:15movement. Oh yeah, these are church growth
- 22:18strategies built on the premise that unchurched people are
- 22:21seekers who just need the right environment to make a decision
- 22:24for Christ. Yes, and the writers of these
- 22:27texts deliver a tremendously sharp critique of that entire
- 22:30church growth model. Their argument is pretty
- 22:33straightforward. If Romans chapter 3 says no one
- 22:36seeks for God, then the entire seeker sensitive movement is
- 22:41built on a theological lie. Pragmatism assumes that the
- 22:45unregenerate person possesses A neutral or even slightly
- 22:48positive orientation toward God. And they think that orientation
- 22:52can be triggered by the right music, the right lighting, or a
- 22:55culturally relevant sermon. But the biblical reality,
- 22:58according to these texts, is that the natural man finds the
- 23:01things of the Spirit to be foolishness.
- 23:03The unregenerate person is not a seeker looking for a friend,
- 23:06They are a fugitive running from a judge.
- 23:09The authors essentially argue that you cannot use worldly
- 23:12gimmicks to fix a spiritual problem.
- 23:14You cannot use fog machines, laser light shows, or Ted talk
- 23:17style self help sermons to entertain a spiritual corpse
- 23:21into life. Turning the sanctuary into a
- 23:23theater that caters to the felt needs of people who are
- 23:26spiritually dead is an exercise in futility.
- 23:29It requires the authoritative proclamation of the Word of God
- 23:33to awaken the dead. It really does.
- 23:35So after the authors tear down every false refuge and worldly
- 23:38gimmick, we arrive at the absolute climax of this deep
- 23:42dive. Yeah, the real turning point.
- 23:44If we are entirely helpless and our methods and gimmicks are
- 23:46useless, how is anyone saved? That is the pivotal question
- 23:51that shifts the tone of the entire discussion to the of the
- 23:54gospel. Total depravity makes sovereign
- 23:56grace absolutely necessary. The texts stress that
- 24:00regeneration must precede faith. Let.
- 24:02Me say that again because it reverses how most modern
- 24:04Christians think. Yeah, regeneration must precede
- 24:07faith. God must grant a new heart.
- 24:09He must take out the heart of stone and give a heart of flesh
- 24:12before a person can exercise saving faith.
- 24:15Because a corpse cannot believe until it is given life.
- 24:18This occurs through a doctrine called effectual calling.
- 24:22OK, effectual calling. God the Father draws sinners
- 24:25inwardly by the work of the Holy Spirit.
- 24:27He does not drag them kicking and screaming against their
- 24:30will. No, He renews their desires,
- 24:32changing their nature so that they see the beauty of Christ
- 24:35and come willingly. Going back to our analogy, the
- 24:38lion's nature is fundamentally changed so that it suddenly
- 24:42craves the grass. Yes, that is a great way to tie
- 24:44it back. And how does this specific total
- 24:47ruin point directly to Jesus? The sources breakdown the
- 24:51matching solution through Christ's threefold office.
- 24:54I love how symmetrical this is. Because our anatomy has fallen
- 24:58in three specific ways. Christ provides the specific
- 25:01corresponding rescue. Let's take them one by one
- 25:04first. He is our prophet.
- 25:06Because our minds are darkened and we actively suppress the
- 25:08truth, Christ is the prophet who reveals divine truth and
- 25:11illuminates our understanding by His Spirit.
- 25:13Second, he is our priest. Because our consciences are
- 25:16defiled and we are legally guilty, standing condemned under
- 25:20the law, Christ is the priest who offers a substitutionary
- 25:23death on the cross. Bearing our penalty and
- 25:26providing the active obedience needed for our justification, He
- 25:29fulfills the vertical goodness we lacked.
- 25:31And third, he is our king. Because our wills are enslaved
- 25:35to rebellion and bound by corrupt affections, Christ is
- 25:39the King who exercises sovereign authority to subdue our
- 25:42rebellious hearts and conquer our hostility.
- 25:45This matching solution eliminates every single ounce of
- 25:49human boasting. Salvation is a monarchistic
- 25:52work. Monarchistic.
- 25:54That is a theological term coming from 2 Greek words,
- 25:57right? Yes, mono meaning 1 and ergon
- 25:59meaning work. It means salvation is the work
- 26:02of one party, God alone. It is not a cooperative,
- 26:05synergistic effort where God does 99% and we do the final 1%
- 26:10by making a good choice. If grace were just divine aid
- 26:13offered equally to everyone, and the deciding factor was our own
- 26:17native ability to choose it, we would have reason to boast.
- 26:20We could look at our neighbor who rejected the gospel and say
- 26:22we were just a little bit smarter or a little bit more
- 26:25spiritually sensitive. Or a little bit more humble than
- 26:27they were. But the texts point out that the
- 26:29only thing we contribute to our salvation is the sin that made
- 26:33it necessary. Salvation is of the Lord from
- 26:35beginning to end. As we bring this to a close, we
- 26:38need to look at the practical application for your daily life.
- 26:41Because this is not just high level academic theology meant
- 26:44for a seminary classroom. It changes how you live tomorrow
- 26:48morning. The texts point out that this
- 26:50doctrine should produce intense humility and massive confidence
- 26:53in evangelism. It absolutely should.
- 26:56It crushes pride because you realize you did absolutely
- 26:58nothing to earn your standing before God.
- 27:01But it fuels immense worship and gratitude.
- 27:04And regarding evangelism, it removes the crushing pressure of
- 27:08thinking you have to perfectly argue someone into the Kingdom
- 27:11of God. Preachers and believers do not
- 27:13rely on their own persuasive abilities, their personal
- 27:15charisma, or their atmospheric lighting.
- 27:17They rely entirely on the Holy Spirit to awaken the dead
- 27:20through the proclamation of the truth.
- 27:23We speak the Word and we trust God to do the resurrecting.
- 27:26Furthermore, if the texts reference the Westminster
- 27:28Confession, specifically Chapter 19 regarding the third use of
- 27:32the law. Yes, for the believer who has
- 27:34been made alive, the law is no longer a terrifying ladder we
- 27:38have to climb to earn heaven. Because Christ fulfilled it
- 27:41perfectly, the law now functions as a helpful rule of life,
- 27:45guiding our grateful obedience. We obey not to be saved, but
- 27:49because we have been saved. So what does this all mean?
- 27:51It means that understanding the staggering depth of the ruin is
- 27:55the only way to genuinely cherish the absolute triumph of
- 27:58the rescue. You cannot appreciate the cure
- 28:01until you accept the reality of the disease.
- 28:03I'm. Going to leave you with a final
- 28:04thought to Mull over as you go about your week.
- 28:07Think back to that initial idea of a spiritual diagnosis, the
- 28:11realization that our condition is far worse than a broken bone.
- 28:14It is a complete lack of life. If your salvation relied on you
- 28:18generating even one single ounce of spiritual life, you would be
- 28:21entirely without hope. But since the God who commands
- 28:24the dead to rise is the exact same God who supplies the life
- 28:27to do it well, how does that reality completely free you to
- 28:30stop striving, drop yourself righteousness, and rest entirely
- 28:34in Christ's finished work today? Thank you for joining us for
- 28:37this deep dive on Reformed thinking.
- 28:39May this truth elevate your view of God's sovereign grace.