Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Viva Villa! (1934)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Ryan, I have to issue a very
- 0:23formal apology to you, to our listeners, to everybody
- 0:27on the, what is it, my dad's side of my family
- 0:31tree. I have no idea where this is going, by
- 0:34the way. The last few episodes where we've been
- 0:37leading up to this episode. And the movie we're
- 0:40covering. Yeah. I have been pronouncing this
- 0:42film like Hank Hill. Viva Villa. It's been so
- 0:46bad. So bad enough to where clearly you've gotten
- 0:50some backlash. Just from me. Just from you? Just
- 0:52from me. Okay. So when I first turned on this
- 0:54movie and I heard them pronounce our lead character's
- 0:59name, I went, what? Well, I need you to know
- 1:04that I probably did the same thing, but I had
- 1:07no idea it was about... The character. So I wasn't
- 1:10sure that was what we were doing. I thought it
- 1:13was more like, I live in the villa, so I'm Viva
- 1:16Villa. Right. So I had no idea. You're referring
- 1:20to Poncha Villa of the movie Viva Villa. Correct.
- 1:25Which now we know. I am half Scottish, half Irish.
- 1:29I am white, right? Yeah. Very different for you
- 1:34to be saying that, I guess. So that's where the
- 1:36apology stems from, I suppose. I'd like to apologize
- 1:39to my grandfather, Joaquin, from Colombia. I
- 1:44guess I don't need to apologize to my grandfather,
- 1:46Gary. Yeah, no, I just, it made me laugh. As
- 1:54soon as it started, I was like, oh, no. I've
- 1:57shamed my family. And that's because we're talking
- 1:59about Viva Via today. I think I made that same
- 2:02mistake, so you're good. Don't worry about it.
- 2:04I appreciate your apology. We both did. But again,
- 2:08it just felt a little more like okay. Yeah. My
- 2:11ancestors aren't screaming at me as much as they
- 2:14are. Right. Yeah. So I'm excited to talk about
- 2:17this one because it has the return of a pod favorite,
- 2:20Wallace Beery. And we could talk a little bit
- 2:23about, you know, when we say, hey, we're talking
- 2:26about a movie starring the character Pancho Villa
- 2:28and also Wallace Beery. We'll talk about that.
- 2:31Yeah. It's a little dicey. A little bit. Yeah.
- 2:35Which is common. We've now covered two Westerns.
- 2:39We'll leave Sim around out of this conversation.
- 2:42As it should. But we did cover In Old Arizona.
- 2:45Yeah. Which also kind of followed the same controversial
- 2:49trend here. That's true. Now, it's hard to tell
- 2:53as much with the... Like the face painting of
- 2:57it, right? Like how much you're portraying that
- 2:59character. I can't speak to this one as much
- 3:01as we could with In Old Arizona, because there's
- 3:03more of a, it's more obvious, I suppose. At least
- 3:06on our lead. In our lead, that's correct. And
- 3:09as much as I love Wallace Beery, I'm kind of
- 3:11like, I was really worried about that. I was
- 3:13like, come on, man. Don't do this. I will say
- 3:16the longer we talk about Wallace Beery, the less
- 3:19I like him after every film. The more I'm given
- 3:21reason not to like him. Yeah. But I am seeing
- 3:23the clear, like, I will give him credit for this.
- 3:26I feel like Wallace Beery is one of the actors,
- 3:28one of the biggest examples of who we've seen
- 3:31so far and talked about, where I feel like they
- 3:34have found their niche. And they are leaning
- 3:37into it. Yeah. So you are seeing them do it.
- 3:39And we'll talk about it here in the breakdown.
- 3:41But something we don't get to do very often here
- 3:42that I want to do real quick. How are you doing,
- 3:44bud? Oh, I'm good. Yeah. I'm living it up, man.
- 3:48We've been watching nonstop 30s movies. You more
- 3:51so than me. I know you're watching more than
- 3:52the Best Picture nominees. Yeah. So how's your
- 3:56search going? It's been fun. The way I've kind
- 3:59of been doing it is I get... The movies we're
- 4:00covering on the show out of the way. And then
- 4:02the rest of the week, I'll try and watch other
- 4:04nominees from that year. Peppermint. Yeah, I've
- 4:07slowed down a little bit this particular week.
- 4:09I don't know why. Maybe I'm a little burnt out
- 4:12on 30s films. Well, you just did our watch party.
- 4:16Yeah. So we had Black Cat, and that's another
- 4:191934 film you're knocking out. Yeah, which was
- 4:22fun. I enjoyed that quite a bit. I had seen it
- 4:24once before already. Side note. Watch Party coming
- 4:27out next week as well on the 16th. If you want
- 4:30to be a part of that, check out patreon .com
- 4:32slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. But yeah, I'd watch
- 4:35that. I don't know. I think this year I'm slowing
- 4:39down. Like 1934. I'm slowing down on the others.
- 4:43I might not watch all of them. I want to watch
- 4:45the one with... Betty Davis, Human Bondage, something
- 4:49like that, Inhuman Bondage. Not knowing the name,
- 4:54I'm going to hope that you're right about one
- 4:56of those words. Yeah, it's something like that.
- 4:59But how are you? That was a lot of me. No, I'm
- 5:01good. I've been watching a lot, too. Not so much
- 5:06in 1934, but catching a lot in theaters. May
- 5:09is a really big month for movies and movie theaters
- 5:12in general. I'm excited to talk about that with
- 5:14you at some point, because I think it's been
- 5:15a really historic month in some ways. But doing
- 5:19well. And, you know, we're, Tay's been home for
- 5:22a very long time right now. So I've been very
- 5:24excited about that. And she actually just headed
- 5:26out today. So I was able to get breakfast with
- 5:28her. So that was super cool. Nice. But then,
- 5:30yeah, I've, you know, I have my, hold on, I'm
- 5:33checking the label to see exactly what it is.
- 5:35My grande iced chai latte with raspberry foam.
- 5:39I prefer cherry cold foam, to be so honest with
- 5:42you. But they did it once. And they were like,
- 5:45hey, we can make any foam you want. I was like.
- 5:47Awesome. Cherry. And they're like, we can't do
- 5:48that. So I was like, you can make pistachio,
- 5:51banana, and anything else, but you can't make
- 5:54cherry? They can't. So raspberry cold foam it
- 5:57is. I normally do something different that's
- 5:59not important. But point is, I'm feeling ready
- 6:02to talk about some movies today. This one I needed
- 6:04a little bit of energy to get me through Viva
- 6:08Villa. I almost did it again. I've almost done
- 6:11it 17 times. I've almost interrupted you just
- 6:14to go, Viva Villa! Of Human Bondage. Of Human...
- 6:19Yes. Okay, well, good. I was just worried you
- 6:21were going to be like, oh, it's called Of Human
- 6:22Tendencies. I'm like, when did bondage come in?
- 6:25All right, we'll talk about the movie. So, Viva
- 6:27Via is the movie we're talking about today, and
- 6:29this had four nominations. Sound recording, the
- 6:33return of someone we've talked about a good bit
- 6:34here, Douglas Shearer. This man never goes away.
- 6:37He doesn't. And you know what? Next time, bring
- 6:39your sister. Please. Of course, that's enormous
- 6:42here. Writing adaptation, Ben Hecht was nominated
- 6:46for this one. The return of him as well. Assistant
- 6:48director, John S. Waters. So, interesting thing
- 6:51to point out here, we talked on our sixth ceremony
- 6:53episode that the assistant director was a new
- 6:57category at the time. And that was less labeled
- 7:00for the movie and more labeled for the studios.
- 7:03In this one, they are actually labeling for the
- 7:05movie. So this is worth pointing out that John
- 7:07S. Waters did have a nomination for assistant
- 7:10director specifically for Viva Via. And then,
- 7:13of course, our fourth and final nomination was
- 7:14for outstanding production on behalf of Metro
- 7:17-Goldwyn -Mayer. Very nice. So this film was
- 7:21directed by Jack Conway, but also. Yeah. Two
- 7:25others. There was some controversy on set. But
- 7:28he's the one that's listed on the poster. So
- 7:31we'll cover the other two directors. We'll call
- 7:32him the final director. Yeah. Wallace Berry returns
- 7:36as Pancho Villa. Leo Carrillo as Sierra. Fay
- 7:42Wray as Teresa. Donald Cook as Don Felipe de
- 7:45Castillo. I'm so sorry, grandfather. Forgive
- 7:49me. Hey, but also George E. Stone is back as
- 7:53Emilio Chavito. I could not tell you who Emilio
- 7:57Chavito is in the movie, but I saw George E.
- 7:59Stone listed on the cast and he's like 15th on
- 8:02the cast. I was like, I know he's going to be
- 8:04called out in this episode. Yeah, he is. I feel
- 8:07like George E. Stone is the ghost haunting this
- 8:08podcast where every other movie I'm like, what's
- 8:11George E. Stone doing here? He's my favorite,
- 8:13man. No, he's great. We're really going to do.
- 8:16These awards that we've been talking about, the
- 8:18podcast awards, and we're going to have a Georgie
- 8:20Stone award. I do think we need a Georgie Stone,
- 8:22this guy doesn't sleep award. Yeah. Where it's
- 8:25just, man, why are you in so many movies? He's
- 8:27so good. So this was written by Ben Hecht, adapted
- 8:30from the 1933 book by Edgecumbe, Pinchon, and
- 8:34Obie Stade. His names are... I know. You're almost
- 8:39out of it. You're so close. I've made it, grandfather.
- 8:42The only thing I wanted to point out about this
- 8:44whole adaptation is that, did you notice that
- 8:46in your research, it doesn't just say that it
- 8:48was based on the novel or anything. it's suggested
- 8:51by the novel. So I think in the opening scroll
- 8:55of this movie, it says that like, you know, there
- 8:58are legends and somewhere between the fact and
- 9:00the fiction is like this story. So it's a blend
- 9:04of reality and fiction. And I think that's where
- 9:07they're using the term suggested from. So this
- 9:09isn't like a straight adaptation of that story
- 9:12or even novel, but it said suggested by the story
- 9:16by Edgecombe Pinchon and O .B. Stade. So this
- 9:21is interesting because it obviously is citing
- 9:23its sources, but it's clearly taking a bit of
- 9:26a detour from what they wrote. Yeah, you know,
- 9:29it's interesting. The movie we'll be covering
- 9:32on next episode, I popped on its sequel, and
- 9:35it had any likeness to any real persons and blah,
- 9:40blah, blah, strictly fictitious. Which, that's
- 9:43the first time I had noticed that on any of the
- 9:45movies we covered, and it got me thinking, when
- 9:47did that start? You know? It had to be around
- 9:50this time. I'll tell you exactly when it started.
- 9:52Oh. 1933. Rasputin and the Empress that we just
- 9:56talked about. Sure. Apparently, the prince that
- 9:59was family to whoever that movie's about. Well,
- 10:03I would assume Rasputin. Or the... The Empress?
- 10:06The people he was against. Yeah. Okay. There's
- 10:08something that happens where Rasputin, like,
- 10:10seduces a character. So he's sued because he's
- 10:12like, that's not what happened. So after that...
- 10:15studios were like we gotta protect ourselves
- 10:17blah blah blah so i wonder if this is not only
- 10:21them saying hey this is based on the book sort
- 10:24of quote unquote but also as like an early way
- 10:28of being like hey just so you know this is This
- 10:32is fiction. We're protecting ourselves. Yeah,
- 10:34that's a good point because what I was originally
- 10:36going to cite when you said that was that Pancho
- 10:39Villa's wife at the time that this came out was
- 10:43actually pretty supportive of Wallace Beery's
- 10:45depiction or characterization of him and thought
- 10:47he did a really good job of that. Which is funny
- 10:50because originally Mexican government officials
- 10:52were not very happy about this and they were
- 10:55pretty hesitant about Beery taking on the role
- 10:57because he... generally been playing like villains
- 11:00and buffoons was their words, not necessarily
- 11:03mine. But Pancho Villa was like an honored character
- 11:06in that culture, right? So they didn't want someone
- 11:09to kind of play the villainous buffoon version
- 11:11of Pancho Villa. Right. And they were worried
- 11:14about that, but at least his wife. thought that
- 11:16it was an accurate depiction. Now, whether that's
- 11:19good or bad, right? It might be like, yeah, my
- 11:21husband was a buffoon and he did well. Sure.
- 11:24Hard to say, but she was appreciative and thought
- 11:27it honored him. And obviously they let it happen.
- 11:30This movie exists. So it's interesting. Were
- 11:32you familiar with Pancho Villa before you saw
- 11:34this? In name, not so much in story. Wow, you
- 11:38were familiar in name and you were still calling
- 11:39him Pancho Villa? Well, hold on. I want to point
- 11:43out that I don't think I called them Pancho Villa.
- 11:45I called the movie Viva Villa because I didn't
- 11:47know it was about Pancho Villa. You're right.
- 11:49You're right. Now, I've watched plenty of cartoons
- 11:52where I think there has been a character depicting
- 11:55Pancho Villa, so give me some break there. Yeah,
- 11:58no, I was not familiar with the story. Yeah,
- 12:00I didn't know anything about him, so... When
- 12:02I was researching and everything, I was like,
- 12:04oh, okay, let me dive into my actual history
- 12:06book and see who this guy was. And it's worth
- 12:09noting that anything we talk about in this is
- 12:11not necessarily us saying, well, Pancho Villa
- 12:13did this in real life. Because, again, suggested
- 12:15by the story. Yeah, the movie's not even saying
- 12:17it, really. Right. Exactly. You're probably right,
- 12:20though. This probably started, not started, but
- 12:22was the beginning of that trend of we've got
- 12:25to protect ourselves. Because think of how many
- 12:26times we've had actual characters depicted on
- 12:30film. that might not be what actually happened.
- 12:32Even doing research for this movie, like, there's
- 12:35a lot of reports on, you mentioned the two other
- 12:37directors that directed this, or Shadow directed.
- 12:39There's a lot of differing reports on what happened
- 12:42here. So who's to say what actually happened
- 12:45at this time? It's an interesting way of kind
- 12:47of recollecting the past just through stories
- 12:50and not through, like, reality. Yeah. Yeah, it's
- 12:53very strange. Do you want to get into the plot
- 12:54a little bit? Yeah. So this takes place, it starts
- 12:58in, I believe it's... Is it 1880? It has to be
- 13:021880 because it does say in the 80s. And I got
- 13:05to tell you, when it started and said in the
- 13:0680s, I was like, Pancho Villa. It was like set
- 13:10to like, I wear my sunglasses at night or like
- 13:12Rio. See, I just think of Blue October. And he
- 13:16like walks out with his one eye closed. Just
- 13:20whipping like a Camaro around. How do you feel?
- 13:26God, that would have been a better movie. So
- 13:28it starts in 1880 and it shows Pancho Villa watching
- 13:32his father being brutally savaged and then ultimately
- 13:35murdered by the Mexican government officials.
- 13:39Because at the time it was just, I mean, even
- 13:41for a while, ran very corrupt. Yeah, it was,
- 13:45quote unquote, the Wild West, if you will. Granted,
- 13:49I know it was south of our Wild West, but you
- 13:53know what I mean. It was the Wild Southwest.
- 13:55Yeah. Yeah, that's what we'll call it. We'll
- 13:57take it. Also, this was a young Pancho Villa.
- 13:59Yes. So we're not seeing Wallace Berry just yet.
- 14:02Although that would have been really funny. Yeah.
- 14:03Because this kid has got to be like 10, maybe
- 14:0611. And also maybe a little more Mexican than
- 14:10Wallace Berry. I clocked that too. At first I
- 14:13was like, okay, cool. We're doing good. And then
- 14:14Wallace Beers showed up. I was like, oh, nevermind.
- 14:16So he immediately takes revenge on the man who
- 14:18was whipping his father, kills him and then leaves
- 14:22and now has dedicated himself to just living
- 14:24in the wild, like raising himself and then becoming
- 14:28a bandit. And he has an army and he grows this
- 14:32moniker and everyone knows him as this. I mean,
- 14:35king of bandits, essentially, right? Kind of,
- 14:37yeah. He will fight and kill and pillage and
- 14:40fight his way for the freedom of Mexico. Right.
- 14:44And he's really becoming an antihero in that
- 14:46sense. But it's not until he gets under the ear
- 14:49or he comes with an earshot of the Francisco
- 14:54Madero. Henry Walthall plays Francisco Madero,
- 14:57and Francisco Madero is kind of the person that
- 14:59gets into Pancho Villa's ear about the idea of
- 15:02actually freeing Mexico, but becoming a better
- 15:04man and becoming a general and not just murdering
- 15:07a bunch of people for not no reason, but actually
- 15:10building up the community. Right. The majority
- 15:14of this movie is kind of almost like a coming
- 15:16of age story for Pancho Villa in a way of like,
- 15:20yeah, I've been doing this for so long and I
- 15:21think I'm helping. But in reality, am I kind
- 15:23of just like stoking the hatred of this? Now,
- 15:27I'm putting a lot more emphasis on like the existentialism
- 15:31of Pancho Villa than this movie does, or certainly
- 15:33Pancho Villa puts on himself. But that's kind
- 15:36of how I took it was him growing into the position
- 15:39of being like a heralded figure. An honored figure,
- 15:44to use the words of the Mexican government officials,
- 15:46of Pancho Villa. Yeah, totally. Because, like
- 15:50you said, Pancho Villa, the way he's displayed
- 15:53in this movie, he's very abrasive. He's very
- 15:57rough. He spends a lot of time in, what are they?
- 16:01What's the proper word? A brothel. Yes. He's
- 16:04with many women. He will shoot somebody, like,
- 16:09on a whim. They're giving him a hard time, kind
- 16:14of. Like, he is your typical outlaw, in a way.
- 16:18Bandit, like you said. But with that, like, twist
- 16:21of a Robin Hood. But, yeah, you do kind of see
- 16:24him evolve into a more noble character. He never
- 16:30really approaches that, like, high level of nobility
- 16:33or honor. Because he's still doing some rough
- 16:36stuff by the end of the film. Yeah, no, I mean,
- 16:38you're inarguably talking about the... hotel
- 16:42scene um there's yeah it's really more he finds
- 16:46himself in this honorable position than it is
- 16:48like a man of honor like getting to that point
- 16:51or becoming a man of honor it's interesting because
- 16:54i i also half the reason i'll go and say i didn't
- 16:58care for this that much um one of the reasons
- 17:00is it felt like such a I was torn between how
- 17:05am I supposed to feel about this man? Because
- 17:07it feels like I'm supposed to celebrate him and
- 17:10honor him. But at the same time, you're showing
- 17:12me a lot of reasons why I shouldn't. And I feel
- 17:15like the female characters in this movie are
- 17:18kind of just, whether it be because they look
- 17:20similar or they're just passed around time to
- 17:23time, I was like, well, who is this? Like, it
- 17:26just, it doesn't feel like they're that important
- 17:28of characters. They're more just kind of, hey,
- 17:30we need this scene to happen. Hey, this scene
- 17:32needs to happen. And I was finding myself confused
- 17:34as to, like, who they were connected to. At one
- 17:38point, there's like, that was my sister, but
- 17:40this is my friend. Yeah. But also, I just got
- 17:42into town. There's a lot of confusion that I
- 17:45had with this. I can't say I was the biggest
- 17:49fan. And I think the biggest issue for me was
- 17:51I just couldn't wrap my head around what the
- 17:53movie wanted me to feel about Pancho Villa. Sure.
- 17:56Yeah. And I think it's one of those things where
- 17:59you're kind of meant to root for the antihero.
- 18:02So when he's doing good things, you're like,
- 18:04hurrah. And then when he's doing awful, terrible
- 18:08things in the hotel scene, you're like, wait
- 18:10a minute. What are we doing? Go back. I think
- 18:12the tone of the movie as well shifted to kind
- 18:16of comedic. Pretty early on, and I was worried
- 18:19about that. Because when the movie first opens
- 18:21and we have young Pancho Villa, and he's watching
- 18:23his father be killed, and he gets his revenge
- 18:26and all of that, it's really dark and very, the
- 18:29tone is so heavy. And I was really excited. I'm
- 18:31like, okay, we're going to get this kind of gritty
- 18:33Western film. Like a revenge story. Yeah. And
- 18:36it, as soon as Wallace Berry shows up, it shifts.
- 18:41almost entirely to kind of a comedic story. Yeah,
- 18:45I want to bring that down with you. So Wallace
- 18:48Beery, to me, again, someone we've been a fan
- 18:51of previously, and then the more we learn, we're
- 18:53just like, oh, and it keeps going down. Unfortunately,
- 18:56this movie will continue that both on and off
- 18:58screen, mostly off screen, I'd say. But with
- 19:01on screen, I was talking previously about how
- 19:03he kind of slips into that niche, and he finds
- 19:06a character and he plays it really well. And
- 19:07with Pancho Villa, he's playing the He's not
- 19:12intellectual. No. Right? He's not intellectual
- 19:15at all, but he knows a thing about violence,
- 19:18and he knows what he's been doing is working,
- 19:20and he knows how to rile up a group. He's like
- 19:22Dodger from Oliver and Company. Right. But then
- 19:24there's moments, and I've even clocked it, like
- 19:26he did the same thing in Grand Hotel, where he's
- 19:29talking about something, and someone knows something,
- 19:32but he doesn't. And the way that he portrays
- 19:34it is like he'll kind of rub his chin a little
- 19:36bit and be like, oh, well, I know it. but you
- 19:40should say it like something to that degree where
- 19:43it's like, he's trying to figure it out. I'll
- 19:45give you an example. He ends up meeting with
- 19:46Johnny Sykes, a writer, fun character. I thought
- 19:50that the relationship between them, maybe they
- 19:53wrote this into the story. Maybe they didn't.
- 19:54There's a little bit of a romance that's kind
- 19:57of written between them that I liked a lot, but
- 19:59he meets Johnny Sykes and Johnny is a writer
- 20:01and he ends up writing about poncho and all the
- 20:03things that he's done. And he isn't afraid to
- 20:06talk about it. He's like, he is murdering. poncho
- 20:09shows up and was like what are you writing he's
- 20:11like well i'm writing about you he's like okay
- 20:13well i can't read so why don't you read it for
- 20:15me and of course this is johnny's opportunity
- 20:17to be like oh well i'm praising you and saying
- 20:19what a great job you're doing and everything
- 20:21that's working he's like well that's amazing
- 20:23how many people do you reach out to and he's
- 20:24like six million and there are like there's a
- 20:27moment where this is really where wallace beery
- 20:29leans into like the six six million like he can't
- 20:33finish his word yeah he's kind of like rubbing
- 20:35his like chin where he's like oh i may have an
- 20:37idea here but clearly he doesn't have the upper
- 20:39hand intellectually in this conversation right
- 20:41so he's leaning into this kind of like buffoonery
- 20:45of the character that i think the government
- 20:47officials in mexico were originally like citing
- 20:50i see what they're saying sure but again there
- 20:53might be something to this depiction of him if
- 20:55even his wife pancho via's wife is like yeah
- 20:58he did a pretty good job right so i think that
- 21:01that The tone is weird because the performance
- 21:04that Wallace Beery is giving here is comedic.
- 21:07But then the next scene, they'll be riding past
- 21:09like at least three or four bodies that are being
- 21:12hung in that moment. So the tone is just like,
- 21:15what is going on here? Right. Yeah. And like
- 21:18as the movie progresses and you see his interactions
- 21:23with some of the like, quote unquote, villains
- 21:25of the movie, like it does shift back into that
- 21:28really dramatic storytelling. I enjoyed more
- 21:31than I did the comedy. Totally. I think the best
- 21:35parts that work comedically are the moments between
- 21:38Pancho Villa and Johnny Sykes. Yes. Because they
- 21:41do have that fun relationship. One of the most
- 21:44interesting parts of the movie that kind of falls
- 21:47flat with its final delivery is when a drunken
- 21:52Johnny Sykes shows up to Pancho Villa's place
- 21:56and he's talking about this story he wrote where
- 21:59he's like, Oh, I put in the paper how you took,
- 22:02oh, you took this town. And he's like, what are
- 22:03you talking about? I haven't done that. That's
- 22:06like, I wasn't going to do it because it's too
- 22:08hard to take. And he's like, oh, well, the paper's
- 22:12on the way to the press. And he's like, OK, well,
- 22:14you know what we got to do? We've got to go take
- 22:16this town. So he like forms this whole plan to
- 22:20kind of do exactly what Johnny Sykes wrote about
- 22:22down to the, hey, we're going to attack from
- 22:25the north. And Johnny's like. I wrote you were
- 22:28coming from the South. And they're like, no,
- 22:29that's too dangerous. But Pancho Villa is like,
- 22:32if he said South, we're coming from the South.
- 22:34So I love that exact scene you're talking about
- 22:37and him being drunk and writing in the paper
- 22:39and then them doing it kind of course correct.
- 22:43That then sets a precedent to where everyone's
- 22:45like, well, Johnny Sykes is this like, how is
- 22:47he getting the story before anyone else? We're
- 22:49going to give him a huge bonus for the story.
- 22:50It's like Spider -Man. It's exactly like, yeah,
- 22:52Spider -Man, where Spider -Man is like taking
- 22:54the photos of Spider -Man. Yeah. And he then
- 22:57continues this trend where all of the bandits
- 23:00in Poncho and Johnny Sykes, who's riding with
- 23:02them, are riding on this train on the way to,
- 23:05I think that's Santa Clara. I think so, yeah.
- 23:09They're going through the plan there. We're going
- 23:11to go through the north. And Johnny's like, oh,
- 23:13well, I wrote that we went through the south.
- 23:15And they tell Poncho. And Poncho's in the middle
- 23:17of playing guitar. And I want to point out that
- 23:20in this scene, I was so impressed. I was like,
- 23:22wow, Walsbury looks like he's actually playing
- 23:23and singing a little bit here. That's great.
- 23:25And then it cuts to him playing here. And he's
- 23:28playing. And he kind of stops. And he's like,
- 23:30how many writers is your paper getting out to?
- 23:33And Johnny was like, six million. He's like,
- 23:35six million. Yeah, no, we're going through the
- 23:37South. Right. And then he continues playing.
- 23:39But he continues playing to where you're like,
- 23:41oh, you're absolutely not playing guitar right
- 23:42now. Sure. And the camera just kind of like cuts
- 23:45away or like fades out with him doing it. And
- 23:47I was laughing so hard at the idea of Wallace
- 23:48Beard. Just like, yeah, this is how you play
- 23:49guitar. It's very funny. But I like that scene.
- 23:52And I agree like that whole interaction between
- 23:54Poncho and Johnny, I think is where I was most.
- 23:58It's when the screen comes alive. Yeah. And don't
- 24:01get me wrong. In a Western. It should be the
- 24:03action. It should be like, you know, the dramatic
- 24:05tension between the hero and the villains. But
- 24:08instead, it just kind of feels like a Western
- 24:10in setting and a Western in the idea of what
- 24:14the plot is. But it doesn't feel like it in the
- 24:17inspiration of the character. Because so little
- 24:20of what Poncho does is like, well... this is
- 24:23what I stand for. He kind of loses what he stands
- 24:25for for a while until, unfortunately, that hotel
- 24:28scene you're talking about at the end is when
- 24:30he actually starts talking about his father again,
- 24:32which was his whole inspiration for liberating
- 24:34Mexico to begin with from this tyrannical lead.
- 24:37So it's a tough beat. And for me, it was just,
- 24:42first off, not going to be a controversial statement.
- 24:46It's too long. It's about an hour and 55 minutes.
- 24:49It is very long. And there's so much that happens
- 24:52in this that takes way too long of, you know,
- 24:56Poncho. He's becoming a general under the eyes
- 24:59of Madero. And Madero really is almost like a
- 25:02father figure of like trying to help him understand
- 25:05this. But at the same time, Madero is also kind
- 25:07of gaslighting him a little bit of like, check
- 25:10out this guy. I'm going to try and get this guy
- 25:12to be on my side. Sure, yeah. And you can't tame
- 25:15an untamed horse. He's going to continue to be
- 25:18wild like this. And when he continues to kill,
- 25:21even though Madero is telling him not to, he
- 25:23ends up getting banished. And Madero fights for
- 25:27him. He's like, well, look, don't kill him or
- 25:28anything, but just let him go and release him.
- 25:30Well, what happened after the war was over and
- 25:33everything was all set to be good, him and his
- 25:37partner, Sierra, they go to the bank, which is
- 25:40also a... funny scene. I say I don't like the
- 25:42comedy in this and now I'm citing all these moments
- 25:44that I thought were funny. But Wallace Beery
- 25:46goes to the bank because now he's a respectable
- 25:49man. He's got all his money in the bank and he
- 25:51brings Sierra along and he shows up like five
- 25:54minutes after the bank closes and he's like,
- 25:56hey, I need 300 pesos or whatever. He's like,
- 25:59oh, I'm sorry, sir. We're closed. And right before
- 26:02Pancho Villa starts putting up an argument, Sierra
- 26:04walks behind the counter, knocks the guy out
- 26:06with his gun and he's like, how much money you
- 26:08want? Which is funny, but he ends up killing
- 26:11the guy. And that's what ultimately lands Pancho
- 26:15in trouble. It's funny, but it's... Out of place.
- 26:19Yeah, it's almost like the way, I guess, like
- 26:23the MCU now. You watch a movie and you're like,
- 26:26man, they really don't leave a moment to sit
- 26:29with the heavy beats of these movies. They undercut
- 26:33everything with a joke. And that's how a lot
- 26:35of this movie felt. And I don't know if that
- 26:37is a tactic. Of movies from the 30s? Because
- 26:41it feels like we see it kind of a lot. If not
- 26:44undercut with a joke, you don't get to sit with
- 26:46emotions very long. Well, it's probably worth
- 26:48noting, you know, you mentioned here at the beginning
- 26:50that the director, Jack Conway, isn't the only
- 26:54director that... had a part in this movie. Now,
- 26:57Jack Conway is the listed director, but there
- 27:00are technically, if you go on IMDb, you'll see
- 27:02two other names. And I didn't write down one
- 27:05of them. It was like William Daniels, something
- 27:08like that. Oh, hold on. Correct me. Sir, that's
- 27:11Mr. William Wellman. Wellman, thank you. Of Wings
- 27:14fame. William Wellman came in, took over. That
- 27:18didn't last very long. But the original director
- 27:19here was Howard Hawks. Yeah. So Howard Hawks
- 27:23was the original director. And also, The original
- 27:26actor who was playing Johnny was Lee Tracy. Right,
- 27:30yeah. So Lee Tracy was originally playing Johnny
- 27:34here, and he was recast by Stuart Irwin after
- 27:38something happened. Now. Here's where reports
- 27:41are kind of like mixed on what actually happened.
- 27:44And what was reported was that Lee Tracy was
- 27:46on the balcony of their hotel in Mexico while
- 27:48filming on location. And there was a military
- 27:51parade that was happening. The report is that
- 27:54Lee Tracy was urinating off of the balcony onto
- 27:58the parade and was then, of course, arrested.
- 28:01Now, the studio wants to make as MGM wants to
- 28:05make as nice with the country as possible with
- 28:07Mexico. So they're like, yeah. take Lee Tracy,
- 28:10like, you know, so we'll sacrifice him, like
- 28:12report or give him all of the, not in that way,
- 28:15but like arrest him, you know, charge him and
- 28:18everything. Like we won't use them in the movie
- 28:20anymore, but we need the director to kind of
- 28:22come out and like stand against him and say,
- 28:24yeah, he did this. And Howard Hawks, the director
- 28:26wouldn't do this. He refused to testify against
- 28:29Tracy. And that's because the reports on Hawks
- 28:33side and another like cinematographer, I believe
- 28:36said that what actually happened was one of the,
- 28:39People in the parade made an obscene gesture
- 28:41at Lee Tracy. My guess is like, you know, hey,
- 28:44you don't belong here, like made an obscene gesture
- 28:46at him. So, of course, Tracy returns the favor
- 28:49and gives a gesture back, which is seen as offensive
- 28:52and disrespectful. And that's what lands him
- 28:54in jail. So that's. reportedly why Howard Hawks
- 28:58wasn't like willing to testify against him because
- 29:00it wasn't true. Gotcha. But either way, when
- 29:03Howard Hawks told the studio, hey, I'm not going
- 29:05to testify against him. They're like, okay, well
- 29:06then you're gone too. And they let go Howard
- 29:09Hawks. So that then brought in William Wellman.
- 29:13I'm not sure what happened with William Wellman,
- 29:15but Jack Conway took over. Clearly the biggest
- 29:17controversy of it was the Howard Hawks and Lee
- 29:20Tracy of it all. And then that brought in Jack
- 29:23Conway, and it brought in Stuart Irwin as Johnny
- 29:26Sykes. So I say that to say that with three directors
- 29:29having a hand in this movie, I wonder if that
- 29:32affected the tone of this at all. Because the
- 29:35tone is one of my biggest issues with this. Yeah,
- 29:37and I think... It absolutely affected the tone
- 29:40and it affected the edits as well. There are
- 29:43so many cuts from like different emotional scenes
- 29:47where you're like, wow, this is heavy. Oh, okay.
- 29:49Now we're hanging out with Pancho Villa and a
- 29:52chicken on his car, which that made me laugh
- 29:56more than it should have when he like knocked
- 29:58the chicken off his car. Well, you know, it's
- 30:00also the way it was filmed. Like, this movie
- 30:02was filmed in 1931. Yeah. At least it started
- 30:05filming in 1931. And then, of course, it wasn't
- 30:07released until 1934. And multiple things sided
- 30:11with this, you know, problems on set, production
- 30:14issues, casting problems. So all of those things
- 30:17could be kind of, like, interpreted as the controversy
- 30:20we've talked about in Plus More. Another thing
- 30:23is that Wallace Beery did not like filming on
- 30:25location at all. Which is so funny because...
- 30:28Filming on location, there's a lot of scenes
- 30:30where, like, they are on location. And I think
- 30:32the movie looks great. But there's so much of
- 30:34this movie that utilizes screens as well. Yeah.
- 30:38Anytime they're, like, riding horses or— They're
- 30:42standing in town and people are riding horses
- 30:43behind them. Yes. Yes. Like, if there's—Pancho
- 30:47Villa's army is, like, riding behind him. It's
- 30:50all screens. So I'm just like, hey, man, like,
- 30:53sorry it was a little hot, but— You're not out
- 30:56there all that long doing anything intense. And
- 30:59then the battle scenes as well. I think that's
- 31:01a lot of what's missing from the Western movie
- 31:03here. Is you do see a lot of, like, in a room
- 31:08people are arguing and someone pulls a gun and
- 31:10shoots a guy. That kind of thing. There is a
- 31:12lot of violence in this movie. Yeah, more than
- 31:14I think we've seen thus far. But you don't have,
- 31:19like, for this guy who's riding into towns and
- 31:22taking them. by force you don't see a lot of
- 31:25that no at least not in a way where you're seeing
- 31:28poncho on the front lines doing things it feels
- 31:31like stock footage yeah it does and it feels
- 31:34almost like a montage of like we're riding in
- 31:37town and then we tell you we've taken the town
- 31:38and then you know repeat recycle repeat so it's
- 31:43it's funny that beery didn't like filming on
- 31:45location in mexico Because he had a private plane
- 31:48on standby, like ready to go whenever he wanted
- 31:51to leave. And I was like, okay, so is it taking
- 31:53him to like Texas or California, like on an off
- 31:56day? Where's it going? Mexico City. So he's still
- 31:59in Mexico. It's just in those specific cities
- 32:02that they were filming that he really didn't
- 32:03like it. So he would have the private plane take
- 32:05him to like Mexico City. in those down times
- 32:08when he could. I don't want to give him credit
- 32:10or anything for being very difficult, clearly,
- 32:13between Grand Hotel, not so much Grand Hotel,
- 32:16The Champ, everything we've seen him in previously,
- 32:19and then this. I don't want to give him too much
- 32:22credit where it's not needed, but I will say,
- 32:25for someone who has had this much controversy
- 32:27that we've read off screen, when he's on screen,
- 32:30when we're seeing how miserable he apparently
- 32:32is behind the scenes, he's... doing well like
- 32:36he doesn't seem like he doesn't want to be there
- 32:37he's not rushing through things i don't think
- 32:39the performance lands in the way something like
- 32:41the champ or even him in like grand hotel did
- 32:44but still like you got to give him credit like
- 32:46he is a good actor it's just he happens to not
- 32:48be the best individual off page yeah and i think
- 32:52his performances have declined for me pretty
- 32:55steadily as we've gone through this is probably
- 32:59my least favorite of the Barry performances.
- 33:02Big House being your favorite? I do. I really
- 33:04like The Big House. Yeah. But, like, I think
- 33:08he's fine here. I just don't think he was the
- 33:11person for this job. And not only just because
- 33:14Pancho Villa is a Mexican individual and Wallace
- 33:17Barry is not. That's obvious. But even if you're
- 33:20going to go the route of casting a white actor
- 33:22in this role, I don't think Barry was the best
- 33:25option for it. I mean, I agree. It seems like
- 33:30he would have played like he could play drunk
- 33:32really well. And that's a lot of what Pancho
- 33:34Villa is in this movie. Sure. And again, the
- 33:36buffoonery of that's not fair to say, but like
- 33:40the buffoon nature of the characters that Beery
- 33:43plays lends itself to a little bit of what they're
- 33:46trying to say with Pancho Villa here. I do want
- 33:48to touch on something you said here where obviously
- 33:50Wallace Beery. not a Hispanic individual, portraying
- 33:53Pancho Villa. Of the, I think I count 16 actors
- 33:57with like speaking parts that are like listed
- 33:59in this movie. Yeah. One of them is of Hispanic
- 34:02nature. And that's because his parents, I'm talking
- 34:05about Leo Carrillo, who portrayed Sierra that
- 34:08you mentioned. His parents were on the conquistador
- 34:12side of his family, so he technically has the
- 34:15heritage there. But otherwise, the other 15 individuals,
- 34:18not of Hispanic nature. And that is unfortunate.
- 34:22It really is. I can't speak to a lot of the brownface
- 34:27in this, but I mean... There's tons of it. It
- 34:30is terrible to see that, especially when you
- 34:33can see that there are multiple Hispanic individuals
- 34:36in the movie as background characters. Right.
- 34:39I will also say the production side of this movie,
- 34:42I don't fully know what they did or how they
- 34:44did it, but there's seemingly like 500 maybe
- 34:48like extras at a time just running through a
- 34:51scene. Yeah. Yeah. That's something I've always
- 34:53been interested about, especially when the extras
- 34:56or, or those scenes involving all the extras
- 34:59are a screen behind the leads. Right. It's a
- 35:03process that I do want to know more about, but
- 35:06yeah, I mean, as I'm watching the movie, I feel
- 35:09like every time a new character showed up on
- 35:11screen, there's that moment where I go, oh, good,
- 35:15they actually casted a Mexican individual. And
- 35:17then I look at the casting and I go, fooled me.
- 35:21And, you know, then I feel bad. But, like, Fay
- 35:23Wray shows up in this, right? Oh, man. And, obviously,
- 35:28going into this, Fay Wray we know from King Kong.
- 35:31And we know that she is not of Mexican descent.
- 35:34So I kind of knew what we were getting into with
- 35:36that. And when she shows up on screen, she plays,
- 35:39is it Madero's sister or is it another individual?
- 35:42I literally can't tell. There is at one point
- 35:45a character that is like, that's my sister. And
- 35:47I thought it was Johnny Sykes at first. It can't
- 35:49be. No, no, no. It's some guy towards the end,
- 35:52part of the political campaign. But ultimately,
- 35:56she kind of flirts a little bit with Poncho throughout
- 35:59the film. And towards the end, they share. A
- 36:04brief relationship together. And she kind of
- 36:09is the catalyst for the downfall of Pancho Villa
- 36:13as the movie progresses. Right. They have an
- 36:16evening together and they do argue at some point.
- 36:20And this is what leads to Pancho's heinous crime.
- 36:23Probably the most disgusting and hard to watch
- 36:26moment on screen. And something that really shifts.
- 36:31how we're supposed to feel about Pancho Villa
- 36:32here. They argue a little bit, and after they
- 36:35fight, he pulls out a whip and begins whipping
- 36:40Teresa, as Feyre's character is called, off screen.
- 36:44And her brother witnesses this, comes into the
- 36:49room, demands that he stops, draws a gun, Pancho
- 36:53puts up a struggle, goes to take it. She shoots
- 36:56him, actually, in the arm. Yep. And... So after
- 36:59the struggle, Poncho is leaving and he turns
- 37:01around and he fires the gun one time, says something
- 37:03snarky and then rides off. And there is kind
- 37:06of a fake out moment here. Were you unsure of
- 37:10what happened? Well, because there's like the
- 37:11moment that the gun goes off, it cuts to Teresa
- 37:14and she has like a drop of blood going down her
- 37:17mouth a little bit. So you're made to believe
- 37:19like she was shot and she's going to die. Yeah.
- 37:21Clearly she's already bleeding out of her mouth.
- 37:23Sure. But then we're the way that it's edited.
- 37:26It almost looks like her brother. has been hit.
- 37:29Like he freezes and it looks like he's grasping
- 37:32his stomach. And then he walks out and this part
- 37:37made me chuckle a little bit because Teresa starts
- 37:40to fall over and she's clearly dying. She falls
- 37:43into her brother's arms and he says, Teresa,
- 37:46what is it? Bro, what do you think it is? Maybe
- 37:49it was the bullet that was just lodged into her
- 37:51stomach. But ultimately she dies here and this
- 37:54sets the series of events that leads to Pancho's
- 37:58death yeah one thing i wanted to bring up here
- 38:01is you talk about fey ray playing theresa that
- 38:04wasn't originally the case mona maris was the
- 38:07original actress who was portraying theresa but
- 38:10it wasn't until wallace beery voiced his dissatisfaction
- 38:13with maris that she was then recast as fey ray
- 38:17so the part of theresa was like completely rewritten
- 38:20to kind of like make a little bit more of i guess
- 38:23like for the The filming, the time that they
- 38:26had, they had to rewrite a lot of it. Same situation
- 38:28for the character of Johnny Sykes, right? That
- 38:31originally recast. And there is footage, significant
- 38:34amount of footage of Lee Tracy playing Johnny
- 38:36Sykes. Wow. So then they have to recast him and
- 38:39refilm that as well with a different director.
- 38:42So to my earlier point, not only in the direction
- 38:46style, but also in the performances and the characters
- 38:48that are written. tonally this is just all over
- 38:51the place so yeah it's really difficult to kind
- 38:53of talk about this movie because it is all over
- 38:56the place and it's going a mile a minute while
- 38:58also being really slow at times sure so it it's
- 39:02a tough one yeah it's obviously just steeped
- 39:05in production disaster like all over the place
- 39:09not the worst that we've seen no like production
- 39:12disaster in the way that like a modern film would
- 39:15suffer from production issues not something where
- 39:18it's like yeah we brought everybody to africa
- 39:20and half the cast died like it's not that again
- 39:23we're looking at you traitor horn jeez but we're
- 39:26never gonna look at you again no i think one
- 39:28of the interesting things here and i would love
- 39:30to i don't know find a commentary track of this
- 39:34movie where someone is able to identify which
- 39:37sections of the movie were directed by it's three
- 39:41directors because there is a moment in a cantina
- 39:45where everybody's celebrating and there's like
- 39:48a girl dancing and that moment the way that the
- 39:52camera was moving and the way everything was
- 39:54set up and block the blocking i was like This
- 39:57feels like William Wellman to me. Wings. Yeah.
- 39:59Yeah. And I don't know if that's the case. Like
- 40:01the camera moves through a crowd and makes its
- 40:03way to the bar. Well, the humor of it, too, because
- 40:06I know what you're talking about. And there's
- 40:07like not a belly dancer, but there's like an
- 40:08exotic dancer in the middle of the room. And
- 40:12the camera kind of like pans back a little bit
- 40:14to show a couple sitting at the table. And the
- 40:16man is looking at the dancer and his partner,
- 40:19wife, whoever, like kind of slaps the backside
- 40:21of his head from like watching. So there's that
- 40:23little bit of humor, too. Yes. In the storytelling
- 40:26and the shot that wasn't in the previous shots
- 40:28that we've seen. Right. So it does feel out of
- 40:30place. I think you're right about that. I really
- 40:32want to know if that was Wellman or not. I bet
- 40:34you're right. I think the funny thing here is
- 40:36that we had... John Waters be nominated for assistant
- 40:40director. And the thing is, like, he is the man
- 40:44holding down the fort. Right. He is the glue
- 40:47to this just nightmare production. Your actors
- 40:51are getting recast. Your directors are getting
- 40:53fired left and right. And he's just like, guys,
- 40:56I need some help here, please. Yeah. It really
- 41:00almost was a consolation prize of like, hey,
- 41:02you survived. Right. Like, good job, man. Yeah.
- 41:05It took three years, but you did it. You did
- 41:07it. Props to you, John Waters. Can we talk about
- 41:10the violence in this movie? Yeah, absolutely.
- 41:13Because, again, I think this like we've seen
- 41:15some violence for sure on the podcast itself.
- 41:17I think the way people are casually shot just
- 41:22at random in this movie, like there's a moment
- 41:26where the the villains walk into Madero's office
- 41:32and there are two guards standing outside the
- 41:35door and they're just. While they're walking,
- 41:37their pace doesn't slow at all. And they're just
- 41:40bang, bang. Takes them both out. And there's
- 41:43so much of that in this movie. But you see it
- 41:46from the villain side, but also Poncho's side.
- 41:50Again, with Fay Wray's character, Teresa, and
- 41:53the whipping that occurs. The movie opens with
- 41:55extreme violence at the death of Poncho's father.
- 41:58Yep. After 100 lashes, I think. Yes. Really tense
- 42:02scene. I wish the movie stuck with that tone.
- 42:06Throughout more of it. But one of the biggest
- 42:08moments here is the man that killed Madero. Yeah.
- 42:14After Poncho captures him. This is General Pascal.
- 42:18Yes. There's a very intense moment where Poncho
- 42:22has him imprisoned. And the tables were reversed
- 42:26earlier in the film. And Pascal was going to
- 42:30have Poncho. executed by by firing squad and
- 42:34he does this whole thing where he gets him to
- 42:37crawl on his knees and beg for for mercy and
- 42:40all of this and after poncho is freed thanks
- 42:44to madero the the roles are reversed and poncho
- 42:48has him in prison and pascal is like hey i'm
- 42:52not gonna beg i don't do that like you're i'm
- 42:54ready for the firing squad and he keeps saying
- 42:56this and there's this really dark, twisted moment
- 42:59that I did not expect from a film in 1934 where
- 43:03Poncho's like, you know, I really like honey.
- 43:06Do you like honey? Let's put some honey on you.
- 43:09And immediately Pascal starts freaking out because
- 43:11he knows what this means. And he's dragged off
- 43:13screen as Poncho says, slather him in honey,
- 43:17put it all over his face, his eyes, his ears,
- 43:19his nose. And you just hear Pascal scream off
- 43:23screen. Yeah. It's haunting. it's a lot dude
- 43:27i was shaken well i think the problem is that
- 43:30again tone is a big issue of this because you
- 43:33have a lot of that comedy happening and then
- 43:34the next scene is them riding through a town
- 43:36where there's like people still hung up from
- 43:38like being like hanging so the tone of that is
- 43:42all over the place another part of this is i
- 43:44wonder how much of the off screen violence they
- 43:47were seeing affected this. Because the other
- 43:50thing that I forgot to mention is that Howard
- 43:51Hawks has cited, or has also been cited, that
- 43:55he left filming because he felt so unsafe on
- 43:58site. A lot of gun violence, a lot of, like,
- 44:01you know, bandits or, like, individuals with
- 44:03guns who were, like, on set, and he was more
- 44:06than happy to leave after, like, ten weeks. Interesting.
- 44:08So that's another report that exists out there,
- 44:10but clearly that was happening, of, like, there
- 44:12was violence offset as well, and some of the
- 44:14violence they were seeing. seeing in mexico may
- 44:16have been painting a bit of the violence they
- 44:18put into the movie sure so i wonder how much
- 44:21of that i mean clearly whether it be bears or
- 44:23whatever it might be covering them in honey and
- 44:25releasing them into the wild yeah like clearly
- 44:28there's some kind of violence and i wonder if
- 44:29they were kind of depicting that and i'm with
- 44:31you a lot of what the like both poncho's team
- 44:34and the enemies the villains in the movie the
- 44:37way they shot at times just kind of felt like
- 44:39almost they didn't have a gun and a gun was like
- 44:42photoshopped in later because it was just like
- 44:44from the hip like And not in a cool, like, quick
- 44:46way, but just like, bam, bam. Yeah. And the scene
- 44:50I talked about, the 12 -minute mark earlier,
- 44:52I was telling you about when they're, like, in
- 44:53a courtroom. And then Pancho comes in and says,
- 44:56it's now the court of Pancho Villa, or the court
- 44:58of Villa. At that point, they start shooting
- 45:00people. And it's even off -screen, but you can
- 45:02see his people start to shoot. And it just kind
- 45:04of looks like, okay, now I look here, and now
- 45:06I look there, and I look here. And it doesn't
- 45:08look like there's intentionality to it. Yeah.
- 45:09It looks just more like, bam, bam, bam, bam.
- 45:11Yeah, all of the action. It feels very chaotic
- 45:13and very unstructured. Agreed. And I think that,
- 45:17again, that's a big thing missing from the Western
- 45:19that I go to for, like, that's my purpose in
- 45:22watching a Western a lot of times. Right. But
- 45:25yeah, I was just shocked by the amount of violence.
- 45:27Some of it's not presented in a way that feels
- 45:31believable. And a lot of it is presented in a
- 45:34way that feels very casual. That surprised me.
- 45:36But specifically that moment with the honey.
- 45:39And the implication is that this man was left
- 45:41in the desert to be eaten by ants, I think. Oh,
- 45:45wow. Because they do a cut to, like, the jar
- 45:48of honey opened up on the ground and ants eating
- 45:51it. Oh, so it was like being eaten alive by insects.
- 45:54Yeah. Okay, I understand. I was like, I don't
- 45:56know how many bears are running around in Mexico.
- 45:58Yeah, no. It was ants and bugs and all of that,
- 46:01which is crazy. It's very dark. Very dark. I
- 46:03mean, it's a very sudden thing to happen if we
- 46:05just go out there and the ants immediately start.
- 46:08Anyways. Well, I think it was one of those like
- 46:09buried with just your head sticking out kind
- 46:12of thing. Okay. It wasn't shown, so. Yeah. Implications.
- 46:16Implications. Yeah, it's you know, it's it's
- 46:20rough because with this one, I think walking
- 46:22into the cast and hearing everything, you have
- 46:25some questions, but you're like, there's a way
- 46:26this can be done right. And ultimately, whether
- 46:28it be this traitor horn or I'm sure there's another
- 46:31scenario to come in the future, clearly filming
- 46:33on site across the seas isn't always the best
- 46:37call because there's just going to be not just
- 46:39the movie is going to be unfavorable, but mostly.
- 46:42production issues are just going to run rampant
- 46:45with something like this yeah i mean it seems
- 46:47to be pretty common for the movies we've covered
- 46:49the second they leave the states they've got
- 46:52issues going on right it's just hard to control
- 46:54a lot of that so it's it does affect the movie
- 46:57very heavily for me i couldn't enjoy it as much
- 46:59it's not all bad i agree like in the idea of
- 47:02like a western you can see the bones being formed
- 47:04here from something like In Old Arizona and what's
- 47:07to come in the future. We'll get to Stagecoach
- 47:10later in the year. So I'm very excited. Our year.
- 47:13Yeah. Decade for the story. Yeah, totally. And
- 47:17this has more like of, this is a historical film
- 47:21first, although based very heavily on fiction.
- 47:24Yeah. And a Western second, I think. That's true.
- 47:28And unfortunately, it just can't find the balance
- 47:31between those. Yeah. One last thing before we
- 47:34get into ratings. I want to point out Georgie
- 47:36Stone. Yeah. He returns. I just love talking
- 47:39about him. He is the gentleman, the artist that
- 47:42Poncho's like, hey, draw me as a bull. Oh, yeah.
- 47:47And he's drawing doves and stuff. Yeah, he keeps
- 47:49drawing the doves, which I'm sure is something
- 47:51where historically Poncho is associated with
- 47:54doves. And this is kind of like a fun little,
- 47:56well, how did that come to be? They do my boy
- 48:00George dirty at the end of this movie. They do.
- 48:02So this is the same character who is writing
- 48:05on the dollar, like the bills for Poncho. Right.
- 48:09So at one point he draws Poncho onto like the
- 48:12money and everything. And Poncho is looking at
- 48:14it and he sees a pigeon. And this was one of
- 48:17my favorite moments was just Wallace Beery just
- 48:19saying like, Pigeon! over and over just saying
- 48:23pigeon screaming it really yeah and georgie stone's
- 48:26in the corner like cowering away and he's like
- 48:28i wanted a bull and he's like i'm sorry i'm sorry
- 48:30so georgie stone not unfamiliar with being a
- 48:34little rat boy yeah does a great job in this
- 48:36for like the five ten seconds he's on screen
- 48:38oh he's in it a lot is he yeah so this is what
- 48:42i'm saying when they did him dirty at the end
- 48:43of the film when theresa's brother is up in the
- 48:46window getting ready to assassinate poncho right
- 48:50Georgie Stone's character approaches him in the
- 48:52street and he's like, Poncho, it's been a while.
- 48:54What's up here? Look at this thing I drew. And
- 48:57he's like, oh, my God, it's pigeons again. Draw
- 49:00me a bull. And in this moment, Poncho is assassinated
- 49:04by Teresa's brother. And Georgie Stone goes to
- 49:07cover him with the parasol that he's holding.
- 49:10And he's killed in the same moment as Poncho.
- 49:14And then Johnny Sykes runs up and he sees Poncho's
- 49:17body. But he doesn't say anything about George
- 49:20E. Stone. No, George E. Stone's body's been like
- 49:22pushed to the side. Yeah, he literally picks
- 49:24him up and pulls his body off of him. And I was
- 49:27just like, man, no closure for Emilio? Is that
- 49:31his name? I think there's something to be said
- 49:34about the fact you had to check your paper again
- 49:36to see what his name was. It's Emilio. Yeah,
- 49:38I just thought that was funny. I love Georgie
- 49:40Stone. I mean, me too. We've talked about building
- 49:43an award around him for the podcast. And we're
- 49:45doing it, baby. It's going to happen. We're doing
- 49:47it. So final ratings on Viva Via. Yeah, so Viva
- 49:51Via, I gave two and a half stars. I did not care
- 49:55for this one that much. You know, a lot of its
- 49:57sins, I think, could be overlooked if it wasn't
- 50:00as long. But a nearly two -hour film with the...
- 50:05casting issues and the production issues that
- 50:08affected the movie as much as it did, mostly
- 50:10in the tone and it feeling disconnected. Two
- 50:13and a half stars felt like the right call for
- 50:16me. I didn't want to go much lower than that
- 50:18because that feels disrespectful to the performance
- 50:20that Wallace Beery is giving, which is a performance
- 50:23and just the size of something like this. And
- 50:27the story of Pancho Villa is an important one,
- 50:29clearly, to the Mexican culture. So it's rough,
- 50:32but... I'd say two and a half is probably the
- 50:36fairest review I can give it. Yeah. I like this.
- 50:38I had fun with it. I saw you gave it, I saw your
- 50:40rating. I don't want to announce it. I gave it
- 50:42three stars. Yeah. Which, you know, I say I liked
- 50:45it and then I give it three stars, but I think
- 50:46that's kind of where I sit for most things. You
- 50:49know, three is like it, four is... And liked
- 50:52it a lot, and Five has loved it. My buddy, Anthony,
- 50:56told me that his Letterboxd concept of three
- 50:59stars is, for certain genres, the most like...
- 51:03Yeah, I saw it. Yeah. That's the review of that
- 51:06movie. Interesting. Yeah, I did see it. Fascinating.
- 51:08It's just middle of the road. Yeah, no, I enjoyed
- 51:10this movie. I think that the tone, you know,
- 51:13it goes up and down from... Really heavy drama
- 51:16and really intense violence, like with the ant
- 51:19scene to like silly, goofy comedy. But the more
- 51:23I talked about it, even here, I enjoyed a lot
- 51:26of the comedic beats when Poncho is getting married
- 51:28and they're being rushed out the door because
- 51:30they have to go do bandit stuff. Yeah. And he's
- 51:34like, do you promise to love and hold dear your
- 51:38wife and all of that? And he goes, I'll try my
- 51:40best. Like, that's pretty funny. You know, it's
- 51:43silly, goofy. I'm with you in this. It's definitely
- 51:47too long. I will stand by that. And I think tonally
- 51:52it misses the beat a lot. And, you know, I don't
- 51:54think Wallace Berry is the best person for this
- 51:57film. But overall, like just entertainment value.
- 52:01I had an okay time with it. Yeah. And I agree
- 52:04with you. You know, it's not terrible. It's just
- 52:06after a while, I'm like, I just, I can't connect
- 52:08with Poncho or really anyone outside of maybe
- 52:11Johnny. Like, and with Johnny, it's not even
- 52:14like you can connect with him. You just clearly
- 52:15see that he sees his angle. But otherwise, you
- 52:18just don't see the inspiration from a lot of
- 52:20people. Yeah. I also, I would be remiss if I
- 52:23didn't mention Madero's death scene in this movie.
- 52:26I don't know if you caught it, but there's a
- 52:28scene where when he's being executed by Pascal,
- 52:31he says like, hey, can I just write like one
- 52:34quick letter to like a friend? And they're like,
- 52:36yeah, who is it? And he's like, well, it's my
- 52:37most trusted champion, and I believe in them.
- 52:40And he's writing on a piece of paper to Poncho,
- 52:43where he's like, you know, my one true, I'm paraphrasing,
- 52:45my one true champion, basically admitting like,
- 52:48you know, I absolve you of your sins, and I'm
- 52:50sorry that like we weren't as close, and I need
- 52:53you now kind of thing. And while he's writing
- 52:55this, Pascal and his team shoot him, and he falls
- 52:58onto the desk. But this is what I wanted to point
- 53:01out. In the shot, it's over his shoulder. And
- 53:04while he's writing, he's shot in the same scene.
- 53:07He falls onto the desk and his hand is just right
- 53:10of the ink glass that he's been dipping his pen
- 53:13in. And he didn't knock it over when he fell
- 53:15over. So his hand kind of like reaches up and
- 53:17knocks it over and like falls back down. And
- 53:19I was like, all right, we couldn't have found
- 53:22a better scene of like him just and then fall
- 53:24back down. No. So it's very funny because the
- 53:27idea is that the ink, the ink. glass is supposed
- 53:31to fall onto the paper then rendering that like
- 53:34this paper can't go out so he's writing this
- 53:36to poncho and it's not going to get out there
- 53:37so when he missed that he just kind of knocked
- 53:39over real quick i thought that was very funny
- 53:41look man you can't the dailies were a lot different
- 53:45yeah it's like they had three years to film this
- 53:47look jack conway was probably like yeah we got
- 53:51that scene right and howard hux was like uh i
- 53:55meant to reshoot that but i'm gone so they're
- 53:58like yeah good enough Let's talk about double
- 54:00features. Yeah. So I will start. I went with
- 54:03a film that follows a historical figure. Maybe.
- 54:07Maybe it's factual. Maybe it's fictional. Who
- 54:11knows? But in like a war setting as well. I won't
- 54:15beat around the bush. I went with Mel Gibson's
- 54:17The Patriot. Oh. Yeah. Not nominated for Best
- 54:21Picture. Nope. Oh, interesting. Rightfully so,
- 54:24I think. We were just talking about whether or
- 54:25not our misunderstanding of films, 2000s and
- 54:28on. When was this released? 90s? Oh, boy. Hold,
- 54:32please. It might be like 98, 99. 2000. Right
- 54:35on the line. Yeah. Crazy. Yeah, it's been a long
- 54:39time since I've seen it. I remember enjoying
- 54:41it for the most part. I think I've seen this
- 54:43more than I've seen Braveheart. Oh, wow. Yeah,
- 54:47but this is the story of the Revolutionary War
- 54:49and one man. Basically creating his own army
- 54:54of guerrilla soldiers and fighting to avenge
- 54:57the death of his son, maybe? That sounds right.
- 55:00Yeah, it's been a while. I forget, but I think
- 55:03it's okay for a double feature. Also, I realize
- 55:06it's not at all the same country, but I do confuse
- 55:09Braveheart and Patriot every once in a while
- 55:11with Mel Gibson. Do you really? Well, just because
- 55:13it's Mel Gibson. That's fair. Also, not directed
- 55:16by Mel Gibson. I said Mel Gibson's the Patriot.
- 55:18It's Roland Emmerich. Well, Mel Gibson is the
- 55:20Patriot. He is. I really wish they would have
- 55:23done that for, like, the trailer of, like, Mel
- 55:24Gibson is the Patriot. Yeah. Versus Jean -Claude
- 55:28Van Damme as not the Patriot. Not a Patriot.
- 55:33Yeah. Yeah, good pick. Sorry. Well, you picked
- 55:38it, so. My double feature, I also went with a
- 55:40historical figure in this way. I actually tried
- 55:42to do something that I think Wallace Beery did
- 55:45not necessarily do here, which is honor the Mexican
- 55:48culture of a specific Civil rights activist.
- 55:53I went with Cesar Chavez, the 2014 film directed
- 55:56by Diego Luna. This is where Michael Pena portrays
- 56:00the civil rights activist. Pretty good. I saw
- 56:04this in theaters. They had a screening of it,
- 56:05actually. Not the best, but I thought it was
- 56:08an accurate portrayal of the story that I've
- 56:10heard of this individual. And I also just kind
- 56:13of wanted to pair this with something that I
- 56:15thought was like the yin and yang of like, you
- 56:18know, a culture. So made by, for, the Mexican
- 56:22community. So, great. I would definitely suggest
- 56:25Cesar Chavez, the 2014 version. Also, love Diego
- 56:28Luna. I don't think he directed a ton after this.
- 56:30You're familiar with Diego Luna, yeah? He's Cassian
- 56:33Andor, right? He is Cassian Andor. Yeah, there
- 56:35you go. There's got to be one other person in
- 56:37the audience that was like, that's Cassian Andor.
- 56:40So, I'm glad you helped them fill a scene. Yeah.
- 56:43Yeah, totally. Solid double feature. Way more
- 56:45representative than mine. Well, mine was direct,
- 56:48starring a monster. No, no, here's the thing.
- 56:50I thought that this was true. I thought that
- 56:53this was a good double feature from both of us
- 56:55because whereas I was trying to see if we could
- 56:58better honor the specific community that I think
- 57:00was not honored extremely well in this movie,
- 57:02you took the angle of a historical story because
- 57:06this wasn't super historical, right? This was
- 57:09blending reality with fiction. And again, something
- 57:12The Patriot kind of does, but more of a historical.
- 57:15depiction and this tone all over the place with
- 57:18this yeah i went with a double feature that someone
- 57:22that pronounced this film viva villa would enjoy
- 57:25oh i love i watched the patriot today and i watched
- 57:28viva villa i tell you what that mel gibson and
- 57:31the patriot oh what's the there's a line specifically
- 57:37from hank hill that every time taylor hears it
- 57:39at one point there's jehovah's witness or something
- 57:41comes to his house they they quote the bible
- 57:44and they say something about like What about
- 57:46Love Thy Neighbor, John 316? And he's like, get
- 57:48out of my house, Exodus. And Taylor's always
- 57:54just losing her mind. I love Hank Hill. He's
- 57:56so good. Very excited for the new season to come
- 57:58out. Yeah, me too. But yeah, that's Viva Villa.
- 58:00You know, that's the best way to do it. Like,
- 58:03that was Viva Villa. It's fine. It's fine. I
- 58:07wonder. What Wallace Berry's legacy is going
- 58:10to be by the end of our time with him on the
- 58:13show? I think it's going to be someone who has
- 58:15such potential and has done a great job. I agree
- 58:19with you, Big House. Thinking about it now, you're
- 58:22right. Everything we've seen him in, like the
- 58:25order, the chronology of what we've seen him
- 58:27in has been best to worst to me. I think so.
- 58:31Where I can't say that I loved the champ, but
- 58:33clearly he's doing great work in it. And then
- 58:36Grand Hotel. He's kind of a side character, so
- 58:39it's hard to say he was amazing, but I thought
- 58:41he was good in it. And then in this, you see
- 58:43him performing, and it's not that he's a bad
- 58:45actor. It's just you misread the part. So the
- 58:48performances are my least favorite going down
- 58:51the line. Yeah, same here. So I think he has
- 58:53the ability, and I've really enjoyed his performances
- 58:57for the most part in his presence. The whole
- 58:59who me. I mean, look. most of the movies we're
- 59:02watching now, someone's saying like, who me all
- 59:04the time. Yeah. And every time I'm like, that's
- 59:06Wallace Berry. That's Wallace Berry. So it's,
- 59:09it's great, but I think it's just, he's going
- 59:11to be plagued with a lot of off screen behind
- 59:13the scenes being very difficult to work with.
- 59:17Yeah. I think that's going to plague him a bit.
- 59:19I think so too, but I guess we'll find out. We
- 59:22will. As we see him, I think at least two more
- 59:25times. So, but if you enjoyed this episode, And
- 59:30you watched Viva Via or any of the other films
- 59:32we're watching for the 1935 Academy year. Feel
- 59:36free to shoot us your thoughts at OUTAOPodcast
- 59:39at gmail .com. A reminder that we do have the
- 59:43episode, the very first episode of our Patreon
- 59:46exclusive bonus show where we cover horror films
- 59:50that were passed by by the Academy. Horror of
- 59:54the Overlooked. That episode comes out. June
- 59:5613th, and it's a 30 -minute episode where we
- 59:59talk about those movies. I'm looking forward
- 1:00:01to it. It's going to be a good time. I'm very
- 1:00:03much looking forward to it. Obviously, we both
- 1:00:05love horror a lot, so it's going to be really
- 1:00:08fun to talk about the movies that were overlooked
- 1:00:10in that time, including, you know, for 1934,
- 1:00:12we just did The Black Cat on the watch party,
- 1:00:16and that's something that's going to factor into
- 1:00:17that story. Absolutely. And then... A reminder
- 1:00:21again, June 16th is our next watch party, so
- 1:00:24if you want to participate, check out the Patreon.
- 1:00:26And next episode, we will be covering The Thin
- 1:00:30Man. Which is available video on demand, or if
- 1:00:34you have a library card, check out Canopy. Also
- 1:00:37want to point out that Viva Via, it's very hard
- 1:00:39to find. It's something that Kyle and I had to
- 1:00:41do some research in order to find a way to watch
- 1:00:44it. Physical media, not very available. Not available
- 1:00:46for Prime Rental or video on demand. It does
- 1:00:49have a physical release, though. It does. If
- 1:00:51you can track it down. Okay. Well, then you could
- 1:00:53find it. Can't say it's worth a huge amount of
- 1:00:57time to find, but certainly good luck out there
- 1:01:01finding it. Yeah, totally. So stay tuned for
- 1:01:03The Thin Man and the other films of the 7th Academy
- 1:01:06year. As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll
- 1:01:09see you at the movies. Played by Henry B. Walthall?
- 1:01:26Walthall? Walthall? I love how I'm looking at
- 1:01:32you. I'm like, you've said every name perfectly.
- 1:01:34You tell me what his name is. We're going to
- 1:01:37say Walthall. Yeah. I couldn't find him. Did
- 1:01:44I make his name up? Who plays Francisco Madero?
- 1:01:48I think it's Walthall. Okay, Walthall. I don't
- 1:01:51know. You're going to say Walthall? So Francisco
- 1:01:55Madero is portrayed by Henry Walthall. So he...
- 1:01:59This is going to be tough to get through.