Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Black Mirror - Joan Is Awful (Chapter 2)
Transcript
- 0:00All right, Berto, this is part two in our very lengthy and tangent
- 0:05filled discussion about the Dow Black Mirror episode Joan is Awful. So let's get
- 0:10back to it. What do you say, Let's do it. This is
- 0:13the Psychology in Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kacana. I'm a
- 0:16therapist under professor. My name is I mean, you know what I do?
- 0:20So that's true. All right, let's get back into it. When
- 0:23you watched Joan is awful because I feel like with Black Mirror, it produces
- 0:30some kind of a feeling, like anxiety or concern about the future, or
- 0:35self reflection. You know, it's designed to do that. It's the Black
- 0:38Mirror, right, It's supposed to make you look at your life or your
- 0:42society. So when you were watching it or when it concluded, how did
- 0:46it make you feel on the inside? Okay, let me think when it
- 0:51ended, I felt some amount of fear. And the amount of fear I
- 0:56felt was related to that? How not so far from possibilities? This could
- 1:02be the well. In fact, I was just lamenting this to our friend
- 1:07Mitch. I was telling him how there's so many videos now of celebrities fake,
- 1:11fake videos, of celebrities, like have you seen all the ones that
- 1:14Arnold in all the old movies? Like they put Arnold in old movies.
- 1:18Yeah, but it's I've seen. Of course, this is not with his
- 1:22permission. He gets no money from this whatever. And now is Arnold someone
- 1:25who needs a lot of help in life? No, of course not.
- 1:26But that's not the point. I feel like, but where's the like,
- 1:32where's the authority over one's body, image, voice, all these things?
- 1:34So I see this and I'm like, oh god, oh God, oh
- 1:38God. And just like the horror of imagine if in reality someone could just
- 1:42usurp your life and your stories and all your things and put them out there
- 1:46for everyone to look at, laugh, GoF whatever, and you have no
- 1:49say over it. Right. That was horrifying. Yeah, I mean that's
- 1:52already happening, right, Yeah. And I guess another thought that I had
- 1:56was, Okay, at some point, presumably you know, when revenge porn
- 2:00first came out, Yeah, there weren't laws that addressed that specifically, So
- 2:05people were doing all these really horrible, immoral, eventually criminal things. But
- 2:10now it's against law from my understanding, and thus you don't see it anymore
- 2:15or at least it's not out there for the common usage. But and right
- 2:21now we're at a stage and so I presume in ten years, right there
- 2:24will be laws. I figure there will be like someone will be harmed,
- 2:29like you know, a soccer mom is depicted, and you know, maybe
- 2:34not even porn. Let's just say that someone that doesn't like her or her
- 2:38teenage kid or something makes a video, a long video, not just a
- 2:43short one, but like a twenty minute video of her walking down the street
- 2:47and taking a dump on someone's lawn or something, and it blows up on
- 2:51the internet, and she gets harmed by it. People get concerned. They
- 2:58because you know, you could demonstrate, and you could bring psychologists into the
- 3:01courtroom to say even though by the next day or the next week, everyone
- 3:07who thought that was the soccer mom that did that was informed otherwise, the
- 3:13damage is done. Yeah, because that that for that week that the community
- 3:19thought it was her. It's noticeable because we have these other studies that demonstrate
- 3:22once that's in the person's head, it's sort of like when you wake up
- 3:25in the morning and you had a dream about someone that you knew. That's
- 3:29right, like you like your spouse, a negative dream. Yeah, even
- 3:31though you now know it was a dream, you feel a little different about
- 3:37This happens to me all the time, and it's horrible, right you wake
- 3:39up, I wake up angry like I can't believe you did that or whatever,
- 3:45and you know, one hundred percent you know it's like it's just a
- 3:46dream. Yeah, but your brain was fully convinced. So and once that
- 3:51memory is in there, you can't just erase it. No, you can't
- 3:53race it doesn't weren't that way, and it'll affect behavior moving forward. So
- 3:57you know, you could demonstrate that even though, or you can even potentially
- 4:00demonstrate that even if you're told upfront it's fake, it can actually alter the
- 4:04way you would behave for something anyway. So presumably you know there'll be a
- 4:08law about it. But on the other hand, it doesn't stop an individual
- 4:12just doing it in their homes, right, and maybe showing it to a
- 4:15few friends or just watching it on their own on their own, because eventually
- 4:18this technology would you'll just you know, just be on your computer and it'll
- 4:23be this tiny little section of your computer. And so someone could say,
- 4:26like I just want Umberto and Kirk to be having sex, right, right,
- 4:33and and they could just make it for themselves. And you're like,
- 4:38well, it's only one person, but it's just like, well, I
- 4:40don't care if it's one person. I don't. You know, you can,
- 4:43you can imagine it in your head. Yeah, let's all just take
- 4:45a second. Imagine Kirk and Embarrel having sex. Oh my god, why
- 4:48are you pointing these ideas in people's but so, listener, I just want
- 4:51you to think about just really think. No, no, no, you
- 4:55already thought about it. I know you did, Listener. I want you
- 4:57to think about, Okay, why did you why did you engineer our bodies
- 5:01in that way? Yeah? And I'm not gonna shame you. I don't
- 5:03like it, but it says something about you that you put me there and
- 5:08Berto there. Yeah that's weird in that position. Yeah, I'm just saying
- 5:12it says more about you than it does about us. I also feel a
- 5:15little dizzy from it. Frankly, you would feel, believe me, you
- 5:20best with the bull, you get the horns out. Yeah. Um so
- 5:25I had the same exact same fear. As I'm watching it, I'm like,
- 5:29well, you know, and it's it's done for comedy, and it's
- 5:31outlandish and cartoonish. But but as it was wrapping up, I was like,
- 5:38well, it was a similar feeling. Don't look up, I'm watching
- 5:42it. I'm like, oh my gosh, that one really feel. This
- 5:44is just so it's so cartoonish, but and that's more consequential. Yeah,
- 5:47of course I felt nauseous at the end. I was like, oh god,
- 5:51yeah, it's like, well, and that's what black Mirrors for.
- 5:55Yeah, and that's what it did to me, was, you know,
- 5:58watching Jonas off, I'm like, and I also, I mean, it's
- 6:01funny to think about it happening to other people, but right, it could
- 6:04be us, Yeah, it could be people. You. So, there
- 6:08are many things I appreciate it, Like I love metas stories and things where
- 6:12they you know, subvert. Like one thing I was thinking as it was
- 6:15playing when it first started, I was waiting for like the tech angle,
- 6:20you know, I'm like, oh, what's going on, what's going on?
- 6:21Where's the tech angle? And then when it landed, I'm like,
- 6:25oh, right, go. As soon as they actually, as soon as
- 6:27they sat on the couch they said let's watch something, I'm like, oh,
- 6:30I kind of knew. I'm like, they're gonna do some computer generated
- 6:33thing, right, and then when they showed her, I'm like, oh,
- 6:36they're like generating her life. So I kind of knew, But then
- 6:41I thought that was the end of the subterfugere. I don't know why I
- 6:43didn't think to think that they could pull a matrix on us, like,
- 6:46Okay, this isn't based reality. Interesting. I didn't see that one coming,
- 6:49so I did, which I don't usually and you usually do. And
- 6:54I think it's because I was expecting them to go like I said the other
- 6:57way, which was that this was some sort of a plot to make people
- 7:00realize how horrible they normally are. When they got to Michael Sarah actually took
- 7:04me a moment. I'm like, wait, what's up. Oh, oh,
- 7:06of course, because usually I one I don't usually see them, and
- 7:13two, I think it's because if I'm really engrossed in a story, I
- 7:16don't actually want to pull myself out. I want to just go along for
- 7:20the ride. You don't want to spend all your time thinking, well,
- 7:24I don't want to. I don't want to ruin it. I want to
- 7:27I want to stay in the story. But for some reason, Black Mirror,
- 7:30I guess, makes you do that. Well, so I'm going through
- 7:33that and I'm really enjoying it. And by the way, Samahayak was funny,
- 7:36like it was all great, very good acting stuff, but then also
- 7:41that feeling of like, oh, because not all Black Mirror episodes do that
- 7:45to me. Some of them are interesting thought experiments, but a little too
- 7:49off for me to like really be worried, but some definitely and this one
- 7:55definitely. Yeah. You know, it's like and it's prescient of Charlie Brooker
- 8:01because he couldn't have known that AI would have just been massively talked about in
- 8:07our society, Like he couldn't have known that that because if this episode came
- 8:13out a year ago, it would have with me. And I know more
- 8:18than the average person does about future tech. You obviously know a lot more
- 8:22about this topic. But if you showed me this episode a year ago,
- 8:24I would have been like, huh, well, you know that'll never happen
- 8:28in my lifetime. You show it to me today, I'm like, it's
- 8:31kind of happening now. So well, I wonder how long ago they filmed
- 8:35it. I mean it must have been after they developed these things years in
- 8:39advance. There's no way that they started working on a last month. Yea,
- 8:43like the contracts and the famous people and the location. I guess the
- 8:46trends were already there, so yeah, they are always working on trends that
- 8:50are very but they couldn't have known that this topic would have blown up so
- 8:54significantly. Yeah. I don't think anyone predicted because you know AI as you
- 8:58know, it's been chugging along for decades. How could you know that in
- 9:03the the inflection point was a little surprising, Yeah, because correct me if
- 9:09I'm wrong. But Chat GPT before Chat GPT, there were other versions.
- 9:13Of course, there were other outfits there were doing first in the fall,
- 9:18even before GPT four that was already a GPT three point five. Yeah,
- 9:22and that's not the first large language model, right, So why Chat?
- 9:28Why it? Really? It really was, it was they crossed a boundary
- 9:31of size of the of the model and the complexity of the model to the
- 9:35point where it became more than just a novelty where it was like it got
- 9:39better way a minute, like it actually got better. Yeah, because you
- 9:43went from like the very previous version being like, wow, that's pretty cool,
- 9:46that's a pretty cool trick, to wait, what do you mean it
- 9:48just passed the bar exam, But what do you mean, like you could
- 9:52fully spe that kind of stuff, because if someone had shown me the ability,
- 9:56because to me, what made chat chat GP to explode was literally everyone
- 10:01could try it out themselves. Right, I'm assuming you could have tried it
- 10:05out last year. Well you could have tried other things last year, for
- 10:07sure. But there's been chatbots for decades, right, So what was it?
- 10:13So it must have been that it crossed the line into newsworthiness because if
- 10:18someone told me, because no one, if anyone would have told me last
- 10:20year. Look, there's a kind of good chat that GPT, you know
- 10:24whatever chat GPT two that you can kind of fiddle around with. I would
- 10:28have fiddled around with it for a second, But no one said anything to
- 10:31me because because it wasn't the news, because it wasn't passing the bars.
- 10:35Yeah, but look the second one, the second shoes about to drop here
- 10:37soon we've had Sirie. Hey, I won't say it, yeah Google yah,
- 10:45because otherwise it'll trigger everyone. And Annie Murphy's character on Ship's Creek is
- 10:50also named after one of the things. Right, and they have Alex all
- 10:56these things, right, We've had these four years and we are all familiar
- 11:00with them. We can say some commands to it, all these things,
- 11:01but we're like only a couple releases away from having full human conversations with these
- 11:05things using the equivalent of chat chypt But but but first listening to the voice,
- 11:11changing it to the what the text is, then changing it back.
- 11:13But that's possible, it just hasn't been fully packaged nice like, well,
- 11:16would it be a true personal assistant where it would have like administrative access to
- 11:22your calendar and stuff, and yes, but even putting the assistant part to
- 11:26the side for a second, just conversation about the conversation. Yeah, that
- 11:30you can literally sit there being like, I mean, what did you think?
- 11:33How are you doing? And it will be yeah, like and this
- 11:37isn't sci fi, this is you can do this right this second, right
- 11:39and it'll inflect like because you know exactly the way that Siri talks, right,
- 11:45it's very compute, and you can do it with famous people's voices.
- 11:48That all of this, by the way, is right now. You just
- 11:50got to go download the right models. But we are like a couple of
- 11:54consumer wave from consumer grade version is very soon. So that's another shoe that's
- 11:58going to drop because but yet we've had these things for years. Yeah.
- 12:01So along those lines, Burto, there's a possibility one that people would be
- 12:07able to pirate our voices so that they could talk to us or and this
- 12:11just occurred to me, we could sell it or make it ourselves free available
- 12:16from you know, but then maybe we could have some control over it,
- 12:20you know, like it. Let's just make an app, and then with
- 12:22this app you can talk to us. Yeah yeah, yeah, and then
- 12:24you could the official licensed one. You can add in filters like well,
- 12:28don't say these don't let them go down these roads. Right, and there's
- 12:31easter eggs like if you do say certain things, we will go down those
- 12:35You will get the bull, you will get the horns. Yeah. So
- 12:39okay, let's take another break, Burto. When we get back, let's
- 12:43actually talk about what what the moral of the story is. What do you
- 12:46say? Let's do it all right, we're back from the break. Let's
- 12:52do an opp What do you say? Oh baby, these people became patrons
- 12:56all the way back in twenty twenty and stayed patrons thick and thin. We
- 13:00have Valerie from Burneh, what do you think? Oh, this is Switzerland,
- 13:07Switzerland, Switzerland. Rights I've learned. I've adapted Marie Anne from France,
- 13:15Emily from Great Britain, Brighton Fatima or Fatima from Chicago, because I've
- 13:20heard both. I knew him, I knew a Fatima and I knew uh
- 13:24Fatima. Veronica from Columbia, Missouri, August from Dearborn, Michigan, Flory
- 13:33from the Netherlands, Emory's from Dublin, Ohio, Dublin in Ohio, Denise
- 13:41from Duncan, British Columbia, Zachary from Everett, Washington. Oh Wow,
- 13:45good old Everett. Emily from California, Leslie from Maryland, Maria from Helsinki,
- 13:52Finland, Alison from Ivanhoe, Australia, Leva Leva from Latvia. I'm
- 14:01gonna guess lt sounds like a lot thank you for being a patron and staying
- 14:05with patron through thick and thin. WHOA seemed like a lot of international with
- 14:11folks in that group. It's like, I wonder what I wonder, you
- 14:13know, because sometimes it has to do with content that I make that will
- 14:18motivate people to become a pandemic. Right it was, But just that section
- 14:24of time, I wonder if there was something about that I talk about Finland
- 14:26or so Berto. What's the moral of the story of Joan is awful?
- 14:33Well, I think that from one angle it is it is a thinking of
- 14:37like, hey, listen, you may think that being the protagonist of your
- 14:41story means something, but that might backfire, it might not be what you
- 14:46wanted. And yet you can be the protagonist of your story if you kind
- 14:50of take more a well well grounded ownership and you're careful with others and your
- 14:54and your empathetic and things like that. I kind of saw that one,
- 14:58but I also see a sort of like a different angle on it, which
- 15:01was it was a little darker actually, which was your life. Basically,
- 15:05you are not a good person. You're not a good person, and so
- 15:11if you were the protagonist of your story, everyone would hate you. It's
- 15:16a dark thing. But that that they were showing this person that seems very
- 15:18normal and yet immediately comes off as a villain, well yeah, and barring
- 15:24the possibility that the originally the real Joane wasn't even bad at all, and
- 15:31that any Murphy Jane was always a little worse and so you know, but
- 15:35one of the things depicted in the show that is a relatable experience is what
- 15:41if your spouse ye were to literally hear the conversations you're having about them behind
- 15:48their back when you're maybe a little upset or friends or co workers or bosses
- 15:54or whatever. Yeah, yeah, yeah, everyone, you're a horrible person.
- 15:58You're one of those villains, right And what does that say? Does
- 16:00that mean that's a bad thing that you shouldn't be saying those things, or
- 16:06you should be wording it differently, or what what do you think? Yeah?
- 16:08Well, so obviously I don't actually agree with the premise that and I
- 16:12don't think that's necessarily their intention. The idea is, as I could read
- 16:18it, is like, look, we took this woman. Yeah, once
- 16:19you see that, that's not even base reality fair enough, they might be
- 16:22exciting. But even if you don't do that, what were the worst things
- 16:26that this person was doing. One, they were having second thoughts about their
- 16:30relationship and they had a misadventure with someone that they used to have a relationship
- 16:33with. Okay, that's not fair to their partner, but this happens day
- 16:37and day out to people. Two, they had to fire someone. They
- 16:41could have shown more empathy, right, like it, But it's tough.
- 16:45It's tough to fire. Okay, number three? Was there a number three?
- 16:48Like? Right? Like, this person is actually very normal, very
- 16:52run of the mill, and they made mistakes, okay, but as soon
- 16:56as it was highlighted to other people, they become a villain. And this,
- 17:00to me is akin to the online experience we have already, which is,
- 17:03look, we put an episode out, you say one thing slightly off
- 17:07to some people, and all of a sudden, you're a villain. I
- 17:10say something, I'm a villain. We are villains instantly, and even just
- 17:15like if you're a little off a mark right let alone, if someone could
- 17:18actually see your whole day, your whole reality, and everything you say and
- 17:23everyone you talk to, can you imagine the villainy? So that, from
- 17:27my perspective is like real. But does that mean that we need to all
- 17:32like that we are really all villains? Well? No, that is part
- 17:36of the human condition. Well what about specifically talking about your spouse behind your
- 17:41back? Oh, that's specific one. You know. I don't think that's
- 17:44fair. It's not fair to have someone listen to what you said about them.
- 17:49Yeah, okay, So this is interesting because, on the one hand,
- 17:52if you're saying really horrible things about your partner, your friend, your
- 17:56whatever behind their back. Well, that's not healthy. That's not healthy.
- 18:00It's probably something that would be bad anyways. But there's also this fine line
- 18:06between the right to privacy, right, and so if you're saying things about
- 18:10someone to someone else and then that's being spied upon without your knowledge consent,
- 18:15well it's also invading your privacy as well. Let me give a scenario.
- 18:18Let's say that you berto are talking about your wife and you don't expect her
- 18:25to be home, right, and so you're talking with someone on the phone,
- 18:27and let's say if you're with someone long enough you've been with your wife,
- 18:33there's probably two or three things. Well, I'd be saying, like,
- 18:36well, I expect her to wear exactly what I need her to wear
- 18:37at you know, you know, seriously, we all have a set of
- 18:45things that annoy us about our partner. Yeah that when we are particularly annoyed
- 18:51by it, or maybe even just day to day if our partner weren't around,
- 18:56we might word it in a plain manner. So you're in the phone
- 19:00and you're complaining about your wife about one of those things, and it's not
- 19:03a deal breaker to you, right, but it is annoying and you're kind
- 19:07of venting, right, Yeah, I'm venting. Your wife comes home and
- 19:11hear and overhears it. Right, it's not an invasion of your privacy,
- 19:14but it was a mistake of scheduling or whatever. She overhears it and she's
- 19:19devastated by yea, and for a month she's upset. She's talking like,
- 19:26why are you even with me? Whatever? What went wrong? Obviously she
- 19:29didn't do any wrong, but what went wrong there? I mean, it's
- 19:33hard. That's a hard thing to say if something went wrong, because I
- 19:37would be the same thing, Like if I came home and I heard her
- 19:40saying something really mean, I'd be devastated too. And I wasn't spying.
- 19:45And maybe what they were saying was was fair. They were talking to no
- 19:48friend. But is it normal, even within a healthy, loving marriage relationship
- 19:53to have those kinds of annoyances that you might, maybe even in a healthy
- 19:57manner, need event about now? Yeah, you know that's probably right.
- 20:02I mean, I guess when I think about my specific case, I don't
- 20:06know. She's probably venting right as we speak, But in my case,
- 20:10like I am more of unopen books, probably everything that I would say about
- 20:14her to someone I've already told her for better or for worse. But that
- 20:18said, it doesn't mean I might word it differently or I might emphasize it
- 20:21more or yeah, and it's true, it's a it's an unfortunate situation of
- 20:26that where to happen. Yeah, I think the simplistic way to look at
- 20:30what happened in the movie or the TV show is that she was suffering,
- 20:37or she has issues, or she wasn't very reflective, or she was a
- 20:40little awful. When she's talking about her boyfriend and she's like, yeah,
- 20:44he's just so bland, and when he gives me his food, I have
- 20:47to act like I like it, but it's also bland, and who knows.
- 20:51If we could sit her down and ask her, how do you really
- 20:53feel about your boyfriend? It's possible that if she would give the full story
- 20:57and she'd say like, well, and she's being honest, she's like,
- 21:00well, I love him, yeah, I want to be with him,
- 21:03but sometimes he's a little boring. He doesn't want to do anything exciting,
- 21:07and I don't know, maybe it's my fault too. But because you know,
- 21:11the food thing, that's just a minor example. The main thing is
- 21:12just like he's he's just always trying to please me, or he just doesn't
- 21:17have any goals in life. And it's and it's clear that she hasn't given
- 21:21him any of this feedback, by the way, right right, because for
- 21:23example, but how could you, right, I mean, how could you
- 21:26say to your partner? Well, but I think that's part of the I
- 21:30don't even know if that's part of the intended message, but as those scenes
- 21:33were playing out, I certainly was thinking, geez, this is why you
- 21:34got to communicate. Yeah, because if you have to pretend every day that
- 21:38you're loving the cuisine, yeah, I mean, come on, yeah.
- 21:41I think there's some obvious examples of just like hey, you know, you
- 21:45could absolutely just be up friend and say like, hey, to be honest,
- 21:48you know, I don't say you're cooking is blanned, but what you
- 21:52just gave me, it's it's not the most exciting thing I've eann. You
- 21:56know, I don't want to hurt your fear. Most people would rather hear
- 22:00that than a lie. So so, in fact, it should be mentioned
- 22:04that at least from the previews of that new Julia Louis Drivers movie, which
- 22:08is getting really good ratings, I think is based on this happening where her
- 22:12husband overhears her talking in her talking about him. Okay, anyway, That's
- 22:19what I'll say about this is that it is a similar phenomenon. Is the
- 22:26thoughts we have. You know, we're not talking with anyone else, we're
- 22:29thinking a thought. Well that's even worse. So we might in our minds
- 22:33during a fight say some pretty awful things about our partner, and we don't
- 22:37say them out loud, hopefully because we differentiate enough at the moment to know
- 22:41that well, I know, I don't really feel this way, and it's
- 22:45not a good idea. And if this thought persists, you know, like
- 22:48I want to divorce, I want to divorce this person right now, I
- 22:49don't. I never want to see this person's face for the rest of my
- 22:52life. And if you could read someone's mind, that would be devastating.
- 22:56So and so, essentially what's happening. The mechanism is if your wife were
- 23:03to overhear you, she would blow it out of proportion because to you,
- 23:07it's a complaint and everything you're saying is honest, right, because you're talking
- 23:11to a friend, but it doesn't represent the full picture, right, So
- 23:15on one hand, if the so for me, if I live in this
- 23:22world so much that I don't know. But if I overheard Stacy talking shit
- 23:26about me behind my back, which honestly I don't think she does. She's
- 23:30like one of the rare people who doesn't do tell me a few things you
- 23:33would now, on a hand, and so for but if I did at
- 23:38this stage of my life, which I wouldn't have been when I was younger,
- 23:42I think it would hurt, but I wouldn't I wouldn't generalize it,
- 23:47and I would go, well, I've already kind of trained my brain to
- 23:51understand that that's not that's not the topic sentence. That's like, you know,
- 23:56page ten, where the first verse nine pages are positive, neutral things,
- 24:03and of course there's gonna be some negative things in there. And I
- 24:06can see her point because I am annoying in that way, you know what
- 24:10I mean. There's also a gradient, like if someone comes home and the
- 24:12thing they overhear is like, I have never loved this person. I've been
- 24:17living a lie. I'm hiding a nuke in their closet. It's like,
- 24:19okay, well, I mean that's escalated. Yeah, and you know,
- 24:23call it defense. There's a nuke in the closet. Well, that's the
- 24:26least of the problems, right exactly. But I'm talking about healthy and healthy,
- 24:33normal complaints that one might have about your partner. And you know,
- 24:36another version of this is that I've worked with with couples in therapy, is
- 24:40they will read the spouse's journal, Oh that's happened a lot, or they'll
- 24:47somehow come across the email or something and read and well, for some people
- 24:52they have it so that you know, if you want to read my journal,
- 24:56go ahead, but sure that's the understanding, but just know that you're
- 24:59going to read some stuff that might disturb you. And so I've had long
- 25:03conversations with people about that, you know, the damage, and about this
- 25:07nuance of well, that's a version, that's that's the person venting. Have
- 25:11you never you know, the person who's hurt? I would ask them,
- 25:15have you ever had thoughts that were, you know, pretty harsh temporarily towards
- 25:21your partner? You know, it's that it's it's not you know, there's
- 25:23a temptation to believe that that's the real story and only what you're getting is
- 25:27the fake version of the person. And that could be very concerning right,
- 25:32So I think, you know, it lends itself to I think what you
- 25:34were getting at earlier is to be a little bit more honest about things so
- 25:37that if they do over here, you you'd be like, well, this
- 25:41shouldn't surprise you that I'm still talking about this, But the intensity of which
- 25:45I was talking about, Yeah, I guess I was being kind of a
- 25:48dick in the moment to you, you know. But but you shouldn't be
- 25:52surprised that I'm complaining about that because I I've told you that I don't like
- 25:56that you do that sort of thing. I mean. An exaggerated version of
- 25:59this is imagine you come home and your your daughter or son is on their
- 26:03phone with their friends, like I hate my dad, right, and that's
- 26:06the thing that they're saying because yesterday they got grounded or whatever. Yeah.
- 26:10Right, that can happen easily. Yeah, that certainly is a slice of
- 26:15time that you should not overendix. Right. And um. Similarly, if
- 26:18someone's like, oh my gosh, I'm it's driving me nuts, keep coming
- 26:22home. The shoes that he the same us he uses to press down on
- 26:26the marshmallows are stuck all over the walls and he keeps doing it. Well,
- 26:30you know if it's the first what, Oh you don't do this?
- 26:33Oh you find I'll use another example. No, but the point is,
- 26:37like you come home sometimes improv and other times the chat GPT just breaks down.
- 26:42But you know, the basic idea is if you hear a slice of
- 26:47time of someone complaining, that's not the entirety of your relationship, right.
- 26:51Yeah, So I wrote down a bunch of points that the show might be
- 26:56trying to make or does make. One Capitals will exploit people. I think
- 27:00that's part of the message. Government doesn't do enough to protect people. People
- 27:04have been giving up their privacy too much. Yeah, that was a clear
- 27:08message, like why don't you read the fine print? Yeah, capitalists manipulate
- 27:14the masses with negative content. That was another point made. And this happens
- 27:18today like when I mean not only with capitalists, so to speak, but
- 27:23people post a lot of stuff on the Internet, and my little slice of
- 27:26the world that I pay attention to is on Reddit, and Reddit gets up
- 27:30voted by the masses. There's no I mean, there's probably an algorithm on
- 27:33some level with Reddit, but they don't really need one because all they have
- 27:37to do is wait, for comments and up votes to feed it onto my
- 27:41front page, you know. And so for the things that rise to the
- 27:45top are often the things that are the most anger inducing in people, you
- 27:51know, for example, the whole Karen thing, right, which I'm not
- 27:53a fan of that word, but the videos of middle aged women who are
- 28:00saying, let me talk to the manager or something close to that, and
- 28:04the assumption and the desire from the audience to want to hate someone, you
- 28:11know, like I was talking earlier about it, I am the main character.
- 28:15I guess have been around the sun enough times to know that you can't
- 28:21just look at a video clip and understand what's happening. That there's a good
- 28:25chance that there's a context there. You just can't know. It looks a
- 28:27certain way, but you just can't know what happened there. And so when
- 28:32people see this, they assume that the person that they're watching is awful because
- 28:38that's what they want for psychological reasons, you know, blah blah blah,
- 28:41instead of and that's what also rises to the top of the algorithm. Of
- 28:45course, there's probably countless videos of people just doing regular things asking for the
- 28:51manager under normal circumstances. Boring it doesn't get doesn't get watched. It's it's
- 28:56not engaging. You know. That's what like if if in this show the
- 29:00scenes had been you know, the show starts, she's like him, I
- 29:04need to talk to you, and she's like, very empathetic. I'm like,
- 29:07oh my gosh, here, I'm so sorry I have this firing person.
- 29:10And then later she gets a text from her acts and she's like,
- 29:14oh, I'm sorry. I'm in a committed relationship. And then she gets
- 29:17home and she's like, okay, so listen, I happen to have a
- 29:18taste. I like stuff with more like um spice. Maybe maybe I'm already
- 29:23asleep, you're asleep. Yeah, right, So the computer doesn't care in
- 29:30which way the algorithm goes. It just knows what causes people to watch in
- 29:33it knew. So that's another phenomenon that I think it was commenting on directly.
- 29:37Also, deep fakes are coming as we were talking about. Also,
- 29:40we might be in a simulation as we speak. Also, AI writing actually
- 29:48is becoming a problem in our society today, you know writers. So writers
- 29:52are already having a problem with streaming because of the way in which the industry
- 29:57works. Now they get paid a lot less because the shows are shorter and
- 30:03the sort of thing, and there's more of them, and so they want
- 30:04to unionize so they can actually make a living at a being a writer.
- 30:07And so additional problem is that now, in particularly the future, a corporation
- 30:15like Netflix might not even need writers. They could just have an AI.
- 30:18It's already happening, like they're already generating plots. They're autoo generating plots and
- 30:22then picking them. Then. I just was having a conversation with a highly
- 30:26highly frustrated teacher who was grading papers because then you know, these school years
- 30:30over right, or it's it's ending for many school districts, and this phenomena
- 30:36is happening, which I'm sure it's happening everywhere where. It's like these people
- 30:38turn their papers at the very last second, and they're not known to write
- 30:42great papers. These papers are way better written than I would expect. Yeah,
- 30:48what do I do? Yeah, And it's happening, right, And
- 30:52it's not like in the past. I think now they do have programs that
- 30:56can try to take a guess as to whether or not AI generated, but
- 31:00there's no way to know because every iteration of a question or even the way
- 31:07the AI is operating that day will pump something. It's different. Plus it's
- 31:11not long from now where you can literally you will subscribe to an AI bot
- 31:18that literally is designed to evade any detection. You would say, write this
- 31:22at my level, which isn't that good, so it would sprinkle in little
- 31:26problems, you know. And so ironic is like, as a student who
- 31:33doesn't want to write your essays to train your algorithm, well, to fake
- 31:37it, you have to write like one hundred essays. So it's like here
- 31:41to onboard, right, one hundred essays about all the following topics, and
- 31:45the students like, yeah, but you know, all you'd have to do
- 31:48is feed it the last ten papers that you wrote, the actual but you
- 31:52didn't write them. But I mean, but yeah, I mean I suppose
- 31:56that's the thing, right, Like, so well, let me ask you
- 32:00what do you think will happen? And also what do you think about the
- 32:01people that say, well, they said this about calculators when it first came
- 32:05out, and it did. It did hurt people's ability to calculate, that's
- 32:08for sure, but it hasn't stopped society for sure. I think there's a
- 32:13couple of things that come to my one something I certainly didn't understand. I'm
- 32:16pretty sure most kids don't understand, because it's just not explained to us.
- 32:20The idea was you thought that you're going to school to get a grade,
- 32:23that that was the whole thing. It's like, I gotta get a great,
- 32:25I gotta get like this A and then why oh, because I gotta
- 32:30get a's because then that's how I graduate. And then I gotta go to
- 32:31college to get a's because then that's how we get a job, to make
- 32:35money to buy the house that I want to buy, right, the car
- 32:37I want to Okay, But what's never explained is like, listen, you're
- 32:40a little baby human who will have a baby brain if you don't train it.
- 32:45So forget the money for a second, forget the a's. We just
- 32:50need to train your little baby brain. And that's not a concept that we
- 32:52get. Yeah, because the whole reason for learning to write the essays and
- 32:54so you can get an A is so your little baby brain can develop.
- 32:59Same thing with the calculator. Baby or kids will say to you, but
- 33:02I don't care. I want to eat, I want to play video games,
- 33:06and if I can in three seconds, right, an essay that will
- 33:09pass. I'd rather do that, and that's why. But that's why I'm
- 33:12thinking that it actually kind of will take a structural change where there can't be
- 33:15an a that there can't be a grade given to you by something you did
- 33:20in the privacy of your house, because that's the wrong incentive that could have
- 33:23been faked. Yeah. Right, So I think that there's a possibility,
- 33:28and maybe there's already movements of destruction that there won't be essays, there will
- 33:31be prompts and then you just have to speak. You just have to off
- 33:37the top of your head, right in class like handwriting class, right,
- 33:40and the papers won't be as good because you won't have as much time,
- 33:45for example, but a different set of skills and maybe more fundamental skills.
- 33:50Right. Yeah. Now there's a different philosophy or a perspective on this,
- 33:52which is and you are alluding to the calculator. It's not a bad metaphor
- 33:55at all, because, for example, do you know how to use a
- 33:58slide rule a calculus? Now? They do. I actually never learn.
- 34:00But you could argue the slide rule when it came on the scene was annoying
- 34:05people because they weren't doing Actually that's true. But certainly that's a skill that
- 34:08none of us ever learned. Well of our generation had to learn, and
- 34:12certainly we don't know. So another way to think about it would be,
- 34:15well, but if our brain is freed from some things that it used to
- 34:19have to learn to do, are there other things? Right? So that's
- 34:22the point, Like with calculators at first, especially people who didn't come up
- 34:27with calculators, or right, this is going to ruin society. It's also
- 34:30going to ruin mathematics and engineering. It could be argued it enhanced it because
- 34:34it freed up engineers and other people using math to do other things that were
- 34:38beyond the brute force calculations that they would have to do. And obviously computers
- 34:44allow you to do computations you could never do on your own. So computer
- 34:49calculators actually help, you know, and in this weird way, and I'd
- 34:53never thought about. Just now, say you have a high schooler who manages
- 34:59given the or even if you say, I don't even care if you use
- 35:02AI. I just want a paper that is persuasive on these points. And
- 35:07you know you can't just type that into an AI bot and have it spit
- 35:12out to be like the best, especially if you're competing against other students that
- 35:16have the same chatbot. So you'd have to do a little bessaging, but
- 35:21you know, not bad, and then you submit it and you get an
- 35:23A. Then you go to college, same thing. Then you go to
- 35:27the workplace. Well, does the workplace care if you're using does the customer
- 35:31care if you're using an AI chatbot to write a website copy or an advertisement
- 35:38for a commercial? Like, No, they don't care, So it's not
- 35:43cheating if in the end the tool will be used effectively in the same way
- 35:49that an engineer on the job at the age thirty five will use a calculator.
- 35:52Yeah, and I guess a lot more jobs might become might go back
- 35:57to being manual things that not the the robots will also replace, but not
- 36:00yet, like we have bought ourselves a little wind of time where manual jobs
- 36:05are more valuable because that you can't fake yet as easily. I also was
- 36:10thinking that if you could also try to solve this via technology itself. For
- 36:15example, if I have a computer with a camera, a microphone, a
- 36:17keyboard, and stuff that actually is using artificial intelligence to detect whether or not
- 36:22you're doing the right thing, right, and now it makes us a little
- 36:24bit of slaves to the tech. But hey, if it's in the in
- 36:28the in the to train your brain, your baby brain, yeah you could.
- 36:31I could totally see that in five years there would be an app that
- 36:36the computer issued LAP because the computers are issued by the school school, right,
- 36:39and it's very secure and robust and it keeps track of everything you type
- 36:46on that computer while filming you and you know, all the disclosures and everything.
- 36:51The other angle, of course, the teachers can take is like,
- 36:52look, you can do whatever you want and kind of put them more on
- 36:54the parents, like, you could do whatever you want, but there's gonna
- 36:57be a final. Two things. If your final is not good, well
- 37:00and if your final doesn't match the work doubled down, yeah right right,
- 37:06and the finals in you know, in person, you're gonna have to write
- 37:07it, you know. Yeah, I mean I kind of had a person
- 37:09of that in high school. It by French class. Yeah. So in
- 37:14my senior year in a relationship I was talking about earlier, I hate being
- 37:19bored and I hate things that I feel like I'm wasting my time. And
- 37:22my senior year in high school, I absolutely felt I was wasting my time
- 37:25because I was already accepted into UDU University of Washington. Or I my index,
- 37:31you know, my tests and my grades were so high I mathematically figured
- 37:36out, I mean, they weren't high high, but they were high enough
- 37:37such that I figured out that if I basically flunked all my classes my senior
- 37:43year, as long as I graduated, as I got a PLUM, I
- 37:45still would have gotten into the University of Washington. So I said, it's
- 37:49illogical for me to do my homework. Now. I loved calculus, I
- 37:52love physics, I loved chemistry, so I actually forehold those classes. But
- 37:58I hated English and I hated it, you know, other kinds of classes
- 38:01like that. So I completely just stopped working in those classes. And my
- 38:07English teacher that year was new and so only knew me as basically some sort
- 38:14of yeah, and someone who wasn't, I guess accomplished academically. And she
- 38:19was at graduation. And you know, when you have a certain grade level,
- 38:22you have a you wear a sash there's that indicates you had a three,
- 38:27eight, five or higher. And I came around the corner and she
- 38:30looked at me, and then she saw the sash, and I actually felt
- 38:35remorse because the calculation I thought she was making in her head was I didn't
- 38:42care about her class. Oh you know what I mean, like she could
- 38:45have taken it personally, right. I felt insanely bad. I'm like,
- 38:49oh no, no, it's not curb your enthusiasm moment. No, no,
- 38:53the sash isn't. I'm actually really dumb. I stole this or thing,
- 39:00And um yeah, I felt because you know, I remember, I
- 39:05guess thinking that she was kind of an underdog new struggling. I felt like,
- 39:10because anyway, point is is she you know, she quit quit teaching
- 39:14after act. And so my senior year, I sat next to a girl
- 39:20name I think her name was Noel, and she loved French but she hated
- 39:23math. Okay, I love math. I hated from change homework. So
- 39:28I did her math homework. When when I just in the middle of class,
- 39:32I was I thought, you meant you were going to tutor each other.
- 39:36No, I just did it. I just did the work, and
- 39:38she did all my French homework, so I, you know, was passing
- 39:43by the end of the by the end of the quarter. And then um,
- 39:46my very last thing that I did in high school, you know,
- 39:50just before the bell rang and everyone graduated, was this like three hour French
- 39:55final and it's passed around the classroom and the instructions are in French. Oh
- 40:01my god, I am so insufficient with French. I don't understand even the
- 40:09gist of what these questions are asking me to do, right, And I
- 40:15mean when I say I don't understand, like I couldn't in my wildest dreams.
- 40:20I wouldn't even begin to fake and answer it. There was just no
- 40:23way. So so I sat there kind of like freaking out, looking at
- 40:29all the prompts, and I was just like, well, if I get
- 40:31an f it doesn't matter because I and by that point I knew I was
- 40:36already going to the University of Washington, and so I just sat there for
- 40:38three hours like doodling. Oh my gosh. But the teacher was probably so
- 40:43confused, like, but you did well on the homework. Yeah, earlier
- 40:45this week you you answered a question that was you know, pretty good.
- 40:50How come you didn't I did exactly, that's exactly, So yeah, you
- 40:53can do that. As a teacher, you'd be like, hey, look,
- 40:57parents, if you let your kids get away with that whatever, But
- 41:00and just just know that half of their grade will be determined by an in
- 41:04person exam at the end of the year. Yeah, absolutely, you could
- 41:07do that. Oh my gosh. Well, actually, let's just take a
- 41:10break here for a second. We get back, let's come to you.
- 41:13What do you say? Let's do it? So Berto, if you were
- 41:20a demotivational speaker, how would you convince everyone to become a patron of the
- 41:25podcast? Listening right now? All right? I want to talk to you
- 41:29about a huge opportunity that you've already missed and you're never gonna find again.
- 41:34And that opportunity was called a great successful life. But you're here now,
- 41:38so why not make the best of it? What does it mean to make
- 41:43the best of it? Well, you can't, but you can actually donate
- 41:47to a thing that will help you understand why donating to this thing is still
- 41:52something you can do. That's the Psychology and Seattle podcast. Donate now,
- 41:58become a patron because you have no other choices. Really, you know how
- 42:04earlier we're talking about definition of the self and how current times and what occupies
- 42:09your thinking will affect the way we see the self and other people's selves.
- 42:15Since AI is such a thing on the brain. Yeah. I literally as
- 42:21you were doing that, I was thinking, oh my god, Burdo's like
- 42:23almost as good as a chat bot, because I because you could enter this
- 42:28the exact same question into an AI and it would it would, you know,
- 42:34produce something I've had that happen. I was like, oh my god,
- 42:37you're you're like a chat bot. You're like almost as good as yeah,
- 42:40yeah, oh my gosh. Um. I could see students using AI
- 42:45though as a tool of like Okay, here's the assignment. They type it
- 42:50in and they get an example, and at least they have like, oh,
- 42:53that's what a paragraph looks like, that's what that's what an argument looks
- 42:57like. Those are some good points. So people are using AI to learn
- 43:00all sorts of things actively and that the other the flip side of this is
- 43:04I think any kid, any student not actively learning how to basically maximize everything
- 43:09AI can do, is going to be working back from the from the back,
- 43:15because like you have to be this is the new learning how to program
- 43:20kind of thing, Like the new thing you have to learn. How do
- 43:22you know, I used to be like learn how to use Microsoft Word or
- 43:25learn how to use a browser. This is the new thing. Well,
- 43:29so what will be the common skills in the workplace, in the home that
- 43:35this will meet, that this will I do. I don't know what it
- 43:37is. It might get a little out of hand, but for the next
- 43:40few years, any any field you're trying to go into. If you're someone
- 43:45who like, imagine you're working at a company and it's like, okay,
- 43:47we need to create some brochures for the thing, you're like, okay,
- 43:51well I'll go find, I'll go hire. Like you're done, You're fired,
- 43:54because in three minutes you could probably produce the brochures we need if you
- 43:58know how to use the tool, or you'll get a good lay of the
- 44:00land by using the AI, and then you can absolutely use that as a
- 44:05basis or something. And then as we speak, the things are getting way
- 44:07more complex because there's all these efforts to link AIS together and then automate things
- 44:13so that essentially it's not just that I can create a little paragraph or a
- 44:16little image, it's that I can create an app or I can create a
- 44:21whole workflow. Yeah, it's interesting. So someone a listener to the podcast,
- 44:27Jocelyn. She reached out to me because she I believe is in school
- 44:30learning how to do web design and needed a project to work on. And
- 44:36she knew that our website wasn't that great, which it isn't, and that
- 44:39she could design a website. So there's a whole process of like talking to
- 44:44the customers and talking with me. You know. It was a whole program
- 44:46and very involved, way more involved, and I thought it would be way
- 44:50more work for her than I thought, And so she's been doing that for
- 44:54a long time, and she actually did a mock up and it was just
- 45:00mind blowing how good it was. And one of the things that I have
- 45:05a dream about but never thought was possible until now. With the possibility of
- 45:08AI, I think there's something on the order of four thousand episodes if you
- 45:13include all the reaction videos that I've made, and people email me all the
- 45:17time. Did you talk about this topic because or I have a question about
- 45:22this topic, and I'm like, I'm pretty sure we did a lengthy side
- 45:25tangent about that, yeah, or I think we did an episode on that.
- 45:30I don't know, and so it would be really useful if I had
- 45:36the ability to answer that question right away, or an AI had the ability
- 45:39to answer that question, right. So also categorizing the episodes by like topic,
- 45:45right, because we go on a lot of directions, so to manually
- 45:49do that would take years. Yeah, you have to listen to every episode.
- 45:52You got to code everything, da dada. So anyway, the design
- 45:55actually had that as a feature that might be included of Like, you just
- 46:00press a keyword like parenting, and it pulls up all the episodes that go
- 46:05into parenting. But we don't really have that data because I didn't keep track
- 46:09of that kind of thing. Well, then another person that we're hiring,
- 46:13actually another fan of the show, Abigail, is a professional in this area,
- 46:17and so we were talking with her about implementing this design, right,
- 46:22And in the moment, I'm just like, well, AI, I know
- 46:28enough that an AI could listen to every episode in ten seconds or however long
- 46:32it takes to process that and at the very least suggest keywords and then could
- 46:38maybe learn, oh, okay, these are the keywords that you're wanting me
- 46:42to look for, And then could actually the AI could actually pull a paragraph
- 46:46and say I'm labeling this paragraph as one of several paragraphs in which Kirk talked
- 46:52about parenting. Is that right? And It would be really quick because I
- 46:55just I would be able to glance at it but be like, yep,
- 46:58that's parenting. I wouldn't code that disparenting. And then you know, lickety
- 47:01split, maybe in four hours of human work, it would be able to
- 47:07not only give keywords for every episode that you would be able to search for,
- 47:10but also like start to pull quotes, and then the AI, you
- 47:15know, the user would be able to be like, Okay, pull you
- 47:19know, seven paragraphs from different episode in which Kirk talked about borderline, and
- 47:23you'd be able to see this this array of paragraphs, right, and how
- 47:30fucking amazing that would be just for myself just to know what I've talked about.
- 47:34And sometimes it's helpful for me to listen to my own past episodes because
- 47:38it happened. I recorded it ten years ago, and I've I've forgotten ninety
- 47:43percent of what I knew at the time, and so, um, you
- 47:45know. So I'm talking with the computer person, Abigail, and she looked
- 47:51into it and she's like, yeah, we're like halfway there in terms of
- 47:54consumer grade, and there's some coding that I can do to maybe kind of
- 47:59do some of that. But I feel like very soon, Abigai, the
- 48:01Abigails of the world wouldn't even have to do a lot of grunt coding.
- 48:07You would just sign up for a thing and you know, pay fifty bucks
- 48:12or a subscription, and it would just do all that shit for you.
- 48:15Right, absolutely, So how soon because I don't want to have to put
- 48:21because at this point, in terms of what the dream is for the for
- 48:23the website to sort of catalog all this stuff, it's going to take me
- 48:28and Stacy probably months of labor honestly to kind of even with AI helping.
- 48:34And you know, similar to when Napster and Kazak came out and MP three's
- 48:38and I started to ooh MP three's, and so I had all these records,
- 48:44so I I manually recorded my records on digitizing them and had to record
- 48:51each song and there would be these little scratches, you know, with the
- 48:55needle drop and stuff. And so for a couple years, half of my
- 49:00MP three is that I'd be listening to my MP three from from records that
- 49:05I had because I did want to steal them from the internet. Plus some
- 49:07songs weren't on Kauza or Dampster. Fast forward a little bit later, and
- 49:10you have things like Spotify and YouTube where every song is available. So I
- 49:16can't tell you how much fucking time I spent. Imagine I had hundreds of
- 49:21maybe thousands of records. I don't know if I digitize all of them,
- 49:23but a lot of them. Yeah, I had to listen and that's real
- 49:25time. You have to listen to the song real time and just sit there.
- 49:30And so I don't like, even in a very small version of that,
- 49:34I remember going through and grabbing a CDs to turn them into MP three
- 49:37is even just that was so time consuming, right, and that's way simpler
- 49:42than when you're just yeah, when you're ripping a CD, it's a lot
- 49:45faster, but you still have to put on folders. Usually you don't get
- 49:50the metadata back then by default you have to like table edge. Yeah,
- 49:52so I don't want to do that again. You never have to do that
- 49:55again. Yeah, So when do you think Kirk will be able to,
- 50:01even for a fee, get an AI to listen to every episode and at
- 50:07the very least pull keywords. So here's the thing that can be done.
- 50:10Now. You can have one AI transcribe every episode to text. The error
- 50:20rate for that is probably not as good as like sid don't on that.
- 50:24So another fan of the podcast, Samuel, actually reached out to me last
- 50:29month, saying that he's a tech guy and he loves the podcast and he
- 50:31wants to help. And he's like, yeah, anything I can do,
- 50:35And I was like, well, I don't think there's much. It's really
- 50:37nice of you, and so, you know, we brainstormed a little bit
- 50:40and he was like, well, how about transcripts And I was like okay,
- 50:44and he's like, AI can code debt or there's a way to use
- 50:47all that, and so we went back and forth and he really dove into
- 50:52it a lot, and he did manage to have one of the best,
- 50:55if not the best transcripts I've ever seen, because you know, I have
- 51:00the ability, you know, text to speech that exists right now, and
- 51:04I've seen transcripts before, but it's real bad and the punctuation is terrible,
- 51:09and this version from Samuel was near perfect, honestly, in terms of the
- 51:15the grammar and the interpretation of my words and that and and so, um,
- 51:21we're already there, but that's pretty far from what I'm saying, right,
- 51:23No, no, but but because once you have it all in text.
- 51:27That's the step one. Yeah. The next thing is you feed that
- 51:29into LAMA or an equivalent model, which is a large language model. So
- 51:34is that something you would pay for? It's like maybe twenty bucks at most.
- 51:38Like, you feed all this into a LAMA model. So I could
- 51:40take ten transcripts, no, all of it. You take your entire videos,
- 51:47all of them transcribed. You feed all of it into a large language
- 51:52model like LAMA. Now LAMA has is it like, is it like a
- 52:00privat area of the server. That's that's just private. It's on your desktop.
- 52:05Oh, it's on your desktop. You need a early enough computer.
- 52:07But you know we can sort of pus you like uploading it to like Wikipedia
- 52:12or something. Now it's like it's now their services. You can do that
- 52:14too. But you can do this all on your computer or a computer or
- 52:16a collection of small computer or whatever. But the point is you download the
- 52:20thing, you put it all into LAMA. So now Lama's got your entire
- 52:24speech that you've given over ten thirteen years, okay, fifteen years. Now
- 52:30that thing you can because it's a large language model, you can talk about
- 52:36everything you've said and it pulls back from that content as I could ask what
- 52:43is a definition of borderline person? Sure, and it will pull the definition
- 52:47from my work. Yes, now asterisk. Remember these language large language models
- 52:52can sometimes get things wrong. Yeah, right, So so there's got to
- 52:55be a little bit kind of mamma is their feedback to refine the algorithm at
- 52:59all. A LAMA is just like an open source version of chat JPT basically,
- 53:02but it's it's nearly as powerful. So you do all this. So
- 53:06now we have two things. First of all, you have it all in
- 53:07tech. Second, you have a large language model that can converse with us
- 53:10freely about all your stuff that we've ever said. The next step is there's
- 53:15another AI that you can now start grabbing, like indexing all of it,
- 53:19right, and not only indexing. I don't know the names, but these
- 53:23are all ais that are and they're all available through things like hugging Face,
- 53:30which is a service that's got hundreds of models that we can use and even
- 53:34better anyways, I'm diagrassing. So then you can not only inventory all the
- 53:39text, but you can also then tie it back to the videos and like
- 53:43time code within the videos and like Eventually this is where this will probably require
- 53:49more a little bit, but then you can pull the little snippets, right,
- 53:52so you can be like, hey, what did Kirk say about blah?
- 53:54And it's like I think that blah blah blah blah blah blah blah.
- 53:58Right, So how long from now do you think it'll be? Before?
- 54:00With say two full days of me fuxing with all this, I will get
- 54:07all that I want. I mean, if you had the right people working
- 54:08on this right now, you could have this in ten minutes, Like I
- 54:13mean, I just mean, like you could have this today. What do
- 54:15you the right people wear others? Right? People just a couple like one
- 54:21or two engineers that are actively working with these models and know how they have
- 54:24access to the models. Everyone's got their open source You don't have to pay
- 54:29their open source models. Meaning so yeah, if you have an engineer that's
- 54:32in the know, that's that is you could contract with, they would use
- 54:37these open source models and be able to do all the things that I've been
- 54:40saying. Yeah, I mean I'm gonna even go further, which I mean
- 54:44I haven't gone through these steps. So we can try it together. We
- 54:47can technically use chat GPT to ask it how we go about using these models.
- 54:55But then now there's actually we can do even better than that because now
- 54:59there's a automated models itself how to use itself. Yeah, basically there's there's
- 55:04new automated models that we can use where what we say is we basically describe
- 55:08the problem that we're describing and it will subtask other ais with the pieces of
- 55:15the problem we're trying to solve. Basically, not code something that you have
- 55:20to run. But actually basically if you and I set aside some time,
- 55:24I think we can get pretty far with us. Yeah, we just literally
- 55:27need to and we could do it remotely, like we could do the thing
- 55:30where we log into a video call and then I'm like doing stuff and then
- 55:32we're both looking at it. I think we can get pretty far because like
- 55:36everything you've described, like the models are there for the usage, right,
- 55:39That's what I was thinking. But it's just not super consumer. What doesn't
- 55:45exist yet is a website or where you you do everything we just said,
- 55:52and then everything else is behind the scenes and I just click on a few
- 55:54buttons and say I want this option and that option. But there's the link
- 55:59to my reposite. Yeah, here is in sentences like actually I speak into
- 56:02a Mic, what I want. I was really thinking blah blah, and
- 56:06you give it like ten minutes description of what you want that doesn't yet exist,
- 56:10but the pieces exist, and so right now, that's why. So
- 56:14how long do you think it'll be before that happens, dude? Like the
- 56:17companies are working on it. It's just because I feel I feel like the
- 56:22business applications for this are astronomical. So not not only for something like what
- 56:28I want to do for every podcast honestly, but if you're a library,
- 56:35if you run a library and you're looking for some way to organize all the
- 56:39data, if you're someone who works with a database, just any old database,
- 56:45like you sell shoes for Nike, and you're just looking for trends within
- 56:51the market, not only just with your data with Nike, but you want
- 56:53all the trends, and you want the machine learning to kind of figure out
- 56:58what your next move should be, like well your next shoe should be read,
- 57:00you know, and you're like, huh, why well because this,
- 57:02you know, huh? Or or for me like what's the next reality TV
- 57:07show I should watch? Or or you know, like the the money making
- 57:13opportunities. Of course, I can't even comprehend what is possible. So I'm
- 57:16just like, I figure those capitalists will make that happen so that I can
- 57:22ride in the coattails of that. So that's podcast could be more convenient for
- 57:27the listeners. That's what I want. I want them to be able to
- 57:30go, Yeah, you know, just type in a question and it'll be
- 57:32our own private database for a for a you know, an AI. The
- 57:37AI would have a private database that you could go into through the public AI
- 57:43that was calling upon the private psychology SHILD database, and they would be able
- 57:49to be directed directly to the audio, maybe even played the audio file right
- 57:54then. There. Well, so two things. One, so Microsoft,
- 58:00Amazon, a lot of companies right now are working on enterprise versions of this
- 58:02where you use their service, you pay them for their service, and you
- 58:07give them access to your enterprise data and they're intelligent. AI helps you do
- 58:13what stuff like what you're describing. Now, there's the next level of that,
- 58:15which is imagine I say this goes back to where we were talking about
- 58:19earlier. I could say I want Kirk to talk to me about the following
- 58:22topic, and then through a combination of maybe actual literal snippets that you had
- 58:27plus just filling the gaps. You get that. Yeah, that's that's a
- 58:31little bit more. But yeah, it's deep fake me giving advice to them
- 58:37particularly and but but still based largely on what you've set right. So I
- 58:42at first of you know, of course it sounds like dystopia, but I
- 58:46would actually consider that. Absolutely. I would have to test it out,
- 58:51and you'd have to have all sorts of disclaimers and say this isn't mean you
- 58:53know, and if it goes wonky, you know, understand, you know,
- 58:58I'm just trying to think of myself as a concuer. Would I want
- 59:01Conan O'Brien to make a joke about me? Yes, what I would I
- 59:06pay twenty Yeah, exactly exactly, That's exactly what I's thinking of it.
- 59:10Would I pay twenty bucks to have Colone O'Brien riff and make fun of me,
- 59:16you know, and for your anniversary, for your thing whatever, right
- 59:20for or yeah or seeing heavy birthday? Um, and you know Colonel O'Brien
- 59:24is authorizing this, right, that would be the thing, and I would,
- 59:29uh, yeah, I would pay twenty bucks for exactly especially well,
- 59:32imagine this, I'm on the Colonel O'Brien show exactly as a guest. Yeah,
- 59:37and I get to watch it, but it's just AI generating oh my
- 59:42god, burto oh my god, happening so deep fake but like authorized and
- 59:47government regulated, you know, like there's they can't get out of control.
- 59:52This is where my stomach starts to churn again. Well, you need young
- 59:54people in Congress as a thing. You can't have those old folks who don't
- 59:59understand wi FI. I mean those asking those senators asking those questions. Like,
- 1:00:02so, the problem we're facing is right now, the young people are
- 1:00:07on the open source networks across the world, downloading these models and iterating at
- 1:00:10light speed on them. So the stuff, everything you can imagine and more
- 1:00:14is coming without any regulation. Meanwhile, the young people are non existent in
- 1:00:20Congress that are at least, you know, really facing these problems and trying
- 1:00:23not well. The thing that I am hopeful and somewhat optimistic about is,
- 1:00:30you know, for those who don't know, because because it seems like the
- 1:00:32Internet, it just it's natural. It sort of is what it is because
- 1:00:37that's the way the Internet is. The Internet is partially the way it is
- 1:00:40the way it is is because of people that innovated it but it's also part
- 1:00:45of the way that it is is because government took action to steer it in
- 1:00:49a particular direction. There was a time and I was pretty sure this was
- 1:00:52going to happen. I think in the teens, maybe it was the odds
- 1:00:55you would probably know the exact sort of year when for Agress was considering making
- 1:01:00it like the fccy. There would be the same rules and regulations like a
- 1:01:07utility, right, it would it would be regulated heavily, right, And
- 1:01:12there was the or and or that every website would be liable for anything that
- 1:01:16is posted on you. There's very different versions of this, and generally speaking,
- 1:01:22of course there's some wrong moves, but generally speaking, the United States
- 1:01:28government has made very human, consumer benefiting, I believe, decisions because they
- 1:01:36could have pretty easily said, look, anything that's posted on Facebook or Twitter,
- 1:01:40if it is found to harm someone, then Facebook will get sued because
- 1:01:45it's Facebook's site. Or another question that was posted them was what about the
- 1:01:51children, because you know, originally with television radio, anyone could broadcast anything,
- 1:01:55right, But eventually the FCC kicked in and said no, in a
- 1:01:59minute, not only can you not just say anything, and we're going to
- 1:02:00make sure that you keep it non vulgar, vulgar or whatever. But also
- 1:02:06only authorized licensed individuals can broadcast on this frequency, right, So I and
- 1:02:12you cannot just make a TV station and start broadcasting from our house because it'll
- 1:02:17interfere with the signaling of a There was a time when they were considering that
- 1:02:22they were considering doing that to the fucking Internet, right, so you and
- 1:02:24I wouldn't have been able to create a website, we wouldn't have a podcast.
- 1:02:28It would have shut down everything we understand to know about the Internet.
- 1:02:34But the government didn't do it, right because we the people spoke up and
- 1:02:39tech minded people spoke up but said, please, government, do not do
- 1:02:44this. It could ruin things, and they didn't do it. So I
- 1:02:45wonder with this that they might make a similar choice. And there are still
- 1:02:50some limits, which is why unfortunately the dark webs is because the normal Internet,
- 1:02:53right soap, does have limitations. Thoughtful limits, yeah, thoughtful you
- 1:02:58know, citizen based limits that protect us. That regulations are important. I'm
- 1:03:05not an antiregulationist. I am a pro regulationist, but when it comes to
- 1:03:09this, you know, as I look, I just want to go on
- 1:03:10the Conan show and have him seeing Happy birthday to me. It's a free
- 1:03:15country. I deserve it. Yes, well, that does it for that
- 1:03:17episode of psychology and Seattle. Everyone out there, please take care of yourself
- 1:03:21because it's a free country and you deserve it.