Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 172 - Still In The Saddle: The Hollywood Western with Author Andrew Patrick Nelson!
Transcript
- 0:01Your listening You've Forgotten Hollywood with Doug Hess here on j LJBDIA. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to have Forgotten to Hollywood your podcasting memories of yesteryear. My
- 0:26name is Doug Hess, and if you're tuning in and Forgotten Hollywood for the
- 0:29first time, what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey
- 0:32back in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may
- 0:36not know about. And in this episode we have a very special guest with
- 0:40us today, author Andrew Patrick Nelson, talking or discussing his book Still in
- 0:47the Saddle the Hollywood Western from nineteen sixty nine to nineteen eighty. Andrew,
- 0:52Welcome to Forgotten Hollywood. Hi, Doug, very happy to be here.
- 0:56Well, thank you, and thank you for spending a few minutes with this
- 1:00day and our listeners to talk about your book Still in the Saddle the Hollywood
- 1:03Western nineteen sixty nine nineteen eighty. And maybe a couple of things you can
- 1:07do right off the bat is one kind of give the listeners an idea of
- 1:11what this book is about. But I'd also like to know how this book
- 1:14came about as well. Sure, so Still in the saddle is what we
- 1:19might call a new history of the Hollywood Western between nineteen sixty nine and nineteen
- 1:23eighty, which is a celebrated, really revered, and somewhat controversial period in
- 1:30the genre's history, when if you would ask most people they would say something
- 1:34called the revisionist Western took over from something called the classic Western. So that's
- 1:40the period that I'm looking at, and I make the case that that argument,
- 1:45that narrative, that story we tell ourselves is if not incorrect, then
- 1:49incomplete, that there was a lot more happening, and that really speaks to
- 1:53the genesis of the book. I kind of reached a point where what I
- 1:59was watching in terms of westerns, what I was seeing, so, yes,
- 2:02I was seeing the Wild Bunch and mcaban, Missus Miller, a little
- 2:06big Man, but I was also seeing all of these John Wayne films.
- 2:09And the more I looked into it, the more I realized that there was
- 2:13there was just more going on than the Wild Bunch, and that John Wayne
- 2:15westerns were more typical of the nineteen seventies than was the Wild Bunch or McCay
- 2:22and Missus Miller. And that, of course raises a big question about why
- 2:27have we told ourselves this story about what the Western was, when that's only
- 2:30a small part of it. So that's the really the genesis where what I
- 2:36was seeing didn't add up to what I was reading or hearing, or it
- 2:39just had been actually taught. And maybe the other important thing too, is
- 2:44that this idea of the classic Western that it was simple and black and white,
- 2:50was also not true and certainly didn't drive with my experience at the time.
- 2:54You know, the idea that once upon a time things were simple and
- 2:58morality was clear, and then something happens in the sixties and it becomes complicated.
- 3:01That's of course not true. So not only is the revisionist Western not
- 3:07really a thing, the classical Western is something like a kind of like a
- 3:10straw man that we put up in order to make arguments. So I try
- 3:15in the book to offer a more inclusive discussion of the Western at this period
- 3:20and hopefully reclaim a lot of what made the Western still really interesting and vibrant
- 3:24and exciting at a time when it was believed to be in decline. And
- 3:31so what so, you know, you you really hit on a point that
- 3:37I have been kind of trying to making myself over the years is when it
- 3:43comes to nostalgia, we all want to look through the past with rose colored
- 3:49glasses and think of it as a more simpler, more spiritual time. I
- 3:55use that word kind of loosely. Then everybody was playing it good and safe,
- 4:00and there was no evil in the world and nothing was wrong. But
- 4:04things have really not changed from you know, the nineteen thirties, if you
- 4:09will, to twenty twenty three, in the sense of immorality, evil.
- 4:15We just kind of take a different spin on it. I think that's right.
- 4:18You know, something I remind my film students all the time is that
- 4:23film is a very young media, you know, just over really one hundred
- 4:29years in terms of the film language that we're familiar with. So when you're
- 4:33looking at film, you know, you can you can get a good sense
- 4:36of the entire history of film, you know, I don't know, almost
- 4:41in an afternoon or it's certainly in a semester at college, And what I
- 4:45do in a semester at college might be a day in an art history class.
- 4:49And so that that perspective, I think is helpful because if if film
- 4:54is a young medium, especially relative to how long we have been making art,
- 5:00then you know, the art isn't going to change as much as we
- 5:02think, because we're not going to change that much in that, you know,
- 5:04relatively short period of time. So I take that point that you know,
- 5:10the past was, especially the recent past one hundred years ago, just
- 5:14as complicated, and people were just as flawed, and art was just as
- 5:17messy trying to grapple with that as it is today. Yeah, and I
- 5:23think that really the only difference is that the movie studios tried to hide it
- 5:30a little bit better than they do today. Yeah, that's a good point.
- 5:33I mean, certainly, you know, the censorship apparatus that govern most
- 5:38of what we call classic Hollywood goes away over the course of the sixties.
- 5:43So you know, that's that's one challenge. And I'm sure you find this
- 5:46with older movies that it's not as though the ideological content the politics isn't in
- 5:53Hollywood movies. It's just there in a different way that is harder for contemporary
- 5:58viewers to see, but audiences of the time new. I mean, my
- 6:00my favorite example from the Western is when I teach a class on the Western,
- 6:05I kind of get to this point in the class about midway through.
- 6:09I pull up a slide of characters like Dallas and stagecoach or Feathers in real
- 6:14Bravo and I say to the class, so what is the profession of these
- 6:17women and that you know that, oh they're singers or dance hall of girls,
- 6:21And I said, well, no, what does that really mean?
- 6:24Like right, so you know, prostitutes. So that's you know, one
- 6:30example of how something that was very obvious to audiences in the thirties who were
- 6:33accustomed to what films couldn't couldn't do, you know, would be a tune
- 6:36to whereas today, you know, if someone's a prostitute, we're used to
- 6:42it being pretty explicit, right, you're going to know it. Where again,
- 6:46it was there in the thirties and the forties, they just hit it
- 6:49even though it was in plain sight. Correct. Yeah, you know you've
- 6:54mentioned John Wayne, and I don't think we could probably talk about Westerns without
- 6:58bringing up John Wayne, right in terms of that, what was his impact
- 7:03during this time? Well, I mean, the thing to remember is that
- 7:10Wayne is still the most popular Western star at this moment and one of,
- 7:15you know, by a variety of metrics, quickly's box office one of the
- 7:19most popular stars right up to his you know, his last film in seventy
- 7:23six, up to his death in nineteen seventy nine, and even even beyond
- 7:28in terms of popularity. And so it's not the case that Wayne was simply
- 7:33you know, catering to an elder audience who were you know, were upset
- 7:36that films cost more than a nickel or something like that. You know,
- 7:41he actually had a kind of broad appeal. And you know, one of
- 7:45the interesting things about you know, writing the book and having people talk to
- 7:47me about it is I've had I can't tell you the number of conversations I've
- 7:50had where someone will come up to me after reading the book and they'll tell
- 7:54me that even though they might have disagreed with Wayne's politics in the seventies,
- 7:59and these are usually people who are coming of age around them, they really
- 8:03liked his westerns and they thought his westerns weren't the kind of the one dimensional
- 8:07caricature that was often made of him as a political figure. That the westerns,
- 8:11you know, true Grit, Big Jake, the Cowboys. I mean,
- 8:15if you were to watch these movies today, you'll realize that these are
- 8:18not simply retreads of the types of you know, b movies that Wayne was
- 8:22making a Republic in the thirties. They're very contemporary films, but they're negotiating
- 8:28changing times in a different way than is a film like mccabean, Missus Miller
- 8:33or The Culpepper Cow Company. Let's say so, I think the most important
- 8:37thing is to remember what a big star Wayne was. I mean, in
- 8:41a way, he's bigger than Eastwood, bigger than Redford, bigger than Paul
- 8:45Newman. It sounds strange for me to say that, but he was there
- 8:50alongside those you know, new Hollywood faces. Yeah. No, absolutely.
- 8:56So. I have an eighteen year fourteen year old at home, and so
- 9:01it's hard to get them to sit down and watch movie old movies with dad
- 9:05from time to time. But one movie that I have kind of gotten through
- 9:09to them is a John Wayne movie, The Man Who Shot at Liberty Violence,
- 9:13and that was a film from beginning to end. My kids are sitting
- 9:18there watching and kind of glued, and I have to sit there and laugh
- 9:22and say, it's black and white. You know, all these characters are
- 9:26gone or deceased in there, but yet they're able to kind of be pulled
- 9:31in here. It is in twenty twenty three, in reality that they should
- 9:37be saying, Dad, I want to go see something else in color or
- 9:39anything. But he still has that draw. And I think that's kind of
- 9:43the point that you're saying that even over time, he still can reach a
- 9:48new generation. I think that's true. I mean, there's something about Wayne,
- 9:52and you know, Wayne has a lot of political baggage that I think
- 9:54is an impediment to taking him seriously as an actor. But certainly when I
- 10:00when I teach Wayne's films, there's a recognition among at least my students that
- 10:05you know, there was kind of more than meets the eye, that he
- 10:09actually was a good performer, and that he was able to, especially in
- 10:13the best moments, often when prodded by John Ford, you know, do
- 10:18do the type of work that was on par with what any of the great
- 10:22actors were doing. You know, in The Searchers, the man who shot
- 10:24Liberty Violence, and I think the man who shot the Liberty Violence is actually
- 10:28a good one because you know, that's a comparatively late film, sixty two,
- 10:33and that film is a little bit more explicit about what it's trying to
- 10:37do than earlier four films, because it could be because it was the sixties.
- 10:41So I could see that film kind of you know, having enough to
- 10:45hook the contemporary viewer and ideally lead them back to the riches that is the
- 10:50Western of the fifties and forties. Yeah, you know, and you brought
- 10:52up John Ford. You know, I had heard that he kind of treated
- 10:58John Wayne in a manner that most people probably wouldn't and kind of go away
- 11:03with it to try to light that fire. Yeah, yeah, I mean
- 11:07Wayne Wayne, Wayne called Ford many things, but he called him, called
- 11:13him coach, which I think gives an indication of how he viewed that relationship.
- 11:20It's true, Yes, Ford could get away with saying things to Wayne,
- 11:24doing things to Wayne even later in his life that no director, no
- 11:28other director except I sect maybe Hawks and Wellman, could get away with.
- 11:33But they you know, they had a kind of a synergistic relationship, and
- 11:37I think Wayne at least recognized pretty early that this was a director who could
- 11:43get the best out of him. And it might be because they had that
- 11:48relationship where he could broad Wayne and get him a little uncomfortable that made him
- 11:52be better in those four directed films. You know, you you brought Clint
- 12:00Eastwood. You know, obviously if we consider John Wayne being number one.
- 12:05Is Clint Eastwood in the seventies number two, Oh definitely, Yeah. I
- 12:11mean he's he's at that point really the only contemporary star who's who's interested in
- 12:16making Westerns. And you know, he only he makes a relative few of
- 12:20them, especially when he gets back to the United States, but he's at
- 12:24least interested in the genre. He's interested in not as a not only as
- 12:26a performer, but also as a director in High Planes Drifter. So I
- 12:31I think so, But what's you know, kind of telling And I think
- 12:35this has a lot to do with why the Western goes away is that,
- 12:37aside from Eastwood, there is no new Western star to emerge in the sixties
- 12:43and seventies. You know, guys like Redford and Newman, they make them,
- 12:48but they they're not Western guys. You know, someone like Gary Grimes,
- 12:52who is a big young star in the late sixties and early seventies,
- 12:56makes a ton of Westerns, but that also doesn't kick on. So,
- 12:58you know, maybe one of the challenges is this failure to develop new stars
- 13:03beyond Eastwood and Eastwood even by the middle of the seventies is really pivoting hard
- 13:09away from the Western. It just becomes something that he returns to once every
- 13:13ten or twenty years when he has something to say. Right, Yeah,
- 13:20during your research, did anything surprise you during this anything surprised me? That's
- 13:26a great question. Well, I suppose just the number of Westerns that were
- 13:31made that you know, I kind of had a comprehensive filmography. It's well
- 13:37over one hundred titles, and you know a lot of them are forgotten titles
- 13:41and some are just terrible. But you know, just the number of films
- 13:46actually did surprise me. I didn't think there would be that many, and
- 13:50that I think is an indication of the you know, the true story of
- 13:54the Western of this period, that it was still a viable part of our
- 13:58popular culture. So just that volume was certainly striking. Yeah, was this
- 14:05something that the studios, studios, the studio heads, how did they feel
- 14:11about the Westerns? Were they That's a great question. It depends on the
- 14:16studio. I mean, there were there was certainly an idea, especially by
- 14:22the midpoint of the seventies, that you know, the Western was on its
- 14:26way out because it didn't have that contemporary appeal that they were looking for.
- 14:31But you know, by and large, you know, and maybe this speaks
- 14:35to another misconception about what Hollywood filmmaking was in the sixties. You know,
- 14:39just as we talked about the Western in terms of McCabe and Missus Miller and
- 14:41Little Big Man, these kind of so called New Hollywood or Hollywood Renaissance on
- 14:46tours, the story we tend to tell ourselves about American cinema that period is
- 14:50a similar one where films like Bonnie and Clyde and Easy Rider and Five Easy
- 14:54Pieces usher in something approaching an American art film. It's true that this was
- 15:00a moment where Hollywood was interested in new topics, films with youth appeal,
- 15:05with more explicit subject matter, but the go to strategy was still popular titles,
- 15:13often adapted from literature that could appeal to a broad audience. You know,
- 15:18really the beginning of what we would call the tent pole strategy, where
- 15:22it was believed that luring the general audience back to the cinema was the way
- 15:26to make the most money. So the Western fit very well into that,
- 15:31along with you know, other tried and true genres like you know, the
- 15:33war film or the musical romances. You know, we don't talk about love
- 15:39story or airport or The Towering Inferno or The Poseidon Adventure. But you know,
- 15:45those are the big hits of this period, and also when you go
- 15:48and look at them, you know, certainly more socially conscious than we might
- 15:54expect, you know, from you mentioned a few minutes ago that there was
- 16:00kind of surprised at the number of films they came out from sixty nine to
- 16:03nineteen eighty that you're looking at this book. Is there a hidden gym that
- 16:10you think is overlooked? I mean, obviously there's certain films that everybody knows,
- 16:15and but I always find that there's a hidden gym out there that gets
- 16:18overlooked. And in your opinion, what would that be, or maybe there's
- 16:22a couple. Yeah, I mean, I'll give you two. The first
- 16:27one would be Big Jake. Got a poster of it on my wall behind
- 16:30me. It's one of my favorite films. So maybe I'm a little biased
- 16:36here, but this is a film that Wayne makes in nineteen seventy one,
- 16:40and I like to tell people to watch this film because it, to me,
- 16:44is a representation of what's happening at the time. So you know,
- 16:47it's John Wayne. He's got some of his old stock company around him.
- 16:51He's got you know, Bruce Cabott is there, Marina Harrow is there for
- 16:52a little bit. He's got his own shoulder and in it he's got Mitcham's
- 16:56son in it. But it's got a rip by Rita and Julian Fink,
- 17:02who also wrote Dirty Harry. So it's actually quite violent, you know,
- 17:07kind of contemporary in some ways with echoes of the Searchers. So it's my
- 17:11favorite film of Wayne's from this period. And I've shown this one to students
- 17:18and told lots of people about it. I think it really is kind of
- 17:22a hidden jam. Another one I might recommend, and it's it can be
- 17:26a tough film to watch. It's called Olzanna's Raid. It's a film starring
- 17:32Bruce Davidson and Bert Lancaster, and it's also kind of a reworking of the
- 17:36Searchers. But it, to me is one of the best westerns of this
- 17:41periods. It's about a kind of a young army lieutenant who is paired up
- 17:48with a whily old scout and they're on the trail of some renegade apaches,
- 17:52and in true Western fashion, the young character learns hard lessons. But it's
- 17:57got a great performance from Burt Lancaster, and it is clearly a film of
- 18:03its time. It's not hard to see it in relationship to the kinds of
- 18:07conversations that we're having that time about American foreign policy. But it does it
- 18:12in a more subtle and I think nuanced way than did a film like Soldier
- 18:18Blue or A Little Big Man, for example. So that's the that would
- 18:22be the second forgotten jam I guess that I would I would strongly encourage your
- 18:26listeners to go and check out. Oh. Absolutely, well, Andrew,
- 18:30I know we're getting closer on time, But any partying words or advice for
- 18:37the audience when they're looking at films from Westerns from sixty nine to eighty to
- 18:44kind of taking consideration when they're viewing films. Yeah, that's a great that's
- 18:48a great point. Well, I think that the important thing to remember is
- 18:52that history was more complex than what's been distilled down in our textbooks. You
- 18:56know, whether whether we want to see it from a political perspective or we
- 19:00want to see it from that nostalgic perspective that you talk about. You know,
- 19:04this was a time when movies were still the dominant form of popular culture.
- 19:10You know, cable television was just kind of emerging, so the options
- 19:15available to people at home were more limited. So we shouldn't surprise us that,
- 19:19you know, there was a wide variety of films available to what was
- 19:25a very kind of homogeneous audience. The other thing I might say is is
- 19:30that we have to remember that, you know, the time itself was certainly
- 19:34more heterogeneous than those narratives might be that people themselves are more complicated that you
- 19:40know, this is a transitional moment in American history where we're kind of going
- 19:44from the sixties to the eighties. Yes, it's a period of malaise,
- 19:48but it's also you know, the rise of a kind of ethos of individualism,
- 19:52you know, something that Tom Wolf wrote about. So it's it's not
- 19:55a one to it's not a straightforward time in American history, and I think
- 19:59the films of the period, and Westerns especially reflect that kind of tension about
- 20:03you know, how do we honor the past but move forward to something better?
- 20:07And in the best westerns of the period, they're asking that question.
- 20:12One last question, you said something that kind of got me thinking, as
- 20:17what's your crystal ball? Ask you to get your crystal ball? What do
- 20:21you think that the future is for Westerns. Yeah. You know, one
- 20:23thing I write about it in the book is how there's this recurrence of two
- 20:26types of articles. One is the Western is dead article, and then there's
- 20:30the Western is back article. I mean, we're at a point now where
- 20:34the appearance of one or two Western movies and cinemas and a show or two
- 20:41on streaming or specialty cable is enough to get people to think, Ah,
- 20:47we're in a Western moment again. I mean, the way I encourage people
- 20:51to think about it is that the Western was once a popular genre. It
- 20:53was a genre for the masses, but now it's a specialty genre. It's
- 20:59at least cinematic iterations, the type of movie you make not if you want
- 21:03big box office, but if you want to win awards. And that's a
- 21:06transition that happens during the period I'm talking about where the Western goes to being
- 21:10a kind of more point. I don't know, highbrow form, and you
- 21:12know that gets crystallized in the nineties when Unforgiven and Dancing with Wolves when Oscars,
- 21:17But even today, you know, when you know the Cohen Brothers can
- 21:19make a Western and people will see it Quentin Tarantino can make a Western and
- 21:23people will see it. But you know, when Antoine Fuqua tries to make
- 21:27a kind of action Western with his magnuscent said remake, even if it's got
- 21:30Denzel and my favorite Chris in it, it just doesn't do well. The
- 21:36Lone Ranger doesn't do well. So I think the Western, you know,
- 21:40on Paramount Plus can do pretty well. And those numbers seem impressive, but
- 21:44they're not relative to what TV used to be. Films can win awards.
- 21:48You know. We've got Scorsese with a kind of Western that's on the horizon,
- 21:52and that's generating a lot of this discourse too. I think that's what
- 21:57the Western is. So I'm I'm glad that the Western is here. So
- 22:00I think rather than fretting about, you know, is it here? Will
- 22:03it go away? We should enjoy the Westerns we have and remember that there
- 22:08are dozens, if not hundreds, of great Westerns and cinema history just waiting
- 22:14to be rediscovered, you know. And you make an excellent point that I
- 22:18think, and this is not just Westerns but movies in general, is I
- 22:25think they went away from This is my personal opinion, and please disagree if
- 22:29you feel them wrong. But I think we went away from trying to master
- 22:33the art and making a good film, and we're chasing awards instead of chasing
- 22:41the classic. For a lack of a better word, yeah, I mean,
- 22:45certainly in terms of the Western, I think that's true. And you
- 22:48know, one thing that sometimes happens with movies, not just the Western,
- 22:52but all kinds of movies is ideas about movies. So the types of things
- 22:56that critics say when they interpret a movie, people like me and academics say
- 23:00when they write about the movie. You know, that was once criticism description,
- 23:04but over time those ideas can kind of filter into the popular consciousness and
- 23:11they become instructions. So if you know, criticism of the Western said,
- 23:15you know, what the Western really is is a vehicle for our great filmmakers
- 23:21to tell allegorical tales about the present set in the Old West. If that's
- 23:25what critics said, well, you know, today that's what a filmmaker sets
- 23:29out to do. And if you read interviews with Jane Campion or Scott Cooper
- 23:33or Kelly reischert people who have made recent critically claimed westerns, they'll talk about
- 23:38the Western as a metaphor for whatever is happening politically at a particular moment.
- 23:45So you know, what was once description becomes prescription, and I think that
- 23:52kind of impoverishes the form because people are, as you say, kind of
- 23:56chasing awards rather than setting out to make a just It's a great picture that
- 24:00might stand up over time. Absolutely well, Andrew, thank you again for
- 24:06coming on and spending a few minutes to talk about your book, Still in
- 24:10the Saddle the Hollywood Western nineteen sixty nine to nineteen eighty. We just talked
- 24:15for a few minutes, but the book is well worth it. Thank you
- 24:18for that, and you can order through the University of Oklahoma or Press who
- 24:22is publication of this book, or Amazon and other outlets as well. Andrew,
- 24:29again, thank you for spending a few minutes with this today. We
- 24:30really appreciate it my pleasure. Doug Well, thank you for listening to this
- 24:34episode I've Forgotten Hollywood. You can search for deckcast or Forgotten Hollywood. You
- 24:40can also find me on Twitter, Instagram, and has Doug fourteen. If
- 24:42you listen to this podcast on iTunes and another podcast service, please subscribe,
- 24:47rate and review this episode. Tune the next time for the latest episode of
- 24:49Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you for listening, and we will see you then.