Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Unruh Civil Rights Act: Fundamentals and Recent Developments
Transcript
- 0:03Good day. Welcome to the UNRWA Civil Rights Act
- 0:07Fundamentals and Recent Developments. I am Lori
- 0:10Krip -Martin, Certified Family Law Specialist
- 0:12and a former Vice Chair of the BHBA's litigation
- 0:16section. I am delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:20Christina M. Lani. Christina M. Lani is a labor
- 0:22and employment partner. at CFARTH in Sacramento,
- 0:26where she counsels and defends employers and
- 0:28public accommodations in disability access matters
- 0:32under the Title III of the ADA. She began her
- 0:36practice at the California Legislative Council's
- 0:39office advising the legislature on drafting and
- 0:42applying employment laws. an experience that
- 0:45shapes her practical approach to compliance and
- 0:47litigation. A member of SAFAR's National ADA
- 0:51Title III Specialty Team, she tracks cutting
- 0:54edge accessibility issues, including those raised
- 0:57by emerging technologies and often use structured
- 1:00negotiations to resolve matters before litigation.
- 1:03And now let's get started. Okay. Great. Hi, everybody.
- 1:10And thank you, Lori, for the introduction. I'm
- 1:13going to share my screen here. So bear with me
- 1:16for a minute while we get this set up. Okay,
- 1:31Lori, are we looking good? Do you see my slide?
- 1:36Okay, we will get started. Please speak up if
- 1:40you don't see it. And actually, let me move this
- 1:43around real quick so I can see the Q &A if it
- 1:47comes in. Okay, so today we are... talking about
- 2:00the UNRWA Civil Rights Act. And as you can see,
- 2:05this presentation is entitled Fundamentals and
- 2:08Recent Developments. So we have 30 minutes here.
- 2:11And the UNRWA Civil Rights Act has been around
- 2:15far longer than I've been alive and probably
- 2:17any of you as well. So we can't cover everything
- 2:20under UNRWA, obviously. but we will cover the
- 2:24basics on what the Act is, so what it requires,
- 2:28and then we'll dabble in a couple of specific
- 2:30areas that we see come up under UNRRA quite a
- 2:33bit. Obviously... by far not a comprehensive
- 2:36survey of UNRWA. So if you have any questions,
- 2:39feel free to ask and I will try my best to address
- 2:43them. As Lori noted, I am a specialist in Title
- 2:48III of the ADA. I've been doing it for about
- 2:5021 years now. And Title III of the ADA is the
- 2:53federal corollary to California's UNRWA Act and
- 2:58other. state laws of similar type. Title III
- 3:01of the ADA is just disability access. However,
- 3:04the UNRRA Act, as we'll talk about in a couple
- 3:06minutes, covers a variety of protected classes
- 3:09in addition to disability. So with that, we will
- 3:13dive right in. Required to put the legal disclaimer,
- 3:18as you all know, this is not legal advice. This
- 3:21is just for informational purposes only. And
- 3:26that's me one more time. Okay, so the UNRRA Civil
- 3:33Rights Act can be found at Civil Code sections
- 3:3951 and 52 of the California codes and it is very
- 3:47broad. It applies to every business establishment.
- 3:52And the reason why that terminology is important
- 3:54is because it's different than the Place of Public
- 3:56Accommodation language under Title III of the
- 3:59ADA. And we'll talk about why that is really
- 4:03significant in a little bit. It also, in this
- 4:07broad coverage, protects a number of protected
- 4:12traits or protected classes. Unlike Title III
- 4:15of the ADA, which just applies to disability,
- 4:18UNRWA applies to a number of protected traits,
- 4:21as we will talk about in a minute. And there
- 4:24has also been throughout the years a little bit
- 4:27of judicially recognized arbitrary discrimination
- 4:29coming within the UNRWA Act's purview. as well.
- 4:33Back to the business establishment terminology,
- 4:38I put the point from Brennan v. Superior Court
- 4:41here, California Supreme Court case from this
- 4:43year, which is actually a really interesting
- 4:46read, if anyone is interested, because it goes
- 4:48through a survey of the history of the UNRWA
- 4:51Act. And one of the points it makes when it's
- 4:54interpreting the meaning of business establishment
- 4:57is that that term conveys reference to commercial
- 5:00entities. those whose principal mission is the
- 5:05transactional sale of goods or services, and
- 5:08the main point there being that the whole point
- 5:11of the UNRWA Act is to cover private entities,
- 5:14private businesses, as opposed to state entities
- 5:17or local governmental entities. If we're going
- 5:21to compare to Title III of the ADA, That applies
- 5:24to private entities. Title II of the ADA applies
- 5:29to state and local governmental entities. Here
- 5:31as well, the UNREACT is the act that's intended
- 5:33to apply to private businesses rather than the
- 5:37government. If we are looking at what does it
- 5:41take to prove a violation of the UNREACT, there
- 5:45are really two different paths to liability.
- 5:48The first is to prove intentional discrimination.
- 5:52And the second is to prove an underlying violation
- 5:55of Title III of the Americans with Disabilities
- 5:59Act. We'll talk a little bit about that as we
- 6:02go forward. And then what's the remedies? If
- 6:05you can prove a violation of Title III of the
- 6:08ADA, And you'll hear me draw that comparison
- 6:13a lot, even though we're not just talking about
- 6:15disability here. But under title through the
- 6:17ADA, the only relief available is injunctive
- 6:20relief in order that the barrier for talking
- 6:24about disability access barrier be fixed, plus
- 6:28attorney's fees and costs. Under California's
- 6:31UNRWA Act, in contrast, the plaintiff can recover
- 6:36$4 ,000 minimum statutory damages per occasion,
- 6:41as well as the same injunctive relief in order
- 6:44to fix the alleged barrier and costs and attorney's
- 6:48fees. So that right there is the main reason
- 6:52why we see So many disability access cases filed
- 6:57in California compared to being filed in other
- 7:00states. We also see a pretty high number of these
- 7:03days being filed in New York because it also
- 7:05under the New York state and city human rights
- 7:08laws allows for recovery of penalties or damages.
- 7:11And we see some in Florida as well. But that
- 7:14has been quite a distinguishing factor in California
- 7:17versus other states when it comes to disability
- 7:20access cases. So those are our remedies for violation
- 7:23of the unreact. So we talked a minute ago on
- 7:29the prior slide about how to establish an unreact
- 7:36claim violation, two ways. The first way is set
- 7:40forth in section 51, subdivision B. To establish
- 7:46that violation, you need to have alleged that
- 7:50the plaintiff was denied full and equal accommodations,
- 7:55advantages, facilities, privileges, or services
- 7:59in a business establishment of any kind whatsoever.
- 8:04Essentially denied equal access to whatever services
- 8:08the business is providing because of, as you
- 8:11see in the second bullet here, the person's membership
- 8:15in a protected class or having certain protected
- 8:18traits. And there's quite the list here. It's
- 8:21not just disability, even though you'll hear
- 8:23me talk about disability quite a bit. The protected
- 8:25classes or traits under the UNRWA Act are sex,
- 8:29race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin,
- 8:34disability, medical condition, genetic information,
- 8:38marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship,
- 8:41primary language, or immigration status. So remember,
- 8:46when we're looking at UNRWA, an UNRWA Act claim
- 8:49could be brought on the basis of any of those
- 8:51protected classes or traits. The vast majority
- 8:55of UNRWA Act cases we see are based on disability
- 8:58or medical condition, but that is by far not
- 9:01the only basis on which an UNRWA Act claim can
- 9:04be brought. Again, as we mentioned on the prior
- 9:07slide and as noted here as well, Case law also
- 9:12prohibits some arbitrary discrimination by business
- 9:15establishments subject to legitimate business
- 9:18justifications and other constitutional limits.
- 9:21That is, I'm sure as you're thinking, well, that's
- 9:23kind of an opaque statement with my apologies
- 9:26that somewhat is. It's beyond the scope of our
- 9:29fundamentals session here today to cover in 30
- 9:32minutes, but wanted to at least flag it. for
- 9:35you. Now, intentional discrimination, if you
- 9:39are pursuing an unreacted claim without an underlying
- 9:44violation of the ADA is required. So you can't
- 9:48just say that someone discriminated against me
- 9:51or denying me access to the goods or services
- 9:53because of my sex, race, color, et cetera. that's
- 9:59not going to be enough to prove a claim. You
- 10:00have to also allege that there was intent to
- 10:04discriminate on those bases to state a claim.
- 10:07Now, if it's a disability access claim, Then
- 10:11you can say that there is an underlying violation
- 10:15of the Americans with Disabilities Act. You can
- 10:17do that by reference to the ADA standards that
- 10:21are set forth in the federal regulations. These
- 10:25days it's the 2010 ADA standards, which are similar
- 10:29to the California Building Code. And a few years
- 10:32ago, California harmonized its California Building
- 10:35Code accessibility provisions with the ADA 2010
- 10:38standards. still have some differences, but they're
- 10:41pretty consistent now. But if there's an underlying
- 10:43violation of one of those ADA standards or, for
- 10:47example, ADA's effective communication or reasonable
- 10:50modification or even service animal provisions,
- 10:53that can serve as the basis for an unreact violation
- 10:57as well. And if there is an underlying violation
- 11:00of the ADA, no intent is required. Again, we
- 11:05see this usually. in the physical access space
- 11:08or these days a lot in the website accessibility
- 11:11space or in the accessibility of other sorts
- 11:14of technologies. We see a lot of kiosk or self
- 11:18-service technologies cases as well that have
- 11:21come through these days when we're talking about
- 11:23the disability access side of things. As I mentioned,
- 11:30physical and digital accessibility. We have a
- 11:34blog that we put out at CIFAR that's at www .adatitle3,
- 11:40and the three is romanumeralii .com, so adatitle3
- 11:44.com. Again, since this is a fundamentals course,
- 11:48I didn't put any of the data slides that we prepare
- 11:51and post on our blog, but you fear it all, curious
- 11:53to see the trends in disability access filings
- 11:57over the years, both in California, federally,
- 12:01and in other states. We track it there. We've
- 12:03been tracking it since 2013. I think it's the
- 12:06first year. We track on the basis of all different
- 12:10types of ADA Title III cases and then also just
- 12:15website accessibility cases because those cases
- 12:18specifically exploded over the past really, you
- 12:23know, 8 to 10 years or so. So we still see the
- 12:28vast majority of the cases being filed alleging
- 12:31physical accessibility barriers. In other words,
- 12:35the ramp isn't constructed so that it is the
- 12:38appropriate slope under the California Building
- 12:40Code and the ADA Title III standards or the grab
- 12:43bars weren't placed at the right measurements
- 12:45or there's, you know, cracks in the sidewalk
- 12:50that are too large. The signage is missing at
- 12:53the parking lot. Still lots and lots of cases
- 12:56like that come through. Some service animal cases,
- 13:00not as much as there used to be. I haven't seen
- 13:02as many lately. And like I said, we've actually
- 13:05seen a decent number of accessible technology
- 13:08cases coming through. So those. The building
- 13:14accessibility cases are the typical physical
- 13:17accessibility cases. When we get to accessible
- 13:19technologies, some of those can be physical.
- 13:22Somebody with a mobility disability encounters
- 13:25a barrier to using them. Like for example, there's
- 13:27not enough sufficient clear space or the screen
- 13:30is too high, things like that. But those technologies...
- 13:34accessibility cases also cross over into things
- 13:38that are more similar to a digital accessibility
- 13:40case where somebody who is blind or has a hearing
- 13:43related impairment, most usually other disabilities
- 13:45can come into play as well. But typically it's
- 13:47blind or hearing related disabilities cannot
- 13:51use the technology because it's not coded to
- 13:54work with a screen reader that can audibly read
- 13:56to them what is shown or written on the screen.
- 13:59Or if there's a hearing related disability, there's
- 14:03not closed captioning or other assistive technology
- 14:06type tools so that they can read what is audibly
- 14:10said on the technology or the website. Those
- 14:15are the two main categories we still see of disability
- 14:20access cases. Because, again, the most prevalent
- 14:24type of Unruh Act case that we usually see these
- 14:27days is disability access and its website accessibility.
- 14:33We have a couple of points here just to highlight
- 14:36some of the principles under website accessibility.
- 14:40This is a place where California is unique and
- 14:43some might say a little bit less plaintiff friendly
- 14:48than some other states. The current prevailing
- 14:52law in California, both in the federal courts
- 14:54and to the state courts, is that there is a physical
- 14:58nexus that is required between a website and
- 15:03a physical place of business. for the website
- 15:08to be subject to the ADA and as such, because
- 15:12they're usually basing the ADA violation or the
- 15:15unwracked violation on a violation of the ADA
- 15:17and therefore allow for an unwracked act claim
- 15:21without intentional discrimination. So in California,
- 15:24you have to have this physical nexus. That's
- 15:26the rule in Florida. It's the rule in some other.
- 15:28Courts as well in contrast in like the district
- 15:32of Vermont, Massachusetts, some other federal
- 15:36and state courts. The courts have held the opposite
- 15:39in a sense that ace. a web -only business or
- 15:44a business where the website does not have a
- 15:46connection to a physical place of business can
- 15:50be subject to Title III of the ADA. Put up just
- 15:53a sampling of the cases here that have held that
- 15:57the Nexus is required in California and that
- 16:01an online -only business is not a place of public
- 16:04accommodation under the ADA. There has also been
- 16:08interesting language in some of the cases that
- 16:11a website that is not accessible or is not coded
- 16:15to be accessible in and of itself, that doesn't
- 16:19establish intent to give rise to an UNRWA Act
- 16:22claim separate from an underlying ADA claim.
- 16:26As you can see from the second to bottom bullet
- 16:27here, the cotton wash case held that the notice
- 16:32of a facially neutral websites allegedly discriminatory
- 16:37effect with failure to remediate does not adequately
- 16:41establish intentional discrimination. There must
- 16:44be affirmative, willful misconduct. So that is
- 16:50an interesting point, especially just because
- 16:53California usually is really on the forefront.
- 16:56And in this one, the courts have been a little
- 16:59more conservative than they have in some other
- 17:01jurisdictions. So elements of a disability access
- 17:07claim, and then I threw in just a tiny little
- 17:10bit outstanding because that as well is a much
- 17:14larger discussion topic. elements of a disability
- 17:19access claim, which really do apply to any UNRWA
- 17:22Act claim. But again, because we see most of
- 17:24the cases in disability access, it's a good framework
- 17:27to use here. So first of all, the plaintiff must
- 17:30have personally encountered the barrier or was
- 17:33genuinely deterred from trying to seek access
- 17:37to the business establishment because they knew
- 17:40there was a barrier there. Same on bases other
- 17:44than disability access, if it's on a different
- 17:47protected trait, that the basis for the alleged
- 17:52denial of access is coming, the person still
- 17:54needs to have been denied access, have attempted
- 17:57to access the business establishment in some
- 18:00way and been denied due to their membership in
- 18:03the protected class. The second element, so they've
- 18:06encountered the barrier. Secondly, they were
- 18:09denied full and equal access. In the disability
- 18:11access space, the violation must have caused
- 18:14difficulty, discomfort, embarrassment, or interference
- 18:18with the individual's access to the business
- 18:21establishment's goods or services. That is an
- 18:25element that over the years had been discussed
- 18:28in case law and was amended into the law. And
- 18:32then occasion -specific damages. We see quite
- 18:35a bit, even still, that plaintiffs try to stack
- 18:38statutory damages. and say $4 ,000 like for example,
- 18:42if you have a large hotel with lots of violations
- 18:45throughout the hotel, they may say it's 4 ,000
- 18:50for the ballroom, it's 4 ,000 for the parking
- 18:52lot. 4 ,000 for the restaurant. The courts have
- 18:56made clear and the legislature's made clear that
- 18:58you can't stack damages like that. It's one incidence
- 19:03of statutory damages per encounter with the entire
- 19:06place of public accommodation unless they're
- 19:09clearly. disparate spaces or disparate places
- 19:12of accommodation or under the unwracked business
- 19:16establishments. And you also can't return day
- 19:19after day after day for the purpose of stacking
- 19:22statutory damages. Amendments came in the series
- 19:28of the Section 55 .56 sections of the Civil Code,
- 19:34which put into place a statutory scheme to try
- 19:38to make this a bit more manageable for businesses,
- 19:41especially small businesses. If you're interested,
- 19:44it's a really interesting setup that the California
- 19:46legislature put into place, including a California
- 19:49certified access specialist program and certification
- 19:52program. And with that, it helps provide some
- 19:56relief to small businesses, mostly if they've
- 20:00gotten a CASP inspection and done certain things
- 20:02to try to mitigate accessibility barriers in
- 20:06advance. But the main point from this slide is
- 20:10that construction -related statutory damages
- 20:12are tied to a particular occasion and that you
- 20:16can't stack them. The point on testers just to
- 20:20make briefly, a tester is somebody who doesn't
- 20:24necessarily have a genuine intent to use the
- 20:28business's goods or services. They rather are
- 20:30visiting the business's goods or services for
- 20:33the purpose of seeing if the business complies
- 20:37with the ADA. standards or complies with the
- 20:40California Building Code and thus the UNRA Act.
- 20:44And there is case law that says that as long
- 20:49as a person has personally encountered an ADA
- 20:52violation or a California Building Code violation
- 20:55while transacting business with or transacting
- 20:59with the business has standing to bring an UNRA
- 21:02Act claim regardless of whether their intent
- 21:04was to go there to drum up a lawsuit. or not.
- 21:10This is something that, again, is different in
- 21:13different jurisdictions. We had thought that,
- 21:16I believe it was last year, maybe the year before,
- 21:19that the US Supreme Court may take up the issue,
- 21:22and it did not. So we still have splits of authority
- 21:25amongst the different states when it comes to
- 21:28the ADA and test or standing. But here is some
- 21:30recent authority on unreacted test or standing.
- 21:34So we talked a ton about disability access. My
- 21:38apologies for belaboring on that, but we'll touch
- 21:41on some of the other bases. Remember a couple
- 21:44of slides back, we listed out all of the traits
- 21:47protected classes that fall within the UNRWAX
- 21:51purview. Here's just a sampling of some cases.
- 21:54recently where various other protected classes
- 21:58other than disability have arisen. So under gender
- 22:03sexual orientation, the Cathy's creation case,
- 22:09which was a court of appeals case from 2025 dealt
- 22:12with the refusal of a bakery to sell a pre -designed
- 22:16wedding cake under a same sex wedding policy
- 22:20and it was argued that that was facially discriminatory
- 22:25and therefore the requisite intent was there
- 22:28for an unreact violation and that the fact that
- 22:31the bakery said they can just go somewhere else
- 22:34and get a cake that isn't enough to supply equal
- 22:37access. You have to provide equal access to your
- 22:39goods or services, not saying we refuse to serve
- 22:41you. You can go somewhere else for them to serve
- 22:44you. Under some age, and the reason why I have
- 22:48age and gender here is because the first case
- 22:52that was noted in the bullets here, they were
- 22:56alleged. To be discriminating the business establishment
- 23:00was alleged to be discriminating based on both
- 23:03classes the plaintiff claimed that the Social
- 23:08media companies and here we're trying to avoid
- 23:11naming the specific defendants since this is
- 23:13for informational purposes only, but it was a
- 23:15social media company and saying that that company's
- 23:18ad delivery algorithm discriminates against women.
- 23:21So on the basis of gender as well as on the basis
- 23:24of age against older people here, this was on
- 23:29an early demur. So the court found that the complaint
- 23:32alleged sufficient facts to state a cause of
- 23:35action. We don't know if the court. ultimately
- 23:37found that there was a valid cost of action or
- 23:41a valid claim stated here sufficient to recover
- 23:45for a violation of the claim, but they at least
- 23:47found it was sufficiently pled to go past the
- 23:51pleading stage. And then in the second example
- 23:55here, the court of appeals found a CCNR restriction
- 23:59against the operation of an abortion clinic within
- 24:03a common interest development was void because
- 24:06it limited the use of the property based on a
- 24:11characteristic protected by the UNRWA Act, which
- 24:14would have been gender female because it was
- 24:16an abortion. clinic that they wanted to operate
- 24:19on this property that had the CCNR restriction.
- 24:21So I thought that was a rather interesting case
- 24:23as well that came down this year. Rates of national
- 24:27origin, I have not listed any. case specific
- 24:31cases here because we've seen it come up a number
- 24:34of times both in lawsuits and in demand letters
- 24:37against retailers and others claiming that someone
- 24:41was being profiled or otherwise denied access
- 24:45to the businesses goods or services because of
- 24:49their race. So wanted to flag that for you even
- 24:52though we can't mention any specific cases there
- 24:54and then we have marital status. In this one,
- 24:58the Court of Appeal agreed with the trial court,
- 25:01which found that a California Department of Insurance
- 25:04regulation that allows private auto insurers
- 25:07to use marital status as a factor in setting
- 25:11rates was okay, so long as there is a substantial
- 25:16relationship between marital status and risk
- 25:19of loss. Under those circumstances, the court
- 25:23found it would not violate the UNREACT, and that
- 25:25was a case that also came down this year in 2026.
- 25:30There were a number of cases that I found that
- 25:32either alleged a violation of the UNREACT based
- 25:36on immigration status or national origin. So
- 25:41because there were a number of them, we didn't
- 25:42list any here, but that is something that we've
- 25:44seen come up under the UNREACT as well. So some
- 25:49recent legislative attempts and changes. I could
- 25:52have done many, many slides on this because both
- 25:55under the ADA as well under UNRRA, almost every
- 25:59single legislative session, there is an effort
- 26:01to reform the UNRRA Act, usually to try to build
- 26:06in protections for small businesses to avoid
- 26:09getting hit. by lawsuit after lawsuit alleging
- 26:13that their parking lot isn't right, or they have
- 26:15a sign that fell down, or their bathrooms are
- 26:17not perfect, because it really is extremely burdensome
- 26:22on small businesses who just simply don't have
- 26:24the information to know what they need to do
- 26:26to comply with the California Building Code and
- 26:29the UNRWA Act. Again. topic for a completely
- 26:32different, more in -depth presentation. So we
- 26:34just have two very recent legislative efforts
- 26:37here. The first is something that was in the
- 26:40UNRWA Act, but also in FEHA and in the Education
- 26:43Code. In 2024, effective January 1st, 2025, the
- 26:49legislature passed SB 1137, which was an intersectionality
- 26:54bill. This change to the UNREACT clarified that
- 26:58UNREF prohibits discrimination on the basis not
- 27:01just of individual protected traits, but also
- 27:04on the basis of the combination of two or more
- 27:06protected traits. So when you pull up the UNREACT
- 27:10and it says, you know, last revised 2025, that's
- 27:13the change that was made. Even though the legislative
- 27:16intent says this is intended to just be clarifying
- 27:19of existing law. It's what the courts have already
- 27:21held that if you have more than one protected
- 27:24trait that not UNRRAC is going to protect you
- 27:27on all those bases. SB 84 from 2025 died in committee
- 27:35in June 2025, but it was one of a number of efforts
- 27:38that we've seen over the years, both in California
- 27:40and federally to amend the ADA and the UNRRAC
- 27:44to allow for notice to be required to be provided.
- 27:50to businesses in California, mostly smaller employers
- 27:54here or smaller businesses, and then an opportunity
- 27:57for the business to correct the accessibility
- 28:00violation before someone can sue on the basis
- 28:03of that violation. And it would have limited
- 28:06statutory damages, fees, and costs for a business
- 28:09that timely corrects the violation. Like I said,
- 28:13it died in committee, so that's not gonna be
- 28:15law. We still have instead the existing civil
- 28:19code section 55 .3 through 55 .56, which I talked
- 28:24about briefly earlier, procedures and that applicable
- 28:28CASP framework to help a little bit with mitigating
- 28:33the risk of damages, but that statutory scheme
- 28:37didn't quite work out as well as everyone had
- 28:39hoped. We've seen for the most part a lot of
- 28:43status quo in the litigation, but we will continue
- 28:45to see uncertain legislative reform efforts year
- 28:48after year after year. Okay, so we are going
- 28:52to wrap up with defending an UNRRA Act claim.
- 28:56What is the typical life cycle? First of all,
- 29:00you know, I only do defense. I represent businesses,
- 29:03small and large, when they are hit with any sort
- 29:07of discrimination claim, be it UNRRA, the Disabled
- 29:11Persons Act, the ADA, and even employment laws.
- 29:15The way it starts, almost always, sometimes you'll
- 29:18get a complaint made through the employer or
- 29:20the business. internal complaint system, but
- 29:23usually you get a demand letter or you get a
- 29:25lawsuit straight away, or you might receive a
- 29:28charge or complaint from the California Civil
- 29:31Rights Department. Typically, you're gonna ask
- 29:35the plaintiff's attorney that sends you the demand
- 29:37letter or the lawsuit if they can provide more
- 29:39details about what barriers the plaintiff encountered,
- 29:43where they encountered them. when they encounter
- 29:45them, any details that you can get to try to
- 29:48investigate and then see if you can discuss and
- 29:51resolve the matter without. having litigation.
- 29:53That's better for everybody, especially when
- 29:56we're dealing with disability access claims.
- 29:59The sooner the barrier is fixed, the sooner everybody
- 30:01else who might have a disability can use the
- 30:05facility without encountering that barrier as
- 30:08well. You're going to want to evaluate the alleged
- 30:11barriers. Retain a consultant, perhaps, depending
- 30:14on what the nature and extent of the alleged
- 30:16barriers is. And then always, of course, as you
- 30:19know in litigation, you need to issue that litigation
- 30:22hold. letter and in it you need to make sure
- 30:24that video is preserved if there is any surveillance
- 30:27or other video. If it's a web accessibility case,
- 30:29a copy of the code or versions of the website,
- 30:33applicable policies, any sort of remediation
- 30:36history if you've remediated barriers before,
- 30:38and any sort of related communications. One very
- 30:41interesting point under the ADA and UNREACT is
- 30:45these are public policy statutes. This is why
- 30:47we have statutory damages. It's sort of a private
- 30:50attorney attorney's general type of law. The
- 30:53point is to make the statutory damages there
- 30:55so that people will pursue lawsuits and try to
- 30:59effectuate change to improve access for everyone.
- 31:02So we do see a number of demand letters saying.
- 31:05Don't touch anything. You can't destroy evidence.
- 31:08And there is case law in California that says
- 31:11it is contrary to the public policy of the ADA
- 31:13and the Under Act to not remediate the barrier
- 31:16when you know that it's there. So you need to
- 31:18make sure you've preserved what the condition
- 31:20was, taken pictures of it, taken recordings of
- 31:22it, but you should fix it to improve access to
- 31:25the public. And then reviewing the litigation
- 31:28history of the property, the website, the plaintiff.
- 31:32Determining whether you can resolve early, especially
- 31:35because, I mean, in Florida, the judges force
- 31:38you to early resolution because they don't want
- 31:39to see these cases in their courts. But it's
- 31:42better for everyone if you can work this out
- 31:44without protracted litigation. Assessing if remediation
- 31:48is required and the effort and time needed. If
- 31:52you are in an area and it's a disability access
- 31:54case where it snows, it's going to be a whole
- 31:56different ball of game and time frame than if
- 31:59you aren't. then finally again determining early
- 32:04resolution or dispositive motion. I put that
- 32:08again because you're probably going to revisit
- 32:09that multiple times. And if you can't do it that
- 32:15way, then you may have to proceed through litigation.
- 32:18But hopefully you can figure out what the alleged
- 32:21barriers are or figure out whatever the conduct
- 32:23was that led to an alleged violation of UNRWA
- 32:27based on any other sort of protected class. Work
- 32:30it out with the plaintiff or the claimant before
- 32:33we get into litigation and clog up the courts
- 32:36with these cases. But with that, that's your
- 32:3930 minute high level. Thank you for joining me.
- 32:45I'm going to check and see if there's any burning
- 32:47questions, but if not, you have my contact information
- 32:53there. If there's anything that I missed or any
- 32:55other questions that you might have, feel free
- 32:57to let me know. All right. So just look like
- 33:11we have two questions within our Zoom Q &A, one
- 33:15from Heather Atkinson. Have you seen examples
- 33:17of UNRWA applied to homeowner association cases
- 33:20or other housing type cases? I have and I've
- 33:26had cases like this in various contexts and actually
- 33:31mediated a case where it was a homeowner association
- 33:37case. You really need to look at the facts of
- 33:40those cases because obviously if it is somebody's
- 33:44private residence, UNRWA doesn't apply. If it
- 33:48is an apartment building, it only applies to
- 33:52certain parts of the apartment building in terms
- 33:55of the true disability access sort of context.
- 33:59So it can even be a hybrid case where Some of
- 34:05the alleged wrongful conduct might be attributed
- 34:08to the association. Some might be attributed
- 34:11to an individual owner. Some might be attributed
- 34:14to a private not open to the public. part of
- 34:17the facility versus the public facility. So it
- 34:21certainly has been applied, but it's going to
- 34:24be very, very fact specific. We've also seen
- 34:27it in the context of assisted living facilities,
- 34:32dorms, things like that. And it is very, very
- 34:34fact specific, but the case law is out there.
- 34:36And if you have any thing more specific on that,
- 34:38be happy to chat with you about it. All right.
- 34:43It looks like we have another question. Can a
- 34:45non -attent disability claim arise from a mold
- 34:48tenant case where tenant advises landlord about
- 34:52some conditions and worries about mold test positive
- 34:55for specific mold first conditions and landlord
- 34:58goes from well remediate as soon as possible
- 35:03to the next day refusing to remediate based on
- 35:05a pretext. Would the deterrence be to continue
- 35:08residing safely? Um, let's see denied full equal
- 35:12access being denied residing in safe environment
- 35:15or would only the intentional discrimination
- 35:17basis apply. Wow, that's almost like a law school
- 35:21question there. It depends on what the context
- 35:29is if this is an apartment building or a private
- 35:32home. And I think I need to think about this
- 35:37one. A little more. I don't know. I mean, this
- 35:42definitely isn't a clean unwracked claim. I think
- 35:44it might be a hybrid sort of claim as well. And
- 35:50that other housing laws would apply as well.
- 35:55But I can't that's one I can't answer off the
- 35:57top of my head because it's a pretty loaded question.
- 35:59But I'll certainly think on it. Private home
- 36:04rental. Well, if it's a private home. Oh, goodness.
- 36:10Yeah, let me think about that once more. And
- 36:13then I see the third question here. Walk through
- 36:17race claim. I'm not sure what you mean there,
- 36:22but I think, I mean, I could tell you just as
- 36:25a general matter, some of the cases we've seen
- 36:27are somebody of a certain race saying, you know,
- 36:32I... attempted to shop in your store and was
- 36:35asked to leave because of my race or you didn't
- 36:40allow me in with a backpack, but you allowed
- 36:44people of different races in with a backpack,
- 36:48all sorts of variations relating to that. You
- 36:51didn't accept my return because of my race, but
- 36:54you accepted other people's returns. There's
- 36:58a number of different variations that could be
- 37:00a race. um or other sorts of protected classes
- 37:05similar to race sort of and it could be gender
- 37:07as well um or national origin with those same
- 37:11sorts of theories all interesting questions though
- 37:17thank you for them okay well if there aren't
- 37:25any other questions thank you again for tuning
- 37:28in i hope you'll have a great rest of your day