Latest / Politics with Paul / Are Campaigns About Mobilization or Persuasion? Why it Matters | Politics with Paul #73
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about whether campaigns are about persuasion or mobilization.
- 0:15One of the most important questions a political campaigner must ask themselves is how much
- 0:20their campaign is about persuading people to vote and how much of it is about mobilizing
- 0:26people to vote.
- 0:27How they answer this question will dictate a lot about their campaign plan, and many
- 0:33campaign strategies and tactics fall into one of these two buckets.
- 0:38Some voters, no matter what you do, will never be convinced to vote for you or your cause,
- 0:43while some voters are guaranteed to
- 0:45vote for you.
- 0:46And there are
- 0:47a ton of electoral factors that impact whether you should focus primarily on persuasion or on
- 0:52mobilization.
- 0:53Yet there are no clear guidelines or checklists that tell you which one you should use.
- 0:59So how do we distinguish between persuasion and mobilization?
- 1:03And which one is quote unquote best?
- 1:07Can one campaign use both?
- 1:09What electoral factors should we look at to determine which way we should go, whether it's
- 1:15persuasion or mobilization?
- 1:17And perhaps most importantly, why does this matter for you, even if you aren't involved in
- 1:23politics for a living?
- 1:25That's what today's episode is about.
- 1:27So let's get into it.
- 1:28First of all, what exactly is the difference between persuasion and mobilization?
- 1:34Some people, no matter what you do, no matter what you say, no matter how convincing you
- 1:39think you are, they're just never gonna vote for you.
- 1:42They've already got their mind made up that they're going the opposite direction.
- 1:46There's nothing you can do about it.
- 1:48Likewise, there are some people that are gonna vote for you no matter what you do.
- 1:52You could have all sorts of scandals or gaffes, any sort of things that you think would tank
- 1:59your
- 2:00standing with some other voters, there
- 2:03are still some voters that are just gonna steadfast be behind you.
- 2:08Now how many of those voters there are for each of those groups, that depends on the race.
- 2:15But it's ultimately about knowing who is in your base.
- 2:18So that is the people who are already predisposed to vote for your candidate or your
- 2:24cause and who was not in that base.
- 2:27It's not necessarily an exact science though.
- 2:30There's no like I said at the intro, there's no clear checklist or rubric that tells you, okay,
- 2:37this is a persuadable voter.
- 2:39This is a mobilization voter.
- 2:42You have to determine that through analyzing the race and all its factors.
- 2:47So let's get a little
- 2:49bit more into both of
- 2:51these kinds of strategies, if you will.
- 2:56So mobilization, it's about galvanizing your existing base so that they are energized to
- 3:01come out to vote for you.
- 3:03These are the quote unquote true believers.
- 3:06These common appeals that you see when it comes to mobilization, if you look at campaigns that
- 3:11mobilize voters, they usually will highlight a candidate's partisan or ideological
- 3:17credentials.
- 3:18This one's a true conservative warrior.
- 3:20This one is a true liberal warrior or progressive warrior.
- 3:24And they'll also advertise in media that that base typically consumes.
- 3:28So if you are conservative and you're you're trying to appeal to conservative voters, you'll
- 3:34probably advertise in things like Fox News or Newsmax or One American News.
- 3:41If you're a liberal, you might be advertising things like NBC News, CNN, or Slate.
- 3:50When it comes to mobilizing, you could be mobilizing for your side or against the other
- 3:56side.
- 3:57A lot of campaign appeals are about we can't let this other person win.
- 4:01They're terrible.
- 4:02Are you gonna be a good democrat?
- 4:03Are you gonna be a good republican and vote for us so we don't have this terrible person that's
- 4:07gonna destroy everything?
- 4:09A lot of mobilization appeals sound like that.
- 4:12This is often the quote unquote easier of the two between mobilization and persuasion because
- 4:18these are people who are already predisposed to vote for you.
- 4:22So you have to do relatively less work to convince them, but it's not it's not easy by
- 4:29any means.
- 4:30At least for some of these voters, it's not easy to mobilize them.
- 4:36If you don't mobilize these kinds
- 4:37of voters, they probably just won't vote at all.
- 4:40These are people that are very likely just like, I can't vote for the other person, but
- 4:45you suck, and I can't vote for you.
- 4:48So they'll just stay at home.
- 4:49Or they'll come out to vote, but they'll just not vote on your particular race.
- 4:53They'll just fill out the rest of the ballot.
- 4:57Now on the other side is persuasion.
- 5:00This is about convincing people not already in your existing base to, quote unquote, come over
- 5:06to your side to vote for your candidate or your cause.
- 5:11And common appeals will be things like hiding the personal traits of the candidate.
- 5:14This person's honest.
- 5:16He's got integrity.
- 5:17He served in the military.
- 5:18Now whether they're honest or they have integrity, obviously, that's in the eyes of the
- 5:22beholder.
- 5:23But you often hear about those kinds of things.
- 5:25It doesn't necessarily focus on specific issue stances.
- 5:29Now sometimes it will, but a lot of
- 5:33times they will just try to be more straight emotional appeals of like, oh, look at how
- 5:39great this person is as a human being.
- 5:42Or they'll be try to be informative like, oh, you don't know about this person.
- 5:47So let me tell you about him.
- 5:49Now, obviously, whether the information they're giving you is true is true or not, that may
- 5:54that's that's for you to figure out.
- 5:57And advertising and media that people outside the base consume.
- 6:00So if a Republican candidate thinks that there are some people that they can get on the other
- 6:07side, they might advertise in liberal resources.
- 6:10And if there's a Democrat that thinks they can get some Republican voters, they'll advertise
- 6:14in more conservative
- 6:16media.
- 6:17Now, obviously, that could be a
- 6:19bit of a gamble, but there's all sorts of media outlets.
- 6:23There's a plethora of media outlets that people can advertise in.
- 6:27And then, of course, you have the ones that are not specifically for one or the other side,
- 6:33like some newspapers.
- 6:35Some newspapers will clearly side with Republicans or Democrats, but not all of them
- 6:40will.
- 6:41Or some of them might be slightly leaning towards one side or the other, but they still
- 6:45have a good mix of both left, right, and middle voters.
- 6:52And, no, so this can be about persuading people about why your side is the better or only good
- 6:59option or about why the other side is not fit for office.
- 7:03So it can sound a little bit like mobilization sometimes.
- 7:05It's not just about convincing people, though, through arguments about your views on political
- 7:10issues.
- 7:10Some people just have their political views set in stone.
- 7:14Even if they're persuadable voters, they still might have concrete issue stances that are just
- 7:20not co do not coincide with your own if you're running for office.
- 7:27But you might try to get these people on personal traits or their capability of winning
- 7:32or why somebody who doesn't often vote should come out to vote for you.
- 7:37So some people are just either irregular voters or they don't vote at all.
- 7:44So those people you might have to persuade to come out, and that is very difficult because
- 7:51voting is a habit.
- 7:52If people don't typically vote, it's very hard to
- 7:56get them to come out to vote now now.
- 7:59Like, now
- 8:03candidates like Barack Obama and Donald Trump, they were more effective than usual at getting
- 8:10voters who don't typically or registered voters that don't typically vote.
- 8:14They were more effective at getting those people to come out, but that is those are
- 8:17exceptions to the rule.
- 8:18That doesn't really happen very often, especially for non presidential candidates.
- 8:24But if you don't persuade these kinds of voters, they might vote for the opposition
- 8:29because they can be persuaded one way or the other.
- 8:32And they they still might stay home because they're just not persuaded by anybody, but
- 8:36these are the people that you run more of a risk of losing to the other side.
- 8:42Now these are not mutually exclusive in every case.
- 8:46I'm not trying to say that they are.
- 8:48I think it's just easier to separate the two for the sake of informing and teaching people
- 8:57about these kinds of tactics and strategies.
- 9:01Some tactics that are meant to activate your base could also be trying to persuade people
- 9:05outside the base to support though.
- 9:07Like, you're talking about how horrible the other person is and that they're gonna destroy
- 9:11everything.
- 9:13You're trying to energize your base to make sure that you keep America safe and that
- 9:18America doesn't die.
- 9:22Meanwhile, that kind
- 9:25of fear is also possibly persuading other people who don't typically vote for you to say,
- 9:29oh, oh, man.
- 9:31That other candidate, he really is gonna destroy us all.
- 9:34We need to vote for this other person who's gonna make sure that America is the best it's
- 9:39ever been.
- 9:40And an individual voter who could be mobilized for one candidate or issue might be persuadable
- 9:45on a different candidate or issue.
- 9:47Maybe they're just absolutely they're gonna vote democrat or they're gonna vote republican
- 9:51or they're gonna vote third option for president every time.
- 9:54But maybe there's a mayoral candidate on the other side of the aisle that they're intrigued
- 10:03by or that they know personally, and they think, I actually really like this person.
- 10:08I'm going to vote for them.
- 10:11And, also, most campaigns must use at least a little bit of both persuasion and mobilization.
- 10:20I know I made it sound it might have sounded a little bit like, oh, these are two separate
- 10:25things you gotta do one or the other.
- 10:27No.
- 10:28That's not true.
- 10:29Rarely, if ever, is a campaign going to go 100% into one side or the other.
- 10:34I was just separating the two just to make clear the difference between the two.
- 10:39But many campaigns will have to go heavily one way or the other.
- 10:45And if you're typically, if you have
- 10:48an advantage in the electorate and you have a much larger base than the opposition, you're
- 10:53probably gonna focus more on mobilization.
- 10:55If you're at a disadvantage, you're probably gonna have to do more persuading.
- 10:59So, again, while there are no clear rules on what you should do where if if a, then you do
- 11:06mobilization.
- 11:07If b, then you do persuasion.
- 11:08Doesn't work like that.
- 11:10But there are some general rules of the thumb that you might want to follow for mobilization
- 11:15versus persuasion.
- 11:17But every election has unique circumstances, so don't just assume that you're gonna do one or
- 11:23the other without analyzing the race and the district and the candidates and all the other
- 11:28factors involved.
- 11:30And there are going to be a bunch of these factors that are relevant, and they're all
- 11:34gonna combine at the same time.
- 11:36Some that might sound more like you wanna do mobilization, but then some that sound more
- 11:40like you wanna do persuasion.
- 11:43Some of those factors are gonna be more conducive to one or the other.
- 11:48And if you ask one person on a given factor whether you should focus more on mobilization,
- 11:54another person might think that you should do more persuasion.
- 12:00And then there's also the difference between academics and political practitioners, the
- 12:05people who are actually on the ground, they tend to see things differently too.
- 12:09Academics can look at it from a 10,000 foot view, look at everything generally, and also
- 12:15have the time to study these things.
- 12:17Whereas political practitioners are very focused on their specific races, and they have
- 12:22to make decisions quick.
- 12:24So you also have to keep those perspectives in mind.
- 12:28So for many of these factors, one might argue that persuasion
- 12:32is more effective while somebody else can say it is mobilization.
- 12:36It is not often gonna be a clear objective like this is what you should do.
- 12:44But we're gonna give you some examples of factors
- 12:49where you might want to mobilize or you might want to persuade.
- 12:53So let's talk about some of those.
- 12:55First of all, if we're comparing Republicans and Democrats to independents, relatively
- 13:00speaking, independents are generally going to have to do more persuading than Republicans or
- 13:06Democrats do.
- 13:07Why?
- 13:08Well, shameless plug for my book, why independents rarely win elections and how they
- 13:13could become more competitive.
- 13:14That dives into many reasons why independents will have to persuade versus mobilize, but I'll
- 13:20talk about a few here.
- 13:21For one, independents have much lower turnout rates than the main parties.
- 13:26So there is less of a base to go with because even though it looks like, wow, there's a lot
- 13:31of independent voters, and there are a lot of independent voters.
- 13:34And a lot of times in polling, they show up as a plurality, meaning they are a larger group
- 13:40than either Democrats or Republicans, not both of them together.
- 13:44They're not a majority.
- 13:45They're a plurality.
- 13:47But independents still turn out at much lower rates, so the base is not as big as you think
- 13:54it is.
- 13:55And, also, independents have a whole wide variety of reasons why they are independents
- 14:01and not necessarily because they are middle of the road and they think the two parties are
- 14:05more extreme.
- 14:05Some of them actually think the parties are not far enough to one side or the other.
- 14:10They think Republicans are not far enough to the right or that Democrats are not far enough
- 14:14to the left.
- 14:16It might
- 14:16be a completely different reason.
- 14:18Maybe people just don't really know which party they wanna go for.
- 14:22Whatever the reason, independents are not a cohesive group, so you can't they are not just
- 14:32because you're
- 14:33an independent candidate does not make all independents part of your base.
- 14:37And many independent voters still simply go with the party that they typically lean towards
- 14:42because they think that it's a, quote, unquote, wasted vote if you choose an independent
- 14:48candidate.
- 14:49So they might as well vote for what they see as the lesser of two evils.
- 14:53And then independents typically have less media coverage and lower name recognition, so they
- 15:00just don't get themselves out there as much, partly partly of their own
- 15:05accord and partly because media just won't cover them.
- 15:08Or
- 15:09when they do cover them, it tends to be for a particular gaffe that an independent candidate
- 15:13made.
- 15:15But then between Republicans and Democrats, Republicans sometimes will do a little bit more
- 15:21mobilizing than Democrats do because Republicans usually turn out a little bit of a
- 15:27higher rate than Democrats do.
- 15:29Not always, but generally speaking.
- 15:32And then Republicans are slightly more ideologically uniform.
- 15:36They're a little bit more cohesive on what conservatism is.
- 15:40So mobilization appeals like Republicans' ideological credentials tend to be a bit more
- 15:45effective for them than Democrats.
- 15:48Democrats don't all subscribe to the progressive label, or a lot of them don't
- 15:54necessarily subscribe to the progressive label.
- 15:56Some of them just say that they're liberal.
- 15:58There's not as much
- 16:00cohesiveness ideologically for Democrats.
- 16:05So there will be a little bit more mobilization
- 16:08on the Republican side.
- 16:10But remember, that is not always the case.
- 16:13If one major party heavily outnumbers the other major party, that more numerous party is
- 16:18probably going to mobilize more, and the less numerous party is probably gonna have persuade
- 16:22more because if you have a larger base, especially a significantly larger base, then
- 16:28you're really just worried about, okay.
- 16:30I gotta make sure that all the people that are predisposed to vote for me all come out to
- 16:33vote.
- 16:34But if you're at that disadvantage, then you realize, okay.
- 16:38I need to convince more people to come
- 16:40and vote.
- 16:40Otherwise, I'm gonna get waxed in the election results.
- 16:44So larger base, typically more mobilization.
- 16:49Smaller base, typically more persuasion.
- 16:52And then if either the Republican or Democratic party decides not to run a candidate, which
- 16:57there are a lot of elections that are uncontested, which is very unfortunate, we
- 17:02should have we should strive to have every election contested and have at least two
- 17:09candidates, if not more.
- 17:12So if a democrat or a republican candidate don't run, if it's just a republican or just a
- 17:17democrat, an independent may function as a stand in for that missing party, in which case
- 17:23the independent might start mobilizing that missing party's candidates.
- 17:28Though they may still need to persuade many of them to crossover because some of those voters
- 17:31will still vote only democrat no matter what, and some of those voters will only vote
- 17:35republican no matter what.
- 17:37So some of them might be a little bit more skeptical, but still open to persuasion, and in
- 17:43which case, that independent who is filling in for that democrat or republican needs to
- 17:48persuade.
- 17:51Another factor to look at is whether you are trying to win a primary or a general.
- 17:57Obviously, in the end, you're trying to win a general election, but your mobilization versus
- 18:02persuasion strategy might change from the primary to the general.
- 18:07But there's this very simplistic view that regular citizens often believe that primary is
- 18:12about who can be the most extreme or ideological while general elections are about
- 18:17moving towards the middle.
- 18:19That's not always true.
- 18:21It sometimes, sure.
- 18:23Sometimes it'll be true, but it's very overly simplified Because there are a variety of
- 18:29primary types in US elections, not just that they all have their own unique electoral
- 18:35factors like number of Republicans and Democrats and independents, but they the
- 18:41primary structure itself is different, and that will subsequent subsequently influence how much
- 18:48persuasion and mobilization you do.
- 18:51So in a closed primary, which means only people of that party can vote in that party's primary.
- 18:58So if I'm a republican, I can only vote in a republican primary.
- 19:00If I'm a democrat, I can only vote in the democratic primary.
- 19:04You're probably going to mobilize more because you are trying to get the party's base behind
- 19:10your campaign and not with the other candidates for that same party.
- 19:16And then when you start getting more and more more and more of these candidates in a primary
- 19:22and it gets very crowded, that can also affect things too, which we'll talk about a little bit
- 19:27more shortly.
- 19:29But if you're in a in an open primary or a top two primary or Louisiana's unique majority vote
- 19:35system where if in the primary you receive a majority of the vote, you automatically win the
- 19:40election.
- 19:41But if you only get a plurality, the top two vote getters go on to the general election.
- 19:45It's different than a regular top two primary where no matter how much of the vote you get,
- 19:50top two vote getters go.
- 19:51So you can win 75, 85% of the vote in a top two primary.
- 19:57You're still going to a general election.
- 20:01But in those cases, you might now have to do more persuasion because there is a wider
- 20:05variety of voters that are participating.
- 20:08But in any case, typically speaking, primaries see a lot more of these hardcore partisan and
- 20:16ideological voters.
- 20:18So there are usually more mobilization appeals that typically, people who are not as invested
- 20:25in one party or another and or in one ideology or another are not gonna be as enthused to come
- 20:32out for primaries.
- 20:33They don't wanna have to come out multiple times to go vote, or they're just like, you
- 20:38know what?
- 20:38I'm just gonna wait for these people to decide who's gonna be in the general election, and
- 20:42then I'll start participating.
- 20:43There's all sorts of reasons that people have for doing that.
- 20:46But the people who are, like, the really strong believers in parties or strong believers in
- 20:53just voting in general, those are the ones who are going to be typically voting in a primary.
- 21:00Sometimes you'll see an uptick from one
- 21:02year to the next, but
- 21:04primaries always see much lower turnout rates than general elections do regardless of the
- 21:10primary type.
- 21:12And then so the number of primary candidates can also affect the mobilization versus
- 21:17persuasion calculus.
- 21:20A crowded primary might not let you mobilize as effectively because the base is split across
- 21:26multiple candidates.
- 21:27So you may need to persuade more people instead.
- 21:31So if you have, like, six candidates in a primary, whether it's a closed primary, open
- 21:37primary, whatever, now you might need to start changing up.
- 21:42You can't just rely on mobilization because even in a closed primary, you have a bunch of
- 21:47candidates in your party trying to vie for those same votes.
- 21:50And if you're in a top two or open or Louisiana's type of primary, now you have a
- 21:56whole bunch of other voters, and so you might have to try to pull some of those.
- 22:02So you also will sometimes see the Democratic or Republican party try to convince a candidate
- 22:08or two to drop out if there are too many in the primary because they're afraid that the vote is
- 22:16gonna split too much between their party's candidates that it's gonna let the other party
- 22:22actually take up those spots.
- 22:24So if you have if it's like a top two primary, like in California, for example, and there's
- 22:31six Democrats in one race and then there's two Republicans in that same race, you might see
- 22:37the Democratic party try to tell one or two or three of those Democrats, hey.
- 22:41Why don't you drop out?
- 22:42Obviously, the ones that they think have less of a chance of winning because if those six
- 22:48democrats split their votes up enough, then the republican candidates could actually earn those
- 22:54top two spots.
- 22:55And then so they would be guaranteed a win in the general election, whichever of those
- 23:00republicans win.
- 23:01Because in the top two primary, whoever the top two vote getters are, regardless of their
- 23:05party, go ons in general election.
- 23:07So sometimes it'll be two Democrats.
- 23:09Sometimes it'll be two Republicans.
- 23:11I don't know if there's ever there's probably been at some point two independents running
- 23:17against each other in a general election, but you're almost never gonna see that.
- 23:22And then so the general election can look different from the primary in terms of focus on
- 23:27mobilization versus persuasion because now there's an even wider variety of voters that
- 23:33are coming out to vote.
- 23:34Even if you're talking about a top two primary or Louisiana's type of primary.
- 23:38Yes.
- 23:39Even though anybody of any party can vote in those primaries, now you have the people who
- 23:43only vote in general elections also participating.
- 23:46So you might need to start persuading those people instead of just focusing on mobilization
- 23:53because you just simply have more voters that are up for grabs or that you at least need to
- 24:02make sure that you pull against
- 24:05the other candidate.
- 24:07And in
- 24:07the case of ranked choice voting, you'll probably need more persuasion there as well, at
- 24:13least if you have three or more candidates.
- 24:15Because sometimes in a ranked choice voting election, you'll still only have two candidates
- 24:21running.
- 24:21But if you have three or more, you may need more persuasion because if you don't win in the
- 24:27first round of voting, because in ranked choice voting, they tabulate votes in the first round.
- 24:33If nobody wins a majority, the lowest vote getter gets knocked out, and then they start
- 24:37voting this or tabulating the second place votes.
- 24:41And then so if you don't win in the first round of voting, you need to have convinced enough
- 24:45people to choose you in the second round.
- 24:48And then if there's a third round or fourth round, you'll need to have made sure that you
- 24:52convinced enough people to do that.
- 24:55It's not gonna be as effective to mobilize people unless, again, your base is just that
- 25:01large in which case, even ranked choice voting election might not be enough to make you have
- 25:09to try to persuade people because you can just mobilize enough voters who are already
- 25:14predisposed to vote for you.
- 25:17Again, there's all a lot of these factors that are working in tandem,
- 25:22so it affects the calculus.
- 25:24And another one of those factors is a partisan versus
- 25:27a
- 25:27nonpartisan election.
- 25:29So many elections, and certainly the vast majority of the most visible ones, are
- 25:34partisan, meaning candidates declare a party affiliation if they have one, and they are on
- 25:39the ballot as that party's candidate.
- 25:42I mean, you can potentially run as no party, but most candidates will have a republican or
- 25:49democrat or a third party label.
- 25:50But there are a lot of elections, mostly at the local level, that are nonpartisan where
- 25:55candidates appear on the ballot without party labels.
- 25:58They may be registered to vote as a Republican or Democrat.
- 26:01In fact, in reality, most of
- 26:03them are gonna be, and most of
- 26:06them are going to have certain cues that indicate they're Republican or Democrat.
- 26:11But on the ballot, they are officially nonpartisan.
- 26:13So in partisan elections, you might have more mobilization efforts than a nonpartisan
- 26:19election because they can rely on the party label as a heuristic, basically a rule of thumb
- 26:24for people to think, okay.
- 26:26I know what this candidate's about.
- 26:27I'm gonna vote for them.
- 26:28It's how people keep track of why they're voting for who they are voting for.
- 26:36And a lot of people just won't participate in a nonpartisan election because they just don't
- 26:41have that party queue.
- 26:43Because party label is the most predictive indicator of how someone will vote, making it
- 26:47the most potent mobilization factor.
- 26:50But some nonpartisan candidates, while they can't explicitly advocate as a republican or
- 26:55democrat in their campaign advertising or highlight party endorsements, the parties can
- 27:02still say who they endorse.
- 27:04So these voters who very much only vote Republican or Democrat can look at what their
- 27:11local party is saying and say, oh, okay.
- 27:13That's who they're pushing for.
- 27:15Oh, that's who I'm voting for.
- 27:17So you still may have a lot of mobilization efforts, not necessarily from the campaign
- 27:21itself, but from the parties.
- 27:24So if candidate Joe Schmo is running for office, yeah, he doesn't say that he's a
- 27:29republican or a democrat, but whichever party he is, that party might still try to mobilize
- 27:35people for his campaign.
- 27:37So even if your candidate's campaign is not doing mobilization or persuasion, the party
- 27:43might be doing it for you instead.
- 27:46Next up is ballot measures versus candidates.
- 27:50You've heard me say several times a candidate or an issue.
- 27:53That's because I'm in the in the case of issues, I'm referring to ballot measures.
- 27:58Now ballot measure campaigns are similar to candidate campaigns in some respects and then,
- 28:03of course, different in others.
- 28:06Ballot measures could be about an issue that typically has a partisan or ideological charge
- 28:11to it.
- 28:12So abortion, gun policy, labor unions.
- 28:16And if that's the case, you'll probably see more mobilization appeals since there's going
- 28:20to be more of an existing voter base to tap into.
- 28:23You can say, this is a Democrat issue.
- 28:27This is a Republican issue, so we need our all of the Democrats and all the Republicans we can
- 28:31get to vote for or against this issue.
- 28:35And then other ballot measures may have fewer partisan or ideological cues.
- 28:40So maybe something like term limits on government officials.
- 28:43That's not necessarily a Republican or Democrat or conservative or liberal issue.
- 28:47Education, government accountability.
- 28:51In this case, you might need more persuasion appeals because the base may not be as large or
- 28:56as obvious.
- 28:57You don't have a specific like, okay.
- 28:59We gotta go get a bunch of Republicans to vote for this, or we gotta get a bunch of Democrats
- 29:03to vote for this.
- 29:04You might need to pull from a lot of different sides.
- 29:07So you might see a lot of cases where politics make strange bedfellows, where Republican and
- 29:14Democratic groups will join in force for a ballot measure.
- 29:20And then on the other side, you'll see Republicans and Democrats against that measure
- 29:24for a whole bunch of different reasons.
- 29:28Then there's also the fact that how well known the issue or campaign is can complicate things
- 29:35too.
- 29:35So it's similar to the idea of name recognition for a candidate.
- 29:40Some measures get far more attention than others do, and the ones that have less
- 29:44attention may need more persuasion appeals because of the need to inform people about that
- 29:50issue or campaign.
- 29:52Whereas if you have a lot more attention on your campaign, you might have people who
- 29:56already have a specific opinion about that issue or about that ballot measure, and in
- 30:03which case then they are a base that you can tap into.
- 30:06And then another complication for whether to mobilize or persuade in ballot measure
- 30:11campaigns is whether you are on the yes side of a ballot measure or on the no side.
- 30:17So back in grad school, I remember I can't remember his name, but I remember this part
- 30:23always stuck out to me.
- 30:25He said more or less that it is, generally speaking, all else equal, easier to win a no
- 30:33campaign than a yes campaign.
- 30:35Reason being, when you're trying to win with a yes campaign, you have to convince people
- 30:43beyond a shadow of a doubt or at least strongly enough that this ballot measure is needed to be
- 30:50implemented.
- 30:51Whereas on the no side, you just have to show just enough doubts.
- 30:55You don't have to have people fully against a ballot measure, but you need them to be
- 30:59against it a decent amount,
- 31:02just enough so that they say no.
- 31:04So it's usually gonna be easier to win a no campaign versus a yes campaign, all else equal.
- 31:10So in that case, the yes side of a campaign for a ballot measure might need more persuasion
- 31:19tactics because you need to make sure you convince people about how great this ballot
- 31:23measure is and how much it is necessary.
- 31:26Whereas if it's on the no side, the persuasion might not be as necessary because you don't
- 31:34have to work as hard to convince people not to vote for a ballot measure, again, generally
- 31:39speaking.
- 31:41So you might actually do more mobilization appeals on the no vote.
- 31:46But, again, you can ask multiple political practitioners whether to mobilize or persuade
- 31:53on a given ballot measure campaign and even on the same side of a ballot measure campaign, and
- 31:59they might give you multiple answers.
- 32:01Lastly, before we end with why persuasion versus mobilization matters to you, even if you
- 32:07are not a political professional, let's run through some more electoral quirks that can
- 32:12impact persuasion or mobilization just real quick.
- 32:17So name recognition, name ID, identification.
- 32:22Well known candidates may be more reliant on mobilization since people know who these
- 32:26candidates are.
- 32:28Maybe some people who know who a candidate is but don't have an opinion yet, but a lot of
- 32:32times people already at least lean one way or another.
- 32:37Then there's money and other resources.
- 32:39So that inevitably impacts how much both mobilizing and persuasion you can do because
- 32:46campaigns cost money.
- 32:47Everything you do costs money.
- 32:49So if you have a lot of money, you probably have more of a base to rely on because they
- 32:53gave you more funds with which to operate with.
- 32:56So you might focus on mobilizing more, whereas if you have less money, you might need to
- 33:00persuade people not only to vote for you, but to also give you money.
- 33:06And persuasion sometimes, but not always, can cost more than mobilization because you may
- 33:11have to try harder to convince people to vote for you, especially if there are people who
- 33:16don't often vote.
- 33:17And and in some cases, the other side's base may be too too large where you can't pull
- 33:22enough people from the other side, and you may have to try to get people who don't typically
- 33:28vote or vote at all to try to vote for you, which is an extraordinarily difficult task
- 33:33because like we said earlier, voting's a habit.
- 33:35If people don't typically vote, it's very hard to get them to go vote.
- 33:39If they vote often, usually have to work less hard to get them to vote.
- 33:47Open seat versus incumbency.
- 33:49So if you're an incumbent or you're working for an incumbent, you're probably gonna do a little
- 33:54bit more mobilization because you have an incumbency advantage simply by being in office
- 34:00already because you are more well known.
- 34:02You often have more resources, you don't have to grapple with the quote unquote fear of the
- 34:07unknown.
- 34:07So part of why some
- 34:09people just choose incumbents is because they are afraid of, well, if we change this person,
- 34:17how do I
- 34:18know for a fact that this other candidate is going to fix things?
- 34:21Usually, you have to be really upset enough with the incumbent to actually kick them out.
- 34:28That's why you see such very high incumbency win rates, especially in congress and similarly
- 34:36across the board in elections in general.
- 34:40But if you're a challenger to the incumbent, you might be having to persuade more.
- 34:44Even if people aren't that enthused about the incumbent, you have to try to get more people
- 34:51on your side because you
- 34:51have to tell people who you are and get them to be you have
- 34:57to convince them to say, okay, you know what?
- 34:59We need something new.
- 35:01We need fresh ideas in this office.
- 35:05Now if it's an open seat, meaning the incumbent is leaving for whatever reason, they
- 35:10unfortunately passed an office or they retired or they ran for a different office, Now it gets
- 35:16a little bit trickier because if the previous office holder was well liked, then you might
- 35:21try to tie yourself to that incumbent, obviously, if you typically support that
- 35:26incumbent or you're the same party.
- 35:27So you may be focusing on mobilization more because you're trying to say, hey.
- 35:32Let's keep up what that incumbent did because he he or she did such a great job, and I'm
- 35:37gonna keep the same job going.
- 35:38So vote for me and keep this gravy train going.
- 35:42So you might mobilize more.
- 35:44If you are unlike the well liked incumbents, then you might need to do more persuading.
- 35:51But if the incumbent was not liked and they tried to hightail it because they knew they
- 35:55were gonna lose reelection, Now, you might have things flipped.
- 36:01Now, if you are unlike the incumbent, you might be mobilizing more people because you have more
- 36:06of a base that's more likely to vote for you.
- 36:08And if you are more like that incumbent that people did not like, you might have to persuade
- 36:12people to say, hey, but I'm different because blah, blah, blah.
- 36:18Incumbency versus open seat can be a lot different.
- 36:22And then even if there is an incumbent, it can be a lot different based on whether that
- 36:26incumbent was liked or not when it comes to mobilization versus persuasion.
- 36:30Turnout rates.
- 36:31This one could be very tricky to determine whether to persuade or mobilize.
- 36:36Because if it's a low turnout election like a lot of local offices are, even a few votes can
- 36:42make a big difference because there's not many of them to go around.
- 36:45So do you mobilize what you have since each vote is at a premium and there probably won't
- 36:51be any other votes to snag, or do you persuade even a few quote unquote crossover votes to
- 36:58make a difference?
- 36:59You could argue one way or the other.
- 37:03I mean, you can on a lot of these things, but this one in particular is very
- 37:08a little bit murky, I guess you could say,
- 37:14because a lot of these low turnout rates, these are people who are pretty hardcore about
- 37:18participating in politics, and they typically side one way or another.
- 37:22So there might not be many persuadable votes that are that are there to go around.
- 37:29Hot button salient political issues.
- 37:32So if a particular issue is more salient and garner stronger responses from voters, that can
- 37:37really complicate persuasion versus mobilization because this might actually
- 37:42influence enough people to change their voting habit.
- 37:49So if a candidate who otherwise could rely more on mobilization gets caught up in a corruption
- 37:54scandal, and then the corruption scandal becomes a big political issue.
- 37:58Whether or not that candidate is guilty of corruption, it's just the the very perception
- 38:03of being tied to a corruption scandal.
- 38:06That's a problem.
- 38:07So they might have to do more persuading to convince people, hey.
- 38:10I'm actually not that person.
- 38:12Or even if they are that person, they're still gonna try to convince people they're not that
- 38:15person.
- 38:16So you thought you were gonna mobilize more, but now you gotta persuade because you gotta
- 38:21make sure people think that you are still fit for the office.
- 38:26Or even if it's a more highly charged issue like abortion or gun policy, you may have been
- 38:37more mobilizing before, but now people starting the tide in your district or your state
- 38:45is starting to turn against your particular view on abortion or gun policy or whatever.
- 38:50Now people are trying to take you to task.
- 38:54Now you might need to start persuading more people about why you are still the person for
- 39:00office.
- 39:01And then lastly, districts with a history of swing voting.
- 39:05So a district that regularly changes who represents it or how it votes for governor and
- 39:12presidents and so on is probably gonna need more persuasion than mobilization because it's
- 39:16already shown that it can go back and forth.
- 39:20It might be a noticeable group of the same voters that are vacillating between Republicans
- 39:25and Democrats or just different voters showing up in different years.
- 39:29It doesn't necessarily mean the same exact voters are just changing their mind.
- 39:33It might be, but not necessarily the case.
- 39:37So just by default, you're gonna have to do more persuading because you don't want people
- 39:43to swing away from you or you're trying to get people to swing towards you, and there's
- 39:47already been a pension for that district to swing both towards the republicans and towards
- 39:54democrats or even towards an independent.
- 39:57Now the number of these districts is decreasing, and what vote party they vote for
- 40:03is becoming more predictable.
- 40:05But if you're trying to, for example, win a governor's race and there's a particular
- 40:12district that doesn't necessarily outright change whether it votes for a democrat or
- 40:16republican republican, but it does shift much more one way.
- 40:23Like, if it voted 35% republican before, but then it votes 45% republican this next election
- 40:31cycle, that might be enough for you to win a governor's race.
- 40:34So even if this doesn't swing completely towards one party or another, just making the
- 40:43vote margin in that district smaller can mean all the difference in a in an office that
- 40:49includes that district, but it's not only for that district like a US house race, US senate,
- 40:55or governor.
- 40:57So to end things off, why should persuasion versus mobilization matter to you?
- 41:04The distinction, which isn't always a distinction, is incredibly useful for a wide
- 41:10variety of people even if you are not involved in politics.
- 41:13Now for people who are involved in politics for a living or want to do it for a living or
- 41:17simply wanna be a volunteer, it's probably obvious why you wanna know, but I'm gonna talk
- 41:22about it anyways.
- 41:23Some voters, no matter what you do, cannot be convinced to support you.
- 41:27You might think you are super persuasive, that your charisma is through the roof, that I I can
- 41:33I can talk anybody into anything?
- 41:35No.
- 41:35There are some voters that are just
- 41:37not gonna bite.
- 41:39Some campaigners think they are more persuasive than they actually are, and you're gonna be
- 41:47surprised at some of the responses you get.
- 41:49But then there are some voters that no matter what you do cannot be mobilized even if they
- 41:55would otherwise support you because some some campaigners think they have a larger base than
- 42:01they actually do.
- 42:02So even if somebody's registered as a democrat and you're a democratic candidate, they might
- 42:10rarely if ever vote.
- 42:11And like we said before, voting habits are hard to break.
- 42:15So if they don't regularly vote, even if you theoretically see them as part of your vase
- 42:22your base, excuse me, they're probably not gonna vote.
- 42:26And then it's the same
- 42:27thing with Republicans.
- 42:28If it's
- 42:28a Republican that doesn't typically vote and you're a Republican candidate, they might not
- 42:33actually be part of your base because they don't typically vote.
- 42:37Knowing who to persuade and who to mobilize isn't just because you need to win a campaign.
- 42:43Obviously, that's the ultimate goal, but it also saves you a lot of time.
- 42:47You're not wasting your time trying to talk to people, trying to persuade people that can't be
- 42:51persuaded, or trying to mobilize people that can't be mobilized.
- 42:54You save money because your appeals cost money, whether you're going door to door, whether you
- 43:01are trying to send them mailers or advertise to them in some other way, and it costs you or
- 43:08saves you a lot of energy because you are not wasting your time and getting frustrated trying
- 43:14to do trying to appeal to people that are just not responding to your appeals.
- 43:19But even if you are not involved in politics, you should still understand why this
- 43:26distinction matters.
- 43:27You may have something you care about that is not necessarily all that political, but you can
- 43:34apply these mobilization versus persuasion principles to that issue.
- 43:39Even if it becomes a political issue, it might not you might not see
- 43:43it as a political issue, and it's just one particular community issue that you really care
- 43:48about.
- 43:49And so knowing who needs to be persuaded and who needs to be mobilized and who responds to
- 43:55neither really helps out that campaign of yours.
- 44:01And it's also good for just defending yourself with healthy skepticism against candidates'
- 44:07appeals.
- 44:07You should always have a healthy dose of skepticism when it comes to election time
- 44:11because they're trying all sorts of things for the express purpose of winning your vote and
- 44:16getting into office.
- 44:17And sometimes candidates will do whatever they can to get your vote, which isn't always the
- 44:23most ethical way of doing things.
- 44:26If you are predisposed to vote for somebody or some issue, you need to check your biases that
- 44:33these campaigns are trying to activate to mobilize you.
- 44:37You have to be open to other information coming in instead of needing confirmation bias where
- 44:42it's just, oh, this person thinks the same as me, then they're good.
- 44:45Okay.
- 44:45I'm just gonna vote for them.
- 44:47And then, of course, likewise, if a campaign is trying to convince you to vote for somebody you
- 44:52might be on the fence for or up for grabs for, you still need to evaluate the information that
- 44:57they are using to try to persuade you.
- 45:00For example, you need to know if it's truthful, if it's just tugging at your emotions, even if
- 45:06it's not necessarily being political, all sorts of ways that they try to use to convince you to
- 45:13to vote for them.
- 45:15So even on one side, you can't
- 45:17just be too stubborn and just be
- 45:21to the point where you don't take in any other information.
- 45:23You also can't be too open to other information that you are just easily persuaded and you
- 45:28don't have any core beliefs.
- 45:29It is perfectly fine and, in fact, encouraged to have some sort of core beliefs.
- 45:35But to the point where you won't budge on anything, that's where it becomes an issue.
- 45:39So you shouldn't be too easily mobilized and you shouldn't be too easily persuaded, and
- 45:43you'll know what kind of appeals people are using and what you respond to more easily if
- 45:50you understand this distinction between persuasion and mobilization.
- 45:54But again, they can both look the same and some appeals can be both a form of mobilization and
- 45:59persuasion.
- 46:01It's I I try to make it much more simplified so that it's more easily understandable, but when
- 46:09you really get into it,
- 46:10it can get very complex.
- 46:12So this is just more of a surface level look at things.
- 46:16But that is gonna do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 46:19So thank you so much for listening and tuning in.
- 46:23Please like, comment, and subscribe, and share these episodes with everybody you know.
- 46:28My links are in the show notes, my Facebook page, Paul Raider author and speaker, my
- 46:33LinkedIn profile, mymedium.com profile, where I write out on political science from time to
- 46:37time, my website, paulraider.org, my five day educational email course about how we can more
- 46:43effectively mitigate political polarization in this country, the sign up for that free course
- 46:49is in the show notes as well.
- 46:51And
- 46:53I think think I cover all
- 46:54of them.
- 46:55Oh, and then, of course, my my book, Why Independents Rarely Win Elections, How They
- 46:58Could Become More Competitive, which I referenced in this episode.
- 47:02The link for the ebook and paperback format will be in the show notes as well.
- 47:07So, of course, once again, thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.