Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Investment Feed Insights #9
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisers,
- 0:03all discussion is limited to publicly available information
- 0:06and should not be interpreted as legal, professional or financial advice.
- 0:09Ensemble does not hold an AFS license, nor provide any financial services.
- 0:12Before making investment decisions, you should obtain financial advice
- 0:15from a qualified financial adviser.
- 0:19Hi everyone, it's Neil Rogan here from Russell Investment
- 0:23and today I'm speaking with Alex Ica,
- 0:26who is the CEO at GlobalX ETFs here in Australia.
- 0:31Alex, the ETF market, as we know, has been growing very quickly
- 0:37and one thing I think everyone loves about ETFs,
- 0:41including myself, is that we can see how investors are behaving
- 0:46in almost real time because these ETFs are traded daily,
- 0:51we can see turnover, liquidity, etc.
- 0:54So really today I want to explore with you,
- 0:59given your role and your insights into the market,
- 1:03to really unpack how investors have reacted and acted
- 1:11during the recent geopolitical tensions that we've seen in the Middle East,
- 1:15which really started around five weeks ago, four or five weeks ago.
- 1:21So I suppose March and April were very volatile.
- 1:25Can you tell us what the Australian investors have been buying firstly
- 1:31and then I want to know what they've been selling?
- 1:34Or should I ask you what they've been selling and then what they've been buying?
- 1:37I'm even flipping in between two or three different things.
- 1:42I'll say these in a forward.
- 1:43Have they been buying and selling the same things in the same week?
- 1:48Thank you for having me back on.
- 1:50So March, normally I think with the amount of geopolitical uncertainty,
- 1:58and clearly the war inflation spike, we would expect mass redemptions
- 2:05in things that are super liquid-like ETFs.
- 2:09We didn't have that, actually, I really.
- 2:11So the first interesting start is that there were positive net flows
- 2:16across the ETF industry in Australia, again, over five and a half billion.
- 2:22Actually came into the Aussie market, which was a surprise,
- 2:26which took us to over 15 billion for the quarter.
- 2:30So it's a record year on any measure that we've had.
- 2:37And they've been commentators that have said,
- 2:39well, ETFs will really suffer during periods of rural stress,
- 2:43and that didn't occur as well.
- 2:46So we had strong flows, not the strongest, but strong flows into the industry,
- 2:52assets under management to fail, but that's expected because markets had fallen.
- 2:57But the trading volume and the amount that was traded was also a record high.
- 3:01So through the period of March, there were over 2 million ETF trades executed in Australia.
- 3:09And to put that in the perspective, the previous record was April 2025,
- 3:16as you remember, Liberation Day.
- 3:17Yeah, and that was 1.7 billion, so 1.7 million and 22 billion of trading
- 3:25in March this year, over 2 million trades and 26 billion turnover through the ETF market.
- 3:33So extraordinary, ETFs were very stable.
- 3:36Trading conditions were good.
- 3:38Everything worked as expected, and investors were able to invest and liquidate
- 3:44as you'd expect with the ETF market.
- 3:46And was that predominantly institutions rebalancing into the market, or is this
- 3:53no? No, it depends on how you define an institution, but if you're defining an institution
- 3:57as the large, big, superannuation funds in Australia, there is no.
- 4:02It's mum and dad investors, brokers executing on behalf of their clients, financial advisors,
- 4:09asset consultants, managed accounts are a big component of the Australian ETF market.
- 4:16And so then, so at the high level, we had significant inflows again into the industry,
- 4:21but then when you look into the detail, there was some interesting things that we can unpack.
- 4:26So first of all, the rally in the oil price and inflation shock with the closure of the
- 4:33of the straight, there's only one real oil ETF in Australia, and it performed very, very well
- 4:42as as expected. But what was interesting, I was watching this real time, where you would have
- 4:47trades coming into that particular ETFs, they're $30 million, $50 million, even $100 million
- 4:52into the ETF. But then as quickly it was going in, it was also coming out, and there was trading in
- 4:57between a cash ETF and that oil ETF. Now, I don't know if it's always the same clients, but people
- 5:03were moving in and out of oil as it was quite volatile. So it wasn't people now allocating the
- 5:09staying put, they were actually moving in and out and just executing their particular market view
- 5:15very, very quickly with that oil ETF. So that was that was one stand-up. So it's like
- 5:22trading and ETF trading and a couple of a couple of a couple of days. I see the the
- 5:28variations at the end of the day. And so people may hold for a few days when their view changes,
- 5:33there's a different tweet from the president of the US. Their view of a change very,
- 5:39very quickly and they're in and they're out. So that was one. Defense technology was popular
- 5:45as expected, but it wasn't, we didn't see standout flows in defense technology, there was about
- 5:52$30 million that came into defense. So I think about one ETF, a detechment. I think most of us will
- 5:59be aware that there is ongoing and increased investment into defense technology by countries
- 6:06around the world. NATO have been very, very public about investing more into defense. But then the
- 6:12other angle or the other aspect of defense is it's moving into the private sector too. So
- 6:18results sporting facilities, big stadiums are investing to defense technology to protect
- 6:23themselves from the potential attack of a drone. So defense technology has been an interesting trade.
- 6:30Then Australian equities surprisingly had the best month ever, a record month for inflows into
- 6:39broad-based Australian equities. So that was about one, well, there was over one and a half
- 6:44billion across all Aussie equity based ETFs. And it's hard to put down what actually drove that,
- 6:52but I presume for Australian investors they're familiar with the underlying companies within those
- 6:57ETFs. Perhaps there's a larger allocation to resources and materials commodity-based companies
- 7:05within the Australian sector. You could argue that they've got a more value-based rather than
- 7:11growth-based companies. And Vanguard, who are the largest ETF issuer in Australia, had a record
- 7:18month. So they had over two and a half billion in their ETFs and Intervass, which is the largest ETF
- 7:26in Australia, $880 million flowed into that ETFs. So I imagine that's a lot of advise driven
- 7:33and managed account flow coming into that. Another observation was the rotation out of US
- 7:42equities, and maybe Australia benefited from that. But US equities were already pretty expensive
- 7:48in the lead up to March. And then the focus on software, such McGaton, that sort of stuff.
- 7:59So we did see flows coming out of US-based ETFs. And if I looked at some of the data,
- 8:05ex-US ETFs. So it could be global equities ex-US. They had the best month ever. So $418 million
- 8:13into ex-US ETFs. That's four times larger than the previous record. Europe was the big
- 8:19beneficiary there. Record flows into European ETFs here in Australia, 275 million. That was five
- 8:25times larger than the average. Japan was a beneficiary constant positive flow into Japanese equities,
- 8:33157 million, three times larger than what we'd normally seen. And I know a global ex-outlet
- 8:39research team has been talking about the broadening trade, if you like. So moving beyond borders
- 8:45and beyond the US. And so we're seeing that, we'll have seen that play out through March.
- 8:50Oh, there were good flows into Australian inflation linked bonds as investors were worried about
- 8:56inflation spiking up. And that was $100 million into an ETF here.
- 9:03By by shares. And that was five times larger than what we'd normally see.
- 9:06Floating rate bonds were popular. And our ETF bank, which has subordinated debt from the banks,
- 9:15was popular. And the other interesting thing was although so globally technology is a little
- 9:22bit on the nose because of the SaaS trade. Australians proved to be contrarian and there was
- 9:28some significant flows into Australian technology. Oh, really?
- 9:31ETFs. Yeah. Which was also a surprise. Yep. The other thing, there was positive flow
- 9:38into Australian crypto ETFs. Now globally, six months straight, there have been
- 9:43redemptions out of crypto or digital asset ETFs. Whereas in Australia, we've seen six months,
- 9:48not big, but we've seen six months of positive flow into crypto based ETFs. Australian investors
- 9:54are behaving a little bit differently to global investors. Another one, there were outflows out
- 9:59of global corporate bonds, specifically global high yield, probably expense, unsurprising given
- 10:07the state of the markets. And gold was actually pretty quiet. So we're a large issue of gold ETFs.
- 10:16And there was despite all the uncertainty in the world where you would expect a lot of flows
- 10:20into gold, there wasn't. So we in Australia across all the entire ETF industry, there was only
- 10:2630 on million that was invested into gold based ETFs. And we would average probably about 140 million
- 10:34a month into gold ETFs. Whereas and in the US, there were actually outflows out of gold. Wow.
- 10:40Yes. So I'm quite interested because we did have this gold rush and the lead up to this happening.
- 10:49Why do you think people, because traditionally people buy gold when there's something unsettled
- 10:58in the world? Why do you think they sold at this time? Yep. So gold had an amazing run as did silver.
- 11:06Yep. Before March. But the momentum was already slowing through through February.
- 11:14And then I guess the geopolitical risk premium comes and goes pretty quickly in markets.
- 11:22And a gold is there as a diversification tool. But what happened in March, gold actually fell.
- 11:29And it fell significantly. So gold fell from 5,400 was basically internet touching,
- 11:36sort of 4,100. It closed down about 12%. And so in an environment where you would normally expect
- 11:44gold to do well, provide meaningful diversification. In Niska, it's not the first time, but it didn't
- 11:52provide the kicker that some people would have expected. So I guess that's for investors,
- 12:00that's a reminder that gold is a diversifier, but it is not a pure hedge for a portfolio.
- 12:08So do you think the role of gold has changed? No, I don't think the role of gold has changed at all.
- 12:15But what we had through late stages of February and beginning of March, we had a lot of fast money,
- 12:21trade, gold. And so this would be CTA's hedge funds just in and out. And basically they started
- 12:28to liquidate their positions very, very quickly in March. And that was almost like selling it,
- 12:33selling everything. Then we had a deleveraging for, I guess, more wholesale, advisor-driven
- 12:38portfolios, predominantly out of the US. Option-based strategies started to unwind. And so that fast
- 12:46money, the tourists, if you like, basically, exited the gold market. And we're now left
- 12:53what looks like to be the fundamental long-term investors. And so gold's role in the portfolio
- 13:01is to provide diversification. Has that role changed? No, it hasn't. What was unusual
- 13:08through March is that central banks typically buy the dip. And we didn't, and based on the World
- 13:13Galt Gold Council data, central banks were not buying in the early period of March. But in the
- 13:19back end of March, they did China's, allow it to come back into the market. And since the lows of
- 13:25gold, it's rally 20%, but it's still off about 11% from its highs. And the thing about gold is that
- 13:32has lots of demand or use cases. So there's the industrial element, there's jewelry, and of course
- 13:39there's the investment case for you and I financial advisors, mums and dads, and then central banks
- 13:44institutional clients to hold gold in their portfolio. So industry kind of takes up about 8%
- 13:50of gold, usage, jewelry, 30, 35%, and then investing central banks of a 60 to 70% of gold.
- 14:00So I think the long-term case for gold is still there. It's a useful diversifying the portfolio.
- 14:06It tends to do well when we have US dollar weakness, when inflation is there,
- 14:13or falling real interest rates with inflation, rising, and then geopolitical uncertainties.
- 14:20So the long-term case is still there. And even looking at investment bank or the largest investment
- 14:24bank forecast, JP Morgan there, their forecast, I think they're still at 6,600 for their forecast.
- 14:35So that's more than a 30% increase in where we are now. And looking at here, I can see
- 14:41Goldman Sachs are at 5,300. Whereas gold is sitting at 4,800 right now.
- 14:46So there's room to move. It certainly looks that way. The case for gold hasn't changed.
- 14:51Yeah. So just in the time we've got left, there's this thing about the halo trade.
- 14:59Do you want to explain to me what that is?
- 15:03Sure. So I touched on Sachs McGowan, which is the software names have been really sold off
- 15:11around the world with AI basically coming in and replacing a lot of what software as a service
- 15:18did. And what we've seen as people have exited software, they moved into halo, which is basically
- 15:26the acronym stands for heavy assets and low obsolescence. So a big critical infrastructure.
- 15:35Once it's put in place, it's very hard to display or replace it with technology or anything like
- 15:43that. So significant investments have gone into this type of infrastructure. So transportation,
- 15:49the traditional infrastructure, rail systems, ports, toll roads, etc. Energy infrastructure
- 15:59is very, very big. And one theme that we're seeing at the moment is AI infrastructure, along
- 16:06with this halo trade idea. So third, the centers. Exactly.
- 16:11Exactly. And I think if you ask anybody on the street, who is the winner from the AI race?
- 16:17Is it chat GPT? Is it Gemini? Is it Claude? People don't know. But the one thing that's
- 16:25for certain is that AI has changed the way we do things. We're using AI. More and more people are
- 16:30using AI. And the requirement for energy has gone through the roof. So that we know. So rather than
- 16:39investing into the, I guess, the tech software side, you can see allocations going into AI
- 16:44infrastructure. So I think I mentioned, there's only one AI infrastructure ETF available in Australia.
- 16:50But that'll give you exposure to data centers. It'll give you exposure to power systems. All
- 16:57over the world, the power grid expansion, but also the materials and minerals that go into fueling
- 17:06these data centers. So so copper is a feature. So mining is hard to replace. It's a heavy industry
- 17:13as well. Uranium as an alternative source of energy as well. So that's that's the halo trade.
- 17:20And that's a beneficiary from, I guess, the, the Sassmageddon at the moment, which I think,
- 17:26which I've brought the very bacon is over done. It's probably unlikely that companies are going to
- 17:31build their own sales force themselves or build their own zero accounting and expense system.
- 17:39So perhaps we see that turnaround. In fact, in not March, but in April, there has been
- 17:46significant flow into big global technology from Australian ETF investors. And the one that
- 17:52comes to my most is Fang, which is a really large big tech. That has seen a lot of flow in the
- 17:59first week and a half of April. Wow. Well, Alex, I know we could talk about this, particularly
- 18:06the halo. I want to talk more about the halo effect that I think I'm going to need to get you
- 18:13back on. Thank you for sharing your insights today about the flow of money. I think over the coming
- 18:21weeks, we'll see even more flows of money. And it may be very different to what we've seen in
- 18:27the last months and a half. But as always, thanks for coming on and really appreciate you taking
- 18:35the time today. No, pleasure. Good to see you again.