Latest / Germ & Worm / 125: Mosquitoes? Try Frickin' LASERS!
Transcript
- 0:09Hidely-Ho!
- 0:09My name is Germ.
- 0:11I'm Worm.
- 0:12Welcome to episode 125 of the Germ and Worm Travel health podcast.
- 0:16Mosquitoes try frickin lasers.
- 0:18It's a big planet.
- 0:19See it in good health.
- 0:20I'm Dr.
- 0:20Paul Pottinger, also called Germ.
- 0:22I'm an infectious diseases specialist at the University of Washington.
- 0:25Dr.
- 0:25I'm Dr.
- 0:26Chris Sanford, also known as Worm Family Medicine Doc, also at the University of Washington.
- 0:30So many great questions today, Chris, from our listeners across the country and around the world, including: Would I need a polio booster before I visit Kenya?
- 0:39What is happening with Bundabugio vaccine trials in the drc?
- 0:43Is Colombia a safe country to visit now?
- 0:45And can I really kill mosquitoes with lasers?
- 0:47Please say yes.
- 0:49A reminder to our listeners, contact us with your questions, your stories and your tips for success.
- 0:53Visit us online germandworm.com or shoot us an email germandworm@gmail.com.
- 0:58As always, our medical disclaimer.
- 1:00This podcast is designed to inform, inspire and entertain.
- 1:03But before you travel, please see a qualified healthcare professional for recommendations specific to you and to your itinerary.
- 1:09Now, Paul, you just got back from abroad.
- 1:12Can you tell us a little about that?
- 1:14Yeah, this is a super exciting trip I did with my wife Julie.
- 1:17We were in Cape Town just for six days.
- 1:19It was a quick trip.
- 1:21The reason to go was because, you know, she sits on the board of Landesa, which is a wonderful human rights and legal advocacy nonprofit.
- 1:28And every other year there's an African Philanthropy Forum which is held somewhere on the continent.
- 1:34And this time it happened to be on Cape Town and she happened to be invited to sit on a panel and talk about her work, telling stories and really inspiring other people participating in the meeting about how to
- 1:46do some philanthropy within the continent of Africa, which is more important now I think than ever.
- 1:50It was a great success.
- 1:52Everybody loved her and I was just her plus one.
- 1:53And you know, we've supported Landesa for many years, so that was fun, you know, to do a little bit of fundraising and some advocacy work.
- 1:59But then we also got a chance to, you know, meet some new friends, visit with some old friends and see this beautiful part of the Western Cape, which was our first time being there.
- 2:08And I have to say, I know you've been a couple of times, Chris, I'd love to get your, you know, do not miss opportunities, I think for it's been named one of the world's great cities, in fact to
- 2:17the number one destination for world travel and you can see why it's very beautiful.
- 2:21The people are warm and friendly and it's a fascinating place.
- 2:26Such a complicated history and very inspiring.
- 2:29So, I mean, for me, the natural beauty was all there.
- 2:31And we visited, you know, the Botanical Gardens and went up Table Mountain.
- 2:35We took the tram once and then I hiked up on my own another time.
- 2:38And then we also went down to the Cape to see the penguins and the ostriches on the beach, where there are ostriches on the beach.
- 2:43That's what they have down there, baboons running wild.
- 2:45And it was really inspiring.
- 2:47But also museums, including the slave lodge, where they have this really incredible museum about the history of slavery.
- 2:53And.
- 2:54And then of course Robben island, the prison island, which has this incredibly difficult history that is now a full museum.
- 3:00And our guide was, you know, was a survivor of having been imprisoned there for 13 years.
- 3:05So it was very inspiring and a lovely visit at the same time.
- 3:09I can't say that for every place I've visited.
- 3:11What would you say about Cape Town?
- 3:13Yeah, I would agree.
- 3:14If you're going to see one place there, it's Robben Island.
- 3:17Similarly, when I went there with one of my sons a few years ago, we had a tour by one of the previous inmates and it was just very fascinating and emotional.
- 3:27Yeah, agree.
- 3:28So nothing but good things to say about visiting Cape Town.
- 3:30And I look forward to going back to see other parts of South Africa.
- 3:33It's a very diverse country.
- 3:34This is only one little piece of it, although a beautiful piece indeed.
- 3:42So from that inspiring background, Chris, bring us back down to earth.
- 3:45In fact, a part of the earth that many people dread to tread.
- 3:49Pennsylvania.
- 3:49What's going on with the measles outbreak in Pennsylvania, please?
- 3:52Ordinarily a lovely state.
- 3:54They're currently having a huge outbreak of measles.
- 3:58And when I say huge, I mean the current case count is over 1400 cases of measles.
- 4:02And this actually in the United States is the biggest outbreak in over 30 years.
- 4:08There have been five deaths due to measles in this outbreak.
- 4:11And this is a large tragedy.
- 4:13This is an entirely preventable disease.
- 4:17When they look at the people who have gotten measles in this most recent current outbreak, fewer than 1% of cases have had the full two dose MMR measles, mumps, rubella vaccination series so people are getting sick and dying
- 4:30because they or their parents are choosing not to get vaccinated.
- 4:35Not only that, but this outbreak appears to be even worse than usual.
- 4:39It seems to have a higher than usual fatality rate.
- 4:42And Paul, can you speculate or discuss a little bit why the fatality rate might be higher in this current outbreak?
- 4:49Yeah, I'm not sure.
- 4:50This is, of course, a hot topic at our international meeting called ID Week.
- 4:54Just got back from dc.
- 4:55That's where I was before Cape Town was at our annual meeting.
- 4:58It's an incredible meeting for many, many reasons.
- 5:00I'll go into that more in a different episode if we have time.
- 5:04But one of the inspiring things about this and humbling things about this meeting was a Beautiful lecture by Dr.
- 5:09Andy Pavia.
- 5:10He's a specialist in infectious diseases at Utah, and he gave an invited lecture called Measles From Rinderpest to Eradication and Back.
- 5:19And there were four crucial things that he imparted to us.
- 5:22I won't go into all the technical details.
- 5:23I learned a ton about the scourge that is the current outbreak, including Pennsylvania and elsewhere.
- 5:29He emphasized that this is a very serious infection and it's not rash and fever, that there is a risk of acute death, especially if there are other comorbidities.
- 5:36But in some cases, not or no identifiable reason why one young child would die and another one would survive.
- 5:43We've neglected this area of science for a long time because measles was a solved problem, because we had the MMR vaccine.
- 5:49I say had.
- 5:49I mean, hopefully at the time people listen to this, we still have it.
- 5:52Of course, the federal government's trying to destroy that vaccine to take it off the market.
- 5:55I am optimistic that will not happen.
- 5:57By the time you hear my voice, which will be in sometime in the month of November, 2026, at least you're okay for a little while.
- 6:02So the point is, this has been a neglected science because we fixed it in terms of prevention.
- 6:06So it may be that some people just have an inherent immunological susceptibility to a worse outcome.
- 6:12There may be other factors, Chris.
- 6:14I don't know, but it's not good.
- 6:15So he emphasized that this is a serious infection.
- 6:17It's not just a fever and rash.
- 6:18And he emphasized that the complications may not show up for years, especially children under the age of two.
- 6:24You know, if you're a kid on the age of two and you get this infection, you may not show serious, deadly effects for up to 10 years.
- 6:31Oh, wow.
- 6:31It's a disease called a complication called sspe, the subacute sclerosis, pan encephalitis, all of which is really bad.
- 6:38Basically, your brain scars and you die.
- 6:41And that takes years in some cases to manifest in these Young children.
- 6:45It's a tragedy.
- 6:45He also emphasized that the epidemiology is very complicated.
- 6:48If you actually analyze the virus itself, it is not just one virus.
- 6:52We have multiple different strains or clades of virus that are running around currently.
- 6:57Today, what we saw in Texas is different from what we're seeing in Pennsylvania.
- 7:02That's different from what we've seen in Minnesota.
- 7:04So the virus spreads around in a way that is difficult to.
- 7:08It's incredibly adept at doing this.
- 7:10And his final point was we shouldn't have to worry about any of this because we have a great prevention.
- 7:14The vaccine works.
- 7:15There is no reliable treatment.
- 7:17There is only prevention.
- 7:18It's everything.
- 7:19And so many other sessions at that meeting.
- 7:21Chris, to answer your question devoted to this concept, how do we gain people's trust?
- 7:24How do we get people to do this?
- 7:26In the case of Pennsylvania, many of those survivors and victims of measles are people who are not immunized.
- 7:33And they're doing that in the context of either the Amish and or Mennonite traditions.
- 7:38What it is about those particular cult cultures that makes it tougher to get the populations immunized, I'm not clear.
- 7:43The numbers of immunized people is rising.
- 7:45People are in many cases responding.
- 7:47But it's just an interesting situation.
- 7:50It's unexpected.
- 7:50It's caught us a little bit flat footed.
- 7:52Now we're having to catch up and do more.
- 7:55Hopefully the government will do the right thing by helping to step up and make a difference here.
- 7:59So just to make a couple points clear, even though there are these different clades of viruses, the vaccine is good at preventing all of them.
- 8:06100%.
- 8:07Yeah.
- 8:08And also, once you get this viral infection, we don't have good drugs.
- 8:12There's no reliable treatment for the infection.
- 8:14This is all about prevention.
- 8:16You got it.
- 8:16So once you get it, we can treat the symptoms, which means we can't do very much at all.
- 8:21Some people will ask about vitamin A.
- 8:22Can we supplement a baby's diet with vitamin A?
- 8:24I mean, yeah, the American Academy of Pediatrics.
- 8:27Other groups have said you can give a dose of vitamin A.
- 8:29That is clearly something that can save the eyes of malnourished babies, especially in Africa.
- 8:35Does that apply to malnourished kids in the United States?
- 8:37I mean, it used to feel unthinkable that could be the case.
- 8:40It's unclear.
- 8:41So I think that's part of a standard response, Chris, that we do supplement with a single dose body weight adjusted pediatric dose of vitamin A.
- 8:48Not too much.
- 8:49Pediatricians are now learning how to recognize vitamin A toxicity and how to deal with that, which is hard because people are giving too much.
- 8:56So the point is there's tiny little things we can do which may make a difference, but it's not enough.
- 9:01Nothing replaces prevention.
- 9:02Got it.
- 9:03Thank you.
- 9:10Paul, question for you.
- 9:11This horrible, speaking of horrible outbreaks, this big outbreak of Ebola in DRC and elsewhere, it's now moved into a new country.
- 9:19Can you tell us a little about that?
- 9:21Yeah, it's interesting.
- 9:22We talked a moment ago about measles, which is a fully preventable, potentially eradicatable virus on our planet.
- 9:28And yet we also have this explosion of another communicable viral infection in Central Africa, especially Democratic Republic of Congo, and that's Bundabugio, Ebola virus disease.
- 9:40And so in that case, there is no vaccine.
- 9:42And so people are dying in tremendous numbers.
- 9:45And in fact, it has now spilled over once again out of Congo and back into, in a small number of cases into Kenya.
- 9:52We talked on a recent episode about how Kenya had two cases and they got rid of it and it went away.
- 9:56No surprise, it's now come back across international borders.
- 9:59The viruses don't care about political borders.
- 10:02They simply infect human beings as they move around.
- 10:05And so, you know, they're trying.
- 10:07There's a really inspiring and fascinating, I think, positive situation in drc, which is this multinational series of vaccine trials that are now getting underway, to be clear, for the original strain of Ebola, which we call the Zaire flavor,
- 10:25we do have a vaccine that works.
- 10:27That vaccine does not, unfortunately, seem to work against Bundibujo.
- 10:30So we need new technology.
- 10:32So the answer is yes, there are several trials that are now getting underway as we speak in drc, and that includes, number one, getting people immunized against the old flavor with Zaire vaccine, but also preparing those people to
- 10:44receive some new vaccines.
- 10:45In fact, there are three of them that will soon be rolled out in clinical trials.
- 10:49One's made by Merck, one's made by Moderna, and one's made by Oxford.
- 10:54And these three vaccines will soon enough start rolling out in well designed clinical trials, including run by partners on the ground in drc.
- 11:03They really do look like well designed trials.
- 11:05I'm not involved in any of these, but what I've learned about them is they really care about this.
- 11:10These are three different vaccines.
- 11:11It's in effect, a race to the top.
- 11:13We'll see which one of them may be better than the others.
- 11:17Who knows, maybe all three of them are excellent.
- 11:19Think about what we did with COVID we actually had multiple different great vaccines that came out at the same time.
- 11:23This strategy is really great that we're going to simultaneously try multiple different ways to protect the people who live in these high risk areas in drc.
- 11:32So stay tuned here to German Worm.
- 11:34We'll talk about whether it's the Moderna, which is an MRNA platform, or the ones made by Merck and Oxford, which are made slightly differently.
- 11:41I'm hopeful that one or more of these may actually make a huge difference here.
- 11:45People need it because this is an out of control problem.
- 11:48This is certainly the biggest and deadliest form of any Ebola virus outbreak that we've seen in recorded history.
- 11:55And Paul, can you touch on your opinion on the US pulling out of who?
- 12:00The World Health Organization?
- 12:03Yeah, I mean we've talked about this many times, so that's a disaster.
- 12:06We shouldn't have done that.
- 12:06It's stupid.
- 12:07And likewise a terrible idea how we have largely defunded major portions of the work of usaid, for example.
- 12:16So is there a role for leadership from the United States in these trials?
- 12:19I mean, the answer is yes.
- 12:20And interestingly, Chris, there are some bright spots.
- 12:22And I'll give you an example.
- 12:24We have reports on 28th October there is an international research organization called IAVI which was happy to announce that it recently received a large gift, US$36 million from the US Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority to help get
- 12:41some of these clinical trials on the ground in DRC vaccine trials against Bundabugio.
- 12:47In fact, this award from the US Biomedical Advanced Research Development Authority could potentially be worth up to $99 million if things go well and they meet certain metrics, as I understand it from the original initial $36 million award.
- 13:03So I'm proud of that.
- 13:04I think that's a great example of what we can do.
- 13:06In my opinion, A grant of $36 million is peanuts.
- 13:10I know that doesn't sound like a small amount of money.
- 13:12Believe me, when it comes to these big international trials, especially for an emerging infectious disease like this, that is a small, tiny investment.
- 13:19And as you and I have said many times, if we can stop this stupid epidemic in its tracks and keep it from spreading elsewhere, including on our shores, that would certainly be worthwhile doing so that's a good thing
- 13:29that's coming.
- 13:30It's not enough.
- 13:31And I'm hoping that there's going to be a lot more of those examples.
- 13:38All right, Chris, here it is.
- 13:39Now, a couple episodes ago we were talking about lasers, frickin lasers and the question that came to us was somebody had read about using lasers to try to shoot mosquitoes out of the sky.
- 13:50Now I have certain friends, I'm looking at you, Chris Haggerty, my friend who loves killing mosquitoes.
- 13:54It's just, that's his thing, that's his one and only thing.
- 13:57He, I can see him wanting to pick up a rifle and start shooting these things.
- 14:00There's a story recently from the New York Times with lasers used to kill mosquitoes.
- 14:05What's your take on this?
- 14:06What's the story?
- 14:07Well, you know, it was kind of thrilling.
- 14:09This came out a few days ago in the New York Times and there's this Chinese startup called Photon Matrix and they're marketing their device and it costs about a thousand bucks and it uses AI, specifically LiDAR, the same
- 14:23technology that drives and operates and controls self driving cars.
- 14:28And basically they shoot lasers at mosquitoes guided by AI and it kills them per lovely quotation from the New York Times.
- 14:38Per them, the witness who saw this, each bursting into a green or blue flame with a tiny pop.
- 14:46Which, you know, it's not nice to laugh at the death of anything but it kind of cracked me up.
- 14:50I'm good with it actually.
- 14:51I'm good with that.
- 14:52So does it work?
- 14:53I don't know.
- 14:54It looked like it killed a whole bunch of mosquitoes in a hurry.
- 14:57Is it safe?
- 14:58I don't know.
- 14:59Is it expensive?
- 15:00Yes.
- 15:00I'm not going to go out and purchase one of these things right away.
- 15:03I'm still going to keep my fly swatter in my bug repellent.
- 15:06Paul, can you talk a little bit about some potential concerns with this new system?
- 15:11Yeah, I mean the idea of giving AI a bunch of lasers is this, they made movies about this I think.
- 15:15It's not just fake news.
- 15:18No, this is a small laser beam.
- 15:20It, it's really super fascinating.
- 15:22It shoots pulses of light 100,000 times per second.
- 15:26That's how quickly this thing jabs out at the mosquitoes.
- 15:29And it's, it is guided by a LiDAR system.
- 15:32I think that's what drives Tesla around.
- 15:34So again, coming back to putting lasers onto Tesla cars.
- 15:37This is headline don't give elon the lasers.
- 15:40But anyway, the tech is apparently very well proven and they have demonstrated that it works.
- 15:45The issue is that stuff will blind you.
- 15:47I mean if you get hit in the fovea back on your retina, you'll end up with a blind spot.
- 15:51They're very powerful lasers and the company to their credit has come up with apparently some smart ways to deal with this.
- 15:57You have to take a test, I forget how many 30 or 50 questions or something.
- 16:01And you have to get 100% on the test before they will give you the keys to make the thing activate.
- 16:06And it's a thing like, you know, should you look at at this?
- 16:09Should you look at the laser?
- 16:10No Even what rooms of the house are unsafe?
- 16:12They gave the example of never put in a bathroom because there might be wet surfaces or tiles that the lasers could bounce off of.
- 16:17So they've tried to deal with this issue and supposedly the camera knows when there's a person around.
- 16:22Sort of like the Tesla thing is supposed to know when there's a truck even though it drives into those trucks.
- 16:27So anyway, there are some safety pieces that are there.
- 16:30Let's see what happens with this.
- 16:32I honestly am fascinated by it.
- 16:34If I had a backyard that was mosquito free, I'd be very happy about it.
- 16:37So we can't cover the world, blanket the world with these lasers.
- 16:40Are there going to be some folks who can afford 1000 bucks to make their backyards less burdened by mosquitoes?
- 16:44Maybe.
- 16:45I think it's way too soon and I am not aware of us FDA filings on this.
- 16:49Let's wait and see what happens.
- 16:50Yeah, I'm not going to buy one right away, but I'm going to stay tuned.
- 16:57Now, Paul, speaking of mosquitoes, there was this vaccine called Icscheck that still exists.
- 17:04It's a vaccine for chikungunya spread by mosquitoes.
- 17:07But the US took it off the market and the FDA did and now another country has too.
- 17:12Can you tell us about that?
- 17:14This is no surprise, but I'm happy to talk about it briefly.
- 17:16Yeah.
- 17:17The United Kingdom has also revoked the authorization for marketing of Icschick as you recall.
- 17:22I still think Ickschik's a great name for an all girl rock band like southern rock or rockabilly, the Ickschicks.
- 17:29Ickschick is a live attenuated chikungunya vaccine.
- 17:32It's a good one.
- 17:33It seems to work well and I have friends who have received it and they're happy about it.
- 17:38The problem with this was that in post marketing surveillance there was an unexpectedly increased small but unexpectedly increased number of elderly people.
- 17:48Elderly meaning older than I am.
- 17:50I think it was actually 65 and above who had an unexpectedly increased risk.
- 17:55Although the absolute risk was small, but it was increased compared to the background of demyelinating neurological disease.
- 18:01And so guillain Barre would be one example of this.
- 18:04Right, so you don't want to give people Guillain Barre Syndrome.
- 18:07How could this happen?
- 18:08It's not clear, but it looks like this live attenuated virus was so immunogenic that unfortunately it led to a non specific immunological activation that attacked not only chikungunya when it gets into your body, but it started attacking in
- 18:21these small number of people.
- 18:23It started attacking the neurological tissue of the patient themselves.
- 18:27Guillain Barre is treatable, but it can be very serious.
- 18:29And so that alone was enough for the United States and other countries to withdraw approval to give icjic.
- 18:35And that apparently has happened in the uk.
- 18:37Why it took them this long to catch up, I'm not sure.
- 18:40Now you can still get it in the European Union, you can get it in Brazil, you can get it in Canada.
- 18:45I just want to remind our listeners, as we talked about before, there is a wonderful and effective and very safe alternative called Vimcuna.
- 18:53That's what I and my wife received, you know, before we visited Sri Lanka earlier this year.
- 18:58I do recommend it.
- 18:59Different technology, not live attenuated, but a virus like particle, the same tech as we have in our beautiful human papillomavirus vaccine, for example.
- 19:07So this is, you know, the death knell, I think, of Icschick.
- 19:10My hope is that if people have no access to Vimcunya, that they would still do this if they were under the age of 65 and they're in a country where they can.
- 19:18My hope is that Vimcuna will become broadly available and affordable.
- 19:21I do think it's better tech and, and should probably replace what we're seeing with what we have seen with icg.
- 19:28Yeah, yeah, I agree with that.
- 19:34Chris, tell me this, a question we got from one of our listeners who says, I'm traveling to Kenya this December, that's next month for safari.
- 19:41Should I get a polio booster before I go?
- 19:44The short answer is you could, but your risk is really, really low.
- 19:48And the reason possibly that you asked this is you read about the recent case.
- 19:52There was a case, per the Kenyan Administrat of Health of polio, and specifically it was vaccine derived polio.
- 20:00And this was in July and it was in a refugee at a refugee camp in Garissa county, which is on the eastern border of Kenya.
- 20:11One case in a refugee in a refugee camp doesn't really change national policy.
- 20:15It's not a common thing.
- 20:18Certainly if you're a doc or a nurse going to a refugee camp.
- 20:21Yeah, I think that's a reasonable thing.
- 20:22If you're a sewage worker and you're working, working with sewage water.
- 20:25Yeah, maybe think about it.
- 20:27If you're going to that county, maybe think about it.
- 20:29But if you're just a routine tourist going to game parks, you could if you wanted to, but your risk is extraordinarily low.
- 20:35If I was going, I wouldn't get an additional booster.
- 20:38Paul, can you talk a little bit about what does a vaccine derived polio virus mean?
- 20:44Yeah, it's just super fascinating.
- 20:46So as our listeners will recall, polio is a terrible disease.
- 20:51In fact, I was just in South Africa.
- 20:52I have also visited the.
- 20:54I should have put this before.
- 20:55And I do not miss this museum called the Heart of Cape Town where they have a museum.
- 20:59This is where the first heart transplant was performed in the world.
- 21:02And all the original operating rooms and stuff are still now a museum for whatever reason.
- 21:05They also had a polio virus iron lung that was there, the last iron lung they used in Cape Town.
- 21:10So it was a reminder to me just a few days ago about the reality of this.
- 21:14It's myelitis, meaning inflammation of the spinal cord.
- 21:17And it can lead to paralysis, in some cases inability to breathe on one's own.
- 21:21So it's serious.
- 21:22That's why we have a wonderful vaccine policy in this country and around the world.
- 21:28The vaccines come in two flavors.
- 21:29There's the killed and there's the live attenuated.
- 21:32Live attenuated.
- 21:32That's the stuff that you get when you stick out your tongue.
- 21:34They put a drop.
- 21:36Many of our listeners will have had this, as I did when we were kids.
- 21:38The beautiful thing about vaccines built on live attenuated virus is that, number one, it elicits a great immune response right in the GI system.
- 21:46That's how the virus gets into our body.
- 21:47That's where you want to fight it off, is in the gut, what we call the gut associated lymphatic tissue.
- 21:52And the oral polio virus does that well.
- 21:54It also comes out in your stool.
- 21:56Now in the United States, when we take a crap, it's usually in a toilet.
- 22:00It goes to central processing and the waste processing is done and that's, that's the end of it.
- 22:04But for so many people around the world, the water that they drink is befouled by human waste, which is awful and unjust.
- 22:10But there is an interesting issue which is that if in your species there is some vaccine, polio virus, you may inadvertently vaccinate your friends who didn't get the vaccine itself but are drinking water with your own poop.
- 22:23This can lead to an increase in what we call herd immunity.
- 22:26Strengthening the herd.
- 22:27It's a great idea and it has made huge difference.
- 22:30And I think the technology in that, I'm going to say this out loud, the technology in that oral polio virus vaccine has saved many, many lives.
- 22:37It's brilliant, but it's not good enough anymore in my opinion.
- 22:41What we are seeing here is people who are now getting actual infection and disease caused by that very same virus, the circulating meaning out in the world virus that is caused originally by one of these attenuated strains.
- 22:55So as we give the vaccine, it's extremely safe, in very rare cases can actually cause a mild or in some cases even a real case of poliomyelitis.
- 23:03And as it gets out into the world, it may start to revert and go back to its more wild type and virulent strain.
- 23:10So it's a problem.
- 23:13The good news is that you can also get an injection that's a killed flavor, more similar to what Jonas Salk did back in the day compared to what Dr.
- 23:20Sabin did.
- 23:21And as everybody knows, Jonas Salk is a true hero.
- 23:24And this is the same idea, different tech in the current killed vaccine.
- 23:27But the nice thing about it is, number one, you don't need a cold chain to do it.
- 23:32It's like any other vaccine.
- 23:33It's easier to administer if you can do shots into people's shoulders.
- 23:37And number two, the risk of this vaccine derived infection is zero.
- 23:43So for many years, the world has gotten to be a better and better place because of the oral polio vaccine.
- 23:48This single case in Garissa is a reminder to us that actually it may be time for the world to change.
- 23:53In my opinion, I'm speaking on behalf of myself, I think we should do better for people.
- 23:57I think we are close enough to getting rid of this stupid infection that we should probably revert back to the injectable stuff.
- 24:03And the cold hard truth, Chris, is that today on planet or Earth, most annual cases of polio are come from the vaccine itself.
- 24:09These circulating wild types with origins from the vaccine and not from wild type.
- 24:15So what you mentioned a moment ago, let's say this person is going on safari in Garissa, they're going to also volunteer digging latrines.
- 24:21They should get a once in a lifetime booster if it's been more than 10 years since their last shot.
- 24:25And that's kind of crazy that we're recommending the consideration of a vaccine to prevent a vaccine originating infection.
- 24:32But there it is.
- 24:32That's where we are in 2026.
- 24:34Stay tuned.
- 24:35My hope is that World Health will really try to promote and advance the use of the killed flavor of this vaccine.
- 24:41If they do, then over the course of a generation to come, these kind of cases of circulating vaccine derived polio, they should theoretically go away.
- 24:51And just to define a term that you just used, you used the term cold chain, for those of you who don't know what that is.
- 24:58Some vaccines, like the oral vaccine, the live vaccine, has to remain cold the entire time in all the steps between the manufacturing plant and when it goes into somebody's mouth.
- 25:08And so if during that trip it warms up even once, it's ruined.
- 25:13And so the cold chain is the whole series of cold to cold to cold places that ends up with it being cold and still effective right before it goes into someone's mouth.
- 25:22And one more point I want to make all of the polio vaccine that's given in the US Currently is the shot, the killed.
- 25:29So it's not putting people at risk for this vaccine derived polio.
- 25:34I agree.
- 25:35I'm glad about it.
- 25:35I'm proud of it and I think everybody in the world deserves that same opportunity.
- 25:47Now, Paul, tell us a little bit about, about Colombia and safety and conflict.
- 25:52Colombia's kind of gone back and forth.
- 25:54Twenty years ago some people thought it was a no go zone due to warfare and guerrillas.
- 25:59Then it was safe.
- 25:59Now maybe the guerrilla warfare, the anti government factions are coming out a little bit.
- 26:05Can you address that complexity?
- 26:07Well, I'm speaking on behalf of someone who's fascinated by Colombia and who would love to go.
- 26:11I've never been actually.
- 26:12I've not visited Colombia in person.
- 26:14But I was just thinking about this the other day.
- 26:16A friend of mine did just go down for a wedding and had a great experience.
- 26:19Came back safe and sound and all good.
- 26:20But the concern here is this report.
- 26:22As of late September, we have this guerrilla group which has been stirring up trouble in one part of Colombia.
- 26:31So in fact, this has led to a curfew in the region of Santa Marta.
- 26:35So this guerrilla group has announced that it's going to continue keeping things locked down over a period of time.
- 26:42They originally said this would go through the end of September.
- 26:44Some of those lockdowns have continued subsequently.
- 26:47This sounds like a dangerous, unpredictable situation.
- 26:49We have reports of the group igniting vehicles on fire, blockading roads and that they're being violent with people who are disobeying their, their capricious order.
- 27:00So it's not a good look for those people.
- 27:02And if you're a traveler, recommendation would be to stay out of Santa Marta and those areas nearby, including Magdalena and La Guara, including Troncal de Carib on the Route 90 corridor, right through Palomino.
- 27:14Know so.
- 27:15Or if you're going to the Tyrona national park or you're going to Zona Bananera.
- 27:20These are regions that I've not visited before.
- 27:22But transportation there is felt to be unsafe.
- 27:25The concept here is the same as what we've talked about before.
- 27:27There are certain countries that are generally safe, some that are generally unsafe, but most are somewhere in between.
- 27:33I would put my own country, the United States, as somewhere in between.
- 27:36Right.
- 27:37There's some parts of the US That I wouldn't go, and I think this is an example.
- 27:40The same is true with Colombia.
- 27:41There are still many places within Colombia that I think are generally safe and advisable.
- 27:45This is dynamic and we've talked about this before.
- 27:47Please do check Department of State listings before you go and if any questions, talk to a trusted source on the ground to find out the reality of what this looks like.
- 27:56Is that your take as well?
- 27:57It is.
- 27:58And I would avoid only Santa Marta anywhere else in the country, frankly, I would go in a heartbeat.
- 28:03Now, I have been there.
- 28:04I've been to Bogota, went to some national parks around Bogota, and then I went down to Leticia, which is a village in the far south Panhandle.
- 28:13Exactly.
- 28:13On the Amazon river.
- 28:14And I did some hiking in the jungle for a few days and it was beautiful.
- 28:18So I think most of the country is calm and tourist friendly.
- 28:21So as you say, Paul, check with the Department of State, but I think it's more calm than not these days.
- 28:26Yeah, that's my impression as well.
- 28:36Everyone, thanks so much for joining us here on episode 125 of German Memorial.
- 28:40As always, we welcome your questions on Travel Health.
- 28:42Just send them along or if you have tips for success.
- 28:44If you've heard something you disagree with, we would welcome the conversation.
- 28:48Send us an email germanworm gmail.com or see us online.
- 28:51Germanworm.com if you've enjoyed this episode, we would love your subscription, your favorable rating right on your device and spreading the word with friends, family and joining us on socials.
- 29:01Those are free ways to support this podcast.
- 29:03I'm Germ.
- 29:04I'm Worm.
- 29:04It's a big planet.
- 29:05See it in good health.
- 29:06We look forward to seeing you next time.
- 29:08This podcast is designed to inform, inspire and entertain, but it does not establish a doctor patient relationship and so it should not replace your conversation with a qualified healthcare professional, please see one before your next adventure.
- 29:18The opinions you hear belong to Dr.
- 29:20Sanford and Dr.
- 29:21Pottinger alone and do not necessarily represent the opinions of the University of Washington or UW Medicine.