Latest / SWOP Behind Bars Advocacy from the Margins / What Did Medicine Get Wrong About Women?
Transcript
- 0:00What did medicine get wrong about women? How decades of research gaps,
- 0:05overlooked symptoms, and assumptions about women's bodies became embedded in modern medicine.
- 0:11She was 49 when she started experiencing chest discomfort.
- 0:15It wasn't the dramatic, crushing pain she had seen in medical dramas.
- 0:19She felt exhausted, occasionally nauseated, and unusually anxious.
- 0:23Sometimes the discomfort traveled into her back. She assumed it was stress.
- 0:28She had a demanding job, family responsibilities, and plenty of reasons to feel overwhelmed.
- 0:34Eventually, she saw her doctor. They discussed her symptoms and anxiety.
- 0:38She was encouraged to manage her stress, improve her sleep, and watch her diet.
- 0:43Nobody initially recognized what was happening to her heart.
- 0:46This fictional composite illustrates a documented problem.
- 0:50Women's cardiovascular symptoms have historically been under-recognized,
- 0:54sometimes contributing to delayed diagnosis and treatment.
- 0:57Medicine is complicated. Diagnoses are missed, research evolves, and treatments change.
- 1:02But what happens when generations of research rely disproportionately on male bodies?
- 1:07Women's pain is interpreted differently, and medications are prescribed without
- 1:10adequately investigating how women process them.
- 1:14For much of modern medical history, women were expected to benefit from research
- 1:18that hadn't adequately included them.
- 1:21We are still dealing with the consequences. The male body as the medical standard.
- 1:25For decades, medical research frequently treated men as the default research population.
- 1:31Women, particularly those who might become pregnant, were often excluded because
- 1:35researchers worried about hormonal fluctuations and reproductive risks.
- 1:38In 1977, the FDA recommended excluding women of childbearing potential from
- 1:43early drug trials, even when pregnancy was unlikely.
- 1:46The intention was partly protective, but medications would eventually be prescribed
- 1:50to patients who hadn't been adequately represented in safety studies.
- 1:53In 1993, Congress established requirements for including women and minorities
- 1:57in NIH-funded clinical research, subject to appropriate exceptions.
- 2:02In 2016, the NIH implemented its policy requiring researchers to account for
- 2:06sex as a biological variable in applicable studies.
- 2:09Women now represent roughly half of participants in NIH-supported clinical research,
- 2:14but historical gaps remain, particularly in laboratory studies relying heavily
- 2:18on male animals and cells.
- 2:20That matters because research becomes the foundation of medical education,
- 2:24diagnostic criteria, treatment recommendations, and pharmaceutical development.
- 2:29When the evidence is incomplete, the consequences can follow patients for generations.
- 2:33When women's pain and hearts are treated differently, ask women about their
- 2:36experiences seeking medical care, and familiar stories emerge.
- 2:40Their symptoms are attributed to stress. Painful periods are considered normal.
- 2:45Chronic pelvic pain becomes something they should learn to manage.
- 2:48Unexplained symptoms may be dismissed as anxiety.
- 2:52Not every experience reflects medical bias, but research demonstrates differences
- 2:57in how women's pain is assessed and treated.
- 3:00A 2024 study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found
- 3:04evidence that female emergency department patients were less likely to receive
- 3:08pain medication than male patients presenting with comparable complaints.
- 3:13Consider endometriosis. It can cause debilitating pelvic pain,
- 3:17painful menstruation, gastrointestinal symptoms, and difficulties affecting
- 3:21employment and relationships.
- 3:22Yet diagnosis has historically taken years. Despite affecting approximately
- 3:271 in 10 reproductive-aged women worldwide, it has received relatively limited research funding.
- 3:33Imagine how differently healthcare might develop if severe pelvic pain were
- 3:36routinely investigated rather than considered something women should endure.
- 3:40Cardiovascular medicine reveals another historical gap. For much of the 20th
- 3:44century, heart disease was treated primarily as a male problem,
- 3:48and research reflected that assumption.
- 3:50We now know that cardiovascular disease is a leading cause of death among women.
- 3:54Chest discomfort remains the most common heart attack symptom in both women
- 3:57and men, but women may also experience nausea, shortness of breath,
- 4:01back or jaw pain, and unusual fatigue.
- 4:04Problems arise when clinicians or patients expect symptoms to fit an overly
- 4:07narrow picture of a heart attack.
- 4:10Research indicates that women with suspected coronary heart disease may experience
- 4:13diagnostic delays and receive fewer referrals or treatments.
- 4:17A 2019 experimental study involving 225 medical students found that when psychological
- 4:23symptoms accompanied possible coronary heart disease,
- 4:26the female patient was perceived as having the lowest cardiovascular risk and
- 4:30was less likely to receive certain treatment recommendations.
- 4:34The study doesn't establish that every clinician behaves this way.
- 4:37It illustrates how assumptions can influence medical judgment before a diagnosis is made.
- 4:42How much of what we consider normal female suffering is actually suffering medicine
- 4:47hasn't adequately investigated?
- 4:49Prescription drugs and the male standard. One revealing example of the research
- 4:54gap involves prescription medications.
- 4:56Historically, biomedical research often relied on a hypothetical standard patient,
- 5:01a man weighing approximately 154 pounds.
- 5:04Yet women generally differ from men in average body size and composition,
- 5:08and certain medications are absorbed, metabolized, or eliminated differently.
- 5:13Many adult medications are prescribed at standard doses rather than according
- 5:17to individual body weight.
- 5:18A drug studied primarily in men may therefore produce different blood concentrations
- 5:22or side effects in women.
- 5:24But weight isn't the entire explanation. Biological differences can affect medication
- 5:28processing independently of body size.
- 5:31Consider Zolpidem, commonly known as Ambien.
- 5:34In 2013, the FDA announced lower recommended starting doses for women after
- 5:39evidence showed they eliminated the medication more slowly than men.
- 5:43Higher morning blood concentrations increased the risk of impaired alertness,
- 5:47including impaired driving.
- 5:49The recommended starting dose of immediate release Zolpidem for women was reduced
- 5:53from 10 milligrams to five milligrams.
- 5:56A 2020 analysis published in Biology of Sex Differences examined 86 drugs with
- 6:01documented differences in how men and women processed them.
- 6:04For 76, women experienced greater drug exposure or slower elimination.
- 6:09Where adverse reaction data were available, these differences frequently corresponded
- 6:13with higher rates of side effects.
- 6:16Researchers emphasized that body weight alone couldn't explain their findings.
- 6:20This doesn't mean women should automatically receive smaller doses of every medication.
- 6:25Some drugs require weight-based dosing, others need individualized adjustments,
- 6:30and some have no meaningful sex-related differences.
- 6:33It means we need adequate evidence rather than assuming the same dose is appropriate for everyone.
- 6:37A woman's body should not become the final testing ground for a medication that
- 6:41was inadequately studied before reaching the pharmacy.
- 6:44Reproductive health and mental health Research gaps become particularly visible
- 6:48during pregnancy, postpartum recovery, and menopause.
- 6:52Pregnancy changes cardiovascular function, metabolism, and medication processing.
- 6:57Mental health conditions may also emerge or intensify during pregnancy and after childbirth.
- 7:02Yet research has historically struggled to include pregnant patients while appropriately
- 7:06managing potential risks.
- 7:08Excluding pregnant women can protect study participants from poorly understood risks.
- 7:13But routine exclusion leaves clinicians with less reliable evidence when those
- 7:16patients eventually need treatment.
- 7:19The solution requires carefully designed research, appropriate safeguards, and informed consent.
- 7:26The CDC's analysis of pregnancy-related deaths from 2017 through 2019 found
- 7:31that mental health conditions, including deaths related to suicide and substance
- 7:35use disorders, were the leading underlying cause among the deaths reviewed.
- 7:39More than 80% of pregnancy-related deaths in that data set were estimated to be preventable.
- 7:45Mental health deserves serious attention throughout women's lives.
- 7:48Depression, anxiety, and other psychiatric conditions require appropriate treatment.
- 7:54But a psychiatric diagnosis should never become an excuse to overlook physical symptoms.
- 7:59Depression can coexist with cardiovascular disease, hormonal changes,
- 8:03chronic pain, and other medical conditions.
- 8:05Treating one diagnosis shouldn't prevent clinicians from investigating another.
- 8:09Women deserve comprehensive medical assessments, not a choice between having
- 8:13their physical symptoms believed and receiving mental health care.
- 8:16Who pays the price for incomplete research? At Swap Behind Bars,
- 8:19these questions extend beyond the examination room.
- 8:22We work with people whose access to health care is complicated by poverty,
- 8:25incarceration, unstable housing, stigma, and previous experiences with institutions
- 8:30that haven't always treated them with dignity.
- 8:32Consider a woman entering a correctional facility with an undiagnosed chronic
- 8:36condition. Someone whose symptoms have repeatedly been dismissed.
- 8:40A survivor whose physical symptoms are interpreted primarily through the lens
- 8:44of trauma, substance use, or her history in the sex trade.
- 8:48Medical research gaps don't disappear when someone becomes incarcerated.
- 8:52Neither do medication side effects, cardiovascular disease, endometriosis,
- 8:57menopause symptoms, or psychiatric conditions.
- 9:01The consequences are particularly difficult for patients who cannot choose their
- 9:05physicians, obtain specialist referrals, afford medications,
- 9:09or seek second opinions.
- 9:11Women aren't one uniform population. Biological differences matter,
- 9:15but so do age, race, disability, income, geography, and living conditions.
- 9:19Research must account for those differences without reducing patients to stereotypes.
- 9:23Medicine has made important progress.
- 9:25Women are better represented in clinical research. Scientists increasingly recognize
- 9:30sex-related differences, and previously neglected conditions are receiving attention.
- 9:35But including women in studies is only the beginning.
- 9:38Researchers must analyze outcomes, report meaningful differences,
- 9:41and ensure discoveries change clinical practice.
- 9:44Medical education must reflect what we know about cardiovascular disease,
- 9:48pain, reproductive health, medication safety, and mental illness.
- 9:51And healthcare must remain accessible to people who cannot afford specialists
- 9:55or navigate complicated insurance systems.
- 9:58At Swap Behind bars, we repeatedly encounter a fundamental problem.
- 10:03People cannot benefit from treatments they cannot access, diagnoses they never
- 10:07receive, or research findings that never reach their physicians.
- 10:10This series began by asking why women's health so often becomes urgent only
- 10:13after something terrible happens.
- 10:16The history of medical research raises another question.
- 10:19How many women experienced unnecessary suffering while medicine was still learning to study them?
- 10:24We cannot recover the years lost to misdiagnoses, inadequate treatment,
- 10:28or preventable complications.
- 10:30But we can examine the assumptions that led to those failures and ensure that
- 10:34future research takes women's health seriously throughout their lives.
- 10:38Because women's bodies were never simply smaller versions of men's bodies.
- 10:42And women should never have to prove they belong in the research that determines their medical care.