Latest / Kentucky Tonight / January 22, 2024 - Safer Kentucky Act
Transcript
- 0:03[♪♪]
- 0:09GOOD EVENING.
- 0:11WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:12I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:13THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:16AS WE BEGIN WEEK 4 OF THE 2024
- 0:18KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY, OUR
- 0:20TOPIC TONIGHT IS HOUSE BILL 5,
- 0:23THE PROPOSED SAFER KENTUCKY ACT
- 0:25— A SERIES OF ANTI-CRIME
- 0:27MEASURES.
- 0:28LET’S BEGIN BY LOOKING AT SOME
- 0:29OF THE KEY COMPONENTS OF THE
- 0:29BILL:
- 0:33FIRST, A THREE-STRIKES PROVISION
- 0:36FOR VIOLENT OFFENDERS - MEANING
- 0:37THOSE CONVICTED OF THREE VIOLENT
- 0:38FELONIES FACE A LIFE SENTENCE
- 0:40BEHIND BARS.
- 0:40THE BILL WOULD TOUGHEN PENALTIES
- 0:42FOR KNOWINGLY SELLING FENTANYL
- 0:44OR A FENTANYL DERIVATIVE THAT
- 0:46RESULTS IN A FATAL OVERDOSE.
- 0:48FENTANYL IS POWERFUL SYNTHETIC
- 0:49OPIOID THAT'S A FACTOR IN MOST
- 0:50OF KENTUCKY'S OVERDOSE DEATHS.
- 0:52IT CREATES A STAND-ALONE LAW FOR
- 0:53CARJACKING.
- 0:55THE BILL PUTS NEW RESTRICTIONS
- 0:57ON CHARITABLE BAIL ORGANIZATIONS
- 0:59THAT KEEPS THEM FROM FURNISHING
- 1:01BAIL THAT’S OVER $5,000 OR FOR
- 1:02PEOPLE CHARGED WITH A VIOLENT
- 1:03CRIME
- 1:05HB 5 CREATES A NEW OFFENSE OF
- 1:07“UNLAWFUL CAMPING,” MAKING IT
- 1:09ILLEGAL TO SLEEP OUTSIDE IN
- 1:10PUBLIC AREAS.
- 1:12THE MEASURE ALSO ENHANCES
- 1:13PENALTIES FOR SEVERAL CRIMES...
- 1:15INCLUDING A POSSIBLE DEATH
- 1:16SENTENCE FOR KILLING A POLICE
- 1:18OFFICER OR FIRST RESPONDER, AND
- 1:20THE BILL UPGRADES PENALTIES FOR
- 1:22FLEEING OR EVADING THE POLICE.
- 1:24AND, BUSINESS OWNERS WOULD BE
- 1:25ALLOWED TO USE REASONABLE FORCE
- 1:29ON SUSPECTED SHOPLIFTERS TO KEEP
- 1:30THEM FROM ESCAPING.
- 1:32TO DISCUSS ALL THIS, WE ARE
- 1:33JOINED IN OUR LEXINGTON STUDIO
- 1:34BY:
- 1:35STATE REPRESENTATIVE JASON
- 1:38NEMES, A MIDDLETOWN REPUBLICAN
- 1:39AND HOUSE MAJORITY WHIP;
- 1:41STATE REPRESENTATIVE KETURAH
- 1:42HERRON, A LOUISVILLE DEMOCRAT;
- 1:44STATE REPRESENTATIVE JARED
- 1:46BAUMAN, A LOUISVILLE REPUBLICAN
- 1:48AND PRIME SPONSOR OF THE SAFER
- 1:49KENTUCKY ACT;
- 1:51GEORGE EKLUND, DIRECTOR OF
- 1:52EDUCATION AND ADVOCACY FOR THE
- 1:54COALITION FOR THE HOMELESS;
- 1:55RYAN STRAW, KENTUCKY STATE
- 1:57FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE VICE
- 1:59PRESIDENT & DIRECTOR OF
- 2:00GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS;
- 2:02AND KUNGU JUGUNA, POLICY
- 2:04STRATEGIST WITH THE ACLU OF
- 2:05KENTUCKY.
- 2:08SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 2:09COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 2:12-- AT K-Y TONIGHT K-E-T. SEND AN
- 2:13EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT K-E-T
- 2:15DOT O-R-G. OR USE THE WEB FORM
- 2:17AT K-E-T DOT O-R-G SLASH K-Y
- 2:18TONIGHT. OR YOU CAN CALL
- 2:201-800-494-7605. WELCOME TO OUR
- 2:21GUESTS.
- 2:27A LONGER INTRO THAN USUAL BUT WE
- 2:30WANTED TO MAKE SURE OUR GUESTS
- 2:32UNDERSTOOD PARAMETERS OF OUR
- 2:33DISCUSSION AND THE BILL DOES
- 2:34MORE THAN THAT.
- 2:36AND WE WILL PEA GET TO AS MUCH
- 2:38AS WE CAN.
- 2:39QUESTIONS ARE ALREADY COMING IN
- 2:40AND YOU EXPECTED THAT TO HAPPEN,
- 2:42RIGHT?
- 2:43I DESCRIBED A LOT OF THE VIOLENT
- 2:46OFFENSES THIS BILL HAS THE
- 2:49KENTUCKY ACT WOULD APPLY TO ARE
- 2:52THERE OTHER OFFENSES MAYBE
- 2:54NONVIOLENT THAT THIS APPLIES?
- 2:56>> YEAH, I THINK REALLY TO START
- 2:58I THANK YOU, RENEE FOR HAVING ME
- 3:00ON THE SHOW TONIGHT.
- 3:01AND JUST WANT TO START WITH
- 3:04COMMENTS AROUND YOU KNOW, THE
- 3:06PUBLIC SAFETY, SECURITY AND
- 3:09DECKIONS ASPECT OF THIS BILL AND
- 3:10IT IS FOUNDATIONAL TO ACHIEVING
- 3:13PROSPERITY FOR THE
- 3:15FOUR-AND-A-HALF MILLIKEN KENYANS
- 3:16TO CHOOSE THE CALL THE
- 3:18COMMONWEALTH HOME.
- 3:18IT IS THE FOUNDATION ON WHICH WE
- 3:20WILL BUILD A THRIVING ECONOMY.
- 3:22THE FOUNDATION ON WHICH WE WILL
- 3:23SUPPORT THE KENTUCKY FAMILY.
- 3:25THE CHIEF SUCCESS IN EDUCATION
- 3:26AND GENERALLY ACHIEVE A HIGH
- 3:28QUALITY OF LIFE IN OUR STATE.
- 3:31AND SO SOME OF THE NONVIOLENT
- 3:33PROVISIONS THAT COME TO TOP OF
- 3:35MIND HAVE TO DO WITH THE STREET
- 3:37CAMPING THAT IS NOT NECESSARILY
- 3:39NONVIOLENT.
- 3:39SO I WANT TO MAKE SOMETHING VERY
- 3:41CLEAR REGARDING THAT PROVISION.
- 3:43I KNOW IT'S POPULAR IN THE MEDIA
- 3:45AND IN THE PUBLIC.
- 3:48THAT BEING HOMELESS OR
- 3:50UNSHELTERED IS NOT A CRIME IN
- 3:51THE STATE OF KENTUCKY TODAY.
- 3:53AND BEING HOMELESS UNSHELTERED
- 3:55WILL NOT BE A CRIME AFTER WE
- 3:58PASS HOUSE BILL 5.
- 4:00>> Renee: THOUGH IT'S INCLUDED
- 4:01IN HOUSE BILL 5.
- 4:01WHY?
- 4:02>> THAT'S CORRECT.
- 4:04WELL, BECAUSE WE HAVE SEEN THAT
- 4:06A LOT OF CRIME PROLIFERATES OUT
- 4:09OF THESE HOMELESS ENCAMPMENTS.
- 4:13THE HOMELESS NUMBERS IN THE CITY
- 4:15THAT I SERVE HAVE SKYROCKETED
- 4:19OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS.
- 4:20SO WE KNOW BASED ON THE RESEARCH
- 4:23WE'VE DONE THAT UNSHELTERED
- 4:26PERSON IS 500 TIMES MORE LIKELY
- 4:29TO COMMIT A CRIME THAN SOMEONE
- 4:31THAT IS NOT.
- 4:32WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THOSE
- 4:34FOLKS HAVE ADEQUATE RESOURCES
- 4:36FOR SUPPORT.
- 4:37THAT WE HAVE THOSE FOLKS IN
- 4:39DESIGNATED AREAS WHERE THEY HAVE
- 4:40RUNNING WATER, BATHROOMS AND ARE
- 4:44ACCESSIBLE TO THOSE ADVOCACY
- 4:46GROUPS THAT WANT TO PROVIDE
- 4:48SERVICES.
- 4:48>> Renee: AN IMPORTANT QUESTION
- 4:50ABOUT WHY THE STATE LEGISLATURE
- 4:52REPRESENTATIVE NEMES?
- 4:53BECAUSE THIS WAS PROPOSED IS
- 4:56PROPOSED BY A CALLEDRY OF
- 4:59COMPANIES IN JEFFERSON COUNTY.
- 5:01MANY PEOPLE WOULD SAY THAT THE
- 5:02BILL WOULD ONLY APPLY TO
- 5:04LOUISVILLE AND TO LEXINGTON.
- 5:05WHY NOT THIS KIND OF MEASURE BE
- 5:07HANDLED AT THE LOCAL LEVEL?
- 5:10YOU WERE A PROPONENT OF HOME
- 5:13RULE THE LOCAL OFFICIALS ARE
- 5:14CLOSEST TO THE PROBLEMS AND HAVE
- 5:15THE BEST SOLUTIONS THE WHY
- 5:20BYPASS THE GOVERNMENT AND DO TO
- 5:21THE LEGISLATURE.
- 5:24>> THE KENTUCKY PENAL CODE IS
- 5:26THE KENTUCKY STATUTE.
- 5:27THERE'S HOME RULE AND THERE
- 5:30OUGHT TO BE, THE PENAL LAWS ARE
- 5:31STATE LAWS HAS THEY HAVE ENGINE
- 5:34IN KENTUCKY HISTORY.
- 5:35THIS BILL WOULD NOT JUST APPLY
- 5:37TO LOUISVILLE IT WOULD BE
- 5:39STATE-WIDE.
- 5:40VIOLENT CRIME IS INCREASING
- 5:41ACROSS THE COMMONWEALTH OF
- 5:42KENTUCKY.
- 5:43KENTUCKY IS ONE OF THREE STATES
- 5:45WHERE VIOLENT CRIME HAS
- 5:47INCREASED IN THE LAST YEAR.
- 5:48AND SO THIS IS NOT JUST A
- 5:50LOUISVILLE SPECIFIC BILL THERE
- 5:51ARE PROVISIONS IN HERE WE'RE
- 5:53PROUD OF THAT WILL REDUCE CRIME
- 5:54AND A LOT IS ABOUT LOUISVILLE.
- 5:56WHEN YOU TALK TO THE LMPD CHIEF
- 5:58AND THE MAYOR AND OTHER PEOPLE
- 6:00IN LOUISVILLE FOR EXAMPLE, ONE
- 6:02THING YOU HEAR IS THE VIOLENT
- 6:04CRIME SPIKE.
- 6:04THERE ARE 150 LOUISVILLE
- 6:08LOUISVILLIANS KILLED FROM
- 6:08VIOLENT CRIME.
- 6:09AND WHAT THEY TELL US IS IT'S
- 6:11LARGELY YOUNG PEOPLE THAT ARE
- 6:13THE TRIGGER PULLERS.
- 6:14AND I THINK THAT IS ONE THING
- 6:16Mr. STRAW CAN TALK ABOUT
- 6:17TONIGHT AS WELL.
- 6:18ONE THING IN THE BILL IF YOU ARE
- 6:20AN ADULT AND USE A KRILD TO
- 6:22COMMIT A CRIME FOR YOU HAPPENING
- 6:24A LOT.
- 6:24WE HAVE A SIGNIFICANT GANG
- 6:25PROBLEM IN LOUISVILLE.
- 6:27THEN THAT PENALTY IS ENHANCED.
- 6:30DO NOT USE KIDS TO COMMIT CRIME.
- 6:33THE ANSWER DIRECTLY IS THE
- 6:35KENTUCKY PENAL CODE HAS BEEN A
- 6:36STATE LAW FROM THE BEGINNING OF
- 6:38KENTUCKY.
- 6:39THAT IS NOT A LOCAL
- 6:40RESPONSIBILITY THAT IS A STATE
- 6:42RESPONSIBILITY.
- 6:43>> Renee: REPRESENTATIVE HERRON
- 6:44I WANT TO GET YOUR RESPONSE TO
- 6:45THAT.
- 6:45DO YOU THINK THIS SHOULD BE
- 6:47DEALT WITH ELSEWHERE?
- 6:48AND THE STATE LEGISLATURE SHOULD
- 6:50BE TAKING THIS UP?
- 6:51>> I DEFINITELY THINK THERE'S A
- 6:54FEW PROVISIONS THAT SHOULD BE
- 6:55DEALT WITH ON THE LOCAL LEVEL.
- 6:58HOWEVER WHEN WE ARE TALKING
- 6:59ABOUT WHAT SAFETY MEANS IN
- 7:01KENTUCKY, I DEFINITELY THINK
- 7:02THAT THE STATE LEGISLATURE HAS A
- 7:05HUGE RESPONSIBILITY TO MAKE SURE
- 7:07THAT WE'RE MAKING EVERYONE SAFE.
- 7:08AND I DON'T BELIEVE THIS IS THE
- 7:10PIECE OF LEGISLATION THAT IS
- 7:11GOING TO MAKE US SAFE.
- 7:13AND THE SAME STUDY IN WHICH
- 7:15REPRESENTATIVE NEMES TALKED
- 7:17ABOUT, YES, CRIME DID INCREASE
- 7:18BY A LITTLE BIT.
- 7:21BUT FROM 2012-2022, VIOLENT
- 7:24CRIME DECREASED BY 5%.
- 7:26SO FOR ME, I BELIEVE THAT WE
- 7:28NEED TO BE LOOKING AT WHAT IS
- 7:31HAPPENED IN KENTUCKY OVER THE
- 7:33LAST FIVE OR 10 YEARS NOT TAKING
- 7:35A SNAPSHOT OF ONE MOMENT IN TIME
- 7:36AND SAYING WE ARE GOING TO
- 7:40LEGISLATE BASED OFF OF THIS.
- 7:41BUT I THINK AS STATE LEGISLATORS
- 7:43WE HAVE A HUGE RESPONSIBILITY.
- 7:45I JUST DON'T AGREE THIS IS THE
- 7:47RIGHT WAY TO DO IT.
- 7:48>> WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THIS
- 7:50BILL YOUR IMPRESSIONS?
- 7:52>> WE HEAR THE SAME GOAL.
- 7:53EVERYBODY WANT A SAFE KENTUCKY
- 7:56AND PROSPEROUS KENTUCKY BUT I
- 7:58DON'T THINK IT'S POSSIBLE YOU
- 8:01CANNOT INCARCERATE YOUR WAY TO
- 8:03PROSPERITY.
- 8:03WE KNOW ENHANCED PENALTIES, NEW
- 8:06CRIMES DO NOT MAKE US SAFER.
- 8:08THEY DO NOT DETER CRIME THAT IS
- 8:10NOT THE WAY TO MAKE KENTUCKY
- 8:12SAFE.
- 8:12THIS IS NOT A WAY TO DO THE
- 8:14THINGS THAT HE SEEKS TO DO IN
- 8:16TERMS OF MAKING KENTUCKY SAFE.
- 8:18I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT AT
- 8:20THE HEARING, WE HEARD A LOT OF
- 8:22CONCERNS ABOUT THIS BILL.
- 8:24IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THIS BILL
- 8:26IS SUPPOSED TO BE VOTED ON
- 8:27TOMORROW.
- 8:28WHY THE RUSH?
- 8:29LET'S TALK, LET'S HAVE
- 8:30CONVERSATIONS LIKE THIS IN
- 8:33FRANKFORT AND SEE IFS CAN'S
- 8:35POSSIBLE WE CAN AGREE.
- 8:37AND SLOW THIS BILL DOWN.
- 8:38LET'S HAVE THESE CONVERSATIONS.
- 8:40AND LET'S TALK ABOUT THE THINGS
- 8:42THAT TRULY MAKE US SAFE.
- 8:45WHICH IS INVESTING IN PEOPLE,
- 8:47AND IN COMMUNITIES.
- 8:49>> Renee: IS THE BILL GOING TO
- 8:51BE CAUGHT UP ON THE FLOOR?
- 8:52>> IT WILL NOT BE.
- 8:54TWO QUICK POINTS IF I MIGHT.
- 8:56AND THAT IS THIS BILL HAS NOT
- 8:58BEEN FAST TRACKED WE'VE BEEN
- 8:59TALKING ABOUT IT FOR NINE MONTHS
- 9:01IT WAS THE SUBJECT OF A
- 9:04COMMITTEE HEARING.
- 9:05I'VE TALKED WITH ALL THREE OF
- 9:06THE FOLKS ON THE OTHER SIDE AND
- 9:08BOTH ON THIS SIDE AND WE'VE
- 9:11INCORPORATED SUGGESTIONS THAT
- 9:13WERE MADE BY REPUBLICANS,
- 9:14DEMOCRATS AND ADVOCATES.
- 9:16REPRESENTATIVE HERRON AND I
- 9:17TALKED ABOUT IMPROVING THE GOOD
- 9:19SAMARITAN LAW AND STATE ONE
- 9:20THING THAT MY FRIEND NJUGUNA
- 9:23SAID WE ARE NOT TRYING TO
- 9:25INCARCERATE OURSELVES OUT OF THE
- 9:26PROBLEM.
- 9:26THIS IS ONE BILL.
- 9:27THERE ARE A LOT OF BILLS.
- 9:29WE ARE VERY PROUD OF WHAT I'M
- 9:31ABOUT TO SAY AND THE GOVERNOR IS
- 9:32TOO BECAUSE HE MADE IT PART OF
- 9:34THE STATE OF COMMONWEALTH.
- 9:35WE HAVE MORE TREATMENT AND
- 9:36RECOVERY BEDS IN KENTUCKY THAN
- 9:38ANY STATE IN THE COUNTRY MORE
- 9:39THAN ANY STATE IN THE COUNTRY.
- 9:41WE ARE NOT TRYING TO INCARCERATE
- 9:44OURSELVES OUT.
- 9:45THIS BUT TREAT OURSELVES OUT OF
- 9:47THIS.
- 9:48IF SOMEONE KEEPS COMMITTING
- 9:50VIOLATIONS OF THE LAW,
- 9:52ESPECIALLY VIOLENT VIOLATIONS OF
- 9:53THE LAW WE HAVE TO DO SOMETHING
- 9:55TO GET THEM OFF OUR STREETS TO
- 9:57TENG THE PEOPLE.
- 9:58>> Renee: QUICKLY IF I CAN GET
- 10:00Mr. STRAW THAT WAS MENTIONED
- 10:02IN COMMITTEE LAST THURSDAY AND
- 10:03IT WAS BY CONSERVATIVE THINK
- 10:07TANK FREE, SARAH WAS THE ONE WHO
- 10:09TALKED ABOUT HOW YOU CAN'T
- 10:12INCARCERATE YOUR WAY OUT OF IT
- 10:13COSTS MORE.
- 10:14AND SOMETIMES THESE ENHANCED
- 10:17PENALTIES, LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE
- 10:18FOR CERTAIN AMOUNT OF FELONY
- 10:21OFFENSES VIOLENT FELONY OFFENSES
- 10:24ENDS UPKEEPING PEOPLE BEHIND
- 10:25BARS THAT END UP IN ENDANGERING
- 10:27THE CORRECTIONS OFFICIALS.
- 10:29ANSWER THAT FOR US?
- 10:29>> I DON'T THINK WE CAN PLAY THE
- 10:32UP THE IDEA THAT SOME LAW THAT
- 10:34IS PASSED IS GOING TO MAKE IT
- 10:37MORE DANGEROUS THAN IT IS.
- 10:38CLEARLY RIGHT NOW, WHAT IS
- 10:39HAPPENING ISN'T WORKING.
- 10:41WE DO HAVE AN ISSUE IN KENTUCKY
- 10:43WITH OUR DEPARTMENT OF
- 10:44CORRECTIONS ESPECIALLY AND THAT
- 10:46WOULD DEFINITELY NEED TO BE
- 10:47LOOKED AT AS WELL AS THIS BILL
- 10:49GOES THROUGH.
- 10:50THE CORRECTIONS OFFICERS THEY DO
- 10:52A WONDERFUL JOB THEY WOULD ADAPT
- 10:55AND NOT BE ANYMORE UNSAFE AND
- 10:57THEY ARE TRAINED TO HANDLE THAT
- 10:59AND WE'LL PUSH FOR BETTER
- 11:00TRAINING AND CONTINUE TO SUPPORT
- 11:02THOSE IN THE ROLES.
- 11:02BUT TO SAY THAT WE INCARCERATE
- 11:05OURSELVES OUT OF THE PROBLEM, I
- 11:07JUST DON'T SEE IT.
- 11:10BECAUSE SEVENTH MOST
- 11:13INCARCERATED STATE COUNTRY IN
- 11:14THE WORLD IF WE WERE OUR OWN
- 11:17COUNTRY, YOU DON'T SA SEE THAT
- 11:18ON THE STREETS RIGHT NOW.
- 11:19OUR COPS ARE OVERWHELMED.
- 11:21WE NEED HELP.
- 11:22AND THIS BILL HELPS.
- 11:24>> Renee: AND YOU ARE FULLY
- 11:26BEHIND EVERY PROVISION IN THIS
- 11:27BILL?
- 11:28>> WE SUPPORT THE BILL
- 11:30COMPLETELY.
- 11:30>> Renee: ALL THE PROVISIONS?
- 11:31>> YES.
- 11:32>> FISCAL NOTE AND BACK TO YOU
- 11:33AND I WILL GET YOU INVOLVED
- 11:35Mr. EKLUND.
- 11:36WE HEARD TESTIMONY THAT THERE'S
- 11:38THE FISCAL NOTE THERE WILL BE AN
- 11:41IMPACT TO STATE AND LOCAL
- 11:42GOVERNMENTS.
- 11:43WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE COST?
- 11:45Mr. BAUMAN CAN YOU ANSWER
- 11:46THAT?
- 11:47>> THE COST IS LISTED AS
- 11:49UNDETERMINED.
- 11:49AND WE KNOW THAT.
- 11:52BUT THERE WILL BE COSTS
- 11:54ASSOCIATED WITH THE BILL AND WE
- 11:54ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO WORK ON
- 11:56THAT.
- 11:56BUT THE COST OF DOING NOTHING
- 11:58OUTWEIGHS THE COST OF THIS BILL.
- 12:00SO THE COST OF DOING NOTHING IS
- 12:01FUTURE VICTIMS.
- 12:02WE TALK ABOUT THE THREE STRIKES
- 12:04WHAT DO WE SAY TO THE VICTIM OF
- 12:07THAT FOURTH FAMILY THAT IS
- 12:09PERPETRATED BY A VIOLENT
- 12:10EXPERIENCED CRIMINAL?
- 12:11WE CANNOT CONTINUE TO HAVE A
- 12:14RESOLVING DOOR FOR VIOLENT
- 12:15OFFENDERS.
- 12:16WE HAVE TO ENSURE THAT WE HOLD
- 12:17THOSE FOLKS ACCOUNTABLE.
- 12:19THE PENDULUM HAS SWUNG TOO FAR
- 12:22WHERE THERE IS A LACK OF RESPECT
- 12:24FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT AND THE
- 12:26CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM.
- 12:26SO WE HAVE TO RESET, ENSURE THAT
- 12:30WE REASSERT SIMPLE TRUTHS THAT
- 12:32SOCIETY IS NOT ACCOUNTABLE FOR
- 12:34THE ACTIONS OF CRIMINALS.
- 12:35THE CRIMINALS THEMSELVES ARE
- 12:37ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS.
- 12:39>> Renee: SO FISCAL NOTE, DON'T
- 12:41KNOW WHEN IT WILL BE DETERMINED
- 12:42ARE YOU GOING TO VOTE ON THIS
- 12:44BEFORE YOU UNDERSTAND HOW MUCH
- 12:46IT'S GOING TO COST?
- 12:47>> WE HAVE A FISCAL NOTE IT
- 12:50SHOULD BE PUBLISHED ON THE
- 12:52WEBSITE.
- 12:53AND HOW MUCH WE SPEND ON
- 12:55CORRECTIONS IN KENTUCKY WE SPEND
- 12:584-5% OF OUR BUDGET ON
- 13:00CORRECTIONS THAT IS THE NOT THAT
- 13:01MUCH WITH THE FACT THAT WE SPEND
- 13:04MOREOVER FOUR TIMES MORE ON
- 13:05PENSIONS FOR STATE WORKERS THAN
- 13:07ALL OF THE CORRECTIONS COSTS.
- 13:08WE HAVE HIGHER INCREASE JUST THE
- 13:10INCREASE IN MEDICAID COSTS OVER
- 13:12THE LAST FOUR YEARS THAN WE
- 13:14SPEND ON ALL OF THE CORRECTIONS
- 13:16COSTS.
- 13:17CORRECTIONS IS MAJOR
- 13:18RESPONSIBILITY OF GOVERNMENT AND
- 13:19WE DO NOT SPEND TOO MUCH ON IT.
- 13:21SPEND MORE THAN I'D LIKE TO.
- 13:23BUT IT'S NOT AN EXORBITANT
- 13:27AMOUNT AND WHEN WE ARE TALKING
- 13:29ABOUT A THIRD STRIKE.
- 13:30PEOPLE COMMITTED THREE VIOLENT
- 13:32OFFENSES.
- 13:32TH SIS NOT THEFT OR BURGLARY.
- 13:35THIS IS ASSAULT WITH A DEADLY
- 13:36WEAPON.
- 13:37THIS IS RAPE.
- 13:37THIS IS MURDER.
- 13:39NOT MANSLAUGHTER.
- 13:40THESE ARE VERY, VERY SERIOUS
- 13:42CRIMES.
- 13:42IF YOU'VE DONE IT THREE TIMES
- 13:44CAUGHT, CONVICTED, SERVED TIME
- 13:46WITH THE PROGRAMMING, DID IT
- 13:48AGAIN AND DID IT AGAIN?
- 13:49HOW MANY TIMES BEFORE WE START
- 13:51THINKING MAYBE WE OUGHT TO
- 13:52PROTECT THE POTENTIAL VICTIMS.
- 13:54THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO.
- 13:56BOTH SIDES OF THE COIN ON COSTS.
- 13:58>> Renee: I WANT Y'ALL TO ANSWER
- 14:00THAT Mr. EXLUCK?
- 14:01>> I WANT TO GO BACK TO
- 14:04SOMETHING SAID ABOUT ACCESS TO
- 14:05TREATMENT BEDS AND THE NUMBER OF
- 14:07TREATMENT BEDS.
- 14:08IT'S GREAT WE HAVE THE HIGHEST
- 14:09PER CAPITA NUMBER OF BEDS IN
- 14:11KENTUCKY BUT THE QUESTION IS HOW
- 14:14ACCESSIBLE ARE THOSE?
- 14:14AS WE HEARD AT THE HEARING, WHEN
- 14:17AN INDIVIDUAL SAY YOU GET
- 14:19ARRESTED AND YOU SOBER UP IN
- 14:21JAIL AND THEN YOU TRY TO GET
- 14:22INTO A FACILITY IF YOU HAD
- 14:24MEDICAID YOU DON'T QUALIFY.
- 14:27YOU CAN'T GET IN.
- 14:28THAT BED IS NOT ACCESSIBLE.
- 14:29EVEN IF YOU HAVE PRIVATE
- 14:31INSURANCE ESPECIALLY IN OUR
- 14:32RURAL AREAS THERE'S ONLY ONE OR
- 14:34TWO PROVIDERS IF THAT PROVIDER
- 14:36DOESN'T TAKE YOUR INSURANCE, YOU
- 14:38GOT TO TRAVEL MILES AND MILES TO
- 14:41ANOTHER FACILITY TO GET
- 14:43TREATMENT.
- 14:43THERE ARE SERIOUS ACCESS ISSUES
- 14:46WITH TO THOSE TREATMENT BEDS.
- 14:48AND THIS BILL DOESN'T PROVIDE
- 14:49ANY OF THAT.
- 14:51ADDITIONALLY AS A SAID IF WE GET
- 14:55PEOPLE FROM TREATMENT BEDS
- 14:57TREATMENT IS A FIRST STEP, 6-9
- 15:00MONTHS AND AFTER THAT THOSE
- 15:02INDIVIDUALS NEED HOUSING, THEY
- 15:03NEED TRANSPORTATION, AND THEY
- 15:05NEED ACCESS TO EMPLOYMENT.
- 15:07THIS BILL DOESN'T HELP WITH ANY
- 15:09OF THAT.
- 15:09>> THIS BILL, BUT THE BUDGET
- 15:12DOES.
- 15:13>> Renee: Mr. EKLUND WE'RE
- 15:15FORGETTING THE ELEPHANT IN THE
- 15:16ROOM ABOUT HOUSING?
- 15:17>> KENTUCKY HAS AN AFFORDABLE
- 15:20HOUSING CRISIS EVERY COUNTY HAS
- 15:22AN ISSUE WITH RENTAL.
- 15:23WE HAVE A HUGE DEFICIT IN
- 15:26AVAILABLE INVENTORY.
- 15:27EVEN IF WHEN SOMEBODY EXITS WHEN
- 15:32SOMEBODY EXITS TREATMENT IF
- 15:33SOMEBODY WHO IS WORKING MINIMUM
- 15:34WAGE CANNOT GET INTO HOUSING
- 15:36WHAT ARE WE TO EXPECT SOMEBODY
- 15:38NEWLY IN RECOVERY STARTING THEIR
- 15:40JOURNEY TO BE ABLE TO ATTAIN
- 15:42THAT AFFORDABLE HOUSING?
- 15:43IT IS A AN ISSUE ACROSS EVERY
- 15:48COUNTY FOR US TO BE ABLE TO
- 15:50ADDRESS HOMELESSNESS WE NEED TO
- 15:51ADDRESS OUR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
- 15:54ISSUE.
- 15:54>> Renee: PICK UP ON THE
- 15:56PROVISIONS THAT TEND TO THE
- 15:58UNHOUSED AND THE PENALTIES THEY
- 15:59WOULD INCUR FOR BEING UNHOUSED
- 16:01AND SLEEPING ON THE STREET OR IN
- 16:03THE CAR.
- 16:03>> WE BELIEVE THAT HOUSE BILL 5
- 16:06IS CRUEL AND UNNECESSARY.
- 16:08LIKE THERE ARE A SLEW OF
- 16:10STATUTES ON THE BOOKS THAT CAN
- 16:12BE USED TO ADDRESS THE BEHAVIORS
- 16:14ASSOCIATED
- 16:15ASSOCIATED WITH HOMELESSNESS.
- 16:15IF SOMEBODY IS USING THEY CAN BE
- 16:18CHARGED WITH LOITERING.
- 16:21HARASSING SOMETHING THEY CAN BE
- 16:22CHARGED.
- 16:23IF THEY ARE CAMPING ON A
- 16:24SIDEWALK THEY CAN BE CHARGED
- 16:25WITH BLOCKING A PUBLIC PASSAGE
- 16:27WE HAVE THE TOOLS ON THE BOOKS.
- 16:29I DON'T SEE A NEED TO HAVE AN
- 16:32ADDITIONAL CHARGE LIKE LAID ON
- 16:33THEM.
- 16:34THAT IT'S GOING TO CREATE A NEW
- 16:36BARRIER FOR US TO MOVE PEOPLE
- 16:37INTO HOUSING.
- 16:38AT THE SAME TIME, BY DEFAULT
- 16:40THIS IS NOT TARGETING
- 16:41HOMELESSNESS AS A CRIME, BY
- 16:44DEFAULT MOST COUNTIES DON'T HAVE
- 16:47A SHELTER N LOUISVILLE WE HAVE
- 16:491600 PEOPLE HOMELESS EACH NIGHT
- 16:51AND WE HAVE 750 BEDS WHAT.
- 16:54IS WORSE WE HAVE 50 FAMILY
- 16:56SPOTS.
- 16:56BY DEFAULT WE HAVE 20 FAMILIES
- 16:59THAT ARE ON THE WAITING LIST
- 17:00TRYING TO GET INTO SHELTER.
- 17:02SO FOR US THIS IS A NOT
- 17:05ADDRESSING THE ISSUES WE HAVE AT
- 17:06HAND AND IT'S REALLY NOT GOING
- 17:09TO GUILD THE RESULTS THE
- 17:11SPONSORS ARE LOOKING FOR.
- 17:12>> Renee: TO THE QUESTION ABOUT
- 17:13THE HOMELESS POPULATION.
- 17:14THERE IS A SIZABLE YOUTH AND
- 17:16UNDERAGE HOMELESS POPULATION AND
- 17:18WOULD THOSE SAME RESTRICTIONS
- 17:20AND PENALTIES APPLY?
- 17:21WE UNDERSTAND DURING THE 2021-22
- 17:24YEAR, THE LAST COMPLETE DATA OF
- 17:28FROM KDE, 21062 CHILDREN WERE
- 17:35IDENTIFIED AS HOMELESS AND
- 17:37ONE-14 KIDS YOUNGER THAN SIX IS
- 17:40HOMELESS.
- 17:41SINCE THERE IS NOT A MINIMUM AGE
- 17:44OF ACCOUNTABILITY WOULD THE
- 17:45CHILDREN POSSIBLY A
- 17:47FOUR-YEAR-OLD BE SUBJECT TO
- 17:49PROSECUTION UNDER HOUSE BILL 5?
- 17:50>> SO LET'S TALK ABOUT WHAT THIS
- 17:53BILL IS WITH RESPECT TO
- 17:55HOMELESSNESS.
- 17:56WE DON'T WANT ANYBODY TO BE
- 17:58CHARGED.
- 17:58GEORGE SAID IT WAS CRUEL AND
- 18:00UNNECESSARY.
- 18:00I DON'T THINK THIS IS CRUEL.
- 18:04WHAT WE ARE DOING NOW IS CRUEL.
- 18:05WE'RE TRYING TO WORK WITH THE
- 18:07MAYOR TO GET MORE FUNDS AND MORE
- 18:09TREATMENT.
- 18:10BUT WHAT IS CRUEL IS ALLOWING
- 18:11THE PEOPLE ESPECIALLY THE YOUNG
- 18:12KIDS YOU'VE IDENTIFIED ALLOWING
- 18:15THEM TO CAMP OUT OVER THE
- 18:16COMMUNITY.
- 18:17WE NEED TO HAVE SPOTS FOR THEM.
- 18:19THIS BILL CALLS ON MAYOR
- 18:21GREENBURG AND LOCAL OFFICIALS TO
- 18:22HAVE A DESIGNATED AREA WHERE
- 18:24PEOPLE CAN CAMP.
- 18:25IT HAS WATER AND FACILITIES LIKE
- 18:29PORT-A-POTTIES.
- 18:30TRYING TO GET THE PEOPLE
- 18:32TREATMENT AS WELL.
- 18:33WITH RESPECT WHETHER THEY ARE
- 18:34CHARGED IF THEY DON'T FOLLOW THE
- 18:36LAW AND GO TO THE DESIGNATED
- 18:38AREA WE ARE HOPING JUDGES DIVERT
- 18:40THEM AND WE HAVE PROGRAMS THAT
- 18:41WE FUND TRYING TO GET PEOPLE
- 18:43TREATMENT.
- 18:44THIS IS DIFFICULT.
- 18:46AND I WANT TO COMMEND GEORGE FOR
- 18:49WHAT HE HAS DONE NT THE
- 18:51ADVOCATES WE ARE WITH YOU.
- 18:52BUT WHAT WE ARE DOING RIGHT NOW
- 18:53IS NOT RIGHT.
- 18:55AND MAYOR GREENBERG IS SWEEPING
- 18:57UP HOMELESS CAMPS.
- 18:59IT IS NOT ONLY THE RIGHT THING
- 19:00TO DO FOR THE BUSINESS OWNER
- 19:02AFFECTED, IT'S RIGHT FOR THE
- 19:04PARTICULAR HOMELESS PERSON.
- 19:05WE'RE TRYING TO GET THEM
- 19:06TREATMENT.
- 19:07WE ARE NOT TRYING TO HURT
- 19:08ANYBODY.
- 19:08THIS IS A DEVIL INITIALLY
- 19:12DIFFICULT ISSUE.
- 19:12>> AND YOU CAN FINE THEM UP TO
- 19:17$250 AND CARRY A JAIL SENTENCE
- 19:19UP TO 90 DAYS.
- 19:20>> THERE HAS TO BE A PENALTY.
- 19:22WE'RE TRYING WHEN THEY DON'T
- 19:24VOLUNTEER GIVE ENOUGH OF A UM OF
- 19:26FOR THEM TO GET INTO TREATMENT.
- 19:29YOU WANT TO GET HOUSING, WE WANT
- 19:33TO DIVERT YOU AND GET YOU
- 19:35TREATMENT BUT THERE HAS TO BE A
- 19:36STICK IF THEY DON'T VOLUNTEER.
- 19:39>> Renee: REPRESENTATIVE HERRON
- 19:39YOUR THOUGHTS ON THIS PART?
- 19:40>> THIS IS NOT THE WAY WE SHOULD
- 19:42BE CREATING POLICY.
- 19:44THAT IS WHAT IT IS.
- 19:45WE ALL AGREE THERE IS A HUGE
- 19:47ISSUE WITH OUR HOMELESS
- 19:48POPULATION AND I ALSO THINK IT'S
- 19:50UNFAIR TO ASSUME THAT EVERYONE
- 19:52WHO IS HOMELESS HAS A MENTAL
- 19:54HEALTH OR SUBSTANCE ABUSE ISSUE
- 19:56THAT IS NOT THE CASE.
- 19:57I KNOW OF A SINGLE MOTHER WHO
- 20:00HAD TWO KIDS AND HER LANDLORD
- 20:02SAME AND SAID I'M SELLING MY
- 20:04HOUSE YOU GOT 30 DAYS TO GET
- 20:06OUT.
- 20:06THAT FAMILY WAS HOUSELESS FOR 90
- 20:09DAYS.
- 20:10THEY HAD PEOPLE THAT THEY COULD
- 20:12GO AND STAY WITH.
- 20:13>> THAT IS IMPORTANT.
- 20:14WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THE HOMELESS
- 20:16NUMBERS THE UNSHELTERED HOMELESS
- 20:19ARE DIFFERENT THAN THE NUMBERS
- 20:20OF HOMELESS.
- 20:21THE HOMELESS PEOPLE SLEEPING ON
- 20:23THEIR NEIGHBOR'S COUCH OR THE
- 20:25BROTHER'S COUCH THEY COUNT AS
- 20:26HOMELESS.
- 20:27BUT THEY ARE NOT UNSHELTERED.
- 20:28THERE ARE VERY, VERY FEW
- 20:31UNSHELTERED CHILDREN.
- 20:32I WANT TO MAKE THAT DISTINCTION.
- 20:34>> BUT THAT IS NOT ALWAYS THE
- 20:36CASE.
- 20:36BECAUSE THAT SAME FAMILY SLEPT
- 20:38IN THE CAR A COUPLE NIGHTS.
- 20:40IT'S THE SAME PEOPLE.
- 20:41>> WHAT WITH WE THINK OF AS
- 20:44HOMELESSNESS PEOPLE WITH SEVERE
- 20:46MENTAL ILLNESS AND THAT IS 30%
- 20:47OF OUR POPULATION POINT ON OUR
- 20:49COUNT THAT WE DO EVERY JANUARY.
- 20:51IT IS MUCH MORE MULTIFACETED
- 20:54WHEN WE TALK ABOUT HOMELESSNESS
- 20:55WE HAVE 500 PEOPLE AT ANY GIVEN
- 20:58TIME ARE FLEEING DOMESTIC
- 20:59VIOLENCE.
- 21:00500 KIDS INCLUDING 50 ON THE
- 21:02STREETS OR IN THE CARS.
- 21:03WE HAVE 400 VETERANS THAT ARE
- 21:06HOMELESS.
- 21:07IT'S NOT A ONE-SIZE-FITS-ALL
- 21:09LIKE TREATMENT PLAN OR LIKE
- 21:11INTERVENTION PLAN.
- 21:12AND FOR US, LIKE OUR WORST DAY
- 21:14IS FRIDAY.
- 21:15LIKE WE GET A SHELTER WAITING
- 21:17LIST OF HOW MANY FAMILIES ARE IF
- 21:19IN SHELTER IN THE CARS AND HOW
- 21:21MANY ARE IN THE CAMPS.
- 21:22AND THE WEEK OF CHRISTMAS WE HAD
- 21:2411 FAMILIES SELF REPORTING THEY
- 21:26WERE SLEEPING RIGHT THERE.
- 21:26IT IS GOING TO IMPACT CHILDREN.
- 21:28IT IS GOING TO IMPACT FAMILIES
- 21:31AND IMPACT THE PERSON THAT IS
- 21:32STILL WORKING AND TRYING TO GO
- 21:34TO WORK EVERYDAY WHILE THEY ARE
- 21:37COUCH SURFING OR SLEEPING IN A
- 21:39CAR.
- 21:39>> Renee: YOU AGREE WITH ALL THE
- 21:40PROVISIONS IN HOUSE BILL 5.
- 21:42WHY THIS PARTICULAR ONE DO YOU
- 21:43THINK IS NEEDED WHEN IT COMES TO
- 21:45ADDRESSING THE HOMELESS
- 21:46POPULATION?
- 21:47>> I TALKED ABOUT THE BILL
- 21:49OVERALL BEING A SAFETY ISSUE FOR
- 21:51OUR OFFICERS.
- 21:52AND THAT CLEARLY IS ONE OF THE
- 21:53BIGGEST ONES IS WHEN YOU ARE
- 21:55COMING UP AND WANTING TO HELP
- 21:57BUT HAVING JUST THE LARGE
- 21:58POPULATION AGAIN, I CAN ONLY
- 22:00SPEAK FROM MY TIME IN
- 22:02LOUISVILLE.
- 22:03IT'S JUST SO OVERWHELMING YOU
- 22:04DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU ARE WALKING
- 22:06INTO.
- 22:07HAVING TOOLS AND AVENUES TO LOOK
- 22:09AT TO GET THE FOLKS HELP WE WILL
- 22:12BE SUPPORTIVE OF THAT.
- 22:13I PARTICIPATED IN THE WALK FOR
- 22:14THE HOMELESS COALITION IN
- 22:16JANUARY TO COUNT THE FAMILIES TO
- 22:17CHECK ON THAT.
- 22:18IT IS A WONDERFUL THING ALL OF
- 22:20OUR GROUPS ARE DOING EVERYTHING
- 22:21THEY CAN.
- 22:22BUT TO SPEAK TO REPRESENTATIVE
- 22:24NEMES AND I THINK A LOT OF OUR
- 22:26FOLKS, WE NEED MORE.
- 22:28WE NEED MORE HELP AND CLEARLY
- 22:29THIS BILL IS GOING TO GIVE US
- 22:30THAT.
- 22:31THERE'S NO LAW ENFORCEMENT
- 22:33OFFICER THAT WILL BE EXCITED
- 22:34ABOUT GOING OUT AND TRYING TO
- 22:36ARREST SOMEBODY SLEEPING IN A
- 22:37CAR OR SLEEPING ON THE SIDEWALK.
- 22:39THEY WANT TO GET THEM HELP AND
- 22:41WE WANT TO CONTINUE TO DO THAT
- 22:42WE DO THAT ALREADY.
- 22:44>> Renee: SO WHAT HAPPENS WHEN A
- 22:45POLICE OFFICER COMES UP ON
- 22:47SOMEBODY OR PEOPLE WHO WERE
- 22:48SLEEPING IN A CAR.
- 22:49WHAT WOULD THE RESPONSE BE?
- 22:50>> THERE'S IT DEPENDS THERE'S
- 22:54CIRCUMSTANCES.
- 22:55THERE IS NO ONE RESPONSE TO IT.
- 22:56IF THEY ARE NOT COMMITTING A
- 22:57CRIME.
- 22:58I RECOGNIZE WHAT THE BILL WILL
- 23:00DO BUT IN THE CURRENT FORM THAT
- 23:02LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER WILL
- 23:03FIGURE OUT SOME WAY TO GET THAT
- 23:05FAMILY HELP, ESPECIALLY IF THERE
- 23:07ARE CHILDREN.
- 23:07I CAN'T TELL YOU THE NUMBER OF
- 23:09STORIES I KNOW A POLICE OFFICERS
- 23:11GONE AND SPENT THEIR OWN MONEY
- 23:14TO PUT PEOPLE UP FOR THE NIGHT
- 23:15TO GET THEM OUT OF THE CAR OR
- 23:17SOMEONE WHO NEEDED A MEAL OR
- 23:18KIDS GETTING THEM TO SCHOOL.
- 23:21LAW ENFORCEMENT DO SO MANY
- 23:22THINGS THAT THE COMMUNITY HAS NO
- 23:23IDEA ABOUT.
- 23:24BECAUSE THAT IS WHAT WE ARE TO
- 23:26DO IS TO SERVE AND PROTECT AND
- 23:27THAT IS A WIDE RANGING SCOPE OF
- 23:30THINGS.
- 23:31I DON'T THINK THAT THE IDEA OF
- 23:33THE BILL IS TO GO OUT AND SEE
- 23:35HOW MANY HOMELESS PEOPLE LAW
- 23:37ENFORCEMENT CAN ARREST.
- 23:37I THINK IT'S TO GO OUT THERE AND
- 23:39GIVE US A DIFFERENT AVENUE
- 23:41SHOULD WE NEED THAT ABILITY TO
- 23:42DO THAT.
- 23:43>> Renee: THIS QUESTION AND I
- 23:45WILL COME BACK TO YOU AND MAYBE
- 23:46PERHAPS YOU CAN RESPOND, THERE
- 23:47WAS A HOMELESS MAN FROM THE
- 23:51VIEWER THAT FROZE TO DEATH IN
- 23:53VERSAILLES LAST WEEK.
- 23:54HOW DOES THIS BILL DO ANYTHING
- 23:56TO SAVE OTHERS IN SIMILAR
- 23:58SITUATIONS?
- 23:58>> ISN'T IT THE POINT?
- 24:01THAT POINT IT'S THAT MAN.
- 24:03IT'S COMMUNITY LARGELY.
- 24:06THAT'S NOT COMPASSIONATE TO LET
- 24:08THAT MAN DIE OF FREEZING.
- 24:09WE WANT TO CATAPULT THE
- 24:12SITUATION FORWARD.
- 24:13WE WANT LOCAL OFFICIALS TO HAVE
- 24:15A DESIGNATED SAFE AREA WHERE WE
- 24:17CAN HELP PEOPLE.
- 24:18AND IF THEY WON'T DO THAT WE
- 24:20HAVE TO HAVE A STICK.
- 24:22THAT'S WHY YOU HAVE CRIMINAL LAW
- 24:23ALL AROUND BUT WE'RE TRYING TO
- 24:24HELP THAT PERSON.
- 24:26WE'RE ALSO TRYING AS WE KNOW,
- 24:27OUR TOURISM NUMBERS IN
- 24:28LOUISVILLE ARE DOWN.
- 24:30GOING BACK UP THANKFULLY.
- 24:31BUT PEOPLE IN OUR NECK OF THE
- 24:33WOODS TELL US AND ALSO PEOPLE
- 24:35COMING TO LOUISVILLE FOR
- 24:36PROGRAMMING FOR CONVENTIONS, SAY
- 24:39OUR HOMELESS PROBLEM IS A
- 24:40PROBLEM.
- 24:41IT'S NOT NEARLY THE PROBLEM IT
- 24:42IS IN SAN FRANCISCO AND CHICAGO
- 24:44AND ATLANTA.
- 24:46LET'S NOT GET THERE.
- 24:47WE'RE TRYING TO ARREST THE
- 24:48PROBLEM NOW.
- 24:49GIVE OPTIONS.
- 24:50WHAT WE'RE DOING RIGHT NOW IS
- 24:53NOT WORKING.
- 24:54>> Renee: I WAS GOING TO SAY IF
- 24:56WE'RE REALLY TRYING TO HELP, HOW
- 24:58DOES IT HELP TO SUBJECT THEM TO
- 25:01ARREST AND FINES THAT WE KNOW
- 25:02THEY CAN'T PAY.
- 25:04>> THEY HAVE EVERY OPPORTUNITY
- 25:06OF INCARCERATING THEM ESPECIALLY
- 25:09IN LOUISVILLE WHERE WE HAD
- 25:10ISSUES WITH OUR JAIL.
- 25:11ALL OF OUR GOAL IS TO DO THE
- 25:13THINGS THAT RYAN TALKED ABOUT,
- 25:16WHY DON'T WE HAVE PROVISIONS IN
- 25:17THE BILL THAT DO THAT AND GET
- 25:19RID OF THE CRIMINAL PENALTIES
- 25:21AND FINES THAT THE INDIVIDUALS
- 25:22CANNOT PAY.
- 25:23>> WHEN PEOPLE DON'T DO WHAT
- 25:25THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO BE DOING.
- 25:26WE ARE TRYING TO GET PEOPLE
- 25:28TREATED NOT ALL ARE MENTAL
- 25:29HEALTH OR SUBSTANCE ABUSE 70%
- 25:31ARE.
- 25:32THAT IS WHAT THE STUDIES SHOW.
- 25:34WHILE THERE ARE PEOPLE THAT
- 25:35DON'T HAVE THOSE ISSUES.
- 25:3770% HAVE MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES OR
- 25:39SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND WE NEED TO
- 25:41GET THEM HELP.
- 25:42>> WE ALL AGREE.
- 25:43THAT IS CLEAR HERE.
- 25:44ALL SIX OF US AGREE THAT WE HAVE
- 25:46TO HELP THIS POPULATION.
- 25:47THE STATUS QUO IS NOT GOING TO
- 25:50WORK.
- 25:50WE ARE NOT GOING TO ACCEPT THAT
- 25:53BECAUSE THE POPULATION IS
- 25:54EXPLODING ESPECIALLY IN THE AREA
- 25:55THAT WE SERVE.
- 25:56WE HAVE PROPOSED THIS CHANGE.
- 25:57>> AND WHAT YOU WANT THE PEOPLE
- 25:59HERE TO KNOW AND THE VIEWERS THE
- 26:02KENTUCKIANS TO KNOW IS THAT NOT
- 26:03ONLY DO WE HAVE THIS BILL BUT WE
- 26:06ALSO HAVE HOUSE BILL 18 THAT
- 26:09PUTS RESTRICTIONS ON HOUSING
- 26:11BASED ON INCOME.
- 26:12SO AND ONE SETTING WE SAY NO WE
- 26:15WANT HOUSING FOR FOLKS.
- 26:17BUT THEN ANOTHER PIECE OF
- 26:19LEGISLATION LATER ON MAYBE THIS
- 26:20WEEK, THAT WE'RE GOING TO PASS A
- 26:22BILL THAT SAYS LANDLORDS CAN
- 26:25DENY A RENTAL FOR FOLKS BASED ON
- 26:29INCOME.
- 26:31SO THESE TWO THINGS ARE GOING TO
- 26:33BE COLLIDING.
- 26:34SO WITH THOSE TWO PROVISIONS
- 26:36THAT TWO BILLS WE'RE GOING TO BE
- 26:39IN TROUBLE HERE.
- 26:40>> MAKE THAT MAKE SENSE.
- 26:42>> HOUSE BILL 18 SAYS THAT IF
- 26:44YOU ARE AN OWNER AND YOU MADE
- 26:46THE INVESTMENTS YOU DON'T HAVE
- 26:48TO TAKE SOMEONE WHO RECEIVES
- 26:50SECTION 8.
- 26:50THAT IS DIFFERENT THAN SOURCE OF
- 26:52INCOME.
- 26:53YES, SECTION 8 MIGHT BE
- 26:55CONSIDERED INCOME BUT IT'S
- 26:56SAYING AND IT'S ONLY THAT LAW
- 26:58ONLY EXISTS IN LOUISVILLE.
- 26:59IF YOU MAKE THE ARGUMENT THAT
- 27:01IT'S PROBLEMATIC NOT TO HAVE
- 27:02THAT LAW WHAT ABOUT FRANKFORT?
- 27:05A LOT OF PEOPLE SAID IT IS A
- 27:07RACIST LAW IS FRANKFORT RACE
- 27:10NIFT I DON'T THINK THAT A FAIR
- 27:13ARTICULATION WHAT HOUSE BILL 18
- 27:15IS.
- 27:15THAT NOT THE SAFER KENTUCKY ACT.
- 27:18BUT HOUSE BILL 18 IS NOT WHAT
- 27:20THAT SAID.
- 27:22>> Renee: A VIEWER ASKED HOW
- 27:24MUCH DO YOU THINK THIS WILL COST
- 27:25TO IMPLEMENT EVERYTHING PROPOSED
- 27:26IN THE BILL GOING BACK TO THE
- 27:28FIRST QUESTION I ASKED.
- 27:29HOW DIFFERENT WOULD THE STATE
- 27:31LOOK SHE SAYS IF WE USE THOSE
- 27:34FUNDS AND REENTRY THAT WORK AND
- 27:35MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES AND
- 27:37CREATE PROACTIVE THINGS FOR OUR
- 27:38YOUTH TO DO?
- 27:39>> YES.
- 27:40AND WE HAVE REENTRY IN THE BILL.
- 27:41WE HAVE REGULAR EVALUATIONS OF
- 27:43OUR PROGRAM.
- 27:44SO WE CAN IDENTIFY THE PROGRAMS
- 27:45THAT ARE WORKING WELL ADEQUATELY
- 27:47FUND AND INVEST IN THOSE
- 27:49PROGRAMS.
- 27:49WE HAVE GROUP VIOLENCE
- 27:53INTERVENTION.
- 27:53>> Renee: WHAT WHICH MEANS WHAT?
- 27:55INCH.
- 27:56>> AND THE COST THE PAROLERIES
- 27:59THAT IS DEMONSTRATED A REDUCTION
- 28:02IN RECIDIVISM.
- 28:03>> Renee: IN LOUISVILLE THAT IS
- 28:04NOT PROVEN?
- 28:05IT'S SLOW TO SHOW THERE'S
- 28:06SUCCESS WITH THE VIOLENT PRE--
- 28:09>> THAT IS NOT TRUE.
- 28:11THE PROBLEM WE'RE HAVING IT'S
- 28:12NOT REQUIRED.
- 28:13THE PEOPLE WHO GO IT HELPS.
- 28:16BUT THE PEOPLE THAT GO THE MOST
- 28:17THEY DON'T GO IT IS NOT
- 28:19REQUIRED.
- 28:20SO WE'RE REQUIRING IT.
- 28:21AS JARED SAID WE ARE GOING TO
- 28:24LOOK AT OUR PRISON PROGRAMS FOR
- 28:26PEOPLE TO HAVE SUCCESS AND NOT
- 28:28COMMIT ACTS OF VIOLENCE.
- 28:30AND HERE IS A PROBLEM I'M HAVING
- 28:32WITH THE DISCUSSION IT IS A GOOD
- 28:35HEALTHY DISCUSSION IT IS NOT AN
- 28:36EITHER OR.
- 28:37THE BILL IS NOT AN EITHER OR.
- 28:39THE LEGISLATURE IS NOT AN EITHER
- 28:40OR.
- 28:41EITHER TREATMENT OR TOUGH ON
- 28:42CRIME.
- 28:43IT'S BOTH AND.
- 28:43WE WANT TO LOVE ON YOU.
- 28:45IF YOU NEED TREATMENT ADDICTED
- 28:47WE WILL THROW TREATMENT AT YOU.
- 28:49IF YOU DON'T WANT IT WE WANT TO
- 28:51THROW IT AT YOU ANYWAY.
- 28:53WE WANT YOU TO DO RIGHT FOR YOU
- 28:55AND NOT ONLY THE COMMUNITY YOU
- 28:57MIGHT HARM AND AT THE SAME TIME
- 28:58AND THIS IS AN AND.
- 29:01IF YOU COMMIT ACTS OF VIOLENCE
- 29:04AGAINST OUR PEOPLE WE WANT YOU
- 29:05TO GO TO PRISON.
- 29:06THIS IS A BOTH AND THIS IS NOT
- 29:08WE'RE BEING TOUGH AND NOT FOR
- 29:10TREATMENT.
- 29:10IT IS THE OPPOSITE.
- 29:11>> THAT'S REALLY NOT A LOT OF
- 29:14REENTRY THERE.
- 29:15OBVIOUSLY IT'S GOOD THING TO
- 29:17EVALUATE THE PROGRAMS WE HAVE
- 29:18FOR INDIVIDUALS.
- 29:19I WILL SAY ONE PROVISION IS
- 29:20AROUND THAT AND THAT IS GIVING
- 29:23ID'S TO INDIVIDUALS LEAVING
- 29:25COUNTY JAILS AND EXPANDING THAT.
- 29:26I WILL SAY THAT WILL NEED AN
- 29:29APPROPRIATIONS TO ACTUALLY DO
- 29:31ANYTHING.
- 29:32SO I'M LOOKING TO THE OTHER SIDE
- 29:34TO GET THAT INTO THE BUDGET THAT
- 29:36IS WHAT IS GOING TO BE NEEDED.
- 29:38OTHER THINGS GREAT FOR REENTRY
- 29:39IS GETTING PEOPLE BACK INTO THE
- 29:41WORKFORCE.
- 29:42AND ONE WAY OF DOING THAT IS
- 29:44PEOPLE WHO ARE JUSTICE INVOLVED
- 29:47AND HAVE RECORDS IS AUTOMATED
- 29:50EXPUNGEMENT.
- 29:51MAKING IT EASIER FOR PEOPLE TO
- 29:53GET EXPUNGEMENTS AND GET HIRED.
- 29:55THOSE ARE THINGS THAT ARE
- 29:57REENTRY.
- 29:57>> AND REPRESENTATIVE MOESER HAS
- 30:00A BILL THAT I SUPPORT AND I HOPE
- 30:02MOVES FORWARD AND I AGREE ON
- 30:04THAT.
- 30:04THE BILL IS ONE BILL OF MANY.
- 30:06AND WITH RESPECT TO GETTING
- 30:07PEOPLE UP AND READY TO GO BACK
- 30:08TO WORK, THAT'S WHY WE HAVE THE
- 30:10MOST THE BEST AND THE MOST PER
- 30:13CAPITA ANYWHERE IN THE COUNTRY
- 30:14PLACES LIKE THE HEALING PLACE.
- 30:17WHICH SAVES LIVES.
- 30:18LIKE THE VOA.
- 30:21>> Renee: VOLUNTEERS OF AMERICA.
- 30:22>> ISAIAH HOUSE.
- 30:24THESE THINGS ARE WHAT DESIGNED
- 30:26TO DO THOSE TYPES OF THINGS WE
- 30:27HAVE MORE THAN ANY STATE.
- 30:29DO WE HAVE ENOUGH?
- 30:30NO, WE NEED MORE BUT WE ARE
- 30:32DOING BETTER THAN EVERYBODY ELSE
- 30:33IS.
- 30:34>> REN NEW, THE ISSUE I HAVE IS
- 30:37I THINK MY COLLEAGUES CARE ABOUT
- 30:39THE ISSUE AND THEY REALLY WANT
- 30:41TO FIND SOLUTIONS.
- 30:43THE ISSUE I HAVE WITH THE
- 30:45PROVISIONS AND HOW THIS WAS
- 30:47DONE, WE HAD A JAIL AND PRISON
- 30:49TASK FORCE IN THE INTERIM.
- 30:52AND THE JAILERS TOLD US THAT
- 30:54THEY ARE HURTING.
- 30:55THAT IT'S OVERCRUDDED.
- 30:58THEY CAN'T FIND PEOPLE TO WORK
- 30:59AND THE OTHER THING THEY TALKED
- 31:01ABOUT WAS A LACK OF
- 31:02CLASSIFICATION.
- 31:03WHAT THAT MEANS IS BASICALLY YOU
- 31:04HAVE PEOPLE WHO ARE SITTING IN
- 31:07JAIL AND THEY CAN'T GET
- 31:09CLASSIFIED FROM THE DEPARTMENT
- 31:10OF CORRECTIONS.
- 31:11IF FOLKS ARE NOT CLASSIFIED THEN
- 31:12THEY CAN'T GET INTO PROGRAMS.
- 31:14SO THE ISSUE I HAVE IS RIGHT NOW
- 31:17THE CURRENT SYSTEM AND WHAT WE
- 31:19HAVE RIGHT NOW IS NOT WORKING.
- 31:21SO WHAT I WOULD HAVE PREFERRED
- 31:22WHAT I THINK IS BEST POLICY
- 31:25MAKING IS THAT WE FIND OUT WHAT
- 31:26DO WE NEED TO GO WHERE ARE THE
- 31:29HOLES?
- 31:30NOT THAT CREATE 26 PLUS NEW
- 31:33PROVISIONS, CREATE A NEW LAW DO
- 31:35ALL THE ENHANCEMENTS AND DO THAT
- 31:37AT THE SAME TIME.
- 31:37WE ARE NOT GOING TO GET THE
- 31:39RIGHT ANSWER.
- 31:40SO THAT HAS BEEN MY ISSUE WITH
- 31:42THIS AND THEN, OF COURSE, THE
- 31:44ISSUE THE FACT WE DO NOT HAVE A
- 31:47FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT.
- 31:48I THINK THAT IS BAD POLICY
- 31:50MAKING.
- 31:50I THINK THAT THAT IS TO ME THAT
- 31:52IS DANGEROUS.
- 31:53IF YOU TALK ABOUT MAKING
- 31:55SOMETHING UNSAFE, HAVING A
- 31:5872-PAGE CRIMINAL JUSTICE BILL
- 31:59THAT IS LOOKING AT MORE PENAL
- 32:03CODES 0 ENHANCEMENTS AND NOT
- 32:05KNOWING HOW MUCH IT'S GOING TO
- 32:06COST THAT'S DANGEROUS.
- 32:07>> IT'S NEEDED, THOUGH, BECAUSE
- 32:09OUR STATUTE NEEDED
- 32:11MODERNIZATION.
- 32:11WE NEEDED THAT.
- 32:12A LOT OF KENTUCKIANS WOULD BE
- 32:14SURPRISED TO LEARN THAT
- 32:16ATTEMPTED MURDER IS NOT
- 32:17CONSIDERED A VIOLENT CRIME IN
- 32:18THE STATE OF KENTUCKY.
- 32:20CARJACKING IS NOT CONSIDERED A
- 32:22VIOLENT CRIME.
- 32:23ARSON THERE ARE A NUMBER OF VERY
- 32:26HAIN NOWS VIOLENT CONTACTS HAT
- 32:27ARE NOT CONSIDERED SO UNDER
- 32:30KENTUCKY STATUTE AND WE NEEDED
- 32:32TO MODERNIZE THOSE.
- 32:34>> I THINK WE SHOULD HAVE THIS
- 32:36SHOULD BE DONE ON A SURGICAL
- 32:38LEVEL WHAT ARE THE ACTUAL ISSUES
- 32:40WHAT REPRESENTATIVE HERRON WAS
- 32:41SAYING RATHER THAN THE WIDE
- 32:44EXPANSE OF APPROACH WHERE WE ARE
- 32:46TALKING ABOUT LOWERING THE
- 32:47THRESHOLDS FOR CRIMINAL MISCHIEF
- 32:48FOR PEOPLE THAT ARE RENTING.
- 32:50RIGHT NOW IF YOU COMMIT OVER
- 32:53$500 OF DAMAGE WANTLY TO A
- 32:56RENTAL UNIT YOU CAN BE CHARGED
- 32:57WITH A CLASS A MISDEMEANOR.
- 32:59THIS BILL WOULD LOWER THAT DOWN
- 33:01TO $1.
- 33:03IF YOU PUT A HOLE IN THE WALL
- 33:05AND IT COSTS $3.50.
- 33:07>> THIS IS NOT FOR HANGING YOUR
- 33:09TV ON THE WALL BUT KNOWINGLY
- 33:11DESTROYING PROPERTY.
- 33:12>> IT IS GOING TO IMPACT PEOPLE
- 33:14WITH SMALL CHILDREN AND PEOPLE
- 33:16WITH PETS.
- 33:18>> IT'S GOING TO IMPACT PEOPLE
- 33:20THAT INTENTIONALLY DESTROY
- 33:22PROPERTY.
- 33:22>> BUT ALL THAT DAMAGE SHOULD BE
- 33:24COVERED BY YOUR SECURITY
- 33:25DEPARTMENT.
- 33:26IN LOUISVILLE WE SPEND $2500 PER
- 33:29PERSON WE PUT INTO HOUSING FOR
- 33:30THE SECURITY DEPOSIT.
- 33:33THAT SHOULD COVER ALL OF THOSE
- 33:35EASILY LIKE SMALL DAMAGES TO A
- 33:37UNIT.
- 33:38WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT SOMEBODY
- 33:39WHO POURS CONCRETE DOWN THE
- 33:42TOILET.
- 33:42>> I AGREE BUT THOSE SECURITY
- 33:44DEPOSITS WILL CONTINUE TO RISE
- 33:46AND THEY HAVE BECAUSE OF THE
- 33:48DESTRUCTION OF PROPERTIES THE
- 33:50LANDLORDS --
- 33:51>> AND THAT IS THE PROPERTY OF
- 33:52THE LANDLORD F THERE IS A
- 33:54FINANCIAL BOND THAT THE LANDLORD
- 33:56IS HOLDING IN A BANK ACCOUNT
- 33:58THAT SHOULD COVER IT.
- 33:58WE SHOULDN'T HAVE TO GO AFTER.
- 34:01>> --
- 34:03DON'T DESTROY THE PROPERTY.
- 34:04>> I WOULD LIKE TO GET BACK TO
- 34:06YOUR POINT ABOUT THE MODERATION
- 34:08OF OUR PENAL CODE.
- 34:09I THINK YOU ARE RIGHT WE NEEDED
- 34:11THAT.
- 34:12AND REPRESENTATIVE NEMES MY
- 34:13FIRST YEAR IN THE SESSION HOUSE
- 34:15JOINT RESOLUTION 87 WHICH YOU
- 34:18COSPONSORED TALKED ABOUT THE
- 34:20FACT THAT OUR CRIMINAL CODE WAS
- 34:21WRITTEN OVER 40 YEARS AGO.
- 34:23AND THAT OVER TIME WE HAD CUSTOM
- 34:26CRIMES, UNEVEN PENALTY SCHEMES
- 34:30AND WE NEEDED TO CREATE A TASK
- 34:32FORCE TO LOOK AT THE CRIMINAL
- 34:33CODE AND WE AGREED WITH YOU.
- 34:36HB5 IS NOT THAT.
- 34:37SO WHAT WE NEED TO DO IS HOUSE
- 34:39JOINT RESOLUTION 87 AND NOT
- 34:41HOUSE BILL 5.
- 34:42>> Renee: LET'S TALK ABOUT WHAT
- 34:43SOME CALLED THE DRUG INDUCED
- 34:46HOMICIDE LAWS.
- 34:48ENHANCEMENTS FOR SELLING
- 34:50FENTANYL THAT COULD BE LEADING
- 34:51TO A FATAL OVERDOSE.
- 34:52THIS QUESTION FROM A VIEWER HOW
- 34:55DOES THE PROVISION IMPACT THE
- 34:57GOOD SAMARITAN LAW THAT LAW
- 35:00PROTECTS DRUG USERS FROM
- 35:01PENALTIES WHEN THEIR FRIENDS DIE
- 35:03OF AN OVERDOSE.
- 35:04>> THAT IS A GOOD QUESTION.
- 35:06>> AND WE HEARD DURING THE
- 35:11TESTIMONY ON THURSDAY THAT THERE
- 35:12WAS KENTUCKY DERBY THIS COULD IN
- 35:15FACT DO HARM AND PEOPLE WOULD
- 35:18NOT DO WHAT THEY WOULD HELP TO
- 35:21EN REMEMBER EMERGENCY AID WHEN
- 35:22THEY WITNESSED AN OVERDOSE.
- 35:24>> THAT LAW WILL BE IN PLAY
- 35:27COMPLETELY.
- 35:37[AUDIO INTERRUPTION] ABECAUSE WE
- 35:38INCLUDELY WANT TO STILL PROVIDE
- 35:40THAT FOR FOLKS THAT ARE TRYING
- 35:41TO HELP SOMEONE IN AN OVERDOSE
- 35:43SITUATION.
- 35:44WE DO NOT WANT THAT PERSON BEING
- 35:46HARMED CRIMINALLY FOR THAT.
- 35:48>> Renee: THIS IS ABOUT
- 35:49TRAFFICKING FENTANYL NOT SHARING
- 35:50IN THE USE OF A DRUG THAT COULD
- 35:53CONTAIN.
- 35:53>> CORRECT.
- 35:53>> FENTANYL.
- 35:55>> SELLING.
- 35:56>> I WOULD DISAGREE.
- 35:58THE DISDISTRIBUTION NO AMOUNT.
- 36:00>> WE KNOW THAT THIS FENTANYL IS
- 36:03POISON AND IT'S KICK OUR PEOPLE.
- 36:06WILLING OUR PEOPLE.
- 36:07SO --
- 36:07KILLING OUR PEOPLE.
- 36:08WE NEED TO CLEARLY DEMONSTRATE
- 36:10IF YOU KNOWINGLY SELL FOR-PROFIT
- 36:13MOTIVE POISON TO SOMEONE AND
- 36:14KILL THEM, THEN YOU WILL BE HELD
- 36:17ACCOUNTABLE.
- 36:18>> THERE ARE TWO PROVISIONS.
- 36:19WE AMEND THE MURDER STATUTE TO
- 36:21WHERE IT SAYS IF YOU KNOWINGLY
- 36:24SELL FENTANYL ZERO AMOUNT AND A
- 36:25DEATH RESULTS OF THAT, YOU CAN
- 36:28BE FOUND GUILTY OF MURDER.
- 36:30THEN THERE'S MANSLAUGHTER WORDS
- 36:33FOR BASICALLY DISTRIBUTION WHERE
- 36:35YOU DISTRIBUTE IT AGAIN NO
- 36:36AMOUNT WHICH YOU ARE GOING TO
- 36:38CAPTURE USERS BUT --
- 36:40SO THE AMOUNT IS NOT THERE.
- 36:42WHAT YOU END UP GETTING ARE
- 36:43PEOPLE LIKE ME WHEN I WAS IN
- 36:45ACTIVE ADDICTION, YOU SHARE YOUR
- 36:48SUBSTANCE, SOMEONE HAPPENED TO
- 36:49BE THERE AND DIE, I COULD BE
- 36:51CHARGED WITH A HOMICIDE.
- 36:52AND HERE IS THE OTHER THING.
- 36:54YOU CAN GOOGLE IT NOW AND LOOK
- 36:55TO SEE WHEN THE CURRENT
- 36:57MANSLAUGHTER CHARGES HAVE BEEN
- 36:59FILED AGAINST INDIVIDUALS IT IS
- 37:00A FRIEND OR A FAMILY MEMBER.
- 37:02I DON'T THINK LAW ENFORCEMENT
- 37:05HAS EVER CHARGED ANYBODY UNDER
- 37:07THAT WHO WAS BRINGING TONS OF
- 37:09FENTANYL INTO THE COUNTRY.
- 37:10>> Renee: THAT BRINGS UP A GOOD
- 37:12POINT IS IT GOING TO TARGET THE
- 37:14WRONG PEOPLE THE FAMILY AND
- 37:16FRIENDS WHO WITNESS THE OVERDOSE
- 37:17AND NOT THE HIGH DEALING DRUG
- 37:20TRAFFICKER?
- 37:20>> NO, IT DOES BOTH.
- 37:22IF YOU SELL IT FOR-PROFIT
- 37:25MOTIVE, THAT IS A HIGHER CRIME.
- 37:28BUT WHAT HE WAS SAYING IS IF YOU
- 37:31KNOWINGLY DISTRIBUTE FENTANYL WE
- 37:33KNOW THAT.
- 37:34>> Renee: YOU KNOW THE DRUG HAS
- 37:35IT IN IT AND SOMETIMES PEOPLE
- 37:37DON'T KNOW.
- 37:38>> THEN THEY WOULD NOT VIOLATE
- 37:40THE LAW.
- 37:42>> Renee: HOW DO YOU PROVE?
- 37:42>> THE KNOWINGLY LEVEL.
- 37:44>> KNOWINGLY IS DEFINED IN
- 37:47KENTUCKY LAW FOR 100 YEARS A
- 37:49TERM OF OURS THAT WE USE.
- 37:51IF YOU DON'T KNOW THERE'S
- 37:53FENTANYL IN IT IT DOESN'T
- 37:54QUALIFY.
- 37:55IT SAYS HE OR SHE KNOWINGLY
- 37:57DISTRIBUTES FENTANYL TO ANOTHER
- 37:59PERSON, WITHOUT REMUNERATION AND
- 38:02THE INJECTION INHALATION OR
- 38:04INTRODUCTION OF THE FENTANYL
- 38:05CAUSES THE DEFENDANT OF THE
- 38:07PERSON.
- 38:08KNOWINGLY DISTRIBUTES FENTANYL
- 38:09TO A PERSON.
- 38:10IF YOU DON'T KNOW THAT IS WHAT
- 38:12YOU ARE DOING THEN YOU HAVE NOT
- 38:14VIOLATED THIS.
- 38:14THIS IS VERY --
- 38:16>> WE NEED TO MAKE THAT CLEAR
- 38:18BECAUSE I THINK THERE'S CASE LAW
- 38:20WHERE THE KNOWINGLY IS NOT WHAT
- 38:23MOST PEOPLE AND TO CLEARLY KNOW
- 38:25THAT YOU SHOULD SAY YOU HAVE TO
- 38:26PROVE THAT THAT INDIVIDUAL HAD
- 38:28ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE IT HAD FENTANYL
- 38:31OTHERWISE YOU ARE GOING TO
- 38:32CAPTURE A LOT OF FOLKS.
- 38:35IF WE CAN WORD IT BETTER IT'S
- 38:38WORDED CORRECTLY BUT WE'RE OPEN
- 38:40FOR THAT.
- 38:41WE DON'T WANT PEOPLE WHO ARE
- 38:42EVEN USING THINGS THOUGH THEY
- 38:44SHOULDN'T BE DOING IT TO BE
- 38:46CHARGED.
- 38:47WE KNOW FENTANYL IN TRACE
- 38:48AMOUNTS IS DEADLY.
- 38:50>> Renee: ABSOLUTELY.
- 38:50>> I WAS GOING TO SAY AS
- 38:53UNFORTUNATE THAT WOULD BE AND
- 38:54FOLKS CAUGHT UP IN IT FROM OUR
- 38:56PERSPECTIVE ON THE LAW
- 38:57ENFORCEMENT SIDE, WE DON'T
- 38:59DIFFERENTIATE THAT THAT COULD
- 39:01KILL US IF WE'RE COMING TO HELP
- 39:03YOU I APPRECIATIVE ADDICTION AND
- 39:05APPRECIATE GETTING ALL THE
- 39:06TREATMENT, BUT IT CAN KILL OUR
- 39:08PEOPLE.
- 39:08AND WE'RE TRYING TO HELP YOU AND
- 39:11I GET THAT THERE IS AN ARGUMENT
- 39:13IF IT IS A CHOICE OR NOT A
- 39:14CHOICE.
- 39:15BUT WHEN WE'RE HAVING TO CARRY
- 39:17NARCAN NOT JUST TO HELP OTHER
- 39:19PEOPLE, BUT TO HELP SOMEONE THAT
- 39:21MIGHT BE RESPONDING ON A CALL OR
- 39:23HOPE TO GOD SOMEONE HELPS US IF
- 39:25WE HAVE AN ACCIDENTAL OVERDOSE
- 39:27FROM FENTANYL.
- 39:29FENTANYL SHUT DOWN AN OFFICE IN
- 39:30LOUISVILLE FOR TWO DAYS.
- 39:32THE SIZE OF IT WAS HALF OF A
- 39:34DIME.
- 39:35AND SOMEONE BROUGHT THAT IN AND
- 39:36LEFT IT THERE.
- 39:37IT IS AN ABSOLUTELY IT IS THE
- 39:40POISON OF THE WORST POISON.
- 39:41>> Renee: THIS BILL IS NOT TO
- 39:43UNDERCUT HARM REDUCTION EFFORTS,
- 39:46GOOD SAMARITAN LAWS THOSE
- 39:48THINGS?
- 39:48BUT DO YOU SEE WHERE THAT COULD
- 39:50BE IN SOME PEOPLE'S EYES
- 39:53COMPETING BASED ON SOME OF THE
- 39:53LANGUAGE IN THE BILL?
- 39:54>> WE DO.
- 39:55WE DISAGREE WITH THAT THOUGH
- 39:57THEY SAID IT WE DISAGREE WITH
- 39:59IT.
- 39:59THE FLOOR AMENDMENT IMPROVES THE
- 40:02GOOD SAMARITAN LAW.
- 40:03WE'VE TAKEN THAT WHICH WE DON'T
- 40:05THINK WAS RIGHT OUT OF GOOD
- 40:08FAITH IMPROVED OUR GOOD
- 40:10SAMARITAN LAW ACROSS THE BOARD
- 40:12IN THE FLOOR AMENDMENT.
- 40:12>> THIS IS A CLEAR DEMONSTRATION
- 40:15HOW OUR TEAM SOME FOLKS SAY IT'S
- 40:18RUSHED, BUT WE HAVE WORKED WITH
- 40:19THE THREE FOLKS ON PANEL HERE
- 40:22WITH US TONIGHT, AND ALL
- 40:25STAKEHOLDERS ANYBODY THAT WANTED
- 40:26TO SEAT AT THE STABLE AS WE'VE
- 40:29GONE THROUGH THE PROCESS HAS
- 40:31BEEN GIVEN A SEAT AT THE TABLE
- 40:32AND WE HAVE LISTENED TO FEEDBACK
- 40:34AND ADAPTED AND ADJUSTED OUR
- 40:36POLICY EVERY STEP OF THE WAY.
- 40:38WE FILED HOUSE BILL 100 THAT
- 40:40CAME OUT OF DISCUSSIONS WITH
- 40:41Mr. EKLUND TO HELP ENSURE THAT
- 40:44THE HOMELESS POPULATION RECEIVES
- 40:46BIRTH CERTIFICATES WHEN NEEDED.
- 40:48WE'VE WORKED VERY WELL WITH ALL
- 40:51STAKEHOLDERS ON BOTH SIDES OF
- 40:52THESE ISSUES.
- 40:54>> Renee: THAT BILL HAS NOT BEEN
- 40:55VOTED ON HOUSE BILL 100?
- 40:57IT'S COME OUT OF COMMITTEE BUT
- 40:59HAS NOT BEEN ON THE FLOOR YET.
- 41:01WE'LL LOOK FOR THAT SOON.
- 41:03APPRECIATE THAT BILLTH THAT IS A
- 41:05BASE HIT EFFORT.
- 41:06>> ANYTIME WE CAN PASS POLICY
- 41:08THAT WILL MOVE PEOPLE TOWARDS
- 41:10HOUSING THAT IS WHAT WE'RE
- 41:12WORKING ON.
- 41:13GETTING PEOPLE ID'S AND BIRTH
- 41:15CERTIFICATES AND GETTING MORE
- 41:17HOUSING ON THE INVENTORY THAT IS
- 41:19GREAT.
- 41:20ANYTIME WE CAN PREVENT
- 41:21HOMELESSNESS ADDRESSING WHAT
- 41:23REPRESENTATIVE HERRON WAS SAYING
- 41:24GIVING PEOPLE THREE-MONTH
- 41:27OFF-RAMP TO FINDING A NEW RENTAL
- 41:30HOUSING IF THEIR LANDLORD IS
- 41:31ENDING THE LEASE.
- 41:32THOSE ARE THE POLICIES WE WOULD
- 41:35SUPPORT.
- 41:35BUT THIS IS STILL LIKE I FEEL
- 41:37LIKE HOUSE BILL 5 IS STILL NOT
- 41:39MOVING US TOWARDS GETTING PEOPLE
- 41:41INTO HOUSING.
- 41:42>> Renee: HOW MANY FLOOR
- 41:43AMENDMENTS?
- 41:44>> MY FRIEND HERE HAS FOUR.
- 41:47[LAUGHTER]
- 41:47>> .
- 41:48>> Renee: MAYBE FIVE.
- 41:49>> 12 THAT HAVE BEEN FILED SOME
- 41:51WE WILL INCORPORATE AND SOME WE
- 41:53WILL HAVE A SPIRITED DEBATE AND
- 41:55A VOTE ON THE FLOOR.
- 41:56>> Renee: TIMELINE WHEN THAT
- 41:57COULD HAPPEN?
- 41:57>> I DON'T KNOW YET.
- 41:58>> THIS QUESTION TO BOTH OF THE
- 42:00REPRESENTATIVES ON THIS SIDE
- 42:03FROM CATHERINE FROM LOUISVILLE.
- 42:05MANY PARTS OF THE BILL WERE
- 42:07LIFTED FROM RIGHT-WING POLICY
- 42:10THINK TANK CAN YOU SPEAK TO HOW
- 42:11YOU WORK WITH THEM TO FILE THIS
- 42:14LEGISLATION?
- 42:15>> WELL, I DON'T THINK THAT IS
- 42:17TRUE WE LIFT TO DO STRAIGHT FROM
- 42:18THEM.
- 42:19WE CERTAINLY CONSIDERED A LOT OF
- 42:21DIFFERENT INPUTS AS PART OF OUR
- 42:23PROCESS WHEN IT CAME TO DATA AND
- 42:25RESEARCH AND WE CERTAINLY
- 42:27CONSIDERED SOME OF THEIRS.
- 42:28WE DID NOT PLUG AND PLAY
- 42:30DIRECTLY FROM THEM.
- 42:31>> THAT IS RIGHT.
- 42:34JOHN TALKED TO A NUMBER OF
- 42:36GROUPS TO GET THOSE PROVISIONS
- 42:37IN THERE.
- 42:38BUT THIS IS A KENTUCKY-DRIVEN
- 42:41PROCESS.
- 42:41REPRESENTATIVE BAUMAN TO HIS
- 42:43CREDIT DRAFTED ALMOST ALL OF
- 42:45THIS.
- 42:45THERE ARE A COUPLE PROVISIONS WE
- 42:47WORKED ON I DID THE MENTAL
- 42:49HEALTH PROVISION AND FLEMING AND
- 42:51SUSAN AND CALLAWAY, WE'VE WORKED
- 42:52TOGETHER ON THAT THIS IS DRAFTED
- 42:54BY KENTUCKIANS FOR KENTUCKY THIS
- 42:57IS NOT AN OUT OF STATE OR
- 42:59RIGHT-WING ORGANIZATION THAT
- 43:01DRAFTED THIS.
- 43:02>> SHE SAID IN COMMITTEE LAST
- 43:05WEEK, I BELIEVE THERE'S 10 BILLS
- 43:06ROLLED INTO ONE.
- 43:07DO YOU SEE THIS BILL EVOLVING
- 43:10WHERE PARTS ARE INCLUDED?
- 43:13AND OTHER PARTS FALL AWAY?
- 43:14>> CONTINUING TO EVOLVE.
- 43:16I WOULD SAY THAT REPRESENTATIVE
- 43:19FLEMINGS' MA'AM BUS BILL IS IN
- 43:22ONE WHICH I THINK IS GOOD.
- 43:25WHEN YOU HAVE GOOD HERE WHAT IS
- 43:27WRONG?
- 43:28WE'VE REDUCED THINGS AND TOOK
- 43:29THINGS OUT THAT HAD TO DO WITH
- 43:31THE PAROLE BOARD BECAUSE WE HAD
- 43:34MEMBERS.
- 43:34>> Renee: AND WIRETAPPING WAS
- 43:35OUT.
- 43:35WE HAVE BEEN ADAPTING FROM THE
- 43:37BEGINNING THIS WILL NOT EVOLVE
- 43:38IT WILL CONTINUE TO EVOLVE AND
- 43:40THE SENATE WILL HAVE ITS SAY
- 43:43ALSO ABOUT HOUSE BILL 5.
- 43:43>> I WANT TO SAY SOMETHING AND I
- 43:46APPRECIATE BOTH OF THE
- 43:48REPRESENTATIVES WHO ARE HERE.
- 43:50WE TALK ON A REGULAR BASIS.
- 43:52REPRESENTATIVE BAUMAN SITS IN
- 43:53FRONT OF ME SO WE JOKE EVERYDAY.
- 43:56BUT I WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR.
- 43:57WE WERE NOT CRUDED IN THIS
- 44:00UNTIL --
- 44:00INCLUDED UNTIL THIS POINT.
- 44:01>> THAT IS NOT FAIR.
- 44:02>> NO, THAT IS VERY FAIR WHEN
- 44:05THEY ROLLED OUT THIS BILL IT WAS
- 44:08ALL REPUBLICANS FROM JEFFERSON
- 44:09COUNTY SAID THIS IS WHAT THEY
- 44:10WERE GOING TO DO.
- 44:11IT WAS AFTER THE FACT.
- 44:12I DIDN'T SEE THIS PIECE OF
- 44:16LEGISLATION UNTIL DECEMBER 14TH.
- 44:17YES, I KNEW THE CONCEPTS BUT TO
- 44:21SAY THAT WE WERE AT THE TABLE
- 44:23THAT'S NOT ACCURATE.
- 44:24AT THIS POINT IN THE GAME.
- 44:25YES, WE HAVE HAD GOOD
- 44:27COMMUNICATION.
- 44:28BUT I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT IT'S
- 44:30VERY IMPORTANT FOR THE PEOPLE OF
- 44:31KENTUCKY TO KNOW WE WERE NOT AT
- 44:34THE TABLE AT THE BEGINNING OF
- 44:35THIS.
- 44:36>> BUT YOU HAD THE OPPORTUNITY
- 44:37TO BE.
- 44:37>> THAT IS NOT ACCURATE.
- 44:38>> WE MADE THAT PUBLIC AND GAVE
- 44:41EVERYONE THE OPPORTUNITY.
- 44:43KUNGU NJUGUNA CAME TO MY OFFICE
- 44:45AND YOU COULD HAVE AS WELL.
- 44:46CHOSE NOT TO.
- 44:47>> I WILL TELL YOU LIKE YOUR
- 44:49COLLEAGUES TELL ME, IT'S HARD TO
- 44:50SAY YES OR NO ON SOMETHING THAT
- 44:52YOU DON'T HAVE LANGUAGE.
- 44:53THERE WAS AN IDEA, IDEAS
- 44:56FLOATING AROUND.
- 44:57THERE WAS NEVER A PHONE CALL
- 44:58SAID, HEY, JEFFERSON DEMOCRATIC
- 45:01CAUCUS, LET'S GET TOGETHER THESE
- 45:03ARE THE THINGS WE'RE THINKING
- 45:05ABOUT.
- 45:05LET'S SIT DOWN.
- 45:05THAT NEVER HAPPENED, EVER.
- 45:07>> WE HAD A NUMBER OF MONTHS
- 45:09WHEN IT WAS OUT THERE AND TALKED
- 45:10TO A NUMBER OF PEOPLE INCLUDING
- 45:12MEMBERS OF OUR CAUCUS.
- 45:14SO I'M PROUD OF THE PROCESS
- 45:16HERE.
- 45:16THIS HAS BEEN ONE OF THE MOST
- 45:18TRANSPARENT PROCESSES SINCE I'VE
- 45:20BEEN THERE.
- 45:21AND IT HAS BEEN.
- 45:22AND THE PROOF IS IN THE PUDDING.
- 45:24WE HAVE MADE A NUMBER OF CHANGES
- 45:26BASED ON SUGGESTIONS FROM OUR
- 45:28FRIENDS ACROSS THE AISLE AND WE
- 45:29WILL CONTINUE TO DO THAT.
- 45:30I KNOW OUR FRIENDS LIKE TO TAKE
- 45:32SHOTS WHEN THEY DON'T LIKE THE
- 45:34PROCESS BUT THIS IS --
- 45:35>> IT IS NOT A SHOT.
- 45:39I WANT KENTUCKIANS TO KNOW WE
- 45:40ARE PART OF THE PROCESS NOW.
- 45:42I SENT YOU AN E-MAIL, BUT WE
- 45:45WERE NOT THERE AT THE BEGINNING
- 45:46AND THAT IS VERY ACCURATE AND
- 45:49KENTUCKIANS NEED TO KNOW THAT.
- 45:50>> Renee: LET ME ASK A QUESTION
- 45:52THERE WAS A REPORT THAT CAME OUT
- 45:54AND ITS ANALYSIS OF HOUSE BILL 5
- 45:57AND THERE'S BEEN AN INCREASE OF
- 45:59CRIMINAL PENALTIES WHEN IT COMES
- 46:00TO DRUG LAWS AND PARTICULARLY
- 46:02FENTANYL AND FENTANYL
- 46:04DERIVATIVES THERE ARE THREE
- 46:06BILLS SENATE BILL BILL 192,
- 46:08HOUSE BILL 333, AND HOUSE BILL
- 46:11215 IN 2022.
- 46:12ARE THOSE WORKING?
- 46:14AND IF THOSE ARE WORKING, WHY DO
- 46:17YOU NEED THIS?
- 46:18AND IF THEY ARE NOT WORKING,
- 46:20THEN IT'S SAYING THAT THERE
- 46:21MAYBE NEED A DIFFERENT APPROACH
- 46:22ALL THE WAY AROUND PERHAPS?
- 46:24>> SO I THINK I DON'T THINK WE
- 46:26CAN GET SERIOUS ENOUGH ABOUT
- 46:28FENTANYL AND FINALLY WE'VE
- 46:29REACHED THE RIGHT RESULT.
- 46:31FENTANYL IS DIFFERENT IN KIND
- 46:33IT'S DIFFERENT ACROSS THE BOARD
- 46:34IT IS NOT COCAINE OR METH OR
- 46:36HEROIN WHERE IT HURTS THE USER.
- 46:39FENTANYL KILLS COPS WHEN THEY
- 46:40TOUCH IT.
- 46:42FENTANYL KILLS KID.
- 46:45FENTANYL IS DIFFERENT IN KIND.
- 46:46THIS IS THE RIGHT RESULT.
- 46:51AND MY FRIEND WAS TALKING ABOUT
- 46:55WHEN HE WAS YOUNGER AND I'M
- 46:56PROUD OF HIM OVERCOMING HIS
- 47:00SUBSTANCE ABUSE PROBLEMS.
- 47:01HE IS A LOCK TIME FRIEND BOUGHT
- 47:04THIS WASN'T THE SAME.
- 47:04THESE WEREN'T THE DRUGS THAT
- 47:06WERE AROUND WHEN WE WERE
- 47:08YOUNGER.
- 47:09AS YOU KNOW.
- 47:10I'M NOT PREACHING TO YOU YOU
- 47:11KNOW THIS.
- 47:12THIS IS DIFFERENT IN KIND.
- 47:14SO IT NEEDS TO BE TREATED
- 47:16DIFFERENTLY IN KIND.
- 47:16>> I WILL DISAGREE IN A SENSE
- 47:18THAT AS I SAID AT THE TESTIMONY
- 47:20WE ARE IN THE AGE OF SYNTHETIC
- 47:23OPIOIDS.
- 47:23THIS IS JUST THE WAY IT'S GOING
- 47:24TO BE GOING THERE.
- 47:26AND A FOCUS JUST ON THE
- 47:29SUBSTANCE DOESN'T FIX IT.
- 47:31WE NEED TO FOCUS ON TREATMENT.
- 47:34I THINK AS KY POLICY FOLKS HAVE
- 47:38SAID WE KEEP PASSING LAWS AFTER
- 47:40LAWS AFTER LAWS IN THE LAST
- 47:43DECADE FROM 2011-2001 --
- 47:512021.
- 47:52INCARCERATION AND THE PENALTIES
- 47:53DON'T WORK IF WE'RE TALKING
- 47:55ABOUT THE SAFER KENTUCKY ACT AND
- 47:57MAKE US SAFE AND INCREASING
- 47:59PENALTIES.
- 48:00THAT'S FAILED POLICIES.
- 48:02>> Renee: SO GO AHEAD Mr.
- 48:03STRAW.
- 48:03>> I WAS GOING TO SAY, I
- 48:06COULDN'T HAVE SAID IT BETTER
- 48:07THAN REPRESENTATIVE NEMES ON THE
- 48:09FENTANYL ISSUE.
- 48:10I THINK THAT THERE IS AN
- 48:14ARGUMENT IN LOOKING ON SOCIAL
- 48:16MEDIA OR READING THE STORIES
- 48:19ABOUT SAFER KENTUCKY IT'S FOP OR
- 48:21LAW ENFORCEMENT WE DON'T SHOW
- 48:24COMPASSION IN THE MOMENTS AND
- 48:25THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR US TO
- 48:27BE COMPASSIONATE AND SAY WE
- 48:29UNDERSTAND THE COMMUNITY WE ARE
- 48:29DEALING WITH.
- 48:30I THINK WE ARE BEING
- 48:32COMPASSIONATE AND SAYING LOOK WE
- 48:33WANT TO GET YOU THE HELP BUT
- 48:35THIS STUFF IS SO DANGEROUS YOU
- 48:37ARE ASKING US TO BE
- 48:39COMPASSIONATE ABOUT SOMETHING
- 48:40THAT COULD KILL US BY JUST GOING
- 48:42TO A AGAIN, NO CALL IS GENERIC
- 48:45BUT TO ANY CALL THAT HAS FENNAL
- 48:47INVOLVED IN IT YOU ARE ASKING US
- 48:49TO WALK IN THAT ROOM, AND PUT
- 48:51OUR LIFE AT STAKE TO HELP
- 48:53SOMEONE THAT WE WANT TO HELP BUT
- 48:56WE CAN'T.
- 48:57YOU'RE ASKING US TO BE
- 48:59COMPASSIONATE IT'S DIFFICULT
- 48:59WHEN YOU ARE ASKING US TO HARM
- 49:01OURSELVES TO GET TO YOU.
- 49:03>> Renee: GOING BACK TO THE
- 49:05HOMELESS PROVISIONS THIS
- 49:05QUESTION FROM A VIEWER WHAT
- 49:07HAPPENS AFTER AN INDIVIDUAL
- 49:09COMPLETES MANDATED TREATMENT AND
- 49:10THEN THEY RETURN TO
- 49:12HOMELESSNESS?
- 49:13>> IT'S IT WILL DEPEND ON THAT
- 49:17PERSON.
- 49:17ARE THEY LUCKY ENOUGH TO GET
- 49:20INTO HOUSING?
- 49:20TO HAVE A SUPPORT STRUCTURE THAT
- 49:22IS GOING TO THEN THEM IN THEIR
- 49:24JOURNEY TO RECOVERY?
- 49:25TREATMENT IS A GREAT CLINICAL
- 49:27SPACE TO ACHIEVE SO BRIGHT AND
- 49:31DETOX.
- 49:31WHAT WE LACK IN KENTUCKY IS THAT
- 49:33CONTINUUM OF SERVICES AND OF
- 49:35HOUSING AND SUPPORTS THAT ARE
- 49:36GOING TO ADDRESS ALL THE OTHER
- 49:38SOCIAL ISSUES AND SPIRITUAL
- 49:40ISSUES PEOPLE NEED.
- 49:41SO I MEAN, HAVING TREATMENT BEDS
- 49:43IS GREAT BUT WE NEED A LONG-TERM
- 49:47CONTINUUM OF CARE THAT IS GOING
- 49:49TO LIKE SOLIDIFY PEOPLE INTO
- 49:51THAT.
- 49:51>> AND GEORGE IS RIGHT ON THAT.
- 49:54100%.
- 49:55THERE'S NO AIR BETWEEN US.
- 49:56THAT IS ONE OF THE WORST THINGS
- 49:58WE HAVE ACROSS THE BOARD EVERY
- 50:00STATE AND KENTUCKY WE KNOW THAT
- 50:02SUBSTANCE ABUSERS THEY ARE NOT
- 50:04SAVED THE FIRST TIME.
- 50:08THEY RELAPSE.
- 50:08I HAVE A CLOSE FAMILY MEMBER
- 50:10THAT I WORRY ABOUT ALL THE TIME
- 50:11BECAUSE SHE CONTINUES TO LAPSE
- 50:13AND TWO YEARS SHE WAS CLEAN AND
- 50:15LAPSED AGAIN AND THAT HURTS HER
- 50:17KIDS SO IT IS DEVASTATING.
- 50:20WE'RE ALSO TRYING TO DO OTHER
- 50:21THINGS.
- 50:22REPRESENTATIVE HERRON IS WORKING
- 50:23WITH CALLAWAY ON HOUSE BILL 124,
- 50:26WHICH SAYS LET'S REMOVE BARRIERS
- 50:28LICENSING BARRIERS POUR PEOPLE
- 50:29WHO HAVE BEEN CONVICTED OF
- 50:31FELONIES TO GET INTO THE
- 50:33WORKPLACE.
- 50:33THIS IS NOT THE ONLY BILL.
- 50:35WE'RE TRYING TO LEAD WITH A BIG
- 50:37HEART AND HELP OUR PEOPLE OUR
- 50:40BROTHERS AND SISTERS OUR KIDS
- 50:41AND COUSINS AND FAMILY MEMBERS
- 50:44AND NEIGHBORS.
- 50:45AND ALSO I CAN'T SHORT SKWIFT
- 50:49THIS IF MY FAMILY DOES SOMETHING
- 50:52A NUMBER OF TIMES AND WON'T DO
- 50:54RIGHT THEY NEED TO BE
- 50:56INCARCERATED WE ARE DOING BOTH
- 50:58AND NOT EITHER OR.
- 50:59>> I FEEL LIKE WE'RE CREATING A
- 51:01SYSTEM WHERE ALL WE'RE DOING IS
- 51:03CREATING MORE STICKS AND PEOPLE
- 51:06SLEEPING, HOMELESS IN AND OUT OF
- 51:08SHELTER ALL THEY SEE IS STICKS.
- 51:10KY STAY OUTSIDE I GET RAINED ON
- 51:12AND HARASSED BY PEOPLE AND I GO
- 51:15TO THE SHELTER I CANNOT BE WITH
- 51:17MY DOG AND MY STUFF.
- 51:19AND I GOT WOKEN UP AT SICK AM
- 51:22AND GET KICKED OUT.
- 51:23>> HOUSE BILL IS NOT A STICK
- 51:28IMPROVING IMPROVING [INAUDIBLE]
- 51:30THOSE ARE CARROTS AND THAT IS A
- 51:32HEART.
- 51:32I DON'T THINK IT'S FAIR TO SAY
- 51:34ALL WE'RE DOING AS STICKS.
- 51:36AS GOVERNOR BESHEAR SAID IN THE
- 51:37STATE OF THE COMMONWEALTH HE
- 51:39SAID HE IS PROUD OF IT AND I'M
- 51:41PROUD OF IT ALSO WE HAVE MORE
- 51:43TREATMENT BEDS IN KENTUCKY PER
- 51:48CAPITA THAN ANY STATE IN THE
- 51:49COMMONWEALTH AND I'M DAMNED
- 51:50PROUD OF IT.
- 51:51>> NOT ALL BEDS ARE ACCESSIBLE.
- 51:53>> SO THIS FROM A PERSON WITH
- 51:56LIVED EXPERIENCE, SABBY
- 51:58JEFFERSON CON TU AS I AM A
- 52:00PERSON OF LIVED EXPERIENCE
- 52:01HAVING BEEN IN JAIL AND WORKING
- 52:03WITH OTHERS WHO HAVE.
- 52:04THE PROGRAMS IN THE FACILITIES
- 52:05DON'T WORK.
- 52:06WILL YOU BE DESIGNING REALISTIC
- 52:09PROGRAMS WITH PEOPLE WHO ALSO
- 52:10HAVE LIVED EXPERIENCES AND CAN
- 52:12SHARE THEIR EXPERIENCE WITH
- 52:13THOSE WHO ARE COMING OUT OF
- 52:15PRISON?
- 52:16>> YES, I THINK THAT IS A GREAT
- 52:17QUESTION AND SOMETHING WE WANT
- 52:19TO DO THAT IS WHY WE WANT TO
- 52:21EVALUATE THE PROGRAMS FOR
- 52:23REENTRY SO WE CAN FUND AND
- 52:24INVEST WHERE THE JUICES WORK THE
- 52:27SQUEEZE.
- 52:28BUT ALSO I THINK THERE IS
- 52:29PERHAPS AN OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN
- 52:31FROM THOSE LIVED EXPERIENCES AND
- 52:34MAYBE GET SOME NONPROFIT OR
- 52:35PRIVATE SECTOR FOLKS INVOLVED AS
- 52:37WELL AND EXPLORE WHAT THAT MIGHT
- 52:39LOOK LIKE MOVING FORWARD.
- 52:41>> PEOPLE WHO ARE CLOSEST TO THE
- 52:44PROBLEM ARE CLOSEST TO THE
- 52:45SOLUTION.
- 52:46AND I WONDER IF ANYONE IN THE
- 52:49ROOM WHEN HB5 WAS WRITTEN HAD
- 52:51SLEPT ON THE STREET OR TAKEN A
- 52:54DRUG.
- 52:54>> Renee: DID YOU CONSULT WITH
- 52:55THOSE WHO LIVED ON THE STREETS?
- 52:57>> WE CERTAINLY HAVE.
- 52:59I'VE NEVER SLEPT ON THE STREET
- 53:01AND TAKEN A DRUG OTHER THAN
- 53:03BOURBON I'M NOT MAKING LIGHT OF
- 53:05THE SUBJECT.
- 53:05I HAVE FAMILY MEMBERS THE
- 53:07CLOSEST PEOPLE IN THIS.
- 53:08AND I KNOW A LOT OF US DO.
- 53:10AND YES, WE DID.
- 53:11WE REACHED OUT TO THEM AND ASKED
- 53:13WHAT THEY WANTED.
- 53:14WE ALSO REACHED OUT TO VICTIMS'
- 53:16FAMILIES.
- 53:18WE PASS ADD BILL THROUGH THE
- 53:19HOUSE THAT SAID THAT WE CAN'T
- 53:21HAVE CORPORATIONS BAILING PEOPLE
- 53:23OUT AND IT DIDN'T PASS THE
- 53:25SENATE.
- 53:26IT HAD PASSED THE SENATE THERE
- 53:27WOULD BE A NUMBER PEOPLE
- 53:28INCLUDING A MAN JAKE, A
- 53:3110-YEAR-OLD, WHO WOULD STILL BE
- 53:32LIVING TODAY.
- 53:33WE HAVE TO THINK OF THEM ALSO.
- 53:35WE CAN'T JUST THROW BIG NUMBERS
- 53:37AROUND AND TALK ABOUT WE HAVE TO
- 53:38TALK ABOUT WHO IS HARMED.
- 53:40THERE ARE REAL PEOPLE WHO ARE
- 53:41HARMED WHEN WE DON'T DO WHAT WE
- 53:44NEED TO DO KEEPING KENTUCKIANS
- 53:46SAFE.
- 53:47MADELINE TROUT DIED.
- 53:49JAKE DIED.
- 53:50WE ARE TRYING AND THERE ARE
- 53:52PROVISIONS IN THE BILL TO
- 53:54ADDRESS THE HORRIFIC SITUATIONS
- 53:55THAT OCCURRED TO THEM.
- 53:57>> Renee: WE SAW THE BRAVE
- 53:58FAMILIES TESTIFY LAST THURSDAY.
- 54:01LAST POINT WE WILL BE ABLE TO
- 54:03MAKE TONIGHT A COMMENT FROM A
- 54:04YOU VOOER FROM GREENVILLE
- 54:07RESEARCH SHOWS FUNDING PUBLIC
- 54:08EDUCATION IS KEY TO CRIME
- 54:11REDUCTION WHY ARE WE NOT
- 54:12EXPLORING THE ONION?
- 54:14>> WE ARE FUNDING EDUCATION MORE
- 54:18THAN WE HAVE WHEN YOU LOOK AT
- 54:19THE PENSION FUNDING.
- 54:22WE'RE FAR OUTSTRIPPING INFLATION
- 54:25FROM THE 2008 NUMBERS THE
- 54:26NUMBERS OUR FRIENDS ALWAYS PICK
- 54:29THE 2008 BECAUSE THAT WAS THE
- 54:31HIGH-WATER MARK.
- 54:31WE ARE OUTSTRIPPING THAT.
- 54:33WE ARE FUNDING EDUCATION AND I
- 54:35THINK THIS BILL THAT
- 54:37REPRESENTATIVE PETRI OUR
- 54:38CHAIRMAN PUT TOGETHER IN OUR
- 54:39BUDGET IS GOING TO BE THE BEST
- 54:41FUNDED EDUCATION BUDGET IN THE
- 54:43HISTORY OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF
- 54:44KENTUCKY.
- 54:44>> AND I WILL SAY THIS, TOO, I
- 54:47STARTED THE PROGRAM TALKING
- 54:49ABOUT THE KENTUCKY ECONOMY AND
- 54:51THE RESEARCH THAT I HAVE STUDIED
- 54:54DRAWS A DIRECT CORRELATION
- 54:56BETWEEN CRIME IN YOUR COMMUNITY
- 54:58AND POOR PERFORMANCE IN THE
- 55:01CLASSROOM.
- 55:01SO, AGAIN, THERE IS A DIRECT
- 55:04CONNECTION BETWEEN CRIME IN THE
- 55:05STATE OF THE KENTUCKY AND POOR
- 55:08EDUCATION PERFORMANCE.
- 55:09SO THIS BILL COULD ALSO HELP
- 55:12WITH EDUCATION PERFORMANCE AND
- 55:13CLASSROOMS ACROSS THE STATES.
- 55:15>> I ALSO THINK IF YOU ARE GOING
- 55:17TO TALK ABOUT THAT YOU NEED TO
- 55:19TALK ABOUT ECONOMIC STABILITY,
- 55:21ACCESS TO FOOD, WHAT PEOPLE'S
- 55:24ENVIRONMENTS ARE, IT'S MORE.
- 55:26AND IT IS ROOT CAUSES OF WHAT WE
- 55:28NEED TO GET INTO.
- 55:29I'M GLAD THAT YOU TALKED ABOUT
- 55:31THAT.
- 55:31AND THIS PIECE OF POLICY, DOES
- 55:33NOT ADDRESS THOSE ROOT CAUSES.
- 55:35AT ALL.
- 55:36BUT YOU ARE EXACTLY RIGHT.
- 55:38ACCESS TO FOOD.
- 55:40HOUSING.
- 55:42EDUCATION.
- 55:42ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT.
- 55:43THOSE ARE THE THINGS THAT WE
- 55:44NEED TO BE DOING AS LEGISLATORS
- 55:46AND THOSE ARE THE THINGS THAT
- 55:49KENTUCKIANS WANT US TO DO.
- 55:49>> Renee: WE HAVE TO LEAVE IT
- 55:50THERE.
- 55:51WE HAVE TO LEAVE IT THERE I'M
- 55:52SORRY.
- 55:54WE COULD GO ON AND ON MAYBE WE
- 55:56WILL HAVE A PART TWO BECAUSE WE
- 55:58DIDN'T GET TO SEVERAL OF THE
- 55:59PROVISIONS.
- 56:00CHARITABLE BAIL AND OTHER
- 56:02THINGS.
- 56:02WE'LL SAVE THAT FOR ANOTHER
- 56:05SHOW.
- 56:06WE HOPE YOU'VE LEARNED AND GOT
- 56:08SOMETHING OUT OF IT AS WELL.
- 56:09MONDAY WE PLAN ON TALKING ABOUT
- 56:10THE DEBATE OVER DIVERSITY,
- 56:12EQUITY AND INCLUSION DEI IN
- 56:14EDUCATION.
- 56:15JOIN US FOR THAT MONDAY NIGHT AT
- 56:178:00 P.M.
- 56:18EACH WEEKNIGHT 6:30, 5:30
- 56:21CENTRAL IS KENTUCKY EDITION WHEN
- 56:22WE FOLLOW WHAT IS HAPPENING IN
- 56:23YOUR STATE GOVERNMENT AND
- 56:25FRANKFORT.
- 56:26THANK YOU SO MUCH.
- 56:27HAVE A GREAT NIGHT I'M RENEE
- 56:28SHAW AND I'LL SEE YOU TOMORROW
- 56:30NIGHT FOR KENTUCKY EDITION.