Latest / Bloomberg Law / Can Former Child Slaves Sue Chocolate Companies?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grasso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:06Speaker 1: The legal question before the Supreme Court was fairly prosaic.
- 0:10Speaker 1: Could a US corporation be sued by foreigners under a
- 0:13Speaker 1: centuries old law for aiding and abetting actions overseas? But
- 0:17Speaker 1: the facts of the case were extraordinary and horrifying. A
- 0:21Speaker 1: suit by six former child slaves who were kidnapped from
- 0:25Speaker 1: their native molly and forced to work fourteen hour days
- 0:28Speaker 1: on Coco farms on the Ivory Coast, where they say
- 0:31Speaker 1: they were starved, beaten, and tortured. Their suit against Nestley's
- 0:35Speaker 1: and Cargo accuses the Chalka companies of complicity and their
- 0:39Speaker 1: enslavement by giving the farmer's financial assistance to maintain a
- 0:43Speaker 1: supply of cheap coco. Nestle's lawyer, Neil Cartial faced some
- 0:47Speaker 1: tough questions here are Justices Sonya Sotomayor and Samuel Alito
- 0:52Speaker 1: set aside for me, why you think international law there's
- 0:56Speaker 1: not an international law against stating and abetting something as
- 1:00Speaker 1: heenious as child slavery. Mr. Many of your arguments leed
- 1:07Speaker 1: results that are pretty hard to take. And josh is
- 1:10Speaker 1: Elena Kagan grilled Kantiale about his theory that no corporation
- 1:15Speaker 1: can be sued under the Alien Towards Statute because this
- 1:19Speaker 1: same former child slave and the same circumstances bring a
- 1:23Speaker 1: suit against ten slaveholders. Uh, you know, if they if
- 1:27Speaker 1: they had met that you know, the requirements under the law. Yeah, yeah, sure,
- 1:31Speaker 1: I mean, if they was, you could bring a suit
- 1:34Speaker 1: against ten slaveholders. When those ten slaveholders form a corporation,
- 1:39Speaker 1: Why can't you bring a suit against the corporation? Joining me?
- 1:42Speaker 1: Is Harold crant To, professor at the Chicago Kent College
- 1:44Speaker 1: of Law. How the Alien Towards Statute was a favorite
- 1:48Speaker 1: tool of human rights advocates to sue for overseas atrocities
- 1:52Speaker 1: until the Roberts Court started scaling it back. What's left
- 1:56Speaker 1: of it, it's unclear. What court has said is that
- 2:00Speaker 1: if there is a action that's closely tied to the
- 2:03Speaker 1: United States that violates all international decency, then at least
- 2:08Speaker 1: an individual who has committed that claim, whether it's piracy
- 2:13Speaker 1: or slavery or assassination, may be hauled into court in
- 2:18Speaker 1: the United States. Two second guests that behavior. But what
- 2:21Speaker 1: has been surprising is that the Court has suggested that
- 2:24Speaker 1: this Alien Towards Statute has to have a close connection
- 2:28Speaker 1: to the United States, and that's not at all what
- 2:32Speaker 1: it seems like on's face. And that's not what it
- 2:35Speaker 1: seems like if you look at the scamp historical precedents
- 2:38Speaker 1: that exist. So this is really a retooling of the
- 2:41Speaker 1: statute to use as a safety valve for when the
- 2:45Speaker 1: US individual has created some kind of atrocities abroad. So
- 2:50Speaker 1: how has the Supreme Court treated corporations under the statute?
- 2:55Speaker 1: There recently has cut back the scope of the Alien
- 2:58Speaker 1: Towards Statute I wouling that foreign corporation could not be sued.
- 3:03Speaker 1: The case arose because of a challenge to a Jordanian bank,
- 3:07Speaker 1: which allegedly had given funds to Palestinian terrorists which injured
- 3:12Speaker 1: U S citizens there. The Court said that foreign corporations
- 3:15Speaker 1: cannot be held in as defendants for a couple of reasons.
- 3:18Speaker 1: One is because of the history that most criminal statutes
- 3:21Speaker 1: and treaties against torture have focused on individuals as opposed
- 3:26Speaker 1: to corporations, and also because of the fear of entangling
- 3:28Speaker 1: the US in some kind of disputes with foreign governments
- 3:32Speaker 1: to extent that foreign corporations can be sued here. So
- 3:35Speaker 1: one of the issues in the case involving Nestle's is
- 3:38Speaker 1: whether domestic corporations such as ness, Leg and Cargill can
- 3:42Speaker 1: be sued under the Alien Toward Statute, and the answer
- 3:46Speaker 1: is unclear. Nestle's lawyer wanted the justices to give US
- 3:50Speaker 1: corporations a shield against lawsuits under the Alien Towards Statute.
- 3:56Speaker 1: That's a big ask, isn't it. Yeah, So there are
- 3:58Speaker 1: really three that of arguments that are played for the
- 4:02Speaker 1: Supreme Court. The one that we've been discussing is whether
- 4:05Speaker 1: any corporation can be sued under the Dealing and Towards
- 4:09Speaker 1: Statute at all. And obviously corporations can violate the Wall
- 4:13Speaker 1: of Nations just as much as individuals can. So there
- 4:16Speaker 1: is a definite issue with respect to the scope of
- 4:19Speaker 1: the Alien Toward Statue and that respect. Another one is
- 4:22Speaker 1: what kind of connection the conduct has to have to
- 4:25Speaker 1: the United States, Because what nestlely has argued here is
- 4:29Speaker 1: that you know, if there's enslavement, if there's forced labor
- 4:32Speaker 1: that's taking place in Ivory Coast, it's not taking place
- 4:36Speaker 1: in the United States. And so they're refashioning the Alien
- 4:39Speaker 1: Towards Statute to really focus on conduct that's more directly
- 4:44Speaker 1: committed by United States citizens and that doesn't seem to
- 4:49Speaker 1: resonate with the language of the Alien Toward Statute at all.
- 4:53Speaker 1: And of course, the Planets in the case they look
- 4:55Speaker 1: Nestles and Cargill approved of the conduct aided and embedded
- 5:00Speaker 1: the United States shores because they're housed here, and so
- 5:03Speaker 1: therefore they should be subject to the Alien Towards Statute.
- 5:06Speaker 1: There is the one that I think is where the
- 5:08Speaker 1: Supreme Court might go. The question is what kind of
- 5:11Speaker 1: conduct or torch is against the law of nations. Clearly
- 5:15Speaker 1: slavery is clearly aiding an abetting slavery substantially is. But
- 5:20Speaker 1: what the Planets have not done is to show what
- 5:23Speaker 1: kind of men's drea or mindset is required before someone
- 5:29Speaker 1: can said to have violated the law of nations with
- 5:31Speaker 1: respective slavery. Is it that nest Lee's was negligent? Is
- 5:35Speaker 1: the question that whether Nestles was willfully blind or did
- 5:39Speaker 1: nesting actually have to know that it was purchasing chocolate
- 5:44Speaker 1: because of the fruits of child labor. The Planets have
- 5:47Speaker 1: not been very careful to ascertain what actually the accusations
- 5:52Speaker 1: are in the case. And it may be that the
- 5:54Speaker 1: Court hasn't out here by holding that yes, slaveries against
- 5:58Speaker 1: the law of nations, and yes, even aiding and abetting
- 6:00Speaker 1: slaveries against law nations, but at a minimum, the allegations
- 6:05Speaker 1: must include some evidence of complicity in terms of knowledge
- 6:09Speaker 1: that the child labor or slavery was going on, and
- 6:14Speaker 1: the plans have been pretty quiet with respect to that
- 6:16Speaker 1: kind of evidence. This Court has given corporations the rights
- 6:20Speaker 1: of individuals, So why wouldn't you be able to sue
- 6:23Speaker 1: a corporation if you can sue an individual. Well, there's
- 6:26Speaker 1: no textual basis for that distinction. However, corporations are not
- 6:29Speaker 1: recognized in terms as political actors or as legal actors
- 6:33Speaker 1: back in seventeen eighty nine when the statute was created,
- 6:36Speaker 1: so there is some kind of reason to be historically
- 6:39Speaker 1: skeptical whether Congress intended to include corporations. And it's also
- 6:44Speaker 1: true that in terms of modern international criminal tribunals, corporations
- 6:49Speaker 1: largely have been excluded. So the argument is both there's
- 6:53Speaker 1: a little bit of history and a little bit of
- 6:56Speaker 1: modern international custom which suggests that individuals should be treated
- 7:01Speaker 1: differently than corporations. Of course, from the perspective of harm,
- 7:05Speaker 1: there is no difference whatsoever whether a corporation slaves an
- 7:09Speaker 1: individual as opposed to another individual. And some of the
- 7:13Speaker 1: conservative justices even seem reluctant to completely exempt US companies.
- 7:20Speaker 1: I mean the court could go there. I would be
- 7:22Speaker 1: surprised if the Court took the ask from the US
- 7:25Speaker 1: Department of Justice, which supported net Place in this regard.
- 7:28Speaker 1: There has been a lot of concern about corporations doing
- 7:32Speaker 1: business with suppliers who are not comporting with international standards
- 7:37Speaker 1: for human rights, and the question here was one of
- 7:41Speaker 1: aiding and abetting, and Justice Brier worried about setting a
- 7:45Speaker 1: worldwide precedent by concluding that international law covers aiding and abetting.
- 7:52Speaker 1: So reason in abomination, and we all have consensus international
- 7:56Speaker 1: law condemned slavery. But as you go down the chain
- 8:00Speaker 1: of actors, it becomes more and more remote. So if
- 8:04Speaker 1: someone suspects that the product has been made in part
- 8:08Speaker 1: due to enslaved labor, are they also complicit? And they're
- 8:13Speaker 1: complicit in some moral sense, But are they complicit in
- 8:16Speaker 1: the sense of violating an international norm? If they just
- 8:20Speaker 1: have reason to believe that some of the chocolate they're
- 8:23Speaker 1: using was formed with the benefit of forced labor. What
- 8:28Speaker 1: if they're as the shipping company who just helps shift
- 8:32Speaker 1: that chocolate, maybe they know as well that some of
- 8:35Speaker 1: the chocolate was fond with the help of forced labor,
- 8:38Speaker 1: and they're just collecting normal charges. Are they also aiding
- 8:41Speaker 1: in the betting because they're shipping the chocolate? So as
- 8:43Speaker 1: you go down the line of production, the question is
- 8:47Speaker 1: it really fair to say that everybody who may be
- 8:50Speaker 1: morally responsible for having some basis of knowledge of this
- 8:54Speaker 1: forced labor really violated an international standard. It's sort of
- 8:59Speaker 1: rare or of international standards of misconduct because of that knowledge.
- 9:05Speaker 1: Overhanging this whole argument is that there's a lot of
- 9:10Speaker 1: evidence that the world's chocolate supply depends heavily on child labor.
- 9:16Speaker 1: So is it in the back of some of the
- 9:18Speaker 1: justice minds how it will look if they come out
- 9:21Speaker 1: with a decision that lets the chocolate companies off the hook. Well,
- 9:24Speaker 1: I think the issue cuts both ways in the sense
- 9:28Speaker 1: of the sort of understanding that there has been child
- 9:31Speaker 1: labor involved in the chocolate industry, because there have been
- 9:35Speaker 1: diplomatic channel and diplomatic overtures to try to limit the
- 9:40Speaker 1: use of forced labor in the production of coco. And
- 9:44Speaker 1: so some justices may say that recognizing this kind of
- 9:48Speaker 1: aiding and abetting cause of action may undermine those diplomatic aperature,
- 9:52Speaker 1: maybe even kind of productive. So on the one hand,
- 9:56Speaker 1: as you say that, the court may be wary of
- 9:59Speaker 1: trying to turn its back on very serious allegations of misconduct.
- 10:04Speaker 1: On the other hand, there has been a recognition that
- 10:06Speaker 1: this has been the systemic problem in the chocolate industry,
- 10:09Speaker 1: and there have been diplomatic missions and efforts to try
- 10:12Speaker 1: to limit it, so that the Court might be on
- 10:15Speaker 1: safe ground, and saying that recognizing a cause of action
- 10:18Speaker 1: here might undermine the diplomacy. The Chief Justice did say
- 10:22Speaker 1: that unlike previous cases involving non US corporations, no foreign
- 10:28Speaker 1: government had interfered here, No foreign government had objected here.
- 10:32Speaker 1: So something he's thinking about. Yeah, no, and it's true.
- 10:35Speaker 1: I mean, one of the ticklish parts about allowing any
- 10:38Speaker 1: kind of these international suits to be broad and United
- 10:41Speaker 1: States is the interruption of foreign affairs. But in this case,
- 10:45Speaker 1: as the Chief Justice pointed out, there has been no
- 10:48Speaker 1: sign that Ivory Coast or Molly is worried about this lawsuit.
- 10:53Speaker 1: In fact, they may favor the lawsuit continuing on its
- 10:56Speaker 1: merry way because of the injustices that have arisen. In
- 11:01Speaker 1: another context, the lawsuit can have foreign affairs repercussions, and
- 11:04Speaker 1: that's what the Department of Justice argued in papers to
- 11:08Speaker 1: the court, suggesting that the court goes very slow and
- 11:11Speaker 1: recognizing these cause of actions because according to the Department Justice,
- 11:15Speaker 1: one never knows when these private lawsuits will disrupt foreign relations.
- 11:20Speaker 1: And the third argument about mens rea, how does that
- 11:23Speaker 1: come out? In my view, I think that the pointests
- 11:26Speaker 1: are on shaky ground here because they've never stated what
- 11:30Speaker 1: is the sort of relevant mendrea with respect to nestleties.
- 11:34Speaker 1: Do nestties know that there was slavery? Did they just
- 11:37Speaker 1: turn the up blind eye to what was going on?
- 11:40Speaker 1: Where they just negligent in not asking the right questions?
- 11:43Speaker 1: And this does not suggest that rest they should be
- 11:45Speaker 1: off the hook in some moral sense. But if you
- 11:48Speaker 1: recognize just a few acts of terror that shock the conscience,
- 11:53Speaker 1: you know, piracy, murder, rape, interference with safe conduct, turning
- 11:58Speaker 1: a blind eye or or not asking the right questions
- 12:02Speaker 1: may not fall within that small category of conduct which
- 12:06Speaker 1: is reprehensible. By all civilized nation. Final question, how, how
- 12:10Speaker 1: do you think that justices will rule? So there has
- 12:13Speaker 1: been a trend about cutting down the Alien Towards statue
- 12:16Speaker 1: to an infinitesimal size, much smaller than that contemplated by
- 12:21Speaker 1: the first Congress that enacted the Alien Towards Statute, and
- 12:24Speaker 1: I predict that the Supreme Court will continue down that
- 12:27Speaker 1: path and limit the Alien Towards Statue to only a
- 12:30Speaker 1: very small number of possible cases. I don't think that
- 12:34Speaker 1: they will say that a corporation can never be a defendant,
- 12:37Speaker 1: but I do think that they will say that this
- 12:39Speaker 1: is the type of claim, this kind of negligent aiding
- 12:42Speaker 1: and abetting, which would not fall within that small number
- 12:45Speaker 1: of cases which can be cognizable under the Alien Towards Statute.
- 12:50Speaker 1: Thanks how that's Harold Grant, professor at the Chicago Kent
- 12:53Speaker 1: College of Law. Non Citizens have been counted in every
- 12:57Speaker 1: census since the first one in seven team, but President
- 13:01Speaker 1: Trump wants to do something no president has ever done
- 13:05Speaker 1: before exclude undocumented immigrants from the census count and the
- 13:10Speaker 1: Supreme Court heard arguments this week on the Trump administration's
- 13:13Speaker 1: plans for the census for the second time in two years.
- 13:17Speaker 1: Several of the justices were skeptical that Trump could exclude
- 13:21Speaker 1: illegal immigrants from the count, with Justice Stephen Bryer summing
- 13:25Speaker 1: up the reasons, and Justice Amy Coney Barrett agreeing. And
- 13:29Speaker 1: it says persons, this started in eighteen twenty, you know,
- 13:32Speaker 1: and they've always counted uh, people who were here and
- 13:35Speaker 1: not naturalized. And this has never happened before that you
- 13:39Speaker 1: included the illegal aliens. And it has a lot of
- 13:41Speaker 1: negative effects on the state. You know. All those arguments, uh,
- 13:44Speaker 1: and they're I think they're fairly strong ones. Justice me,
- 13:48Speaker 1: what do you what do you want to say their persons?
- 13:50Speaker 1: Aren't they? But if if an undocumented person has been
- 13:55Speaker 1: in the country for say twenty years, you know, even
- 13:58Speaker 1: if illegally, as you say, why would some person not
- 14:02Speaker 1: have such a person not have a settled residence here?
- 14:04Speaker 1: Some of the gealice is acknowledged the practical problem here.
- 14:08Speaker 1: The administration has no plan for identifying the illegal immigrants
- 14:12Speaker 1: it wants to exclude something. Justice Samuel Alito question Deputy
- 14:17Speaker 1: Solicitor General Jeffrey wall about can you're not provide us
- 14:20Speaker 1: with any more information than what you provided in your
- 14:23Speaker 1: answer to the Chief Justice was that basically they're working
- 14:28Speaker 1: on it. I can provide you with a little bit more.
- 14:31Speaker 1: I don't know how satisfying it will be, but I
- 14:35Speaker 1: think it is very unlikely that the Bureau will be
- 14:37Speaker 1: able to identify all or substantially all illegal aliens president
- 14:42Speaker 1: in the country, So anything like the ten or eleven
- 14:44Speaker 1: or twelve million numbers that are flying around. The administration
- 14:48Speaker 1: is in a race to finish the count and submit
- 14:50Speaker 1: the report to Congress before Joe Biden takes over the presidency,
- 14:54Speaker 1: and many gealices, including Chief Justice John Roberts, suggested the
- 14:59Speaker 1: Court might take a wait and see attitude right now
- 15:02Speaker 1: is the questions have shown. We don't know what the
- 15:04Speaker 1: Secretary is going to do. We don't know what the
- 15:06Speaker 1: President is going to do. We don't know how many
- 15:08Speaker 1: aliens will be excluded. We don't know what the effect
- 15:11Speaker 1: of that will be an apportionment um, all these questions
- 15:15Speaker 1: would be resolved if we wait until the apportionment takes place.
- 15:20Speaker 1: Joining me is Leon Fresco a partnered Holland and Knight.
- 15:23Speaker 1: Leon was there one overwriting focus of the justices questions? Well,
- 15:29Speaker 1: there are two overwriting focuses of their questions. One is
- 15:34Speaker 1: why did they need to decide the case today? And
- 15:37Speaker 1: I think there was a spoken issue and an unspoken issue.
- 15:41Speaker 1: The spoken issue was, until the Trump administration actually determined
- 15:46Speaker 1: which categories of undocumented people it wasn't going to count,
- 15:51Speaker 1: and then that analysis could be undertaken by the CORD,
- 15:55Speaker 1: it wouldn't be appropriate to actually decide this issue. But
- 15:59Speaker 1: the spoken issue was, well, maybe by the time we
- 16:03Speaker 1: get to all of this, Joe Biden will be president
- 16:07Speaker 1: and this case will just implode under itself and we
- 16:11Speaker 1: won't have to deal with this. And they didn't really
- 16:14Speaker 1: want to talk about the second because it's kind of
- 16:17Speaker 1: an unseemly thing for the Supreme Court to do. But
- 16:19Speaker 1: they were very much pushing on why they needed to
- 16:22Speaker 1: decide this case immediately. At one point, johns as Alito
- 16:26Speaker 1: talked about the fact that there could be ten and
- 16:28Speaker 1: a half a million illegal immigrants or there could be
- 16:32Speaker 1: sixty and he said he was frustrated with the posture
- 16:35Speaker 1: of the case. The problem in this case was that
- 16:39Speaker 1: the Trump administration has always does wanted to keep its
- 16:42Speaker 1: options open and has not wanted to block itself by
- 16:45Speaker 1: saying it was going to do one or another specific thing.
- 16:49Speaker 1: So what the Trump administration's demo says is it seeks
- 16:52Speaker 1: to exclude as many undocumented individuals as possible. So then
- 16:57Speaker 1: the Solicitor General was pressed by the core does that
- 17:00Speaker 1: mean DOCTA recipient? Does that mean everyone? Does that mean
- 17:04Speaker 1: only people in immigrating detention? Does that mean only people
- 17:08Speaker 1: with final orders of removal? Does that mean people with
- 17:12Speaker 1: criminal convictions or some amalgamation of people with criminal convictions
- 17:17Speaker 1: find out orders of removal and who are in immigrating detention.
- 17:21Speaker 1: And so that's why that number could be anywhere from
- 17:23Speaker 1: sixty thousands to eleven million. And so you had Justice
- 17:27Speaker 1: sort of mayor saying, look, we have to treat this
- 17:30Speaker 1: as it's eleven million, because that's what the memo says,
- 17:33Speaker 1: is we're going to try to exclude as many of
- 17:35Speaker 1: the eleven million as possible. And the a c l
- 17:38Speaker 1: U was arguing, it doesn't really matter what the number is,
- 17:41Speaker 1: because since the memo purports to want to exclude as
- 17:44Speaker 1: many undocumented individuals as possible, than any subset that you
- 17:49Speaker 1: take from that group, it's still a subset of an
- 17:52Speaker 1: illegal memo. Because the justices in general seem to agree
- 17:57Speaker 1: with the concept that you could be on document mented
- 18:00Speaker 1: in the United States and still be a resident for
- 18:02Speaker 1: the purposes of the census. Several of the justices talked
- 18:07Speaker 1: about the crunch of time here, just as Kagan said,
- 18:11Speaker 1: your thirty days out. Well, the entirety of this case
- 18:15Speaker 1: is based on the fact that there's currently an injunction
- 18:18Speaker 1: that is preventing the Trump administration from transmitting a number
- 18:24Speaker 1: of undocumented people that it seeks to exclude from the census.
- 18:28Speaker 1: So they would like to be out from under that injunction.
- 18:32Speaker 1: They in other words, they want to be able to
- 18:34Speaker 1: actually report a number of undocumented individuals and then have
- 18:39Speaker 1: a litigation about whether that number of undocumented individuals should
- 18:44Speaker 1: or shouldn't be counted in the census. That report was
- 18:48Speaker 1: originally supposed to be due by the end of this year,
- 18:51Speaker 1: and that was one of the first things that got
- 18:53Speaker 1: established was they're gonna miss their deadline. But there were
- 18:57Speaker 1: some beliefs that still they needed to get out a
- 19:00Speaker 1: under this injunction or they wouldn't be able to do
- 19:03Speaker 1: any of this process. And there was a lot of
- 19:05Speaker 1: frustration from all of the justices both with regard to
- 19:09Speaker 1: these timelines that with regard to the lack of sensificity
- 19:13Speaker 1: of who is going to be counted and for what purpose.
- 19:16Speaker 1: Leon the court is expediting this case, how fast do
- 19:20Speaker 1: you think they can get a decision out? So the
- 19:23Speaker 1: court doesn't actually need a lot of time to enter
- 19:26Speaker 1: its decision. The Court could literally enter a three line
- 19:29Speaker 1: decision today simply saying that the case is not right
- 19:33Speaker 1: for adjudication, and so break your case back again. Once
- 19:38Speaker 1: the apportionment is done. That could happen today. And if
- 19:41Speaker 1: that happened today, then the president can actually or the
- 19:45Speaker 1: administration can actually start preparing the number they want to
- 19:49Speaker 1: prepare of who's excluded from the census. So that could happen,
- 19:53Speaker 1: and in my view, that's actually the most likely event
- 19:57Speaker 1: to happen. Not so much again in I view, because
- 20:00Speaker 1: I think that's a satisfactory result, and the justices want
- 20:05Speaker 1: to not count undocument the people towards the census. But
- 20:09Speaker 1: really I think they're hopeful that if they can just
- 20:13Speaker 1: keep punting this case, it might go away and that
- 20:16Speaker 1: they won't actually have to grapple with the merits of
- 20:20Speaker 1: this case. We'll see if one of the I think
- 20:23Speaker 1: there are four justices for grappling with the merits of
- 20:26Speaker 1: the case. We'll see if one of the other justices
- 20:29Speaker 1: wants to come in and join Justice Roberts and the
- 20:32Speaker 1: three Liberals with grappling with the merits of this case.
- 20:36Speaker 1: But at the end of this day, I can foresee
- 20:40Speaker 1: some compromise occurring where the idea is come back when
- 20:45Speaker 1: a count is made, and when that count is made,
- 20:49Speaker 1: will will address, even when we have to address it,
- 20:53Speaker 1: whether that count should have excluded the people that are
- 20:55Speaker 1: being excluded. Justice any Tony Barrett said that illegal aliens
- 21:01Speaker 1: have never been excluded from the census, and then the
- 21:05Speaker 1: Acting Solicitor General said, well, that's the other side's best argument.
- 21:09Speaker 1: Does that indicate anything on her part? Well, absolutely, on
- 21:14Speaker 1: the merits of the argument, unless a very very small
- 21:19Speaker 1: number of people are going to be excluded who you
- 21:23Speaker 1: can say legitimately do not reside in the United States
- 21:27Speaker 1: because they literally have no address there in a detention facility,
- 21:32Speaker 1: and their schedules to be removed, so that that we're
- 21:35Speaker 1: talking about a few thousands people. Unless we're talking about that,
- 21:40Speaker 1: it's going to be almost impossible to get even this
- 21:43Speaker 1: court to rule that a person isn't a person, which
- 21:46Speaker 1: is what it would require for the purposes of the census.
- 21:49Speaker 1: If you're a person and you have an address in
- 21:52Speaker 1: the United States, you reside here in the United States
- 21:55Speaker 1: for the purposes of the census. And so the question
- 21:58Speaker 1: is the as the government really want to get to
- 22:02Speaker 1: the merits of this case, or are they just trying
- 22:04Speaker 1: to pump this issue to sort of give some faith
- 22:07Speaker 1: saving for this administration and then everybody can sort of
- 22:11Speaker 1: move on with this issue for a subsequent administration. And
- 22:15Speaker 1: I think that's what's going to be interesting in terms
- 22:17Speaker 1: of cobbling together a majority. Is are there five justices
- 22:23Speaker 1: that will just say, look, at the end of the day,
- 22:25Speaker 1: let's just punt this issue. And I think that's the
- 22:29Speaker 1: most likely scenario, But we'll have to wait and see
- 22:32Speaker 1: would they punt it because you know it's not right.
- 22:35Speaker 1: But there's also a standing question here. I I don't
- 22:38Speaker 1: think they're gonna say that there's a lack of standing
- 22:41Speaker 1: to bring this claim, but I do think what they'll
- 22:44Speaker 1: say is that until that there is a I mean,
- 22:48Speaker 1: it's kind of a saving claim because you haven't been
- 22:50Speaker 1: harmed yet, but it's more traditionally known as a rightness
- 22:54Speaker 1: claim in the sense that we won't know what state,
- 22:59Speaker 1: if any has long funding or apportionment until we have
- 23:04Speaker 1: some idea of who was excluded or not excluded, and
- 23:08Speaker 1: if at the end of the day, even if twelve
- 23:11Speaker 1: thousand people were excluded, but that didn't change anything in
- 23:16Speaker 1: terms of what states would get what funding, and what
- 23:20Speaker 1: states would get what uh seat in Congress. Then at
- 23:25Speaker 1: the end, who's going to be able to come forward
- 23:28Speaker 1: and bring a claim? Even an undocumented person if they
- 23:31Speaker 1: wanted to bring back claim, wouldn't be able to show
- 23:34Speaker 1: how they were harmed. And so, yes, that is sort
- 23:37Speaker 1: of a concept of sending is you can't show exactly
- 23:39Speaker 1: how your harms by not being counted in the census.
- 23:43Speaker 1: And so that certainly does become a critical issue, and
- 23:47Speaker 1: I think that will be the issue in which they
- 23:49Speaker 1: will try to punt it. But again I don't think
- 23:52Speaker 1: they would punt it ordinarily if they thought that at
- 23:56Speaker 1: the end of this the Trump administration is going to
- 23:59Speaker 1: exclude millions of people from the census. What their hope
- 24:03Speaker 1: is that either this will lead to a decision to
- 24:08Speaker 1: exclude so few people from the census that it doesn't
- 24:11Speaker 1: end up actually changing anything, so that there would be
- 24:14Speaker 1: no laws who needed or in the alternative, it at
- 24:18Speaker 1: least gets you to abideen administration and nothing ends up happening. Period.
- 24:23Speaker 1: At the very beginning of the argument, Chief Justice Robert said,
- 24:27Speaker 1: you know, this would be like unscrambling the eggs, and
- 24:30Speaker 1: the Solicitor General said, well, we do that all the time.
- 24:34Speaker 1: Explain what Chief Justice Roberts was talking about. Well, I
- 24:37Speaker 1: think see. Justice Robert's concern was once you go down
- 24:43Speaker 1: this route of excluding undocumented individuals, then you have two
- 24:49Speaker 1: sets of litigation that go on. Number one should you
- 24:53Speaker 1: have excluded the category of people that have been excluded?
- 24:57Speaker 1: And two did you get the right number? And what
- 25:01Speaker 1: he was concerned was he didn't want to have this
- 25:03Speaker 1: second litigation of did you get the right number? Because
- 25:07Speaker 1: that is a very difficult litigation. The government all the
- 25:13Speaker 1: time ends up having to give five, six, seven different
- 25:16Speaker 1: sets of statistics because they never get the right count
- 25:20Speaker 1: in the first place, and who knows if they ever
- 25:22Speaker 1: get the right count, because it's just hard no matter what,
- 25:25Speaker 1: it's not nefarious, it's just that the government turns out
- 25:28Speaker 1: to be very bad at keeping statistics. And what Justice
- 25:32Speaker 1: Roberts was saying is why do we need to go
- 25:35Speaker 1: down this route of having what I know is going
- 25:37Speaker 1: to be very unseemly and inconvenient litigation on statistics that
- 25:43Speaker 1: we know are gonna be flawed. If we can make
- 25:47Speaker 1: a larger, overarching decision that the government shouldn't be in
- 25:51Speaker 1: this business of excluding anyone from the census? Serious did
- 25:55Speaker 1: the Solicitor General say where they were going to get
- 25:59Speaker 1: the from? Well, I think he retreated to certain known
- 26:04Speaker 1: nons to use a Donald Rum sub phrase, which is
- 26:08Speaker 1: that we know how many people have orders of removal,
- 26:12Speaker 1: and we know how many people are in immigrations attention,
- 26:15Speaker 1: and we know how many people are in immigration proceedings
- 26:20Speaker 1: who have criminal convictions. And he said that worst case scenario,
- 26:24Speaker 1: at least that group should be allowed to be excluded.
- 26:28Speaker 1: And then that wasn't really debated as well, should that
- 26:33Speaker 1: be the basis of a decision, because the Trump administration
- 26:36Speaker 1: hasn't said it's only got to be these three groups.
- 26:39Speaker 1: And so that's the sort of problem in this case
- 26:42Speaker 1: where the justices started getting frustrated is maybe if it
- 26:46Speaker 1: had been limited to those three groups, and they could
- 26:49Speaker 1: actually zero in on litigation as to those three groups,
- 26:52Speaker 1: you could have a discussion as a proper or not. Now,
- 26:55Speaker 1: the a c l U attorney did say, even in
- 26:57Speaker 1: some of those groups, people will have tully win and
- 27:00Speaker 1: get out from under whatever charges being charged onto them.
- 27:05Speaker 1: And those people are in fact presidents once they finish
- 27:08Speaker 1: this process. And so you have to even in this cent,
- 27:12Speaker 1: count some portion and say, look, babe, of these individuals
- 27:16Speaker 1: win on average. And so you would only tecent let's say,
- 27:22Speaker 1: as undocumented. And so this becomes such a logistical nightmare
- 27:27Speaker 1: that no matter how you're doing it, it's hard to
- 27:31Speaker 1: say it's appropriate account x number of people. But it
- 27:34Speaker 1: becomes even worse in this case because the Trump administration
- 27:38Speaker 1: wasn't even willing to give a category of people that
- 27:41Speaker 1: it felt was appropriate to exclude as opposed to include,
- 27:46Speaker 1: rather than just saying, well, it could be all the undocumented,
- 27:49Speaker 1: or it could be some segment of the undocumented. And
- 27:53Speaker 1: so the New York Times report last week that Census
- 27:56Speaker 1: Bureau officials have told the Commerce Department they can't who's
- 28:00Speaker 1: the state population totals until after Trump leaves office. So
- 28:04Speaker 1: then is all this just moot? Well, that's what the
- 28:10Speaker 1: underlying current of these arguments are. That's what that's what
- 28:14Speaker 1: the unsaid portion of today's argument was if at the
- 28:18Speaker 1: end of the day, do we really need to have
- 28:21Speaker 1: this debate about whether you can count undocumented folks or not.
- 28:26Speaker 1: If at the end of the day, this is all
- 28:28Speaker 1: gonna be boot because Biden will get to this before
- 28:31Speaker 1: any damage is done. And I think if this depends
- 28:34Speaker 1: where you come down on this, I think there are
- 28:36Speaker 1: a number of justices, certainly uh Briar and so of
- 28:41Speaker 1: Major and Kagan who definitely would have wanted and would
- 28:45Speaker 1: want just to get a president on record saying this
- 28:48Speaker 1: is agregious stump and it shouldn't happen in this country
- 28:53Speaker 1: and we should count people, and people are people and
- 28:56Speaker 1: the story. But I just don't know where that's gonna
- 29:00Speaker 1: fall with the other six justices in this court. And
- 29:04Speaker 1: I can just really see them wanting to find some
- 29:07Speaker 1: offer ramp that does the lease amount of damage possible.
- 29:11Speaker 1: And so the off ramp might be what the d
- 29:14Speaker 1: C three judge panel did correct. The off ramp would
- 29:19Speaker 1: be that they come back to us when there is
- 29:21Speaker 1: an exact number of people excluded for exact reasons, and
- 29:25Speaker 1: then we can have that debate about whether somebody was
- 29:28Speaker 1: armed and whether anybody lost feat or funding because of this,
- 29:33Speaker 1: but for now we don't know, and so now is
- 29:36Speaker 1: not the time to be having this discussion at the
- 29:39Speaker 1: court because we don't know if anyone's actually been hardened yet.
- 29:43Speaker 1: Thanks for being on the Bloomberg Lass early on. That's
- 29:45Speaker 1: Leon Fresco, a partner at Hollanden Knight. And that's it
- 29:49Speaker 1: for the sedition of the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm June Grosso.
- 29:52Speaker 1: Thanks so much for listening. You can always get the
- 29:54Speaker 1: latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can
- 29:57Speaker 1: find them on iTunes, SoundCloud, or an www dot bloomberg
- 30:02Speaker 1: dot com slash podcast Slash Law. And remember to catch
- 30:06Speaker 1: the Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight. It's m damn Eastern
- 30:09Speaker 1: right here on Bloomberg Radio.