Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / California Evidence Law Update: The Court Decisions That Shaped 2025
Transcript
- 0:03Good day. Welcome to California Evidence Law
- 0:07Update, the Decisions that Shape 2025. I'm Lori
- 0:11Crip -Martin, a certified family law specialist,
- 0:14and I'm a past co -chair of the Beverly Hills
- 0:17Bar Association Litigation Section. I'm delighted
- 0:20to introduce our speaker, Eileen A. Scallin,
- 0:25who is a professor of practice at UCLA School
- 0:28of Law. Professor Scallin, previously served
- 0:33as Associate Dean for Curriculum and Academic
- 0:35Affairs and later as Director of Part -Time Faculty
- 0:38at UCLA, earning the 2023 Rudder Award for Excellence
- 0:45in Law Teaching. A magna cum laude graduate of
- 0:50the University of Minnesota Law School and a
- 0:52former editor -in -chief of the Minnesota Law
- 0:55Review, she clerked for Judge A. Wallace Tashima
- 1:00before practicing at Latham and Watkins and teaching
- 1:03at UC San Francisco and Mitchell Hamlin College
- 1:07of Law. She is the primary author of the California
- 1:11Evidence Courtroom Manual and working together
- 1:15in law with the research focusing on evidentiary
- 1:18privilege and theories of influence in team settings.
- 1:22And now let's get started. Thank you, Laurie.
- 1:26And thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 1:30for inviting me to participate in this session.
- 1:36I'm always happy to talk about California evidence
- 1:40law. This year was an unusual year because there
- 1:49were no changes to the statutes, no amendments,
- 1:53no new statutes. And I've always told our students
- 2:01that, you know, changes in the California evidence
- 2:06world are as common as changes to the phone book.
- 2:10But of course, nowadays, nobody knows what a
- 2:13phone book is. So that's kind of sad, but it's
- 2:18true. This is the first year that I can recall
- 2:23from 2000 when I started doing this project on
- 2:28California evidence law that we've not had any
- 2:32statutory changes. So it's all case law. This
- 2:37is a focus on California evidence law. deliberately
- 2:44do not include Ninth Circuit or District Court
- 2:50decisions because there's already way too much
- 2:56to focus on in California evidence. So I'm going
- 3:01to, with those caveats, I'm going to start sharing
- 3:06my PowerPoint screen and I will start taking
- 3:20it from there. Let's see. Stop for a second.
- 3:38Okay. Need to... There. Okay, here we go. So
- 4:02just one more word about the book. The California
- 4:08Evidence Courtroom Manual. is available both
- 4:12in print and it's available online. It's one
- 4:16of the databases in LexisNexis. So to the degree
- 4:21you're interested in this, you can get access
- 4:24either way. And let me go through what we're
- 4:29going to focus on today. The first thing I'm
- 4:35going to talk about is the creative expression
- 4:39statute, which is 352 .2. There were some big
- 4:44case interpretations of that statute this year,
- 4:49so I'll focus on that. Second, I will be talking
- 4:54about character evidence, and it's a piece of
- 4:58character evidence that doesn't usually get discussed,
- 5:02which is the character of a victim. in criminal
- 5:06cases and it's a tricky situation and you'll
- 5:13see it in the People versus Barrett case. Then
- 5:17we'll talk about confrontation clause. California
- 5:20has been at the vanguard of confrontation clause
- 5:26cases and the Sanchez case from 2016 continues
- 5:32to be a focus of the Supreme Court and the courts
- 5:36of appeals. So we'll talk about that. We're going
- 5:39to do a little bit on hearsay. I'm going to give
- 5:42you a little bit of a refresher on hearsay because
- 5:49one of my goals with the book is to provide resources
- 5:54for people that have forgotten their evidence
- 5:58or they never learned it in the first place.
- 6:01I know they're Will be a few of you and that's
- 6:07normal. So I want to just with the cases that
- 6:11come up in the hearsay context, I can provide
- 6:15a little bit of that re teaching of hearsay.
- 6:19There's some good expert cases just. nothing
- 6:23novel, but good reminders and some good privilege
- 6:27reminders as well. I don't know if we'll talk
- 6:31about the penal code section 1172 .6 cases, re
- 6:36-sentencing. We'll see if we have time for that.
- 6:39It's kind of a... niche area, but a very important
- 6:44area right now. So we'll see if we have time
- 6:47for that. The PowerPoint that I have provided
- 6:51for you in a PDF form is. pretty detailed, so
- 6:57you may not want to read it all while we are
- 7:01talking about this. I always go back and forth
- 7:05about how much detail to provide on a PowerPoint
- 7:08slide, but I like to have everything in one place,
- 7:13so that's why I provide more comprehensive PowerPoint
- 7:18slides. You can come back and refer to them later.
- 7:23I won't be covering everything in the slide.
- 7:27But it is there so you don't have to take notes.
- 7:31You don't have to remember anything. It will
- 7:34be there for you to come back to. So let's start
- 7:38in on the material. And the first area I want
- 7:43to talk about is the creative expression statute.
- 7:47And many of you will not be familiar with this
- 7:50because it was it's fairly recent. It was added
- 7:53in 2022 and it is part of a movement. There has
- 8:00been a proposed federal counterpart, but. It
- 8:04was proposed by one of the Democrats in the House
- 8:10and has gone nowhere, as you can predict, given
- 8:15the composition of Congress. The problem that
- 8:19has arisen is what do we do with evidence of
- 8:26creative expression, particularly rap cases,
- 8:31rap music? There's a very funny excerpt. I don't
- 8:39have time to show it to you and don't want to
- 8:42violate any copyright provisions, but Jordan
- 8:46and Peele have a very funny skit with a criminal
- 8:53defense lawyer trying to defend his client in
- 8:57the face of some very damning rap lyrics that
- 9:02his client has written, but the actual situation
- 9:06is less amusing and prosecutors have wanted to
- 9:13really expand the use of rap lyrics against criminal
- 9:20defendants charged with violent crimes and a
- 9:24lot of rap music does reference violence and
- 9:30So it's pretty volatile area well the federal
- 9:34or the California legislature. Created a special
- 9:39statute to deal with evidence of creative expression
- 9:44and that includes rap lyrics. Whether they are
- 9:49just audio or written or in videos to expand
- 9:55that in criminal cases. You'll see that it's
- 9:59section 352 .2. That is a variation on the theme
- 10:07of our standard 352 balancing. Remember, section
- 10:14352 is the ultimate tool for courts to exclude
- 10:22evidence where the probative value of that evidence
- 10:26is substantially outweighed by its dangers. And
- 10:33the primary danger people tend to focus on is
- 10:37unfair prejudice or undue prejudice. But there
- 10:41are other dangers. And in fact, I would argue
- 10:44more important dangers or at least ones that
- 10:48push trial courts buttons, including waste of
- 10:52time. And so Section 352 is kind of the generic
- 10:58tool that trial courts have. But the legislature
- 11:03added to that in 2022, creating the special statute
- 11:08that applies to evidence of creative expression.
- 11:15It really is just. expanding on what is covered
- 11:22by 352, requiring that the court look very carefully
- 11:29at the probative value, the overlap between the
- 11:33lyrics and the facts of the crime, and especially
- 11:39spelling out what would constitute a danger of
- 11:44this evidence. Primary dangers are that the jury
- 11:48will misuse the evidence, that they will treat
- 11:53it as character or propensity evidence, which
- 11:57they are not entitled to do. The other aspect
- 12:02that the California statute 352 .2 spells out
- 12:08is that with many rap lyrics, it implicitly interjects
- 12:16racial bias, racial stereotypes, violence, and
- 12:26other kinds of implicit and explicit bias into
- 12:33the proceedings. So the court is required under
- 12:36this special statute to weigh those and to spell
- 12:41out its reasoning. The issue that came up this
- 12:46past year in 2025 was whether that statute, the
- 12:52creative expression statute, is retroactive.
- 12:55And I will cut to the chase. The Supreme Court
- 12:59has held that it is not retroactive, that it
- 13:07is only prospective. And I'm going to kind of
- 13:13glide through the next slides a little bit faster.
- 13:17It's a very interesting issue, but I'm not sure
- 13:22it's worth taking up our time right now. I want
- 13:27to contrast, though, PeopleVHIN, which was decided
- 13:35before the Aguar case because it does help me
- 13:41kind of, again, reteach 352, which is really
- 13:47a fundamental rule to understand in the practice
- 13:50of evidence law in California and even its counterpart
- 13:54in federal practice. The federal rule, of course,
- 13:58is federal rule 352. This case, People v. Hinn,
- 14:08did not reach the creative expression statute.
- 14:13So they didn't deal with the retroactivity issue.
- 14:17They dealt only with the generic tool, Section
- 14:23352. But what is important about that is the
- 14:28court did a really careful job of examining,
- 14:34first of all, the probative value. The probative
- 14:38value of the evidence is crucial because it doesn't
- 14:44take much, but it does take some. And once there
- 14:49is some probative value found, then the scales
- 14:53tilt and it is Hard to exclude evidence under
- 15:00352 if there is some probative value because
- 15:05the probative value has to be substantially outweighed
- 15:11by any of the dangers of unfair prejudice or
- 15:17Waste of time misleading the jury all those kinds
- 15:21of dangers that are listed in other words Section
- 15:25352 is not an even balancing test. Once there
- 15:30is some probative value, the scales are in favor
- 15:34of getting the evidence in. And the hard work
- 15:39is on the side that wants to keep it out. But
- 15:43what was interesting about HIN is this was one
- 15:47of the rare cases where the evidence should have
- 15:51been kept out under 352. The evidence was a song,
- 15:57Bang Bang, that was found on a CD in the defendant's
- 16:03bedroom and that was admitted into evidence both
- 16:08at the guilt phase and the penalty phase. But
- 16:11there was nothing tying that evidence to the
- 16:18defendant. except that it was found in his bedroom.
- 16:24There was no evidence that the defendant wrote
- 16:27the song or produced the song or that the defendant
- 16:32even had heard the song. And so here we had one
- 16:38of the rare cases where there is no probative
- 16:43value to the evidence because of the lack of
- 16:47foundation. On the other hand, there were, in
- 16:52this case, extensive 352 dangers. So even if
- 16:58there had been some probative value, some foundation
- 17:02laid, there was a lot of potential harm. And
- 17:09remember that the harm under 352 is not about
- 17:15whether it hurts your case. This is probably
- 17:19the most common error under 352. Does it hurt
- 17:24my case? Does it damage my case? Sorry, that's
- 17:29not one of the dangers under 352. The kinds of
- 17:34dangers under 352 are problems of the proof finding
- 17:40process. All evidence that hurts your case is
- 17:48prejudicial in some sense, but that's not what
- 17:52352 means. Here, the primary unfair prejudice
- 17:58was the invitation of racial bias, the use of
- 18:02racial bias against the defendant and the potential
- 18:07for jury misuse. the potential for using it as
- 18:13propensity or character evidence, the defendant's
- 18:17propensity to engage in violence as proof that
- 18:22the defendant committed the crime, violent crime
- 18:25charged in this case. So here we had no real
- 18:32probative value at all, but even if there had
- 18:35been some, It probably was substantially outweighed
- 18:41by these dangers. And that's what the court held,
- 18:44that it was an abuse of discretion to admit this
- 18:49evidence. However, and again, here is a reminder,
- 18:55a teaching point, evidentiary decisions are Boy,
- 19:01if you're trying to rely on an appeal for evidentiary,
- 19:04on evidentiary grounds, you have two major hurdles.
- 19:08The first is, was there an evidentiary error?
- 19:12And here, yes, there was an evidentiary error.
- 19:16The 352 abuse of discretion and allowing the
- 19:23evidence. It should not have been allowed. It
- 19:25was an abuse of discretion. But the other hurdle
- 19:29is the standard for appellate reversal, which
- 19:35is it had to have likely impacted the outcome
- 19:39of the case. And in the Hinn case, it did not.
- 19:45There was a lot of other evidence against an
- 19:49defendant. And so the evidentiary error was deemed
- 19:54harmless. And as a result, not requiring reversal.
- 20:01So the second case in this area of creative expression
- 20:06was People v. Aguare. And this case squarely
- 20:16holds that the evidentiary statute does not have
- 20:23retroactive impact. Here, the case was different
- 20:29than Hind. There were two types of evidence at
- 20:35stake here. There were instant messages found
- 20:37on a defendant's computer, and there were handwritten
- 20:43lyrics that repeated some of the same messages
- 20:48of violence. both were sufficiently connected
- 20:54to the defendant. So here we had some probative
- 21:00value. Here the probative value was on motive
- 21:05and intent to engage in the on the gang participation
- 21:11charge and the enhancements. The defendant challenged
- 21:18the lyrics under 352 and then used 352 .2, the
- 21:26creative expression, to bar both the messages
- 21:30and the lyrics. And so it differed from HIN in
- 21:37that there was, in this case, some probative
- 21:39value. The majority focused on the retroactivity
- 21:48issue of 352 .2 and they look to a case that
- 21:54established the proposition that only laws that
- 21:59lessen punishment for defendants are presumed
- 22:05to be retroactive. Of course, if the legislature
- 22:08spells out retroactivity, that is a more helpful
- 22:13situation, but the legislature often does not.
- 22:18So the Estrada rule, the question was whether
- 22:21352 .2 Creative Expression was a statute that
- 22:28would reduce the punitive punishment for a defendant.
- 22:37The majority held it does not, that it's simply
- 22:41a rule of evidence. It doesn't as it on its own.
- 22:46It does not change the elements of an offense
- 22:50to make it less likely that a defendant will
- 22:53be punished. It does not create any kind of path
- 22:59to a lesser punishment. Doesn't decriminalize
- 23:05anything. It simply states whether evidence of
- 23:10creative expression is admissible or not based
- 23:13on certain factors that the court has to balance.
- 23:18Well, Justice Liu, who is a very thoughtful justice,
- 23:26took on the issue in the dissent and argued that
- 23:31what we should be looking at is whether the law
- 23:37has an ameliorative effect. And it doesn't need
- 23:41to be a change in elements. It doesn't need to
- 23:45be expressly aimed at reducing a defense punishment.
- 23:51It's a very creative, thoughtful argument, but
- 23:54ultimately only was joined by Justice Evans.
- 24:02So it is clear that Section 352 .2 going forward
- 24:09is just a rule of evidence that applies prospectively,
- 24:15not retroactively. And it did overrule a couple
- 24:19of cases that I've cited that were court of appeal
- 24:22cases. By the way, I deliberately in my book
- 24:30kind of have a time lag. because I know that
- 24:36people don't always check the current status
- 24:40of the law, even though you should. So I try
- 24:45to wait out the Supreme Court to see whether
- 24:47they are going to de -publish decisions of the
- 24:51Court of Appeals before I put them in the book.
- 24:55So you will see that any of the materials I'm
- 25:01pretty positive that they will stand as citable
- 25:05precedents. And that's why our book is 2025,
- 25:14not 2026. I'm not going to go into this slide.
- 25:20There was interestingly another provision that
- 25:25involve the Estrada presumption of whether it
- 25:30is retroactive, but you can take a look if you
- 25:34are interested. The admission of the one piece
- 25:39I will talk about is that the lyrics, which were
- 25:42challenged only under 352, those were deemed
- 25:48admissible. And again, I think it is because
- 25:52there was adequate foundation. So there was that
- 25:57link to the defendant, which tilts the scales
- 26:01towards admissibility. And it takes an awful
- 26:06lot under 352 of waste of time or unfair prejudice
- 26:11to substantially outweigh that probative value
- 26:15and result in the exclusion of the evidence.
- 26:20Well, we're gonna change topics now. And by the
- 26:24way, if you have questions, I will take them
- 26:27at the end. I'm going to leave some time for
- 26:30questions. We're about half a little less than
- 26:33halfway through. This is also this next topic
- 26:38is character evidence and you will recall that
- 26:42character evidence is generally banned in criminal
- 26:46cases. But there are exceptions to that. And
- 26:51one of the exceptions is where the defendant
- 26:54opens the door and the defendant, one of the
- 26:57key points of this case, people versus Barrett,
- 27:02is that it's the defendant's choice to open the
- 27:05door to character evidence. Well, here, The issue
- 27:11was whether the defendant had in fact opened
- 27:15the door to character evidence by challenging
- 27:18and impugning the character of the victim. So
- 27:24if the defendant does open the door. to character
- 27:28evidence by putting on evidence of the victim's
- 27:32character for violence or whatever character
- 27:34trait. Usually it's violence. This comes up most
- 27:38often in self -defense cases. If they do that,
- 27:44well, they can. And unlike federal rules, they
- 27:49can use reputation, opinion evidence of the victim's
- 27:54character, and they can use specific acts. So
- 27:58it's the defendant's choice to make the character
- 28:00of the victim for violence an issue. But if they
- 28:05do, they have also opened the door to the prosecution
- 28:09coming back with evidence of the defendant's
- 28:14character for violence. And that was the issue
- 28:18in this case, people versus Barrett. Barrett
- 28:22was convicted of murder. of his cellmate, but
- 28:29Barrett claims self -defense, a common situation.
- 28:34And the defendant's theory was kind of an interesting
- 28:37one, but it was a very delicate dance. The defendant's
- 28:43theory was that his cellmate was known as kind
- 28:49of a tough guy, kind of a bad guy. And as a result,
- 28:56he was very respected in the prison population.
- 29:00And that would mean that the defendant had nothing
- 29:04to fear from him. Interesting theory. The prosecution's
- 29:09theory was that Barrett killed his cellmate because
- 29:16he believed that the cellmate was a rat. And
- 29:22so The defendant tried to introduce some misconduct
- 29:28by the victim in the prison. The victim flooded
- 29:37his cell with noxious fluids and did some other
- 29:43pretty horrible stuff. The defendant really tried
- 29:48to argue that no, he wasn't attacking the victim's
- 29:52character. He was just trying to show that the
- 29:56victim was respected because he was kind of a
- 30:01tough dude, a bad dude. But that really didn't
- 30:06work. And as a result, the court in this case
- 30:12held that the defendant opened the door to the
- 30:17prosecution's evidence, not just The prosecution
- 30:22could have put on evidence of the victim's nonviolent
- 30:26character that probably wasn't available. But
- 30:30as in addition, the prosecution gets to use the
- 30:34rule that says if the defendant opens the door
- 30:37to the defendant victims character for violence,
- 30:41prosecution can respond with evidence of the.
- 30:46Defendants character for violence and Barrett
- 30:49had a number of bad specific acts and So it's
- 30:57a real warning Be careful about the strategic
- 31:01choices you make and here the theory of the case
- 31:05made all the difference So we're gonna switch
- 31:10topics again and We're still in the criminal
- 31:15context. People versus Cardenas. And this case
- 31:22is one of several that invokes the Sanchez decision.
- 31:27The Sanchez decision, 2016 decision that tried
- 31:32to clarify how the confrontation clause applies
- 31:37when there is an expert that uses hearsay. Well,
- 31:47the court in Sanchez held that where an expert
- 31:51uses and testifies to case specific out of court
- 31:56statements. Generally, and it was in the case
- 32:01in Sanchez police reports step reports the out
- 32:07of court statements that would refer to defendants
- 32:11interactions with police. in the gang context.
- 32:16If those are not covered by a hearsay exception
- 32:19or independently admissible, Sanchez held that
- 32:24it was inadmissible as a matter of hearsay. And
- 32:29if those statements were testimonial, remember
- 32:32the confrontation clause currently turns on whether
- 32:38hearsay statements are testimonial. meaning they
- 32:43are likely to be used and the declarant likely
- 32:47knows that they are to be used in prosecuting
- 32:50crime. They cannot be used unless there is a
- 32:57showing that the declarant is unavailable. And
- 33:01crucially, there was a prior opportunity to cross
- 33:04examine that declarant, the person who made the
- 33:07out of court statement. Well, You would think
- 33:11that by now, 10 years later, people get Sanchez.
- 33:17But as People vs. Cardenas shows, prosecutors
- 33:22are still making mistakes. There was an expert.
- 33:26This is another gang situation. The expert testified
- 33:32to... Specific conversations with investigators
- 33:36and police reports that underlie their conclusion
- 33:41expert conclusion about the gang, the defendant
- 33:46status as a gang member. It's all hearsay and
- 33:51as a result needed to be covered by a hearsay
- 33:56exception. But even if it was, this is a criminal
- 34:01case. And as a criminal case, if the statements
- 34:05were testimonial meant for prosecution and they
- 34:10were. Well, that's probably going to result in
- 34:14a constitutional violation and constitutional
- 34:18violations more likely, I think, to be held not
- 34:22harmless error. And that was the case in this
- 34:26case. So the judgment was reversed. To contrast
- 34:31it, let's use a couple of other Supreme Court
- 34:36cases also involving confrontation clause. But
- 34:41these cases illustrate when the confrontation
- 34:45clause is not violated. Here, People versus Jasso,
- 34:51one case. The prosecutors have tried to use this
- 34:57technique to get around Sanchez and of course
- 35:02what the leading confrontation clause case Crawford
- 35:07by not having the in court witness actually testify
- 35:15to the out of court statements, but rather the
- 35:19prosecutor will ask a series of leading questions
- 35:23to basically have the prosecutor testify in a
- 35:32way that implies what the out of court statements
- 35:36might be. So in JASO, they had a non -responsive
- 35:42accomplice, defendant's accomplice. So the prosecutor
- 35:44basically led the witness through statements,
- 35:51but those statements were not. Out -of -court
- 35:54statements offered to prove the truth in the
- 35:56matter asserted. They were statements of the
- 35:59witnesses own knowledge, things the witness had
- 36:03observed. And that is not hearsay in this case.
- 36:12It was not relying on out -of -court statements.
- 36:15So there was no hearsay and no confrontation
- 36:20violation. The second type of evidence that was
- 36:25at stake was an accomplice's statement against
- 36:30interest, a statement that made the accomplice
- 36:35subject potentially to criminal prosecution.
- 36:39That statement was deemed admitted as under the
- 36:44hearsay exception for statement against interest,
- 36:46but it was not testimonial because it was made
- 36:50to a friend. And statements between friends,
- 36:57real co -conspirators, those kinds of statements
- 37:01have been found to be not testimonial because
- 37:04you don't expect your friend to turn around and
- 37:11turn evidence on you. So that was not, there
- 37:17was no confrontation clause violation in that
- 37:20case. People versus Alvarez. This is also an
- 37:26illustration of the rule that casual remarks
- 37:31to acquaintances or kind of private conversations.
- 37:37Here it was a four -year -old statements about
- 37:40his father's abuse and these statements were
- 37:43made to his mother, her boyfriend, boyfriend's
- 37:47family. Those were admissible under 1360s child
- 37:53abuse hearsay exception, Section 1360. And they
- 37:59were not testimonial because, again, these were
- 38:03private kind of personal conversations. There's
- 38:08an issue, I think, generally with children's
- 38:11statements, whether children can legitimately
- 38:15predict that their statements will be used for
- 38:18criminal prosecution. We don't have time to get
- 38:22into that here, but the court here, this case
- 38:26was similar to a federal case, Ohio versus Clark,
- 38:30that was also a child abuse case. And the Supreme
- 38:34Court in that case also held that statements
- 38:37made by a child to, in that case, a teacher They're
- 38:42not the kind of statements that the declarant
- 38:45believes will be used for prosecution. It takes
- 38:50a leap to some degree, depending on how old the
- 38:54child is, to make these kinds of categorical
- 38:58statements, but this is not an unusual finding
- 39:02that this was not a violation of the confrontation
- 39:06process. These cases, I know Laurie is involved
- 39:13in family law and many of the rest of you might
- 39:17be as well. And these two cases are court of
- 39:22appeal cases in remarriage of MP and MC and then
- 39:26adoption of XD. But I will also use these to
- 39:31kind of refresh your recollection. That's a little
- 39:35evidence joke about. hearsay, because both of
- 39:43these cases rely on distinctions between using
- 39:49an out -of -court statement for its truth, where
- 39:53you would need a hearsay exception, versus arguments
- 39:57that the statement is not hearsay at all. It
- 40:01is an out -of -court statement, but it is not
- 40:04being used to prove the truth of what the statement
- 40:07said. So, in in -ray marriage, this was a domestic
- 40:15violence protection act case involving a restraining
- 40:21order, and it was based on hearsay evidence,
- 40:25evidence of a child's statements to her mother
- 40:28about sexual abuse by the father. The court here
- 40:35noted that these statements could not be used
- 40:39as non hearsay, meaning that they were just evidence
- 40:44of a state of mind. That's a very common argument
- 40:49to make in response to a hearsay objection. Your
- 40:53honor, this out of court statement just goes
- 40:56to state of mind. Well, there is a state of mind
- 41:00exception. In fact, there are a couple under
- 41:05the Section 10, here precisely Section 1250.
- 41:13So sometimes out -of -court statements are used
- 41:16for purposes other than to prove the content
- 41:22of those statements. But here those statements
- 41:27couldn't be used for that. There was no relevant
- 41:30purpose, non -hearsay purpose. So for example,
- 41:37The speaker here, the declarant was the child.
- 41:42And sometimes we'll see as in the next case,
- 41:47the state of mind of a listener of the statement
- 41:51or a reader of the statement that the audience's
- 41:56state of mind is irrelevant, but not in in -ray
- 42:00marriage. The mother's state of mind was not
- 42:03relevant. and the state of mind of the child,
- 42:13the declarant, which would have invoked 1250,
- 42:17that state of mind wasn't relevant. However,
- 42:22there was another hearsay exception, and it comes
- 42:26from case law in the child dependency context.
- 42:34Court of Appeal decision I think is in Ray Carmen
- 42:38and then the court Supreme Court approved that
- 42:44allowed that exception that child dependency
- 42:48hearsay exception recognized it. Well, this case
- 42:54in Ray marriage extends that hearsay exception
- 42:58to Domestic Violence Protection Act. proceedings,
- 43:03rejecting the argument that this exception was
- 43:07limited to dependency cases. So there was a hearsay
- 43:12exception here and a need for an exception because
- 43:16the statement was being used to prove its truth,
- 43:20that the father had in fact abused the child.
- 43:25Contrast this with adoption of XD. Here, the
- 43:30evidence was the biological father's text messages
- 43:34sent to his sister. And in those text messages,
- 43:39he threatened to kill the mother and her unborn
- 43:43child. Well, the sister shared those texts with
- 43:49the potential victim, with the mother. And the
- 43:54court held that those texts were authenticated,
- 43:58properly authenticated text messages must be.
- 44:01But what was important here is those text messages
- 44:04were admissible as non hearsay evidence that
- 44:10showed circumstantial evidence of the mother's
- 44:13reasonable fear. So they were usable because
- 44:19not only, yes, the father did those, so they
- 44:22are admissible. Remember, anything a party says
- 44:27is admissible. Party opponent exception. But
- 44:35here they also served as circumstantial evidence
- 44:39of the mother's reasonable fear of the defendant.
- 44:42So this is another case where the listener or
- 44:45the reader of those texts, where her state of
- 44:49mind was relevant, and it was here, that gets
- 44:54around the hearsay rule. So sometimes statements
- 44:59are just used to show, as we often say in the
- 45:03law, to show their effect on the hearer or the
- 45:06effect on the listener. And that was the case
- 45:09here. OK. Here we have some cases involving experts.
- 45:21And of course, these would apply to both criminal
- 45:24and civil practitioners. The Charlie L. versus
- 45:32Kangavari case is pretty narrow, but it involves
- 45:37the special requirements that apply to emergency
- 45:43care physicians. when you are suing someone who
- 45:50provided emergency care, the requirements for
- 45:56the experts in those cases are stiffer. And so
- 46:02the court in this case found that both experts,
- 46:07the plaintiff's expert and the defendant's expert,
- 46:10didn't meet this standard. In both cases, the
- 46:14physicians were They were licensed, you know,
- 46:19fully qualified in that sense, but they failed
- 46:22to satisfy the specialist requirement that these
- 46:28individuals provide emergency services in emergency
- 46:36departments. And one of the physicians was just
- 46:40a regular hospital radiologist. that wouldn't
- 46:43qualify. Has to be from an emergency, someone
- 46:48who practices emergency medicine in emergency
- 46:51departments. That was also the case with the
- 46:54plaintiff's expert. So there had to be a reversal
- 46:59of the summary judgment here, but it was interesting
- 47:01that both experts got called on this. Birdsall
- 47:07is a seatbelt case and just said that the lack
- 47:12of use of or the use of seat belts did not require
- 47:18an expert. Everybody knows these days why we
- 47:23use seat belts, and so there was no expert testimony
- 47:28required. My favorite expert case, however, From
- 47:33last term is the Richard case Court of Appeal
- 47:36decisions sexually at 2024 late 2024 And this
- 47:41is one that I held off putting in the book till
- 47:43I was sure that its status was good It excluded
- 47:49the testimony trial court excluded the testimony
- 47:52of an engineer with 42 years of experience 42
- 47:55years and most of it with this exact kind of
- 48:01train and this exact kind of situation which
- 48:06was a collision between cars. The defendants
- 48:13in that case had presented some pretty sophisticated
- 48:16high -tech data that argued that this was not
- 48:23negligence but the court held that the expertise
- 48:29here was relative to the subject, meaning the
- 48:35collision, whether a collision was negligent
- 48:38or not, not rigidly tied to former credentials.
- 48:43And the quote that I don't provide here but is
- 48:47my favorite, the expert, plaintiff's expert,
- 48:52could not testify about the database that the
- 48:56defendants used to try and dispel the negligence
- 49:00claim, but definitely had relevant experience
- 49:05with the actual facts of the case. And the court
- 49:09said that just because an expert can't testify
- 49:13to all subjects doesn't mean that they don't
- 49:17have admissible opinions on some topics, and
- 49:23so I really like this case because it shows that
- 49:28experts, while they are superhuman, don't have
- 49:31to be perfect. They can testify to partial issues
- 49:36and don't have to be experts in all areas. I
- 49:40like that. So we have some Expert or sorry, some
- 49:47evidentiary privilege issues and confidential
- 49:52Brady material pitches material. The Johnson
- 49:59case is worth taking a look at. It was an employment
- 50:04law case. It resulted in disqualification of
- 50:08the plaintiffs attorney. where that attorney
- 50:12violated a protective order, the plaintiff's
- 50:16attorney sent a defense side email to a potential
- 50:22witness and ended up being disqualified. The
- 50:30court does, I can't for time purposes here, do
- 50:34a thorough job here, but it's a really good court
- 50:38case that just renews your understanding of privilege
- 50:43in the corporate setting, who is the client,
- 50:47and then waiver of the privilege and the disqualification
- 50:51standards. So I highly recommend it to you. For
- 50:55those of you in the criminal context, the Schneider
- 50:58case, did a reached an issue of first impression.
- 51:05The court used the pitches procedures. They said
- 51:14pitches procedures are appropriate when determining
- 51:18whether Brady material is discoverable. But.
- 51:25The trial court aired in following just the pitches
- 51:29approach of giving contact information names.
- 51:37Instead of full Brady material, the documents
- 51:42and the audio visual if that exists and it did
- 51:46here that was exculpatory and so the pitches
- 51:52procedures are. to be followed, but the discovery
- 51:57has to be complete discovery when there is a
- 52:01Brady request. The last privilege issue is from
- 52:09juvenile situation. The juvenile's attorney raised
- 52:16doubt about the client's competency and that
- 52:20was sufficient to create tender the issue of
- 52:26the juvenile's mental status triggering a patient
- 52:31litigant exception so that previously privileged
- 52:36records may be considered in the competency evaluation.
- 52:40Again, it's a strategic choice how to present
- 52:45your client's case. We can't fault the attorney
- 52:50necessarily, but you have to watch out for potential
- 52:54waiver issues here. Here is the last slide evidence
- 53:03in penal code section 1172, and I'm going to
- 53:07stop here because I first just talked about the.
- 53:13pitches Brady issue, people versus Nuno raises.
- 53:18And I want to see if we have questions. So here's
- 53:21a summary of what we talked about. And I want
- 53:26to take a look at whether we have questions.
- 53:32It does not seem to me that we have questions.
- 53:37Suzy, did you see any questions here? Not currently,
- 53:42no. Okay, well, then I can go back. Just close
- 53:55that and we can. Yeah, let me just talk about
- 54:06Ramos for a minute. Here was a classic situation.
- 54:12This is in a re -sentencing, the re -sentencing
- 54:17provisions of relatively recent statute 1172
- 54:23.6. The co -defendant of the person appealing
- 54:28was tried separately. And this case holds that
- 54:33the prosecution could use the transcript from
- 54:36that separate trial at the resentencing hearing.
- 54:40There was no need to show that the. Co -defendant
- 54:44was unavailable and no need to show that the
- 54:49petitioner had a prior opportunity to cross -examine.
- 54:52This was not a situation, in other words, where
- 54:55the confrontation clause was at issue here. And
- 55:01as I mentioned, people versus Nuno. process for
- 55:07obtaining peace officer personnel information
- 55:10that is exculpatory requires pitches procedures.
- 55:16And that is the same rule that applies when you
- 55:21are using those records in advance of a resentencing
- 55:26hearing under 1172 .6. So this wraps up. Another
- 55:34year of great court cases from our courts of
- 55:41appeal and California Supreme Court. Very thoughtful
- 55:46cases. Will this year produce new California
- 55:53evidence statutes? Oh, I'm betting on it. And
- 55:57there is likely to be a federal change that relates
- 56:05to California. The federal courts are finally
- 56:08going to treat prior inconsistent statements
- 56:12the way California treats them. And so we will
- 56:17see some new developments in 2026, which is only
- 56:21half over. Again, let me thank the Beverly Hills
- 56:26Bar Association for inviting me to participate
- 56:31in your robust CLE program. And if there are
- 56:38no additional questions, Susie, I think we're
- 56:44wrapping it up. Thank you so much to our audience
- 56:46for joining us. Have a great day, everybody.
- 56:50Take care.