Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 6: Salary or Dividends for Doctors? The decision thats costing your thousands!
Transcript
- Vishal Gill,: Welcome everyone, episode six of Portfolio Talks. And today we'll be talking about salary or dividends. If you're a doctor in Canada, this decision was going to cost you hundreds of thousands of dollars over the longevity of your career. And oftentimes, when we hear about this discussion of salary versus dividends, it's usually because you talk to your accountant and it's a tax filing decision based off last year, as opposed to a tax planning decision on the longevity of your career. So oftentimes you All right, Tyson, we are back. Episode six, salary or dividends. But before we jump into that, what is new in the world of Tyson Nagasaka? Wha how's your weekend? Tyson Nagasaka: Weekend was good. always stuff going on. I had a lot ⁓ ⁓ you know, just like running around and catch up on stuff to do. And then we had a very special first birthday party to attend, ⁓ ⁓ it was awesome. So happy birthday to Amaya, but ⁓ I been to one of those in a long time. My kids are a little older, so ⁓ it was nice to to ⁓ get back to one of those and the amount of work. Vishal Gill,: Don't really know what to do, you just kind of do a knee-jerk reaction and like, okay, cool, we'll just divid it out for the year. That one decision over the entirety of your career is going to be compounding more and more and more problems that you're turning off levers that you can use at the latter part of your career to wind down your wealth and enjoy it. So, in this episode, we're going to talk about why that is and what you can do about it. And before we jump into the episode, be sure to like and subscribe so we can keep on growing this platform. And with that, let's jump into it. Episode six, Portfolio Talks. Tyson Nagasaka: organization and details and stuff. I was like, man, done it. I don't know if I miss it. it a special person to do that. Vishal Gill,: Crazy. It is love. Yeah, and that special person isn't me. it was ⁓ yeah, for those of you who don't know, ⁓ it was my daughter's first birthday ⁓ over the weekend. So it was a production for sure. And it was so funny because it was great to see Tyson, his family, his kids, all my friends, all my family, everyone in one spot is always a blessing. I think it's times like that that you see all the love in the room and everyone from different avenues and aspects of your life in one space is is such an amazing gift to be able to have. So that's a beautiful thing. But it's funny everyone's coming in, like, ⁓ you guys did such a great job. They know the venue's great, the decor, all that kind of stuff. I was like, appreciate it. T talk to my wife, because I didn't do anything. I just showed up. I felt like I was also surprised. My job, actually, funny thing, side story. My job, I had one job, which was bring my daughter to the venue, get her ready and bring her to the venue. So I did her nap time, said her in the morning, all that kind of fun stuff. And ⁓ when I was getting her ready in the outfit, I pulled up and I got her dress. And usually, if you from my office, I I usually go based off the take. So the take is always in the back. So I pick up the dress and I looked and there was no take. And instant panic. I was like, God, which way is the front? Which way is the back? I kept turning it back and forth, back and forth. I was looking at it from different angles. Only thing I had to go off was the buttons. And I was like, the buttons sometimes are in the back. I'm like, but it kind of looks like it should be in the front. I was like, whatever, it's fifty fifty. So I put the dress on, got her to the venue, ⁓ ⁓ I bring my daughter inside. ⁓ right I think it was my sister in law first, I can't remember. She looked like, hey, ⁓ her dress is on backwards. I was like, damn it, man. I had one job and it's 50-50 and I got it wrong. but it was funny, I didn't really know anything like the decor, I had no idea. so I walked into the ⁓ the venue. I felt like me and my daughter were both surprised at the same time. Like, whoa, look at the blue grounds, whoa, look at the coffee cart, whoa, look at all this stuff. which is great. So I love it. I'm a guest on my own party, which is always a nice thing. But I was laughing so hard about the dress, I was like, man, no take. So if you're someone that's making clothes out there, Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. Vishal Gill,: Put the take on the back so it just makes your life a lot easier. So I know which way's the front, which way's the back, or else it's just embarrassing, you know? Crazy, crazy. Okay, well, let's talk to the docs about their I I that's I think this episode we wanted to kind of build our last episode. Our last episode we talked about tax filing versus tax planning. Two very, very different things. And Tyson Nagasaka: Yep. Been there. Vishal Gill,: Filing is just the reactivity of your taxes when it comes to tax time, especially personal tax year end is always the most profound of the two because that's the one where people kind of forget about things. We talk about shareholder loans, or like, ⁓ my God, I spent so much money or this and that, versus task planning, which is doing frequent check-ins throughout the year. So if you missed it, if you want to learn more about that, go back on episode, listen to episode five. So this episode, we're gonna talk about you know that is being done. And now you have a decision, again, either reactive or proactive. about salary or dividends or both. So let's jump into that and let's first talk about the biggest myth that we hear, which is dividends are always more tax efficient. Always caution when it comes to definitive statements as like always. But in the world of finance, that's always one thing I remember when I was doing my CFP exam or ⁓ prof prof, ⁓ Jason Watt, great, great, great instructor. Well, it's always saying anytime you hear a definitive statement in financial planning, it's always a cause for pause and just double double check that math. So dividends are always more tax efficient. Is it a myth? Is it not? Let's jump into that, Tyson. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. I think ⁓ for a lot of what we see out there in the marketplace, there seems to be it's a method of training, or maybe it's the ⁓ that our accountants use. But that is something that's super common is dividends are more tax efficient. you're gonna be you're gonna get more out of your dollars and you have l a little bit easier of like flow and maintenance. ⁓ part of the challenges with that though is when we start to come to the planning side a client comes to us and they're now, you know, 45 years old and they're thinking the exit might be closer than I want it to. ⁓ start doing retirement planning, let's start mapping out the future. Now we start talking about all of the other benefits that come when you're doing ⁓ a blend of salary and dividends. So if we just stick to dividends for a second. The dividend tax rate that you get, ⁓ what you would pay corporately, is something that's called integration. And so CRA basically doesn't ⁓ you to pick a path that's going to be dramatically ⁓ tax efficient taking dividends than it would be if you took salary and dividends. At the end of the day, on the personal and on the corporate side, they're trying to make it about the same. And really it comes down to is. Is what's your short-term need? What is your long-term need? And what are we what's the objective that we're trying to ⁓ achieve? So a great point that you always bring up with clients is you know, by doing dividends only, you're not going to be contributing to CPP. And some of our clients they have they have loads of money, they're not really concerned about what CPP is, but we lay it out in in a very good way. You know, it's indexed to inflation. you're going to receive it. You don't have to receive it at 65. You can delay it to 70. And then if you wanted to do something with that later, you could even, you know, give it away. You could do CPP philanthropy at a later date. ⁓ but it's your benefit and you're entitled to it. when doing dividends only, you are able to forego the dividend or the CPP contributions. So you are the employer and the employee. And so if you're doing dividends only, you're able to forgo that part, which is it's like what 8,500 bucks a year right now. the challenge is if you're not contributing that money to CPP, you should be investing that in a long-term vehicle where we see a lot of people not doing that. ⁓ I think I have a lot more thoughts on this, but we'll continue through sort of our process of of talking through it. Vishal Gill,: Okay. Yeah, love that. I think ⁓ the process that Tyson brings is always really good because I go on tangents and I could just talk forever. But ⁓ I agree. I think one of the biggest things about that is everyone likes to talk about multiple streams of income until it comes to CPP and they're like, whoa, whoa, whoa, that's that's where I draw the line. one of the most important things we always talk to our clients about as the negative of just doing dividends is twofold. And Tyson just nailed both of them. Number one is the longevity risk that we see ⁓ clients nowadays, and I think that's gonna be even more relevant later on because science and medicine is getting better. So people are living longer but with less ideal health. So the longevity of your money is a very concerning thing. Like one of my one of my family friends, they just celebrated their grandma's 95th birthday. ⁓ my grandma lived over a hundred. Like it's it's one of those things that, you know, it's ⁓ longevity is concerning. So what you don't want to do is be running out of money in your most vulnerable years. So ⁓ a robust avenue of different streams of income, especially that are linked to inflation, very, very important. Whether you use it or not to Tyson's point is irrelevant, you can donate it later on if it makes more tax sense, but at least you're building it in the years. Because to Tyson's second point, what we find almost, you know, almost always, not fully definitive, but almost always, is that when that conversation from accountants usually comes in, it's like, ⁓ don't even do CPP, you can outperform that in your corporation. On service level, that could be true, but you know, when it comes to the behavioral finance or the you know, the qualitative side of your your finances. People may do that for a couple of years and then they stop because it's very easy to find ways to spend money. So ⁓ what we want to do is make sure that the things that your money should be going towards to build to your future is happening automatically. and then you can sp spend whatever you want later on guilt free, but at you know you're in the right things today. So ⁓ would say that's a very big myth where dividends are always more tax efficient. Again, the word always kind of give that away, but dividends are always more tax efficient is for sure a myth that we hear Almost always, honestly, when we talk to our clients' accountants, even when we do year end planning with accountants, like, ⁓ that just dividend it out, dividend it out, and ⁓ and kind of go from there. So don't we go into CPP then we'll go to the RSP room and we'll kind of break down each one. So as you kind of talked about CPP implications, ⁓ the fact that you don't get that when you do dividends, but you know, besides the fact that it opens up another revenue stream. for for doctors in retirement, while CPP relevant. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I I mean CPP is one of those things where if it all goes wrong, they make a big bet and it all goes away, it's not gonna I mean it's not gonna happen to any of our clients. But if it did, you have a guaranteed income stream in retirement that's there. you get ⁓ certain for it. So if ⁓ the main income earner passes away early, the spouse gets a survivor benefit of the CPP, to an extent. And and so there's these all these built-in safety nets that you can get there. It it's good. It's it's not a bad thing. and so I think it's something to be aware of and I think it's something to not be dismissed easily. on on the same note, I mean, we are doing retirement planning for doctors that are going to have a hundred or two hundred thousand dollars a year or three hundred thousand dollars a year that they could spend without ⁓ risking financial ruin given longevity risk and certain other things. So it's something to consider. ⁓ but a good point that you always make is it's a risk-free like rate of return, it's an income stream, it's something that you're gonna get. if you're a Canadian citizen, ⁓ it's right to receive this. We pay into it. And like are dismissing it? It seems so silly to dismiss it. And some of the information that is tied to it is really Old. It's it's like 20 years old. And so if we if we like zoom out a little bit ⁓ 2000-ish, the ⁓ CPP investment board was kind of founded and they started changing CPP from like bonds only into a stock portfolio. It was like a balance portfolio of stocks and bonds. they kind of completed that by about 2006, and then we had the GFC, the great financial crisis of 2008. CPP was cut in half, not good. bad. And this is where like the C it was the CGA at that time. It wasn't CPAs yet. They hadn't converted. So the CGA ⁓ association was saying there's not enough money in CPP to fund like our generation when we retire. but since then, the CPP investment board has totally converted the way that they do their portfolio into one of the top asset managers in the world, not in Canada, but in the world. And it's billions and billions of dollars now in CPP because of the way that they manage it, making sure that everybody has the right to receive that. There's money that's going to be received. And the way that they're growing the ⁓ the pot of money is done really, really well. So that's my investment nerd spiel. There is money that's there, it's working, it's growing. If you're Canadian, you have a right to receive it. Vishal Gill,: Yeah. I'll just tack on two things there. You know, when it comes to paying for CVP, no one likes paying for anything, and I get that. But what are you getting for the money that you're paying into it? and I think it's far too simple to just say, ⁓ okay, like I'm just investing into the government to get some kind of pension. what you're really doing is exchanging those premiums of what you're paying into the program in exchange for ⁓ a or guaranteed pension that's indexed to inflation. We keep talking about that how it's indexed to inflation. the other thing that can help you is when you look at the estate planning. way long term down the road, there's things that will cause tax problems for you, like your RRSPs. And I think that's something that there's a lot of literature about people starting understand a bit more is in an ideal world, you don't want to defer all your RRSPs or your RIF later on and then pass away. It all gets deregistered, added to your last ta last tax bill, and then your your estate has to pay huge tax and everyone's upset. Having a stable source of income that's indexed to inflation again, with your CPP, older security, things of that such. gives you a good amount of money that you can start to either ⁓ that and get tax credits and use that to offset other stuff. You can receive that money and start to, you know, redeem your your your RIF and start to withdraw money from your RSPs because you know you have this guaranteed income. So sometimes people will donate it early in their retirement from like seventy to seventy five or seventy to eighty ⁓ they're donating it, pulling money out of the RIF and then they flip it later on, stop donating it, and then ⁓ RIS a little bit Lower so the tax bill is is significantly less for their state. So there's a bunch of different reasons why it could make sense, but it goes back to the very beginning, especially in the early parts of your career. The compounding effects of you putting money into CPP are very, very, very strong. So opening up another revenue stream that you can do a bunch of different things with, why not? And it is not invested like it used to be, where for lack of a better term, it sucked. It was a bond. If if we came to you was like, hey, you're, you know, you're ⁓ an optometrist and ⁓ in Alberta and you're making a good amount of money. What we're gonna do is build you 100% bond portfolio. You're like, get out of here, man. What are talking about? And it was invested like that. So it's not invested like that anymore. But people don't know about it. They don't research it, they don't read it, they just hear, they just do dividends. Who cares about CPP? And they're like, all right, it sounds good to me. It's more money in my pocket, ⁓ but it's less money in your pocket in the future, which is very important to know. So CPP, good things, implications of CPP if you only do dividends because you're not doing your CPP contribution. So That is one of the things you want to keep in mind for that. Moving to the next one is there's also our RSPs. and those are, you know, tied into the fact of whether you do not do salary and you only do dividends, you're not opening up your RSP room. and I kind of just alluded to RSP room and RIF, so that's probably a perfect segue to switch over. So the second consideration of only doing dividends instead of salary, Tyson, is RSPs, if you want to take the audience through that. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So when you are only, you're not it like you're not paying yourself on the personal side. You're just pulling money out of your corporation, the corporation's paying the tax. Whereas if we're doing salary or a blend of salary and dividends, now your corporation's going to issue you a T slip because you are an employee of the corporation that earned income gets taxed at your personal marginal tax rate. And you're going to generate R RSP contribution room, which is a which is a good thing. It gives you a way to sweep money out of your corporation and get it into the personal pocket, which we always talk about. you're gonna get a deduction from your income for putting it into your RSPs on the personal side. So it's a tax-free move, but it's fairly tax neutral most of the time to pull money out of salary ⁓ and ⁓ contribute to your RSPs on the personal side and build your retirement nest egg. if we're doing dividends only, we have to have a valid strategy for what the retirement roadmap? How are we going to get income out? What is it ⁓ what the timeline look like? Because if they're planning on keeping their corporation open forever, are they factoring in the cost of running the corp, the accounting, the banking fees that you always talk about. just the the upkeep and the maintenance. It could be thousands and thousands of dollars. And they have a long retirement, I mean we might be talking sixty, seventy, eighty thousand dollars of fees over the duration. Is ⁓ is worked into the plan? Do they know that? so we want people to get money out of their corporation onto the personal side in a tax efficient manner and build them a kind of bulletproof retirement war chest. So they can pull the parachute and retire at any time that they want. They'll be f they'll be fully financed. They'll have money in different pots. ⁓ 'cause we haven't even talked about tax-free savings or other things. What RSP Room does though for you is if you are a incorporated professional and you're 40, 45, 50 years old and you've got a long track record of working there, you might qualify for an individual pension plan. That's not really on our docket for today, but it's essentially a supercharged RRSP program. You can stand it up. The the equation doesn't make sense for you until you're it at least in your 40s. But you get to buy back all your past service. So the actuary will do a calculation. So you've been earning high income since you were, you know, 25, 30 years old. You've been practicing for 15, 20 years. You might have a million dollars of past service contributions that you can buy. You can use your RSPs for that, and you can top up out of your corporation. So that's a huge tax-free sweep from your corp into your personal pension plan. ⁓ then You get what's called the terminal funding. So when you go to retire at 55, 65, 70 years old, you also get a large balloon payment that you can pull from your corporation to fund your individual pension plan tax-free. ⁓ it's a tax-free sweep, it's a business deduction for your corporation get onto the personal side, which oftentimes is also close to a million dollars. So you have the lifetime contributions. You have the past service contributions and then you have the future terminal funding. We're potentially talking about millions of dollars, but you can't do that you're doing dividends only. Vishal Gill,: Yeah, and honestly, I don't really have much to add there besides the fact that free options are always good. So Tyson nailed everything right on the head. And I think just, you know, for all the listeners that are out there right now, just think to yourself in your own career path. If you are not gonna have a sellable business, let's say a a private practice or you know, you you're owning a franchise owner of ⁓ or so you own a location for like FYI doctors or ⁓ your own dental practice or something. So if that is not an asset that you're gonna sell. As per your retirement plan and then use the left-hand capital gains exemption. You really just need to build up avenues to extract the wealth from the corporation to the personal side at some point. And your real goal is to smooth out your tax bill over your career as well as you can. And RSPs are a free option to that. And people oftentimes, well, it's not free because I got pay personal tax via salary. Well, to Tyson's point, it's kind of tax neutral because yes, you are going to trigger a salary. So you're going to trigger your marginal tax rate probably higher. On the personal side, they're gonna remove that same marginal tax rate when you pop that into RSP, and then you'll use it later on. So everything is about a calculation. So we can calculate how much money based on your retirement spending goals, what is your marginal tax rate in retirement going to be as you pull that money on an annual basis, in consideration your government benefits as well. So now we can calculate what the the max R RSPs or max RIF you want to have eventually. And then you have a target. Okay, cool. So I'm tax neutral and I'm not in that space where my marginal tax retirement is gonna be higher than it is in my working career. That makes sense. And then once you get to that number, you can solve it with a bunch of different other ways. But if there's a free solution or a paid solution, why not go for the free ones that's already there for you? which is your RSP in this case. So if you are doing only dividends, you're closing that door for the RSPs, and then you're only leaving yourself very expensive options down the road because You don't see it as a problem until it becomes a problem. ⁓ and then it's too late to go back. So a lot of what we do is financial planning is opening up doors and avenues because your career can change very quickly. I think all of you on the call, or sorry, all of you on the the podcast listening on whatever platform see that. Like I think your career in 2026 is very different than it was in 2024, and it'll probably be the same in 2028. So you may go back and add another, you know, thing that you can do to to add 15 to 20 percent to your revenue. So your your life could materially be different when it comes to your income. So opening up other revenue streams is of the utmost importance. Awesome. So moving to another implication. So we talked about CPP, we talked about RRSP, parental leave. So a lot of our clients are planning to start families, or they did start families, or anything kind of in between. And parental leave considerations is a part of that when it comes to, you know, salary or dividends. So it's a blind spot that almost no one plans for until it's too late. And Obviously there's a caveat. Like I I remember I had a client that we met and and ⁓ onboarded them and she's like, Yeah, you our goal the next five years is to ⁓ a family, buy a house, you know, all that kind of stuff now that I'm in the main earn income earning years, and ⁓ all that stuff was great. Three months later, ⁓ me, hey, by the way, we're having a kid. we also put a down payment in the house. I'm like, holy cow, everything changed real quick. So ⁓ obviously ⁓ we can of map out as much as possible. And you know, we have situations where clients are like, You know, a lot of doctors are kind of like that. They're very linear in in timelines where like I had a goal and I graduated this date. Now I have a goal to do this. Now I have a goal to do this. And you could be very clear-ish where it's like five-ish years is my plan that I want to do to have kids and and we can build your finances to be like that. They build up EI contribution rooms and things like that. but other times it's like it just kind of happens and either one is fantastic and a blessing. but ⁓ you if you want to plan for having a family and you're not doing any salary. It could impact you a little bit. You know, Tyson, why? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, so if you're expecting to get your like EI paternity benefits, it's based on salary earnings. and so EI is based on insurable earnings and what's reported. And need to have a track record ⁓ of income or T4A income from ⁓ your to you paying as salary and paying tax as salary. Some of the deductions that come off of there ⁓ are Then your personal taxes and then whatever other like benefits and stuff that your company might provide to you as ⁓ health benefits. but if you're paying dividends only, you don't really show up on that map, you don't have any insurable earnings that show, and so you don't get to ⁓ EI. You have to fund and finance your paternity leave yourself. We have had clients that do that, but we recommend then like having a full you know, twelve to eighteen months worth of your income needs as retained earnings in the corporation so that you can flow those monies out when you need. but again, it's another benefit that's there, that's available, that you're sidestepping because there been a lot of planning or maybe it hasn't been talked through to say like by choosing this you're foregoing these options. and I think it's not anybody's fault. We're not here to talk bad about any of our partners in the industry because they are partners, but I think about how hard it is to get an appointment with your accountant, how much do you talk to them and how much scope they really have to cover in the 25 minutes, 30 minutes that they're talking to you? It's really tough for them to cover ⁓ every and every available planning tool that's there, which is why the financial planning team comes in and we really look under the hood ⁓ and discuss options and choices with clients. Vishal Gill,: Yeah, just to add on to the counting thing, I literally just had a conversation with a client last week about this. you know, they were saying the same thing ⁓ about their accountant, and I was like, heard out, but I'm like, you know, to be fair, it's not fair professionally for you to expect them to do all these things for you because that's not their scope, that's not their specialty, and they don't have the capacity to do that. They're building a predictive practice based on your tax returns and your tax filing. And it's the same thing as you know going to your optometrist, getting your eye exam, and they're Yeah, your you know, your prescription isn't 2020 anymore. It's this. And you're like, okay, laser eye surgery for me right now. And they're like, Well, I don't laser eye surgery. Like, well, like you're my optometrist, you should also do my laser eye surgery. ⁓ it's the same kind of thing. There's, you know, certain times that you get triggered into the point of like, hey, you need to start doing financial planning. And we get ⁓ a ton of referrals from ⁓ our accounting partners for the same reason once that. triggering moment happens where their client starts getting to shareholder loan problems and things like that. They're like, hey, you know what? You could really benefit from financial planning. Go talk to this firm and they'll kind of set you up. it's the same idea when it comes to your family doctor not being your ⁓ You're not gonna go to your family doctor, book an appointment, and be like, okay, cool, like since I have you, can you just do some, you know, put a stent in for me real quick. Like, no, that does that doesn't work. So ⁓ it's also to be fair, professional to your accountant, they can't do everything all at the same time. The same as You can't do all the subspecialties ⁓ at the same time as well. but yeah, so you know, going to parental leave, I think there's a of different ways to kind of plan for it. So I know in like BC, for example, if you're a physician in BC, you get ⁓ the PDI insurance. If you opt for a C section or or if a C section happens, you can claim your disability insurance and and collect that money. And that would be on top of your EI. So you know, we had a client who took zero dollars in in EI during Her ⁓ parental leave because she was just doing dividends only. And it was one of situations that ⁓ we got engaged basically right as she was prepping for ⁓ going on to parental leave. And the only real option is use your retained earnings as kind of your parental leave. ⁓ so that was one option and it got zero dollars. We had another client who had thirty-five thousand dollars from EI. They got paid the same, they just structured their salary and their compensation differently. So one did dividends only, one paid the same amount of tax, but did a blend of salary and dividends because again. Salary trigger tax, but it went to RSPs and offset some taxes and things of that type. But earned income triggers EI and it allows you more flexibility. Again, flexibility is key in parental leave because ⁓ yes, EI thresholds for clawbacks and things like that. But for special benefits like parental leave, you don't there's a lot of exemptions for that. So you could get your $35,000 from EI and then a bunch of other things as well if you need to pull extra money from your corp or whatever. You know, it just adds another layer of your financial plan, which is great. So is also a thing that you're giving up if you're only doing dividends instead of any kind of salary. So it's the way you compensate yourself, the same $150,000 is $150,000 on your personal side. It depends how you're declaring it ⁓ when it comes to your taxes. So we got one more and then we'll we'll kind of jump into our prescription pad, just be mindful of time here. So ⁓ retained earnings. So know retained earnings something we talk about very, very, very often because our our client base is all about retained earnings. And ⁓ you know, I think that's so important to know. but the third option is kind of hiding in plain sight, which is, you know, if you just do dividends, ⁓ know, you cast the implications on your corporate retained earnings, which is your leftover money that if you put onto the personal side for those of you who don't know, that's what retained earnings are. ⁓ what is that last implication that people need to consider when it comes to dividends per salary in regards to your corporate retained earnings? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I think corporate retained earnings, I mean, well, it's funny. Sometimes we see retained earnings on the ⁓ the balance sheet from from accountants and there's actually no money there. But when there's earnings and there's money in your corporate account, there's things that we want to do with that. And I think it's a great option, right? I I a great safety net. So number one, if you have ⁓ lots of retained earnings your corporation. I think you should be investing those. I think should they should be growing tax efficiently. ⁓ and you want to make sure that they're set up properly. We have seen people get the advice that you want that money ⁓ and available. So what they do inside their corporation is GICs. GICs are not tax efficient. ⁓ so if you're earning 3% on a GIC, passive income rules inside your corporation is 50% So you're actually only earning 1.5%. on a GIC. It's not good. I think you should take your passive ⁓ or take your return retained earnings and invest those and have them grow. It's a great ⁓ chest. And so we talk about this from a couple of different points is the instance that you want to take parental leave and you've been doing dividends only, you now have a source where you can continue to dividend yourself income. ⁓ Or If you were taking a salary and dividend blend and now you're getting your parental leave, but you need a top-up because babies are expensive. Or you now you need to renovate your house, or you need to upgrade from your cool sports car to a cool minivan, which I've been telling Vashal to upgrade to. ⁓ I've been a minivan driver for like 20 years. very handy. Vishal Gill,: That's what I draw the line. Tyson Nagasaka: Having access to funds that is lightly taxed corporate dollars is is a really good option. And so some want to do that for the parental leave portion where we're talking about topping up your income, making up the difference, unexpected expenses, or the opposite is like looking future forward. You want to buy into into a clinic that you're working at. Maybe you're an associate there and now you want to be a partner. That is your war chest to buy into a practice, to build a business, to do something. ⁓ those retained earnings that you haven't spent that are in your corporation, they have a lot ⁓ optionality to them and it's a good thing. so it's just ⁓ you know, of our clients very, very responsible. with ⁓ with their money. We've got some other professions. They are high income earners and they are high income spenders. And that's wonderful, but we want you to have some money to pivot and make some really big moves. Vishal Gill,: Yeah, and I think that's a good segue into our last thing before we jump to our prescription pad ⁓ why your accountant defaults to dividends. And you know, I see this very often ⁓ ⁓ time. ⁓ and again, to be fair and transparent to to everyone, this is the reality of it. ⁓ reality is from accountant's perspective, their client spends the money throughout the year. So they don't talk to them throughout the year and then they come to them at tax time and ⁓ hey okay, Tyson, you have a $230,000 shareholder loan, which is overdrawn from your corporation. Tyson's gonna say, ⁓ my God, that's crazy on top of everything else that I spent. They're like, no, no, like you've spent $230,000 in 2025. So for tax time, we need to declare for the $230. How are we declaring? Are we doing dividends or are we doing salary? Or know, what are we doing? For most part, if you are one of those types of clients and you don't have a financial planner, you also haven't been contributing to your RRSPs. So if you do declare any of the 230 from or to a salary, then that triggers higher personal tax rate. Your overall tax rate is the same because you're getting a deduction in the corporation. It's integrated. However, that tax due is due on the personal side and you've been spending this money, but you've not kept any of it on the personal side. So if you were to declare salary of your $230,000, you need more money on the personal side to pay the tax bill. So you're gonna draw more dividends in the next year. So that's usually why we see. People doing dividends only, it's usually an indicator of the symptom of not having a good plan. It's the same thing as if you go into your doctor's office and they can check your blood pressure. Like that's usually telling me that they have some other kind of underlying issue. when we see people pay themselves just dividends, it's a a a tell of underlying symptom, which is bad cash flow planning. ⁓ So usually what happens is not your accountant is giving you bad advice. They're usually not left with any other opportunities because by the time that your taxes, R RSP season has passed. You have drawn $230,000. You have two options show it as a salary or show it as a dividend. And you're going to say, Hey, I never kept enough money on the personal side to pay for this personal tax bill. So only have corporate money. So that'll lend them to, okay, well, let's just do a dividend. Then you can pay that same same tax bill, but you're going to pay from your corporate account. And then let's try and fix it for next year. But next year's not going to get fixed. And do the same thing over and over and over again. Seven years go by, seven years of dividends, and seven years of No CPP, no RSP, no parental leave. And ⁓ it it just ends up being quite chaotic. So it's not your accountant's fault. It's a that you need to get some financial planning. So if you're one of those clients that ⁓ or sorry, one of those ⁓ you know doctors that are listening and you're saying, ⁓ wow, this all sounds like me and I've only had dividends, talk to your financial planner, build out a plan, because everything can be based on a calculation of, you know, ⁓ what your risk maximum should be, knowing what your retained corporate passive income should be, like How much money or or how long do you have until you get into these problems? And that's what your financial plan team can help you with. So, on that note, let's switch over and let's wrap up with our prescription pad before we get out of here. So, a couple questions ⁓ is we from audience. And again, as a reminder, if you want to get questions into the prescription pad on the segment to get your questions answered live, ⁓ is join Facebook group, Doctors in Canada Wealth Forum. it's gonna be linked to the show notes as well. And these are ways that you can ask your questions to get answered. On the podcast, and then we'll go further in detail on the Facebook group as well. So, question number one: knowing your RSP room. ⁓ I think we talked about that as well in our last episode of the one before that, but on set real quick is just log into your buy CRA account. it'll be on your bottom right-hand side for the most part. If you log into your computer, that's where mine is. ⁓ it'll also be on your notice of assessment. when you get your taxes completed, give it a little bit of time. It usually kicks in like a month or so after tax time is done. but your RSPs are going to be based on your last year plus any care carry forward room as well. So if you want to know your RSP room and you're like, okay, I think I may be running this issue that I've been doing dividends. I don't know if I have any RSP room, check that out. It'll be in your My Serie account on the bottom right hand side or your notice of assessment. Next ⁓ is cost CPP. So one person asks the cost of CPP, you know, how does that get paid? Because the I thought I'd just pay one side. So Tiz, you can talk about before in a little more detail about C P B contributions and and where that comes from. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So CPP contributions, you're paying, you know, it it's about eight thousand dollars a year at the maximum. So you're paying part of that corporately as the employer and you're paying part of that personally coming off of your paycheck, your salary as the employee. ⁓ you're both contributing. So, like when you have a job and if you're working for another company, you usually only see one part because they're paying their part behind the scenes and and you're not aware of it. So it's it's about eight thousand dollars a year contributions, you're paying part, corporations paying part. if you're ⁓ you're a incorporated professional, you just feel the pain on both sides. That's all. That's the only difference. Vishal Gill,: Yeah. ⁓ I would say one thing to know on there is it's a deduction on the corporate side too. So ⁓ it is always nice to get deductions whenever you can. So Tyson mentioned this, I think, three times on this episode, but it's an integrated tax plan. So ⁓ as much as everyone hates on the CRA, which there's a lot of things they don't do right, ⁓ it is also, you know, you get some deductions on that side. So whether you pay things corporately or personally, it does kind of blend out. So salary ends up not costing you as much as long as you plan for having the cash on the personal side. That's the only thing, but more or less it's the same bill, which is nice. next one ⁓ you talked about passive income. but one question we had here was about deductions. They're talking about salary. So yeah deductions. So how are ⁓ how does salary create deduction in my corporation? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, salary for your corporation is an expense. It's it's an it's an item on on the ⁓ it's a line item for your corporation that's you're paying out. Just like you have licensing subscription fees for your Microsoft or for your equipment, your staff, which is you, also an expense to the corporation. So that money gets paid out. It it gets deducted from the income in the corporation, which lowers you and maybe even lowers you below the small business deduction limit. So you're in that nice small tax bracket corporately. And then you're paying tax on the personal side, on your personal marginal tax rate. Like Vashal was just saying, it's integration. But corporately, sometimes we see strategies where, you know, a client's making $600,000 a year in revenue in the corp. Let's pay ourselves a little more salary this year to bring that threshold down. So we're at that nice eleven percent in BC small business deduction tax limit ⁓ get that efficient like tax rate. It's a nice little maneuver that you have available to you. Vishal Gill,: Yep. And the only thing I would say is, you know, salary is one of the biggest deductions that you can get and the easiest deduction you can get inside your corporation. So if you're at that point where you're over the small business limit, so you're earning like, I don't know, six hundred thousand dollars after all your other deductions. So your net income is gonna be six hundred K and you're gonna be in that general tax rate. the quickest way to get yourself in the small business tax rate is to kick over a hundred K onto the personal side via a salary, and then you'll get a hundred thousand dollar dollar for dollar deduction inside your corporation. Last question before we get out of here is going to be in regards to compensation. So ⁓ there was a person in the audience here that said they have done salary and dividends. And is it fair to assume that I can stick with this same blueprint for the entirety of my career or does that have to change year over year? Tyson Nagasaka: Think it could change. again, like we don't want to speak in absolutes because to say like this is what you should be doing, and we make a plan. I I mean the joke is is if you you want to make God laugh, you tell him your plans ⁓ that he's gonna throw a whole bunch of things at you, right? so want to have a plan. The reason that you want to have a really, really good financial plan is so you can flex away from the financial plan and always revert back to it, like revert back to the mean. ⁓ because as soon as we make a plan, that instant we have a picture and we have a roadmap for you, gonna happen. You're gonna have a new child, you're gonna get married, you're gonna get divorced, you're gonna get a new business partner, the roof is gonna blow off your house. Like something's gonna happen that was not anticipated in the plan. And is comical ⁓ and sometimes ⁓ tragic and hilarious. It's all of the things, right? So You want to have a really good plan so you can flex away from the plan but always come back to it. And you want to have a team that understands that you want to have some optionality. You want to have some breathing room built into your plan because life is going to happen. yeah, the blend of salary and dividends, it might change as you go through the seasons of your career and you're really starting to prepare for other things in the future. I think where we see people work in absolutes, you know, it's costing doctors. hundreds of thousands of dollars over their lifetime because they're trying to pay zero tax this year versus building a roadmap of tax efficient income and and reliability for their plan and for themselves in the long term. And so just to pay the least amount of tax this year, they're sacrificing things that are in the future without knowing it usually. Vishal Gill,: Yeah, really well said. And and that's hopefully a good blueprint for you all to understand the difference of salary and dividends. As we mentioned at the start of episode, that decision, if you don't make it correctly, compounded over the entire career, can have catastrophic results on your finances. So oftentimes your goal is to open up as many, you know, relevant doors as possible, as long as it makes sense of the overarching theme of your finances your career changes. The world you are in today is very different than the world you were three, four years ago. And I can promise you it'll be the same three, four, five years down the road as well. So a good financial plan goes with you as well. And if you've got some value out of this, make sure that you join our closed Facebook group to get your questions into the mailbake segment of our show. also to follow along with more education than we do on the Facebook group. ⁓ like and share and subscribe. And we will see you next time on Portfolio Talks.