She Fell In Love With A Conman And Then Disappeared

Murder Files Unsealed · Sep 5, 2026 · 42m · transcript

This episode details the disappearance of Nancy Hartz, a 71-year-old woman who vanished after beginning an online relationship with a man using several aliases. Investigation into her case revealed that her partner, eventually identified as Robert Carnegan, was a serial con artist who targeted older women for their financial assets. Through the efforts of a private investigator and the use of trick questions during phone calls, authorities discovered that an impostor was pretending to be Nancy to mislead her family. Further searches linked Carnegan to at least two other missing women…