Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Google‘s AI Protocol Ends E-Commerce?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome everyone to the Deep Dive.
- 0:02Just think about the last thing you bought online.
- 0:04You probably searched for it. Maybe you clicked on an ad or,
- 0:07you know, saw it in your social feed.
- 0:09But what if that whole model, the way we find and buy things,
- 0:13is about to change completely? We're tracking a huge shift
- 0:16here, something that could really signal the end of
- 0:18e-commerce as we know it. That's exactly right.
- 0:20That's our mission. For this deep dive, we're
- 0:22looking at Google's Universal Commerce Protocol, or UCP.
- 0:26And this is not just some minor technical update, it's a massive
- 0:31ideological shift. We're moving from person seeks
- 0:33goods to good seek person, and now into this whole new era.
- 0:38The industry is calling it the AI Intent transaction.
- 0:41That phrase right there, AI intent, transaction, that's the
- 0:44key. That's what we're really digging
- 0:45into. If you think about it, commerce
- 0:47has had these distinct stages. Stage 1 was search commerce.
- 0:50That's your Amazon, your Taobao where you have to go looking for
- 0:53the product. And then came Stage 2, which was
- 0:56recommendation commerce. That's the world of TikTok,
- 1:00where the algorithm is king. The product finds you through,
- 1:03you know, entertainment live streams.
- 1:05It works, but it needs you to keep scrolling.
- 1:07Right. And UCP is the framework for
- 1:10what comes next, Stage 3 smart commerce.
- 1:13This is a totally new game. It's dialogic, it's
- 1:15transactional. The moment of purchase moves
- 1:18from a website or an app right into a chat box with an AI.
- 1:22It's about so much more than just a faster checkout.
- 1:25It's a direct challenge to the big players who dominate online
- 1:28retail right now. OK, let's unpack the protocol
- 1:30itself. When did Google even announce
- 1:33this? It feels like it came out of
- 1:34nowhere. The timing was really
- 1:36interesting. They released it on January 11th
- 1:38at the National Retail Federation's big annual Expo in
- 1:41New York and they defined UCP as an AI driven universal
- 1:45e-commerce protocol. That's and this is the keyword
- 1:48decentralized. Decentralized.
- 1:50I mean my mind immediately goes to blockchain and crypto, but
- 1:52that's not what they mean here is it?
- 1:54Our sources say that in this context it has a very specific
- 1:57commercial meaning. It means anti Amazon.
- 1:59Exactly. It's Google's big play to
- 2:01dismantle the walled garden, that closed system where one
- 2:05single company controls everything from your search to
- 2:08the checkout to the delivery. So to challenge that, they had
- 2:10to build a real alternative, a complete one.
- 2:13A complete one. UCP is incredibly comprehensive.
- 2:17You could think of it as the ultimate checklist for
- 2:19e-commerce. It's a universal set of rules
- 2:22for how any AI agent can and should transact with any online
- 2:27seller. So what's actually on that
- 2:28checklist? It must be pretty detailed.
- 2:30Oh it covers everything. It defines all the modules A
- 2:33merchant needs to talk to an AI. Things like automatic discovery
- 2:36so the AI instantly knows what a website offers, and then all the
- 2:39basics. Cart functionality, pricing,
- 2:41checking, inventory, payment authorization.
- 2:43And it goes beyond just the buy button.
- 2:45Right way beyond. It defines the entire post
- 2:47purchase process, order management, tracking shipments,
- 2:49returns, after sales service. It even covers things like user
- 2:52management and anti fraud systems.
- 2:54It's the whole package, designed to work for a tiny independent
- 2:57shop just as well as it does for a giant like Walmart.
- 3:00And on the technical side, it's built for AIS to talk to other
- 3:03AIS. Yes, it fully supports agent to
- 3:06agent or A to a communication which is crucial.
- 3:10This let's something like Gemini talk directly to a stores
- 3:14inventory system, but it also supports traditional OPI, so
- 3:18it's flexible. OK, but here's the contradiction
- 3:20that I see. Google is pushing this open
- 3:23decentralized standard to fight Amazons closed system.
- 3:28But Google is the one writing the standard.
- 3:30How open can it really be? That is the classic Google
- 3:33Playbook, isn't it? On the surface it looks
- 3:35completely open. All the documents, all the it's
- 3:37right there on GitHub with an Apache 2 point O open source
- 3:40license any day rapper can go look at it right now.
- 3:43But there is a catch. There's always a catch.
- 3:45The sources compare it to Google Mobile Services on Android.
- 3:48What does that mean for people who aren't developers?
- 3:50It means the base layer, The code itself is free for anyone
- 3:53to use, but this is the big but. If you want to plug into the
- 3:57real value, the fire hose of customer traffic coming from
- 4:00Google search or the Gemini app, you have to be certified by
- 4:03Google. You have to pass their quality
- 4:05check and be admitted into the program.
- 4:07I see, so anyone can build with the Legos but only Google
- 4:11approved creations get to be in the main toy store.
- 4:14They control access to the customers.
- 4:16So it's open source, but with Google as the gatekeeper.
- 4:19Precisely, they're using openness to build a massive
- 4:22rival ecosystem to Amazon fast, but they keep tight control over
- 4:26quality and more imortantly over the flow of traffic at the very
- 4:30top. Which brings us to trust.
- 4:33You can't have an AI buying things for you if you don't
- 4:35trust the system. How does UCP solve for security
- 4:39and privacy? They have two really clever
- 4:41features here. The first one is called
- 4:42tokenized payment. The AI agent is basically
- 4:45blindfolded when it comes to your financial data.
- 4:47It never ever sees your actual credit card number.
- 4:50So how does the payment go through?
- 4:52Well the payment processors like PayPal or Visa, they create a
- 4:55secure one time use token. The AI just uses that token for
- 4:58validation. It's like giving your AIA secure
- 5:00voucher to use instead of your actual wallet.
- 5:03OK, that handles the financial risk, but what about the privacy
- 5:06of, well, your thoughts conversation itself?
- 5:08That's the second, and I think more radical, feature context
- 5:11isolation. This means that the conversation
- 5:14you have with the AI, the context which could be deeply
- 5:16personal, is completely hidden from the merchant who fills the.
- 5:19Order The source material has a very memorable example for this.
- 5:24Let's walk through it. It's a striking 1.
- 5:27So imagine a woman is chatting with her AI assistant.
- 5:30Maybe she's talking about a legitimate problem, like needing
- 5:32to protect some antique clothing from pests.
- 5:35Or the conversation could be about something much more
- 5:38serious, a difficult domestic issue, what the source called a
- 5:41three inch nail situation. Two very different, very private
- 5:45conversations. But in both cases the AI
- 5:48understands the user's intent is to find a solution, and it might
- 5:52recommend purchasing a tiny amount of arsenic.
- 5:55And the source adds this really important historical context
- 5:58that arsenic was actually used for things like seed coating or
- 6:00insect control in clothing in very small, controlled amounts.
- 6:04Right, so the AI processes this complex, sensitive intent and
- 6:08facilitates the purchase. But here's the key part for
- 6:12context isolation. The merchant sees none of that.
- 6:16They only get the bare bones order details.
- 6:19Someone bought arsenic? Here's when, and here's the
- 6:21shipping address. They have zero idea why the AI
- 6:24knows your needs but the seller just sees a shopping list.
- 6:27That is a fundamental shift in the power dynamic and it has
- 6:30huge commercial implications. This is probably the biggest
- 6:33reason for retailers to get on board.
- 6:35It absolutely is. Think about it.
- 6:37In the past, platforms like Amazon would hold on to user
- 6:40data, your address, your phone number, and keep it from the
- 6:43third party sellers on their site.
- 6:45They said it was for your privacy, but it was also a
- 6:47business move. Because it meant the original
- 6:49seller couldn't contact you for a repeat purchase.
- 6:51If you needed more ink for that printer you bought, Amazon would
- 6:55be the one selling you ads for ink taking a cut of that second
- 6:58sale. It's exactly with UCP that
- 7:01essential data like the shipping address goes back to the actual
- 7:04seller. This lets them provide real
- 7:07after sales service. Maybe remind you when it's time
- 7:09to buy that toner they get to own that customer relationship
- 7:12again. The source is pretty blunt about
- 7:14it. Privacy clauses often hide
- 7:16commercial interest. UCP brings that out into the
- 7:19open. So if you're a retailer, this is
- 7:21your chance to break Amazon's hold on your customers, which
- 7:24explains why so many big names are signing up.
- 7:27Who is in the club? The list of joint initiators is
- 7:30telling. It's a lot of companies that
- 7:32rely heavily on Google search traffic.
- 7:34You've got Shopify listed first, then Etsy and retail giants like
- 7:38Target and Walmart. They all want a path to AI
- 7:41transactions that doesn't go through Amazon.
- 7:43And then there are the ecosystem partners, the ones providing the
- 7:46plumbing. Right, Best Buy, Macy's, Home
- 7:49Depot and crucially all the major payment platforms are in
- 7:53Adm, PayPal, Amex, MasterCard, Visa, Stripe, you name it and
- 7:57it's even global and international, which is part of
- 7:59Alibaba is on board to enable Alipay.
- 8:02Payments. The payment companies must love
- 8:04this. It's a whole new fire hose of
- 8:06transactions for them. A massive 1.
- 8:08They get fees, but they also get the interest they can generate
- 8:11by floating that money during the payment process.
- 8:14It's a huge opportunity. OK, so we know who's in, but
- 8:17this is a fight. Who is on the other side?
- 8:19Who's refusing to join? Well, no surprise.
- 8:22Amazon explicitly refused. They are not playing this game.
- 8:26Instead, they launched their own internal AI shopping assistant
- 8:30called UFUS to keep their system a closed loop.
- 8:34Amazon's strategy seems to be to beat UCP, what the source calls
- 8:38a makeshift team with a superior, tightly integrated
- 8:42user experience. They're betting on quality over
- 8:45openness. And what about the other big AI
- 8:47player? Open AI.
- 8:48They're not just watching from the sidelines.
- 8:50Not at all. Open AI launched their own
- 8:51competing standard, the Agentic Commerce Protocol or ACP.
- 8:54It's a bit lighter weight, more tool based and they partnered up
- 8:57with Stripe. And what's really fascinating is
- 8:59that companies like Shopify and Etsy, they've joined both UCP
- 9:03and ACP, they're hedging their. Bats.
- 9:04Smart move. And then you have the disruptors
- 9:06who are trying to skip the protocol war entirely.
- 9:09Like Perplexity. Yeah, they went St. for what
- 9:11they call the Super entry point. They just built a one click
- 9:14shopping feature directly into their search and chat interface.
- 9:17How did Amazon react to that? Ferociously, they saw it as a
- 9:21direct threat. Amazon sued Perplexity for
- 9:24illegally scraping their data and immediately put up a data
- 9:27blockade to stop them. It shows just how aggressively
- 9:31they're willing to fight to protect their turf.
- 9:34So let's pull back for a second. Why is all of this happening
- 9:36right now? What's the big driver?
- 9:38It's a massive shift in user attention.
- 9:40People are spending less time just, you know, endlessly
- 9:44scrolling social media feeds and more time having these deep
- 9:47engaged conversations with AI assistants like Gemini and
- 9:50ChatGPT. And these AI companies have to
- 9:53figure out how to monetize that time beyond just a $20.00 a
- 9:56month subscription. And the way to do that is
- 9:58through intent discovery. The AI isn't just a search
- 10:01engine anymore. It understands what you're
- 10:03really trying to achieve, and then it can orchestrate A
- 10:06transaction to solve that problem for you.
- 10:08This is where it gets really powerful.
- 10:09The source used a fantastic analogy, the Manchu Han feast.
- 10:14Imagine a user just tells the AII want to cook this incredibly
- 10:18complex multi course feast for a dinner party.
- 10:22The AI agent takes that one high level intent and just decomposes
- 10:27it into dozens of smaller actionable tasks.
- 10:30So it's not just giving you a recipe, it's buying everything
- 10:33for you. Everything.
- 10:34It automatically buys all the specialty ingredients from
- 10:36different stores, it orders the right cookbooks, it finds the
- 10:39specialized knife you'll need, and it arranges all the
- 10:43deliveries. The user never has to open a
- 10:45single app or do a single search.
- 10:47The intent is stated and the AI executes.
- 10:50The business upside there is incredible.
- 10:52Conversion rates must be through the roof and the whole nature of
- 10:55competition changes. It's not about being number one
- 10:57on a search page anymore. Exactly.
- 10:59The new battlefield is optimizing for AI intent
- 11:02matching. It's about making sure your
- 11:04product is the one the AI picks when it's fulfilling one of
- 11:07these complex user goals. And for Google, the success of
- 11:10UCP really depends on them controlling those entry points,
- 11:13right? Google search, AI mode, the
- 11:16Gemini app, Any future integrations like if they power
- 11:19Siri on the iPhone, That's the lifeblood.
- 11:22That is the whole game. The uninterrupted flow of user
- 11:25intent is what makes the protocol valuable.
- 11:28So bringing this all together, what does this mean for everyone
- 11:30listening, for businesses, for consumers?
- 11:33Well, the biggest take away is that this shift to smart
- 11:36commerce driven by AI dialogue isn't some far off future.
- 11:40It's happening now. So for a business owner, the
- 11:42advice from the sources is pretty clear.
- 11:44First, get on board. Integrate immediately.
- 11:47Don't turn down new sources of traffic.
- 11:49And second, start optimizing. Figure out how to make your
- 11:52products the AI's preferred choice.
- 11:54Let's be realistic about that optimization.
- 11:56The source acknowledges that it probably won't just be about
- 11:59having the best data. There will likely be a path to
- 12:01just pay Google to increase your matching success rate.
- 12:04The Pay to Play model always finds a way.
- 12:06And for any developers listening, this really changes
- 12:09how you should think about building apps.
- 12:11Transaction capabilities need to be a core feature.
- 12:13Now, if you build a travel app, it shouldn't just plan a trip.
- 12:17It should be able to seamlessly buy the museum tickets, the
- 12:20local specialty foods, the travel insurance.
- 12:23That's what makes an app into a true agent.
- 12:25And that leads to a final provocative thought for you to
- 12:28chew on. This whole revolution might feel
- 12:31almost invisible. It will be non intrusive.
- 12:34But if these AI agents get really good at this, better and
- 12:38more efficient than we are at fulfilling our own goals, like
- 12:41that Manchu Han feast example, what does it mean for our own
- 12:45agency? What happens when we completely
- 12:46outsource our purchase decisions to an AI that is demonstrably
- 12:50better at it than we are? You just eat the goal and the AI
- 12:53handles the rest. That is a powerful place to
- 12:55leave it a lot to think about before we wrap up.
- 12:58If you are looking for ways to track the bigger market shifts
- 13:00happening during all this technological change, we'd
- 13:02recommend you search for and download the iOS app Buffett
- 13:05Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 13:07It's a great tool for daily market sentiment.
- 13:09And if you enjoyed this deep dive and want to access even
- 13:13more of our in depth analysis, please feel free to join our
- 13:16Deep Value Club membership. You can also subscribe to us on
- 13:19the Apple and Spotify Podcasts channel, Deep Value Investing
- 13:23and of course at luluvc.com. Thank you so much for joining us
- 13:26for the Deep dive. We'll see you for the next one.