Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Strange Allies: The Atheist and the Baptist (with Amanda Tyler)
Transcript
- 0:00Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast, hosted by Seth
- 0:46Andrews. My special guest today is a Christian. Amanda Tyler is executive director
- 1:03of the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty. She is also lead organizer for
- 1:08Christians Against Christian Nationalism. That's an organization I've talked about and written about quite
- 1:15a bit. She co hosts the Respecting Religion podcast and we are allies in
- 1:22the fight to protect state church separation. Amanda Tyler, this sounds like the
- 1:26start of a joke. Right, an atheist and a Baptist walk into a
- 1:30bar, or restaurant or cafe or something like that, or a zoom room.
- 1:34Right, it's great to have you. It's so nice to be able
- 1:37to talk to you here on the show. Thanks for being here. Oh,
- 1:41thanks so much for having Mesa. Before we get into the meat of
- 1:44the discussion here, here's a question that I would ask you over coffee.
- 1:49Okay, and this is somebody who I was raised in a Baptist school.
- 1:53I spent years in a Baptist church. You're a Baptist. What is your
- 1:57take on the whole Southern Baptist Convention thing when it comes to women. It
- 2:01was just a couple of three months ago something like that they ousted five churches,
- 2:06including the megachurch at Saddleback Church in California. And the reason they ousted
- 2:10them is because they had female pastors and women in positions of pastoral leadership.
- 2:17From the spc's own policy quote, the office of pastor is limited to men
- 2:23as qualified by scripture. You're a Baptist woman in a point position. What's
- 2:30your perspective on all this? Well, first of all, I think it's
- 2:35important to understand how diverse and large the Baptist movement is. People often ask,
- 2:43you know, what's the position of the Baptist Church? And I start
- 2:46by saying well, there is no Baptist church. It's not like the Catholic
- 2:50Church. It's rather a movement. Baptists are famously disorganized, So I just
- 2:54want to start by saying Southern Baptists is not synonymous with Baptist. In fact,
- 3:00the Southern Baptist Convention is not one of the supporting bodies of Baptist Joint
- 3:07Committee for Religious Liberty, the organization I lead, though it was for many
- 3:10years. I myself am not a Southern Baptist, though I was for many
- 3:16years, and so there's some complexity to this question that I into just the
- 3:21concept of what it means to be a Baptist, So let me say that
- 3:23upfront. I think, second, it's important to note that this current position
- 3:29that the Southern Baptist Convention has is not a position they have always had.
- 3:32So it's interesting for them to be so dogmatic on this issue of scripture when
- 3:38it wasn't even a position that they have always held within my lifetime, and
- 3:44so it is not a theological position that I hold. I would defend their
- 3:49right to hold that position as a matter of religious freedom. Within their denomination,
- 3:54they can make choices about who they call to leadership and I do think
- 3:59that that's something that the state doesn't have any control over, but I also
- 4:03note that their theological position. He is also coming at the same time that
- 4:10the Southern Baptist Convention is waning, in part because of the way that they
- 4:15have treated women within their denomination, not just in roles of pastoral leadership,
- 4:19but also with a number of instances of sexual abuse and misconduct. So all
- 4:26of that to say, it's a very messy situation, and I just want
- 4:30to leave your listeners knowing that the Southern Baptist Convention does not speak for all
- 4:34Baptists, and certainly doesn't speak for this Baptist. I just I want to
- 4:38make sure I wasn't This isn't a setup, right. I'm not saying the
- 4:42Baptist because we when I was being raised, it was Southern Baptist or you
- 4:46free will Baptist or an independent Baptist. You know. We see all of
- 4:49these different denominations and in different interpretations, and people do this all the time.
- 4:55They say it's about the Muslims or the Jews or the atheist. We
- 5:00tend to want to have a cookie cutter, a model or portrait of who
- 5:03and what they are. But you know, they probably almost certainly base it
- 5:08back in the New Testament out of First Corinthians. You know, the women
- 5:11should keep silent in the churches. They are not permitted to speak, but
- 5:15should be in submission. How do you approach a scripture like that as a
- 5:20Baptist, Well, I approach scripture and religion in general from a posture of
- 5:27freedom, of an idea of freedom to understand and interpret scripture on our own.
- 5:32I don't interpret scripture literally or from a fundamentalist perspective, though I understand
- 5:40that a number of people do. So I think that scripture is something that
- 5:46is open to our own interpretation and understanding, and I don't take those scriptures
- 5:54out of context. Right. I also don't believe in proof texting from scripture,
- 5:58but thinking about it as a whole and thinking about the spirit of God
- 6:02and as God as a freedom loving entity that wants freedom for us as well.
- 6:08So the God that I believe in is one that calls all people to
- 6:14different forms of ministry and that doesn't distinguish between men and women in terms of
- 6:18ability to preach and held other positions of church leadership. So you're a Christian,
- 6:25but you and I join in being critics and sounding the alarms about Christian
- 6:30nationalists. How do you define the difference? Well, absolutely, we are
- 6:35allies in this cause of working to call attention to Christian nationalism and to dismantle
- 6:43it, which is going to be decades, if not centuries, work to
- 6:46dismantle Christian nationalism from our culture. But I define Christian nationalism as a political
- 6:54ideology and a cultural framework that seeks to merge our identities as Christian and Americans,
- 7:00suggesting that to be a true American one has to be a Christian.
- 7:05And this undercuts the promise of religious freedom for all that is included in the
- 7:13US Constitution, one that says that our belonging in American society should not depend
- 7:18on what we believe, or how we worship, or how we identify religiously,
- 7:24or even if we're religious at all. And so that central idea of
- 7:28equality regardless of religion is attacked by Christian nationalism. But as a Christian,
- 7:35I also find Christian nationalism to be a gross distortion of the Christian faith that
- 7:42I hold dear. It takes the central message of Christianity, which is a
- 7:46gospel of love, and turns it into a false idol of power. But
- 7:51the Bible declares that not just a nation, any nation, but the entire
- 7:57planet really is the property of the Christian God, even after Adam was given
- 8:01dominion over all the earth. You get into the Psalm twenty four, right,
- 8:05the earth is the lords and everything in it. And so if these
- 8:09people are standing on scripture, I mean they blame perhaps biblically, that it's
- 8:16all Christian or it all should be Christian. How would you respond to that?
- 8:20Well, I think there are lots of it links back to the way
- 8:22we began our conversation today. There's so many links between fundamentalist religion and Christian
- 8:30nationalism as an ideology. Both try to use scripture in a very literal sense,
- 8:35claiming that their interpretation of scripture is the only way to interpret scripture,
- 8:41and then proof text using those scriptures to defend whatever their political views are.
- 8:46And I don't find, and millions of other Christians agree with me, don't
- 8:50find that that is an accurate depiction of our faith. The ideas of our
- 8:56faith are encompassed, and a God that loves everyone, leaves in everyone's equality,
- 9:01that wants the best for God's creation, and would not use that theology
- 9:07in one of these other iterations. You know, I think some of what
- 9:11you might be getting into is this dominionist theology, this theology that uses a
- 9:16particular scriptures as proof for a political agenda, one that would use religion to
- 9:24take over every sphere of society and use that to lord over others. That
- 9:30cuts against Jesus's command for us to love our neighbors as ourselves. If we
- 9:35love our neighbor as ourselves, then we protect their religious freedom as we would
- 9:39our own. And so it's these Christian principles that lead me to be in
- 9:43this fight against Christian nationalism and to protect your religious freedom, seth your freedom
- 9:50to choose not to be religious as zealously as I protect my own, as
- 9:54zealously as I would protect my Muslim neighbors, my Jewish neighbors, and my
- 10:00Southern Baptist neighbors for that matter. I'm struck by the performative nature of so
- 10:05much of what you and I see sort of grandstanding, you know, this
- 10:09sort of chest thumping. I'm reminded of that verse out of Matthew six,
- 10:13Jesus had said, when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites,
- 10:16for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to
- 10:22be seen by men. But when you pray, go into your room,
- 10:26close the door, and pray to your father, who is unseen a lot
- 10:31of grandstanding out there. I know you've seen it, right, I have.
- 10:33I have. And when I hear that scripture, I kept to tell
- 10:37you I wasn't anticipating so much scripture and Bible study in our conversation. This
- 10:43is what happens when you speak to an ex Christian who's been thirty years in
- 10:46the faith. We are able to sort of play in that same sandbox.
- 10:48So yeah, yeah, no, And I love conversations like these. And
- 10:54I think when I hear that scripture, how I understand how that's relevant to
- 10:58our life to day is that Jesus cares much more about how we live our
- 11:03lives than about how we perform our lives, how we live out our faith,
- 11:09not how we talk about our faith. And so I think we do
- 11:13see examples of people who would much more like to show that they're Christians by
- 11:18saying certain things or praying in certain ways than by living their life and service
- 11:24of others you actually attended. This is a bit of a digression. But
- 11:28I saw this I think on your Twitter feed. You actually attended the reawaken
- 11:33America Tour, Is that correct? I did. I went to its latest
- 11:39stop. You know. It's this traveling road show that's been all over the
- 11:43country. For interjecting, Yeah, I know. I have a lot of
- 11:48people who may not be aware of it. So before you tell me about
- 11:50your experience, please flesh it out. Was it, you know, Charlie
- 11:54Kirk or Roger Stone or the my Pillow? I mean, who was there?
- 11:56And what's the whole flavor of reawaken in America if you would so.
- 12:01Reawakened America Tour is something that started back in twenty twenty one by someone named
- 12:07Clay Clark, working closely with Michael Flynn Disgrace General Michael Flynn, and they
- 12:13have been to a number of places across the country, often in churches,
- 12:16sometimes in other community spaces, and these events draw you a few thousand people
- 12:22at each stop. It is a mix of Christian nationalism, COVID conspiracies,
- 12:30election denial with some marketing on the side. And I first became aware of
- 12:37the Reawakened America Tour back in November of twenty twenty one when it had one
- 12:41of its first stops in San Antonio, Texas at a church where Michael Flynn
- 12:46said the quiet part out loud. He said, you know, we're one
- 12:50nation under God. We should have one religion. And that caught my attention
- 12:56because, of course, at how it odds that is with the US Constitutution,
- 13:01with America's promise of religious freedom for all. And then I've been paying
- 13:05attention to these stops because I find them deeply concerning and even dangerous the way
- 13:09that they mix election denialism, COVID conspiracy, and Christian nationalism in a way
- 13:16that really could lead to more political violence in the future. And so when
- 13:22we learned that the tour was going to be at a Trump property in Miami,
- 13:26Florida, we decided at Christians Against Christian Nationalism, working with our partners
- 13:31at Faithful America, to organize a public response to have a counter witness to
- 13:39the version of Christianity that's on display at the Reawaken America tour and this guise
- 13:43of Christian nationalism. And so we did some advertising around Miami. We actually
- 13:50rented a barge that had some advertising of Christians against Christian nationalism that sailed around
- 13:54the Miami River, had some mobile billboards, had a press conference, but
- 14:00also decided while we were there to actually go into the conference itself to get
- 14:05a feel for what it was like. And yes, I saw Mike Lendall
- 14:09speak, I saw Michael Flynn, I saw Roger Stone, I saw Greg
- 14:16Locke, who's one of these Christian nationalist pastors. It was the whole crowd,
- 14:22and it was it was a constant drum beat of exactly what I've said,
- 14:26COVID conspiracy theories. In fact, when we bought our tickets, the
- 14:30first thing they said is just be sure not to wear a mask. If
- 14:33you wear a mask, you'll be thrown out of the conference. That was
- 14:37the one thing we could not bring in. And so COVID and a lot
- 14:41of mistrust of government and lies about vaccines that figured heavily in a lot of
- 14:48the programming, as did election lies, as did Trumpism, And of course
- 14:52what was uniting throughout the entire event was Christian nationalism. How all of this
- 14:58was done in Jesus his name, using kind of cherry picking some of the
- 15:03more fiery scriptures from the Bible to galvanize this crowd and at times to call
- 15:09in very thinly veiled calls for violence, which was what was so deeply concerning
- 15:15to me. And also it was deeply concerning to me to see the response
- 15:18from the crowd. I do think that the leaders very much have political aims
- 15:24in mind and are just using the language of religion to try to galvanize the
- 15:28crowd. But for the people there, I think many of them this truly
- 15:31is a religious experience. They understand that their religion and their allegiance to Trump
- 15:39is so mixed up that they have a difficult time telling the difference between the
- 15:43two. And so it was very eye opening, instructive, alarming for me
- 15:48to see this for myself. When I was in Miami last month. Do
- 15:52you remember, I'm sure you've seen the photographs from SEPAC, from a conservative
- 15:58political committee, and they had a gold idol of Donald Trump. I remember
- 16:03that, like a golden calf, and they didn't see the irony, and
- 16:08I just I still can't believe it. What was your reaction, Well,
- 16:14that's Christian nationalism right there. It merges political leadership with religious authority in ways
- 16:18that lead to idolatry. And you know, I also saw this in the
- 16:23way that they have appropriated the sacred symbolism of baptism. You know, I'm
- 16:29a Baptist. Baptism is very important to me and to my expression, my
- 16:33particular expression of Christianity. But at these Reawakened America tours, people are baptized
- 16:40in pools of water, but it's unclear into what exactly they're being baptized into.
- 16:45There's no liturgy at all, and many of them are baptized in Trump
- 16:48shirts or in qan On shirts, whatever they're wearing to the conference, in
- 16:53ways that really look like you're being baptized into a religion of Trumpism and Christian
- 16:59Nationalism, not Christianity, but in using the sacred symbols of Christianity. To
- 17:03observers, it looks like the same thing. And that is deeply troubling to
- 17:08me as a Christian, as someone who sort of didn't sneak in to Reawaken
- 17:14America that you were sort of there. Am I to understand that they forbade
- 17:18masks, but you could probably carry a firearm in there? Is that true?
- 17:22Yeah? Well, there were certainly no signs saying that you could not
- 17:26have a weapon. They did not tell us not to bring a weapon.
- 17:29There were no metal detectors. And the night before the conference started, there
- 17:34was a gathering for a new organization called Pastors for Trump. It's a five
- 17:40O one C four organization organized to intervene in the election. They had their
- 17:47first ever in person gathering. It was standing room only, crowded ballroom at
- 17:52the Trump resort, and one of the pastors who spoke from the stage after
- 17:57his speech, after he called up Michael Flynn to speak to the crowd,
- 18:03he whispered to Flynn, who then repeated to the crowd that he was packing
- 18:07at that moment. So not only do I assume people some people did have
- 18:15weapons, but this pastor bragged from the stage right after he had told a
- 18:21story about how we want our enemies surrounding us because then we can shoot in
- 18:26all directions, that he actually had a gun on him at that moment.
- 18:30And that was one of the more alarming moments of the conference for me.
- 18:34And that's what I was talking about with these calls for violence and this appeal
- 18:38to violence, which again is so against the Christianity that I know. A
- 18:44Christianity, a peace loving religion, and certainly not a religion that tells us
- 18:48to turn the other cheek, not to resort in violence. It's very different
- 18:53expression of Christianity in this form of Christian nationalism that I saw firsthand re a
- 19:00Week in America and at this Pastors for Trump event. I want to talk
- 19:07about Texas. They tried to jam in the Ten Commandments to every public school
- 19:11classroom. I'm going to talk to my special guest about Texas next, speaking
- 19:22here with executive director of the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty and the lead
- 19:30organizer of Christians Against Christian Nationalism, Amanda Tyler. I know many of my
- 19:38viewers and listeners are like wanting me to have theological discussions with you about the
- 19:44nature of God and the scriptures. And I'm sitting on the edge of my
- 19:47chair the activist in me and I'm sure the activist in you who would probably
- 19:51we could go to coffee and there would be a whole day, right,
- 19:52and it would be an amazing and pleasant conversation. But I want to stay
- 19:56with kind of where we are. Texas, they were this close with Senate
- 20:02Bill fifteen fifteen to place the Ten Commandments in all public school classrooms. It
- 20:10stalled. It missed a time deadline, it did not pass. I believe
- 20:15they have moved for chaplains, unlicensed chaplains to be school counselors. And I
- 20:19want this guy, a Christian and an ally, James Telarco, he's a
- 20:26politician in Texas, and he opposed the Ten Commandments bill because he said it
- 20:32was idolatry, nobody, no EU devout Christians, and so am I.
- 20:37This bill to me is not only unconstitutional, it's not only un American.
- 20:44I think it is also deeply Unchristian. And I say that because I believe
- 20:49this bill is idolatrous. I believe it is exclusionary, and I believe it
- 20:55is arrogant. And those three things, in my reading of the Gospel are
- 21:00diametrically opposed to the teachings of Jesus. So I'm from Texas. I'm from
- 21:06Austin actually, so this hits very close to home what's going on in Texas.
- 21:11And I was appalled when I heard about this bill that would require the
- 21:15posting of the Ten Commandments in every public school classroom. Talk about taking us
- 21:21back. This was a bad idea decades ago when Kentucky tried to do it
- 21:26and the Supreme Court said it was unconstitutional, and emboldened by some misguided recent
- 21:33opinions from the US Supreme Court, the lawmakers in Texas decided, well,
- 21:38we're going to test this court. We're going to go for broke, We're
- 21:41going to go after this bill. And a real example of Christian nationalism and
- 21:47the language they used to try to justify an educational reason for this bill,
- 21:52you know, telling lies basically that all of American laws based on the Ten
- 21:57Commandments, when there is in fact no such case to be made that American
- 22:03law is based on the Ten Commandments, and then pushing for this government sponsorship
- 22:07of religion. Talk about government picking and choosing between religions, in this case
- 22:12picking an edited version of a sacred text. Right, So that's another They're
- 22:21different versions of the Ten Commandments. Even within the Bible, there are different
- 22:25versions of Ten Commandments that Judaism uses, and even that different expressions of Christianity
- 22:30used. So the government's picking sides by picking any version of the Ten Commandments,
- 22:36and then they've picked an edited version, and then they've turned what is
- 22:41a religious text into some pseudo patriotic text. So there's so many troubling layers
- 22:48of violations of religious freedom for all in this bill, I am concerned that
- 22:53other states might pick up the mantle and might try to do copycat legislation in
- 22:59other places. And so we're ready. We're ready with our arguments, and
- 23:02we're ready to help mobilize people of all faiths and none to stand up against
- 23:07this legislation and explain why it's an attack on everyone's religious freedom for the government
- 23:12to play. Here in my home state of Oklahoma, we've got Superintendent of
- 23:15Public Instruction, Ryan Walters, and I mean he's hardcore. He's so hardcore
- 23:21that his fellow many of his fellow goopers are saying, we've got to do
- 23:23something about this guy, like he's so extreme. And so we're waiting for
- 23:27the Ten Commandments classrooms, chaplains, etc. It's interesting to me. I've
- 23:33done exercises where I see people bleed on about the necessity of displaying the Ten
- 23:38Commandments public schools, courthouse lawns, the state capitol building, etc. And
- 23:45so I say, all right, well, fine, here's I got forty
- 23:48bucks in my pocket. I'll pay you whatever's in my wallet if you can
- 23:52give me seven of the ten. And most people don't even come close.
- 23:56How much of this do you think it's just about marking territory, not about
- 24:00the commandments? For a lot of people, do you think it's just like
- 24:02this is a brand that says the Bible, Christianity, so now this belongs
- 24:07to us. You think they're just marking territory. I think there's a lot
- 24:10going on. I think that's part of it. I think part of it
- 24:12is again furthering this Christian nationalism ideology that to really belong here, you have
- 24:18to have some kind of religious identity, specifically a Christian identity, even more
- 24:25specifically a particular kind of Christian fundamentalist identity that aligns with certain political positions.
- 24:32So I definitely think that's part of it. I also think in the Texas
- 24:37example and in other examples, it's used as a distraction from dealing with real
- 24:42policy to address, for instance, education or in Texas gun control. A
- 24:48lot of times people will say, you know, well, if we just
- 24:52had more religion in the public schools, we would have less violence. But
- 24:56instead of like really putting forward some curious policies to deal with the epidemic of
- 25:03gun violence, they have this distraction of having more government sponsored religious exercise in
- 25:08the public schools. So I do think that there is quite a bit going
- 25:14on, and I do, and there is this very well funded movement that
- 25:18is pushing Christian nationalism in all different areas of our society and government. And
- 25:25this Ten Commandments Bill is one that I think some people saw as low hanging
- 25:30fruit, particularly in a state like Texas. And so it is a victory
- 25:33and one that we need to celebrate in these difficult times for it to have
- 25:38not passed. At the end of the day, if I was to move
- 25:41to Texas, I'd live in Austin, a progressive town, and the esthetics
- 25:48nice. I don't know how it is in the summertime, Texas, and
- 25:49the summer scares me a little bit. I'm sorry, I'm digressing talking about
- 25:53That's a great Austin. It's a great place, Okay, all right,
- 25:56Well, I'm glad to hear that endorsement from a native. Amanda Tyler is
- 26:00executive director of the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty. She leads the Christians
- 26:07Against Christian Nationalism. When I say leader or lead organizer, or I mean,
- 26:11what's your position with him? Well, the Christians against Christian Nationalism is
- 26:17a project of b j C. And so I call myself the lead organizer.
- 26:21But because it's really a grassroots movement of Christians who are concerned about Christian
- 26:27nationalism and called to make a public stand against it. Okay, well,
- 26:32I'm going to come back to that. I don't want to bury the lead
- 26:34too deeply into our conversation, but I want to really get into this organization
- 26:38because I'm a fan. Okay, we're seeing this rise of anti Semitism.
- 26:44We've seen a bigotry against you's since forever. But saying no, it's really
- 26:48on the rise. We're seeing it in the spotlight more and more. You
- 26:52know, the biggots often waiving Bibles. I'm not saying that anti Semitism is
- 26:56exclusive to Christianity. It certainly isn't. But I'm hearing a lot of like
- 27:00the Holocaust example, the blood curse upon the Jews. They link it to
- 27:04Matthew twenty seven. You know, his blood be upon us, and that
- 27:07excuses why God didn't intervene during the Holocaust as six million Jews were murdered.
- 27:15You're watching this rise in Jewish hate. Talk about that from your vantage if
- 27:18you would, Absolutely, I think it's important that we talk about the real
- 27:25life implications, the real world implications on our neighbors, including our Jewish neighbors.
- 27:32And it was the shooting at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh of
- 27:37twenty eighteen that was, in fact one of the main galvanizing events that led
- 27:44us to start Christians against Christian Nationalism. The shooting at Tree of Life Synagogue
- 27:48remains the deadliest attack on Jews on American soil ever. In October of twenty
- 27:56eighteen, coming just over a year after to Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville
- 28:02with hate groups marching through Charlottesville, Virginia yelling Jews will not replace us with
- 28:07tiki torches. These are violent expressions of anti Semitism, deadly expressions of anti
- 28:15Semitism. And since then we have seen a rise in the normalization of anti
- 28:18Semitism, whether it be from the repeating of tropes and hate from celebrities to
- 28:26banners being hung off highways and cities across this country. This feeling that we
- 28:30are seeing not a decline in hate, but actually a very sharp rise in
- 28:36hate, and that is in part what led the Biden administration last month to
- 28:41release its first ever national strategy to combat anti Semitism more than one hundred actions,
- 28:48and I was actually asked to be part of listening sessions that the White
- 28:52House held around that policy, in which I talked about how Christian nationalism was
- 28:59a major dry of anti Semitism. And I approach this work not only because
- 29:03of my professional work Bleeding Baptistroint Committee for Religious Liberty, my commitment to religious
- 29:10freedom for all people, my religious identity as a Christian who cares about the
- 29:15faith freedom of my neighbors as much as I do my own, but also
- 29:18from a very personal advantage point. My husband is Jewish, I am an
- 29:22inner faith family. I feel the threat of anti Semitism to my family members,
- 29:29to my friends, and it is a tragedy that we are living in
- 29:33this country now where our Jewish neighbors do not feel fully safe to live in
- 29:38our society. And so it's up to all of us to stand against it
- 29:42and to understand how Christian nationalism drives it, How Christian nationalism even when they
- 29:48appeal to quote unquote Judeo Christian values, they're really talking about Christian values.
- 29:55They're using Judeo. There is window dressing, because we see and I saw
- 29:59it at the Reawakened America tour. Even though they disinvited the most virulent anti
- 30:04Semitic speakers, there was still plenty of anti Semitism laced throughout the speeches that
- 30:10I did here. And it is this poisonous hatred that is really very dangerous
- 30:17and urgent in our country today. It's maybe a stretch. I may be
- 30:19too clever on this outsmarting myself, but you know, there's a biblical tradition
- 30:25that the Jews, descended directly from the ancient Israelites, are the chosen people.
- 30:30I feel of temperature of that from Christian nationalists. We are the chosen,
- 30:34we are special, We're first class. Everybody else's second class. Am
- 30:40I trying too hard, Amanda, No, not at all. In fact,
- 30:44BJC hosted a program recently with doctor Katherine Breckas a lecture called the Myth
- 30:51of American Chosenness, and this idea that this myth of chosenness that really is
- 30:56this revisionist, made up history, that God has a special plan for the
- 31:03American people in God's plan for the world. It is a dangerous ideology because
- 31:10it does create special citizenship for Americans and specifically for American Christians. Above everyone
- 31:18else. And as a Christian, it goes against you know, that famous
- 31:22passage in John three sixteen doesn't say that God's will love the United States.
- 31:26It says God's will loved the world right. And so it is against the
- 31:30gospel of God's love for everyone to single out the United States as having some
- 31:37special place in God's plan. And I think that you're right. For God
- 31:42to have selected the United States over the Jewish people also carries with it some
- 31:48inherent anti Semitism and just that idea, and inappropriating that idea for this again
- 31:56political ideology of Christian nationalism. I'm sitting on the edge of my chair again,
- 32:00Amanda, because you know, I look at the Bible and I think,
- 32:05well, you know, the best version of Jesus is amazing. But
- 32:08I also realized that, I mean, there are conditions, and there are
- 32:12pretty harsh penalties for those who don't tow the line, you know, for
- 32:15those who don't drop to their knees and confess and accept, etc. And
- 32:21so I love this version of Jesus, but I can't help but wonder if
- 32:27we I don't know, if fashion our own gods sounds. I don't mean
- 32:30for that to sound condescending in any way, but I feel like we have
- 32:34gods that sort of ring true to our values. Your Jesus is an amazing
- 32:39Jesus. Is that the Jesus of scripture, you know, the God that
- 32:44created hell and that's separated the sheep and the goats and said, depart from
- 32:50me, all you who are cursed, into the lake of everlasting fire.
- 32:53I mean, let's go into the weeds for a second. How do you
- 32:57reconcile that. Yeah, I think this is a beautiful conversation, and I
- 33:01think it calls into how personal theology and religion is to me and to many
- 33:08other people. But my understanding, my experience of Jesus, my understanding of
- 33:14religion, is a religion of love, of love that God has for me
- 33:19that is not special and above the love that God has for every living thing,
- 33:23And that Jesus is God's expression of God's love for the world. That
- 33:30Jesus would come and live among us and live a human life and experience all
- 33:36the things that humans experience, and that we can feel a special closeness and
- 33:42kinship with God because of the incarnation of God in the person of Jesus.
- 33:47But of course Jesus all also gives us this amazing example of what it means
- 33:53to show the love of God to every person that we meet. If we
- 33:59really were to follow the example of Jesus, and not just the teachings that
- 34:02he left us, but the example he left us of how he lived his
- 34:07life, I believe the world would approximate God's wish for the world, God's
- 34:13kingdom on earth if we truly lived the way that Jesus lived. So that's
- 34:16how I understand that Jesus and the Bible and the scriptures and the stories and
- 34:22the work. I'm not trying to say that the Bible, as a piece
- 34:28of many books, right, is not one book. I do not believe
- 34:32that. In the literal interpretation of scripture, I do not believe that it
- 34:39is one. There's all kinds of human intervention in Scripture in many different ways.
- 34:45So I'm not trying to say that the Bible is not an uncomplicated text,
- 34:51and I think it deserves serious reckoning and reconciling. But that's that's the
- 34:55work of religion and the work of a lifetime. So that that's my personal
- 35:01I'm not coming after you. I just as we're talking about this is the
- 35:06kind of stuff that goes on in my mind. And I'm just like,
- 35:07oh, that'd be interesting to talk about. There's a welcome it okay,
- 35:13good, good, Well, I don't want to be that guy I saw
- 35:16and I've seen this phrase or sentence out there. The cruelty is the point
- 35:22Trump DeSantis. Many of these hardcore Christian nationalist types are cruel toward their fellow
- 35:30human beings, toward non Christians, toward LGBT people, toward people of foreign
- 35:35nations. And this seems to be the version of strength that you know,
- 35:40there are some people who think, well, you need to go in and
- 35:45throw your weight around, and if you don't, you're weak, and if
- 35:47you're weak, you're a loser. It's very Trumpian. I'm just just cruelty.
- 35:52Can we talk about that, Amanda? Yeah. I mean I think
- 35:55you're right. I think it's awesome. I think it's hard to talk about
- 35:59the kind of girl you're talking about without talking about power, about using power
- 36:02in ways that oppress other people. And you know, since we're having this
- 36:08really rich theological conversation and you've invited my views on how this Christian nationalism departs
- 36:16from how I understand Christianity. You know, Jesus was someone who is always
- 36:21on this side of the oppressed, the marginalized. Jesus was never on the
- 36:25side of power. Jesus was not a cruel person. Jesus was executed by
- 36:30the state for speaking truth to power by threatening the status quo. So this
- 36:36cruelty that I do think that you aptly name is at odds with Christianity,
- 36:42and then to use the language of Christianities, the symbols of Christianity to justify
- 36:47it. I mean, the image that's popping into my mind is Trump with
- 36:52the Bible in front of Saint John's Church outside of Lafayette Square, right after
- 36:58he had cleared the where of peaceful protesters using chemical agents. You know,
- 37:05the sense of trying to justify that cruelty in the face of peaceful First Amendment
- 37:10protest, and to do so with a holy symbol was deeply offensive to Christians
- 37:19all over the place, right, And so I think that that sense of
- 37:22cruelty is part of what is driving the righteous outrage that many people feel about
- 37:30Christian nationalism and the impact on our neighbors. It would be interesting to see
- 37:36Jesus arrive in the United States in the year twenty twenty three, right,
- 37:39and the immigrant of color. How might that Jesus be treated today? You
- 37:45know, I don't know, it's hypothetical. Okay, how are we doing?
- 37:50Have I lost you? As the whole idea of being friends and allies
- 37:54with religious people that driving you crazy. I'm going to talk about Christians against
- 38:00Christian Nationalism, the organization, who the power players are, how we might
- 38:06be able to join them in the fights. Hang on, my patrons,
- 38:15get the broadcast early and commercial free. You have no idea how much of
- 38:20a difference it really makes when you become a patron. You set the amount,
- 38:23you set the terms, and you have my thanks. Patreon dot com
- 38:29slash Seth Andrews. Continuing with my special guest Amanda Tyler, executive director of
- 38:37the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty and lead organizer of Christians Against Christian Nationalism.
- 38:46Tell me about Christians against Christian Nationalism. I mean, you got Baptist
- 38:52ministers, you got Catholic women leaders, which the Catholic Church I think would
- 38:57be weird about. But okay, you've got reverends representing what Presbyterian and Episcopal
- 39:02Church of Christ. Lutherans you've got theology professors, higher ups, mega pastors.
- 39:08I mean Tony Campolo's a preconfranchise player, right, He's a big name.
- 39:12This is an amazing thing that you guys are doing. Splash it out.
- 39:15Christians against Christian Nationalism now, Christians against Christian Nationalism is a growing movement
- 39:23of Christians, both clergy and lay, who are committed to calling out Christian
- 39:30nationalism as an urgent threat to democracy and as a perversion and distortion of our
- 39:37faith. And the names that you've named there are some of our early endorsers
- 39:40of the project, but they represent We're now up to more than thirty three
- 39:45thousand Christians who have joined our movement. And what makes our project distinct one
- 39:52is it really does represent a broad diversity of Christian expression in this country,
- 39:59urban all suburban. More than six dozen different Christian denominations are represented among the
- 40:06signers, so it's really across the ideological spectrum. We have signers in every
- 40:10congressional district in this country and it's all open source. The list is public
- 40:15on the website and so it can be It is meant to be a tool
- 40:21and organizing tool for people in local communities to find like minded Christians who are
- 40:28likewise concerned about Christian nationalism and try to push back against what they're seeing in
- 40:32their communities. And we started the project. Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty,
- 40:38the group that I lead organizes the project. We started it in twenty
- 40:43nineteen and we are in the next phase of the project where we're really scaling
- 40:49it for growth and impact. And our next way that we're scaling it is
- 40:52to really go into local organizing, and we are piloting our first local organizing
- 40:58project in North Texas, so just south of the Red River from where you
- 41:01are, where we are going to be hiring an organizer and working to work
- 41:07with people on the ground, not just Christians, but also with our allies,
- 41:10allies who are non religious, allies who are from different faith traditions.
- 41:15How can we raise our collective voice and our diverse coalition to push back against
- 41:22Christian nationalism as it is showing up in our local communities. Because we know
- 41:27what's happening on the national level, it's happening on the state level, but
- 41:30where it has the most impact is when it happens in our neighborhoods, When
- 41:34it happens at our schools, when it happens at our school boards, when
- 41:37it's happening with violence in our communities, and we want to make a difference
- 41:42on the ground. And so I hope you can hear the passion in my
- 41:45voice, the commitment that we have to this project, to really making a
- 41:50difference, into finally making some progress on dismantling this poisonous ideology. And it's
- 41:55important. I think that people like you and I share the same space talk
- 42:00in this way. You know, we tend to, especially in the age
- 42:02of the Internet, we like to talk about people and bumper stickers, you
- 42:06know, we make these tiny cookie cutters and labels and you are this.
- 42:09And you know Christians have done it to atheists, and you know other religions
- 42:15and atheists have done it to Christians. Another way. People do it to
- 42:17people. Tribes do it to each other in grouping out grouping. And I
- 42:21just think by having a shared humanity and having this shared sense of values,
- 42:27you know, I Greta Osper is a reverend up in Canada, and she's
- 42:30got this great line that's values are more important than beliefs, and I think
- 42:37I hold to that. You know, you and I are on the side
- 42:38of humanity. Do you ever get any hardcore types who give you beyond the
- 42:43cranks and the trolls and all those people. Do you ever have people who
- 42:45say, well, you guys aren't true Christians? Yeah, this bad,
- 42:49this enterprise, you guys, this is not true Christianity. You've betrayed the
- 42:52faith. You ever get that? Oh? Sure, I mean there are,
- 42:57Because that's part of what Christian nationalism does to people. It says that
- 43:00there's only one way to be Christian. So this idea, of this beautiful
- 43:04diversity of Christian expression is that whole idea is something that they reject. So
- 43:08I'm not surprised when they say that, and so I don't treat them in
- 43:14kind. I don't say, well, you're not a real Christian. In
- 43:16fact, I honor that that's their Christian expression. But what my calling is
- 43:22to help organize and those of us who view Christianity differently and who have concerns
- 43:28about Christian nationalism, for us to take our rightful place in the public square
- 43:31to push back. And I am in spaces a lot with people who are
- 43:37from other faith traditions and from people who don't claim a faith tradition at all.
- 43:42You know, from a theological perspective, this is something that Baptists have
- 43:45been doing for centuries, and part of it is because we think that we
- 43:49have freedom of choice to say yes to God, and our yes to God
- 43:52is meaningless if we don't have the opportunity to say no. And so we
- 43:57stand up for everyone's opportunity to say yes or no to God. Right,
- 44:00that's again from our theological position. So being in spaces like this today,
- 44:06and I also wanted to highlight our work with the Freedom from Religion Foundation that
- 44:10we did on a report on Christian nationalism in January sixth, and I think
- 44:15it's important for us to come together because I recognize that people from non religious
- 44:22tradition, you know, from atheists, agnostic humanists, they are often the
- 44:25ones who are most attacked in our country under Christian nationalism, in addition to
- 44:30other impacted groups. And so I think it's important for Christians to stand up
- 44:36and explain that our religious identity has nothing to do with our belonging or should
- 44:40not have anything to do with our belonging in American society. If there's anything
- 44:45that I can do to help support you, like if there's ever an extra
- 44:47seat for a heath. Then on the bus and I'll sit on the bus
- 44:51next to you. You and I will shoulder to shoulder. You know,
- 44:54I think I often phrase it this way. I'm weary. I was telling
- 44:59Natalie, I'm aie of so many people out there who simply don't want to
- 45:01share this world. Like there's room for all of us, there is space
- 45:07for all eight billion of us, and yet so many simply don't want to
- 45:09share this world. And I fight despair and I fight burnout, and I
- 45:15wonder, well, are we just circling the drain? How do you overcome?
- 45:19I mean, obviously you have optimism, how do you push through that?
- 45:22As we wrap up, well, I feel like we're making progress,
- 45:27right, There's so much to do. But I just think even as having
- 45:30this conversation, having a national conversation about Christian nationalism, that's progress, you
- 45:36know. James Baldwin said, not everything that is faced can be changed,
- 45:40but nothing can be changed if it's not faced. And so I feel buoyed
- 45:45every time we face Christian nationalism in the face right and in the eyes and
- 45:50say no, not today, we are going to join together. We're going
- 45:52to join together across all different kinds of difference, and we're going to stand
- 45:58up for this religious freedom tradition that has enriched our country and that can enrich
- 46:02everyone's lives. So I am not naive about how hard this fight is,
- 46:07but I'm convinced that it's the fight that we need to be in. And
- 46:12I'm pleased to be on the bus with you, Seth. I think this
- 46:15is work that we can do together. Yeah, and I want people to
- 46:17see us as an example. I mean, Amanda, Seth, we are
- 46:22in this way, We're allies, and we share this world. And I
- 46:25think it's been amazing and it's been an honor being able to speak with you.
- 46:29Amanda Tyler, Executive director of the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty.
- 46:34I'm going to include a link to Christians against Christian Nationalism and that Insurrection study,
- 46:39the January sixth study that you were a part of, because it's huge
- 46:44and I think it's probably the definitive work on what that day represented, especially
- 46:49tied to Christian nationalism. So I'm going to tie people to you and your
- 46:52work. You've been amazing. Thanks so much for talking to me. Oh
- 46:55thank you. Following aist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts
- 47:01and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo,
- 47:07links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and
- 47:12conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com