Latest / Worderella Reads with Belinda Kroll / 19 | Mr. Gardiner a.k.a. the uncle who out-parents everyone
Transcript
- Hello, Kindred Spirits.
- This and all episodes of Wordarella Reads is, sponsored by my patrons over at the Society of Kindred Spirits.
- If you're a patron, thank you.
- I love you.
- If you're new here, my tiers are three, five, and $9 monthly, and they were recently modified because, the economy is bonkers.
- So I hope it helps because I appreciate so much how you guys support me.
- All right, let's begin.
- So last time we talked about Mr.
- Bennet and how he might be the worst dad in Pride and Prejudice, and then a couple of you wrote in, and honestly, even as I was talking about it, I thought, gosh, well, it's a good example.
- And I thought, okay, well,, who is the good one? Is there a good one in Pride and Prejudice? Because surely Auntie Jane could give us at least one father figure who isn't a walking cautionary tale, right? And she does, but it's not, technically speaking, a father figure of one of the main characters.
- He's an uncle.
- He's in trade.
- And he is, I would say, pretty clearly doing a better job raising both his own kids and the Bennet daughters from the sidelines than their actual dad is doing from the head of the table.
- I will say more.
- That is a hot take.
- Go with me on this.
- I'm talking about Mr.
- Gardiner, and today I wanna walk through exactly what he does that Mr.
- Bennet doesn't, and then because I can't help myself, I wanna drag Mary Bennet into this because I think what happens to her and the other Bennet sister makes sense, but only if you understand what, like, a Gardiner-style house would offer to someone like Mary.
- But first, before we go down that rabbit hole, Mr.
- Gardiner.
- Mr.
- Gardiner doesn't get a ton of page time in the actual Pride and Prejudice book.
- He is a pivotal character.
- He is Mrs.
- Bennet's brother.
- He lives in Cheapside, and he's in trade, and that was kinda the three main things we know about him.
- And in this world, that's basically Auntie Jane's shorthand for not quite, not quite respectable enough for, Mr.
- Darcy's aunt to approve of, the venerable Lady Catherine de Bourgh.
- And Caroline Bingley even sneers at the thought of him.
- So everything about the Pride and Prejudice story sets up Mr.
- Gardiner to be a little beneath the Bennets socially.
- But here's the thing.
- Then Auntie Jane makes him the most competent adult, in the entire book, if you ask me.
- And I think that's the thing that I love about it.
- Competence is not loud.
- Competence shows up, gets the job done, moves on.
- We love a confident and competent person.
- Mr.
- Bennet's failures are pretty loud.
- He's got these one-liners.
- He hides in his library.
- We have that, "You've delighted us long enough" line that cuts Mary to the bone.
- Mr.
- Gardiner doesn't really get a signature bit the way Mr.
- Bennet does.
- Mr.
- Bennet has this sharp wit, and that's why we know him.
- But Mr.
- Gardiner, he just kinda shows up, and he shows up consistently in the moments that matter.
- And I think that's exactly why we undersell him, because Auntie Jane did not hand him a personality quirk that you could just, turn the page and hope you get to see again.
- She just gives him actions.
- And they are some very interesting actions.
- So let's take a look.
- So first, he takes Lizzie traveling So the trip to Derbyshire, the trip to Pemberley, actually, that is because of Mr.
- and Mrs.
- Gardiner, right? He and his wife invite Lizzie.
- They treat her like a person.
- They invest time into their relationship with her, and, they don't treat her as just, a daughter or a niece to marry off.
- And this matters more than you would think because what Mr.
- Bennet has offered his daughters in terms of experience is exactly zero.
- Like, nothing.
- He keeps them at Longbourn their entire lives, and Lydia, being the social butterfly that she is, begs to go to Brighton, and his response, I mean, he basically, just gives a shrug and lets her go, without supervision because supervising takes effort, and effort is not really his thing.
- He just wants to be philosophical and sit in his library and read and look over his glasses pointedly, so that way you know that he's judging you silently.
- I do love Mr.
- Bennet, but again, in terms of great father figures, I don't think he's at the top of the list.
- But then we have Mr.
- Gardiner, the uncle, and he brings Lizzie somewhere on purpose intentionally.
- And that trip is actually the one that puts Lizzie back into Mr.
- Darcy's path, at the right moment, by the way.
- Mr.
- Gardiner has impeccable timing.
- Not that he knows it.
- He's just a really nice, thoughtful, down-to-earth guy doing a good job, working hard to support his family.
- But it's so interesting that even though he is actively not trying to matchmake, his actions set up the, most important turning point in Lizzie's romance because her uncle took an interest in her, where her father didn't, at least not in that way.
- And then secondly, we have Lydia.
- Ugh, Lydia, oh, Lydia.
- So she runs off with Wickham, and who handles it? It's not Mr.
- Bennet.
- Mr.
- Bennet runs to London.
- He's not used to really doing anything, so he just kinda flails around and is like, "Oh my God, I have to do something.
- I don't know how to What do I do? My daughter has shamed the family, and I, I don't even know where to look."
- And then he comes back home.
- Mr.
- Gardiner He does live in London.
- He lives in Cheapside, so I'm sure from a cost-effective standpoint, it makes more sense for Mr.
- Gardiner to continue the, search for Lydia.
- But, he's the one that actually pays Wickham to make the marriage happen, or at least that's what we're led to believe, right? I don't wanna act like spoilers for a 250-year-old book, but Mr.
- Bennet assumes that Mr.
- Gardiner spent the money and the time on the family's behalf to bring them out of this potential shame grave.
- And he's visibly relieved that he didn't have to feel the full weight of his own I don't know.
- Negligence feels strong, but just the way of his own, inattentiveness because he had his wife's brother to come in and quietly clean it up.
- And I think that's such an interesting pattern with Mr.
- Gardiner.
- He very routinely does the unglamorous, expensive, exhausting work of actually parenting.
- He shows up, he fixes, he pays for things, and he gets none of the credit because he's not the one with the funny lines or the built-in, narrative of being the father figure.
- Where Mr.
- Bennet gets to be the character that we quote.
- Mr.
- Gardiner, he's just a guy who solves all the crises.
- Wait for it.
- I can't believe I'm gonna say this, but Mr.
- Gardiner is a guy who solves all the crises that Mr.
- Bennet's whole parenting style created.
- Oof.
- Oh, I feel mean even saying it.
- Ugh.
- Okay.
- All right.
- Moving on.
- So I think what kinda separates them isn't really, money or class even though the book keeps pointing to that.
- The book keeps saying, "Oh, yeah, Mr.
- Gardiner has more money than Mr.
- Bennet," and stuff like that.
- But I think it's attention.
- Mr.
- Gardiner pays attention.
- He notices Lizzie's wit, and he, engages with it instead of just, being amused by it from a distance.
- Mr.
- Bennet likes Lizzie's wit and he does say that she's his favorite, but he doesn't really invest in her.
- He just kinda sees her as this funny, witty creature that he can lock eyes with over the dinner table while his wife is being ridiculous, or, or, or Mr.
- Collins, right? But Mr.
- Gardiner invests.
- He enjoys being around her.
- He develops an interest in her and helps her develop a sense of self by traveling away from the family and getting to actually be around people like Lady Catherine de Bourgh, Mr.
- Darcy, and Colonel Fitzwilliam.
- And it's What's really interesting too is once you start looking at the family through, hey, who actually pays attention, you kinda can't stop, and you realize it's not just the fathers.
- Look at Mrs.
- Bennet and Mrs.
- Gardiner, and you kinda get the same contrast all over again, right? Mrs.
- Bennet is loud about her daughters.
- She wants them married.
- She talks about it all the time.
- She has nerves.
- She's this walking volcano of anxiety that her husband's gonna die, and it's gonna be her and her five daughters on the streets, which is absolutely a legit thing to be amazingly afraid of, especially given the era.
- And like on paper, this can look like devotion, but again, it's devotion to an outcome.
- It's not a devotion to helping the girls become themselves.
- And again, that's not necessarily, what parenting was back in like 1816 except for the fact that we do have historical records about how Jane Austen's father, invested time and energy and spent money buying this expensive diary because he knew she liked to write and think and read.
- So I think Jane had examples of parenting and parents who invest in their children, and then also got, getting to witness parents who, you wondered why they had children in the first place other than, not like they had really great, birth control options back then.
- So you know, I think it's just really, it's just really interesting.
- Mrs.
- Bennet, she doesn't know that Mary needs anything other than more piano practice.
- She doesn't no- she doesn't even notice that Lizzie and Darcy are like noticing each other, are interested.
- There's a slow burn happening like three feet away from her, and she is just flipping out about Jane and Bingley, and it's not until everything resolves between Lizzie and Darcy that she realizes, what? My daughter bagged a guy that makes five times as much as the guy that my other daughter bagged.
- What are you talking about? Oh my God, I'm brilliant.
- No, you're not brilliant.
- You're just really loud, and you're not really paying attention.
- Mrs.
- Gardner is quiet.
- She is the one who asks Lizzie about Wickham early on and says, "Oh, something's kinda off about this guy.
- He's really confident talking about other people and their father dying in a town where no one really knew anything about this family, except that they thought that- You know Mr.
- Darcy was a prick.
- She's the one that Lizzie can talk to honestly, about her own confused feelings about Mr.
- Darcy.
- She could never talk to Mrs.
- Bennet like that because Mrs.
- Bennet's not a safe circle.
- You can't talk to Mrs.
- B- You can't say to Mrs.
- Bennet, "Okay, so there was this morning where I had this headache, and we don't have ibuprofen and Tylenol at this time in human history.
- So I'm just sitting there with a headache, and Mr.
- Bennet, Mr...
- Mr.
- Bennet.
- Oh my God.
- Mr.
- Darcy walks in and is like, 'Hey, I hope you're feeling better.
- So actually, I came here to propose to you.
- I, uh, I, I don't like your family.
- Actually, everything about your family and your situation is beneath me.
- But in spite of all that, I love you, and I want you to marry me.'
- And then on top of all that, he got pissy with me when I said no.
- And I still have that headache.
- What do I do, Auntie?" Could you imagine sitting there and watching Mr.
- Darcy come in and pace the room, and you're like, "I just, I just, I just finally got some tea, and my headache was just starting to go away, and now here's this dude making it all about him."
- If Mrs.
- Bennet heard that, she would have started screaming, "What do you mean you said no? That man makes 10,000 a year.
- You go turn right back around and you get on your knees and you beg him to take you, even if he could be, like, the most foul human being on Earth," right? So but Mrs.
- Gardiner just, she just listens.
- She listens and she's interested and she asks a couple questions, but she doesn't tell Lizzie what to do.
- She very much is the, the mother figure that I think a lot of people hope for, which is someone who is there to hear you out, ask questions, so that you have the ability and capacity to make a choice that you hope will be in your best benefit, The Gardiner house, like both of Mr.
- and Mrs.
- Gardiner, they turn their attention as a way of showing love and affection and intention, whereas the Bennet household everything runs on attention, that attention as a form of performance.
- So no wonder Mary starts to bloom, when she moves to London to be with the Gardiners is because out of nowhere she goes from not having any attention paid to her at all, and being told, after she's played the piano too long and she's trying to show how she can be up there, right there with all of her other witty and pretty sisters, and then her dad comes along and says, "That, that'll do.
- You've delighted us long enough," and she's just trying to participate in this crowd of people that she doesn't know how to interact with.
- And that's the thing.
- Again, like Mr.
- Bennet, oh my God.
- Making a joke like that in public, that's not just neglect.
- That's like cruelty dressed up as a joke, which is, a major pet peeve of mine.
- And so while Mr.
- Bennet is witty, he, he is not, he does not have, It's not like he doesn't harm anyone.
- He has victims, right? Mary does not know how to laugh things off.
- That's not how her mind and heart work.
- So I think what's really interesting is then, okay, so let's pull Mary out of Longbourn, let's put her into Cheapside with the Gardiners.
- That's where she meets Tom Hayward and the other Bennet sister, right? And that was probably 100% intentional, right? The whole thesis of the book is Mary doesn't become capable of being loved because she gets prettier or wittier or, suddenly interesting in, like, a Lizzy sort of way.
- It's just because, someone finally puts her somewhere where she can just be taken seriously as a person instead of the family's default joke.
- The Gardiners don't fix Mary.
- They just stop being the Bennets, which then gives her space to grow into herself.
- And so it's interesting 'cause, if you put that next to everything that the Gardiners do for Lizzy and for Lydia, and, everything Mrs.
- Gardiner offers just by proper active listening, it starts to look less like a coincidence and more like a role that this whole couple plays in the family story, which is they're the adults who actually see these girls.
- Instead of casting them as characters in somebody's, like, private comedy or as the, reason for why, the mother has nerves, they're just there to pay attention.
- Maybe that's the trick.
- Just pay attention.
- Pay attention and give them room to think and speak and try stuff out and be a safe spot to land when mistakes are made so that they can learn and do better next time or be safer next time Mr.
- Gardiner doesn't have, like, all these amazing one-liners, and he does not have a ton of humor built around him.,
- And his wife is, barely in the book, but when she is in the book she is there laying down wisdom, and active listening, and,...
- When she's there, she is there.
- And so between the two of them, they are proof that Pride and Prejudice does know what good, attentive parenting looks like.
- It's just handed to the aunt and uncle from Cheapside instead of the couple running Longbourn.
- And once again, there you are, Auntie Jane being sneaky.
- making you notice that eventually who's doing the actual work.
- So I don't know.
- I wanna hear what you guys think about this.
- Who's, your favorite quietly competent side character in a book, the one who's doing all the, unglamorous work where someone gets, the, someone else gets all the credit? I would really like to hear your thoughts on, one, Mr.
- Gardiner, how I've pitted him against Mr.
- Bennet.
- Two, are there other examples of characters who, are quietly competent, but without them the book literally, the story wouldn't resolve? All right.
- Yeah.
- Anyway, that's it for me this week.
- For everything else, the monthly broadsheet newsletter, the community, what I'm reading next, just jump over to wordarella.com/links.
- That's, it has links to everything, my Shopify, my Amazon, my books, just every s- every little thing that you could potentially want to connect with me about, go to wordarella.com/links.
- I'll talk to you guys soon.