Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPOs Use Earnings Calls to Defend Their Valuations
Transcript
- Lucas: If you've listened to a post ipo tech company's earnings call recently, you've probably noticed something: the CEO spends a lot of time talking about metrics that aren't in the GAAP financial statements. Adjusted EBITDA, non gaap gross margin, free cash flow excluding one-time costs. And there's a reason for that. Luna: Because the GAAP numbers don't always tell the story they want to tell, right? Lucas: Exactly. And in this market — where we've seen the S&P 500 dip and big names like Apple and Microsoft down three to five percent in the last week alone — post ipo companies are under a microscope. They need to defend their valuations every quarter. Luna: So the earnings call becomes a tool. Not just a report, but a pitch. Lucas: Right. A Harvard Business Review study from last year looked at earnings calls from about 400 post ipo companies. They found that companies that emphasize forward-looking metrics — things like revenue guidance or adjusted EBITDA margins — see about fifteen percent less stock volatility in the five days after the call. Luna: Fifteen percent less volatility. That's meaningful for a stock that just went public and doesn't have a long track record. Lucas: Exactly. And it makes sense. If you're an institutional investor looking at a company that's only been public for six months, you don't have years of quarterly data to benchmark against. So the management team has to fill that gap with narrative and context. Luna: But isn't there a risk that they're just spinning the numbers? I mean, adjusted EBITDA can be a pretty flexible concept. Lucas: It can be. And that's the tension. The SEC has rules about non gaap metrics — they have to be reconciled to GAAP, and they can't be misleading. But there's a lot of gray area. Take Palantir, for example. Their stock is down about six percent in the last five days, and on their last call, they emphasized adjusted free cash flow margin, which was strong. But their GAAP net income was negative. Luna: So they're pointing to the metric that makes them look healthier. And if investors buy it, the stock might stabilize. Lucas: That's the strategy. And it's not unique to Palantir. Airbnb did something similar on their last call. They're down about one and a half percent in the past week — not as bad as some, but still off. They focused on non gaap EBITDA and talked about market share gains in international markets. They gave specific numbers: adjusted EBITDA margin of 38 percent, up from 34 percent a year ago. Luna: So the message is 'we're growing profitably, even if GAAP net income doesn't show it yet.' Lucas: Exactly. And for a company that's only been public since 2020, that kind of framing can be really powerful. It tells investors: focus on the cash generation, not the accounting noise. Luna: But here's the thing I wonder about: do investors actually buy it? Or do they see through the adjusted numbers? Lucas: That's the million-dollar question. There's some evidence that the market is getting more sophisticated. A study from the University of Chicago found that the average post ipo company that uses aggressive non gaap adjustments sees a negative stock reaction within six months, as the adjustments become clearer. Luna: So the market eventually catches on. Lucas: Eventually, yes. But in the short term — those first few quarters — the earnings call narrative can have a big impact. And that's why companies invest so much in crafting it. They're not just reporting results; they're managing perception. Luna: So what should a listener look for on the next earnings call? What's the tell? Lucas: One thing I watch for is how many adjustments are being made. If a company has a long list of one-time costs that they're adding back — restructuring charges, stock-based compensation, acquisition-related costs — it can be a red flag. Especially stock-based comp, which is a real expense, even if it's non-cash. Luna: Right, because if you strip out stock comp, you're ignoring the dilution that shareholders are experiencing. Lucas: Exactly. And some companies do that. But the ones that are most credible, I think, are the ones that reconcile their non gaap metrics clearly and explain why each adjustment makes sense in the context of their business. Luna: It's almost like they're teaching investors how to value them. Lucas: It is. And that's part of what makes earnings calls so interesting for post ipo companies. They're not just reporting the past; they're trying to shape how the market thinks about the future. Luna: So if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, we should mention: this show stays ad-free because of listener support. If that matters to you, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, we keep it independent on purpose. No ads, no sponsors. Just the conversation. And listeners like you make that possible. Luna: Alright, back to it. So we've talked about the framing. But how does the actual content of the call differ from what you'd hear from a more established company? Lucas: Great question. One thing I've noticed is that post ipo companies tend to spend more time on the business model itself. They'll explain the unit economics, the customer acquisition cost, the lifetime value — things that a mature company might take for granted. Luna: Because they're still educating the market. Lucas: Exactly. And that's smart. If you're a company like Rivian, which went public in 2021, you're still trying to convince investors that your path to profitability is real. On their last call, they spent a lot of time on production efficiency and cost reduction — showing that they're getting closer to breakeven on a per-vehicle basis. Luna: And the stock is down half a percent in the last five days. So the market is still skeptical, but the narrative might be helping them avoid a bigger sell-off. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the whole game. It's not about making the stock go up every quarter. It's about preventing it from crashing when the GAAP numbers look ugly. Luna: So the earnings call is really a risk management tool. Lucas: I think that's a fair way to put it. And we're seeing more and more post ipo companies adopt this playbook. They're bringing data, they're bringing visuals, they're bringing specific targets. It's almost like a mini-investor day every quarter. Luna: But doesn't that also create a risk of over-promising? If you set a target for adjusted EBITDA margin that you can't hit, you'll get punished worse than if you'd never set the target at all. Lucas: Absolutely. There's a fine line between providing helpful guidance and setting yourself up for a miss. And the market is unforgiving. Look at what happened to some of the ai focused companies that went public in 2024 — they set aggressive revenue targets, and when they missed, the stock dropped twenty, thirty percent. Luna: So the earnings call is a double-edged sword. It can stabilize your stock, or it can amplify the downside. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the best CFOs and IR teams spend weeks preparing for that one-hour call. They're not just reading the script. They're anticipating questions, they're thinking about what metrics will resonate, and they're carefully choosing which numbers to emphasize. Luna: So next time you listen to an earnings call from a newly public company, pay attention to the adjusted metrics. Are they reasonable? Are they consistent? Or are they trying to hide something? Lucas: And if they're transparent about the adjustments and they tie them back to the business strategy, that's a good sign. It means they're thinking long-term, not just trying to smooth the quarterly numbers. Luna: Good advice. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. That's all for this episode of Tech IPO Conversations.