Latest / In God We Trusted / How Does Islam Treat Women Compared to Christianity?
Transcript
- 0:29Welcome to God We Trusted. I'm your
- 0:31host, Will. I'm here alongside Sam. Sam,
- 0:32what are we talking about today?
- 0:33>> Today, we are going to be continuing our
- 0:35series on Islam. And today the entire
- 0:37episode we are going to set aside and
- 0:39devote to the treatment of women. Uh and
- 0:42so this this might be upsetting. I mean
- 0:45it should be upsetting for a lot of
- 0:46people. But what I want to do is to go
- 0:49through uh the Quran, the Hadith, the
- 0:51examples of Muhammad, what is taught
- 0:53about women and just say like if Islam
- 0:56is growing in our world, if it is being
- 0:58welcomed into Western cultures um with
- 1:01open arms, like we should be aware of
- 1:05what its foundational documents teach
- 1:07about the treatment of women.
- 1:09>> And we are approaching this as two men
- 1:10who not only have wives, we each have
- 1:12daughters. So this is important to just
- 1:14not just the whole human conversation,
- 1:15but the fact that this is personal for
- 1:17us. How people treat women matters to
- 1:19us.
- 1:19>> That's right. Like the thought of my
- 1:21daughters growing up in in cultures that
- 1:23look like what we're going to talk about
- 1:25is something that grieves my heart.
- 1:27>> The fact that there are millions of
- 1:30women who exist in cultures that treat
- 1:32them as we're going to be discussing
- 1:33today breaks my heart. It should break
- 1:35all of our hearts. But we need to be
- 1:37honest enough to come and say, "Okay, if
- 1:38this is the truth, if this is what Allah
- 1:40and Muhammad want for us. If they're if
- 1:43this is the truth, then this should be
- 1:45our reality." And what I'm saying is
- 1:47this is absolutely not the truth. It is
- 1:50destructive. It's disturbing. And we
- 1:52should reject it and fight against this
- 1:54worldview from having any place or
- 1:57stronghold in our cultures. So where do
- 1:59we begin? I think one of the things that
- 2:01would be helpful for this conversation
- 2:03is to gain some perspective of of what
- 2:05existed before Christian ethics spread
- 2:08to the to the rest of the world because
- 2:10the the mistreatment or malreatment of
- 2:12women is something that's pretty
- 2:13universal through all of human history.
- 2:15Uh you could go back and look at
- 2:16different legal codes and they're
- 2:17they're shocking, right? So, like the
- 2:20Assyrian code of 1075 BC uh talks about
- 2:23that if a if a woman goes out into the
- 2:25streets and is veiled when she shouldn't
- 2:29be, she should have her garment ceased
- 2:30and 50 blows inflicted on her with hot
- 2:33tar bitmen poured on her head. And
- 2:36you're like, okay, well, that's the
- 2:37ancient Assyrians. They're pretty
- 2:38they're pretty awful. But then you hear
- 2:41Aristotle, right? Aristotle, super
- 2:42respected Greek philosopher. Listen to
- 2:44what he says about women. He says the
- 2:46female is a female by virtue of a
- 2:49certain lack of qualities. We should
- 2:51regard the female nature as afflicted
- 2:53with a natural defectiveness. And so
- 2:56this is Greek culture. This is one of
- 2:57the most famous philosophers or Ko the
- 2:59Elder. Let's moving forward. What does
- 3:01he say about women? Woman is a violent
- 3:04and uncontrolled animal and is useless
- 3:06to let go the reigns and then expect her
- 3:08not to kick over the traces. you must
- 3:11keep her on a tight rain. Or Plutarch,
- 3:14one of the more famous historians of
- 3:16history, a wife should have no feelings
- 3:18of her own, but share her husband's
- 3:20seriousness and sport, his anxiety and
- 3:24his laughter. When you go to the first
- 3:26century and you look at demographics,
- 3:28books have been written on this by a guy
- 3:30Rodney Stark. And he says, "Infanticide
- 3:32was so widely practiced by the Greco
- 3:34Romans. It was especially female infants
- 3:37who were dispatched. A study of
- 3:39inscriptions at Deli made it possible to
- 3:41reconstruct 600 families. Of those, only
- 3:44six raised more than one daughter. It's
- 3:46estimated that there were 131 males per
- 3:49100 females in the city of Rome, 140
- 3:52males per 100 females elsewhere in the
- 3:54empire. Well, why would that be? Because
- 3:57if you have a daughter, you get rid of
- 3:58her.
- 3:59>> You get rid of her. We found papyrus.
- 4:01This is a letter from a Roman soldier
- 4:03sending a note, a letter home to his
- 4:06wife saying, "Know that I'm in
- 4:07Alexandria. Don't worry. If they all
- 4:09come back, and I remain in Alexandria, I
- 4:12ask and beg you to take good care of our
- 4:14baby's son. And as soon as I receive
- 4:16payment, I'll send it up to you. If you
- 4:18are delivered of a child, so she's
- 4:20pregnant. If it is a boy, keep it. If
- 4:22it's a girl, discard it. You've sent me
- 4:24word, don't forget me. How can I forget
- 4:26you? I beg you not to worry. And so,
- 4:29here you have it's just casual
- 4:30conversation. Of course, if it's a girl,
- 4:32just get rid of it. Well, all of that
- 4:35changes when you get to Christianity.
- 4:37like you know for all of the the garbage
- 4:39and accusations of the patriarchy and
- 4:41everything else Christianity comes and
- 4:44it radically changes the world's views
- 4:46of women and human rights right if you
- 4:48go to any place in the world that has
- 4:50not been touched by Christianity and
- 4:52western ethics you'll find women's
- 4:55rights issues right but you go through
- 4:57the gospel and you look at the stories
- 4:59of Jesus interacting with women you look
- 5:01at what the the scriptures have to say
- 5:04that the the widows are going to be
- 5:06taken care of you know Paul comes along
- 5:08and it says, "As for your inheritance in
- 5:09Christ, there is neither male nor
- 5:12female." Right? Everybody's entitled to
- 5:14the same rights. The you have 1
- 5:16Corinthians 7 coming along and saying,
- 5:18"The wife does not have authority over
- 5:20her own body, but the husband does." But
- 5:22likewise, the husband doesn't have
- 5:24authority over his own body. The wife
- 5:26does. That would have been wild to say
- 5:29in the ancient world that wife has
- 5:31ownership of her husband's body. But
- 5:34Christianity comes and it levels all of
- 5:38the ancient ethics that say that women
- 5:40are not entitled to dignity. They don't
- 5:42have a seat at the table. They're not as
- 5:44valuable. All of the other cultures are
- 5:46screaming that. Now, when when
- 5:49Christianity begins to spread, you have
- 5:53Paul who is praising the church in Rome,
- 5:56saying that of of the 33 co- lababorers
- 5:59that he mentions at the end of that
- 6:00book, 15 of them are women. Right? He
- 6:04refers to a deaconist, Phoebe. He refers
- 6:06to a fellow worker in Jesus Christ,
- 6:08talking about Priscilla. He says that
- 6:10there had been some of them that were in
- 6:11prison with him, calling them
- 6:13outstanding among the apostles. So, you
- 6:15have this great dignity given to women
- 6:18in the early church. And what do you
- 6:19think was the result? Demographics will
- 6:21show you that in the early church, women
- 6:23flocked to Christianity and overwhelming
- 6:26and disproportionate numbers. Men were
- 6:27hesitant because if you're living in the
- 6:29Roman culture, you're like, I got it
- 6:30all. Why would I want that where my wife
- 6:32gets exalted and now I have to consider
- 6:34her as an equal in dignity? And bis the
- 6:38bishop of Carthage named Kiprien says
- 6:41Christian maidens were very numerous. In
- 6:43fact, it became a problem because
- 6:45Christians only are supposed to marry
- 6:47other Christians. But in a world where
- 6:49there's way more men than women,
- 6:51>> impossible to find. In the Christian
- 6:53church, it's way more women than men to
- 6:55where they're having a hard time finding
- 6:57husbands for all of these Christian
- 6:59women because they were flocking. And so
- 7:02Rodney Stark says the abundance of
- 7:03Christian women resulted in higher birth
- 7:06rates and this superior fertility
- 7:09contributed to the rise of Christianity
- 7:12and Christianity was mocked mercilessly
- 7:14for this. Marcus Aurelius says they
- 7:17talking about the church have gathered
- 7:19together the lowest dregs of a people
- 7:21from a number of ignorant women ignorant
- 7:24men and credulous women always ready to
- 7:26believe anything and so they're mocked
- 7:29for being made up of women. Celsus who's
- 7:31a skepsus the skeptic one of the first
- 7:34earliest people who speaks out against
- 7:36Christianity says this with words they
- 7:38acknowledge that such individuals are
- 7:40worthy of their god and they manifestly
- 7:43show that they desire and are able to
- 7:44gain over only the silly and the mean
- 7:47and the stupid with women and children
- 7:51and so in early Christianity
- 7:53Christianity is getting knocked for
- 7:55giving so much dignity and equality to
- 7:59women
- 8:00>> and yet women are flying there because
- 8:02they are saying, "Wow, look at how we're
- 8:04being treated here as compared to
- 8:05everywhere else. This is where we want
- 8:07to be." That's right. And so today, one
- 8:09of the things that we're going to talk
- 8:10about Islam and women, one of the things
- 8:13that is stunning to me is European women
- 8:16are turning to Islam in massive numbers.
- 8:20The conservative Europeans are
- 8:22converting to Islam. Women are one of
- 8:25the fastest growing converts. And yet
- 8:28when you take a step back and let's
- 8:29let's set aside religion for a moment
- 8:31and just look at the consequences of
- 8:34Islamic nations and the treatment of
- 8:36women. The World Economic Forum's Global
- 8:39Gender Gap Index took 156 countries and
- 8:43they they ranked how well do women do in
- 8:46these countries. And so they looked at
- 8:47things like financial security and
- 8:49health, education, civil liberties,
- 8:51political involvement of women. of the
- 8:55of all the rankings, the 15 worst
- 8:58rankings, every single one of them was
- 9:01Muslim majority countries.
- 9:03>> To the contrary, not one single Muslim
- 9:07nation ranked in the top 15. And when
- 9:11you look at a map at how they're ranked
- 9:12and it's colorcoded, you can see where
- 9:15do you see the least prosperous
- 9:18women?
- 9:19>> Africa and the Middle East. It's all
- 9:21centered right where Islam dominates. Or
- 9:25or if you look at laws that require like
- 9:27compulsory veiling, you'll find it's all
- 9:30there. And that when you don't do it,
- 9:32you it's bad. You look at child brides
- 9:35where they where they say we're going to
- 9:36take women against their will, even as
- 9:38young as 6 years old, and we're going to
- 9:40force them into marriage to other people
- 9:42to pay off debts of their parents or
- 9:44whatever. Overwhelmingly, this is in
- 9:47Muslim cultures. UNICEF, the UN branch
- 9:49found that the percentage of girls
- 9:51married before they reach 15 is
- 9:53dramatically higher. And Muslim cultures
- 9:56like Niger, Chad, Moritania, Iraq,
- 9:58Nigeria, Afghanistan, Somalia, enormous
- 10:02numbers of young girls given away in
- 10:04marriage by their parents. If you look
- 10:05at female circumcisions, which is like I
- 10:08didn't even know what that was.
- 10:09>> Yeah. I didn't know they existed. But
- 10:10you like it's it's genital mutilation
- 10:13where they do this to prevent a woman
- 10:16from experiencing too much pleasure so
- 10:18that she's not as likely to cheat on her
- 10:21husband.
- 10:21>> When you look at where this is, there's
- 10:24estimates that there's more than 230
- 10:27million females that suffer this fate
- 10:29around the Muslim world. And if you go
- 10:33into the hadith Abu Dau 5271, which is a
- 10:36contested one. I'll I'll say that even
- 10:38though it's canonical in Islam, they say
- 10:41that it is better for a woman and more
- 10:43desirable for a husband if a woman is
- 10:46cut. But Muhammad says don't cut her too
- 10:48severely. Now, they question whether or
- 10:50not that's legit, but it's happening all
- 10:52over the Islamic world, right? According
- 10:55to UNICEF, more than 80% of women in
- 10:57Muslim nations of Somalia, Egypt,
- 10:59Djibouti, and Sudan have suffered this
- 11:02fate. So, it's it's common and in some
- 11:04cases it's overwhelming. And you can see
- 11:06the the heat map of where you find that.
- 11:09And what do you notice about it?
- 11:10>> Right in the same spot.
- 11:11>> It's right in the same spot. honor
- 11:13killings which in some nations are
- 11:15prevalent like Pakistan you know had a a
- 11:18thousand honor killings per year where
- 11:21if a woman gets out of line with a man
- 11:23or a daughter from her father you know
- 11:25that they are allowed to kill them just
- 11:27like the Romans back in the ancient day
- 11:28gave fathers the right to kill a child
- 11:30if he wanted to because they didn't have
- 11:32an innate right to life in Muslim
- 11:34cultures the father controls that and
- 11:36and in many cases they're not prosecuted
- 11:39you look at literacy rates let's go
- 11:40through the entire Muslim world among
- 11:43Muslim nations, the illit the illiteracy
- 11:46rate for women is twice as high as the
- 11:49global average. And you look at the heat
- 11:50map for literacy and what do you notice?
- 11:53Same spot. It's the same spot. And so,
- 11:56you know, Muslims will come and they'll
- 11:57claim no no Muhammad was a champion for
- 11:59women's rights by, you know, and they'll
- 12:01say, and this is true, by the way, that
- 12:02in Arabia at the time of Muhammad's
- 12:04ministry, they used to kill girls and
- 12:06bury them in the sand. This was a common
- 12:08practice all over the world, right? In
- 12:10places where Christianity did not
- 12:11dominate, this was common. You just got
- 12:13rid of young girls. And so the Arabians
- 12:16were killing baby girls and burying them
- 12:18alive in the sand. In the Quran, Surah
- 12:2081:es 8 and 9 comes and says, "No, you
- 12:23may not do that anymore." So like, okay,
- 12:25good. That's great. That's that's
- 12:26wonderful.
- 12:27>> But he also talked about women as though
- 12:30they were objects, right? He says in in
- 12:33Muslim 14:53,
- 12:35the best object of benefit of the world
- 12:37is the pious woman. And you're like,
- 12:39"Okay, that's
- 12:40>> that's
- 12:40>> kind of nice.
- 12:41>> Kind of nice." And yet it's referring to
- 12:43her as like you get possession of her.
- 12:45She's the best object you can get as a
- 12:47man is a pious wife. And it's like,
- 12:49okay, that's kind of a backhanded
- 12:50compliment. Bkari 5196,
- 12:54Muhammad tells people that the majority
- 12:57of people who will go into hell are
- 12:59women. So this is a doctrine of Islam
- 13:02that the majority of the people in hell
- 13:03are women. He says, "I stood at the gate
- 13:06of the fire and saw that the majority of
- 13:09those who entered it were women." Okay?
- 13:13And so then he commands these women
- 13:15using that truth that's revealed to him
- 13:18commands them to give more alms. In
- 13:20Bkari 304, he says, "Oh women, give
- 13:22alms. I have seen that the majority of
- 13:24dwellers of hellfire are you women."
- 13:27That works out for right. So, Bkari 304,
- 13:31the women hear this and they they're
- 13:32like, "Whoa, why do you say this about
- 13:34us?" And this is Muhammad's logic back
- 13:36to them, these women. Speaking of women
- 13:38in general, you curse frequently and are
- 13:40ungrateful to your husbands. I have not
- 13:43seen anyone more deficient in
- 13:45intelligence and religion than you. A
- 13:48cautious, sensible man could be led
- 13:49astray by some of you. And then he
- 13:52explained that the female deficiencies,
- 13:55not just for these women he's talking
- 13:56to, he says, "No, no, no. Quran itself
- 13:59which is his revelations right requires
- 14:02two female witnesses for every one man.
- 14:05And so it's a doctrine of Islam that
- 14:07women are deficient.
- 14:09>> Quran 2 verse 282 says bring to witness
- 14:13two witnesses from among you men. Right?
- 14:15So two witnesses or men. But he's like
- 14:17well you know if there's not two men
- 14:19then bring a man and not just one woman
- 14:22because you need two woman to replace
- 14:25the one man. And it's interesting to see
- 14:28how many of of the attempts of Muhammad
- 14:31to speak kindly of women come with like
- 14:32a backhanded compliment like we talked
- 14:34about earlier. This is Muslim 1468.
- 14:38He says, "Act kindly towards woman." And
- 14:40you're like, "Oh, good. Well done,
- 14:41Muhammad." For woman is created from a
- 14:44rib and the most crooked part of the rib
- 14:46is its top. What does that mean? What's
- 14:49at the top of a person?
- 14:51The head. Right? And so woman is created
- 14:54from a rib and the most crooked part of
- 14:56that is the top where it bends around.
- 14:59And so her head is broken like her mind
- 15:01is broken. If you attempt to straighten
- 15:02it, you will break it. And if you leave
- 15:04it, its crookedness will remain there.
- 15:06And so you hear like there's a defect.
- 15:09They're going to hell there. Like
- 15:10overwhelmingly like it's it's not not
- 15:12great. It's not speaking of women. Well,
- 15:14Muslim 27:40 says, "I have not left
- 15:17after me any turmoil." So Muhammad's
- 15:19leaving behind his his Islam, right? He
- 15:22says,"I have not left after me any
- 15:24turmoil more injurious to men than the
- 15:27harm done to them because of women."
- 15:31When he talks about evil omens or things
- 15:33to keep in mind, Bkari 57:53 says, "An
- 15:37evil omen may be in three things. A
- 15:40woman, a house, or an animal." So when
- 15:43you're looking for like evil that will
- 15:44come upon you, three things. You got
- 15:46three places.
- 15:47>> An animal, a house, or a woman. And so
- 15:51like this is how do you how do you walk
- 15:53away from this without this being
- 15:54demeaning? How would you how could you
- 15:56be a Muslim and be like, "Oh, this is
- 15:57the inspired words of our prophet who is
- 15:59the ultimate example to us according to
- 16:01the Quran and hear him say these things
- 16:03and not look down upon women." Like we
- 16:05started with the beginning, I wouldn't
- 16:06want my daughter to marry a man who
- 16:08valued her like this.
- 16:09>> No. And we're in the easy parts right
- 16:11now still. And I'm already like, gosh,
- 16:14this is this is rough. Uh here's another
- 16:16one. This is Iban Maja 2055. So this is
- 16:19a canonical hadith. It says any woman
- 16:21who asks her husband for a divorce when
- 16:23it is not absolutely necessary, the
- 16:26fragrance of paradise will be forbidden
- 16:28to her.
- 16:29>> So if you divorce your husband when it's
- 16:32not sanctioned, you're going to hell.
- 16:34Even Maja 18:54 says, "Any woman who
- 16:37dies when her husband is pleased with
- 16:40her will enter paradise." So when you
- 16:42start thinking about this, I mean, if
- 16:43you're walking with the teachings of
- 16:45Muhammad, how does a woman get to
- 16:46heaven?
- 16:47>> By pleasing her husband.
- 16:48>> That's right. You divorce him, you go to
- 16:49hell. You please him, you go to heaven.
- 16:51So what is your primary mission in life?
- 16:54There's no interaction directly with
- 16:56Allah. Your entire purpose is your
- 16:59husband. Period. And that's what
- 17:01determines whether or not you go to
- 17:03paradise. Uh the laws for divorce are
- 17:05just kind of crazy and fascinating. So
- 17:09Bkari 5264 says that a couple is no
- 17:12longer allowed to remarry unless the
- 17:15woman first remarries. And the new
- 17:18husband has ta t t t t t t t t t t t t t
- 17:19t t t t t t t t t t t t t t t t t t t t
- 17:19t t t t t t tasted her sweetness. And so
- 17:21like, and that means what you think it
- 17:23means. So here's here's a couple they
- 17:25get, you know, I'm divorcing. Oh, no,
- 17:27just kidding. I'm divorcing. I'm just
- 17:28kidding. I'm divorcing. I'm just
- 17:29kidding. And Muhammad's like, okay,
- 17:31that's craziness. If you keep doing
- 17:32that, you're making a mockery of
- 17:34marriage. And so here's the deal. You do
- 17:35it a third time, she's not allowed to
- 17:38remarry you unless she goes and has some
- 17:40other guy take her first. And so that
- 17:42makes the the logic behind this of why
- 17:44Muhammad commands this is you'll take
- 17:46divorce more seriously because if you do
- 17:48it three times, she's got to be taken
- 17:49raped by another guy before you can
- 17:52remarry her again. But again, notice
- 17:55it's not the man has to be she has to
- 17:58she has to she's the problem. She's the
- 18:01deficient one. He his desires for her
- 18:04have to be violated. Right? So, Muslim
- 18:071480 says this, "My husband divorced
- 18:10me." This is a woman saying, "My husband
- 18:13divorced me with three pronouncement and
- 18:14Allah's messenger made no provision for
- 18:16lodging and maintenance allowed." So,
- 18:19that's another thing. When a man
- 18:21divorced you and sent you away by
- 18:23Muhammad's decree, there's no safety,
- 18:26right? He is allowed in this case to
- 18:28leave her exceptionally vulnerable. Iban
- 18:31Maja 1762, Muhammad prohibited wives
- 18:35from fasting without their husband's
- 18:37permission. And so, like, let's take a
- 18:39step back. You don't have any autonomy
- 18:40over your relationship, right? Well, now
- 18:43here's your spiritual relationship.
- 18:44Like, can a woman pursue God on her own?
- 18:47And Muhammad is coming and saying, "You
- 18:50are not to fast without your husband's
- 18:53permission." Or another one, Muslim 333,
- 18:57the the A Muhammad required his own
- 19:00wives to abandon prayer when they were
- 19:02ministrating because they're unclean.
- 19:04You are not allowed to pray to God
- 19:06during ministration. Or Abu Jahoud 3547,
- 19:10Muslim wives must gain the husband's
- 19:12approval to give any charity out of the
- 19:14household funds. There's no autonomy.
- 19:16There's no leadership. There's no equal
- 19:18dignity going on here. Women are not
- 19:21supposed to shake a man's hand because
- 19:23Muhammad's wife, Aisha, claimed that his
- 19:25palm never touched the palm of another
- 19:28woman. And so, it's a sign of great
- 19:29virtue. I've seen videos where a woman
- 19:31reporter will go to shake a man's hand
- 19:33and he's he's like, I can't do that
- 19:35>> because men are not. And, you know, out
- 19:38of an abundance of caution, they would
- 19:39say for virtue and everything else. No,
- 19:42but you can see how this begins to
- 19:44impact the way women are seen in
- 19:47culture. And and speaking of the the
- 19:50obsession with the purity of women. And
- 19:52notice that it's going to be
- 19:53overwhelmingly directed toward the
- 19:55women, Muhammad was obsessed with the
- 19:57dress of women, which is why like that's
- 19:59one of the most notable things about
- 20:00Islam. When they come to another cult,
- 20:01they're dressed way differently. Well,
- 20:03where does that come from? Muhammad once
- 20:05described hell as being filled with
- 20:07tyrants, right? And seductive women who
- 20:10are quote naked in spite of their being
- 20:12dressed. And so they're wearing
- 20:13provocative clothing or they're wearing
- 20:15things that are too tight fitting or
- 20:17something like that. And so he says
- 20:18women are quote seduced and seduce
- 20:21others with their hair high like humps.
- 20:23So they wear provocative hairstyles. And
- 20:25so he says these women will not get into
- 20:28paradise. So, if you're a woman who
- 20:30dresses even remotely provocative or you
- 20:32have hair that's high, which I guess is
- 20:34provocative and
- 20:36>> whatever, that's that's Muslim 2128.
- 20:40And he's saying you don't get into
- 20:42paradise if that's you. And so, where do
- 20:45where does the clothing come from? It's
- 20:46prescribed by Muhammad. And Abu Daw
- 20:494104, he's having a conversation with
- 20:52one of the daughters of Abu Bakr. Her
- 20:54name is Ashma. And she entered upon the
- 20:56messenger of Allah wearing thin clothes,
- 20:58right? So they're they're kind of like
- 20:59draped and clingy. The messenger of
- 21:02Allah turned his attention from her like
- 21:04he's just shocked and he turns his gaze
- 21:06away and he says, "Oh Asma, when a woman
- 21:08reaches the age of ministration, it does
- 21:10not suit her that she displays her parts
- 21:12of body except this and this." And he
- 21:15pointed to his face and his hands. And
- 21:18so you want to know where the different
- 21:20types of dress come from like the nicad,
- 21:22the hijab, burrka, and and one of the
- 21:25other ones that's from Persian culture.
- 21:27What do you notice about all of those
- 21:28types of dress?
- 21:29>> Just the face and the hands are
- 21:31uncovered.
- 21:31>> Just the face and the hands. Because
- 21:34Muhammad is saying if you do anything
- 21:36differently, if you dress any other way,
- 21:39you're not getting to paradise,
- 21:41>> right? Because you're not virtuous.
- 21:43You're tempting men. You're the worst
- 21:44thing that I'm leaving behind. I mean,
- 21:46it's like good grief. Like, and the fact
- 21:49that the European women are flocking to
- 21:52this is like shocking to me. And for any
- 21:56woman out there that is under this to
- 21:58see like
- 22:00you're not diminished in the sight of
- 22:02the one true God.
- 22:03>> Yeah.
- 22:03>> He sees you. He values you. He loves
- 22:06you. You're of equal dignity as any man.
- 22:10This is this is wild. And so Quran
- 22:1233:59,
- 22:13you have Allah through Gabriel
- 22:15supposedly telling Muhammad, "Oh
- 22:18prophet, tell thy wives and daughters
- 22:20and the believing women that they should
- 22:22cast their outer garments over their
- 22:24persons when when abroad that this is
- 22:26the most convenient that they should be
- 22:28known as such and not molested." And so
- 22:30you cover up yourself so that you don't
- 22:32you everywhere you go, you're not
- 22:33allowed to show anything. You cover up
- 22:36everything. you lose in a sense your own
- 22:39identity especially with a lot of the
- 22:40dress where you can only see the eyes
- 22:42but this is coming directly from Allah
- 22:45so to expect them to to wear anything
- 22:48that might show legs or ankles or knees
- 22:50or elbows you know no it's you may only
- 22:53show face and hands so Quran 33:53 you
- 22:56have Allah who's coming to Muhammad and
- 22:59he's giving instructions which
- 23:00Muhammad's like Allah said so he says
- 23:02when you ask your wives for something do
- 23:04so from behind a green. This is purer
- 23:08for both your hearts and for theirs. It
- 23:10is not right to offend God's messenger
- 23:12just as you should never marry his wives
- 23:14after him. That would be grievous in
- 23:16God's eyes. So Allah comes and says
- 23:18Muhammad's wives are off limits. And oh
- 23:20by the way, if anybody comes into
- 23:23Muhammad's house to ask his wives, you
- 23:25may not look at them directly. They have
- 23:27to be behind a screen. And so a lot of
- 23:29people look at that and they say, "Okay,
- 23:30well to protect virtue if you can only
- 23:32show face and hands." Well, then we need
- 23:34to put a screen over the face so that
- 23:36you can't look at them directly because
- 23:37that's what Muhammad did. And he is the
- 23:40excellent example and Islam. And so all
- 23:43of a sudden you have the the dignity of
- 23:46women just diminished more and more.
- 23:49Their identity, their individuality
- 23:51diminished more and more. Abu Dawood
- 23:53567. Though Muhammad allowed women to
- 23:56visit the mosque to pray, he taught them
- 23:58that their houses are better for them.
- 24:00So yeah, you can come, but
- 24:02>> I'd prefer you not to.
- 24:04>> Yeah, it'd be better for you to stay
- 24:06there. Bkari 5195.
- 24:08In an effort to prevent infidelity or
- 24:10temptations, wives are not permitted to
- 24:13allow anyone to enter his house except
- 24:15with his permission. By the way, they're
- 24:16not supposed to go out either. Um, so
- 24:21here you have Allah in Quran 33:es 32
- 24:24and 33. Allah comes to Muhammad
- 24:27supposedly and says, "Wives of the
- 24:29prophet, you are not like any other
- 24:31woman." So Muhammad's wives get, you
- 24:33know,
- 24:33>> they're elevated.
- 24:34>> Well, they're elevated, but their
- 24:35restrictions are higher because
- 24:36Muhammad's a little bit more
- 24:38>> possessive, I guess. If you are truly
- 24:41mindful of God, do not speak too softly
- 24:43in case the sick heart should lust after
- 24:45you, but speak in an appropriate manner.
- 24:48Stay at home and do not flaunt your
- 24:50finery as they used to do in the pagan
- 24:52past. Keep up the prayer, give the
- 24:54prescribed arms and obey God and his
- 24:56messenger. God wishes to keep
- 24:58uncleanness away from you, people of
- 25:01Muhammad's house, and to purify you
- 25:04thoroughly. And so, don't talk to
- 25:06people. And if you do talk to people,
- 25:08don't talk with a soft voice that might
- 25:10allure them. You got to be mindful of
- 25:12your hands and your hair and you
- 25:13everything else and the way you talk
- 25:15because none of Muhammad's wives could
- 25:17possibly ever do anything that might
- 25:19gain attraction. And by the way, do that
- 25:21all behind a screen. Abu Dude 4048. When
- 25:25going out in public in order to
- 25:26eliminate any possibility of sex appeal,
- 25:28Muhammad commands this. The perfume used
- 25:31by women should have no odor.
- 25:33>> Exactly.
- 25:35>> What What are you wearing perfume? I
- 25:36don't still don't understand that. Why
- 25:37would you wear perfume if there's no
- 25:39odor odor? Like that's that's kind of
- 25:41different. Muslim 1453, a married woman
- 25:45comes to Muhammad and asks how to deal
- 25:48with a young This one's wild. How to
- 25:50deal with a young male slave that's
- 25:52expressing impure desires for her. So a
- 25:54young male slaves coming up and is
- 25:56making eyes with her. You know, it's
- 25:58like uh the flirtations upset the
- 26:00woman's husband, the slave owner. And so
- 26:03Muhammad instructed her, this is Muslim
- 26:051453D.
- 26:07These are his instructions to her.
- 26:09suckle him so that he may become your
- 26:12foster child and thus he may be able to
- 26:14come to you freely. Do you understand
- 26:16what that's saying? You know what suckle
- 26:18means?
- 26:18>> Breastfeed him.
- 26:20>> So that now when he comes to you, it's
- 26:22like he's coming to his mom. And so it
- 26:24disqualifies the young man from being a
- 26:26potential husband. That would crush his
- 26:28hopes.
- 26:29>> It's one way to go about it.
- 26:31>> What? Like you imagine the pool guy
- 26:33comes to your house and you're like,
- 26:34I've got some advice, Will. like it's
- 26:36just it's wild and it shows no dignity
- 26:39to her. One of the other things that you
- 26:41find in Islam is how convenient the the
- 26:44revelations that Muhammad receives for
- 26:46the Quran are. So let give you an
- 26:48instance on one occasion Abu Bakr who's
- 26:51going to be the first caiff best friend
- 26:52of Muhammad reported that Muhammad had a
- 26:55sexual affair with Mariah who's a
- 26:57Christian slave of his in the house of
- 26:59his wife Hafsa. And so Hafsa hears he's
- 27:02having sex with this Christian slave.
- 27:04She's upset and so she confronts him for
- 27:07this doing it in my house and on my day.
- 27:10But Al Tabari explained, "Well, the
- 27:12revelation came at that point allowing
- 27:15him to be with his slave girls again."
- 27:17And so this revelation suddenly comes in
- 27:20the Quran. So Muhammad gets busted
- 27:21having an affair with a slave again
- 27:23against his wife. She's upset and all of
- 27:26a sudden Gabriel's like, "Hey Muhammad,
- 27:27I got a message from Allah for you." In
- 27:29the resulting surah, Allah assured
- 27:31Muhammad that he had the right to pursue
- 27:33other women. Oh prophet, Allah said,
- 27:35"Why do you forbid what Allah has made
- 27:37lawful for you? Don't worry about this."
- 27:39Right? And so as a result of her
- 27:41protest, Allah told Muhammad that he
- 27:45would be morally justified if he
- 27:46divorced his wife for complaining.
- 27:48>> Wow.
- 27:49>> Right. The dissolution of his oath to
- 27:51his wife. Surah 66:2. And then Allah
- 27:54rebukes the wives of Muhammad through
- 27:57Muhammad. And listen to this. Surah 665.
- 28:00Maybe if he were to divorce you, your
- 28:02Lord might grant him in exchange wives
- 28:05better than you, those who truly submit
- 28:07to Allah. So you're you're upset about
- 28:09him having sexual relationships with
- 28:13slaves that are unbelievers in Islam.
- 28:17I'm telling you, Muhammad would he could
- 28:19do better than you. Like you're going to
- 28:20complain about this. How dare you?
- 28:22>> He should divorce you and move on.
- 28:24>> Yeah, he would be justified to divorce
- 28:26you. you have what kind of Anyway,
- 28:29here's another story that that boggles
- 28:31my mind. So, Muhammad comes into the
- 28:33home of his adopted son, right? And he
- 28:36sees his wife's, you know, his son's
- 28:38wife and she's unveiled. And, you know,
- 28:41Zahed, who is the name of his adopted
- 28:43son, had been gifted to them as a slave
- 28:45earlier on from a slave raid. And
- 28:48Altabari writes this that Muhammad came
- 28:50to Zed's house and saw Zanab, his wife,
- 28:53unveiled. She was fair-skinned and
- 28:55beautiful. So the prophet said, "Praise
- 28:58be to God who turns the hearts." Zed
- 29:00sensed what had happened and offered to
- 29:02divorce her so that the prophet could
- 29:05marry her. But the prophet said, "Keep
- 29:07your wife." And you're like, "Okay, well
- 29:09good."
- 29:10Not for long. Muhammad changed his mind,
- 29:13took his son's wife, and then received
- 29:15another revelation from Allah who shows
- 29:17up and like, "Oh, no, no, it's okay. You
- 29:18can do that." And listen to what it is.
- 29:20You are afraid of people, but it is more
- 29:22fitting that you fear God. When Zahed no
- 29:24longer wanted her, we gave her to you in
- 29:27marriage so that there might be no fault
- 29:29in believers marrying the wives of their
- 29:31adopted sons after they no longer wanted
- 29:34them. That's in the Quran. So he's
- 29:36having an affair with his son's wife and
- 29:38all of a sudden Allah shows up and goes,
- 29:39"Yeah, that's good. We're good with
- 29:40that." Like that. Let's do that. And so
- 29:42the marriage covenant is like, "I don't
- 29:45want her anymore." Hear the language
- 29:46there. If he no longer wants her, you
- 29:48can marry your daughter-in-law.
- 29:50>> Yeah. Just an object.
- 29:51>> Wow.
- 29:53That's that's disturbing to me. I don't
- 29:55want that to take root in Western
- 29:57culture. Here's another one. This this
- 29:59one now we're starting to get into
- 30:01really really more disturbing material.
- 30:06One hadith recounts how Muslim soldiers
- 30:09took captives some excellent Arab women,
- 30:12it says. And so they explain, you know,
- 30:15they're on this conquest mission. They
- 30:18capture these really beautiful women.
- 30:20And then they explain in in the hadith,
- 30:22we desired them for we were suffering
- 30:24from the absence of our wives. In other
- 30:26words, we look at these beautiful
- 30:27captive women that we've just conquered
- 30:29and killed their husbands. Man, we
- 30:30wanted them because we didn't have our
- 30:32wives. And the soldiers really wanted to
- 30:34sexually abuse these women, but they
- 30:36feared if they did, impregnating them
- 30:38might make them undesirable in the slave
- 30:41market, right? Because you're not going
- 30:42to get as much money if you impregnate
- 30:44one of these women that you're sexually
- 30:45abusing. And so they go to Muhammad and
- 30:47they say, "We decided to have sexual
- 30:49intercourse with them, but we withdrew
- 30:52before emitting semen into the women
- 30:54because we didn't want to impregnate
- 30:55them." And so they're looking to
- 30:57Muhammad to give them counsel. This is
- 30:59Muslim 3371.
- 31:02And Muhammad's advice is not what you
- 31:04would guess if he's a decent person,
- 31:06which would be what? Stop that. You're
- 31:09>> how dare you do that. Right? He says
- 31:12this. This is them talking. We asked
- 31:14Allah's messenger and he said, quote,
- 31:17"It does not matter if you do it or do
- 31:19not do it. For every soul that is born
- 31:22up to the day of resurrection will be
- 31:24born." He doesn't come in response and
- 31:26say, "You may absolutely not do that."
- 31:28What he says is, "It doesn't matter if
- 31:31you risk impregnation or not. Everybody
- 31:34that's supposed to be born, Allah will
- 31:36make born, but no rebuke for the rape of
- 31:39these captives." So Muhammad didn't
- 31:42address any of that because Allah had
- 31:45already condoned the rape of female
- 31:47captives and the lucrative slave market
- 31:49for female captives. This is surah 424
- 31:54where Allah through Gabriel tells
- 31:55Muhammad supposedly forbidden are
- 31:58married women. In other words, you may
- 32:00not go have adulterous affairs with
- 32:02married women except for female captives
- 32:06in your possession. And so what does
- 32:09that mean? If you are a female captive,
- 32:12you're free game.
- 32:13>> Yeah.
- 32:14>> You may be abused. And it's it that is
- 32:18shocking to me. And you see that still
- 32:20bearing fruit in the world when you look
- 32:22at Islamic terrorism and and ISIS raping
- 32:24victims and all of those kinds of
- 32:26things. It's unbelievable.
- 32:28>> Elsewhere in the Quran, Allah blessed
- 32:30believers who quote guard their chastity
- 32:33except with their spouses or their
- 32:35slaves, meaning captives. With these
- 32:38they are not to blame. So you're limited
- 32:40to your wives and
- 32:43your captives.
- 32:44>> Captives.
- 32:44>> That's right. So when you conquer people
- 32:46and you kill their husbands and you ex
- 32:49you you expand the conquest of Islam,
- 32:52all of the women that are captured there
- 32:54belong to you. Doeth them what you want.
- 32:56And Muslim men are freely permitted to
- 32:59have sex with their wives, their slaves,
- 33:01and their captives. And so, but you're
- 33:04one of the reasons that polygamy, I
- 33:06mean, you want to you want to have more
- 33:08incubators to spread the number of
- 33:10Muslims. And so, polygamy is endorsed in
- 33:14Islam. And I want to pause here for a
- 33:16moment because a lot of people will
- 33:18respond to that and say, "What? There's
- 33:20polygamy in the in the Bible, right?
- 33:21There's polygamy in the Old Testament."
- 33:23Well, let's look at that real quick.
- 33:25When you look at the polygamy, like when
- 33:26Abraham has a wife, Sarah, and a maid
- 33:28servant, Hagar, is that good? Always
- 33:31goes wrong. It always goes wrong, right?
- 33:33Like that that blows up. You have
- 33:34conflict. When you have Jacob with two
- 33:36wives with with Leah and Rachel, what
- 33:39happens? They hate each other. When you
- 33:41go and you look at Solomon who has 700
- 33:44wives, says the Bible like, "Hooray,
- 33:45Solomon, 700 wives." It talks about how
- 33:47that was his downfall. That that was the
- 33:50bad thing. David, it's not good for him.
- 33:52When you get to the New Testament, the
- 33:54ethic of monogous marriage is so crystal
- 33:56clear that even like in 1 Timothy 3
- 33:59where Paul is saying to have leadership
- 34:01in the church, you must be the husband
- 34:03of
- 34:04>> one,
- 34:04>> one wife. Don't miss that. Polygamy in
- 34:08the Bible is utterly dismissed. It's
- 34:10always presented. It's like where in the
- 34:13Quran it's prescriptive. Go do this. In
- 34:16the Bible, it's descriptive. This
- 34:17happened and it had terrible
- 34:19consequences. Hint, hint, don't do that.
- 34:21Right? But in the Quran in surah 42 and
- 34:25three, you got all these captives that
- 34:28you're conquering. Listen to what Allah
- 34:29through Gabriel says. If you fear that
- 34:31you will not deal fairly with orphan
- 34:33girls that why are they orphaned?
- 34:34Because you've killed their family. You
- 34:36may marry which other women seem good to
- 34:38you? Two, three, or four. And so what is
- 34:41the limit? How many how many wives is a
- 34:44Muslim allowed to take?
- 34:45>> Four.
- 34:45>> Two, three, or four. That's the max,
- 34:47right? And so, but Muhammad, he he wants
- 34:52more than four. So, what do you think
- 34:54happens?
- 34:55>> Makes an exemption.
- 34:56>> That's what makes an all of a sudden
- 34:58Gabriel shows up and says, "Not you,
- 35:01Muhammad." And so, it's, "Oh, prophet,
- 35:03we have made lawful for you, the wives
- 35:06whose bride gift you have paid, any
- 35:08slaves that God has assigned to you
- 35:10through war, and the daughters of your
- 35:12uncles and aunts on your father's and
- 35:13mother's side." So, all of your cousins,
- 35:15feel free to take as many wives as you
- 35:17want. and also any believing woman who
- 35:19has offered herself to the prophet and
- 35:21whom the prophet wishes to wed. This is
- 35:24only for you prophet and not the rest of
- 35:26the believers. So you should not be
- 35:28blamed. That's surah 33 verse 50 at the
- 35:32end there. So you're you're finding a
- 35:34pattern right
- 35:36>> every time that he needs an exception
- 35:38for sexual relationships or all of a
- 35:41sudden Gabriel shows up and it's like
- 35:43well the standard is this for them but
- 35:44it's this for you. And so Muhammad is
- 35:47going to marry a total of 11 women
- 35:48during his lifetime, nine at one time.
- 35:51When he's married to Kada, who's
- 35:52powerful, he only is married to her.
- 35:54When she dies, he starts just collecting
- 35:56wives, right? He's got a paternal
- 35:58cousin, two captives that are taken in
- 36:01war. And Bkari says, because then the
- 36:04question is, how in the world could he
- 36:05show affection to them all? Well, don't
- 36:07worry. Bkari 5068 says, "The prophet
- 36:10used to visit all his wives in one
- 36:12night, and he had nine wives at that
- 36:14time.
- 36:17All right. An honest claim that the
- 36:19prophet was given the strength of 30
- 36:21men, which if he's visiting every wife
- 36:23every night, nine times a night,
- 36:25>> I I suppose so. And so you have Islam
- 36:28that comes and promotes polygamy. So
- 36:30what do you think you find in the world
- 36:32for centuries, even up to this day,
- 36:34every nation in North America, South
- 36:36America, and Europe has outlawed
- 36:38polygamy.
- 36:39>> Every one of them.
- 36:41>> Islam on the other hand endorses
- 36:43polygamy for men. So out of the 57
- 36:45Muslim majority nations, how many do you
- 36:47think have prohibited polygamy?
- 36:50>> Two.
- 36:51>> Wow. Only two.
- 36:52>> Two. And modern day, two nations out of
- 36:5557 have outlawed polygamy. Why? Because
- 36:58the Quran says it's utterly lawful. You
- 37:00should do this because the prophet did
- 37:03it. And he's the ultimate example. And
- 37:06so in early Islam, Muhammad uses
- 37:07polygamy as an incentive in warfare and
- 37:09conquest. It's like if I can't get you,
- 37:11hey, you could get some get a wife. Get
- 37:13a her and bring her in. You know, she'll
- 37:14be another servant in your house. You
- 37:16can do with her what you want really.
- 37:17You know, treat her well. You know,
- 37:18don't don't do crazy stuff with her, but
- 37:20she's yours to to do with you what you
- 37:22want in a sexual relationship. And so
- 37:24soldiers were permitted to seize orphans
- 37:27and widows. And one case, it's just
- 37:31reprehensible to me. This is Bkari 4350.
- 37:35Ali, who's Ali? He's the fourth caiff
- 37:38for Shia Islam. He's the first rightful
- 37:40caiff, right? So Ali is sent to retrieve
- 37:43Muhammad's portion of raided loot which
- 37:45is going to include all these captured
- 37:47orphaned slave girls. On his return
- 37:50trip, Ali commits quote a sexual act
- 37:54with a slave girl. This is Bkari 30
- 37:564350. When a Muslim official named Beda
- 37:59reported the act to Muhammad, what do
- 38:01you think Muhammad does? He's really
- 38:03upset with Ali right now.
- 38:04>> Yes. He rebukes Bera and affirmed Ali's
- 38:09right to have sex with these captives,
- 38:11adding that quote, "Ali deserves more
- 38:14than that."
- 38:16>> And when do you see it's like Muhammad's
- 38:17example is it it's it's an example for
- 38:20monsters when you see Islamic terrorist
- 38:23organizations like ISIS and Boo Haram
- 38:25and Al-Shabaab and the Taliban and they
- 38:27use these verses and stories as
- 38:29justifications from their literature to
- 38:32to justify sexually abusing captives.
- 38:35And so when you read about in Nigeria
- 38:37all of these school girls being taken
- 38:39captive, you can guess what's happening.
- 38:42Yeah. When you look at ISIS that goes
- 38:44through Syria and kidnaps the Yazidis
- 38:46and the Christians, you can, you know,
- 38:48what's happening. We've gotten
- 38:49testimonies from them of what happens.
- 38:51And they point to Muhammad as the
- 38:55justification for this. So there's one
- 38:57case where after torturing and killing a
- 38:59Jewish man at Kbar, Muhammad initially
- 39:02gave his widow Safia to one of the
- 39:04Muslim soldiers. But then Muhammad sees
- 39:06her beauty for himself and commands the
- 39:08soldier now you take another slave from
- 39:10among the captives and he selects her,
- 39:12sets out with her. And Muhammad himself
- 39:16will take one of these captives for
- 39:17himself and be in a relationship with
- 39:20her. And I'm sure having grieved the
- 39:22loss of her husband and parents or
- 39:24father at least
- 39:26>> this is not consensual regardless of
- 39:28what Muslims may say that she says later
- 39:30under duress I'm sure. But like you look
- 39:33at pamphlets offering guidance on the
- 39:35issue. ISIS instructs their soldiers
- 39:38quote it is permissible to have sexual
- 39:40intercourse with the female captive. Why
- 39:44do they say that? Well listen they
- 39:46because they they give the prescription
- 39:48of Muhammad. They say if she is a
- 39:50virgin, her master can have intercourse
- 39:52with her immediately after taking
- 39:53possession of her. However, if she
- 39:55isn't, her uterus must be purified to
- 39:58make sure that she is not already
- 39:59pregnant. And Isis quotes from Quran
- 40:02surah 23:5 and 6 and gives the example
- 40:05of Muhammad as justification. And that's
- 40:08also why when Muhamm when Hamas runs
- 40:12into Israel and kidnaps all these women,
- 40:14what do you hear inevitably about the
- 40:16way that they're treated?
- 40:17>> They're abused. What do you see in the
- 40:19pictures? You see bloodied clothing,
- 40:21pants. Don't miss that. You go to Europe
- 40:25today where there's this influx of of of
- 40:28Muslims. And this is hard to say. Like,
- 40:30and I really don't want to offend, but
- 40:31it's just true. Like in 2018, Sweden
- 40:34convicted 843 rapists. Only 20.8% of
- 40:39Swedes are foreign born, but 58% of the
- 40:42rapists were born outside of Sweden. In
- 40:44cases of stranger rape, the number
- 40:46jumped to 80% of the rapist. In Paris,
- 40:50street rapes, quote unquote, 70% of the
- 40:53accused were foreign nationals. In
- 40:55Spain, 45.6% of convicted rapists were
- 40:58foreign nationals. From 2021 to 2023,
- 41:01foreign nationals were 71% more likely
- 41:04to be convicted of a sexual offense in
- 41:06the United Kingdom. Well, why why the
- 41:09spike? It's because you had this massive
- 41:12flood of immigration of people who are
- 41:14coming who have a radically different
- 41:15ethic toward women and toward their
- 41:17sexual dignity. That's what you see. And
- 41:21when you look at the Quran, say surah 22
- 41:242:23,
- 41:26Allah teaches your wives are your
- 41:28fields. So go into your fields whichever
- 41:30way you like. What does that mean? Do
- 41:33whatever you want.
- 41:33>> Do whatever you want with them. They're
- 41:35your fields. Or in Muslim 14:36, if a
- 41:38man calls his wife to bed and she
- 41:40refuses and he spends the night angry
- 41:42with her, the angels curse her till
- 41:45morning. This is Muhammad. If your wife
- 41:48doesn't do what you say in regards to
- 41:50your sexual desires, the angels curse
- 41:53her. So imagine being a woman living
- 41:56under that kind of oppressive religious
- 41:58belief. You look at the 57 Muslim
- 42:00nations around the world and the vast
- 42:02majority have no laws against marital
- 42:05rape.
- 42:06>> If you go to Egypt, the United Nations
- 42:08reports 99.3% of women in Egypt have
- 42:10claimed claimed to have experienced
- 42:12sexual harassment and 82.6 of these
- 42:15women did not feel safe in their own
- 42:16streets. 47% had been physically or
- 42:19sexually abused by their spouse.
- 42:22>> It's insane.
- 42:23>> Quran 4:34. As for women of whom you
- 42:26fear rebellion, in other words, they're
- 42:29not obeying your demands in this
- 42:31category, admonish them and remain apart
- 42:33from them in beds and beat them. Then if
- 42:37they obey you, do not seek ways to harm
- 42:39them. Allah is exalted. Great.
- 42:43So what do you do if your wife is not
- 42:45fulfilling your demands in the bedroom?
- 42:48Well, here's your prescription. You
- 42:50admonish her. You remain apart from her.
- 42:52And you beat her. And you can go online
- 42:54and look at YouTubetubes of all these
- 42:56imams and all these scholars that
- 42:57explain how to appropriately beat your
- 42:59wife. And they're like, "No, no, no. It
- 43:00really gives them dignity, you know,
- 43:02because you're you're not allowing them
- 43:03to do wickedness." And it's like, good
- 43:06grief. Here's one. At the Islamic
- 43:09University of Gaza, Dr. Zad Mikdad says
- 43:13this, "The husband's beating of his
- 43:15wife, if it happens at all, should be
- 43:17like a guy beating his sweetheart. It
- 43:19should be a therapeutic beating rather
- 43:21than a vindictive one.
- 43:24It's crazy therapeutic beating. In 1984,
- 43:28Shik Ysef Kared Howi, head of the
- 43:30European Council for Fatwa and Research,
- 43:33taught that the husband is quote
- 43:35entitled to the obedience and
- 43:37cooperation of his wife and may quote,
- 43:39"beat her lightly with the hands,
- 43:41avoiding her face and other sensitive
- 43:43parts." He added, "None of you must beat
- 43:46his wife as a slave is beaten and then
- 43:48have intercourse with her at the end of
- 43:50that day.
- 43:54Yeah. And Muslim, here's the hadith.
- 43:57Muslim 23:28, you have Aisha who is so
- 44:00precious to to Muslims, one of
- 44:03Muhammad's wives, right? She boasts that
- 44:05Muhammad quote never beat anyone with
- 44:07his hand, neither a woman nor a servant.
- 44:10And you're like, okay, well, at least
- 44:11Muhammad didn't. But then you go to
- 44:13another hadith in the same collection of
- 44:16hadith, Muslim 974, and listen to what
- 44:19happens. Aisha says that Muhammad struck
- 44:22her in the chest for following him
- 44:23outside the house. So Muhammad goes out
- 44:26and so she gets up and follows him to
- 44:28see what he's up to, see that she's he's
- 44:30coming back, races back in to get into
- 44:32bed before he notices that she has dared
- 44:34to leave the house. And Aisha recalled
- 44:36that quote, "He struck me on the chest
- 44:39which caused me pain." And then Muhammad
- 44:41rebuked her for following him outside.
- 44:45>> What a life. and in the Old Testament
- 44:48because Muhammad gets so many scriptures
- 44:51wrong which we'll get into in a future
- 44:53episode. But in that story, you remember
- 44:55how Job's wife is curse God and die.
- 44:57Yeah. Well, Allah adds or Muhammad adds
- 44:59to that story that Job is commanded to
- 45:02quote take in your hand a bundle of
- 45:04grass and strike your wife with it. And
- 45:07grass here means flexible plants. So it
- 45:09could be reeds or twigs. In other words,
- 45:12when she says something in in our Bible,
- 45:14it's like Job is like, "No, no, no. God,
- 45:16God gives, God takes. And the Muslim,
- 45:18it's like, "No, Joe beats her."
- 45:19>> You know, how dare you ever say that
- 45:21about Allah. And so, one of the most
- 45:25disturbing, as if it can get worse, you
- 45:28have Aisha, who's the daughter of Abu
- 45:30Bakr. So, Abu Bakr is going to be the
- 45:32first caiff to follow Muhammad, leads
- 45:34Islam, right?
- 45:35>> So, this is his daughter and he finds it
- 45:37to be a good idea to do what we're about
- 45:39to read. So Muhammad's best friend first
- 45:41Caleb when she describes her first
- 45:44encounters with Muhammad she said quote
- 45:46I used to play with the dolls and his
- 45:49presence of the prophets here you got a
- 45:51little girl playing with dolls and my
- 45:52girlfriends also used to play with me
- 45:54and when Allah's messenger used to enter
- 45:56my dwelling place they used to hide
- 45:57themselves but the prophet would call
- 45:59them to join and play with me and so
- 46:01here's like what such a stark contrast
- 46:03when Jesus comes around what do children
- 46:05do
- 46:06>> run to him
- 46:06>> they run to him he has to be like hold
- 46:08on don't hinder them from coming to Come
- 46:10on kids. Like he blesses them. I mean
- 46:12when Muhammad comes around what do kids
- 46:14do?
- 46:14>> Hide themselves.
- 46:15>> They hide themselves. And he goes back.
- 46:16No, no, no. Come play with her. And so
- 46:18that's Bkari 61:30. Now here's where it
- 46:21gets unbelievable to me. According to
- 46:23Bkari 5158, quote, "The prophet wrote
- 46:26the marriage contract with Aisha, the
- 46:28girl playing with dolls, the daughter of
- 46:30Buk of Abu Abu Bakr, while she was 6
- 46:34years old and consummated his marriage
- 46:37with her while she was 9 years old. And
- 46:39she remained with him for 9 years more
- 46:42till his death. So Muhammad's going to
- 46:44be 51 years old when the two of them are
- 46:46married. She's six." He consummates the
- 46:49relationship with her when she's nine.
- 46:53>> When she's nine. And you'll get you'll
- 46:56get Muslims that are like, "Oh, no.
- 46:57There's there's people who reach puberty
- 46:59by nine." And it's like, "No, there
- 47:01aren't.
- 47:03There's a name for this kind of
- 47:04behavior."
- 47:06And if you are saying, and this is this
- 47:08is the deal breaker for me. Like I mean
- 47:11you could you could twist all kinds of
- 47:14other things to make him, you know, well
- 47:16maybe this explains that or maybe this
- 47:18explains that. There is nothing on this
- 47:20planet that you could say to me that
- 47:23would justify a grown 51-year-old man,
- 47:27>> a man in his 50s
- 47:30taking sexually sexual advantage of a
- 47:329-year-old.
- 47:33>> How do you follow this man? How do you
- 47:36say that he is the perfect moral example
- 47:39sent by Allah? This is the deal
- 47:42breakaker and anybody who embraces Islam
- 47:45has to say that this is okay. And what
- 47:48Jesus never does this none of the
- 47:49apostles ever do this like this isn't a
- 47:51cultural thing apart from
- 47:54perverts of the ancient world. And so
- 47:57when Aisha is talking back to the
- 48:00prophet later, he says, "Oh, Allah's
- 48:02messenger, a virgin feels shy, he says
- 48:06to her, her consent is expressed by her
- 48:09silence,
- 48:12>> right?" Like I don't I don't understand.
- 48:15Like there's so many people that I know
- 48:17have a conscience, who have a moral
- 48:20compass that count themselves under
- 48:22this. But how do you look at your own
- 48:24holy writings and say, "This is the best
- 48:26way. This is the behavior we should
- 48:28emulate. And yet, because this behavior
- 48:32is emulated, wherever you see Islam
- 48:35move, you see incidents of child rape
- 48:37and child marriage skyrocket. It's what
- 48:39you see in the United Kingdom where they
- 48:41just did a national audit on groupbased
- 48:44child exploitation, sexual exploitation,
- 48:46and abuse, and it's through the roof.
- 48:48You go through history of Islam and some
- 48:50of their most revered voices like Al
- 48:52Gazali whose writing in the 12th century
- 48:55says this about how you are to engage in
- 48:58relationships with children. Quote, "A
- 49:00man may enjoy his wife in all
- 49:02permissible ways. As for a minor girl,
- 49:05it is not unlawful, in other words, it's
- 49:07legal to touch her with desire or to
- 49:10embrace her. If she is able to bear
- 49:12intercourse, it's not forbidden with a
- 49:14child."
- 49:15>> Wow. You look at I mean within the past
- 49:17century Ayatollah Kmeni who's the
- 49:19founder of the Islamic Republic of Iran
- 49:21wrote about this issue. You want to know
- 49:23what he said? Listen to this. A man can
- 49:25marry a a girl younger than 9 years of
- 49:28age but he is not allowed to have sexual
- 49:30intercourse with her before nine
- 49:32>> because Muhammad did that.
- 49:33>> Correct. And then he says other sexual
- 49:36acts such as lustful touch, embracing
- 49:38and rubbing are permitted. This is the
- 49:41official doctrine, the official position
- 49:45of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Not
- 49:47because they just made it up.
- 49:50>> It's because they read the holy writings
- 49:52of Islam and say, "This is the path."
- 49:56ISIS granted soldiers and their
- 49:59permission to rape captive children,
- 50:01citing Muhammad's example. Listen to
- 50:02what they wrote. It is permissible to
- 50:04have intercourse with a female slave who
- 50:06has not reached puberty if she is fit
- 50:08for intercourse. However, if she's not
- 50:11fit for intercourse, then it is enough
- 50:12to enjoy her without intercourse.
- 50:17And so, if you were to take all of this
- 50:19and just go back to the beginning where
- 50:21the majority of hell is going to be
- 50:23filled, all of the things you exist to
- 50:25please your husband, all how do you feel
- 50:28like Islam presents women? Do you think
- 50:30that there's any way that you could take
- 50:32everything that we've just said and say
- 50:35that this God
- 50:39sees women with dignity and honor?
- 50:42>> Not at all.
- 50:43>> No. It's unbelievable. And when I think
- 50:47that this culture is gaining more and
- 50:50more of a foothold in the west and I
- 50:51look at my precious little girl and I
- 50:53think if this any of this were to happen
- 50:55to her,
- 50:58I want to speak now before it gains any
- 51:01more influence. I want to call it out.
- 51:02And again, we keep emphasizing I Muslims
- 51:06need love. I believe that they're
- 51:08enslaved to a doctrine and a worldview
- 51:10that is horrendous. And I want them
- 51:12freed from it. I want them to know the
- 51:13love of a God who shows all people
- 51:15dignity, who lifts all people up, who
- 51:16calls them to peace and beauty. A God
- 51:19who would go to a cross and lay down his
- 51:21lives and never take a bride for
- 51:22himself. Why? He would kill all of his
- 51:25desires. He would suppress all of his
- 51:27desires to live the perfect life that we
- 51:28couldn't to give it for us. And Muhammad
- 51:31is the absolute opposite. There's no
- 51:34pleasure that he withholds from himself.
- 51:35He given special exceptions all over the
- 51:37place. And his people, oh, you know, Ali
- 51:39did that. he deserves more than just
- 51:41that slave woman. Like, oh my goodness.
- 51:46Don't tolerate this because all
- 51:48throughout all 1400 years since
- 51:51Muhammad, wherever this example goes,
- 51:53you see the treatment of women just fall
- 51:57to pieces. Don't buy it. And again, like
- 52:01I I I've got to believe that there are
- 52:05millions of Muslims who would hear this
- 52:08and go, "Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
- 52:10That's not me. I don't agree with that."
- 52:13And I know that for for millions of
- 52:15Muslims, Islam is this beautiful
- 52:17religion that calls you to family and
- 52:19community and prayer and all of those
- 52:20things and and habits. But what I want
- 52:23like the smelling salt says, "This is
- 52:25your prophet.
- 52:27This is your God. It is a false
- 52:30religion. It is false prophet. But when
- 52:33you sign up for Islam, this is what you
- 52:36affirm.
- 52:38And I know that it is unbelievably
- 52:41difficult to to separate yourself from
- 52:43something that defines your entire life.
- 52:46But Jesus is worth it. The future is
- 52:49worth it. The dignity of women and and
- 52:52and the marginalized is worth it. It's
- 52:56worth walking away from this and
- 52:57experiencing the love of a God who is
- 53:00true
- 53:01>> and amazing. Not this God that exploits
- 53:06and treats women like property or
- 53:08garbage. And that's the invitation at
- 53:10the end of all of this to come to Jesus
- 53:12who gives women value, who loves them,
- 53:14who died on a cross for their sins. So,
- 53:16thank you so much for watching. Join us
- 53:18next time on God to Trust.
- 53:22Heat
- 53:27up here.