Latest / Bad Decisions Podcast / #52 The Animation Industry is COLLAPSING with Zach Mulligan
Transcript
- 0:00What it means to watch a movie is changing.
- 0:02Your layoffs have begun at pixelsive cost cutting measures.
- 0:05This is part of a larger problem.
- 0:07The VFX should be getting better and better and better with all
- 0:09this tech coming out. The big secret is that movie
- 0:12executives don't really care about quality.
- 0:14All they care about is making sure that people go see it.
- 0:18This is Zach Mulligan, a 3D animator with over a decade of
- 0:21experience in Hollywood working at studios such as DreamWorks
- 0:24Animation. He has worked on movies like The
- 0:26Bad Guys, Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom, Black Adam and the
- 0:29Flash. Zach has captivated a huge
- 0:31audience online by breaking down animated films and addressing
- 0:35problems in the industry. What do you think is the most
- 0:38significant 'cause that could be the downfall of the animation
- 0:41industry? The obvious answer, and the most
- 0:43uncomfortable one is probably just if you talk about the
- 0:46future of where this industry is going, I think indie studios is
- 0:50kind of the future of this. When you start democratizing
- 0:53these tools and making it easier for artists to access the same
- 0:56tool sets, you're going to see a lot of really cool art comments.
- 0:59You have created amazing content.
- 1:01You break down all your ideas. You talk about the industry.
- 1:04Zach, what we want to start with is how did you get into the
- 1:08animation industry? Zach, welcome to the Bad
- 1:11Decisions podcast. Hello, guys.
- 1:14Great to be here. Thank you.
- 1:16I love it, man. It's a pleasure to have you, me
- 1:19and Farrah have some burning questions.
- 1:21Farrah, I'll give the mic to you. 100%.
- 1:24Technically we have two mic so don't need to do it, but
- 1:27theoretically. Zach, we've been watching your
- 1:29videos on YouTube. We have stumbled upon your clips
- 1:32on TikTok as well. You have created amazing
- 1:35content. We really love the way you
- 1:37breakdown all your ideas. You talk about the industry, the
- 1:41way you share information, I think is one of the most
- 1:44outstanding pieces that we've ever seen.
- 1:47Oh, thank you guys. I appreciate that.
- 1:49And Zach, what we want to start with is you've worked at
- 1:53DreamWorks Animation Studio. Also, you've worked on big
- 1:57titles such as The Flash, Black Adam, Aquaman.
- 2:01How did you get into the animation industry?
- 2:04Yeah, so I went to film school and I had an LA program out here
- 2:09in Los Angeles, and I got an internship at DreamWorks.
- 2:13And through my connections there, I was able to just kind
- 2:17of learn about the animation industry as a whole.
- 2:21And, you know, my specialty in school kind of became animation
- 2:24just through my own interests. And I kind of became like the
- 2:27VFX guy and then the animation guy.
- 2:30So it just kind of like, you know, dovetailed into animation.
- 2:34But. But when I started at
- 2:36DreamWorks, I was an intern for like that first semester and
- 2:40then moved back to graduate in New York, moved back to LA,
- 2:44worked at the Jim Henson Company for about a year and a half, and
- 2:47then after that got a job at DreamWorks on their TV side in
- 2:51the post production department. So I was there starting like
- 2:54from that stint in post production for four years after
- 2:58that. So I was working in different TV
- 3:00shows as a post coordinator through the pandemic and then
- 3:04starting remotely on the bad guys, which was the feature that
- 3:07I worked on at DreamWorks, which was a lot of fun.
- 3:11But yeah, I kind of, you know, went to went to school to be a
- 3:14filmmaker, kind of like, like anybody just wanting to go and
- 3:18did something creative and just kind of found myself like really
- 3:22falling in love with my animation roots and, and just
- 3:26going through going through the pipeline like that.
- 3:27But yeah, so I, I ended up at DreamWorks just as, you know,
- 3:31the sort of the on the coordinator side and the
- 3:35production side. And we could talk about the two
- 3:37of how the production side and the artist side are two
- 3:40different, you know, branches that I like to call it in
- 3:43animation, but both are equally important.
- 3:46So I was more on the production side and I got to see how a lot
- 3:49of the like, you know, the structure of the animation
- 3:52industry plays out and interface with the artist directly that
- 3:57we're working on these shots and, you know, giving them their
- 3:59work, checking in with them, making sure that they had
- 4:01everything they need. And in addition, I am also an
- 4:04animator as well. So I kind of had that like
- 4:07background to be able to like talk with them and know exactly
- 4:10kind of what I was talking about.
- 4:12But but yeah, so that's that's kind of how I got into the the
- 4:15industry was just, you know, just powering forward, I guess.
- 4:20I love that. What was the most favorite
- 4:22project of yours that you worked on?
- 4:24Probably the bad guys because that was my first introduction
- 4:27to feature film. Before that it was all episodic
- 4:30TV. I worked on shows like Captain
- 4:32Underpants, Where's Waldo, some other like you know, Peacock and
- 4:36Netflix original series. But once I started working on
- 4:39the bad guys and I got to interface with a lot of the like
- 4:43the feature artists at that point, it was a completely
- 4:46different pipeline, a lot more fast-paced.
- 4:48You know, TV, the nature of TV is that it's quick and
- 4:52fast-paced, but you know, there's not a lot of money in
- 4:54it. With feature, it's they're
- 4:56throwing everything into the machine and trying to get that
- 4:58to work. So it was really cool to see
- 5:00that feature animation side. And you know, we were completely
- 5:04remote during 2020 into 2021 for the entirety of this project.
- 5:09And it was a lot of fun to work with these artists for so long
- 5:13and then finally meet them in person in the last, like, couple
- 5:15months of development and, you know, realize that everyone's a
- 5:18lot taller than I am you. Didn't see any of your team
- 5:21members when you started the project?
- 5:24Correct. Yeah, I knew one person.
- 5:26It was something that I worked with at Henson and she was my
- 5:28supervisor. But other than that, I didn't
- 5:31meet anybody in person until like a year into working on the
- 5:34project, which was crazy. But yeah, so trying to do a
- 5:37whole movie remote was a whole experience.
- 5:40And I don't know if I recommend it, but it was a lot of fun.
- 5:43How did you guys collaborated? Basically because everybody was
- 5:47working from home and there was no physical meeting happening at
- 5:51that time. Yeah, so we did everything over
- 5:54like Google meets and, you know, Gmails and chats and everything.
- 5:58So it was a lot of, you know, just chatting artists and
- 6:03getting on a a call with them maybe once or twice a week.
- 6:06But other than that, you know, you're just working by yourself
- 6:09and getting all your work done independently.
- 6:11And then, you know, getting on the giant meetings with
- 6:13everybody where you have the director and you have the
- 6:15producers and the animators themselves, and, you know,
- 6:19sitting in these gigantic meetings on mute, camera off,
- 6:22but still being able to kind of see everybody.
- 6:25And so it was a really unique experience.
- 6:28And once we started going into the office and I realized, like
- 6:32how it's supposed to work, I was like, oh, we're getting so much
- 6:34more done in person. This is crazy.
- 6:37So it was it was very unique. And it, you know, some of the
- 6:41artists I know had a really good experience with being completely
- 6:44at home. Like, you know, they were
- 6:46raising kids and they were able to like, be home all the time
- 6:49and be able to work. So they were like, this is
- 6:51great. I never want to go back in the
- 6:52office. And others were like, I need to
- 6:54be in person because I need that, like, human connection.
- 6:57So it's kind of a mixed bag. But we ended up making it work.
- 7:00And I think the movie came out really well.
- 7:02But it's. Yeah, it was a lot of fun.
- 7:05You know working on a feature film is a dream of many artists
- 7:08like yourself as well. This is why it's your most
- 7:10favorite project. What is the one thing that you
- 7:13overlooked or one thing that surprised you when you joined in
- 7:16that you didn't expect at all? That's a good question.
- 7:20I think just, you know, the, the amount that goes into the
- 7:24smallest details, I would say of, you know, entire meetings
- 7:28can be had about the color of the jacket of a background
- 7:32extra. And you know, it can be a whole
- 7:34discussion and it can be the thing of like, you know, the
- 7:37colored designer comes in and production designer and says,
- 7:39well, this jacket has to be blue because in the the tonality of
- 7:43the scene and what's going on, the character is feeling sad.
- 7:46So we need to emphasize the cooler colors and it can't be
- 7:49red because XYZ. So, you know, entire discussions
- 7:51can happen about the smallest details and that's the kind of
- 7:54thing you can do in feature animation is like really harp on
- 7:58those background details and you know, just get really into the
- 8:01weeds. And that's kind of where the fun
- 8:03discussions happen of especially with character animation,
- 8:07specifically where the performance of the characters.
- 8:10You know, sometimes the notes that they are giving is, you
- 8:13know, just raise the eye bout just a little, a little bit
- 8:15higher or just, you know, squint the eyes just a little bit more
- 8:19because we need to XYZ. Like it's the the amount of
- 8:23small, tiny details that get discussed on these movies is
- 8:26astounding. But so, you know, if you're very
- 8:29detail oriented, you're gonna do well in feature.
- 8:32I've always said that, but it's. Yeah, that was probably the big
- 8:36thing that surprised me was just how much control that, you know,
- 8:40the artist had over the smallest details.
- 8:42And sometimes they'd be on screen for three frames and that
- 8:45was it. But we've had these like, long,
- 8:46like hour long discussions about what needs to go through.
- 8:49But yeah. But everybody's on board with
- 8:52that, right? Everybody's down with OK.
- 8:54So even the team, they're OK to go back and make changes and.
- 8:58Yeah, they're. Getting paid well, I think.
- 9:00That's actually overtime. If it's not that, we can.
- 9:04No, I think, you know, the the nature of feature animation just
- 9:09in general is that everyone is super on board with making the
- 9:12best thing that they possibly can.
- 9:14And you know, if it needs few more rounds of retakes and
- 9:18notes, then they're going to, you know, do the best they can
- 9:21to make it as good as possible. And the sequence that we worked
- 9:25on for like the longest chunk of time was this, this like Guinea
- 9:29pig swarm where you had like hundreds of thousands of Guinea
- 9:32pigs forming into like one gigantic like shape, like a hand
- 9:35or something that would like come down and grab the
- 9:37characters. So it was, you know, researching
- 9:41how to do that, how to even start that process was just a
- 9:44whole like year long process for a sequence that maybe lasts like
- 9:4870 seconds in the movie, in the final movie.
- 9:51So it's like maybe thirty shots. But it was something that we had
- 9:54researched like the entire year leading up to it of just how to
- 9:58do this effect at all. And you know, again, it's only
- 10:01on screen for maybe a minute or two, but you know, just even
- 10:04those quick shots that are like 25 frames, I'm just like, I
- 10:08remember when we were discussing that.
- 10:09And you know, there's, it's just a lot of fun.
- 10:12Wow, after hearing all of this I'm gonna appreciate every
- 10:15single frame that I see. Yes.
- 10:17Yeah. The hours and hours of revision
- 10:20of work that has been put through to get this frame to
- 10:23look absolutely beautiful. I think one of the best examples
- 10:26is your own TikTok video where you're analyzing Puss in Boots.
- 10:29Oh, we were watching that. Not only is that fight scene one
- 10:32of the best, your your analysis of the whole scene makes it even
- 10:36more engaging to watch because you get to understand all the
- 10:40little details they went into to make it as perfect as it was.
- 10:44I do want to talk about one thing.
- 10:45We'll get into the Poots and boots, the direction.
- 10:47Is it? Because I think that's
- 10:48interesting. You talked earlier about the
- 10:50difference between production and the animation department.
- 10:53Yeah. I have no idea what you want to
- 10:55talk about, but I'm very interested to know exactly what
- 10:58you meant by it. Yeah, yeah.
- 10:59So the way that I describe it is that you can think of the entire
- 11:04animation team as a tree. So I I call this the tree
- 11:08metaphor. So the leadership is the trunk
- 11:11of the tree where everything, every decision that comes
- 11:14through has to be filtered through them.
- 11:16So that would be the directors, the executive producers, the
- 11:18producers, your core leadership team, the artists are the leaves
- 11:23on the tree. That's the thing that you see
- 11:25immediately when you first watch the movie is you can see all the
- 11:28hard work of the the artists and that would be the leaves of the
- 11:31tree. So then the branches is what
- 11:33production represents, and that's the part that connects
- 11:37the leaves to the trunk. So production is the part of the
- 11:40department that is responsible for making sure that the artists
- 11:44have exactly what they need, taking notes, making sure they,
- 11:47you know, stay organized and on top of everything.
- 11:50But also, you know, getting creative with like trying to
- 11:53provide artists with a different direction sometimes from the,
- 11:57you know, from the leadership team.
- 11:58And so a lot of the production work that is done is, you know,
- 12:03by people that aren't actually in shots themselves and
- 12:06animating things, but are still directly influencing the entire
- 12:10pipeline by making sure that, you know, notes get past
- 12:13seamlessly back and forth. And, you know, if you have to
- 12:16get super creative about, you know, when the note goes into
- 12:20whom and where and why, there's kind of a lot of logistics with
- 12:24that. So it's really great for people
- 12:26who are very organized and, you know, maybe want to work in
- 12:29animation but are not artists themselves.
- 12:32That's, I know that a few people that have worked into production
- 12:35that, you know, cannot draw. I mean, I, I can't draw myself.
- 12:38I can agree to animate, but I really can't too.
- 12:41Yeah. So it's, you know, it's a
- 12:43department that is often overlooked because when you
- 12:46think people who worked on an animated movie, the term you
- 12:49think is animators. So it's not necessarily
- 12:52something that you would think of going into.
- 12:54And, you know, there's entire teams in feature animation that
- 12:57you wouldn't expect, like lawyers and accountants and, you
- 13:00know, entire teams that are equally as important to the
- 13:04entire process. And, you know, all the artists
- 13:06need to get paid. So we need an accounting
- 13:08department to take care of that. So there's, you know, that's
- 13:11that's kind of the thing that I like to talk about with
- 13:13production is just highlighting the coordinators and assistants
- 13:16and supervisors and production managers and all these different
- 13:19roles that, you know, are not getting the high praise of like,
- 13:23you know, like what I'm animating a scene and saying
- 13:25like, you know, oh, these animators did this and this, you
- 13:28know, I can't really say like, oh, well, the coordinator did a
- 13:30good job of taking this note. And you know, it's not really
- 13:32something that you can see visibly, but is equally as
- 13:35important to the entire animation pipeline.
- 13:38Wow, You know when you say all of this, this has to go into the
- 13:43next part of our discussion, which is regarding one of your
- 13:47videos that has over 200,000 views on YouTube.
- 13:49And your title is basically the animation industry is facing a
- 13:53crisis. And some of these factors that
- 13:55you're talking about include the impact of AI, generative AI, to
- 13:59be more precise, massive layoffs, corporate strategies.
- 14:02And over this long period. In that video, you're discussing
- 14:06all of these different factors and more of them in detail.
- 14:09And the way you open up that discussion is, is quite
- 14:13interesting because a lot of the people in the industry are aware
- 14:16of it, but a lot of people watching from the outside are
- 14:18unaware of it because once in a while we'll see these beautiful
- 14:21animations that are being released.
- 14:23So to the outsiders, this doesn't look like it's a
- 14:26problem. Everything's fine, but
- 14:28apparently it's not. And I want to ask you one
- 14:32question. Based on all of these factors
- 14:33that you discussed in that video, what do you think is the
- 14:36most significant 'cause that could be the downfall of the
- 14:40animation industry? I think the the obvious answer
- 14:44and the most uncomfortable one is probably just corporate greed
- 14:48at this point is just, you know, a few people at the top of these
- 14:51corporations that are making these decisions that happen to
- 14:54trickle down to the rest of the company that get affected.
- 14:57For example, the AI conversation, you know, I, I
- 15:00think everyone has their own opinion about AI, but I think
- 15:02there are two discussions that are happening simultaneously
- 15:05that often get muddled together. And that's number one is AIA
- 15:09tool and the other one being like, how will AI affect jobs?
- 15:14And you know, we can say that AI is a tool.
- 15:16Like, you know, a Carpenter has a power tool, but you know, if
- 15:21you had a Carpenter laying off skilled workers with experience
- 15:25to then hire, you know, amateurs to build a house or something,
- 15:30you would be concerned about the quality of the house that's
- 15:32being created because it's being used.
- 15:34You know, it's being built by people that are not skilled.
- 15:37They don't have the the same sort of experience.
- 15:40And that's kind of what we're seeing in our industries.
- 15:42It's like, you know, the tools themselves, to me personally are
- 15:46not really the issue. It's really like how the tools
- 15:48are being put out there and by whom and for what reasons.
- 15:52So a lot of these studios are looking at generative AI and
- 15:56they're not thinking, oh, this is great.
- 15:58We can empower our current artists to create really amazing
- 16:03work more efficiently. What they're looking at is
- 16:05saying, oh, we can cut costs dramatically by laying off 90%
- 16:10of our department. And that's where you see like
- 16:12executives like Jeffrey Katzenberg saying that, you
- 16:14know, 90% of all animation roles will be, you know, made obsolete
- 16:18by AI. That's exactly what he's talking
- 16:20about is, you know, his perspective is, oh, we can, you
- 16:23know, these studios can save a lot of money if we aren't, you
- 16:27know, if we're not hiring artists to be the ones to use
- 16:30these tools. And so I think at the end of the
- 16:33day, I think the, the biggest thing is just the, the
- 16:37difference between what the workers at these studios want
- 16:40out of the studio and what the people at the top want out of,
- 16:44you know, their company. And sometimes it's, you know,
- 16:46they the executives want a little bit more of a bonus.
- 16:48So they'll, you know, layoff. Obviously there's a vast
- 16:52oversimplification of both sides, but I think that's kind
- 16:56of where it stems is just having that conversation about, you
- 16:59know, what the studio, what the workers in the studio wants
- 17:01versus what the executives want out of the same company.
- 17:04You know, I just want to ask Farad the same question because
- 17:07I have something to say about Jeffrey Katzenberg.
- 17:09Farad, what is your take on? What do you think is the most
- 17:11significant cause of the downfall?
- 17:13I would, I would think of the corporate strategies, AI, I
- 17:16would say that would be something that we have to worry
- 17:18about it in a year or two for it to actually come in and cut it,
- 17:22cut jobs. But I think corporate strategies
- 17:25and looking at profit over quality, this is the biggest
- 17:28problem that we are facing now. We can see that the the movies
- 17:31are going out, prequels, sequels, remakes, 1 after
- 17:35another, but the level of quality doesn't doesn't resonate
- 17:39with the titles. Right.
- 17:42You know, this is funny because Jeffrey Katzenberg, me and
- 17:45Farrah are reading Steve Jobs book.
- 17:46Farrah's done. I'm halfway through.
- 17:48Jeffrey Katzenberg is the guy who was working at Disney at a
- 17:51time where Steve Jobs was building Pixar and they made the
- 17:54deal to create Toy Story together.
- 17:56Now, Steve didn't really like Katzenberg.
- 17:58You can see it. He fucking hated him.
- 18:00You can see it in the fucking book.
- 18:02You just have to read it yourself.
- 18:04I have to give it to Katzenberg. Without his existence, these
- 18:08movies, these amazing animated films would still not happen
- 18:10because he was part of the deal. But again, there's a reason why
- 18:13Steve didn't like him. And we have to talk about Steve
- 18:16Jobs the the role he played in bringing animated films to a
- 18:19whole new level. And yeah, this translated to his
- 18:22products at Apple as well. He cared about the product, not
- 18:25the money. He was a freaking millionaire.
- 18:28He made so much money, but he cared about the product 1st.
- 18:32And that's why we saw so many graded animated films when he
- 18:34was working at Pixar. I am.
- 18:37I'm just afraid we don't have that anymore.
- 18:39I'm just afraid we don't have people at the top who care
- 18:43enough about the product itself. They can be rich.
- 18:46They're still going to make a lot of money.
- 18:47They probably can't even spend all that fucking money.
- 18:50But I just don't think they care because it it shows.
- 18:53I'm seeing so many Tik Toks, not just yours.
- 18:55Yours is actually one of the the more famous ones.
- 18:58I'm seeing Tik Toks with just thousands of views, just random
- 19:00people talking about the same thing, saying, yeah, oh, this
- 19:04theater is just putting the 20th anniversary of this movie, The
- 19:0715th anniversary of this movie, and people are going and.
- 19:10Watching that, how many Fantastic Four do we need?
- 19:13Four. No, yeah, no, no, that's a good
- 19:18point. I think there are there's always
- 19:22the discrepancy between what the executives want out of, you
- 19:27know, they want something that will make money.
- 19:30This is a business investment for them at the end of the day.
- 19:32So they want something that they're going to get their money
- 19:34back on. And then, you know, the age-old
- 19:36discussion with, you know, money versus creatives and you know,
- 19:40the creatives wanting to care about the product and make sure
- 19:43that it's the best thing that they can be versus the people
- 19:46that want to make sure that they're going to get a good
- 19:48return on these movies on these things.
- 19:51And I think it's interesting that the the Katzenberg and
- 19:55Steve Jobs comparison is really it's, it's an interesting
- 19:58comparison because, yeah, they are two executives at the top of
- 20:02their game in, you know, very smart at what they do.
- 20:05A Katzenberg, you know, was leading a lot of the Disney
- 20:08movies and even just the on the 2D side for the longest time.
- 20:12And then he kind of got in a fight with, I, I believe he got
- 20:15in a fight with Michael Eisner and then left to start
- 20:18DreamWorks Animation. So that's kind of where that
- 20:20came from. But he, I mean, Katzenberg
- 20:23always wanted to have a good story and everything too.
- 20:27He was just coming at it from the perspective of we we need
- 20:30this to do well and we need this to make money.
- 20:32And I think, you know, Steve Jobs can probably say something
- 20:35similar. But a lot of what Steve Jobs was
- 20:38coming out this with was, you know, the, the consumer he was,
- 20:41he always had the consumer in mind, even just for Apple
- 20:43products and for Pixar movies too.
- 20:45So his big thing was like, for example, Toy Story.
- 20:50When Toy Story came out, it was such a hit, and they knew that
- 20:54they had a really good hit on their hands because the reviews
- 20:58for Toy Story didn't really mention how it was the first
- 21:01computer animated film, first computer animated feature film.
- 21:05It was saying how great the story was.
- 21:07And that was the thing that these reviews were focusing on,
- 21:10not the technical achievements, not the shiny things.
- 21:13It was story. And that's the thing that made
- 21:15Pixar realize, OK, we're on to something here.
- 21:17Like we have something, you know, we have this great story
- 21:20story machine, and that's what we value Pixar for is they're
- 21:22they're wonderful stories. But yeah, I mean, Steve Jobs, it
- 21:26was definitely at the the forefront of that, making sure
- 21:28that the quality was always there.
- 21:30And, you know, I think there are, you know, I to say that
- 21:33there are no executives that care about the quality.
- 21:37You know, I, I would maybe disagree with that, but I think
- 21:40like a large majority of, you know, what their decisions are
- 21:44based on is shareholder value. And, you know, if Disney's going
- 21:48to make a decision to make a, you know, feature animated movie
- 21:51that takes a visual risk and is not in the same art style as
- 21:55their other movies, you know, like the Disney's wish that came
- 21:58out last year, that didn't do so well at the box office and with
- 22:02critics. So the take away for them
- 22:04probably will be, well, the thing that, you know, kept
- 22:07audiences away was probably because we took this risk.
- 22:10So we're going to play it more safe and do more sequels and
- 22:14reboots and everything. And, you know, inherently, I
- 22:17don't really have an issue with sequels and reboots unless
- 22:20they're, you know, just kind of just made for, you know, the the
- 22:24sake of just checking a box because, you know, the audience
- 22:27will say, I mean, how many times have you heard people say like,
- 22:30I'm so sick of remakes, I'm so sick of sequels and everything.
- 22:32And then you see something like The Lion King remake from 2019.
- 22:36It's the top grossing animated movie of all time.
- 22:38So clearly there is this desire for people to have this, you
- 22:42know, this experience, this, you know, this to have these
- 22:46animated movies come out that are remakes, that are sequels.
- 22:48There's clearly a demand for it. But what the audience wants
- 22:51versus what their spending habits are are two very
- 22:54different stories. And I think like people like
- 22:56Steve Jobs and Jeffrey Katzenberg know that.
- 22:59So, you know, the way that they butt heads is more like caring
- 23:02about the quality versus if they're making something for
- 23:05just, you know, making the shareholders happy.
- 23:08And I that's kind of the age-old discussion now of, you know, the
- 23:11shareholders versus the creatives.
- 23:12And you know what, who are you making this movie for?
- 23:15Are you making it for? Are you trying to get, you know,
- 23:18best animated feature at the Oscars?
- 23:19Or are you trying to, you know, make sure that the stock value
- 23:23of your company goes up because your movie did well.
- 23:25So it's had equally valid reasons, frankly, but it's it's
- 23:30just a different discussion. But the interesting thing is
- 23:33though, and I I want to know if you guys agree with me on this,
- 23:36there is a way to do it. Steve Jobs was known for being
- 23:40very efficient with costs. He knew how to build a lean team
- 23:44and create amazing products so you can actually make great
- 23:47returns, save money, and create amazing products.
- 23:52But it's not going to be easy. So the bright side and the
- 23:56silver lining to all of this is that with the right leadership,
- 23:59it can be done. The point here is the number of
- 24:01films made. When you are making too many
- 24:04movies in a year, you have to hire too many resources.
- 24:09Then you will lose the quality control.
- 24:11Steve Jobs had a very lean team focusing on one animation per
- 24:14year. Imagine if Disney wants to make
- 24:16now 10 animation. They have to outsource half of
- 24:19this work to somewhere, to maybe to other countries, and then the
- 24:22result wouldn't be the same. Yeah, exactly.
- 24:25No, I, I think that is the the key element in this is that
- 24:28right now, you know, with the infinite growth mindset that
- 24:32these companies are kind of operating on, they have to
- 24:35produce more and more and more every year.
- 24:37You know, you can't just make a good film every year that checks
- 24:41the box, that makes a billion dollars every time, which would
- 24:44be great. But you know, the shareholders
- 24:46want to see a billion and a half dollars and then $2 billion.
- 24:50So they, they want to see growth out of these companies.
- 24:53And you know, that kind of conflicts with the model of
- 24:56quality over quantity is you really want to create something
- 25:00that that people connect with and, and people really resonate
- 25:04with. But also, if you're a company
- 25:07like Disney, you're trying to, you know, pay for your parks and
- 25:11your employees salaries and everything by this movie doing
- 25:15well. So like, you know, you have to
- 25:16have a movie that does well because a lot of people's, you
- 25:19know, careers and their salaries depend on these movies doing
- 25:23well. So, you know, that's kind of
- 25:25where you can see maybe too many cooks in the kitchen where you
- 25:27have a lot of executives coming in thinking that they know
- 25:29what's best for the movie, when in actuality, what they need is
- 25:33someone who can just tell an authentic story to them.
- 25:36You know, right now, I think what you see at Disney Animation
- 25:39and you know, maybe studios like Pixar as well, where the leaders
- 25:43of these companies, you know, they're, they're often pairing
- 25:47new directors with someone who's a little bit more experienced.
- 25:51And I think, you know, their recent announcement is they kind
- 25:53of want to scale that back and not tell stories like Turning
- 25:57Red or Luca or Soul, which are, you know, they're really great.
- 26:02I, I love all three of those movies, but they're all really
- 26:06personal stories. And I think, you know, the, the
- 26:09direction of saying like, we don't want to tell personal
- 26:11stories anymore. We're going to move forward with
- 26:13sequels and reboots in order to play it safe.
- 26:17You know, that is an option. That's something you can do.
- 26:19I don't think that will, you know, create the right
- 26:22conditions to create beautiful, meaningful, lasting art.
- 26:26But you know, I'll still see Toy Story 5.
- 26:29What the heck? Why not?
- 26:30So, you know, it's, it's all that's people thinking they know
- 26:34what is right for the company. But yeah, I, I, I think it's an
- 26:38interesting conversation to be having of, you know, who are
- 26:42these movies being made for at all?
- 26:44And I think, you know, these these Pixar movies, these Disney
- 26:47movies are coming out and they're, they're really just
- 26:51checking a box at this point. And so that the shareholders
- 26:54are, you know, they can be secure knowing that, OK, Disney
- 26:58is doing well enough that I will continue supporting it and make
- 27:02the stock go up. But yeah, it's it's the D'Angelo
- 27:04conversation. So we are talking about the
- 27:07impact that these decisions have on the quality of the output,
- 27:11but there has to be an impact to the artists that are also
- 27:15working on the film. You had a TikTok video that had
- 27:18more than 8 million views, and this number shows that a lot of
- 27:22people resonated with what you were saying.
- 27:24So the video titled as the The Flash is Bad VFX is just the tip
- 27:29of the iceberg. And you were talking about the
- 27:31unrealistic expectation, the overtime and the workload that
- 27:35the artist was facing. Yeah.
- 27:37Could you tell us a bit more about that project?
- 27:39And I believe you left it after three months, right?
- 27:42Yeah, so I came in to a VFX company that was working on a
- 27:49small part of The Flash. And you know, the nature of
- 27:52these Movies Now is you have many VFX companies working on
- 27:55these movies. So, you know, part of my work
- 27:57was working on The Flash in the same day as working on Black
- 28:01Adam or Aquaman. Like, you know, the nature of
- 28:03the job just required you to be handling, you know, different,
- 28:07different files for each project on the same day.
- 28:10So I was a volume post. What was it?
- 28:15There's a coordinator role, but it was like volume capture, post
- 28:19production coordinator or something like that.
- 28:21So I got to see a glimpse of what the VFX industry is like
- 28:27and you know, the VFX industry versus the animation industry,
- 28:30two very different industries right now.
- 28:33And you know, very similar in that they, they kind of do a lot
- 28:36of the same work, but VFX right now is getting a lot of pressure
- 28:41on it to deliver faster and faster and faster results in a
- 28:44shorter amount of time. And I was saying the way that
- 28:47these studios will get work is they will bid on these projects.
- 28:51And you know, the a bidding economy like that will often
- 28:54almost always create a lower and lower quality because, you know,
- 28:58companies want to outbid each other and say, you know, we can
- 29:00do this for a million and another company say we can do
- 29:03this for 800,000. So that becomes the standard
- 29:06when you only have a few companies making superhero
- 29:09movies or large budget VFX films like a Disney, like a Warner
- 29:14Brothers, so that you know it. It becomes that they're
- 29:18competing with each other in this environment.
- 29:20And it leads to a lot of overtime with these artists.
- 29:23A lot of them are burning out, creating unsafe working
- 29:27conditions where they, you know, the artists have to work a lot
- 29:30of long hours, sometimes with no overtime pay.
- 29:34And it's just creating this economy of, you know, depending
- 29:37on making things faster and faster and faster.
- 29:40And one of the things I said in the video is, you know, if it
- 29:42looks like a shot was made in a week, it probably was, you know,
- 29:46that's, it's not a very uncommon thing in VFX is to turn out
- 29:49these shots really, really quickly.
- 29:51And you would think that, you know, like, let's say a movie
- 29:54like Pirates of the Caribbean two, you know, the gold standard
- 29:57of VFX, Davy Jones. The, the, the way that that VFX
- 30:01was in that movie is so timeless because, you know, the economy
- 30:05of VFX wasn't really figured out by the studios of, oh, we can
- 30:09overwork these artists and get 3 movies a year instead of just
- 30:12the one. So, you know, you, you, you kind
- 30:15of have this, this discrepancy between the quality that is
- 30:19expected of a superhero movie from a large company like Disney
- 30:22or Warner Brothers and what is being put out.
- 30:25And, you know, the audience can see through it.
- 30:27You know, the, the sequence in the Flash that that people were
- 30:30very critical about, rightly so, felt very much rushed.
- 30:35And it's probably because it was.
- 30:38And you know, it, it kind of, it feels like this is just all too
- 30:42common. And, you know, and I decided to
- 30:45leave just out of kind of realizing that, OK, this is not
- 30:48for me. This.
- 30:49I'm not going to be part of this.
- 30:51Yeah, I don't really, I don't really agree with how they're
- 30:54operating this. And you know, I don't want to
- 30:56age 50 years in one week. And, you know, I was just, it
- 31:01was just unsustainable. And I knew that I wanted to do
- 31:04my own, you know, start my own company, make my own animations.
- 31:07So I kind of took that, you know, opportunity to say, OK, I
- 31:11think this is the right time for me to step away.
- 31:14And, but also, you know, looking back at it, I would hate for
- 31:19people to think to, to watch a movie like The Flash or Avengers
- 31:23or, you know, Dead Man's Chest and think, oh, I really want to
- 31:26go into VFX because I want to, I want to have my work valued by,
- 31:31you know, people and by these companies.
- 31:33And then to get into VFX and be surprised by the industry and to
- 31:36be, you know, to, to not expect how tumultuous it really, truly
- 31:41is right now. So I, I kind of, you know, just
- 31:45made it for myself. Really didn't think 8 million
- 31:47people would see it. But that's just the nature of
- 31:50TikTok, I guess. But yeah, I, I thought it was
- 31:53important to at least, you know, make it a, make it known.
- 31:56And not to say that like the Flash specifically was the
- 31:59issue. Like it, it wasn't, you know,
- 32:01the, the team I worked with was great.
- 32:02They were just really overworked and very stressed.
- 32:05So it like, I had no issue with the people that worked on these
- 32:08movies. It was more just like, you know,
- 32:11this is part of a larger problem in VFX is you know, the the VFX
- 32:16should be getting better and better and better with all this
- 32:18tech coming out, you would think that the VFX are going to be
- 32:21really great. You know, they should look
- 32:23better than Dead Man's Chest did.
- 32:26What was it 18 years ago now? I think so it's it's a crazy
- 32:30difference in what we expect the quality to look like and then
- 32:33what we see in these final movies.
- 32:35And, you know, sometimes the audience doesn't really care.
- 32:38And I think that's, you know, that the point that I made in
- 32:41that video, too, was like, the big secret is that movie
- 32:44executives don't really care about quality.
- 32:46All they care about is making sure that people go see it.
- 32:49So as long as, you know, your movie makes a billion dollars at
- 32:52the box office, you know, they could care less whether, you
- 32:55know, the skin texture on the Flash looked like rubber, you
- 33:00know, or something like that. So yeah, that was.
- 33:03That was you're like, you're like the Edward Snowden of the
- 33:07Hollywood industry. I'm just joking.
- 33:10I want to ask, I have, I have a really important question.
- 33:13But before I get to that, you mentioned the volumetric capture
- 33:17production coordinator. What is that?
- 33:18Yeah, yeah. So the, the volume that we were
- 33:22working with and I, I can talk about it because they made a
- 33:24whole behind the scenes video on it now.
- 33:26But the essentially what they did to get these actors into
- 33:31these 3D environments and everything was they created a
- 33:34rig where the actors could stand in, you know, like like the
- 33:38classic like cage of cameras that you know, gets, you know,
- 33:41it can scan the actors. They did that in a way that they
- 33:45could basically create 3D models and sequences that they could
- 33:50drop in. So this this animated
- 33:52performance could be dropped into like an Unreal Engine and
- 33:56you can light the actor in a different way.
- 33:57So it's kind of acting like, you know, Polycam, but 24 frames a
- 34:01second essentially. So like. 4.
- 34:04D Yeah, 4D. Capture sort of thing, right?
- 34:07Yeah, yeah, in a way. So you know, the, the, the
- 34:10details on it, I probably shouldn't talk about too much,
- 34:13but the, you know, the idea was that, you know, you have this,
- 34:17this volume capture process and then you need a team to
- 34:21interpret that data and make it usable for the rest of the team,
- 34:24clean it up and everything like that.
- 34:26There's a whole team that was just really making sure that the
- 34:29data that was captured can be usable by production.
- 34:32So our team was responsible for cleaning up the data and making
- 34:35it usable for the layout artists, the animators to be
- 34:39able to go in and tweak the performances as needed.
- 34:41This but. This is really sick.
- 34:43So for architectural visualization, we were going on
- 34:46this website, I believe it's called Render People.
- 34:48And there's a four 4D section now.
- 34:50And it's it's the exact same thing.
- 34:52It's a volumetric capture. And for anybody that doesn't
- 34:55know what this is, you have to understand how amazing this
- 34:58technology is because there is cloth simulation baked in that
- 35:02video. So essentially what we worked
- 35:05with, I don't know about you guys, was an Olympic file that
- 35:08comes in with everything. So you've got 3D video if that's
- 35:12like a way to explain it. All the hair, the cloth is
- 35:16moving in the perfect way, no artifacts.
- 35:19And yeah, it's it's amazing. It just works instantly.
- 35:22And as you said, you can light it and all that sort of things.
- 35:25It's very cool, but it's very heavy at the same time.
- 35:28Yeah. Have have they used that a lot
- 35:30in these movies? Are they going to be using a lot
- 35:32more of this you think based on your experience?
- 35:34Yeah, From my understanding, the tech was being built so that it
- 35:37could be used moving forward in these different, you know, by
- 35:41these different companies, by these different films.
- 35:44And, you know, part of it is a tool.
- 35:46Like sometimes you're you're getting it.
- 35:47And maybe the animator will get this data and realize actually,
- 35:51you know, we have to reanimate this character because, you
- 35:55know, the nature of the scene is just so crazy chaotic or
- 35:58something like that. So it's kind of used as a tool
- 36:01in that sense and just a way for the team to quickly capture, you
- 36:06know, accurate lighting data and everything like that.
- 36:08But also the way that they set this rig up was they had screens
- 36:12on the inside of this cage essentially that the actors
- 36:16could see a previz version of the scene.
- 36:20So you know, like for for Aquaman, you know, if he was
- 36:23swimming through the scene, you can see, he can see from his
- 36:27perspective on the screen, you know, the the camera moving
- 36:30through a tunnel or something like that.
- 36:32So, you know, it's just a little bit more for the actor to work
- 36:34off of than just, you know, like, OK, you're in front of a
- 36:38green screen and you're being chased by a giant squid.
- 36:40Go yes. Like it's, it's a lot harder to
- 36:43do something like that then if you just give them something to
- 36:46work with. And I, I think that was the, you
- 36:49know, the, the big revelation with that tech was that it was,
- 36:53it was useful for both production and the actor
- 36:56themselves. So I think the idea was to just
- 36:58try to push the volume capture process even further with this
- 37:02and, you know, try to get a good result.
- 37:04A get a good result, but B get something that the actors can
- 37:06play with and have fun with and get better performances out of.
- 37:10OK. That's actually very
- 37:11interesting. I'm looking forward to see that.
- 37:14One of the things I want to talk about is AI.
- 37:17Of course we have to talk about it.
- 37:19It's on everybody's minds and we can go as detailed as we want.
- 37:23But talking about corporate strategies, that was one of the
- 37:26main causes of the animation crisis.
- 37:28And the reason for that is because as we talked about the
- 37:31shareholders interest is to raise more money, raises in more
- 37:35profits. And one of the best ways and the
- 37:37most appealing ways to do that is through AI, because guess
- 37:41what? It makes things quicker.
- 37:43It eventually is going to make a lot of things better in terms of
- 37:46quality. Not at the moment, it still
- 37:49sucks in a lot of areas, but eventually will, yeah,
- 37:52eventually will, as every every company is in an arms race like
- 37:56Open AI and Google Gemini to make better models.
- 37:59And they use more data from the Internet to make better models.
- 38:02So it is without a doubt that a IS will become more and more
- 38:06intelligent at what they do. And this is a problem as well
- 38:10because at the same time, when there is more profits through
- 38:14AI, that means we are going to be taking away some of the jobs
- 38:18that artists are doing because they take longer and they cost
- 38:22more. And the third reason, which is
- 38:26quite devilish, is we don't have to deal with people.
- 38:29You just like a code and you press enter and it does the
- 38:32work. What are your thoughts on that?
- 38:34I want to hear both of your thoughts.
- 38:36Yeah, Yeah. I think the way that it's
- 38:39currently situated is it's a lot of potential and it's a lot of
- 38:45promises being made by a company like Open AI to say like, yes,
- 38:50in three years this tech is going to be so good that it will
- 38:54replace character animators. Reminds me a lot of the self
- 38:58driving functionality that we are supposed to get anytime from
- 39:01Tesla where it's full at any point, we're going to get this
- 39:05self driving and it's going to be great.
- 39:07And I think I think 2017 was the year that we're going to get it.
- 39:11So a lot of perhaps, yeah. So a lot of, you know, a lot of
- 39:15this tech is just based on the promise of and the potential of
- 39:20creating these, you know, these, these amazing images and these
- 39:23amazing videos. And you know, there are people
- 39:28actively working on AI models like this to make them better
- 39:31and better. And, you know, I don't think the
- 39:34people that are creating these AI tools have in mind like, oh,
- 39:39this is going to be great. I'm going to take jobs away from
- 39:41millions of people. Like I don't think it's that
- 39:43nefarious. I think it's just a difference
- 39:46between like what the tool is being created for and who is
- 39:50using the tool for what reason. So, you know, to get back to
- 39:52kind of what we were saying earlier, just like the the
- 39:54studios that are looking at this to say, oh, I can replace
- 39:58artists with this with this tool essentially.
- 40:02They probably have not, you know, created a character
- 40:06themselves, you know, like, or they don't have the, the mindset
- 40:09of like a character designer. So they can get an output and
- 40:11think, Oh yeah, this looks good enough.
- 40:13This looks good for what I need. Meanwhile, if you had a
- 40:16character designer looking at this, you can say like, Oh well,
- 40:19you know, there's a lot of primary shapes, but there's not
- 40:21a lot of secondary shapes and tertiary details here.
- 40:24So we need to make sure that the balance of the character works
- 40:26so that it's not coming across as asymmetrical and you know,
- 40:29things like that, that a character designer would have
- 40:31this, you know, this knowledge set of.
- 40:34And I think, you know, in the hands of like, like, let's say a
- 40:37character designer uses this tool, they can probably steer it
- 40:41in a direction that will get a really solid output.
- 40:45But you know, if you're replacing artists with
- 40:47inexperienced people that, you know, like for these like AI
- 40:51prompt engineers that the some companies are hiring or AI
- 40:54artists that, you know, these companies are bringing in, you
- 40:58know, if they don't have the experience of creating, you
- 41:02know, character animation is a great example.
- 41:05Because the amount of notes, kind of like what we were saying
- 41:07earlier, the amount of notes that go into a close up of a
- 41:11character where all they have to do is like, look up, think, look
- 41:14down, scrunch their face and then look back.
- 41:17You know, the amount of notes and details that go into a shot
- 41:20like that is insane. And in a production pipeline
- 41:24might be unmanageable. Because, you know, the way these
- 41:26AI models currently work is you get a brand new output every
- 41:29time. Even if they're saying like, oh,
- 41:30it only tweaks a little bit, they're still like losing some
- 41:33of the detail. And maybe they it's a different
- 41:34shirt or it's a different like, you know, facial hair on the
- 41:38actor. So I think yes, it probably will
- 41:42continue to get better and it will continue to, you know, push
- 41:45towards something that is usable by these companies.
- 41:49The thing that I, you know, kind of try to make sense of it with
- 41:53is you know how artists are adapting to it and you know, if
- 41:59the artists have the same exact tools as what these studios
- 42:03have. In my opinion, I think artists
- 42:06should be learning AI and what it does and more importantly,
- 42:09what it does not because a lot of what these companies are
- 42:12promising is you're going to get a Hollywood great shot right
- 42:15away. But the reality is it takes a
- 42:17lot of iterations to get anything close to what they show
- 42:20in those demo videos. So you know, it's, it's probably
- 42:23maybe days and weeks worth of iterations to get it perfect.
- 42:27And that I don't think will go away.
- 42:29I think, you know, the, the curation of this of the images
- 42:33is something that artists are still going to have to be good
- 42:35at. And so, you know, my advice to
- 42:38people and people listening, artists listening is just learn
- 42:41what these tools do and what they don't do because you might
- 42:43be surprised what they don't do. And how you as an artist can
- 42:46fill in the blanks in that sense.
- 42:48And you know, like something like Photoshop, Generative A,
- 42:50you know, generative fill. It does a decent job for, like,
- 42:54very specific portions, but you know, it won't replace your
- 42:58entire image and get it completely photorealistic every
- 43:01time. It's just a, it's just a tool.
- 43:04And I think to frame it that way of of still using it as a tool
- 43:08is equally as important. And making sure that artists
- 43:11know that going forward. Like, yeah, we have the same
- 43:14tool sets as these Hollywood studios do, but, you know, you
- 43:18still need the experience and you still need to, like, put in
- 43:21the hard work of making it look as good as possible.
- 43:25I agree with you. I think that the analogy of
- 43:28Adobe Firefly is the best example of how it speeds up the
- 43:32process and how it can take care of some of the elements.
- 43:36I still believe a film or an animation is a curated story,
- 43:41and in order to get that curated story, you need to go through a
- 43:44lot of iterations with the current models, with the current
- 43:48devices, the current language models that we have, this is not
- 43:51possible in the future. It can help to speed up the
- 43:54process and it can help the artist.
- 43:57But it would be really, really amazing if we have the artist
- 44:01learn these tools at the same time.
- 44:03Because if an artist can use them effectively, there would be
- 44:07the person who can generate the best image, generate the best
- 44:11video animating the character. Because now we can see AI tools
- 44:14that helps us with character animation or character creation,
- 44:18but the best person who can use them is the person who actually
- 44:20knows how to create those characters in the first place.
- 44:23Right. I think for me, what AI will do
- 44:27is definitely going to eliminate some of the traditional jobs at
- 44:30traditional companies because the companies are going to want
- 44:34to make more profit by getting rid of people just like they are
- 44:37in the massive layoffs. That's something you've
- 44:39discussed as well. But at the same time, I think
- 44:42the upside here is the silver lining lies in the resistance.
- 44:46I saw this video just a couple of days ago, might have been an
- 44:50ex post actually. Just a threat of how people love
- 44:53the resistance. We love being part of the
- 44:56resistance, even in movies. That's why we like the Matrix,
- 44:59right? And every single time you watch
- 45:01a movie, you take side with the resistance and here what AI can
- 45:06do, because there's going to be so many different types of AI
- 45:09and so many AI agents, AI assistance for each artist.
- 45:13You're going to essentially democratize different skill sets
- 45:17to an artist and allow them to use that.
- 45:19So you'll see, and I think this is something you discuss as
- 45:22well, you'll see a lot of a smaller, leaner teams in these
- 45:25studios coming out with three man teams making a gigantic
- 45:29feature film on their own and feature animation because they
- 45:33can fill in all the blanks, all the weaknesses that they have
- 45:36using AI. They have a great story.
- 45:39They just use AI to fill in the bits.
- 45:40So instead of taking two years to create something, they'll
- 45:43take six months and they create an amazing story on their own.
- 45:47And they beat Disney productions or Pixar productions, for
- 45:50instance, because they cared a lot about their product and
- 45:53their story. Again, I'm generalizing here.
- 45:56I'm not saying all of Disney and Pixar productions are are are
- 45:59bad. I'm just saying there are some
- 46:01and that's what we're talking about.
- 46:02But one more thing that I think is really interesting is that we
- 46:06really have to understand people like Ian Hubert.
- 46:09I don't know if you know him, he's a, he's an amazing YouTube
- 46:14with Blender, which is a software that has been
- 46:17democratized, right, A free 3D software.
- 46:20He is able to create his own film on his own.
- 46:22He has some help, but he does the majority of the things
- 46:25himself. This is not something that was
- 46:27possible 20 years ago because all these 3D softwares were just
- 46:30too expensive. You needed hardware that was not
- 46:33accessible to individuals and that is what I think can happen
- 46:38with AI as well. Just like what happened with
- 46:41Blender and Ian Hubert where you see him creating all these
- 46:43amazing films on his own. So I'm, I'm excited, as as
- 46:48pessimistic as I can be. I'm also optimistic about where
- 46:51AI can go. Yeah, no, I I think that's a a
- 46:54fair assessment that like, yeah, at the end of the day, like I'm
- 46:57a tech guy. I love looking all all this new
- 46:59tech coming out and and getting really excited about it and, you
- 47:03know, understanding what it's place is going to be going
- 47:05forward in the future. I think the Ian Hubert example
- 47:08is, I mean, he's like the king of DIY with one day.
- 47:10It's like, you know, he's able to, you know, like balance a lot
- 47:16of the parts of production and and animation all himself.
- 47:20But there's that classic graph. I don't know if you've seen it
- 47:23where it's, I believe it's like quality, like good, fast and
- 47:27cheap. And you can only pick two.
- 47:29Yeah. And that's, that's like the, the
- 47:31way that every production gets made is like, you can, you know,
- 47:34you can focus on the quality and doing it quickly, but that means
- 47:38that it's going to be a lot of money or, you know, so I think
- 47:42AI tools like this can kind of help balance that out a little
- 47:45bit of making something that you know, is, is good looking and
- 47:50you can do it fast and it, you know, you can do it for a
- 47:53reasonable cost at this point because these tools are so
- 47:56accessible. You know, I, I think the Ian
- 47:59Hubert example is interesting because he's taking, you know,
- 48:03for his own schedule. He's taking, you know, quite a
- 48:07long time to get it just right and to do it on his own terms.
- 48:10And, you know, the, the stuff that he puts out is amazing.
- 48:13It takes months and months and months to get it to that point,
- 48:17But you know, he's able to do this on his own because he's
- 48:20indie. And I think, you know, if if you
- 48:22talk about the future of, you know, where this industry is
- 48:25going, I think, you know, indie studios is kind of the future of
- 48:28this. And you know, you have a lot of
- 48:31people like, like look at the amount of pilots on YouTube that
- 48:36have done amazing, like the amazing digital circus is a
- 48:39great example from Glitch Productions where, you know, I
- 48:41think they're something like their first episode has like 300
- 48:45million views or something like that 22 minute pilot.
- 48:48And it's this crazy, crazy viral thing completely independently
- 48:53funded through like Patreon and merch and everything.
- 48:56And I think like, yeah, that's I think the future of the industry
- 48:59is these indie teams working on this.
- 49:01And you don't need, you know, the infrastructure of something
- 49:04like Disney and Pixar. And I think they might know that
- 49:08too. The these larger studios know
- 49:10that, you know, there is this impending revolution happening.
- 49:14I think it started with YouTube and I think it's being continued
- 49:17by people on TikTok and people on Instagram and everything like
- 49:20that. Like, you know, when you start
- 49:21democratizing these tools and making it easier for artists to
- 49:24access the same tool sets, you're going to see a lot of
- 49:28really cool art come and also, you know, make stuff that's
- 49:31really, really revolutionary in terms of how it gets made.
- 49:35I mean, my own studio, we're working on a VR animation that
- 49:39is, you know, I'm, I'm completely self producing it and
- 49:42it's completely independently create like, like right now, I
- 49:46don't, I'm just, you know, funding it off of my own income.
- 49:49And that's something that I can do because the the tools are out
- 49:53there and I can use the tools and create something unique and
- 49:57I don't have to rely on pitching it to a studio in order to get
- 50:01the funding to create this thing.
- 50:03Can just, you know, put the hard work in and model the characters
- 50:06and animate them and use Unreal. And that's follow the bad
- 50:09decisions, Unreal tutorials. Oh yes.
- 50:12That's something you couldn't say, not the unreal bad decision
- 50:15part, but when you say self funding it and working on it on
- 50:18your own, you couldn't say that 20-30 years ago.
- 50:20You couldn't say the bad decision Part 20.
- 50:22You couldn't say that. Yeah, that's a little baby.
- 50:25But the point is now you can because of the tools available.
- 50:29So if we're being optimistic, maybe, just maybe, if everything
- 50:33goes the right direction, in 20 years time you'll have artists
- 50:37just like yourself. 20 years. OK, you're right.
- 50:43Two fires. Yeah, and you're, you're right.
- 50:4620 years, it's exponentially growing.
- 50:48You're right. You're right.
- 50:48You're right. I got it.
- 50:49I got it. Before it becomes the dominant
- 50:51part of our industry, maybe 20 years.
- 50:54But, you know, I, I think these studios and, you know, these
- 50:57tech companies are not going to go down without a fight.
- 51:00And I think they're, they're going to want to like, maintain
- 51:03that foothold. Yeah.
- 51:05So, you know, it happens to be that like Google is the one
- 51:08creating these tools to create generative AI and things like
- 51:11that. So they kind of have ownership
- 51:13of that. And I, I think, you know, open
- 51:16AI Sora model I don't think is going to get released publicly.
- 51:19I think they were kind of keeping that one close to the
- 51:21chest. It's OK, but Dream Machine by
- 51:23Lumas out there. Yeah, exactly.
- 51:25So like. The Chinese version is pretty
- 51:27good too. Yeah, exactly.
- 51:28I haven't used that. They're going to open source a
- 51:30lot of this for sure. And but I think, you know,
- 51:34that's to me, I think that's the coolest part of all of this new
- 51:37tech coming out and making it, you know, democratized as I
- 51:41think the blender model is perfect where you have, you
- 51:45know, the studios creating. I I think the way that blender
- 51:47gets worked on is genius where they're working on short films
- 51:51and animations. And then as they create these
- 51:54tools, like they get a really good hair simulation tool, they
- 51:57push that out immediately. And if they get good animation
- 52:00tools, they'll push that out like the next week.
- 52:02You don't have to wait like years and years for these tools
- 52:04to come out. It's just part of their
- 52:06pipeline. But they're doing so by creating
- 52:09these these pieces of art, this these short films and
- 52:12everything. And I think that's a a really
- 52:15interesting model for me is the open source mindset, isn't that?
- 52:18Ingenious. It's crazy, yeah.
- 52:20And the fact that, yeah, if you pay a little bit of money to
- 52:23them, you can download their project files that they are
- 52:25working on. It's it's such a revolutionary
- 52:28concept that I think more, you know, more artists should
- 52:32explore in the future, too. But Blenders free.
- 52:36And Blenders. Believe it.
- 52:37Can you believe it? Community driven.
- 52:41It's insane. I mean, that's hats off to the
- 52:43entire Blender development team because they are just kicking
- 52:46ass and making it, making it so artists like myself can create
- 52:51animations that, you know, can be seen by, you know, hundreds
- 52:55of thousands of people because I, you know, I have the ability
- 52:59to do that for free. And it's it's just, yeah, I
- 53:03think that's the future of the industry.
- 53:04I think it was at SIGGRAPH or somewhere where I was looking at
- 53:07the pipeline, production pipeline of different animation
- 53:11in production houses, and Blender was already a part of a
- 53:14lot of these teams, but it was mostly in the 3D modeling phase,
- 53:18so everything after that was done in other 3D software.
- 53:21Do you have any knowledge of if that's changing where you'll see
- 53:24Blender in more and more parts of the production pipeline which
- 53:29could be promising to the future Blender artists?
- 53:32Yeah, I think from my understanding, like the UV
- 53:36unwrapping in Blender is kind of unmatched.
- 53:38And like they've, they kind of nailed it with their algorithms
- 53:41and their ability to just like do it so quickly that it's not
- 53:45this like arduous task that, you know, I, I haven't used Maya
- 53:48extensively to that like to beat like do a lot of UV unwrapping.
- 53:52But I know like the way that Blender operates with that
- 53:54specifically is just radical and and just very intuitive as far
- 54:00as how Blender is being used in the professional pipelines.
- 54:03I think a lot of the, the studios at like let's say
- 54:07DreamWorks, they do have their own proprietary tools that they
- 54:10developed their own animation studio or like animation
- 54:13software in house that was built like by artists for artists.
- 54:17And, you know, so I think like maybe with the larger studios,
- 54:21Blender is not really something that you know, will be used
- 54:24directly. But you know, whenever I learn a
- 54:27new software, I kind of come in with the mindset of like, OK, I
- 54:31know, I know Blender, I know how Blender operates.
- 54:33And I know like, you know, when you when you use the the right
- 54:38mouse button tool, it brings up this menu.
- 54:41OK, so I just need to figure out in Maya how that same tool
- 54:45operates in their ecosystem and you know, okay, the the WER keys
- 54:50being like rotate, scale translate, you know, Blender
- 54:53does it with the G RNS keys. Okay, It's just a different way
- 54:57of using this tool. So I think like if you can learn
- 55:01Blender and get really good at using that software, if you go
- 55:06to switch to something like Maya or 3DS Max, you will find that
- 55:10it is an easier transition than if you were to just start from
- 55:14scratch. And I think knowing those tool
- 55:17sets and even with Unreal Engine, like I think going into
- 55:20this software that is OK, more of a game engine and OK, they do
- 55:24the materials just a little bit differently than how Blender or
- 55:26Maya would do it. You know, it's a little bit of
- 55:28an adjustment, but I can equate it to something in my head
- 55:31already that I'm familiar with of, oh, instead of, you know,
- 55:35opening up the node tree here in Blender, OK, it's just a double
- 55:39click on the material asset in Unreal and it pops up with this.
- 55:42OK, you can kind of wrap your head around that, but you have
- 55:46something to base it off of. So, you know, I still encourage
- 55:50a lot of people to learn Blender and to try it out.
- 55:52And you know, if you're completely new, there are so
- 55:55many tutorials out there, it's insane.
- 55:58So it's, it's, there's always easy to get started in something
- 56:01like that. And it's always better to have
- 56:03that in your toolkit so that if you get to, you know, let's say
- 56:07you get a job at DreamWorks as a character animator, you know,
- 56:10their proprietary software is something that they would have
- 56:13to teach you anyway. So you wouldn't know how to use
- 56:16this. So if you have an understanding
- 56:18of, you know, 3D software and any 3D software is like if, if
- 56:22you have that understanding of, you know, an X axis, Y axis, Z
- 56:25axis, like you have that understanding already to be able
- 56:29to just translate it in your head into something that you
- 56:32know is is workable in their ecosystem.
- 56:35But, you know, I think the value of having an open source
- 56:39powerful 3D software cannot be understated.
- 56:42And I think, you know, even if it's not being used by these
- 56:46large studios, who cares? Because it can be used by your
- 56:49studio. And like, that's how you can
- 56:52make movies is through this open source software.
- 56:54And you don't have to pay the Maya licensing fee.
- 56:56So, you know, I, I, I still encourage people to learn
- 57:00Blender, even if it's not used in these studio systems, because
- 57:03I found, you know, the transition can be doable and you
- 57:06know, it can work. Speaking of 3D softwares, in
- 57:102024, what is the best way to learn animation?
- 57:16So I think right now, I mean the obvious answer is YouTube.
- 57:21Frankly, I think if if you have no animation skills whatsoever
- 57:26going on YouTube and just searching animation tutorial, it
- 57:29will get you so many free videos that you won't even know where
- 57:32to start. But I think there are some like
- 57:35some specific like people that I can highlight.
- 57:38I mean, like the Sir Wade Neistat is a great animator and
- 57:42a great mentor and instructor on some animation basics.
- 57:46Obviously Blender Guru being a big one for I know he was on
- 57:50your podcast, which is awesome, by the way, shout out to Andrew.
- 57:53He's awesome. But but yeah, I think the best
- 57:57way to learn animation is just to try it really is to just get
- 58:01into the software. Even, you know, forget the
- 58:03software, just take out a pencil and a paper and just start going
- 58:07frame by frame, you know, get a, get a, what is it, sticky notes
- 58:11and just make a little flip book and learn.
- 58:13Like, OK, when I make this drawing here and this drawing up
- 58:17here and I flip between the two of them, it looks like it's
- 58:19jumping this far. But if I add a frame in between,
- 58:22OK, now it's going a little slower but a little smoother.
- 58:25Like understanding the fundamentals with that is, is, I
- 58:29think, a great way to just experiment with it.
- 58:31As far as books, the one that I always recommend to people is
- 58:35The Illusion of Life, which is written by Frank Thomas and
- 58:38Ollie Johnston, who are two of the original Disney 9 old men.
- 58:42If you've ever heard of them. They were some of the animators
- 58:44that like invented squash and stretch and anticipation.
- 58:49Yeah. So these guys were just these,
- 58:51these crazy kooky animators that just came up with all these
- 58:54principles that became like the founding principles of animation
- 58:58anywhere worldwide. But they, the, the two of these
- 59:01guys wrote a book that equally inspires you to become an
- 59:05animator and teaches you each principle in detail of like what
- 59:09happens in an anticipation. Why do we have anticipations?
- 59:12You know, why is squash and stretch important to maintain
- 59:14volume? So things like that.
- 59:16So I mean, the best ways to get started is YouTube #1 if you
- 59:21could YouTube search for someone explaining the illusion of life,
- 59:24even better. But but I would also recommend
- 59:27that book because it's like the definitive way to get a
- 59:30inspired, but B, to get started. And then just try it for
- 59:34yourself, you know, start on pencil and paper, move into
- 59:37Blender, figure out like, you know, how that operates
- 59:41differently, you know, 3D animation versus 2D animation.
- 59:44I mean, 2D, you know, Blender can do 2D animation now, which
- 59:47is insane. So, I mean, I've been using
- 59:49Blender since 2000, 1009. So I remember when it was not
- 59:53good and it was very different and it was a lot harder.
- 59:58I mean, so it, I, I have seen it come so far in the last, you
- 1:00:02know, decade and 1/2 that it's, it's crazy that it can do 2D
- 1:00:07drawings at all. So I that's that's would be my
- 1:00:10recommendation to get started and check out my YouTube channel
- 1:00:12for other animation breakdowns. 100% Speaking of your YouTube
- 1:00:17channel, you also talked about the VR experience that you're
- 1:00:21creating for spatial computing. Can you talk a little bit more
- 1:00:24about that? Yeah, so I, one of the first
- 1:00:28animations that I made in college was this animation about
- 1:00:31two robots, you know, 2 characters that are very easy to
- 1:00:34model. And it's these, it's this love
- 1:00:36story between two robots and they're in this abandoned kind
- 1:00:40of city. And I always liked the story and
- 1:00:42I liked the characters. And I always wanted to adapt it
- 1:00:45into something else, whether it's a new short film or for
- 1:00:49something like VR. And then once I got, you know,
- 1:00:52interested in VRI, realized, oh, this is the perfect medium to
- 1:00:55tell the story. So the way that I'm approaching
- 1:00:58it is more like theatre than film.
- 1:01:01And, and I, I think that's kind of a better metaphor for VR at
- 1:01:04all, is that when you put on a headset, you are entering a new
- 1:01:09space and you are in cap, you know, in captivating yourself
- 1:01:13around a new environment. You know, it's not real.
- 1:01:16Like, you know, the, the experience is not trying to
- 1:01:18trick you into thinking, Oh my gosh, this is real life.
- 1:01:21But you you have the understanding that you're
- 1:01:23suspending your disbelief and, you know, being able to enter a
- 1:01:28new space means that, you know, the rules of cinema and film
- 1:01:33don't really apply in that sense.
- 1:01:34So like a hard cut will be a lot more jarring than it would be in
- 1:01:39in a film. So the way that I'm approaching
- 1:01:41this is more like theater in that sense.
- 1:01:44And, you know, trying to come up with different ways of
- 1:01:47understanding space. And, you know, just like, for
- 1:01:51example, like the way that I'm blocking everything out is as if
- 1:01:54I'm sitting in front of a Broadway show, like right at
- 1:01:58this the front of the stage. And then everything is staged
- 1:02:01around that sense, you know, around that idea.
- 1:02:05So, you know, we're updating the the characters and the
- 1:02:08environment. I have a brand new art style
- 1:02:10with this. It's more art deco than like
- 1:02:12cyberpunk. Because I think I'm a little
- 1:02:15bored of cyberpunk. I don't know about you guys, but
- 1:02:17I think it's just, you know, it's, it's more about like the
- 1:02:20shiny. Yeah, I think it's more now
- 1:02:22about like the shiny tech and everything with it.
- 1:02:25But like the, the fundamentals of like, what makes cyberpunk,
- 1:02:28cyberpunk is like how dystopian it is.
- 1:02:30So anyway, the art style is more art Deco because that Harkins
- 1:02:34back to like the early days of cinema.
- 1:02:36And in my opinion, where VR is right now is where cinema was
- 1:02:41100 years ago with the Kinetoscope, where you would
- 1:02:44look in this gigantic machine and you would only see these
- 1:02:47little novelty experiences that maybe last like 2030 seconds.
- 1:02:51It wasn't, you know, the language of film wasn't invented
- 1:02:53yet. So that's how I'm looking at
- 1:02:56this piece of tech that like, you know, the stories that we're
- 1:02:58making in this will last, you know, decades into the future
- 1:03:02because this new medium is still being figured out.
- 1:03:05And you know, as as cool as I think like VR Chat is or Rec
- 1:03:09Room or things like that, I still want to approach this from
- 1:03:13like a storytellers perspective and like, what can you do in VR
- 1:03:18to tell a great story? And I think what we're
- 1:03:21developing is really cool. I'm very excited about it.
- 1:03:24It's in black and white. There's no dialogue.
- 1:03:26It's like going back to basics of story of like it's 2
- 1:03:29characters interacting with each other, pantomime.
- 1:03:32And it's this, you know, this beautiful world that we're
- 1:03:34trying to create and I'm trying to document it on my YouTube
- 1:03:38channel by going step by step of the writing process.
- 1:03:42The next episode I'm making is about the character designs and
- 1:03:44the characters themselves. And like, you know, our
- 1:03:46character designer that we're working with is a friend of mine
- 1:03:49who worked on Rick and Morty. He worked on the Pickle Rick
- 1:03:52episode. So it's, it's, you know, he, he
- 1:03:55took the designs that were in the scripts.
- 1:03:58I didn't even show him the original animation.
- 1:03:59I was like, I want a fresh perspective.
- 1:04:01And, and I, you know, he, the character designs that he came
- 1:04:05up with were just amazing and they're just so appealing and so
- 1:04:09of this world and of the story and just so unique.
- 1:04:13So it's, it's something I'm really excited about and trying
- 1:04:16to document at the same time and slowly get the word out that
- 1:04:20we're going to be, you know, crowdfunding this at some point,
- 1:04:22hopefully and, and trying to get more eyeballs on it to, you
- 1:04:27know, I, I think the, you know, the way that VR has kind of
- 1:04:31adapted in the last like six or seven years.
- 1:04:34I'm frustrated by it because, you know, you had these
- 1:04:37animations maybe five or six years ago that were like Oculus
- 1:04:40Story studio was this animation studio that just made animated
- 1:04:44films for VR and like, like tried to explore this medium
- 1:04:48with storytelling. And then the thing that kind of
- 1:04:50became popular was the metaverse or, you know, like VR chat, that
- 1:04:55kind of experience as social, it's like social interactions
- 1:04:58became more the norm. And, you know, I still think
- 1:05:01that kind of falls in the novelty category where it it
- 1:05:04does feel like it's, you know, it's, it's good, it's fun, but
- 1:05:07it doesn't keep you coming back. And I think, you know, there
- 1:05:10needs to be and I think the way that like film adapted was it
- 1:05:15had artists, you know, the tech got into, you know, kind of
- 1:05:18going back to what we were saying, the tools were
- 1:05:19democratized and it got into the hands of artists and the artists
- 1:05:23were able to push that into the future of what became the film
- 1:05:26industry and cinema as a whole. So that's the approach we're
- 1:05:30taking with this. But that's that was a really
- 1:05:32long answer, but that's. Interesting that you're
- 1:05:35documenting the journey. I think that that makes it super
- 1:05:39valuable and super important because when people see how you
- 1:05:43are creating, then the entire process would be much more
- 1:05:47pleasing for people to watch. So I think you should keep on
- 1:05:50creating. The YouTube videos on, I
- 1:05:52remember you posted one about how did you do the writing, that
- 1:05:55the writing was so hard and difficult.
- 1:05:58So we are, we are looking forward to see all the videos
- 1:06:01that we're going to create on YouTube and we are looking
- 1:06:02forward to see. Thank you the.
- 1:06:04Actual short film that you're going to create.
- 1:06:06It's also the way you described it.
- 1:06:08The language of film was not invented at that time.
- 1:06:10And what you're saying is that the language of storytelling in
- 1:06:13VR has not been invented. And you're you're trying to pave
- 1:06:17that path. And it's so true because me and
- 1:06:20Farah have owned multiple VR devices and there was no reason
- 1:06:24for us to go back to it. We never really felt like you
- 1:06:26want to go back and pick it up. We always got excited in the
- 1:06:28beginning and eventually the excitement fell off.
- 1:06:32So with the way you're describing it and how you
- 1:06:36connecting it to theater and the way you're going to tell your
- 1:06:39story using that. So there's no hard cuts and you
- 1:06:42try to take away everything and just focus on the story.
- 1:06:45Going back to the old Toy Story days where the the focus was not
- 1:06:49the fact that this was done with amazing systems like CAPS, which
- 1:06:53was used as the the method to render these images.
- 1:06:57That was revolutionary at the time.
- 1:07:00You don't care about the VR technology.
- 1:07:01You're trying to tell a great story, but at the same time it's
- 1:07:05backed by great VR technology. The story is the focus.
- 1:07:08So that's the, that's the important point.
- 1:07:10So I, I love the way you're looking at this and as Ferret
- 1:07:14said, we're looking forward to it.
- 1:07:16Do you have any release date in mind?
- 1:07:18Like an approximate 1? Before I'm dead.
- 1:07:21It's a good one man. That's a good 1.
- 1:07:27And we have no deadline. We need to get some corporate
- 1:07:31strategies over your head. Right now, yeah.
- 1:07:35No, I think like what I'm trying to do is, you know, raise
- 1:07:39awareness of it, try to get some funding maybe later this year or
- 1:07:41early into next year, and then go into production on it.
- 1:07:45You know, because I'm an animator myself too.
- 1:07:47I'm going to be, you know, handling the character
- 1:07:49animation, a lot of that in addition to any animators that I
- 1:07:53try to bring on. So, you know, my, my pie in the
- 1:07:56sky goal is to have it done in 2026, maybe 2027.
- 1:08:01You know, the nature of animation just in general is the
- 1:08:06average animated film takes about five to seven years to go
- 1:08:10from script to screen. So it, it is a long process.
- 1:08:14And, you know, having worked in the animation industry, I'm
- 1:08:17aware of that now when, you know, in college, I did this in
- 1:08:20like a year, like an 8 minute short film in a year.
- 1:08:24And I don't recommend that because it was just a lot of,
- 1:08:27lot of long nights, a lot of stress, a lot of sleep.
- 1:08:29Yeah. So I'm, I'm trying to approach
- 1:08:32this more professionally, like bring on, you know, character
- 1:08:35designers and artists, environment artists, and just
- 1:08:38really try to do it as professional as possible.
- 1:08:41And, you know, my producer works at Pixar and we're trying to get
- 1:08:45that level of quality with this. And we understand that that is
- 1:08:49going to take time. I went to animation school for a
- 1:08:51semester to like sharpen my animation skills to bring it up
- 1:08:54to that level of Polish that, you know, we're going to expect
- 1:08:57out of this. So, you know, we understand that
- 1:09:00good quality takes time. So we're not trying to rush this
- 1:09:04out for like next year, but you know, it is encouraging to see
- 1:09:07things like Apple saying that they are, you know, they're
- 1:09:10starting to have immersive narrative series.
- 1:09:14I think they just announced in their last keynote that there's
- 1:09:16going to be like the first Apple TV immersive narrative series,
- 1:09:20which is encouraging for people like me to say that like, OK,
- 1:09:24this medium is not dead yet. It's not it's not going the way
- 1:09:28of metaverse and social and it's never coming back to immersive
- 1:09:31story. I think there is still the
- 1:09:34desire for that, even if you know, even if people don't know
- 1:09:37it yet. I think once they see any
- 1:09:40animated film in the. Desire, because I haven't fully
- 1:09:42experienced that yet. It's it's the new thing in my
- 1:09:45opinion, because I haven't experienced a really good
- 1:09:47immersive storytelling. So I think it's, as you said,
- 1:09:50beginning, it's just the beginning of.
- 1:09:52Just the beginning, yeah. Yeah, and I'm definitely not
- 1:09:54claiming to like invent a lot of the stuff.
- 1:09:56I know there's, there's a lot of people that have been creating
- 1:09:59VR animated, you know, immersive films for many years.
- 1:10:04I'm just trying to help make it more known and make it more
- 1:10:09publicized and, and show that, you know, there is a market of
- 1:10:12artists doing amazing work. And I, I think, you know, by
- 1:10:16showing how to do this kind of step by step, it's not
- 1:10:19necessarily a tutorial. It's more of like a production
- 1:10:22diary that you can reference and go back to and like, I'm not
- 1:10:25teaching you like, OK, here's how to animate a character and,
- 1:10:29and do all this. It's more just documenting like
- 1:10:32here's what I here's what my journey looks like.
- 1:10:34And, you know, to go from zero to 100 with a final product is
- 1:10:39going to take a long time. And understanding that well
- 1:10:42ahead of time and you know, from episode one is very crucial.
- 1:10:46And, you know, trying to use my platform to show that, you know,
- 1:10:49there's, there's more than just Horizon VR, as as fun as that
- 1:10:53can be. But yeah, no.
- 1:10:55Absolutely, Zach, we got to say first of all, it was a pleasure
- 1:10:59having you on the pod. Thank you so much for your time
- 1:11:02and thank you for all the wonderful conversations because
- 1:11:05we learned a lot and I'm sure people have.
- 1:11:07And I would encourage people to go ahead and check out your
- 1:11:10YouTube channel, not just to follow your amazing
- 1:11:12documentation of the entire series you're creating, but the.
- 1:11:15Breakdowns. The animation breakdowns.
- 1:11:17The animation breakdowns but. They're fun.
- 1:11:19I got more coming. Yes, please, dude.
- 1:11:21They're amazing. But more importantly, if you
- 1:11:24guys heard the discussion we had and a debate about the the
- 1:11:29issues that the animation industry is facing, then you
- 1:11:33have some amazing discussions about that in full length on
- 1:11:36your channel. And I'm pretty sure you're going
- 1:11:37to be making more of them because there's so many people
- 1:11:39asking you. So I would definitely recommend
- 1:11:42people go ahead and check out your channel.
- 1:11:44So thank you so much for your time once again.
- 1:11:45Yeah, Thank you guys. You guys are fantastic and keep
- 1:11:50up the Unreal to tutorials and everything because those are so
- 1:11:52entertaining and fun and it just makes learning something that's
- 1:11:56as difficult and as intimidating as Unreal just so much more fun
- 1:12:01and approachable and enjoyable. So you guys are killing it too.
- 1:12:03And I see you guys are closing in on 100,000 Subs on YouTube.
- 1:12:07So I'm I'm rooting for that. That's going to happen soon.
- 1:12:10Doesn't get that. But now this was a pleasure.
- 1:12:13Thank you so much. Awesome was I appreciate it man.
- 1:12:17For everybody watching and listening as well.
- 1:12:19You guys are awesome. We'll see you guys on the next
- 1:12:21episode. Until then, Ciao.