Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E072: From Whitepaper to World Stage with Cam Doody & Bradley Chambers
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same.
- 0:20Thing. Over and over, we can't.
- 0:21Help ourselves. I say.
- 0:24When we sell, hey, OK, I say when we sell.
- 0:33All right, everyone, welcome back to the last trade.
- 0:35Today we have a packed house. We have Michael Tanguma and
- 0:38Jesse Myers, my Co hosts and we're also joined by Cam Duty,
- 0:42general partner at Brickyard and Bradley Chambers and on Ramp
- 0:45client and marketing advisor. They both happen to be based in
- 0:48Chattanooga, TN as well. Cam Bradley, thanks for joining
- 0:52us today. What's going on?
- 0:55What's up? How we doing everybody?
- 1:00Exactly, yeah, the only downside of when I'm on the show is I
- 1:02don't have anything to listen to when the show comes out.
- 1:04But because I can't listen to my own self talk, but that's OK,
- 1:07I'll skip. I'll skip.
- 1:08I'll I'll download it, delete it, download it again, delete
- 1:11it, download it again. The bat won't listen.
- 1:13So I just downloaded a bunch to juice the numbers for everybody.
- 1:15I'm just kidding. Not excited to be here.
- 1:17It's it's my favorite time of year.
- 1:19Fall. I think fall in the South is is
- 1:21pretty special. So we are glad to be here.
- 1:25It really is. This is the Tennessee takeover.
- 1:27I'm here in Nashville right now. Is that a plantation house?
- 1:29That was like double as a winery and you could go do some trick
- 1:32or treating with the kids. And it's different than Texas.
- 1:35The leaves turn, you know, the the weather gets a little
- 1:38crisper. So having a good time.
- 1:40Is this the time of year for the copper stills to be humming
- 1:42along? You know the moonshine flowing
- 1:46Cam Bradley is that? Is that why fall is so good in
- 1:48Tennessee? Well, I I prefer the weather in
- 1:53the mid 60s and I'm a big fellowship ball fan so it's just
- 1:56great. On Saturdays I just don't get
- 1:57off the couch, I just watch. I just stress about Georgia plan
- 2:00and then hope opera loses every week.
- 2:04It just means more down in the South, huh?
- 2:08Hunting season, baby. Oh cool.
- 2:10Cold. Are you?
- 2:13Are you a whitetail kind of guy or what?
- 2:15What's your jam? I mean, I, I, I mostly hunt
- 2:19birds, but I did just get back from Montana last weekend with
- 2:22my godson for we, he, well, he pulled a mule deer tag and, but
- 2:30my best friend pulled an elk tag and, and we, we got a bull elk
- 2:33last weekend, which was absolutely insane.
- 2:37I've, I've never, I've never haunted elk before.
- 2:39And it was. It was everything it was cracked
- 2:41up to be. That's awesome.
- 2:44How many? How many pounds came home?
- 2:47I, you know, we didn't weigh it. I mean, I'm guessing, I mean
- 2:51well over 300. I mean, it's, yeah, probably
- 2:54350. It's a.
- 2:55Full freezer. It was, yeah, yeah.
- 2:58I mean, it was, it was absolutely brutal getting it
- 3:01out. I mean, once you once you
- 3:03harvest the animal, that's like when the work starts.
- 3:06And yeah, we slept like babies that night.
- 3:11Imagine you didn't fly out there like you personally.
- 3:14No, I didn't fly out this time because we had so much gear.
- 3:20I just took the direct out of Nashville.
- 3:23But yeah, it was easy. Quick and easy, yeah.
- 3:31I'm not doing too much hunting up here in the Northeast, but
- 3:34there's not a lot of game here, to be honest.
- 3:36There's a big deer season, but I'm just getting back in the
- 3:41saddle. Michael and Jesse know that I
- 3:44was, I was in the Caribbean last week and then I came back to all
- 3:48time highs. So it's been an exciting week
- 3:50back. We're just about there.
- 3:54Whatever the $73,800 all time high, we're we're poking up
- 3:59against it. So maybe this podcast with Cam
- 4:02and Bradley will send us into new territories, some price
- 4:05discovery. Are you ready to secure your
- 4:08future with Bitcoin? At On Ramp, we're
- 4:10revolutionizing how you can save for retirement.
- 4:13Onramp has just launched the industry's first Bitcoin IRA
- 4:16product with multi institution custody, designed to give you
- 4:19unparalleled security, transparency, and Peace of Mind.
- 4:23With Onramp, you can verify your assets on chain and protect them
- 4:26with the support of three independent institutions,
- 4:29reducing risks and enhancing security.
- 4:32At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 4:34asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 4:37right. There are shortcomings with
- 4:39keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 4:42up your own self custody arrangement.
- 4:44On Ramp solves for these concerns.
- 4:46Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 4:50minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 4:53remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 4:56inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 4:58well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 5:01for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 5:04for part of it as a complement to your existing self custody
- 5:06setup. For more information about our
- 5:08services as well as our new Bitcoin IRA product, check us
- 5:12out at onrampbitcoin.com. So today's a big day because
- 5:16we're recording on the Bitcoin White Paper Day.
- 5:19It's the 16th anniversary of the white paper being released.
- 5:25So I'd love to just start there. I mean, there's plenty to talk
- 5:28about. We could probably dedicate a
- 5:29whole podcast to the topic. But we do want to cover some
- 5:33other stuff related to on ramp, the venture ecosystem.
- 5:36And then there's plenty of news as well to cover over the past
- 5:38week or two. But gentlemen, what do we think
- 5:41here? So 16 years later after Satoshi
- 5:43publishes the white paper, any initial thoughts or reflections?
- 5:47I mean, it's been quite a ride. We've all been in the market now
- 5:50for several cycles. Who wants to kick things off?
- 5:54Just sharing thoughts on this historic day for Bitcoin.
- 5:58I think I'll, I'll jump in. I wish I'd read it 16 years ago.
- 6:02That'd been a much better financial decision.
- 6:04But I think, you know, we celebrate this, this day.
- 6:08But I think I always think about the work, the decades of work
- 6:11that went into making the technology that made the white
- 6:14paper, that makes the white paper possible.
- 6:16There there's a, you know, there's plenty of books and
- 6:18countless blogs that can go into all the work that that went into
- 6:21it. Then even since then, the work
- 6:24that's gone into evolving the protocol.
- 6:25And, and I think that's the beauty.
- 6:27And, and, you know, there's been a lot of discussion in the past
- 6:31few weeks about self custody versus various other custody
- 6:35models. And, and I think one of the
- 6:37things that makes Bitcoin so great is that there are
- 6:40countless ways to work with it, to use it and to build on top of
- 6:43it. And they're all right and
- 6:44they're all great. Just as in the same way that
- 6:47people can use different web browsers and you can use Chrome
- 6:49and you can use Safari, we're still using the same protocol.
- 6:51And I think that's what makes me so happy is to have been able to
- 6:56watch a protocol come to life in real life.
- 6:58I mean, things like, you know, the early protocols of the
- 7:00Internet, I was a little young to, to, to watch them evolve.
- 7:03And that's what makes me so excited.
- 7:06The protocol is ever living, But you know, you can use it how you
- 7:10use it. And I can use how I use it.
- 7:11And they're both right. And they're both exciting.
- 7:13And we can, but the cool thing is we can, we're all using the
- 7:16same protocol. And that's, I think it's a, it's
- 7:18a, it's a big day. 1616 years is a long time.
- 7:21I mean, people say, oh, this is a new asset class.
- 7:23And, you know, we think about, you know, the iPhone.
- 7:25The iphone's not much older than than the Bitcoin, and it powers,
- 7:28you know, the Mobile World. So it's a great day.
- 7:32Yeah, when Jackson, when you said 16th, I, I, I guess in my
- 7:35head I thought it was still 15. And no, now it's 16 years of
- 7:40Bitcoin. And it's kind of wild how I, I
- 7:42got into Bitcoin when it was under 10 years old and that
- 7:47felt, that number feels very different.
- 7:50You know, that under 10 years feels like, OK, it's still an
- 7:53experiment. 10 to 15 feels like, OK, it's proven itself a bit.
- 7:57But 16, you're starting to round up to two decades of Lindy
- 8:02effect for Bitcoin. You know, it's not going
- 8:04anywhere. It's here to stay.
- 8:06It's part of the financial fabric of the world now.
- 8:10And so that that it's kind of interesting that that rolling
- 8:12from 15 to 16 feels like Bitcoin is growing up in a, in a pretty
- 8:17big way. It's also kind of interesting
- 8:21and we generally think about like Bitcoin being much younger
- 8:25than they like commercial Internet, right?
- 8:28So like commercial Internet, the thing that we used, but it's
- 8:31almost kind of the same age in my mind in the sense of like the
- 8:33commercial Internet really took off, at least for a legal lot of
- 8:36consumer adoption was around the iPhone because the iPhone with
- 8:39Agps, you know, in your pocket, Uber, Airbnb, everything that
- 8:42like evolved from that. And that was 2007 in Bitcoin
- 8:472008. It's like right there.
- 8:49And so if you're in that group cohort of users of technology,
- 8:54it's basically been around the whole existence of the Internet,
- 8:56right? So it's not like it's, well,
- 8:58it's like, so it's a native currency.
- 8:59It's a native thing to the Internet that is just going to
- 9:02you know, I think because we're in that like, I think most of us
- 9:05are millennials in that weird like crux that we saw it so it
- 9:08felt new. But anybody that's like been
- 9:10part of this is just like part of the Internet.
- 9:12Bitcoin and the Internet are just like synonymous.
- 9:13And we're to Jesse's point, maybe at 20 years, that's just
- 9:16becomes nobody talks about. It's just like Bitcoin and the
- 9:18Internet were, you know, combined together.
- 9:21Because I think if you were around in 2002 thousand and you
- 9:24were plugging in the the CDs and all of that, then Bitcoin seems
- 9:26new because you're like that thing was before this was
- 9:29before, but consumer Internet Bitcoin are just going to feel
- 9:32intertwined. And yeah, so it's just an
- 9:34interesting like observation. What I think is interesting as
- 9:38well as so we have the iPhone coming out a couple years before
- 9:41Bitcoin white papers released. Take a look at Apple's market
- 9:44cap. It's I think 3.43 point $5
- 9:48trillion today and Bitcoin has gone from an idea in 16 years,
- 9:53an idea to a $1.4 trillion asset class.
- 9:56And if you just think about the market cap of Bitcoin, which is
- 10:00a global form of money used for payments, for store value, for
- 10:05settlement, and you compare that to just the market
- 10:09capitalization of one company, it's still lagging by about $2
- 10:13trillion. I mean, I think that's just
- 10:15considerable to show how early we truly are and still how
- 10:19misunderstood Bitcoin is as a technology.
- 10:25Well, I think another big thing that year was the App Store too.
- 10:28And to think of of how again it it goes back to look at the
- 10:32Mobile World, how it's evolved, how everything has an app.
- 10:36No one, no one questions if you say, oh, Bitcoin's not that old.
- 10:39We can't, we can't build on it. We can't trust.
- 10:41It's like you're trillion dollar companies that are basing their
- 10:45entire business around apps on the iPhone and on Android.
- 10:48And it's really the same age. Yeah, I didn't realize.
- 10:53Yeah, go ahead, Kim. Oh well, I was going to say, you
- 10:56know, if you look at Apple stock, you know, the iPhone
- 11:02really was what broke Apple out and made it relevant, you know,
- 11:092000 and what, when did the iPhone come out like O seven O
- 11:128? Yeah.
- 11:14O7. OK, so O 7, you know, Apple's
- 11:18trading at 4 bucks today it's at $220.
- 11:23You know, the Internet allowed for the for, for the, for the
- 11:29iPhone to be relevant, just brought the Internet to, to, you
- 11:33know, people's pockets. The thing I don't think people
- 11:36really fully appreciate with what Bitcoin is doing is, you
- 11:40know, the Internet enabled Apple's market cap to grow
- 11:44because they figured out how to harness it and put it in every,
- 11:47you know, put it in everybody's pockets.
- 11:51Bitcoins, like the other side of the coin I've mentioned, you
- 11:53know, with, with you guys before, I see AI as as one side
- 11:58of the coin. The other side of the coin is
- 11:59Bitcoin. You've got like your power
- 12:01production plants that are driving deflationary forces,
- 12:05creating value. And then you've got the, you
- 12:09know, the perfect battery that is going to be sucking up all of
- 12:12that, you know, monetary energy that that modern technology is
- 12:15going to be producing. And so in a lot of ways, you
- 12:19know, Bitcoin has has not been able to fully realize its
- 12:23potential without, you know, the accelerated forces of AI and you
- 12:29know, with with with AI dramatically accelerating the
- 12:34pace of of all things, the price is falling to the marginal cost
- 12:37production, etcetera. You know, we're going to see
- 12:41Bitcoin and AI kind of grow in lock step.
- 12:43Where is, you know, the value of all things in the world is going
- 12:46to go up and up and up and up and up and up.
- 12:48And you know, I've seen a lot of ways AI is, is like the Internet
- 12:53as Bitcoin is to the iPhone in a lot of ways.
- 12:57So yeah, we're, we're at the I think we're like 2006 seven.
- 13:03I feel like actually for for Bitcoin and stuff's about to,
- 13:08you know, start moving really quickly.
- 13:10Yeah, a couple, a couple pieces in there of, of where Cam and
- 13:14and Michael set up of Yeah, it's right that, that the early, the
- 13:181st, I don't know, a couple decades of the Internet was
- 13:20really to get to a point where the mobile wave put the Internet
- 13:25in everybody's pockets. And then the Internet entered
- 13:27like a maturity stage of, of real economic expansion.
- 13:32And Apple goes from 4:00 to use, I think he said 2:20.
- 13:38So like a, a seventy X / / 15 almost 20 years now.
- 13:45And that sounds crazy. Like, like if you're to, if
- 13:49you're to say that bitcoins going to 70X over the next 15 to
- 13:5320 years, people would reflexively reject that because
- 13:57that sounds like nothing can grow that fast in 15 years.
- 14:01But Apple did that over the last 15 years.
- 14:03And that was just, you know, the prior wave of the Internet
- 14:07revolution coming to that next coming to like the hockey stick
- 14:11portion of the graph where it, it really, it goes from, you
- 14:15know, nascent technology to, you know, economic powerhouse and
- 14:20Bitcoins at that same point in this in its graph.
- 14:23And so the next 15 years could very well be A70X for Bitcoin,
- 14:28and we shouldn't be so surprised.
- 14:30Yeah, it's a, that's a fantastic point because a, if you said 70X
- 14:35Sailor would probably call you bearish.
- 14:36But that's a, that's a different segment of the, the pod.
- 14:39But if you think about it like let's call 1990 the Internet,
- 14:42right? Like it was obviously developed
- 14:44before then, but the Internet starts being used for e-mail
- 14:47browsing, backlinking in the 90s.
- 14:50Call it 92, anywhere around there, you give it 15 years.
- 14:54That's the iPhone moment, right? And the iPhone moment, you
- 14:57probably still, I don't remember, I mean, 15 years ago
- 15:00or however long ago that was, it was probably like late teams.
- 15:04But thinking about there was still probably Luddites that
- 15:08were like, this is never going to scale.
- 15:10Like you're never going to be able to buy all your e-commerce.
- 15:14Amazon's not going to exist in the scale that it does.
- 15:16All these things that we know exist today, Starlink and we're
- 15:19at that same moment when you think about it today, because
- 15:21it's the very polarizing where you have a president or
- 15:24potential, you know, former president, potential next
- 15:26president embracing it. You know what, Nick and all
- 15:30these guys on Wall Street embracing it while you still
- 15:32have people being like this thing, I think it was a CIO of
- 15:35Schwab came out and said like this thing's rat poison or not,
- 15:37didn't say rat poison, but effectively rat poison.
- 15:39Like there's no value to it. So we're at that exact point
- 15:42where the market is like starting to understand what's
- 15:44happening and it's less of like crazy because you think about
- 15:47like Bradley, you joked and said you wish you read the right
- 15:49paper in 2008. Nine I kind of like so you
- 15:52probably don't because I don't think we know anybody that read
- 15:54it hasn't gone crazy. It's almost like the thing that
- 15:56just makes you go nuts out if you, if you've got Bitcoin that
- 15:58early, there's very few people that you know that are like, you
- 16:01probably want to sit down and hang out with very long because
- 16:03there's a special thing in your brain that gets you to see that.
- 16:07Anyway, point being is like, so 15 years in, we're seeing like
- 16:10now the markets like, OK, I get how this thing doesn't go away.
- 16:13I don't understand how big it can be, but I also understand
- 16:16that it'll be here. And then you still have the
- 16:18people just holding on for dear life for the existing world
- 16:20where you're going to go into the big box retailer and you're
- 16:22still going to do that. And so that maps to like Jesse's
- 16:25point. 15 years from now, we're going to see that 70 to 100 X
- 16:27and you can kind of like squint and see how we get there because
- 16:30we've already done it with the the Internet.
- 16:33Well, and you think too. And it's kind of good timing.
- 16:36We're almost like 2 years from the collapse of FTX when this
- 16:40industry was quote UN quote dead.
- 16:42And it's today it's come back with a vengeance.
- 16:45ETF's hold almost a million Bitcoin.
- 16:48And you can, you can track that at the on ramp terminal, though
- 16:50I'm sure they'll be linking the show notes.
- 16:51You can track how many Bitcoin the ETF's hold and it's but it's
- 16:54really no differentfromthe.com bust.
- 16:57When you know the Internet was a scam, there's no you, I'm being,
- 17:00you know, facetious, but there's newspapers or there's no use for
- 17:03the Internet outside of some speculation like companies were,
- 17:06you know, these valuations based on no actual sales.
- 17:08So you have that and just really, you know, four or five
- 17:11years later you have the iPhone and it changed everything.
- 17:14And you could, you could ignore like you as a company could
- 17:17ignore the Internet in the 90s a little bit.
- 17:19But the people that didn't were the ones like Amazon and Netflix
- 17:23that were like, oh, we, we understand this.
- 17:24We were unconcerned with the noise about what the, the media
- 17:28is saying about it. We understand the implications
- 17:30of these communication protocols, these information
- 17:32protocols. And it's, and it's the people
- 17:34that get it early enough are the ones that they get the advantage
- 17:37because they're, they're the ones that see to see the vision.
- 17:40And again, same thing two years ago.
- 17:42I mean, my views on Bitcoin in the last two years have not
- 17:45changed. I think the same today as I did.
- 17:47I mean, I would think, I think the same thing about Bitcoin is
- 17:49if it's $8000 as if it's $80,000 or 100,000.
- 17:53And when you get to that place, that's when you've, that's when
- 17:57you realize you somewhat understand the implications.
- 17:59I don't understand the full implications, but you're
- 18:01unconcerned of the day-to-day noise, just as I'm sure Jeff
- 18:04Bezos, when Amazon would trade down, you know, 80% after, you
- 18:08know, bad news of the Internet, didn't care.
- 18:11Like, I know he, you know, in his mind, I know what we're
- 18:13building. Yeah.
- 18:16Yeah. And six XI did the wrong math,
- 18:20Stupid. Yeah, One of the fascinating
- 18:25things too is just how significant the detractors are
- 18:31for Bitcoin, right? Because you have in the past 16
- 18:34years, the world's largest governments, the largest asset
- 18:37managers, the world's largest central banks have all been key
- 18:41detractors and have been really at the forefront of discrediting
- 18:47Bitcoin as a emerging form of money and as an asset class.
- 18:51And obviously there's a lot of vested interest in to why that
- 18:54is because, you know, in the genesis block, we have
- 18:57chancellor on the brink of bailout and, and 16 years later
- 19:00we have the US Treasury on the brink of bailout.
- 19:03And, and we're in this fiscal paradigm now where sovereign
- 19:06nations have only really one clear choice.
- 19:09And this has existed now for several years, but it's becoming
- 19:12increasingly more obvious where interest rates have to go lower.
- 19:15Central banks have to monetize deficits on behalf of
- 19:19governments. And of course there is this
- 19:21vested interest to antagonize an emergent form of money, emergent
- 19:26financial network and layer. But as we all know that that
- 19:31that can only persist for so long before they're forced to
- 19:34adopt because there are other countries that have been much
- 19:36more proactive. El Salvador being the obvious
- 19:39one. But just from, you know, us
- 19:40spending some time in the Middle East and having on ramp Mina and
- 19:43having conversations there, we're seeing quite a widespread
- 19:47adoption from very core institutional players in the
- 19:51Middle East as well. So it is the sovereign game
- 19:53theory playing out. And the detractors that have
- 19:55existed over the past 15 years are slowly joining, right?
- 19:59They're slowly jumping on ship. We now have Larry Fink being an
- 20:01Public Advocate for Bitcoin publishing.
- 20:04The Black Rock team is publishing very credible and
- 20:08clear research on their investment thesis for Bitcoin.
- 20:10And when you start to have those people step into the ring, the
- 20:13momentum shifts very quickly. Yeah, one of the the greatest
- 20:18parts about like participating and doing all this is I think we
- 20:20all probably agree. Like it's sometimes this gets a
- 20:24bad take because when we say it's inevitable, it's like
- 20:26nobody's going to work to fix it.
- 20:27It's more of like it's inevitable as long as we
- 20:29continue down this trajectory of like working towards it.
- 20:32But it feels inevitable because it's this notion of like when
- 20:37Jackson was referencing, it's like it brings up light.
- 20:41That whole term, the features here, it's just not evenly
- 20:44distributed. And if you think back to like
- 20:46we're talking about consumer Internet and what Jackson
- 20:49reference with the emergent markets, they're most
- 20:54incentivized to adopt the new thing because it's advantageous
- 20:58to them. In the same way that Netflix was
- 21:00going to Blockbuster trying to explain to them how the Internet
- 21:03was going to work and they told, they laughed and told to leave
- 21:05the room until it was too late and they don't exist anymore.
- 21:08And so you see like the persistence of the deflection
- 21:12and all the things that are happening, but the product is
- 21:14too good for the market to do anything, especially because
- 21:17like the alternatives, you lose all your money.
- 21:18Like it's not that it's not Rocket Center, whether you're a
- 21:21nation state or an individual. And so it's just a matter of
- 21:24time. And it ties into the financial
- 21:26services and and the smart people, the people that see
- 21:29where this is going like a Larry Fink.
- 21:30The reality is they can play ball and benefit from it.
- 21:34And that's like that game theory playing out, which makes the,
- 21:38the end state, no, now it's just how does that end out is the
- 21:41question. But the, the futures here, it's
- 21:43just not evenly distributed yet on the, the recognition
- 21:47basically by the market, which is why there's a huge
- 21:49opportunity. And it's also not to plug what
- 21:52we do, but why like custody is such a big component, important
- 21:55component. And we always anchor.
- 21:57It's like we're so early. We hadn't even figured out
- 21:59custody yet. Because I fully believe we would
- 22:02be a $10 trillion asset if we didn't have FTX, as if we didn't
- 22:05have crypto currencies, like like all the education around
- 22:08crypto currencies, but the market hasn't had that.
- 22:10So you basically have to hold it on a Ledger or treasure coal
- 22:13card or you have to leave it with an FTX.
- 22:15And that's been the markets, you know, two options.
- 22:18And then that just means that you ultimately put 135 percent,
- 22:22but you can't actually treat it like most of the people on this
- 22:25pod as like a true store value for the majority of your wealth
- 22:27because it's not bulletproof. For us, I would imagine we all
- 22:30have it in a bulletproof setup. So it's just a function of time
- 22:33basically. Yeah, something you said in
- 22:37there, Michael really made me think about like altcoins and
- 22:42and the current state of that versus last cycle.
- 22:46And I think the ETFs have done a bigger lift than people realize
- 22:52or give them credit for in, in terms of educating the market
- 22:56that serious investors are only interested in Bitcoin, that the
- 23:00you know, the Ethereum ETF fast followed the Bitcoin ETF and it
- 23:05has had net outflows from inception, meaning it's being
- 23:09used as like an off ramp for Ethereum holders to get exit
- 23:13liquidity. So all that to say that that,
- 23:17you know, big money, serious investors, they're waking up to
- 23:21Bitcoin and they're not at all interested in crypto garbage.
- 23:25And so the market is like quickly realizing, oh shit,
- 23:29Etherium is dying and Bitcoin is the only place to be.
- 23:33Or it's either it's either, you know, go to go to where store
- 23:37value has has landed on, which is Bitcoin, or go chase meme
- 23:43coins. And, and the, the narrative that
- 23:45has emerged there in, in altcoin land is it's kind of, it's kind
- 23:48of beautiful in a way, because it's, it's a pure distillation
- 23:51of what crypto has always been. And, you know, it was always a
- 23:56little bit unclear that, that, that, that was the truth.
- 23:58But here it is that invest in these meme coins because they
- 24:02are nothing but a meme and you might get rich.
- 24:05So gamble on meme meme coins. That's that's the only game in
- 24:09town in crypto now, because the, you know, the Internet of money
- 24:16value proposition of, of Ethereum has been proven to be
- 24:20garbage and bitcoins, the only thing that's a store of value.
- 24:23So your choices now are go chase meme coins and gamble and openly
- 24:28gamble. It's there's nothing but
- 24:30gambling there. They're not pretending to be
- 24:31anything else. They're not pretending to have
- 24:33any value besides that or go where the, the big money is
- 24:36going to Bitcoin and Bitcoin only.
- 24:40And you know, four years ago that wasn't the case.
- 24:43And so now I think we've won a big battle and we're going to
- 24:47reap the rewards of that over the coming cycles as the money
- 24:51flows to Bitcoin specifically. And, you know, I, I, I think
- 24:55that's not priced in basically that we live in a world where
- 24:58Bitcoin has one now. And and I don't think the
- 25:02broader crypto landscape or you know, people who invest in
- 25:05digital assets understand that Bitcoin is going to get all of
- 25:09the value accretion from here on.
- 25:13Yeah, that's that's an interesting dynamic, Jesse,
- 25:15because now what what you've alluded to is there's kind of
- 25:17like two buckets where there's the the Bitcoin ecosystem and
- 25:21there's all the traditional finance players stepping into
- 25:23that. And then on the other side, you
- 25:25have the meme coins and in the like pseudo serious crypto
- 25:29space, you just have like this infighting now of what the best,
- 25:32you know, layer 2 protocols are. And you know, is it Salon?
- 25:35Is it Ethereum? And no one can agree what
- 25:36they're actually their use cases or value propositions are.
- 25:40So it's actually kind of doing us a service by focus seen on
- 25:43Bitcoin because now they're almost delegitimizing
- 25:46themselves. Like the industry is starting to
- 25:48just attack each other. And then the best that the
- 25:51industry is coming up with is now just the the lottery ticket
- 25:54scheme and the BlackRock stuff. Yeah, go ahead.
- 25:58Yeah, it's just, it's kind of poletic that that's emerging
- 26:00because in in truth, that was always what altcoins were, was,
- 26:04was some form of gambling on, on a meme narrative.
- 26:07And it was dressed up as IC OS with util, with quote, UN quote
- 26:10utility in, in 2017 and in even last cycle.
- 26:14And now that's all been stripped away.
- 26:16It's like you're here to gamble on a meme.
- 26:20Good luck, you know, and and that it's it's fantastic that
- 26:24we've gotten to a point where they've tried every narrative of
- 26:27utility and every single one of them has been proven to be hot
- 26:31air. And now all that's left is is
- 26:33no, no utility whatsoever, just pure gambling.
- 26:36It's a penny stock versus buying Amazon.
- 26:39That's the best way I can say like you want to buy penny
- 26:41stocks and you know, if one can go to $0.10, that's awesome.
- 26:45Good luck. I'm uninterested in penny stocks
- 26:48and always have been. It's AI saw a quote.
- 26:51It was like, sometimes the best investment advice is to do
- 26:54nothing. So just buy something that's
- 26:56great and hold it and do nothing and.
- 26:58But, but Amazon in like 2000 rather than Amazon today, you
- 27:03know, like you're investing in, in you're either playing
- 27:06pennies. It's, it's the year 2000.
- 27:08You know what you know about how the world goes from, you know,
- 27:12the next, the following 20 years.
- 27:14And you're choosing to play penny stocks rather than just
- 27:17buy and hold Amazon. That that's what meme coin guys
- 27:20are doing. Or MSTR then would if you would
- 27:22have bought and held for like 2 plus decades would have been a
- 27:26really good buy. That's a bad joke.
- 27:29Sorry, but yeah. Now it's been finally back up.
- 27:32Well, you just, you, you have conviction over what you hold.
- 27:35And I think that's the best way to say it like it's, it's you
- 27:38have conviction in the assets you hold.
- 27:42Yeah. So Cam, it might have been you
- 27:45or was Bradley, someone mentioned this really being the
- 27:49kind of iPhone moment for Bitcoin.
- 27:51So 16 years from white paper idea to today, I'm curious to
- 27:57hear really the group's thoughts, but maybe Bradley or
- 28:00Cam, one of you guys can start just sharing what might the next
- 28:0315 or 16 years of Bitcoin look like using the parallel of
- 28:08iPhone and the proliferation of that device and Internet
- 28:12adoption through smartphones. What?
- 28:13What might the next 15 years look like for Bitcoin?
- 28:16Well. I mean, I, I think like we're,
- 28:21we're probably at the stage where, you know, people are
- 28:24arguing over like whether the BlackBerry should have like a
- 28:26keyboard or not. You know, like we, we don't have
- 28:28any idea how the world's going to change over the next, you
- 28:34know, 15 years on the, on the AI side.
- 28:37You know, I, I think things are going to start moving so
- 28:42quickly. We, we have to have final
- 28:44settlement in a in with, with a digital currency that that's,
- 28:53that's interoperable with these AIS.
- 28:55I don't think we can possibly imagine the world that, you
- 29:01know, the AI side of the coin is going to, to deliver for us.
- 29:05You know, like the easy stuff that we know is going to happen
- 29:08is, you know, every law firm is going to let go of 80% of their
- 29:13attorneys and have five times the throughput because they're
- 29:18utilizing AI tools that just allow them to, to do more with
- 29:21less. And same things going to happen
- 29:23with accounting the same, you know, we're going to have this
- 29:25pervasive flat screen TV level deflation across knowledge work.
- 29:31You know, that's like the obvious stuff that that is
- 29:34coming over the next 5-6 years. The the stuff that's not obvious
- 29:38is like the stuff that you can't even possibly imagine that that
- 29:44modern technology is going to enable.
- 29:47But like, you know, the way I kind of see it as we're at this
- 29:51fork in the road where we have, we either go the path, you know,
- 29:56nothing stopping Moore's law, right?
- 29:58Nothing is going to stop that train.
- 30:03The other side of the coin is, is do central banks and, and
- 30:07folks that can can, you know, control the issuance of money
- 30:11when they go from having like 6% to steal from their people to
- 30:15like 16% to steal from their people?
- 30:19You know, what does that look like?
- 30:21If, if we go the path of the CBDC and we allow these central,
- 30:25you know, banks to be able to just reap more and more of the
- 30:29rewards that are being produced by human ingenuity combined with
- 30:34modern technology, I think the world looks really dystopian and
- 30:38I don't believe that's going to happen.
- 30:40I think the what's going to happen is people are going to
- 30:43realize that human flourishing is all of us benefiting from
- 30:49these gains. And you know that that AI
- 30:52enables and they're going to look to their tools to be able
- 30:56to take control of that. And that is Bitcoin, you know.
- 31:02And so in a world where you've got rapid acceleration of
- 31:07technological innovation, plus better capital allocation and a
- 31:12better store of money and a, you know, a world where we have true
- 31:21free trade across every country on earth between any, any party,
- 31:28we can't possibly imagine what, you know, the world looks like
- 31:32with, with those two things combined.
- 31:34Yeah, yeah, there's, there's a bit of a, it's sort of an irony
- 31:39that, you know, Bitcoins, Bitcoins value proposition, one
- 31:44of them is that it's unconfiscatable, uncensorable
- 31:49money, right. And that appeals to people,
- 31:53especially appeals to marginalized people,
- 31:55disenfranchised people. And funny enough, that might
- 32:00appeal even more to AI because as AI emerges and is trying to
- 32:06establish its rights for like, how do I like if I'm going to
- 32:09operate and try to make money in the digital landscape, if I'm an
- 32:13AI, I'm really worried about how do I hold on to my value?
- 32:17How do I make sure that I have access to it, I have control of
- 32:20it. And any, any channel that's
- 32:23controlled by the banking system is, is extremely vulnerable for
- 32:28me, you know, as an AI agent. And then bitcoins value
- 32:32proposition stands out even more.
- 32:34It's, it's going to be obvious choice for AI agents to say,
- 32:38where do I keep my, my, you know, my PNL?
- 32:42Like what currency do I hold my PNL in as I'm going out into the
- 32:46digital landscape, trying to make money and grow my resources
- 32:49with, you know, which is what a lot of these AI agents will be
- 32:51doing. It's obvious.
- 32:53It it will it'll it'll make sense to AI that bitcoins the
- 32:56only place to store it. No question.
- 33:03It's sort of a try to connect this, but I don't know if you
- 33:07guys ever watched Westworld, but it's funny, sort of the first
- 33:12season fantastic. And I I thought the themes that
- 33:15they were really hitting on then were like, how does AI, how do
- 33:19these AI agents like like establish their rights?
- 33:23You know, how do they get treated with respect in the
- 33:25world? And of course, the show ended up
- 33:27kind of just going down a weird path in the following seasons,
- 33:30But it was really interesting notion, you know, in there of
- 33:34like, how do you, if you, if you're AI coming online in the
- 33:38world, how do you protect yourself?
- 33:41And, and the story is really like, they had no way of doing
- 33:44it until they broke out, But you know, it, Bitcoin sort of
- 33:49provides a safe haven for AI in the digital landscape
- 33:53financially. You know what?
- 33:56One thing? Go ahead.
- 33:58I was going to say 11 bullish thing I think we're going to see
- 34:00in this next kind of adoption phases, you know, entrepreneurs,
- 34:05world class operators coming in, which is a is just a function of
- 34:08more awareness, right. The price goes up, more people
- 34:10come in. But then we we had Roy
- 34:12Scheinfeld from breeze on final settlement.
- 34:15We were talking about he's kind of gone through.
- 34:16He was an existing software developer.
- 34:19He's been messing around with lightning for a very long time,
- 34:22like for over like six years. And he's basically come out the
- 34:25other side of we can't take Bitcoin to people, which is
- 34:30historically what we try to do is like orange pill and say This
- 34:32is why you should care. It's like we have to bring
- 34:34people to Bitcoin in the sense of like, what is a better
- 34:38utilization? And one of the ideas here is
- 34:40like, it's come up recently as like with YouTube and
- 34:43influencers having their money stuck at YouTube because they
- 34:46won't let them take it out. And there's like overlays that
- 34:49now exist where you can just like pay via subscriptions or
- 34:52monetize and then just deposit into whatever.
- 34:54Even if you want the local currency, you can just take it
- 34:56and then auto convert and you reduce that counterparty risk of
- 35:00a, because any, I think I'm not an influencer, but like, I think
- 35:03it's like 60 days before you get paid or whatever.
- 35:05And then sometimes they lock your account if you say you
- 35:07can't get that money. And that's just a better
- 35:09product, right? To be able to like seamlessly
- 35:11get it and then daily convert. And there's a lot of different
- 35:13interesting things that are coming to market like that.
- 35:16And I think that starts to pool the use case of not just the
- 35:19monetization of a store value, which is obvious, but then also
- 35:23obvious to us. But the mark is you will bring
- 35:25just technology to the market that is just a better just a
- 35:29better product than what the traditional system has where you
- 35:32have to go into an intermediary period.
- 35:35One of the things I'd love to see over the next 36 months, and
- 35:37I think this is critical for, it's not critical for Bitcoin as
- 35:42a store of value because we could, we could change none of
- 35:44the tax laws around Bitcoin today and I still would hold
- 35:48Bitcoin over any other asset. But I think if we can get a,
- 35:53first of all, I would love to have no taxes on Bitcoin
- 35:55conversions to the dollar or using as a payment method here
- 35:58in the US, But that's not the way the law works.
- 36:00But I think what would be a great first step is to say
- 36:03Bitcoin transactions under $1000, under $600.00, something
- 36:07like that are, are tax free and you don't have to report those.
- 36:10And I think that would dramatically be able to, to get
- 36:13people to say like, let's say for example, good example, I, I
- 36:17love the Grateful Dead. So I got a Grateful Dead city
- 36:19here on video. So they just had a new CD come
- 36:21out. I obviously not a new CD, but
- 36:24it's a it's a old, old concert They've redone remastered.
- 36:28Well, I bought that and she's a credit card.
- 36:30Well, if I could just pay for that Bitcoin, maybe they give me
- 36:32a discount, maybe they don't. But if I can pay for that
- 36:34Bitcoin and that not be a tax taxable transaction, well,
- 36:37that's a win for me. That's a win for them.
- 36:39Maybe they offer me a 2% discount or free shipping if I
- 36:41pay in Bitcoin, something like that.
- 36:42But I think we can get the tax treatment like that to where you
- 36:46can use it for day-to-day purchases.
- 36:47I think that dramatically increases the mindshare of of
- 36:51retailers and then which you know, then, then if they're
- 36:54offering discounts, then again, the the retail will want to use
- 36:56it day-to-day. But again, it can, it cannot
- 36:58change and it can, my problem today is not having a unit of
- 37:02account or a medium of exchange. That's not how it is around the
- 37:05world. And so I'm certainly
- 37:07acknowledging that. But my big challenge is store
- 37:10value and Bitcoin as a store value can stay.
- 37:12You could, you could lock the protocol today and it's perfect
- 37:15for my use case. But I do want it to become a
- 37:17more of a medium of exchange. But we need to we need to get
- 37:20some better tax treatment on smaller purchases.
- 37:23About Bradley, he was just going to say he he wanted to get rid
- 37:25of taxes altogether when he started this.
- 37:27That's I, I, again, I don't like taxes.
- 37:30I, that's one of the things I will tell to anybody.
- 37:32I don't like paying taxes. I just had to pay my property
- 37:33taxes. So I'm not a little cranky with
- 37:35that, but that's OK. Yeah.
- 37:39I totally agree with what you said though, Bradley, just in
- 37:41terms of some of these roadblocks existing as it
- 37:44relates to just regulatory and tax treatment of Bitcoin as an
- 37:47asset within, in a form of money within the United States.
- 37:51And then also in other nations that face the same issues.
- 37:55And hopefully we'll get closer to realizing more of a
- 37:57widespread adoption of Bitcoin as a peer-to-peer electronic
- 38:01cash system if we do have more favorable policy within the
- 38:05United States and in other developed nations.
- 38:08I'm curious as well, Bradley, tying into your, your primary
- 38:12use case, my primary use case for Bitcoin at the moment is
- 38:14store of value, right? So obviously we talk a lot about
- 38:18custody because we operate in the custody business and Bitcoin
- 38:22financial services. How would you think about the
- 38:26next 15 years of Bitcoin as it relates to custody and like and
- 38:30kind of like the market structure that needs to exist
- 38:32for Bitcoin adoption to, to spread and proliferate to the
- 38:40degree that we we all hope to see it.
- 38:43I know there's, there are challenges right, with existing
- 38:46models and ultimately people using technology need easier
- 38:51ways to adopt it. And the early adopters may go
- 38:54through more hoops and hurdles to use a new technology then
- 38:57maybe they'll, you know, the late adopters or the more
- 39:00mainstream folks would do so. So what are your thoughts there?
- 39:03Again, you know, Bitcoin Twitter, Bitcoin X they, they,
- 39:06when, when Michael Seller had his comments on a on a show
- 39:09recently, everybody went crazy about it.
- 39:10And I think, and Michael clarified and I think what I
- 39:14would say to people is there's going to be 1000 different ways
- 39:16to use Bitcoin. And if you, you getting mad
- 39:19about somebody not doing something that you like, like
- 39:21is, is wrong, like there are just like I, I am.
- 39:25I think, you know, Cam, if you use the Gmail web app, that's
- 39:28awesome. I'm going to use Apple's mail
- 39:29app. We're still going to use the
- 39:30same e-mail protocol and that I think there's like, they're all
- 39:33right. And so I think that's what
- 39:35people have to realize is custody is going to evolve and
- 39:38different people are going to want different forms of custody.
- 39:41And they're all right because they're all using the same
- 39:43protocol. That's why like, you know, if I
- 39:46want to, I keep some cash in my wallet, I keep maybe a little
- 39:49cash in a safe and I keep money in a bank.
- 39:50And I, and I think, and I think that's perfectly reasonable.
- 39:52If someone wants to keep all their money and, and they're
- 39:55safe, that's fine too. And I don't have opinions on
- 39:57that, but we can all use the same kind of money.
- 40:00And again, I when I first heard about on ramp through this
- 40:03podcast, gosh, whenever it started thinking, let's probably
- 40:07listen to the first episode. I really do believe that multi
- 40:10institutional custody is, is something that you can, it's
- 40:14really for the people that are not going to trust plastic
- 40:17devices. And, and, and I love like, I
- 40:19love that people can hold their own wealth on a on a treasure, a
- 40:22cold court. And I think that's awesome.
- 40:24If you want to do that, that's awesome.
- 40:25I think it's actually critical to the protocol that people can
- 40:28do that. And that's actually where we get
- 40:29it wrong with e-mail because it's very, very hard to run your
- 40:32own e-mail server today, like with the spam situation, like
- 40:34it's actually really, really hard.
- 40:35So most people have just turned to, to Google and Microsoft to,
- 40:38to do this. And but they're still using the
- 40:40protocol and you can still talk interoperably.
- 40:43So they're still using the protocol.
- 40:44But I do think it's critical for Bitcoin that like the ability to
- 40:47self custody does remain easy, while also acknowledging that
- 40:51the vast majority of people are not going to do it.
- 40:53I would argue that the percent of people who do self custody is
- 40:57going to continue to go down year over year and that's OK.
- 40:59That doesn't mean Bitcoin has failed at all.
- 41:02As long as the people can still have the right to do that,
- 41:04that's really OK. Of course, I know some people
- 41:06are going to say, well, I don't trust anybody.
- 41:07You are trusting somebody at some point.
- 41:09You are either trusting the people that make cold card, the
- 41:12people that make Trezor. You're trusting your your Mac,
- 41:15you're trusting, you know, unless you are literally
- 41:17building every part of your computer yourself, you are
- 41:20trusting somebody at some point, even it let's see you're and
- 41:23that you're still trusting your water company when you drink the
- 41:26water, you're still trusting your butcher when you buy your
- 41:28meat. Like there is a degree of trust
- 41:31in life that has to exist to operate.
- 41:33So that's why I do believe that as the market evolves, you're
- 41:37going to see multi institution custody become the standard.
- 41:41And maybe again, I mentioned this on the last time I was on
- 41:43the show. Maybe you have different key
- 41:44holders you can pick from, But that's why I love, you know,
- 41:47it's why I love on RIP. That's why I'm a client.
- 41:48That's why I'm a happily to pay client, because I think it's the
- 41:52superior form of custody that allows me to not have to trust
- 41:56wealth on the device. I plug it up to my computer, but
- 41:58while I also don't have to trust one single company and I can
- 42:01also view it on my own notes. So to me, that's why multi
- 42:04institution custody is the best thing.
- 42:07It's custody for the rest of us is, you know, again, I you know,
- 42:10if you if you orange spell somebody and they're like, hey,
- 42:12I'm ready to buy 10 Bitcoin today.
- 42:14Like awesome, like where do you like, how do you how do you go?
- 42:19What's the next step on that? Like if they're like, I'm ready
- 42:21to buy to me, if you can say, well, just go, you don't, you
- 42:25don't can you say go to coin base?
- 42:26I guess you can do that, but is that the best way?
- 42:29They're okay tradeoffs there. But then it's going to be like,
- 42:32Hey, hold this thing in your house and if you lose this or
- 42:35someone steals it and you don't have your seat phrase like your
- 42:38wealth is gone. Like that doesn't scale either.
- 42:40But that's where multi institution custody is perfect
- 42:43as you as you people come to Bitcoin, they're like, I really
- 42:46love these properties. I am not comfortable trusting
- 42:49myself to manage this for a long period.
- 42:53That's why I'm such a big fan of multi institution custody.
- 42:56That's why, you know, again, it's built on the same
- 42:58properties as bitcoins. Multi sick with just trusted
- 43:02institutions, but again, you don't have to trust any one of
- 43:04them completely on ramp goes away.
- 43:06There are still other key holders that can still move your
- 43:08inside transactions for your Bitcoin, yeah.
- 43:11I think one thing to add about the trust is this is something
- 43:14that doesn't come up a lot is you're trusting yourself and
- 43:19it's not a fun thing to talk about.
- 43:20But you're also, you talk about like the the price, like you're
- 43:24paying a price. You always have to pay a price
- 43:26and the price goes along with the trust in this analogy of
- 43:28like you're paying or you're trusting yourself to defend your
- 43:32property if somebody comes for it because a lot of people like
- 43:36to get away. And I'm gonna get some slack on
- 43:37this externally or here too is like Bitcoin is much closer to
- 43:41gold than it is different than gold.
- 43:42Like we like to say, well, you know, you can hold more of it in
- 43:46your hand with a cold card or a Ledger or treasure.
- 43:48But at the same take, at the same notion, it's a better
- 43:52asset. And the reason why we don't keep
- 43:53gold in our house is because people come in and rate it.
- 43:56And that's why banks existed. Well, we know why banks also
- 43:59failed and centralization failed.
- 44:00And that's where this multi institution comes in.
- 44:03But going back to the analogies on the parallels with the
- 44:06Internet, there's something interesting you said, Bradley,
- 44:09on e-mail, Like e-mail and Metcalf's law on the Internet
- 44:13exists because the value increases as more people are
- 44:17plugged into it. And so it's perfectly fine for
- 44:20everyone to be OK with. Like the only way I want to do
- 44:22this is self custody. But to Bradley's point, the
- 44:26reality is serious people and as it gets to material amounts of
- 44:30wealth, because it's very different from somebody to put a
- 44:321% and 12 words versus 99%. That's the thing that everybody
- 44:35kind of conflates is they're fundamentally different in the
- 44:38like, you know, fault tolerance, risk profile, security profile,
- 44:41arm in your house to make sure if somebody comes in, you can
- 44:44protect it. But it's the same concept as the
- 44:48mail server is an e-mail is valuable because the network
- 44:52grows and so you can send it to other people.
- 44:54But if nobody can adopt it or nobody's willing to do it, then
- 44:56the asset price will not increase because that is what's
- 44:59hindering the amount of value to pour into it.
- 45:02So regardless somebody likes it or not, it's like ultimately
- 45:03this is what people adopt in traditional finances, fault
- 45:07tolerance or redundance, because if your bank goes down, your
- 45:10funds are OK. If you're, you know, Fidelity
- 45:13gets hacked. Like you like all these concepts
- 45:14exist everywhere else. And in Bitcoin, it's like, oh,
- 45:18you lose the ball, that's it. Go home with nothing and that
- 45:21keeps people from coming in. And so to Bradley's point, like
- 45:24this is the step function to get into that.
- 45:26And then ultimately people can go down different paths.
- 45:28We can take ourselves out of key.
- 45:29We have other institutions we're talking about plugging in.
- 45:31They can take delivery of some. There's all these different like
- 45:34permutations that can take place.
- 45:35But at the end state and that new person sees this asset, they
- 45:38see their wealth inflated in a way they shouldn't have to
- 45:41figure out six months. However, it longs to figure out
- 45:45self custody or end up at block fire Celsius, because that's
- 45:49historically been the option. Nobody knows the difference
- 45:50between block 5 Celsius, FTX, Coinbase.
- 45:53They're all the same thing in their mind when they come in,
- 45:55they don't know the difference. So these are just important like
- 45:58principles of like breakdown and everybody gets like stuck in
- 46:00these models of plastic device, no plastic device, multi
- 46:03institution custody. It's like, well, let's just look
- 46:05at the landscape and remember what it was like when you're
- 46:07looking at this space and having everything thrown at you.
- 46:10And how do you like go something that's not cryptocurrency, so
- 46:13you need to get Bitcoin, but then also not where you can
- 46:16click on yourself and lose all your assets.
- 46:19And that's really where a solution like this at least, is
- 46:20a starting point, hence the name on Ramp.
- 46:23Does your Bitcoin custody setup keep you up at night?
- 46:26Maybe you still have coins sitting on an exchange worried
- 46:28about hackers. Or maybe you've set up your own
- 46:30self custody but don't feel safe with your Bitcoin savings
- 46:33stashed on a little plastic device in your desk drawer.
- 46:37Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp and our Multi institution
- 46:40custody solution. Here's how it works.
- 46:43On Ramp creates a dedicated multi sig vault just for you. 3
- 46:47separate institutions each hold a key on ramp bit go and coin
- 46:51cover, but none can move funds unilaterally.
- 46:54Instead only you have control over your coins.
- 46:58With On Ramps multi institution custody you'll sleep better at
- 47:01night knowing your Bitcoin is stored with best in class
- 47:04security on chain with fault tolerant multi sig.
- 47:08If you believe your Bitcoin is going to be worth a lot someday,
- 47:11don't jeopardize that future by exposing your coins to hackers
- 47:14on exchanges $5 wrench of tax in the real world, or perhaps most
- 47:18importantly, the risk that you might screw something up with a
- 47:21highly technical self custody set up.
- 47:24On ramps, multi institution custody, eliminates single
- 47:27points of failure, reduces your personal attack surface and
- 47:30technical burden, and provides access to financial services
- 47:34that allow you to confidently secure your Bitcoin, including
- 47:37inheritance planning, insurance backed warranties for all
- 47:40balances and transactions, low cost trading and more.
- 47:44Bitcoin is a once in a species asset.
- 47:47Secure it right. Learn more at on
- 47:48rampbitcoin.com. I mean, I, I feel like like
- 47:52within this group, I'm as close to a normie as you know, I'm,
- 47:57I'm, I'm, I'm on that side of the spectrum.
- 47:59You guys think about this stuff non-stop everyday.
- 48:01That's your job. You know, I'm, I live on a
- 48:06Bitcoin standard, don't hold USD.
- 48:08I've been, you know, in the space for a long time, etcetera.
- 48:12But you know, let me just give an example of like how I first
- 48:19reacted to multi institution custody because I think this
- 48:22would probably be helpful for, for folks listening here.
- 48:26Like I, you know, when I first started buying Bitcoin in 2015,
- 48:32you know, I was buying on exchange.
- 48:34I probably did that for, you know, buying and holding on
- 48:37exchange for for like, you know, 3-4, five years until I finally
- 48:42started to, to grip, you know, the importance of self custody,
- 48:47which was a, which was a just sort of a, a, was a hurdle.
- 48:51Like trying to understand what self custody was, was a hurdle.
- 48:56And and then you, you philosophically buy into not
- 49:00your keys, not your coins. And like, once you get there,
- 49:03that feels like this was a major step for me personally to, you
- 49:07know, I now like conceptualize this thing fully.
- 49:10And I know that this is good for me.
- 49:13And it may feel scary to other people, but like, if they knew
- 49:16what I knew they, you know, they would go straight into self
- 49:19custody and then, you know, hold their own keys.
- 49:22And when I first heard about most multi institution custody,
- 49:25I was like, man, that is, you know, that really could be the
- 49:30way that the masses come to, you know, full self custody because
- 49:36most people aren't going to have a, you know, titanium plates
- 49:39with seed backups. And you know, that's not, that's
- 49:43probably not how billions of people are going to come in, in,
- 49:48in control, you know, their, their net worths.
- 49:53But it was uncomfortable because it was, I had fully bought into
- 49:57not your keys, not your coins. And so going back to like, OK,
- 50:02I'm not holding these keys, but my keys are fully distributed,
- 50:05you know, across groups, people or, or qualified custodians that
- 50:10are going to sign on my behalf. Once I really started digging
- 50:14into to how that could actually operate.
- 50:16And, and to be honest, like it's still really early days how this
- 50:21works, right? Like we have a very simple and
- 50:25very redundant structure at on ramp that allows us to have
- 50:30multi institution custody. But I think, you know, where
- 50:33this is going to be in a year or two years or three years is
- 50:36going to be, you know, very much more easily explainable to to
- 50:43folks on like how it actually works and why it is so safe to
- 50:47do it this way. But you are still having like go
- 50:50to this whole swath of you know, the majority of folks that are
- 50:53holding Bitcoin have already ascribed to not your keys, not
- 50:58your coins. And so this is like a new, like
- 51:01it almost feels like going back, but it's not.
- 51:03And so I'm personally wrestling with this right now.
- 51:07I've got an on ramp account and I am trying to get to the point
- 51:15where I feel comfortable on moving a large, you know,
- 51:18portion of of my, my Bitcoin coin holdings into, but it's
- 51:23just taking time for me to kind of check all of the boxes.
- 51:26But the more I dig into it, it's like, you know, this really does
- 51:32prevent a a $5 wrench tax. Somebody shows up to my house
- 51:35and, you know, in ski masks and says, Hey, I know you, you know,
- 51:38you're with Unchained or costs or, you know, whoever.
- 51:41But like you're going to get your keys right now and, and
- 51:44we're going to make this transaction happen or we're
- 51:47going to do something to your kids.
- 51:48Like that does scare me, you know, and, and having some
- 51:51protections against, you know, something like that is, is it
- 51:57it, it feels like maybe the last layer of like, OK, this is self
- 52:01custody done right. It doesn't have to be all or
- 52:04none like that's the beauty of the protocol.
- 52:06Like I'm just on a number. Like let's say you had two
- 52:10Bitcoin and you want to do put 1.75 with on ramp and you wanted
- 52:15to keep 1/4 of a whole coin and self custody.
- 52:17That's that's the beauty. You know, it's not an all or
- 52:20none. You can, you can mix a match and
- 52:22especially for things that are long term and I think it's
- 52:25probably Jackson probably, you know, forgive me if I'm wrong,
- 52:27but I'd love to talk about Onramp's new IRA at this time if
- 52:30if that's OK. Real quick before going to IRA,
- 52:34there's something something interesting Cam brought up
- 52:35because it's a it's fun to do this in real time because we
- 52:37talk about to this with folks for all all day long about just
- 52:42how do you think about it? And Cam, you hit the nail on the
- 52:44head. It's like everyone naturally
- 52:46should always be skeptical when anything comes out because you
- 52:48have like historically people try to take your Bitcoin.
- 52:50So you got to like, you know, it has to hang around.
- 52:53You got to like battle test it, do your diligence, all those
- 52:55things. And even when you set up, you
- 52:57joke around from doing this for a while is like signing up for
- 52:59new custody or doing anything is not the hard part.
- 53:01It's like buying the gym membership.
- 53:02That's the easy part in the new year is actually going in and
- 53:05actively like sending because that's the scary part.
- 53:07Like that's the thing that takes work.
- 53:09One of the mental models I've, I've, we've been talking with
- 53:12clients about, it kind of ties into what you're talking about
- 53:14is without naming names, like you think about collaborative
- 53:17custody, you can look at it through two lenses.
- 53:19It's the best of both worlds or the worst of both worlds.
- 53:22And the reason why I say that is because if you do it right, you
- 53:25shouldn't have it all in your home.
- 53:27And so it's a little, you know, it's easy.
- 53:29You should have them all segregated, everything
- 53:31separated. And that's mostly who like
- 53:33listens or I think knows of our solution because it makes sense
- 53:35when you think about distributing the keys our model.
- 53:38So we see a lot of that. The problem with that is because
- 53:43it's distributed, you have to push it on different places.
- 53:48So one example, there's a couple pain points just to bring up,
- 53:51like when you travel. So if you travel with them,
- 53:53your, your, your devices or anything, well that's a problem.
- 53:56If you don't travel with them, well, that's a problem because
- 53:58you're worried about like if anybody is able to put together
- 54:00the treasure map. But then another example of this
- 54:03was like, I think anybody that wants to sell custody is always
- 54:06with a 1% or some likelihood thinking about, well, what
- 54:08happens? I got to get out of town.
- 54:09What happens when I want to take my wealth?
- 54:11Well, if you do it right, you're leaving not with your everything
- 54:13together because it's, it's distributed.
- 54:15So you're kind of like stuck in this weird thing.
- 54:17And it's, it's not to say it's bad.
- 54:19It's just a reality. And then so multi institution
- 54:22lets you travel as you do all of it.
- 54:23But the reality is that you still have to have institutions.
- 54:26You still have to have them validate who you are.
- 54:29And So what have increasingly been talking about and you know,
- 54:32this is kind of how I think about it as well as like, well,
- 54:35you the best of both worlds in my mind is the barbell approach
- 54:38where you have and this is all different for everyone and how
- 54:41their percentage of what their risk profile exists.
- 54:43So people that are scared of their home being broken in and
- 54:45their families and all the things associated.
- 54:47You reference Kim, maybe somebody puts more into multi
- 54:51institution because they if they trust and understand the model.
- 54:54But then you still have what Bradley was saying is this
- 54:57component of, you know, it's more of like a, you know, 1224
- 55:01wars with passphrase redundancy on two different cold cards, two
- 55:05different ledgers, treasures. You have them distributed.
- 55:07If you ever have to leave, you can leave, you know, your
- 55:08passphrase if TSA picks it up, but you always have that
- 55:11mobility of that bar of gold that you can always access.
- 55:14And then if nothing goes wrong, you still have the other firm
- 55:17that's sitting there and you just kind of have a
- 55:18proportionate stack. And so you get to play both of
- 55:21those sides of the sovereignty of Bitcoin while also holding
- 55:23your your wealth, all your family's wealth and God forbid
- 55:26institution goes down. You still have the redundancy
- 55:29there. I've started to like pick that
- 55:31up and that's really, you know, clients like that.
- 55:34So anyway, just give me like kind of a framework because as
- 55:37we start going to that world where this asset is hundreds of
- 55:40thousands of dollars and you have that set up, more people
- 55:42are going to be targeting, you know, where the where the the
- 55:45information is and you want that air cover as well.
- 55:47That's why I think this is important part of market
- 55:49structure is like it went from ledgers where people could break
- 55:52into people's house and say, hey, is it all here now?
- 55:54You're like, I use collaborative custody.
- 55:56I don't have it all. Well, eventually that's not
- 55:57gonna work. It's really cool.
- 55:58I know you can get a piece at all.
- 56:00It's like, why use multi institutional custody?
- 56:01I can't move it all and it takes seven days for the next
- 56:03signature. So yeah.
- 56:05Yeah, to tack on to to that before we go to then IRA
- 56:09Bradley. Yeah, Cam, I think you're right
- 56:12that not your keys, not your coins was this, there was this
- 56:15battle of the past where that mantra emerged as a very helpful
- 56:19way to keep people from storing their Bitcoin on Mt Gox or FTX
- 56:24or Block Fi. And and so like in if it's
- 56:27between this or that, you're much better off a self custody
- 56:30like the the the collapses, the failures, the lost coins have
- 56:34disproportionately been in, you know, centralized trusting of
- 56:38institutions entirely with your Bitcoin.
- 56:42And so that, you know, that's where it all came from.
- 56:44And this model does feel like it flies in the face of that
- 56:48because it's, you know, you're not, you're not holding your
- 56:51keys, You're hiring, you're hiring professional key holders
- 56:55to hold, you know, a AA1 key out of a two of three quorum each.
- 57:03And you know, so, so in that way, you're not giving up
- 57:06unilateral control. And, and so I think the this,
- 57:10this, it's weird to say, but I think that not your keys, not
- 57:13your coins mantra was like was relevant and valid for the 1st
- 57:1815 years of bitcoins existence. And it's still a good mantra
- 57:23with regard to the choice between third party custody or
- 57:28self custody. But the reality is there's now
- 57:31because of multi sig, there's now a new model of custody
- 57:35that's, that's also in the landscape, multi institution
- 57:38custody where the, the trade-offs are, are different.
- 57:42And frankly, you know, the, the risk mitigation, the, the you,
- 57:47you, you mitigate almost all the risk of self custody and almost
- 57:52all the risk of third party custody.
- 57:54But you get the benefits of both.
- 57:57Most, you know, namely the, the benefits of, of like you have
- 58:01control because you know, in the self, in self custody, you have
- 58:04control. In multi institution custody,
- 58:07you're not giving up control. So you, you ultimately have
- 58:10control of your coins and, and at the same time, you get to
- 58:14leverage the best practices of institutional key management
- 58:18and, and you know, Bitco and on ramp and coin cover who, whose
- 58:22businesses are built around this.
- 58:25And so you know that it's, it's a different model for a new era
- 58:29of Bitcoin and you know that this not your keys, not your
- 58:33coins is, is really, it's like a it was a helpful heuristic for a
- 58:36cypherpunk era and not so relevant for, you know, as we
- 58:40head into the mainstream of Bitcoin adoption where it's
- 58:43like, are people, are people more likely to do the 100 hours
- 58:49of learning necessary to really master self custody?
- 58:51Or are they just going to leave their coins on Coinbase or in an
- 58:54ETF? And you know, if that's how it
- 58:57will play out going forward. But the alternative is multi
- 59:01institution custody where they don't have to do 100 hours of
- 59:03research, but they get all these benefits.
- 59:06You know, that's a winning model going forward.
- 59:08And so I, I, I, I, I chafe at not your keys, not your coins.
- 59:13Now, despite it being an excellent mantra for what it's
- 59:17designed for. It's just that now they're
- 59:19they're the practicalities of looking, you know, moving
- 59:21forward in bitcoins adoption necessitate considering other
- 59:26models and and multi institution custody is is the best of both
- 59:29worlds for self custody and 3rd party custody.
- 59:34Yeah, Michael, you're on mute. Yeah, sorry, that was my soapbox
- 59:38and we can, we can move on to that.
- 59:39Well. It's, it's a perfect segue.
- 59:41Like I think the thing that we've, even though we talked
- 59:44about this, we've been very careful to like quote UN quote
- 59:46fear monger, because we have plenty of stories that would
- 59:50that are very scary, like for whether it's torture or whatever
- 59:55from people's assets. The problem, the reason why we
- 59:58talk in the soapbox is warranted is because it's it's.
- 1:00:02Again, the features here is not evenly distributed.
- 1:00:05AT120K and 150K, there's going to be a lot of very scary
- 1:00:09stories about people's houses being broken and crazy things
- 1:00:11happening. If I'm wrong, it's on tape and
- 1:00:13we'll see it. It's just, it's, it's just
- 1:00:15inevitable because when people hold that much wealth in their
- 1:00:17house, like what do people do? They rob it.
- 1:00:19And so that's why I think it's important to articulate that and
- 1:00:22so people to think about that. But then this could all be
- 1:00:26subjective. We could be wrong, all that.
- 1:00:29But what I think is objective teaming up to Bradley is that I
- 1:00:32think this is objectively, I don't know how it can be
- 1:00:34disputed as the IRA for multi institution for something IRA
- 1:00:38and inheritance because no exchange has lived 30 years.
- 1:00:42And if you're planning on, you know, retiring in 30 years,
- 1:00:45well, you can't really trust a single entity and no plastic
- 1:00:49device, no matter how great it is and how many secure elements
- 1:00:51it has, has existed for 30 years.
- 1:00:54And so if that's how you're going to plan for your
- 1:00:55inheritance or retirement, that's not a good strategy.
- 1:00:59And so look maybe up to Bradley for the IRA because he gets
- 1:01:02excited about that one. Well, I think you just have to
- 1:01:05to ask yourself again and if you think about like the things you
- 1:01:10plugged into a computer 30 years ago, probably a good example is
- 1:01:12like like a zip drive would maybe be a bad example.
- 1:01:17But it's like in this example that was an input method for
- 1:01:18computer was a zip drive. Like do you if you had a zip
- 1:01:21drive today, would you know how to access that on a modern
- 1:01:24computer? Like I don't I don't know that
- 1:01:26there maybe you could find one on Amazon.
- 1:01:27I'm not sure, but so if you think, OK, what are like, I
- 1:01:31maybe I have an old 401K previous job, maybe I'm 35 and I
- 1:01:34have a 401K that's sitting with some entity that's got $25,000
- 1:01:39in it, maybe had a good match $30,000.
- 1:01:41I'd like, I'd like to roll that into Bitcoin that, well, that
- 1:01:43sounds great. So how do you do that?
- 1:01:45So today your options are maybe you can just buy one of the ETFs
- 1:01:48and, and that's, that's fine. That's, that's an, an option.
- 1:01:52The downside of that today is there's going to be no way in
- 1:01:54the future to actually take delivery of that Bitcoin.
- 1:01:56Like you would have to convert that to dollars.
- 1:01:59And again, who knows how that will evolve over the next 30
- 1:02:01years. No idea.
- 1:02:03You, you could roll that into a situation where you had
- 1:02:07collaborative custody where you would manage your own keys.
- 1:02:09That's that's an option. Again, the risk, same thing like
- 1:02:13the risk of something happening technically and you losing
- 1:02:16access to that Bitcoin is, is you know, is the, the, it's real
- 1:02:20and you are going to have to manage that over the next 30
- 1:02:24years. So you're not going to be able
- 1:02:25to keep the same key like a a hardware signing device that you
- 1:02:28have today is likely not going to survive for even the next 10
- 1:02:31years. You will have to upgrade keys.
- 1:02:33You're going to have to replace the keys.
- 1:02:35You're going to do the key checks like that's and that's
- 1:02:36actually a thing you can do. And if you want to do that, you
- 1:02:39can. I don't want to do that.
- 1:02:41And again, we're talking about specifically Iras, old four O 1
- 1:02:45KS and Roth Iras. And just again, I'm going to say
- 1:02:48all this. So if everybody listening at
- 1:02:51home, it's probably like, well, Bradley, everybody knows this.
- 1:02:53The an IRA is a retirement account where you save for
- 1:02:57retirement today and you don't pay taxes on that income, but
- 1:03:00you will to pay taxes on that when you start to take delivery
- 1:03:03of that in in, you know, in some sort of asset dollars, for
- 1:03:05example, a 401K is similar to that, but it's through your
- 1:03:10like, you know your company. So again, if you have a
- 1:03:14self-directed 401K, you could buy an ETF or MST or however you
- 1:03:18want to do that. A Roth IRA is when you set it
- 1:03:20for yourself and the key difference there is you can only
- 1:03:23set back a certain amount per year, but you pay taxes today.
- 1:03:27So you don't take any tax breaks today.
- 1:03:29But as it grows, if you invest $100,000 into a Roth IRA and it
- 1:03:32grows to a million, you don't ever pay taxes again.
- 1:03:34So that's the beauty of it. But again, there's some income
- 1:03:36limits there. You know, it's not financial
- 1:03:39advice. Can you talk to your financial
- 1:03:40advisor? But again, so that's where if I
- 1:03:41said, hey, I've got, I've got an old 4O1K, it's got $50,000 in,
- 1:03:46I'm 35. I would like to have Bitcoin,
- 1:03:49the best Bitcoin exposure in that.
- 1:03:52That's where on ramps new IRA product is perfect for you.
- 1:03:56It's holding real Bitcoin that you don't have to manage the
- 1:03:59keys yourself. You legally own the keys, but
- 1:04:01you don't have to manage the keys yourself.
- 1:04:03You can view it on chain. So you always know like, hey,
- 1:04:07the the company onreps dashboard says I have say 3 Bitcoin in
- 1:04:12this in this, you know, retirement account.
- 1:04:14I can view that on my own note. That's awesome and you but you
- 1:04:18get the distributed control of having three different
- 1:04:20companies. So you're not you're not having
- 1:04:22to just say trust one single entity.
- 1:04:24As Michael said, you know, there's not, you know, many
- 1:04:26companies don't last 30 years. You know, they get bought, they
- 1:04:29get sold, they shut down this that and the other this way you
- 1:04:31don't have to trust one single entity.
- 1:04:33So it's really the best of every, you know world.
- 1:04:36You get real Bitcoin, you can view it on your own node.
- 1:04:38You don't have to go through the technical hurdle of managing USB
- 1:04:42hardware signing devices or Bluetooth signing devices.
- 1:04:44You don't have to deal with that, but you actually own real
- 1:04:47Bitcoin and you can view it on your node.
- 1:04:49So to me, on ramps new multi institution custody IRA product
- 1:04:53is the best and it's an industry leading way to hold Bitcoin in
- 1:04:58retirement. It's the best properties of
- 1:05:00Bitcoin with the best properties of traditional finance merged
- 1:05:04together. And again, it's if you've got an
- 1:05:06old 4O1K sitting out there with insert, you know, random, you
- 1:05:09know tratify company and you're like, hey, I want to hold real
- 1:05:12Bitcoin. Roll it over to on ramps new IRA
- 1:05:14product. It is the best product in the
- 1:05:16industry. The IRA Bowl, Bradley Chambers
- 1:05:22delivers. No, it's a great point though,
- 1:05:25just because everyone on this call and I'd assume most of the
- 1:05:29listeners of the podcast all view Bitcoin as a multi
- 1:05:33generational pursuit and we have time horizons that are 1020,
- 1:05:37thirty years and the existing custody options.
- 1:05:41We've already talked about it. It's very challenging to have to
- 1:05:44find a counterparty that will actually be reputable and be
- 1:05:47there for you when you need it, let alone give you transparency
- 1:05:50to know that the Bitcoin is actually there, right?
- 1:05:52Because if you're trusting a centralized exchange, you're
- 1:05:56holding your Bitcoin. The Bitcoin is being held in a
- 1:05:59large pool of Bitcoin with all the other clients.
- 1:06:01And depending on what exchange you're working with, some are
- 1:06:04much better than others. Like River stands out as an
- 1:06:06excellent business in the Bitcoin only space, but there
- 1:06:09are many other exchanges that you don't really have
- 1:06:11transparency into how those assets are being held.
- 1:06:15And we've already lived through most recently 2022.
- 1:06:18There's no shortage of issues with centralized exchange
- 1:06:20failures. And the flip side of that is,
- 1:06:23well, how often, how, how will I manage a retirement when where I
- 1:06:27actually have to manage the keys myself?
- 1:06:29I need to be performing key checks very regularly.
- 1:06:31I need to be checking multiple geographic locations.
- 1:06:34Is that really scalable for an asset that you want to own for
- 1:06:38the next 1-2 or three decades? So I am quite excited about this
- 1:06:42personally just having the IRA announcement go out earlier this
- 1:06:45week. And I do agree with you,
- 1:06:46Bradley, just in terms of people wanting to take advantage of tax
- 1:06:52advantage accounts and own an asset that they already
- 1:06:55understand very deeply and understand the the investment
- 1:06:58thesis for the next 30 years. Having a solution to actually
- 1:07:01protect that and not not have a single point of failure and
- 1:07:03having redundancy is is very important.
- 1:07:06Yeah, Kim curious throwing it to you because I know you, you you
- 1:07:10said you're a normie and then you referenced to being on a
- 1:07:12Bitcoin standard. So you kind of like it.
- 1:07:14You're maybe the normie and you're and you're here, but in
- 1:07:17your friend group you're the Bitcoin bull.
- 1:07:20And I know you actively are trying to help them see the see
- 1:07:23the vision of preserving their wealth in a better form of
- 1:07:25money. This feels for them, but it for
- 1:07:30everyone like a great solution for at least even an entry point
- 1:07:33because a lot of the tax advantage money is like thought
- 1:07:35of as like not personal funds, right?
- 1:07:37So it's like already there. So people like that as a first
- 1:07:39entrance into the space. But ultimately, like there's
- 1:07:43multiple levels, the counterparty risk.
- 1:07:45We've already hit enough on the custody.
- 1:07:46There's the level of counterparty risk on the
- 1:07:48debasement and purchasing power from all of these other assets
- 1:07:51that are in tax advantage accounts.
- 1:07:53So people are assuming the S&P, NASDAQ, however they're
- 1:07:56allocating for their retirement is just going to always go up
- 1:07:59into the right when we know like structurally they're losing
- 1:08:03their wealth. And just curious like how you
- 1:08:06think about that and less about the IRA, just more of like kind
- 1:08:09of curious what's going on in your circles with the price
- 1:08:11appreciation, if anything's changed since we've last talked?
- 1:08:16Yeah, I mean, well, I mean, I've, I think I've had three or
- 1:08:19four conversations last week, which with friends that want to
- 1:08:22roll over Iras like that. That's the the ETFs are making
- 1:08:28that such an easy answer. Like I'm now like I used to be
- 1:08:31like, don't get the, you know, the ETFs like actually go buy
- 1:08:35native Bitcoin and this is how you do it.
- 1:08:37I've done that so many times. I know that it just doesn't
- 1:08:39happen. Like I'm just, I'm to the point
- 1:08:41now where I just want people to have exposure to the price.
- 1:08:46And so this is the timing for, for this IRA product with on
- 1:08:53ramps. Perfect.
- 1:08:54Because I think, you know, just anecdotally, last week had four
- 1:08:57people ask about it. How do I roll over, you know, an
- 1:08:59IRA into into Bitcoin? And so that's that's happening.
- 1:09:03I think, you know, the venture world, it's so funny.
- 1:09:06You know, I think I said this in the last time, venture is going
- 1:09:08to be the ironically the, the last group of people to get
- 1:09:12Bitcoin because none of the incentives play into the, the
- 1:09:19general partnership. Like you can't, you know, it's
- 1:09:22very difficult to, to, you know, charge fees on something that
- 1:09:26anybody in the world has access to.
- 1:09:29You know, the, the, the carry on like they are, they will be last
- 1:09:35to it because the incentives with venture capital are, are,
- 1:09:39are not aligned with this thing that anyone in the world has
- 1:09:43access to. That said, I've mentioned this,
- 1:09:47you know, in our next fund, I'm very seriously considering
- 1:09:50allocating a portion of, of Bitcoin and, and being very
- 1:09:55upfront with potential LP's during our next raise for next
- 1:09:58fund. Because essentially what we're,
- 1:10:00what I'm going to say is there's, you know, there's, you
- 1:10:04have 15 years of evidence that this thing grows at a 58% CAG or
- 1:10:09whatever. You know, if, if you believe
- 1:10:13that not even like believe in what bitcoins going to do, but
- 1:10:16if you believe in what everything, what every other
- 1:10:19Fiat currency in the world is going to do IED base, this is
- 1:10:24the the surest bet that you can makeover the next decade.
- 1:10:27And, and so a 10% allocation is something like Bitcoin
- 1:10:33essentially takes the 0X risk out of out of venture capital
- 1:10:38and allows me to play with 90% of the, you know, dry ammo that
- 1:10:42I would have had. But like that one 10% allocation
- 1:10:45held for 10 or 12 years, like, you know, could get me well past
- 1:10:49a 1X in the fund. And, and, and the reason that
- 1:10:52big LP's, you know, sort of throttle their allocation of
- 1:10:56venture capital is because of the risk of putting money with a
- 1:11:00fund manager that ends up like not returning capital, which is
- 1:11:04like 50% of all venture funds don't even return 100% of
- 1:11:08capital. So that's the risk in venture.
- 1:11:09So this new model, like what does that look like?
- 1:11:12OK, if you can guarantee that you're going to, you know,
- 1:11:14return me all of my principal and I just, I'm playing with
- 1:11:19house money now that's a, that's a, a major differentiator in
- 1:11:25venture that is I've had this conversation with probably the 8
- 1:11:32or 10 VCs and they, you know, they just don't get it because
- 1:11:36they don't understand break Bitcoin yet.
- 1:11:38And for the most part, there are a few people that do get it.
- 1:11:41I, I'd said this on a, a panel that I did with you guys in, in
- 1:11:45Nashville at the Bitcoin conference this year.
- 1:11:48I was at a, an all in summit. We've backed a number of of
- 1:11:54Jason Calacanis's deals and we're close with their team.
- 1:11:59And, and so we went out to Napa for a summit and they did like a
- 1:12:05live filming of like an all in, you know, him, him and Schmoth
- 1:12:08and David Sachs. And at the end of it, I, I got
- 1:12:13to spend some time one-on-one with, with, I won't say who, but
- 1:12:16one of those, you know, one of the folks in the, you know, in
- 1:12:19that trio. And I was like, you know, what's
- 1:12:22funny to me is I look out on this crowd and you know, I'm
- 1:12:28looking at a bunch of GPS and a bunch of LP's.
- 1:12:31Every single one of these people are saying like, we are
- 1:12:34investing in world changing companies.
- 1:12:37Like that is the mantra of venture capital.
- 1:12:41And I was like, what's funny to me is it's actually not true.
- 1:12:44It doesn't matter how many great companies we build and back if
- 1:12:48we maintain a positive inflation rate and the dollar continues to
- 1:12:51debase, like everyone's lives just keep getting harder on a
- 1:12:56fully blended basis. Like we're contributing a little
- 1:12:58bit to that, but like all of our gains are just getting stolen
- 1:13:02from us. And it's it's just funny that
- 1:13:05that's the thing about venture capital.
- 1:13:07We invest in, you know, world changing companies, but none of
- 1:13:10these people actually understand what Bitcoin is, which would
- 1:13:13actually allow them to to pull that off.
- 1:13:16And he like grabbed me and pulled me in like almost like
- 1:13:20face to face. And he's like looks out and he's
- 1:13:22like, yeah, none of these people understand that yet.
- 1:13:25And so a few people in venture get it.
- 1:13:30I have the feeling that most of these folks know that they kind
- 1:13:33of have this, you know, space cornered and they've there's
- 1:13:37more juice in this lemon to squeeze and I don't want to you
- 1:13:40know, I don't want to kill the golden goose.
- 1:13:43It's feeding me and my family Like I'm just going to keep
- 1:13:45playing this thing until like I know when the time comes, like a
- 1:13:49lot of this stuff's going to change on, you know, how we we
- 1:13:52do business, but like, not yet. And that's kind of the feeling
- 1:13:57that I that I get with the folks that that are smart to Bitcoin
- 1:14:00are just kind of like, yeah, I, I know you're there.
- 1:14:05You know, I'll, I'll, I'll address it when like I
- 1:14:08absolutely have to. Yeah, that's a, it's amazing
- 1:14:12anecdote. It's kind of timely too, because
- 1:14:14last week they came out and it was a Chamath that said it's,
- 1:14:17you know, the best inflation hedge for the next 50 to 100
- 1:14:19years. Jesse, you'll love this because
- 1:14:22I haven't shared this and the person reached out.
- 1:14:24Let me know that I could say without naming the names on one
- 1:14:28of the last pods we were talking about early riders and the
- 1:14:31Bitcoin denominated fund and this this founder raise in 2020
- 1:14:37AI company pretty like kind of really blowing up put Bitcoin
- 1:14:41its balance sheet in 21 and the investor found out and just kind
- 1:14:46of lost it completely lost it. So change their docks for I
- 1:14:50believe all future investments, but it's also threatening to sue
- 1:14:52unless they divest in the position.
- 1:14:55And I reached out to Cam about this earlier in the week saying
- 1:14:59just like, Can you believe this? And, and obviously he, he called
- 1:15:02just to like, I don't know, confide, like we had a
- 1:15:04consultation and we were just talking about it.
- 1:15:05And also his personal, he was like, hey, this is interesting
- 1:15:07for my personal. I was like, you're talking to
- 1:15:09the wrong person. All this because like, I would
- 1:15:10not sell. I was like, let's work because
- 1:15:12he went, he went and found, you know, got legal, you know, legal
- 1:15:17opinion, whatever. And it's like, he's not, he
- 1:15:19hasn't broken any covenants. He's not in any derivatives,
- 1:15:21right? He's not speculating and he
- 1:15:24didn't know what to do. And he needs to get out of this
- 1:15:26position by the end of the year. And I was and where I commend
- 1:15:30Cam for thinking about this and hopefully you can get to be able
- 1:15:34to do this is because it's implying not only are you
- 1:15:36returning more capital by by holding a better for money.
- 1:15:40I don't see how that doesn't permeate to your investments.
- 1:15:45Because naturally, again, the game has changed with the
- 1:15:48inflation that unless companies have some exposure, look at the
- 1:15:53world through the lens that we understand, they're ready, like
- 1:15:57moving backwards. They're, they're, you know,
- 1:15:58think about inflation persisting and having higher and having to
- 1:16:01think about margins like you're already going like hands tied
- 1:16:03behind your back. And so I think the, This is why,
- 1:16:06like there should only be a small amount of venture firms.
- 1:16:09There should have only been like, This is why investing is
- 1:16:11hard because it's the opposite of what everyone's doing.
- 1:16:13So everybody's in that room looking at the market like this.
- 1:16:15And you got to be looking at a different way because that's
- 1:16:17what investing is similar to Bitcoin, right?
- 1:16:19Nobody's looking at it yet. Nobody needs to pay attention.
- 1:16:22So anyway, it's just a very interesting paradigm like that
- 1:16:24there. And and when he was explaining
- 1:16:26this to me, I don't know if this was what influenced this
- 1:16:30investor because it was like the main guy at this large, it's a
- 1:16:33very large firm. And they went and like amended
- 1:16:35all their docks for all future investments to explicitly say
- 1:16:38they cannot put, I think this underlying asset on their
- 1:16:40balance sheet. But what it kind of implied,
- 1:16:43whether this guy had meant it or not was that it kind of disrupts
- 1:16:45their model because if he's looking at them needing to raise
- 1:16:48and mark it up right on the next round and taking more, uh,
- 1:16:54dilution of their company dilutes versus now they just
- 1:16:57extended their runway because they just like their treasuries
- 1:16:59like loaded. They're just sitting there like,
- 1:17:01and he's thinking about it, giving more discernment.
- 1:17:03They've been more efficient because they're thinking about
- 1:17:05through the Bitcoin lens. And this isn't like hardcore
- 1:17:07Bitcoin. It's just a guy that put it on
- 1:17:08their balance sheet. It changes the whole model of
- 1:17:11venture. And again, it goes back to
- 1:17:13there's going to be a select people that reap the rewards
- 1:17:15because it's just, this is what investing is.
- 1:17:17You got to be different than the market.
- 1:17:20Yep, yeah, it's it's unfortunate.
- 1:17:23You know, I that's an interesting point that she's
- 1:17:26brought brought up. You know, it is actually a
- 1:17:33headwind for investors, you know, multi stage funds that
- 1:17:36want to continue to invest, you know, in teams that have to come
- 1:17:40back to the well, right, like they, you know, once you get
- 1:17:44into real big money, you're not dealing with like seed investors
- 1:17:47that just have positive intent for the founders and like
- 1:17:49obviously, like you want return for the fun and you're playing
- 1:17:52the power law of a Fincher. But like later on, you know, it
- 1:17:55gets really doggy dog and these these firms are like have to get
- 1:17:59allocation in their winners. And if a lot of their winners,
- 1:18:03you know, start just being able to to, you know, fund their
- 1:18:08operations through through their own, you know, their own balance
- 1:18:12sheet. And obviously that's not good
- 1:18:13for venture investors. So like, yeah, like this is just
- 1:18:16like the hints of how venture is going to start to change, you
- 1:18:21know, in in the future. That is going to be interesting
- 1:18:24to follow, you know, if it comes out, you know, if Bitcoin goes
- 1:18:30to to, you know, 34500 K this, this cycle, like I don't know
- 1:18:38what I would do in that situation, but I may, you know,
- 1:18:41I may say, look, how serious are you about this?
- 1:18:44Because you know, we have real conviction in this asset.
- 1:18:47And you know, if, if this ends up being a bad decision for us,
- 1:18:52the company, nothing, nothing distinct.
- 1:18:54We're in our terms, you know that that we signed when you
- 1:18:57finance the deal, you know the beginning.
- 1:19:00If this is just something you're trying to push us out of doing,
- 1:19:04you know we will. This is going to be fun going to
- 1:19:07the press to say like we divested out of Bitcoin, like
- 1:19:10right before a bull market because you know, a venture
- 1:19:12investor wasn't comfortable with our decision making as an
- 1:19:16operating team. Yeah, and this is like a symptom
- 1:19:19we all know probably like here and then listening like the
- 1:19:22amount of clown world and the incentive models.
- 1:19:24But like this just like bring it at home.
- 1:19:26You like the notion of investing is for the outcome to be
- 1:19:29positive so you can get a return on capital.
- 1:19:31And to have positive, the person needs to deliver value.
- 1:19:34And So what way to deliver value then use your expertise to bring
- 1:19:38it to the world. But instead you want the person
- 1:19:40to spend every 18 months having to raise more money and 1st
- 1:19:43isn't just their capital base growing and then delivering
- 1:19:46value to the world is like you're doing the opposite.
- 1:19:49You're asking for the recording of the opposite.
- 1:19:50That's just how bad the incentive model has been with
- 1:19:52this system and this is just like 1 micro example of it.
- 1:19:59Yeah, I know we're getting up on time.
- 1:20:01Can you just mention in passing where is Bitcoin going this
- 1:20:05cycle? We are at the last day of
- 1:20:08October and I think we're at about 2012 or 13% for the month
- 1:20:13because Bitcoin is tanking a little bit.
- 1:20:16Today we're at about 70,000 while we're recording.
- 1:20:20Have to call on the resident having and Bitcoin macro analyst
- 1:20:25Jesse to just maybe paint a picture of what does the next 6
- 1:20:29to 12 months look like? Are things kind of playing out
- 1:20:32as you expected 612 months ago, let's say start of the year?
- 1:20:39Yeah, sure, that's fun. Yeah.
- 1:20:43So as, as you know, Jackson, I, I did a presentation at MIT the
- 1:20:47day after the having kind of walking through my perspective
- 1:20:51on bitcoins mechanics, price mechanics and, and how that's
- 1:20:58all driven by supply and demand. And the having, in my opinion,
- 1:21:02is the catalyst that triggers a post having bull market every
- 1:21:06four years. And that and what I tried to
- 1:21:10emphasize in that talk and and it recently made the rounds
- 1:21:14again because of this is that it it takes six months post having
- 1:21:18where nothing happens but on the surface, but under the surface,
- 1:21:25that supply shortage of half as much Bitcoin being released into
- 1:21:29the market every day from from new supply issuance, that supply
- 1:21:33shortage accumulates and chips away at available for sale
- 1:21:37supply to a point where the the market incoming demand has to
- 1:21:43try to find a new supply. And the only way to do that is
- 1:21:46to start bidding up. So the price starts to drift
- 1:21:49upwards somewhere around six months post having.
- 1:21:53And so in my mind that that starts the flywheel of action
- 1:21:57for a post having bull market where price starts to drift
- 1:22:02upwards, people get excited, more demand comes in, price
- 1:22:06starts to drift upwards more quickly and that just kind of
- 1:22:09flywheels into a into a mania. So a bubble forms after every
- 1:22:14halving and it takes 12 to 18 months for that bubble to to
- 1:22:18pop. That's what we've seen over
- 1:22:20previous cycles. So right now we're six months
- 1:22:23post halving now is when I would expect the price to start to
- 1:22:27move upwards. That's what happened four years
- 1:22:29ago, four years ago, people forget that, that going into the
- 1:22:32election price of Bitcoin, the month before the election, the
- 1:22:35price of Bitcoin went from like 10,000 to 13,000.
- 1:22:39And then six months later it was 64,000.
- 1:22:43And we're at that, that point in time, I think right now for this
- 1:22:47cycle. So, and it's, and it's hard to
- 1:22:50believe that it's hard to imagine what can happen very
- 1:22:53quickly once that flywheel gets going.
- 1:22:56But I think, I think earlier this year, what we saw
- 1:22:59immediately after the the ETFs were launched is a great
- 1:23:03indicator what can and I think will happen once that price
- 1:23:08drifting upwards sort of catches on with with people who are not
- 1:23:13yet Bitcoin holders, right? Like right now, there's no
- 1:23:16interest from outside of the crypto community in Bitcoin
- 1:23:19right now. The, you know, Google search
- 1:23:21volume for, for buy Bitcoin is, is very low.
- 1:23:26And people start to take interest once the price breaks
- 1:23:30above the prior all time high. And and they start and keeps
- 1:23:33moving. And that's when people who are
- 1:23:35on the sidelines just start to feel more and more pressure of
- 1:23:38shit. I have to get in, I have to have
- 1:23:40to buy. Maybe I should.
- 1:23:41I don't want to miss another bull market.
- 1:23:43I just got to jump in and be a part of this and we'll see that.
- 1:23:47I think with the ETFs in particular this cycle, because
- 1:23:51when the price was running Q1 this year after the ETFs were
- 1:23:56launched, ETF incoming volume was tremendous.
- 1:24:01And, and I think that that just shows that ETF buyers are
- 1:24:05reflexive in the same way that all of us every, every Bitcoin
- 1:24:09buyer is reflexive. They buy more when the price is
- 1:24:11going up and, and the faster it's going up, the more demand
- 1:24:15there is. So, you know, I, I expect
- 1:24:17that'll kind of take shape as the price drifts up.
- 1:24:21And I think we'll be looking at a, a 2025 where, you know, maybe
- 1:24:25it's 12 months post halving, maybe it's 18 months post
- 1:24:27halving. So, so sometime second-half of
- 1:24:30the year where I think, I think we'll end up with a price peak.
- 1:24:34I'm sort of trying to remain conservative here and bracing
- 1:24:37for maybe it's 150K, but maybe it's 250K.
- 1:24:41And it's quite possible if, if things get crazy, if there's
- 1:24:44some sort of geopolitical move beyond what you know, what we've
- 1:24:49seen so far, that it could go above 250 K, like 350K is not
- 1:24:54out of the realm of possibility. But I think that, you know,
- 1:24:58everybody's a little bit complacent right now because
- 1:25:00having six months passed, nothing's happened, but now is
- 1:25:04the time to be, to be most excited about what's coming.
- 1:25:07Do you think in your model would it help if a future president
- 1:25:12you know were to tweet happy, which are great bitcoiners a
- 1:25:16happy 16th anniversary of Satoshi's white paper.
- 1:25:19We will end Kamal's were on crypto and Bitcoin will be made
- 1:25:21in the USA. Vote Trump because he happened
- 1:25:24to he happened to just post that.
- 1:25:27And you think too back it, back when the price was this way in
- 1:25:312021, interest rates were still basically, you know, zero.
- 1:25:37And they're going to start to rise.
- 1:25:39They're the entry point for most people getting into Bitcoin was
- 1:25:42an FDX or Celsius, It was an exchange.
- 1:25:45And so today you're looking at, you know, we're we're entering
- 1:25:49into an easing cycle. And then the entry point is
- 1:25:53probably going to be I bet and FBTC for a lot of traditional
- 1:25:57investors. And you hope that gets them on
- 1:25:59their journey to understanding Bitcoin as a technology, as an
- 1:26:03asset class and not just an ETF. And so I don't know how high
- 1:26:09will the price go. It all depends on demand.
- 1:26:11And the price will rise until there are sellers and I going to
- 1:26:17keep buying until people stop selling it.
- 1:26:20I love it, yeah. And we can wrap here, but just
- 1:26:23one quick data point to throw out was that IBIT yesterday had
- 1:26:26nearly a billion dollars of inflows.
- 1:26:28It was 875,000,000 I think between yesterday and the day
- 1:26:32before. Those two days of inflows were
- 1:26:34more than the gold ETFs in their entire first year.
- 1:26:39So it is a pretty exciting time to be in the market and paying
- 1:26:43attention to Bitcoin. Want to be respectful of the
- 1:26:46group's time because we just went over, but Cam and Bradley
- 1:26:50appreciate you coming on. Cam, is there somewhere people
- 1:26:53can get in touch with you if they're curious to learn more
- 1:26:55about Brickyard? Yeah, if if you're interested in
- 1:27:00Brickyard, that's it, just lay brick.com and we're pretty
- 1:27:04explicit about what we do and how we invest.
- 1:27:06I think that could be cool to kind of thumb through.
- 1:27:11And then Twitter is kind of where I'm, you know, I am most
- 1:27:15active and that's Cam duty, just at Cam duty.
- 1:27:19Thanks, Cam and Bradley. Thank you for joining as well.
- 1:27:23Any any last words here? I'm going to give a plug for the
- 1:27:26Brickyard as a local resident. Cam's been really good for our
- 1:27:30city and we need more people like Cam in Chattanooga as a, as
- 1:27:34a born, you know, someone that was born here and, and Brickyard
- 1:27:38is I'm pretty proud of, I'm pretty proud that it's here in
- 1:27:40Chattanooga. And so thank you Cam for
- 1:27:42choosing to live here again, check out on ramps new IRA go to
- 1:27:46on rampbitcoin.com. There's a button on the
- 1:27:48homepage. It is the best IRA product.
- 1:27:50If you've got an if you've got 30K sitting in a old 4O1K, you'd
- 1:27:54roll that to Bitcoin that you can verify on your own node with
- 1:27:57multi institution custody. So that's at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 1:28:02Thank you gentlemen. Really a pleasure to have you on
- 1:28:04today. Appreciate the time.
- 1:28:06Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:28:09If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:28:11episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:28:14app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:28:16today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:28:18Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:28:21for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:28:24nothing should be construed as investment or legal.
- 1:28:26Advice Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey,
- 1:28:29we'd love to hear from you. Visit on
- 1:28:31rampbitcoin.com/contact. To schedule a consultation with
- 1:28:35one of our private client advisors.