Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Tales of the Wild: How Dr Tasmin Rymer Decodes Animal Behavior
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating the Human
- 0:07Side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and will discuss their meanings
- 0:17from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:22Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating
- 0:24the Human Side, where we explore the intersection
- 0:27of science, human experience, and behavior. In
- 0:30today's episode, we focus on the intricate world
- 0:32of behavior. how it drives not only animal survival,
- 0:35but also influences the way we as humans understand
- 0:39and interact with the world around us. Whether
- 0:42it's unraveling the instincts of wildlife or
- 0:45examining the subtle motivations behind our own
- 0:48actions, we'll uncover how behavior shapes both
- 0:52species and environment, making it a key force
- 0:56in adaptation and survival. We are excited to
- 0:59welcome to Dr. Tasman Reimer, a behavioral biologist.
- 1:03and lecturer at James Cook University, whose
- 1:06career has been devoted to studying how animals,
- 1:09particularly rodents, adapt to environmental
- 1:11stressors. Dr. Reimer holds a PhD in behavioral
- 1:15ecology from the University of Wheat and has
- 1:19conducted extensive research on animal cognition,
- 1:22stress responses, and resilience. Her current
- 1:25projects explore how individual animals, each
- 1:28with their own unique personalities and problem
- 1:31-solving abilities, cope with changing environments,
- 1:35offering critical insights for species conservation
- 1:38and reintroduction. Today we explore Dr. Reimer's
- 1:42journey from studying African rodents to her
- 1:45groundbreaking research in Australia, revealing
- 1:47how behavior is key to both animal survival and
- 1:49our understanding of ecological balance. Dr.
- 1:52Reimer, welcome to the podcast. Thank you both
- 2:01for having me. Firstly, we have guests who work
- 2:04in behavioral ecology, but to dive deeply today.
- 2:08Could you please explain the key evolutionary
- 2:11milestones in animal behavior? What is that?
- 2:14Why is it important? So I guess animal behavior
- 2:18has had a very long history from people who've
- 2:21studied it extensively in the laboratory. So
- 2:24many people know Pavlov and some of Pavlov's
- 2:27experiments on dogs and those sorts of conditioning
- 2:30experiments and similar. And it's moved progressively
- 2:33more to people trying to understand what's happening
- 2:36out in the field. But I think for me, it was
- 2:39back in 1963 that a very important paper was
- 2:43published. It was published by Nicotin Bergen,
- 2:46who is now known as one of the fathers of ethology,
- 2:49along with a couple of other people. But in this
- 2:53paper, he articulated ways in which we can actually
- 2:55study behavior. And so what he did is he emphasized
- 2:59that in order to understand any particular behavior,
- 3:03we really need to approach it from... sort of
- 3:05four directions or four sides so the first side
- 3:09is to ask the question how it arises so how does
- 3:11that actual behavior develop so that sort of
- 3:15developmental pathway that an individual might
- 3:17follow so from a juvenile to an adult the next
- 3:20question or the next set of questions sort of
- 3:22look at what influenced the expression of the
- 3:24behavior so these would be the mechanisms so
- 3:26these are things like genes or hormones or neurobiological
- 3:30factors or similar Then he also said that we
- 3:34need to understand the function of behavior.
- 3:36So how does it actually work and why does it
- 3:39work? So what is the necessity of it? And this
- 3:43comes down to thinking about behavior as having
- 3:45an adaptive function or as an adaptation to a
- 3:48particular environment. And then the last sort
- 3:51of angle that we can look at or side that he
- 3:53approached from was to ask the question how the
- 3:56behavior has actually evolved. So that's looking
- 3:59at the evolutionary history, looking at phylogenetics
- 4:02and similar. And I think for me, that was a really
- 4:05pivotal point in the study of behavior because
- 4:08we had two different sort of opposing sides.
- 4:11We had people who focus very much on laboratory
- 4:15work and their sort of ideas were that behavior
- 4:18is driven by genes and there's very little change.
- 4:22And so it's passed down from one generation to
- 4:24the next and it's sort of very fixed. And then
- 4:27we had people who were studying behavior in the
- 4:29field. So true ethologists who were trying to
- 4:32sort of understand why animals were doing what
- 4:34they were doing. And I think bringing it all
- 4:37together, you can look at a behavior and answer
- 4:40it from all four sides. And it's still a correct
- 4:42answer. It's not just this is the right one or
- 4:45this one is the right one. It's the approach
- 4:48that we take. And so I think this integrated
- 4:50approach is now... It's a place that people are
- 4:53trying to get to in the study of behavior, rather
- 4:56than just looking at one tiny focus, looking
- 4:59at trying to bring the four sides all together.
- 5:03So for me, that was, I think, a critical turning
- 5:06point in the study of behavior. That is very
- 5:08interesting. We know that, for example, different
- 5:12organisms are subject to different evolutionary
- 5:17times and different reproduction schemes. So
- 5:22how do you see or can you give us some examples
- 5:26of the difference from different organisms on
- 5:29this evolution of behavior? So most of my work
- 5:34doesn't actually focus on that particular question.
- 5:37Generally, sort of these long -term questions.
- 5:40However, there's a really cool example, behavior
- 5:43sort of changing very, very quickly in blackcaps.
- 5:46And that was a migratory behavior. And that was
- 5:48to do with climate change. I don't remember the
- 5:51exact details, but what they found was that these
- 5:54little birds have actually shifted their migration
- 5:56patterns and that they're now actually passing
- 5:58that information on to the next generation. So
- 6:01it's shifting where those birds are actually
- 6:04moving and how individuals are learning about
- 6:06that behavior. And so what I would expect is
- 6:09that over time, you're actually going to see
- 6:11a full shift to the birds all moving in the same
- 6:13direction rather than the old sort of pathway.
- 6:17So it was a very, very quick shift. It occurred
- 6:19in about 30 years we started to see these shifts.
- 6:23But if you think about behavior a little bit
- 6:26more broadly, pretty much everything that we
- 6:28do is shaped by what we're carrying in our genes,
- 6:31but also about our environment. So behaviors
- 6:34are like morphological traits and physiological
- 6:37traits. They change with the pressures in the
- 6:39environment. So as soon as you have a change
- 6:42or a stress in the environment, that has the
- 6:44capacity to then promote behavior moving in a
- 6:47sort of a different direction. If you think about
- 6:50classically like speciation, events where you
- 6:53see two new species forming, that causes those
- 6:56sort of big speciation events, so maybe something
- 6:59like a flood separating two populations, will
- 7:02not only lead to changes in the genes, but it
- 7:05also leads to changes in the behaviors. And then
- 7:08those sort of pathways diverge and you end up
- 7:11on different evolutionary tracks. I'm not sure
- 7:14if that answered your question, but I hope that
- 7:16it did. Yeah, I think it does. And also with
- 7:21what you said, I'm thinking that behaviors as
- 7:25these other traits that you mentioned may have
- 7:28like this plasticity of other traits depending
- 7:32on the circumstances and environmental conditions,
- 7:35maybe. So, yeah, we tend to think about behavior
- 7:38as being generally somewhat flexible. Some behaviors
- 7:41are not as flexible than others. So by flexible,
- 7:44we just sort of mean the capacity to change relatively
- 7:47quickly. And so for a long time, people have
- 7:52understood that compared to something like a
- 7:54morphological trait, a behavioral trait can change
- 7:57generally quite quickly. Now, some traits or
- 8:01some behavioral traits. don't change very fast
- 8:04so if you think about what we might call a sort
- 8:06of instinctual behaviors like pecking behavior
- 8:10in baby birds sort of pecking towards a stimulus
- 8:13that's under a very strong genetic control and
- 8:16there's a lot of reasons for that the main one
- 8:18being that if the baby bird doesn't perform the
- 8:20behavior it doesn't get food so you don't want
- 8:22to mess around with that sort of stuff too much
- 8:25but when we're starting to think about the flexibility
- 8:27of behaviors You want an animal to be able to
- 8:31respond to something in its environment, particularly
- 8:34if there's change, because otherwise that animal
- 8:37is going to die. If there's a massive change
- 8:40in the environment, so let's start thinking about
- 8:43things like urbanization, where you're getting
- 8:45new foods coming into environments and similar.
- 8:47If animals don't try new foods, they could potentially
- 8:52starve because their food source is declining.
- 8:55If they don't come out because they're too scared
- 8:58because there's people around, then they also
- 9:00might starve because they're never going to come
- 9:02out and they don't eat. So it becomes sort of
- 9:06a necessity to be somewhat flexible. That sounds
- 9:09maybe a little bit negative, but there's some
- 9:11really cool examples of behaviors which have
- 9:14shown this plasticity or that flexibility. And
- 9:16it's led to some really interesting, should we
- 9:20say, conflicts maybe between people, but I think
- 9:24it's fascinating nonetheless. And so the best
- 9:26example that I could think about is in Sydney,
- 9:30in Australia, there are cockatoos. And for those
- 9:33of you who don't know cockatoos, cockatoos are
- 9:35very loud and annoying birds, parrots. They're
- 9:39really clever. And what they've done is they've
- 9:41actually learned how to open trash bins. You
- 9:45know, the big wheelie bins that people put their
- 9:47rubbish in. And they've learned how to open those
- 9:49and then gain access to the rubbish bins and
- 9:51get food from the rubbish bins. And naturally,
- 9:54you can imagine that this causes a huge amount
- 9:56of mess. So it's led to sort of an evolutionary
- 9:59arms race between humans and cockatoos, as cockatoos
- 10:03have to learn more and more intricate techniques
- 10:05for opening the bins because people are using
- 10:08more and more intricate techniques to keep their
- 10:10bins closed. And this is moving really, really
- 10:12fast. The birds are learning through cultural
- 10:15exchange, basically, or social learning. They're
- 10:19learning really, really quickly how to open these
- 10:22bins just by watching other individuals. And
- 10:25it seems like urban environments are also particularly
- 10:28good for sort of pushing flexibility of behavior.
- 10:31There's another really great example of crows
- 10:34in Japan that have learned how to take walnuts,
- 10:38put them on the road on a pedestrian crossing
- 10:40when the traffic light is red. and then move
- 10:44off the road again traffic light goes green the
- 10:47cars come running over they'll come driving over
- 10:50they they crush the nut traffic light goes red
- 10:52and the little crows walk back out on the pedestrian
- 10:54crossing and eat the nuts so they don't get run
- 10:57over by the cars which i think is really clever
- 10:59so some of these behaviors emerge really really
- 11:03fast and they really really quick at adjusting
- 11:05and changing and so i think that's the beauty
- 11:08of It does tend to be able to evolve or change
- 11:12very, very quickly compared to some of our other
- 11:15traits. I have a question. Well, actually, you
- 11:19study individual differences among the groups
- 11:24and we can make generalizations considering the
- 11:29behavior of an animal, of a group of an animal,
- 11:32if we take it to an individual level. because
- 11:36it's going to have a big variation. And of course,
- 11:39some individuals are going to have a crazy behavior
- 11:42compared to the other ones, which I observed
- 11:45in the spider. So why is it important to study
- 11:48or understand these traits, individual traits,
- 11:52and how they are contributing, for example, to
- 11:55the population, and how these can have an impact
- 11:58in the survival? Also, we can transfer that one
- 12:01into humans, because we are here. I think people
- 12:06in general have been very focused on ecosystems
- 12:10and there's a good reason for that because animals
- 12:13can't survive without the ecosystem so you know
- 12:15they they need a place to live and so if you're
- 12:18conserving at a at a broad level you're conserving
- 12:21the organisms in it so that makes a lot of sense
- 12:24however I think it's equally important to look
- 12:27at the bottom so I think it's really important
- 12:30to look at the individuals because As we know
- 12:32from people, everybody's different. Everybody's
- 12:36got their own quirks and individuals respond
- 12:39differently. And some individuals are just naturally
- 12:42more resilient than others. And that extends
- 12:45to animals too. And I think a lot of people forget
- 12:48that. And I think also people forget that an
- 12:52individual is the one that is carrying the genes.
- 12:56And the gene is the ultimate unit on which selection
- 12:59is going to act. I mean, you don't have selection
- 13:02without really having those genes from which
- 13:05your traits ultimately arise. So I think for
- 13:10me, we have to think about the individual because
- 13:13the individuals that make it from one generation
- 13:16to the next are the ones that are contributing
- 13:18to natural selection and evolution. And some
- 13:21individuals will just be naturally more resilient.
- 13:25than others some individuals will just cope better
- 13:28with stress and if we just come back to humans
- 13:30everybody knows somebody who's a little bit more
- 13:33anxious or somebody who's a risk taker or maybe
- 13:36a little bit more neurotic everybody knows somebody
- 13:39who's a little bit different and sometimes people
- 13:42you might know somebody who falls apart at a
- 13:45very small thing another person just brushes
- 13:47it off and animals are exactly the same and I've
- 13:51seen it with my work with mosaic -tailed rats.
- 13:54So they're a little native rat that we have here
- 13:56in Australia. And individuals are so different
- 14:00that it becomes hard to sort of generalize what
- 14:03outcome you might actually expect. So yes, generally,
- 14:08we can look at an average and say, on average,
- 14:10a population is going to do this. But the individuals
- 14:14within that population are what's actually really
- 14:17interesting because That's where we get innovation.
- 14:20That's where we get new behaviors emerging. And
- 14:22so for me, I think people really shouldn't forget
- 14:25that it's the individuals that make up the populations
- 14:27that are then the ones who are going to be driving
- 14:31change and particularly innovative behaviors
- 14:34and similar. We know that you have worked with
- 14:38different group of animals in this behavior research.
- 14:41What are the difference between studying the
- 14:44behavior of contrasting animal groups, like,
- 14:46for example, invertebrates versus mammals or
- 14:49reptiles? I think every different set of animals
- 14:53has its own set of challenges. So particularly
- 14:56with me working with rodents and similar, anything
- 14:59that has a spine or a backbone. There's a lot
- 15:03of red tape associated with working with them
- 15:05through animal ethics. And, you know, you've
- 15:07got to really consider the welfare of their animals,
- 15:09which is important. And then on the other side,
- 15:11when you look at invertebrates, most people don't
- 15:14care. They don't necessarily think about the
- 15:17welfare of animals, which can actually become
- 15:19really important if you're studying insects in
- 15:22a laboratory environment or a captive environment,
- 15:24because they have hormones too. And they experience
- 15:28stress too. And they experience fear. By sort
- 15:31of not taking that into account, we sort of forget
- 15:34that, again, these are individual animals that
- 15:38are responding to their environment around them.
- 15:40And we can't just make the assumption that an
- 15:44invertebrate, just because it doesn't have a
- 15:46backbone, isn't going to necessarily respond
- 15:48in a similar manner to a vertebrate. I also think,
- 15:52you know, when we think about invertebrates,
- 15:55there's so many sort of behaviors that are cool.
- 16:00and new and emerging and again some of the classic
- 16:03studies by von frisch in like the 40s 50s somewhere
- 16:07around there was on the littlest things it was
- 16:10on bees yeah so i think a lot of our insights
- 16:14actually come from studying these sort of lesser
- 16:17should we say lesser known taxa or lesser known
- 16:21groups animal groups Everybody tends to focus,
- 16:25or maybe everybody is a bit of a strong statement,
- 16:27but a lot of people tend to focus on the things
- 16:30which are iconic and we can see and maybe is
- 16:34rare or is threatened by, you know, their conservation
- 16:37is threatened. And I think people sort of forget
- 16:40that often it's the little things which are driving
- 16:43systems. So many of our insects, for example,
- 16:46are important pollinators, but so little of their
- 16:49natural behavior is actually understood. So if
- 16:53you go to mammals, lots of people know about
- 16:56lots of mammal behavior things. When you come
- 16:59to insects, so little is known. And just to give
- 17:03you an example, some of the work that we've been
- 17:05doing, we've been working on a species of tarantula
- 17:07here in Australia. And it's been around for a
- 17:12long time. It's not like it's brand new to science
- 17:16and nobody's ever seen it. But the babies stay
- 17:19with the mom. And this is the first time we're
- 17:23recording this in a tarantula species in Australia.
- 17:27And I'm pretty certain people have noticed it.
- 17:29They just haven't bothered to record it. And
- 17:33it's the same thing with trapdoor spiders. Trapdoor
- 17:35spider babies stay with their mother and it leads
- 17:38to a social system known as subsociality. But
- 17:41nobody talks about it. You know, it's just, it's
- 17:44not seen as important, probably because they're
- 17:47trapdoor spiders and, you know. What do we know
- 17:49about spiders that some of them kill people?
- 17:52And I find it fascinating that people sort of
- 17:56forget some of these taxa. And particularly they
- 17:59offer sort of really rich areas for studying
- 18:02behaviours just because, you know, lots of people
- 18:04haven't studied them before. And I have to add
- 18:07that, for example, the perception and also the
- 18:09knowledge that we have about them and also how
- 18:13we get that information and how the public...
- 18:16get related to the information, for example,
- 18:18related with invertebrates, with cockroaches
- 18:21that are like, oh, sorry, well, it's a pest.
- 18:23Well, actually have an important function when
- 18:26they are in the forest. But also like a little
- 18:30beetles that are really important when they just
- 18:34recycle or they... pieces from other vertebrates
- 18:38and then they come the ecosystem completely relied
- 18:41on them on this tiny little animal but then each
- 18:44at each individual level is not like they are
- 18:47they're robots tiny little robots just behaving
- 18:50in the same way but also recently has been shown
- 18:55that they feel pain that they have something
- 18:58that is called nociceptors that is the ability
- 19:01of feel that pain And it's not only a reaction
- 19:05or a response to just run away. So that goes
- 19:09to, as you mentioned before, into the animal
- 19:11ethics who have to be expanded. But there's another
- 19:14invertebrates that are the octopus, for example.
- 19:18It's amazing how these animals are so brilliant,
- 19:22so intelligent. But then they are invertebrates.
- 19:26Well, it's actually funny you say that because
- 19:29at least here in Australia and every country
- 19:32is different. So every country has its own set
- 19:34of guidelines, its own set of rules that they
- 19:36try and follow when it comes to animal welfare.
- 19:39But here in Australia, cephalopods are considered
- 19:43vertebrates because you have to get an animal
- 19:46ethics permit to actually work with them. And
- 19:48also decapods. So things like lobsters and crabs
- 19:52and similar. So I think there's the capacity
- 19:55for change. It's just slow. Do you research focus
- 20:00on the behavior of rodents and spiders? As you
- 20:03mentioned previously, could you share some of
- 20:05the most fascinating behaviors you have observed
- 20:07in this species and how these behaviors stand
- 20:10out compared to similar animals in other parts
- 20:14of the world? You already mentioned one amazing
- 20:16one that was this tarantula. For people that
- 20:19have heard before, I want to make a big quote
- 20:23that these ancient spiders, solitary spiders,
- 20:26haven't been reported at least before as a social
- 20:30act. animals but in the we have the older the
- 20:35new ones that they call the new spiders and they
- 20:38have been reported like a social so that's really
- 20:41a big remark that you are mentioning before the
- 20:45first of this tarantula that we know of this
- 20:47particular genus in australia actually there's
- 20:50been several observations of the sub -sociality
- 20:55in megalomorphs so megalomorphs are spiders that
- 20:58are considered old world spiders. So your tarantulas,
- 21:01your funnel web spiders, not the American funnel
- 21:04web spiders, the Australian ones, mouse spiders
- 21:07or their relatives and similar, trapdoors, those
- 21:10sorts of things. But compared to our new world
- 21:14spiders, so the web building spiders, there's
- 21:17very few that have actually been studied. I'm
- 21:20working on a project with an honors student here
- 21:22at JCU on this particular topic. And we... Found
- 21:27a review paper that was written, I think, in
- 21:292014 that actually reported some of these behaviors
- 21:33or sub -sociality in some of these sort of megalomorph
- 21:37spiders. But their list was relatively small.
- 21:40We've managed to actually expand that list by
- 21:43just delving more deeply into the literature
- 21:46and looking at some sort of newer literature
- 21:49that has come out since then. But even so, there's
- 21:53very few papers that have come out looking. specifically
- 21:56at things like trapdoor spiders. So I'm pretty
- 22:00certain that trapdoor spiders in general are
- 22:03subsocial or the offspring stay with their mothers,
- 22:07but it's just not reported. And some really cool
- 22:12behaviors are documented in these spiders, which
- 22:14you wouldn't necessarily think because, hey,
- 22:17it's a spider. Spiders are creepy and they're
- 22:19crawly and they have venom and they're horrible.
- 22:23But we've actually found some cases or from going
- 22:27through the literature, the mother actually provisions
- 22:29the babies. So she actually catches the prey,
- 22:32mashes it up for the babies, and then leaves
- 22:35the food for the babies to come and eat. And
- 22:37we've seen this in our little tarantula here
- 22:40in Australia, which is really awesome. So it
- 22:43sort of opens our eyes a little bit to the fact
- 22:46that these animals are much more maternal than
- 22:48we might have given them credit for. And I think
- 22:50for me, it's... Parental care behavior is really,
- 22:54it's something that I'm fascinated with. And
- 22:56it started many, many years ago when I was doing
- 22:59my PhD, because I was working on a little species
- 23:02of mouse. And again, mice are viewed as pests.
- 23:05People don't like them. They eat all the crops,
- 23:08etc. But this little species of mouse is the
- 23:11only mouse in Africa where the fathers actually
- 23:15provide parental care. And it only occurs in
- 23:19certain areas. And it's very much driven by environment
- 23:23and population density. So it's highly flexible.
- 23:26The males only show the behavior under particular
- 23:29conditions. So this changes the entire social
- 23:33system throughout the year. And it switches from
- 23:36having individual females raising young alone
- 23:39to females in groups raising young with a male
- 23:42who provides care. Sometimes those males don't
- 23:45provide care. Sometimes they just roam between
- 23:47females. It's driven largely by what's going
- 23:51on in the environment, which causes these huge
- 23:53massive shifts. And that's really what got me
- 23:56interested in actually understanding the sort
- 23:59of the mechanisms and the development of these
- 24:02behaviors. Another example that I can give you,
- 24:05you were just asking about, you know, some of
- 24:07the really cool things that I might have found
- 24:10out compared to, you know, other species or similar.
- 24:14There's this general understanding in terms of
- 24:17life history. that you have trade -offs between
- 24:20things like energy production, so producing sugars
- 24:24and similar, and testosterone, so formating and
- 24:28similar. I found the case in that sort of same
- 24:32trade -off in a little species of mouse, the
- 24:34mosaic -tailed rat. It's never been shown before,
- 24:38and yet we showed it. But it's also, it's not
- 24:41so simple as just being a physiological change
- 24:44or a physiological response. It's also related
- 24:48to the personality of the individual. So individuals,
- 24:53particularly individuals which are bolder, actually
- 24:57it's a bigger cost for them, should we say. So
- 25:01basically, in order to produce more testosterone
- 25:04to be bolder, they have a very large energetic
- 25:07cost associated with that. But the shyer ones
- 25:11don't because they're not expending testosterone.
- 25:15to be bold. So it's a pretty cool sort of system.
- 25:18I think there's just, there's so much to be learned
- 25:21out there. And a colleague of ours, Dr. Misha
- 25:26Raul, she's just been using social media to find
- 25:30out whether individuals, you know, different
- 25:33species solve problems. And she's found lots
- 25:36of new animals solving problems innovatively
- 25:39that has never been seen or never been reported,
- 25:41at least in the scientific literature. So there's
- 25:45so much new stuff out there. It's really hard
- 25:47to pinpoint one individual thing that's cool.
- 25:51Wow. And how do you think that reporting and
- 25:56publishing these kind of behaviors may challenge
- 26:00the common perceptions that scientists and general
- 26:03public have about these animals? So I think there's
- 26:08two different things there. I think a lot of
- 26:11the general public... sort of don't have access
- 26:14to academic work. A lot of them are hidden behind
- 26:18paywalls, although with open access publishing
- 26:21these days, it's a lot easier for them. But science
- 26:24writing tends to be dry, tends to be clinical.
- 26:27It's not friendly to generally read. If you think
- 26:31about it, you're not going to take it home and
- 26:33read it to your children in bed. So I think a
- 26:36lot of our findings tend to sort of be missed
- 26:39by the general public. Or it's missed and only
- 26:44certain parts of the public will access it because
- 26:47they have a vested interest in it or are really
- 26:49keen to learn more about it. Citizen science,
- 26:53I think, has really been useful for bringing
- 26:56science to the general public. But again, it
- 27:00becomes challenging because there are limitations
- 27:02to what you can actually achieve with citizen
- 27:05science. And again, it comes down to things like
- 27:07permitting and similar. I think we need to do
- 27:10better with science communication. But as an
- 27:13academic, there's not a lot of time in my day
- 27:15to be able to do these. So I think that the challenge
- 27:19is how do we get the information out there as
- 27:22an academic, as a researcher? And I think also
- 27:26the challenge is to minimize sort of mistakes
- 27:30that get made along the way. So we can, for example,
- 27:34put out a press release. and say, hey, we've
- 27:37got this really cool paper, the public should
- 27:40read it, etc. I've had several instances where
- 27:44the reporters have just misinterpreted what we've
- 27:47said or changed the meaning without necessarily,
- 27:53not being vindictive, but changing the meaning
- 27:57because they think it sounds better. And I think
- 28:00that's an inherent problem is things get lost
- 28:03in translation. To give you an example on Misha
- 28:08Rao's work, we put out a press release about
- 28:11a paper, which was pretty cool. We got interviewed,
- 28:14which was great. And all of a sudden we were
- 28:16exposing our little rats to razor blades. And
- 28:20we hadn't mentioned the word razor anywhere,
- 28:23but we had used the word pencil eraser. So all
- 28:28of a sudden it was blown out of proportion. And
- 28:30we were also talking about things like problem
- 28:32solving. And all of a sudden the title of the
- 28:35news article was something about NASA -style
- 28:39space tests or something similar. So I think
- 28:43sometimes things get a little bit lost in translation.
- 28:45So we do need to do a bit better with our science
- 28:48communication. Because we like to explore the
- 28:51human side of the researchers in this program,
- 28:54we... would like to know how important are the
- 28:57relations between students and mentors from the
- 29:01perspective of both? What do you think about
- 29:03this? I have been very lucky to be both. Yes,
- 29:08you were my main supervisor. So if I start from
- 29:14my own personal experience of being a student,
- 29:18I was very, very lucky. I had an advisor or a
- 29:23mentor who... Continues to be my mentor to this
- 29:26day and is a very, very close friend of mine
- 29:29to this day. But he was strong enough to give
- 29:33me independence, but also knew when I needed
- 29:36help without me necessarily knowing that I needed
- 29:40the help. He was supportive, but he also pushed.
- 29:44And he pushed me pretty hard. But I think at
- 29:48the end of the day, I needed that. I needed that
- 29:50discipline, if that makes sense. But he was still
- 29:55good enough to let me have a bit of free reign
- 29:58and to let me develop my ideas in my own way.
- 30:01So he didn't constrain my thinking. And I think
- 30:04it's very important as a supervisor to try and
- 30:07not constrain the thinking of your students because
- 30:10they have different opinions to you. And, you
- 30:14know, we all have our own idea about what something
- 30:17means or how it can be interpreted. And I think
- 30:21as a supervisor, it's our job to guide a student,
- 30:25but also to understand that they may come up
- 30:29with a different interpretation to the results
- 30:32that they're getting. I think also sometimes
- 30:35as a supervisor, it becomes necessary to sort
- 30:40of work with the student that you have, not with
- 30:44the student that you'd like them to be, if that
- 30:47makes sense. but also to accept that they're
- 30:50human beings and that they have other things
- 30:52going on in their lives. So to be patient when
- 30:55they need that time, because not everybody will
- 30:58work at the same pace. Not everybody will be
- 31:01a publishing superstar. Some people are, but
- 31:04not everybody will. So it's being, again, using
- 31:07that word flexible as a supervisor and adaptable.
- 31:11So allow a student to grow in their role rather
- 31:15than forcing them down a pathway and sort of
- 31:18trying to you know make sure that they're going
- 31:21down the path that you as a supervisor want as
- 31:24a student i relied a lot on the emotional support
- 31:29provided by my supervisor more so i think than
- 31:32my family although they gave me fantastic support
- 31:35but i think your supervisor the supervisors and
- 31:38students know the project and sometimes the best
- 31:43person that you can rant at or whose shoulder
- 31:46you can cry on is your supervisor. And I think
- 31:49the supervisor needs to really be willing to
- 31:52deal with those sorts of moments. I also think
- 31:57it's important that the supervisor doesn't do
- 31:59the work of the student. I think from my own
- 32:02experience, it becomes very, very easy when,
- 32:05you know, maybe for whatever reason a student
- 32:08isn't delivering. It's very tempting to then
- 32:11just want to do the work to help. But I think
- 32:14you have to take a step back and you've got to
- 32:16let that person make a mistake or let that person
- 32:20go at their own pace because that's going to
- 32:23be the best for them at the end of the day. You
- 32:25can hold their hand and when they fall, you can
- 32:28help them up, but you can't always carry them.
- 32:31And I think that's a, for me, that's a lesson
- 32:34I'm still learning. I do tend to be a little
- 32:37bit of a mother hen as Linda, you know. And it's
- 32:41just, I think it's trying to find that balance
- 32:43of when to let them go and when to make sure
- 32:48that you're holding on to them. And my supervisor
- 32:51is an incredible person for bringing out the
- 32:55best in you and motivating you. And I don't know
- 33:00what it is specifically about him, but I can
- 33:04just say it was the package that came with. And
- 33:09he had a fundamental understanding of me, of
- 33:12this, which I don't know if other people would
- 33:17have seen because I'm my own complex human. And
- 33:20I think him being an animal behavior person helped
- 33:24with that because he could see me as an individual
- 33:27and he could see that I wasn't the same as somebody
- 33:29else. And he knew what he could say that was
- 33:35appropriate, that would push me as opposed to,
- 33:38uh sort of pushing me down or anything like that
- 33:41and i'd like to think at the end of the day if
- 33:45if i could emulate what he is and what he was
- 33:48to me if i could emulate that as a supervisor
- 33:51that's what my goal would ultimately be and i
- 33:54would hope that my students see me in the same
- 33:56way i i completely agree In a moment, I remember
- 34:01pretty well someone mentioned that, for example,
- 34:05doing a PhD or a master, well, especially a PhD
- 34:08was like a marriage and get for 40 years or in
- 34:13US and other places like a seven years. And then
- 34:16actually, I think that is the supervisors are
- 34:19the 90 % of the success of the PhD and a master
- 34:24or any project and the relationship that they
- 34:27have with student supervisor is. Fundamentally
- 34:30important because as you mentioned before, it's
- 34:32not only about the researchers and we are just
- 34:34like robots working without stopping. We have
- 34:39a life, we have a family, we have the same problems
- 34:44that other person has. And understanding that,
- 34:48I think that your point is really important because
- 34:50you study the behavior and I think that you're
- 34:53more conscious about that. But I always tell
- 34:55my friends like, look. Have a conversation with
- 34:58your supervisor or your possible prospects of
- 35:02supervisor. And then if you see that something
- 35:05is off, just don't go for it. Because it can
- 35:08be amazing love, but you're going to suffer so
- 35:11much if you don't have the support. And I think
- 35:14that the clear communication is important and
- 35:16being independent and just pushing and nudging
- 35:18a little bit is also important. Supporting but
- 35:21not doing everything for the student, that's
- 35:24amazing. And I was really lucky. That's great.
- 35:28And well, this next one is in two parts. The
- 35:32first one is, how do you see the future of animal
- 35:34behavior research developing? And the other part
- 35:38is, do you consider that the technological advances
- 35:41have enabled breakthroughs in the field? I think
- 35:44one of the sort of movements now is largely away
- 35:48from the big iconic things and more moving towards
- 35:51understanding the little things, as I like to
- 35:55call them. Also understanding that not all individuals
- 35:59behave the same and not all behaviors are the
- 36:02same. So what we might consider, I'm just going
- 36:05to use a very general sort of foraging in bees
- 36:09is not the same as foraging in lions. And I think
- 36:12there's more of an appreciation there. I know
- 36:15that's a very extreme example and it's ridiculous,
- 36:17but you understand, I think, what I mean. And
- 36:21I think, you know, in terms of the technologies...
- 36:25The study of animal behavior historically was
- 36:27very much you go out, you sit down, you open
- 36:31your eyes, and you watch. That was classic ethology.
- 36:35And if you think about Jane Goodall's work, she
- 36:38sat in the forest and watched chimpanzees and
- 36:41documented what they were doing. In the other
- 36:45case, when you had people studying behavior in
- 36:48the laboratory, they would... basically putting
- 36:51animals in situations and going, what did they
- 36:54do? So highly, highly, highly controlled environments,
- 36:57changing one thing and going, what happened?
- 37:00But it was all very regulated and very controlled.
- 37:03But again, it all came down to using these two
- 37:05little things on your face called your eyes to
- 37:08just watch what happened. And I think now with
- 37:12technology, with particularly things like AI
- 37:16and machine learning, all of those sorts of things,
- 37:19It's increased the potential for studying behavior.
- 37:23Because let's face it, if you're studying an
- 37:26elephant and you want to track that elephant
- 37:29over its lifetime, well, you're probably going
- 37:32to die before it dies. Elephants live to like,
- 37:34what, 70 odd years? And they move places. So
- 37:38unless you're going to sit there watching them
- 37:41with your notebook for 70 odd years, which is
- 37:44what they used to do in the old days, it's just
- 37:46not feasible. you know these days and especially
- 37:49for like cryptic species and very rare species
- 37:51slogging around in a rainforest you might never
- 37:54actually see your species if you're trying to
- 37:56use those sort of traditional methods so i think
- 37:59with the with particularly new technologies or
- 38:02maybe someone so new anymore it allows us to
- 38:05track animals and watch animals in ways that
- 38:08we haven't before um so there's been some really
- 38:10cool studies um on movement patterns and navigation
- 38:14in ants For example, so they've been using different
- 38:17technologies. So putting like little accelerometers
- 38:19or similar onto the ants themselves and then
- 38:22tracking where they go. So you don't actually
- 38:25have to physically watch them. You get your computer
- 38:27to watch it for you. And you've got all these
- 38:29cool behavioral analysis programs that can do
- 38:32all of the analysis for you. It actually makes
- 38:34life very boring if I think about it. But there
- 38:36you go. But, you know, we can also, yeah, if
- 38:40you think about a very basic thing like a camera
- 38:42trap. I mean, a camera trap is relatively simple,
- 38:45but what it's doing now is it's allowing us to
- 38:48actually observe those rare species that you
- 38:50just can't see because as a human, we go into
- 38:53an area and make a lot of noise and things hide
- 38:55away. So by putting these in there, we can see
- 38:58rare species. We can see novel behaviors. We
- 39:01can get sensors and recorders that can measure
- 39:05physiology. We can measure all sorts of behaviors
- 39:07and similar without actually having to be there.
- 39:12You don't actually have to see the animal in
- 39:15order to record its behavior, which I think is
- 39:17a huge step. It's a huge change for animal behavior
- 39:20research. And I think also, you know, if we think
- 39:24about how behaviors were analyzed, and Linda
- 39:26can attest to this probably, but you collect
- 39:30hours and hours and hours worth of data. And
- 39:34to analyze that physically by hand takes hours
- 39:38and hours and hours and hours. I remember for
- 39:42my PhD back in the day, I used a VHS and videos
- 39:48and I sat with a stopwatch and my remote control
- 39:54for my TV and I'd watch and then I'd stop, I'd
- 39:57record the time and then I'd watch again. Sometimes
- 40:00I'd have to go backwards a little bit and then
- 40:02watch again. So it's just with the analysis software
- 40:06that we have now, it just makes analyzing behave
- 40:10like... the data so much easier. And I also heard
- 40:14about a really cool example. I think it was last
- 40:17year, somebody was working on bird calls and
- 40:20they were actually looking at using, you know,
- 40:25machine learning to learn templates to basically
- 40:29pick these out of thousands and thousands and
- 40:31thousands of hours of birds calls. So in Australia,
- 40:34there's a big bioacoustic array, which is all
- 40:38of these acoustic sensors put out all over different
- 40:41parts of Australia. And it's collecting bush
- 40:43sounds. So it's collecting the sounds that are
- 40:46naturally occurring. But you can imagine it's
- 40:49collecting days, hours, weeks, months, years
- 40:53worth of data. And we just physically cannot
- 40:56sift through that. We just can't do it anymore.
- 40:59There's just too much data. So with... some of
- 41:02these sort of machine learning patterns and algorithms
- 41:05and AI, we can just make them do the work. They
- 41:08can do it faster and we can still get the answers
- 41:11now. And so I think there's been a huge shift
- 41:14in traditional animal behavior methods to more
- 41:19incorporating these new technologies and similar.
- 41:22I'm still a dinosaur so I haven't really incorporated
- 41:26these. But who knows, maybe in the future I will
- 41:30also join the ranks of the AI -initiated. Your
- 41:34research on resilience and adaptability in animals
- 41:37is especially relevant given today's environmental
- 41:40issues. How do you think the study of animal
- 41:43behavior can inspire or inform human approaches
- 41:47to coping with global change? Oh, that's a tough
- 41:52one. I think probably climate... There's an emphasis
- 41:57on climate change. And yes, I think climate change
- 42:00is something that we need to be worried about.
- 42:03For me, in terms of behavior, I think animals
- 42:07will respond to climate change. Some will go
- 42:13extinct. That's just the natural order of things.
- 42:15Some are going to persist. That's just the natural
- 42:18order of things. That's obviously my own feeling
- 42:22there. I think one of the biggest... changes
- 42:25though is urbanization and I know it's not climate
- 42:29change but I think humans are transforming landscapes
- 42:32so fast that it's encroaching on on animals and
- 42:38animals have to adjust their behaviors very very
- 42:40quickly and I think knowing how animals are responding
- 42:46to those changes allows us as people to sort
- 42:50of make better informed decisions about what's
- 42:54what we are changing and how it affects us in
- 42:57the long term so looking if we focus on how animals
- 43:01are responding to things like fragmentation it
- 43:04shifts our perspective because then we go hang
- 43:08on a second but if we live in a city which is
- 43:12just bricks and cement and tar and you know high
- 43:17-rises it's not aesthetically pleasing for us
- 43:21either so One of the things that we might potentially
- 43:25do is shift our focus and go, well, people need
- 43:28to live in cities, but how can we incorporate
- 43:30animals and beautiful trees and forest in our
- 43:36city? Because it'll improve our own health, it'll
- 43:39improve our own emotional well -being and mental
- 43:43health, for example, but we can then incorporate
- 43:45conservation in it as well. So I think... Specifically
- 43:49asking how the study of behavior can inspire
- 43:52humans. I think for me, I don't need climate
- 43:57change to be inspired. That's just me. I think
- 44:01it's challenging. I really do. For me, I find
- 44:03that it's a question that it's difficult to answer
- 44:06for me. I think we can use it to shape what we
- 44:09do and how we manage. But specifically behavior
- 44:13itself. I think it's got to be incorporated with
- 44:17other things as well. So it's, you know, specifically
- 44:21if you're talking about climate change, it's
- 44:23not just behavior that's going to be affected.
- 44:25It's going to be physiology as well and physiological
- 44:28responses. You know, and if we think about, you
- 44:33know, how these animals are going to respond,
- 44:35we're going to respond in a similar way because
- 44:37we're animals at the base of it. I'm just trying
- 44:39to think of some really... interesting examples
- 44:43of people that have used, should we say, animal
- 44:46behaviors or animal ways to try and better manage
- 44:50themselves. So you've probably all heard about
- 44:54biomimicry. Biomimicry is basically using what
- 44:58nature has done for the benefit of people and
- 45:01to try and improve things that we do. So I think
- 45:05it's in Zimbabwe. They've actually, Zimbabwe
- 45:08or Botswana, somewhere in Africa. southern africa
- 45:11they've actually built buildings that are based
- 45:14on termite mounds and because they've built those
- 45:17buildings in that sort of structure they don't
- 45:20need air conditioning because the buildings naturally
- 45:23cool themselves and so if you can design something
- 45:27like that which doesn't use electricity hey that's
- 45:30a win for the planet and climate change but it's
- 45:33built on a natural design so it's using those
- 45:36behaviors of those animals to inform us to construct
- 45:40in a different way. So I think we can use that,
- 45:44those sorts of things, but I think we can also
- 45:47use it to manage ourselves and basically our
- 45:52world better, if that makes sense. Yes. Thank
- 45:57you, Tasmin. And just to finalise this exciting
- 46:02interview. Would you like to send a message to
- 46:05the public and all the audience from Latin America
- 46:08and from Australia who is listening to you? I
- 46:13can, I guess. I think be mindful of the little
- 46:18things. Be mindful of the things you don't necessarily
- 46:22like because they're individuals. They have their
- 46:25own unique behaviors and they're pretty important
- 46:28somewhere down the line. If as an individual
- 46:32you think you are important to other people and
- 46:36other things that you're doing, the animals themselves,
- 46:39the individual animals themselves are just as
- 46:42important. So next time you see a rodent or a
- 46:47snake or a spider, don't persecute it just because
- 46:51that's what it is. It's just trying to do its
- 46:53job. It's just trying to be what it is. And it
- 46:56is its own unique individual. Maybe think twice
- 47:00about, the things you may not like yeah that's
- 47:04a good one yeah you see that you mentioned these
- 47:08different behavior traits in invertebrates like
- 47:12these arthropods the spiders and and these animals
- 47:15how far down the the evolutionary tree we can
- 47:19go to and say this this organism have behavioral
- 47:24traits like we can expect protozoans to have
- 47:29behavioral traits or things like this i think
- 47:34even if you look at in organisms which are genetic
- 47:37clones so if we take a bacterium and you clone
- 47:41it they still don't respond exactly the same
- 47:45way i think that they in general will do the
- 47:48same thing but how they do it might vary somewhat
- 47:52and i think that's that's the key is at what
- 47:55level like where do we see those tiny little
- 47:59nuances or variations coming in. So for example,
- 48:04if we take bacteria and we measure how long it
- 48:07takes for them to ooze their way from one side
- 48:11of the petri dish to another, I would say with
- 48:16let's say 95 % confidence that they are not going
- 48:19to move at the same rate. They're not going to
- 48:22move in exactly the same way. And that's individual
- 48:26variation. it's it's a a capacity for being different
- 48:32if that makes sense and so if we can see that
- 48:35like right down in bacteria in archaea i think
- 48:40that the capacity for that sort of level of individuality
- 48:43is very much there that's obviously my own opinion
- 48:47i don't study bacteria so i actually don't know
- 48:49if i'm just talking rubbish um but i i would
- 48:53imagine that if you can measure Very simple behaviors
- 48:56like movement. I'd say that you're not going
- 49:00to see each bacterium doing exactly the same
- 49:04thing. And all a behavior is, very, very simply,
- 49:08all a behavioral behavior is, is a response to
- 49:11a stimulus. That is all it is. So if we can show
- 49:15the animal or the organism is responding to a
- 49:18stimulus, it is behaving. That's how we know
- 49:21plants behave. And classically, people don't.
- 49:24think of a plant as being something that can
- 49:26behave yeah for example how they respond to music
- 49:32or to noises or vibrations or the way that you
- 49:37talk to them there's some really cool studies
- 49:40that shows that or how they connect between them
- 49:43they might say oh it's cool thank you very much
- 49:46that's me for accepting this invitation and for
- 49:50sharing all your amazing knowledge Thank you
- 49:53for having me. It's been a wild journey. Of course.
- 49:58Thank you very much. This podcast is fully self
- 50:01-funded and self -edited by your dedicated host.
- 50:04And we rely on your support to grow. You can
- 50:07help us spread the word by subscribing, sharing,
- 50:11and leaving a review. Find us on YouTube, Spotify,
- 50:15and our official website, www .sciencebehindtheglass
- 50:19.com. Follow us on X, Facebook, and Instagram
- 50:22for the latest updates. A special thanks to our
- 50:26friend Bernardo Aguila for the original music
- 50:28and to our promotions manager Rafael Jordán for
- 50:32his invaluable technical support. Let's keep
- 50:35the conversation going.