Latest / Finding God at Work / 14: The AI Future: "Machines of Loving Grace" or "A Full-Grown Man"?
Transcript
- 0:04(Transcribed by TurboScribe. Go Unlimited to remove this message.) Hi, I'm Chris.
- 0:07This is Finding God at Work.
- 0:14Just a reminder that Finding God at Work
- 0:16isn't just a podcast, it's also an online
- 0:18course.
- 0:19Check it out at findinggodatwork.org.
- 0:27Our current series is A Mysterious Business, bringing
- 0:31ministry and marketplace wisdom together.
- 0:35I want to start with a question that
- 0:36I sometimes use for discussion when I'm leading
- 0:38workshops at churches.
- 0:40What do you think you'll do on a
- 0:43normal workday 10,000 years from now?
- 0:47And the question is meant to make you
- 0:49think a couple different things.
- 0:50One is that you're going to be alive
- 0:5210,000 years from now, unless Jesus tarries
- 0:55for a very long time.
- 0:57In the new heavens and new earth, you
- 0:59will be actively going about your business, which
- 1:03might literally be business.
- 1:06So the second idea is you'll be working,
- 1:08you'll have a job in the new heavens
- 1:11and new earth.
- 1:11Now we think of the new heavens and
- 1:13new earth as a time of rest and
- 1:14a time of celebration and it absolutely is.
- 1:16But it's also a place of work because
- 1:18work is something God gave to us before
- 1:21the fall.
- 1:23And we've talked about this in other episodes.
- 1:25We're not going to do a deep dive
- 1:26into like Genesis and the vision of work
- 1:28here because we've done that in other times
- 1:30and places.
- 1:31But I want to think about that future,
- 1:33right?
- 1:34What is the future that we imagine?
- 1:36And what is the place of humanity in
- 1:38the future?
- 1:38Is there still a place for the dignity
- 1:40of doing work, of exercising creativity and agency
- 1:44in the world?
- 1:45I sure hope so.
- 1:46I think that work will be different, but
- 1:48it won't be gone.
- 1:50And this question of the future often surfaces
- 1:53as we think about artificial intelligence.
- 1:56In fact, some of the leaders of artificial
- 1:58intelligence businesses explicitly invoke this vision of the
- 2:02future in the way that they try and
- 2:05get people to invest in their companies.
- 2:07So one of these leaders is a guy
- 2:09named Dario Amadei.
- 2:10He's the leader of or the CEO of
- 2:12Anthropic.
- 2:13And I actually like Mr. Amadei quite a
- 2:16bit.
- 2:16He's a thoughtful guy.
- 2:18He seems to really care about the potential
- 2:20risks of AI and is asking questions like,
- 2:23what does it mean to be human?
- 2:24But like you would imagine is true for
- 2:27any CEO of an AI company.
- 2:28He's also very techno optimistic.
- 2:31And so I want to draw from an
- 2:33essay that he wrote a couple of years
- 2:35ago now.
- 2:36This was back in October of 2024.
- 2:39Machines of Loving Grace.
- 2:41How AI could transform the world for better.
- 2:44Now, it's a complex article.
- 2:46Again, he's nuanced.
- 2:47He talks about the potential downsides of AI,
- 2:51but also the potential upside.
- 2:52And his vision of the potential upside is
- 2:55really dramatic.
- 2:57Okay, so this is towards the end of
- 2:58the essay.
- 2:59He kind of summarizes what he said.
- 3:01He says that it would be, quote, a
- 3:03world worth fighting for.
- 3:05If all of this really does happen over
- 3:07five to 10 years, the defeat of most
- 3:10diseases, the growth in biological and cognitive freedom,
- 3:14the lifting of billions of people out of
- 3:16poverty to share in the new technologies, a
- 3:18renaissance of liberal democracy and human rights.
- 3:21I suspect everyone watching it will be surprised
- 3:24by the effect it has on them.
- 3:26I don't mean the experience of personally benefiting
- 3:28from all the new technologies, although that will
- 3:31certainly be amazing.
- 3:32I mean the experience of watching a long
- 3:34held set of ideals materialize in front of
- 3:37us all at once.
- 3:39I think many will be literally moved to
- 3:41tears by it.
- 3:42Throughout writing this essay, I noticed an interesting
- 3:45tension.
- 3:45In one sense, the vision laid out here
- 3:47is extremely radical.
- 3:49It is not what almost anyone expects to
- 3:50happen in the next decade and will likely
- 3:52strike many as an absurd fantasy.
- 3:54Some may not even consider it desirable.
- 3:57It embodies values and political choices that not
- 3:59everyone will agree with.
- 4:01But at the same time, there is something
- 4:03blindingly obvious, something overdetermined about it, as if
- 4:07many different attempts to envision a good world
- 4:09inevitably lead roughly here.
- 4:14Okay, do you get what he's saying in
- 4:16that paragraph?
- 4:16He's saying, okay, some people might call what
- 4:18I'm saying an absurd fantasy.
- 4:20But on the other hand, whenever we try
- 4:23and envision life the way it should be,
- 4:24doesn't it kind of look like this?
- 4:27And the this that he's describing is, what
- 4:29if we overcame disease?
- 4:31What if we overcame poverty?
- 4:33What if our governance was fair and just
- 4:36and gave opportunity to lots of different people?
- 4:38He's saying like, if that actually suddenly happened,
- 4:41people would be moved to tears.
- 4:42And I agree, if that actually suddenly happened,
- 4:44people would be moved to tears.
- 4:45And I agree with him that when we
- 4:47try and envision a good world, many of
- 4:48those things are what we envision.
- 4:50Where I disagree is that somehow AI is
- 4:53going to make this happen.
- 4:55That's not to say that AI couldn't be
- 4:56involved in works of justice, in works of
- 4:58beauty, in works of bringing democratic freedoms to
- 5:01new places.
- 5:02AI could be part of the puzzle, sure.
- 5:04But the fundamental human problem is not a
- 5:06technological one.
- 5:08That's why I tend to not be as
- 5:09much of a techno-optimist as many other
- 5:11people.
- 5:12And it's because I read the Bible, right?
- 5:14The Bible says the fundamental human problem is
- 5:17called sin.
- 5:18The fundamental human problem is a matter of
- 5:20the heart.
- 5:21It's not actually a technological limitation.
- 5:23It's the fact that we have this warped
- 5:26interior character.
- 5:27And that does damage to all of our
- 5:30relationships, our relationship with God, our relationship with
- 5:32each other, our relationship with the earth.
- 5:33What we need is someone to rescue us
- 5:37from that and to lead us into a
- 5:39future where somehow we all learn a different
- 5:42way of life.
- 5:44So Amadei here, he is, he's getting so
- 5:47close.
- 5:47He's like, isn't there some sense that this
- 5:49is the way the world ought to be?
- 5:50It's like, yes, but you don't get there
- 5:52through a new breakthrough technology.
- 5:53You get there through the gospel of Jesus
- 5:56Christ.
- 5:56You get there from Jesus who came to
- 6:00bring that kind of life to us, who
- 6:02died and who rose again and who ascended
- 6:04into heaven and who will bring us to
- 6:07the glory that he now enjoys someday.
- 6:09Okay, so I promised in our last episode
- 6:12that I was going to explore more of
- 6:14Pope Leo's encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas, which I will,
- 6:18but I want to start with Ephesians chapter
- 6:22four.
- 6:23So just like last time, we'll start with
- 6:24the Bible, then we'll go to the Pope.
- 6:27And if you didn't get my little disclaimer
- 6:29last time about how I'm not Catholic, but
- 6:31I still love the Pope, you can go
- 6:32back to last episode and listen to that.
- 6:34But there's this vision in Ephesians chapter four,
- 6:36as elsewhere in the New Testament, of Jesus'
- 6:39ascension, as though the ascension says something really
- 6:42important about our future as human beings.
- 6:45So I'm going to read this longer passage
- 6:47starting in verse seven, and then we'll talk
- 6:48about it.
- 6:50But grace was given to each one of
- 6:52us according to the measure of Christ's gift.
- 6:56Therefore it says, when he ascended on high,
- 7:00he led a host of captives and he
- 7:02gave gifts to men.
- 7:04In saying he ascended, what does it mean?
- 7:06That he also descended into the lower regions
- 7:08of the earth.
- 7:09He who descended is the one who also
- 7:11ascended far above all the heavens, that he
- 7:13might fill all things.
- 7:16And he gave the apostles, the prophets, the
- 7:18evangelists, the shepherds and teachers to equip the
- 7:21saints for the work of ministry, for building
- 7:23up the body of Christ, until we all
- 7:26attain to the unity of the faith and
- 7:27the knowledge of the son of God, to
- 7:29mature manhood, to the measure of the stature
- 7:33of the fullness of Christ, so that we
- 7:36may no longer be children tossed to and
- 7:38fro by the waves and carried about by
- 7:40every wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by
- 7:42craftiness and deceitful schemes.
- 7:45Rather, speaking the truth in love, we are
- 7:47to grow up in every way into him
- 7:50who is the head, into Christ, from whom
- 7:53the whole body joined and held together by
- 7:55every joint with which it is equipped, when
- 7:57each part is working properly, makes the body
- 7:59grow so that it builds itself up in
- 8:02love.
- 8:04And that is such a rich passage.
- 8:05That passage has like 25 sermons packed into
- 8:09it.
- 8:09But just to hit the highlights here, it's
- 8:12talking about Jesus' ascension, right?
- 8:14And it also talks about his descent, right?
- 8:15So even in the Apostles' Creed, we say
- 8:17that Jesus descended to the dead.
- 8:19It's kind of referencing this passage where Jesus,
- 8:21he died.
- 8:22And there's a sense in which he descended
- 8:24to the dead, you know, in this almost
- 8:26kind of archetypal descent to the underworld.
- 8:30And then he rises again on the third
- 8:32day.
- 8:32But then eventually he ascends into heaven, the
- 8:34place of glory, right?
- 8:36And so it says he ascended far above
- 8:38all the heavens that he might fill all
- 8:40things.
- 8:41There's a sense that when Jesus ascends to
- 8:43heaven, he is enthroned.
- 8:45He's in the place of full glory.
- 8:46He's filling all things.
- 8:48Heaven and earth now all point and find
- 8:51their fulfillment in him.
- 8:54And then Paul talks about the church.
- 8:56He talks about apostles and prophets and evangelists
- 8:59and shepherds and teachers, right?
- 9:00He's saying that Jesus from his ruling throne
- 9:04in heaven, filling all the heavens and the
- 9:06earth is now working through the church.
- 9:09And what's the point?
- 9:10To equip the saints for the work of
- 9:11ministry.
- 9:12So we're equipped by all these different giftings
- 9:14so that we can do the work of
- 9:16God's ministry in the world, right?
- 9:18For building up the body of Christ, a
- 9:20reference to the church, right?
- 9:22Until what?
- 9:22Until we attain to the unity of the
- 9:25faith and the knowledge of the son of
- 9:27God to mature manhood.
- 9:30Okay, now that's not primarily meant to be
- 9:32like a gendered term in this passage.
- 9:34It's talking about manhood in the sense of
- 9:36humanity.
- 9:37There's even a footnote on my ESV translation
- 9:39here that says that that is more literally
- 9:41in the Greek to a full grown man,
- 9:44right?
- 9:44Paul wants us to imagine that it's like
- 9:46a human body and we're growing like a
- 9:49human body, just like a teenager starting to
- 9:51get whiskers on his chin, right?
- 9:52Starting to get broader shoulders, starting to get
- 9:54some more muscles, right?
- 9:55And eventually it's a full grown man, right?
- 9:58Full muscles, broad shoulders, full beard.
- 10:01I can't still even do the full beard,
- 10:02but I got the goatee, right?
- 10:05And there's a transformation.
- 10:07There's more power.
- 10:08There's more strength.
- 10:09There's something that happens when someone becomes an
- 10:11adult human being, right?
- 10:13And Paul is saying that's what's happening to
- 10:15us as the community of God's people.
- 10:17We are growing up into what he calls
- 10:19the measure of the stature of the fullness
- 10:22of Christ.
- 10:24The life that Jesus is experiencing in heaven,
- 10:27that's the life that we are growing up
- 10:29into as human beings by God's grace.
- 10:33Okay, this is a really exciting vision of
- 10:36the future.
- 10:36And I think it's more robust than Amadei's
- 10:40vision of the future.
- 10:41Amadei's, the title of his essay is Machines
- 10:44of Loving Grace.
- 10:45And again, it's interesting using theological language, right?
- 10:48Machines of Loving Grace.
- 10:49He's actually referencing a poem written by a
- 10:51kind of techno poet named Richard Broutigan, where
- 10:55the last line of the poem is, or
- 10:59last couple lines, that we will be, quote,
- 11:01all watched over by machines of loving grace.
- 11:04There's this sense that we need something transcendent.
- 11:07We need something full of love, full of
- 11:09grace.
- 11:10Absolutely.
- 11:11But is it machines that are going to
- 11:12give us that?
- 11:13Is it machines?
- 11:14No, no, no, no.
- 11:15It's God himself who's the source of that
- 11:17love and that grace.
- 11:19Okay, now we're going to go to Pope
- 11:21Leo's encyclical, and he's going to help us
- 11:22unpack this.
- 11:23So he talks about this as the authentic
- 11:26more than human grace in Christian humanism.
- 11:30Quote, the expression more than human is not
- 11:33an exclusive domain of technological promise.
- 11:36For centuries, the Christian tradition has maintained that
- 11:39human beings are not confined by the boundaries
- 11:41of their own nature, rather they are called
- 11:43to self-transcendence, not through an escape from
- 11:46reality or a contempt for their limitations, but
- 11:50through their fulfillment in love.
- 11:53Faith recognizes an openness toward the beyond, which
- 11:56originates as a gift from God.
- 11:58This transformation is a work of the Holy
- 12:01Spirit.
- 12:03Okay, you get what he's saying?
- 12:04We didn't get fully into it with Amadei,
- 12:06but sometimes in the AI world, right, there's
- 12:08this idea that of transhumanism, that not only
- 12:11will there be machines of loving grace, but
- 12:13that human beings will become more than human
- 12:15because of our relationship with those machines.
- 12:18We'll become more than what we are now.
- 12:20And Pope Leo is saying, well, yeah, we're
- 12:22going to become more than what we are
- 12:23now, but by the grace of God, by
- 12:25the power of the Holy Spirit, as we
- 12:27grow up into the fullness of the stature
- 12:29of Christ, not by machines.
- 12:33Again, and maybe machines will have their place
- 12:36as they already do within human exercise of
- 12:40gracious activity, but they're not going to be
- 12:42the source.
- 12:43God himself is going to be the source.
- 12:45The fundamental problem is not a technological limitation,
- 12:49it's the condition of the heart for which
- 12:51we need God's forgiveness and his power for
- 12:53new life in the Holy Spirit, that promise
- 12:55that we are moving forward into the kind
- 12:57of life Jesus enjoys in heaven now.
- 13:02Okay, back to Pope Leo, drawing from an
- 13:05earlier part of his encyclical, he kind of
- 13:07talks about this idea of human limitation.
- 13:09There was a little bit of that in
- 13:10the earlier quote, now he unpacks a little
- 13:12bit more earlier here.
- 13:14So he says, building the common good means
- 13:16accepting the limits and weakness of humanity without
- 13:20considering them an error to be corrected.
- 13:23Today, the human desire for fullness of life
- 13:25is at risk of being misled by deceitful
- 13:27goals, such as the prospect of a technology
- 13:30that promises to free us from all weakness
- 13:32and models of wellbeing that leave behind entire
- 13:35populations.
- 13:36All too often, we place our hope in
- 13:38unlimited upgrades and forms of progress that exacerbate
- 13:41inequalities and an immediate solutions incapable of healing
- 13:44people's wounds.
- 13:46As a result, while some pursue the illusion
- 13:48of unlimited self-assertion, many are deprived of
- 13:51basic necessities.
- 13:54Okay, what is Pope Leo saying?
- 13:56He's saying we're not going to have some
- 13:59major technological breakthrough that's then suddenly going to
- 14:02free us from our limits as human beings.
- 14:04Our limits are not a problem.
- 14:06God created us to have limits.
- 14:07The body itself is limited, right?
- 14:09I can only be in one place at
- 14:11a time.
- 14:11That's a good thing.
- 14:13God wants me to be present where I
- 14:14am at any given time.
- 14:17Technology increasingly displaces us, right?
- 14:20I'm sitting at a certain desk, but I'm
- 14:22on a Zoom call thinking about some totally
- 14:24different location or in some third cyber location
- 14:27that doesn't really have any correspondence to place
- 14:29in the world.
- 14:31We have limits.
- 14:33That's not a problem.
- 14:34We don't need technology to free us from
- 14:36our limits.
- 14:39And when technology is implemented, it often has
- 14:43an unequal effect.
- 14:45So Amadei, in his vision, he's like, it's
- 14:46going to help with democracy.
- 14:47It's going to help liberate billions of people
- 14:50from poverty.
- 14:51And again, we can hope that it's wisely
- 14:53used to do things like that.
- 14:55But by itself, technology does not tend to
- 14:57do that.
- 14:58New technological innovations follow the patterns of human
- 15:01sin.
- 15:02Just like there's already individual patterns of sin
- 15:04and cultural and social patterns of sin.
- 15:06You introduce a new technology and those all
- 15:08get amplified too.
- 15:09So that's why there's often inequality when these
- 15:12technological breakthroughs happen.
- 15:14So even as some people have access to
- 15:16all of these new ways of being, right,
- 15:18these new powers, so to speak, it leaves
- 15:21other people behind.
- 15:22And Pope Leo says, that's not good.
- 15:24That's not good.
- 15:24We shouldn't be focused on trying to upgrade
- 15:26humanity.
- 15:27We should be focused on making sure that
- 15:29every human being can eat three square meals
- 15:32a day.
- 15:33We should be focused on how every human
- 15:34being can get clean water.
- 15:35We should be focused on helping human beings
- 15:37be human, not on some ephemeral goal of
- 15:42transhumanism.
- 15:43The true transhumanism, the true more than humanity
- 15:46is us sharing in God's life through Jesus
- 15:49Christ.
- 15:50That's what we should focus on.
- 15:52And that, interestingly, leads us into working for
- 15:56equality, working for the vulnerable, slowing down to
- 15:58keep pace with people who might get left
- 15:59behind.
- 16:01Okay, so Paul has this vision in Ephesians
- 16:05of us ascending to where Jesus is, that
- 16:08we're growing up into a mature manhood, a
- 16:12full-grown man.
- 16:13And Pope Leo is saying that that's the
- 16:15true transhumanism.
- 16:16That's what it means for us to be
- 16:17more than human.
- 16:19And we have to be careful about thinking
- 16:21that technology, machines are somehow going to do
- 16:25that for us because God is the source
- 16:26of that life.
- 16:27And we need to have the humility to
- 16:30let God work out his life in us
- 16:33in all the slow ways that that requires
- 16:35for us to realize who we're meant to
- 16:38become.
- 16:40But now I want to come back to
- 16:41the question I started with.
- 16:42What will you be doing for work 10
- 16:44,000 years from now?
- 16:46Because another aspect of this is the question
- 16:49of becoming fully mature, becoming more like Jesus,
- 16:55becoming more like that ascended into heaven life.
- 16:57What does that mean for work?
- 16:59Well, work is part of that life.
- 17:02We are meant to be workers.
- 17:04We are meant to exercise creativity and agency
- 17:06in the real world.
- 17:07In God's new heavens and new earth, we
- 17:09will still have the capacity to do that.
- 17:11Part of growing up into humanity, into what
- 17:14humanity was truly meant to be, is learning
- 17:16to work in true humanity, bringing humanness to
- 17:21our work and letting work become what work
- 17:24was meant to be.
- 17:25Work that reflects the creativity and agency of
- 17:28human beings.
- 17:31So when we think about adapting our work
- 17:36in the context of AI, when we think
- 17:40about bringing AI into our work, the church
- 17:44has a lot to teach the business world
- 17:46because the church knows what it means to
- 17:47be human.
- 17:49And so when we're applying AI, we shouldn't
- 17:51just be asking the question, oh, how do
- 17:52we make it more efficient?
- 17:54Or, oh, how do we make it more
- 17:55profitable?
- 17:56But how do we make it more human?
- 17:59How do we help this work serve human
- 18:03needs?
- 18:04And how do we bring human creativity and
- 18:06agency into the center of this work?
- 18:09Because that's where work is going long term.
- 18:11And so we don't want to get in
- 18:12the way of what God is doing with
- 18:13work.
- 18:13We want however we use technology, including AI,
- 18:16to serve that kind of human-centric vision
- 18:19of work.
- 18:22Okay, I get that this was a little
- 18:24bit abstract.
- 18:24We'll hopefully break this down in future episodes
- 18:26in a little bit more of a pragmatic
- 18:28way.
- 18:29But I want to end by just giving
- 18:30a kind of a question for reflection.
- 18:32This comes from an author named Stephen Garber.
- 18:34And he's got a book called Hints of
- 18:37Hope that's recently come out.
- 18:39And it's a question he's asked before too.
- 18:40And that's, what is the business of business?
- 18:43What is the business of business?
- 18:45What is business really for?
- 18:47And so whenever you're kind of making a
- 18:49tough decision at work, whether it's like, do
- 18:51we use AI for this or not?
- 18:53Do we hire for this position or not?
- 18:55Do we pursue this project or not?
- 18:57This can be a kind of helpful heuristic,
- 18:59a helpful shortcut question.
- 19:00What is the business of business?
- 19:01What is the real purpose of our business?
- 19:04It's not just to make money.
- 19:06It has to be more than that.
- 19:09It has to be serving humanity created in
- 19:13the image of God, drawing on the resources
- 19:16of humanity for creativity, for agency, for working
- 19:20God's world.
- 19:21So that can be just a question that
- 19:23helps guide those decisions.
- 19:24What is the business of business?
- 19:26What is the business of our business?
- 19:27Why are we really here?
- 19:29And are we doing our business in a
- 19:31way that reflects that and honors that every
- 19:33step of the way?
- 19:36Lord Jesus, thank you that you are wise,
- 19:39that even when these questions can be complicated
- 19:42and hard to grapple with, that you help
- 19:45us.
- 19:46We pray that you would help us to
- 19:47grow up into mature manhood, into a full
- 19:50-grown man, into your ascended life, that that
- 19:54would be the vision of the future that
- 19:55motivates us, and that we would be willing
- 19:57to live with our limitations and our real
- 20:00needs and honoring the real glory of your
- 20:04image in every human being around us.
- 20:06In the meantime, Jesus, do your work in
- 20:08us as we do our work with you.
- 20:15Thanks for listening.
- 20:17Finding God at Work is a production of
- 20:19Mission Central, a ministry based in Aurora, Illinois,
- 20:22dedicated to forming Christians for mission in everyday
- 20:24life.
- 20:25You can subscribe to the podcast wherever you
- 20:27listen to this episode to get 10 minutes
- 20:29of teaching on faith and work every Thursday.
- 20:32To get resources to go deeper with each
- 20:34podcast series, read our blog, and get info
- 20:36about upcoming courses on faith in the workplace,
- 20:39go to our website missioncentral.church.