Latest / The Broadcast with Amanda, Shandy, and Colleen / Ep. 7.41 "Are You There, Audience? It's Us, The Broadcast."
Transcript
- 0:04Maybe bites broadcast. Are you there, audience, it's us the broadcast with
- 0:23a man of Shandy and Colleen. My name is Colleen, My name is
- 0:27Amanda Shandy. Welcome to the show, everybody. This is season seven,
- 0:31episode forty one, Episode number three hundred and eleven. Wow, crazy,
- 0:37Yeah, here we are here, we are here. We are for maybe
- 0:40one of the most um, I don't know, the one of the episodes
- 0:45that I'm the most excited about. I am I'm I remember when it was
- 0:49like January and we were like, in May, we're going to talk about
- 0:53this movie. And now the first time when I first saw that it was
- 0:56a thing, and I was like, so and to do little numbers thing
- 1:02three eleven almost three twelve. Oh my name is Margaret. Oh my god,
- 1:12that's so great number. It was all meant to be, This was
- 1:15all meant to be. There. We are, Oh my god, very
- 1:19very excited to talk about this movie. Um. And book. I waited
- 1:23until the last minute, of course, but I was always going to wait
- 1:26to the last minute. I just got very very lucky that I was able
- 1:30to see it yesterday afternoon and then I read the book this morning. Oh
- 1:36my god. Well, I stayed up late last night. Actually, I
- 1:40stayed up till like midnight setting posts for Geek Dead Life to go up in
- 1:45the morning so I would have the time the content would go up prescheduled,
- 1:49and I would have I was like, all right, Colling, you have
- 1:52two hours and you have to read the funk out of this book that it's
- 1:57take five days. I got a lot of it done well. I've also
- 2:00been reading a lot lately, like I try to make Sundays my reading days,
- 2:05so I just didn't so I feel like I've gotten quicker at reading.
- 2:08Um. But anyway, I got most of it done, and then I
- 2:13had at one point to stop to go to Costco to get gas because now
- 2:17I do that during the week when they're closed people, And I was like,
- 2:22you know what, Colling, You've got like twenty twenty twenty five pages
- 2:24left. I'm sure you can knock this out in the gas line. Nice
- 2:30also very like Apropos, It's like, what is this nineteen seventy on the
- 2:36Kime. I was talking to my grandma when I pore things changed the more
- 2:43they say the same. I was talking to my grandma when I pulled up,
- 2:47and I was like, okay, grandma. Well, I'm actually here
- 2:50to get gas at Costco. It's thirty cents cheaper than it was a week
- 2:53ago. Also, I've got to go read a book now that i'm parked.
- 2:57She was like what, and I was like, don't worry about it.
- 3:00No, not a girl gets a period. It's fine. Oh,
- 3:07I'm sure my grandma was a teacher's aide for like thirty years. I'm sure
- 3:10she you know, in the like, Yes, I'm sure she is aware
- 3:15of this book if have not read it multiple times exactly, she has read.
- 3:19Um, I know she's read the Summer Sister's book. I know she's
- 3:22read Oh I love that book because she had she had that out on her
- 3:27like like coffee table stuff. Um, you know, around the time when
- 3:31it came out for a long time, and I've seen her read it,
- 3:34so I know she's definitely ready the book is pretty sure. Yeah, that
- 3:39book. I think that's awesome that your grandma just put it right out there
- 3:43on the coffee table. Yeah. Well, you know at me folk,
- 3:46it's Judy Bloom. I'm assuming she loved it. I don't know though,
- 3:53but I know I know she had it though, so I know she's read
- 3:55it. I'm sure she's read other books. I need other Judy Bloom books.
- 3:59I'm sure what year did I actually meant to look up in nineteen seventy
- 4:04was it was first printed? Yes? Okay, because I know I've been
- 4:09into I like to read the copyright. I'm just curious. Yeah. No,
- 4:13And it's just wild because I mean, thinking about what's happened with abortion
- 4:18in that time. It's kind of with flashtastic. But it's like, I
- 4:25think this this book, like it's it's still fucking relevant. Well, the
- 4:30most amazing thing it does not feel there's one thing that's changed in the book
- 4:35that I can remember from the time that I read it as a kid.
- 4:39But other than that, like it is still what's the thing? What's the
- 4:43thing that you were thinking of? Because I wonder is the thing I'm thinking
- 4:46of? Okay, So I remember and again this is my memories as a
- 4:48kid. I can't, for the life of me remember I think I wrote
- 4:53belt yes, okay before I got my period. Yes, And I remember
- 4:59the belts and our remember like, okay, so there's these like belts that
- 5:01you have. There's this whole like get up that you have to wear when
- 5:03you get your period. And then when I got my period, it was
- 5:06so much easier, like you just put a pad in your underwear. And
- 5:11I remember being like, what the fuck. And then when I was older,
- 5:14being like, oh, well that's because it was the fucking nineteen seventies.
- 5:17Ship's changed, so um yeah, I mean yeah, let me so
- 5:26in. I have vivid memories of this too, from when I first read
- 5:30it in middle school or whatever year it was where they actually talked about practicing
- 5:35with the like menstrual belts who it was like a whole thing. And I
- 5:41when when it wasn't in because I have this edition, which is the one
- 5:44that's in the documentary, actually watched the study Boom Forever very well. I
- 5:48pink, Oh, oh my god, it's it's really nice. It's kind
- 5:53of leather bound, and yeah, the pages are like really thick and silky.
- 5:58The pages of mine are so thick too. I was so thrown off
- 6:00multiple times today look Greek flipping pages. I kept like thinking I was had
- 6:04like multiple pages at once. Yeah, it's got like a real diary like
- 6:09most Ye, it's very nice and mine sucking in between her because I know
- 6:14it's not the original version that was published because I do remember the belt and
- 6:17it's not in here, but I probably got this like fifteen is years ago,
- 6:23and it's it's just like a normal paperback. Yes, yeah, I
- 6:26alway right on yours because this is, um, this is a twenty fourteen
- 6:30reprint it yeah, let me see twenty fourteen. Oh yeah, that's when
- 6:34the updated copyright. Let me double check that actually before I just spout April
- 6:40twenty fourteen. Yes, yeah, okay, so mine two. Mine's July
- 6:45in nineteen eighty six. So then I'm which is weird because I certainly read
- 6:48it before nineteen eighty six after sorry, I was reading. I was reading
- 6:56books at three years old. But I guess my library I must have had,
- 7:00like maybe the og the copy that I had wasn't so they in the
- 7:04documentary they showed the original cover and that's not the one I had where she's
- 7:10like, I think, like it's a cartoon figure and she's blonde. I
- 7:13think that's what it was. I had the one that must have been after
- 7:15that, and it's where it was very babysitters Club style where she's like sitting
- 7:20there with her mom in the front. I think, I know, it's
- 7:24like this kind of thing going on No, I mean not this cover,
- 7:28but like similar style. Yeah, that's that's some sweet, sweet early nineties
- 7:32geared towards a suburban three team girls for listeners at home. I'm showing just
- 7:42as long as We're Together, which was all one of my other favorite books
- 7:46by her. And yeah, when you said Colin, when you said baby
- 7:48sort of club, that made me think, I feel like this has a
- 7:51baby sort of club vibe to it on this cover. But this one is
- 7:55from nineteen no copyright nineteen eighty six. This one was printed in nineteen eighty
- 7:59four, so yeah, nineteen nineties. Okay, let me go with that
- 8:03one. I loved the ship out of there. There's so many Judy Bloom
- 8:05books, and I think there's like a lot that I haven't actually read,
- 8:09but there's a few that I was like obsessed with, And this one I
- 8:11used to read like every year. I fucking love it. I just texted
- 8:16you guys the original cover. That's not the one I had, but that's
- 8:20the one that I believe is the original cover. Okay, I don't think
- 8:24I'm gonna remember. That's very pretty. I've never seen that either, and
- 8:30Shannon, until I saw it on the documentary I did not remember which one
- 8:35I had. I still don't because I didn't have a copy when I was
- 8:37a kid. I just checked it out of the library. So I got
- 8:43I remember the cover of Forever that I have, which is not this cover
- 8:46you have Forever. I don't have Forever. I had very different Judy Bloom
- 8:52awareness levels. I just sent you the I guess it's the eighty six Vinngage
- 8:58book, which I don't know. That's not with chanties. Look, that
- 9:03does look very um babysit. It looks like, yeah, that's the artist.
- 9:11Yes, it must be the same must which they recently. I sent
- 9:16you, guys the article I think, and I asked you to put in
- 9:18the outline for something maybe or yes, this sounds fair familiar where they did
- 9:22an interview with the artist of the Babysitters Club books. Oh my gosh,
- 9:28how did I miss this? I did not. I'm sorry, not a
- 9:31problem at all. I just talked about it. So um. But yeah,
- 9:37there's a ton of book covers. I gotta go. I gotta find
- 9:41the one at my parents house. I know it's there. Um anyway,
- 9:43Okay, so uh funny we all have different versions of the book cover.
- 9:50But yes, okay, so the I and I actually was thinking about this
- 9:54when they did not in the book, because I was like, when would
- 9:58they have even taken that out? And why would they have taken that out?
- 10:01Um, because it doesn't make sense to readers anymore. Like I think,
- 10:05I do think that we should leave Margaret in the seventies. But I'm
- 10:09okay with that one change. Yeah, I guess so. I just I
- 10:11couldn't remember then if it was a different book involving periods that I read and
- 10:18associated. Um, but okay, the whole section border or so construation books,
- 10:24right, But no, I can I I co sign that, like
- 10:28I specifically, so I as soon as you said one change, I was
- 10:33like, oh my god, that has to be it. Yeah. So
- 10:35I I watched the whole documentary, which we don't you know. I'll just
- 10:41I have like a start left. It's so good. I think you started.
- 10:45I like almost started crying. It's like I had. I got very
- 10:48emotionally beginning too, especially when she's talking about when she finally got published all
- 10:52the rejection and how she made her angrier to keep going. And I was
- 10:58like inspired. I was like, oh my god, I have this documentary
- 11:01makes you want to go out and write a book that's gonna get banned totally.
- 11:07Yeah, but like, okay, there is a there's a one of
- 11:09the authors. So they interview a bunch of like childhood friends and and current
- 11:13authors of YA fiction. And one of them says that, um, you
- 11:20know some of the things in the books, you know, they bring up
- 11:22at the end, like how some of it stated like all the moms are
- 11:24stay at home moms, um, and that wouldn't be today, and you
- 11:28know, uh, justin what's his face, he says, you know,
- 11:33her books, she didn't write them to be timeless. She wrote them to
- 11:35be timely, and in being timely, they actually ended up becoming timeless.
- 11:41And I loved that. Wow, that really really profound. Yeah, I
- 11:48loved it. I loved it so much. Ye. So yeah, but
- 11:54I know you're a very busy person, Amanda. But if you I listened,
- 11:56I did. I was clean, I was cleaning my hire downstairs at
- 12:01my house, and then I was like trying to shower the kids and stuff,
- 12:05and I headed in headphones, so I listened to a lot of it
- 12:07where I'm sure I missed visuals, but I you know, I wasn't able
- 12:11to stare at. The audio part is way more important, exactly. Yeah,
- 12:16but it's it's great. It's a great document. It's called Judy Bloom
- 12:18Forever and it's on Amazon Prime perfect, right, Yeah, I will check
- 12:24it out. Yeah ninety Okay, So six. I know Colleen and I
- 12:28both read this as adolescents and Amanda didn't. So I want to know am
- 12:33Yes, I want to hear what you're want to say, and then and
- 12:35I will talk about the kid versus adult perspective from the comparison. So what
- 12:41did you think reading it the book? And then we'll talk about the movie
- 12:43after the book though? Okay, So in true Amanda style, like couldn't
- 12:50get the assignment done in the correct order she finished reading it. And I've
- 12:54only been recording for fourteen So I think this like utterly worked to my favor,
- 12:58and I think this might be the way to go into movies based on
- 13:03books totally in the future. I read, well, I read half the
- 13:09book the movie finished the book. I did actually just because of timing,
- 13:16but I had read it before, so it was not quite the same thing.
- 13:18So what do you think? So, I think when you think about
- 13:20it that way, it'll well, I mean, like I think I sort
- 13:26of come into it sort of knowing that we were doing this is not like
- 13:30an assignment for this conversation, but like as background for this conversation, sort
- 13:35of coming into it with sort of that mindset and sort of thinking about it
- 13:39and sort of a grander scale. It was really interesting to go about it
- 13:48that way because it sort of you had enough context going into the movie that
- 13:50I had the basic setup and I could start to see like immediately where they
- 13:58were taking the story, where they were staying like true to the cannon of
- 14:01the book, and where they were modernizing it, and where they were playing
- 14:05and adapting it to the different medium, which was like sort of fun.
- 14:09But I was still rooted in like a knew enough of the story to pick
- 14:13up on all that nuance, and then it was sort of fun. At
- 14:16like about twenty minutes in, it was like, oh, we're now officially
- 14:20passed where I read, and now we're like just like off into a movie
- 14:24and I can just like enjoy it as a movie because I know I've ever
- 14:28know what's going to happen, right, And so then with all that information
- 14:33in mind, coming back to the book, it was really fun to see
- 14:37to see that fully realized of like where they took the story for the movie
- 14:41and I sort of walked away was sort of a few things, so like
- 14:45sort of top line, just like as a you know, podcaster having a
- 14:52conversation about this story. I think the movie adaptation was like a really smart
- 15:03adaptation. They knew their audience, they knew exactly who was going to want
- 15:07to come and see this movie, and they thought and they made something that
- 15:11they thought that that audience was going to enjoy and appreciate. I didn't have
- 15:15any plaints about anything that was different, so that I know, we'll talk
- 15:20more about that when we talk about the movie. But I there were parts
- 15:24of the movie that because I wanted to read the book first and then the
- 15:26movie, but just didn't work out that way. But there were definitely parts
- 15:30of the movie that I think we're really smart plot devices to do, right.
- 15:37So I think, you know, it's like in general, when you're
- 15:39adapting from one medium to another, like you just have to make certain story
- 15:45changes to adjust for the medium. So like adjust from a visual medium where
- 15:50you're sort of losing the you know, the writer narrator perspective. There's certain
- 15:58things you just have to switch to dialogue so that you get that information into
- 16:02the story and like so that I think was all really smart, but just
- 16:04the sort of choices they made and sort of not quite color blind casting,
- 16:08but just being a little mindful of like how they could be a little more
- 16:15diverse without like being um performative about it. And you know, I think
- 16:19anytime you call it blind cast, like it is performative. It is just
- 16:22like okay for a modern audience, like we want to bring in some diversity.
- 16:26But I think there was clearly a bit of see the Babysitters Club actation.
- 16:30Yeah, Like I think there was a general like thought and like real
- 16:34intention between like how I thought about that. I think a lot of change
- 16:40story around. Yeah, like it just it sort of made it fun.
- 16:44And then to go back and read the rest of the book and sort of
- 16:45see like the big plot things that they sort of shifted, it's like okay,
- 16:49yeah, like you know, I understand, I understand why they did
- 16:52that, and yeah, but I think it's also coming into it, like
- 16:56I am not emotionally attached the story, so it's like I can sort of
- 17:00see it, you know, and more like I don't know the word I'm
- 17:06looking for, but like you know, I'm not so attached to the original
- 17:11text that is sort of like oh, that's a fun choice to like do
- 17:14it that way, or like to bring the grandma in, you know,
- 17:17to have both granmas, like I thought with the like the conflict, and
- 17:22to sort of make the Nancy character more of like a big bed like oh
- 17:27that like that helps the drama and like it, like it's just clever.
- 17:32But and then the other side of that, like big reactions for me and
- 17:36the sort of just like personal like me as a grown ass woman the wing
- 17:41to see this movie about this book that is made for preteen girls. It's
- 17:47like I related to the mother and I loved how they made her a bigger
- 17:51character, which I think is like intentional knowing your audience and knowing who was
- 17:56coming to see this movie and like making that more of a best character.
- 18:00But like I did feel myself being much more relating to that character because like
- 18:06that's my entry point. We're the same age as from at this stage in
- 18:11my life, like I am the mother of a daughter. I'm going to
- 18:14be there someday, and it's just like, man, I mean I think
- 18:18this all the time. But just like I'm going to be more like Rachel
- 18:19mcgauns would like that. So what do you think though of the book itself?
- 18:27Can you understand why, like you know, all of us middle schoolers
- 18:32back then, we're like, oh my god, we love this book.
- 18:34I think so. I mean again, like you know, I'm so far
- 18:38removed from from that, Like so it is kind of hard to sort of
- 18:42rewind the clock and put yourself back into that time, Like how would how
- 18:48would me as like an eleven year old I was, I was brought keep
- 18:52this book, you know, I was anything like that? Yeah, And
- 18:56I think, you know, I think I really did read this before I
- 19:00got my first period, which was also before I became an atheist, And
- 19:04so like the whole thing of like questioning God was like, holy fucking shit,
- 19:10sort of like mind blowing that a kid could do that, and also
- 19:15that I was in a book. It's crazy. They talk a lot in
- 19:18the documentary about how her books broke barriers and really changed the way why a
- 19:26fiction was written, including the book Forever, which was like she specifically wrote
- 19:33that book because books at the time that she was writing that her daughter was
- 19:37reading them when she was you know, sixteen seventeen, eighteen years old books
- 19:41at that time, if a girl had sex, it always automatically either resulted
- 19:47in her being shamed or regretting it, or getting pregnant and you know,
- 19:52needing to get married or needing a legal as out a portion right, so
- 19:57like dying. Her the daughter came to her one day and she said she
- 20:02used to, like, you know, let her her daughter, her kids
- 20:06read the drafts of the books, so they like, you know, there
- 20:07was never any secrets. There was never ether like we don't know what mommy's
- 20:11writing about. Like they they always knew her mom actually because she had she
- 20:17would type or handwrite things and her or she would type them and then like
- 20:21she would give them to people to make the notes. And her mom was
- 20:23a really good typer, so her mom would type up the final drafts to
- 20:27send out, which which is fascinating certain books talks about masturbation. And she
- 20:36said that her she had a closer relationship with her father growing up. Her
- 20:40mom was very much like, we don't talk about emotions, we don't talk
- 20:44about private things. We don't do that. So she's like, I can't
- 20:47believe I had my mom read them and she never once ever made a comment
- 20:51to me, you know, because to me, the thing that was surprising
- 20:53about Deanie, even more so honestly than the masturbation, is the relationship between
- 20:59the mother and the daughter. And how like, wouldn't you you know,
- 21:03I could like somebody like Judi Boom like writing that might worry that her own
- 21:08mother would take that as a criticism of how she raised her, and you
- 21:12know, like that that's what her mother never said a word. Yeah,
- 21:15which I think it's great. I think it's crazy and great, but you
- 21:19know, because that's we're aspire to be as parents, somebody that our kids
- 21:22trusted enough to Yeah, but no, okay, So obviously this book is
- 21:29is such a first of its kind because they're oh oh so just to finish
- 21:32the forever thing is that her daughter came to her and was like, hey,
- 21:36mom, how do you feel about writing a book where people where teenagers
- 21:40do it and they don't end up regretting it or having bad consequences where it
- 21:45actually ends up well for them. And that's why she wrote that book,
- 21:49because forever, if people my age a book where sex's portrayed is good,
- 21:56like you got it heard of that either were what was I was not reading
- 22:00books. I remember going to the library and because I like, I read
- 22:06quite a few Judy Bloom books, like you know, at different stages in
- 22:10my life. Yeah, and again I was like stuck on just as long
- 22:14as we're together and the sort of sequel here see Rachel Robinson for a really
- 22:18long time, like I've read them and reread them, and then somehow at
- 22:22the library again, I like fell upon Forever and took it home and was
- 22:26like, really fucking because they think there's like explicit like and yes, I've
- 22:32never read an Yeah, never read anything like it. It's kind of like
- 22:37when I was seventeen or eighteen and went to em and I was like,
- 22:41oh, that's the first time I've seen that on screen. It's very similar.
- 22:49But she's a little bit younger with Judy Bloom. And she was like
- 22:52and she you know, she's like a trusted She's like like, you know,
- 22:56I've been been through some stuff with her, like you yeah, no,
- 23:00but it's it's great. So this though, like she had said,
- 23:06and this is one of the quotes from the documentary which I think leads into
- 23:11this discussion. It was very good for our discussion. Is she said,
- 23:14you know, it's good to know, no matter how old you are,
- 23:17that other people feel the same way. And I have always That's like why
- 23:22I think sometimes on podcasts, you know, I'm always more open and Tmie
- 23:27is. I've always had that also kind of like had that philosophy where it's
- 23:33like, I don't know, if you're I'm feeling it, somebody else out
- 23:36there is feeling it too, So let's all feel it together. Yeah,
- 23:40we're not all so neat so unique that right, and someone else out there
- 23:45that's going through what you're going through in some capacity. And also at the
- 23:49time that her books came out, a lot of parents were or moms were
- 23:53still very much in like they were very religious. They were not as open
- 23:59about out talking about periods and sex or maybe it's just I don't know,
- 24:03maybe maybe just some parents weren't. But like for the people who grew up
- 24:07with parents who you know, were uncomfortable broaching those subjects, or they grew
- 24:12up uncomfortable broaching those subjects with their parents, which I was always uncomfortable about
- 24:18that kind of stuff. Not my sister, though, I think I've told
- 24:19this story where my mom was taking my middle sister Caitlyn to dance class,
- 24:23and Caitlin just was she was in like fifth grade, and she just started
- 24:26peppering her with questions about boyfriends and sex and this and that, And my
- 24:33mom was like, I almost crushed the fucking car because, like I was
- 24:41not expecting that because her older one was very much not one to talk about
- 24:47that kind of stuff or to feel comfortable talking about the good of stuff.
- 24:52So you know, be careful what you wish were I guess, but you
- 24:56know, just even because even nowadays, like you know, we're kind of
- 25:00cycles and we can go back to that, but like it's important for kids
- 25:03to have things like that because they learn through they learned from peers, they
- 25:08learned through literature. They they seek out things that they want to know because
- 25:14it's natural to be curious about it. Kind of like when I was reading
- 25:18the Sweet Valley High books, that stuff was. I was reading that stuff
- 25:21when I was in like seventh grade, and a lot of that stuff was
- 25:23well over my maturity level. Like I learned what rape was because Lila fer
- 25:29Fowler got raped. Yeah, don't go home. Yeah, I mean I
- 25:36think I read the like the the preteen version, like because there's what Sweet
- 25:40Valley, Sweet Valley, Sweet Valley Valley Twins. Yeah, there was like
- 25:45yes, that was the Unicorning Club one, right, but there's like Valley
- 25:49Twins, yes, yeah, and then there were Sweet Valley High. I
- 25:52was like saying where there was like goose Bumps and Fierce Street. That was
- 25:56like I think that was more where I was. I think Baby's babysitters,
- 25:59little sister like and yeah, like they all they all had different levels of
- 26:03maturity. And then Sweet Valley University like uh, I had like almost give
- 26:10it up. I have ooks right now, but no peoples that talked about
- 26:18stuff program but like even some Valley University when I was older in reading those
- 26:22that talked about stuff like um unprotected sex and you know, needing abortion.
- 26:27Maybe one of them either needed an abortion or it was like like Rizzo and
- 26:32Greece where you're like, why is she's so concerned that she's late? Like
- 26:37no, you know what I mean, So like I don't know, I
- 26:40feel like this kind of stuff is important to be out there. And yes,
- 26:44well the rap rape book. My mom actually did look at that one.
- 26:49And I don't know if she was raped or he like attended to rape
- 26:52her, but like my mom actually did look through that one was like,
- 26:56I would feel comfortable if you could maybe wait until you were a little older
- 26:59to read this book. So then I would just go to the library and
- 27:02I would read the book in the library in between the shelves, nice inside
- 27:08of a bigger book. And I guess, but anyway, are you there?
- 27:14Got well? And I think, like it's important for you know,
- 27:18kids whose parents don't explain these things. But even if your parents do,
- 27:22like to be able, you know, it's like about representation and seeing yourself
- 27:26represented and like what you're saying of, like just to be able to relate
- 27:30to another kid, even if it's a you know, fictitious kid, to
- 27:33be like, okay, you know, because I think you know, your
- 27:37mom telling you what it was like when she got her period. It's great,
- 27:41but maybe different than what it's like if your friend is telling you,
- 27:45yes, exactly, this is what this is what happened to me, and
- 27:49this is how it happened. Yeah, yeah, it's so a man.
- 27:53You were mentioning the mom in the movie before, but I as one of
- 27:59the key, big, key differences I had reading it this time around was
- 28:03I read the mom in a totally different light. I remember the mom in
- 28:10my ten year old, twelve year old brain being different like I just maybe
- 28:15I just applied because when you know, you apply your own life experiences to
- 28:18things, maybe I applied my own mom's like tone or personality or whatever to
- 28:23that mom, where now I had a much just different like way. I
- 28:29was like, Oh, the mom is not in it that much. She's
- 28:32you know, she is harmless. She's not just you know, a mom,
- 28:33you know what I mean, not harmless, but like she's a minor
- 28:37character. I remember the mom being a much bigger character in the book when
- 28:41I was younger, where she's clearly not as big of a character in the
- 28:44actual book. Now that I think that's kind of the brilliant I mean,
- 28:48there's also brilliant parts of the writing, but I think that's one of the
- 28:52brilliant parts of the structure of the book is that like Judy Bloom just such
- 28:56a good job of just getting into the pre teen mindset that like, yeah,
- 29:00preteen girl wouldn't be that like aware of like her parents' personality, Like
- 29:07you know, they're your parents, they're you know, they're mom, they're
- 29:10letting make a dinner, and they're there and they're just you know them,
- 29:14and then occasionally for granted, because like they're you know, like if you
- 29:18have a great family structure, you take your parents for granted, like and
- 29:22then and you get and you get like embarrassed when you have to ask if
- 29:26you can go by oh I remember yea. So like I like all the
- 29:33characters so like one note because then it's like the reader can apply like their
- 29:37own relationship to their parent, parental figure to it. So it's like that
- 29:41relationship morse like, yeah, I imagine as you read it in different stages
- 29:45of your life and can kind of shade in what she the outline she drew
- 29:49for you. Yeah, if that makes sense. Yeah. I always kind
- 29:52of thought Nancy was like, you know, a snobby kind of whatever,
- 30:00But I did like that in the end of the movie they ended up she
- 30:03and Jane Janey ended up being friends with Laura. I liked that too.
- 30:11I was kind of bumped when that wasn't in the book. I was like,
- 30:12oh, that felt really authentic to the story. Like I couldn't remember
- 30:15if it was in the book or not. Yeah, you know what,
- 30:18I kind of feel like, So I enjoyed it in the book, I
- 30:22thought that was a really fun change. Sorry in the movie. Um yeah,
- 30:26And I feel like especially like sort of like revisiting some of je Bloom's
- 30:30other stuff in what I did see of the documentary, it's sort of like
- 30:36to me, it's like that kind of makes sense because that's sort of although
- 30:41I like it, I like what they did with the movie, but it
- 30:42sort of ties it up in a with a nicer bow and gives some resolution
- 30:47to the whole conflict, you know, with her, And that is very
- 30:52like movie and in Judy Boom's books, sometimes things don't resolve and that's kind
- 30:59of life sometimes times. So I can I can appreciate both. That's a
- 31:03good point. That's a really good point when they talk about that in the
- 31:07documentary too. Like the book Blubber, which I'm really sure I read,
- 31:11but I don't really remember it to anywhere. I don't think I read it,
- 31:15but I do actually like remember it being a yeah it existed for anybody
- 31:19that isn't familiar. The plot of the book is a girl who gets bullied
- 31:23over her weight. It doesn't have a happy ending because in the end,
- 31:27doesn't she She ends up kind of becoming a bit of a bully herself,
- 31:32and the it left a lot of people feeling a little like kids feeling unnerved
- 31:36because the moralist story it wasn't like, you know, she stood up to
- 31:40her bullies and then everyone was nice to her. The morals story was don't
- 31:42be a dickhead to people like and don't like you know, just and don't
- 31:48be an innocent bystanderd because even the people that are there laughing at the bullies,
- 31:52you're just as You're just as bad even you're not saying anything. So
- 31:55you know, kind of had a really brilliant bloom though too is not sort
- 32:00of like hit you over the head with like and now we're at the part
- 32:04of the book with the moral ye know, which is like American usually and
- 32:08yeah, yeah that's real. You know. Teenage adolescence is messy, it
- 32:14is, and you do them in so many ways literally figuratively, like all
- 32:19the way. Yeah they can they can handle nuance. As adults, we
- 32:23should be able to handle nuance, you know. We it's like less and
- 32:27less in our society, but like, that's life, and kids can also
- 32:30handle that and come to their own conclusions, which I really appreciate. Yeah
- 32:36I do. She treated she treated kids with the same respect she would treat
- 32:40adult writers. Huh yeah, yeah, yeah. I was very much brought
- 32:45back during the movie and the book to how I felt at the time period
- 32:50in which I did read that book, Like I was embarrassed to get a
- 32:53bra. I didn't want to wear a bra. I mean, once I
- 32:58started wearing bras, I started my life long tradition of taking it off as
- 33:00soon as I got home. I didn't knew that. For a very long
- 33:05time, I was fine with I was fine with wearing a bra. I
- 33:07specifically remember when my boobs started growing just a little bit, like you know
- 33:13when you just have like that like hard spot, like right in your nipple.
- 33:16Yeah, I specifically remember feeling that for the first time. I don't
- 33:22I remember because it was like all of a sudden, I was like,
- 33:24what is this kind of hurts? And yeah, like the period stuff.
- 33:30Yeah, I didn't mind the bra, but the periods of and I remember
- 33:35like the all the anxiety of like when are you gonna get your first period?
- 33:38You know, you like go to middle school and it's like what if
- 33:40you're at school, like what you know, so many things that could happen.
- 33:45I have like the best first period possible because I was. It took
- 33:50me like Margaret did. Kind of yeah, actually very much the same,
- 33:54um well, very similar. In any case, I was at home sick
- 33:59that day, and my mom was at home with me, so we were
- 34:01the only two people at home. And now with my adult brain, I'm
- 34:05like, oh, I wasn't sick. I had pims. I probably had
- 34:07cramps, like I probably felt like shit just because my period was coming.
- 34:10Yeah, and so, but so I was at home and it was just
- 34:13the two of us, and I went to the bathroom and I was like,
- 34:15oh, I'm having my period. I'm home alone with my mom.
- 34:20I believe I was in eighth grade. I was like fourteen. I was
- 34:22late. I was early. I was I was technically still eleven, not
- 34:27quite twelve, a couple of months away from twelve. Gotcha, too many
- 34:30hormones and too many mills. I was my sisters. My sisters subsequently got
- 34:36their's earlier earlier. Yeah, yeah, I think me starting late. That's
- 34:40when I think my mom said. When I Easter, I was like,
- 34:43am I going through menopause? Early menopause? I'm getting my period every two
- 34:46weeks? And she was like, no, you started your period too late.
- 34:51That a thing? Is that? Is that a thing? I don't
- 34:53know. I don't know if that makes it difference. I'm no doctor.
- 35:00It's not like working towards retirement where you have to work a certain number of
- 35:04years to start now. And I was like, you gonna have to work
- 35:12a few extra years. Um no, but uh it was I remember I
- 35:20it wasn't such a big deal to me getting it that late, but I
- 35:24had feelings when my sisters subsequently got their's earlier. I don't remember the exact
- 35:30I'm kind of blanking on the exact years that they were helped them to sync
- 35:36up. Maybe maybe I did pull it out of them, But now I'm
- 35:42pretty I'm I know. I know my middle sister got hers at an earlier
- 35:46age than I got mine, and I'm pretty sure my youngest sister also got
- 35:52hers, although I was I was older at the time and not paying so
- 35:55much attention. Just you know. Yeah, but um, my bigger thing
- 36:01wasn't my period. My bigger thing was being able to shave my legs.
- 36:06That was the thing, not the bra and not the period. I am
- 36:09Italian, I am fucking hairy. I just could not wait to be able
- 36:14to shave my legs. I do remember, like my aunt's saying, or
- 36:21maybe it was my mom, I can't remember, but just kind of being
- 36:22like, you know, once you start, like then you're just shaving for
- 36:27the rest of your life, which technically is not true. You can stop
- 36:30anytime you want, but but yeah, and they were kind of like,
- 36:35why do you want to start now? I think I got a razor,
- 36:37but I got an electric razor. That's what that's what my mom got me.
- 36:39So I wouldn't so I wouldn't like fancy well, I mean it doesn't
- 36:45actually clean clean, clean shave you I ever used no legs, it's not
- 36:50it's it's super not worth it. Don't get it. It's okay, Yeah,
- 36:53I won't start now, but it's yeah, I think there were there
- 36:58were concerns about me cutting myself or what a reason. But yeah, which
- 37:02I still have a scar on my ankle, like I took a good like
- 37:07five inches. Oh wrong, it was like a real because it's like my
- 37:14mom would use like the disposable razor, so that's then what I used.
- 37:16And those things I still us like the ones. I literally like the ones.
- 37:21They're a little risky. I really like the ones that they've changed names
- 37:25now, but they used to be like named after like Twilight characters. Was
- 37:30like Tella. No, there was one was like Della, and I can't
- 37:35remember the other one, but it was like literally like named after Twilight characters.
- 37:38And I think I just got it because it was on sale. I
- 37:42needed something and I was like, oh, I really like these. And
- 37:44they've since changed names, but I get the same one still and it's been
- 37:47like fifteen years. That's really funny because if they knew him after any of
- 37:51the vampires, I don't know, it's like it draws blood, Like I
- 37:54don't think that's what you want to be saying about yours. But oh,
- 37:58fun back, guys, A man and I used to have shave your legs
- 38:00parties in college. Yeah, from I got that from summer camp. I
- 38:06was like, we did. We would sit there with the shaving cream over
- 38:08the bathroom sinks, in the communal bathrooms. Amanda, did you go to
- 38:14summer camp similar to what little Margaret went to? No, it was just
- 38:17one one week a summer. We couldn't afford a full full summer camp.
- 38:22Ye. No, it did not have a wealth wealthy grandparents. Yeah.
- 38:31I always wanted to go to like a week one camp. We had a
- 38:36we had these like in town half day camps that were free. So that's
- 38:40what it wasn't really camp doesn't count. I know that was a very sullen
- 38:45teene. It was kind of a you know, yeah, our version of
- 38:50mental health and go into the woods for a week. Yeah, try and
- 38:53be less. I always seemed so fun. Yeah. Yeah. It was
- 38:58a very meaningful part of my adolescence and then into my adult life. It's
- 39:01yeah, I went back and counseled for a long time. I think three
- 39:06podcast I think, yeah, I think. I don't think there was any
- 39:08overlap between. I don't think so either. Yeah. Okay, So any
- 39:14last thoughts in the book, And I'm sure we'll bring more about the book
- 39:16into the movie as it as it naturally comes up. But any last thoughts
- 39:21though about the just specifically pertaining to the book and how awesome these pages are,
- 39:28because they really, they really are, now they really are. I
- 39:32do have to say one thing, maybe if I can, I do love
- 39:36Judy Bloom. But one criticism I can offer is that there is and I
- 39:40think it's partially due to the times, but a preoccupation with weight that really
- 39:46goes through kind of like all of her books that I can think of off
- 39:51the top of mine. I wonder if your audition is different, because Manda,
- 39:54did you notice in ours anything really? It's just mentioned it. Yeah,
- 40:00you know, okay, and um, like and one of the friends
- 40:05has to stop doing something because she gained too much weight. There's like a
- 40:10little thing about here and there, um and just as long as we're together.
- 40:15I remember specifically, she's like depressed. At one point, she's eating
- 40:21a lot and she's gaining weight and everyone's commenting on it, and she just
- 40:23to like try to lose the weight where she gets the flu and that's how
- 40:29she like loses the way and everyone's super happy. I'm like, wow,
- 40:30that's not really you know. And even in the even even in the special
- 40:37the Judy Boom Forever her one of her friends when she first comes on and
- 40:42it's like a childhood friend and she's talking about her and she lists off her
- 40:45qualities and she says, she says that she was so skinny. Oh really,
- 40:50yeah, it's it's very Yeah. I think that's probably something that was
- 40:54passed down to her from her mother, and it was the time and it
- 40:58was, you know, and she has like objectively very very thin but like
- 41:02an eighty three. Yeah, she's eighty three. She talks about it.
- 41:08She's but forgetting his family all died young of heart problems or something, and
- 41:16she part of the reasons why she wrote so much was she wanted to get
- 41:21all the thoughts, m and ideas out of her before she died because she
- 41:24thought she was gonna die young like them. Oh my god. Yeah,
- 41:28that's pretty intense. Also had the record owned that I just killed a fly
- 41:31on my landed on my arm, and I have ever actually hit one and
- 41:35actually killed it, so feeling it was a little accomplished. Yeah, there's
- 41:40been some like fruit flies that have been kind of circling because there's like a
- 41:44hole in this um the screen in this window over here. So I've gotten
- 41:49very good at It's like I'll be here during like work meetings and I'm like
- 41:54catch up. I'm sure my co workers are like she like me go dancing,
- 42:01Like what is she doing here? Um? Okay, yeah, so
- 42:07sorry, I'm sorry attending us. Um. Yeah, the way thing is
- 42:09is a little the way thing yeah, and I mean definitely it's like very
- 42:14white like that's yeah, kind of Yeah, yeah, I suppose it goes
- 42:19without saying, although I do I remember for a very long time, like
- 42:22for a very long time never really like knowing like what her religious background was.
- 42:28Um, And I remember like wondering if she was Jewish, because Jewish
- 42:31characters do tend to show up in her books like fairly regularly, which doesn't
- 42:37doesn't have to mean that she's Jewish obviously, but she said in the in
- 42:42the dutmentory, yeah, that her family's Jewish. I was like, oh,
- 42:45okay, mystery that's resolved. Yeah. Interesting. Yeah. Also,
- 42:51just the themes, like the religious themes, which I guess we should talk
- 42:54about, are just as important, I think as the preteen girls stuff.
- 43:01Totally. Like that's actually when you think about how she wrote this book in
- 43:07the late sixties while living being a suburban housewife who wanted a career and didn't
- 43:14want to be a suburban housewife, and which because you know that her neighborhood
- 43:19was probably like everybody either joins the why or the community center right right,
- 43:22And just to think that she put that out there, that's that's something that
- 43:28is like so incredibly like powerful in a way, because I think that her
- 43:37idea that God is for everyone is actually really great because whatever deity you believe
- 43:44in, that's that's a I've always thought this is that's a personal relationship between
- 43:49you and whatever God or God's or whatever it should be there. And to
- 43:53like have somebody that young, like put it out there in an era where
- 44:00people still went to church all the time or temple all the time, like
- 44:02it's it's I feel like that's even ballsier to write about somebody questioning religion,
- 44:08especially a character that has no religion questioning religion. I feel like that's even
- 44:14ballsier to put out there than even like the period stuff. Definitely, And
- 44:20there is the one other thing that I'm like ninety nine percent sure of this
- 44:25very small change. But maybe somebody who listened and read closer than me,
- 44:31who's listening to this episode, or maybe you guys can either confirm this or
- 44:37not. But I remember in the book when she's like, I looked for
- 44:40you a temple, I looked for you at church blaa, and she says,
- 44:45why is it that I can only feel you when I'm alone? That's
- 44:50that's how it's sort of phrases in the book. And I'm sure that she
- 44:54says. But in the movie, in the movie she's she basically says,
- 45:00why do I just feel like I'm alone? Or it's just me? It's
- 45:04sort of changed a little bit to be even. Also she also says the
- 45:08quote, how why is it that I only feel you when I'm alone?
- 45:12She does say that in the movie. But then I feel like there's this
- 45:15part where she says specifically like maybe I can't remember how she says, but
- 45:20the idea behind it is maybe God doesn't exist. Movie, it's just me.
- 45:22Yes, yes, yes, that that is a separate Yeah, that
- 45:25is a scene, and that's not and that without wording, is not in
- 45:29the book. Correct, I don't believe it is now, which I thought
- 45:31that was. And then even in the movie she comes back around because at
- 45:36the very end, she you know, still like goes back to talking to
- 45:38God. But I thought that was really powerful and I couldn't you couldn't remember
- 45:44whether it was in the book or not, like it stuck out to me
- 45:46when I was at the movie, and when I was at the movie,
- 45:49I hadn't gotten to that part of the book yet. So then back to
- 45:52the book, I think you're onto something with this, like out of order,
- 45:57or like how I think I'm kind of doing this way. Yeah,
- 46:00forward, I realized I noticed certain I notice things that I I didn't think
- 46:05anything of it because I had read the book before, But now that we're
- 46:07talking about it's like, yeah, I noticed certain things on the reread that
- 46:10I may not have if I had done it both in like one fel s
- 46:15boop. Yeah, but it's like to yeah, to continue on that thought
- 46:20a little bit. It's just like I very much appreciate this like non judgmental
- 46:25sort of way it's framed of like just this questioning, which is just a
- 46:30very natural thing, whether you come down on the side of ultimately sticking with
- 46:36your religion or finding redefining religion for yourself or deciding like it's not for you
- 46:40at all. Like I think questioning it at some point in your adolescence.
- 46:46I think it's universal. I think it doesn't you admit it to yourself or
- 46:51not. I think everybody has a little bit of questioning and a little bit
- 46:54of doubt. And it's like very nice that there is a safe non judgmental
- 47:00space spring can kind of explore that, and like, I think that's really
- 47:02lovely. Well, and I don't think that it like necessarily obviously everyone's different.
- 47:07It's not always at like eleven twelve years old, but there's something about
- 47:12that age. I think it's often eleven and twelve years old. It was
- 47:15for me, And I mean you can think about like that's kind of when
- 47:20like Christians do a communion. That's also kind of the age where Jewish kids
- 47:24do their barments. Fuzz Like, there's there's something very special about that age
- 47:28and the questioning and then either coming down on the side of like reaffirming or
- 47:37doing something different. And doesn't mean that the rest of your life is going
- 47:39to be like that either, but I do think there's something very special about
- 47:43that age for that's just everything. I think you're just starting to become more
- 47:46aware of the world around you, so you just start to question, question
- 47:50every everything. Yeah, you're becoming a little like a little tiny version of
- 47:54what you'll become as an adult. Yeah. It's like, yeah, yeah,
- 47:58you're starting your own independent thought for realities. Yeah. Yeah. I
- 48:02like the use of with the religion. I like that she talks to God
- 48:08instead of it being like a plot thing where she's like writing in a diary.
- 48:13Yeah, it's a fun twist and a very common trope, particularly in
- 48:17like Yah Yes, it's just like the first person narration through like letters to
- 48:23someone or a diary exact, which I love me a little pistolary novel,
- 48:29don't get me wrong. What a word, What a word? I love
- 48:36that genre. But I agree it's it's a nice twist, and I just
- 48:39love that in the end because you know, you're kind of you're kind of
- 48:44waiting, like what's she gonna choose? Is she gonna be Jewish? Is
- 48:46she gonna be Christian? Is she gonna be Catholic? And she doesn't choose,
- 48:51And that's great, yep, And that's actually probably more realistic than her
- 48:55choosing Yeah, it would be, it would It's not the it would be
- 49:00device, but she could have chosen and people could still like it. But
- 49:04I just love that it just leaves it open of like, first of all,
- 49:07you don't have to choose. Second of all, this is maybe something
- 49:09that will evolve throughout your life. Third of all, there's different ways of
- 49:13being. It doesn't have to be you don't have to be in this box
- 49:15or that box. It can just it can it can be a you know,
- 49:19a non box. And it's also made pretty clear that her search for
- 49:22religion isn't that she wants to find a faith, it's because she has a
- 49:27faith. I mean she talks to God. Yes, she wants to fit
- 49:30in and everybody else yeah, and then realizes that she can still fit in
- 49:35and doesn't have to go to the y or the community center. Yeah.
- 49:38So um, okay, as far as the movie goes, um, I
- 49:43think we all liked it. I loved it so much. I want to
- 49:47report. So I m I had just assumed, and this is why it
- 49:52never make assumptions, Okay, but I had just assumed that, like I
- 49:55would be doing this movie solo like Frank because very cool and open minded.
- 50:00But I just like, for whatever reason, I was like, twelve year
- 50:04old girl gets her period, Like I just would have assumed that he wouldn't
- 50:07be interested. Yeah, which is bad on me. I showed on the
- 50:13trailer and he was like, no, that looks cool, Like let's go
- 50:15let's go watch. And he really really liked it and he said he like
- 50:21got emotional at the end when she got her period with her mom and stuff.
- 50:24And I mean he doesn't France doesn't cry at movies, Like he's not.
- 50:29I don't know if he actually cried, but he did say he got
- 50:30you know, WELTERI eyed. He was he was emotional. Um so she's
- 50:35saying like I cried, Oh yes, I yes, yes, I cried.
- 50:39Not even want my period. I was just so happy for her at
- 50:43the end. But like, um as I was like, I was wiping
- 50:47my e so the I'm used to the Marvel movies where like, you know,
- 50:50you've got like fifteen minutes of credits to like wipe your eyes, but
- 50:53like the lights went up right away, so they're like like DearS. So
- 50:57I'm like wiping my eyes and I'm walking down the aisle like I'm still tear
- 51:00eyed. And it was me this older gentleman who was just there in his
- 51:06popcorn and watching the movie by himself at the other end of the row.
- 51:08And then like all the other rows were you know, filled up with like
- 51:14five six people, good three or four rows though, so there was there
- 51:19was probably good thirty people in the movie of meum and it was just like
- 51:22oh, like you know, old ladies. And one of them like looks
- 51:25at me as I'm walking down and I'm like I have tears, and she
- 51:30just goes. It was a nice movie. Dear. I was like,
- 51:40all right, I'm not getting camaraderie from this old lady. Oh funny.
- 51:49She's probably thinking, like, just wait until you don't get your period anymore,
- 51:52and then you can really live life. Freedom is subside once you get
- 52:01through that. Um. I just thought that that was so funny. I
- 52:07was like, all right, well, my things, we have different experiences
- 52:12in the same room. Cool, we sure did. Um. I liked
- 52:17the movie was still set in the sixties, yes, seventy okay, sorry,
- 52:23I liked that it was still set in that time period. I don't
- 52:27think I would have liked it if they had made it like are you there
- 52:30got it to me Margaret taking place in twenty twenty three? Yeah, no,
- 52:34I think yeah. I think that sort of thing where something is just
- 52:37so beloved you can't muck with it that much. You really have to like
- 52:44be very intentional with like the delineations from the text. Yeah, although I
- 52:50guess if you give it a few years, you could technically set it in
- 52:52Florida in like twenty twenty five and it would be like the name the same
- 52:57setting. Yeah. Yeah, and that I think that wrong though it's not
- 53:05wrong, no, but it kind of goes back to what they were saying
- 53:07about how it's supposed to be time and that's what became timeless. And also
- 53:13I read because I've read a couple of articles in like New York Times whatever,
- 53:17m NBR probably one of them said had some interview with UM with Judy
- 53:23Bloom and she mentioned that, you know, people like wanted to see Margaret
- 53:28like you know, go through menopas or you know, do these other stages
- 53:32in her life. And she was like, no, market, it will
- 53:35always be twelve, Like, yeah, she's twelve, and she's and she
- 53:39says at the inn the documentary that she's she's done writing long books because she's
- 53:45at the point of her life now where she wants to go outside and see
- 53:49the world and like, you know, experience life, because she takes her
- 53:52like years to write these books. Yeah, and I'm like, respect,
- 53:57she's made her contribution. Can I think she especially eighty three, like you
- 54:02could be done, You could be done. The woman owns a bookstore in
- 54:07Key West, Florida that sells banned books, Like I love that about her.
- 54:12She's such a badass, like Amanda. I hope you do eventually get
- 54:16a chance to watch documentary because she's I really will, I really really will,
- 54:21But no, I love I love the movie. I think, going
- 54:23back to talking about Rachel McAdams, I don't know if I would have cast
- 54:27her like twelve year old Colleen thinking bad not rereading the book would have cast
- 54:30her. But she's perfect. I mean she's she's also, isn't she's like
- 54:36forty seven and she just looks like she's twenty eight. Like it's just infinitely
- 54:42youthful, like she's but yeah wow, but like well into her forties and
- 54:45like wow, looks so young. Yeah good, George is forty four.
- 54:52Yeah, crazy, that's wild because she was like twenty eight. She was
- 54:57like practically she was almost thirty when she was a me girls, like amazingly
- 55:01like so far removed from me a teenager, but she had to be like
- 55:06twenty four. Me and girls came out in twenty I feel like she was
- 55:09very old. Yeah yeah, she's she's old. She's several years older ones
- 55:15the old hand. But um, that's all I kept thinking. I was
- 55:19like, oh my god, she's a cool mom mom. I love the
- 55:23journey that she went on, Um that was fun. I loved relationship with
- 55:30her husband. It's like really nice and again like they were herb like very
- 55:35fairly equal partners without without like you know, stuffing it down her throat,
- 55:39which is in the book it kind of makes them equal partners too. Yeah.
- 55:44Yeah, there's like more conflict I think in the book, especially when
- 55:49it comes to like her partner's parents. Yeah, there's much more conflict and
- 55:53less of alike equal partnership than I think they did in the movie. Like
- 56:00I think they really explored that relationship and like intentionally wanted to make them more
- 56:05of like I agree, but or just play that up like yeah, I
- 56:09agree. But they also in the book go out of their way to mention
- 56:13how Mom can talk dad and doing anything like buying the car, and she
- 56:19actually like pleads with them like please understand where I'm coming from. And then
- 56:22Margaret and the Dead both are like, you know, give her a hug
- 56:27and are like, Okay, well we'll make this work for you or whatever.
- 56:30Well except that it's going to happen, I think, like for for
- 56:34again the year nineteen seventy, you know, And you can tell in the
- 56:37documentary when they that when she's starting to talk about how like she hated being
- 56:42a housewife, like she loved having kids, but hated being a housewife.
- 56:45And I was like, oh, this is gonna end with her getting divorced,
- 56:47and then and then whom they were lying, and then she got divorced,
- 56:51and I was like, Okay, I could see that she literally hid
- 56:54her feelings about her first husband. What blew my fucking mind is that?
- 56:59So and they were married when she started having like all of the success,
- 57:02and she said she doesn't think he ever read one of her books. I
- 57:06know, it's nuts. It's like, good, pla get out of here.
- 57:08Yeah, she did ye publishing money with me yep um back and that's
- 57:20I'm sure alimony didn't go both ways. I'm sure take it all. Yeah,
- 57:25it's just the stuff that she faced as a writer for the subject matter,
- 57:31especially as the eighties hit. She talks about the turning point in the
- 57:37election of Reagan and how how once the Conservatives took over, that's when she
- 57:45got like, one day, she got like seven hundred death threats because she
- 57:47had made it known that she was in supportive planned parenthood, and she was
- 57:52constantly scared of book signings that somebody was going to come up and shoot her.
- 57:59And I'm like, girl, you're lucky that Republicans had another ten years
- 58:01before they removed the twenty years before their in politics just yet. But she
- 58:08must have had some serious fucking whiplash in twenty sixteen. Yeah, But like
- 58:15she's and she you know, she's I guess maybe I don't know if she's
- 58:17the original like Queen of banned books, but like she's certainly up there,
- 58:22and like the Royal Court of people who've had books bad, it's not just
- 58:24one and it's not just two. It's right where she had like actual like
- 58:30she was on Crossfire arguing with m Patty Cannon and she kept being like,
- 58:38you're cherry picking it, you're misrepresenting that. Basically, she basically said,
- 58:44like you're taking things out of context, you're trying to scare parents, and
- 58:47like you're taking like small little things and not looking at the bigger aspect of
- 58:52the book. And her last book with was it Bradbury Books or whatever,
- 58:57Her last book with them was the one where she uses the word fucking one
- 59:01time, and she had to actually have this whole conversation with her editor and
- 59:10he was like, if you leave the word fucking in book clubs aren't going
- 59:14to read it, And like it's gonna be a thing. And she actually,
- 59:19like you know, had heart to heart with her with her kids and
- 59:24whoever else, like being like should I change the words? Should I just
- 59:28make it fricking? Should I just take it out? And then at the
- 59:31end she was like, you know what, your kids are out there on
- 59:35the playground saying, fucking, fucking, fucking it's okay if they read this
- 59:37one word. And the character felt so upset in that moment that he did
- 59:44the natural thing, which is to use drop an F bomb. So I'm
- 59:46keeping it in nice. She's such a badass, she's one of the one
- 59:52of the things. Because I saw that part with Pat Buchanan and he was
- 59:55trying to say, you know, like a Damia is a book about masturbation,
- 59:59and she's like, Dani is a book about a girl with schooliosis.
- 1:00:01And then he keeps going and at one point she's like, are you hung
- 1:00:05up on masturbation? And thus began a lifelong, a decades long obsession at
- 1:00:15the right heads people touching themselves. Yeah, it sure bothers them what other
- 1:00:22people do in private. It don't shut up the party. It's real mad
- 1:00:25if you make yourself come and I do like I remember reading Deanie for the
- 1:00:30first time. I don't know if I've read it more than once, but
- 1:00:34I remember being like a young you know, like a tween or what how
- 1:00:37role I was when I read it. And I do remember that line because
- 1:00:42it's she doesn't dwell on it. It's just like a line, it's how
- 1:00:46special place? And then yeah, and then it and then it goes on,
- 1:00:51and I remember that sort of like in my young brain being like,
- 1:00:55wait, is that did she just? Is that what we're talking about?
- 1:00:59But then the story goes on and you just keep going on and you know,
- 1:01:01yeah, and now thinking back, it's like, wow, that's like
- 1:01:04fucking revolutionary. Well there was a list. There was yesterday or within the
- 1:01:09last few days. Who you know how Ronda Santis used a study that had
- 1:01:15a list of recommended books to be banned behind his like don't say gay and
- 1:01:21like, um, you know, his little authoritarian takeaway of Florida, and
- 1:01:25the list of books. Finally, like the report came out and it's wild
- 1:01:30some of the books that are in there. It's like a book on different
- 1:01:35cultures and how they live. And one picture, one picture is of a
- 1:01:40tribe in or An African village of some sort, and there's the buttox of
- 1:01:45a little like two year old kid and they teamed it pornography and that's why
- 1:01:50it's on the list. And there's another book where a character is taking a
- 1:01:54bath in an illustration and that's pornography. So it was like, doesn't understand
- 1:02:00the difference between nudity and pornography. And what that indicates to me is that
- 1:02:06they are all jacking off at things that infensive. It's always projection. Yeah,
- 1:02:14because I see a little kids two year old bare bottom because he's running
- 1:02:17around without a diaper, and that's right, and there's just natural is like
- 1:02:25no connection to anything whatsoever sexual, But they are the ones that are making
- 1:02:30that connection for them in their own minds, because yes, I guarantee you
- 1:02:37if a fifth grader is going to see and it's not even a fifth grader,
- 1:02:40but like, let's just say a fifth grader sees a naked butt of
- 1:02:45a two year old or a three year old, you know what they're gonna
- 1:02:46do. They're gonna laugh, Yes, that's it. You're like, oh,
- 1:02:50but but but you're not going to be like, oh, this is
- 1:02:54trying to sexualize me, like exactly yeah, it's all the dub Is stuff.
- 1:03:01But it's crazy though, just the way that, um, everything like
- 1:03:07is just a giant cycle. Yeah. Yeah, we never moved too far
- 1:03:10away, no, which is very disheartening to be honest. But the movie
- 1:03:15anyway, Yeah, yeah, I thought that the actress that played Margaret herself
- 1:03:20was phenomenal, so good. All the kids were great, I mean seriously,
- 1:03:23everyone, they were all great, wonderful. Yeah, Nancy Wheeler was
- 1:03:27exactly how I always exactly. Yes. Oh did you notice another little difference,
- 1:03:34um, is that in the book they had like the same sort of
- 1:03:36like suburban cookie cutter house. I live in a big house. Yeah.
- 1:03:42I felt like, you know, I reread I reread her introduction part to
- 1:03:49like once it got to the point where she said, oh, she lived
- 1:03:51in the house that looked like mine, I was like, wait a second,
- 1:03:52did she not say that line? Yeah? Yeah, yeah, but
- 1:03:58I thought that was a good change too. Yeah. But it's like,
- 1:04:00I like how they sort of found coloring and like beefed up these characters by
- 1:04:05like finding little details in the book, like the little thing about not picking
- 1:04:09out the furniture and how like that became a much fair plot point and just
- 1:04:14developing the mother character in the film, and it's like that came from the
- 1:04:17source text, like it was their Yeah, and it just you know,
- 1:04:21like just finding those little moments, like it was just very clever, like
- 1:04:24it sort of you could tell that there was a lot of love and like
- 1:04:29reverence for the story in sort of the development of the movie. Like it
- 1:04:33wasn't just like hey, like reboots and like making movies out of books is
- 1:04:39really popular, Like this was a really popular book. Let's just do it
- 1:04:43for the money crap, Like clearly it was really I wanted to have much
- 1:04:46love and you felt it. I should have looked it, looked at this
- 1:04:49beforehand, And I wonder how much Judy Bloom consulted. What did you guys,
- 1:04:54SI? Yeah, did you catch the cameo? Yeah? Yes,
- 1:04:57I did. She was really my name person. I I like like I
- 1:05:02was like, okay, I got to mention that. Yes, I was
- 1:05:06like, oh my god, she was on I forgot to even look at
- 1:05:13me very like was it Stanley and like the Marvel movie, Like it was
- 1:05:18a great sort of homage to that, like just kind of dropped her in
- 1:05:23and if you knew what you were looking for with like yes, to be
- 1:05:26real, like everybody in that audience knew what they were looking. Everybody knew
- 1:05:28what they did. You guys like that they changed the storyline that Margaret learned
- 1:05:33about her grandparents in real time versus in the book she knew about it ahead.
- 1:05:40I knew about it. Yeah, I mean it definitely added to the
- 1:05:43drama quite know how you would have, because again, like they're the sort
- 1:05:47of narration of the book. I like how they really sort of kept those
- 1:05:53sort of voiceover moments within the movie of Jess when she's talking to God.
- 1:05:58So I love it they were all word for word from the text to yeah,
- 1:06:00And I do love when you just sort of dropped in like yeah,
- 1:06:03the actual like dialogue from the book. But yeah, I think like that
- 1:06:06sort of to make that storyline work, I think they had to tell it
- 1:06:12that way, Like I don't I don't know how they would have done it
- 1:06:15otherwise. And I think it also gave that really lovely moment for Rachel McAdams
- 1:06:19when they're sort of talking about it at like they catch the dining table and
- 1:06:23like writing the letters. It just like it adds really lovely. Yeah,
- 1:06:29it was a really good motivation to show like why she would send the letter.
- 1:06:31Oh, I was just talking to my daughter about this. Maybe it
- 1:06:34is time. So I was one of the changes I was okay with.
- 1:06:39I really liked that Sylvia drops in instead of the next marine during it.
- 1:06:44I thought that that was good. Kathy Bates was hilarious. Oh my god,
- 1:06:46she's another one that's just like utterly perfection and like everything. I just
- 1:06:51love Kathy Bates. I love she can do no wrong as far as I'm
- 1:06:55concernous. Yeah, yeah, and that was great. I did it.
- 1:06:59Mentions I think in the book anyway, that Margaret's birthday is March eighth,
- 1:07:03and I was like, oh, that's International Women's Day. I wonder if
- 1:07:08that was intentional, But I just googled it and that didn't start until nineteen
- 1:07:11seventy five, so oh maybe, yeah, maybe that's the day. I
- 1:07:16mean, I'm just gonna go with that. Just start that rub and go
- 1:07:21with it. Um. You know. One line that I was also secretly
- 1:07:26glad they kept in when Sylvia sews up and she's like, this is mister
- 1:07:30Benneman and he goes rides with cinnamon. Yeah that was great. Yeah.
- 1:07:34Part of me was like, oh, that's got to come from the book.
- 1:07:36That's that's I feel like that is a lifted moment. Yep, I
- 1:07:41loved it so much. That was great. Yeah, I love this scene
- 1:07:46in the in the movie that's not in the book of like Margaret and the
- 1:07:49grandmother bed together are like after the day in the theater, Like I hope
- 1:07:56that was just like such a sweet like just these moments where they sort of
- 1:07:59built back in. Yeah, a character development and the relation well not the
- 1:08:02character development, but like the relationship development. It's like such a sweet moment.
- 1:08:09Oh yeah, I love I love her and her grandma's relationship. I
- 1:08:14don't think I can complain about any anything they changed for the movie, honestly,
- 1:08:18I don't think so. I loved the scene because that also reminded me
- 1:08:23of like being that age where she and Janey go to buy the teenage softies.
- 1:08:30It's like, oh my god, is a great piece of comedic timing.
- 1:08:34I was a little broms that, like that moment wasn't in the book.
- 1:08:40Um the spit the five minutes in the closet, two minutes in the
- 1:08:43closet, whatever it is, two minutes in Heaven the Bottle. I like
- 1:08:46that they changed it in the movie that Nancy doesn't get to kiss Phil what's
- 1:08:50his face at all? Because yeah, that they like definitely streamlined that scene
- 1:08:58for the movie, which again I think it made sense since like in a
- 1:09:00movie you want to cut down in the characters you have, Like I think
- 1:09:02the way they sort of reframed that scene like worked for me. I was
- 1:09:06like when I got to that point in the book, I was like,
- 1:09:09oh, this is a little more complicated. Yeah, like a lot of
- 1:09:12unnecessary stuff that I was like, Yeah, it was funny because like just
- 1:09:15thinking about what came from Judi Blom's own life, Like there was a conversation
- 1:09:18in the part that I saw of the documentary where she's talking with a friend
- 1:09:21and apparently they did have a crush on the same boy at one point in
- 1:09:26time, and they would both go out with him and then compare notes on
- 1:09:29like how yeah this is each of them had and stuff. So that felt
- 1:09:30like very much pulled. Judy Boom also said that she herself lied about getting
- 1:09:34her period when she was Yes, great, it was like, okay,
- 1:09:38so that little thing about Nancy, like she herself, well that was her
- 1:09:41first real book. I mean she had the other ones, but this is
- 1:09:44the one that she lives with. Her second or third one that she liked
- 1:09:46was like, all right, I am writing this book and based on voice.
- 1:09:54Yeah, yeah, oh I love it so much. Yeah, anything
- 1:09:59else with them movie. I'm sure we'll also we have a lot of feedback
- 1:10:02that I'm sure will I'm sure we'll be talking about it, especially when we
- 1:10:05get to mess No, it's just great five stars. Would see again,
- 1:10:13Yeah, yeah, total, we'll see again. Yes, I will see
- 1:10:16it again too. I'm very glad that I also own this book, which
- 1:10:20I will give to one of my nieces someday. Are my kids right up?
- 1:10:26Yes, I'll be like, hey, you guys like those Fudge books
- 1:10:30you liked, Well, I got one for you. Eighth grader, seventh
- 1:10:36grader, sixth grade or whatever she's in. Yeah, I love that she
- 1:10:42uh so. She had said in the documentary that she never wanted to really
- 1:10:46base any of her characters on the kids, to not invade their privacy.
- 1:10:50But her son, her kids were much older when she wrote the Fudge books,
- 1:10:55and she based a lot of it on her son. But he was
- 1:10:58like early twenties and like day eating at the time, so everyone he dated
- 1:11:01would just be like oh, so I'm dating Fudge. So what I told
- 1:11:08Jay that? He was like, but did he really eat the turtle?
- 1:11:10And I was like a documentary that might just be fiction? So um,
- 1:11:20but anyway, Yeah, let's take a quick break, um, and then
- 1:11:24we will come back and your feedback. All right, we're backorated. Hear
- 1:11:29what everybody else thought about the movie? Are you there, audience, it's
- 1:11:31time for feedback? Yeah, I know the joke didn't work the second time.
- 1:11:35Um. We're gonna start off with a voicemail for Maggie. Here we
- 1:11:41go. Hayman is standing and Colleen, it's Maggie with bye. Are you
- 1:11:46there? God, It's me Margaret book Um feedback. Because I have not
- 1:11:51had a chance to watch the movie, I hope to watch it before the
- 1:11:56episode comes out, or I will wait and watch it, as I really
- 1:12:00do want to watch the movie. So I had never read the book until
- 1:12:03just recently, which is really weird because I loved Judie Bloom. I read
- 1:12:10all the Fudge books and actually like one of my favorite books from a kid
- 1:12:15is a Judy Bloom. It's called just as long as We're Together. It's
- 1:12:18about three friends actually have it downstairs. I've been thinking about rereading it since
- 1:12:25I read Margaret and the sequel, So I don't know how I never read
- 1:12:30either. Got as mean Margaret, I guess because I wasn't waiting at my
- 1:12:34period to start, because it started when I was like ten, So like
- 1:12:40I guess, I was probably more the person like Laura, the character you
- 1:12:45know in Margaret's class, that probably was more me than Margaret. So that
- 1:12:50maybe why I've never read it. But I really enjoyed it. I really
- 1:12:57thought it was interesting how Margaret was kind of searching her faith and her parents
- 1:13:02were sort of kind of not there. It was just, yeah, it
- 1:13:08was I really enjoyed the book. I was really glad to read it.
- 1:13:11It was a very quick read, and I'm trying to think, yeah,
- 1:13:15I just liked the friendships and you know, teenage girls are fun and put
- 1:13:23yourself back in that headspace, which I mean, yeah, I don't want
- 1:13:28to. I don't want to be a teenage girl again. It's kind of
- 1:13:30buckers and crazy. But so yeah, I am. I have heard really
- 1:13:36good things about the movie, excited to see that and can't wait to hear
- 1:13:41what you think. I will talk to you later. Bye bye, Maggie.
- 1:13:45We are on the same page here here about just as long as we're
- 1:13:47together. Also, so yes, I don't remember reading that one. It's
- 1:13:53worth reading. Well, I think now I'm going to pull up the Libby
- 1:13:56app and see what they have for Judy Bloom and you know, and have
- 1:14:00some fun. Yeah, have some fun. The speed is sick anyway.
- 1:14:06Sorry, guess I did a lady guy quote. Sorry, Maggie. Yeah,
- 1:14:13I'm with you with being brought back to the head space. All right,
- 1:14:20thank you for the feedback. I can't wait to hear what you thought
- 1:14:24about the movie, which I guess we should mention now we have already recorded,
- 1:14:30so we're not recorded together again until Tuesday, June sixth, is it.
- 1:14:34We actually prerecorded already two episodes with the real Weird Sisters, so stay
- 1:14:40tuned for those over the next couple of weeks, and then we will be
- 1:14:45back on June sixth, So you have a couple of weeks to see the
- 1:14:48movie and get your feedback in. Anybody out there listening to this, all
- 1:14:54right, Our next bit of feedback is a very long email from Matt,
- 1:14:59which makes a little nervous that we are not going to agree again. I've
- 1:15:03got a little anxiety, Matt, I admit I just saying saying this was
- 1:15:09They were both awesome. I loved them and I'm sure you all did too.
- 1:15:12Doesn't it taken? Oh my god, I can't. Okay, let's
- 1:15:23just get to the email, and he already has to think. Okay,
- 1:15:27Matt writes in with AYTG, I amm feedback, which took me a second,
- 1:15:30but it's yeah, Are Either Got To Me? Margaret? I Hey,
- 1:15:39Brods, it may be hard to believe, but I don't remember reading
- 1:15:43any Judy Bloom growing up. Maybe there was a stupid I don't want to
- 1:15:46read girl books bias that I've obviously our ground. So I decided to check
- 1:15:50out the audiobook of Are Either Got To Me? Margaret in preparation for this
- 1:15:54Math special show. I can't say I got a whole lot out of it,
- 1:15:57However, who gives a fuck? The book isn't really for me,
- 1:16:00but I'm glad it exist in as touched countless readers in the other half in
- 1:16:06the over half a century since it came out as well. Yeah, putting
- 1:16:12it that way, yeah, yeah, I know. The nineteen seventies was
- 1:16:15not thirty years ago. Turns out it was actually eighty ninety one hundred,
- 1:16:23yeah, twenty ten, yeah, half century uh so yeah, um plus
- 1:16:31yeah plus take let it thinking, just let it. Yeah, it's going
- 1:16:38to come in a few waves, just let it just little. Was I
- 1:16:41kind of feel like somebody like did that thing where like you know, put
- 1:16:44like something cold on my head and it's like now like preeping down. Just
- 1:16:49let it wash over you like the orgasms and forever doesn't feel that good though,
- 1:16:57No, No, I have a different kind. It's not going bottom
- 1:17:00up, it's going up down and that doesn't feel great. Just it's never
- 1:17:04the same. It's just not the same feeling. No, always go bottom
- 1:17:09up always time you can go ask the mouth. You're all welcome. I'm
- 1:17:18very warm right now. Anyway, what was that saying? That was saying
- 1:17:28the book isn't really for me, but I'm glad it exists, and as
- 1:17:30such, countless readers in the over half a century since it came out,
- 1:17:34as well as helped establish what eventually became y a plus anything to piss off
- 1:17:40the bad books assholes. Yeah, I was saying, man, this is
- 1:17:44starting out strong. Yes. I also saw the film, which I loved,
- 1:17:48Okay, okay, all right, It just was a nice film.
- 1:17:54Dear, it was a nice film. It just showed how timeless and universal
- 1:18:00that themes of the book are. While I wasn't a twin girl, I
- 1:18:03also wondered about when I would hit those milestones of puberty, compared myself to
- 1:18:09other guys, how they were doing, trying to figure out tricks to jump
- 1:18:14start those changes, and believing the kids who were lying about the changes in
- 1:18:17some cases, not to mention all the other topics like religion and figuring out
- 1:18:24deeper meaning in life for the first time. The film covers a lot of
- 1:18:27ground and does so well. Abby writer and Forreston Fortson does a great job
- 1:18:32as Margaret, and to make us all feel old, Heath Ledger has been
- 1:18:39dead longer than she's been alive. That's an interesting that's a weird choice to
- 1:18:45place us in time. Well, we have talked a lot about Heath Ledger
- 1:18:49and some of our previous episodes on Special Well, I mean ten things I
- 1:18:56hate about you? Okay, okay, all right, way to bring it
- 1:18:59back home. But you're done in two thousand and seven, right. And
- 1:19:01she was born in twenty eighteen March fourteenth, almost on the same birthday,
- 1:19:06not twenty eight she can't have been born in twenty ye two thousand and eight.
- 1:19:12She was an aunt man in the walkure three year old I've ever seen
- 1:19:21like six. She even beats Alex who let oh. Speaking of the topic
- 1:19:28of God, Alex is very like he has his opinions and it's hard to
- 1:19:32change them, which we're working on, not like to stifle him, but
- 1:19:35like, you know, some things that you know, I'm like, you're
- 1:19:39just you're you're you're incorrect, um and you know you're you're gonna go to
- 1:19:43school and people, you know, not like like the equivalent of like the
- 1:19:45earth is flat kind of stuff, you know, like five year old stuff
- 1:19:48where I'm like, you're wrong, but okay, good for you for thinking
- 1:19:53of this through. But one of the thing is he is convinced that God,
- 1:19:57even though we go to church a few time times a year, right,
- 1:20:00like very infrequently, but he's convinced that God is a woman. And
- 1:20:05he will fuck him. He's not wrong about that. He will throw down.
- 1:20:10He will He had a fight with my mom and at Good Friday Mass.
- 1:20:16During Good Friday Mass, I believe they're about over whether or not God
- 1:20:23was a boy or a girl. And he kept insisting God is a girl.
- 1:20:27And then I was like, no, God's a boy, and he
- 1:20:30was like, no, God is not a boy. God is a girl.
- 1:20:32And my children yesterday morning were fighting about whether God was a boy or
- 1:20:39a girl at the breakfast table, and it was so earnest and cute that
- 1:20:44I didn't say anything. And then finally I stepped in and it was just
- 1:20:48like and I hadn't even read or seen the movie yet because it's happened before
- 1:20:53both of those, but like I was like, guys, God is in
- 1:20:56your heart and it can be a boy or girl or turtle or whatever you
- 1:21:01want, you know, your God figure to be. Like you know,
- 1:21:05I was trying to be like you're both right. I was trying to do
- 1:21:09the like you're both right kind of thing like and then you know, I
- 1:21:12give my little speech and God and Alex is like, yeah, but God
- 1:21:15is a girl. Like sure. I mean there's a lot of like progressive
- 1:21:21Protestant church churches that now say like Mother, Father, yeah, instead of
- 1:21:28prayers, instead of like you know, sort of like yeah, we don't
- 1:21:30really need you. See, Catholics can't do that because Mother would then just
- 1:21:32be the blessed Mother Mary, right, like they were already kind of covering
- 1:21:36it, but they still kind of made her like subjugate to God. They
- 1:21:40were like, we know that we probably should have two people, but like
- 1:21:43let's just make one slightly less, Like we gotta have multiple, multiple figures
- 1:21:47from people to pray to, because because they're coming from polytheistic religion, right,
- 1:21:54it's like they want to you know, put arms on top of their
- 1:21:58right to throw on a few saints and give them things that they understand the
- 1:22:01things. Right, It's like, yeah, yeah, exactly, like they
- 1:22:09keep that one. Like they hit like the year one hundred a D and
- 1:22:13they were like or or BC or CE whatever it's called now. They hit
- 1:22:16like year one hundred and they like had a focus group and they were like,
- 1:22:19how do you feel about like just having God as a man and you
- 1:22:24know, God's character working. Somebody was just like what and they were like,
- 1:22:28what if you worshiped his mother? Better? Worse? I was trying
- 1:22:33to think about it, you know, and then you know, because think
- 1:22:35about it because you know, the focus group was like you know, ninety
- 1:22:39nine percent men. They were like, but she could be a virgin bride
- 1:22:44and they were all like, we're in there, and they were so lazy.
- 1:22:53They're like, we'll call them all Mary whatever, you know, and
- 1:22:59if we were at a Mary, we're gonna call them all the rest of
- 1:23:01them Teresa. Anyway, so sorry, um oh wait, wait you want
- 1:23:11she's supposed to suckle him. That's like a thing, Okay, because that's
- 1:23:14there were sculptures of that in Egyptian religions. Okay, we'll just we'll take
- 1:23:20that wholesale and make it a we Actually, it is kind of crazy when
- 1:23:26you like look into the history of religions and how everything kind of borrowed from
- 1:23:30everything else, some more than others. But yes, yeah, but like
- 1:23:34because she Annity walked in and they're like, there's this whole established religion called
- 1:23:39Judaism. We're gonna take their book. We're just gonna like add some chapters
- 1:23:44and and divilify them and call it a day. And they remember, we're
- 1:23:47gonna cancel a bunch of the first books, but we're all dancing. It's
- 1:23:58like you take the part right and you flip it and you reinvented and it's
- 1:24:02a whole. Yeah. And then modern day evangelicalism was like we're gonna take
- 1:24:09the parts we like we're going to cancel the We're gonna cancel the whole Jesus
- 1:24:12was a good person thing. We're going to keep the part of that hated
- 1:24:15everybody. He wanted to smite everybody. Yes, and you know Merca,
- 1:24:18so we gotta put that in there. Yes, that part in there.
- 1:24:23Jesus wasn't big on like countries and been like, you know, nationalism,
- 1:24:27but that's fine for Jesus also wasn't really big on a lot of things that
- 1:24:31Christians do nowadays. Jesus was not big on capitalism. Give away your possessions.
- 1:24:41We're judging that was like a whole ass commandment sermon thing. Yeah,
- 1:24:45but you know some of them you wouldn't se me lose um anyway. Sorry,
- 1:24:51Matthew, Sorry, sorry, continues Well, I'll get it back to
- 1:25:00religion, he said, Yeah, not to mention all the other topics like
- 1:25:01religion of figuring out you remaining life for the first time, which is I
- 1:25:04think what brittles down this tangent Colin German Craig brings the book and it's straightforward,
- 1:25:12compassionate and non patronizing ideas to life. Any issues I have far more
- 1:25:15into nitpicks. I can definitely see Amanda showing this film and giving this book
- 1:25:19to Eden, and also call it Colleen Judana's same with her sons to help
- 1:25:23him understand. I'm going to read it to them. Those are both things.
- 1:25:30I also recommend the documentary, but I'm sure Sandy probably talked about that,
- 1:25:33and I'm late for the eight thirty deadline. Hey, Colin talked about
- 1:25:38it too, because she actually finished it, Judy Bloom, but I will
- 1:25:42be finishing it. But you got to the Pat Buchanan parts. You're really
- 1:25:45close exactly. Yeah, Judy Bloom just seems like a genuinely good person,
- 1:25:49and it makes her filming at the mouth critics, including a classically trained ship
- 1:25:56Pat you kid, all the more ridiculous. It'd be like calling mister Rogers
- 1:26:03an asshole. It is too by the film is underperforming at the box office.
- 1:26:09I don't like anything that's not a Marvel movie is probably underperforming at the
- 1:26:14box office. Even the Marvel movies are underperforming. Guardians isn't, but um
- 1:26:19Aunt Man underperformed well. To be fair, it cost me like almost forty
- 1:26:26fifty dollars to go to the movie, so whatever argues several people's tickets because
- 1:26:33like you know, I had to get the Bugi popcorn and I had to
- 1:26:35get well you do, and you know it was it was life choices again.
- 1:26:41I don't need to condemn myself here. I didn't go to I went.
- 1:26:44I went to Nighthawk, which is like the Brooklyn's version of Alamo.
- 1:26:47Okay, because Alamo does that gee butter and it is worth the calories and
- 1:26:53the price. I know, I know, Alamo popcorn. Nighthawk is even
- 1:26:58better. Everybody else in the world, but Nighthawk popcorn. Man, I'm
- 1:27:04so jealous right now. It's so good. It's so good. Next time
- 1:27:08you come visit, Well, we'll go see a movie. Oh yes,
- 1:27:10let's do that. Okay, I'm gonna meet myself because just wants to finish.
- 1:27:14We're getting late. I gotta go to bed. Yeah, to get
- 1:27:16up extra early tomorrow. Okay, choking uts are coming out during a busy
- 1:27:23time. Not to mention some people may still be reluctant to go back to
- 1:27:25the movies. I hope it finds the audience it deserves to have. See.
- 1:27:29I can like a female coming of age movie. Now, this is
- 1:27:31where I would bring up some problematic part of the movie or some weird fact,
- 1:27:35but directly, I don't have much. Benny Safti, Margaret's dad,
- 1:27:41is one of the filmmakers with his brother behind Good Time and Uncut Gems,
- 1:27:46and one of the producers has been facing some accusations. But that's it.
- 1:27:50Some people got all upset because Rachel McAdams did a photo shoot with hair under
- 1:27:56her arms, and I'm sure I can guess that youth would give them a
- 1:28:00big old fuck you in the face. Yeah, yeah, I'm sure some
- 1:28:04of those guys would gladly have her put them in a headlock, assuming she
- 1:28:09gave that Ponds gun the time of day. I'm related to this, but
- 1:28:15I totally forgot during the N and T Talk two months ago to mention Melanie
- 1:28:18Griffith. Griffith's mom, Tippy Hadron, and her husband were into some Tiger
- 1:28:26king shit in the seventies, even filming a movie with actual lines of tigers
- 1:28:29who attacked the cass and crew regularly. But that's a story for another time.
- 1:28:32Oh my god, whoa. And that's where he leaves it, Matt,
- 1:28:39Just like random time, that's actually like a Tiger King an episode where
- 1:28:44literally the escalating Yeah, well, I'm glad that we basically did you guys
- 1:28:54all feel like I actually did think that a lot of this movie had now
- 1:28:58and then vibes. Oh, I don't know if I made that connection,
- 1:29:00but I don't like just I don't disagree with the assessment. I just I
- 1:29:04don't think I made that connection myself. I felt like it had that same
- 1:29:06like kind of filter. It opens up with like them doing the summer camp
- 1:29:11stuff, and yeah, there's certainly some real nostalgia and it matches at toe
- 1:29:15for toe with like the sweet sweet soundtrack. Oh yes, yes really really
- 1:29:20some like great uh bops. It doesn't have a teenage Brandon Frasier though it
- 1:29:28does not, so it does have that against it. No, no film
- 1:29:33is perfect. Yeah you do. Yeah, yeah, Thank you so much,
- 1:29:38though, Matt for that email. I think we answered a lot of
- 1:29:40it as we went along, much to shandy chagrin. Thank you though.
- 1:29:47I'm glad you uh I gad you enjoyed the movie. Okay, all right,
- 1:29:53well we got one more email from our dear friend Mandy are you there
- 1:29:58dot dot dot? I read are you there God as a preteen, I
- 1:30:01remember highlights of it, so decided to reread before seeing the movie. I
- 1:30:05reread it a couple of weeks before the movie and got Maddie now thirteen as
- 1:30:11of last weekend, Happy Birthday. Maddie her own copy to read before seeing
- 1:30:15it. She got through chapter five. She says she will finish it,
- 1:30:19but was okay to see the movie the book. Hey, as I'm telling
- 1:30:24you, reading half the book, seeing the movie and then finishing the book
- 1:30:27is the way to go. But that's just me. The book in the
- 1:30:30movie, We're delightful. I loved the relationship between Margaret and Sylvia. Yes,
- 1:30:36agreed. I thought the mom character was much better in the movie.
- 1:30:41Agreed. I could see moving to a new town and wanting to join all
- 1:30:45the PTA committees, only to then regret it when making ten thousand Stars.
- 1:30:51Yeah, that was probably the one thing that, like, I sort of
- 1:30:54get the character, like building of the character, but I feel like that
- 1:30:58the star storyline just really kind of like unnecessary. I could have done without
- 1:31:02it and like not missed it. I think that it actually went to show
- 1:31:06her motivation at the end where she was like, you know, I would
- 1:31:11love to, but I guess I want to. Yeah, agreed. I
- 1:31:15don't know if I gave her something to do during the scenes where it was
- 1:31:18like developing her character better than that, Like yeah, like it was fine,
- 1:31:24it didn't bother me, but like I didn't need it. Yeah.
- 1:31:27Seeing how they kept true to the book with Margaret trying out different religions on
- 1:31:30her own was great. If I was her, I would have picked to
- 1:31:34go with Janey every week. Yeah, I probably would have too. Seeing
- 1:31:39the movie with Maddie was so wonderful. She and I both laughed so much
- 1:31:44at though we must, we must, we must increase our busts, which
- 1:31:46was exactly like I always imagined it. Yeah, Yeah, that that felt
- 1:31:50pretty on point. Randomly she'll start doing it and I and only I get
- 1:31:58the reference. Love that for you guys. Maddie does disagree about the girls
- 1:32:03wishing wishing for their periods. She would be happy. She happy to never
- 1:32:10have gotten hers. I'm sure I could go on and on, but my
- 1:32:14words would most likely have already been said by one of you three in the
- 1:32:17past hour or hour and a half, two hours. Who's who's keeping track
- 1:32:21anymore? So? My last note is Nancy is a bitch o. What
- 1:32:30a sentiment to go out on. I feel like we're in stranger things with
- 1:32:36all this Nancy talk like Nancy Wheeler, Like, isn't that like the character
- 1:32:43in Stranger Lens? Yes, isn't she Nancy Wheeler? Is this one Nancy
- 1:32:47Wheeler? Yeah, that's her last name? Yes, Holy shit, I
- 1:32:53think Shanny and I both just took the Google. We were like old school
- 1:32:58Google. I will double check. I love how I really emphatically said that.
- 1:33:02No. I'm like, wait, Nancy Wheeler is definitely no, it's
- 1:33:06Nancy. Holy shit, They're both Nancy Wheeler. Wow, whoa wow?
- 1:33:15Because that was my point of reference. I was like, like, Stranger
- 1:33:18Things, Wow, do you think the Deafer brothers read this book and new?
- 1:33:23Why is nobody pointed this out until now? Why have we gotten like
- 1:33:27eight years into Stranger Things and not recognize this until right now? Well?
- 1:33:33You know what, here's what I would say to Mandy Um, Nancy Wheeler
- 1:33:38gets better apparently, you know yep, yeah, you know. So does
- 1:33:44that mean Gretchen or Nan or Margaret or Janey or Barb oh is totally barb?
- 1:33:54Yeah, Gretchen's a barb. That's a yeah. Thanks many anyway,
- 1:34:00thank you so much, Maddie. I am excited to hear what happens.
- 1:34:03What Maddie thinks when she finishes reading the book, so you have a couple
- 1:34:10of weeks to let her finish it in and let us know. All right.
- 1:34:13On that note, everyone, thank you so much for listening. Thanks
- 1:34:16for all the feedback. We're very excited to talk about this, as you
- 1:34:21can tell. Thank you all so much. Thank you to the patrons,
- 1:34:24especially the ones that contribute a certain level that we Eckartrigner, Maggie the Magnificent,
- 1:34:28Joanna, the Plan and Ed the creepeople we had Milan. If you
- 1:34:30have any feedback, the broadcasters three atmail dot com. It's a call three
- 1:34:33through one, two seven and six, two three seventy three. We would
- 1:34:36love I feel like I speak for everyone when I say we would love to
- 1:34:41talk about this more so we as of right now, and you'll hear this,
- 1:34:47you know, in the next week's episode maybe where we do not have
- 1:34:53an announcement for what we were going to talk about in June, so I
- 1:34:57don't know, we may take June off, that may be a to be
- 1:35:00continued. But I feel like something always pops up, something always pops up
- 1:35:05exactly. I want to watch y'allow jackets regardless. I hope. I think,
- 1:35:10yeah, it's just not a show that can be rushed. I feel
- 1:35:12like if we all try and binge through it, it's just not going to
- 1:35:15be good for anybody's mental health. That's a good point anyway. All right,
- 1:35:18thanks though, everybody for that. Thank you Shandy for staying up late.
- 1:35:23I have a great trip, both of you and I can. I'll
- 1:35:28miss you and I will see you all in June. It's gonna be great.
- 1:35:34It be great. It's like we're all going it's like we're going away
- 1:35:38to summer camp and we're gonna come back and we're gonna hear about everybody's h
- 1:35:43summers. I wonder who's going to send a postcard saying they got it?
- 1:35:47Okay, I hope it's me. Yeah. No, seriously, though,
- 1:35:53you guys better send me postcards saying I got it. That's all you have
- 1:35:59to all right. On that note, everybody, well, thank you so
- 1:36:01much. We will see you soon. On that note, my name is
- 1:36:05Colleen, my name is Amanda, and everybody by