Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 28
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the podcast where we discuss anything and everything criminal. I'm your host
- 0:05Jordan Lee. On today's episode, we are going to delve into the case
- 0:08of Marian Carver. What happened to Marian Carver? Marian Carver, forty,
- 0:12went missing on a seven day Royal Caribbean cruise from Seattle to Alaska in August
- 0:16two thousand and four. Her ship Steward was the last person to see her.
- 0:20He reported her missing several times, and his boss instructed him to forget
- 0:24about it and go on with your job. This case involves NDAs, private
- 0:28investigators and a lot of cruise line negligence. Many people assumed she committed suicide,
- 0:33while others say she was murdered or fell overboard. But what happened to
- 0:36Marian Carver leaves us with more questions than answers. M R R I A
- 0:40and Carver. Marian Carver was born in Cambridge, Massachusetts, on April third,
- 0:45nineteen sixty four. She was a former banker who enjoyed writing and traveling.
- 0:49Her father describes her as an overachiever, a sensitive person who was always
- 0:53traveling, and a very adventurous person. Marian is forty years old divorced and
- 0:58lives alone. At this time. She and her ex husband share a thirteen
- 1:00year old daughter who is spending the summer in England with her father. Marian
- 1:04and her daughter checking on each other at least once a day. CRUs She
- 1:07boarded a plane from Boston to Seattle, Washington, on August twenty seventh,
- 1:11two thousand and four. She doesn't tell anyone where she's going or what she's
- 1:15doing. She simply packs her belongings and departs. She didn't tell her family
- 1:19where she was going, but it wasn't the craziest thing she'd done. Marian
- 1:23decides to embark on her own cruise. She boards the Royal Caribbean Celebrity Mercury
- 1:26Cruise ship in Seattle, bound for Alaska, but crew she boards has twelve
- 1:30decks in a capacity of two thousand passengers. This wasn't her first cruise either.
- 1:36She was staying on the ninth floor with a panoramic deck view. While
- 1:38Marian is on board, there is a party going on, complete with people,
- 1:42drinks, and music. Her sense of security is enhanced because she is
- 1:46alone. She doesn't approach any one on the ship and strike up a conversation
- 1:49with them. But people do approach her and talk to her. She returns
- 1:53to her cabin to write in her journal when the ship's steward enters, and
- 1:56the reason is that she had asked for some towels earlier that evening, which
- 2:00he had provided. Strangely, the doors lock electronically and there are no safety
- 2:04latches or deadbolts to hold the door shut. That is something that Marian is
- 2:07frightened of. Marian spends the following day on the ship, riding and roaming
- 2:10around. Her daughter had attempted to reach her the night before, but there
- 2:15was no cellular reception. Marian decides to stay in her room and read a
- 2:17book that night because there is a party going on. On the second day.
- 2:22I sat around eight to eight thirty p m. The ship steward enters
- 2:24her room, and when I say walk into her room, I mean it
- 2:28literally because there is no lock, and there was a formal taking place at
- 2:30the moment and practically everyone on board attended. He apologized for entering the room
- 2:36and asked Marian whether she was going to the formal, to which she replied
- 2:39that she was not. Marian apparently asked the ship's steward if he could assist
- 2:43her in ordering room's service. Marian's parents hired a private investigator who stated that
- 2:49he does not understand the relevance of her room's service order, in which she
- 2:52orders two sandwiches rather than one. That's hardly the strangest thing. Perhaps she
- 2:57hadn't eaten all day and ordered the sandwich for herself, but a part of
- 3:00you also wonders whether she did eat and got two sandwiches to share with another
- 3:04person. Marian offers the steward a tip, but he declines, claiming that
- 3:07it is his duty to serve her. She finishes her meal, places the
- 3:10dish on the floor outside the room, and puts some money aside for the
- 3:14steward, which she will give to him in the morning before going to bed.
- 3:16That is, if she was going to give him the tip the next
- 3:20morning. She was intending on seeing him again the next morning. The steward
- 3:23arrives the next morning, takes the dishes Marian left, find she isn't in
- 3:28her room, and has no contact with her. That morning, the cabin
- 3:30steward searches the ship but is unsuccessful in finding her. He becomes concerned since
- 3:35she is nowhere to be found and goes to his supervisor's office to inform him
- 3:38that someone is missing. The supervisor calls the ship's stewards to his office and
- 3:43asks them to sign a non disclosure agreement, which is quite troubling if you
- 3:46don't know what an endia is. It's a legally binding contract that ensures confidentiality
- 3:51between two parties. It basically says that after you sign this, you will
- 3:54stop talking investigation. Marian's father added that they have emails revealing the process of
- 4:00covering up her disappearance. In an email, there was someone asking did you
- 4:03check her on board account? Did she make any purchases? They answered no,
- 4:08there were no purchases. Can I have her Sea pass data and photo,
- 4:11which they said they already sent just to know who they are looking for
- 4:14and when she got on the crews? Have you checked the security cameras the
- 4:17security is looking into it, they said. It's been a week since Marian's
- 4:21daughter has heard from her, and she is concerned. She calls Marian's father
- 4:25and informs him that she is unable to contact her mother. So Marian's father,
- 4:29Ken tries to call Marian, but nothing comes through. He rings her
- 4:31apartment landline phone, but no one answers. They contact Cambridge Police and file
- 4:36a missing person's report. So the police go to Marian's residence to investigate,
- 4:41and when they arrive they look for traces of a break in. Nothing seemed
- 4:45unusual, so they take her laptop and some of her belongings to examine.
- 4:48They ask her neighbors whether they have seen or heard anything from her, but
- 4:51no one knows where she is. Back on board, the crews claims operation
- 4:56manager and hotel operations managers meet with the supervisor and the steward wishes to approach
- 5:00the manager and explain what occurred. The steward returns to the room to double
- 5:04check everything. Nothing has changed. When he returns, the tip money is
- 5:09still there. The steward informs his boss that Marian is not in her room,
- 5:12and for each day that Marian is gone, he informs his supervisor,
- 5:15and the supervisor instructs the steward just forget about it and do your job.
- 5:19Marian's bed is made by the steward, who also leaves chocolate and flowers on
- 5:24her bed. The private investigator stated that because she was on the ninth floor,
- 5:27if you took the elevator and went two floors up. She'd be on
- 5:30the deck and near the ship's edge, and if you took the elevator from
- 5:32the ninth to the sixth floor, the first thing you'd see is the deck
- 5:35in the edge of the ship, and you might easily be pushed overboard or
- 5:39fall, especially if it's early in the morning when no one is awake and
- 5:43strolling around. Marian's parents begged the FBI to help three weeks after her disappearance,
- 5:47and they continue to call the Cambridge Police, but nothing happens. Police
- 5:50were able to access Marian's bank account and discover that she had purchased a ticket
- 5:55for an Alaska cruise. Ken Carver contacts the cruise ship and inquires about Marian's
- 6:00whereabouts. He is told, yes, she was on the cruise, but
- 6:02they have no idea if she got off the cruise. Is there any surveillance
- 6:06footage of Marion on the cruise? Ken ask no, there is no video.
- 6:11It's been three weeks, so it's been a raced they claimed. Ken
- 6:14contacts a private investigator because the FBI and Cambridge Police have no jurisdiction over the
- 6:18cruise ship. October two thousand and four, Tim the private investigator arrives on
- 6:24the ship two months after Marian's disappearance and talks with the claims manager, but
- 6:28he also wanted to speak with the cabin attendant, who was apparently unavailable,
- 6:31and on another ship, he was also informed that the supervisor was unavailable.
- 6:35The only person you actually need to talk to is me, because I have
- 6:39all the essential information, the guest claim representative said. While on the ship,
- 6:43Tim discovers that the windows on Marian's floor, the ninth floor with the
- 6:46panoramic view, are latched and bolted, making it impossible to open the windows.
- 6:50He asked about viewing the security cameras. They also inform him that the
- 6:55footage is deleted every two weeks. Tim requests to speak with the security officer,
- 7:00but they refuse because they are training new employees and Tim has more questions
- 7:02than answers. Ja and Utwolf thousand five pasos. Ken hires lawyers from both
- 7:08Massachusetts and Florida in January two thousand and five, and after months of hard
- 7:13effort, they are able to obtain subpoenas for the cruise ship crew. In
- 7:15a telephone deposition, two cruise line stewards testify and Ken finds that they were
- 7:20aware of Marian's abduction but did nothing about it. The cabin steward, who
- 7:25spent the most time with Marian, recalls seeing her on the first day of
- 7:28the cruise and discovering she was missing two days later. He reports it to
- 7:31his supervisor several times, and the supervisor tells him to do your job.
- 7:35The steward approaches the supervisor and asks, what shall I do with her belongings?
- 7:40Put it in a bag and put it in a locker. The supervisor
- 7:43replied, they got rid of everything she owned. The captain, staff,
- 7:46captain, and hotel director all have keys to all the rooms and can enter
- 7:49anyone's room. If the top three persons on board have access to all of
- 7:54the keys, it's quite likely that someone else has access to the keys as
- 7:57well. An example, if you are close to the cap he may grant
- 8:00you access to all of the keys on board, the keys might be in
- 8:03the hands of any one on board. A second deposition is scheduled with the
- 8:07ship's manager of hotel operations. The manager stated that despite the fact that no
- 8:11one on the ship acknowledged Marion's disappearance, the cruise line company launched its own
- 8:16internal inquiry and fired the steward's supervisor for failing to disclose Marian's disappearance. The
- 8:22investigation began at the end of September when a Cambridge investigator contacted the cruise operator
- 8:26and asked if Marian could be reported missing. However, no one on the
- 8:30ship reported a missing person. Instead, five weeks after Marion's disappearance, the
- 8:35cruise line filed a missing person report with the FBI, but the FBI is
- 8:39unable to conduct an investigation because it has no authority over the cruise ship.
- 8:43Ken Carver chooses to write to the cruise line's chairman and board of directors expressing
- 8:48his need for answers and closure over what happened to his daughter. A month
- 8:50later, he receives a copy of the security report. The report, that
- 8:54was filed on September thirtieth and written by the manager of Security, noted that
- 8:58company regulation had been violated and that the ship's captain, the security office,
- 9:03and the ship's captain should have been notified the second Marian vanished. According to
- 9:07the report, Marian's possessions should not have been relocated, and evidence discovered at
- 9:11the scene of the incident should be left alone. According to the report.
- 9:15The ship's security personnel must also protect the site and safeguard the integrity of the
- 9:18incident scene, ensuring that nothing has moved or interfered with until outside investigators reach
- 9:24on board. After mass, Ken Carver clears out Marian's apartment, donating some
- 9:28belongings to charity and keeping the truly personal items for the family. Ken Carver
- 9:33continues to contact the Coastguard, police and the FBI asking for an update.
- 9:37In addition, his lawyers contact them on a daily basis asking the same question.
- 9:43Ken files a lawsuit against the cruise Line for being careless and negligent.
- 9:46The legal struggle becomes public in August two thousand and five, and the cruise
- 9:50line makes a statement declaring marian debt. They told Ken that they checked the
- 9:54footage, which they claimed had been removed since the start of the investigation,
- 9:58and that after watching, she jumped overboard. The letter from the cruise Line
- 10:01set ms Carver had serve emotional problems and had attempted suicide before, and appears
- 10:07to have committed suicide on our ship. The death of Marrying Carver is a
- 10:11horrible tragedy, but regrettable. There is very little a cruise line, a
- 10:15resort, or a hotel can do to prevent someone from committing suicide. This
- 10:18appears strange, since how can they write this and imply that someone they don't
- 10:22know has mental problems and how do they know she attempted suicide before Ken Carver
- 10:26stated that if it was a suicide, show us evidence rather than simply writing
- 10:30it off as a suicide for the sake of closing a case and hoping that
- 10:33the family will accept that conclusion. Ken stated that there is an issue with
- 10:37the cruising industry because so many individuals have gone missing while on cruises and no
- 10:41one knows what happened to them. He contacts four families and together they form
- 10:46the International Cruise Victims, whose mission is to penalize corporations that choose to operate
- 10:50outside the law and fail to take necessary action when crimes occur. They have
- 10:54victims of sexual assault, debts, missing individuals, overboard events, assaults and
- 11:00accidents, and other crimes. They have all of the victims faces and names
- 11:03on their websites. Their main purposes to increase public awareness of the potential risks
- 11:07as well as the rights and protections passengers are relinquishing to travel on a cruise
- 11:11ship to provide support for passengers who have been the victims of crime, violence,
- 11:16negligence, or other tragedies while on a cruise voyage. They also provide
- 11:20constantly updated cruise ship news, and a podcast called the ICV Podcast will be
- 11:26available soon. International Cruise Victims was created on January first, two thousand and
- 11:31six, by four families who had lost loved ones on a cruise ship.
- 11:35They have an increasing number of individuals from nineteen nations sharing their stories as of
- 11:39January first, twenty fourteen. In twenty fifteen, a decade after Marion's disappearance,
- 11:43Senator Blumenthal of Connecticut and Senator Marquis of Massachusetts introduced the Cruise Passenger Protection
- 11:48Act of twenty fifteen, ensuring that improvements have been implemented since cruise lines have
- 11:54been held accountable for reporting crimes and crime prevention on the seas. Ken Carver
- 11:58received the Ronald Regan Public Policy Award on April seventh, twenty seventeen, for
- 12:03public policy leadership, vision and innovation that benefits crime victims. The way they
- 12:07handled the case suggests that they are concealing something. I don't think someone by
- 12:11someone, I mean a company would conceal suicide, but I do believe someone
- 12:16would conceal murder by claiming it was a suicide. Whatever happened was a tragedy
- 12:20in any case, and we now have more questions than answers. I admire
- 12:22Ken Carver for fighting for answers about what happened to his daughter, exposing the
- 12:26Cruise Line for not investigating, and opening our eyes to the fact that this
- 12:31happens much too frequently. Ken Carver is a hero who fought until the very
- 12:35end for his daughter. Ken Carver died on December thirtieth, twenty nineteen.
- 12:39He'll never know what happened to his daughter, but they're both in a better
- 12:41place. Now. That's all for this episode. Please don't forget to like
- 12:46and subscribe so you never miss an episode. If you'd like to support the
- 12:48channel, you can go to pad Arion www dot Patyrion dot com, Forward
- 12:54slash Forever Haunted podcast dot com. By joining our pata rihon you will get
- 12:58access to bonus episodes monthly, as well as a free book of creepy stories.
- 13:03Once a month, I will draw names from the pad rons and select
- 13:05winners for free bookmarks as well as signed paperback copies of creepy stories, so
- 13:09don't forget to sign up. It only costs two dollars. Thanks for tuning
- 13:13into today's darkness. I hope to see you on the next chilling episode.