Latest / Worderella Reads with Belinda Kroll / 17 | The Other Bennet Sister & gently wanting what you shouldn’t
Transcript
- So I watched The Other Bennett Sister, thanks to a friend who let me camp on her couch for two nights because I do not have the streaming network that it's currently being distributed.
- And I'm going to pretend like you asked me what I thought of it, because it's a great question.
- Let me tell you, I have thoughts, and they are not small ones.
- All right.
- So I went in expecting a nice, solid Austen spinoff.
- Mary Bennett gets her turn.
- Good for her.
- I'll clap politely.
- But what I did not expect was to end up chest-deep in feelings about a fictional lawyer with glasses.
- But here we are Now, if you've read Haunting of Mistwood, you clearly know I somehow have a thing for fictional lawyers from 19th century England, but that's beside the point.
- Back to The Other Bennett Sister.
- The thing I think that almost lost me was actually the pacing in the middle.
- Mary's London section takes a while, and if you're used to romance where we have a meet cute by, like, minute 10, you get kind of squirmy.
- This is more like a true Jane Austen in that we don't meet our hero for a while.
- And it's, it's on purpose.
- That slowness is doing something, and I'm gonna get to that in a second.
- But, I will say that my patience was a little tested.
- By episode six, I had pulled out my iPad thinking, "Oh, this would be a great time to draw the, summer character art drop for my patrons," while the show played behind me because honestly, episodes one through five, kind of turned me off a little bit.
- But of course, episode six is when it got good, and so then I sat there with my iPad just sitting on the coffee table.
- I will say, I don't think this mini series needed 10 episodes.
- I think it could have gotten away with eight if you had, consolidated some of those first five into, two or three or something.
- So anyway, something else that really bothered me actually was how they portrayed Mrs.
- Bennet.
- I haven't read the book, so maybe this is accurate to the book, in which case I take issue with the book as well, because this version has Mrs.
- Bennet being, like, outright mean and cruel to Mary, not just, careless or full of herself the way Pride and Prejudice book Mrs Bennet is.
- And it was like, it was just layered really heavily, and it, it just made it difficult to suspend my disbelief, honestly.
- Mrs.
- Bennet being embarrassing, self-absorbed, oblivious.
- I wouldn't even call her self-absorbed because she is obsessed with getting her daughters married, and that's as much for their benefit as hers, so she's just single-minded.
- I wouldn't even call her self-absorbed.
- But this show kind of pushes her into something a bit meaner, and it honestly took away from some of the warmth I was expecting to get out of The Other Bennett Sister, so that's the only reason why I bring it up.
- So big picture, it is a romance.
- So the setup is, um, blahdy, blahdy, blah, things happen.
- Mary ends up living with the Gardiners in London.
- I'm not gonna say things 'cause I don't wanna completely spoil the series for you.
- But Mary is in London.
- She meets Tom Hayward.
- He is a lawyer.
- He loves poetry.
- He wears glasses, and nobody makes a big deal out of any of this because this is just who he is.
- He is a close friend of the Gardiner's family.
- He shows up, surprises Mary with his warmth.
- And, you think, "Oh, this will be great."
- Except Tom Has an understanding with a woman, named Anne Baxter.
- So an understanding back in the day was kind of like saying they were dating, right? They're not engaged, but they have an understanding.
- So, he's off limits until if and when his Anne Baxter decides to toss him, and that's kind of worse because nothing's official, nothing is closed, but everyone acts like, "Oh, yeah, well, they're gonna end up married anyway."
- So this becomes one of the main conflicts, which is that Mary starts to like Tom, and she feels bad about it because she also really likes Anne, and Anne is really kind to her and, helps her come out of her shell.
- And, both Tom and Anne are, like, good friends to her.
- So Mary understandably feels a bit guilty that she likes Tom maybe more than she should.
- So this is the part that I found really interesting is that this is not a normal love triangle.
- A normal love triangle would ask "Oh, who is she gonna choose?" But this one actually is a it's a meaner question for our character to have to deal with, which is, is there even a point to wanting this? Which I feel is so relatable in the real world, you know? It's, it's not quite unrequited love, but it's close, right? It's this, gosh, I really, I really want this job.
- I've put so much energy into improving my skills and getting the education and, you know, this, that, and the other, but there's a good chance that this just isn't gonna happen.
- And so is it even worth me putting energy into this? Am I just setting myself up for disappointment, right? That's kinda what this is.
- So that question doesn't go away, from scene to scene the way, jealousy can, go in waves with a story.
- This question sits there the whole time.
- And you're not waiting to see who wins, you're waiting to see if the wanting something was ever really, allowed in the first place.
- I will say then the back half of the series does something I really didn't see coming.
- I mean, Bookstagram kinda hinted at it because, everyone loves a good hand flex, and it's really easy to, just pick the scene snippets, where it clearly feels like a love triangle.
- So the back half does have a love triangle, but it's still not the way you would think it is.
- It is two men bickering over Mary, but Mary is,, literally confused because she only has feelings for one of them.
- And the other guy she just likes as a person.
- She's flattered that he seems delighted she's witty.
- He likes her sharp tongue, thinks it's a good thing instead of something to manage the way Mrs.
- Bennet has been trying to do her entire life, which is sweet.
- Right? It's sweet and it builds like a platonic love, I think, for Mary, but it's not romantic.
- And Mary knows the difference the whole time.
- The men clearly do not.
- So they are bickering and having some pretty, pretty funny interactions, for no reason because Mary is just living her life and being like, "These two doofuses."
- That being said, I do wanna dedicate some time to Tom, Mr.
- Tom Hayward, because he's not angsty.
- Like even through all of this sort of, trying to seek Mary's attention and/or redirect her attention away from the other guy, he's not moody about it.
- He doesn't like brood by a window.
- He doesn't, he's not giving some big speech about duty and honor while staring off in the middle distance.
- He's just kind.
- He's just a kind guy all the time, even when it's not gonna help him, and nobody's watching, and like it doesn't, ensure that he's gonna get a reward for being kind.
- And to be clear, like this is not a calculation.
- Like literally, this is Tom.
- He's a close friend of the Gardiners.
- He's warm with Mary because he's just warm with everybody, and it's not his fault that she falls for him.
- I actually know a couple guys like this in real life.
- They're genuinely nice.
- They have no agenda.
- They have no idea that just being steady and kind is enough to make someone fall in love with you because the options are slim on the ground, okay? It's hard to find a person who is steady and kind and matches your weird.
- So I can totally see how Mary would fall for this guy, not meaning to.
- Tom would exhibit things that would make her fall for him without him meaning to.
- And, and thus, this is our conflict because we still have Anne Baxter in the picture.
- But I think this makes, this is where we get this really interesting switch.
- He's more than just a nice guy caught in a misunderstanding, right? He's not just accidentally misleading Mary.
- Um, spoiler, spoiler, spoiler alert, if you have not seen The Other Bennet Sister, do not listen for the next couple of minutes because I will be saying things that you will probably have figured out, but, just, it...
- Just don't, don't listen for a bit, okay? Are you ready? Okay.
- So Anne Baxter leaves Tom for a richer man.
- He, Tom, by this point in the story, has basically already been told he isn't enough if he doesn't get more money.
- So when he finds out that someone with real money has an interest in Mary, he backs off even though he has m- admitted to himself that he likes her because he knows that he's already gonna lose.
- And not because he's noble, because he's been taught to not bother trying.
- So again, it's is there any point in wanting this? That's the question.
- Are you going to be brave and courageous enough to want the thing that you think you shouldn't want? And that's sad.
- You know, that's like a really specific hurt because it's not just like this hero steps aside for the woman he loves.
- It's a guy who's been told, "You only matter because of a number that you can give me," and, this lady acting like that's totally true.
- And then still through all of it, he never stops treating this overlooked, too plain and too serious middle sister, Mary, like he still treats Mary like she's worth his time.
- Even though technically she's kinda in the same boat he is, right? She doesn't really have a dowry to give.
- Though, yeah, so it's...
- I don't know.
- It's very in- it's way more swoon-worthy, I think, than any grand gesture would be, right? Grand gestures are easy.
- Any well-written hero can do a grand gesture.
- But being quietly kind with no audience, especially, especially if you've been told that, especially since you've been told that kindness doesn't win, that's hard.
- That is a difficult choice to make.
- And I just wanna put on the record that I'm a simple woman, and this is all it takes.
- Choose to be kind without an agenda, and be consistent about it, and show up for people.
- You'll be amazed at how that goodness will be reflected back on you, I think So underneath all of this, there is this big question.
- The fantasy is still never, which man do I end up with? The fantasy of...
- The fantasy really, the r- the romantic fantasy in this story is about being seen.
- Being seen, paid attention to, taken seriously for yourself, right? Mary going to London, separating from her mother and sisters.
- She has an opportunity to dress the way she wants to dress.
- She reads the books she wants to read.
- She goes on walks.
- She gets glasses.
- She speaks her mind.
- And in London she's considered a wit.
- It's fantastic.
- And on top of all that, being taken seriously, there's Tom, who is treating her well.
- She knows that he's a good man, but a part of her still feels like she doesn't deserve it.
- She spent her entire life being told she's the letdown.
- She's not pretty enough, she's not charming enough, she's too serious, she causes too much trouble.
- And then this genuinely kind person looks at her and treats her like she matters, and she doesn't know what to do with that.
- And honestly, in real life, I don't either, and I'm not even the one in the show.
- This is w- The way in which I relate to Mary Bennet, this instance of Mary Bennet in The Other Bennet Sister, is almost uncomfortable.
- In a good way, in a good way.
- But it's wild, you know? I think they really honed in on that experience of carrying around this narrative in your head, and then being surrounded by people who, without saying a whole lot, but showing you, are saying, "Girl, you crazy pants."
- So would I recommend The Other Bennet Sister? Yes.
- You will need to get through a slow beginning.
- You will need to, stomach a really mean Mrs.
- Bennet.
- And, but you get some really good parts, like a really nice dude talking himself out of something because he, because he wants what's best for the girl he likes.
- And that's, can you ask for more than that? I don't know.
- Not in a cozy fantasy.
- Not in a cozy fantasy romance, I don't think.
- So definitely watch The Other Bennet Sister.
- I am going to watch, Seeking Persephone soon.
- I just received the Blu-ray in the mail because I'm that person that doesn't wanna just stream things, I wanna own them.
- I'm an elder millennial, so sue me.
- Maybe I'll talk about that one, next time.
- If you would like to support me and you're not able to make it to one of my in-person events where I hand-sell books and stickers, I would love it if you could come to wordarella.com.
- That's Cinderella, but with words.
- You can buy my books there.
- I have Jane Austen-themed tote bags and shirts.
- If you're not ready to make a purchase, please join my monthly newsletter.
- or follow my Patreon,