Latest / The Vegan Report / They Fought Factory Farms. Now They Want to Run One.
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan
- 0:03and what if I told you that the best way to fight
- 0:07for animals was for animal advocates to open
- 0:11and run a factory farm? You heard me right. It
- 0:16sounds absolutely ridiculous, yet this is far
- 0:20from a joke. This is a very serious, unfolding
- 0:24plan, backed by millions of dollars in funding.
- 0:28and this will have dire implications for our
- 0:31entire movement. To discuss this topic, I have
- 0:35with me Sam Tucker Davis. Sam is a long -time
- 0:39animal rights activist, entrepreneur and technologist
- 0:42from New Zealand. He has worked in animal advocacy
- 0:45for more than two decades. He notably founded
- 0:49Open Pals, a non -profit that developed AI tools
- 0:53for more than a hundred animal advocacy organizations.
- 0:57Today he is developing Gary OS, an AI system
- 1:01designed to give individual activists the capacity
- 1:05to operate at the scale of a large organization.
- 1:09He is also the writer behind the Substack, collectively
- 1:12Gary. We discussed the psychological, economic
- 1:17and ideological reasons explaining why animal
- 1:22advocates would choose to operate a factory farm.
- 1:26The possibility that this is all a scheme for
- 1:30AI companies to infiltrate big meat. How some
- 1:34donors in our movement are funding experiments
- 1:37to make animals insensitive to pain. How high
- 1:41tech like AI will be used to make factory farming
- 1:45even more lucrative. How the meaning of labels
- 1:48like vegan and animal rights activist might shift
- 1:51in the future and much much more. To stay updated
- 1:56on the latest news on this issue, sign up for
- 2:00Sam's Substack. He is really at the forefront
- 2:03of all of this. Link in the episode notes. Share
- 2:08this episode with the vegans you know. Let's
- 2:11ring the alarm bell on this issue. Follow the
- 2:15show for more newsworthy and thought -provoking
- 2:18conversations. Leave a good review. This podcast
- 2:22is a labor of love. And your support is always
- 2:25appreciated. Thank you for tuning in every week.
- 2:29Welcome to The Vegan Report. Thank you so much
- 2:32for having accepted my invitation. Thank you
- 2:35so much for inviting me. I'm really happy to
- 2:37be here and to talk about this. Wonderful. So
- 2:40you appeared on my radar because of your substack
- 2:45article titled Factory Farming 2 .0. And I actually
- 2:51think it went viral because I would share it
- 2:53with people and then they would tell me someone
- 2:56already shared it with me. And then we would
- 2:59message each other comment on your piece. So
- 3:04what do you make of the fact that it became viral
- 3:07in the animal advocacy space? Well, I mean, I
- 3:12think, you know, the headline in itself is shocking
- 3:15enough that it seems like satire. So, you know,
- 3:20this idea of animal activists actually going
- 3:22out, buying a factory farm, not to shut it down,
- 3:26but to run it. I think, you know, you couldn't
- 3:28really make this stuff up if you tried, but unfortunately,
- 3:31this is genuinely the reality of what is happening
- 3:35in this section of the movement. When did that
- 3:40appear on your radar? So I would say a bigger
- 3:45picture sort of factory farming 2 .0 as a whole
- 3:48has been on my radar for a few years now. The
- 3:52industry has been investing in developing AI
- 3:55a lot longer than animal activists have been
- 3:58aware of it. This is something that's already
- 4:00been going on. for decades. So even before all
- 4:03of these new advances we've seen in AI with chat
- 4:06GPT and things like that, there's always been
- 4:10a huge financial incentive for these companies
- 4:13to monitor everything and to optimize for reducing
- 4:17their costs, reducing labor costs, having to
- 4:21spend less on feed. And so that's always been
- 4:25on my radar. But I think that this sort of turn
- 4:30that I've seen in the movement towards thinking,
- 4:34or parts of the movement anyway, thinking that
- 4:36this is something that we should fund, something
- 4:38that we should accelerate. That's been much more
- 4:40recent. I would say the last year or two, I've
- 4:43known that there have been sections of the movement
- 4:46that sort of want to promote this. You've seen
- 4:49it, for example, at certain conferences. Precision
- 4:53livestock farmers have been invited to speak
- 4:56at those conferences. So It's been around to
- 5:00some degree, but I think that over these last
- 5:04maybe three to six months is when you've seen
- 5:07a lot of actual resources from the movement going
- 5:11towards this. And beyond just kind of having
- 5:14someone speak at a conference, but actually towards
- 5:17funding the development of these technologies.
- 5:20So I think that's been a very recent shift. And
- 5:22it seems to me to be tied to the anticipated
- 5:26funding coming in from companies like Anthropic
- 5:30that are going to be launching their IPOs. And
- 5:33so essentially, you have a lot of the employees
- 5:36of those companies who have a lot of money in
- 5:39equity. And that's going to be now converted
- 5:41into something they can actually turn into money
- 5:44and spend. So there's been this coordinated effort
- 5:48within animal advocacy to sort of get animal
- 5:53issues as something that those donors care about.
- 5:56And it does seem to be highly correlated in that
- 6:01as this has happened and as people are expecting
- 6:04to be able to cash out on their equity within
- 6:07these coming months, that's the same time that
- 6:11we've seen this new factory farm be announced,
- 6:15Frontier Husbandry. We've seen incubators specifically
- 6:18now. saying that people don't need to be vegan.
- 6:21They don't need to even feel any emotional attachment
- 6:24to animals to start an animal charity. They're
- 6:26also saying that these charities that they incubate
- 6:31are going to look less like traditional activism,
- 6:34less like corporate campaigning, and more like
- 6:36bringing technologies to market. And at the same
- 6:39time, you have these funds coming from movement
- 6:43veterans, you know, people who started some of
- 6:45the largest organizations in the movement, that
- 6:49are now moving millions and millions of dollars.
- 6:51And I think with our spring innovation fund,
- 6:54it's up to like half a million per incubated
- 6:56company. So I would say like the hard shift has
- 7:01been the last few months, but this has been something
- 7:04that has been building for years in the background.
- 7:08So why did you decide to write about it now?
- 7:14So I've always been an outspoken opponent of
- 7:19AI in factory farms. Two years ago, I spoke about
- 7:23it at the International Animal Rights Conference
- 7:25in Luxembourg. I've, you know, debated sort of
- 7:29the pro precision livestock farming activists
- 7:32at various conferences. So it's always been something
- 7:35that's been on my radar. But most of these last
- 7:39few years, I was working, leading an organization
- 7:43called OpenPause. So we were building AI for
- 7:46the movement. And I think, you know, that really
- 7:49consumed all of my free time, essentially. So
- 7:55I kind of have talked about this theory of change
- 7:58of thinking of the future of AI and how it affects
- 8:00animals, like a game of tug of war. So you can
- 8:03imagine if you're playing tug of war, you've
- 8:05got animal activists on one side, you've got
- 8:07animal agriculture on the other. And so there's
- 8:11three ways you can kind of influence your chances
- 8:13of winning that game. You can either get more
- 8:16people on your side, start pulling with more
- 8:18strength. So that would be the equivalent of
- 8:22in the AI space, having better tools for activists.
- 8:25better education about how to use those tools
- 8:28for activism. The other way that you could influence
- 8:30your chances are weakening your opponent's grip.
- 8:34So that would be restricting the use of AI in
- 8:37factory farms, whether that's through regulations
- 8:39or whether that's through pressure campaigns.
- 8:42And then you have sort of changing the landscape.
- 8:44So it's much easier. to pull your opponent down
- 8:47a hill than it is to pull them up a hill. So
- 8:49that's about changing the overall values in the
- 8:53tech space, both in terms of the developers building
- 8:55the models, but also in terms of the actual models
- 8:58themselves. So OpenPause was largely focused
- 9:02on strengthening our sites of growth, building
- 9:04those AI tools for activists. And so recently,
- 9:10about three months ago, I left OpenPause. And
- 9:13this was around about the same time that all
- 9:16of this started happening. And so I think that,
- 9:20you know, now when OpenPause started, I think
- 9:24there wasn't really any other organization that
- 9:27was focusing on sort of building the AI capacity
- 9:31of the movement. But I think now there are other
- 9:33organizations doing that. And the field as a
- 9:36whole has started adopting AI a lot more. So
- 9:40now I think that that side of weakening our opponent's
- 9:44grip is going to become more and more important.
- 9:49I love this dog of war image. It's very helpful.
- 9:54So what happened exactly with this decision to
- 9:59take over a factory farm and run it ourselves?
- 10:05Have we looked at our opponents and thought We
- 10:08can't win this tug of war. And so why not join
- 10:11them? That's exactly what it is. So the thing
- 10:16that I've been privately talking to a lot of
- 10:21the sort of pro PLF activists about over these
- 10:23last couple of years has been this concept of
- 10:26the durability test. So I think the argument
- 10:30for PLF, the people who support this, believe
- 10:35that it's going to improve animal welfare. And
- 10:39I think that it gets categorized in the same
- 10:42kind of category as welfare reforms more generally.
- 10:45But I think that there are a lot of important
- 10:48differences here. So I think that, you know,
- 10:52Over this last maybe decade or so I think the
- 10:54movement has seen a lot more unity between these
- 10:57two camps of welfarists and abolitionists. I
- 11:00think when I was in my early days of activism
- 11:03they were very divided. But they started to come
- 11:05together a lot more because they understood that
- 11:08they both shared each other's end goal. So, welfareists,
- 11:12they wanted to see immediate improvements for
- 11:15animals, but they ultimately did still want to
- 11:18end the industries that exploit them. And abolitionists,
- 11:21they wanted to end the industry, and they also
- 11:23cared about short -term improvements and helping
- 11:28animals. You could kind of think of this like
- 11:31you have two different axes. So one is whether
- 11:34or not in the short term, you're improving or
- 11:38harming the welfare of animals that are currently
- 11:41in the system. And then you have this other axis,
- 11:44which is over the long term, are you weakening
- 11:46the industry? Are you contributing to the end
- 11:49of animal exploitation? And I think that these
- 11:52two camps worked best together when they were
- 11:56working on interventions that ticked both of
- 11:58those goals. So they had short -term welfare
- 12:01improvements. But importantly, they imposed a
- 12:04cost on the industry that made it harder for
- 12:06that industry to continue. So you see this with
- 12:09things like bands of battery cages, bands of
- 12:13sale stalls. Those things improve the welfare
- 12:16for the animals that are in the system. But they
- 12:18also make it more expensive to produce these
- 12:21products and make those industries less profitable.
- 12:24So That was sort of how I saw the two camps as
- 12:28working together over this amount of time. So
- 12:32the way that I tried to privately talk to the
- 12:35activists supporting this was applying that same
- 12:38kind of test, right? Like, if you want to support
- 12:40this technology, are there instances of this
- 12:44technology where it both helps animals in the
- 12:47short term and weakens the industry long term?
- 12:51However, nobody has been able to give me a single
- 12:54example of that actually being the case with
- 12:56this technology. Instead, the response is the
- 13:00industry is entrenched. We can't fight it. That
- 13:03question is irrelevant whether or not this makes
- 13:07the end goal harder or easier to achieve because
- 13:10that end goal has already been abandoned. So
- 13:17it's kind of a defeatist attitude. that they
- 13:21have adopted. Is it? Yeah, absolutely. I think
- 13:26that a lot of, yeah, I think that it is very
- 13:34much a defeatist attitude. I think that people
- 13:36have unfortunately lost hope in our movement's
- 13:41ability to win. And I do think that is where
- 13:43a lot of this comes from. And, you know, I think
- 13:47that There's also this sort of way that this
- 13:54gets phrased in these circles, which means that
- 13:58you don't have to accept that you're being defeatist.
- 14:00So the way that they think about this isn't like,
- 14:05should we abandon our goal or not? The way that
- 14:08they think about this is, well, what is the realistic
- 14:12probability that we do? Compare that to the amount
- 14:16of money it costs to get there. and basically
- 14:19calculate the expected value of the action. It's
- 14:22very much a kind of utilitarian, effective altruist
- 14:27kind of approach. But I think the problem with
- 14:30that when you're talking about something that's
- 14:32a social permission is that asking about the
- 14:36probability of achieving something is partly
- 14:38a way of not asking, will I be part of making
- 14:41that happen? So I think you can't accurately
- 14:45predict a future that is dependent on your own
- 14:48actions. And so I think that, yeah, if you think
- 14:53about these two ideas as well, like the idea
- 14:56that we can achieve animal liberation versus
- 14:58the idea that we can't achieve it, regardless
- 15:01of which one you want, if you don't think that
- 15:04we can achieve it, you're not going to take the
- 15:06actions that are required to achieve it. So it
- 15:10becomes a sort of self -fulfilling prophecy.
- 15:12If you don't believe that change is possible,
- 15:15then you don't fight for change to happen. One
- 15:21thing that surprised me reading your piece was
- 15:25this use of AI to continue exploiting animals.
- 15:31Because when I think of high tech, I think of
- 15:34replacing animals altogether. It's weird to think
- 15:39that we will use this godlike technology. to
- 15:44just continue this very, like in my mind, I picture
- 15:47it as a very primitive practice. What do you
- 15:52think of that? I mean, I think that's absolutely
- 15:55right. And I think this technology has plenty
- 15:59of applications within animal advocacy, within
- 16:02the development of alternative proteins. And
- 16:04I think that, you know, I would like to see much
- 16:07more of these resources going towards that, towards
- 16:10building the alternative. But I think that at
- 16:13the same time, there's an obvious financial incentive
- 16:16for the industry that currently does exist and
- 16:19that does exploit animals to want to use it to
- 16:22optimize their own profitability. So I think
- 16:25that we're already seeing across society, there's
- 16:28very few sectors of industry that are not being
- 16:31transformed by AI in some way or another. So
- 16:35I think that really AI is an optimization tool.
- 16:39Whatever goal you set it, it learns how to achieve
- 16:43that goal more and more efficiently. So if the
- 16:45goal that you give it is to develop alternatives,
- 16:49to help with corporate campaigns, it can optimize
- 16:52towards those goals. But in the hands of an industry
- 16:56that exploits animals, that wants to continue
- 16:59to do that indefinitely and to make more profit
- 17:02from it, then unfortunately, it can also optimize
- 17:04for that. And what about the the alternative
- 17:11protein camp. I thought this was the big bet.
- 17:15We're going to put all of this money to replace
- 17:18meat by something grown in a lab. Have they abandoned
- 17:24this venture or are they still hoping for it
- 17:29to take off? So interestingly, A lot of this
- 17:36funding that is going towards developing PLF
- 17:38is also coming from funds that actually are invested
- 17:40in all protein as well. So I think that this
- 17:45might not make sense from an advocacy perspective,
- 17:48but if you think about this from a market perspective,
- 17:50it makes a lot more sense because investors want
- 17:54to diversify in order to decrease their risk.
- 17:58So Essentially, if you think of it this way,
- 18:02if you're invested simultaneously in PLF technologies
- 18:06that become more profitable as factory farming
- 18:10grows, and you're also invested in the alternative
- 18:13that becomes more profitable as factory farming
- 18:16decreases, then ultimately you're going to make
- 18:19profit either way. That's fascinating. We should
- 18:26define precision livestock farming and give a
- 18:30bit more color to what we mean by that. Yeah,
- 18:34absolutely. So precision livestock farming is
- 18:37the industry term for using technology to exploit
- 18:43animals more efficiently. So a lot of the technology
- 18:48involves sensors on farms, cameras on farms.
- 18:51and the use of machine learning and AI to optimize
- 18:56these factory farms for increased efficiency.
- 19:00So examples of that, you have precision feeding
- 19:03is one section. So the hens that are bred to
- 19:07be consumed as meat, they're bred so that they
- 19:12grow a lot faster than is natural. And that causes
- 19:16significant health problems as they get older.
- 19:21the intended result for, you know, the chickens
- 19:24that end up on someone's plate, but for the breeder
- 19:27hands, the ones that are actually producing those
- 19:30chicks that become eaten, that's a problem because
- 19:33as they get into older age and as they're reaching
- 19:36sexual maturity, that's the same time that their
- 19:39bones start collapsing under their own weight,
- 19:42their hearts start giving out. So the way that
- 19:45the industry has solved this is not to stop.
- 19:48uh you know selecting for faster growth but instead
- 19:52to starve the breeder hens as much as they possibly
- 19:55can without them dying and not being able to
- 19:58breed so the use of this precision feeding technology
- 20:04you have essentially a feeding platform that
- 20:08has scales every can has an RFID tag that identifies
- 20:13them individually and the feeding station will
- 20:16only release feed when they're below their target
- 20:19weight. And the restrictions on this can be severe
- 20:22as up to 80 % less of what these hens would eat
- 20:27voluntarily. So I think that's a very good example
- 20:32of like how industry uses this technology. And
- 20:37that again is actually something that which is
- 20:40it's very common across precision livestock farming
- 20:42that you will have these welfare claims. So there
- 20:46will be the claims that this is good for the
- 20:48welfare of these hens. And in that case, they
- 20:50argue this is good for their welfare because
- 20:52it means that they don't eat so much that their
- 20:55bones crumble under their own weight, and they
- 20:58don't eat so little that they starve to death.
- 21:00But really, the core goal is to not remove the
- 21:06constraints of what is actually causing that
- 21:07suffering, but to increase it as much as biology
- 21:11will enable. And so precision livestock systems,
- 21:17like I mentioned, they've been around for decades
- 21:19already and they've been the most adopted in
- 21:23the dairy industry. The reason for that is because
- 21:27dairy cows are more economically valuable to
- 21:30the industry than factory farmed animals. So
- 21:34I think on average, it costs farmers thousands
- 21:39of dollars to look after a dairy cow. And so
- 21:42if that cow gets sick or something is making
- 21:46her produce less milk, for example, there's a
- 21:51strong economic incentive to fix that, to intervene.
- 21:55Whereas with, say, factory farm chickens that
- 21:59are only worth a couple of dollars to the industry,
- 22:02the incentive is just to let them die instead.
- 22:05So we've already seen over these last couple
- 22:09of decades a lot of adoption of this technology
- 22:12within dairy farms. But we're starting to see
- 22:16a lot more adoption of the technology now in
- 22:18factory farms because of the changing economics
- 22:22as the technology gets uh more developed it becomes
- 22:26cheaper to implement and so that's uh quite a
- 22:30recent shift and another reason the main reason
- 22:35they're adopting this technology is because it's
- 22:39increasing their margin of profit it allows them
- 22:43to make more money by keeping more of their animals
- 22:48in the state that they want to keep them and
- 22:51their production and operations going, being
- 22:55optimized and going as they want them to go.
- 22:59Is that a good assumption? Yeah, absolutely.
- 23:03So there's even carve outs within the legal system
- 23:10that specifically enable increasing stocking
- 23:14density if you have monitoring of these things
- 23:17in place, and increasing the lines for slaughterhouse
- 23:21speeds if you have the same monitoring. So there's
- 23:25already these, in European law, there's sort
- 23:29of three different tiers. There's the sort of
- 23:32minimum standard, and then once you start monitoring
- 23:37things like the emissions, you're monitoring
- 23:40the mortality of the birds, how many of them
- 23:42are dying before they reach a slaughterhouse,
- 23:44the law then enables you to increase how many
- 23:49chickens you put in that shed. And then if you
- 23:51can prove that things like mortality are below
- 23:54a certain threshold, you can increase that even
- 23:57further. So definitely there is The only reason
- 24:02these technologies get adopted, I mean, ultimately,
- 24:06factory farms and slaughterhouses are businesses.
- 24:08They're trying to make a profit. They're not
- 24:10going to willingly adopt a technology unless
- 24:14it is making them more profitable. The flip side
- 24:19of this is through things like campaigns, regulations,
- 24:24there can be instances where a producer has to
- 24:27accept a cost imposed externally, but that's
- 24:30not really what this technology is about. And
- 24:34you see that in the language for the incubators
- 24:37and the funds as well is these are not technologies
- 24:41that... being adopted because it's like a forced
- 24:44adoption because of public pressure or because
- 24:46of regulations. They're trying to develop things
- 24:50that do make the industry more efficient and
- 24:53that the industry actually does want to buy.
- 24:58Okay, so I hear all of that and I think. This
- 25:05is, you know, the defeatist camp that we mentioned
- 25:09earlier. They also heard all of that and they
- 25:14looked at that and thought this is inevitable.
- 25:18This will happen and there is no future where
- 25:23those technologies are not adopted in mass and
- 25:26actually become the norm. Why did they get that
- 25:30impression that this is unavoidable? That's a
- 25:36great question. ultimately, you know, I can't
- 25:41read the private thoughts of others. So I can't
- 25:43really know what leads people towards this. But
- 25:47what I can say is that, you know, I mean, I've
- 25:50experienced burnout myself in the movement. I've
- 25:53had times in my life where I've thought, you
- 25:55know, this is too hard of a struggle. I've thought,
- 25:58you know, I'm not going to see a significant
- 26:00change in my lifetime. And so I think that a
- 26:03lot of that can just come from despair. It can
- 26:07come from you know, like mental health issues,
- 26:10depression, anxiety. And I think that that might
- 26:16be playing a role here as well. I think that
- 26:19when we see the scale of this industry that we're
- 26:22opposing, the scale of the harm that's been caused,
- 26:25it is easy to feel disillusioned with that if
- 26:28you're not focusing on the other hand of all
- 26:31the wins the movement has had. You know, we've
- 26:33had a lot of those, you know, the amount of vegan
- 26:38products that are available has increased dramatically
- 26:41in the 20 years since I've been doing activism.
- 26:44We've seen a lot of legal reforms happening to
- 26:47ban some of the worst practices around the world.
- 26:50We've shut entire industries down. In Europe,
- 26:54the fur industry is non -existent in a lot of
- 26:57countries with complete bans on both the production,
- 27:00the import, the sale. So I think that we definitely
- 27:05are seeing wins. But I think that, you know,
- 27:09at the same time, the scale of what is still
- 27:12being done to animals is so large that it is
- 27:15easy to feel disillusioned. And yeah, I also
- 27:20think that there's maybe a lack of understanding
- 27:29of the history of social movements and how long
- 27:31change actually takes. I think that, you know,
- 27:35Activists will talk about, we've had a sort of
- 27:41organized animal rights movement for about 50
- 27:44years and meat consumption is still increasing.
- 27:48So therefore they see that as a sign of like,
- 27:50well, we can't win. But 50 years in the grand
- 27:54scale of the evolution of humanity is a blip
- 27:58on the radar. It's nothing. And most social movements,
- 28:01like the abolition of slavery, that took over
- 28:04a century to achieve. So I think that plays a
- 28:09role as well as not learning from the history.
- 28:13And the history is full of things that people
- 28:16said were impossible that could never be done,
- 28:20moral atrocities that everybody said would last
- 28:22forever that have ended. Slavery is one example,
- 28:25civil rights, the feminist movement, all of these
- 28:30movements faced the exact same objections of
- 28:34these idea of, you know, you're being idealistic,
- 28:37you need to be realistic, like, this is not going
- 28:39to happen. But change only happens because of
- 28:42the people who do believe that it's going to
- 28:44happen despite that. So, yeah, I mean, I think
- 28:50that, you know, I hope that I'm being fair to
- 29:00their reasons for why they think this. Because
- 29:03again, like I say, I'm not in their head. I can't
- 29:06say why people believe what they do. But from
- 29:11an outside perspective, it does seem very defeatist.
- 29:14It seems like disillusionment and it seems honestly
- 29:18like a sign of burning out. And so that's actually
- 29:23something else as well that I think that we need
- 29:27to have uh you know compassion for the people
- 29:30who are advocating uh this even though you know
- 29:33it's it's very harmful to animals and it's you
- 29:38know not uh something that the movement should
- 29:40adopt i think that the adoption of this belief
- 29:44does still come from this genuine place of wanting
- 29:47to help animals but it's mixed with that belief
- 29:49of not thinking that it's possible to liberate
- 29:52them and there's really interesting research
- 29:55actually on sort of the psychology of motivation.
- 30:00So the dominant theory with this is that motivation
- 30:04is how much you value an outcome multiplied by
- 30:09how much you expect that outcome to happen. So
- 30:12you can value an action enormously, but if you
- 30:15expect it at zero, that produces zero motivation.
- 30:19So I think that a lot of the activists who are
- 30:24promoting this technology. I think they do still
- 30:27value animal liberation, but because they don't
- 30:30believe it's possible, that doesn't motivate
- 30:32them to act towards it. Have you come across
- 30:39any sign, any clue that they might have been
- 30:44captured by the industry? And I say that because
- 30:48I've seen so many ex vegans online going from
- 30:54being like activists and on board with everything,
- 30:59the philosophy and visiting sanctuaries and all
- 31:02of that and going from that to, oh, I love chicken
- 31:06and I love those animal products. And so it can
- 31:11happen. Do you think it happened with them? Yeah,
- 31:18well, I mean, I think there's an obvious financial
- 31:24incentive to develop this technology. Like the
- 31:27animal agriculture industry obviously has a lot
- 31:30more resources than animal advocates do. I think
- 31:34we're outspent about 10 ,000 to one for every
- 31:37dollar that we have as activists, factory farms
- 31:40have $10 ,000. And even specifically this nation,
- 31:46what the industry calls precision livestock farming
- 31:49and what I call factory farming 2 .0, even that
- 31:53is currently about an $8 billion industry annually.
- 31:58So on the other hand, the animal rights movement
- 32:00collectively across the entire world, every organization
- 32:04is under 300 million annually. So there definitely
- 32:08is a lot more money to be made in building AI
- 32:13for factory farms than there is to like build
- 32:15AI for animal activists. So the financial incentive
- 32:19I think is there. And, you know, as far as capture,
- 32:24I think that actually, you know, you can explain
- 32:27this also, you know, in a way that doesn't rely
- 32:32on, you know, criticizing anyone individually,
- 32:36but just looking structurally at what happens
- 32:39to organizations when incentives shift. So I
- 32:43think that anytime that your incentive is tied
- 32:49to an industry doing well, that is going to remove
- 32:53any incentive to oppose that industry. And so
- 32:56if your entire investment thesis is that you're
- 33:02creating companies that make these farms more
- 33:05profitable, then that structurally is going to
- 33:08prevent you from being able to campaign against
- 33:12them, even if you wanted to. So I think that
- 33:15definitely there is a big financial incentive
- 33:18to develop this technology. And I think that
- 33:21it is a mistake for anyone in our movement to
- 33:27align their incentives with that, regardless
- 33:29of what their intentions are. We discussed the
- 33:35possible psychological reasons, defeatism, explaining
- 33:39why would animal activists be willing to run
- 33:43a factory farm, as well as the possibility of
- 33:47capture by the animal agriculture industry. But
- 33:52what if their reasons were more of an ideological
- 33:56order? I interviewed Vera Flock. a philosopher
- 34:00who wrote a paper called the repugnant conclusion
- 34:04of effective animal altruism where she explores
- 34:08how animal effective altruism brought to its
- 34:12logical conclusion would mean building more factory
- 34:16farms i shared that paper with you and so i wonder
- 34:20what did you think of the paper and do you think
- 34:23effective animal altruism is to blame for this
- 34:28recent development? Yes I definitely do think
- 34:32that there are ideological reasons for this as
- 34:35well as the psychological reasons and the financial
- 34:39reasons. I think that there is a layer deeper
- 34:44than effective altruism that we need to look
- 34:47at which is the underlying moral philosophy of
- 34:52what drives effective altruism. So I think effective
- 34:55altruism is essentially an applied form of utilitarianism,
- 35:01this idea that the sole definition of what is
- 35:06morally right or morally wrong is purely a result
- 35:11of aggregated welfare metrics. So take all the
- 35:15happiness, subtract all of the suffering. I think
- 35:19that is one of many different theories in moral
- 35:22philosophy that is being treated as if it is
- 35:25the only one. There's also deontology, there's
- 35:28rule -based ethics, there's virtue ethics, there's
- 35:33care -based, ecofeminist, there are so many different
- 35:38ways to think about moral philosophy and I think
- 35:41that it's a mistake to only treat one of those
- 35:45as the sole source of truth. I think if you take
- 35:48any of those moral philosophies and you take
- 35:51them to their extremes without balancing them
- 35:54in any way, they all lead to some pretty horrible
- 35:57conclusions. There's a famous thought experiment
- 36:01within utilitarianism, for example, of, you know,
- 36:05imagine that you are a doctor, you have five
- 36:08sick patients who will need different organs,
- 36:11and you have one healthy person in the waiting
- 36:14room who you could kill and harvest their organs
- 36:18and save five lives. Now, there's no way to say
- 36:22that you shouldn't kill that person if you are
- 36:26working from strict utilitarian principles. The
- 36:30way that utilitarians usually solve that is with
- 36:33something they call rule -based utilitarianism.
- 36:36So they look at which rules are most likely on
- 36:40average to lead to the greatest utility, but
- 36:44functionally what that is, is importing the rules
- 36:48from deontology. So you have to have a mix of
- 36:53these different frameworks in order to actually
- 36:57do morality robustly and without leading to these
- 37:02horrible conclusions. So hardcore utilitarians,
- 37:06they have a framework for essentially rejecting
- 37:13that. So they call this biting the bullet. So
- 37:17taking the argument to wherever it leads, no
- 37:21matter how horrific the outcome is. And I think
- 37:25that is very much a parallel to what we're seeing
- 37:30happening within Factory Farming 2 .0. We're
- 37:35seeing this logic of, you know, a particular
- 37:39framework, a particular way of thinking leads
- 37:42to a conclusion that is obviously morally horrific,
- 37:46but To actually acknowledge that is considered
- 37:52within the framework of the ideology to be. Not
- 37:57consistent to not be robust and I think that's
- 38:01a massive mistake in terms of how we should be
- 38:05relating to ideology. I think we need to consider
- 38:08multiple perspectives and I think we need to
- 38:12weigh those perspectives up rather than. allowing
- 38:16ourselves to be very narrowly and rigidly governed
- 38:20by a single framework that leads to a horrific
- 38:24conclusion at its extremes. believes it is some
- 38:44sort of scheme to get big meat to invest in AI
- 38:48controlled animal factories. I guess a form of
- 38:53what Bill Gates called creative capitalism, where
- 38:56you use philanthropy strategically to open doors
- 39:01to business opportunities. Do you think this
- 39:04is another possible explanation for what is happening
- 39:08right now? Well, I think that there's a version
- 39:13of this claim that doesn't rely on there being
- 39:17any kind of conspiracy. We can look at actually
- 39:20what these institutions are publicly stating.
- 39:24So, Spring Innovation Fund, for example, is publicly
- 39:27stating that, you know, they are a non -profit
- 39:30venture studio. Their intention is to create
- 39:33for -profit companies that then get sold to big
- 39:37companies. So, they've named in trade press releases
- 39:42things like Merck Animal Health, Zoetis. So this
- 39:46is not something that requires any belief in
- 39:50a like a grand conspiracy. It's much simpler
- 39:53than that. They are explicitly and publicly saying
- 39:57that the intention is to use philanthropic funding
- 40:00to subsidize the R &D costs that Big Meat has
- 40:05to invest in these AI controlled animal factories.
- 40:08And They are using that philanthropic capital
- 40:11to create business opportunities, and that's
- 40:14also part of the model for how they intend to
- 40:18sustain themselves. They intend to take the profits
- 40:22from profitable companies and to reinvest into
- 40:27continuing that flywheel. So you don't even need
- 40:31to believe that there's any scheme or conspiracy
- 40:35in place. You can literally just read what these
- 40:38institutions themselves are publicly stating.
- 40:41It's on the record and it's not a controversial
- 40:46thing to suggest. I also think that regardless
- 40:50of what people's intentions are, regardless of,
- 40:54you know, even if everybody in this whole situation
- 40:57was acting from a place of perfect integrity,
- 41:02skewed incentives still lead to skewed behavior.
- 41:05If you are taking a movement that is supposed
- 41:10to be opposed to factory farms, and you're getting
- 41:13that movement now to invest heavily and be dependent
- 41:17on the continued existence of factory farms in
- 41:21order to remain earning revenue, income, profit,
- 41:26then again, without anyone needing to have any
- 41:31bad intentions, it will structurally create.
- 41:35a situation where the types of campaigns, the
- 41:42types of interventions that the movement focuses
- 41:44on are going to shift to the ones that are aligned
- 41:47with industry. I mean, you see this already within
- 41:52philanthropy as a whole, where organizations
- 41:55shift their strategies according to what it is
- 41:58that funders are willing to fund. There was a
- 42:03A research report done by the Stray Dog Institute,
- 42:06for example, that found seven out of ten fundraisers
- 42:11for animal advocacy organizations reported feeling
- 42:15pressured or coerced into changing their strategic
- 42:19priorities as a result of the strategic priorities
- 42:24of funders. So again, I think that, you know,
- 42:28even if you take this at the most surface level,
- 42:33taking people at their word, assuming the best
- 42:36intentions from everyone, we're still creating
- 42:39the structural problem that will lead to the
- 42:45same kind of results as accepting the full conspiracy
- 42:49theory. And, you know, I don't say conspiracy
- 42:52theory there in any kind of derogatory way. I
- 42:57think, you know, There are also legitimate conspiracies
- 43:01that do happen. People do conspire and have secret
- 43:04motives. Like, I think that is not a controversial
- 43:08opinion to have. That's just human nature to
- 43:13some degree. But again, you don't need to try
- 43:19to read between the lines or to understand what
- 43:23people's, you know, private thoughts and feelings
- 43:26are. You can just look at what is being said
- 43:29and done publicly and look at what that structure
- 43:34is likely to output given what we know about
- 43:38how human minds work. Let's describe the solution
- 43:43they came up with against this impossible problem.
- 43:48Can you tell us a bit practically what they want
- 43:51to make and what's their strategy here? Yeah,
- 43:57so there's quite a spectrum. On the narrative
- 44:03end, you're seeing support for research in this
- 44:10area. So this is part of why this new factory
- 44:16farm is being built by an animal advocacy organization
- 44:20is to create a test bed so that they can run
- 44:24a factory farm in real world commercial settings
- 44:27and they can apply these technologies and they
- 44:29can measure and test and see is this improving
- 44:34welfare or not. So I think that's sort of like
- 44:37the most immediate thing. Then once they kind
- 44:42of prove various technologies, then there's the
- 44:46sort of venture capital arm that takes those
- 44:49companies and accelerates them, gets investment
- 44:53in them. And As far as the end state, there's
- 45:00a lot of different approaches in this space.
- 45:04It's very broad, but there have been a lot of
- 45:08people in this space who have been arguing for
- 45:10things like genetic modification of animals to
- 45:13reduce their capacity to experience pain and
- 45:17suffering, and with the ultimate goal of actually
- 45:21breeding out their brains entirely so that you
- 45:24have uh, essentially just headless bodies. And
- 45:28let me stop you for a second. I heard that at
- 45:33the dinner a few months ago, this rumor that
- 45:36funders in our movement are actually doing experiments
- 45:40on animals to create those zombie creatures you
- 45:44just mentioned that are incapable of suffering.
- 45:48And I could not believe what I was hearing. It's
- 45:52very dystopic and comes from an vegan nightmare.
- 45:56Sorry for interrupting you, but yeah, I want
- 45:59to collaborate. You're completely right. It is
- 46:02very dystopian. And I think that, uh, yeah, there's,
- 46:08there's a technique that I've seen, you know,
- 46:10the advocates who support this use, which I think
- 46:14is, um, basically, you know, they will acknowledge
- 46:19that that reaction is going to be the reaction
- 46:22you have before they say it. And then they will
- 46:24frame it in the way of like, but don't let your
- 46:27moral purity get in the way of helping animals.
- 46:30So I think that a lot of what I'm seeing is,
- 46:34you know, like this kind of people are very disconnected
- 46:39from their emotions. And they like feel like
- 46:41their emotions are something that they have to
- 46:44repress so that entirely logic can be the only
- 46:49thing that drives them. But I think that that's
- 46:52a fundamental misunderstanding of how emotions
- 46:55and logic work. They're supposed to be integrated
- 46:58together, not one thing that you separate out.
- 47:01So I think when we have that visceral reaction,
- 47:05that is our body's way of telling us something
- 47:09has gone wrong here. So you can't logic your
- 47:13way out of it. You have to actually like sit
- 47:17with that feeling. And yeah, I think that I mean,
- 47:23but even, you know, if you, if you do want to
- 47:25say, Hey, you know, put emotions aside, let's
- 47:27only talk about this logically. Then, you know,
- 47:30from a logical perspective, like we know very
- 47:33little about why it is that anyone is conscious,
- 47:37right? Like we, there's This is something to
- 47:40talk about in philosophy, the hard problem of
- 47:41consciousness. If you could hypothetically have
- 47:45all of your neurons firing, every atom moving
- 47:48around, but why does that actually create a conscious
- 47:53experience? You can explain the mechanisms, but
- 47:55you can't explain why it creates this conscious
- 47:58feeling. And we know so little about how those
- 48:02two things connect that I think... to assume
- 48:06that we can even breed an animal to be, you know,
- 48:11just completely unthinking, unfeeling, like we
- 48:15have no way to know that. What we would most
- 48:19likely do is breed out the signals of suffering.
- 48:24So, you know, breed, and I mean, this is something
- 48:26we've already done, like this isn't hypothetical,
- 48:29this is the selective breeding that humans have
- 48:32done has been to make animals easier to exploit.
- 48:35So we breed for animals that are more domesticated,
- 48:39that don't fight back, that are easier for people
- 48:43to farm. So I think we already have a long history
- 48:48of breeding out the objection to suffering, but
- 48:52it clearly has not resulted in actually breeding
- 48:55out the ability to feel that suffering. So I
- 48:59think even if That is your goal. There's no way
- 49:02to know when you've reached it. That's such an
- 49:06interesting perspective. Yeah, this whole thing
- 49:10feels like making a wish and it's the evil genie
- 49:15that Makes your wish come true, but there is
- 49:20a twist. And that's the twist. No more animal
- 49:23suffering because they don't have the organs
- 49:27or neural connections to feel suffering. That's
- 49:31not what I wished for. That's not what I meant
- 49:34by wishing for that. Yeah. It's very maddening.
- 49:41Yeah, it really is. And I think, you know, there's
- 49:44also, um, an interesting maybe blind spot in
- 49:50people who advocate for this. So a lot of the
- 49:54time, the reason they're advocating for this
- 49:56is because they think again, like factory farming
- 49:59is inevitable. And so they think like alternative
- 50:02proteins, cultivated meat, they're like, people
- 50:04won't adopt that because they want to eat animals.
- 50:06And because they'll think that it's unnatural
- 50:09to like grow cells inside, you know, an incubator
- 50:14inside a of that, but for some reason they think
- 50:17that that same public that won't adopt cultivated
- 50:20meat because it's unnatural will be totally fine
- 50:23with, you know, this sort of dystopian image
- 50:28of like these brainless animals connected up
- 50:30to computers. Yeah, I always felt like a vegan
- 50:38world was the future that awaits us. That's the
- 50:44real destination. Whatever setback we go through
- 50:49as a movement, at some point we will win this
- 50:53long war. So maybe we won't win every battle,
- 50:57but the victory is ours. And this is the unavoidable
- 51:02future. But they think the opposite, which is
- 51:07very weird. Gosh. Yeah, I completely agree. I
- 51:14think that if you look at the arc of humanity,
- 51:20our moral circle has constantly expanded and
- 51:23it hasn't always done it evenly. There's been
- 51:26setbacks. But if you look at the arc over thousands
- 51:28of years, the direction is clear. We started
- 51:32off kind of only having empathy for our immediate
- 51:36family, our immediate tribe, then humans came
- 51:40Together, we built towns and villages. We expanded
- 51:44our circle of compassion to the town and the
- 51:46village. We created nations. We expanded it to
- 51:49the nations. Then we extended it beyond nations
- 51:52and between nations. And look at every marginalized
- 51:57group throughout human history. And things definitely
- 52:01still have a long way to go there as well. But
- 52:04the progress that we've made is clearly in this
- 52:08direction of greater compassion and empathy for
- 52:13more and more sentient beings. So I think that
- 52:16if you look at that arc to assume that we've
- 52:19just reached a peak now, and there's no, you
- 52:21know, nowhere for it to go. I think there's no
- 52:24evidence to support that. And also, psychologically
- 52:29speaking, I was not always a vegan. And in fact,
- 52:33I loved meat, I loved animal products, I would
- 52:37Add them to every meal I ate. And the idea of
- 52:41becoming vegan was so foreign, so alien to me.
- 52:45I remember the first vegan person I met. I thought
- 52:48they were completely crazy. Like, how are you
- 52:51surviving? And the idea that I became vegan and
- 52:55then became an animal rights activist. That's
- 52:59what gives me great hope and more than hope,
- 53:02a certitude that it can happen. This World that
- 53:07was trying to birth is going to happen So yeah,
- 53:13it's hard for me to put myself in their shoes
- 53:16But like you said there is the burnout aspect
- 53:20and all of that. Okay, so they're developing
- 53:23those strange technologies What's the next step
- 53:28they want to then sell them to the industry make
- 53:32them more available? how are they intending to
- 53:37inject the animal welfare aspect of it in this
- 53:41equation? Yeah, great question. So I think that
- 53:47the approach very much is like a traditional
- 53:53sort of venture capitalist approach. So they
- 53:56want to incubate new companies that are for profits
- 54:00and then they want those companies to get an
- 54:04exit to be acquired by Big Ag. So this has already
- 54:08been named publicly. This is not me, you know,
- 54:12talking shit about anyone. This is, you know,
- 54:15for example, spring innovation funds, trade press
- 54:19articles, they explicitly mentioned that they
- 54:22want to sell those companies to like Merck Animal
- 54:25Health, Zoetis. and these big sort of animal
- 54:29farmer companies. So that is the intended exit.
- 54:32It's been stated publicly. And yeah, that's ultimately
- 54:37what the next step is, is create these for -profit
- 54:41tech startups and then sell those to the industry.
- 54:47But then why would the industry care about the...
- 54:51Because they're crafting those technologies,
- 54:53thinking about the animal welfare of... aspect.
- 54:57Why would the big guys out there, the big companies,
- 55:01the big corporations care about that aspect of
- 55:05things? Why would they not modify those technologies
- 55:07on the long run? Well, I think that they absolutely
- 55:13will. But their argument is they're trying to
- 55:17find sort of these edge cases where animal welfare
- 55:24increasing is also better for the farmer. So
- 55:28if you look at what that actually means, mortality
- 55:32is a good example. So it doesn't benefit a farmer
- 55:36to have a chicken suffer to death in a factory
- 55:39farm before she can reach the slaughterhouse.
- 55:41So if you can create technologies that prevent
- 55:47diseases or prevent you know, overfeeding to
- 55:50the point that, you know, the chicken actually
- 55:53dies, then that's actually economically valuable
- 55:56for the industry, because it means that, you
- 55:59know, they're profiting off every bird, and they
- 56:01don't have, you know, birds who are suffering
- 56:04to death that they can't profit from. So what
- 56:08they're trying to do is find these kind of areas
- 56:13where the welfare of the animals and the interests
- 56:16of the industry are economically aligned. I think
- 56:20that what they fail to grapple with is that AI
- 56:26in particular is a system that learns to whatever
- 56:30goal you set it for, whatever you optimize it
- 56:33for. So you could hypothetically create a perfect
- 56:38welfare technology that is an AI that only optimizes
- 56:42for that one goal, although it would also be
- 56:46optimizing for the goal of production efficiency
- 56:50in order to be able to sell to the industry.
- 56:52But once the industry then actually owns that
- 56:55technology, they can repoint it towards whatever
- 56:57goal they want. And AI systems are very good
- 57:01at learning new goals. And they're very good
- 57:04at taking previous learnings and applying that
- 57:08towards optimizing for a new goal. So I do think
- 57:10absolutely that what is going to happen once
- 57:14these companies get brought out by the factory
- 57:18farms, essentially, is that's what they're going
- 57:22to point things at. So it's like, you could imagine,
- 57:27let's say you have an AI system that is optimizing
- 57:29for two goals. It's simultaneously trying to
- 57:32increase the welfare of the animals and improve
- 57:36the efficiency of the factory farms. It's very
- 57:42easy then to just, you know, once you actually
- 57:45own that AI and you have control of the model
- 57:48to switch it over to one and optimize only for
- 57:51that and have the model forget that it ever was
- 57:54optimized for welfare in the first place. So
- 57:57I definitely think that that is going to happen.
- 58:01And I think that the people who are advocating
- 58:04for this technology, they're relying on this
- 58:08assumption that animal welfare and industry productivity
- 58:12are going to stay attached to each other. And
- 58:17I think that, you know, we have so much proof
- 58:20throughout the industry's history of this not
- 58:22being the case. So there is... A few examples
- 58:26that I think illustrate this quite cleanly. So
- 58:29one would be selective breeding and gene editing.
- 58:33That was actually a technology that was largely
- 58:36developed in universities for welfare purposes.
- 58:39They were trying to breed out genetic deformities.
- 58:43Then that exact same technology, once the industry
- 58:46adopted it, they pointed it at having the birds
- 58:49grow faster. so that they can make more money
- 58:53off them, which leads to all sorts of terrible
- 58:55animal welfare problems. So, you know, literally
- 58:58the technology that was created to breed out
- 59:02deformities was actually then used to optimize
- 59:06for the deformities that are profitable for the
- 59:09industry. So I think that we've seen this history
- 59:12already. Another good example is antibiotic use
- 59:16on factory farms. So one of the biggest obstacles
- 59:20that factory farms had in the early days was
- 59:23that all of the animals get sick and die because
- 59:25you cram a lot of animals into one space. As
- 59:29soon as one bird gets sick, suddenly all of them
- 59:32are sick and you lose the entire flock. But if
- 59:35you give them all antibiotics, I mean, you know,
- 59:38that's great for preventing disease, but it also
- 59:40means now you can actually stack them all into
- 59:43a single shed without killing the whole flock
- 59:47off. So I think that The trajectory for this
- 59:52technology is exactly the same thing. There's
- 59:55all of these short -term welfare benefits that
- 59:59are claimed, but the industry doesn't have any
- 1:00:01incentive to optimize for animal welfare. The
- 1:00:05industry has an incentive to optimize for its
- 1:00:07profitability. Again, this is actually encoded
- 1:00:12into law. reduce mortality so much, you prove
- 1:00:18that you're not creating disease, you're allowed
- 1:00:20legally to stack more birds into that shed, or
- 1:00:24on a slaughter line to to slaughter more birds
- 1:00:27per manor. Yeah, you mentioned the farmers, who
- 1:00:33cares about the farmer, it will be a robot. And
- 1:00:36the gene editing stuff, why would they not decide
- 1:00:40that chickens don't need eyes anymore? What's
- 1:00:44the use of eyes on chickens that will be killed
- 1:00:48for meat or something. This horrific story has
- 1:00:55no end. It's... I get the feeling they haven't
- 1:01:00thought through this plan much. It's not a very
- 1:01:03solid plan, I feel. Yeah, I mean, I think that
- 1:01:08is definitely, you know, the temptation to think
- 1:01:11that these people haven't thought it through.
- 1:01:13But I mean, if you look at the amount of money
- 1:01:16that's going into it, and you see that this kind
- 1:01:20of has been something that's been like advocated
- 1:01:24throughout various like conferences within the
- 1:01:27movement. I think, you know, they they have thought
- 1:01:30it through a lot. And I think that, you know,
- 1:01:34we We often kind of think that, you know, if
- 1:01:39somebody is doing something bad that they haven't
- 1:01:40thought it through. But sometimes people have
- 1:01:42thought it through and decided to do the bad
- 1:01:44thing anyway. Well, I'm trying to figure out
- 1:01:49what's the master plan. What's escaping us? What's
- 1:01:53what are they thinking about that might be this
- 1:01:56covert thing that we're not realizing yet? But
- 1:02:01I can't find. anything that would point to something
- 1:02:06like that, like a master strategy behind all
- 1:02:10of this? Yeah, I mean, I think that really it
- 1:02:15just comes back to the defeatism as I think that
- 1:02:19because they have decided that, you know, they
- 1:02:25think animal liberation is impossible, that's
- 1:02:27no longer the thing that they are progressing
- 1:02:29towards. And so I think this also confuses people
- 1:02:33because our movement has this long history of
- 1:02:36the welfarists and abolitionists camps. And so
- 1:02:39we naturally think that this is the same debate.
- 1:02:43So within that, there is part of this long -term
- 1:02:47strategy of, OK, we can decrease the costs of
- 1:02:49the industry. We can start building public support.
- 1:02:53But none of that is present here because they're
- 1:02:58not optimizing for that goal anymore. They've
- 1:03:00abandoned the goal. And again, this is not me
- 1:03:06mischaracterizing anyone's opinion. They say
- 1:03:12this. One of the largest funders in our movement
- 1:03:17publicly talks about the inevitability of factory
- 1:03:21farming, like it's a law of physics that we can't
- 1:03:25change. And so I think that, yeah, to understand
- 1:03:30the mindset, you have to understand that the
- 1:03:34goal has been completely abandoned. So it's not
- 1:03:38this dystopian image that they're proposing.
- 1:03:43Like that is the new goal. That is what they're
- 1:03:45trying to get towards. There's no greater strategy
- 1:03:48for like how that eventually leads to animal
- 1:03:51liberation. No, like what they're describing
- 1:03:54is what they want to see happen. And so to be
- 1:03:58as fair to them as possible, I think most of
- 1:04:00these people still would prefer animal liberation
- 1:04:03to this dystopian image they're describing. But
- 1:04:06because they don't believe that it's possible,
- 1:04:08that's not what they're working towards. Yeah,
- 1:04:12I guess it's like an election campaign and you
- 1:04:15have two really bad candidates and you're just
- 1:04:19thinking what's the lesser evil. That's exactly
- 1:04:23right. I wish there was like a better candidate
- 1:04:27and I wish there was more dynamic democracy and
- 1:04:32all of that, but the system is what the system
- 1:04:36is. We can't change the system and so we just
- 1:04:40need to choose the lesser evil. Yeah, that's
- 1:04:43exactly right. I think that is exactly what it
- 1:04:46is. Yeah, trying to choose the lesser evil and,
- 1:04:51uh, you know, not even considering the option
- 1:04:54that actually we could end the evil. What is
- 1:04:59this? What is the big ag? What is big ag thinking
- 1:05:03of all of this? How are they feeling about all
- 1:05:06of that? Because I'm sure they're just shocked
- 1:05:11to the executives from big ag companies to see
- 1:05:15that. Are they celebrating? Have they chosen
- 1:05:19a date for a big party, all of them, because
- 1:05:23animal rights is over, basically, or do they
- 1:05:27feel suspicious about it? You're not, you don't
- 1:05:29know their thoughts, but tell me what your best
- 1:05:33guesses are here. Yeah, I mean, you know, if
- 1:05:36I were to sort of like put myself in their shoes,
- 1:05:38I would be celebrating, right? Like if I was
- 1:05:41them, I mean, essentially, You know, if you break
- 1:05:45this down to just looking at it from a business
- 1:05:48use case is any adoption of new technology is
- 1:05:52risky. You have to spend a lot on introducing
- 1:05:54the technology to the farm. you don't really
- 1:05:57want to be like the test bed for R &D in your
- 1:06:00commercial farm. So if a nonprofit, a charity
- 1:06:03that used to fight against your industry is now
- 1:06:07saying, hey, we'll provide the R &D for you,
- 1:06:09you don't have to pay a cent, we'll test it out,
- 1:06:12we'll make sure that it's actually economically
- 1:06:14valuable, that it's improving your profit margins,
- 1:06:17and then you can buy it from us once we're done.
- 1:06:20I mean, yeah, that seems like definitely a win
- 1:06:23for them. Yeah, sorry, it's not very funny, but
- 1:06:29it actually is because You know like thank you.
- 1:06:34Thank you for all of those amazing gifts. Like
- 1:06:37are you saying? You you'll be you know paying
- 1:06:41upfront for the the cost of all the risks of
- 1:06:48creating those new technologies and then implementing
- 1:06:51them practically Sorry, I'm losing my words here.
- 1:07:04Yeah, it is one of these things that just does
- 1:07:06leave you speechless. I mean, yeah, the whole
- 1:07:10thing, I think for a lot of activists in the
- 1:07:14movement that are watching this unfold is it
- 1:07:17seems like satire. And so I got a lot of comments
- 1:07:19on my article originally where You know, people
- 1:07:22were saying like, you know, I had to have my
- 1:07:25AI explain this to me five times to make sure
- 1:07:27I was understanding what I was actually reading.
- 1:07:30I understand that. We'll soon see the CEOs of
- 1:07:35big ag companies like Tizen call themselves animal
- 1:07:39rights activists and vegans. Why not? The meaning
- 1:07:43is shifting here. For sure. I mean, you know,
- 1:07:47the industry has a long history of that already,
- 1:07:50right? With welfare washing is, you know, they
- 1:07:52love to make it seem like they're at this frontier
- 1:07:55of like trying to improve animal welfare, but
- 1:07:58that means something very different to industry
- 1:08:00than it does to everyone else who has the word
- 1:08:03because, you know, the only welfare metrics they
- 1:08:05care about are the ones that affect their profitability.
- 1:08:08So you know, things like reducing disease, reducing
- 1:08:12the number of animals that die before they reach
- 1:08:15a slaughterhouse. Like those things, you know,
- 1:08:18if you have this very, very narrow view of animal
- 1:08:21welfare of thinking like, you know, okay, anything
- 1:08:24that reduces disease or reduces mortality is
- 1:08:26good for animal welfare, then you know, there
- 1:08:29is kind of an intersection there. And so the
- 1:08:33industry loves that the industry loves to talk
- 1:08:35about, you know, how humanely they treat their
- 1:08:38animals and how much they care about animal welfare.
- 1:08:42So, yeah, I think that, I mean, it's going to
- 1:08:45be great marketing for them as well to be able
- 1:08:47to say like, look, these institutions that used
- 1:08:50to fight against us, like now they're selling
- 1:08:53to us. Now we're adopting the technology that
- 1:08:56they built for us. So I think it's definitely
- 1:08:59going to, you know, hand that over to the industry,
- 1:09:03the ability to just welfare wash at a level that
- 1:09:07we haven't seen before. How much is this going
- 1:09:13to hurt our activism? Because the money they're
- 1:09:16putting on those new technologies and ventures,
- 1:09:19that's money they're not putting in activism
- 1:09:23organizations, campaigns that would have done
- 1:09:27lots of good. I guess with that defeatist attitude,
- 1:09:32I'm sure they will also reduce their donations
- 1:09:36and funding overall. I would expect that from
- 1:09:39them, from the movement, since our purpose goes
- 1:09:44against their purpose. They look at us and they
- 1:09:47think we live in a utopia. We're pursuing a utopia
- 1:09:52and giving us money is like burning money. So
- 1:09:56I would expect that. But do you think they would
- 1:09:59go? They would actually actively go against us
- 1:10:04because those are funders who know this movement
- 1:10:07intimately. I'm sure know internal strategies
- 1:10:11and are on the boards of or were on the boards
- 1:10:15of various important organization in this movement.
- 1:10:19And so if they decide to put an end to us, they
- 1:10:23could do a lot of harm. So yeah, what do you
- 1:10:27think could happen? Yeah, so I think that it's
- 1:10:33important to go back to that idea of the fact
- 1:10:38that the future is not predetermined and that
- 1:10:42we have agency in shaping what that future is.
- 1:10:44So I think the default, if we do nothing, is
- 1:10:48going to be very, very bad for animals. I think
- 1:10:52the scale of what we're talking about is, if
- 1:10:55you imagine pre -factory farms, to then what
- 1:10:59factory farms are, it's going to be that same
- 1:11:02gap applied to intensifying factory farming.
- 1:11:05So it's easy for activists. We look at how terrible
- 1:11:08the industry is now, and we think it couldn't
- 1:11:10possibly get any worse. But it can get worse,
- 1:11:13and it will get worse if we don't do anything
- 1:11:15about it. But that said, this is not like a law
- 1:11:20of physics that this is going to happen. We can
- 1:11:24take action against this. And I think that Especially
- 1:11:28in this space, I think we have some unique opportunities
- 1:11:33for things like pressure campaigns, campaigning
- 1:11:38for regulation to restrict the usage of these
- 1:11:40technologies. So if you think about campaigning
- 1:11:44against a factory farmer themselves, that's a
- 1:11:48very tough battle because They've probably been
- 1:11:52in that industry for multiple generations. Their
- 1:11:56great -great -grandfather owned the farm. And
- 1:11:59so it's multi -generational. It's very kind of
- 1:12:03entrenched attitudes. So it's very hard to convince
- 1:12:07a factory farmer to, say, close down your factory
- 1:12:11farm. Although that said, that does happen. There
- 1:12:14are groups out there, like Transformation Project.
- 1:12:17uh that actually genuinely are helping to convert
- 1:12:21factory farms into things like uh places to grow
- 1:12:25mushrooms and so like you know I don't want to
- 1:12:28like suggest that that's not possible but it's
- 1:12:31tough it's it's a challenge however I think it's
- 1:12:34much easier when you think about uh you know
- 1:12:37some computer science student who's fresh out
- 1:12:40of university who learned how to code because
- 1:12:42you know they love solving difficult problems
- 1:12:45they didn't learn that skill to go and optimize
- 1:12:50the machineries of exploitation. So I think the
- 1:12:53people who are actually building this technology,
- 1:12:56they're reachable in a way that a multi -generational
- 1:13:02farmer isn't. So I think that things like pressure
- 1:13:06campaigns, things like having early interventions
- 1:13:10in universities where we steer people away from
- 1:13:14going to build this technology, there's a lot
- 1:13:16of different levers involved in which we can
- 1:13:19affect change. And most of these kind of tech
- 1:13:23startups, they're very reliant on capital. So
- 1:13:28they need investment, they need funding, because
- 1:13:31there's a long R &D process before they become
- 1:13:34profitable. So again, those investors are not
- 1:13:39necessarily tied to the technology. in the same
- 1:13:42way. So a lot of them are already very diversified,
- 1:13:46they're already investing in all proteins. So
- 1:13:48basically, you know, if we as a movement can
- 1:13:51make this something where it becomes reputationally
- 1:13:56damaging to work on these technologies. And so
- 1:13:59within the tech space, you know, you have things
- 1:14:02like people are pledging not to work in this
- 1:14:04industry, and it gets this kind of taboo around
- 1:14:07it. I think that we can stop the development
- 1:14:11of this technology and let alone when it comes
- 1:14:14to regulation, I think there's a lot of opportunities
- 1:14:17there as well. And I think one of the interesting
- 1:14:22things that I've talked to a lot of people working
- 1:14:25in political campaigns within the movement, one
- 1:14:28of the things that they have always said to me
- 1:14:30is that, To be successful, you need to bring
- 1:14:34together unlikely coalitions. So you don't want
- 1:14:37something that is only like considered an animal
- 1:14:40advocacy issue. But if you can show that a bunch
- 1:14:43of different constituencies all support something,
- 1:14:47you can make a lot more progress. And I think
- 1:14:49AI and factory farms actually has the ability
- 1:14:52to bring together more than just the animal advocacy
- 1:14:55movement. I think... Like you have the sort of
- 1:15:00AI safety movement who's concerned about harms
- 1:15:03of this technology. You have the environmental
- 1:15:05movement that's worried about that impact of
- 1:15:08the farms. You already have this groundswell
- 1:15:12of local support, both for rejecting planning
- 1:15:17permits for factory farms and for doing that
- 1:15:19for data centers. And this is a technology that
- 1:15:22combines the two. So I think that by default,
- 1:15:26if we do nothing, the future is going to be very
- 1:15:28bad for animals. But if we do take the right
- 1:15:32actions as a movement, if we get organized, we
- 1:15:35campaign against this and we prevent it from
- 1:15:39coming, then these same technologies of AI applied
- 1:15:43to things like alternative proteins and cultivated
- 1:15:46meat and animal advocacy, that could actually
- 1:15:49give us a huge competitive advantage. If we can
- 1:15:52simultaneously restrict it in industry, and increase
- 1:15:56it in the alternatives, then yeah, that actually,
- 1:16:00I think, you know, gives me probably more hope
- 1:16:05than I've had in my life about like how soon
- 1:16:07we can achieve animal liberation, because these
- 1:16:09are very powerful technologies. And if we point
- 1:16:11them at the right thing, and we stop them from
- 1:16:13being pointed at the wrong thing, there's very
- 1:16:15little we couldn't achieve with it. And it all
- 1:16:20goes back to the choice of consumers. Will they
- 1:16:24accept that? Will they accept... Most people,
- 1:16:28and I covered that on a recent episode, oppose
- 1:16:32factory farming in its current form. So what
- 1:16:36would they think about this farming 2 .0, factory
- 1:16:41farming 2 .0? I'm pretty sure they would oppose
- 1:16:45it. I'm counting on that. And I hope... I think
- 1:16:49that's absolutely right. I think that, yeah,
- 1:16:52the... the public already, like you say, is opposed
- 1:16:56to factory farming. And I think that this idea
- 1:16:59of scaling it up further, intensifying it, and
- 1:17:03removing kind of the human from the equation,
- 1:17:06I mean, it's dystopian. And that visceral reaction
- 1:17:10that we have to it as animal activists is actually
- 1:17:12the same visceral reaction that most people have
- 1:17:15to it. Like, so I do think actually it is something
- 1:17:19where, you know, maybe even it's easier to attract
- 1:17:24sort of public support for ending factory farming
- 1:17:272 .0 than factory farming alone. Because I think
- 1:17:30it's also like much easier to convince people
- 1:17:35like not to do a new thing than to like stop
- 1:17:40doing what they're already doing. So I think
- 1:17:43that yeah, if anything, like the fight against
- 1:17:48this from sort of a public angle and a public
- 1:17:52pressure angle. I think we actually do have a
- 1:17:56very strong case and a public that is on our
- 1:17:58side. But I do think we need to stop the spread
- 1:18:04of that defeatist attitude. I think that's key
- 1:18:08to continuing this fight, because if we don't,
- 1:18:12then we'll just join their camp and be nihilistic
- 1:18:15about it. A hundred percent. I think, um, There's
- 1:18:21no greater gift to the industry than that belief
- 1:18:24amongst advocates, this idea that we can't win.
- 1:18:28I think the industry can tell you that themselves,
- 1:18:34and that feeds a movement. It's like, we'll prove
- 1:18:38you wrong. But when it's internal, I think that
- 1:18:42is extremely damaging. And if you look again
- 1:18:47throughout history, there has never been a social
- 1:18:50movement that has won that didn't think that
- 1:18:52they could win. And this conversation is also
- 1:18:56not unique to our movement. Every movement gets
- 1:19:01asked this question at some point or another.
- 1:19:04Like, I have a friend that's writing a book on
- 1:19:08the Indian independence movement, for example.
- 1:19:11And there were people, you know, in the time
- 1:19:13of Gandhi, who would argue that, you know, Colonization
- 1:19:18has always lasted for thousands of years. This
- 1:19:22has only been around 100 years. We have another
- 1:19:25900 to go. So we can't win. And obviously, they
- 1:19:28did win. But if enough people had thought that,
- 1:19:31if enough people had thought we can't win, then
- 1:19:34they wouldn't have fought for it. And they wouldn't
- 1:19:35have actually achieved the goal. So I think this
- 1:19:40is not unique to our movement. It's something
- 1:19:42every movement gets asked at some point. You
- 1:19:45know, there's only one answer to it, which is,
- 1:19:48you know, not just answered through your words
- 1:19:50and your beliefs, but answered through your actions
- 1:19:52as well. Well said. Yeah, this this whole conversation
- 1:19:57reminds me of a Zen saying, if you see the Buddha
- 1:20:01walking on the path, kill him because the Buddha
- 1:20:05is not walking on the path. The Buddha has already
- 1:20:08walked the path. And so what you're saying, seeing
- 1:20:12is not the Buddha. It looks like him, but it's
- 1:20:15not. So kill him. Yeah, thank you so much, Sam.
- 1:20:18Did you want to add something before we stop
- 1:20:20the recording? Yeah, I think the one thing that
- 1:20:25I would like to leave people with is just reiterating
- 1:20:27that, you know, the future is not determined
- 1:20:31by, you know, unchangeable laws of physics. The
- 1:20:34future is determined by the actions of individuals
- 1:20:38and, you know, This question of like whether
- 1:20:41or not we achieve animal liberation is largely
- 1:20:44a question of whether or not you're going to
- 1:20:46fight for animal liberation. So keep fighting.
- 1:20:49And, you know, as much as, you know, it's easy
- 1:20:52to feel despair, to feel disillusioned when we
- 1:20:55see what's happening. Like the moral arc of history
- 1:20:59is always in one direction. It's towards justice.
- 1:21:02And we just have to keep driving it there. Beautifully
- 1:21:08said. Again, thank you so much, Sam, for having
- 1:21:11written that piece for letting us know and informing
- 1:21:16us and for taking the time to answer my questions.
- 1:21:20Truly appreciate it. And yeah, I hope lots of
- 1:21:23people go and subscribe to your sub stack. Thank
- 1:21:27you so much, Sam. Thank you so much. It's been
- 1:21:30a great conversation. Thank you, everyone, for
- 1:21:33listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 1:21:36podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 1:21:39more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 1:21:43so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday
- 1:21:46for a new episode.