Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Living With Water: Insights Into Impact and Resilience
Transcript
- 0:01Roughly 4 billion people, and that's about half the world's population,
- 0:05live under highly stressed water conditions at least one month out of every year.
- 0:11And yet, in many of those same places, when the rain finally does come,
- 0:15it comes too hard, too fast, and floods the very communities that were rationing water weeks earlier.
- 0:21That paradox, too little, then too much, sometimes both at once,
- 0:26is at the center of today's conversation.
- 0:29I'm very pleased to be joined by the team at Walter P. Moore,
- 0:32whose new stewardship report, Living with Water, looks at engineering not as
- 0:36a way to control water, but as a way to steward it, designing systems that work
- 0:40with water's natural behavior instead of fighting against it.
- 0:43Very pleased to have this team here today because it's something that is an
- 0:48important topic that the world is wrestling with.
- 0:50And it's going to be a great conversation. Can't wait to dig in.
- 0:54So please join us. This is engineering influence podcast for the American Council
- 0:58of Engineering Companies. Let's get into the conversation.
- 1:09I'm pleased to be joined by Rucker Simon. He is the managing director,
- 1:13Houston Civil Engineering with Walter P. Moore.
- 1:16Rucker's got more than 11 years of experience in civil engineering and sustainable design.
- 1:21He is a subject matter expert in green stormwater infrastructure,
- 1:24low impact development systems and horizontal infrastructure lifecycle carbon assessments.
- 1:29He is one of the authors and creators of the sustainability report that we're
- 1:36talking about here on water.
- 1:38Rucker, thank you for joining us today on this very important topic.
- 1:43Absolutely. Happy to be here.
- 1:45So you have a lot of experience in this area. You're kind of one of the reasons,
- 1:50the Living With Water report exists.
- 1:53Give us a little bit of background on the report and talk to us about kind of,
- 1:58that idea of water as a continuum.
- 2:01Yeah, that's a great question. I mean, the thing with water and working with
- 2:07water as a civil engineer and infrastructure is you quickly learn that it's
- 2:11not something that you can put the blinders on about.
- 2:13When you try to solve a problem directly on a site or with a specific campus
- 2:18or something like that, water is part of a much broader cycle,
- 2:22like a natural water cycle, part of much broader municipal systems.
- 2:27And it requires zooming out to understand the context.
- 2:30And if you keep zooming out and zooming out, you start to see that each individual
- 2:36drop of water may look individual as you're on those tiny projects that you're
- 2:41focusing on, but that it really is all one thing.
- 2:44It's all part of a singular continuum.
- 2:48And the way that we address water in different scenarios,
- 2:52whether it's fresh water or scarce fresh water or flood water it's all water
- 2:59right and it's all a natural phenomenon that is a major need of humanity,
- 3:06so understanding that is as a continuum it's the same thing it's the same resource
- 3:10it's how we treat it that are creating the consequences of that resource.
- 3:16And that's, it was really zooming out that kind of gave us this perspective
- 3:19to say, let's look at water as it truly is, as a resource along a continuum.
- 3:25And then understanding that, you know, that's inherent to our being,
- 3:28it kind of makes the storytelling a little bit easier, too, to frame all of
- 3:32our different approaches to water along that same continuum.
- 3:36And that's the nice thing about the report, is that it uses these case studies
- 3:39across that continuum to kind of make that case.
- 3:43Two projects are, you know, interesting because they're both supply and demand
- 3:51stories. One is Half the World Away, Bangalore Airport, and then contrasted with Rice University.
- 3:58You kind of use that as a supply and demand story, but different contexts.
- 4:04Tell us about those projects and what the common design principles were that
- 4:08really made those projects successful.
- 4:12Yeah, so the Bangalore Airport story and the Rice University story are similar
- 4:17in the way that you described.
- 4:18But to give those listening who may not have had a chance to read the report
- 4:23yet, our Bangalore Airport project is a story really about water positivity.
- 4:28It's about capturing significant amounts of rainfall and,
- 4:33designing a storm sewer system and really a stormwater management system that
- 4:38uses natural systems for filtration, for conveyance, for storage,
- 4:43in a way that they can leverage those massive volumes for water reuse.
- 4:48The story about Rice University is similar in that it approaches rainwater harvesting
- 4:54as a piece of it, but it's a more
- 4:56holistic water balance and water management approach across all different kinds
- 5:01of water systems across the entire campus.
- 5:05And it really digs into balancing those supplies and demands and quality and
- 5:11availability across the entire spectrum of different types of uses across the campus.
- 5:17They're both massive projects, though, and they're both, I would say, substantial scales.
- 5:23They're in very different environments. And so when they're in those separate,
- 5:28contexts, the similarities and approach have to differ in response to those contexts.
- 5:34So I would say that the primary design principle that sort of spans,
- 5:43the two projects is really that core value of stewardship and understanding
- 5:48what it means to be a steward of water as a resource, a steward of a community,
- 5:54a steward of your clients' needs,
- 5:56and understanding that context in depth in relationship to the resource and availability.
- 6:03To then create design solutions that properly leverage it in a way that's harmonious and balanced.
- 6:10The firm did work for Water for People in India, which was really about mainly
- 6:16water stewardship. And then it really comes down to the question of how do you
- 6:21handle stewardship when access is uneven?
- 6:25How do you design for that and what elements go into to that level of stewardship.
- 6:31I think that when we talk about access to water, the Water for People story
- 6:36is about creating and maintaining access to clean water and that that can happen
- 6:42unevenly or said another way, inequitably.
- 6:47If you look at the way that that tends to happen, it's because we haven't zoomed
- 6:52out far enough to understand the impacts of what we're doing.
- 6:56You essentially end up in a situation where if you have a finite resource and
- 7:00you have your blinders on and you're using it all well in one area and you don't
- 7:03see the impacts of it in another, you can end up in a situation where you have these uneven impacts.
- 7:10In the Water for People story, it's about scarcity of water,
- 7:13scarcity of fresh water in particular regions of India.
- 7:17And if you're acting truly as a steward of that resource, being a steward is
- 7:21about understanding the finite nature of a resource.
- 7:26And then on the other side, it's universal need.
- 7:29And if you're only meeting one set of needs and not that universal need,
- 7:35then it's hard to say that you're being a steward of it, right?
- 7:38You're kind of robbing Peter to pay Paul at that point.
- 7:41So uneven access means the way that we're using that resource is not meeting
- 7:48that universal need. And when we look at that, that's not just an example in
- 7:53India. I mean, that story is about an example in India.
- 7:55But you see that happen across the world. And historically speaking,
- 8:02the worst impacts of uneven access tend to hit communities that don't necessarily
- 8:08have the means to object to it.
- 8:11And Flint, Michigan is a great example of that in recent U.S. history.
- 8:16And so the way that we want to approach stewardship towards water is to make
- 8:21sure that that access to it is equitable.
- 8:23And the best ways to do that is to, you know, one, zoom out,
- 8:27make sure that you're looking at all of the impacts of different projects that
- 8:31may not even have to do with that.
- 8:33But the work we did with Water for People was really about setting guidelines
- 8:37and technical guidances for how to set up resilient systems.
- 8:41So there's a piece of it that is civil engineering focused.
- 8:45It's grounded in the reality of the geography, of weather patterns,
- 8:50of statistical rainfall.
- 8:52But I think the key that really unlocks that equity and creating that equitable
- 8:57access is stakeholder engagement.
- 9:00It's getting the community involved because you can design a system that may
- 9:05work, but if you have operators that don't understand all of the intricacies
- 9:10of that design or the way that it's intended to work because it hasn't been
- 9:13properly communicated,
- 9:15that system starts to break down.
- 9:16And then as you have users that need to use that water who may not,
- 9:21you know, just from looking at it, understand the way that it operates or what's
- 9:25keeping that consistency and supply in balance, it can fall apart there as well.
- 9:30So you have to create a, not just a design, but an entire system of understanding
- 9:34around it that allows and really empowers communities to maintain that access
- 9:40and be stewards of the resource as well.
- 9:42Well, you know, it's really interesting how it's more, you know,
- 9:47it's, I guess, a systems engineering, right? It's the fact that it's just,
- 9:50it's not a simple, you know, kind of a linear thinking.
- 9:55It seems like in the past, and I'm not sure, you know, let me know if you have,
- 9:59some insight into this, but, you know, a couple decades ago,
- 10:03it used to be a little bit less connected in thinking, right?
- 10:08It's the idea that now it's not a question of water issues, not just a water issue.
- 10:16It could be tied into so many other things and that need to have that stakeholder engagement.
- 10:21The fact that you have to look at the, like you said, take a step back and look
- 10:25at the complex interweb of systems that will impact what you're trying to address and how those,
- 10:31maybe unintended consequences downstream of that change could have impacts.
- 10:38You know, talk a little bit about that in your experience and how that,
- 10:43has changed the way that you approach problems, the way that the firm approach,
- 10:48or even just the industry approaches problems, not as independent problems to
- 10:52solve, but as pieces of a larger complex system. Definitely.
- 10:58I think you nailed the difference there, right? They're not individual problems
- 11:02to solve. Everything is interdependent.
- 11:05And the way I would put it with regard to stewardship around water,
- 11:09stewardship isn't an achievement.
- 11:11It's not something you can say, great, I've done stewardship,
- 11:14we're good, right? Thumbs up.
- 11:17It's a way of being. It's an approach. And it has to be consistent and it has
- 11:21to be shared for it to be effective.
- 11:24You know, zooming out, like we've talked about a lot so far,
- 11:28is really, I think, the key to that and understanding all of those little impacts.
- 11:34There's an example of a hospital system that is in a rural location that we've
- 11:38worked on where the hospital itself was having challenges in getting enough fresh water.
- 11:45That's partially because of the municipal system not being quite ready to serve that hospital.
- 11:50There are some other options in the area for how we might get to that demand.
- 11:54They're needing to expand.
- 11:55At the same time, we're finding that there's significant amount of water use in mechanical systems.
- 12:02In makeup water for cooling towers and irrigation systems that are kind of adding
- 12:07stress to that system and so when you start to
- 12:11look at this continuum and look at it across not just what's hitting your meter
- 12:15and do you have enough where is all of that going and how can you make slight
- 12:19adjustments that might make improvements across the system,
- 12:23you start to conserve more and you use more water more efficiently.
- 12:27And it's sort of, I guess said simply, the approaches that we would once consider
- 12:33to be sort of a sustainable approach or like an add-on green approach are now
- 12:38integral to meeting the water needs of different places.
- 12:42And they're kind of the first place you look, as opposed to how do I pull more out of the ground?
- 12:47It's how do I develop consistency and mitigate the peaks of my demand by getting
- 12:54smarter about the way that I use water everywhere that I use it.
- 12:58Yeah. And I think that, you know, it's for the client side, especially if you
- 13:03have a private sector client, you
- 13:05know, there is, of course, the cost analysis of saying that,
- 13:08you know, if we're going to be building a facility, if we have significant footprints
- 13:12in real estate, then we have to be mindful of the water usage from a cost basis.
- 13:17But then they also have the overlay over maybe certain environmental or sustainability
- 13:22targets that they have, if they have, you know, shareholder,
- 13:26shareholder, you know, requirements and.
- 13:30Requirements for, you know, investing,
- 13:33you know, but it's kind of changed over time because it's no longer just a checkbox, right?
- 13:38It's actually become more of an integrated model of doing business.
- 13:43From your position at Water P. Moore, we always like to say at ACEC,
- 13:47the engineers aren't just doing the work.
- 13:49They're also just trusted advisors to their clients to state that this is how
- 13:54you can achieve these goals. Or have you thought about this thing that you may
- 13:59not have thought about in the business plan, but it could have an impact down the line?
- 14:04How have you seen that thinking change on the client side? When,
- 14:07you know, we talked about stakeholder engagement beforehand,
- 14:10this kind of ties in with that,
- 14:12that understanding that the environmental impacts of the projects they want
- 14:17to have designed, you know,
- 14:20are really more important than, you know, just what they might see on a bottom
- 14:24line, but could have, you know, larger, larger impacts.
- 14:29It's a great question. I think that it's, in my experience and in the clients
- 14:33that we work with, it's a result of a lot of things.
- 14:36Because the thinking has changed over the course of the past few decades from
- 14:43let's check this box to let's understand the net benefit outcome.
- 14:48You know, in sustainability analyses, we talk about the triple bottom line,
- 14:53right? And so there's this trend towards thinking that way.
- 14:56Part of it is the reality with water, like we just talked about.
- 15:01Part of it's the reality of available resources.
- 15:04Part of it's the cost associated with that and the understanding that things
- 15:07are getting more expensive and payback periods for evaluating things that way
- 15:12are becoming more attractive.
- 15:14General consensus and sort of public understanding of these issues has also changed and grown.
- 15:23And then I think another, maybe the most integral piece of it is just as engineers,
- 15:29serving as that trusted advisor, educating our clients.
- 15:33Because the folks that we work with across the board, they're sophisticated. They're smart.
- 15:37They may not have the subject matter expertise that we have,
- 15:41but that's why we're there, right?
- 15:44We're aiming to be stewards and we are subject matter experts and we are intended
- 15:50to be used as tools, right?
- 15:53And the clients we work with know what they need. They are asking us to help
- 15:58them understand what's the best way to get there.
- 16:00And so by sort of illuminating what all of the options are and actually paying
- 16:07closer attention to not just checking one box, but looking at systems thinking
- 16:12approach and understanding a net benefit,
- 16:15part of it's just laying it out there, right?
- 16:17And I think that's a thing we're doing better on the engineering side in the industry,
- 16:21partially because of the way that thinking has has changed within the industry
- 16:25partially because of the tools and technologies that we have available to better
- 16:30understand that and to come to answers on it a little bit more quickly,
- 16:34it allows us to to,
- 16:37highlight that and and really educate our clients so that they can be making
- 16:41informed decisions and then,
- 16:44i think that the reason that we were starting to see more of that is because
- 16:47when you're making those informed decisions, they're kind of no-brainers, right?
- 16:51It's easy to say this solution that's a little bit more systemically integrated
- 16:56that provides that net benefit that is more sustainable, that typically doesn't cost more, is easy to do.
- 17:03And so it's just about laying out the facts and laying out those interdependencies
- 17:07for the decision makers.
- 17:10One of the examples in the report is Walmart, and I think that goes to a good
- 17:14example of a large institutional, one of the largest employer in the United
- 17:20States, huge real estate footprint.
- 17:22They've made strides in their own headquarters that they're building of a lot
- 17:30of advanced engineering, sustainable engineering.
- 17:33You know, in the report, it talks about, you know, how they,
- 17:36you know, were able to get 40% less dependence on municipal water.
- 17:41Explain that project a little bit and how that kind of fits into this kind of
- 17:46view of sustainable water. Absolutely.
- 17:52Water stewardship in the sense of the Walmart campus, I mean,
- 17:55this is a massive campus that we worked on in Northwest Arkansas, recently completed.
- 18:01One of the driving principles of the design of the campus was big nature.
- 18:06Big nature meaning a lot of different things. And it's hard to kind of say succinctly.
- 18:13I've seen videos of it. I mean, it is big nature. I mean, really, it is.
- 18:17It's hard to explain. It's like Apple's got its spaceship out there in Cupertino,
- 18:21right? It's very modern. It's very Apple.
- 18:24You don't think of Walmart as a company that has a headquarters that is practically
- 18:29half nature park, half headquarters.
- 18:33The way that it actually integrates nature into the design is really stunning.
- 18:39So it's, it's, you know, we'll try, maybe we'll see if we can put some pictures
- 18:43up when we're talking about this, but to give you some, I, it's really something. So definitely.
- 18:49And that's part of that big nature approach. And so I think you're right that
- 18:54that was maybe not the perception previously, but that is what the values are
- 18:59of Walmart as a client that we've worked with.
- 19:03And what that boils down to is not just sticking trees out there for the sake
- 19:08of it, but really digging in historically to understand what are the real natural
- 19:12systems of a specific geography?
- 19:16How do we recreate those and restore those as we're developing a place to improve it?
- 19:23How do we bring people into connection with that nature as well?
- 19:27Because it's understanding that we're not independent of nature.
- 19:31We're not independent of water, right?
- 19:34We're connected to it. We're all part of this same cycle together.
- 19:38And so when we understand that and use that as a design principle,
- 19:42this is sort of the result of that. I mean, the campus has...
- 19:45Integration with the Razorback Trail coming through, I think that there were
- 19:49something like 2,500 trees planted over the course of six years.
- 19:54But that approach doesn't just meet the landscaping needs.
- 19:59It's the foundational approach for the engineering needs, too.
- 20:02So focusing on the stormwater, we're using low-impact development,
- 20:08nature-based solutions to manage all of the stormwater across the campus.
- 20:13That stormwater is collected and routed to the central amenity ponds that are
- 20:18retention ponds that have the ability to hold detention volume,
- 20:24but also meet reuse needs.
- 20:26And so it's those large ponds that are sort of being cleaned through natural
- 20:30systems and then stored within these natural amenity ponds that are then being
- 20:35used to meet irrigation demand across the campus.
- 20:38It's like 50 million gallons reused annually, right? Exactly.
- 20:44Yep, that's right. So they're massive ponds, but there's a massive need.
- 20:48And to integrate that seamlessly in a more natural system is really useful.
- 20:54You know, one of the things that you look at before this development,
- 20:58the campus had a lot of older buildings. I think it was developed in the 70s.
- 21:03Parking lots everywhere. And so, as part of understanding this big nature philosophy,
- 21:10ecological historians were hired to go back and understand what did this look like well before that?
- 21:15What is, back to the orchid farmers that were out there and even before,
- 21:21how do we recreate the ecological system that was here in a way that also allows
- 21:26people to thrive within it and work in harmony with it, with human health and
- 21:31wellness sort of at the center of that.
- 21:34So the water story, if you follow the water through the campus,
- 21:38it's a part of that big nature story, and it's integral to that big nature story,
- 21:42of using those natural systems in the way that they're intended to work, right?
- 21:48It's very cool. It's a really exciting project for us.
- 21:51So talking about, you know, one of the issues that is, of course,
- 21:56on a lot of people's minds is,
- 21:58flooding and the fact that you could have a situation where you don't get enough
- 22:01rainfall and then all of a sudden you get way too much flash flooding or just flooding that happens.
- 22:07You know, we've seen, you know, century floods that happen more regularly than they should.
- 22:13You know, there's a story in the report with Harris County.
- 22:19You know, you had a situation where you've had a lot of flooding and.
- 22:26You know, a question comes to how do you forecast that?
- 22:30How do you handle the idea of flood risk and how do you report flood risk?
- 22:36Kind of an idea of moving from an annual percentage to kind of more of a 30-year
- 22:41cumulative probability.
- 22:43Go into that a little bit about how technology is helping with flood mitigation
- 22:48and how this longer view is going to benefit development.
- 22:54Sure, sure. I mean, a big, I think the biggest piece of reframing the way that
- 23:00we understand flood risk is about communication.
- 23:06So we have more advanced tools, we have modeling systems that can operate more
- 23:12quickly, flood alert systems, real-time gauges and Doppler radar management
- 23:17that can inform our flood alert systems,
- 23:20You know, recently we just completed the MapNext project in the Harris County
- 23:25area for the update to FEMA maps, which is still kind of going through that process with FEMA.
- 23:32But all of this adds to our understanding as engineers of what does flood risk look like.
- 23:39But to a normal homeowner who's not an engineer,
- 23:44who's who's hearing these things about a hundred year storm or a 500 year storm
- 23:48or a 500 year flood or a 50 000 year storm whatever harvey was it's,
- 23:54it doesn't mean much you you look at a hundred year storm and you think okay
- 23:58that's a storm that's going to happen a hundred years or once every hundred
- 24:01years but then we're going to have it every three years what does that mean,
- 24:05it doesn't really translate to reality of what do I need to be prepared for
- 24:11as a person who lives in a flood-prone area?
- 24:14And so translating that to, for instance, a 30-year mortgage and maybe a likelihood
- 24:20of flooding over the course of that 30-year mortgage is much more tangible to
- 24:25homeowners that might be at risk for this.
- 24:28They can say, okay, I don't need to know what.
- 24:34A 0.2% recurrence interval is for a certain type of storm.
- 24:38I understand that if I buy this property, I have a risk of in the next 30 years
- 24:43flooding at whatever percentage.
- 24:46And if I raise it and elevate it, that risk goes down.
- 24:50And you get to understand what the real risk is in terms of your own life.
- 24:54And because of that, you get to understand even better what your own risk tolerance is, right?
- 25:04That's sort of the magic that this type of study allows us to do.
- 25:09It's taking previously inaccessible engineering terminology and making it actionable
- 25:16for everyday people who don't deal with that every single day. Yeah.
- 25:21Yeah, that's important. I think that, you know, it's, we always get tied up with the technical.
- 25:27We get, you know, we have our own kind of engineering as one of the hard sciences.
- 25:32It has its own kind of nomenclature. It has its own, you know, vocabulary.
- 25:37And it just adds to that larger vocabulary in the development,
- 25:42you know, areas of development and design and construction that is usually not
- 25:48paid attention to by people outside of it.
- 25:50So actually being able to translate into something that's usable is really important.
- 25:55So it also, I think, ties back the idea that, you know,
- 26:00I, along with everybody else who has a home, who, you know, uses our infrastructure
- 26:06on a daily basis, you know, we are susceptible to it.
- 26:11We are susceptible to nature, that we're not bystanders here,
- 26:14and we need to have actual, you know, and we actually are impacted by this work,
- 26:19which is one of the reasons why I think engineering is so interesting is the
- 26:22fact that you actually, it's one of those things that touches every single aspect
- 26:25of your life on a daily basis, whether you know it or not.
- 26:29And having that communication to kind of break it down from the technical into
- 26:33more of an accessible way of looking at things is really important.
- 26:38You know, how, yeah, with that, I mean, that idea with, with the stakeholder
- 26:43engagement, I think that kind of runs through the entire of the entirety of
- 26:48this report from all the case studies.
- 26:50That really that communication piece is important. You know,
- 26:54how much in your experience, you know, in the industry has that,
- 27:01the softer skills of communications conveying these ideas to non-technical audiences,
- 27:07you know, how has that kind of grown as part of the job?
- 27:12I'm always interested in getting people's thoughts on that, especially for people
- 27:17out there who might be interested in engineering.
- 27:19And think that, well, if I go into engineering, I'm not going to have that interaction
- 27:26with people or I'm not going to have,
- 27:29that ability to kind of maybe have that more interpersonal conversation with the end user.
- 27:37Right. Yeah, I think that's foundational now to engineering.
- 27:43I think that that is maybe the biggest piece of what we do because when we look
- 27:47at what we do as engineers, We're responsible for the public health and safety of people, right?
- 27:53That's what we're licensed to do. That's sort of the oath we take as engineers.
- 27:57And I think the thinking used to be, the math is difficult, the concepts require
- 28:05deep study and accreditation and licensure and degrees and all this stuff.
- 28:11And the thinking used to be, well, I know a ton about this and therefore I know what's best.
- 28:16And there wasn't necessarily an idea of community or stakeholder engagement.
- 28:22But what we come to see is that I may know all this stuff, but you know what's
- 28:27best. It kind of comes back to understanding the engineer as the subject matter
- 28:31expert that is a tool for the end user.
- 28:35And if the end user doesn't necessarily have the vocabulary to talk about it,
- 28:39it doesn't mean they don't understand the concepts. It just means that you as
- 28:44the engineer can do a much better job of translating that.
- 28:47And I think that that's what we see in the AEC industry is it's that communication
- 28:54of ideas and that translation of needs back into action, translating,
- 29:01starting with the end result of what a community may be after,
- 29:06because they have the best understanding of their needs.
- 29:09There's actually a story in the report about some work that we did in Dumengbe
- 29:14in Sierra Leone in Africa that is really about that stakeholder engagement.
- 29:20It's about understanding and respecting that communities know what they need.
- 29:24They just may not have the tools at their disposal to be able to get it.
- 29:28And that's what we did with that project in partnership with Engineers Without Borders.
- 29:34It's a really inspiring story about issues that they were having with flooding,
- 29:38particularly during the monsoon season that was cutting off access to healthcare,
- 29:42to markets, basically everything that you need.
- 29:45And to solve that problem, the village was really building seasonal bridges
- 29:50that would just get washed away.
- 29:52Out of necessity. And so coming in and understanding,
- 29:56offering up those services as a tool to say, here's what this looks like,
- 30:00here's some options for how we can go about it, what do you think is going to
- 30:03work, and tell us what you need in the way that you're going to use it was extremely useful.
- 30:08And so when it comes to delivering outcomes that work, that communities can
- 30:11adopt, that are sustainable, that people can become stewards of,
- 30:15you have to have that input.
- 30:16And the only way to get that input is to be able to translate the abstract engineering
- 30:22technical language that we use into that everyday understanding and marry the two.
- 30:27Yeah, and that's really important, especially in areas where you might,
- 30:30you know, you might be able to bring in the tools and technology that is lacking
- 30:34generally in those areas and those projects. But at the end of the day,
- 30:38the end users, they know what they need.
- 30:40And it's, you could say, yeah, well, you know, you should approach it this way.
- 30:45But then you hit the actual rubber meets the road and you realize that's actually
- 30:49unusable for the way that people actually interact with the environment.
- 30:53And to kind of have that give and take and that understanding what the end user
- 31:00actually does need out of the project and being able to meet that need through
- 31:04communication is really key.
- 31:07Yeah, definitely. And I mean, it's also about understanding that the engineering
- 31:12principles we were working with, especially with water, we've talked about it
- 31:16being along a continuum.
- 31:17It's the same resource, the same physics applied to it, the same engineering
- 31:21principles applied to it, regardless of the tools that you have at your disposal,
- 31:26whether that's additional technology or survey or LiDAR data.
- 31:30And then understanding those foundational aspects that don't change,
- 31:37you start to look at what you have available to make the changes you need to
- 31:41make, what materials are at your disposal, all that, to develop a solution that
- 31:46works within its context.
- 31:49And in that way, that approach coming from a place of stewardship and stakeholder
- 31:54engagement allows you to develop those solutions that are going to work and
- 31:58that are going to be implementable.
- 32:00Well, I want to wrap up and kind of go into an area, and I want to get your
- 32:04thoughts on this because it's probably the hot topic of today.
- 32:09Of course, that's the water demand and data centers.
- 32:13You know, how much have you worked on that? And what's, what's your view?
- 32:17Because I feel like, and correct me if I'm wrong here and I want to get your
- 32:20take, but, you know, in hearing how this is being communicated, they're not.
- 32:25They're not, it's the companies that are engaged with the AI who are making
- 32:29the arguments instead of the people who are designing the facilities or the
- 32:34people who understand what needs to be done to make these facilities work.
- 32:38And it just seems like one of those areas where the engineering industry is,
- 32:41as this trusted advisor, as this industry and group of professionals who are
- 32:47problem solvers, but at the same time are looking at systems,
- 32:51should have a bigger role.
- 32:53What's your take and, you know, from your own experience and what you're seeing,
- 32:58on how this conversation is going about water demand on data centers?
- 33:03Yeah, I would tend to agree with you. I do think a lot of the conversation that
- 33:08you see in the news is being led by the companies that are developing data centers.
- 33:14We talked about it a little bit, but the way that I think about it from a system
- 33:19standpoint as a steward of water, we're trying to meet everybody's needs.
- 33:23We're not trying to meet someone's needs at the expense of someone else's.
- 33:29And so when it comes to data centers, we all understand at this point that they're
- 33:33kind of mega water users, depending on the types of cooling systems that they
- 33:36use. Some use more water than others.
- 33:39And I think understanding its context, understanding water use within that context,
- 33:44when you go to develop a data center, at least in the ones that we worked on,
- 33:48the siting application is a few things.
- 33:51It's access, it's contiguous land, it's availability of electricity,
- 33:56it's availability to develop your own renewable electricity on site.
- 34:00So the power demands are all heavily evaluated in that way, and so are the water demands.
- 34:05Is there enough water to get there? And I think that in asking the question,
- 34:10is there enough water for these demands?
- 34:13There may be, but I think the analysis doesn't quite go far enough to understand,
- 34:18okay, this water is here.
- 34:20Let's see what happens when we actually put that demand on the system and understand
- 34:24what that looks like. So I think the industry is moving that way to do a better
- 34:28job of evaluating that holistically.
- 34:31Part of being water positive is.
- 34:33You can't really be water positive on a standalone site because you can be net
- 34:38zero water if you're on a site where you can infiltrate.
- 34:41You can call that water positivity, but really you have to understand the position
- 34:45of that development within its broader water cycle context.
- 34:49And is there a way to add more water into the system at a point where there is a lack or a dirt water?
- 34:57And it's possible. We see that with the data center that I just mentioned.
- 35:02And we wrote an article, actually, as part of this stewardship report that talks
- 35:08about the future of water stewardship.
- 35:11When we're in an environment that is consistently changing in demand and data
- 35:15centers being one of the sort of flagship examples, it's the buzz,
- 35:21right? It's what everyone kind of talks about and understands at this point.
- 35:24But it's representative of the increased intensity of water use that we're going
- 35:29to have across different industries.
- 35:31So trying to meet that water demand is coming at the same time as other results of climate change,
- 35:38areas where water scarcity is becoming a problem, not just because of data centers,
- 35:42but also because of population growth or concentration of population in single
- 35:48areas that utilize the same water sources.
- 35:51And so this idea of scarcity applies kind of everywhere.
- 35:57And we have to be thinking about the systems that we know and use today to address
- 36:03that scarcity, to try to conserve, to try to reuse, which are commercially available
- 36:09and totally implementable.
- 36:10Those are going to move from a nice to have to a necessity to meet the way that
- 36:15we we need to use water that's that's sort of the preliminary in the next few
- 36:20years thing that i think is going to become commonplace,
- 36:24and so really it's it's it comes back to zooming out it comes back to understanding
- 36:30as you're using a finite resource that's part of a continuum of.
- 36:34Whether that's energy, whether that's water, in this case, it's water,
- 36:38what are the impacts of your use and how far do those impacts reach?
- 36:42Where do you truncate your study at the boundaries of your site?
- 36:45We know we need to be looking beyond that and really starting to study that,
- 36:51as far out as necessary until those impacts diminish.
- 36:56That theory already exists when we do work within hydraulics and hydrology, right?
- 37:00We do no impact studies all the time for building adjacent to the floodplain.
- 37:04And thinking about that from a water impact or a freshwater impact standpoint,
- 37:08I think, is the direction that we're going to go.
- 37:11And what's great about that is that we also have tools at our disposal now,
- 37:16technology now, that enables more rapid understanding of that.
- 37:2110 years ago, it could have taken you a year to do that type of study to get
- 37:27to the extent necessary to understand that.
- 37:30And now with the technology at our disposal, we can do that much more rapidly
- 37:35in months or weeks and actually come to real actionable answers that can,
- 37:40from a high level, inform decision making at the outset so that we're building
- 37:45places in a way that allows us to continue to be stewards of our finite resources. like water.
- 37:53Well, it's really important, I think, for anybody watching and listening that
- 37:57understand that this view of water as, you know, not just, it's a question of
- 38:05scarcity versus excess.
- 38:07It is that continuum and a requirement for us to be stewards across that continuum
- 38:14and to really work in harmony with the environment. That's something that the
- 38:18engineering industry is doing, something Walter P. Moore is doing.
- 38:21I really do encourage anyone out there to download the report,
- 38:25to read it, and the associated articles around this from Rucker and his colleagues
- 38:30over at the firm. It's really something else.
- 38:33It is really interesting to learn more about this, to read more about this,
- 38:38exactly how the industry and engineers like yourself are approaching these challenges
- 38:46through a holistic lens.
- 38:48And I appreciate you spending some time with us today, Rucker,
- 38:52and talking about the report.
- 38:54Anytime. This has been a blast. Always happy to talk with you, Jeff.
- 38:58Fantastic. And again, we'll have links to everything in the description of the
- 39:02episode. And thank you for joining us. This has been Engineering Influence,
- 39:06a podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 39:08And we'll see you next time.