Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / Getting Sh*t Done: Tom Amies-Cull on Fixing Broken Agency Operating Models
Transcript
- 0:03This is signal and noise, bringing clarity to data, tech
- 0:07and AI. Hey everybody.
- 0:14Welcome back to Signal and Noise.
- 0:16I'm Brett House with my Co host Rhea Longacre.
- 0:19Today we're talking about something that sits underneath
- 0:22everything in this industry, everything across industries,
- 0:25but doesn't get talked about nearly enough.
- 0:28That's how organizations actually work effectively
- 0:31operationally together to achieve common goals.
- 0:35And our guest, Thomas Amy's going to get that right.
- 0:38You did, yes. I got to write the first time
- 0:40put he, he as, as you've put it. And I, I read this in one of
- 0:44your things that I thought was one of your LinkedIn posts that
- 0:47I thought was really interesting is called creating scale with
- 0:50soul, right? So how do you actually bring
- 0:52organizations together? There's, there's a soul
- 0:55component to this, which I thought was fascinating.
- 0:57So certainly want to dive into that.
- 0:59But you've spent your, your career inside large agency
- 1:02environments. You know, your senior, you had a
- 1:03senior role at Knessos, the global chief delivery and
- 1:07transformation officer. That's quite the title.
- 1:10Otherwise it's known as a COO maybe and as well as IPG Dentsu.
- 1:16I prospect and I certainly knew I prospect backed in, in the
- 1:20days COO rules and, and you know, these are high pressure,
- 1:24highly matrixed organizations, right?
- 1:28And, and it seems like you were right at the center of, of
- 1:31really driving organizational transformation and, and
- 1:35operational system transformation within these
- 1:39organizations. So was that a good intro?
- 1:42And and and would love you to tell tell the audience a little
- 1:44bit about yourself. Yeah, sure.
- 1:47So thank you for having me. Great to be here.
- 1:49I think the only person who calls me Thomas is probably my
- 1:51mother. So Tom will.
- 1:52Tom will do that's yeah. So I've been in and around the
- 1:55industry for you know 20 plus years as as you said, working
- 1:59predominantly for the large cold codes, then a few bits and bobs
- 2:03outside of that currently outside the agencies doing some
- 2:07advisory consulting work. My, my kind of background early
- 2:11on was performance marketing, so working in and on clients hands
- 2:15on keyboard, having client accounts, et cetera.
- 2:18And then have have moved into kind of agency management
- 2:21leadership roles. And as you said, Brett sort of
- 2:23focusing more on CEO type type roles.
- 2:26And for me, the bit that's always stuck is the guess
- 2:28recurring theme through any of that is, is that the people and
- 2:32culture element of it. And whether that's running, you
- 2:34know, campaigns for clients or or more laterally driving
- 2:37transformations, it's in a matter of all this or the
- 2:39technology, the noise that sits around it, it's people in our
- 2:42industry are fundamentally still the core.
- 2:44And so that's always been something that's been my kind
- 2:46of, you know, cool I come back to.
- 2:50Well, Tom, we're thrilled to have you on this and not going
- 2:52to call you Thomas, don't worry. I don't think I called him
- 2:55Thomas. They said Tom Amy's call, right?
- 2:59I was saying his last name which is hyphenated last name.
- 3:01Just giving you a hard time house.
- 3:02Come on. But but, but Tom, we really want
- 3:05to have you on here. We've known each other for a few
- 3:06years. I've I've appreciated like not
- 3:08only the content you post, but your point of view, which I
- 3:10think is kind of is, is, is unique and interesting.
- 3:14But we really wanted an episode about, you know, the gap between
- 3:17what the industry says, which is a lot.
- 3:18It's an industry where there's a lot of hot air, right?
- 3:20There's a lot of talk about AI platforms, operating systems,
- 3:24and there's a lot of change, right?
- 3:25That that's not pretend there isn't.
- 3:27But none of this happens. Absolutely none of it happens
- 3:30successfully unless companies really change how they operate
- 3:33and how they how decisions get made, how teams align and how
- 3:37leaders behave and how it really makes people feel, right?
- 3:39That's really important. I think it's underplayed a lot
- 3:41of times, especially when you look at these big Brett, to your
- 3:43point Matrix complex organizations or Tom, you've
- 3:46been in a room, you've been seeing these change happen,
- 3:49making them happen. And we'd love to talk today
- 3:52about what that's really all about.
- 3:54So thanks for coming. Yeah, and I've got, so I'll
- 3:56start with the questions here. So, so I had an interesting
- 3:58quote that I thought would would you know, start us off
- 4:01Transformation usually fails not because companies lack strategy,
- 4:04but because they cannot convert intent into coordinated
- 4:08behavior. So it's sort of like the old
- 4:10quote, strategy without execution is hallucination,
- 4:13right? What do you think is the largest
- 4:15blocker of of you know large matrix organizations or
- 4:19companies that have recently acquired other orgs into their
- 4:23into the mothership to actually be effective in terms of
- 4:26transformation and change management?
- 4:29Yeah. I mean, I, I think, yeah, a huge
- 4:32blocker. And, and this sometimes sounds
- 4:34obvious when you say it out loud is, is that clarity upfront and
- 4:39then the ability to then link that through to to an execution
- 4:42plan, right. And you know, if I think about
- 4:44my businesses that have been acquisitive or being acquired
- 4:47and bingo through change, one of the first stumbling blocks that
- 4:50they come up against is the inability to actually
- 4:54articulate, you know, what is what is complicated, A
- 4:57complicated strategy into something that is, is clear and
- 5:02is clear and it can be understood top to bottom.
- 5:04And you know, when you, when you get clarity, you then need to
- 5:07get alignment. And you know that alignment
- 5:09needs to be with your most senior executives, but it also
- 5:12needs to be those who are on the front line.
- 5:13And if you can't articulate what you're trying to do in a, in a
- 5:18way, you know, both in terms of the words, in terms of the, the
- 5:22methods, the, the, you know, go and pick anyone on your
- 5:25frontline and they understand what they're doing and how that
- 5:28connects to your overall goal, then you then you failed at the
- 5:31first hurdle. Yeah.
- 5:33And and would you say that strategy making sure that
- 5:36everybody understands the kind of fundamental strategy, do you
- 5:38have to break that up into pieces because there's
- 5:41organizational strategy, there's company, you know, KPI ROI
- 5:45oriented strategy. How do you how do you think
- 5:47about that? Yeah, I mean, I think so.
- 5:51I think like all this is in business, I think there's a lot
- 5:53of buzzwords and people take huge pride in some of the more
- 5:56interesting stuff. So, so strategy, yeah, has a
- 6:00huge amount of huge number of component parts to it.
- 6:03And I'd probably hasten that and link that link that to the
- 6:06operating model piece, right, which is people talk about
- 6:08strategy and operating model. And often what they really mean
- 6:12is, is a PowerPoint presentation for the strategy and an org
- 6:15chart for the operating model. And I think, you know, there's a
- 6:18bit of a lack of maturity in our industry.
- 6:20And I think if you go outside and talk to some, some clients
- 6:23that sit, you know, work with us that they're slightly more
- 6:26mature in here. But fundamentally, a strategy
- 6:28has a load of different component parts to it.
- 6:30Yes, there is a there is a presentation and there is a kind
- 6:33of a central organizing construct that you you can share
- 6:35out, but it is far more than that.
- 6:38And a good strategy has equal weighting and balance to what
- 6:41are you going to do to make that strategy land in the
- 6:43organization. So the execution of that plan
- 6:46equally with an operating model, you know, strategy is one part
- 6:50of that. Yes, the the boxes and sticks,
- 6:53the the org chart is one part of that.
- 6:56But but it is, you know, one part of many other parts.
- 7:00And when you think about the operating model and the things
- 7:03you need to do to make your strategy land, you're going to
- 7:05think about your talent. You've got to think about your
- 7:06performance management KPI, as you mentioned, think about, you
- 7:09know, the the culture you're trying to cultivate and
- 7:13encourage in your organization, how it links to your commercial
- 7:16outcomes. And so I think, yeah, first,
- 7:18first challenge is people think about strategy and an OP model
- 7:21is fairly binary things that are 1 offset pieces that a group of
- 7:24people get into a room and do and then job done, e-mail sent,
- 7:27town hall done. Yeah, that should just land and
- 7:31and be delivered. I find a lot of people confuse
- 7:34those terms like operating model or designed strategy.
- 7:38I mean, it's, I think there's a lack of clarity generally and
- 7:42people mix and match them. I don't really understand, but
- 7:44you think that's true? A. 100%, yeah.
- 7:46I think there's a, there's a, there's a whole number of kind
- 7:49of points of conflation. So I think operating model is,
- 7:54is you don't have to go and do a, a, a search to figure out
- 7:57there's lots of different models, right?
- 7:59You know, pick one doesn't really matter.
- 8:00An operating model describes lots of different connected
- 8:02components of the system structure, reporting lines is is
- 8:051, but, but not the only part of that.
- 8:08I think there's conflation around strategy and what that
- 8:11means. And I think there's also, you
- 8:12know, really present to, to my world, there's a, there's a
- 8:15conflation between transformation and optimization.
- 8:20And I think actually, if you, if you look at a lot of the
- 8:23companies in our space today that talk about transformation
- 8:27capital T, actually what they're doing is optimizing and
- 8:32restructuring. They're taking costs out.
- 8:35They're maybe reorganizing the, the kind of the roles, smashing
- 8:39together brands and capabilities.
- 8:41And maybe that sometimes feels and looks a bit like
- 8:43transformation. So the upwards, you know when
- 8:46they're we're having kind of reports.
- 8:47Really just tweaking and tuning something you don't.
- 8:50Get tired of that, right? There's constant, constant
- 8:52transformations, like transformation fatigue almost.
- 8:54I see a lot of that in the industry.
- 8:56Yeah. And and I think that's a really
- 8:58important word to pick up on. So people transformation
- 9:03fatigue, I get a bit knocked when I hear that comment.
- 9:06It's used fairly disparagingly by leaders to talk about the
- 9:09workforce and they argue everyone's, everyone's fatigue
- 9:12and IA little bit would would call that out and say if you go
- 9:16and talk to a 2530 year old in, in the kind of the the client
- 9:21teams, whatever they're not change fatigues per SE.
- 9:24They're fatigued of bad change, right.
- 9:26And and I think the the the breakdown is that they're they
- 9:31are recipients of dual point Rio wave after wave of real
- 9:35restructure. Well, they're not experiencing
- 9:39is a genuine reevaluation and and kind of rebuilding of the
- 9:46organization. You know, so it's, yeah, it's
- 9:47reorganizing the deck chairs, but not point.
- 9:49Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 9:51And when I find out, I know when I when you're saying operating
- 9:53model, I was thinking that as you're taking a change strategy,
- 9:56let's say it's an acquisition through an organization, the
- 9:58operating model almost in my experience and I've been through
- 10:01this more times than I can count M&A going from from startup sort
- 10:06of mid level SAS to acquisition. You know, I was I was part of an
- 10:10acquisition by TransUnion by a from a, you know, a company
- 10:14called Nustar X late to Nielsen. And these were examples of
- 10:17companies that had very tight, very specific cultures, SAS kind
- 10:23of tech forward cultures that suddenly were absorbed into much
- 10:27bigger animals. Right.
- 10:29And and at your to your point about about sort of you, you
- 10:32have this kind of overarching deck and and sort of the goal,
- 10:35the key goals and and strategic objectives around around an
- 10:39acquisition, for example. But what I find often breaks is,
- 10:44is that that it has to be sort of translated for every core
- 10:47function, right? Because people like I'm an
- 10:50operations person or I'm a marketing person or I'm a
- 10:52customer success person. And that strategy at a very high
- 10:55level often times gets lost in translation when it's brought to
- 10:59the specific teams themselves. And then the teams are like,
- 11:02well, what does it mean to me? And then you can go down even
- 11:05another lever that level down where like individuals within
- 11:08the team and that's where things get broken.
- 11:11Well, yeah, Brett, I think what what Tom called us is a really
- 11:14good point too. So what you just said like what
- 11:15it ends up meeting in practicality is just a shifting
- 11:18leaders are changing. It's just constant like like
- 11:20restructuring of just like reporting lines.
- 11:23It's not real transformation, right.
- 11:26I'd really like that point a lot.
- 11:27Yeah. And Brett, I think I, I've
- 11:29always kind of said if, if you, if you go and talk to, you know,
- 11:32the, the, the person, not necessarily the most junior, but
- 11:35the person furthest away from the CEO, right, in terms of
- 11:37levels and, and, and distance. If they can't say in sort of two
- 11:41or three steps, yeah, I do this, which is helping our company do
- 11:46that, which is linked to our vision.
- 11:48You've failed. And, and I think if you're in,
- 11:50if you're in a sort of a client facing role as well, you need to
- 11:54be able to, to articulate to your clients as well.
- 11:56You know our company is doing this and that is going to help
- 11:59you, Mr. or Missus client, be better at what you do.
- 12:02Yeah. So that being the very critical
- 12:05point, right, Because, yeah, yeah, once downstream, you're
- 12:08not actually able even to communicate this to clients at
- 12:10the client management level or the sales level.
- 12:13Yeah, that sorts of like deleterious effects on the.
- 12:16Company it's amazing how many people can't do that right you
- 12:19ask them and like and they're like well I don't even know and
- 12:21he asked them why all because they get changed all the time
- 12:24and yeah I. Don't or they're kind of making
- 12:26it up in the spot, right and you get a lot of.
- 12:28Yeah, and and people fill in the blanks, right?
- 12:30Because the people, again, you know, I'm, I'm, I'm not smithed.
- 12:33I believe people are trying to do the right thing.
- 12:34But if you're a client leader and you're in a client pitch
- 12:36room or a big meeting and a client asks you, you know,
- 12:39sorry, I've just read announcement X.
- 12:42What does this mean for me? The client leaders aren't
- 12:44normally going to go, I don't know.
- 12:45That's not, it's not normally their D for answer.
- 12:47They will make an answer up. And so again, the obligation
- 12:50comes back on on the business to say you've got to equip your
- 12:54your, your teams, your leaders, certainly those who are going
- 12:57having, you know, critically important conversations
- 12:59equipment with the information that they need.
- 13:00And going back to your point, Brett, that might have a few
- 13:03different lenses. You know, are you talking to a
- 13:05global client or a local client? Are you talking to a a client in
- 13:08a particular vertical or using a particular service?
- 13:11But as you think about communicating and making that
- 13:13strategy real, then you've got to be able to cut that into a
- 13:18really simple way that your core leaders or, or kind of your
- 13:21teams can go. Yeah, actually we're doing this
- 13:24thing that's gonna be really good for you because of.
- 13:26Why yes. And do you think this isn't just
- 13:28a, a calm strategy, right? This, you know, the people
- 13:31sometimes narrow it down to like, give me the messages, the
- 13:33key messages like you're APR, you know, leader, would you say
- 13:37it's more than that? I mean, because behavior doesn't
- 13:40change just because you've got a key messages document that says
- 13:44this is what it means. This is why you should care.
- 13:47Yeah, and, and you know, I think we've all been in a room where
- 13:51you've been creating a, a plan, transformation plan, strategy,
- 13:54plan, whatever. And someone comes in and they
- 13:56say, oh, we need, we need a change in comms line on that.
- 13:59And, and suddenly you wheel in a comms person and yeah, comms
- 14:02super brilliant, by the way. That word that there's some word
- 14:05smithing. Yeah.
- 14:06And it's like he create me a slide or a briefing pack or
- 14:09talking notes and that's that's part of it.
- 14:11But again, I think in the spirit of being kind of blunt and what
- 14:14what you know, on average the industry needs, there are people
- 14:16who do it well, obviously. But is yeah, the the obligation
- 14:20to to think about the impacts of change on a client or on a team
- 14:24That's on on the leaders. Now you can then lean on a comms
- 14:27person or a change person to help stress test that, to craft
- 14:31it, to maybe help you can build it out, but you can't outsource
- 14:34the responsibility to think about or what does this mean for
- 14:38Yeah, my client? Team A-Team B, Team A, Client A,
- 14:41Client B, Since you've got to train the trainers, right,
- 14:45you've got to train the leaders in order to be able to
- 14:47communicate that sort of that operating model, how it applies
- 14:50to that specific function, to that specific team.
- 14:54There's there's a, there's a pace around accountability now
- 14:56as well, which, yeah, everyone says they want accountability,
- 15:00but do they really want it? And you know, we've got some
- 15:02very senior leaders in our industry who, you know, have got
- 15:06roles leading big clients. They can't just expect to be
- 15:09spoon fed. And yeah, perhaps they're
- 15:11inflammatory but can't be spoon fed kind of, you know, what does
- 15:15something mean for their client? You know they need to be able to
- 15:17the ones who take account translating that.
- 15:20That's where they're hired, that's where they that's where
- 15:22they get paid the big bucks, right?
- 15:23But the agency world, I don't know, agency world, I think a
- 15:26lot of people like dock accountability.
- 15:29I think you know that the CYCOIA is pretty prevalent.
- 15:32I mean, I, I think that's a good point you just made.
- 15:34But but Todd, you've actually called out.
- 15:35You're ready. I really like this like you've
- 15:36called out a couple times. How like you've seen this where
- 15:39companies roll out a new strategy, then they just, you
- 15:42know, they don't give it enough time And maybe, you know, they
- 15:43maybe they missed details, maybe the execution's been bad.
- 15:45But next thing you know this, you know, it's broken.
- 15:47We're starting over and it just a cycle repeats again and again.
- 15:50Love you to talk a little bit about that.
- 15:51I really like that point you made.
- 15:53Yeah. I mean, I think it's probably
- 15:54for me over the last 10 years, the number one sort of problem
- 15:58and and frustration. You see big, big announcement.
- 16:01A huge amount of time is spent on creating the strategy.
- 16:04And there's these off sites. We fly people around the world
- 16:07in, in, in global businesses. I think I did a post about this.
- 16:10Yeah, everyone wants to be at the off site.
- 16:11Yeah, picture taken. We've done the new strategy.
- 16:13Here's the new buzzword, hashtag something.
- 16:16And then there's a the comms team diligently put together a,
- 16:19a whole roadshow, blah, blah, blah.
- 16:22We've all been there, done that. And then, you know, that's day
- 16:25one. And then you look around and
- 16:28suddenly everyone's fallen away. All the the execs have gone, you
- 16:31know, and focusing on something else.
- 16:32And they've probably got a couple of project managers to go
- 16:35and make this giant shift happen.
- 16:36And I'm not saying one should be more important than the other,
- 16:39but the two halves, the equation needs to be looked at, you know,
- 16:42in equal measure and equal balance.
- 16:44And so yes, spend some time on creating a really good strategy
- 16:47for sure, but but spend equal energy on thinking about how do
- 16:54you then make that sticks? The, you know, the routines and
- 16:58the rituals. Again, at a team level, you
- 17:00know, or a market level, what what needs to be in place to
- 17:02make sure that the, the strategy, the structure, the
- 17:05products, whatever you're kind of, you know, thinking about
- 17:07changing or building, they stick and that takes time.
- 17:12And you know, no one likes to hear that you can accelerate it,
- 17:14you can focus it and do sprints. But yeah, we're, we're people
- 17:18back to that very early point. And, and people take a while to
- 17:21learn new habits and behaviors. They can do it given the right
- 17:24conditions. And so you need to get the time
- 17:26right space and need to make sure those things bed in because
- 17:30the worst thing that can happen, and we've we've seen this across
- 17:33several, you know, examples in, in our industry is to your point
- 17:37where, you know, new strategy gets announced.
- 17:39It's been taken, probably taken 18 months for strategy to be
- 17:41created. And then three months, six
- 17:44months down the line, it's it's not driving sort of radically
- 17:47different results. And then, you know, Zach
- 17:49suddenly says, well, let's, let's change it.
- 17:51We must need a new thing. And suddenly go from country LED
- 17:54to client LED and capability LED.
- 17:56And people have got whiplash in the organization and the
- 17:59frontline teams, which again are 98% of the people we employ in
- 18:03these organizations, like what's going on?
- 18:06And then they just start making up their own strategy because
- 18:08they they can't operate in a world whereby every six months
- 18:11there's a new thing. And so that's when you get into
- 18:13the really dangerous area of leaders, teams creating their
- 18:17own shadow strategy, their own structure, and that's where you
- 18:21get. Potential fiefdoms almost by
- 18:23nature. Yeah.
- 18:24So I mean, it's sort of the same thing that kills value after
- 18:27acquisitions. I mean, weak integration, you
- 18:29know, in your, in your investors, your shareholders
- 18:31actually see it unresolved politics, which can be poisonous
- 18:35and toxic with an organization like the fiefdoms you just
- 18:37mentioned, kind of unclear decision rights.
- 18:39And where are these decisions coming from?
- 18:41Where are they? Are they, are they?
- 18:43And often times, like I, I find within organizations that I've
- 18:46been part of that have gone through this is that they, they
- 18:49kind of the culture of the organization starts getting
- 18:51discussed as like a belief system.
- 18:54And but it, to me that only goes so far, right?
- 18:57It's like the rah, rah, rah wave your hand.
- 18:59We're all in this together. We're going to fight till the
- 19:01end, you know, and then, and then you, you sit back as a
- 19:05leader or, or somebody on a team and you're like, well, how, how
- 19:09do I actually tactically, technically implement this
- 19:12within my organization, which to, to me says there has to be
- 19:15kind of an operating model behind this.
- 19:16Just like when you're launching a product to market, there's an
- 19:19operating discipline. And it seems is that what's
- 19:22driving a lot of the the failure in in?
- 19:25Yeah, I mean, I, I, I first actually go back to a point you
- 19:29just mentioned politics, right, Which is, yeah, a huge, everyone
- 19:34talks about it, sort of jokes about it, but it's, it's a huge
- 19:38reality in any organization. But it, it, it's definitely
- 19:41prevalent in scaled organizations.
- 19:43And I think compounds when you, when you've got multiple
- 19:46services and multiple geographies and the amount of
- 19:49energy an an effort and ultimately cost that that is
- 19:53spent on internal positioning versus sort of, you know,
- 19:56external value is huge. And, you know, we've all seen
- 20:00the research around how many hours are spent in meetings.
- 20:03A lot of those meetings are created for, for political
- 20:05reason, you know, sort of ask covering crazy shutter.
- 20:08So I think, I think that's, that's, that's key.
- 20:10And and that leads into what I call like the the nodding room,
- 20:13which is, you know, a really dangerous dynamic I see with
- 20:16leadership teams where big important meeting happens.
- 20:19All the execs around a table or off site, whatever, and
- 20:22everyone's like, Yep, Yep, that's a great idea.
- 20:23Everyone's nodding, you know, really great.
- 20:26And then they all leave the room and then at best they are kind
- 20:29of, you know, quiet and ignore that the agreements at worst go
- 20:33and brief against it. And then you have, you know,
- 20:36corridor conversations and shadow strategies and then left,
- 20:39left unmanaged. You then have, you know, an
- 20:43entire unpicking of of the decisions that are made.
- 20:45And so you've got, you've got to, in my view, you're going to
- 20:47name that and you're going to get your leader, your or
- 20:49whoever's bringing that group together.
- 20:52They've got to be really strong and firm in, in really
- 20:55unearthing. There's difficult questions that
- 20:56people actually keep nodding out but aren't actually happy with
- 20:59and force that conversation, you know, disagree and commit
- 21:02whatever you want to call it and then hold those leaders to
- 21:05account to go and deliver that and take action if they're not
- 21:09delivering it. Yeah.
- 21:10And that's difficult because we're a relationship business.
- 21:12So, so I think the politics pieces is critical and shouldn't
- 21:16be sort of under. Yeah, and growing the right type
- 21:19of context, right for Rihanna, you're going to say something.
- 21:21But but the right type of environment or or or place or
- 21:25setting for people to be able to voice to wear the Black Hat like
- 21:28in the in, you know, kind of that classic example of six
- 21:31different halves. Right.
- 21:31Yeah, but, but I've been in those rooms, Brett, where it's
- 21:34like everyone's nodding and Tom, I'm sure you've seen this
- 21:37before, but like a couple people there know that something's
- 21:39really fundamentally wrong with the strategy or what's being
- 21:42decided. And like, yeah, you can, you can
- 21:45be, you can be part of the consensus and not or you or you
- 21:48can say something. And I've been in those rooms
- 21:50where like it like dissent was not appreciated.
- 21:53And I think that's a very like, that's a very dangerous place
- 21:56for a company to be in. Yeah.
- 21:57And I find the bigger the meetings get ready to your point
- 21:59and this just happened. I mean, this has happened a
- 22:01couple of times where, where we would have monthly operating,
- 22:03you know, meetings, right, and you'd get every, you get a whole
- 22:06large kind of multifunctional team.
- 22:09And the, and there was a certain point, like a certain threshold,
- 22:11like when you cross this line of the, of the, of the meeting
- 22:14getting too large, regardless of how it was positioned as being
- 22:18sort of a democratic opportunity to share your opinions and share
- 22:22that, you know, this is, this is the team that runs the
- 22:24organization. And so if you don't say it now,
- 22:26you're not going to say it ever. Often times George will put that
- 22:29in place as if it's going to help bring things to the surface
- 22:33that need to be brought to the surface.
- 22:35And often times, to your point, Rio, you, you just get a lot of
- 22:38people nodding because of just the dynamics, the power
- 22:41dynamics, the nature of large groups.
- 22:44Some people are less likely to speak out in large groups than
- 22:46others, right? So you have to, I think, sort of
- 22:48set up an environment where people can communicate these
- 22:51things that doesn't like, you know, potentially embarrass them
- 22:55in front of a large group and people.
- 22:57You get into some really interesting stuff, right?
- 23:00You get into obviously the psychology of meetings and
- 23:03people and cultural differences and, and geographic differences.
- 23:06And yeah, when you're running a global meeting like that, you
- 23:10know, you've got to lean in and appreciate the fact that there
- 23:13are inbuilt defaults, if you will, based on where people are
- 23:17coming from in that meeting. And so, yeah, there are some
- 23:19cultures that are absolutely happy to in the room in the
- 23:22moment to how their their opinion, you know, and we're
- 23:26talking on yours. There are some cultures that are
- 23:31they more reflective and we'll we'll say maybe and these are
- 23:36the Brits typically, you know, who will maybe be more.
- 23:38Have we thought about this? There are some cultures that
- 23:40wouldn't dream of saying something in the room.
- 23:42So the. Japanese.
- 23:44Yeah, of running those meetings is, you know, there's probably a
- 23:49bit of pre work to be done to make sure people have got a time
- 23:51to digest it and some people reflect.
- 23:53I'm a reflector, right? So I, I, I normally react very
- 23:56quickly, but then a day later my brain defrags and I go actually
- 23:59here's some here's some further thoughts.
- 24:02I always appreciate, you know, if it's a big discussion, just
- 24:05having sight of some of the things to talk about so you can
- 24:07structure the meetings. And equally you don't always
- 24:10have to have everyone in every meeting.
- 24:13And I think sometimes you can break down.
- 24:15It might be two or three people who you know, are going to be
- 24:18the ones who have the most input and feedback.
- 24:22And so don't create a breakout with those people to be more
- 24:25efficient. Doesn't matter the other people.
- 24:27And then you might come back to ratify it with the broader
- 24:29group, but give the right space environment.
- 24:31So yeah, it's it's hard because it is a bit dependent on each
- 24:34group's dynamic, but have. You have you actually what do
- 24:38you think about like the back to that idea of the 6th thinking
- 24:42hats, right? Like where you actually
- 24:44designate people in the room to play the Black Hat, the green
- 24:47hat, the the blue hat. You know, there's like a
- 24:49creative hat. There's a somebody that.
- 24:52I think that could be how that could be constructive, but like
- 24:55contrived. But but I've seen that work best
- 24:57where you have people of different love, because The
- 24:59thing is, I where I've seen strategies fall down.
- 25:02And Tom, I'd love to hear what you think about this is where
- 25:04like you've got people who will come to the strategy and you
- 25:06have people implementing the strategy, right?
- 25:08I mean, it just sometimes you can have a, a pretty big divide
- 25:11between them and where the people implementing it are like,
- 25:13actually like, no, that's not going to work because here's
- 25:15curious reasons, AB and C, why the the strategy is
- 25:18fundamentally flawed. And so that you need people from
- 25:21the different levels in order to be giving feedback, right?
- 25:23And I don't, I don't know, thoughts on that because I've
- 25:25seen a lot of times the strategy is cooked up at, at, you know,
- 25:27let's say at A, at a top level, but then like it's, it's
- 25:32impractical and it kind of Withers on the vine after.
- 25:34That and so I think I think related to this, I think
- 25:37something, you know, when people say, you know what a what a
- 25:40great leader is looking like these days.
- 25:42I think there is a there is a muscle that's I think it's
- 25:46always have to be there. But I think is is increasingly
- 25:48important of of leaders who are responsible for strategy essay.
- 25:52I mean, all leaders, but certainly in this context of
- 25:54being able to say, well, let's zoom in and look at a bit of our
- 25:58organization and look at understanding how work is done.
- 26:01I'm not expecting every leader to understand everything.
- 26:03Yeah, we're vastly complex systems.
- 26:05Yeah. Everyone will come from a core
- 26:07area, T shape, M shape, whatever.
- 26:09But I think a muscle that a leader, a good leader can
- 26:11exhibit is, yeah, identifying when they're creating strategy,
- 26:14zooming in or taking the council of people where to zoom in,
- 26:17understand how that work is done, where the friction is, you
- 26:20know, what the implications and consequences of said strategy
- 26:22would be. So then zoom out again and look
- 26:25at how that sits in terms of the broader kind of system.
- 26:27And having those two things, there's two kind of frames and
- 26:31kind of distances in parallel becomes a really important
- 26:35dimension of a good leader because you have to be able to
- 26:38understand the consequences of the strategy.
- 26:41You don't have to be living in that, in that sort of deep dive,
- 26:44but you've got to be able to go there to understand how things
- 26:46are actually executed by the feet on the ground.
- 26:48And then you'll be able to pull out.
- 26:50And if you don't have that perspective, your strategy to
- 26:53your point, Rio will die in the. I think there's a, there's a bit
- 26:56of a, a catch people fall into and this is not my words.
- 27:00This is ingenui. The old, you know, the PepsiCo
- 27:03CEO talks about this. I think in today's world whereby
- 27:07we are running such complex businesses, the the more senior
- 27:11you become, the more student you need to be, right?
- 27:13You need to accept you don't know everything.
- 27:15Maybe in past generations when you were the top of the tree,
- 27:18you knew everything. But I think in today's world,
- 27:22you know, you know less as you become more senior because
- 27:24you're looking at such a complex web of things.
- 27:26So that the skill you have to build is actually your point.
- 27:29Brett is being able to say, well, who are the experts I can
- 27:31go and talk to you about 123 and how do I then go and zoom in and
- 27:35figure out what the right things are and then zoom back out
- 27:37again. And it's being able to do both
- 27:38those things at the same time or.
- 27:39Knowing who to talk to, that's super important.
- 27:42Yeah. I mean, that's, I think any good
- 27:43leaders going to know, they're going to know right away because
- 27:45they, you know, because like they may not be like in the
- 27:47weeds as much as they were because they can't, to your
- 27:49point a second ago, they have other responsibilities, but
- 27:52they, they, they should have their finger on the pulse of the
- 27:55organization well enough to know, OK, these are the real
- 27:57leaders that are, that are doing things that know what's going
- 28:00on. And if I'm going to come up with
- 28:01a strategy, I better get their input and they're buying, right?
- 28:04Yeah, and related, I think there's something a skill the
- 28:10leaders need to build around knowing, knowing where to zoom
- 28:14in, but also kind of where to pick into.
- 28:15So the reason I say that is when, when you're creating a
- 28:17strategy. And the same could be said for
- 28:19if you're, you know, sharing results in a, in a, in an
- 28:22earnings call or, or a pitch. The, the, the, the global big
- 28:30organisations are vastly, you know, diverse in terms of
- 28:33services, lots of different layers.
- 28:36By the time you're at a senior level, you've had probably if
- 28:39you, if you ask for a deep dive about particular technology or
- 28:41particular service, yeah, that ask goes down 5 layers, 6 layers
- 28:47to people who know what they're talking about, then comes back
- 28:49up again. And each time it comes back up,
- 28:50someone's putting their own shine and finesse on it and
- 28:53managing up because that's what people do, right?
- 28:54Yeah. People want to make sure they
- 28:56impress the boss. And so by the time the, the CEO,
- 28:59you know, the the leader gets the state of nation
- 29:03presentation, it's probably like 50% exaggerated because it's got
- 29:06all these kind of. It's completely divorced from
- 29:08reality. I think I see this right.
- 29:10I mean, caveat, there's lots of people who don't do this and do
- 29:13this really well. But there is a common trap that
- 29:15people fall into. And you see this in, in earnings
- 29:18calls and pitches whereby leaders not not dishonestly,
- 29:24naively are presenting, you know, this tool does this or, or
- 29:28we've got a solution around our markets that does this to it, to
- 29:31a client or to investors. And, and again, not, not not
- 29:35purposely dishonestly, but that information has been built for
- 29:38so many layers of kind of exaggerated wildlife truths that
- 29:43they believe it. And actually, you go and talk to
- 29:45the practitioners on the ground, they're still stitching
- 29:48together, you know, 65 different systems doing something.
- 29:51Is that? Because the practitioners are
- 29:52tea are telling the leader this just reminds me of our country
- 29:57what they want to hear, you know, and sycophantic like I'm
- 30:00going to tell that the leader, you know, the great leader of
- 30:03what they want to hear and then it and then the leader doesn't
- 30:06isn't fully informed and it is that.
- 30:09Actually, I think Tom, before you answer, I actually think
- 30:11there are people who manage up really well and there are people
- 30:14who manage down really well and they're very the big the best
- 30:17leaders do them both well. Yeah.
- 30:18I think the worst leaders are the ones who manage up well but
- 30:21suck at managing down because they will it'll be a toxic waste
- 30:25dump. The org, the org they're
- 30:26running, they don't care. It'll be like the everything
- 30:28they do will be to the like at at the expense of the people who
- 30:31report them because they don't care about them.
- 30:33They don't know what they're what's going on.
- 30:34All they care about is perception of.
- 30:36So I don't know that's having. Worked a big work so well really
- 30:38do you think? Do you think it's because of
- 30:39bandwidth though? Because I've been in
- 30:41organizations, PE bad startups, you don't think it's where the
- 30:45leaders so obsessed with new CEO comes on new leadership team.
- 30:49They're so obsessed with integrating with that group that
- 30:52they're they're lose. They're not able to just pay
- 30:55attention to. I think a good leader will will
- 30:57be able to do both. But Tom, I'm Yeah, I wish I cut
- 31:00you off. Go.
- 31:01Ahead, I think it's, yeah, I agree.
- 31:02I think for sure there are moments in time in, in, in, in
- 31:06the BA U cycle around results. And then when you've got changes
- 31:09like new leaders or clients that, that, that create a
- 31:11pension and that, that, yeah, we all know that like when we're
- 31:14stressed and and lacking time, that the worst versions of
- 31:17ourselves pop out. But but I, I think generally as
- 31:20an underlying behaviour skill of, of a good or bad leader in
- 31:26being able to do that. And it comes back to, I think
- 31:28some of it comes back to, you know, the, the ability of that
- 31:30leader to create the right culture.
- 31:33The culture again, is something that often gets banded around as
- 31:36a bit of a wishy washy kind of let's put some values on the
- 31:39wall. Let's just do Wellness often and
- 31:41those things are important artifacts of it.
- 31:44But again, a good a good leader will say, well, you know, what
- 31:46culture do we want to cultivate? You can't just create a culture.
- 31:50You know, what have we got and where do we want to build?
- 31:51What are things we want to dial up, dial down?
- 31:53And, and part of that is around, you know, the, the things we've
- 31:56been talking about, which is how do we want our teams to manage
- 31:58up and down? How do you want information to
- 32:00be shared and creating a, an environment, you know, the whole
- 32:03radical kind of kind of piece where actually, you know, your
- 32:07teams feel, yeah, your teams feel comfortable giving and
- 32:11receiving feedback, which is, you know, that might not be
- 32:13perfect. And that applies up and down the
- 32:16chain to then get to a culture whereby, yeah, genuine honesty,
- 32:20even if sometimes that's a little bit uncomfortable for,
- 32:23you know, the moment genuinely leads to better results in the
- 32:26long run. Yeah.
- 32:27Well, one thing that I, we actually experienced that done
- 32:29really well where when it came to company values, when it came
- 32:33to company strategic direction, it was actually kind of a group.
- 32:36Like think of it as senior leadership team that's beyond
- 32:39just the, the Uber executive team that's actually coming up
- 32:43with these things in kind of group sessions so that they're
- 32:48not being told what you know, what, what your cultural values
- 32:51are, what your strategic objectives are, you know, and so
- 32:54they get voted up and so they feel like they're part of the
- 32:56process of actually building the process.
- 32:58Important. Yeah.
- 32:59So critically important. And then and then, yeah, then
- 33:02then to me, I think when things were breakdown where there where
- 33:04there's a lack of community, you start to implement some of these
- 33:07things and the communication starts to slow down and it
- 33:10starts to stop. And people are like, where did
- 33:12that thing go? Where did that particular you
- 33:14know, and? Maybe picking up on your kind of
- 33:17urban leadership point, I think there is a if I think three kind
- 33:20of way some of these where these things fail and succeed.
- 33:24If you think of the organization really simplistic, you know,
- 33:27your senior exec and exec team, they are typically all aligned
- 33:33because they're all in the same room and quite frankly, they're
- 33:35paid enough to absorb into pain and friction.
- 33:38You've got your frontline who as we talked about before,
- 33:40actually, you know, going to ask most 30 year olds who are
- 33:42driving companies, they are dead up for change and they want to
- 33:45do this stuff. They don't want to be sat and
- 33:46excelled in. You've got this sort of group of
- 33:48what I'd call maybe middle management or maybe so that sort
- 33:50of extended leadership team who probably have grown up in a
- 33:54world whereby there being incentivized behaviours that we
- 33:56now don't want. They probably haven't been
- 33:58involved in all the kind of really senior kind of alignment
- 34:00sessions, but they're the ones who are, you know, I don't know,
- 34:04capability leaders leading big clients, maybe markets.
- 34:07They're the ones who have to stand up in front of the teams
- 34:10and explain the change, explain the culture of slain, what we're
- 34:14doing with that group of people on on cohesive, excuse me,
- 34:20unaligned and unable to, you know, back to our earliest ones,
- 34:24articulate the what and the why. Create that culture that you
- 34:27know, cultivates the right up and down because they are, they
- 34:30are the the gatekeepers. The connections issue, yeah.
- 34:34Both ways. And so that middle management,
- 34:36also some senior management layer, I think is such a under
- 34:39invested area in, in organizations because they've
- 34:43become they're the communicators of the messages.
- 34:46They're the gatekeepers of information up and down.
- 34:49And if you don't get that bunch of people working, you know,
- 34:54cohesively around kind of the culture you want to create, then
- 34:56then you've got a real problem. That's a really, that's a really
- 34:59good point. So like I guess Tom turning to
- 35:00like the advertising industry and specifically looking at hold
- 35:03coasting as you, you have years of experience working at senior
- 35:05levels. This is what we really want to
- 35:06dig into. We recently published an article
- 35:09in Sigla Noise that I wrote about kind of holding companies
- 35:11in their transition to more operating, operating different
- 35:15operating model like more like operating companies having our
- 35:18operating systems maybe even and how this is seems to be the
- 35:21direction like many, much of the industry is trending.
- 35:24We have perspective like this is free, let's take it.
- 35:27How far away are these orgs, which are big and complex and
- 35:30multinational? How far away are they from doing
- 35:32anything like this? Well, so another caveat, there
- 35:38are some that are doing brilliantly.
- 35:39You know, there's, you know, there's outliers.
- 35:41I think if we're talking in, in general, then I think probably
- 35:47further away than they say and probably further away than they
- 35:51realize. And yes, 2 steps.
- 35:55A lot of that is back to what we're talking about before.
- 35:56I think in terms of the, the senior leaders quite possibly
- 36:02believe when they're in the room that they are further ahead.
- 36:07And that's a combination of, you know, the way information is
- 36:11being packaged up, the fact they have to sell a little bit
- 36:14farther ahead to, to, you know, satisfy various kind of, you
- 36:17know, stakeholder groups. But I, I think probably in, in
- 36:23many of the large, you know, global firms, certainly the ones
- 36:26that I've been in and seen and worked in and around, I think
- 36:30the reality is still a little bit far off.
- 36:31Yeah. That's not to say there's not
- 36:33pockets of excellence. And I think in every company
- 36:35there'll be, there'll be clients where it's nailed.
- 36:38So that'll often be because you've got heroic efforts of
- 36:41people who want to make change at a local level.
- 36:44You've got perhaps integration happening because of some
- 36:48relationships and, and favours being called internally versus
- 36:51like systematized integration. You've got technology working
- 36:54because they've, you know, worked around the clock to make
- 36:56it work. But is, is the kind of the, the
- 36:59model is advanced as people say it is.
- 37:02I, I, I don't think it is. And I think if we go and go back
- 37:07to our early conversation, you know, that's, I think because
- 37:10the, the strategies are all probably sound, but then getting
- 37:14that strategy to be delivered across the organization end to
- 37:17end requires energy, effort and investment in some form, which
- 37:21is, which is often lacking. Not in all cases, but yeah.
- 37:25And the old codes have grown from, I mean where you had a lot
- 37:27of acquisition, right, classic example, a lot of point
- 37:30solutions that were part of those acquisitions, a lot of
- 37:33sort of R&D that's done in sort of innovation centers of
- 37:36excellence. But it's not unified around a
- 37:38central, it's a product org, right, where it's centralized
- 37:41and you're trying to bring all that together plus huge volumes
- 37:45of headcount with the FT ES and, and this kind of reminded me of
- 37:49it. It seems like change just
- 37:51generally in the advertising industry, in the tech industry,
- 37:53obviously at operating Holt and Holtkos is, is just the, the
- 37:59change is more frequent, higher volume, right, potentially even
- 38:04more radical with AI. And it like I, I was reading a
- 38:06Harvard Business Review article that said that employees are
- 38:09seeing five to seven times more change and this is recent today
- 38:14than they were seven years ago. Doesn't surprise me.
- 38:17Yeah. And so the adoption to that
- 38:19change from a correlation perspective has dropped as well
- 38:22from 72% of supporter change to about 42% of employees.
- 38:26And, and to me, you know, hold codes are a perfect example of
- 38:30like massive amounts of change, disruption, technology
- 38:35integration, trying to unify point solutions and teams that
- 38:38come across, you know, from, from acquisition in many cases.
- 38:42How do you, how do you coach agencies?
- 38:45How have you thought about that as a transformation leader?
- 38:47So, yeah, so I think, I think as all was definitely all true.
- 38:50I think there's a few things so I would say, and again, these
- 38:53are the obvious things, but say them out loud and hopefully they
- 38:56resonate. 1 is transformation. I think yeah, there's a paradigm
- 39:01shift in in play already and needs to be accelerated.
- 39:04Which transformation? So the big tech tech
- 39:06transformations used to be big program start to end and you
- 39:10know, big CapEx projects, blah, blah.
- 39:12Everyone says done and we'll we'll revisit that technology
- 39:14again in five years time. That's just not the case.
- 39:17You know, the, the, the stats you just talked about because,
- 39:19you know, every a week there's a new model released in a new
- 39:22piece of AI and everyone's got my ward already now.
- 39:25So I think, yeah, part of the the job of people leading
- 39:30transformations is as well as to deliver any specific kind of
- 39:35initiatives or or kind of programs of the moment is to
- 39:38build Easier said than done, you know, a culture or a behaviour
- 39:43of adaptability because we are going to be going through this
- 39:46for a while. And so it needs to be, you know,
- 39:49integration is a great point. Yeah, yeah, the business
- 39:52businesses have been and probably will be acquisitive.
- 39:57We've got to build it into kind of our rhythm.
- 39:59And that's, that's, that's the industry we're in.
- 40:01And you know, change is going to be here.
- 40:02We are, I think, wonderfully positioned.
- 40:07I talk to my friends who don't work in this industry, you know,
- 40:08we're right at the forefront of disruption.
- 40:10It's really exciting. We're going to make it feel
- 40:12exciting. And to make it feel exciting,
- 40:13we've got to build a kind of a slightly different like paradigm
- 40:17and culture, as I say, of, of how we work and our rhythms of,
- 40:20of business around, you know, this sort of always on change,
- 40:27being more adaptable and what doesn't help there.
- 40:30And again, which is where I think we need to think things
- 40:32through is, is certainly the list of companies, you know,
- 40:34quarterly results, annual results drive so much of the the
- 40:38rhythm. You know, every quarterly result
- 40:40requires a bit of a reset and mini strategy.
- 40:42It's almost like there's a Sprint of transformation between
- 40:44each one. I think there's an opportunity
- 40:46to rethink how we do that. And you know, to to I think the
- 40:49ones that are winning have a more longer term consistent
- 40:52approach to that. It's fine to have my views, fine
- 40:57to have a path that changes. It's fine to find course correct
- 41:01as long as people have a have a clear vision of this of the high
- 41:04level vision, right. And it goes back to our earlier
- 41:06point of if your teams can start up and say this is where we're
- 41:09going, yeah, this is the sort of business we're going to become.
- 41:12These are the sort of things we're going to do.
- 41:13This is sort of how it's going to work.
- 41:15The path they choose to get there, you know, whether they're
- 41:17using tool A or 2P becomes less consequential.
- 41:20Where where we where that where where that state you talked
- 41:23about in terms everyone's receiving so much change becomes
- 41:25a problem is when there isn't that North Star, because then
- 41:28all that happens is people feel they're being buffered around
- 41:30zigzag kind of flip-flopped and people then get disenfranchised.
- 41:34The firm gets accused of not knowing where they're going and
- 41:36sewing going all the way back to that first thing we were talking
- 41:38about clarity of division and strategy in a way that people
- 41:42can understand that that's clear enough and broad enough that you
- 41:48know, whether it's tool A or tool B tomorrow or whether we're
- 41:51using capable like that. That sort of is a is a how we
- 41:54get there versus where we're going.
- 41:58So, Tom, I think people like outside of the industry or let's
- 42:02say outside of agencies and holding companies typically
- 42:05underestimate how how they are actually very good at changing.
- 42:09There's been multiple iterations.
- 42:11I mean, I can't tell you how many times in you know, my
- 42:12career, don't you know, like it goes back 25 years.
- 42:14People all like this is in housing is going to destroy
- 42:17agencies. Guess what?
- 42:18It didn't you know, they fought back and they figured out and
- 42:20like it's like they're really good at that.
- 42:22I I the best and it's funny, I had just analogy all like
- 42:25they're like agencies, like cockroaches, you know, they they
- 42:27would survive a nuclear war. They figure out a way they'd
- 42:30evolve right. So, but sorry, people
- 42:32underestimate that. But but that said, I mean,
- 42:35Brett, to your point, changes never happened as quickly and
- 42:37maybe AI, maybe this time is different.
- 42:39I don't know thoughts on that. How how impactful will this be
- 42:42on the model on the way work gets done and the FTE model?
- 42:45Curious get your thoughts. So yeah, a few things.
- 42:51Maybe not a cockroach, but it's something like whack A mole, I
- 42:53think. Yeah, there's always something.
- 42:55What? Kind of the title of this
- 42:56episode. Agencies are like cockroaches.
- 43:00And I think maybe the continued energy that the frequency of
- 43:03whack A mole things is coming is is increasing, right?
- 43:05And you know, the, the commercial models, the the way
- 43:08in which partners and the ecosystems evolving is all is
- 43:11all accelerating. Those things have been there.
- 43:14And I think, you know, that the, the, the world of new
- 43:17technologies is not new, You know, facts to Internet, to
- 43:19mobile, to digital, it's all stuff.
- 43:20But the pace of that and the distance between each is, is
- 43:23increasing. But I think my kind of personal
- 43:27view on this would be that what we're seeing is that the the the
- 43:29pace and attention that AI is getting, rightly or wrongly, is
- 43:38surfacing and acting as a catalyst to solve some
- 43:42structural challenges that the industry has had way before this
- 43:45AI. Yeah, these changes are going to
- 43:47be had to be made anyways. So, you know, to your point now
- 43:51in housing offshoring, you know, technology automation, you know,
- 43:56services spinning up services, but all those things have been
- 43:58happening for decades, but we've been able to manage it by sort
- 44:01of lurching point. I think what's now happening is,
- 44:03is the pace of that and, and the, the, the depth of that is,
- 44:06is such which you can't avoid it anymore.
- 44:09And so we're now having to lean into genuinely address things
- 44:12like, OK, if you know, 3040 + 50% of of work today is going to
- 44:17be done differently. How do I charge that?
- 44:20How do I get rewarded that by clients?
- 44:21You know, the commercial conversation is now good one.
- 44:24Why, you know, how do I govern intellectual property and new
- 44:28all those sort of things which I've been bubbling away.
- 44:31I mean, I've been in rooms for years.
- 44:32We talked about, you know, these sort of questions, but now they
- 44:35are unavoidable questions that have to be answered in in the
- 44:38near term. You can't disrupt under the rug
- 44:40anymore, right? Yeah.
- 44:42And I think yeah, there's there's you know things, things
- 44:43that are also coming out of the wash that have been under
- 44:46arrested in I was talking to to a client about this this week is
- 44:49at 1 talent planning. You know, I think our industry
- 44:53is really mature in this where, you know, we have always had
- 44:56services that are emergent services that are growing,
- 44:59services that are in structural decline.
- 45:02And the industry has always seemed to address that by, you
- 45:05know, hiring a lot of new capables over here and firing a
- 45:07load of capables over there. Rather than having a three-year
- 45:09workforce plan that says, why don't we take some of these
- 45:12people that are in that team that's declining, retrain,
- 45:15redeploy and move them there. You know, you avoid the hiring
- 45:18and firing cost, you retain the institutional knowledge and you
- 45:20have a much better kind of, you know, kind of place for everyone
- 45:23to work. So, so I think town planning and
- 45:26then I guess it goes back to the point around operating model,
- 45:29you know, the, the earlier conversation is these things are
- 45:32new things. Yeah.
- 45:34And all I need to look at, but they're happening now at a
- 45:38scale, breadth and depth that means that you've got no choice
- 45:41but to face into them because other people are up, you know,
- 45:43eating their lunch. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 45:45And you mentioned that indie agencies and PE backed firms
- 45:48might have an advantage in this, in this, in this play.
- 45:52And and I wonder with PE firms, I mean, do you see that to kind
- 45:56of a leading question here? Do you see that indie agencies?
- 46:00I can see. So I'd love to hear your
- 46:01perspective on that. P backed firms, is there a bit
- 46:05of short termism that that forces, you know, thought that
- 46:11forces action that may not be the best long term strategic
- 46:13action just simply because of the price, the the pressure.
- 46:17Yes. So I think in the Indies, yeah,
- 46:19two point I think yeah, a lot, a lot of them, all of them they've
- 46:21got less of that says structural debt, less of the the competing
- 46:26PNLS, the legacy brands, the personality matrix kind of
- 46:30stuff. So, so they can act more like
- 46:32integrated businesses, probably because they.
- 46:35Found the get go. They're almost built that way.
- 46:37Yeah. And and then I think PE is
- 46:40interesting, right. On one hand, you don't have the
- 46:44reporting out of the street every quarter, which as we
- 46:46talked about a minute ago has a whole set of of kind of.
- 46:49Big advantage in some ways. Yeah.
- 46:53And and so the time horizon is perhaps longer, you know a
- 46:57couple of years, but but the expectation is, is greater I
- 47:00would say. Yeah, I think you're still.
- 47:01Reporting out, you're just not reporting out to the street, so.
- 47:04You're three to five years to do something, but I do.
- 47:06So that's going to be a big event, right.
- 47:07It's not going to be just a good quarter, right?
- 47:09It's going to be, it's going to be an exit spin off or
- 47:11something. Yeah, what it does and this is
- 47:14anecdotal, but I think if you if you look at a lot of the space
- 47:20is full of operators who have come from not just advertising,
- 47:22but yeah, all over the all over industry.
- 47:24And I think there is a certain level of maturity around what it
- 47:27takes to drive some of these things and the ability to come
- 47:30into a media and advertising business with the relentless
- 47:33focus on value creation. And they are, you know, if you
- 47:36talk about creating clarity, creating focus, go into a room
- 47:40with APE person and you know, you haven't got you can't afford
- 47:45not to be focused and clear on what you're doing.
- 47:48Yeah. And I and I think there is,
- 47:50there is a benefit to that. So there's this.
- 47:52Yeah, there's pros and cons to to any and all of the options,
- 47:55but I think they. Have the patience to train and
- 47:57to change for change management. I mean, what I've seen in my own
- 48:00experience is that if a person is not, you know, let's say a
- 48:04person that's that's, or a team is not sort of fit for the
- 48:07specific job at hand today and we need to shift them to the job
- 48:11at hand tomorrow, right? Oftentimes there's zero patients
- 48:16with any sort of internal education.
- 48:18With PE firms or. Yeah, PE firms, and I've seen it
- 48:21in my own experience. And So what do they do is they
- 48:23just fire. They go right to fire because
- 48:26there's no time for training and development in transport.
- 48:29It's funny, Brian, I've had a bunch of clients and partners
- 48:32who've gotten bought by PE over the over the years.
- 48:37It's interesting. I mean, there's been a couple of
- 48:39that great outcomes, like a Marketo, for example.
- 48:41I remember I was, yeah, I, I work with them for years.
- 48:44They came in, they got rid of the entire sales team.
- 48:46I mean, they, they sacked everyone.
- 48:48You know what, I don't think they were very good, to be
- 48:50honest. They brought in a bunch of
- 48:51better. Ones.
- 48:52They grew it and the next thing you know they got they got
- 48:54acquired by Adobe. Sort of amazing outcome for like
- 48:56for. It for for.
- 48:57Really everyone involved except, you know, people got like go
- 49:00unfortunately, but like, but I got it.
- 49:01I work for Big Toy Company leveraged leveraged leveraged
- 49:06acquisition saddle with loads of debt that I think they would
- 49:09have actually made it but they ended up liquidating because
- 49:12because of the PE firm. So I've seen some really bad
- 49:14outcomes P firms. I'm sorry Tom cut you off.
- 49:16No, I think I was going to agree with you were saying at the end.
- 49:19Now I think yes, probably in general, Brett, I think probably
- 49:23it points to the fact that again, without being too damning
- 49:25and there's obviously pockets of excellence.
- 49:28There's a lot of people who are in senior religion roles who
- 49:30haven't got to the operational maturity or business maturity to
- 49:33do what APE firm wants. And so are they do they have the
- 49:38patience? Not necessarily, but are they
- 49:41putting in the best people to do the best thing to return on the
- 49:43capital then then probably. And is there an onus on, you
- 49:46know, is there a learning or an onus on, on people who are in or
- 49:49going to be in those situations to to really think about the
- 49:52right people then yeah. And what they'll do is they'll
- 49:53come in again and create that focus.
- 49:55And it's, I mean, it's a, it's a fairly binary, what's the best
- 49:58thing to do for, you know, X time period and ry and maybe
- 50:03there's a, there's a happy middle ground we'll get to.
- 50:05But I think if you if you flip back into the the whole Co
- 50:08space, then I think a lot of decisions because that politics
- 50:13point we talked about, yeah, it just it's gummed up and you
- 50:16know, things that AP firm would take days if not weeks to make a
- 50:20decision. Whereas the PE firm has.
- 50:21An absolute priority. Yeah, right.
- 50:24Yeah. And so and so that's that.
- 50:26It's it's gummed up because of just old operational models, old
- 50:30human. Capital models and the politics
- 50:33righteous. Politics.
- 50:35Politics, politics lack, lack of, you know, politics is, you
- 50:38know, from an exit point of view, lack of accountability.
- 50:41And, you know, I've worked in, you know, in many firms and
- 50:43around firms where people want to make a decision, but no one
- 50:46knows who can. And just again.
- 50:48Yeah, that's a key point. That's a critical point like
- 50:51because you talk a lot about, you know, sort of getting shit
- 50:53done. I used to give a a GSD T-shirt
- 50:55award out to get shit done leading on my team, right.
- 50:59It you know, easier said than done.
- 51:00And what I've noticed is when I've gone from sort of, let's
- 51:02say mid market SAS or tech into much larger companies, which I
- 51:07told you a couple of those examples, I found that the, the
- 51:10challenge of moving into a super matrixed organization and trying
- 51:15to get shit done because it, it was almost like accountability
- 51:19got lost. Like you'd have to, you'd have
- 51:21to work across three or four or five different people, maybe two
- 51:25or three different teams with a lot of politicking and sort of
- 51:29testing and. Yeah, and just.
- 51:31To get something simple done. Yeah, you come out, the
- 51:33operating model pays, right. So the again, part of the big
- 51:37challenges we see with structures is, you know, Rios
- 51:40are announced, you know, I know agency group is moving from a
- 51:44market model to a, to a client model or a cluster model or
- 51:47capability model. And there's a new, there's a new
- 51:49org chart. And typically it's got matrix
- 51:51reporting lines everywhere. But then the piece of work
- 51:54hasn't been done to say, OK, for X decision, which person in
- 51:58their org chart. And if you've got 2 bosses, you
- 52:00know which one of them or both of them can make the decision.
- 52:03And if you didn't scale it up to 10s of thousands of people doing
- 52:07very different things. And if you're trying to sign off
- 52:09some investment, if you're trying to, you know, do do a a
- 52:13deal with a client and and get, you know, some, some
- 52:16commercials. Agreed.
- 52:16It's actually just to be difficult to understand well who
- 52:20who makes that decision and then no you.
- 52:22Don't know where all the bodies are buried and you got to bring
- 52:2435 people into a. Politics, yeah, layer in the
- 52:28politics and then also the the other reality, which is, you
- 52:30know, we have, you know, in, in many of our, you know, spate
- 52:34many of the firms in this industry, new CEOs and senior
- 52:37leaders every two years. So you've got new, new
- 52:40transformation every year. You've got new CEO every two
- 52:42years. But it's, it's trying to
- 52:44understand like, you know, mud stepping 3 fingers in terms of
- 52:46where, where is decision made and who.
- 52:49Should be sometimes like people don't want to make the decision
- 52:51because you make a decision, you're sticking, you're sticking
- 52:53your head out, right, I mean. Yeah, and you can definitely,
- 52:57you can definitely play the system and defer and people talk
- 53:00about wanting accountability possibility, but the quite a lot
- 53:02of people don't want the actual accountability because they
- 53:04realize the buck stops with them.
- 53:05So that is something that I think as you start to roll out a
- 53:09new structure, you've got to be really clear on the
- 53:12accountability, who makes decisions, who's accountable for
- 53:15that. And then equally, you know, the
- 53:17other piece of that is consequences.
- 53:19If you've made someone accountable for decision and
- 53:21they make the wrong decision, then there's a consequence for
- 53:23that. And you know, there's a
- 53:24training, there's a there's, and then you've got to think that's
- 53:26right. Looking at the different kind of
- 53:28like in the industry, like because you have your whole
- 53:30legacy hold codes, right? You've got your kind of your big
- 53:32Indies like, you know, like your Horizon Stagwell, I guess a
- 53:36couple of good examples, right? And then you've got your, you
- 53:39know, PE back, kind of like insurgents, right?
- 53:41There's a lot of them, right? And then and then maybe, I guess
- 53:44the 4th category might even be like your, you know, maybe
- 53:46they're dark horses, maybe like your Accenture songs.
- 53:49So my guess is they make a media acquisition in your future
- 53:52Deloitte Digital. You can probably, you know,
- 53:53let's say the digital. Consulting.
- 53:56Let's say digital consultancies that are more becoming more like
- 53:58agencies every day. So out of those four, I mean
- 54:00like which one gets you, which one are you most interested in?
- 54:04Which one do you think would you would you bet on or anything you
- 54:07want to call out in that? I mean, I think there's,
- 54:10there's, it's going to be interesting, right, Because it
- 54:13happens if I think that's the big Indies, I think really
- 54:16exciting space right now that they've got enough scale to be
- 54:21valuable to kind of the partners and ecosystem because you know,
- 54:24a lot of this been driven by very few partners and ecosystem.
- 54:26And so you've got to have enough scale to to matter to some of
- 54:29those partners. And this is an FTE scale.
- 54:32This isn't people scale necessarily.
- 54:34This I. Mean scale with clients, spend
- 54:36client Billings, you know, that's kind of volume in the
- 54:38market because you know, if you're going based with some of
- 54:39the partners you need to have, they've got the agility because
- 54:43of, you know, ownership structure and behaviours to, to,
- 54:46to, to move with some of that quicker.
- 54:47So I think there's going to be some really interesting space
- 54:49work from those in those space. Yeah.
- 54:53So do we move to quick hits? Let's do quick hits.
- 54:57So, yeah, so this is when we're going to just a little wrap and
- 54:59fire around, you know, it's in the episode.
- 55:02So what's the biggest illusion large agencies still believe
- 55:06about themselves? General statement, I'd say that
- 55:09a lot of the large networks, operating companies, holding
- 55:15companies, whatever they call themselves, I think still feel,
- 55:18still still feel and act like scale is, is their single Moat,
- 55:21right. And, and yeah, it can be
- 55:23important. It is important still, but it's,
- 55:25it's also a big cost structure, you know, having that big scale.
- 55:30And I think, you know, firms growing right now back to our
- 55:32previous point are probably ones who have fundamentally changed
- 55:35the model, not just growing the same thing to be bigger.
- 55:37Tom, what kills transformation faster, Bad strategy, slow
- 55:40execution, or something else entirely?
- 55:44I'd, yeah, I'd flip that. I would, I would, I would rather
- 55:48have it's, it's speed, right. So I would rather have a, a, a
- 55:51poor or not poor, a mediocre strategy but executed versus a
- 55:56brilliant strategy that took 18 months to create, was redundant
- 55:59before it got launched and then no effort was put into it.
- 56:01Yeah, I've seen so many brilliant pieces of thinking and
- 56:05brilliant people and it doesn't go anywhere, you know, And so
- 56:09it's a. Sort of balancing act between
- 56:10like readiness, yeah, an actual execution.
- 56:14And I would say, you know, there are there are only so many ways
- 56:17to skin a cat. So anyway comes to the gut
- 56:18structure like just pick a model and make a stick and make it
- 56:23work. Yeah, yeah.
- 56:26So, So what? What is one thing that leaders
- 56:31want to say they want? We've talked a lot about
- 56:33leadership in this podcast, but actually resist doing.
- 56:37I'd go back to my earlier point, accountability.
- 56:40I think everyone says they want accountability and then actually
- 56:44when the acid test comes and it applies to them, you know, I
- 56:49think sometimes they aren't as keen and up for it as maybe they
- 56:53said originally. Move the goal posts.
- 56:56But I think I know the what are you going to say to this one?
- 56:58But curious to hear it. What's more dangerous right now,
- 57:01moving too fast or moving too slow?
- 57:05Obviously too slow with with the with the I guess caveat the slow
- 57:10and wrong, sorry, fast and wrong.
- 57:13It's still wrong, right and so move fast, but but be purposeful
- 57:18and clear on what you're trying to do and break it up.
- 57:20Don't try and ball the ocean as well.
- 57:21You know, that's I guess the the sub point is move fast with
- 57:25focus, do a few things in really well, then move on to the next.
- 57:28Don't try and do everything one at once.
- 57:30I like that. So, so fill in the blank.
- 57:33The future agency CEO will be more like A and less like a.
- 57:39The future agency CEO will be more like a system integrator
- 57:45orchestrator than a client or creative director.
- 57:50There we go. Like that.
- 57:52That's awesome. So, Tom, how can people get a
- 57:54hold of you if they want to reach out to you, connect, read
- 57:57any of your work, that stuff? Hit me up on LinkedIn is
- 58:01probably the easiest thing. I've got a website that I blog
- 58:04on. Happy to chat about any things
- 58:06we talked about today or anything else of course.
- 58:09Great. Well, thanks Tom for joining us
- 58:11today. This has been an awesome
- 58:12conversation just just under an hour.
- 58:14We're with us short for us, but but you know, thrilled to talk
- 58:19to you and for everybody that made it this far.
- 58:21Visit us at Deb Deb Deb dot signaling noise dot AI.
- 58:25Follow us, subscribe and listen to all of our episodes on
- 58:28YouTube, Spotify and Apple podcast, and we will see you
- 58:31next time. Thanks.
- 58:33Very much for having me. Thank you.