Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Vehicle Maintenance and Collision Costs
Transcript
- 0:09All right, so if you're looking at electric vehicles, you hear
- 0:12one thing constantly, right? You're going to save a ton of
- 0:14money on maintenance. Absolutely.
- 0:16Fewer moving parts, no oil changes.
- 0:19Simplicity is definitely the big promise.
- 0:22But there's that nagging question that when you sent
- 0:24these sources over about what actually happens if that shiny
- 0:28new EV gets into a Fender Bender or worse, do electric cars
- 0:33really cost, you know that much more to repair after an
- 0:38accident? Is it just hype or is there
- 0:40something to it? Well, that's what we need to
- 0:41unpack. OK, let's do it.
- 0:43Because digging into these sources, the picture is well,
- 0:47it's really nuanced. We're basically looking at two
- 0:49different things here. Routine upkeep, which looks
- 0:52pretty good. Yeah, very good.
- 0:54And then collision damage and that's a whole different story.
- 0:56Sometimes a pretty surprising. One exactly.
- 0:59You've got to separate them. Ownership cost isn't just one
- 1:01number. And when you look at the data,
- 1:04you see this interesting contradiction.
- 1:07EVs are mechanically simpler, like fundamentally simpler than
- 1:10gas cars. Yet when they get damaged, the
- 1:13repair bills can be astronomically higher sometimes.
- 1:16So how can both be true? That's what we need to figure
- 1:20out. Right, let's break it down.
- 1:22OK, first the good news, the maintenance advantage, it's
- 1:27real, and it basically comes down to what's missing into the
- 1:30hood, doesn't it? It really does.
- 1:32Think about all the stuff you just don't have to deal with
- 1:34anymore. No oil changes, obviously no
- 1:38spark plugs, no complex transmission systems, no
- 1:41mufflers, no catalytic converters.
- 1:43Wow, yeah, those catalytic converters alone can be
- 1:46incredibly expensive to replace on a gas car later on.
- 1:49No belts, no hoses. Right, a lot of the common
- 1:51failure points just aren't there.
- 1:53So what does routine service actually look like?
- 1:55Like them, the sources suggest it's minimal.
- 1:57We're talking cabin air filter, maybe checking the wipers,
- 2:00rotating the tires. And occasionally checking the
- 2:02coolant level for the battery pack, but yeah, that's pretty
- 2:05much it for regular scheduled stuff.
- 2:07And that translates to actual savings.
- 2:09There's hard data on this. Oh yeah, the federal Office of
- 2:12Energy Efficiency put numbers on it.
- 2:14They estimate gas cars cost about $0.10 per mile to
- 2:17maintain, EVs just six cents per mile.
- 2:20OK. Six cents versus $0.10.
- 2:22That doesn't sound like that much per mile, but over a year.
- 2:25It adds up fast. If you drive say 15,000 miles a
- 2:28year, that 4 cent difference is about $600.00 saved right there
- 2:32year after year. Some estimates push it even
- 2:34higher, closer to maybe $1500 depending on the models
- 2:37compared. And the real world comparisons
- 2:39like from Edmunds or KBB, they back this up.
- 2:42They do very consistently. Take a Chevy Bolt and entry
- 2:46level EV over 5 years, maintenance might run you about
- 2:49$2800 right. A similar small gas car you're
- 2:52looking at over $4400. That's a $1600 difference.
- 2:55Wow. Even in the luxury space, an
- 2:57Audi Q4 E Tron maybe just over $3000 for five years.
- 3:01The gas powered Audi Q5 over $5000.
- 3:05So consistently cheaper annual cost maybe 400 to $700.00 for
- 3:08the EV versus easily $1000, maybe $1500 for the internal
- 3:12combustion car. That's the.
- 3:13Ball car. Yeah.
- 3:14And then the big one, brakes. We all hate getting that brake
- 3:17of estimate. Right, but with EVs you've got
- 3:19regenerative braking. The electric motor does a lot of
- 3:22the slowing down, sending energy back to the battery it.
- 3:25Means you're barely using the actual brake pads and discs in
- 3:29normal driving. Exactly.
- 3:30They last significantly longer, huge savings there potentially
- 3:34over the life of the car, OK. OK, but we have to talk about
- 3:38the elephant in the room, the battery itself.
- 3:41That's the single most expensive part, right?
- 3:42We hear figures like 5000 dollars, $10,000, even $15,000
- 3:47for replacement. That's true, it is the most
- 3:50expensive component by far. So is that a maintenance cost we
- 3:54need to budget for? Not really.
- 3:55Not in the routine sense. The sources are pretty clear on
- 3:57this. Those batteries, they come with
- 3:59long warranties, usually eight years, sometimes 10 years or
- 4:02100,000 miles. And they're designed to outlast
- 4:05the typical ownership cycle of the car itself.
- 4:08Battery failure within the warranty period is covered, and
- 4:11failure outside warranty, while potentially very expensive,
- 4:14isn't a regular maintenance expectation.
- 4:17Like say, replacing a timing belt.
- 4:19It's more of a potential major repair down the line, but not
- 4:22retain upkeep. All right, so maintenance looks
- 4:25great. We save thousands.
- 4:27Breaks last forever. It almost sounds too easy.
- 4:31But here's the twist You mentioned.
- 4:34There's one routine cost where EVs often lose that advantage
- 4:38and takes people by surprise. Tires.
- 4:40Exactly. The tire tax some people call
- 4:43it, and it comes down to 1 simple thing, weight.
- 4:46Because of the batteries? Yep.
- 4:47Those big battery packs are heavy.
- 4:49They add hundreds, sometimes over 1000 lbs compared to a
- 4:53similar gas car. And that extra weight means you
- 4:55need special tires. You do.
- 4:57They need to be stronger to handle the load and they often
- 5:00have lower rolling resistance compounds to maximize range.
- 5:03Plus they need to cope with that instant torque.
- 5:06E VS deliver. Right.
- 5:07So specialized tires, they cost more.
- 5:10Generally yes, expect to pay maybe 20 even 30% more for EV
- 5:15specific tires compared to standard ones for a similar
- 5:18sized car. OK, so they cost more upfront,
- 5:21Yeah, but there's another issue, isn't there, the way EV's drive
- 5:24actually wears them out faster? That's the other side of the
- 5:26coin, that instant torque, the quick acceleration that makes
- 5:29EV's so fun to drive. It puts a lot of immediate
- 5:32stress on the tires, especially if you enjoy spirited starts.
- 5:37Guilty, huh? Well, that combined with the
- 5:40extra weight means the tires tend to wear down quicker than
- 5:43on a comparable gas car. So you're paying more for the
- 5:45tires, and you might be replacing them more often.
- 5:48Precisely. So while you're saving all that
- 5:50money on oil changes and tune UPS, some of that gets clawed
- 5:53back when it's time for new rubber.
- 5:55It definitely balances the maintenance budget a bit more
- 5:58than people expect. OK, that makes sense.
- 6:00Yeah, Now let's shift gears completely away from routine
- 6:04stuff into the big worry collision repairs.
- 6:07Right, the crash costs. We saw that recent study finding
- 6:11the average EV repair after an accident costs about $950 more
- 6:15than for a gas car. That sounds pretty significant.
- 6:18It does sound like a big jump, but, and this is crucial,
- 6:21context matters immensely here. How so?
- 6:24That average figure is heavily, heavily skewed by 1 brand Tesla.
- 6:29Because they dominate the market share right now.
- 6:31Exactly, and Tesla's repair costs, for various reasons we
- 6:35can get into, are known to be significantly higher than
- 6:37average, even compared to other EVs.
- 6:39So what happens if you like statistically remove Tesla from
- 6:43that calculation? What does the picture look like
- 6:45for say, a Ford Mustang Mach E or a Hyundai Ionic 5?
- 6:49It changes dramatically when they split the data.
- 6:52The average repair cost for a non Tesla EV was only $269
- 6:57higher than the average gas car repair.
- 6:59Only $269? That's almost negligible really,
- 7:03a tiny premium. It's a much smaller difference,
- 7:05yes. So that headline $950 figure
- 7:08needs that big asterisk next to it.
- 7:11It doesn't necessarily apply across the board to all.
- 7:13EVs, That's a really important distinction.
- 7:15So the collision cost panic might be a bit overblown if
- 7:17you're not buying a Tesla. It seems less dramatic for non
- 7:21Tesla models based on that data. Yes, and interestingly, the data
- 7:24also showed something positive for EVs overall.
- 7:26Fewer reported collisions. Accident claims frequency was
- 7:29actually 19% lower for as compared to gasoline cars in
- 7:33that study period. Fewer accidents, but potentially
- 7:37higher cost when they happen, especially for certain brands.
- 7:39OK, right. But even with the Tesla factor
- 7:41considered, an overall increase is still there.
- 7:44Mitchell, the repair data company, pegged the average EV
- 7:48repair bill around 6066 fixes versus 4703 lies for internal
- 7:53combustion. That's still a 30% jump overall.
- 7:57Why? OK, let's dig into the why 2
- 7:59main drivers, labor and parts. Let's start with labor.
- 8:03The estimate showed almost double the mechanical labor
- 8:06hours for EVs, 3 hours, versus about 1.6 for gas cars.
- 8:10Nearly double. But wait, you just said EVs are
- 8:12simpler mechanically, fewer parts.
- 8:14So what are mechanics doing for that extra hour and a half?
- 8:17It doesn't quite add up. Good question.
- 8:18It's not about fixing more parts, it's almost entirely
- 8:21about dealing with the high voltage battery safely.
- 8:24Safety procedure. Exactly before a technician can
- 8:26do significant structural repairs or even some paintwork
- 8:29involving heat, that high voltage system needs to be de
- 8:32energized, made safe. That often involves specific
- 8:35diagnostic steps, specialized equipment, and sometimes even
- 8:38completely removing the entire battery pack from the car just
- 8:42to ensure safety during the repair.
- 8:44Wow, and that takes time. Specialized training too, I
- 8:47imagine. Loads of time and specialized
- 8:50training, yes. So a big chunk of that extra
- 8:53labor cost happens before they even start fixing the dent.
- 8:56It's all safety protocol for the high voltage system.
- 8:59Got it. OK, that explains the labor.
- 9:01What about parts? Why are EV parts apparently so
- 9:03much more expensive? If I smash the bumper on my old
- 9:07Civic, the shop can probably find a cheap aftermarket one,
- 9:10right? Or a used one from a salvage
- 9:12yard. That market is mature for gas
- 9:15cars, but for EVs it's still very new.
- 9:17So no cheap aftermarket alternatives yet.
- 9:20Not really. Not widely available.
- 9:22The aftermarket and recycled parts supply chain just hasn't
- 9:25caught up yet, which means repair shops are heavily reliant
- 9:28on ordering brand new parts directly from the manufacturer.
- 9:31OEM parts. Original equipment manufacturer.
- 9:33Exactly, and your sources indicated that for many EV
- 9:36repairs, up to 90% of the parts might have to be OEM.
- 9:40When there's no competition from aftermarket suppliers, the
- 9:42manufacturer can charge premium. OK.
- 9:45So specialized labor for battery safety and expensive
- 9:48manufacturer only parts. That makes sense.
- 9:51Anything else driving up costs? Well, there's the fact that a
- 9:54lot of EVs currently on the road are higher end luxury models.
- 9:59Something like 77% were classified as upscale.
- 10:01And luxury cars just cost more to fix anyway, gas or electric.
- 10:05Correct. They're packed with sensors,
- 10:07cameras, complex driver assist systems, expensive trim pieces.
- 10:11A minor bump can damage a lot of costly tech that often needs
- 10:14full replacement, not repair. Right.
- 10:16And then there's the ultimate cost driver, the risk of the car
- 10:19being declared a total loss. This brings us back to the
- 10:22battery. Because it's so expensive, if
- 10:25the battery pack itself sustains damage and a collision, even if
- 10:28the rest of the car looks fixable, the cost to replace
- 10:31that pack can easily exceed the car's remaining value.
- 10:34So. Even a seemingly moderate hit
- 10:36that cracks the battery case or damages cells could lead to the
- 10:39insurance company just writing the car off.
- 10:41It's a significant factor, yes. It makes the threshold for
- 10:45declaring an Eva total loss potentially lower than for a
- 10:48comparable gas car, purely because of that one massive
- 10:51component cost. There was that specific example
- 10:54in the sources, right? Taylor Faust's Tesla Model S,
- 10:57His neighbor just backed into the bumper.
- 10:59A simple dent, seemingly. Yeah, a relatively minor
- 11:02incident. Looked like just a bumper scuff.
- 11:04And the final repair bill was? Over $17,000. $17,000 for a
- 11:10bumper dent. Why?
- 11:12Well, partly sensors in tech, but a huge factor was the
- 11:15material. Tesla's in particular use a lot
- 11:18of aluminum body panels. Which is harder and more
- 11:20expensive to repair than steel. Much harder, yes.
- 11:23Repairing aluminum requires specialized equipment, different
- 11:26techniques, and often involves replacing entire panels rather
- 11:29than just banging out a dent. It's a complex structural
- 11:32repair, even for what looks like minor damage, and drives the
- 11:35cost way up. Wow.
- 11:37OK, so pulling all this together, what's the final
- 11:41verdict for someone weighing this decision?
- 11:43Well, it really is that duality we started with you.
- 11:46Save potentially thousands on routine maintenance over the
- 11:49years. Oil changes, tune UPS, breaks.
- 11:53Big win there. Definitely a big win on the
- 11:55upkeep side, but you need to be aware of the potential for
- 11:59significantly higher costs if you have an accident.
- 12:02Especially involving the battery or complex body materials like
- 12:05aluminum, or if you're driving a brand known for higher repair
- 12:09costs and a higher risk of it being totaled.
- 12:12Right. More complexity, higher parts
- 12:14cost for now, specialized labor. It adds up in a collision
- 12:18scenario. So is this just the reality we
- 12:20have to live with for EVs? For now, perhaps.
- 12:23But if we connect this to the bigger picture, think about
- 12:25market maturity. This is likely to change over
- 12:27time. Now so well as more EVs hit the
- 12:30road that aftermarket and recycled parts supply will
- 12:32develop. Competition will increase, which
- 12:34should bring down parts costs. Makes sense?
- 12:36And automakers are also working on battery design, making them
- 12:40more modular, easier to repair individual sections perhaps
- 12:44rather than replacing the whole expensive pack, maybe moving
- 12:47away from using the battery as a core structural piece that's
- 12:50vulnerable. So the hope is that these high
- 12:52collision costs are a temporary phase as the technology in the
- 12:56market mature. That's the logical expectation,
- 12:59yes. We should see those costs
- 13:01gradually come down over the next decade as adoption grows
- 13:05and the industry adapts. OK.
- 13:06That provides some really valuable perspective.
- 13:09It's not just one simple answer you save here, but you might pay
- 13:12more there, at least for now. Exactly.
- 13:14Know what you're getting into on both sides of the Ledger.
- 13:17Brilliant. Well, thank you for breaking
- 13:18that down and thank you for sharing these sources and
- 13:21joining us for this deep dive. Hopefully this clarifies the
- 13:24real picture of EV maintenance versus repair costs.
- 13:27Hope it helps. If it did, definitely follow the
- 13:29channel for more deep dives like this and maybe share this one
- 13:32with someone else trying to figure out the true cost of
- 13:34going electric. Thanks for listening.