Latest / The Dokkcast / Marcela Fiuza: Perimenopause Nutrition. Why Weight Changes in Your 40s
Transcript
- Dokkcast 7 Marcela === [00:00:00] So welcome everybody to our doc cast number seven, and I'm delighted to welcome Marcella Fusa, who's a registered dietician and a wonderful nutritionist practicing in London, focusing particularly at some of the challenging and difficult topics in and around nutrition and diet. So welcome, Marcella. Please introduce yourself to us. Thank you so much for having me. Pleasure. Um, yeah, so I'm a registered dietician. I work in private practice. I'm based in London. Um, just a little bit of background about, um, kind of my career to date. Mm-hmm. So I, um, started studying nutritional science. Um, during my degree, I did a research project on, um, appetite regulation in women. Um, and that really got me into kind of the The concepts and the ideas around kind of, uh, appetite regulation and weight management. Uh, really enjoyed the research, and [00:01:00] from there I went on to do a master's in nutrition, which is, was another couple of years. Did another, um, study, also focused on metabolic health, this time looking at the, kind of the effect of the structure of dietary fats on, um, the vascular system- Mm-hmm and the impact on cardiovascular disease. Loved doing the research, really fascinated by it, but at that point I realized that I really wanted to work with patients clinically, so I went on to study dietetics. Uh, so I did a- Wonderful ... postgraduate diploma in dietetics, and which involved a lot of clinical placement in NHS hospitals. Um, and from that I went straight on to work for the NHS, which I did for about seven years. Wonderful. And it was absolutely incredible, amazing experience. Um, after about seven years, I realized that I really wanted to apply my kind of diet skills, knowledge into the prevention [00:02:00] rather than just the kind of acute management of disease, and that's when I moved to private practice- Mm-hmm and it's where I am now. And most of my practice is around kind of, um, helping patients manage, kind of, uh, prevent and manage chronic diseases. So there is a lot of weight management with and without medication. Mm-hmm. Um, I am particularly passionate about women's health- Mm-hmm ... so I work a lot with women, uh, going through perimenopause and menopause. Um- Wonderful. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you very much. And today we're going to particularly focus on this last point that you brought up, which is essentially women in their 40s, there or thereabouts, and trying to understand what happens to our bodies at that point, and in particular, how nutrition plays a part of that. And I love your story essentially going on from prevention to risk factors to actually working, uh, within the NHS, uh, with children as well, and now onto women's health. So you've really done the whole sort of 360 [00:03:00] developmental- Yeah ... you know, within ages. So let's pick that up, and if we sort of, um, try and discuss what is actually happening to women in their 40s, what is it that they come to you with? What do they say? What are the main complaints, main problems? So women in their 40s- Yes ... what's different? Well, so much is happening around, around that time. So, um- Menopause is the kind of most obvious one Mm-hmm Um, so it might be useful to explain a little bit about kind of what- Yes, please ... menopause is. Yeah. Yeah. So, you know, menopause, it's not necessarily in, in your 40s that it happens, but what menopause itself, it's the time point where a woman hasn't had a menstrual period for 12 consecutive months. So it's that exact date- Yeah ... where you haven't had a period for 12 months. After that day, you're post-menopausal, and before that day you are perimenopausal. Mm-hmm. Um, so at that time [00:04:00] point, it's when estrogen levels have declined to a persistent low and your kind of ovaries have stopped releasing eggs. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So essentially it marks kind of the end of, uh, reproductive capacity in a woman's life. So it's a time of real change. It's a time of real change, but the change doesn't happen overnight. Mm. The menopause itself is one day- Mm-hmm ... but the change doesn't happen overnight. It happens over many, many years. Mm. Yeah. So the period leading up to menopause, it's what we call perimenopause. Mm. And that can last anything from two to 10 years. So it can be- Which is really therefore difficult- It can be a whole decade to see that change. Yes. So the average age for menopause in the UK is 51 years old- Mm ... but it, anything between 45 and 55 is considered normal. Mm-hmm. So if you think that perimenopause can last up to 10 years, you could be in perimenopause from your mid, mid-30s. 30s. Yeah. And you, and you may not know, of course. You may not know. Yeah. And I will refer our audience back to the menopause [00:05:00] podcast we did just a few weeks ago- Brilliant ... which is, which is it, which, which sort of talks to this topic, which to your point means that it's a long time, uh, where you may not even be thinking about this. You may not even be thinking. Yeah. Exactly. And your GP may not be thinking about it because- Yeah ... you could potentially be considered too young- Yeah ... to be going through perimenopause. Yeah. And the thing is, the symptoms in perimenopause, they are not specific to, to perimenopause. Mm. They could be indicating anything else. So sometimes it can be quite difficult to kind of put everything together and say- Mm-hmm "Well, that is due to- Mm ... perimenopause." Yeah. I think, um- You know, it's becoming ... It's easier to kind of identify once the woman is on, in kind of their mid-40s Mm-hmm You naturally tend to think more about it, but it can be difficult if you're- Yeah ... a little bit younger. But during perimenopause, what's happening is, so when you reach menopause, the estrogen [00:06:00] levels have declined to a persistent low. Mm-hmm. But perimenopause, it doesn't mean that estrogen levels are declining in a straight line- Yeah ... because that would be- It's not a linear loss It's definitely not. That would be too easy and too- Yeah ... simple for women. Our bodies don't work like that. It, they do not work. Any, anybody doesn't work like that. No. Yeah. Definitely not. So what happens instead, it fluctuates. Yeah. So some months it might peak higher than you used to be during kind of normal reproductive years, and in other months it might decline significantly. And these kind of erratic hormonal fluctuations are what causes very kind of unpredict- unpredictable symptoms. Hm. And that can be really kind of ... That's the, the perimenopausal years are the real kind of lived experiences- Mm, mm-hmm ... of menopause. Mm-hmm. And that can cause all sorts of symptoms, right? And I, I tend to kind of think about the symptoms in three different kind of categories. Okay. So you've got your kind of day-to-day symptoms, which are things that often t- [00:07:00] often will take women to see their GP. Yeah. So things like, uh, night sweats, hot flashes, anxiety, mood swings, insomnia. Then you've got, uh, the symptoms which are changes that are happening to your body- Mm-hmm ... which is often bring women to see me. Okay. Interesting. Things like weight gain, loss of muscle mass, changes in appetite, changes in energy level. Mm-hmm. Um, all very real. And then we also have kind of this, this third group of symptoms, which are the kind of more silent longer-term ones- Mm-hmm ... which are changes in bone density- Mm-hmm ... changes in cardiovascular risk factors, so, uh, raised cholesterol, raised blood pressure, um, increased insulin resistance. So all those things that happen- Mm ... simultaneously. And- The really important and interesting thing is that nutrition has a really, really crucial role across all of those [00:08:00] All three of those. Yeah. I love that. Yeah. I really love those three pillars, 'cause it's very holistic. So one is the immediacy of your symptoms. I'm really suffering from this right now. The second, of course, is all around nutrition- Mm ... and we're gonna pick this up. And the third one is obviously long-term health and wellness prevention. Yeah. The osteoporosis, et cetera, and, and the cardiovascular risk. So, so those are three really important pillars, and of course, nutrition goes across all three of those. Um, so tell us a little bit around what they will present you with in terms of that middle pillar, the second pillar- Yeah ... with nutrition. What is happening that it, to women's bodies around that time? Yeah. So that's, that's, you know, universally is the main, the main complaint I get. So when women first come to me- Mm I'm gaining weight. Um, so usually in their 40s, "I'm gaining weight. I haven't really changed anything in my diet. I haven't really changed my exercise pattern. Why, why am I slowly gaining weight?" Or- I'm not, I'm not [00:09:00] changing ... I'm not doing anything. Why is my body changing so drastically? Exactly. Or, "Oh, I've gone on holiday. I've gained a couple of kilos. Previously, I used to just eat a little bit less and exercise a bit more, and the weight would drop, and now- And I can't get rid of it now ... those couple of kilos are part of me." Yeah, yeah. "They will not go away." And by the way, those couple of kilos can feel qui- quite debilitating in some respects, as in, as in all this- It can be uncomfortable Yeah, yeah Yeah, so when you can- You don't feel yourself. Ex- exactly. Mm. Exactly. And- You know, it can slowly- Creep up ... creep up as well. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Um, so it's a, it, it's valid- Mm-hmm ... and it's real, and, and it's very common. And I think it's really important to say that it's not something that happens due to personal failure- Yeah ... or lack of willpower. Mm-hmm. There are real physiological changes and metabolic changes that are happening- Mm around that time, some of which are related to hormonal changes around menopause, and some of which are related to [00:10:00] the natural aging process. That's a really important point- Mm ... which I was going to actually, uh, ask you about or press you on, is of course there's two prongs here that for women around that time come together. Yeah. One is just chronological age. That happens to everybody. If you're lucky enough. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly, if you make it. Um, and then the second thing is particular to the hormonal changes around- Yeah ... that time, so there's a confluence of these two factors of both time and hormones- Yeah ... together. Yeah. Because there are, uh, some elements, and I, and I'll discuss that a bit more, that will happen to both men and women- Mm-hmm ... but we know that they are exacerbated by the hormonal changes of menopause. Okay. Can you say a little bit more about that? Yes. So what is, what is the one that's common to men and women? Because of course we- Yeah ... we have listeners of, of, of, of every type. Yeah. So you know what... You know, for, for the men that are listening to this, you know, what is happening to my body that would happen to a female body, and what is happening to women in particular would be really helpful. Yeah. So like, um, in, i- in terms of kind of, uh, [00:11:00] metabolism and, and the influence on kind of weight management as well- Mm so muscle loss is something that happens from around our mid-30s, early 40s- Mm-hmm, mm-hmm ... and that's a natural part of aging. Mm-hmm. Yeah, so it, it's a process called kind of sarcopenia, that we start to lose muscle mass, and there are ways to work around it to try and prevent it and minimize it to, to a certain degree. But with muscle mass loss, our metabolic rate also reduces, which means- It's a double whammy ... it's a double whammy, so which means that your body needs... will, will use less energy at rest. So for just sitting and breathing and doing nothing, it needs less energy than it would if it had more muscle mass. So if you keep your cal- calorie intake constant, you will naturally gain weight. You will naturally- Yeah ... gain weight. Slowly, but it will naturally happen. Mm-hmm. And that is a natural, um, thing that happens as part of the- To everybody ... aging process- Mm-hmm ... that unless you do something about it, it will [00:12:00] happen. Mm-hmm. Yeah? And when I say do something about it, there are things that you can do in terms of resistance exercise and adequate- That's where resistance comes- diet and protein- Mm-hmm ... intake- Mm-hmm ... that can be really, really helpful. So that's natural part of aging, but we know as well, like, um, from research, that the- Fluctuating hormones around perimenopause- Mm-hmm ... and then the lower estrogen around menopause, they exacerbate that. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. So they will speed up that, that loss of muscle mass because estrogen has- So they compound the sarcopenia- Exactly muscle mass loss as well as the decline in metabolic, basic metabolic rate. So- Yes, they do. So the basic metabolic rate will reduce as a result of the loss of muscle mass. Muscle. Mm-hmm. Yes, because estrogen has a protective role in muscle. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So it's compounded. It's compounded. So the aging effect is compounded by the hormonal effects. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. So that's aging, but then there is also an effect that is kind of related to the hormonal fluctuation. Mm-hmm. So for example, the lack, the lower levels of estrogen- Mm ... will have an [00:13:00] impact on kind of fat distribution. So before menopause, women tend to store fat around hips and thighs, for example. Mm-hmm. And after the menopause, that tends to shift to kind of a visceral fat deposition, and that's a problem because visceral fat carries a much higher risk- Mm ... um, from a metabolic and cardiovascular perspective. Cardiovascular risk. Yeah. Yeah. Can you tell us, for those who don't know, what is visceral fat? What does that mean? Visceral fat- Where is that? Yes, of course. Yeah, good question. So visceral fat is the fat that accumulates around kind of your abdominal, um, area, and it accumulates around your organs. So it's- So it's inside It's inside- Inside of you ... yeah. Yeah. So whereas the fats that you accumulate around hips and thighs is subcutaneous fat, so it's under- Almost fat, fat that you could feel- the skin ... right, under the skin? Yes, exactly. Yeah. Mm-hmm. So the, uh, visceral fat is inside, is around your organs. So you can't see it. It's almost an unseen risk. Yes. You can see, like, the increase in, um, uh, waist [00:14:00] circumference, for example. Mm-hmm. Like, and men t- tend to have that kind of pattern of fat deposition- Anyway through life anyway. Mm-hmm. And women are protected until kind of around menopause. So estrogen is hugely protective. It's very protective. Mm. So it's very protective from a cardiovascular perspective in terms of, um, fat deposition- Mm-hmm ... but it also has direct kind of protective role in terms of the vasculature- Mm-hmm in terms of, like, an anti-inflammatory and vasodilator effect. Mm-hmm. So at that time of menopause, women do lose that protection- Mm-hmm ... and there is an increased risk of cardiovascular disease. Cardiovascular. Okay. Which is, which is a really important consideration. And, like, women don't tend to come to me initially because they're worried about cardiovascular health. They come because of weight, but I always see it as a really good opportunity to touch on that- Yeah ... and to address that because cardiovascular disease is the pr- Biggest killer in, you know, in, in- In, [00:15:00] in women, yes ... the Western world. Yeah, absolutely. And, and in women. Yeah. And I don't think that's, um, talked about enough. Yeah. And we, we, we will have a, we will have a podcast on that particular cardiovascular risk in women because actually it's also the presentation's very different. Very different. They don't, they don't present like men do, you know, the clutching of the chest- No ... and, and, and, you know, sort of all of those typical things. But just picking up on the nutrition p- piece of that, um, so when they've come to you, obviously we've established they tend to present with sort of slightly insidious, slow but persistent weight gain that's- Yeah ... very difficult to shift in and around, uh, perimenopause, perhaps a little bit earlier, a little bit later, but definitely in their 40s for, for the most part. Um, so how do you start that conversation, to your point, around nutrition and diet? Um, you mentioned the word protein. Um, so and obvious- obviously, you know, that's a very topical area now. Very. And pretty much, pretty much everything that you will see in the shops will say, "Has protein." Has protein. You know? Yes. And, and, and yeah, so what, what is protein at a s- at a, at a very sort of, you know, summary high level? And, you know, what kind of foods [00:16:00] have it, and w- what is it? What should we do? Yeah. Okay. So, um, what is pr- well, it might be, it might be useful to just give a little bit more context in terms of kind of maybe the key- Mm. Please ... diet. Mm-hmm. The most common diet kind of problems, let's say problems- Yeah ... that I see. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Um, with, with kind of the, these women. So I think it's probably relevant as well to say about kind of lifestyle changes that are happening around this time. Mm-hmm. So what's ... Obviously you can't generalize to everybody, but, uh, as it's not uncommon that women, you know, in their 40s, they're juggling quite a lot. So they might be dealing with demanding kind of careers. They might be kind of raising kids, looking after elderly parents, running a household. There's a lot going on at that time. There is a lot going on. Yeah. So there- In all different ways, but people- In different ways- ... tend to have a lot on their plate but there is a lot going on. 100%. Um, it tends to be more- Busy time ... than what you have on in your 20s, let's say. [00:17:00] Yeah. You're balancing different plates there, and- Women are also very good at prioritizing everybody else- 100% ... but themselves. So there is limited time and to, and kind of headspace to prioritize their own health, their diet, their exercise. So something that presents very regularly in clinic is, for example, diet, uh, pattern and structure- Mm-hmm ... is often kind of lacking there. Interesting. Um, so excessive snacking, picking on foods, just grabbing something kind of reactively rather than- Maybe eating the kids' leftovers. Oh, that's, that's like the number one. Yeah Like everybody does that. 'Cause you don't want it to go to waste. No, you don't want it to go to waste. It's only a te- It's that time of the day. You had lunch. You didn't eat in the afternoon. You got home from work. You're quite hungry. You're not gonna have your dinner until later. Yeah. The leftover, the tea is there, and you know, it just goes. So easy. It's so, so easily done. Yeah. And everybody does it. [00:18:00] Everybody does it. Everybody does it. And by the way, on that note, be kind to yourself. Don't give yourself a guilt trip for doing that, right? Absolutely. It's just, yeah. Ab- no, absolutely. Yeah. Entirely. Absolutely. Um, but yeah, so kind of this kind of meal pattern, eating more kind of reactively- Mm-hmm rather than intentionally- Mm-hmm ... can kind of... It's not that it's a problem. It kind of can slow down on how you can achieve your goals, really. Um- So that's one side of things. The other side in terms of the diet itself, something that I see almost universally with my patients in clinic- Mm-hmm ... are kind of insufficient intake of protein and fiber. Interesting. Yeah. Again- Very, very common ... combined effect. Combined effect, both extremely important from a satiety perspective. Mm-hmm. So they're both kind of very kind of filling nutrients. Mm-hmm. Um, and if you're undereating protein, if you're undereating fiber, you're probably overeating something else, which tends to be [00:19:00] carbohydrates. Mm-hmm. And I don't have a problem with carbohydrates. I think starchy food is absolutely brilliant. It's more like the types of carbohydrates that you're- Mm-hmm ... that you're eating. Um- Very interesting. So we're not sort of, uh, demonizing any food groups. No. We're not saying that at all. No, definitely not. We're not saying- No ... carbs are bad. No. We're not saying that- Absolutely not ... at all. But what we are saying, if I'm hearing you correctly, is that if you combine a suboptimal eating pattern and eating habits with an imbalanced eating portfolio, if we put it that way- Yeah ... nutritional profile- Yeah ... then that, that's not a good combination. And- And the metabolic changes they already have- And then on top of that ... in their medicals- Yeah ... then, yeah. Okay. Then you're probably- Interesting ... not gonna- It's not gonna go... Yes ... achieve what you're trying to achieve. No, you're not gonna... Yeah. Yes. But, but you're going opposite to your goals. Exactly. Yeah. That's a challenge. So how do you tease that out? Do you get them to keep a food diary? And what should- So- So somebody says, "Okay, I, I, I hear you, Marcella. I want to see how far I can do this on my own," what should they do? Yeah. Food diaries or- So before, before an [00:20:00] appointment, I'll always ask people to keep a food diary. It doesn't have to be for very long, even for three days. Okay. And it's really helpful for me before I see someone in clinic, but I actually find that it's very helpful for the person to do that. Could be illuminating. It, it can, because if I ask you right now, "What did you have to eat yesterday?" You're probably gonna come to me... You're probably gonna struggle to remember. Yeah. And then you're gonna tell me, "Oh, I had this for breakfast, this for lunch, and this for dinner." And most people don't think about all the bits that they had in between. Or what- The things that were just lying around. Exactly. So- That packet of nuts you had on the way back. Absolutely. The bits from the kids' tea that you had to eat. Yeah. Whatever you had later in the evening while you're watching TV. Hmm. And it's not because we're trying to hide it, it's just because our mind, it doesn't You know, it doesn't clock it. It is- So one of this, one of this, one of the sort of the effects of doing this is, is bringing it into consciousness, so you're becoming very conscious and intentional- Absolutely, yeah about your eating About what you, what you're eating, how you're eating, what is actually [00:21:00] going on. Yeah. Um, are you actually feeling hungry? Mm. What kinds of foods- Yeah ... are you choosing? Okay. Um, so I think that's a very good kind of starting point. Mm-hmm. And, and there are some patterns that I can, I see quite frequently. So a lot of very well-intentioned kind of women that decide, "Okay, I'm gonna do really well." They will start the day, they will eat a really good breakfast. Mm-hmm. They will do their best at lunchtime, and then it's towards the afternoon, evening that things- It slightly falls apart ... start to fall apart. Mm. Exactly. And there are ways to mitigate that. I think over-restricting during the first part of the day can definitely backfire. Mm-hmm. So I always say to people, try and distribute things a little bit more evenly- Mm ... especially, like, the protein intake and the fiber intake as well. So if you're having a high-protein, high-fiber breakfast, for example, and then at lunch you're less likely to be absolutely starving later on in the day. So be very intentional of what [00:22:00] you're eating as well. Be very intentional. Try and plan a little bit ahead. Mm-hmm. When I say planning ahead, it doesn't have to mean you're meal prepping all of your Sunday, like, you know, women in their 40s, you don't- It's not gonna happen ... have time to do that. Yeah. It's, it's, it's not gonna happen. Has to be something that can be rooted in real life. It has to be rooted in, in real life. Yeah. And, uh, it needs to be, it needs to be tailored to, to the individual. Mm-hmm. So can I pick that up, if I could? Yeah. About, um, looping us back to the protein point, because, you know, it's, it's words that we know really well, so I'm gonna ask you about protein and fiber- Yes, yes separately. Um, so they're words that we know really well, and we think we know what foods contain it. There's almost a perception sometimes that it is, it needs to be added to things, so very often you will see packaging that will say protein, and that can be confusing 'cause it may just have protein anyway. So- Yeah ... so, so to that, back to that point, so tell us a bit about, again, very high level, just what, what, what is that, and what foods naturally contain it- Yeah ... without addition, obviously. And by [00:23:00] the way, you can have enough protein without adding it to stuff, as in, like, in terms of powders and things like that, which we can come to. Um, but yeah, what, uh, how, how do you advise people as to what it is? How do you incorporate protein in your diet? What does good adequate protein intake look like in a- Yeah ... in a varied diet? Okay, so- Protein overall kind of in diet, you've got animal proteins and you've got plant-based proteins and they both have a value- Mm-hmm in a, in a healthy diet. So in terms of animal protein, things like, uh, beef, chicken, fish, uh, dairy products and- Milk, cheese ... milk, cheese, eggs- Mm-hmm ... very good type of protein. And then we've got kind of a plant-based protein, so things like, uh, soy, uh, beans, lentils, chickpeas. Mm-hmm. So those are all sources of protein. Proteins. Mm-hmm. And animal protein is a very kind of high quality type of protein, [00:24:00] meaning that you get a complete amino acid profile. Mm-hmm. Which just means that they are ... On their own, they're effective in stimulating muscle protein synthesis. Okay? So they are- Highly kind of effective- Yeah ... types of protein. Yeah. Sometimes there's a jargon term for that is anabolic, isn't it? Yeah. Which actually is a word for, say, building. That's all it means. Yes, yes. It can build muscle mass. It just- exactly. Mm-hmm. I- it's got a complete amino acid profile, so unless you're consuming all of the 20 amino acids, um, your body can't kind of synthesize new, um, muscle cells. New, new muscles. Yes. So it needs that whole library- It needs all the- ... of amino acid complements. Yes, yes. Yeah, which is why sort of animal proteins are good at doing that. They are very good at doing that, but saying that, you can also do that with plant proteins. Mm-hmm. Um, you just need to have a combination of plant proteins. Mm-hmm. But the good news is that- We tend to eat a variety of foods. Yes. We don't eat just one type of plant protein And we're lucky enough to have access to [00:25:00] a variety of foods. Exactly, exactly. Yeah. So you can absolutely get that full amino acid profile- Mm-hmm ... from, from plant proteins. Mm-hmm. You would probably need a higher quantity. So for example, the quantity of protein that you get from a chicken breast will be much higher. You would need a much higher volume of legumes, for example, to get that same amount of- And give us an idea how much different ... protein. So, and chicken breast is a good one, so one chicken breast fillet. Quite a bit different. So depending on the size of the chicken breast, you might be getting about 25 grams of, um, protein. Mm-hmm. And if you're to get the same amount in terms of legumes, you're gonna have a significant bigger amount, like a plate of legumes mixed there. So maybe like you might have to eat three, 300 grams, maybe? Would that, would that be a, a good estimate, or do you think less or more? Around that. Around that. Yeah. Okay. Around that. Which is quite a bit. That's quite a plateful. It, it is. It is quite a bit. Yeah. It is quite a bit. Yeah. Obviously, you can mix and match and, you know, if you're, if you're, um, eating vegetarian diet, there are things that you can add. [00:26:00] Tofu, for example, that will be- Mm-hmm ... more kind of similar to that, um, protein content of animal protein, even though a different kind of amino acid profile, but you can combine different sorts- You can combine them. Mm-hmm ... of protein to achieve that. So it's absolutely doable. It just requires a little bit more planning. Little planning. And on that, if I could pick it up, if somebody who is having a completely vegetarian or, or, or not animal product diet, what combination of those legumes, chickpeas, and, and beans, and soy works well? What combination do you advise people to have if they say, "Actually, I have a fully plant-based diet"? Um, it's ve- it's not very difficult to achieve it, and I think over the years, like if, when you think about typical foods, we kind of naturally have developed and, and evolved to achieve those combinations. Mm-hmm. So for example, I'm, I'm from Brazil, and in Brazil, the typical combination is kind of rice and beans. Yes. And rice and beans, they complement perfectly the amino acid [00:27:00] profile. Fantastic. So it's mostly like, okay, if you're having, like, chickpeas, and you're having beans, and then you're having quinoa, or you're having rice- That will work ... they will work together- Together ... to complement the amino acid profile. Okay, so as long as you've got that complementary and varied diet within that. Yes, absolutely. Pretty much the same way that your animal protein intake shouldn't just be chicken breast or shouldn't just be fish- Exactly ... or shouldn't just be- Exactly. Mm-hmm. So I think variety is something that is extremely important. Mm-hmm. Um, and on the protein topic, it's worth mentioning that, um- It, it, like protein targets, like we can look at it from a, a population level Mm-hmm ... and at a population level, we are not massively worried about how much protein people are eating. But at an individual level, there are groups of the population that have higher requirements. Um, so for example, the older population or women going through that perimenopause or menopause Mm-hmm ... um, if you're actively trying to lose weight, there are a number of things that will push your requirements to the [00:28:00] higher- Slightly higher ... end of the spectrum. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. And, and that's why in clinic, I often see women that are well, the vast majority of the women that I see, they are not eating. They are eating enough to prevent a protein deficiency, absolutely, but they're not eating enough to optimize health. So not enough for satiety, to feel full enough for long enough- Yeah ... and to actually muscle build. Yeah. So it's enough, just. It's enough. Yeah, yeah. Yes, exactly. It's enough to prevent insufficiency. Mm. It's not enough to optimize outcomes. Okay. Yeah. So let's then follow that up with the fiber point. Yeah. Tell us about fiber. What, what is it? So- We read so much about it and some, you know, and people tell us it's good for you- Yes, fiber salad, et cetera. But anyway, yeah ... fiber is having, fiber is definitely having a moment. Uh- And, and yeah, and most of us don't get enough fiber. Mm-hmm. So the recommendation is that we should be trying to get, uh, about 30 grams of fiber a day, and the vast majority of people- Don't get that ... don't get there. Mm-hmm. [00:29:00] And, uh, it's extremely important. It's ex- important, like from a satiety perspective. It's important from a gut health perspective, metabolic health. It's, um, there is a variety of different fibers- Mm-hmm ... like that could be a, a whole new podcast just on its own. And present in loads of different foods. So it's not just salad, it's legumes are, uh, a, an excellent source of fiber. Carbohydrate foods, like whole grain carbohydrates are a very important source of fiber in the diet as well. So whole grain bread- Whole grain bread ... rice, pasta ... whole grain, yes, yes, absolutely. Mm-hmm. And there's so many different types of grains. You've got quinoa, you've got spelt, you've got oats, and ... well, oats not really a, a grain itself- No ... but it's, um, there are so many different types, and they're extremely important. So when people say, "Oh, uh, you know, oh, carbohydrates, eliminate carbohydrates from your diet," I always think that's a really bad idea- Bad idea, yeah because it's a very important source of fiber there. [00:30:00] Yeah. Seeds and nuts, absolutely brilliant. Mm-hmm. Um, good source of fiber, very good for your metabolic health. Mm-hmm. So it is something that fiber and protein- Often lack both of them together. At the moment, there seems to be kind of two camps when you look at, like, social media and media in general. Yeah. Like, some people really pro-fiber, some people really pro f- pro- Protein, yeah ... protein. And I'm alw- always wondering, why does it have to be one or the other? This is, this isn't an either/or, yeah? Exactly. It's like- Yeah ... it's both. It's not an either/or. They are- Yeah ... extremely important. Yeah. And so what does fiber do? Why do we need it? Oh, we need for so many different things. So one of the things is, yes, it does have this, uh, satiating effect, so it's very good for- Fills you up ... keeping us feeling fuller. It's very important for feeding our, um, gut microbiome- Mm-hmm ... which is involved in all sorts of things that are beneficial for health. It's in- at the most basic level, it's very important for keeping our digestive, uh, [00:31:00] tract functioning properly- Mm ... and making sure that you're regularly going to the loo. Going to the loo. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, which is actually really important. And again, that's incredibly important. A normal gastrointestinal tract, that is to say anything that leaves- Very from, from, from your mouth all the way down to the bum, is essentially needs to be, have movement through it. So you don't want anything to get slow movement through- Absolutely not ... like, yeah. It's, uh- Um, yeah. And we were, we were talking, again, I'm gonna refer the audience back to our screening podcast, which was about, uh, bowel cancer. Mm. And we're saying that one of the things that's very difficult about bowel cancer is that involves talking about poo, and people don't like talking about poo. People don't like to talk about it. People don't like talk about p- poo or bottoms. But actually on this point, on the fiber, you have to talk about poo and bottoms. Absolutely. Um, because that's what it does. And I always say that to patients in clinic. Like, whenever they say, "Well, I'm sorry if I'm being too descriptive," I said, "No, no, no. I-" This is a normal bodily function. "... hear this several times a day, every day. We have to be descriptive." Yes. Yeah. We have to be descriptive, and you have to, we have to talk about this in order to have that, that, that, that health. Um, okay. So that's wonderful. So we've obviously discussed, you know, [00:32:00] pres- patient presentations, some of the challenges, the fact that this is not just in your head. These are hormonal changes as well as aging changes. Absolutely. Yeah. They are definitely hap- happening. And with women kind of in, in, in clinic, what I often say, because it can be difficult. Like, it's much easier if you're rushing around, if you don't really have much time to think about a meal, it's much easier to say, "Oh, I'll have a plate of pasta"- Yes ... than to think, "Oh, I'm gonna cook this salad with, uh, chickpeas and lentils- And quinoa and, yeah ... and quinoa- Yeah ... and salmon and- Yeah ... um, but there, there are ways around it, and I think there are quick things that you can do, and maybe having a little list of, like, quick meals that you can put together. Mm. And something that I often say to women is whenever you're planning a meal, or even if you're ordering out, if you're eating out- Always think, where is my protein coming from- Mm ... and where is my fiber coming from? So have those, have those little trigger words in your head. Those trigger things. Yeah And- Going back to [00:33:00] being intentional. Exactly, and it's not because you shouldn't be having carbohydrates- Mm ... but carbohydrates, they seem to find their way into the plate regardless, so we, uh, so we don't have to- You- we're not gonna be short of carbohydrates. We're not gonna be short of it. Yeah. Uh, they will find their way in. Mm. So it's more thinking, where is the protein? Is there a protein source here? Where is the fiber? Is there a, a, a source of fiber- Fiber, yeah ... in my plate, a significant source of, of fiber? Yeah. Because if your meal consists of, you know, a plate of pasta and a side salad that's just kind of lettuce and tomato, occasionally- That's not enough fiber that's okay, but- That's not enough protein ... on a, on a day-to-day basis, that, that's not going to be good enough. That's not gonna cut it. Yeah. And so, and do you cover... So obviously, what's very important, and what I love about your approach, is actually you're looking at the whole human, right? So when somebody presents to you, it's important to understand, you know, why we are where we are. Mm. So some of the things that play into it are things like sleep and stress- Yeah ... and exercise. Yeah. How do you unpick those? Because of course, there is a sort of a very negative [00:34:00] catch-22 if you haven't slept well- Absolutely ... if you're incredibly s- stressed, you're, you're not gonna have intentionality about your diet the next day. How, how- No ... how do you unpick that? No. And that, and that's really interesting you say that because I think particularly for women kind of going through the menopause- Mm ... women, they're experiencing kind of those vasomotor symptoms like night sweats and hot flashes, their sleep can be really disrupted. Mm. And that, you know, has an impact on cortisol levels, has an impact on your appetite control the following day. It's got an impact on your blood sugar management the next day. So your- y- y- you're, you're already starting a, at disadvantage- Mm-hmm ... on, on the next day. So it's really important to try and, and manage that. So a lot of the women that I see, they're going through kind of difficulties with sleep or vasomotor symptoms. They, um, you know, I work with wonderful doctors as well, and, uh, and a lot of the, the ones that are suitable for HRT- Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm ... find that HRT can be a [00:35:00] really big help. Um, I think nutrition works really well with HRT- Mm-hmm ... to improve symptoms. It's very holistic. Yes. I, I never like to give the impression that nutrition is a substitute to HRT, because if you're suffering from menopausal symptoms, that is the gold standard. You, you need it treated. Yeah. That's the gold standard. So don't, don't suffer in silence. Yeah. Don't wait five years- Mm-hmm ... to, to, to try something that can literally change- Yeah ... your quality of life. Mm-hmm. Um- And that duality of the approach allows for someone to- Absolutely ... you know, replace the estrogen that you've lost or losing, and at the same time, that obviously will help with any of the symptoms around anxiety, insomnia, et cetera. It won't remove your stress. It won't remove- Yeah ... the stress. And, and I think that is kind of, that's really challenging, and I think that's kind of part of life. Mm-hmm. And I think that stage of life can come with loads of different stresses there. Mm-hmm. Um, and that is something that it really is [00:36:00] individual. Um, that is something we discuss on an individual basis. I think- Yeah, but it, it is definitely something that needs to be considered Yeah. So you have a, you have a discussion about that and signpost them to- Yes ... other- Yeah. So on a- Yeah ... absolutely. So on an initial consultation, um, I'll spend one whole hour with it, which is a big luxury to have one whole hour with- Yeah the patient, and we'll discuss everything in terms of, um, lifestyle, work patterns, sleeping patterns, exercise, diet, family history, medical history. And maybe even just that one hour there allows someone to have some thinking space to- Yeah ... try and understand. Yeah. Um, so for those who are listening who may be obviously not in London, don't have access to you specifically, which I'm sure they'd love, um, what can they do at home as a DIY approach to reproduce what you're doing? It sounds like if you were to sit down and write all this down for yourself- Yeah ... could they do that? [00:37:00] Yeah, I think- How could, how could they do that? What would you, what would your advice be to someone who's like, "I really like Marcella's approach, and I'd like to try this out for myself"? What can they do? I think a really good starting point is start with a food diary. Mm-hmm. Keep a food diary for three days just to, to try and understand a little bit more- Mm-hmm ... what is going on. Be as honest as you can. It's just for yourself. You don't need to show it to anybody. Mm-hmm. Um, and try and understand what is going on. The first stage in terms of diet modification for anyone I see will be kind of a structured meal pattern. Mm-hmm. So sta- stop mindless kind of snacking. Um, I find something that often happens is kind of people might think in advance about breakfast, lunch, and dinner, but then there's that period in the afternoon, that period between lunch and dinner can be quite long. Quite long. And that's when kind of mindless snacking can start to happen, and it can derail the whole thing. Mm-hmm. Like, they can be going really well until that point, and then you might have a few snacks that you're not planning, and you [00:38:00] just think, "Oh, you know what?" Forget it. "Forget it. I'll start again tomorrow or on Monday." Yeah. Yeah. Um, so be intentional about it. Plan a snack ahead. Plan a meal. So do your food diary. Do a food diary. Then do a plan. Set up a, kind of a structure. Meal plan. Mm-hmm. And what works for you. It might be that it's breakfast, lunch, mid-afternoon snack, and dinner. It might be that- And dinner ... you're the type person that needs a couple of different snacks at different times points through, time points through the day- Mm-hmm plus the three meals. So see what works for you. Mm-hmm. Think about where is the protein coming from, where is the fi- the fiber coming from- That suits your diet, whatever that may be ... with ev- whatever suits your diet- Mm ... if it's a plant-based or animal-based, but for kind of all your main meals. Amazing. So there's lots of myths- Yeah around nutrition. If you could myth bust one, what would it be? For this particular kind of population group- Mm-hmm ... that you... Okay. [00:39:00] Oh, there are so many. I think- You can pick more than one. Yeah. I think, I think that You know, it sounds so kind of, uh, perfectly plausible and reasonable to just eat less and exercise more Mm-hmm. Okay But it's not that simple. Okay. That's really helpful. Not because, not because it, it doesn't work. Yes, of course it would work. If you are spending more energy than you're consuming, you will lose weight. But we have evolved over the years to, to survive and to protect our, a, a set point of our body weight, right? Our bodies... You know, as a doctor, you know our bodies are very good at maintaining homeostasis. Yeah. We like to be the way that we are. Our survival depends on it. Exactly. Yeah. Our survival depends on it, so we like to be exactly as we are- Mm-hmm ... even if that's not perfect. Yeah. So there is this theory of, you know, the [00:40:00] set point for, for weight, that your body's happy around a certain weight. Mm-hmm. And that can change over time and over the years. Mm. But once your body's happy at that set point, the moment it starts deviating from that, it has very, very powerful mechanisms in place- To pull you back ... to pull you back. Yeah. So the moment that you start, uh, restricting calories and exercising more, your body perceives that as danger. Yeah. Well, it, yeah- Like that something's terribly wrong ... the red light starts to flash. Exactly. Yeah. Like, okay, starvation is coming- Yeah ... I need to survive. Yeah. So what it does, it will send all the signals to your brain that will signal hunger. Yeah? So you're absolutely starving, so your appetite will go up, and at the same time, it will reduce your metabolic rate- Mm so you can survive. Yeah. So it will save any energy that you've got left for your essential vital organs, so, so your heart's beating, so your brain is functioning- Mm ... so you'll be extremely tired, you'll be [00:41:00] extremely hungry. Um- And you won't feel great whilst you're doing that ... and you won't feel great. Mm. And that is really, really difficult, so you're literally fighting biology. Okay. So to- That's really helpful ... so to say exercise more, eat less, it's really counterproductive- Yeah ... because- And in and of itself, it may... Exactly. It may actually achieve exactly the opposite of what you're trying to do- Yeah because- And, and I think having a little bit more understanding about what is going on metabolically and physio- physiologically can help us navigate it a little bit more- Mm ... um, and a little bit better and actually to be a bit kinder to ourselves- 100% ... because I think so many times women just feel like, oh, I'm failing this. Yeah. And, and you're not. I think that's a really, really wonderful point to end on because you've, you've taught me so much actually 'cause you're, you, you, you've, you've mentioned that real sort of intentionality and self-awareness Which very often comes from the fact that we don't spend enough time on [00:42:00] ourselves and just trying to analyze what is going on in terms of our lives, our exercise, our eating habits. Um, what people can learn from you as to what they can do at home, obviously they can come and see you, but if they can't for whatever reason, 'cause they're on the other side of the world, um, then have that food diary, put down what you're eating, have some reflection about exercise. Definitely look at, um, your holistic approach, cardiovascular health, menopause health, hormonal health- Mm and that this isn't just in your head. This is real metabolic hormonal effects that are going on in your body, and, and yeah, take it easy, be kind, be intentional, be holistic. Exactly, and I think also kind of readjusting our expectations that, you know, you're, uh, wanting to have the same weight and exactly the same body you had in your 20s when you're in your 40s, it- it's- it's a fight that- It's, it may not be a realistic- It might not be worth fighting it might not, yeah, may not be a realistic ask. Yeah. E- [00:43:00] exactly. Yeah. So, and, and I'm not saying about, oh, you know, giving up or- Yes ... no, but it's just... It's a reset. Yes. I think it's a really, it's a really important time for kind of a reset for reflecting- And could be an opportunity. Absolutely. Yeah. I think it's a huge opportunity, and it's why I love working with kind of this, this particular group- Mm because I think it is an opportunity. I think it's a moment of reset in a woman's life. It's a moment that women tend to turn to themselves a little bit more. Mm. Yeah. Wonderful. And it's a, it's great. Wonderful. Thank you so much, Marcella. Thank you. Thank you so much for joining me today. Thank you for having me. Lovely to have you. Thank [00:44:00] you.