Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP229: The Death of Martha Moxley
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Welcome back, everyone to another episode of
- 0:38Crimes and Consequences. I'm Tanya and this is my lovely co host, Talia.
- 0:44No. We are a couple lawyers who also enjoy talking about true crime
- 0:49and swearing yes and eating yes. Those are We have lots of hobbies.
- 0:56This is a story that I think a lot of people may know. It
- 1:00was pretty popular in the news. I'd say probably in the nineties. But
- 1:06anyway, before I get into it, I don't even know what it is.
- 1:08I know you're going to know it, though I know you will before
- 1:11we get into it. I just like to remind everyone to hit the subscribe
- 1:15or follow button on whatever app you're listening to, if you're on YouTube.
- 1:19And we'd like to thank True Crime Daily for hosting us. Thank you so
- 1:23on October Friday, I am no chit chat. No, we don't.
- 1:27Ain't nobody get time for that. Man can't get a toime. On October
- 1:32thirty first, nineteen seventy five, around twelve fifteen in the afternoon, a
- 1:38girl named Sheila McGuire, who was a teenager living in the exclusive Bell Haven
- 1:42community in Greenwich, Connectic Kid, was walking from her house to her friend
- 1:49Martha Moxley's to invite her to go downtown that day. Oh, I know
- 1:53this, I told you, you know, I know, I don't know
- 1:56all the details. I know I forgot all the details. So to get
- 1:59to her friend's house, she cut through a wooded section of their backyards and
- 2:05she's, you know, going along, she spots underneath the low hanging branches
- 2:08of a pine tree what looked like a sleeping bag lying on top of a
- 2:14foam mattress. As she continued to walk closer, she was able to see
- 2:17that it was the partially clothed body of her friend Martha, who was somewhat
- 2:23hidden by the branches of the tree. And so Sheila ran to the Moxley
- 2:28house and rang the doorbell. This ended up being a cold case, right
- 2:32yeah, for a while. Dorotha Moxley, who was Martha's mom, was
- 2:38there with several of her friends who were gathered to show support because she'd been
- 2:43worried when Martha hadn't returned home the night before, and she'd been reaching out
- 2:49to Martha's friends for hours up to that point, you know, looking for
- 2:52Martha. And the night previous was Devil's night, at least that's what we
- 2:55call it here. October thirtieth, October thirtieth, Roy Devil's Night is yet
- 3:00night. They didn't turn down all the abandoned houses them, not anymore.
- 3:06No, I don't think they do that. There's too many abandoned. Yeah,
- 3:08but you know, kids go out and like toilet paper, the trees
- 3:12and yeah, soap, no doubt, exactly Devil's Night. In fact,
- 3:21Martha had just called her husband, David, who's Martha's dad. He was
- 3:24out of town for work, and she left him a message that Martha was
- 3:28missing and to come home as soon as possible. When Sheila came to her
- 3:32door, she told Dorothy that she'd found Martha and it didn't look like she
- 3:38was okay. Martha was face down, her head was covered with dried blood,
- 3:44her blue jeans and underwear were pulled down to below her knees. I
- 3:47didn't know that, yeah, and her body was ice cold upon hearing this,
- 3:52Dorothy collapsed into a chair in the living room. John Moxley, who
- 3:58was Martha's older brother, had been at football practice when Martha was found.
- 4:01The night before, he'd been out with other neighborhood teens going to parties.
- 4:06It's, like I said, bibles night. I don't know what they call
- 4:09it in Connecticut. But when John got home and this was around midnight,
- 4:16so this is her brother, Yeah, this is her brother. Martha wasn't
- 4:19there obviously, and Dorothy had asked him to go around the neighborhood and search
- 4:25for a sister. While he was getting dressed in the locker room after practice,
- 4:30his coach and this is now the next day, like after Martha's found,
- 4:32his coach pulled him aside, telling him something happened at home, and
- 4:38he didn't give him any further details. So John ran out the door and
- 4:41just drove home like a bat out of house, freaking out. Yeah sure,
- 4:44I'm sure. When he arrived he saw his house surrounded by police cars.
- 4:48There were, you know, officers, the media trucks were already there
- 4:53with a bunch of reporters. There was emergency personnel. Curious neighbors because this
- 4:58is a rich neighborhood. Yes, the rich neighborhood, and there was other
- 5:01onlookers. So he left his truck at the end of the driveway and he
- 5:05ran up to the house. Martha had been hitting the head with a golf
- 5:10club several times. Her head and face were so bloody that first responders said
- 5:15they didn't realize she'd been blonde, had blonde hair. Wow, that's how
- 5:19bad it was. The murderer had hit Martha with such force that her skull
- 5:25had cracked and the golf club had broken. Oh wow. Yeah, and
- 5:29that's got to be hard to break a golf all right. And then the
- 5:31remainder of the club was used to stab her. Oh, I didn't know
- 5:35that what stab and ware it was through her neck. Oh, and it
- 5:44had threaded a lack of her hair through the skin like when when she was
- 5:47like hit with it like her you know, through her muscle and her skin
- 5:51like a needle. Like that's the club impaled her and her hair went into
- 5:57the wound. Poor baby. Yeah, fuck is that I know? And
- 6:01she's fifteen. I don't know if I mentioned it, she's only fifteen.
- 6:05Maybe it's believed that the stab wound is what killed her. Okay, okay,
- 6:10So it wasn't necessarily the blows to the hut, even though it crushed
- 6:14her skull. Yeah, even though a crushed her skull. Oh wow.
- 6:17The police believed that Martha had been attacked from behind when she was first hit
- 6:21in the hut. After she'd been beaten, the killer dragged her body seventy
- 6:27feet into her backyard and placed her underneath the pine tree. So she didn't
- 6:32she was found where she wasn't killed? Correct? Yes, Yeah, she
- 6:36wasn't killed underneath that pine tree. She was placed there by the killer.
- 6:42Where was she killed? It was like somewhere else in the yard. It
- 6:46was a huge yard, and I will we're gonna show a picture of like
- 6:50a diagram of what the yards and things look like. So, although her
- 6:55pants and underwear had been pulled down, there was no sign of sexual assault.
- 7:00Tests determined there was no drugs or alcohol in our system. So she's
- 7:03hit in the back of the head by surprise, m hm. Her skull
- 7:08is crushed, and then somebody tries to pull her underwear and pants down.
- 7:12Yeah, apparently strange, right. The crime scene itself was huge, about
- 7:18one hundred feet away from the pine tree where you know. Martha's body was
- 7:24found. There was a three to four foot pool of coagulating blood, so
- 7:29that's where they believe she was attacked. She was attacked, and there was
- 7:32a section of the shaft of the golf club was also about one hundred feet
- 7:38away. Another twenty feet away where the drag marks across the gravel driveway,
- 7:45blood and some tissue were found, like along the drag marks as as on
- 7:49the other side of the asphalt were more pieces of the murder weapon and more
- 7:54blood was found. Why would her killer dragger? I don't know, what
- 7:57does it matter, Like you're just dragging her under a tree. I don't
- 8:00know. I guess maybe, I mean that's she was hidden kind of right,
- 8:03kind of on her yeah property, Yeah, on her own property,
- 8:07right. I don't know, because maybe there were just kids around the neighborhood
- 8:11and maybe I was afraid. I have no idea, That's what I'm thinking.
- 8:16It just seems weird. Her death was approximated to be around ten pm.
- 8:20The Greenwich Police Department had little, if any experience processing violent crimes.
- 8:26The police chief had been in the department for thirty years and he hadn't been
- 8:31able to recall investigating even one murder before. Wow. They called him the
- 8:37Connecticut State Police for help, and the people of bell Haven immediately began suspecting
- 8:43it was an outsider because you know, nobody in the neighborhood could have done
- 8:46this, right, no way, Yeah, I mean, rich people don't
- 8:48kill people, right. No one who met Martha they figured, you know,
- 8:54would want to kill her. She didn't have any enemy. She was
- 8:56a very nice girl. And like I said, Greenwich is an upscale town
- 9:01in Connecticut. The cost of living in this area is about sixty four percent
- 9:05higher than the national average. So just to give you an idea, the
- 9:11drawdic Grantwich tends to be like because it's in like close proximity to New York
- 9:16City Manhattan. There's access to the ocean, the city ocean, right,
- 9:20yeah, the Atlantic Ocean is there. But it also has like a small
- 9:24town feel, right, So that's you know, along the ocean and things.
- 9:31They call it the Gold Coast right there. Oh yeah, sounds lovely.
- 9:35It does, doesn't right when you're right right, we've never been No,
- 9:41never mind, I'm sure it's lovely. Fort Letterdill's, Yeah, what
- 9:43we can afford exactly when the Moxley's moved into their home just a year before
- 9:50Martha was murdered. They fit right in with the people there. David Moxley
- 9:54was a partner in charge of the New York office of the Big Eight accounting
- 9:58firm, which is now called Deloitte, you know, but then it was
- 10:03called Touschross. No, I have no idea. Yeah, I've heard of
- 10:07Deloitte. The neighborhood kids Martha had been hanging out with the night before,
- 10:11Helen Ix and Jackie Wittenhall. Their fathers were president of Cadbury Schweps like the
- 10:18Cadbury eggs and Schwepp's ginger Ale is what I think of club soda? Yeah,
- 10:24I have it in my car right. And the other father was the
- 10:28chairman of the American Dairy Association. So where everyone in Bellhaven was rich,
- 10:33Martha's next door neighbors, the Scale family. They were obscenely rich. Okay.
- 10:41The dad was rushed in Russian scagell and he and his wife had seven
- 10:46children. The Scale family were owners of one of the largest privately held companies
- 10:52at the time, which was called Great Lakes Carbon, and Russian's sister at
- 11:00had married Bobby Kennedy. Yes, yes, in nineteen fifty. So that's
- 11:05his sister that married Ethel married Bobby Kennedy. Robert Kennedy, right, Robert
- 11:11Russian unfortunately was an abusive alcoholic and kind of an absent father, and his
- 11:18wife passed away in nineteen seventy three. So he's got, you know,
- 11:22all these children, and when does the story take place? In nineteen seventy
- 11:30five, seventy five? Right, so his kids are you know, he'd
- 11:33often have to go out of town for work, leaving his children, and
- 11:37some of them were adults. There was Rushton Junior who was nineteen, Julie
- 11:41who was eighteen, Thomas was seventeen, John was sixteen, Michael was fifteen,
- 11:46David was twelve, and Steven the youngest, he was nine. So
- 11:50he would often leave the kids in the care of household help because he had
- 11:56to go out of town. His six boys had a reputation of being wild
- 12:01and out of control, and Thomas and Michael had a huge sibling rivalry and
- 12:05they were extremely competitive with one another. I mean they're only a year apart,
- 12:11right, and their teen boys. Yeah, and their teen boys.
- 12:13On the evening of October thirtieth, nineteen seventy five. Martha was fifteen.
- 12:18Like I mentioned, she left her house that night to go celebrate. Oh,
- 12:22they called it mischief Night. I forget mischief Mischief night, right,
- 12:26it was a little softer than devils. Yeah, she went out to celebrate
- 12:31Mischief Night. And they would go toilet paper houses, throw eggs at passing
- 12:37cars, and they'd played ding dong ditch and dong ditch when you ring the
- 12:41doorbell on you and other types of pranks. No, no, I didn't
- 12:48know there was a name for what I did. Yeah, back in the
- 12:50day, Yeah, ditch. This was not only the day before Halloween,
- 12:54but the first day of a three day weekend, so it's kind of you
- 12:58know, party time. Right on this night, security in the community was
- 13:03increased for the anticipated you know, youth activities, mischievousness, Yes, the
- 13:09mischievousness of the teens. Martha and her friends walked around the area, going
- 13:13between houses, hanging out with one another, other and other friends, and
- 13:18ended up the at some point during the evening, about nine o'clock, at
- 13:22the Scicle home, the next door to her house. Right. Yes,
- 13:28the Scalle boys went to a private school called Brunswick, and Martha attended a
- 13:33local high school she went to Runwi Chhai, so they didn't know each other
- 13:37very well, but she had recently met and began to get to know Thomas
- 13:41and Michael, who were both just a little bit older than her. Yeah,
- 13:46and they were both romantically interested in her. Oh, both were Yeah.
- 13:50Most said they were like they had extremely compatitive right, and she enjoyed
- 13:56and she enjoyed the attention and had begun writing about it in her diary.
- 14:01And I do have a few pages from her diary that I mean, you
- 14:03won't be able to really read it, but you know, there are a
- 14:05few pages. She is really nice handwriting. I know it's a weird thing
- 14:09to say, but she does have I appreciate it. I appreciate that.
- 14:15That night before she passed away, the before she was murdered, she had
- 14:20been sitting in front in the front seat of the Scagles Lincoln with Michael,
- 14:24Helen and Jeffrey Byrne, one of the other local teens. They were in
- 14:28the back seat. Neither Michael nor Martha he had their driver's license, so
- 14:33they were just sitting in the driveway listening to music like a parent's car.
- 14:37I think, so, yeah, I'm thinking it was a parent's car,
- 14:39someone's car, none of their carn Yeah, exactly, about nine p fifteen,
- 14:46Thomas got out of the car, saying he wanted to go get one
- 14:50of his cassette tapes, but instead he climbed into the front seat, sandwiching
- 14:54Martha between he and his brother. So that's a little weird, right,
- 15:00Both boys had more than a few beers in them. Thomas started flirting with
- 15:05Martha. He put his hand on her leg, to which she told him,
- 15:07get your hand off, and she probably smacked it. And then his
- 15:11brother's on the other side of her, mm hmm, and Michael's watching his
- 15:13older brother move in, you know, on Martha, and he's trying to
- 15:18win her affection. Maybe fifteen minutes later, Rushton Junior, who was nineteen,
- 15:24and John came out to the car and said they needed to use it,
- 15:26so maybe it was Russian's car. I'm not sure. They wanted to
- 15:30go to their cousin's house to watch Money Python. Michael wanted to go and
- 15:35asked Martha if she'd like to go and watch the movie with them, and
- 15:37I'm not sure exactly what Money Python movie, but she declined, and she
- 15:41said she had to get home, and Thomas decided to stay behind. Also,
- 15:48Thomas and Martha walked off the driveway near the Skygles shed and they were
- 15:52flirting and kind of kissing a little bit. Oh yeah. OK. Helen
- 15:56and Jeff, who had stayed behind with their friends and began to be disgusted
- 16:00by Martha's behavior, and they decided to go home. Why were they discussed?
- 16:06No, no, I'm not sure, but they were. And as
- 16:10they walked away across the Scagle's backyard, they saw Thomas and Martha fall together
- 16:15behind the fence near the Scagle pool. That was the last time they would
- 16:21see her alive. Martha didn't have a real curfew. She was only expected
- 16:26to be home at a reasonable quote unquote hour. Oh yeah, I get
- 16:30it. Yeah, it was her judgment as to what a reasonable hour should
- 16:33be. You know, she's getting a little older. Her parents are trying
- 16:36to give her some freedom. The previous week she had stayed out until two
- 16:40or three in the morning, a little yeah, she was pushing her mom's
- 16:44patience with that. Around nine point thirty, when Martha and her friends were
- 16:48splintering to their homes, Dorothy Moxley was home painting around the windows of one
- 16:53of their bedrooms on the second story of their basically mansion. A scuffle on
- 17:00the side of the house through the closed windows. Although she was used to
- 17:04hearing kids cutting through her property, this voice didn't sound too friendly or innocent.
- 17:11So she went and she turned the light on on their back porch,
- 17:17you know, looking to see if she could see anything. Around that time,
- 17:19also, several dogs in the neighborhood started barking loudly enough and for such
- 17:26a sustained amount of time that many of the residents of Bellhaven noticed, and
- 17:32several neighbors were startled enough to go and check on you know, what's going
- 17:36on. Yeah, Around ten PM, Dorothy decided to stop painting. She
- 17:41cleaned up, took a shower, got dressed for bed, and by eleven
- 17:45she was downstairs watching the news. John returned home from his friend's house around
- 17:52eleven twenty. Dorothy was getting annoyed at this point that Martha wasn't home yet.
- 17:57John was kind of secretly pleased his perfect sister was getting in trouble,
- 18:02right, they probably had that kind of relationship, and he told his mom,
- 18:07I'll go look for Martha. He got in his truck and went driving
- 18:11around the neighborhood for about half an hour. He came and reported back to
- 18:15his mom that he had only seen one drunk kid sleeping it off in a
- 18:18neighbor's yard and there was no sign of Martha. One drunk kid. Mm
- 18:23hmmm, it's almost I'm thinking it's almost close to midnight now, so maybe
- 18:27they'd all gone home and who knows right now. I like the fact that
- 18:32he's just sleeping it on in somebody's yard. I know, it's like,
- 18:37okay, I know he was like whatever, bucket. Yeah. Dorothy fell
- 18:42asleep in front of the television, and she woke up after midnight. She
- 18:47first went and checked Martha's room to see if she was home, and seeing
- 18:51her daughter's bed was empty, she went downstairs and she started making phone calls.
- 18:56First, she called Helen I's house, where Helen told her that she
- 19:00had last saw Martha with Thomas Skekell. Helen gave Dorothy the phone number to
- 19:04the Scalele house and she called there. Immediately, Julie answered the phone.
- 19:11Dorothy, Julie's the sister. Okay. Dorothy asked her if anyone had been
- 19:17had seen Martha, so she went to ask her brothers what they know,
- 19:19Julie went to go ask her brothers. When Julie got back to the phone,
- 19:23she told Dorothy that her brother, her brother Thomas, had said he
- 19:29last saw Martha at the back door of his house around nine thirty when he
- 19:33went inside to work on a school project about Abraham Lincoln a mischievous night or
- 19:38whatever, mischief night and the beginning of a three day weekend. H I
- 19:42don't know you, but I always waited until Sunday to get like shit done
- 19:45right. I'm always I'm a procrastinator, so I would always wait for the
- 19:49last minute. I certainly wouldn't start it on a Thursday night, the day
- 19:53or whatever it was before mischief night all night. No, no, I'm
- 19:59going to be the one past drunk. Over the next few hours, Dorothy
- 20:04would call the Scagell's house back several times, expressing concern and asking for more
- 20:10details about Thomas's last interaction with Martha. He consistently said that he saw her
- 20:17at his back door around nine point thirty and when he went inside, and
- 20:19that's when he went inside to study. What did he say? Did she
- 20:23she's what is she doing at the back door? Like? I think they
- 20:26were probably saying goodbye or good bye okay. At one point, on Dorothy's
- 20:30insistence, Julie woke up her brother so Dorothy could speak to him herself,
- 20:36because she's Thomas, Yeah, Thomas. She simply asked him do you know
- 20:40where Martha could be? And he replied, I have no idea where she
- 20:44is. Dorothy called neighbor after neighbor, waking them all up. Between the
- 20:51hours of midnight and three am, no one had seen Martha or had any
- 20:55clue for Dorothy as to where she might be. At three fifty fifteen,
- 21:00Dorothy woke John up, her son, and asked him to go once again
- 21:04searching for his sister. Kind of yes, he's like, damit, damn
- 21:08it, you know, it's three o'clock in the morning. But he was
- 21:11really concerned now, yeah, because he's like, Martha should be home,
- 21:15right. So when he returned with no information about Martha, Dorothy called and
- 21:21reported her missing to the Greenwich Police Department. And it was about three forty
- 21:25eight a m. Where was he looking for her? I'm thinking he drove
- 21:29around the neighborhood. He wouldn't aaturally look in their yard. I don't think
- 21:33I don't think he got out of his truck. That's what That's what I'm
- 21:37kind of picturing. Yeah, Like I don't know how big the neighborhood is,
- 21:40but I picture like big homes with huge yards, right, huge yards,
- 21:45And so he's looking around because he's probably thinking, you know, like
- 21:48maybe she's passed out, you know, like that drunk kid, and you
- 21:52know, maybe that happened, or maybe she's sitting somewhere, who knows.
- 21:56Right. When the police arrived, Dorothy answered their questions and told them she
- 22:02had no reason to suspect that Martha had run away. Yeah, that's just
- 22:06ridiculous because it's a popular that was a popular thing for the police to say
- 22:10about when teenagers went missing. She went in and helped the officers search the
- 22:15main house as well as a small cottage that was behind the main house.
- 22:18Oh that's nice. Yeah, neither saw anything to hint at you know,
- 22:23what may have happened to Martha. I'm guessing they didn't come upon that pool
- 22:27of blood yet, or maybe it was too dark, who knows. Two
- 22:32Greenwich police cars drove around the neighborhood, shining lights around the homes, hoping
- 22:37to see her walking around the streets or in somebody's yard. Just after six
- 22:41thirty am on October thirty first, an officer called Dorothy to see if there'd
- 22:47been any sign of Martha, like maybe she should be home, right,
- 22:49But Dorothy told him, nope, she's still not home. I'd be freaking.
- 22:55Oh, I would be too. I had a horrible dream last night
- 22:57that just reminded me that my daughter went missing. It was like it was
- 23:00a nightmare, like I really shouldn't. But at some point in those early
- 23:07morning hours, Dorothy fell asleep in the window seat of the library of their
- 23:11mansion by the phone, waiting for news. She woke up around ten am,
- 23:18and she still saw no sign of Martha. She walked out the front
- 23:21door, down the drive right, sorry, down the driveway, and right
- 23:26to the scagle's back sun porch, and she knocked on the door. Michael
- 23:30answered, looking pale, hungover and exhausted. Was he the passed out one?
- 23:36I don't know if he was passed out. There probably was a lot
- 23:38of kids that got drunk. She asked him if he had seen Martha or
- 23:44if he knew where she could be. He said no. Looking around,
- 23:48Dorothy saw a camper on the property. Knowing Martha liked beer. I mean,
- 23:56she thought maybe her daughter had too much to drink and she passed out
- 23:59in the camper rather than either come home drunk or pass out in the yard.
- 24:03Maybe, So after asking the gardener to unlock it, they checked to
- 24:07find there was no sign of her daughter there either. Disappointed, Dorothy went
- 24:11home to call her husband David, to tell him, you know, police
- 24:17come home because Martha's missing. And when her body was found at and the
- 24:22reporters began to gather at his house. A friend also called David to and
- 24:27left him a message and what time was her body found? Again? It
- 24:30was in the morning, so it's it's a late morning. Then, yeah,
- 24:34it was late morning. I don't think it was in the afternoon.
- 24:38So David called from the airport to let Dorothy he know, he's on his
- 24:44way home. The investigation into Martha's murder began just after noon on October thirty
- 24:51first, nineteen seventy five. The police first examined the murder weapon. They
- 24:56noted that a six iron golf club was that the that the golf club.
- 25:00It was a rare Tony Panna model. I know nothing about golf either.
- 25:06We just go with it. It sounds expensive because it's rare. Right.
- 25:10During the search, police found a set of Tony Pana clubs in this Scahle's
- 25:15garage that happened to be missing a six iron coincidence, right, I think
- 25:21not. When asked, they stated that those clubs had belonged to Russian's late
- 25:25wife. Upon learning that, coupled with the fact that Thomas was the last
- 25:30known person to sign Martha alive, it moved Thomas to the top top of
- 25:36the suspect list, and the police went and knocked on the Scall's door.
- 25:41Julie, the second oldest of the children and the only daughter, answered the
- 25:45door. When he asked, she told police that ken Lyttleton the live in
- 25:48tutor. They live in tutor, live in tutor, live in tutor and
- 25:53a gardener and you know, gardener and what else? How much tutoring can
- 25:59you do because they're seven? Yeah, that could be a full time job.
- 26:03Yeah, there's seven kids, that's true, right, but really we'll
- 26:07live in Wow. So she told police that the tutor, ken he had
- 26:11taken Julie and her brothers to the bell Haven Club for dinner and they got
- 26:15home about nine October thirtieth. In fact, was Ken's first night on his
- 26:21job with the scicles. Ken was twenty three years old and a recent Williams
- 26:26College graduate. He'd been hired by the Brunswick School where the Scale boys were
- 26:33attending. Oh yeah, the private school. Yeah, and he taught science
- 26:37and coaching. Ken's employment at their school is more likely than not where Rushton
- 26:44met him, and his popularity with the students at the school is one of
- 26:47the reasons why he was hired for this in house tutoring position. Rushton thought
- 26:52that having a man in the house when he was gone on long trips couldn't
- 26:56hurt either, you know, an attempt to keep the kids in line.
- 27:00The police next interviewed Michael. He said that Martha, Helen and Jeff had
- 27:04come to their house around nine ten. They listened to music in the car,
- 27:10and Thomas had come out to join them. He told them he had
- 27:12gone with his brother to his cousin's house at nine thirty that was to watch
- 27:18Mighty Python, and he didn't return home until about eleven twenty. Believing the
- 27:22murder took place around ten pm. The police determined they weren't interested in Michael
- 27:26Michael as a sason right and she was last seen with Thomas right, but
- 27:32when Thomas arrived home on October thirty first, around five thirty pm, detectives
- 27:37were eager to talk to him. During his interview with police, Thomas told
- 27:41them he went to the car to get a cassette around nine point fifteen,
- 27:45and after the group left to go to Thomas's cousin's house, he stood and
- 27:51spoke to Martha for a few minutes in his yard before going into the house
- 27:53to study. Around nine thirty. He watched Martha walk out of the driveway
- 27:59toward her backyard on November three, so a few days later, detectives asked
- 28:06Rushton if Thomas would take a polygraph, and both the teen and his father
- 28:11agreed. After the after three tests, the results were inconclusive all three.
- 28:18All three. The seventeen year old hadn't been sleeping and was obviously anxious about
- 28:22the polygraph being aspect right, Andy Newmartha, that's all got a right and
- 28:32it was a violent death right by his house. Yeah. On November ninth,
- 28:37they decided to try again, and this time he passed. Although he
- 28:41was clearly a suspect for the police, the people of Greenwich didn't agree,
- 28:45including the police chief, who stated that such things were a quote irresponsible and
- 28:49groundless rumors end quote. The Scaygold family had cooperated with the police at every
- 28:56turn. The Greenwich detectives never had to file for a search warrant because Russion
- 29:02allowed them to examine whatever they asked. And he had even given police keys
- 29:07to search his ski lodge without him being present ski lodge. And I'm not
- 29:11sure how far away the ski lodge is, but like a room in the
- 29:14ski lodge or the whole whole ski lodge, I'm guessing it can't be that
- 29:18far because I mean, there's snow in Connecticut, in New England, right,
- 29:23I don't know. November fourth, nineteen seventy five, it was a
- 29:27Tuesday. That was the day of Martha's funeral. The first Lutheran Church was
- 29:33standing room only because over five hundred people attended the service. When it was
- 29:38over, the people who attended it had to walk by cameras, photographers,
- 29:45reporters. I mean, it was just swarmed outside closed casket. I don't
- 29:49know. I bet it was, I hope. I don't know. Marl
- 29:52for Martha fifteen, I know detectives watched from the sidewalk, observing people as
- 29:59they exited the church looking for clues and any behavior of the mourners. Dorothy
- 30:03was one of the last to leave, and she noticed Thomas Skeakell sitting alone
- 30:07and looking sad. Michael was close by, talking to his friends and brothers.
- 30:14Like many others in the community Belle Haven, you know, she didn't
- 30:19believe that anyone in bell Haven could have done this, could have done it,
- 30:23especially not young boys, right like, she was convinced that it had
- 30:26to be an outsider. She approached Thomas and gave him a hug, And
- 30:32she didn't know at that point that he was a suspect. Oh, she
- 30:33didn't even know that. No, she didn't know that. By December eleventh,
- 30:38nineteen seventy five, the case had begun to go stale. Police began
- 30:42pulling people in to reinterview them, including Helen Ix and Jeffrey Byrne. At
- 30:48this point, Helen and jeff told investigators about how they had seen Thomas and
- 30:53Martha flirting and kissing at the back door of the Scagele home around nine point
- 30:57thirty. The detective developed a new theory as to what happened. They this
- 31:03is what they thought Thomas was making sexual advances at Martha, and she said
- 31:11no, leading Thomas to get so mad that he murdered her. Just two
- 31:15days later, Thomas reported to the detectives for another interview on his own,
- 31:21during which detectives took samples of his hair for testing, and Thomas agreed to
- 31:25this. They had hair samples of yeah. About a month later, detectives
- 31:32asked Rushton for permission to request Thomas's medical and school records, and the authorization
- 31:40was quickly received. Rushian gave it a week later. After that, investigators
- 31:44received a phone call from the council of the Whitby School, another private school
- 31:49some of the Scaygold children went to, and during this conversation regarding the record's
- 31:53request, the lawyer seemed to get agitated, indicating to detectives that he believed
- 32:00an arrest was imminent. So what is the school lawyer doing? I don't
- 32:07know what you know? Right. On January twenty second, nineteen seventy five,
- 32:13Russian appeared at the Greenwich Police Department with a letter for the Chief a
- 32:17Police rescinding his authorization for them oh requesting his son's records. But what are
- 32:22what is the school records? And Montic records, gonna what he's a troubled
- 32:27Like what is he a troublemaker? Like? What is what? I don't
- 32:30know if he is, but like, are they hoping to find that he's
- 32:34a troublemaker at school or maybe threatening other students? I don't know. I
- 32:37can only think they could get that through testimony of rights. Right. Thirty
- 32:43minutes later, an ambulance was dispatched to the x residents. Russian had gotten
- 32:49pains, collapsed and had to take had to be taken to the hospital for
- 32:52treatment. When the detectives Arride arrived at the hospital to talk to him,
- 32:58he informed them and he had hired a criminal attorney for his son, and
- 33:01he rescinded the records authorization for Thomas and on the advice of their attorney,
- 33:07they would no longer be cooperating. Their lawyer would not only represent Thomas,
- 33:13but also the rest of the family and the household staff, the tutor,
- 33:16the maid, the cook, and the gardener. Oh wow, yeah,
- 33:20well I can see. I mean I would hire obviously lawyers. Yeah,
- 33:23I'd hire a lawyer right away. Yeah. I don't even think I would
- 33:27have talked to them. Yeah, I definitely would not have talked to them.
- 33:30Not I think not without a lawyer. It's not without a lawyer.
- 33:34Emmanuel Manny Margolis, who was Russian's council, refused to allow police to interview
- 33:42any of the Scaygow family members, but permitted them to interview the help Ken
- 33:47Lyttleton, the newly hired live in tutor, became their focus. Then,
- 33:52upon being continually interviewed by police in April nineteen seventy six, he retained his
- 33:58own attorney in addition to the services of Russian's lawyer. Littleton cooperated, participating
- 34:06in the interviews, but he refused to sign any statement indicating that circumstances circumstantial
- 34:12evidence pointed at Thomas, well why would he? I mean, so,
- 34:17I think what you're saying is they were trying to lay out what happened that
- 34:22night and he refused to sign it. Right right, right, He's like,
- 34:27I'm staying out of it. Right. Late in nineteen seventy yeah,
- 34:30late in nineteen seventy six, Ken Littleton was still being interviewed by police.
- 34:35So this is almost you know, I mean a year later and he had
- 34:39failed a polygraph when he lied about the fact that he had been arrested earlier
- 34:45that summer. The police decided to dig into what was going on with him,
- 34:50and they noticed that since the murder, he seemed to be on the
- 34:53path of self destruction. He'd become a petty thief who was arrested and hospitalized
- 34:59several times for alcohol problems. The police practically forgot about Thomas and they began
- 35:05to focus on Ken. Despite all the effort and work that was put into
- 35:09the investigation, the police couldn't find a link between Ken and the murder.
- 35:15It seemed that without the help and cooperation of the scicles, they were just
- 35:19out of ideas. Now, weren't their fingerprints on the golf club, you
- 35:22would think, I mean, I don't know. Around the same time,
- 35:28Rushton approached the Maxleys at their home. He was holding a drink in one
- 35:34hand and joked that he just returned home from an AA meeting. Uh huh,
- 35:37that's funny, Yeah, rush Yeah. Rushton told the Maxleys that he
- 35:43wanted to set their minds at ease about Thomas. He disclosed that they had
- 35:46several tests done and they all indicated that Thomas was innocent of their daughter's murder.
- 35:52And I'm thinking, maybe these are the polygraphs, but they were inconclusive.
- 35:57Only one. Yeah, yeah, only one he passed. David Moxley
- 36:00inquired as to whether the police had been informed about the tests that he was
- 36:05speaking about, and Russian said, well, on the advice of my lawyer,
- 36:08they do not, so they don't know about these tests. So it
- 36:12couldn't have been the polygraphs, right, I don't know what other tests are
- 36:15could possibly be they could have done. Yeah, that's true, Russian.
- 36:20I'm sorry. When the Moxley's told the police. When the Moxley's told the
- 36:24police, the Scaygal lawyer handed over the tests, so they you know,
- 36:29they found out about it, and they got the tests once the Moxley's attorney
- 36:34had time to examine them. The Moxley's and their lawyer and the police came
- 36:38out and said that it seemed the tests were satisfactory, that they satisfactorily were
- 36:44done, approved, they were done Thomas's Thomas's innocence, okay, satisfactorily stopping
- 36:53the satisfaction. Yes, thank you. The investigation was again at an impasse.
- 37:00Over the next few years, little movement was made on the case.
- 37:02Unfortunately, Greenwich PD reached out to the Detroit police department. At the time,
- 37:08Detroit was the murder capital of America. We're not trying to brag here,
- 37:14I'm not trying to brag, but we are that we are from the
- 37:16suburbs and Detroit. Yeah, and their detectives were considered among the best in
- 37:21the country, I mean, in the murder capital of the world or America.
- 37:25I mean, you're working on a lot of murders, right, it's
- 37:28still like number two or three. Yeah, and the links like number one,
- 37:31and we're right in between the two. That's nice. Two of their
- 37:36detectives went to Greenwich to assist in the investigation. Detectives from NASA County in
- 37:43New York also flew to Connecticut to help. And although this assistance, you
- 37:47know, they had this assistance of more experienced detectives who could give new insight
- 37:53into the investigation, nothing came of it. In nineteen eighty eight, Vid
- 38:00Moxley, who's Martha's dad, he died of a heart attack. He had
- 38:04been very active in the investigation and now it was left to Dorothy to take
- 38:08up the reins Dorothy felt overwhelmed. Her husband was a successful businessman with connections
- 38:14all over the place, and she had been a homemaker. She began talking,
- 38:19and she lost her daughter, She's lost her husband. She talked to
- 38:23anyone who would listen about the case, and she ended up meeting with journalist
- 38:28Len Levitt. He attempted to do research and realized there was very little in
- 38:32the way of public records about the Martha Moxley investigation. The news publication which
- 38:39is called The Greenwich Time, and len Levitt sued the police department for the
- 38:45release of the police records. Eventually they eventually there were heavily redacted records that
- 38:53were released. I've had them. You get like one line, Yeah,
- 38:57exactly, There is no information. But that was only the first part of
- 39:00this battle. Once he had written a story about Martha's murder and investigation,
- 39:06he couldn't find a single Connecticut newspaper to run it. What I know,
- 39:10right, you think they'd be all over that, h right, you'd think.
- 39:15In spring nineteen ninety one, a man named William Kennedy Smith was arrested
- 39:20and charged with rape in Palm Beach, Florida. I don't know if you
- 39:22remember that one. I remember that one a little bit. The reporters on
- 39:25that case began searching for related stories and they came across the Martha Moxley murder
- 39:31and the connection between Rushed and Skekele and the Kennedy family. When the connection
- 39:37was made, rumors started circulating, calling it another Kennedy cover up, and
- 39:43speculation cattle out there. Yeah, that maybe William had been at the Scape
- 39:49House on the night of Martha's murder. William Kennedy Smith. Wasn't he a
- 39:53very handsome guy? Yeah? I think he was. I feel like I
- 39:57kind of remember, I could be wrong. Because of this publicity. In
- 40:01June nineteen ninety one, both Greenwich Time that newspaper and the Stamford Advocate ran
- 40:07len Levitt's story. Finally, it was the first time there had been a
- 40:13comprehensive news account of the murder, an investigation released to the public, and
- 40:17authorities were all but forced to reopen her case to all that pressure. Yeah,
- 40:22all that pressure. Right, It's now out in the open and people
- 40:25are wondering. A press conference was held on August ninth, nineteen ninety one,
- 40:30and officials announced the formal reinvestigation of the Moxley case, and Dorothy and
- 40:36John were in attendance to announce a fifty thousand dollars reward and the funding of
- 40:40a toll free tip line For the next few years. The renewed interest in
- 40:45the investigation led to movies being made. Yes, this is where I remember,
- 40:50Yeah, like hearings written it was a big deal. Yeah, it
- 40:52was a big deal. And news programs running specials related to the investigation.
- 40:57I'm thinking like twenty twenty dateline, Yeah, and news programs like that.
- 41:02By January twenty first, nineteen ninety four, after all the forensics examination and
- 41:08thorough review of the evidence, the analysis, and the accompanying six inch thick
- 41:15report, even though all this happened nothing, it seems that it didn't go
- 41:20anywhere. By October of that same year, the Greenwich PD had practically given
- 41:24up, and the chief was forced to admit that no arrests or it's were
- 41:29expected. This is what's confusing is it's the Scaleles golf Club. I know,
- 41:35how did someone get the Scalles six iron? I know, I have
- 41:38a huge problem with that part of the garage open, and like, I
- 41:44mean, do you just leave your garage open? I guess if you're in
- 41:45a rich neighborhood to do you're like a crazy killer in a neighborhood. You
- 41:51don't blong and you want to kill somebody, you're just gonna go. You
- 41:55just have to look for something in a garage. I mean, this is
- 42:00all They had to have happened, like within a half an hour, forty
- 42:04five minutes. So yeah, it just happened to be an outsider, right,
- 42:08Yeah, wanting to kill and uses Yeah, goes in someone's garage and
- 42:14steals a golf club. Yeah, I have a huge problem with the golf
- 42:15club. When the official investigation was announced, the Scale family hired Sutton Associates,
- 42:22which was a PI firm, to do their own investigation. Sutton Associates
- 42:27was a firm that included former law enforcement officers, including a fifteen year veteran
- 42:31of the FBI. The mandate from Russian was investigate the Martha Moxley murder from
- 42:37the beginning and see if the evidence pointed to anyone outside of the Scale family.
- 42:44He said, quote, if my kids didn't do it, I want
- 42:45my family's name clearly right. If they did do it, I want to
- 42:50prepare the best possible defense end quote. The investigation took years and cost upward
- 42:55of a million dollars. The Sutton team discovered the evidence against the Scale boys
- 43:01that it was even more damaging than had been previously thought, and the new
- 43:06information would only cause more suspicion. What do you do if you're the dad,
- 43:09I know, and the evidence comes back that your kids could have been
- 43:14involved. I know, it's a hard one. The story Thomas gave to
- 43:17the police regarding the night of the murder was that, remember, he's dodying
- 43:22it. Yeah, he saw Martha at the back door of his home around
- 43:25nine thirty and then he went inside to work on this assignment about Abraham Lincoln.
- 43:30Right, the story was already suspicious because Thomas had been drunk and likely
- 43:37also high, but also just from general knowledge, he wasn't a very good
- 43:40student, and it's hard to do a good job when you're drunken. Yet,
- 43:45and like I said, been to college. It was the beginning of
- 43:46a three day weekend. In addition to all those factors, neither his teachers
- 43:52at a school, nor ken Lyttleton, the living tutor, had given such
- 43:55an assignment. Oh what he's doing it for shits and giggles. Yeah,
- 44:00he's just making that up, right, he could have made up something else.
- 44:02He could have I make up something like that's totally non existing. Yeah.
- 44:08The story Tomas told during the Sutton interviews, so this is now years
- 44:13and years later, was that instead of going inside to do homework, he
- 44:16and Martha kissed and mutually masturbated each other to orgasm. Oh, in an
- 44:22encounter in this Scaco backyard that lasted about twenty minutes or when they were by
- 44:25the pool. Yeah, I'm not sure if they were by the pool,
- 44:29but they were on the grounds and it was from like nine thirty to nine
- 44:31fifty, putting him with Martha right around the time she believed to have been
- 44:36killed. Right. Michael also changed his story. He continued to claim that
- 44:40he had been at his cousin's house, returning home about eleven thirty, But
- 44:45after returning home, he said that he walked around peeping in windows until he
- 44:49came to the Moxley home working in windows, Yeah, where he climbed a
- 44:52tree and began throwing pebbles at the window he believed belonged to Martha's bedroom.
- 44:59When Martha didn't come to the window, he climbed down from the tree and
- 45:01went to the sideyard. The attack had occurred in the side yard by the
- 45:07time he said he got home. He'd been outside from eleven forty to twelve
- 45:12thirty am. When Len Levitt heard about the change in their stories, he
- 45:16took it to his newspaper. When Sutton Associates took the revelations to the Scago
- 45:22family, they told the firm not to complete the investigation. We're the report.
- 45:27We're done now, Yeah, We're done now. The case stalled for
- 45:30years. In nineteen ninety eight, the book Murder in Greenwich was written by
- 45:35author Mark Furman the Markman Mark Furman from the oj Trials it was published.
- 45:42The book pointed out numerous mistakes, oversights, and flat out lies, stating
- 45:47from when the police the first police officers arrived at the Moxleys until and until
- 45:53after Sheila found Martha's body. I think when his book came out, it
- 45:57really hipped off, yeah, more publicity than he was already out there,
- 46:02right, because I remembered that book, Yeah, I mean, yeah,
- 46:06you remember it because it was Mark Furman, right. Yeah. In the
- 46:09book, it stated that officer Jones went inside to use the phone to contact
- 46:14the department to avoid the media from hearing about the violent death. It said
- 46:19also that Officer Hickman was left to ensure no evidence was lost. In interviews
- 46:24in nineteen ninety seven, both Hickman and Jones said that's not what happened.
- 46:30After Jones had left to use the phone, Hickman, in a panic,
- 46:32ran to the car to make calls over the radio for more officers and a
- 46:37medical examiner, which explains why John arrived home. That when he arrived home
- 46:42after football practice, he couldn't even make it up the driveway because there was
- 46:45just tons of you know, personnel air. When Jones returned to the body
- 46:51from calling the department, Hickman was standing next to Martha's body, petting a
- 46:54dog who was licking up the trail of blood. What in the leaves and
- 46:59grass? Fuck? Is that literally eating evidence? It's understood that before a
- 47:06body has moved, much evidence, as much evidence as possible should be collected.
- 47:09Yeah, of course and recorded pictures, notes, measurements, write all
- 47:15this hyeah yeah yeah yah. Of course. Between the time Martha's body was
- 47:20discovered in two PM, at least twelve people had touched the remains and a
- 47:23dog and a dog, and she'd been moved a minimum of three times.
- 47:30Why who knows? I mean, they have they have no experience. But
- 47:34even I know, I know not to touch as I know, I'm not
- 47:37a trained professional, but damn. The number of police that had arrived at
- 47:42the Moxley property when her body was found was noted by John when he pulled
- 47:45up to the house that afternoon. He said, it would have been a
- 47:49great day to be out robbing houses because all the police were basically at his
- 47:52house. But that's a good thing, though, Yeah, it is a
- 47:55good thing writing. But everybody was there and they were just fucking up the
- 48:00crime scene. Afterward, it was noticed that all the police were mulling around
- 48:05in the driveway where the initial attack seemed to have taken place. The civilians
- 48:12that had shown up when the excitement started were trampling all over the trail of
- 48:15blood, where it was discovered the killer had dragged her body from the driveway
- 48:20to under the pine tree. When a perimeter was finally established, the Greenwich
- 48:24Police attempted to line it out with Manila folders because they did not have any
- 48:30crime scene tape. I don't know what to say. Yeah. The detectives
- 48:35that had arrived at the Moxleys, instead of investigating the crime scene and gathering
- 48:38evidence on arrival, went to canvas the neighborhood as the evidence was deteriorating or
- 48:45even being blown away in the wind. The Greenwich Police had requested help from
- 48:49the Connecticut State Police Mobile Crime Lab, and they arrived at nearly five pm,
- 48:54making it nearly dark because it's fall and it gets dark early. When
- 48:59the vampulled up to the Moxley house, they drove almost on top of the
- 49:02site of the original attack. After they arrived, within a half an hour,
- 49:07Martha's body was removed from the scene. She sudden laying out there for
- 49:12twenty hours, yeah almost. Greenwich PD had requested the State Medical Examiner to
- 49:19come and remove the body, but when there wasn't any response from the office,
- 49:23Martha's body was picked up by a local funeral home and the mobile crime
- 49:28lab had completed whatever they had done by five point thirty pm. No medical
- 49:31examiner had observed the rigor mortis of Martha's body or the lividity, so it
- 49:37was unclear how the police determined Martha's time lef and she died. Yeah.
- 49:43During the review of the autopsy, had been found that Martha had blood in
- 49:45her lungs, indicating that when the killer stabbed her through the neck, she
- 49:49had still been alive and breathing. There had been a wound on the left
- 49:52side of her head that looked like the shaft of a golf club. The
- 49:58police had long assumed the incident in the side of her head was the first
- 50:01strike of the attack, but when the medical examiner had the chance to review
- 50:06the autopsy, they said that it wasn't a wound. There was no bruising,
- 50:09no fracture to the skull in that area. The review determined that Martha
- 50:15had died while lying on the shaft of the golf club for around thirty minutes.
- 50:19So it pressed on her head, yeah, like it made an indentation.
- 50:22Yeah, so she didn't I thought her skull was crushed. Yeah it
- 50:25was, but she's bleeding out, you know, she was hitting the head,
- 50:30but saying that this was like the first blow. Oh okay, gotcha,
- 50:34and it made an indent in her skin and no other moon. When
- 50:37Martha was found she was face down under the tree, not lying on her
- 50:42left side on a golf club though, so she'd been moved. Who knows
- 50:45right or is this all bullshit? I don't know. There became little doubt
- 50:51that the killer had bludgeoned her she'd moved, yeah, right, left her
- 50:53for dead and returned later to hide the body. I don't know how they
- 50:58determined that, but right when he returned and Martha was still alive, he
- 51:02then stabbed her in the neck with the golf the killer. Additionally, on
- 51:07examination of the report of her stomach contents, an unrelated medical examiner was able
- 51:14to estimate that the time of Martha's death was between nine thirty PM and one
- 51:19thirty am. Oh, it's a huge window four hours. Yeah. In
- 51:22June nineteen ninety eight, Judge jor And Thim was appointed as a one man
- 51:28grand jury, which was a rare practice and it's something that a prosecutor can
- 51:34request when other investigative procedures have failed. Between nineteen eighty five and nineteen ninety
- 51:40seven, there had only been seven grand jury investigations in all of Connecticut.
- 51:46Judge Thim spent a year and a half reviewing the evidence, interviewing witnesses,
- 51:52and studying transcripts. In September nineteen ninety eight, it was reported that the
- 51:58director of a school for troubled youth where Michael had attended as a teenager in
- 52:01nineteen seventy eight, was refusing to testify before the judge. Joseph Ritchie opened
- 52:07Alan's School in nineteen seventy to serve primarily as a drug rehabilitation center. The
- 52:13school used a controversial method of treatment based on the synonym philosophy, using confrontation
- 52:20and attack therapy but yeahs like shouting and humiliation as tools that were supposed to
- 52:27force the person to face their problems. In nineteen seventy eight, Michael had
- 52:30been arrested for drunk driving and rushed and son his son away wearing the handcuffs
- 52:35he'd been arrested in. At the time, the tuition for the Eland School
- 52:38treatment program was around thirty thousand dollars a year. Sounds horrible, I know.
- 52:44And during his stay at Alan, students would testify at Michael's trial that
- 52:47they had seen him throwing thrown into a boxing ring and watched him beaten by
- 52:52fellow students to get him to confess, oh, to get him to confess.
- 52:59Yeah. It was stated by another student that he was forced to wear
- 53:00a sign that read confront me about the murder of Martha Moxley. What the
- 53:05fuck is this ton out? I know? For several weeks and he was
- 53:07the subject of a general meeting where over one hundred students would shout in his
- 53:13face, yelling at him to confess. So do you think his dad thought
- 53:15he did it? Because why would he allow this to all happen? I
- 53:19don't know. Before Joseph would have even been able to testify. He died
- 53:23of lung cancer ahead of the school, and Alan School closed in twenty eleven
- 53:28after the publicity surrounding their therapy practices led to a very sudden drop in enrollment.
- 53:34Yeah, that's horrible. Yeah. The grand jury convened after deciding there
- 53:37was enough evidence to charge Michael Skagel in January two thousand with the murder of
- 53:44Martha Moxley, not Thomas. Yeah, not Thomas, Mike Michael, and
- 53:47he surrendered himself to authorities later that day before being released shortly on a five
- 53:54hundred thousand dollars bail. In March that year, he was arraigned in juvenile
- 54:00court due to the fact that he was fifteen at the time of the murder.
- 54:04I remember that. Yeah. By the end of January two thousand and
- 54:07one, a judge ruled that he should be tried as an adult. The
- 54:10trial began in May two thousand and two and lasted three and a half weeks.
- 54:15And he's gross. Yeah, he's gross. On May ninth, the
- 54:19prosecutor called witness Andrea Renna to the stand. Michael's alibi had always been that
- 54:23he'd gone to his cousins, right to Monty Python. Yeah. And on
- 54:29the stand, Andrea said she'd been at the Scaicole house that night of the
- 54:32murder, and she was positive that she had seen Michael still home after Rushton
- 54:37Junior and John had left to watch the movie. On May seventeenth, two
- 54:43thousand and two, a former classmate of Michael's from a lawn school named John
- 54:46Higgins testified that when they were students, that Michael had confessed one night crying
- 54:52while thinking back on what seemed to be a foggy memory. Higgins also said
- 54:58that Michael had boasted during their stan rehab quote, I'm going to get away
- 55:01with murder. I am Kennedy end quote. Other witnesses called to the stand
- 55:07that had been at the school with Michael said sometimes he became angry and at
- 55:12other times he cried and said he didn't know if he killed her. On
- 55:15June seventh, two thousand and two, The New York Times reported quote.
- 55:20A jury convicted Michael Cieskygeal today of murder in the nineteen seventy five bludgeoning death
- 55:25of Martha Moxley. And I'm sorry he today, they said, after today's
- 55:34verdict after a three and a half week trial in which there was no direct
- 55:37physical evidence. You know, it brought a conclusion to the nearly twenty seven
- 55:43year saga of the Moxley killing, and it was one of the most sensational
- 55:46murder mysteries in the Northeast. Don't they think that he got upset because she
- 55:52rejected him or something? Maybe that could be a possibility. That's what I
- 55:57thought. Maybe, and you know, not remembering it, I mean,
- 56:00I don't know. The jury reached a verdict shortly after starting their fourth day
- 56:05of deliberations on October thirtieth. Scale was given twenty years to life. November
- 56:13twenty fourth, two thousand and three, an appeal on the murder conviction was
- 56:16filed. One of the grounds was the defense attorneys that the defense attorneys were
- 56:22challenging was whether the prosecution inflamed the jury by referring to Michael as quote a
- 56:28spoiled brat end quote. In January two thousand and six the appeal for not
- 56:34I know they rejected filing ridiculous. However, in October twenty thirteen, a
- 56:39Connecticut Superior judge granted Michael a new trial, stating that the defense attorneys in
- 56:46two thousand and two had provided ineffective council. Oh really, and he was
- 56:52allowed freed on bail after over a decade in prison. You know how,
- 56:57and an effective they have to be to actually get that. I don't know,
- 57:00appeel right. In twenty sixteen, his conviction was reinstated and he was
- 57:05returned to prison by May thirtieth. But on May fourth, twenty eighteen,
- 57:10the Connecticut Supreme Court decided to review its twenty sixteen decision on request of the
- 57:15defense, and they reversed the decision, vacating the murder conviction. But yeah,
- 57:22I didn't know that. So January twenty nineteen, after several attempts by
- 57:25the prosecution to revive the conviction, the US Supreme Court denied their efforts and
- 57:32Michael walked free. Ironically on October thirtieth, twenty twenty, the forty fifth
- 57:38anniversary of Martha's murder. That's so he's all free, and it was he
- 57:45exonerated or what was His conviction was overturned, So is that exoneration I guess
- 57:52right, not really, No, that's not generation No, but it was
- 57:55overturned and was an acquitted he just it's just like they didn't press charges against
- 58:01him. Yeah, and they I think because it was like a new trial
- 58:06maybe and then the prosecution decided not to pursue it. Yeah. Maybe,
- 58:09and that's why because he already served a lot of time. Yeah. So
- 58:14I don't know what to think in this case. I can't. I don't
- 58:17think it was an outsider. No, I think it was him him or
- 58:22his brother or both of them. I don't know. So I'm just alleged.
- 58:25I don't know the alleged there. But I mean, he did get
- 58:29convicted, but he had ineffective counsel apparently, so his lawyers did a real
- 58:31shit job. Really. I just can't imagine him having lawyers that did a
- 58:36ship job, I know, because they had to be expensive lawyers, lawyers,
- 58:39and I don't know, lazy lawyers. I don't know. I have
- 58:45no idea what to think. Some minor technicality, but I'd love to hear
- 58:49everybody's thoughts. Well, thank you, you're welcome, and thank you everyone
- 58:52for listening or watching. Before we go, I would just like to remind
- 58:58again everyone to hit likeribe, follow whatever you know the drill. If you
- 59:04would like other episodes like this that are not released to the public, we
- 59:09have a Patreon account. It's patrion p A t R e o N dot
- 59:15com slash t n T Crimes. You can sign up there and we release
- 59:20one new episode a week that is not released to the public. And when
- 59:23we release these public episodes, you get them early and add free. You
- 59:29can also subscribe on the Apple podcast app you get the same episodes that are
- 59:34found on Patreon. We have merchandise like this T shirt. This is my
- 59:38favorite one, I'm Dead Inside. I'm Dead Inside. That's on our website,
- 59:44Crimes Andconsequences dot com, along with other merchandise, other T shirts.
- 59:47There's one that says don't kill each other. So if you would like to
- 59:52support us that way, you may. And I think that's everything. Yeah,
- 59:57thank you for watching. Yeahts go out to the family, you know,
- 1:00:00because what a terrible thing. I mean, it's just so yeah,
- 1:00:05I know, it just seems was justice really served. I don't know until
- 1:00:08our next episode. Don't kill each other, Bye bye