Latest / Newcomer Pod / This Episode Wasn't Sponsored By Techmeme
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome back on Sally. So Tom I was reading technium.
- 0:16I was reading, do, people read Tech me.
- 0:18I was looking at the technique you scan through Page meme.
- 0:21Yeah, do you read technium? But I like reading the internet.
- 0:23Yeah, so I was scanning, take me.
- 0:26And I thought that it was like, I was looking at the three Top
- 0:30articles on Tech name to be introduced the episode.
- 0:32Did you do like, hey, it's Katie.
- 0:34Do we do that? No.
- 0:35Why do we have to do that? I mean, if people listen
- 0:37regularly, they know, we are mean, I don't know, let's do it,
- 0:40just do it, just do it. I'm Katie.
- 0:42I'm Tom, this is dead cat. Welcome.
- 0:45This is an Eric newcomer list episode.
- 0:47He's on vacation, it's Kitty and I holding down the fort.
- 0:51Barely. Yeah barely.
- 0:53It's the two Elder Statesman of the podcast and yet I feel like
- 0:57we get admonished by Eric four times that we almost Our it's
- 1:00just us I mean newcomer yeah so Tom is Holding On by a thread.
- 1:05He needs a vacation, I'm definitely on vacation but I'm
- 1:07working every day so here we are.
- 1:09Yeah. And I was scanning the top of
- 1:12tech meme like you do. I don't think you read it, you
- 1:15just scan it. And again, notice that top three
- 1:17articles one, the first number one article is about
- 1:20self-driving cars. The number two is about Poober
- 1:23and the number three is about a Down Round.
- 1:27So I like this because It's so similar to when I was covering
- 1:31Tech, I felt right Aronson. Exactly.
- 1:34It's very 2017 and so I like the familiarity but clearly it seems
- 1:39to me just from scanning technique the arguably, the most
- 1:43important website, in fact that the text seems somewhat to be in
- 1:49a rut. So Tom as somebody who's
- 1:51covering this day to day, why is this happening?
- 1:54It's very strange, it's very strange.
- 1:57I think, first of all, we have to say, any sort of News cycle
- 2:00has to be caveat it with the fact that it is.
- 2:02So, it's July, it's July, no one really wants to work.
- 2:06I know this on a daily basis and yet we do.
- 2:10And so the sort of flow of news gets extremely weird, I think,
- 2:14the analogy, I mean, this is across all, you know, all Beats.
- 2:18I'll sections of the paper. But the analogy to me is always
- 2:21like, remember Network TV during the summer.
- 2:23Used to be just like, just weird shit.
- 2:26Like, you have to seat the shows we get to their season finale,
- 2:28in May, and then Like the next week it'd be like here's a weird
- 2:32ass game show that ever get put on the air except during the
- 2:35summer like here's a bear eating a thousand, hot dogs like
- 2:38Trapper John MD oh yeah. Show that I think was made only
- 2:42to be Runnin Syndicate but by and large weird shit happens
- 2:45during the summer and so the news cycle gets strange and
- 2:49slow. So I do want to say up front
- 2:51that is definitely something to consider, but I think there's
- 2:55something larger at play here. I think we are dealing with part
- 2:59of the Cycle. Writ large, like the multi-year
- 3:02cycle that has reached some sort of a trough, a stasis, a moment
- 3:07of disillusionment and I don't know, just stuck stuck in this.
- 3:11We just feel like we're like the cursor is just sort of spinning
- 3:15and we don't really know if like the program is operating in the
- 3:17background. We keep staring at the cursor
- 3:19being like is something going to load.
- 3:21Is anything is anything going to happen here?
- 3:24And I think the story is that you mention and just generally
- 3:27my experience on the be talking to people.
- 3:29All right. Now we are in a very, very
- 3:32interesting and in my opinion of the like what has it been like
- 3:37eight fucking years that I've been on this beat a a kind of
- 3:40unrecognizable part of the cycle and I see what's happening in
- 3:44the news, it feels like, first of all, there's no Tech, it's no
- 3:47longer fun and they're definitely no new ideas.
- 3:50I mean, just look at these stories.
- 3:52Self-driving cars, right? Boober down rounds, right?
- 3:55This a is so it's not only our that is the news, the same, the
- 3:59news, Is usually the news of the same, because the activities are
- 4:03the same, right? And so, what's going on with
- 4:07ideas in Tech and then what's going on with money?
- 4:10So like no one's really having any fun and ones, creating any
- 4:13new ideas. And yeah, certainly, there's
- 4:15something going on with the money, the money and maybe,
- 4:17maybe maybe is a good idea to take each one of these stories
- 4:20from by one. I remember, I started covering
- 4:22tack at the information with a mirror of Rowdy, mr.
- 4:27Self-driving car, mr. Zalto, Himself.
- 4:30Yeah, my favorite person that we did work uncomfortably close.
- 4:34He insisted on the standing desk I had a seated desk and I'll
- 4:38just say positionally. It wasn't, it wasn't, it wasn't
- 4:42ideal for not recommended Ocho probably would have a good case
- 4:45against the entire office layout of early days of other really,
- 4:49is really tight. I'll put it that way but um, but
- 4:52I remember when we were talking about this story is the
- 4:54self-driving car. Listen 20, 2014 2015, its
- 4:58self-driving car was going to be upon us. 20:22 wish I think
- 5:02know. For sure if not Belgium
- 5:04self-driving car was here flying car was going to be further
- 5:07away, the self-driving car was Within Reach and so this is not
- 5:12only an article about the self-driving car but about how
- 5:14self-driving car is definitely not happening at least for
- 5:17Apple. Right?
- 5:18And it isn't, it's not happening for Apple.
- 5:20I mean apples willing to spend more time and more money.
- 5:22They will accuse better Parts. They're willing to use like more
- 5:25effective but / more. More expensive technology.
- 5:29It was not happy. Grapple.
- 5:31I would dare posit. It's probably not happening for
- 5:33others. So is this, you know what, what
- 5:36is happening with this story? Definitely, the matically fits
- 5:38with that. So the technium headline, we're
- 5:40really giving our time are time to Tech Meme here, which Eggman
- 5:44is sponsoring this episode. Yeah, thanks Gabe.
- 5:48So yeah, the technium headline, is report.
- 5:50Details apples eight-year. Struggle to build a self-driving
- 5:53car as 20 people who worked on the project site, constant
- 5:55shifting goals and more and then this is a summation.
- 5:59A Relation of a story that was in the information by my former
- 6:03colleague, Wayne ma who is really getting deep into all the
- 6:06kind of failed initiatives inside Apple.
- 6:09These days here earlier had a story about their a, our efforts
- 6:14and why those have also just been completely uninspiring and
- 6:18shitty. So yeah, the story basically is
- 6:21explaining over the years, why they are one of the many
- 6:25companies that have spent billions and billions of dollars
- 6:27on this thing, but just won't do anything.
- 6:29Being close to what it needs to do, in order for it to be ready
- 6:33for you, or me to take it. And I think this is like a
- 6:37perfect explanation encapsulation of where Tech is
- 6:40with its most ambitious and interesting products right now,
- 6:44right? Look, there's no question of
- 6:46self-driving car would actually be transformative, right?
- 6:49I mean, that's actually, first of all, four companies like
- 6:51uber, it would give them like a real business model because they
- 6:54would, they would like, crap, you know, transformative Okay.
- 7:00Can you do well I'll think about transformative.
- 7:02Maybe like patchily, transformative, transformative
- 7:05for some open you. I'm willing to debate that point
- 7:07but at least we got a pretty cool.
- 7:08The idea of like a robot car that would drive around and not
- 7:12kill people, which seems call you problem for at least a.
- 7:16And then the Apple car is detailed in the story to have
- 7:18almost hit a jogger but before a human stopped it from doing
- 7:22that, you know, it's just, it's just not there.
- 7:25I just see them at this stage now where they need something
- 7:29new in Her to consider themselves an Innovative
- 7:32technology company they can probably.
- 7:33I mean you covered Apple Katie's you maybe have some I don't know
- 7:37Distant Memories of this but they could probably like lean on
- 7:40the profits of making everyone buy a new iPhone every 18 months
- 7:44for a while. Yeah, I mean, they're kind of
- 7:45becoming a software company. You have to pay them every month
- 7:48for your data space, you have to pay them every month for your
- 7:51iTunes, or for your Apple music, or for your Apple TV.
- 7:55They're running a subscription software company and I think
- 7:57that's where they're going to get a lot of their growth.
- 7:59But to your point they would like to have a new product.
- 8:03This is not necessarily an iPhone and I wonder at what
- 8:07point they kill the car, you know, that they're just like,
- 8:10what's on this idea? This is a dry.
- 8:12Well, we are, we are, we are pumping a dry well and it would
- 8:15be. Yeah, I know I just like they
- 8:18probably will at some point, right?
- 8:20There's no way that this thing is going to be Street ready for
- 8:24regular people in the next decade or so I just don't and
- 8:27there is always this argument that it will.
- 8:29Inevitably happen, it must happen.
- 8:32And first of all, I don't know that it must happen.
- 8:34Like I think that people human beings can drive cars and they
- 8:37do it pretty well. And the other issue is that when
- 8:42robots drive the cars humans or much warier about the statistics
- 8:45around accidents. So right now obviously there's
- 8:48human error and their car accidents Galore because of
- 8:50human error and we've kind of accepted that but I think that
- 8:53we that there's something about the robots taking over.
- 8:57We don't want there to be accidents where much Forgiving
- 9:00about that, margin of it. Oh yeah, yeah, because the
- 9:03number of people that get hit by humans is unlike unacceptable,
- 9:07really good through the roof right now, like in Washington
- 9:10DC, it's pretty pretty, pretty terrible.
- 9:14Statistically, it's gone up. Thank you pandemic.
- 9:16But at the same time, you know, is it really?
- 9:19An inevitability? Do we need to have self-driving
- 9:22cars? Is that something that must
- 9:24happen? Even if I buy the argument that
- 9:26it will, by the time happens? What else will be going on in
- 9:31the world? What other new technology will
- 9:33have happened? That makes it just feel a little
- 9:35bit less exciting if and that's a very optimistic case too.
- 9:39Because it says that there could be really new big, fresh ideas
- 9:42and Tech. And I don't really see those
- 9:45happening so much and again, like business model wise for a
- 9:50company like uber, which spends, you know, 80% of every fair or
- 9:54so on paying, you know, drivers fucking human beings that Carry
- 10:00out the tasks and work, the, you know, the robo taxi idea is very
- 10:04interesting to them. Like, for them, it is kind of
- 10:06existential debatably existential for Apple.
- 10:09It's not right? It's just a thing.
- 10:11It's just like well we need to be at the Forefront of what we
- 10:14think. Go, new technology is so I guess
- 10:16we have this money that we should spend on cars.
- 10:19What is the new technology? That's the, that's the other
- 10:20question. Like what are we?
- 10:22What are we lacking right now? The technology is going to help
- 10:26us with. I'm not saying that doesn't
- 10:27exist. I can think of numerous things
- 10:29in medicine. Sun' alone.
- 10:31But it seems like BC money over the last few years was really
- 10:35pouring into. How does somebody put this to me
- 10:38the other day? Maybe it was you Tom things that
- 10:41make life marginally better for people with a lot of money.
- 10:43Oh, I think that was me. Yeah, yeah, Bruno Kirby.
- 10:49And When Harry Met Sally, I was waiting to hear if it's out of
- 10:52those parts where I took credit for it.
- 10:54I wrote that line, it pleases me.
- 10:56Yeah. But I think AR is a better
- 10:59example. Of something that Apple really,
- 11:02really wants to have happen because that, you know, that
- 11:04does sound like a new platform G.
- 11:06That is like, a new way to experience the world, which is
- 11:08what Apple's always trying to claim their Tech can do, right?
- 11:12And I think it sucks. I think everything that these
- 11:15companies have been investing in for the time being right now.
- 11:19It's really shitty. It's nowhere.
- 11:21Close to the promise and actually this this information
- 11:24story. I thought had a great line in
- 11:26it. I hadn't heard before but they
- 11:28were because they what they've managed to do.
- 11:29What? Apple has managed to do is train
- 11:32some of their self driving cars to perform really well in closed
- 11:35circuits that can go on fixed routes.
- 11:38So it's not right dealing with, like, real-time human activity.
- 11:42But you can kind of get it on a course to do stuff, which is
- 11:44what you need in a self-driving car.
- 11:46Yell time human activity. Yeah.
- 11:48And and the term he used was demo where?
- 11:50Yes, yes. I said.
- 11:51I love that. Yeah.
- 11:52And that's, that's what it is, right?
- 11:54I mean, and that's what they are is and I, you know, I've bitched
- 11:56about this constantly on the show that like, these companies.
- 11:59Really good at getting groups of reporters to go down to their
- 12:03offices and give them demos of these products.
- 12:06That at the time, they right, where the glowing reviews about
- 12:09and then nothing ever comes of it because it can't do anything
- 12:11outside of the presentation that they gave to credulous reporters
- 12:16in the moment that they gave it to them.
- 12:17I think also, the problem is, is that, you know, you could argue
- 12:20that a lot of the technology especially around on demand and
- 12:24other, you know, especially right on demand, like, uber are
- 12:27things that made life better. It made you feel like you
- 12:30enjoyed existing in the world more.
- 12:32You could even say that if some social media you went out to go
- 12:35on Hikes and to go to weddings you could share these pictures,
- 12:37etc, etc. But it's I think it's hard to
- 12:40make the argument that for most people, particularly those with
- 12:42a disposable income that technology companies want to
- 12:45Target that living in a are is better than living in real life,
- 12:50right? And so, even if it was the most
- 12:52amazing, a our upper, if all it did was make you feel like you
- 12:55were doing the thing you could do, if you walk out your door
- 12:58and people are like, oh but you could go to the loo.
- 12:59When you could never do that in real life, I'm sorry about the
- 13:02audience of people that companies actually want to
- 13:04Target, who have disposable income.
- 13:06They probably could get to an art museum, right?
- 13:08So if they really wanted to, and I probably would enjoy it a
- 13:11little bit more in person because then you can go to the
- 13:13cafeteria after and get an ice cream and talk about thing.
- 13:15You just saw and I and I think that that is one of the big
- 13:19problems that they are. It's just not going to make it
- 13:22even if it is. So so good.
- 13:24It won't be better than real life.
- 13:26And so it feels like yes, a new platform but Bit of a waste of
- 13:30time, right? Right.
- 13:32I thought you actually was, yeah, let me quote, you back to
- 13:35UK it earlier episode owning a sick show ya, what are you gonna
- 13:40do? Who would have thought that
- 13:41Eric's? Not here, it gets even more
- 13:43self-congratulatory. So I think you were talking
- 13:47about how, like, you know, the people that are spending
- 13:50millions and billions of dollars creating the metaverse, which,
- 13:53by the way, that's not a thing. We've talked about, in a couple
- 13:55months, I don't have another metaverse now.
- 13:57It's really pitch in the butter verse, not a Of a tech meme.
- 14:01I think, you know, these are rich people that are spending
- 14:04their money going on ski trips in.
- 14:06You know, what I can tell is skiing.
- 14:09Yeah, look out there in Vail, they're in the Alps, or what's
- 14:12left of the snow in the Alps. I mean, they're not spending
- 14:15time in the metaverse pretending that it's fun to like virtually
- 14:18enjoy a concert. They're getting like backstage
- 14:21passes to the concert. Yeah.
- 14:22And so there is definitely a mismatch between what, you know,
- 14:25the people at the top of the business World.
- 14:27Think the rest of us losers will enjoy.
- 14:29Oi and what they're doing and what they claim is going to be
- 14:32the future. When, in fact, it's not a future
- 14:34that they seem all that particularly interested in
- 14:37participating and whatsoever. So then the other one on the
- 14:41list you want to move on down to, I think we have to address
- 14:43this like uber story thing. Yeah, over files.
- 14:46I don't think. I really don't want to belabor
- 14:48it for a variety of reasons, including the fact that I don't
- 14:52have time to read the entirety of it.
- 14:54You have it all under 25,000 doctor but I did, I did notice
- 14:58that a lot of the Things that I'm seeing these stories.
- 15:02I feel like I've somewhat read right before, right?
- 15:07And that the that no, no. I mean, you can argue that some
- 15:11of these things have been reported before and they're not
- 15:13necessarily knew you could argue that doesn't matter because
- 15:15having the documents to stand them up as important, putting
- 15:17that debate aside. What you're looking at is a
- 15:20company that was growing really fast and was really interesting
- 15:25several years ago and you're looking at the things that
- 15:27happened when it was growing really fast was really Ting.
- 15:30Several years ago, which says, to me that like, uber is not
- 15:33really as interesting today and that sort of that cohort of
- 15:37companies, it makes me wonder, are they have they all kind of
- 15:42topped out and nothing is really replacing.
- 15:44If what we're doing is reading about, you know, the sort of
- 15:48mascot of the era of Mac. But just, you know, what was
- 15:52happening? Five years ago, right?
- 15:55Right. It's like it as the new cycle is
- 15:57slow and both because of the season.
- 15:59Just like where we are and like the broader Tech cycle.
- 16:03It's like they're the universe is trying to like pull out
- 16:05Greatest Hits from the time where Tech was more interesting.
- 16:09So it's like, all right self-driving is this anything
- 16:11for you? Ok.
- 16:12No. OK, how about Uber Scandal?
- 16:15There's a candle is so hot in 2017.
- 16:18It's like, oh, is there a new Uber Scandal?
- 16:20No. Yeah.
- 16:21It's the old Libra scandals. You're like, oh yeah, you be the
- 16:25stories that every news Outlet was writing about endlessly in
- 16:282017 there like Like yeah, it's those like even the same cast of
- 16:32characters. Yeah it's like what you know
- 16:34what is Travis doing these days? Well he's gotta you know it's
- 16:36really not a PR person and defending himself it's like,
- 16:39okay. Because remember that terrifying
- 16:42with the law. So let's go back to when he
- 16:44wasn't, that was pretty cool. Yeah.
- 16:46I will say, I don't want to spend too much time on Uber
- 16:49specifically because we are going to have an episode about
- 16:52it. And several weeks and newcomer,
- 16:53whatever we do Eric is going to be really upset.
- 16:56Yeah, yeah, he did allow us to talk about it, but I think we're
- 16:59going to Only a limited fashion. Yeah.
- 17:02So without going into too many of the specifics of it, I will
- 17:06say again, I think it's funny that these stories do not seem
- 17:09like they have caught the World by storm.
- 17:12I mean, I don't know, I mean like, they've been in all these
- 17:15newsletters there at the top of tech beam.
- 17:17Like, I don't know what catching the World by storm.
- 17:20It's hard, it's hard. If you do such extreme things.
- 17:23Now bring a sack a major government building.
- 17:25Gonna do a lot of things. It's really cat.
- 17:27Yeah, it's like capturing people's attentions for
- 17:29difficulties. Yeah, yeah yeah.
- 17:30And you know I'm like I see right now, as we record this
- 17:33like on the Washington Post, it's the front of this.
- 17:35You know, it's the top of the top news story, they have that
- 17:37they really blew it out. There's any one of the news
- 17:39outlets that worked with the international Consortium of
- 17:43investigative journalists to analyze the documents.
- 17:46And, you know, they're trying to make a big thing out of it.
- 17:48And they've had a couple of interesting stories or does it.
- 17:52The leakers already? Come forward and stories, like,
- 17:54not even a day old. Like, what don't don't?
- 17:57Don't whistleblowers want, Mystique.
- 17:59Or what happened. I thought that the cycle the way
- 18:02it works, like the rollout work, is that you do the big, couple
- 18:05of stories and you get everyone. So Juiced about your like, who
- 18:08is this person? It's just guy.
- 18:10Who is this, you know? And then on the last day, it's
- 18:12like the big reveal and it's like, oh, it's someone that we
- 18:14don't know, but maybe maybe famous know.
- 18:17Yay. They really speeding up the
- 18:19cycle. It seems like things are going a
- 18:21little too fast, right? Just kind of a tech him in a
- 18:23baby. That's a tech information.
- 18:25Yeah, what if we reveal the leaker on day one and then
- 18:28everyone move Saint addict. I don't know, I don't know what
- 18:31the strategy is there. It seems like it would stick to
- 18:33me. We really don't want to draw
- 18:35this out anymore. We really want people to digest
- 18:37this as soon as possible. Take out all the mystery so they
- 18:40can move on with their lives by Tuesday, so it's Mark McGann.
- 18:44Yeah, barking again, everyone. We are getting closer by the way
- 18:47to. I don't know if you've just
- 18:49discuss this on this show, but like we've collected quite a few
- 18:52whistleblowers over the last few years that I would watch that
- 18:55reality show of like whistleblower house where we
- 18:58just kind of like the World, the original MTV's, Real World, we
- 19:01put them on an apartment together in New York City.
- 19:05We got a West Village townhouse and they start to get real.
- 19:09I don't think it could be in New York because of Snowden so we'd
- 19:12have to do it in Russia. That's really cold Mountain cow
- 19:16real world Moscow. But yeah, you get you get
- 19:19Snowden and you get Francis heylighen, you get Mark began.
- 19:24I think the other like, I don't think that's I mean maybe maybe
- 19:27Snowden and Manning or just from a Different era, maybe it's
- 19:30really just McGann. I'm not to be moved on again.
- 19:35Mark me, guess not your McGann. Francis how again and they can
- 19:41just be on an island together. Somewhere talking crypto, have a
- 19:46baby that we pair it with survivor of the ACT actually
- 19:50hunt their own on thrown him down their own meals.
- 19:53Hmm. Create potable water.
- 19:55Yeah, or like I wonder if they end up just blowing whistle on
- 19:57each other the whole time and let people in.
- 19:59I mean, the producers of like all my misdeeds at the others
- 20:02are doing well, sometimes our reality TV is, right, there's no
- 20:06special to draw movie extreme. He's so good at it.
- 20:09Yeah. Hey, Buffy survivors for sure.
- 20:11I worry people are going to take the wrong message for this that
- 20:14we do not value whistleblowers as report we absolutely value.
- 20:17We do I I genuinely think that they are heroes.
- 20:20I do this is more of a conversation about like whistle
- 20:23blowing and fame I think and if you want to really be the most
- 20:26famous whistleblower, you have to combine it with the popcorn.
- 20:29Culture phenomenon, that is created more Fame for more
- 20:32everyday people, which is reality television, right?
- 20:35I mean dick, one of these people could become president if
- 20:37they're on reality TV. What is this?
- 20:39Is like, you're like, you're like a powerful medium, right?
- 20:42Yeah, I think we've talked on the show about how
- 20:44whistleblowers are and, I mean, again, I don't mean to be
- 20:47cynical about it. Is another version of being an
- 20:49influencer, right? Especially when you're going
- 20:51forward, I made me very uncomfortable.
- 20:54Yeah, yeah. So yeah, I yeah, I get I feel
- 20:59kind of That is were making fun of these people from a celebrity
- 21:02perspective. I do think their access is
- 21:05incredibly heroic not making fun of them.
- 21:07We are making fun of the circle of life that has been created
- 21:10around the active whistle blowing.
- 21:12Yeah, did not examine the life that exists Beyond just the
- 21:14story, right? That, this is really kind of
- 21:16like, isn't it really sort of somewhat of like a 20/20 18
- 21:20post, 2018 phenomenon? You know I mean it was like up
- 21:24until up until that Ukraine will sell blower phenomenon.
- 21:28I don't think people like Blowing, the whistle then jumped
- 21:31in front of the camera, like, I think that's different, right?
- 21:34Well, I mean Snowden is the obvious one.
- 21:36Yeah, she's right. I mean, he and then that was the
- 21:39documentary. Yeah, that was a big reveal and
- 21:42he'd work closely with, you know, Greenwald and Laura
- 21:45poitras. My favorite part of the
- 21:47documentary is when he's hiding under the blankets on this
- 21:49computer. Uh-huh.
- 21:51As I say, that was an incredibly claustrophobic documentary, just
- 21:54imagine all the time that they spent in that hotel room
- 21:56together, knowing that if they ever went downstairs, it could
- 21:59be a A nightmare. I'm still like slightly anxious
- 22:03thinking about all of those cameras and Snowden just sitting
- 22:06in that room together, like waiting for the story to go up,
- 22:09there's a great documentary, that was really in some ways
- 22:11like the high Watermark of so many things.
- 22:15But, without naming names of many, many people, well, no, I
- 22:18don't even think about that. The people involved just, like
- 22:21sort of the high Watermark of like, people trusting
- 22:24journalist, right? People failing like You know be
- 22:29crew feels like that. Led to change like to change in
- 22:33government you know feeling of accountability.
- 22:35You think also the revelations themselves eroded people's trust
- 22:39in government to a point that it just felt like any sort of
- 22:43repair of the system was beyond the scope of tickets.
- 22:46An interesting question thought of it.
- 22:48That way, you know, because I feel we were just at this moment
- 22:51of Maximum like, give us your data, everyone wants to share
- 22:55data, and I've always thought of it as Snowden like you know.
- 23:00So his and the information you shared having sort of this dual
- 23:04consequent until set of consequences.
- 23:06One being okay. There's something wrong with
- 23:08government that needs to be addressed.
- 23:10But the other being a woman, by the way, do you as a consumer
- 23:14just want to like throw your data out, willy-nilly liked it,
- 23:17should there be some seat belt on that?
- 23:18And I think it sort of put the brakes on, tech companies that
- 23:21were really pushing this idea. That's very Mark, Zuckerberg
- 23:23idea that human beings would soon like not really want
- 23:26privacy or care about At all ever ever again.
- 23:30And so I felt like I've always thought about it through that
- 23:32lens. I've never really thought about.
- 23:34It was a sort of like the postmodern project destroying
- 23:36faith and institution. I don't think it'll be enough
- 23:39maybe, but maybe yeah. But maybe that was just sort of,
- 23:42like, one of the one of the knock-on effects, right?
- 23:46And I mean, like when you're pulling back the screen that
- 23:48much and you really see how rotting the system that your
- 23:53whistle blowing on has become, you kind of Wonder, I mean, I
- 23:57think they They come at it from a good place which is like this
- 23:59can be repaired and like, you know, Francis Hogan's her
- 24:03perspective. Supposedly was that she's like
- 24:05so long like Facebook can be fixed.
- 24:07If we get rid of Mark Zuckerberg and he's the problem here and
- 24:11right, you know, whatever that is what it is.
- 24:14But I you know, I think as these people are coming forward and
- 24:18leaking the documents they think like they're improving the place
- 24:21that they worked at or the country they live in or
- 24:23something like that. And it just seems like the
- 24:25effect is mostly been people read the stories.
- 24:27They're right Leo. If I'd buy it and they're like,
- 24:29man, it seems like everything fucking sucks.
- 24:31It sounds like everything's broken, isn't it bad enough?
- 24:35That just the Zeitgeist, right? How much, how much can really be
- 24:38done about that, right? And that's so, like, so the Uber
- 24:43thing maybe to finish that up, like that's kind of, especially
- 24:45when you're leaking documents about a period that is long past
- 24:49for a company who is at a kind of weak point as a business, you
- 24:54know, like they're not really at a position of strength and we
- 24:57knew a lot of the Galatians. It's really hard to know what to
- 25:00make of any of these things. It's like company that many
- 25:02people had already decided, was bad.
- 25:05Is still bad. Or was bad.
- 25:06Was what that, right? Well, that's yeah.
- 25:09Anyway, we should save the Deep. Yeah, we're heading to deep into
- 25:13newcomer territory. We gotta move on to down rounds,
- 25:15which also I mean that's a very newcomer adjacent tooth will
- 25:18have to tread carefully but I don't mind I don't mind.
- 25:21So yeah, that's the other thing on there.
- 25:24His decision to make ticket variation beats you down with a
- 25:27wire hanger. I'm just gonna say I told you so
- 25:30cause of death talking about genres, so fucking sad magic.
- 25:37Yeah. You're talking about karna, the
- 25:40fintech companies pay me in, but please, no Clara.
- 25:45De carne is just a placeholder for any company but can judge Ya
- 25:48Down rounds, are you know, it's definitely.
- 25:50No one's heard of karna. You know, people in.
- 25:54Where is it? Sweden.
- 25:55I think it was like one Sweden's.
- 25:57Or Europe's Most Valuable privately, I think just fin tech
- 26:01company, fin tech company. You know, they raise 100
- 26:05million. It's a Down Round, major major
- 26:09down round. They were at 46 billion June 20
- 26:1221 now down to six point seven billion.
- 26:14I mean, that should pretty sure. Yeah, that's crazy.
- 26:16That's a good one. That's a good one.
- 26:19As like, shocking down rounds, go, I'm going to put them up in
- 26:24in a top-ten single cell, but maybe lost some money on that.
- 26:28Dollar the employees. Don't worry.
- 26:30Yeah. Right.
- 26:31No one important as far as the investors are concerned.
- 26:34But yeah, I don't know. I mean Sequoia which is like the
- 26:40Doomsday prophecies are of the valley put out a presentation, a
- 26:45couple months ago. Basically saying, you know, get
- 26:48ready for the bad times. Again, they love doing that.
- 26:50They're famous for the rmp, good times, presentation of the times
- 26:54got really good. So maybe it was our IP good
- 26:57time. Because we're going to go into
- 26:58great times, right? Exactly yeah, I didn't dot dot
- 27:02dot. They don't read the whole way
- 27:05through the presentation. You guys all get sad slide
- 27:10right? We're about to completely fuck
- 27:12up the San Francisco real estate market descriptive.
- 27:15Rooms going to be pretty good. Yeah.
- 27:17And then you're going to buy a house in Portugal.
- 27:20Yeah, right. All right be good times the
- 27:22great times as we're going to have a Trader Joe's on Market
- 27:24Street. Say goodbye to the good times.
- 27:27Yeah, they are. There are so ripped the think
- 27:30it's good times, but I mean like it's a reality from covering the
- 27:33space, you know, every company has been given that very firm
- 27:37directive that they have to make money, which is sad and sad.
- 27:44Think about that. The initial directive is not to
- 27:45make money. It's to grow different thing,
- 27:48right? So there's always a surprise.
- 27:50I think to the company's when somebody from outside says, okay
- 27:55we take it back. Yeah, just make money.
- 27:58Yeah. And I think maybe that more than
- 28:00anything is what has caused people to, you know, if there is
- 28:03like a lassitude or like moroseness about the tech World
- 28:07these days, I do think like that, the business models have
- 28:10to become rational is really fucking depressing because
- 28:15making money isn't fun. People have been doing that for
- 28:17hundreds of years and they never seem to have fun doing it.
- 28:20Yeah. So this is where I like the
- 28:22dearth of Joy, the dearth of ideas and the dearth of money.
- 28:24All kind of come together in one neat package.
- 28:27Yeah, And we don't know, like, we talked about that with Rick
- 28:30heitzman a couple months back, like, you know, for the VC
- 28:34perspective, they're having, you know, that they've got to tell
- 28:39their companies. Some of you are going to die and
- 28:41we're not going to save you. And that's not very fun.
- 28:44That doesn't sound like a moon shot.
- 28:45No. But it's also like I think the
- 28:48reason why we're not getting the sort of big downturn that
- 28:51Sequoia had predicted and and was warning people about is also
- 28:56the reality that none of these companies not none that still
- 29:00very few of these companies. Even from like the 2015, 2016
- 29:05boom have gone public. And so as long as they're all
- 29:09privately, held the good times end when the private investors
- 29:14won't play ball anymore. And since every company goes out
- 29:16to the market, to raise money at different times.
- 29:18And they do it, privately and quietly, and hopefully secretly.
- 29:21You don't kind of see that money rush out like it did in the late
- 29:2490s, where public shareholders were like weird.
- 29:27Being you and we're putting all of our money into bonds or
- 29:30whatever. And so it creates this like huge
- 29:33public dramatic Rush of funding out of the industry.
- 29:37That looks really terrible. Instead, you just see it in
- 29:39these dribs and drabs on a semi consistent basis, but it doesn't
- 29:43have the same kind of like, terrifying umph.
- 29:46So you can still if you want. I mean you can still delude
- 29:48yourself and say, like the good times are here and I'm going to
- 29:52gamble with them. You could say argue that.
- 29:54That's somewhat. What the crypto.
- 29:55Boom was the post. R.i.p.
- 29:57Good. Times presentation crypto.
- 29:59But you could argue that, maybe that's what it was.
- 30:02But yes. So also, I think that things
- 30:05like these down rounds are kind of symbolic of the fact that
- 30:09these companies did not go public and probably that's a
- 30:13good thing. Yeah, really great.
- 30:15Right liability. Yeah and probably best not to be
- 30:18public in tank. The economy writ large.
- 30:21Yeah I mean when I said that big that big lake collapse that
- 30:25we're all looking for. I don't think we're actually
- 30:27very good. Big collapse that were bracing
- 30:29for, I think would be more accurate, which, which may be to
- 30:32say, way to like the last thing that explains this era and the
- 30:37thing that I am so amazed and amused by that you have followed
- 30:41almost not at all in the really tridents that really tried to
- 30:45avoid up his elom. It's my I'm supposed to be on
- 30:48vacation, I'm working every day. So this is how I am getting a
- 30:52vacation in Tha just by not reading about really cool shit.
- 30:56Yeah, avoiding Eli. On it.
- 30:58Just just that has like really it's the I live in a condo in
- 31:02the world. Do you want me to explain to you
- 31:03what happened? Last please do please do so on
- 31:07Friday. The hammer finally fell.
- 31:10Well actually no. Let me let me back up a little
- 31:12bit on Thursday, the Washington Post.
- 31:13Ran a story saying that Elon was no longer engaging with his
- 31:17financial advisors or something involved at the deal.
- 31:20And the deal was in Jeopardy and he was bringing up the fact that
- 31:23he wasn't getting. This is the story wasn't getting
- 31:25all the data that he felt he needed to prove.
- 31:28Twitter doesn't have a bot, which is such a great argument
- 31:30because it's like, it's like if I said to you Tom I want data on
- 31:35your secret second child and you're like, but I don't have a
- 31:37secret second child and I was like Tom, we're not doing this
- 31:40deal until I get data on your secret.
- 31:42Second child and your secret second wife like but I don't
- 31:47have a secret second wife. Well, this deals over.
- 31:50All right. That's the beauty of this, you
- 31:53know, I love it so much. It goes so many layer.
- 31:56I get you don't want to read about it.
- 31:57It. But, but it goes so many layers,
- 32:01deep. Because if you can recall at the
- 32:03origins of the deal, one of elon's promises and becoming the
- 32:06owner of Twitter is that he was going to fix the bot problem.
- 32:08Absolutely. And so, he's basically just been
- 32:11looking for an out when it was clear, that he overpaid for a
- 32:14company as the market collapsed and Tesla stock collapsed.
- 32:17And I'm assuming he was close to getting margin called on the
- 32:22loans that he was taking out against his Tesla shares.
- 32:25So it was looking like a worse and worse.
- 32:27Deal. Everyone was kind of I don't
- 32:29know wondering how he was going to, How You Gonna wriggle out of
- 32:31this one and then on Friday. Yeah, there's pretty simple.
- 32:36I bet that's what I do. I'm the, I'm the rig a lot of
- 32:38things that guy. You used to think of me as the
- 32:40Innovation guy but now I'm just the wriggle out of shit guy,
- 32:43which is also very cool. We're out of ideas, the out of
- 32:47money, we will get to that, we will get to that.
- 32:50Okay, that is very true. I think that is a perfect
- 32:52encapsulation of our, maybe our country at this point but so I
- 32:57day, he files a letter with her. His lawyers fires a letter with
- 33:01the SEC saying deal's off. I no longer want to be the
- 33:05Twitter owner because because of the Bots is the Bots that are
- 33:14the problem. I really want to make a t-shirt
- 33:16that says, I no longer want to be the Twitter owner.
- 33:19Yeah. If you would do it, he would
- 33:21wear it. Because it's just, I mean,
- 33:23that's all of us, kind of, right?
- 33:24Yeah. Well, I don't want to be the
- 33:25Twitter user, but I'm required to be.
- 33:29Did you read the story about the reporter that says they don't
- 33:31read the news anymore? Oh, it's funny enough.
- 33:35I haven't read that either. So Ilan said, will reload vacuum
- 33:52that made me really happy. Continue sir.
- 33:56Okay, so Elon says he's backing out of the deal a couple hours
- 34:00later. Bret Taylor, who is the chairman
- 34:02of Twitter tweets out. We at Twitter, think you are
- 34:05full of shit, and we will sue you to make sure that the deal
- 34:09goes through all the way citing, there's this one is able to
- 34:12specific performance clause in the contract, which basically
- 34:15means that they can see you in Chancery Court along as a sink.
- 34:18Example of the coarsening of the discourse of don't like it
- 34:21continued. Yeah, no.
- 34:22You don't want Chairman's. Talking about Chancery things.
- 34:25Are things are in a bad place as a company when you're having to
- 34:27like call Mom at the Chancery Court to fix things for you.
- 34:31So anyway so then Elon he thinks he's got a real Ace in the Hole
- 34:35because of this Bots thing. Twitter is going to take him to
- 34:38court. They've lawyer dup.
- 34:39Ilan has got Skadden Arps on his side and Twitter is got I don't
- 34:45remember some other, you know, lock tell Lipton.
- 34:47I think it's real battle of the white-shoe law firms, right?
- 34:51But I guess the question throughout all of this is this
- 34:54really Over long tired episode just keeps dragging on.
- 34:58Is that why are we? And I guess I could talk about
- 35:01this episode, this episode? No continue.
- 35:05Sorry. Yeah.
- 35:06Why are we why do we care about this?
- 35:10Well, whatever it is like, I as an as an emblem, there's nothing
- 35:14better than Twitter. It was this, their Twitter was
- 35:18supposed to World. Peace, was going to flow from at
- 35:21peace in the Middle East specifically.
- 35:23I think there's quite a democracy in China To they
- 35:25constantly being there is going to be payback for the lunatics
- 35:30who murdered you know who murdered half the staff of
- 35:32Charlie hebdo' Twitter was this huge phenomenon.
- 35:35It was a part was going to be part of the state department was
- 35:39like it was just so this was like the most high flying part
- 35:43of the of the tech boom. And like the social media, boom
- 35:46was in so many ways to Twitter and now it's like nobody wants
- 35:50to own it. Not even ship company.
- 35:52Not even this. Don't want stick?
- 35:54No, no, no wants to. I run it, nobody wants to run
- 35:57it, people are going to go to court over who, who has to have
- 36:01it? Yeah.
- 36:01Ring, right. We're going to fight you to not
- 36:04have this yet. It's the most depressing, like
- 36:06family court trial of all time. And then you have Elon Musk, you
- 36:13should probably be like a divorce settlement.
- 36:14We're like Eli. Do you like better?
- 36:16That's the end of my family feud.
- 36:18No, no, no. It should be like a divorce
- 36:20court. They like Elon owns twittering
- 36:22on like weekends and like, every third week of the month
- 36:25Wednesday, it is. Yeah, holidays.
- 36:28It gets like a month. Immuno a month, a year and like
- 36:30one of iman's compounds and then like, you know, Twitter's
- 36:34boredoms at the rest of the time and likely, nah, finds a new
- 36:37husband Twitter, hates being with Ilana.
- 36:39On holidays because it's to fight for attention with all of
- 36:41us actual children. Just like that through an
- 36:44increasingly crowded and unfriendly household, tell.
- 36:48But but other, what else is beautiful?
- 36:49Use of Twitter was drizzles defining, social media, darling
- 36:53of the of the big Tech era, no options left and then you have
- 36:57Ilan who was supposed to be the big Genius of the industry.
- 37:00He was Tony Stark, he was the cool one, he was the person who
- 37:04was just a font of ideas, he's got nothin, except for except
- 37:07for box. Exactly.
- 37:09Robots. Grunts it right?
- 37:11That's all you got. Yeah.
- 37:12This it's it is it is really depressing if you think about
- 37:15it, because I do think, like, a nation's lonely eyes turned up
- 37:19toward Ilan as like The Innovation Factory.
- 37:22You know, like he did the Rockets thing, which I always
- 37:24thought was like 80% overrated, but at least it's a thing, you
- 37:28know, Nick, those are pretty cool rocket.
- 37:30Sounds like, and the electric cars.
- 37:32Yeah. Debatable as to like, its
- 37:34overall environmental impact. But yes, it's new.
- 37:38That's the new thing. Yeah.
- 37:40Yeah I don't know. It all started to feel very
- 37:42rickety to me in terms of what he actually had in store when he
- 37:46was raising the financing for it.
- 37:48And the New York Times and a bunch of other outlets reported
- 37:50like what he was promising for Twitter and it was so realistic.
- 37:55It is like a billion users in three years and in billions in
- 37:59profits and just all the stuff that he had no actual plan for
- 38:03really other than, like, putting Trump back on Twitter and like,
- 38:08you know, I don't know allowing every girl an image ever to you
- 38:13know I mean he had he had not thought it through and we've
- 38:15already let the beheadings flow. Yeah I got is this in some ways?
- 38:19Robert Denney Juniors fault because imagine if Tony Stark
- 38:22you've been played by somebody. Less cool.
- 38:24Right. Less cool.
- 38:26So Tony Stark been played by like the guy from Guardians of
- 38:28the Galaxy. Yeah, thank you, right?
- 38:32Right there. So like a song kind of Christian
- 38:35City. Tony Stark would what Elon Musk?
- 38:39Gotten that kind of residual glow up.
- 38:41I don't think so. No, I don't know.
- 38:43Thought he was like a religious zealot but yeah.
- 38:46Or what? If it were like Paul Giamatti?
- 38:48Who is cooler than Robert Downey jr.
- 38:50But like maybe closer to the actual wow.
- 38:54Yeah, exactly. What if have been Paul Giamatti
- 38:57playing Tony Stark and not like some Paul Giamatti who's gone to
- 39:00the gym and gotten a personal trainer and does a superhero
- 39:02Thing? No.
- 39:04But Paul Giamatti circle like that movie about wine?
- 39:07Yes. Sideways called Giamatti.
- 39:09Thank you sideways. Paul Giamatti plays, Tony Stark.
- 39:12We would not have the Elan problem we have today.
- 39:15All right, just fucking great. Yeah, it it he clearly believes
- 39:22in his social or he's media representation his own
- 39:26celebrity. And the fact that he is
- 39:28constantly being, you know, built up by a legion of hooting
- 39:32sycophants on Twitter who I think.
- 39:35Maybe he now realized 80% of them are Bots.
- 39:39Maybe that's why he's upset. Well, what's also great, is that
- 39:42as Twitter, declines as a platform, his sick offense, will
- 39:46need a new platform in order to get the word out.
- 39:49And they've already decided that mainstream media is not the
- 39:53place for them, so that's not going to happen.
- 39:56Twitter, just feels like somewhat of a Dying platform.
- 39:58True. Social hasn't really gone off
- 40:00the ground yet. Doesn't seem so, we're, where
- 40:03will they go? I don't think they know.
- 40:05I mean, if anything is the special tears of what Absolutely
- 40:10right. Yeah, that would be great.
- 40:12Well, that was like, you know, after the electromagnetic pulse
- 40:14like destroys all technology on Earth and then those who were
- 40:18ready for. Yes, just basically.
- 40:20Paul Giamatti handing out leaflets just bawled told you
- 40:23about. He is the town crier and every
- 40:26it every city around the country that would be great.
- 40:30No, I think, what's what? I find so revelatory about this
- 40:35episode, not this episode, the Twitter episode Is that there is
- 40:44no good outcome here for either party.
- 40:47Nothing good will happen. I mean, Elon will maybe get by
- 40:50having only only to pay like, a couple billion dollars Twitter,
- 40:53which is go on being at sad self as a company, and Ilan has like,
- 40:57such a preview for the Democratic primary continue.
- 40:59Yeah, exactly. There's no good outcome.
- 41:01And everyone is just, you know, disaffected, and we're covering
- 41:05it as the train wreck that it's always been.
- 41:08But also with The realization that there's nothing else there
- 41:12that it, that it, that it, we've descended purely into the
- 41:14spectacle and, you know, entertainment of collapse when
- 41:20the promise of it is so far in the rearview mirror.
- 41:22No one even discussed and because we can't say the thing
- 41:26that is so Apparent from this Fiasco, which is that, you know,
- 41:30we actually can live without social media.
- 41:33We can't we can kind of just live without it right actually
- 41:36that essential. Yeah, and the people that can't
- 41:38live without it or the one. That one at the most and and are
- 41:42willing to pay for it. But apparently not as my basic.
- 41:44I'm saying, Elon can't live without social media and and so
- 41:48he's now stuck, you know getting too close to the thing that he
- 41:51thought he wanted. I think the only positive
- 41:53outcome that I could see with this is that Elon owns it at a
- 41:57lower price. That's the only thing that would
- 41:58be good to me. I still want them to own it.
- 42:01Yeah, I mean I mean obviously you know why I want him to own
- 42:04it so you could be right once I can be right because I said he
- 42:06was going to but two because I think it will hasten.
- 42:09Ian, again, winding of the Twitter experiment.
- 42:12Hmm, some experiments I don't want me around like I would love
- 42:15for the Democratic experiment that we have engaged in for more
- 42:19than 200 years. Here, the United States to
- 42:21continue on. That is my deepest wish.
- 42:23But you know, that the Twitter experiment.
- 42:25Yeah, I think it. I think that's okay.
- 42:26If that one comes to an end. Yeah, it actually might help
- 42:30this, the, the latter experiment.
- 42:32But it's just, yeah, clearly, we can't exist with both.
- 42:36She and, I think we, as a country are having to make the
- 42:38tough decision of What do we want to see persist into the
- 42:42next, you know, decade or Century the American Democratic
- 42:45experience or social media and Twitter?
- 42:49And that's a very that's very binary.
- 42:50We're going to take that one up with Eric.
- 42:52See you? He thinks yeah.
- 42:54After he does a careful check of this episode and edits out any
- 42:57mentions of uber that go too far into newcomer territory, right?
- 43:01So with that, you know, we're will sign off for this episode
- 43:04as the plottings text cycle. Continues onward new Come.
- 43:09We'll be back in a couple weeks. We will dive deep into the Uber
- 43:13files which maybe people remember in a couple weeks maybe
- 43:16they won't. Maybe people have read a couple
- 43:18weeks. Maybe.
- 43:19Yeah. That's right.
- 43:19Take take some time during your vacation to read.
- 43:21The Uber files. Check back in with us and we'll
- 43:24have a lot to say about it but until then, thanks Katie.
- 43:28All right, dog days of summer. Episode part.
- 43:29One is in the can. All right, we did it.
- 43:45Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 43:46Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.