Latest / Live Like a Girl with Dr. Mindy Pelz / Belly Fat or Bloating? A Gut Health Conversation with Dr. Sarah Myhill
Transcript
- [00:00:00:00 - 00:00:01:15] (Gentle Music) [00:00:02:16 - 00:00:47:13] Hey, Dr. Mindy here, and welcome to the Live Like a Girl podcast, where I bring you icons, disruptors, educators, scientists, and doctors that show you what can be possible when you love and celebrate the female body you are blessed to live in. Let's dive in. (Gentle Music) Well, I'm gonna be completely honest with you about something. For years when my YouTube community told me belly fat was their number one thing, their number one health concern that they wanted to understand, there was a part of me that was like, isn't just belly fat, just vanity? [00:00:48:15 - 00:02:36:19] Are we all just standing in front of the mirror then I started to pay attention to what women were actually describing. The bloating that never settles, the reflux, the waistline that keeps growing no matter what they cut from their plate. Women who were doing everything right and still carrying a belly that won't budge. And in my own clinic, the women with the hardest cases, the ones that were the toughest to get their bodies to heal the cases of SIBO, the anxiety, the weight loss that simply wouldn't move. And all of that taught me something. It wasn't always about the fat itself. It was about what was happening underneath it. And so that's the reason I have invited today's guest on to the Live Like a Girl podcast. She said something that I heard in an interview that stopped me in my tracks. If your belly is bigger than your hips, it may not be a fat problem at all. It may be actually a gut problem. Here's what that means. Your gut is a tube about 30 feet long and the first 25 feet of it should be close to sterile. When the upper gut becomes overrun because of constant snacking, a diet heavy in carbohydrates or low stomach acid, food starts fermenting where it shouldn't. The gut lining gets inflamed, the immune system gets busy, and your body stores fat right where all that action is happening. [00:02:38:00 - 00:03:14:12] Dr. Mai Hill, my guest today says a woman's waist should measure about 80 centimeters, roughly 31 inches or less. Past that, it may be a signal worth listening to. So this is why I've brought you Dr. Sarah Mai Hill. Dr. Mai Hill is a British physician with decades of clinical experience. She is a leading voice on mitochondria and energy and she is the author of the infection game. Her website has been visited tens of millions of times. [00:03:15:12 - 00:03:21:02] In this conversation, we talk about how to read your own belly as a clue. [00:03:22:04 - 00:03:57:17] We also dove into menopause and why menopause can unmask a sluggish thyroid. And perhaps my favorite part of the conversation was what a ketogenic diet does for the gut and the brain. And why so many of us are carbohydrate addicts without even really realizing it. So whether you've been told your belly is hormonal or genetic or simply a vanity problem, I think you're going to want to hear a different story. I welcome to the Live Like a Girl podcast, Dr. Sarah Mai Hill. [00:03:59:00 - 00:06:21:06] Well, let me start off Dr. Sarah Mai Hill by just welcoming you to my podcast. I'm super excited to have you here. Very kindly Mindy, thank you for inviting me. I've watched lots of your YouTube videos and I just love them. And I send all my patients in your direction. Thank you, thank you, I appreciate that. You have said something that stopped me in my tracks and is the reason I invited you here, which is when a person's belly is bigger than their hips, it is not a fat problem, it is a gut problem. And so many of the women who watch this channel, listen to my podcast, are really trying to overcome that belly fat. Help us understand that. Okay, well, this is predicated on some lovely work by Dr. Caroline Pond, who asked the question, where do wild animals dump their fat when they have an excess of calories? Which doesn't happen very often, of course, because wild animals and their food is in demand. And at this time, she was working at Milton Keynes University and she was cycling to work on her bike and pick up roadkill. And having picked up roadkill, she would then dissect it and of course, sometimes the ear, more food and sometimes less food. And what she found is that they dumped their fat where the immune system is busy. Now that makes perfect sense because the immune system is like the brain, is enormously demanding of energy and the immune system is responsible for healing and repair. So if you're a wild animal, trotting around, finding food, hunting, being hunted, you're going to damage yourself at some stage, very often arms, front legs, back legs or whatever. And the healing and repair is done by the local lymph nodes. So fat was being dumped at the local lymph nodes for the business of healing repair when that damage occurs. She actually went on to Oxford University where she specialised in fats and rose, and she wrote a lovely book called "The Facts of Life". Oh, that's cute. One of my interests is the upper fermenting gut. So let's start off with what the normal gut is. Now the normal gut is a tube, it starts at the mouth, finishes at the anus, it's about 30 foot long. Now the first 25 foot of that gut should be sterile or near sterile. [00:06:22:08 - 00:06:43:07] The microbiome resides in the last five foot of gut, the colon, and that's where we have pounds, kilograms of bacteria and yeast and viruses that are fermenting away. Now, if we eat a dart that is based on carbohydrates, we overwhelm the ability of the upper gut to remain sterile. [00:06:44:11 - 00:09:16:02] And that's worse if we're snacking all the time, if we're eating constantly and we're eating lots of carbs. And what happens then is those foods start to ferment in the gut instead of being digested. So we should have a sterile gut maintained by stomach acid, which kills all those microbes and the foods to say it's properly digested and properly assimilated. But if the bacteria and the yeast move in, they start to ferment those foods and that causes a whole host of problems. Those microbes make themselves at home, they adhere to the lining of the gut, they get their little grippers in there so that they stick there. And when the right food comes along, they wake up and they're actively fermenting and having a jolly good time. And then when the food is not there, they go into a more quiescent state. Now, we know that those microbes on the lining of the gut make for the gut wall to be slightly inflamed. And when you've got an inflamed gut, you've got a leaky gut. And there is the potential for those microbes to get from the gut into the bloodstream. Now, this is potentially a very dangerous situation because obviously you risk septicemia. So the immune system, so where you've got an upper fermenting gut, the immune system is very busy in the gut. And where the immune system is very busy in the gut, fat will be deposited. So belly fat and peritoneal fat is symptomatic of the upper fermenting gut. So essentially, the female waste should be about 80 centimeters or less. If it's much more than that, then that points to fat being deposited around the gut and you can infer from that that you have an upper fermenting gut. And I think this is a major driver of pathology because it's not just that it stimulates the laying down of belly fat. Those microbes can get into the bloodstream and they can get stuck at distal sites. And if they get stuck in the joints, they drive arthritis. If they get stuck in the muscles, they drive fibromyalgia, in the lungs, intrinsic asthma, in the skin, urtic area, and on we go. The most interesting one, and this is work done by a Japanese research called Nishihara, is if you've got fermenting microbes in the gut, you can have fermenting microbes in the brain. And in the brain, there's potential for them to ferment out neurotransmitters like adrenaline and ordrenaline, dopamine, or whatever into LSD and amphetamine-like substances. And this is the basis for psychosis. [00:09:17:06 - 00:09:25:02] So sorting out the upper fermenting gut is absolutely a starting point. Treats so much pathology. In fact, there's some wonderful doctors, [00:09:26:08 - 00:10:11:19] both of them now deceased sadly, Carl Pfeiffer and Abram Hoffer, who you may have heard of. And in the 1940s and the 50s and the 60s and 70s, they were curing psychosis, they were curing schizophrenia with ketogenic diets and sorting out the upper fermenting gut, and then a few micronutrients for the brain. So we've known for a long time that people who are apple-shaped, instead of being pear-shaped, have a greater risk of disease and pathology. And I think this is all about the upper fermenting gut. And one symptom of that is belly fat. So it's so interesting because belly fat has been the number one topic on my YouTube channel that people wanna know about. And I'll be really transparent. There's a part of me that's like, [00:10:12:23 - 00:12:43:16] is that just a vanity thing? Or I know that a lot of women look in the mirror and they just don't love the way their belly looks. And then is it a hormonal thing? A lot of hormonal experts will say, well, when you go through menopause, all of a sudden the transfer of fat goes to the abdomen. But what you're offering us is twofold. You're offering us the ability to actually look in the mirror and say, is your belly bigger than your hips? And if it is, now we have an opportunity to look at it through a third lens, which then this is an upper fermenting gut issue. Do I have that right? Correct, it's a very powerful symptom of off-fermenting gut. I mean, there are other symptoms as well. So anybody with almost any digestive disturbance, so like reflux, heartburn, nocturnal cough, which is symptomatic of reflux. Again, that's typical of the off-fermenting gut. So let's just move back to what the stomach, how some should work. So the first chamber into which food drops is the stomach. And that should be acid. And when I say acid, it's extremely acid. It can be as much as pH two, which is, if you put your finger in that, you'd probably burn your finger. I mean, it is extremely acid. And that is important for at least three reasons. The first thing is that we need an acid stomach to digest protein, to hydrolyze protein. We need an acid stomach to absorb minerals. And we need an acid stomach to sterilize the upper gut. So I've written another book called "The Infection Game." And the point is that the stomach acid is a major defense against infection. Nearly all pathology has an infectious driver, if not an infectious associate. And 90% of infection comes in through the mouth, either because we eat, we drink water, which is contaminated, or we eat food, which will have bacteria and yeast in it, and all food has some, or because we are inhaling microbes that get stuck onto sticky mucus of the nose or the chest, coughed up and swallowed. So we need a nice acid stomach to keep those microbes at bay. And the way that the body achieves that is obviously the lining of the stomach is aligned with cells that pump acid from the bloodstream into the luma of the stomach. And then we have a plug hole of the stomach. The plug hole is the pyloric sphincter. And the pyloric sphincter is an acid-sensitive muscle. [00:12:44:18 - 00:13:40:15] So when the stomach is empty, it's normally acid and the pyloric sphincter is closed. Now when we eat, of course, that acid is immediately diluted. And so the pH rises, becomes more alkali, and the stomach remains closed. The plug hole remains closed. And it will not open until the certain acidity has been achieved. And that is achieved because the lining of the stomach pumps protons, hydron ions, pumps acid into the luma. The pH drops and in dropping, the food is sterilized, the microbes are killed, the acid moves on, that the minerals are digested, absorbed, the protein is digested. And when that acidity has been achieved, the pyloric sphincter opens up and the food moves into the duodenum, which of course is acidic, and then along come the pancreatic enzymes, the bar salts, and the rest of digestion proceeds. Now, if we have a leaky stomach, [00:13:42:00 - 00:14:11:09] so we cannot achieve the necessary acidity, the plug hole of stomach stays shut, it doesn't open. And then of course, the stomach says, okay, time for food to move on, starts to contract, but it's doing that against the closed plug hole. The food's got nowhere to go. And so it comes back up the esophagus. So then we get the symptoms of heartburn, esophagitis, indigestion, nocturnal, cough, which are all typical of the upper fermenting gut. [00:14:12:10 - 00:14:24:20] So once we understand the mechanism of the upper fermenting gut, that has obvious implications for treatment. And of course, the first thing is stop feeding those little bacteria, sugars and carbohydrates. [00:14:25:23 - 00:15:21:02] Okay, so before we go into the carbohydrate, here's a thought that I'm having as I'm listening to you is snacking. So if the idea is food goes down into the stomach, and then it closes that off, and it's a closed system. And then I eat again, and then I eat again, you are disrupting, it's the actual frequency of food that could be causing this disruption within the gut. I think that would be the first place to start, wouldn't it be? Well, yes, that's, well, I would always start with, the point about bacteria and yeast is they can only ferment carbohydrates. They cannot ferment fat and protein, they can only ferment protein if there's some carbohydrate there as well. So the first priority is to starve the little wretches, stop feeding them sugars and carbohydrates, that's the first thing. [00:15:22:02 - 00:15:52:07] Then yes, the next thing is we want windows of time when the stomach is completely empty, and then it has a chance for normal acidity to be restored, and any microbes that are there can then be killed by stomach acid, and got rid of that way. And that's where the time restricted eating, and the intermittent fasting can be so helpful. But I know many people, especially when people are first getting into this, when they're carbohydrate addicts, as I call it, they find it very difficult to do time restricted eating, because you get very hungry. [00:15:53:11 - 00:17:34:15] One of the joys of starting off with a ketogenic diet is that the body learns to fat burn, and then if the food is not available, or if you do decide to do a fast, then we can burn fat from our subcutaneous, and we don't run out of fuel. Now, you might feel a bit peckish, you might feel, oof, feel like something to eat, but if you ask yourself, is the brain working well? Guess what it's working fine. And is the body working well? Guess what it's working fine. And then the hunger pangs pass. Right, I've said that, yeah. I've said that all the time, give it a moment, it'll go away. So the ketogenic diet really becomes the solution for this, well, I'm gonna call it belly fat, but you call it gut fermentation. Well, it's both. I mean, after venting out is one symptom, belly fat is another symptom. But the cause is hypochlorhydria and microbes where they should not be. They should not be in the upper gut. Yes, in the lower bowel, not in the upper gut. I mean, again, whenever there's, I have a difficult question, you know, what should we eat? Yeah, right. Which foods? I always go back to evolutionary biology. Me too. I'm a great fan. Me too, you can never go wrong if you go back to where we lived, but it's so true. It's the true essence of the human body. Agreed. Absolutely. And I don't know if you are aware of Elaine Morgan's theory, the aquatic ape. But I will do that, run that through it past you quickly. So about 65 million years ago, our nearest relative was the chimpanzee in probably in Central Africa. [00:17:36:03 - 00:19:53:23] And she hypothesizes that there was a window, there was a time when some of those chimpanzees moved into water. Now, Africa was much more like South America then. They had huge lakes and of course a long coastline. And in moving into water, there are some very clear evolutionary changes that happened. The first thing is that we became naked, we lost hair. Hair is an encumbrance in water. So the aquatic mammals like dolphins, seals, whales, they have their hairless because hair would slow you down in water. So we became naked and we kept warm by having subcutaneous fat. So most mammals are hairy and don't have subcutaneous fat, but we do. The other interesting thing is in moving into water, water afforded buoyancy. And so we came up onto two legs. So we became upright. And so our naked ape became an upright naked ape. The other really interesting evolutionary thing is our nose became turned down. So if I go swimming, I can go under water without drowning because the water, this little air trap and air bubbling. It's not constantly pouring in. Correct. Whereas if you put an ape, if you put a chimpanzee underwater, they drown because the water pours in through their nose. So these are very simple evolutionary changes which support her theory. But the most interesting aspect is, is that in moving into water, they would have consumed a diet that was very high in arachidonic acid, DHA and iodine. And those three things are essential for brain development. And as a result, our brains just went whoosh. So the chimpanzee brain was 350 milliliters in size 65 million years ago. And today it's 350 milliliters in size. Hours at one stage, it was 1700 milliliters in size. It's now shrunk a bit. It's now about 14, a 1417, maybe millions. It's a bit smaller. But the point is our brains grew and we became more intelligent. And in coming more intelligent, we cooperated. We were in tribes and we became a very effective hunters. So as the population increased and we moved out of water, first of all, we were on two legs. [00:19:55:08 - 00:21:18:23] That freed up our arms and our hands. And with that intelligence, we could manifest that intelligence through our hands to make tools. And in making tools, we became very effective hunters. And the interesting thing about primitive man is, or man generally is we were persistence hunters. So me on my own, I can't run down a zebra or a mastodon or a bison, but with all my friends I can. Cause we can take it in terms to run and run and run. And because we are naked apes, we sweat, we can lose heat. But the hairy mammals overheat and eventually they come to bay. And once they come to bay, then you're in position with your sticks and your stones and your spears, whatever to kill their animal. And again, the ability to carry the produce, to cut it up with flints and carry it back to the tribe was a great evolutionary asset. So the point here is that humans evolved because we were carnivore, not to become carnivore. And for many of my patients, a carnivore diet is a very good starting place because a carnivore diet is high in meat, is high in fat, and those foods cannot be fermented or they're fermented very slowly. So very often the starting point for somebody who has an upper fermenting gut characterized by all the symptoms we're doing, we talk about and barely fatter, and all that is to do a carnivore diet. Interesting. [00:21:20:07 - 00:23:12:17] You know, in my clinical experience, when I had anybody with SIBO, with anxiety, extreme weight loss resistance, I would always do a five day, what I call carnivore fasting, where we would stimulate autophagy for 17 hours, we'd get that kind of rhythm going, they're not eating. And then when they did eat, they would do the carnivore, just meat only. And what I found was it was the quickest path to not only repairing any gut problem, but it also was the quickest path to weight loss resistance. So I never mapped it to evolutionary biology like you did just now. And I think that's really important to point out. The second thing I wanna point out is the part that you said where the apes went into water and lived off of what was in the water, which is fish. And one of the things that we're seeing on my YouTube channel right now, and we do, we practice different fasts every month, but outside of carnivore fasting, the next most impactful fast that I've seen work for all kinds of weight loss, but especially brain clarity and belly fat is sardine fasting. And now I'm like, both of those have been linked to how we evolved from apes into humans. And nobody ever made that connection for me until right here. Oh, bless you. That was amazing. Bless you, but not just, but all shellfish. I mean, all these fantastic seafoods are rich in, I say, all the things the brain is deficient in. Right. And that's why our brains go whoosh. And even today, I suspect most people are starved of those essential fats. We have another wonderful character in this country called Patrick Holford, who you may have heard of. And he set up a website called Food for the Brain. [00:23:13:21 - 00:23:19:21] It's the largest website in the world. He is currently doing an audit into dementia. [00:23:20:23 - 00:24:25:03] And he has enrolled over a million people onto his website. And he maintains that dementia, which in this country is now the commonest cause of death in women, is 99% preventable with three interventions. The first is a ketogenic diet, because the brain loves to run on ketones. The second is to measure homocysteine, because homocysteine is a major risk factor for dementia, heart disease, and cancer. And the third thing is fish oils. Eat fish. And he recommends three portions a week of oily fish. And the acronym he uses is to smash it, salmon, mackerel, anchovies, sardines, and herrings. That's what we did, by the way. I'm gonna smash fast, because I was like, I know some of you may not want to eat sardines for three days, but you might eat salmon. So I love the smash fish are really, really powerful. Fantastic. Well, it's so good for the brain. And so satisfying for the appetite. And so many of my patients I see, once they're established on carnivore, [00:24:26:08 - 00:25:05:04] they just find that they're just not craving foods anymore. Their brain is restored. They've got more energy and all that. Now, I'm ashamed to say, I don't do a pure carnivore diet, but I'm very meat, fish, eggs heavy. Because I'm a gardener and I've got berries in the garden and green vegetables and salad, I eat those things for the pure joy of eating those lovely foods. And I'm grieving that. Yeah, carnivores are a heart. I think it is, we need to state that. I always tell people, if we're gonna carnivore fast and it's boring, just know that right now, it's so boring. But the beautiful thing is you won't be hungry. You're just gonna be bored and tired of eating meat. [00:25:07:16 - 00:25:09:05] Like, let's just call it what it is. [00:25:11:04 - 00:25:29:07] Well, it depends the author. It depends on the quality of that meat. And I'm very lucky, I keep my own pigs. So I get the most delicious pork fat and bacon and ham and sausage, which is just pure meat. So I don't find it too troublesome being carnivore. [00:25:30:08 - 00:29:57:06] So one thing I'm thinking, because this is how I use carnivore fasting, and now I'm thinking about how do I combine carnivore fasting with smash fish fasting, combine those. This is just what I like to do for my YouTube subscribers. And then we do that, let's say for five days as like a therapeutic dose, dosing. And so we start to starve those microbes. We're using fasting and the fish and the meat. And now, okay, now let's go back to regular food. Is, and adding some things in. So you say you do berries and you do some other vegetables. Is there, are there like a list of like, if you add these in, they'll be okay, but if you add these in, they're not good at all. Okay, well, we can supercharge the carnivore diet because there's two aspects to treating the alphamintin gut. First of all, we starve them, which is what we're doing with the carnivore diet. And the second thing we do is we kill them. And there are three tools that I use to kill microbes in the alphamintin gut. The first is vitamin C. Now, vitamin C is ascorbic acid, that contact kills all microbes. There is no microbes that's resistant to vitamin C. So I like people to take that, well, usually about five grams of vitamin C, just as ascorbic acid and ascorbic acid helps to acidify the upper gut. So that's, it's very cheap and cheerful. So one, five grams, which is about a teaspoon of ascorbic acid on an empty stomach, that contact kills any microbes that might be in the stomach. So powdered, not a tablet? No, not a tablet, just powdered. My second favorite tool is iodine, because iodine contact kills all microbes. We're all iodine deficient. It's also great for the brain. It also helps pull out heavy metals. It's a very good, both of them are good for protecting against cancer. But I use Lugol's iodine 15%, three drops, build up slowly. Don't take it at the same time as vitamin C, because one is a reducing agent, the other's an oxidizing agent. One's an electron donor, the other's an electron receiver. I can never remember which way round it is, but that doesn't matter. So they shouldn't go together because we're trying to change the pH of the gut. Correct, so the point is take them separately. So I usually suggest five grams of vitamin C on rising it dissolves best in warm water. On rising you've got an empty stomach. So you've got maximum concentration of vitamin C that will kill any microbes in the stomach. And then midday two or three drops of Lugol's iodine 15%, and that will contact kill by another mechanism. So that allows it to go faster. And the third ploy that I often use is MSN, methyl sulfonyl methane. And that is an organic form of sulfur. The fact of the matter is we are all sulfur deficient. Not my words, but the words of Stephanie Sennath, who's a great girl, and so wise and fantastic tips. But she points out we're all sulfate deficient. Now the interesting thing about MSN is that in the aerobic environment of the upper gut, it kills microbes, and it's a sulfate. But in the anaerobic environment of the lower gut, it works the prebiotic. It helps to sustain the microbiome. So it's, and MSN is well absorbed. We need it to repair the lining of the gut. It's very good as we speak, I'm doing a study, I've collected 60 patients so far, where I'm using MSN to see which heavy metals it pulls out of the body and are excreased in urine. Now I haven't number crunched all the figures yet, but what's so interesting is it does act as a chelating agent. And one of the-- Are you measuring that? I'm just curious, I did a ton of heavy metal detoxing in my office. Are you measuring that in urine? Yes, yes. So it goes to, so Genova Laboratories do the testing. So I load them up with about 10 grams of MSN and then collect urine for six hours, send off an aliquot, and then they measure-- Just like we did with zeolite and all the other binders. I can't wait to hear what you find out. Correct. So, but there are one or two fantastic, really interesting results. The first thing is, is it pulls out aluminum really well? [00:29:58:06 - 00:33:25:18] Now you may be aware of the work of Professor Chris Exley, who's in this country, who points out that we are all poisoned with aluminum because it's so ubiquitous in the environment. It appears in foods, aluminum foil, aluminum tin cans and all that sort of thing. And he maintains that the only way you can get aluminum out of the body is by using silica water. Well, that's great, but it's very expensive. And guess what? If my patients are sick and they can't work, money is at a premium. So MSN is really cheap, but it pulls that aluminum reliably well. I see big spikes of aluminum coming out. The other really interesting one is, anybody who has radio-pake imaging or-- using gadolinium, gadolinium is really nasty, heavy metal, pulls out gadolinium really well. So anybody who has such, must take MSM afterwards to stop that being toxic. But I've seen high levels of bismuth, barium, tungsten. I mean, where does that come from? You know? So it is very useful as a heavy metal collator. So we did, like I said, a ton of heavy metal detoxing in my clinic and there were three heavy metals I saw on everybody. And we call it aluminum just so everybody does it, your accent just to make sure people are catching that. So I saw aluminum, I saw lead and mercury on every single human that I've ever tested. Yeah, so, and all very, very high levels. And then gladininium we saw, barium we saw after they did diagnostic tests, you would start to see that. And the other thing I'm finding interesting about what you're saying, just to bring this forward to people listening is MSM, we used to use that for joint health, right? Wasn't it packaged with glucosamine and all those supplements? Absolutely. And so it's working the same way I would think. It's the same type of mechanism just on the gut. Correct, well, we have, well, I don't know if, it's working the gut as a collating agent, but it certainly works systemically as a collating agent. And we then we have to ask the mechanism of this because the other interesting thing I've found doing this little study is that when I use other collating agents like DMSA, for example, which is what I usually use, you often get big levels of especially copper, but often manganese, zinc, selenium, it's pulling out the friendly minerals. But MSM doesn't do that. Okay, sometimes the copper's a bit high, but it doesn't pull out the other trace elements, which is very reassuring because that's one of the worries about doing heavy metal chelation. You pull out some of the friendlies. Amazing, okay, let's go back to the ketogenic diet because I have interviewed a lot of people about the ketogenic diet. I have been studying the ketogenic diet for almost 20 years now, watching every evolution of it. I've watched it take hits. I've watched people cure cancer with it. Like for whatever reason, the ketogenic diet seems to be so controversial. And one of the number one complaints, especially for women who are going through menopause and perimenopause is that we, a woman's body needs carbohydrates. Help us unpack that. Okay, I think this has much to do with the thyroid. [00:33:27:13 - 00:34:20:01] And the underactive thyroid is often unmasked at the menopause because female sex hormones give us, as I call it, false energy. And this is one of the reason why some women do feel better taking the pill, do feel better taking HRT. But I don't like those drugs. When it comes to menopause, suddenly the levels of hormone diminish very rapidly. And if our thyroid is not functioning well, then the underactive thyroid will be unmasked. Yeah, they say 50% is like the diagnosis is 50% of women will have a thyroid problem when they go through menopause. And what I hear you saying is it was there, it just all of a sudden revealed itself. Correct, I agree entirely. It's very, very common. The thyroid is particularly susceptible to toxic stress. But the point here is we need thyroid hormones to fat burn. [00:34:21:04 - 00:34:43:19] How do we know that? What happens when somebody's thyroid toxic? They fat burn like mad and the weight just falls off them. So if you haven't got the thyroid hormones to fat burn, then the body can fat burn, but it fat burns with adrenaline. And that's what gives you the wired but tired, feeling terrible. And what I find is incredibly helpful is continuous glucose monitoring. [00:34:44:22 - 00:36:05:10] And you can get kits, you don't have to get to your doctor for this. Oh yeah, there's tons of them. Yeah, correct. And that's incredibly helpful because people say, "Oh, I feel hypoglycemic. "I feel like I need to have some carbohydrates." Look at the blood sugar, it's fine. It's running between four and six. I've watched the ketogenic diet work miracles, like miracles. Absolutely. And it gets so much criticism because there are so many menopause experts and women health experts out there that are saying the female body needs carbohydrates. And what I just heard and what you just said was if you watch your blood sugar, you will know if you need it or not. But I'm really working here to give my people practical information. So where are carbohydrates necessary and where are they not? Okay, well again, whenever there's a difficult question, let's go back to evolutionary biology. How is it that carbohydrates came into our diet because we evolved as carnivores? And we were very successful and as a result, human beings migrated away from the equator to the Mediterranean, to Europe, and ultimately up into Scandinavia and the North. And as they did that, they then had the problem of surviving winter. [00:36:06:13 - 00:37:11:15] And in winter, food is more scarce. But in autumn, we have a carbohydrate feast. We have free food. It's called fruit, nuts, seeds, grains, parses. These are all carbohydrates. And we evolved the carbohydrate addiction gene. And that, once switched on by eating some carbohydrates, makes us crave and crave and crave. And there's no off button for eating carbohydrates. Does every human have a carbohydrate addiction gene? I, well, I think yes, because this was a very successful evolutionary ploy because those humans that didn't have the carbohydrate addiction gene, didn't eat carbohydrates in an addictive way, didn't get fat and didn't survive the winter. Because being fat is survival value for the winter. It's a food source and it's an insulation layer. Of course, in primitive times, the carbohydrates ran out. Right. Nowadays, they never run out. So carbohydrates are available 365 days a year. We never switch off the carbohydrate addiction gene and we go on craving it. [00:37:13:00 - 00:38:59:19] So this is very much like the research I did for Fast Like A Girl, where I found that there was something called the thrifty hypothesis gene. It was the thrifty gene hypothesis. And its idea was that we, in the primal days, there was a genetic profile that could go a longer period of time without food. And the people who didn't have that genetic profile couldn't handle the winters without food. And so they perished and they died. So they were out of the gene pool. And the people that actually were able to survive in harsh conditions have this thrifty gene inside of them. And what's happening right now in this day and age is they believe that things like diabetes, insulin resistance, all of them even say they're contributing to metabolic dysfunction is because they are not fasting and they are not honoring their genetic profile. What I hear that almost all humans have. Now what I hear you saying is that same time period as we started to integrate into more modern food, we started to create a carbohydrate addiction gene. And that now we've got a double whammy is what I hear you saying, because we've got a gene that has us addicted to carbohydrates and we're eating that all the time. And then we have a gene that's our thrifty gene that tells us not to eat. And we're going against that genetic profile. Absolutely. And what switches off the carbohydrate addiction gene is doing a ketogenic diet. [00:39:02:11 - 00:39:11:08] And it honors the thrift, and also so it can honor the thrifty gene theory because I've had, do you know Dr. Georgia Edie? [00:39:12:08 - 00:45:42:21] I don't think I do. Oh, you need to study her. I brought her on here. She's a metabolic psychiatrist and she believes in the ketogenic diet long-term. She actually just put out an expert consensus and says that for many mental health conditions that, and she lists them out, that we need to have people on a ketogenic diet for at least 90 days. And now what I'm hearing is that's turning off a gene that has been created in you. It's also honoring your thrifty gene. But she and I ended up in a conversation of like, well, how do you get into ketosis? Her preferred way to get into ketosis is by removing carbohydrates. Honestly, my preferred way to get into ketosis is through fasting and using fasting windows. Well, both work. Right, agreed. But my experience is that it's much easier to fast once you're in ketosis. So I never start people on fasting. I usually start with, let's get into ketosis first and sort out the upper fermenting gut in parallel. For some people, the most frictionless route is carnivore. And then once they're well in ketosis, and obviously we can test that with blood tests, which are very simple, then the fasting becomes so much easier. Right. I think that's actually, you know, it's funny because we do, I mean, I've done so many different fasts with people and there's a lot of people ask, what's the prep work? And I've, you know, I'm looking at somebody who's been on the standard Western diet and it's take the ultra processed foods out. You're offering me another layer, which is, let's take that all carbohydrates out. Let's make sure that you're sticking more towards a ketogenic diet, the days leading up to a longer fast, the fast will be much easier. Absolutely, absolutely 100%. And one of those useful clinical tips that I can give my patients is what I call my addiction test. Now we are all carbohydrate addicts. And guess what? I'm a carbohydrate addict in spades, you know, I know that. And so I have an addiction test for all foods, which is if I can have one of that food, but not eat the packet, it's safe to have it in the house. So I don't have cashew nuts in the house because I have one cashew nut, the whole packet goes, you know. I don't have a bar of chocolate in the house so I have one square, the whole packet goes. So, and I find that very helpful because, you know, and I will eat a meal and sometimes I won't eat all that's on my plate because I'm satisfied. There's meat, there's fat, maybe a bit of sand. Well, because I just wanna point out ketones kill hunger. It's like everybody's injecting themselves. And I'm like, you just need to get into ketosis and it kills hunger. So I just want, you bring it, and also I do the same thing. I'm like, if there's a food I know I'm gonna go crazy on, I can't control myself, it does not come in my house. Correct. And let's have a quick look at the history of after processed foods. Because this starts off with the tobacco industry in the sixties and the seventies. And of course it was addictive, it was a big money spinner and they had teams of scientists making tobacco more addictive. So they put more nicotine in it, they put more sugar in it, they put flavors in it, they put burners to make it burn smoothly. But when the Richard Dole paper, the Oxford paper came out that clearly showed that smoking cause heart disease and cancer, the cigarette companies realized, the tobacco companies realized that their days were numbered. So they bought up the food companies and they turned the attention of those scientists to make food more addictive. And that's the origin of ultra-processed foods. It's addictive by design. That's crazy. And I don't have any ultra-processed foods in my house because they are so addictive. Right, yes. And they change your brain chemistry for sure. With the ketogenic diet, how long do you think people, especially women, how long do women stay on it? I have seen, and this is why I've written about this in many of my books, that cycling the ketogenic diet can be really helpful, especially around a woman's menstrual cycle. And I know you prefer, and Georgia prefers this as well, keeping people, both men and women, but especially even women, like in a long-term ketosis. What happens hormonally? Do we worry about progesterone tanking because progesterone needs glucose? What do we think about the fact that that could have some side, some consequences? I have to say, I like people to be constantly on a ketogenic diet. And from my own experience, I know if you fall off the wagon, it's difficult to get back on it again. Yeah, on and off can be hard. It's a little bit like smokers. We notice, if I said something, it's okay to have one cigarette a day, we know that's not good advice. What do the alcoholics celebrate? Complete abstinence. Now you're absolutely right, sugar and glucose is essential. It's essential to make the energy molecule ATP. It's the raw material from which we make DNA and RNA. We use sugar for glucuronidation, for detoxification in the liver. But we can make sugar from protein if necessary. So the thing is, is sugar and carbohydrates, and even fiber, actually they're not essential foods. We can cope without them. Yes, that is a very good point because the way that I teach the protein is you need to be able, if you're gonna do this high-load protein that so many experts are recommending, you need to make sure you're using that protein by lifting heavy weights or using your muscle, otherwise it will go to fat. Because protein breaks into glucose, just like carbohydrates break into. And I also have had Ben Bickman on here talking about carbohydrates. And he believes, I asked him the question, do you feel like there is ever a good time for a carbohydrate? And he's like, not really. Like he is not a fan of carbohydrates. I'm the same. And I know if, from my own personal experience and my patients, if I have a bit, the whole, I want more and more and more. I mean, I say I'm a gardener. We've had a very good summer. And for the first year ever, my Victoria plum tree has ripened. Oh, were they delicious? Could I stop eating them? No. [00:45:43:23 - 00:45:44:09] (Laughs) Yeah. [00:45:45:22 - 00:47:15:04] So would you say then if you have belly fat and you are using this visual that you've given us, your belly is bigger than your waist, you know you have a fermenting gut. And the first door in is the ketogenic diet along with the supplement protocol that you recommend. And I'm along with fasting. I'm gonna put some fasting in there. And that is the formula to help the fermenting gut. And that once you overcome that, if you have the willpower and the discipline, can you pulse in what I call nature's carbs, like your plum example. I think the highly refined carbohydrates and the ultra processed foods, they're so addictive you won't come back from them. But I love this protocol that you've created. And then, but I also know working with so many people that there's gonna be a boomerang or there's gonna be some moment where you go, that was really exciting. That felt really good, but I cannot sustain that. Where do we go from that moment? Well, obviously primitive woman would have fallen off the wagon in the autumn. And I say that affords you survival value for the winter. So windows of time of carbohydrates are not going to kill us. And guess what, if I go out and have supper with a friend, then yes, of course, and then there's some carbohydrates there, then yes, of course I eat those. But I get back on the wagon the next day. [00:47:16:06 - 00:48:32:01] Right, so don't go more than a day. Don't go more than a day is what I heard. That's right, that's what I say. Yeah, I think that's a good, yeah. And I think the difference between the true addict and the person who likes carbohydrates is the person who likes carbohydrates can get away with a day of it and get back on the wagon. Whereas the alcoholic can't, once they start on the wine, that's it, they're in real trouble again. Yeah, and going back to this carbohydrate addiction gene, I just wanna point out that when we're looking at this through the lens of epigenetics, if the ketogenic diet is the thing that will overturn, shut this gene's expression off, then consistency matters. And I've always said stick to something for 90 days and then test it. Do we have any scientific evidence of how long you would need to be on the ketogenic diet to shut the carbohydrate addiction gene off? Well, you just know from yourself. Yeah, right. You just know from your own cravings, don't you? Suddenly you just don't, you're not thinking about those things. I mean, the carbohydrate addicts are thinking about food all the time. They're measuring in their minds, how much bread and how big a salmon and how many biscuits, it's constantly there. Whereas as soon as you get into ketosis, you just stop thinking about food. [00:48:33:02 - 00:51:42:14] It's so true. I mean, sometimes even if I'm doing a gardening day, I do what I call a peasant gardening day when I'm attituting the garden and I get out there at six o'clock in the morning and I suddenly look at my watch, it's four o'clock and I haven't had anything to eat and haven't even thought about food. And then yes, okay, I go and I really enjoy my supper. And again, when I'm fasting, I find my brain works better and my body works better too. I'm sure you know the samurai warriors, before any altercation, they will fast for 24 hours because they're stronger and their reflexes are faster. If I've got a big writing project I've got to do, then I do it when I'm fasting, because guess what, I didn't have to shop, I didn't have to cook, I didn't have length table, I didn't have to wash up. So much easier. Yeah, it's so much easier. Yeah, and I think the interesting thing that when I first heard about the weight loss drugs, I would ask people, what do you notice? And they were like, my hunger's gone away. And I'm like, but fasting in the ketogenic diet does that. So I was so confused in the beginning, I was like, here I've been out profilatizing fasting in the ketogenic diet for over 20 years and people have gotten great success at it. And then a drug, a shot comes and they're like, think it's the miracle. Even experts within the wellness space think it's a miracle. And it's like, I understand people have extreme food addiction, it has been a savior, but the off-ramp, what I am learning in this conversation and doubling down on is the off-ramp of these medications is fasting in the ketogenic diet. Correct, correct. And just a quick story now, I had a friend of mine come up and have some supper and she works for the Metropolitan Police in the forensic department taking photographs of post-mortems. And this year they've had 13 deaths from people taking a Zempik or Monjaro or those weight jabs. And she said the pancreas in all cases has just been a mush, it's just gone to porridge. Yeah, well, I do wanna just state for people thinking about going on it or on it is you are putting your body in an abnormal state because GLP-1 hormone was not meant to be pulsing through your system. And that alone, we just don't know long-term what happens because it's an abnormal state of the body. So, I have empathy for people are like, if the food noise finally stopped, like I get it, I get it. Now let's get you a lifestyle that gets you off this drugs before they kill you. So, I think that's really, what are your thoughts on fiber because fiber is having a moment as well. And the research I've done a lot of resistant fibers, certain fiber strains do really well for increasing GLP-1 hormone production. Do we know where fiber is helpful and not helpful? Well, the first point is that fiber is not an essential food. The carnivores who don't have any vegetable fiber, there is quite a lot of meat fiber of course, and there are some studies showing that the microbiome is just as diverse on the carnivore diet as it is on an omnivorous diet. [00:51:43:23 - 01:00:50:10] And of course we don't know much about the microbiome, but what we do know is the more diverse it is. Good point, I just want everybody to know we don't know much about the microbiome, these 72 trillion little bacteria that are driving us. We're still learning. But what we do know is the more diverse it is, the healthier you are. Again, back to Stephanie Seneff, wonderful book, "A Toxic Legacy", which you and in there she points out that 54% of the microbiome is sensitive to glyphosate. Glyphosate was originally patented as an antibiotic. Now in America, again, she did the studies, it's the most used pesticide, and it is often used immediately before harvesting. And the reason for that is if you kill a harvest before you, or you kill the grain before you harvest it, it dries very quickly, and you save money in the drying stores, in the grain stores. But what it means is that all that glyphosate is going straight into the food chain. Now she worked out that the glyphosate is used at the rate of about one pound per head of the population. So one pound is 450 grams, 365 days a year, ballpark figure, if you're not using organic, you're probably consuming about one gram of glyphosate a day. Now that is not a trace amount. Drugs are given in milligram amounts. It is a therapeutic dose. And again, we know that our microbiome is becoming less diverse, it's becoming more and more narrow. And I think the biggest problem is glyphosate. Now there's a guy in this country called Tim Spector who says, "We should have 30 different foods a week in order to get that diversity." But organic is just so important. And I am mindful that organic food is more expensive, but I think that is one of the most important things you can do for your health is to eat organic. And again, coming back to the ketogenic diet, what many people tell me, oh, they don't tolerate the fat very well, but interesting if they're having organic fat, they tolerate it much better. What's an example of organic fat? Oh, well, organic butter, if you're not dairy allergic. Grass fed. Grass fed, correct. I mean, in this country, grass fed beef and grass fed lamb is going to be pretty organic. The problem meats are going to be pork and chicken, which are all intensively reared in sheds. They're not at the sunshine, they're not eating grass and they're using poor quality, high chemicalized foods. Yeah. Do you think, I really, when I lay out the ketogenic diet, I don't think of it as a high fat diet. I think of it as a fat and protein diet at normal amounts with less carbohydrates mixed with a fasting window. I don't see it as a high fat diet. Well, I do. That's fine, that's fine. I'm just, George and I disagree on this too. But this is why I think the ketogenic diet mixed with fasting becomes essential. Well, it can be high protein and many cope with that fine. But it's actually normal protein, high fat diet. You may have heard of a guy called Andrew Scarborough and in 2013, he was diagnosed with an astrocytoma, which is a very nasty aggressive brain tumor. He actually presented with severe epilepsy. And before the brain tumors diagnosed, he was tried on lots of drugs, didn't work. And he read that the ketogenic diet is a very good treatment for epilepsy. So he put himself on an incredibly strict ketogenic diet. He just ate fat with a little bit of meat, absolutely zero carbs. And his astrocytoma was diagnosed. It was too large to be operated on. He didn't want the chemotherapy and the radiotherapy. As you know, the average life expectancy at an astrocytoma is 13 months. He has been eating high fat diet, a little bit of protein, and he's alive and well today with no conventional treatment. So brain tumors are particularly susceptible to ketogenic diets, but he has just lived on fat for the last 13 years. That's crazy. So talk about like what a day would look like eating a high fat, high protein diet. Like how would somebody go about that? Well, normally I just have two meals a day and I time restrict. I try and eat in six hours. Me too, me too. So breakfast would be eggs and bacon. I'm very lucky I've got my own chickens. I've got my own pigs. So I have very good eggs and very good bacon. And then lunchtime would be meat and maybe, or fatty meat, because again, the joy of pigs and I have ancient breed of pigs, which are very fatty. So today I had ham with some salad. And now I do allow myself some potato. And the joy, the thing, the way I do potato is I cook it first, boil it up, and then let it cool in the fridge for at least 12 hours. Yeah, that's the resistant start. We started doing that too in my house. It's a really good trick. Yeah, it's great. And then I roast it in the oven with lots of fat and it makes the most delicious crispy potatoes that you've ever had. And they pass my addiction test. I have a couple and I don't want any more. Whereas if you gave me a pile of mashed potato, I might be spooning that back, fasting and then eat. So that's very helpful. And I don't eat rice because that's far too high carb. But as I understand, rice is also susceptible to the resistance starch. So you boil it, leave it cold in the fridge and then maybe fry it up with some eggs or some vegetables or whatever. It doesn't work for root vegetables like parsnip and carrot. So, but hey, but it doesn't mean I can eat potato, which I do love those roast potatoes. Right. So what I just heard is you're having a typical protein and in that protein there is naturally inherent fat. I did just hear you say you have a salad at lunch. So you have just a little bit of a salad. Correct. I mean, I eat whatever's in the garden at the time. Of course, it's seasonal. I'm in the autumn now and I've got some green peppers, I've got some lettuce, I've got a few tomatoes and some cucumber. And so, I have a bit of all those things. Very low carb, all that is less than 5% carb. And I eat it for the crunch factor, for the pleasure of eating those delicious salads. And it's diversification too. Correct, I'll have it with some balsamic and some olive oil and some salt and it's, mm. Yeah, and then you'll have a few of the potatoes or a little bit of rice in the cool down method. Well, I don't eat rice at all. Oh, you don't do rice, but you'll do potatoes. Well, because I can't grow it in the garden. I do do potato and they grow very well and they're absolutely exquisite. Yeah, this was really good. I really, I hope people are listening from through the lens of many different pain points. Belly fat being one, energy and mental clarity. I have been sitting here talking about ketosis for so long watching critic after critic after critic come. And I just kind of like scratch my head because I'm like, I can't argue with the results people are getting. And your explanation just took our, all of our understanding to such a deeper level. So I just, I really appreciated this. So thank you. Bless you, bless you. And I was always go back to evolutionary biology. That has all the answers and obviously you do the same. And people say to me, where's the evidence of the paleo-chentogenic dark works? Well, about 65 million years of evolution actually. That's right. And the evidence is in the results. Correct. You know, we're so focused on science being our hero, but you're right. Evolutionary biology never steers us wrong. And those of us who have been sitting with patients for so long using these skills, we just can't turn away from it. We're like, these, this works. And so I absolutely agree with you. And of course, if you have a carbohydrate addiction gene and you see an influencer say, "Hey, women need carbs." You're like, "Yes, that's it." Yeah. Right? It seems to be. Exactly. So I do think sometimes, you know, understanding that these principles work over and over again, but they're difficult in the beginning. And that is, and even if you do it the way we just talked about where you do the ketogenic diet and then you move into fasting and you combine those two, you can do a little bit of carnivore fasting. And you can see that the belly fat drops and the other symptoms you have dramatically change. Absolutely. Yeah. This was amazing. So last question for you. And that is, this podcast is called "Live Like a Girl" because I believe women have unique lifestyles that need to match our physiology. What does living like a girl mean to you? Oh gosh. [01:00:52:21 - 01:03:22:05] I think you have to stay young and think young. Yes. Thank you. Say more, say more. And the ketogenic diet does that because, you know, what seems to characterize old age in many people's minds is the lack of energy. Yeah. Energy delivery mechanisms are not right. And if you've got good energy delivery mechanisms, the brain works brilliantly well, and you've got the energy to go out and do all the stuff you want to do. Yeah. And, you know, the analogy I like to use with respect to energy delivery mechanism is the car analogy. And for your car's run, you've got to have the right fuel in the tank. You've got to have some oxygen. You've got to have the mitochondrial engine, and that's my special area of interest. We must do a podcast about mitochondria at some stage because that's fun. Definitely. The thyroid accelerator pedal and the adrenal gearbox. But the single most important thing is the right fuel in the tank. And that's ketones. And if you've got ketones in the tank, then your biochemistry works more efficiently. It works in a more frictionless way. It's also a low deuterium diet, and that's another long story. It protects you from cancer. So you can live life to its full potential. And that's what we should all be doing. That's beautiful. You know that when a woman goes through menopause and her brain starts to prune away neurons she no longer needs, what the byproduct of that are ketones. Because the innate intelligence knows that if it's going to make a brain change, that the preferred fuel source for the brain, especially the female aging brain, is a ketone. So your own brain in its remodeling makes ketones. You can't debate physiology when you hear that. And yet we are looking at dementia, Alzheimer's through the wrong lens. Correct. Because the body and the brain thrives on ketones. And I will continue over and over again to be such an advocate for that. Absolutely. Well, there are some people who are awake and there are some people who are asleep. And those that are asleep, some people are so addicted, they can't even hear the message. They'll say in push in place. But those are awake once they get it, you transform their lives. Yeah, it's beautiful. Well, Sarah, I loved this. Thank you for your work. And how can people find you if they want to go? Oh, on the website. Just if you just Google Dr. Myhill, it comes up. And I think it's had about 37 million hits. So somebody likes it. So all my stuff's there. I've written various books, [01:03:23:08 - 01:03:47:23] which you can, I think some are available in America. Chelsea Green published them in America and obviously available in this country. But my website, most of the stuff is there. I can't put it all there. Because if I put it all there, my publisher gets very cross because she wants people to buy the books. But there's a good chunk of useful stuff there. Amazing. Well, thank you for everything you're doing. I loved this conversation. My pleasure. It's lovely speaking to you, Mindy. It's absolutely joy. Yeah, thank you. Thank you. [01:03:49:00 - 01:04:05:23] Thank you so much for joining me in today's episode. I love bringing thoughtful discussions about all things health to you. If you enjoyed it, we'd love to know about it. So please leave us a review, share it with your friends and let me know what your biggest takeaway is.