Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / SAR Confidentiality: The Line Between the Filing and the Facts Underneath It
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker: Hey, everyone.
- 0:00Welcome back to another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm Mark Trakel, former NCUA executive director, and I spent over three
- 0:06decades on the regulator side before I changed teams to start helping
- 0:10credit unions with all things NCUA.
- 0:13Today's a short update.
- 0:15We're breaking down a joint statement that NCUA and other banking regulators
- 0:19and FinCEN put out just a few days ago.
- 0:22It's one of those rare pieces of guidance that gives you
- 0:25more room to operate, not less.
- 0:27So let's get specific.
- 0:29On September 2nd, five agencies signed this, the Federal Reserve,
- 0:32FDIC, OCC, NCUA, and FinCEN.
- 0:37That's every prudential regulator plus the BSA rule maker all putting their
- 0:41name on the same page, which tells you this wasn't one agency freelancing.
- 0:46It's a coordinated interagency position.
- 0:49The subject, suspicious activity report confidentiality.
- 0:53Specifically, what you can say to a member when you've filed or are consider
- 0:58filing a SAR involving their account.
- 1:01The headline's simple, SAR confidentiality rules do not prevent a credit union
- 1:07from communicating with a member about a potentially fraudulent transaction or
- 1:12about an action you've taken on their account, like a closure or a hold.
- 1:16What stays confidential, what you legally cannot disclose, is the existence
- 1:21of the SAR itself and its contents.
- 1:24Those are two different things, and for years a lot of compliance
- 1:27programs have treated them as if they were the same thing.
- 1:31Here's where I wanna get precise, because the statement itself gets
- 1:34precise, and that precision is what you're going to lean on in an exam.
- 1:40The underlying confidentiality rule comes straight out of the Bank Secrecy Act,
- 1:44and NCUA has its own version of that same rule for federally insured credit unions.
- 1:49Both say the same thing: you cannot disclose a SAR or any information
- 1:54that would reveal that a SAR exists.
- 1:57But here's the operative sentence from the joint statement, and I'd
- 2:01have your BSA officer put this exact language in the procedures manual.
- 2:05A SAR or information that would reveal a SAR exists does not include the
- 2:10underlying facts, transactions, and documents that the SAR is based on.
- 2:15That's the legal test, not how cautious do we feel, not what's
- 2:19our institutional risk tolerance.
- 2:21The test is whether you're disclosing the SAR itself or
- 2:25disclosing the facts underneath it.
- 2:28Telling a member, "We identified unusual activity and placed a hold while we
- 2:32investigate," or, "We're closing this account due to activity that violates
- 2:36our risk policies," those are statements about facts and about actions taken.
- 2:41They are not disclosure of a SAR's existence or content, and the agencies
- 2:45are now saying that explicitly, because enough institutions were conflating the
- 2:50two and leaving members in the dark, sometimes for weeks, out of the caution
- 2:54the rule never actually required.
- 2:57Now, why does this belong on a CEO or board member's desk and not just
- 3:00the BSA officer's file cabinet?
- 3:02Two reasons, both regulatory.
- 3:04One, this is an exam finding waiting to happen in either direction.
- 3:08If your BSA program's internal guidance is written more restrictively than the actual
- 3:13rule requires, that's not a safe harbor.
- 3:16That's your own policy manufacturing member service and complaint handling
- 3:20exposure that examiners may ask about under the consumer compliance
- 3:24side of the exam, separate and apart from your BSA AML module.
- 3:29Examiners are going to ask how you communicate with your members during a
- 3:32fraud hold, and we say nothing ever out of caution is now a harder position to defend
- 3:38than it was a week ago, because there's an interagency statement on the books saying
- 3:42that caution wasn't required by the rule.
- 3:45Two, there's a safe harbor angle worth knowing here, too.
- 3:49Separate from the confidentiality piece, the Bank Secrecy Act also gives you a
- 3:53liability protection for good faith SAR filings and related actions, including
- 3:59account closure tied to that filing.
- 4:01So you're actually protected on both ends, protected from liability for the
- 4:05action you took, and now expressly told you can explain the action itself to
- 4:10the member, so long as you don't cross into confirming or describing the SAR.
- 4:15So here's what I'd actually put in front of my BSA officer this week
- 4:19if it were me, and I'd frame it as a gap analysis, not a policy overhaul.
- 4:23First, pull the current SAR confidentiality training materials
- 4:26and fraud hold call scripts and check them against the joint statements.
- 4:31Underlying facts test.
- 4:32If your materials say anything broader than don't confirm or describe a SAR,
- 4:37you're potentially more restrictive than the regulation requires, and I'd want
- 4:41to document that before the exam starts.
- 4:45Second, get a one-page reference in front of the frontline and fraud
- 4:48staff that states the actual line, "Discuss facts and actions taken.
- 4:52Never confirm or describe a SAR," with sample scripted language, because
- 4:57know the difference isn't a control.
- 4:59It's a hope.
- 5:00Third, have counsel sign off before you finalize anything.
- 5:04Remember, this is a joint statement, an interpretive position from five agencies.
- 5:08It's not a change to the underlying regulation itself.
- 5:12I'd want counsel confirming how far your specific pre- procedures can move on the
- 5:17strength of guidance versus a rule change.
- 5:20The rel- regulatory theme here is one worth sitting with.
- 5:23This wasn't a new obligation being layered on you.
- 5:26It was five agencies telling the industry that a common
- 5:29practice was more conservative than the rule actually requires.
- 5:33That's worth an audit of where else your BSA program, the safe answer, became
- 5:38the house rule without any rechecking it against what the rule actually says.
- 5:44That's all I've got for you today.
- 5:46I hope you're having a wonderful Labor Day weekend.
- 5:48This is Mark Trakel, as always, signing off with flying colors.
- 5:52I hope you'll listen again soon.