Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Therapist has a Bad Boss
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. When I started out as a therapist in the mid
- 0:04nineties and I started learning about ethics, I thought that ethics were a set
- 0:11of rules that US therapists were supposed to follow, and I kind of wanted
- 0:15it that way because then it would be easier to know what to do,
- 0:21like in this situation, you're supposed to do this, and in this situation
- 0:25you're not supposed to do or you're never supposed to do X, Y and
- 0:29Z, like a common one would be never accept a gift or a tip
- 0:35from a client, that kind of thing. And as I progressed into my
- 0:41career, and particularly as I became a professor and a supervisor myself, I
- 0:47kind of slowly realized because I didn't really have proper guidance around this, and
- 0:54or I'm just slow to learn to sort of, I don't know, but
- 0:58I slowly realized over this span of years, honestly that ethics and ethical decision
- 1:03making is a complex system of various different considerations like the standard of care and
- 1:14consensus and how you can justify certain actions your process. You know, like
- 1:22you can do something that is harmful to it not well, how do I
- 1:26words if you take actions that result in the harm of a client, but
- 1:34you went through a very rigorous decision making process, then on average, it's
- 1:42more likely that you're not going to be considered liable or having committed an ethical
- 1:49violation, even though harm happened to the client. Whereas if you do the
- 1:53exact same harm to a client, but you just decided on on your own,
- 2:00you didn't consult with others, you didn't think about it, you didn't
- 2:02document your decision making process or your or the pros and cons that kind of
- 2:08thing, then you will on average be found more likely you'll be more likely
- 2:15to be found liable or having committed an ethical violation, you know, just
- 2:22things like that. Also understanding different pockets of research and thinking within my field,
- 2:30because within the field of psychotherapy and mental health there's a lot of pockets,
- 2:36there's a lot of individual silos, if you will, and the consensus
- 2:42can be hard to determine when you have all these different groups of people in
- 2:46my field. But when you have an understanding of that, then you have
- 2:51an understanding as to one of the factors involved in decision making. Ethical decision
- 2:58making not only just as a principle to follow, for yourself, but also
- 3:01what will hold up in a licensing board hearing or in a civil case or
- 3:07even a criminal hearing. So I slowly started to learn that. And one
- 3:14of the things that I slowly started to realize regarding ethical decision making is understanding
- 3:21how these cases are actually adjudicated in court or among lawyers or in the licensing
- 3:30board hearings. And just so you know, the typical end result of the
- 3:37question as to whether or not a therapist has committed an ethical violation happens in
- 3:40two main venues. One is in the licensing board, which is a government
- 3:46agency or an agency that has been designated by the government that will oversee the
- 3:54licensing of clinicians in the jurisdiction. And my country, it's in Washington's,
- 4:00you know, it's a state by state, and the licensing board can take
- 4:08away your license or sanction your license in some way, or put you on
- 4:12probation, that kind of thing. So that's one end result of an ethical
- 4:17violation. Another is in a civil case where a plaintiff sues the therapist,
- 4:26and a court or a judge or a jury, a try or fact determines
- 4:31whether or not the therapist did indeed commit an ethical violation that resulted in harming
- 4:36of a client. There's other kinds of legal suits anyway, So those are
- 4:43the two main end results. And so when we understand what actually happens in
- 4:49those two venues, then it of course helps us to understand what we should
- 4:55do day by day, hour by hour, session by session, client by
- 4:59client. And yet what I find is that these rulings in courts and in
- 5:06the licensing board hearings are almost never made available to us therapists. It's embarrassing
- 5:16how long it took me as a clinician to hear I mean just from my
- 5:23own memory anyway, of my very first actual court hearing or licensing board hearing.
- 5:31You know, the typical conversations that happen, and I see this today
- 5:35as well, is you'll have a bunch of therapists that will talk about whether
- 5:43or not something is ethical or not. You know, a very common thing
- 5:46that happens today is on Reddit, someone will post a question and say is
- 5:51it ethical or unethical this or that? And the you know the different subreddits
- 5:56on Reddit. I don't know the exact names, but I've seen them where
- 6:00it'll be a group of therapists or it'll be a group of clients that are
- 6:02talking and there will be these questions that will be raised. And for sure,
- 6:09some of the comments below, some of the answers to the question are
- 6:15what I believe to be intelligent and informed, but many of their responses are
- 6:19not. And that is typical. Therapists aren't really told or given access to
- 6:27good information or where to even look for good information because again, these decisions
- 6:33and these quote unquote rules, and they're not rules, but these guidelines are
- 6:39made a little opaque to us. I mean, we have our ethical codes,
- 6:43and if you look at our ethical codes and you understand them, you
- 6:47know whether you're a psychiatrist's psychologists, marriage of family therapists, counselor social worker,
- 6:53psychiatric nurse, those are all the main professions. Each have their own
- 6:58ethical guide ethical codes, but generally they're very very similar, and when you
- 7:02read them and you really understand them, they don't really tell you what to
- 7:08do. They're pretty broad and brief, and they don't provide explanations. I
- 7:14mean, there are extra literature and explanations that will provide that, but it's
- 7:18not easily understood. And if you just understand the code, you just read
- 7:24the codes because they're pretty clear. So I personally follow both the American Psychological
- 7:31Association Code of Ethics for psychologists and also the WMFT for Marriage and Family therapists
- 7:40their code of Ethics as well. I also generally will consult with the ACA
- 7:46American Counseling Association Code of Ethics because it's just I like to absorb all that
- 7:54resource. But just looking at the APA the Psychologists Code of Ethics, an
- 8:00example of one that is very clear, maybe the only one that is very
- 8:05clear, is the following. Psychologists do not engage in sexual intimacies with current
- 8:13therapy clients slash patients. That's it. It's probably the shortest ethical code.
- 8:20Usually they're paragraphs. Psychologists do not engage in sexual intimacies with a current therapy
- 8:24client. So what about right after you terminate, So you terminate that week
- 8:31and then the next week, now you can have se because it says current
- 8:35right, And of course there's a lot of other literature around this, but
- 8:41anyway, so that's the only one that is really clear. But just looking
- 8:45at some others. So another category of ethical guidelines and codes has to do
- 8:50with what we call multiple relationships or dual relationships. And Internetshell. One way
- 8:56of demonstrating this is that if I treating a client, I have one relationship
- 9:03with that client as therapist and client relationship. Let's say that I also have
- 9:11a child that it goes to the same school as my client's child. Okay,
- 9:20so that's another relationship that I have with the client. In addition to
- 9:24the therapist client relationship, I also have a relationship with that person in that
- 9:31we're both parents of kids who go to the same school. That's pretty distant
- 9:37in terms of relationship, but you know, it's a relationship. We might
- 9:39run into each other, there might be required meetings or assemblies at the school
- 9:46that I undoubtedly will be in the same room with that person. A more
- 9:52commonly discussed multiple relationship might be something like if a my uncle went to school
- 10:03with my client or something like that. Or one of the problems that therapists
- 10:09will head into is if a therapist were to hire their client to do something
- 10:16like they might hire their client to do landscaping, or hire their client to
- 10:20do babysitting or something like that. So these are other relationships with clients,
- 10:26and a lot of people will claim, and I've heard this that any multiple
- 10:31relationship is inherently unethical and is against the rules. Is unethical. But that's
- 10:37just not true. You can engage Well, it's not a matter of can
- 10:43or can't, it's a matter of many multiple relationships that clinicians engage in are
- 10:52not found to be an ethical violation, in that the risks are not severe
- 10:58enough to justify passing up on the benefits. That's here. I say that
- 11:05it's not like do this or don't do that anyway, So just reading and
- 11:11this is a number of paragraphs, but just reading like sort of the main
- 11:16part here is that a psychologist refrains from entering into a multiple relationship if the
- 11:24multiple relationship could reasonably be expected to impair the psychologist's objectivity, competence, or
- 11:31effectiveness. Blah blah blah. So a psychologist refrains from entering into a multiple
- 11:37relationship if that relationship could reasonably be expected to impair the treatment, you know,
- 11:41impair the psychologist's ability to treat the client. Well, what does that
- 11:46mean? Reasonably could could reasonably be expected to impair? That's not clear who
- 11:54decides what's reasonably expected to impair. There's a lot of wigger room there there
- 12:01and there's nothing in the ethical code that says this sort of multip relationship is
- 12:07guaranteed to impair, whereas this one might be more of a gray zone.
- 12:11It's case by case. So for example, in small communities where there's not
- 12:20a lot of people, it's well understood in my field that it's really hard
- 12:26to avoid multiple relationships. Like if you're one of the only therapists in town
- 12:31or the or you're the only therapist in town, or you're the only therapist
- 12:35who specializes in something. And let's say you have a client that comes to
- 12:39you, and that client happens to be the only dentist in the area,
- 12:45and you need a dentist. So what are you going to do? You're
- 12:50going to drive three hours to find a dentist. Is that is the dentist
- 12:54going to drive three hours to find a therapist? Now, with like online
- 12:58therapy, it really kind of throws wrench in this. But but you know,
- 13:01it could be argue that for some people online therapy just isn't going to
- 13:07work or isn't preferred, you know. Anyway, So in that instance,
- 13:13if I am in this small town and this person comes to me and they
- 13:18happen to be the only dentist, and then I hire the dentist to be
- 13:20my dentist. That's a multiple relationship. It's pretty interesting, right. It
- 13:26requires a lot of thought. Now, it's not like small communities are completely
- 13:31off the hook. There are case by case there's a lot of things you
- 13:33have to consider, and if you engage in that multiple relationship, you have
- 13:37to do a lot of things to ensure that the client won't be harmed or
- 13:41that the risk is kept to a minimum. The client, of course,
- 13:46has a lot of say in the matter. So in that instance, I
- 13:50would have a client that I see weekly, and then every six months I
- 13:56go to my client and they put their hands in my mouth and do stuff.
- 14:03It's a multiple relationship, and it's well understood that that is, you
- 14:07know, a consideration in these small town situations or in specialty situations. So
- 14:16these are not rules, their codes, their principles, their guidelines, if
- 14:24you will, their considerations. And again, one of the main things that
- 14:30is not provided at least to the people in my circle is okay, when
- 14:35you finally get to court or the licensing board hearing what exactly happens, because
- 14:41then we could work our way backward and it'll give us another tool to use
- 14:48when we're trying to decide what we're going to do. Oh, here's what
- 14:50I want to saying. So a lot of people in my anecdotal experience therapists,
- 14:56clinicians, when they're talking about what is and what is not ethical is
- 15:01often I find, once I became knowledgeable about what actually happens in court,
- 15:05is that there's this sort of weird echo chamber among clinicians where everyone is just
- 15:13making shit up essentially, and I'll hear them talking amongst themselves, or I'll
- 15:18see them talking online, or I'll be in a meeting where people are talking
- 15:22and I'll think, well, based on my knowledge, Eventually, I really
- 15:28just set out to become a lot more knowledgeable. And one of the things
- 15:31that I did was I started to look into these actual case studies. But
- 15:35also I would consult with lawyers, and I would have lawyers on the podcast
- 15:41since the early days, and hearing them talk because they are involved in these
- 15:45court hearings and these licensing board hears and hearing them talk it's very eye opening
- 15:50because lawyers, if they're experienced and competent, particularly if they work in mental
- 15:54health cases, they understand that it's nuanced. Of the most classic things you're
- 16:00going to hear from an actual expert regarding an ethical choice. If you were
- 16:06to go to them and say, okay, you know I did this thing.
- 16:10Was that ethical or not? And what the expert will say is,
- 16:14huh, well, it depends, you know. Let me ask you some
- 16:18questions, and then as you provide more information, the expert might say something
- 16:23like, well, I understand your decision making there, but you could be
- 16:30liable if this happens, and if the court sees it this way, then
- 16:33that could be a problem. Plus there's this unknown you know, it's very
- 16:38amorphous. And at first this really bugged me because I thought, shouldn't we
- 16:45just have some fucking rules about this and then we could just put it to
- 16:49rest and know what to do, you know. Like the classic that I
- 16:53remember was in graduate school at the mid nineties. I I don't know if
- 17:00I asked the question or someone else did, but a case is brought up.
- 17:04And for those who know my small community, Ned Farley was my ethics
- 17:10instructor. He still teaches at Antioch today, a friend of mine now,
- 17:15and he was giving a case in which you have a I think it was
- 17:22ned anyway in which you have a teenager who you're seeing in individual therapy and
- 17:29she discloses to you that she is using cocaine and using it fairly often.
- 17:37So confidentiality guides us regarding you know post thirteen and above in my jurisdiction,
- 17:47that the child has confidentiality that you don't tattletale on the kid. You don't
- 17:52tell the parents. You know, that's the question mark. You know,
- 17:53do you tell the parents? And of course the answer is no, of
- 17:56course not. This is a confidential relationship. You don't blab this information.
- 18:00It's it's one of the central principles of our profession and it's clearly laid out
- 18:07in the ethical codes and in the case law. But so I thought that
- 18:14was the answer. But then the professor said, but let's say that this
- 18:18teenage girl uses and dies from it, and then there's an investigation. They
- 18:25pull the file, the parents or whatever, or somehow the parents find out
- 18:30that you knew about the cocaine use and this teenage client, and then they
- 18:34sue you. And I'm thinking, well, obviously the answer is the parents
- 18:38would lose that case. My professor said, no, the parents might win
- 18:45because they could argue and could convince a jury or the judge, depending on
- 18:49who's the try or fact, that you should have informed the parents that there's
- 18:56a certain level of risk and danger to life, that it's it's expected that
- 19:06we should try to reduce the risk of a client dying, and that might
- 19:11actually involve breaking confidentiality, such as informing the parents about the drug use that
- 19:17kind of thing. But it really depends on the situation. Maybe you suspected
- 19:23that the parents were abusive, or maybe on the other hand, you knew
- 19:29that the that the parents already knew about it because there's enough evidence from the
- 19:33client that says the parents alayw So you don't really need to break Yeah.
- 19:38So when I heard that, I said wait to say wait, wait,
- 19:41wait wait. So you're saying that if I'm a teenage client that is telling
- 19:45me that they use cocaine and I say nothing because i'm you know, I'm
- 19:52preserving confidentiality, then I could be sued successfully by the parents. Is that
- 19:57what you're saying? Professor says yes. On the other hand, if I
- 20:00do break confidentiality and tell the parents, the teenage daughter could sue me successfully
- 20:07for breaking confidentiality. Is that what I'm hearing. Professor says yes, and
- 20:12I thought that is fucked. That is a stupid ass syst How do we
- 20:18have a system. And the other factor here is that us mental health people,
- 20:23we don't get sued very often. Thus the case precedents are not numerous,
- 20:30so we don't really have that to go off of. And when these
- 20:36cases do add up in court, the judges or the juries don't have that
- 20:41to go off of either. So a lot of these cases are one they
- 20:47never end up in court or in the licensing board hearings, but two,
- 20:49if they do, they might be the first of its kind. So all
- 20:53this is leading me up to the following, which is that this morning I
- 20:59receive an email from my malpractice insurance. It's a newsletter and it had an
- 21:07actual case that my malpractice was working on and had worked on with another insured
- 21:15mental health professional, and they type it up and it's anonymized and they provided
- 21:22as a learning tool for us who have this malpractice insurance to learn from.
- 21:29And I love these cases. And if you've been listening to this podcast for
- 21:33a while, you know that I've always liked these cases. Whenever I get
- 21:37them, I probably get maybe five a year or something from my malpractice and
- 21:41whenever I get one, I almost always talk about it on the podcast because
- 21:45it gives me an opportunity to sift through it myself, but myself, but
- 21:49also I just want to get the word out to people, not only to
- 21:52therapists so that they can understand, but also to the public that you understand
- 21:56what your rights are and what is good therapy and bad therapy, and that
- 22:04if you're being treated poorly or in a way that is risky, I think
- 22:10you should know that. And clients almost never know that they're being mistreated,
- 22:15or if they suspect they're being mistreated, they almost never know what to do.
- 22:22So these cases I think are important for a number of reasons. One
- 22:26is for a therapist to learn so that they don't commit these mistakes, because
- 22:30the vast, vast majority of therapists are not trying to make a mistake,
- 22:34they're not trying to cut corners. They care deeply. But this is anecdotal,
- 22:40but a majority of therapists and counselors psychologists just have not been educated or
- 22:45supervised well and they don't know where to turn. So, you know,
- 22:51this is why for me, in my career. It took me a while
- 22:55to realize this, and once I realized it, I was like, oh
- 22:57crap, I'm a supervisor. I'm in charge of this sort of thing.
- 23:02I could be sued if one of my superviss does something that I should have
- 23:06done something about. Plus I don't trust any education system to inform my supervises,
- 23:15so that's on me. And one could argue that that's the ethical way
- 23:19of looking at it, that if I'm going to be supervising somebody, I
- 23:22can't blame their training program. I can't say, well, you know,
- 23:26they should have been trained that The book stops with you. And that's why
- 23:30I take supervision so and always have I ticket so seriously since that, up
- 23:37until this point, the only book that I've ever written was about supervision.
- 23:41It's like it's a very very passionate topic of mine. It's not just checking
- 23:48on their progress notes. It's a deep relationship that involves not only a supervisor
- 23:52that fully understands how to detect and investigate and inquire about ethical situations with their
- 24:03supervisors, but also how to guide people how to teach people around that.
- 24:08Not only that, but also the deep mentorship relationship that happens between a therapist,
- 24:15between a supervisor and a therapist. One that for me the two or
- 24:22three high quality supervisors that I've had, and I've had something like seventeen or
- 24:27twenty supervisors in my career. It's common to have a lot of supervisors,
- 24:33particularly with the way my career went, because I basically have two professionals.
- 24:37I'm both a marriage and family therapist. I'm also trained as a psychologists.
- 24:41So they're going to get a lot of supervisors and a small minority of them,
- 24:45looking back, I consider to be actual supervisors, and the rest of
- 24:49them were mediocre or downright abusive. And that is what research shows is that
- 24:56there's a bell curve of supervisors with most in the middle mediocre zone, and
- 25:03you have a few at the high end that are doing their job and take
- 25:10it seriously, and you need to have a few at the low end that
- 25:11are abusive, harmful to the supervising. That's absolutely my experience. I have
- 25:18absolutely been abused by supervisors. It's unfortunate. So I want to present this
- 25:27case that I got this morning. I got it and I didn't plan on
- 25:32doing this today, but I started reading it and I was just getting so
- 25:36into it. I thought, well, shit, if I'm this, if
- 25:38I've got it sort of downloaded into my head, I might as well yammer
- 25:41about on the podcast. So let's get to and this case has to do
- 25:45with supervision. It has to do with all the typical things, and it's
- 25:52an example of a therapyt, a counselor a supervisor, and an agency that
- 25:59all all get sued successfully for dropping the ball in a very very severe way
- 26:06that resulted in a very dire consequence for a client. So let's get into
- 26:11it. But first let's take a break, and then when we get back,
- 26:15we'll get into it. All right, we're back from the break.
- 26:22So this case brief comes from my malpractice insurance company, which is called HPSO,
- 26:29which I think is healthcare provider service organization. And a lot of what
- 26:34I'm about to read is verbatim from the brief, but other statements in here
- 26:40are my own embellishments, so just keep that in mind, all right.
- 26:44So this case involves an agency and an agency owner and a supervisor and an
- 26:51intern and a client. Okay, So getting into the brief, the agency
- 26:56had a contractual relationship with a local university to provide training and supervision for interns
- 27:03and accounting program. So, just to provide an explanation of what they're saying
- 27:08here, is that you have a university training program that trains therapists, such
- 27:15as the university that I teach at, and that university hired this agency to
- 27:22provide supervision for their interns, and my university doesn't do this. But I'm
- 27:30guessing what is actually occurring here is that the university has a clinic, because
- 27:37if it was if the interns were going into the community and working at regular
- 27:41agencies, the regular agencies have their own supervisors. So I'm guessing that this
- 27:47is a university clinic and the university either as short staffed, or they don't
- 27:55have enough qualified supervisors as professors, or they just don't want to provide supervision
- 28:02for whatever reason, and so they've hired this agency to come into the clinic,
- 28:07which I'm guessing it's a clinic, to provide supervision. Okay, So
- 28:12you have that agency and the owner of that agency, and so moving forward,
- 28:19all right, the owner of the agency was a licensed Professional Clinical counselor
- 28:25or LPCC. So the owner of the agency is not only the owner of
- 28:32a business but also licensed as a counselor. All right. Going on,
- 28:37the owner held the title of Director of Student Training, but I know from
- 28:42the rest of the brief that this owner does not actually provide supervision. In
- 28:47this role, the owner was responsible for the oversight of the intern training program,
- 28:52including policy implementation and intern assignments. This will all come into PlayLater later,
- 28:59all right. A second person at the agency is a supervisor and an
- 29:06employee of the agency, and this supervisor was responsible for direct intern supervision.
- 29:12I'm wording that kind of weird, but so essentially of the owner. And
- 29:17then you have an employee of the agency that is hired as a supervisor to
- 29:22go to this university program and provide supervision for the internet art. So the
- 29:29client in this case was a thirty year old female. She had a history
- 29:33of bipolar and a history of substance use disorder. She was under the care
- 29:41of a psychiatrist already. She had a recent hospitalization for treatment of a manic
- 29:48episode and psychosis. So just chiming in here. Hospitalization is pretty severe but
- 29:57common for folks who are suffering from a manic episode, particularly if there's psychosis.
- 30:04You know, what this can look like is that somebody is maybe hallucinating.
- 30:11They will have delusions. Perhaps they will will be pretty confused about decision
- 30:18making and about what's going on. They can become very grandiose about their own
- 30:26they become extremely delusionally optimistic at times. They can be staying up all night,
- 30:33they have a ton of energy. They might be alienating everyone around them.
- 30:37Yeah, there's just a lot of different profiles to what this can look
- 30:42like. But it's very concerning it. You know, from an outsider's point
- 30:48of view, it seems to come out of nowhere, particularly because the common
- 30:53state of someone with bipolar without treatment is depression. And then all of a
- 30:57sudden they seem to mean a good mood and you're thinking, oh, maybe
- 31:02they're doing better, and then they escalate to full mania and it's usually short
- 31:08lived, and usually given the behaviors and the signs, these individuals will very
- 31:17quickly cause so much concern from people around them that they might end up being
- 31:22hospitalized, either voluntarily, you know, sometimes they'll go voluntarily or involuntarily,
- 31:29either because the family convinces the authorities to do an assessment as to whether or
- 31:38not involuntary placement would be recommended, or the psychiatrist or even the law enforcement
- 31:45will initiate this anyway, So we don't know that the circumstances around that,
- 31:51but we know that this client had been recently hospitalized from, you know,
- 31:56due to mania and psychosis. Upon diste charge, the client was referred to
- 32:01counseling and instructed to follow up with our psychiatrists. So just chiming in here,
- 32:07what this indicates to me is that the client wasn't in counseling already,
- 32:15so upon discharge, the psychot say, hey, you need to be an
- 32:19ongoing counseling, so that was the referral. Upon discharge, the hospital discharge
- 32:25summary noted that the client had been non compliant with the prescribed antipsychotic medication recommendation.
- 32:32So just chiming in here, what the discharge summary is saying is that
- 32:38upon being recommended to take this medication to manage the client's mania or just bipolar
- 32:49in general, the client was not complying or was indicating that they weren't going
- 32:54to take the medications. So that's pretty concerning at the very least, because
- 33:01untreated bipolar can really ruin the client's life, but it can also be very
- 33:07harmful to others potentially, so right away, we're seeing some risks there.
- 33:16Going on, three weeks following discharge, the client contacted the agency to make
- 33:22an appointment. So you know, this is three weeks after, so it's
- 33:25a while after discharge. That's a little concerning right there. You would think
- 33:31that the client, if they were fully on board with the treatment regimen,
- 33:37they would contact a therapist that day upon being discharged. You know, that
- 33:44would be the recommendation. But you know, we see three weeks. You
- 33:45know, it's not a long Maybe there were some complications there, but it's
- 33:50just a little red flag. And it's possible that there's nothing in the brief
- 33:55that indicates either way. But it's possible that the client, given that they
- 34:00were non adherent with their recommendations regarding meds, that they were begrudgingly going to
- 34:06counseling to begin with. It's just a factor to think about that. I
- 34:10don't know if that was president or not, but it has the profile of
- 34:14that. So three weeks following distarts, a client contacted the counseling agency to
- 34:19make an appointment. The client was assigned a new intern because the agency was
- 34:23short staffed and there was there were no licensed counselors available. Okay, So
- 34:29just timing in here. Not only was it an intern, but it's a
- 34:31new intern. And that says a lot because if you're an intern in your
- 34:37first term, in the first few months, that's different than if you're an
- 34:40intern close to graduation. You learn a lot. And you know, typically
- 34:45an internship is about a year. So there's that. Now some people might
- 34:50be thinking an intern that doesn't sound good. Well, you know, you
- 34:53got to start somewhere. And interns, for the most part, if they
- 34:59are super vised closely enough, are capable and competent and able to treat all
- 35:06the same sorts of clients that everyone else can treat. And you got to
- 35:10learn somewhere. And often, like in this agency, you don't have a
- 35:15choice because your short staff, there's no other slots available, so they've got
- 35:20to go to the interns. All right. So there's that, but you
- 35:24need to make sure you supervise sufficiently going on. The administrative assistant was in
- 35:30charge of assigning new clients to an intern, all right, just chiming in
- 35:35here. So the administrative assistant would be some probably someone that takes the phone
- 35:39calls or works at the front desk or something along those lines. And this
- 35:45admin person is in charge of assigning new clients. So when a new file
- 35:51comes in or a client calls or referral comes this admin's job. Part of
- 35:57their job was to find an open slot among the various stable of therapists that
- 36:06are employees and assign that case to that particular therapist. And you know,
- 36:10it's a pretty important job. And these admin people hopefully have at least some
- 36:17knowledge as to which clinicians are better than others given the situation at hand.
- 36:25Some admin people don't really know what they're doing and they're just randomly assigning without
- 36:30considering a good fit, if you will. Some admin people don't have that
- 36:36luxury because of short staff issues and the amount of high risk clients that come
- 36:42in. But that's what we're hearing. Other agencies will have supervisors that will
- 36:46do this or at least be a part of it, but it's not uncommon
- 36:50to have an admin person assign it. Two weeks later, the initial assessment
- 36:55was conducted by the intern and the intern supervisor, and the client was diagnosed
- 37:00with unspecified schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorder. All right, so let's scrutinize
- 37:07this part. So there's an appointment that's made and then two weeks later is
- 37:10the initial assessment. It's not the best situation because we know that this is
- 37:19a pretty high risk situation given that the client was just hospitalized and is also
- 37:24potentially not compliant. Also, not only is the client apparently suffering from bipolar
- 37:31but also is suffering from a substance use disorder, which can exponentially complicate things
- 37:39not only for their own behavior and their medication compliance, but also risk of
- 37:45suicide that kind of thing. Also upon coming down from a manic episode,
- 37:52that can be a pretty high risk time because for these folks, they often
- 37:57as they start to gain their a sense of reality, they start you know,
- 38:02reflecting back on what they did and how their life has been potentially severely
- 38:10negatively affected by their own behavior over the past few weeks. You know,
- 38:14it could be a very stressful time, very sad time, demoralizing time.
- 38:20So it's very important that people get immediate help during during and potentially monitoring there
- 38:25is time to get them through that time. So hearing that it's two weeks
- 38:30later, but again not uncommon, and it's unclear if the admin assistants even
- 38:37new because the client calling the agency would have to inform about that, and
- 38:45I'm not there's no data either way, But I'm just going to take a
- 38:47guess and say that the client didn't say, Hey, I'm in an emergency
- 38:52situation, I need a therapist right away. I'm guessing the client just said,
- 38:58yeah, I want to counselor. And sometimes that's all that's being asked
- 39:05about, maybe just like a tiny detail of the presenting problem. So anyway,
- 39:12we here two weeks later. That's when the assessment is done by the
- 39:15intern. But the supervisor is there present in the assessment. So that's a
- 39:19good sign. Because the intern alone that'd be tough. But I would say
- 39:22nine times out of ten it is the intern by themselves and with proper supervision
- 39:29and oversight, that that isn't necessarily a problem. It's a common complaint or
- 39:35stress that I will hear from my interns that I am supervising, because i'll
- 39:40supervise them at the university side, and I will hear from them just how
- 39:47terrified they are. And often interns will be given and I can't confirm this,
- 39:52but I think a lot of agencies will, you know, say they
- 39:58get a new client and there's a lot of red flags that it's going to
- 40:00be very complicated and difficult. And when that admin person goes to the staff
- 40:08therapists that are more experienced, a lot of those staff therapists are already full.
- 40:12But also those staff therapists will say I don't want that client. That
- 40:15sounds awful, and because the staff therapist has some political power, they can
- 40:23push back. And then the admin person is like, well, who do
- 40:27I give this case? Well, I'll give to the intern because the intern
- 40:29doesn't know any better, and the interns are usually dying to get clients because
- 40:32they need their hours, and so it's something that I can't confirm that's what's
- 40:37actually happened, but I think it does happen sometimes. But again, with
- 40:40proper supervision not only from the on site supervisor, but supervision from me from
- 40:46the university side, we can help the therapist to get through it all right.
- 40:52Going on, Also, they diagnosed the client with unspecified schizophrenia spectrum and
- 40:59other psychotic disorder. I'm going to take a guess and say that in the
- 41:02time limitation they had to assess this client, they either needed more time or
- 41:10the client was being resistant during the assessment. There's no data along those lines,
- 41:15but there just seems to be some profile indications of a client that isn't
- 41:20necessarily being fully on board with the treatment. Who knows, But a lot
- 41:24of times what clinicians will do is they will at first label someone with an
- 41:30unspecified and then upon further assessment, will lock in. You know, if
- 41:36I saw this from an intern, I would say, that's a temporary diagnosis,
- 41:39correct, and they would say yes, Whereas if they said no,
- 41:44I'd say that's not typically something that you'll land on. That's something that is
- 41:49unusual. It's unusual to have, you know, schizophrenia symptoms and psychosists and
- 41:53you don't meet the full or you don't meet enough of the criteria for schizophrenia,
- 41:58or it's gets to affect or bipolar anyway going on. During the initial
- 42:04assessment, the client stated, well, so just back up. But what
- 42:08this does say is that the intern and the supervisor from the very beginning identified
- 42:15psychosis and some schizophrenia symptoms. So that says something. It says, well,
- 42:23they knew that something was going on there, and those kinds of symptoms
- 42:29carry with them a fair amount of risk that would raise your intensity level regarding
- 42:37the need to monitor the situation and to make sure that the client is doing
- 42:43okay, particularly in the initial phase of therapy, because you don't really know
- 42:46the rhythms of the client yet. All right, going on during the initial
- 42:52assessment, the client stated that she had suicidal thoughts in the past, but
- 42:58she currently deny having a plan or a means or an intent to kill herself.
- 43:02The client also denied having any recent suicidal ideation A right, So just
- 43:07chiming in here. The brief is very brief, if you will, and
- 43:12if you're a clinician you might know, but you know it might be reading
- 43:16between the lines. But for you non clinicians, So this initial assessment is
- 43:22conducted, I'm going to take a guess and say it could have been even
- 43:25just an hour long a lot of assessments. That's all the time they have.
- 43:30Could have been a couple hours, but I'm going to take guests to
- 43:32say that if the supervisor was there, tops would have been ninety minutes.
- 43:37So it's hard to get a lot of information during that time. But anyway,
- 43:43they as a part of the assessment, either asked or the client volunteered
- 43:46that the client had in the distant past had thought about suicide. There's no
- 43:52mention of it here, but I'm guessing the implication is that the client did
- 43:58not indicate that they had ever attempted. So that was my question as to
- 44:02the hospitalization regarding mania. A lot of hospitalization mental health related have to do
- 44:09with suicidal risk, but with mania, that's not typically the case anyway.
- 44:15It's just a detail there. But the client stated that she had in the
- 44:19past had thought about suicide, but she denies she currently says, I don't
- 44:23have a plan, I don't have the means to kill myself, and I
- 44:27don't have the intent to kill myself, and I haven't even recently thought about
- 44:32suicide. Okay. Now, with bipolar and potentially with schizophrenia spectrum in psychosis,
- 44:40you should know that that could change pretty quickly. Other kinds of clients,
- 44:46for example, if someone suffered from moderate depression, you assess that in
- 44:52the first session and they say, you know, let's say they're thirty five,
- 44:57and they say, yeah, I used to think about suicide when I
- 45:00was a teenager in my early twenties, but I haven't. That doesn't occur
- 45:05to me anymore because of this, this and this, But I am very
- 45:07depressed. If you heard that that's a more stable possibility, you still need
- 45:15to do everything you need to do to protect the client and to address it.
- 45:21But when you hear schizophrenia spectrum with psychosis, particularly with the recent hospitalization
- 45:27which they don't know about, which they never find out about, by the
- 45:30way, then at the real least we know because of the information that we
- 45:36have available to us, that just because she's currently saying she does not think
- 45:40about suicide does not mean that it couldn't change on a dime at any point.
- 45:46You know. Like another profile, if I had a client who was
- 45:52suffering from grief because of a divorce or something, and when in the course
- 45:58of assessment, I asked if they had ever thought about suicide, and they
- 46:00said, no, They've never thought of It's never occurred to them. They've
- 46:05never considered it. That It's just never no matter how bad life gets,
- 46:07they would never do that. That's a very different situation. I'm not going
- 46:12to think that next week suddenly they're going to start thinking about suicide. That
- 46:16would be very rare. It could happen, and I need to monitor things,
- 46:20but that would not be a prediction. Whereas with bipolar schizophrenia, psychosis,
- 46:27recent hospitalization, the information that we know, a substitute disorder. You
- 46:31know, it's not a severe risk at this point because the client is reporting
- 46:37anyway that they aren't thinking about it and they don't have a plan to do
- 46:42it, So it's not a huge risk in the upcoming weeks. But it's
- 46:47more of a risk because that also given everything that we know, the fact
- 46:52that she was not compliant with a medication is another red flag that would you
- 47:00know, if I were the supervisor in this case and I knew all the
- 47:04information, I would be telling the interurn. You have to in the beginning,
- 47:08anyway, treat this case as if it were just baseline a modern risk
- 47:15of suicide, even though there's no signs of it, because there are these
- 47:19other factors and so, you know, let's just make sure that we're keeping
- 47:22track of that and addressing that maybe even having a safety plan and a safety
- 47:27plan would be good anyway, not just for suicide, but given everything we
- 47:30know, a safety plan regarding if she were to the client were to escalate
- 47:37in terms of her mania. You know, if you see the first science
- 47:40of mania, here is the crisis plan, you know, here's the plan
- 47:44that we're gonna implement and that you're agreeing to implement anyway. So just going
- 47:50on, she reported, the client reported that she was under the care of
- 47:54a psychiatrist and she didn't. Now some of you might be thinking, isn't
- 48:00isn't there just some database that the counselor and supervisor, the intern supervisor could
- 48:05just look at, And maybe there is, I'm not aware of one.
- 48:09We need the clients to tell us stuff. So going on, the client
- 48:15told the intern and supervisor that she currently had a psychiatrist, but she did
- 48:22not inform them that she had recently been hospitalized, and the supervisor and the
- 48:28intern did not inquire about hospitalizations. So the fact that the intern and the
- 48:34supervisor didn't know and never found out about the hospitalization, is that because they
- 48:39didn't ask, or is that because the client was withholding. That we'll never
- 48:45know, but of course they should have asked, and it's one of those
- 48:47standard questions that you asked, particularly if you're detecting schizophrenia symptoms and psychosis,
- 48:55that should be the immediate question. So, I have you been hospitalized?
- 49:00In point? Now, you know, it's hard to you can't really blame
- 49:05a client in this situation. But if I were a little birdie on the
- 49:09client's shoulder, I would say, tell them that you were hospitalized, even
- 49:13though they're not asking you, you know that that's relevant. All right?
- 49:16Going on here? A consent form was signed by the client, meaning that
- 49:22the intern and supervisor said, Hey, can we talk with the psychiatrist?
- 49:29Yes, okay, well you need to sign this, and so for A
- 49:30consent form was signed by the client, permitting the supervisor to request the healthcare
- 49:36information record from the treating psychiatrist. The record request was sent to the psychiatry
- 49:40office. However, due to an administrative error, the records were not received
- 49:46by the agency, and neither the intern nor the supervisor followed up to ensure
- 49:52receipt of the records. I wouldn't it wouldn't be unusual for an intern and
- 49:57a supervisor to have collectively like hundreds of clients you know that they're treating,
- 50:02and you can't be expected to keep track of all the little details, and
- 50:07you know, you're running around client to client, and then you know,
- 50:10you sit down. When I did this kind of work full time, a
- 50:15client would walk into my office at the agency and I'd be like, oh,
- 50:17it's it's that client. I wouldn't even know which client because I was
- 50:22just so frazzled all the time, and then they'd sit down in my office
- 50:27and I would not have thought about them since they left my office. So
- 50:31you know, it was just very stressful and overworked and that kind of thing.
- 50:37So you need to have reminders to look at when you're calm and have
- 50:44the time to be like, oh, yeah, that's right, I need
- 50:45to make sure that I reach out to that psychiatrist. And they didn't do
- 50:49that. And part of the problem is that these this kind of labor,
- 50:54the labor involved in tracking these records down, we are often not paid for
- 51:01it, and we can't necessarily bill for it, and thus there's not a
- 51:07lot of yelling at us to make sure that we do it, and there's
- 51:12not a lot of attention given to these kinds of things. And you know,
- 51:19we call this like collateral contact, and I've seen a lot of clinicians
- 51:25neglect this area unfortunately. All right, so let's take a break, we
- 51:30get back. I'll continue back from the break. Another thing along these lines
- 51:38of what I was saying earlier is that the psychiatrist also could have done better
- 51:45by reaching out to the intern and the supervisor after getting the consent form.
- 51:53So if you're the psychiatrist, you aren't necessarily monitor in the situation closely,
- 52:00but hopefully you're concerned about this client, and so when you receive this release
- 52:07of information, you're like, oh, okay, good, my client that
- 52:12was recently hospitalized is connected with a counselor. Now that's great, and they're
- 52:16requesting the health record. Okay, I'm going to send over the written record,
- 52:22and you know it's pretty limited, the written record, so I am
- 52:29going as a psychiatrist, I should one make sure they received that and to
- 52:35just have a conversation for ten minutes over the phone, to let them know
- 52:40the highlights and to just connect so that you know, we can confer a
- 52:45lot of times with collateral contacts. For me, the initial conversation is just
- 52:53an introduction. It's just a hey, I've got your number, I now
- 52:58know the best way to contact you, what's the best email for you?
- 53:01You know that kind of stuff. And then having that already established it makes
- 53:06both of us a lot more likely to reach out to each other when there
- 53:09are concerns, whereas if you just don't have that introduction, sometimes it just
- 53:15feels like a hassle in the moment and people will avoid it anyway. Going
- 53:20on with the brief, all right, So two days following the initial assessment,
- 53:24the client initiated counseling with the intern. All right, So that's good,
- 53:30right there is that for It took three weeks for the client to call
- 53:35the agency, it took another two weeks to find a time for the assessment.
- 53:39But two days following the initial assessment, the client is in session with
- 53:45the intern, So pretty pretty quick turnaround. That tells me the intern had
- 53:51a lot of space in her schedule going on here, and the client continued
- 53:57to participate in weekly counseling sessions over the course of a two month period.
- 54:01During these sessions, the intern utilized techniques such as rapport building active listening.
- 54:08The in turn, incorporated the client's passion for music into the counseling techniques.
- 54:15These techniques enabled the client to communicate her emotions through the use of lyrics.
- 54:21So just chiming in this all sounds great. Building rapport active listening, the
- 54:25intern is entering the client's world of music and lyrics, and the client is
- 54:34finding it easier to communicate about things through lyrics, maybe songs that she had
- 54:39written or something, So things are looking good in that area. Approximately two
- 54:46weeks after the initial counseling session, the supervisor reviewed the intern's progress notes.
- 54:54So I'm guessing this is two sessions of review that the supervisor is doing.
- 55:01The supervisor identified that the interurn was not performing suicide risk assessments. The supervisor
- 55:09emailed the intern and advised that a suicide risk assessment should be performed at each
- 55:15session based on the client's prior history of bipolar. All right, So when
- 55:19I get to this point in the brief, I'm thinking, so they do
- 55:22know that there's a history of bipolar. The only way they would, since
- 55:27they never got the records from the psychiatrist, would be from the client.
- 55:31So what I'm hearing is the client told the intern and the supervisor, I
- 55:37have a history of bipolar. So that's what it says to me. But
- 55:43anyway, going on, the supervisor also communicated detailed destructions about how to assess
- 55:46suicidality. Based on the feedback received from the supervisor, the interurn conducted suicide
- 55:52risk assessments at each future counseling session and noted that the client denied suicidal adiation.
- 55:57All right, So just summarizing this, the supervisor reviewed the record,
- 56:02didn't have a conversation with the intern, just reviewed the progress notes and noted
- 56:09that the intern was not conducting a suicide assessment. Now, under normal circumstances,
- 56:17if someone had a distant history of suicidal thoughts but didn't have any recent
- 56:23suicidal thoughts and had never attempted, it wouldn't be, in my book,
- 56:30a necessity to ask every single session. But given the bipolar that's when the
- 56:37supervisor says, well, regardless, you still need to be assessing. So
- 56:42that was a good, good indication there. But we're hearing the way that
- 56:46the supervisor the supervision is being done. We're hearing email, reading of progress
- 56:52notes, that kind of thing, because typically the way supervision is conducted is
- 56:59in person, in one on one meetings where particularly for interns, but really
- 57:05at any level. Every supervis I've worked with, I meet with them one
- 57:08on one for an hour and we talk about their cases and their development,
- 57:15and we talk about deficits and their you know, the supervisor's learning, and
- 57:19we talk about technique and personal development and self awareness and counter transference and career
- 57:24and their their personal life stresses that might affect them them and also their work
- 57:32with clients. Blah blah blah. So we're hearing email and reading of progresses,
- 57:38all right, and then the supervisor in a good move says no suicide
- 57:45risk assessment. You need to do that. In the intern said, okay,
- 57:46I'll do that. In the intern started to do that in recession.
- 57:50All right. The standard of care is that, so I'm back to reading.
- 57:55The standard of care is that supervisors meet regularly with supervises to monitor their
- 58:00work. Again, like I said, once a week, but usually what
- 58:06I see the interns that I work with, they have a one on one
- 58:10supervision meeting with their on site supervisor. So I'm at the university and I
- 58:15have a class that's three hours a week, and the class is usually around
- 58:22six students, sometimes less, and we talk as a group about their cases
- 58:30and development as a therapist. And the intern in my class also, you
- 58:37know, because the intern at a site like an agency, and that agency
- 58:42as a supervisor that's supervising them as well, and the supervising is getting group
- 58:47supervision on site as well. So the intern both meets one on one with
- 58:52their supervisor, and the supervisor will hold a group supervision for all of the
- 58:58interns or a group of the interns at that site. So the intern is
- 59:02getting two hours of supervision at the site, and they're getting three hours of
- 59:07supervision a week from me. So that's five hours. Now at the very
- 59:13least there, you should get at least one hour of supervision every week.
- 59:19But like I said, two hours is better. Really, especially in the
- 59:22beginning, the intern needs a number of hours. And what I will say
- 59:29is in the work that I do. When my interns are getting five hours
- 59:34of supervision a week and then sometimes I'll meet with them outside of class,
- 59:37which would be another portion of time those five hours, it's still not enough
- 59:44because these interns, you know, they've learned a lot up until that point
- 59:50before they started their internship, but there's just so much to learn, and
- 59:54it's one thing to read about it in a book, it's another thing to
- 59:58do it. So so they're saying, you know, the standard of care
- 1:00:02is that supervisors meet regularly with supervisors to monitor their work. You know,
- 1:00:07they don't lay out exactly what that means, but to me, it means
- 1:00:10at least once a week, if not much more. However, the supervisor
- 1:00:15conducted all supervisory communications with the intern via email, and there were no regularly
- 1:00:21scheduled supervisory meetings. So just chiming, all right, So all of the
- 1:00:27supervision was conducted over email. That is, you know, there are a
- 1:00:36lot of things you can do over email. You could schedule all appointment,
- 1:00:39you could send a happy birthday, you could coordinate a party or something.
- 1:00:47You cannot provide supervision over email. It's just you know, some details of
- 1:00:53supervision maybe, but you're never going to be able to supervise someone even sufficiently
- 1:01:01over email. It's just not possible. So we're hearing that. Yikes,
- 1:01:07going on. The agency owner did not establish or implement formal policies delineating supervisory
- 1:01:14requirements. See. The owner also did not institute a process of handling client
- 1:01:19emergency site situations. All right, So just chiming in here. So the
- 1:01:22owner is responsible for the policies of the agency that the supervisor works at.
- 1:01:32It could be argued like, and who knows what the situation was. It's
- 1:01:36possible that the supervisor was asking the owner, Hey, I need more time.
- 1:01:42You need to because because it's money. Is the problem is that in
- 1:01:45order to provide the interns that I work with with five hours of supervision,
- 1:01:51well, all of those hours of supervision has to be paid for by somebody,
- 1:01:55right, and time is money. So when you're a profit oriented or
- 1:02:05you know, concerned about money the bottom line, sometimes one of the corners
- 1:02:10that will be cut will be supervision time. It should never be cut,
- 1:02:15but you know, it's one of those considerations, you know. The reason
- 1:02:20you know, I was saying that five hours isn't enough, I would say,
- 1:02:24like in a perfect world, and sometimes interns will have this is you
- 1:02:28have those five hours that are laid out, but they also have the ability
- 1:02:31to in the moment or very quickly access one of their supervisors, whether it's
- 1:02:37me or their on site supervisor, to just ask small questions and big questions.
- 1:02:43You know, like they just got out of session and they don't have
- 1:02:45supervision for another few days, they can call or bop into, you know,
- 1:02:50their supervisor's office and ask them a question. Some interns will have that,
- 1:02:53but usually they don't. So to allow for that, you have to
- 1:02:59have the supervisor just sitting there doing nothing, and that's money, and the
- 1:03:05supervisor could be doing something else. They could be treating their own clients,
- 1:03:07you know, and that generates revenue. Supervision generally doesn't generate any revenue.
- 1:03:14Right, Yeah, it's complicated, But the point is that the owner might
- 1:03:21have been telling the supervisor you need to limit your time because you have to
- 1:03:28do all these other tasks. You have to limit your supervision time of this
- 1:03:30intern and the supervisor at all. Likely that had a number of other interns
- 1:03:34as well. So who knows. But I don't know who to blame now,
- 1:03:42I will say that for me as a supervisor, I have been in
- 1:03:46this. You know, normally as a supervisor, the majority of my supervision
- 1:03:51was done in two venues. One is that I was at the university.
- 1:03:53I would have a small group of interns that I would meet with for three
- 1:03:59hours a week and it would be group supervision that I would just occasionally do
- 1:04:03one on one supervision with all them. That was one venue. The other
- 1:04:08venue was I would supervise postgrad therapists, people who had graduated. And to
- 1:04:14get your license you need to have a certain number of hours of client time
- 1:04:17and a certain number of hours of supervision times. So people would hire me
- 1:04:21to meet that requirement. Also, I think also to hire me just because
- 1:04:26they wanted further help regarding their clinical work right, and so I would be
- 1:04:32providing that service to them. But occasionally agencies would hire me to provide supervision
- 1:04:39for their staff therapists and or their interns. And there have been times when
- 1:04:45these organizations hiring me will not give me enough time and space to adequately,
- 1:04:54even at a minimum level, provide supervision for those clinicians. And at first
- 1:05:00I'll try to make it work, but if it if I feel like I
- 1:05:03mean, there's two there's two considerations that I have in the situations. One
- 1:05:08is that what if a client is harmed and or you know, what's what
- 1:05:12if a clinician? What if? What if one of what if one of
- 1:05:15my supervises is left out on the lurch and I didn't have enough time to
- 1:05:17help them? But two, what if I get sued? Because if I
- 1:05:24don't have enough time to monitor and assist and guide these supervises, then stuff's
- 1:05:31going to start falling through the cracks. A client is going to get harmed,
- 1:05:35the you know, the family, or the client's going to sue the
- 1:05:40therapist, and then I'm going to get dragged into it because I'm the supervisor
- 1:05:43and I should have been doing something. You know, and I don't want
- 1:05:48that to happen. I don't want either one to happen. I don't want
- 1:05:50a client to be harmed. I don't want one of my supervisors to be
- 1:05:53harmed. And I don't want to get harmed. So what I will do
- 1:05:57is I and and really it's just a matter of principle, is I will
- 1:06:00go to the powers that be and I'll say, either you allocate more funds
- 1:06:05and time for me to adequately supervise, or I quit. And I've I've
- 1:06:12had to push back sometimes. And there's a lot of other stories I could
- 1:06:17tell you, not only just in that role, but in other kinds of
- 1:06:20roles. We don't know. We don't know if the supervisor wanted more time
- 1:06:25and wasn't given it. We don't know if the supervisor was allowed more time
- 1:06:28but just didn't use it. But we're hearing that the supervisor is doing all
- 1:06:32of their supervision over email, which is just completely unacceptable. We're also hearing
- 1:06:40that the owner had no established formal policy about how much supervision needs to occur,
- 1:06:48which typically would be the case you would have a policy that says you
- 1:06:51must meet one on one. I mean a lot of times agencies, they
- 1:06:57don't want to be sued, and they also want they do want to provide
- 1:07:02a good service to their clients at the very least out of altruism and at
- 1:07:08another level a matter of marketing. Right, you don't want a bad YELP
- 1:07:12review. And part of it has to do with oversight of your workers,
- 1:07:14and so agencies usually are in the business of telling interns, look, you
- 1:07:18have to meet with your supervisor every week. Don't because sometimes an intern will
- 1:07:24cancel a supervision meeting because they're busy or whatever, and then the agency will
- 1:07:30crack down on the intern and say, no, no, no, you
- 1:07:32can't. You got to reschedule it the next day because you need to.
- 1:07:36There's a lot of different attitudes about this, and we're hearing about this agency
- 1:07:42owner. Is there there was no policy, just like up in the air,
- 1:07:45and it was unofficial or hadn't been thought about or something. Maybe it
- 1:07:49was a new business I don't know. The other detail here, which will
- 1:07:54come into play later, is the owner had no policy about to about how
- 1:07:59to handle clients emergencies, which is just amateur hour. I mean, that
- 1:08:03should be the first thing that you have a alble to. Also, you
- 1:08:09don't have to invent the wheel or reinvent the wheel. Crisis emergency policy and
- 1:08:15plans are well established. You could probably just google it and find a dozen
- 1:08:20examples and then just maybe modify it slightly or just use that because you know
- 1:08:28it's not You don't have to think about it much. You could just say,
- 1:08:30let's it wouldn't take long, is the point. The problem, and
- 1:08:34I don't know is that that requires time and energy, and if you're trying
- 1:08:42to cut corners, you might cut that corner, all right. Going on
- 1:08:45the day before the tenth counseling appointment, the Interurn received several texts and voicemails
- 1:08:51from the client containing pressured speech with erratic and disorganized thought patterns in a lyrical
- 1:08:57format. All right, so it's just chiming. Sounds like mania, right,
- 1:09:01and remember her history of mania, but also her history of non compliance
- 1:09:05with medication. We don't know it wasn't told to us in the brief,
- 1:09:11but it's quite possible that she never took the medication upon discharge. It's unclear
- 1:09:20if she was suffering from a substituse disorder, given the fact that she hasn't
- 1:09:25received any sort of substance use treatment. In all likelihood she was still using
- 1:09:28whatever she was using. But anyway, so the day before the tenth counseling
- 1:09:31appointment, the intern receives a bunch of texts and voicemails from the client that
- 1:09:38are disorganized, erratic, and are communicated in a lyrical format in reference to
- 1:09:45the content of the sessions that the therapists and client had established. So pressured
- 1:09:54speech, okay, sound sounds like mania is occurring. So the intern,
- 1:09:59upon getting this, was concerned, and the intern shared the texts and voicemails
- 1:10:04with the supervisor. So in turn, two thumbs up. That's that's great.
- 1:10:11It sounds like an obvious thing to do. But I've had interns and
- 1:10:14superviss that never did this, and then a couple of weeks later they'll tell
- 1:10:19me, oh, yeah, this thing happened to be. Like remember our
- 1:10:24talk about inform. Ninety nine percent of the superviss that I've worked with are
- 1:10:30on the ball, responsible, lovely individuals, but you know, occasionally,
- 1:10:35So this in turn immediately reached you know, contact supervisor, informed them,
- 1:10:41giving the supervisor all the information they need to act appropriately. Going on,
- 1:10:46The supervisor advised the intern that she could address these communications at the next scheduled
- 1:10:53appointment, and that no immediate action was necessary. All right, So,
- 1:11:00given that this is a brief from my malpractice insurance will assume that this and
- 1:11:05I've already read ahead, will assume that this story doesn't end well. But
- 1:11:11the vast majority of situations, if you're faced, you know, if you're
- 1:11:15faced as a supervisor, if you face one hundred of these situations, ninety
- 1:11:18nine of them will not result in anything bad happening. So, you know,
- 1:11:25just think about what the supervisor knows at this point. Well, one,
- 1:11:30they've had zero communication with the psychiatrists. They don't know about the hospitalization,
- 1:11:36but theyume they presumably would have found out about it if they actually had
- 1:11:41that communication with the psychiatrist. So the supervisor doesn't know anything. Probably only
- 1:11:49knows what the client said, which I'm guessing was I have bipolar and I
- 1:11:54have a psychiatrist, and I have medications or something. And the supervisor also
- 1:12:00knows from the client that the client reports no current or recent suicidal thoughts.
- 1:12:06Okay, and no means no plan. I'm assuming no previous attempt because a
- 1:12:11previous attempt is a huge risk factor in a future attempt. According to research.
- 1:12:17So the supervisor doesn't have any reason to believe that suicide is imminent,
- 1:12:28and these texts and voicemails don't indicate any kind of suicidal thoughts. It's just
- 1:12:33garbled, psychotic, pressured speech. Right now, you're hearing what sounds to
- 1:12:43be like a client that is in full mania, possibly psychotic, that carries
- 1:12:48with at a certain amount of risk, right And you wouldn't. I wouldn't
- 1:12:54if I were that supervisor, I wouldn't say, you know, like,
- 1:12:57the way that the supervisor reacted is something that we will do as clinicians and
- 1:13:03as supervisors, often not in this situation, but like, it's not uncommon,
- 1:13:10particularly given that most clients can communicate to their therapists via email or text,
- 1:13:16It's not uncommon for a client to occasionally or frequently have, you know,
- 1:13:25disclose something or inform the therapist about what's going on with them outside of
- 1:13:30therapy, you know, like a client, I'm just trying to think.
- 1:13:36Okay, So let's say you're treating client and it's been six months, and
- 1:13:41then I'm the therapist. I'm treating this client, and then in between sessions,
- 1:13:45I get this email and it's it's very long, and it starts out
- 1:13:50by saying, Hey, you know, my husband left me suddenly and I
- 1:13:58don't know what's happening. Is a cheat on me, you know, And
- 1:14:00it's just a lot of a lot of thoughts, right, And if there's
- 1:14:05no reason to believe there's an emergency or any kind of risk or red flag,
- 1:14:13then a common response for me, as a matter of policy, because
- 1:14:16it's written in my disclosure, is I will reply back and I'll be brief.
- 1:14:24I'll say something to the effect of I appreciate what you're going through,
- 1:14:29I'm so sorry this is happening. We will definitely get into this in our
- 1:14:33next session, And when the client comes to the next session, I might
- 1:14:38say, would you like me to read the email out loud now? Would
- 1:14:42you like to read it? Or do you just want to or you just
- 1:14:44want to tell me what happened verbally. The reason why I do this is
- 1:14:47because I have learned that if I, as a policy, entertained those kinds
- 1:14:57of emails, then with a very small minority of clients, it's very rare
- 1:15:02that this would happen. But with those clients, they will email frequently,
- 1:15:08maybe even every day, and they'll be very long. You know, if,
- 1:15:11for example, with certain clients, if I were to reply in a
- 1:15:15very lengthy way, they might reply back in a lengthy way. And so
- 1:15:20and I'm not saying that's bad. It just means you have to consider that
- 1:15:26possibility as a therapist when you have these kinds of policies. So unless there's
- 1:15:30an emergency, and sometimes with some clients, if it's particularly long and I'm
- 1:15:35particularly busy, I might even reply back. I might even say I'm sorry,
- 1:15:42I'm super busy with work. I only had time to read the first
- 1:15:45three sentences, so I didn't have any time to read the rest. If
- 1:15:49you are in an emergency, you need to call nine one one, or
- 1:15:53follow a safety plan or email back to me with like a one sentence.
- 1:15:59Is there a question in Here's you know, just some kind of you know,
- 1:16:02cut to the chase please kind of a thing. And of course this
- 1:16:06all has to be considered within uh, you know, the capacity of their
- 1:16:11relationship to handle this kind of blow. And of course I've learned over time
- 1:16:15that I need to inform people in the beginning of therapy along these lines.
- 1:16:18You know, I'll tell them right up front. I'll say, like,
- 1:16:20my policy is this about emails and texts, and so if this happens,
- 1:16:24this is what I'm going to do, you know, just so that if
- 1:16:27it does happen, I'll remember when I talked about that in the datada anyway,
- 1:16:30So it's not unusual as me as a supervisor to tell an intern a
- 1:16:35supervise okay, because you know the supervise. Often they are in a new
- 1:16:42they don't know what their policy is yet, or they're worried about crises,
- 1:16:47you know, naturally, but they don't know how to detect what a real
- 1:16:50crisis is. So they'll reach out to me like, oh my god,
- 1:16:53I got these emails, and I'll look it over and sometimes I'll just say,
- 1:16:58well, I don't see any reason to worry about a safety concern.
- 1:17:03So what my recommendation is is that you want to draw a bit of a
- 1:17:08boundary here, not because you want to be a dick, but just because
- 1:17:12you can't. Once you open that door, you might get it might open
- 1:17:15the floodgates to an expectation that you are basically available twenty four to seven,
- 1:17:23and that's not good for you, it's potentially not good for the client as
- 1:17:27well. So you want to reply back with empathy and say you'll definitely talk
- 1:17:33about it in the next scheduled session, so that it sounds like that.
- 1:17:36So they did, that's what the supervisor did. But given even what the
- 1:17:42supervisor knows, but also the supervisor should have a question mark here of we
- 1:17:46don't know what the psychiatrist would say, We only know information from the client.
- 1:17:54What if the psychiatrist would tell us that this person is an in grave
- 1:17:57danger of something just don't even know, So we need to play it safe
- 1:18:02by addressing this more rigorously. And as a supervisor, upon looking at the
- 1:18:10record, they should be kicking themselves for letting ten weeks go by without having
- 1:18:15confirmed communication with the psychiatrist. But that anyway, so if we just go
- 1:18:21off of if we just enter the mind of the supervisor, supervisor, well,
- 1:18:30I'm guessing this. If we assume the supervisor doesn't consider supervision to be
- 1:18:36as important as they should, and evidence of that is doing supervision over email.
- 1:18:45And if we consider that, then the supervisor is probably fairly hands off
- 1:18:53and doesn't have the fear of God in them so to speak. You know,
- 1:18:58they don't they don't worry about danger or risk or being sued or something
- 1:19:02you know, so it wasn't motivating them, and they're just like, Okay,
- 1:19:08well, what do I know? Well, we know that the client
- 1:19:11has indicated no indication of suicidal thoughts, so and there's no new and the
- 1:19:17intern has been assessing that every session. So there's that we know the client
- 1:19:24as a history of and current symptoms of schizophrenia and psychosis, and we're well,
- 1:19:30I mean, hopefully the supervisor immediately recognized a strong possibility of mania.
- 1:19:36And it's just strange that under any circumstance, if if if if I had
- 1:19:45an intern that told that presented me information that their client was in the midst
- 1:19:50of a spike in mania, I would I well, well one, So
- 1:19:56so then we have to talk about safety planning. In the the very first
- 1:20:00session the assessment, presumably the client tells the intern in the supervisor that she
- 1:20:04has a history of bipolar because we hear that in the brief later and they
- 1:20:10did diagnose with this unspecified schizophrenias with psychosis. So right off the bat,
- 1:20:15either session one or session two, definitely, by the end of session two,
- 1:20:19a safety plan should be established about symptom management and about safety management that
- 1:20:27okay, if these symptoms start to occur. This is what you will do.
- 1:20:31You will call your psychiatrist, you will call us, you will engage
- 1:20:38with your support system. You will go to the hospital. You will call
- 1:20:42that one. You know, there would be a safety plan. I mean,
- 1:20:45safety plans aren't just for suicide. They're also for homicidal ideation. But
- 1:20:49they're also for these kinds of situations because as a clinician, the chance that
- 1:20:56you're going to be in session as these things are happening is very slim.
- 1:21:00The things are going to happen outside of session, and you're responsible for doing
- 1:21:05what you can to reduce harm outside of the session as well. And so
- 1:21:10when you hear these these symptoms, a safety plan should have been should have
- 1:21:15been established, But we don't hear that because when I think about what the
- 1:21:19supervisor should have done in this moment, if they don't have a safety plan,
- 1:21:24there's not a lot the supervisor can do. You know, the supervisor
- 1:21:28could tell the intern Okay, you're getting these texts and voicemails, you know,
- 1:21:32interurn of mind, you need to schedule an emergency appointment with this client.
- 1:21:38Well, given the client is so disorganized, is what's the likelihood that
- 1:21:43the client is even going to be able to make an appointment, you know,
- 1:21:46establish one and actually show up for it. So it's hard to you
- 1:21:51know, corral a situation that you didn't do any prep for anyway. Going
- 1:21:57on. Based upon this advice, the intern told the client that they would
- 1:22:00discuss any new issues at their upcoming counseling appointment in two days. Notably,
- 1:22:05the intern later testified that she was not aware of the association between pressured speech
- 1:22:13patterns and manic episodes. So just shoving here so later, because you know,
- 1:22:15this goes downhill, the interurn testified that, you know, hey,
- 1:22:21I didn't know what I was seeing. I now know we call that pressured
- 1:22:29speech. I also now know that that's associated with with mania. I didn't
- 1:22:34know that at the time. Now, for some people reading that or hearing
- 1:22:38about that, that might they might think, wait, so you have a
- 1:22:41clinician that doesn't know that pressured speech is a symptom of mania, particularly when
- 1:22:46the client presented with a history, you know, stating that they have a
- 1:22:51history of bipolar presumably and also showing signs of psychosis cprhinia. You didn't know
- 1:22:58that pressured speech is a component of media. Okay, So On one hand,
- 1:23:01yes, that isn't great, but it's not uncommon. That's why,
- 1:23:06especially new interns need very close oversight. You know, the intern might have
- 1:23:13learned it but forgot it. You know, there's a lot of information that
- 1:23:17students are trying to retain and some of it's going to go. Also,
- 1:23:23learning occurs with repetition, particularly when you're finally in front of clients and you're
- 1:23:29not just reading about it in a book or watching an actor in a vignette
- 1:23:33DVD or whatever. They probably don't use DVDs anymore. But anyway, so
- 1:23:41the intern didn't know that, and you know, but the supervisor saw the
- 1:23:47emails or you know, saw the texts and listened to the voicemails. Surely
- 1:23:53the supervisor should have done anyway. Going on later that evening, the intern
- 1:23:57received an email from the client's boyfriend. So this is just later that day,
- 1:24:01so earlier in the day, texts and voicemails, pressured speech lyrics doa
- 1:24:08data supervisor. The intern reaches out. Supervisor. Supervisor says, I just
- 1:24:13wait till your next session. It's in a couple of days. Later that
- 1:24:15evening, the intern receives an email from the client's boyfriend. He stated that
- 1:24:21the client was exhibiting manic behavior use the word manic. He also stated that
- 1:24:29he was concerned for her safety. All right, So just chem me in
- 1:24:32here. I know from the later in the brief that the boyfriend and the
- 1:24:40therapist the intern had never communicated before. So this is out of the blue.
- 1:24:45And what I'll tell you is from my personal experience and also upon reading
- 1:24:49a lot of these briefs, is that this is a huge red flag that
- 1:24:54needs to be paid very close attention to. I mean, there's already been
- 1:24:57red flags, but when you have a family member that reaches out to you
- 1:25:01out of the blue and says, I'm worried about my person in my life
- 1:25:10such that I'm actually contacting you know, I figured out how to contact their
- 1:25:14therapist, and I'm telling you something's going on here. If you because people
- 1:25:18almost there's a high bar for people to do something like that. So if
- 1:25:21someone's going to do something like that, then that's a that is a sure
- 1:25:30indication that the risk is a lot higher than otherwise. Also, just from
- 1:25:36a liability standpoint, if you have a family member that is reaching out to
- 1:25:42you and you drop the ball, then the family member is like, my
- 1:25:46god, I called you and told you and you did nothing or you didn't
- 1:25:53do enough. So you know, it's just something to think about. You
- 1:25:58know, first priority is the moral responsibility that we have to humans such as
- 1:26:04our clients. But you know, secondarily is the concern of just your own,
- 1:26:09your own skin as a clinician going on. The client's boyfriend also said
- 1:26:15that he did not believe that the client knew who to contact. The client's
- 1:26:21boyfriend also said that he didn't believe that the client knew who to contact in
- 1:26:25an emergency. He said that he had to search through the client's computer to
- 1:26:29find the entrance email address. So just shining in here. So the boyfriend
- 1:26:33is saying, I don't know if my girlfriend even knows what she's supposed to
- 1:26:42do if she is having an emergency. So what that tells us is more
- 1:26:46information in the direction that there was no safety plan, no discussion of what
- 1:26:53to do in a crisis. And this really just drives me nuts. And
- 1:26:57also the safety point and should have involved the boyfriend from the beginning. That's
- 1:27:03what I do almost all the time, and if I'm not doing it,
- 1:27:08it's because there is no one in the client's life, or the client is
- 1:27:11refusing, you know, maybe for good reasons that they don't want their partner
- 1:27:15or their family member or one of their parents involved. But I find the
- 1:27:23single most important thing that can help me sleep at night with certain clients is
- 1:27:27if I have a family member involved in the safety monitoring and implementation. So
- 1:27:35I do everything I can to try to convince the client if they're resistant to,
- 1:27:40you know, involving someone in their life, because that person's there twenty
- 1:27:44four seven in a way that I can't be anyway. Also, as a
- 1:27:48secondary thing, just as a savior own ass kind of a thing, is
- 1:27:54that if the family is involved in the monitor and they know as much information
- 1:28:01as you do relevant to the safety concern, then if something bad does happen,
- 1:28:09like suicide, then the family won't They probably won't blame you because you
- 1:28:14were communicative with them and you were letting them know and giving them the tools
- 1:28:19and giving them recommendations about what to do under such circumstances. So if something
- 1:28:27bad happens, they're not going to think that you drop the ball, because
- 1:28:30they have a lot of evidence showing that you were doing everything you could.
- 1:28:34Anyway. Going on shortly after reading this email, the intern was no,
- 1:28:41doube okay, So you have earlier in the day, you know, the
- 1:28:45lyrics, the voicemails, the texts. Intern reaches that supervisor. Then the
- 1:28:48boyfriend calls and the interns like, now, we don't know what the intern
- 1:28:53was thinking at that point, But shortly after reading this email from the boyfriend,
- 1:28:58the intern was notified by the client's family that the client had died by
- 1:29:01suicide. So that's what happens. And it's I'm only laughing because I'm uncomfortable,
- 1:29:10but it's awful. It's awful. It's awful. It's awful. If
- 1:29:14I'm going to take a guess, I'm going to say that you had a
- 1:29:17woman who was developing bipolar throughout her thirties, had shown signs. It's a
- 1:29:28pretty typical course of bipolar you know, maybe late teens, early twenties.
- 1:29:32There's there's a little bit of depression, a little bit of mania. It
- 1:29:38gets worse over time. She turns thirty, and the symptoms become much more
- 1:29:44severe, much more noticeable. She ends up in the hospital, and she's
- 1:29:48new to treatment and medication or relatively new, and is kind of reeling from
- 1:29:59the whole experience and maybe even takes the medication they antipsychotic medication, and doesn't
- 1:30:04like the side effects. They often do carry with them, some very unpleasant
- 1:30:09side effects, and so the client's like, oh, no, I can
- 1:30:14handle this. I don't need the medication, or I don't need therapy.
- 1:30:17I just need to get my life in order or something. And then you
- 1:30:23know, she complies by getting a counselor who knows what she was doing with
- 1:30:27the medication, and she did not know that it was going to happen again,
- 1:30:35and then it happened again, and then who knows what sort of you
- 1:30:40know, step by step resulted in her killing herself. You could argue that
- 1:30:45the intern should have done more than just listen and build rapport. That the
- 1:30:51intern should have been advised to talk with the client about adherents and compliance and
- 1:30:58also the risks. So that's that's what I've done whenever I have a client,
- 1:31:01particularly and I don't know where. You know, maybe this client with
- 1:31:04bipolar had been diagnosed ten years prior, but that wouldn't be normal. The
- 1:31:10way it sounds, it sounds like it's a relatively new It could have been
- 1:31:12brand new, or it could have been a year old or something like that.
- 1:31:14It's pretty common for people in the beginning of their diagnosis of bipolar to
- 1:31:20resist accepting it, and so then she died by suicide. If she had
- 1:31:28proper treatment, there's a good chance they would have been able to get her
- 1:31:32through this difficult time and she could have emerged on the other side of this
- 1:31:39initial phase of treatment with an acceptance of the diagnosis and an adherence to the
- 1:31:46treatment regimen. A grieving process is often involved in the acceptance that you have
- 1:31:53this ongoing severe mental condition and you're just going to have to live with the
- 1:32:00side effects of the medications for the rest of your life, and the worry
- 1:32:04and also the fallout from the episodes that you've had, and you know,
- 1:32:10there's a lot involved. It's very difficult, but with proper treatment, with
- 1:32:15enough attention, it's quite possible they could have gotten her through that. It's
- 1:32:18also possible that no matter what they did, the intern and the supervisor,
- 1:32:24that she still would have died by suicide. We just don't know. Of
- 1:32:29course, I'm going to assume that the intern was devastated, but I've been
- 1:32:36close to situations like this, and it's not uncommon for an intern in a
- 1:32:41situation like this to consider and even take action to quit their career as a
- 1:32:47clinician because of this. I had a supervisor you once early in my career
- 1:32:55who had a stressful situation on the job and she quit as she just you
- 1:33:02know, she was almost to graduation and she's like, yeah, I can't
- 1:33:06handle this. Well. I'll tell you specifically. What happened was we were
- 1:33:12doing a group therapy with teenagers in the agency, and it was a house
- 1:33:18that was converted into an agency, and so we're in the back of the
- 1:33:23house and there was a back door and a boy, a random teenage boy,
- 1:33:28walks in through the back door and identifies one of the girls in the
- 1:33:31group their boyfriend girlfriend. And then the girlfriend is like oh, and they
- 1:33:38leave together. You know. The boyfriend's like, hey, I don't know,
- 1:33:43I'm trying to remember what the this is literally twenty five years ago.
- 1:33:46But the I think the boyfriend was just like, Hey, you're no longer
- 1:33:51under the thumb of your parents. They're not around right now. How about
- 1:33:55we use this opportunity to skip out and get some time together or something.
- 1:33:59And the girl friends like, yay, let's do that. So she leaves
- 1:34:02and I'm in the beginning of my career, but I don't know, situations
- 1:34:06like that just don't really rattle me. But my my co therapists was an
- 1:34:12intern that I was supervising in that capacity, and you know, I immediately
- 1:34:18called the well one. I looked. The intern is looking at me,
- 1:34:23like what do we do? And I'm like, you don't have to do
- 1:34:25anything. You're the intern. This is my job, so you know,
- 1:34:29observe, I guess. So I called the police, and I called the
- 1:34:31parents, and I gave a description to the police about the situation, and
- 1:34:39and then we continue to monitor it. The parents would give us updates that
- 1:34:43they hadn't seen her, and it was several hours later and we still hadn't
- 1:34:49uh, you know, the girl hadn't shown up yet. And I'm thinking,
- 1:34:56well, you know, they're probably just smoking weed and making out in
- 1:35:00a car or something. You know, it's it's the most likely situation.
- 1:35:05It's not great, But what am I supposed to do. I can't chase
- 1:35:11her or tackle her, or chain her to her chair or search the neighborhood
- 1:35:15for you know, like, I'm limited in what I can do. So
- 1:35:23if I if something bad happens, I don't think this could possibly be my
- 1:35:28fault. I'm you know, I'm worried about this teenager but uh, you
- 1:35:36know, I'll use that worry to motivate me to document, well, consult
- 1:35:42with a colleague. But then you know that that's that's the end of the
- 1:35:45line in terms of the options. The intern, she was very stressed out
- 1:35:49about it. She was stressed out about it over overnight. I think we
- 1:35:54might have talked about it later that evening, after our shift, maybe the
- 1:35:58next day or something, and she's like, what don't understand, Like,
- 1:36:00what are we supposed to do? And you know, in the end,
- 1:36:03everything was fine. I don't know what the teenager girl was doing, but
- 1:36:09from my memory it was something like that. It was like, well,
- 1:36:11let's just assume they were. You know, she showed up the next day
- 1:36:14or something, and you know, she was probably just making out with the
- 1:36:16guy or so. I don't know. And the intern it was a long
- 1:36:21time ago, but she eventually told me that that experience was so stressful to
- 1:36:29her that she realized that she could not be a clinician and she dropped out.
- 1:36:33So, you know, this could be and that's that situation. Imagine
- 1:36:40what this intern went through a new intern maybe in the you know, the
- 1:36:44first couple of months of their career, and they have a client that dies,
- 1:36:48and it's possible that the intern is part partly to blame that they didn't
- 1:36:56do enough right the supervisor. Take guess is also but that besides themselves.
- 1:37:01You know, people get into this career not because they're just trying to pass
- 1:37:06the time. You know, they're trying to help people. And to have
- 1:37:10a suicide happen, and it's possible that you didn't do enough to address it,
- 1:37:16it's devastating. Even when you did everything you could, it's still devastating.
- 1:37:21You still in it blaming yourself. So I'm going to take guess that's
- 1:37:25rough. And then the owner of the agency is also a therapist. I'm
- 1:37:30going to assume that that individual also cared and is very sad, sadened by
- 1:37:36this. Maybe a lot of self blame. Some that's justified, some that's
- 1:37:40not. I don't know, but this is awful. And then if you're
- 1:37:44the boyfriend, if you're the family and you're thinking, we thought our family
- 1:37:49member was under good care, and then when they find out the details are
- 1:37:55like what just it's a very very upsetting situation all around. Okay, So,
- 1:38:03going on several months after the client's death, the client's parents file the
- 1:38:08wrongful death lawsuit asserting that the intern, the supervisor, and the agency owner
- 1:38:12failed to provide appropriate treatment. The treating psychiatrists who worked at the previous agency
- 1:38:19or at the hospital was also named as a defendant in the lawsuit for failing
- 1:38:24to ensure that the client adhere to the medication regimen. So we haven't heard
- 1:38:29much about this side of the lawsuit because the psychiatrist, I'm guessing has a
- 1:38:33different malepractice insurance and therefore this brief doesn't have access to information or whatever.
- 1:38:41But just know that the psychiatrist was also sued by the family saying you didn't
- 1:38:45make sure. You didn't do enough to make sure that she was actually taking
- 1:38:50the medication. Now, some of you might be thinking, well, what
- 1:38:54are we supposed to do. We don't have the power to force people to
- 1:38:57do things, and that is true, but we are responsible for taking reasonable
- 1:39:01actions within our capabilities to increase the likelihood of safety behavior is occurring. So
- 1:39:11if you're a psychiatrist, you can't force someone to take the medication. Under
- 1:39:15most circumstances. But what you can do if you're the psychiatrist is check in
- 1:39:23with the client more often. There's no evidence either way, I'm guessing the
- 1:39:28psychiatrist didn't do that. You could have also made sure that the agency the
- 1:39:33intern had the information. You know, you sent the file over, but
- 1:39:39you never had confirmation that they had received it. Plus you didn't call them
- 1:39:42to have a conversation over the phone. As a psychiatrist, you might even
- 1:39:47consider it your job to make sure that the intern is doing the right thing,
- 1:39:50even though you're not directly a supervisor, but you know, you're a
- 1:39:55senior clinician and you're involved with the client. I mean, I've been that
- 1:39:59way. I've had clients who have psychiatrists who I felt were in over their
- 1:40:05head, and I would reach out to those psychiatrists. I'm not their supervisor,
- 1:40:11but I'd reach out to those psychiatrists and you know, help them to
- 1:40:15get through and understand and get more aligned with what I believed to be the
- 1:40:19treatment path. So, I mean, that's asking a lot, but the
- 1:40:24very least the psychiatrists could could have done more could have had more check ins,
- 1:40:28more, you know, in person check ins to just make sure that
- 1:40:31Medicaid they could have a lobbied for additional hospitalization because of the lack of adherence.
- 1:40:39Anyway, going on the plaintiffs further assertives of the family, they further
- 1:40:45asserted that the agency owner was negligent in failing to implement policies regarding supervision.
- 1:40:53So I've already been over this, but yeah, clearly so. Going on
- 1:41:00the plaintiffs counseling experts. So the family and the lawyers, they hire experts
- 1:41:09to look over the case, to provide insights and guidance, but also potentially
- 1:41:15to testify in court if need be. And these experts looked into it,
- 1:41:19and they said, yeah, the agency should have had policies about supervision and
- 1:41:26they didn't. And yes, the agency should have had policies about after hours
- 1:41:31client emergencies. You know, the experts think, how do you possibly not
- 1:41:36have a policy about after hours emergencies? What's wrong with you? They also
- 1:41:43said that an intern should not have been assigned to this client, or if
- 1:41:49the intern was assigned to this client, the supervisor should have been much closer
- 1:41:56of a supervisor to the situation. Now, to their credit in rescisponts,
- 1:42:00the agency owner and the supervisor said that if they had known about the client's
- 1:42:03recent psychiatric hospitalization, the client would have been assigned not to an intern and
- 1:42:11to licensed counselor. So the agency owner of the supervisors saying, well,
- 1:42:15with the information available to us, we have a client with no prior attempts,
- 1:42:20with a history of suicidal thoughts, which is very common by the way,
- 1:42:26but no current suicidal thoughts. We didn't you know, there's no sign
- 1:42:31there of risk. But given that there was this hospitalization that we didn't know
- 1:42:38about, that would have caused us to take more action. Now, the
- 1:42:43other thing here is, okay, you didn't know that, and that's mostly
- 1:42:47due because due to your negligence, because you didn't make sure that you had
- 1:42:53open line of communication with the psychiatrist going on. The experts for the family
- 1:42:59also said that there should have been an immediate client intervention when the intern reported
- 1:43:05the clients change in condition to the supervisor. So when the intern contacts the
- 1:43:11supervisor that day and says, hey, I got these emails and voicemail,
- 1:43:16and the experts are saying there should have been an immediate response. You know,
- 1:43:19the supervisor either should have done it themselves or the supervisor should have told
- 1:43:24the intern you need to reach out this client right away, blah blah blah
- 1:43:28or whatever, and that what it wasn't done. Now, I'm going to
- 1:43:30take a guess and say that even if that had happened, that the clients
- 1:43:35still would have died by suicide, because if we look at the timeline here,
- 1:43:41we have at some point during the day the intern receives these texts and
- 1:43:46these voicemails. The intern shouldn't be expected to respond on their own to that.
- 1:43:53It takes time to reach out to the supervisor. It takes time for
- 1:43:56the supervisor to have free a free moment in their day because they're doing their
- 1:44:00own appointments, right they get that information, takes time to communicate back.
- 1:44:06By the time that communication happens, and by the time the intern or the
- 1:44:11supervisor does anything. Uh, I'm just going to take a guess and say
- 1:44:15that it's pretty low likelihood because because the client, uh, you know,
- 1:44:20died by suicide that that evening that that day, Now, that's not necessarily
- 1:44:29relevant. You know, earlier when I was saying, you can have the
- 1:44:32same outcome, but different actions that lead up to that outcome, and one
- 1:44:40will be considered unethical and a problem the other one will not. In this
- 1:44:44situation, we see a lot of a lot of neglect and a lot of
- 1:44:49mismanagement, and a lot of bad choices. So it's not a matter of
- 1:44:55whether or not we predict that something could have been done. The fact is
- 1:45:00that if something could have been done, those things were not done, and
- 1:45:05so you know, there's a chance and if everything was done properly from the
- 1:45:11beginning, then there's a you know, a pretty good chance that the client
- 1:45:15wouldn't have been suicidal that day or manic to begin with because of the collaboration
- 1:45:21with the psychiatrist and the non you know, because one of the things that
- 1:45:26could have happened if they were paying better attention, not extreme attention, just
- 1:45:30normal attention, is the intern and supervisor would have told us psychiatrists, look,
- 1:45:35we can't confirm if this client is actually taking the mets, so you're
- 1:45:40going to have to do more. And so the psychiatrit okay. So the
- 1:45:44psychiatrist starts to do more, and then eventually five weeks in, the team
- 1:45:49starts to talk with the client, getting the boyfriend involved, maybe in other
- 1:45:54people, and they say, hey, if you aren't taking your medication,
- 1:45:59then we are going to move towards involuntary hospitalization again because you're at risk of
- 1:46:05hurting yourself and other people with the non compliance. And then, you know,
- 1:46:10sometimes that's that's what a client needs to hear before they're like okay,
- 1:46:14fine, and then they take it, and then they get used to it,
- 1:46:16and then they're like, okay, maybe medications. You know, there's
- 1:46:19a lot of different paths for that could have helped anyway. Going on.
- 1:46:25The defense experts, so the agency and these are experts that would be working
- 1:46:31close with the malpractice insurance that I have, that is the defense experts.
- 1:46:36They said that the client did not exhibit suicidal ideation. So the defense people
- 1:46:44are like, okay, when we look into it, we see, yes,
- 1:46:47it is true. The intern and the supervisor are in the right by
- 1:46:53asserting, okay, we had a client that died by suicide, but there
- 1:46:57was no indication of suicidal thought prior to that. So what were we supposed
- 1:47:03to do? And the intern was assessing that every session. Now we don't
- 1:47:09know the adequacy to that assessment, but given the fact that there wasn't any
- 1:47:15ideation, the fact that the intern was asking at all is actually going above
- 1:47:19and beyond what other people would do. So the defense is like, it's
- 1:47:25like, well, we have a good defense that the client had not indicated
- 1:47:29any suicidal thoughts prior to that. However, the experts were critical of the
- 1:47:34intern and the supervisor for failing to obtain the client's psychiatric medical records. Also,
- 1:47:43as is the case with a lot of these cases that I read on
- 1:47:45the podcast, the documentation for both the intern and the supervisor was insufficient.
- 1:47:53It's almost always the case. The case was determined by the defense lawyers as
- 1:48:01potentially having a really high jury verdict, and according to the brief, meaning
- 1:48:06that in the civil suit, the jury would award the family a lot of
- 1:48:12money and the MAP practice and the agency and the counselor and the intern and
- 1:48:16maybe the psychiatrist, so it would have to fork up a lot of money.
- 1:48:21And the factors that the brief identified were the client's age and this what
- 1:48:29they call the sympathy factor, for that could influence the jury's decisions. So
- 1:48:35the first one I don't know about. It sounds like what they're saying is
- 1:48:41given that the client was young when she died by suicide or on the younger
- 1:48:45side of things that could cause more jury sympathy and thus a higher jury verdict.
- 1:48:55That seems kind of funny. It's like, so old people don't matter.
- 1:48:57I don't know, but this other one I definitely know about the sympathy
- 1:49:01factor potentially influenced in the jury's decision. That and this happens all the time.
- 1:49:10Legal experts that I know of will tell me this that if we just
- 1:49:14look at this objectively, the liability or the fault of the interns supervisor agency,
- 1:49:23you know, it's up there, but it's not like astronomic, right,
- 1:49:27given the fact that there was no talk of suicide, there have been
- 1:49:30no previous attempts. Yes, there was seemingly a manic episode that had begun
- 1:49:35that day or maybe the early or yesterday. They are they do have a
- 1:49:40scheduled session in two days. The client is connected with a psychiatrist, so
- 1:49:47you know, under a lot of circumstances, you're going to see that reaction
- 1:49:55from interns and supervisors. I'm just like, well, you're going to see
- 1:49:58her in a couple of days, so just wait until then and address it
- 1:50:00from then. I mean, as I say that out loud, I'm like,
- 1:50:05well, but they also would have had a safety plan, and you
- 1:50:11know anyway, so it's a pretty common It's it's not like the intern and
- 1:50:17the supervisor were egregious, egregiously negligent in the situation. However, given the
- 1:50:26fact that she died, she's dead, and given the fact that there is
- 1:50:31some blame potentially that you could point a finger at the intern, supervisor and
- 1:50:36agency and psychiatrist. Uh, the legal experts are saying juries typically will say
- 1:50:45you need to pay a lot of money because someone died in the situation,
- 1:50:51and the jury won't take into account the amount of blame that should be a
- 1:50:59bestowed upon on the agency. It might make you sense, you know,
- 1:51:03like under a quote unquote objective evaluation of the situation, you'd say, well,
- 1:51:12in terms of a percentage, what percentage would we say that the clinicians
- 1:51:15are at fault? And you know, given the limited information I get from
- 1:51:19this brief, I might say that the clinicians are I don't know, maybe
- 1:51:26fifty percent, certainly not one hundred percent and not ninety percent, because there's
- 1:51:33some evidence given the profile and there's no data, but there's some evidence pointing
- 1:51:38in the direction that the client was not complying with therapy wasn't because if the
- 1:51:44client was really concerned and really on board, the client would say, hey,
- 1:51:47by the way, I was hospitalized, so we need to talk about
- 1:51:50this. Also, it's unlikely that the client suddenly thought about suicide. It's
- 1:51:56more likely that that was going on and the client just was trying to avoid
- 1:52:00being hospitalized. Again, who knows, I'm just making all this up,
- 1:52:03but there's probably data along those lines, and therefore there's not a lot that
- 1:52:13clinicians can do under under circumstances like that. But anyway, so if the
- 1:52:17jury said, well, a million dollars is what this is worth, and
- 1:52:23so instead of going to half a million that the agency has to pay,
- 1:52:28they would say that the agency has to pay the full million, just because
- 1:52:30of the sympathy factor. Anyway, I'm not a lawyer, so don't lessen
- 1:52:34what I'm saying. The defense lawyers predicted that they would lose in court,
- 1:52:42so they decided to settle, and they settled for quote unquote more than two
- 1:52:46hundred thousand dollars. So I'm guessing it's not much more than two hundred thousand.
- 1:52:51So recommendation, These are my recommendations. This is what I will I
- 1:52:55mean, it's pretty clear from what I've been saying, but just to be
- 1:52:59clear that agencies should have adequate policies about supervision and crises. It's pretty obvious,
- 1:53:05but I should put that out there. And the standard of care should
- 1:53:12be considered when establishing these policies. And this standard is very standardized. You
- 1:53:18know, there's things in my field in therapy that we would consider to be
- 1:53:24the standard of care. But there's a lot of people at the edges.
- 1:53:28There's a lot of very a lot of differing opinions about this and that.
- 1:53:31But when it comes to these kinds of things like the amount of supervision and
- 1:53:36whether or not you should have a crisis policy, you know, is the
- 1:53:43vast, vast majority of agencies all agree that X, Y, and Z
- 1:53:45should be happening going on. Another recommendation is that everyone should appreciate the importance
- 1:53:51of supervision. Agencies should appreciate it, supervisors should appreciate it. The training
- 1:53:58program, because that's the other aspect here, is that there's a university involved,
- 1:54:01right, So you had the university and I think a university clinic,
- 1:54:04and then you have this outside agency that was hired to supervise the interns well,
- 1:54:12what was the university doing to monitor the situation? Because I've been there
- 1:54:15before. I've had to go after agencies and say, hey, you need
- 1:54:18to be providing more supervision for this person, and if you don't, then
- 1:54:25our relationship is going to be harmed and I'm not going to send interns to
- 1:54:29you anymore. And your bottom line depends on me sending you free labor,
- 1:54:33which is a whole other topic. It shouldn't even be free, but you
- 1:54:38know, it's not like agencies are rolling in money. It's more of a
- 1:54:41matter of tax dollars. But anyway, so everyone needs to appreciate the importance
- 1:54:47of supervision. And if the owner had appreciated it better, if the supervisor
- 1:54:51had appreciated it better, if the training program had appreciated it better, then
- 1:54:57I'm guessing there would have been an different outcome. At the very least,
- 1:55:00the intern would have had more supervision, more guidance, and a lot of
- 1:55:06the times interns want more supervision. I mean, it's it's almost universal that
- 1:55:13interns feel even with you know, with the model that I'm a part of,
- 1:55:16it's five hours a week, interns are still looking at me, particularly
- 1:55:20in the beginning and going I have no idea what I'm doing. I need
- 1:55:26more time with supervisors and stuff, and so interns typically are asking for more,
- 1:55:30but they don't have the power to speak up, and even if they
- 1:55:33do, they often aren't listened to. So it has the blame is on
- 1:55:39the agency and the supervisor going on. Another another recommendation is that there needs
- 1:55:45to be better training for interns. I don't know if the intern was poorly
- 1:55:48trained or well trained, but the fact that she didn't know that pressured speech
- 1:55:55was a sign of mania, you know, says something maybe hard to say.
- 1:55:59Also, so there needs to be better documentation, which I always it
- 1:56:03will say at the end of these ethics cases. Another is that there needs
- 1:56:08to be timely communication with collaterals like the psychiatrists, particularly with high risk cases.
- 1:56:15And I see everything, I see the whole spectrum here. I see
- 1:56:19some people in my circle that are very diligent about connecting with other collateral contacts,
- 1:56:28whether it be psychiatrists or schools or parents or or you know, spouses
- 1:56:34or you know their physician, their uh, their dietitian, their you know,
- 1:56:41they're there. They vary on the ball, and it's just built into
- 1:56:45their weak that they allocate the time for that. It's on their mind.
- 1:56:48They have their their lists that they keep track of, they document about it
- 1:56:54well. And then I see people the other other end of the spectrum that
- 1:56:57literally never reach out to collateral contacts. I'll just do my own thing,
- 1:57:01and it's irresponsible on so many levels. And we see the result of the
- 1:57:09case. And by the way, I like this case because a lot of
- 1:57:12the cases that I review from my malpractice are so over the top ridiculous.
- 1:57:17Like what was the last one that we did where the therapist had hired the
- 1:57:24client or had switched to becoming a life coach, and then the client moved
- 1:57:30in to the therapist's house and then there was like a bartering situation and you
- 1:57:39know, it escalated from there. There are other cases that I've read where
- 1:57:44there's an appropriate sexual contactor, you know, whereas this case, this is
- 1:57:49the things that are outlined as problems in this case are much more common than
- 1:57:57the typical case that I read on this podcast. The problems that we're running
- 1:58:01into, especially the devaluation of supervision. I run into that quite a bit
- 1:58:08where I'll have an intern who is at a site, or someone will hire
- 1:58:14me postgrad and they will tell me how bad their supervision was up until that
- 1:58:18point. That I'll have an intern that they're on site supervisor. It basically
- 1:58:26just chats with them casually. They'll maybe they'll meet for an hour, but
- 1:58:31it'll be all business stuff, you know, stuff that you need to cover
- 1:58:35in supervision, like are you up to date on your treatment of plans,
- 1:58:40your progress notes, you know that sort of the nuts and bolts, if
- 1:58:44you will, and those are all things you need to cover. But I've
- 1:58:47had interns who will tell me that they're on site supervisor. That's all they
- 1:58:50talk about. They never talk about counter transference or psychotherapy theory, or intervention
- 1:58:58options, or stress management or new research or diagnosing or whatever. There's no
- 1:59:09talk along those lines. It's all just nuts and bolts. And I think
- 1:59:15it's because, well, there's a number of factors, and I've seen it
- 1:59:17all over the twenty five thirty years that I've been seeing this happen. One
- 1:59:24is that you have a bunch of supervisors that don't know what supervision really is
- 1:59:27because there's no required or there's very little required education around what it is to
- 1:59:32be a supervisor. But also you have a lot of supervisors who don't want
- 1:59:39to be supervisors, but they're forced to be supervisors because the agency needs someone
- 1:59:44to supervise, and they might be one of the only staff therapists that has
- 1:59:48the qualifications, and in order for that person to keep their job, they
- 1:59:51have to take on supervises, but they don't want to. Another factor is
- 1:59:57that when you overwork people, then you know things are going to fall through
- 2:00:00the cracks and you're just you're not to supervise correctly. To be a therapist
- 2:00:05well, and to be a supervisor, well, you have to have a
- 2:00:09lot of energy, and you have to have a lot of brain space and
- 2:00:13heart space and the energy to dedicate yourself to the extras of being a supervisor.
- 2:00:21You know. Like for me as a supervisor, if I just wanted
- 2:00:24to coast through my career, I could have done supervision the way I would
- 2:00:28see it done sometimes, which is just casually having conversations and going over their
- 2:00:32paperwork, and I would never get in trouble and people would probably think I
- 2:00:38was a good supervisor. But I couldn't sleep at night if I was doing
- 2:00:43that. I care about my supervisors and about their clients, and so I
- 2:00:48would put the effort in not because anyone was telling me to or I was
- 2:00:53trained to, but because I just wanted to. And so you have to
- 2:00:58have that kind of of mindedness as a supervisor. And like I said,
- 2:01:01a lot of people are foisted the job is foisted upon them and they don't
- 2:01:06really want to do it. Okay, So going on, and the last
- 2:01:11recommendation is that, of course you need to have a good suicide risk assessment
- 2:01:15procedure and safety planning procedure. This drives me nuts. I can't tell you
- 2:01:19how many times I will have clinicians that come to me having worked in agencies.
- 2:01:28And by the way, there are a lot of agencies and supervisors that
- 2:01:30do this very very well. So I'm not saying it's across the board,
- 2:01:32but it's not uncommon for me to see a situation where every time there's a
- 2:01:38suicidal client, the therapist or the intern is in a panic because they don't
- 2:01:45know what to do. It's sort of like, I don't know, this
- 2:01:47has popped in my head, but if you're a firefighter when there's an actual
- 2:01:53house on fire, you shouldn't walk up to the house and go like,
- 2:01:57oh crap, what do I do? The solution is and practice and procedure
- 2:02:02right or the military for example, you know it's reps. You got to
- 2:02:06run through the reps and there's just there's got to be very little left to
- 2:02:13randomness and even to decision making. And when it comes to suicide assessment and
- 2:02:17addressing risk, there should be as little possible left to you making a choice
- 2:02:26in the moment. It should just be something that's just a matter of routine.
- 2:02:29You just follow this flow chart. And I have actually developed my own
- 2:02:33for my supervises because the available tools out there I find to be insufficient because
- 2:02:41there's so many nuances to suicide and you can listen to my whole deep dive.
- 2:02:45Part of the reason why I did that deep dive years ago was because
- 2:02:48I wanted to have a more robust approach when I was helping my supervises,
- 2:02:55and so when someone would hire me as a supervisor, I would just hand
- 2:02:58them this tool and say, when you have a client that is even on
- 2:03:02the low end of the spectrum of suicidal thoughts, here is what you do.
- 2:03:08And there's a lot of nuances because every client's different, but at least
- 2:03:12the baseline and it was pretty elaborate. It wasn't. Like I said that,
- 2:03:15the common tools that I see are I won't go into the old details,
- 2:03:19but they're pretty limited in terms of the guidance and the You can still
- 2:03:26look at these tools as a clinician and say, like, wait, what
- 2:03:29am I supposed to do? So there's that. And even with this tool
- 2:03:34that I give my superviss, inevitably, when they do have a client that
- 2:03:40presents with moderate to high risk of suicide, the intern or the superviz will
- 2:03:46still have tremendous anxiety and quote unquote not know what to do. But it
- 2:03:54doesn't take me long to kind of nudge them back into what we've already repped
- 2:03:58a bunch of times, you know what I mean? Anyway, So that
- 2:04:01clearly was not or that seemingly was not being done or it wasn't robust enough.
- 2:04:09And hopefully that agency has changed their ways, but who knows. All
- 2:04:15right, well, stay ethical out there and stay classy, San Diego,
- 2:04:20because and take care of yourself because you deserve it, You really really do.