Latest / The Vegan Report / This Is How We Win. With Jareb Gleckel | Ep. 49
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you are listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:06Today I offer you hope.
- 0:09What if I told you that some smart people came up with a viable strategy to end factory
- 0:16farming for good?
- 0:18A way to channel all our activism in the most impactful way.
- 0:24A roadmap telling you where this animal rights struggle ends.
- 0:29This master plan comes in the form of a legal article titled A New Age of Animal Law written
- 0:35by three animal rights lawyers.
- 0:38Jereb Klekel, a staff attorney for Animal Outlook, Grace Brasovsky, a public defender
- 0:45and Cheryl Lihi, director of Animal Outlook.
- 0:49I welcomed on the show one of the co-authors, Jereb, and we discussed the good and bad of
- 0:55animal welfare before getting to the core of his paper.
- 1:00Then I challenged him on some of the points and assumptions he makes.
- 1:05If you want to read A New Age of Animal Law, you will find a link in the description for
- 1:10a longer and shorter version of the article.
- 1:14I also left a link to Animal Outlook's website.
- 1:18Think about supporting a non-profit powered by such talented and passionate attorneys.
- 1:24Hi, Jereb.
- 1:27Thank you so much for having accepted my invitation and welcome to the show.
- 1:32Thank you for inviting me.
- 1:33I'm very excited to be here, talk to you.
- 1:37My first question for you is, what's the point of your article?
- 1:41Why did you decide to publish it and talk about it publicly?
- 1:48This article, A New Age of Animal Law, I think comes from, for better or worse, just being
- 1:53a people pleaser and wanting to try to take a lot of really smart perspectives in the
- 1:58animal law movement and to combine them and to put them together and to create a synergy
- 2:02that I think can and should exist in the movement.
- 2:06We're a small movement of animal lawyers.
- 2:09By that, I mean lawyers who are litigating on behalf of animals.
- 2:15But historically, there's been a surprisingly sharp divide in the movement between abolitionists
- 2:20on the one hand and welfarists on the other.
- 2:23I think there is opportunity for that to change and to evolve and to grow and for really smart
- 2:28minds on both sides to work together as opposed to against each other as historically it's
- 2:34maybe seemed necessary to do.
- 2:37That's the basis of this paper is how can we create this unified system, this unified
- 2:43thought for advancing animal law so that everybody is working together to achieve the same goals.
- 2:49That's exactly what I got from the paper.
- 2:55It feels like something unifying and it feels like it's like a strategy for the movement
- 3:04and it gave me clarity in what are the next steps and how to be consistent in what we're
- 3:12doing as activists in the activism space.
- 3:18It also gave me a goal, a light at the end of the tunnel.
- 3:27Here is the plan, here's the strategy, and here's how we could get to the kind of world
- 3:34we wish was a reality.
- 3:39Was this also an aim and intention you had while writing the paper?
- 3:45Absolutely.
- 3:46In a lot of ways, I see it almost as more of a starting point because there's a lot
- 3:51of smart people in this movement and I'm sure that as people read the article, they will
- 3:56see things, parts of the strategy that they can tweak for themselves or add to or subtract
- 4:01from.
- 4:03I think having this outline in my head, this framework gives me some kind of purpose going
- 4:08forward and some structure as you said and hopefully can be a bit of an educational tool
- 4:13for young lawyers who are coming up in the movement, at least in terms of seeing the
- 4:19different perspectives and how they want their role to fit in.
- 4:22And hopefully also for non-lawyers because we can talk about this a little more later
- 4:26if it's interesting to you, but I think that people who aren't lawyers and people who are
- 4:31activists also play a very big role in the legal side of the movement as well.
- 4:36And so I hope the paper kind of fits all of that together.
- 4:40So let's get into understanding some of the words that are used in the article, some of
- 4:46the concepts starting with animal welfare.
- 4:50Now I have to say before starting this podcast, before really starting this activism journey,
- 4:58I did not give lots of thoughts about this divide between abolitionism and welfareism.
- 5:07For me, animal welfare was just part of the animal rights movement in the sense of I would
- 5:15see some of my favorite pro-vegan organizations like Mercy for Animals pushing animal welfare
- 5:26policies, laws, supporting them, being active around that, launching campaigns, animal welfare
- 5:37campaigns.
- 5:38And I would think, yeah, it's just consistent.
- 5:41As a vegan, I would support animal welfare as much as animal rights.
- 5:48I feel like I did not truly realize the difference between this divide and what it meant really.
- 5:59So for the other ignorant people in my audience, what would you have to say?
- 6:07Well I started very much in the same boat, not even realizing when I first became vegan
- 6:12and got into the movement that there was this divide.
- 6:16But the divide, historically, it makes sense.
- 6:18I don't think it just comes from an unnatural tension.
- 6:20So I'll take a step back and start with the definitions that you asked for.
- 6:24And when we talk about welfareism, of course I'm painting in broad brushstrokes here, but
- 6:28welfareism is the idea of improving welfare for animals, improving their living conditions.
- 6:34Now for a pig at a factory farm, that might mean a slightly bigger cage size or eliminating
- 6:40a certain practice that's especially painful.
- 6:43All of those would be considered welfare measures.
- 6:46On the flip side, you have what I call the abolitionist perspective.
- 6:51And that comes from a place of animals have inherent rights and at least the right to
- 6:59a continued life and to be free from harm and free from exploitation and to not be treated
- 7:04as property.
- 7:05And so the idea is that you shouldn't be exploiting them for food or for other purposes.
- 7:12And you might think they do go hand in hand and in a lot of ways they do.
- 7:16Improving conditions for animals is trying to improve the lives for animals the same
- 7:19way you would be improving their lives by no longer exploiting them altogether.
- 7:25But when you look a little closer at those positions, you see a pretty big dichotomy.
- 7:30You can talk a little bit about why that dichotomy has evolved, but Professor Gary Francione
- 7:37is really, I think, the first or at least one of the main people to point out why that
- 7:42dichotomy is important and why it exists.
- 7:45And he's now more of a dissenting viewpoint, I would say, in the movement, but very much
- 7:50one of my idols and role models in the movement because he asks the hard questions, right?
- 7:55Which is if we are just taking these incremental steps to improve the lives of animals by making
- 8:02their cages bigger, are we actually reaching a more abolitionist angle like we want to
- 8:07in the long run?
- 8:08Or are we actually fighting against ourselves in one way or another?
- 8:14So I can go into a little bit more detail if you want about how those emerge, but that's
- 8:19broad strokes the overview of the welfarists who want to incrementally improve the lives
- 8:23of animals and then you have the abolitionists who want to end the exploitation altogether.
- 8:30Sometimes how this is presented is, welfarism is a more realistic approach and abolitionism
- 8:38is more of an idealistic one.
- 8:40Would you agree with that?
- 8:43I think that that's definitely how it's presented.
- 8:45I agree that that's how it's presented.
- 8:48So I think welfarists will say, listen, we live in a world where people eat animals.
- 8:53That's just the reality.
- 8:54We're not going to overnight wake up and see that all animals are freed and we no longer
- 8:59eat them.
- 9:00So we might as well do what we can for the animals, right?
- 9:03And they will critique an abolitionist by saying, listen, you're wasting a lot of your
- 9:06time and resources when you could be taking these tangible steps to help animals.
- 9:12And I think that's maybe a position that more people intuitively are drawn to.
- 9:17But from the abolitionist side, what someone like Professor Francione would say is you're
- 9:21actually fighting against yourself because if you take these incremental steps and you
- 9:26start celebrating that, say, now cages are bigger for animals.
- 9:30Look, we won this huge victory.
- 9:32They have more space to move around.
- 9:34Then you're just reinforcing the idea that there is an ethical way to consume and to
- 9:38exploit animals.
- 9:39And you have consumers who will then look at supermarket shelves and see cage free and
- 9:43be like, oh, look, the animals are happy.
- 9:45I'm going to keep eating eggs.
- 9:46And it prevents them in a way from confronting the bigger picture question of should we be
- 9:50doing this in the first place?
- 9:52And so that's a lot of the pushback you get on either side.
- 9:56And that's kind of where the divide starts and how it's framed.
- 9:58In preparation for this interview, I watched one of your lectures online and there was
- 10:08those three animal welfare laws, policies that you identified and that were applied
- 10:15in the US, namely the 28 hour law and then the Humane Metals of Slaughter Act and the
- 10:23Animal Welfare Act.
- 10:25And I guess those three are considered like big victories by animal welfareists.
- 10:32Could you maybe expand on what they are?
- 10:35And I think that will give us a better idea of concretely what is animal welfare.
- 10:41So I apologize to you before the podcast and we'll again here now that we're reporting
- 10:46about my limited knowledge of American law.
- 10:50So this focuses on US law, but there's really only three federal statutes.
- 10:55And by federal statutes, I mean the laws that apply to the entire country as a whole.
- 11:01There's three federal laws that Congress enacted to protect farmed animals.
- 11:05I'm sorry, two statutes they've enacted to protect farmed animals.
- 11:09And I start pretty much every lecture or every topic you'll see me give to law students or
- 11:12anywhere else this way, right?
- 11:14There's the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act and the 28 hour law.
- 11:18And you can tell by the names exactly what they do.
- 11:21The Humane Methods of Slaughter Act regulates in some ways how animals are slaughtered and
- 11:25it tries to eliminate some of the cruelest slaughter practices.
- 11:29And then the 28 hour law is a transport law.
- 11:32And this law I think is probably most shocking when I explain it to people because it means
- 11:37you can't transport animals for over 28 hours in the back of a transport truck.
- 11:43And when you think about that as the baseline, that's pretty crazy because it means that
- 11:46under that law, you can have an animal in the back of the truck and create for 27 and
- 11:51a half hours and that's compliance, right?
- 11:53So that's the level of baseline that we're dealing with.
- 11:56And that's why protecting farmed animals through the law can be very difficult, right?
- 12:00That's the baseline.
- 12:02So if you think about those two statutes and what they protect, right?
- 12:08Slaughter and then hopefully less than the 28 hours leading up to the slaughter during
- 12:13the transport.
- 12:14And I usually stop there and I say, okay, so who can tell me what's missing from those
- 12:19protections?
- 12:20And people have various answers.
- 12:22And then when they realize, oh, it's the rest of their lives, it's everything that they
- 12:27experience up until that point of transport to slaughter, they go, oh, wow, these baselines
- 12:33are really, really well at the federal level.
- 12:35And so that's kind of where we're starting.
- 12:39And some of those laws, they do protect animal welfare to a degree, but you see how low the
- 12:45federal baseline is.
- 12:46Now you asked me about the Animal Welfare Act and you may have noticed that I didn't
- 12:49mention it in saying that Congress enacted laws to protect farmed animals.
- 12:55And that's because also as a surprise to many people, the Animal Welfare Act does not protect
- 13:00animals, or it's radical culture.
- 13:01It doesn't apply to farmed animals.
- 13:03So your biggest federal animal welfare statute in the country doesn't apply to farmed animals
- 13:09at all.
- 13:10That's the baseline we're dealing with.
- 13:11And something that you raise in the article is that it's one thing to have those laws.
- 13:24It's something else to enforce them.
- 13:28And there's no such thing as animal police.
- 13:32And I have witnessed some acts of animal cruelty.
- 13:37And I have witnessed how the police has its limitations in addressing those behaviors
- 13:45and the social acceptability.
- 13:51I will edit this out, but how socially it is acceptable for those acts to occur.
- 13:59So people don't even have the instinct of calling the police when they witness.
- 14:06So yeah, there's this dog, for instance, who is outside all the time, even in winter.
- 14:16It goes against animal welfare laws, protecting companion animals.
- 14:21You call the police, they're powerless.
- 14:23What are they going to do?
- 14:25You call different agencies, shelters, or whatever.
- 14:30They are overwhelmed.
- 14:32So basically you have this law that was adopted.
- 14:35You had activists behind it who worked hard to craft that law.
- 14:40But then it's not enforced.
- 14:43And so my question is, how many of those laws are enforced in the world of factory farming?
- 14:56And then is it worth pursuing, creating those laws and establishing them if they will not
- 15:09be enforced?
- 15:10There's a lot of pieces to that question, I'm going to try to hit all of them.
- 15:14And I will start by saying, I agree with you entirely that enforcement is a very big issue,
- 15:20or lack of enforcement rather.
- 15:23Now when we were just talking, I talked about federal laws.
- 15:27Part of the reason the legal system in the United States is a little weird and different
- 15:32and complicated is because of the federalist structure.
- 15:35So there's federal laws that apply to the whole country, but then there's state laws
- 15:40and states act as their own separate sovereigns and can establish their own laws.
- 15:45And it's really states that have a lot of the stronger laws that are out there for protecting
- 15:51animals.
- 15:52And those are the ones that can be enforced a lot more and that are often under enforced.
- 15:57And states also have a lot of flexibility to pass some of the stronger laws for protecting
- 16:03animals.
- 16:04So California's Proposition 12, which we can talk about a little later too if you want,
- 16:10is one of the biggest examples that people think of, right?
- 16:13This gestation crate ban or the ban on the sale of meat that comes derived from pigs
- 16:18that were kept in gestation crates, right?
- 16:21And so there are these state laws that can actually do more, at least for animal welfare,
- 16:26right?
- 16:27And the problem that we see a lot is the lack of enforcement.
- 16:30So this comes back to your question and to exactly what you're asking.
- 16:34But sometimes it's because there aren't laws on the books and sometimes it's just because
- 16:39of practice where people don't think about enforcing the law that way, even though they
- 16:43very clearly should based on the text of the law itself.
- 16:47So I'll give you an example.
- 16:48We have a case in Maine right now, the state of Maine, where we're litigating against Maine's
- 16:53Department of Agriculture.
- 16:55And our big issue with the department is that they are not protecting animals kept in the
- 17:02state's aquaculture facilities.
- 17:04And the aquaculture facilities, the aquaculture industry is blowing up, it's expanding exponentially
- 17:08and it's like the Wild West because there's no animal welfare measures at all in that
- 17:16industry.
- 17:17Now, Animal Outlook, where I'm an attorney, did one of the first investigations into the
- 17:22aquaculture industry in the US and it was in Maine and we saw just horrible cruelty,
- 17:26everything that you would expect and more.
- 17:30Because anything that people will do to animals, they'll do tenfold to fish because it's just
- 17:34like, oh, they're just fish, right?
- 17:37And we go to the Department of Agriculture, which has the state's animal welfare program
- 17:41and we say, hey, you have to protect the animals in this industry.
- 17:46And before we even got to this point where we are in litigation, the first thing the
- 17:50agency said is, oh, that's not our job.
- 17:53And that blew our minds.
- 17:55It just blew us out of the water and you wouldn't think that it would because we see stuff like
- 17:58this all the time, but the agency has the animal welfare program and animal is defined
- 18:04to include every living sentient creature that's not a human being.
- 18:08So we say, so your job is to protect these fish, right?
- 18:11And they say, no.
- 18:12We say, well, your job is to protect animals.
- 18:14Yes.
- 18:15And animals is defined.
- 18:17Yes.
- 18:18Every living sentient creature that's not a human being.
- 18:20Yes.
- 18:21Fish or animals.
- 18:22Yes.
- 18:23And fish are sentient.
- 18:24Yes.
- 18:25And fish are living.
- 18:26Yes.
- 18:27And fish are creatures.
- 18:28Yes.
- 18:29So you have to protect the fish, right?
- 18:30No.
- 18:31And you're like, where's the disconnect here?
- 18:32What has happened?
- 18:33Right.
- 18:34Because there's some animals that are just, you know, the government is not doing its
- 18:39job to enforce the law and protect these animals, even though it very clearly can under the
- 18:44letter of the law, right?
- 18:47Whenever Animal Outlook does investigations, a lot of investigations, we see law enforcement,
- 18:52we see prosecutions.
- 18:53And typically we want to prosecute either the corporation or like the owner manager
- 18:57of the facility rather than just, you know, individual workers.
- 19:02And that's for a few different reasons.
- 19:03But one for the animal purposes is you start going after individual workers.
- 19:08You're kind of sending this message that, oh, it's just a few bad apples who are hurting
- 19:12animals in these unusual circumstances.
- 19:15When really it's systemic, it's companies themselves that have these conditions and
- 19:19practices that are inherently cruel to animals.
- 19:22And in a lot of states, the cruelty laws should be applied to those facilities by prosecutors,
- 19:29by law enforcement, the same way they would be applied to a cat and dog.
- 19:32But when you tell a prosecutor that, they go, what do you mean?
- 19:36Like, no, that's not what we do.
- 19:37We don't prosecute, you know, agriculture industries.
- 19:40And so part of Animal Outlook's work, part of my work as an attorney there is trying
- 19:45to actually work with prosecutors to get them to enforce these laws against the corporations,
- 19:50because there are sometimes these laws on the books that are just being under enforced,
- 19:54like you said.
- 19:56And we've been very successful in that in the last couple of years and getting these
- 20:00prosecutions against owners and managers of facilities.
- 20:04And I think the more the law actually starts to be enforced the way it should be, the more
- 20:09you'll actually see this kind of systemic change in the industry.
- 20:12And the more the public will recognize, oh, this is these practices, the way these companies
- 20:17are operating is just inherently unawful.
- 20:19It's just cruel.
- 20:20Let's talk about what I find the strongest argument for animal welfare laws.
- 20:25And that is the driving up prices of exploiting animals.
- 20:30In many ways, I find that veganism is about driving change in the market.
- 20:37So it's more or less something that has to do with influencing the economy.
- 20:45And I learned about this driving up prices animal welfare argument from your article.
- 20:51I was completely ignorant about it.
- 20:54So could you please explain what the argument is about and how much is it realistic?
- 21:03Is it a goal that has been fulfilled in the past?
- 21:06Do we have historical data to back up this claim of animal welfarists?
- 21:14Yeah.
- 21:15So historically, the argument from welfarists have been if you add regulation to an industry,
- 21:21then the costs go up to the industry and it costs them more money to operate and they
- 21:28can't make as big a profit.
- 21:30It's a very simple kind of economics argument.
- 21:32If you tell an aquaculture industry, it can treat fish however it wants and they can have
- 21:38free reign, then they're not going to implement measures to take care of the fish.
- 21:43And if you start implementing them and all of a sudden they need bigger tanks and cleaner
- 21:47water and all of these other measures, their costs are going to go up.
- 21:51That's the historic argument.
- 21:53From the abolitionist side, there's really been two counters to that and I will take
- 21:58them in turn.
- 22:00So the first, and this is really where I think I would disagree most with Professor Francione's
- 22:04approach is that these welfare measures inherently make the industry more profitable all the
- 22:11time no matter what.
- 22:13That by increasing animal welfare, you're actually making the animals live longer and
- 22:19do better and the industry will ultimately make more money because there will be, I don't
- 22:26know, fill in the blanks, less need for antibiotics, less recalls, et cetera.
- 22:31It'll just make the industry operate more efficiently.
- 22:34And I think that just has to be wrong.
- 22:38And without kind of weighing in on the back and forth debate about which measures is that
- 22:44true about, which measures is it not, I think you can just look at a couple of basic hypotheticals
- 22:50and see that it can't be true across the board.
- 22:53If cages for chickens are three feet and you implement a measure that means the industry
- 22:58has to then go and make them four feet and then has to go and make them five feet and
- 23:02six feet and 10 feet and 12 feet, the industry has to keep spending more money to build bigger
- 23:07cages and to expand them.
- 23:10And then it takes up more space and they need more land and they can have fewer animals.
- 23:14So you can very easily see how a welfare measure can increase costs.
- 23:18So I start from that premise that regardless of what you may think of welfare measures
- 23:22that currently exist and whether they're driving up costs, there certainly are welfare measures
- 23:27that will drive up costs.
- 23:29And I think to say that there's not, it's just too much of a blanket statement.
- 23:37And I think that's one of the responsibilities of animal organizations if they're bringing
- 23:41litigation or proposing legislation is to make sure, yeah, this is the kind of measure
- 23:45that will actually drive up costs to the industry.
- 23:47But I'm going to set that aside now and assume that there are measures that can actually
- 23:52increase costs for the industry.
- 23:54And this is where you get to the second counter argument, which I think historically has been
- 23:59the more persuasive at least to me, which is that animal products like meat, I'm just
- 24:04going to take as the example, are inelastic.
- 24:09If you look at basic economics and you look at supply and demand, if you have a necessity,
- 24:14a product that's a necessity, if you cause the industry to increase its costs, it doesn't
- 24:22really matter because it's going to pass that cost on to consumers.
- 24:25An example I always give is if you're wandering through the desert and you haven't had water
- 24:29for two days and you come across somebody in the desert who's selling a bottle of water,
- 24:34you will pay whatever they ask for that bottle of water.
- 24:37Maybe a bottle of water costs $2 in the real world, but you will pay 10 or 20 or 100 because
- 24:42otherwise you will die.
- 24:43So if it's a necessity good, then you will pay more for it.
- 24:47And historically, the agriculture industry for animals has done a great job of persuading
- 24:54the public that animal products are necessities.
- 24:57You grow up with them in the food pyramid.
- 24:59And I think abolitionists, that's one of their big roles is putting a dent in that and saying,
- 25:06these products aren't necessities.
- 25:08Actually you can live a vegan lifestyle and be perfectly healthy.
- 25:11And if you do it right, you can be even healthier.
- 25:13And meat can actually be unhealthy.
- 25:15And you kind of change that narrative in a way that aligns with the science.
- 25:19But historically, it's been viewed as a necessity.
- 25:21So if we pass a welfare measure, costs go up for the industry, they just pass those
- 25:27costs on to the consumers and they say, all right, well, now your stake is $12 instead
- 25:30of 10 and people just pay it.
- 25:33And that's kind of the end of the story because they say, well, we have to eat meat.
- 25:36It's just part of life.
- 25:39So that's the necessity piece.
- 25:41And I think abolitionists really in charge of tacking that piece.
- 25:47Then you have the substitutability prong.
- 25:52So when products have substitutes, they're more elastic.
- 25:56And so I give you an example there to make that a little more concrete.
- 25:59Just say you have a type of chewing gum you really like, like a fig gum.
- 26:04I don't even think I don't know why I said fig gum.
- 26:06I don't know if that exists.
- 26:07My antler has been growing figs.
- 26:08So I have figs on my mind.
- 26:10But say you have fig chewing gum, right?
- 26:13And you're like, there's nowhere else I can get this.
- 26:15It's not a necessity.
- 26:16So I'm not going to spend $8 on gum too often.
- 26:18But when I want to treat myself, spend $8 on gum.
- 26:21It's great.
- 26:22OK, so you pay it because there's no substitutes for it.
- 26:25But then if other companies start coming out with it and it's $6 and $5 and $4, now you
- 26:31have options.
- 26:32So if you think about the fig gum company that's charging $8 a pack, somebody sues them
- 26:38and they have to up their cost to $9 and there's no other products.
- 26:41It's probably not going to change the demand that much because people who want the gum
- 26:44will pay $9 if they would pay $8.
- 26:47But now if there's other products, there's another product that comes out and they charge
- 26:51$8.50.
- 26:52And that company has to go up to $9.
- 26:55Now people have an option.
- 26:56They can switch.
- 26:58And that's, I think, what we're seeing for the first time in history with these really
- 27:01realistic plant-based products that really replicate the taste and the texture of animal
- 27:07products.
- 27:08And hopefully, at some point, relatively soon at a cost-effective level, cell-based products,
- 27:13fermentation-derived products, you see all of a sudden there are substitutes in the market.
- 27:18And so I think what that means is for the first time now in history, as welfare measures
- 27:22start to drive up prices for the industry, it's no longer going to just be like, oh,
- 27:28we'll pass this on to consumers.
- 27:30The industry will then have two options.
- 27:31They either take the hit and it cuts into their profit margin or they pass those costs
- 27:38on to consumers and it gives consumers more pause in thinking about the substitutes that
- 27:43are out there.
- 27:44And maybe they switch over to plant-based products because of that change in price parity.
- 27:48Fascinating.
- 27:49Now we're getting at the strategy, the core of your article, which is, you know, the way
- 27:56I see it is like a fight on many fronts.
- 28:01First of all, you need to drive up prices of animal products, bypassing animal welfare
- 28:09laws.
- 28:13Then you have to advocate and make alternatives.
- 28:20So the Impossible Burgers and the lab-grown meat out there make them viable options, accepted
- 28:30by the public, embraced, and to see them now as great alternatives for those animal products
- 28:42that are becoming more and more unaffordable.
- 28:46Yeah.
- 28:47So I think it's a few fold.
- 28:50And obviously I have a little bias as an attorney, but I think the law will start to play an
- 28:56even bigger role in the movement now that there's more options.
- 29:00And if you're the kind of person who doesn't want to read a thousand page law review article,
- 29:06you can go right to page 52 and it gives you that roadmap.
- 29:09And I can walk right through that.
- 29:11I also might, my co-author Cheryl Lay, he's the executive director of Animal Outlook.
- 29:17And I published a kind of summary piece on the Brooks Animal Law Digest that walks through
- 29:22this.
- 29:23So that's a bit of a shorter summary as well.
- 29:26But the idea is, right, we've talked about kind of this phase one, so to speak, right?
- 29:31These alternatives come closer to replicating counterparts.
- 29:34Consumers start to consider them as substitutes.
- 29:36They go, oh, maybe the demand curve starts to become more elastic.
- 29:40Right.
- 29:41And I've said, it's up to abolitionist activists and lawyers to make the public and not just
- 29:46a portion of the public, but the entire public, accept alternatives as viable substitutes.
- 29:51And I think there's a couple of ways to do that.
- 29:54Right.
- 29:55One is, as I mentioned before, showing that animal products are not necessities.
- 29:59Right.
- 30:01And there's a lot of different ways you can do that as both an activist and a lawyer.
- 30:05To give you one example of the case that we have right now at Animal Outlook, it's a lawsuit
- 30:09against the American Heart Association.
- 30:11The American Heart Association puts its heart check stamp of approval on certain beef products.
- 30:17Right.
- 30:18And we're suing them by saying, hey, you're actually, that's a paid endorsement.
- 30:23You're getting paid by the beef industry to put that heart check on those products.
- 30:27And it goes counter to the science and even science that American Heart Association journals
- 30:31publish.
- 30:32And, you know, and by bringing these efforts in courts, which I think have an inherent
- 30:37legitimacy to them as, you know, like a serious legal system, you show through the court system
- 30:44that, oh, these animal products aren't necessities.
- 30:47They're not even, they're not even necessarily healthy.
- 30:49They might actually be damaging to us.
- 30:52Right.
- 30:53Well, let me just maybe present the, you know, devil advocate, be the devil advocate and
- 31:01present maybe the opposite side argument, which is, you know, the beyond meat and the
- 31:06impossible burgers of this world are processed food.
- 31:11It is hard in the minds of people to present the case that this is healthier than meat.
- 31:22And you know, just from my personal experience, I use an app called Yuka and it allows you,
- 31:30you know, to scan the labels of products and cosmetics and it gives you a list of the different
- 31:36additives.
- 31:38And also it tells you, oh, those additives are forbidden, you know, in Europe, European
- 31:47countries or Australia and they link all sorts of study studies around that.
- 31:54And I won't name the company, but it's a big meat alternative company.
- 32:00And I tried scanning their products.
- 32:02I used to be a customer of them.
- 32:06And then I discovered how bad they were ranking and how many additives were in their products.
- 32:15And I thought, ooh, this is not good when you try to sell the idea that those alternatives
- 32:23are healthier than the animal products.
- 32:27Yeah.
- 32:28So I think there's a couple of ways to think about that issue.
- 32:34One is that not all alternative products are going to be made equal.
- 32:38And I think it would be naive and I hope that vegans don't fall into this trap too often
- 32:45of just saying, oh, all plant-based products are inherently super healthy for you, right?
- 32:49Oreos are plant-based products.
- 32:51They're not healthy for you.
- 32:53I treat them like they are, but they're not.
- 32:55And that's going to be the case with alternatives as well.
- 32:58There's going to be some that are healthier than others, right?
- 33:01And it's going to depend too on the nutritional criteria that you're looking at, right?
- 33:06Some products may be healthier because they have lower cholesterol.
- 33:09And that may be especially important to someone who's trying to cut down on their cholesterol
- 33:13that like an alternative burger has way less cholesterol than a meat product, right?
- 33:18But maybe there is a disadvantage in some ways because some of the processed chemicals
- 33:22in that product aren't great, right?
- 33:25And I think as consumers, you kind of have to weigh your options and see which of these
- 33:31products are healthy in the ways that you want it to be and the way that you need it
- 33:35to be.
- 33:36But it doesn't change the bottom line that meat products are unhealthy, right?
- 33:42When it comes to carcinogens, high saturated fat, and so on and so forth, right?
- 33:48And so it's the job I think of.
- 33:52And again, here we're not even talking about the substitutability problem.
- 33:55We're just talking about the necessity problem, right?
- 33:58If you go after and you show that meat products are not a necessity when it comes to health,
- 34:03that they are actually detrimental to health, at least if consumed in large amounts, right?
- 34:09Then you're showing the product, sorry, you're showing consumers that these are not necessity
- 34:13products, right?
- 34:15And that's really the first step in making sure that these products no longer have this
- 34:20inelasticity value, showing consumers that they don't even need to buy them, right?
- 34:25When it comes to substitutability, you can look at other factors.
- 34:29And I think that's where the second piece, the ethical piece really comes to play, right?
- 34:35Because I think it's also up to abolitionist lawyers to show people that these other products
- 34:40have to be adequate substitutes, even if you don't think they're perfect, because animal
- 34:45products can never be an ethical option, right?
- 34:48And as an abolitionist, you have to show why that can be the case.
- 34:52Yes, I do agree that some people will see animal products and we make the case that
- 35:01they're unethical.
- 35:02We show the footage and they understand that this is not the ethical option.
- 35:10I hosted the debate recently between different vegan activists and they were all in agreement
- 35:18that people are selfish and that going about trying to appeal to their morality was not
- 35:32that efficient.
- 35:33So how do you address that weakness?
- 35:37So unfortunately, I am not going to be the person who comes on the show and argues that
- 35:42people are not inherently selfish because I tend to agree with every one of your other
- 35:47panelists.
- 35:49Unfortunately in saying that, or I should say fortunately in saying that, I think that's
- 35:55the advantage to kind of the roadmap that I've tried to lay out here is that people
- 36:01are selfish to a point, but they're also self-conscious beings, right?
- 36:08And so maybe if you think of meat as a necessity, right?
- 36:11And you say, okay, this is a necessity product.
- 36:15People are like, well, of course I'm going to eat this, it's a necessity.
- 36:18Maybe they should, right?
- 36:19Maybe it's natural and healthy and evolutionary to be selfish to that point.
- 36:24But then as you start to chip away at that necessity approach, right?
- 36:28And you start to see the prices go up and you start to see substitutes that are more
- 36:33on parity price-wise, right?
- 36:35Maybe somebody is selfish enough to say, I'm not going to eat a plant-based burger.
- 36:40I'm not going to eat a veggie burger for $11 if I can eat a cheeseburger for four, right?
- 36:48But are you selfish enough to say, I'm not going to eat a veggie burger for six, I'm
- 36:53going to eat a cheeseburger for 450?
- 36:55What about five and 550?
- 36:58And then if you're really ingrained in your ways, you know, and we've talked a lot about
- 37:02plant-based meat, right?
- 37:03What happens when cell-based meat, if cell-based meat hits the market and is the exact same
- 37:09food product as meat from a slaughtered animal, you know, maybe people will say at first,
- 37:13oh, this is gross.
- 37:14I wouldn't eat this.
- 37:15It comes from a lab, even though everything they consume comes from a lab.
- 37:20And then they will turn and they will say, oh, well, now the cell-based product is $3
- 37:24and this hamburger is $7.
- 37:27Maybe I should give it a try, you know, until eventually I think it just starts to become
- 37:31the norm.
- 37:32And so I agree with you that people are selfish, but I think there is a tipping point in there
- 37:37somewhere where people are like, am I this selfish?
- 37:43And I think selfishness can be a spectrum, right?
- 37:46Like most things.
- 37:47And so I think that's where these strategies come together.
- 37:51And that's why these substitutes, I think, become so valuable because historically, right,
- 37:56it's made abolitionist jobs easier, right?
- 37:59We used to have to say, oh, you should stop doing this for ethical reasons.
- 38:03And it sounded like a sacrifice.
- 38:05I still don't think it was, but you could think of it that way, right?
- 38:08You're giving something up, right?
- 38:10Now you're just saying you have to have a good enough substitute and here's why.
- 38:15And it makes the argument a lot easier.
- 38:18And so I think you have to play off the degrees of selfishness that people have.
- 38:24If you can always cut this out, if it bores you, but don't me for a second.
- 38:28This is kind of my big picture theory to animal rights.
- 38:33It's a simple minded theory and that's why I like it.
- 38:39Is that killing and torturing and hurting animals is just always wrong.
- 38:44And I don't think it takes a really deep philosopher to figure that out.
- 38:49I think you can take an animal like a rat that a lot of people don't like to say, I
- 38:52don't like rats.
- 38:53And you say, all right, well, do you think it's okay to just pull that rat's toes off
- 38:57one by one or pull its feet off or light his tail on fire?
- 39:00And then they'll stop.
- 39:01Like, why are you saying these things?
- 39:03Why are you doing that?
- 39:04Right.
- 39:05That's horrible.
- 39:06Right.
- 39:07So you don't really have to convince somebody that it's wrong to torture an animal.
- 39:09It's a harm an animal.
- 39:11And then you think about these whole grass fed free roaming myths and you think, all
- 39:18right, well, if you have this lovable dog and she grows up in your house and she cuddles
- 39:24and she gets everything a dog could want with the walks and the running and the playing
- 39:28and food.
- 39:31And then one day you just shoot her in the face.
- 39:33Well, that's not right.
- 39:34Right.
- 39:35So everybody knows like you can't just, just because an animal had a good life doesn't
- 39:36mean it's ethical to kill them.
- 39:38Right.
- 39:39This is all intuitive stuff for us.
- 39:40You know, people think of veganism as extremism in some ways, but when you think about it,
- 39:45it's really a simple principle, right?
- 39:46Don't torture and don't kill an animal that has a life and feels pain and the sentience.
- 39:52It's pretty basic.
- 39:53I think most people will agree with those premises if you're actually confronted with
- 39:57it head on.
- 39:58And then the question becomes, is it justifiable?
- 40:01Right.
- 40:02And there's a concept in the walk, the justification defense where, you know, the idea is not that
- 40:08something is ever right, but can it be justifiable nonetheless?
- 40:11Right.
- 40:12So a robber is always going to be unethical.
- 40:14It's never ethical to rob a store.
- 40:16Nobody would be like, oh yeah, it's great.
- 40:17Go rob a gas station.
- 40:18That's a great thing to do on a Saturday night.
- 40:20It's just not okay.
- 40:21Right.
- 40:22But it's worse if Bill Gates does it than if, you know, there's a homeless pregnant
- 40:27mother who needs to feed her family of three.
- 40:30Right.
- 40:31It's not that it becomes ethical for her to rob the store, but it's justifiable.
- 40:34And I think that's how I view the animal rights issue and consuming animals and animal agriculture
- 40:41is, you know, if Ben Gunn is a vegan, right, Ben Gunn being a artist stranded and marooned
- 40:47in Treasure Island, right, and he needs to catch and kill an animal to survive.
- 40:51Like, okay, right.
- 40:52But he doesn't have to put the animal's life above his own.
- 40:55He can still survive and I think he'd still consider him to be an ethical vegan if he
- 41:00leaves it as a vegan.
- 41:02But then it becomes, you know, what justifies it?
- 41:04And I think the more substitutes we start to see, more people start to see that these
- 41:09aren't necessities, the more people will start to realize like, oh, this is unethical
- 41:14and it is also unjustifiable.
- 41:17And I think that's where the movement needs to push people is this is not justifiable.
- 41:22I also wanted to address the fact that, you know, we talk about those products, those
- 41:29meat, you know, lab grown meat and the impossible burgers of the world and the just eggs as
- 41:37alternatives.
- 41:39But why should they be the alternative?
- 41:44Why people would not have the instinct of purchasing both, you know, animal products
- 41:50and those alternatives, so to speak?
- 41:54Yeah.
- 41:55I mean, I think you identify a real problem.
- 41:57I think that we're seeing that in the market now in large part.
- 42:01And that's something the article talks about is where people don't look at it as an alternative,
- 42:07but they look at it as in addition to.
- 42:10Right.
- 42:12I think that's only true with some products and some industries.
- 42:15And maybe that talks for product quality and price and where things are.
- 42:18Right.
- 42:19I mean, products like oat milk put a huge dent into the market for dairy milk.
- 42:25And so I do think there is the opportunity to get there.
- 42:29But you're right when it comes to products like just egg or beyond burgers, impossible
- 42:34burgers.
- 42:35Right.
- 42:36You're seeing more of an in addition to rather than an alternative kind of approach.
- 42:41And that's where I think a couple of things have to happen.
- 42:43Right.
- 42:44You have the economic side where you have to keep pushing for that price parity, because
- 42:48right now plant based products are largely more expensive still across the board.
- 42:53And as the companies work to bring down those prices and on the other hand, as lawyers are
- 42:58working to kind of litigate up costs for the animal industries, whether that's through
- 43:05litigation or attacking subsidies from the government, you'll start to get that price
- 43:10parity.
- 43:11And that's when I think you'll see more of a substitute than an addition to.
- 43:15And on the other side, to the extent you can give people that ethical argument, even if
- 43:21you can't convince everybody ethically, I think the more it becomes out there and the
- 43:25more people start to think about it, the more they'll be like, all right, these other products
- 43:29aren't that bad.
- 43:30I can switch over.
- 43:31So I think it's both.
- 43:33I think it's a twofold response.
- 43:35And I think right now we're not seeing it yet, but hopefully we will get to the point
- 43:40where we are seeing that if you can reach that price parity there.
- 43:46And what are the indicators of this strategy working?
- 43:50Well, I mean, I think you kind of have your stereotypical statistical indicators, right?
- 44:01Which are, is the quantity of animal product sales going down and the product of plant
- 44:07based sales going up, right, and you can try to kind of quantify everything.
- 44:11And then I think there's indicators that just aren't really quantifiable, right?
- 44:16You can kind of start to see shifts in society and judges that are hard to quantify at first
- 44:23and aren't really obvious until they take hold, right?
- 44:25The non-human rights project had a case on behalf of Happy the Elephant in New York,
- 44:30right?
- 44:31A habeas case about saying that the rights of Happy the Elephant were being infringed
- 44:36by being kept in the Bronx Zoo and ultimately lost in the highest state court in New York.
- 44:45But there were seven judges, I believe, on that panel and two of them wrote very strong
- 44:50opinions, disagreeing with the opinion as cultural dissent.
- 44:53And they wrote two very strong dissenting opinions, which maybe shows you like, oh,
- 45:00these kind of off the wall ideas, as we would call them, are now becoming a lot more on
- 45:05the wall, right?
- 45:06So you get these kind of subtle indications along the way that the thought is starting
- 45:11to change.
- 45:12You now have these very kind of prestigious judges sitting on the bench who agree with
- 45:16this as a theory, who believe that animals should have legal personhood.
- 45:20And 20 years ago, you know, you barely had lawyers who would agree with that, let alone
- 45:25judges.
- 45:26So you get indicators like that that show there's progress.
- 45:29You have your quantitative indicators, you know, and then you kind of have your indicators
- 45:32of your own, which is difficult because n equals one is always bad statistically.
- 45:38But you can go and you have conversations with people and you see how people are thinking
- 45:42about things and have they heard of veganism?
- 45:44You know, a lot of you know, just a few years ago, you hear people going like, oh, are you
- 45:48a vegan?
- 45:49Or are you a, you know, and they wouldn't even know the word.
- 45:52Now I think most people know the word and maybe that's an indicator of progress.
- 45:56I wish there was something like a doomsday clock of veganism, something that could, you
- 46:05know, measure, have this overview measure of the progress of the cause and just, you
- 46:13know, instruct the movement to, you know, hey, you should be critical about what you're
- 46:22doing right now because in the past three years we had a 5% increase in our universal
- 46:33vegan cause indicator.
- 46:35And this year we had like 3%.
- 46:37What happened?
- 46:39Something like that, some kind of universal way of, oh, we're making progress towards
- 46:45our end goal.
- 46:46Yeah, I listen, I would love that.
- 46:49And I think everybody in the movement would because you love to see some indication that
- 46:54what you're doing matters and makes a difference.
- 46:57And I'm guilty of the same thing, right?
- 46:59Like when Animal Outlook, when we put out our New York Times article about the Holden
- 47:03Farms investigation, you know, you can get the media imprint numbers and see like this
- 47:09story has reached so many hundreds of millions of people, right?
- 47:13And it's quantifiable and it makes you feel good.
- 47:15You think, okay, this is getting out there.
- 47:18But I think we also have to be pretty cautious and circumspect about relying too much on
- 47:23that short-term positive reinforcement.
- 47:26You know, like we live in a world of social media where it's a lot of times about likes
- 47:30and clicks and, you know, how many people have seen your posts and things along those
- 47:35lines.
- 47:37And it can obfuscate, I think, the long-term goal sometimes.
- 47:40It certainly has an intrinsic value to it, you know, but I think, you know, if we look
- 47:46back historically, it's like when people were fighting for whatever cause they were fighting
- 47:51for, they were doing it just because it was the right thing to do.
- 47:54They had no idea if it was going to make an impact.
- 47:56They just knew, this is what I know.
- 47:59This is a black and white issue.
- 48:00I, you know, I would like to make some impact in my life and whether I win this fight or
- 48:05lose this fight, I'm doing it because it's the right thing to do.
- 48:09And I think that mindset is sometimes difficult to keep in a world where you want to quantify
- 48:16things.
- 48:17And again, I don't say this standing on like my high horse over here, you know, like I
- 48:22think we're all guilty of it, myself included, of wanting to see these tangible short-term
- 48:27results.
- 48:28And I love statistics.
- 48:29My most influential legal paper was not a legal paper.
- 48:32It was a scientific statistical paper.
- 48:36And I think it has a ton of value.
- 48:39But I also think there's something to be said for just saying, this is a black and white
- 48:43issue, exploiting animals is wrong.
- 48:45I'm going to just fight this out till I, you know, and that's, that's what I'm here to
- 48:51do.
- 48:52And I think that'll move the movement forward as well.
- 48:56Yeah.
- 48:57Let me just say something a bit shocking.
- 48:59You know, I think maybe if those past successful social justice movements were using maybe
- 49:10more indicators or more data and more, you know, you know, measures of impact, maybe
- 49:16they would have had more success and, you know, at a quicker rate than they had.
- 49:25And also, I do believe that the animal protection movement is its own thing.
- 49:32I think, yeah, it is helpful to compare to other social justice movement up to a certain
- 49:39point.
- 49:41This is, this is in every way you look at it, a different ballgame, you know, in terms
- 49:49of how big it is, you know, what we're going against this industry, but not just that,
- 49:56the ideology behind it and how much it is has been established for thousands of years
- 50:04and how it is universally adopted by every culture and how it's not a divide between,
- 50:12you know, gender or race, but different between species, you know, divide between species.
- 50:21It's crazy.
- 50:22I agree with you completely.
- 50:24I think, you know, on the one hand, if you ignore history and don't learn lessons from
- 50:29history, then you're, you know, you're being naive and not learning lessons that you can
- 50:34learn.
- 50:35And, you know, like one of my favorite books I remember reading is What Can Animal Law
- 50:37Learn from Environmental Law?
- 50:40And I'm blocking on the author's name right now, which is mortifying.
- 50:43But you know, you get these kind of analyses that compare it up to their movements and
- 50:48how they've evolved and they're very helpful.
- 50:51But also, you don't want to stick to a rubric because everything does work in its own way.
- 50:56And this is, like you said, you know, no pun intended, a different animal.
- 50:59And so, you know, you know, it's we're humans, we're inherently imperfect, and we're winging
- 51:07it a little bit as we go.
- 51:10But it's, you know, maybe I've just been a lawyer too long where I keep giving wishy
- 51:14washy answers.
- 51:15But I think when you don't know the answer, you have to be open to all strategies and
- 51:21you have to be open to pulling from the past.
- 51:23And you also have to be open to, you know, to taking risks of your own.
- 51:28Think can actually move things forward and make a difference.
- 51:31And they're not inherently contradictory.
- 51:33No, it's a good answer.
- 51:37And you're at the forefront of this fight, which I'm not.
- 51:43So no, you definitely are.
- 51:46And I think, you know, we all it's I don't know, I guess maybe we all struggle with this
- 51:53of, you know, wanting to you want to know you're making a difference, but also have
- 51:59the humility to know that you're one small piece of a wheel.
- 52:03And yeah, I mean, I think that we what you're doing is incredibly valuable.
- 52:08I mean, when I was in law school, we didn't have an animal law class.
- 52:12I learned animal law by listening to the Animal Law Podcast, right?
- 52:15I'm Mary Ann Sullivan's podcast.
- 52:17That's how I taught myself animal law.
- 52:20So people like you who are getting ideas like this out there that wouldn't otherwise be
- 52:25out there, I think is as valuable as anything that can be done.
- 52:29And if nothing else, it's certainly nice to hear intelligent people like yourself asking
- 52:35intelligent questions and making people think and, you know, making the movement reflect
- 52:41and think.
- 52:42I certainly can't say that I have all of the right answers or good answers or certainly
- 52:46not the best answers.
- 52:47But you know, when we start having these conversations and thinking it through deeply and taking
- 52:52the issue seriously, I think that's in a lot of ways the most we can ask of ourselves.
- 52:57And so I am very grateful for you for doing this and for inviting me on for challenging
- 53:02me.
- 53:03And yeah, I think it's I think it's very valuable.
- 53:07Thank you, Sherb.
- 53:08And did I miss something?
- 53:10Is there a question I should have asked and I missed?
- 53:15No, I mean, I don't think so.
- 53:18I'm happy to answer anything else you have.
- 53:20I mean, some of the questions I get a lot are like, oh, what should, you know, law students
- 53:25do if they're looking to become animal, you know, things like that, which I think are
- 53:28probably a little bit more off the mark for your podcast.
- 53:31I'm a legal nerd.
- 53:32If there's like nuances, I'm happy to go into them.
- 53:35But I think we've hit a lot of, you know, the big points.
- 53:39Well, let me now thank you, Sherb, for for this wonderful article.
- 53:44And you know, not just you, but also the other two co-authors.
- 53:49It's wonderful to have this not mindset, but to be able to conceptualize what we're doing
- 53:55and to have this clear view of, you know, here's the plan.
- 53:59Yeah, I loved that article.
- 54:02And thank you so much for having written the article and for your activism work.
- 54:08Well, thank you.
- 54:10And thank you to you as well for all the reasons that I said and for having me on to talk about
- 54:16it.
- 54:17And, you know, like I said at the beginning, I hope it gives a good roadmap.
- 54:20And I also think it's a starting point.
- 54:22And if people see ways to improve it or to tweak it, I think, you know, that's always
- 54:28a very positive thing.
- 54:29It helps to move us forward.
- 54:32And I hope that, you know, putting it out there serves some sort of a unifying force.
- 54:37But I also hope that it encourages people to critique me and to put ideas out there
- 54:43that are even better and stronger.
- 54:45And, you know, I obviously would not have been able to write it without my co-authors,
- 54:50without Brace and Cheryl.
- 54:51Brace is my best friend from law school who got me into Adam along in the first place.
- 54:55So I was very happy to be able to write the article with her.
- 54:59Thank you everyone for listening.
- 55:00I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 55:05Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 55:08Again, thank you so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.