Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Retail media networks: when they destroy margin
Transcript
- 0:00Host: Leaders' Insights, today turn your first-party data into a margin line.
- 0:09Expert: A grocery buyer I know spent last Tuesday morning not haggling over pallet prices, but
- 0:14Expert: staring at a dashboard showing which brands were bidding for the digital shelf above the
- 0:18Expert: pasta aisle.
- 0:19Expert: That's the room now.
- 0:21Host: And that room is where the money is.
- 0:24Expert: The thing that happened this year, retail media networks, meaning the ad businesses
- 0:28Expert: retailers run on their own sites and apps, crossed from novelty into structural profit.
- 0:34Expert: We're talking margins that rival a grocer's entire net margin on selling food.
- 0:38Host: Rival it.
- 0:39Host: That's a big claim.
- 0:41Host: Put a number on it.
- 0:42Expert: A supermarket nets somewhere around 2-3% on the groceries themselves.
- 0:47Expert: The advertising line inside the same business runs at 70-80% margin.
- 0:53Expert: So a retailer doing a billion in media revenue is throwing off more profit from ads than
- 0:57Expert: from half its stores.
- 0:59Host: Amazon proved that years ago.
- 1:01Host: Why is a regional grocer suddenly relevant?
- 1:04Expert: Because the asset finally matured.
- 1:06Expert: First-party data.
- 1:08Expert: What your own shoppers actually bought from you, not what a third-party guest, is the
- 1:12Expert: only clean signal left after the privacy rules gutted the tracking cookie.
- 1:16Expert: Kroger, Walmart, Tesco built the muscle.
- 1:19Expert: Now the mid-tier is copying, and most of them are copying badly.
- 1:23Host: Define badly.
- 1:24Host: I want the field report, not the brochure.
- 1:27Expert: Quietly means a CMO who launches a media network to hit a revenue target and quietly
- 1:31Expert: ruins the customer experience.
- 1:34Expert: I watched a chain.
- 1:35Expert: I won't name them.
- 1:36Expert: They're a client.
- 1:37Expert: Stuff so many sponsored products into search results that their own private label range,
- 1:42Expert: the high margin stuff they own, vanished below the fold.
- 1:45Expert: They sold ad slots and cannibalized their best profit line.
- 1:50Expert: Net negative.
- 1:51Host: So the ad money masked the loss.
- 1:53Expert: Exactly.
- 1:54Expert: The dashboard glowed green on media revenue, while basket size shrank.
- 1:59Expert: Nobody connected the two for two quarters.
- 2:02Host: What separates the ones getting it right?
- 2:04Expert: They treat the media network as a margin line the CMO owns, not a side hustle for the ad
- 2:09Expert: sales team.
- 2:10Expert: That means one person accountable for both ad revenue and shopper loyalty, so the tension
- 2:15Expert: is visible.
- 2:16Expert: When those live in separate silos, the ad side always wins and the customer always loses.
- 2:22Host: You keep saying data's the asset.
- 2:24Host: Everyone says data's the asset.
- 2:25Host: How much is actually usable?
- 2:27Expert: Less than you'd hope.
- 2:29Expert: HubSpot puts marketers' data readiness at something like 60-odd percent.
- 2:34Expert: Though worth flagging, they sell the software that fixes it.
- 2:37Expert: So cross-check that against something independent.
- 2:40Expert: MIT Sloan's work is more sobering.
- 2:44Expert: Most retailers can't reconcile a loyalty card with an online account for the same
- 2:48Expert: human.
- 2:49Expert: If you can't join those two records, you don't have first-party data, you have two
- 2:53Expert: piles of noise.
- 2:55Host: So the first job isn't selling ads.
- 2:57Host: It's plumbing.
- 2:58Host: The plumbing?
- 2:59Expert: Identity resolution.
- 3:01Expert: Matching the card, the app login, the email to one actual person.
- 3:05Expert: Unsexy, and it's where the value either exists or doesn't.
- 3:09Host: Let's talk about who shouldn't build one.
- 3:11Host: Because the article's blunt.
- 3:12Host: This can destroy more value than it creates.
- 3:15Expert: If you don't have scale, don't start.
- 3:18Expert: You need enough weekly shoppers that an advertiser can reach a real audience.
- 3:22Expert: Below roughly a few million active customers, the ad inventory's too thin to charge a premium.
- 3:28Expert: And you burn engineering budget building a shop nobody wants a stall in.
- 3:32Host: Give me the threshold moment.
- 3:34Host: When does a CMO know it's working versus vanity?
- 3:37Expert: Watch incrementality, whether the ad actually caused a sale that wouldn't have happened
- 3:41Expert: anyway.
- 3:42Expert: SEMrush and the analytics vendors will sell you attribution models that claim everything
- 3:47Expert: worked.
- 3:48Expert: Naturally, they're selling the measurement tool.
- 3:51Expert: Scale incrementality means running a holdout, a group you deliberately don't advertise
- 3:55Expert: to, and comparing.
- 3:58Expert: If the advertised group doesn't outperform the holdout, you're charging brands for sales
- 4:02Expert: they'd have made regardless.
- 4:04Expert: That fraud gets found out fast, and the ad budget leaves.
- 4:07Host: One thing the listener does Monday morning.
- 4:10Expert: Pull one week of loyalty data and one week of online orders, and ask your team to count
- 4:14Expert: how many customers appear in both, matched to a single ID.
- 4:19Expert: Whatever that number is, it's the ceiling on everything you're about to build.
- 4:23Expert: Know it before you sell a single ad.
- 4:25Host: Sources for today's episode.
- 4:27Host: SEMrush vendor SEO analytics tools, DigiDay HubSpot vendor CRM marketing automation,
- 4:36Host: MIT Sloan Management Review.
- 4:39Host: That's your five.
- 4:40Host: The full CMO track, structured and free of fluff, is at MBA-training.com.