Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Just When You Thought It Was Safe - ECOA Part 2
Transcript
- 0:00While a specific number of reasons is not mandated, more than four
- 0:07reasons is probably not helpful.
- 0:10And the reason is because if somebody has a significant number of problems,
- 0:16it's probably going to be hard for them to deal with all of them, but it would
- 0:21be much more beneficial for those people to know that the 3 or 4 most significant
- 0:26problems with your credit are ABC and D
- 0:30Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:36I hope you enjoy.
- 0:38Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:41Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the Insider's View on passing
- 0:44your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:47The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:50Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:52If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:55team and receive Support to optimize your results with NCUA.
- 0:59So you save time and money.
- 1:01Visit us at marctreichel.
- 1:02com to find out more.
- 1:05Hey everyone.
- 1:05This is Marc Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 1:08I'm back again with Joe Goldberg.
- 1:10Joe, you ready for part two?
- 1:12Absolutely, Mark.
- 1:14All right.
- 1:14Well, Joe, I'll keep your intro, your bio a little bit shorter.
- 1:18Joe's been an attorney for 40 years.
- 1:20He's now consulting and doing a few other things.
- 1:23He spent eight years at NCUA.
- 1:25And he's a consumer compliance guru of sorts.
- 1:29And we are going to jump back into ECOA, Reg B and a few remaining topics
- 1:35on this that we didn't cover in part one, Joe, the microphone is yours.
- 1:40All right.
- 1:41Thank you very much, Mark.
- 1:42Then in the first part of this, we talked about the background
- 1:45of ECOA and then we went through.
- 1:47What I characterize is one of the two primary purposes of the law,
- 1:51which is to prevent discrimination.
- 1:53And now we're going to look at the second primary purpose, which is to encourage
- 1:58the informed use of credit, which is a stated purpose that Congress put right
- 2:03in the Equal Credit Opportunity Act.
- 2:06And the way that it did that is that it required.
- 2:09A creditor to provide a notice to an applicant who is either denied
- 2:16credit or received credit on terms that were not as favorable as the
- 2:23terms that the person applied for.
- 2:25Many of you may be familiar with the term adverse action notice, and
- 2:30that's what this, this notice is.
- 2:31It's a notice that adverse action was taken on the application.
- 2:37So, let's take a look at what, what is done either through the
- 2:41act itself or through Regulation B.
- 2:45So, the purpose of this is to inform an applicant of the
- 2:48reasons for the adverse action.
- 2:52Why was the credit denied?
- 2:54Why was it revoked?
- 2:55Why was it provided?
- 2:58Obviously, the revocation would be existing credit, or was
- 3:02existing credit adversely changed?
- 3:04Or was the credit applied for originally approved, but approved with less
- 3:10favorable terms than those requested.
- 3:13So it's the why, here's what, here's why we didn't want you to be our customer.
- 3:20The adverse action notices must provide specific reasons in some level of detail.
- 3:27For example, you cannot just say applicant does not meet our lending standards.
- 3:32It's just not sufficient.
- 3:34First of all, a borrower is not going to know what your lending standards are.
- 3:38And which one is it that they didn't meet?
- 3:41It's just simply isn't informing the applicant of the reasons
- 3:45for the adverse action.
- 3:47So, uh, so, uh, Joe, if they have a debt to income ratio of X percent.
- 3:53And you were at X plus 5%.
- 3:55You could say that your obligations and debt ratio is that would be,
- 4:00would that be something that would be specific enough to meet this right?
- 4:04That would be specific.
- 4:05There's not a need to put the exact numbers that you're looking that
- 4:09the credit union looks for what the persons were just the fact
- 4:12that the debt to income ratio.
- 4:14However you want to term it was too great to, to, for the credit
- 4:19union to provide the credit.
- 4:21Got it.
- 4:22All right now, this is all the way the regulation approaches
- 4:28the adverse action notice.
- 4:29It does say that the notice should contain the principle
- 4:32reasons for the adverse action.
- 4:35And the reason that it discusses this is there's a problem with
- 4:40not providing enough information, but there's also a problem with
- 4:45providing too much information.
- 4:47What the official interpretation of regular regulation be states is that.
- 4:52While a specific number of reasons is not mandated, more than four
- 5:00reasons is probably not helpful.
- 5:03And the reason is because if somebody has a significant number of problems, it's
- 5:08probably going to be hard for them to deal with all of them, but it would be much
- 5:14more beneficial for those people to know that the 3 or 4 most significant problems
- 5:20with your credit are ABC and D that then gives that borrower or applicant.
- 5:28The ability to start to address the credit deficiencies, and it makes sense
- 5:33because I didn't yeah that I learned that today that I was today years old,
- 5:38understanding that but that makes sense that you don't want to pile on you
- 5:41don't want to say here's the 47 reasons.
- 5:43What were the main reasons, and then they can look towards resolving those.
- 5:48Exactly.
- 5:49If, you know, if the main reason is your income is too low, or if your debts are
- 5:53too high, those whether whether the person can actually address those is debatable.
- 5:59But the fact is, for for most people, that's going to be the type of
- 6:04problem that if it was alleviated.
- 6:07We get them into consideration for some type of credit, maybe not,
- 6:11maybe under different terms, but so, yeah, you want to be able to, as an
- 6:16applicant, know what are the few things I can do to try and better my credit.
- 6:21And again, for some people, it may be beyond repair, unfortunately, but for
- 6:27the great number of people, it's not.
- 6:29And if they know what they can, they have to address, they can take
- 6:32some steps to, to address that.
- 6:35So now there's, there's some wrinkles to this, for example, if
- 6:40the credit union says, we can't give you this loan on these terms.
- 6:46However, we can give you this car loan at X plus 2%.
- 6:53Interest rate instead of what you asked for.
- 6:57If the person accepts the counter offer, then, then they're okay.
- 7:02There, there is no need for adverse action because the credit has been consummated.
- 7:07Also, if there's an automatic denial based on one factor in an AUS, automated,
- 7:12automated underwriting system, you don't have to, it, it also permits the
- 7:18creditor for, to provide only one notice where the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
- 7:27Also requires an adverse action notice.
- 7:29Again, some of you may be familiar with the fact that if a credit
- 7:33report or a consumer consumer report as a proper terminology is used.
- 7:40In considering whether to extend the credit.
- 7:44The fair credit reporting act also has an adverse action notice requirement
- 7:48so that if the credit is denied, or the terms are less favorable that applied for.
- 7:54And a credit report was used in that determination.
- 7:58There has to be an adverse action notice under the F.
- 8:01C.
- 8:02R.
- 8:02A.
- 8:03Interesting.
- 8:03The, the ECOA Reg B, the CFPB said a few years ago, and then I say a few,
- 8:11it may have been six, seven, eight years ago, that, The use of a single
- 8:16notice for both will satisfy ECOA.
- 8:22So, and there, I believe that there's even a form, a sample form in the
- 8:27official interpretation of the regulation.
- 8:29Am I, am I right?
- 8:31Excuse me, that, that the applicant can, has a way to say, hey, if, if, if you're
- 8:36going to give me an adverse action.
- 8:39I'd rather get it in hard copy or electronically.
- 8:42Are, am I right about that?
- 8:44And then are, is the institution required to do both?
- 8:49The institution can actually give an oral notice, but you won't find that
- 8:55very often because the, what you have to say orally is pretty much what you
- 9:01would have to put in a written notice and it's a little bit complicated to have
- 9:07somebody sit down there and, you know, sit and read this orally to a consumer.
- 9:12So.
- 9:12The answer is yes.
- 9:13And in fact, the person doesn't have to provide the notice, but has to
- 9:17say that the notice is available.
- 9:19Excuse me.
- 9:19The creditor doesn't have to creditor can say the notice is available.
- 9:23And then the person can ask for it.
- 9:25But it really doesn't make sense for a creditor to try and give the reasons.
- 9:32Orally, you run a real risk for compliance purposes.
- 9:37Consistency would be hard to maintain and then it also could get, you know,
- 9:42into a debate and you could end up having conversations you wouldn't
- 9:46even want to contemplate having.
- 9:48Exactly.
- 9:48Exactly.
- 9:49And then the last thing I do want to say is that there's also a requirement for
- 9:53something similar for business applicants.
- 9:55The standards are different.
- 9:57I don't want to go into them, but they're, they're.
- 9:59Pretty easy to read in the regulation.
- 10:01I don't think we need to go into him at this time.
- 10:04Got it.
- 10:05All right.
- 10:05Now, you know, we talked about the 2 significant provisions, but there
- 10:11are some other provisions of a coa that everybody should know about.
- 10:15And 1, I did mention a little bit earlier, and that is a special
- 10:18purpose credit program, and this is a carve out that allows creditors.
- 10:24To meet the credit needs of specified classes of persons, and these are
- 10:29for programs for those who are economically or socially disadvantaged.
- 10:34Either consumers or commercial enterprises, there are rules that
- 10:40govern these, there actually is sort of one set of rules for for profit,
- 10:46financial institutions, and then another set for nonprofits, they, they allow
- 10:53this type of credit to be extended.
- 10:56And there has to be, it's one of two things.
- 11:00It's a credit assistance program that's expressly authorized by federal
- 11:04or state law for the benefit of an economically disadvantaged class of
- 11:08persons, or a credit assistance program offered by a not for profit organization
- 11:15for the benefit of its members.
- 11:17Or an economically disadvantaged class of persons credit unions fall under
- 11:22the not for profit organization prong.
- 11:25So, you know, there is consideration of the membership and the credit union
- 11:31can target a portion of its membership if it is specifically an economically
- 11:36disadvantaged class of persons.
- 11:39Again, if you're interested in looking at this, I know that I believe in 2022,
- 11:45NCUA sent a letter to credit unions describing the availability of these
- 11:50programs to credit unions and encouraging some to look at the possibility of
- 11:57implementing some of these programs if it was appropriate for their membership.
- 12:02Interesting.
- 12:02Yeah, I'll have to take a look at that letter.
- 12:04I'm not familiar with that if that's out there.
- 12:06Thank you.
- 12:06It went out, I believe it went out at the same, may have been something other than a
- 12:09letter, a formal letter to credit unions, but I know that whatever was sent out was
- 12:14done around the same time as banks put out something similar, you know, banks.
- 12:18Yeah, it probably was a letter to credit unions.
- 12:22That would be the natural way to do that.
- 12:24Yeah.
- 12:25All right.
- 12:26So, we talked in the first part of this presentation about the referring
- 12:34of credit unions to the Department of Justice for violations of ECOA.
- 12:40There is a provision right in ECOA, it's section 1691E, and then in
- 12:47parentheses, it's subsection G, that requires a financial regulator,
- 12:56Federal financial regulator to refer to the Department of justice.
- 13:03Institutions under its supervision when there is a reason to believe that the
- 13:09institution has engaged in a pattern or practice of illegal discrimination.
- 13:16And I mentioned in this, the 1st, part of this presentation that has done so for age
- 13:24violations violations for discrimination based on the prohibited basis of age.
- 13:31And also on the prohibited basis of marital status, at least.
- 13:36During the time I was there, the Department of Justice returned all
- 13:43of the referrals, mostly because they felt that the NCOA, as an agency, had
- 13:49properly handled the matters internally, and there was no need for the DOJ to
- 13:55be involved and to file an action.
- 13:58In 1996, DOJ issued guidance.
- 14:04To the federal banking regulators, and I use that term in its broad sense,
- 14:08because included in the title of it is identifying lender practices.
- 14:14That may form the basis of a pattern or practice for referrals
- 14:18to the Department of justice.
- 14:20It's publicly available.
- 14:23It's still in, it's still in play, DOJ considers it to be still an active
- 14:29guidance if you will, NCUA uses it, it's available to the, to the credit unions.
- 14:35It might be on NCU's website, NCUA's website.
- 14:39I'm not positive.
- 14:40I'll talk about that in a minute where things are, but I know that
- 14:45DOJ has it publicly available.
- 14:47Got it.
- 14:47It's actually fairly interesting reading because it does give you some guidance on
- 14:53how to avoid being caught up in a problem with a COA that results in a referral.
- 15:01All right, so, and I did note that NCOA has done that is
- 15:06now become a regular thing.
- 15:07Unfortunately, there are a number of credit unions who just can't
- 15:10seem to get this either age discrimination or marital status.
- 15:15Issue fixed.
- 15:17So some of the others, as you said, as you said, the word is required.
- 15:21If NCOA comes across the fact pattern that fits, they have to refer it to the DOJ.
- 15:27It's not, it's not a, there's not an art to that determination.
- 15:31If the facts are the facts are the facts.
- 15:33And if there is a discrimination, it must go to DOJ and, and then NCOA can
- 15:38tell the credit union to fix it or the credit union can respond and fix it.
- 15:43And it's those kinds of things that DOJ weighs once it's referred to them.
- 15:47Right, and generally, I can tell you my experience was we would have conversations
- 15:51with credit union management and explain the standards that are in that DOJ
- 15:58publication, which includes such things as restitution having been made the problem
- 16:02already being corrected and, you know, we would point out that abiding by those.
- 16:09Provisions and that DOJ guidance would go a long way to the DOJ, not keeping
- 16:14referrals and it's, it's, it's just makes sense that you'd want to take care of
- 16:18your members anyway, if there was any issue that, you know, that similar to
- 16:22similar to showing remorse at sentencing.
- 16:25To some extent, to some extent, if, if, if it's, if it's sincere, yeah, I wasn't,
- 16:33I, I was just trying to put it into, you know, I'm not a lawyer, but I'm putting
- 16:37it into the real world ramifications and analogies that I can think of.
- 16:41But anyway, all right.
- 16:42And in, in, in defense of all the credit unions we dealt with to
- 16:46a credit union, each one said we had no idea this is not right.
- 16:51We shouldn't, we don't want to do this to our members.
- 16:53How do we make it right?
- 16:55And it's easy.
- 16:56I mean, you have something, we've always done it this way, right?
- 16:58It's been in there for five years or 10 years.
- 17:00And then when you, and so it goes in and raises the question and you look
- 17:03at it through a different lens, you can go, Oh my gosh, I didn't realize that.
- 17:07How do I fix it?
- 17:08Oh, yeah, there were, there were definitely credit unions where there was
- 17:10nobody left in the credit union who knew when that practice had been implemented.
- 17:16So get that.
- 17:17Yeah.
- 17:18All right.
- 17:19So some of the other requirements of a COA that haven't yet been covered is that
- 17:22it does require a creditor to provide a written copy of an appraisal or offer.
- 17:29The appraisal that was used in a credit decision and at no cost for the copy to
- 17:36the applicant, just it's a requirement.
- 17:39There are also in this kind of dovetails into what we just talked about with the D.
- 17:44O.
- 17:44J.
- 17:44referrals to some extent.
- 17:46There are incentives built into.
- 17:49The for self testing and self correction, it can eliminate a finding of a violation.
- 17:58Uh, if a credit union on its own self tests, that could be either internal
- 18:03or the use of a, you know, a 3rd party doing some type of external audit and as
- 18:09a means of testing and self correction.
- 18:12Um, and I know that there have been some credit unions who self reported to when
- 18:19I was there saying, hey, we found this.
- 18:22We've corrected it.
- 18:23What do we do?
- 18:24And under a would not have been a problem because as long as the standards were
- 18:30met for self correction and self testing.
- 18:33So that's again, that's an incentive.
- 18:36To the.
- 18:38Credit industry as a whole to do things right and to get things right.
- 18:43There is a brand new, um, section of a co op that essentially, let's
- 18:50see, the effective date is going to be April, excuse me, August 29th of
- 18:562023, although the compliance date as well after that, there is a separate.
- 19:03Podcasts that goes into detail on it, but it refers there.
- 19:07Excuse me.
- 19:07It requires.
- 19:09Those who lend to small businesses to collect data similar to hum the data
- 19:15and beyond that for every application.
- 19:18And report that data to the CFPB, um, as long as you, the creditor meets
- 19:26the threshold of threshold is at least 100 originations to small businesses
- 19:33for each of the prior 2 years that would require report collection
- 19:37reporting in the 3rd year and detailed.
- 19:40Joe, let me interrupt there for one second.
- 19:42The, that podcast is podcast number 111, which is, which is published
- 19:50and was published on June 13th.
- 19:52So, all right, if you that'll this, the one we're recording
- 19:55today will come after June 13th.
- 19:57So if you're listening to it, and you want to hear the podcast Joe is referring to on
- 20:01the small business loan data collection, it's number 111 published on June 13th.
- 20:07Great.
- 20:07Thank you for that, Mark.
- 20:08Great.
- 20:09Um, enforcement for federal credit unions.
- 20:13The NCOA is the enforcing agency for ACOA for federally insured
- 20:18state credit unions and for non federally insured state charters.
- 20:23The Federal Trade Commission is the enforcement agency.
- 20:27Now, the Act also includes provisions for private actions against
- 20:35a creditor who violates ACOA.
- 20:39The, the act allows for the recovery of actual damages for punitive damages, up to
- 20:4610, 000 for a case involving an individual class actions are not prohibited.
- 20:53And in fact, there is a provision under the punitive damages section that governs
- 20:59how much the punitive damages can be.
- 21:02And just so you know, it's the lesser of.
- 21:05500, 000 or 1 percent of the net worth of the actor.
- 21:14If there's a punitive damages in a class action for class actions, if
- 21:19there are actual damages, there's not a limit to the actual damages.
- 21:24And also there can be injunctive relief and an award of attorney's fees and costs.
- 21:30Joe, on, on class actions, um, you know, just, this is just kind of a
- 21:35something that jumped into my head and not related to this particular
- 21:39topic, but a class action lawsuit for, um, you know, your, your cable
- 21:44company overcharged you a dollar for.
- 21:47Something over 10 years and you, you get a notification that you had service by this
- 21:52cable company and, you know, you can, you can opt in as part of the class action.
- 21:59And then 2 years later, you get a check for 4 dollars and 76 cents.
- 22:04And, but the law firm got a big settlement, right?
- 22:08Um.
- 22:09Any thought, and I know that what, what's being protected under these
- 22:14laws here and the ability to have these class action lawsuits make
- 22:19sense because, because of the.
- 22:22The if there's an intent to do something very bad against people that that
- 22:28kind of protects that from happening, but can you think of examples?
- 22:32And I know I'm kind of putting you on the spot here, but, you know, the example of
- 22:36where I got a check for 4 and 12 cents to me seems to be almost an inappropriate
- 22:42use of class action lawsuits.
- 22:44Can you in your history of what you've seen out there in this arena?
- 22:49Can you think of some class action lawsuits that?
- 22:52That, um, that, that were, were worthy and actually ended up
- 22:56getting a reasonable settlement for, for people there are attorneys.
- 23:02Yeah, I can't, I can't come up with one off hand, but I was involved in several
- 23:06class actions in my private practice.
- 23:09And what you're raising is an argument that sort of has been there historically.
- 23:14The, the, the issue is.
- 23:17Is it okay to steal a million dollars from one person or it's
- 23:21or it's not okay, obviously, to steal a million dollars, right?
- 23:24One person, right?
- 23:25What is the materiality?
- 23:27It's okay to steal 10 million, you know, dollars from 50 million people
- 23:31because you, if you file a class action, everybody only gets 50 cents, but,
- 23:37you know, if you don't have the class action process, then the, the business
- 23:42that acts illegally gets to keep.
- 23:45The profits from the legal activity, I guess it's, it's like having
- 23:49a referee or an umpire, right?
- 23:50You gotta have someone there to call balls and strikes.
- 23:53Yeah, exactly.
- 23:54Exactly.
- 23:54And you know, people complain about the attorney's fees, which may or, you
- 23:59know, um, sometimes they're exorbitant, sometimes they're not, but that, that
- 24:03sort of also fits into the whole concept of if there's no penalty for, you know,
- 24:11The, the actor legally, look, there are some class actions that are questionable,
- 24:19whether there is a violation and they get settled because it's cheaper to settle.
- 24:23You know, I understand that.
- 24:24But there are great many who of class actions.
- 24:29That have a lot of value and, you know, it stops illegal activity and it does,
- 24:35um, it, the profits are not, they don't stay with the, the bank robber, you
- 24:40know, they, they go back to somewhere.
- 24:43At least they don't get to keep the fruits of their illegal activity.
- 24:46Perfect.
- 24:46Perfect explanation.
- 24:48I'm glad I asked the question.
- 24:49Yeah, it's, it's, it's not a, it's not a perfect system in,
- 24:53you know, but it's what we have.
- 24:56And to be honest, those, a lot of those types of class actions
- 25:02are things that a regulator.
- 25:05Could handle if the regulator had 10 times as many people working in the
- 25:10field, of course, nobody wants to do that.
- 25:12So class action sort of takes the place of a regulator in a lot of ways.
- 25:17Interesting.
- 25:18That's I like, I like how you frame that too.
- 25:20That's that's that's good.
- 25:22Yeah.
- 25:22All right.
- 25:23Now, quickly, I just want to talk about, um, because this is always
- 25:27important is what can the credit union do to make sure it's in compliance
- 25:31with ECOA and the regulation.
- 25:351st thing is no law be familiar with the Cohen regulation be and I'll
- 25:39talk about some resources for that.
- 25:42Um, make sure the compliance management system is sufficient.
- 25:47I know for a lot of smaller credit unions, if they even have somebody
- 25:51who's dedicated to consumer compliance, that that can be a stretch.
- 25:56And having somebody who would be dedicated to fair lending is just, you
- 26:01know, beyond, uh, beyond comprehension.
- 26:03I mean, the staff is small and I understand that, but assuming it's
- 26:07very important to have some type of compliance management system in place.
- 26:12So that somebody is looking at these functions within the credit union things
- 26:18that also apply to this are training.
- 26:22Those who are engaged in lending have to have training on a somewhat regular
- 26:27basis and fair lending, but not just those people, there have to be those
- 26:31who have play any role in the credit making and improving decision of the
- 26:37process, but also management because management has to be able to know that
- 26:43the CMS staff and the, the credit making Staff, whoever the lending staff is
- 26:49that they are also acting properly.
- 26:52So there has to be proper oversight within the credit union and you
- 26:56need to train the people who are responsible for the oversight.
- 26:59There also has to be oversight of third parties.
- 27:01You know, unfortunately, so many credit unions, not just credit unions, all the
- 27:06financial institutions use third party systems for a lot of the lending process.
- 27:11Um, and for better or for worse.
- 27:15The, the creditor itself is responsible for the acts of the 3rd party.
- 27:21So you have to have some ability to, um, have oversight over the indirect
- 27:28lenders or the vendors, whoever it may be.
- 27:31And again, I talked earlier about self testing.
- 27:34You know, audits and self testing are ways that you can accomplish
- 27:39that type of oversight as well.
- 27:40You can test to see if what's happening is compliant with the requirements of ECOA.
- 27:49Finally, in terms of resources on NCUA's website, there is a Fair Lending Guide.
- 27:55NCUA sends out regulatory alerts and letters to credit unions.
- 27:59We talked about this, referred to some of them in this and the previous COA podcast.
- 28:06There's a reason that they do that.
- 28:09NCOA will only send out these letters or regulatory alerts if there's
- 28:14something significant that's taken place or will be taking place.
- 28:18So that's a clue right there that if it says compliance or deals with something
- 28:23in compliance and you are involved in compliance, you need to read it.
- 28:27That's a great point.
- 28:28That's a great NCOA is seeing trends.
- 28:33Or irrespective of that, NCOA is going to start looking at something because a
- 28:37lot changed or because they've decided to pocket a certain area of potential law.
- 28:43Exactly.
- 28:44And then finally, on the NCUA website, there is a, what's called
- 28:47the financial, excuse me, Federal Consumer Financial Protection Guide,
- 28:53which is a collection of the exam procedures for all the different areas.
- 28:58And there is 1 for ACOA.
- 29:00So I would urge you to take a look at that because it has some helpful sections that
- 29:06can give you some guidance on, it'll tell you what the examiners are looking at.
- 29:11When they go out in the field, the fair lending examiners, especially, and
- 29:14finally, I would recommend you take a look at the CFPB's website, consumerfinance.
- 29:21gov is the website, but find your way to the fair lending section because
- 29:25they have a number of fair lending resources, including those on ECOA.
- 29:31Fantastic Joe, a lot, a lot, a lot to unpack here, a lot, a lot of
- 29:35good information for our listeners.
- 29:37And Joe, I want to thank you for being, for sharing your, your
- 29:40wisdom here with my listeners today.
- 29:42Good.
- 29:42Thanks for having me, Mark.
- 29:44You got it.
- 29:44And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 29:46I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 29:48This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 29:53Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 29:57your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 30:01of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 30:05If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 30:09out our services at marktreichel.
- 30:11com.