Latest / James O'Brien Daily / The Conservatives’ identity crisis
Transcript
- 0:02This is a global production.
- 0:05Welcome to today's James o' Brien Daily.
- 0:08Sit back and enjoy all the best bits from my daily LBC show where we get into the biggest news stories of the moment.
- 0:18If we were to talk about class, as we have done many, many times in this country on this program, I think we've overlooked what is possibly one of the most obvious signifiers.
- 0:30You know, someone says they're working class and you think, no, you're not.
- 0:33Or someone says they're middle class.
- 0:34And if you're a bit of a snob, you might think, no, you're not.
- 0:37Cami Badenot claimed to be working class, didn't she?
- 0:39Because she'd done some shifts in McDonald's which was, I mean, hilarious, bless her.
- 0:44But it spoke in her defence to the confusion that these words convey.
- 0:50What class are you?
- 0:51What class am I?
- 0:52What class is anybody?
- 0:53And I think one of the things that we would probably read reach for first would be manual labor, even quite highly skilled manual labour.
- 1:03If you're working with your hands, you are more likely to not only be considered by other people to be working class, but you are more likely to consider yourself working class.
- 1:16And that breaks the socio economic mold somewhat, doesn't it?
- 1:21Because these days you could be earning a heck of a lot more money working with your hands than you are.
- 1:26I know technically if you're operating a computer keyboard, you're working with your hands, but you know what I mean, you could be earning a heck of a lot more money as a plumber than you would be as a
- 1:35data entry clerk or somebody working from home on your computer in a sort of backroom office role.
- 1:45That highlights the inadequacy of the word class when we're trying to describe a category of people, but I think it probably comes closer than almost any other two dimensional distinction.
- 2:02What's the difference between working class and middle class?
- 2:04Well, middle class, your job involves a degree.
- 2:07Working class, your job involves working with your hands.
- 2:12And I think this is getting turned upside down not just because of the two stories that sit alongside each other today.
- 2:18Train up pupils as brickies and plumbers on the one hand, and graduates face worst job market on record on the other, but also because of the underlying reasons for both of these stories.
- 2:28Most obviously, technological change rendering a lot of what we would once have considered to be white collar work redundant.
- 2:35It is going to be done by AI.
- 2:37It is going to be done by in the most lazy of shorthands, it's going to be done by computers.
- 2:43What is currently done by people.
- 2:45And on the other hand, we need houses.
- 2:47We will always need houses.
- 2:48We will always need buildings.
- 2:50We need up to 755,000 construction workers by 2030 if we're to pursue the government target of one and a half million new homes.
- 2:59That was a National Audit Office report last month and it's a funny one, isn't it?
- 3:07It's the Plant Hire Association Chief Executive, Construction Plant Hire Association Steve Mulholland who's drawn attention to this.
- 3:16This morning the Daily Mirror picks up on his comments.
- 3:18Skill shortages are a major concern for construction companies across the uk.
- 3:22Young people need the technical skills and industry understanding to enter the work.
- 3:28Okay, I'll say a couple of things that may have been completely incorrect, but that's why it's a phone in show.
- 3:36You can ring me up and tell me.
- 3:37I think despite.
- 3:40Do you remember the loads of money characterization?
- 3:42Do you remember the Harry Enfield character, loads of money who was.
- 3:45I think he was a hot carrier actually.
- 3:47And he just made.
- 3:48During that 1980s building boom, he just made tons of money.
- 3:52So much so that it became what would now be called a meme.
- 3:56I don't know if I even knew the word meme in the 1980s.
- 3:59I'm pretty sure I didn't.
- 4:00But Harry Anfield's character loads of money.
- 4:02So all of the lads working on, usually lads working on the building sites were making money hand over fist during that era.
- 4:12And yet at the same time,.
- 4:16Or.
- 4:16At least by 1997, it wasn't necessarily work that you'd want for your children.
- 4:23So working and the correct phraseology I can tell you with a straight face is on the tools.
- 4:30Working on the tools was not necessarily something that you would want for your children for a whole heap of reasons.
- 4:36Most obviously the physical toll that it can take on you and the difficulty, of course of working in unpleasant circumstances, weather usually based circumstances.
- 4:47So you kind of wanted.
- 4:49I'm not going to labor the point that I spent two weeks on a building site in Doncaster in 1988.
- 4:53I do that with my tongue in my cheek and it doesn't give me any insights or qualifications into this conversation except to say that you didn't really want that for your children.
- 5:04You know, certainly I could tell you the person I was working for that he was a plasterer.
- 5:09Was he?
- 5:09Loads of money.
- 5:10I thought he was a hog carrier.
- 5:11Anyway, it makes no odds he was on the tools.
- 5:15The person I was working for in Doncaster in 1988 sent his son to university or his son went to university.
- 5:22It wasn't what you wanted necessarily for your children.
- 5:26And that's what I want to talk about today.
- 5:30That's what I want to talk about today.
- 5:34And it doesn't have to be your own child, but it does have to be something that you have personal experience of because most of us don't.
- 5:41And we're back to class again.
- 5:42So I sit here as someone who gets paid to talk for a living in a way that could not be further removed from a life of physical graft, a life of physical toil.
- 5:55Everybody writing articles about this lives a million miles away from a life of physical toil.
- 6:01Politicians jumping up and down about the need to build more houses, they don't know what that means.
- 6:08They don't have any particular interest in.
- 6:10They certainly would not intend it to be a job that their own children would do.
- 6:14I think that might be changing, which is part of the reason for today's conversation.
- 6:19I think that might.
- 6:20I mean if you had an 18 year old, particularly perhaps an 18 year old who wasn't setting the world on fire academically but was physically fit and they were looking at what to do next and you, whatever class
- 6:33you were from, unless you're like super posh, you would be thinking, well, maybe you should train up as a, as a plumber actually, rather than going to university to get a degree in a non vocational subject, maybe you
- 6:45should actually be training up as a plumber.
- 6:47Maybe you should actually be thinking about bricklaying or another trade because you're probably going to have more job security, you're probably going to have better pay and you're probably going to have better terms and conditions.
- 6:58But of course you don't know about the rest of it because you don't know anyone who does that for a living.
- 7:05Well, I do.
- 7:06I know you.
- 7:07So that is my question.
- 7:09It's not a morning for pontifications or particularly complicated queries.
- 7:13It's a simple question.
- 7:15Having spent your life or much of your working life on the tools, on building sites, in the trades, would you recommend it to the next generation?
- 7:29Tim's in Brighton.
- 7:30Tim, what would you like to say?
- 7:32I just like to say I think it's a fantastic job.
- 7:34I'm 59, I've been a builder all my life.
- 7:37And it's interesting you talk about the class thing because I'm as middle class as you can get.
- 7:42Cut me in half and you'll see Jenny Murray on the radio.
- 7:47I love that.
- 7:49Years on building sites.
- 7:50And I think it was at 2:15 all my mates would go, oh mate, can you turn it down?
- 7:54It's that Archers thing on again.
- 7:56You'd have Radio 4 on.
- 7:57On the building site.
- 7:58I like that.
- 7:58And I mean you would have been in a minority but no.
- 8:03Suggested that you people like you didn't exist.
- 8:06It was not when you were.
- 8:07If you're 59 now, 40 years ago it was not an obvious path for someone from your background to go down the trades, was.
- 8:15It wasn't.
- 8:15I mean I'm not academic.
- 8:17Right.
- 8:17And I like to keep moving.
- 8:19You know, I like to be.
- 8:20I'm quite physical.
- 8:21I like to keep on the go and it's just absolutely brilliant.
- 8:24I'm still loving it now.
- 8:26I think it's a wonderful job.
- 8:28So in terms of the differences between now and 40 years ago when you started, I guess it would make more sense for somebody from somebody considering a degree, somebody who 20 years ago would have thought it was a
- 8:42no brainer that they go to university now to be considering a construction trade would make a heck of a lot more sense given the state of the world and the march of technology and the changes that that generation
- 8:54is going to deal with.
- 8:55What about the physical toll?
- 8:56Tim, it's fine, you know, it's fine.
- 8:59You just learn how to look after yourself reasonably.
- 9:02I had a hernia operation last year.
- 9:05No, no biggie.
- 9:05And I feel great.
- 9:07It's quite a biggie for.
- 9:09I mean, I mean.
- 9:10No, I know.
- 9:10I guess you're right.
- 9:11What is it?
- 9:12A month off, two weeks off and then you're back?
- 9:14Yeah, yeah, it was fine.
- 9:17So you think for the longevity of my career, and I intend to, I haven't got any intentions of stopping.
- 9:23Hey ho.
- 9:23You know, that's pretty good.
- 9:25And when you say you're a builder, what do you mean?
- 9:28Oh, we got the phone lines going a bit funny now.
- 9:30Okay, so.
- 9:30So there it is.
- 9:31Yeah.
- 9:31Bricky and.
- 9:32And well all weathers come.
- 9:33Hello high water.
- 9:34You're out there rain or shine.
- 9:36If it rains too heavily, I go home and I'll get over that.
- 9:39Okay.
- 9:39Yeah.
- 9:40I mean why would you not want your child to go down this path with guaranteed work, decent income and many of the other benefits that Tim describes.
- 9:48And I am just harking back to that era when it would have been something confined to people who describe themselves like Tim did as not very academic.
- 9:57Why?
- 9:57How academic do you need to do or be to do most white collar jobs?
- 10:01Remember, we're also interested in downsides.
- 10:04I don't want to get just uninterrupted avalanche of positive perspectives.
- 10:09But I mean there's one here which actually covers it.
- 10:12Quite nice.
- 10:12I'm a 32 year old carpenter.
- 10:13I've been doing it since the day I left school.
- 10:15There's no doubt it's hard work, it is hard on your body.
- 10:18All weather conditions, it can be very stressful.
- 10:20But there are days I love it and days I don't.
- 10:22I would always recommend it to youngsters, not all trades, but I would recommend carpentry.
- 10:27It's like a form of artistry.
- 10:29I earn more money than probably a lot of people I know who did go to university.
- 10:32I've got no debt.
- 10:33I have the freedom of being self employed, no threat of AI taking my job.
- 10:37We've built this society that doesn't think tradesmen can earn good money.
- 10:41I think that's changing Jordan, I really do.
- 10:43People can't expect that a tradie can earn more than them.
- 10:45I'm constantly having to justify the money that I earn and yeah, I think again, I mean it's your life, not mine.
- 10:53But I think, sorry, I'm constantly having to justify the money that I charge.
- 10:57When you explain to people that not all the money ends up in your own pocket and they sometimes understand that's from Jordan in Devon.
- 11:03Why wouldn't you.
- 11:04Why wouldn't you recommend it to an 18, 19 year old today?
- 11:07Looking at a variety of options, many of which are profoundly different from what they would have been for someone in the same situation 10 years ago.
- 11:14John's on Canvey Island.
- 11:15John, what would you like to say?
- 11:17Hi, James, just regarding.
- 11:20Would I get my son to do my job?
- 11:23Certainly not.
- 11:26I've been classroom 40 years.
- 11:27Yeah.
- 11:29And my body is basically giving up on me.
- 11:32Whereas the money side of it.
- 11:35Yeah.
- 11:35Sometimes you say, you know, we earn good, a good wage.
- 11:40We don't.
- 11:41If you're on site to earn a good wage, you basically have to virtually kill yourself.
- 11:46Got you.
- 11:47I.
- 11:47If I went on site now, which couldn't because I'm too slow, too old, I would probably only be earning what I was earning 25, 30 years ago.
- 11:54Because it's piece work, is it?
- 11:55You get.
- 11:55You're getting paid per meter, as it were.
- 11:58Per meter, yeah.
- 11:59And the rates, from what I can tell because I'm on some of the forums and whatnot, the prices are not, not much more than I was getting when I was in my 20s.
- 12:11There's something really sad about you using the words I'm too old and too slow.
- 12:15And that would be true of anybody in any business, you know, if you were.
- 12:19I don't know if you were a banker and you told me you were too old and too slow, I'd find that sad as well.
- 12:23But in your world what does that mean?
- 12:25And when did it, when did you realize?
- 12:26Well I've had a trapped nerve in my neck and shoulder for about five years.
- 12:31My back's gone, went last Monday, I've had a week off, I've torn the meniscus in my left knee and for instance my friend, he worked in an office same time as me.
- 12:42Well a couple of years younger than me.
- 12:44I was on double what he was earning when we first started.
- 12:47Right.
- 12:47He retires next year at 54.
- 12:51Blimey, that's interesting.
- 12:54So I mean the young men and women getting in touch to tell me they love it are probably some of them will be waiting.
- 13:01We've got a bit of a shock coming in the future.
- 13:03Yeah, of course and they.
- 13:05That's the problem now think, you know, we can go on building sites, we can have a laugh but in 10 years time he'd probably be only earning 100, 200 pound a week more than what he is now and
- 13:17or day unless they're killing themselves.
- 13:20But it's comparisons as well though because I guess going down a white collar route is not what it used to be.
- 13:25You're, you know, there's not going to be that, that gradient of, of wage inflation on a white collar route when, when, when I left university.
- 13:33I'm just going to make you smile because I can tell that you're in pain still at the moment.
- 13:36This message just came in while you were talking, John.
- 13:38It says I honestly think this would be a different conversation if you had it on a Thursday, James, when we're all knackered.
- 13:45Yeah, yeah, well to be honest I'm knackered now.
- 13:48I've got a sailing and a couple of walls on and I'm wrecked.
- 13:52Yeah, and I'm sorry to hear that, you know I am but, but it's an important angle to get into the conversation, isn't it?
- 13:58Yeah.
- 13:59On the subject of super from what I remember and I was told he owned his own classroom something I've got.
- 14:07Such a well informed audience as you say that David dropped me a note.
- 14:10He said you're dealing in stereotypes, James.
- 14:12The trades are not well paid unless you start your own company and are successful, which isn't guaranteed no sick day or holiday pay for self employed tradesmen and women.
- 14:20You can be sacked with a moment's notice.
- 14:22And again Superhod was the company director and not an Employee.
- 14:26He was the employer.
- 14:28So you're right.
- 14:29Yeah.
- 14:29I think it was just a publicity stunt.
- 14:32Have you got children?
- 14:33Yes, got.
- 14:34So.
- 14:35And would you.
- 14:35I mean, I think I know the answer to this question, but you wouldn't want them to follow you into plastering.
- 14:40What would you want them to do?
- 14:41I don't even take him to work with me.
- 14:43You don't want him to see it.
- 14:45I don't want him to even get a glimpse of this because I'm in the.
- 14:50I'm in a nice side of the building trade.
- 14:52Yeah.
- 14:52Work for myself, you know, I do.
- 14:54I've got my own customers.
- 14:56You know, money's not great, but, you know, it's a lot easier than being on site, I understand.
- 15:02Yeah, no, I do.
- 15:03And, and there is the.
- 15:04There is the warning, if you like, or the caution.
- 15:06It's.
- 15:06I mean, it is a little bit ridiculous to talk about the trades as big as a big sort of homogenous generic constituency of people when there's not only people doing very, very different jobs from each other, there's people
- 15:18technically doing the same job who have, as John's just reminded us, have completely different experiences.
- 15:24So would you want your.
- 15:26Either your own child or this fictional 18, 19 year old that I'm putting in front of you today to follow you into that trade?
- 15:33And from John in Canvey island, it is a resounding no.
- 15:37Gary, who I know has dropped me a note, so I have the neck of a 60 year old.
- 15:42Apart from that, happy days.
- 15:43Huge satisfaction with my trade.
- 15:45And I know that one of his pet hates is the perception that tradesmen are sort of thick or ignorant.
- 15:50That's certainly not my experience and it isn't the experience of this conversation, but the reason he mentions his neck is that he's a.
- 15:56He's a painter and decorator.
- 15:58I prefer to call him an artisan, actually.
- 16:00I.
- 16:01I've seen some of his work and it's glorious.
- 16:03But you know, if you're doing a ceiling or something like that, as John has just reminded us, whether you're painting it or plastering it, your body is being contorted into positions that are not entirely natural and that is
- 16:14going to take a toll.
- 16:16Mikey's in Glasgow.
- 16:17Mikey, what would you like to say?
- 16:19Hi, James, how you doing?
- 16:20I'm all good, mate.
- 16:20What's on your mind?
- 16:22Well, this call really resonated with me because I am a heating engineer.
- 16:26Okay.
- 16:27But I started, I left school and I was pointing the direction of going to university because I breezed exams.
- 16:34I'm not saying I'm the cleverest guy, but always just passed exams so no one wanted to take me on as an apprentice because everyone said go to uni, go to uni.
- 16:43Okay.
- 16:44But when I was there I just kind of enjoyed it.
- 16:47For the first year I was working, making some money and I decided this isn't for me.
- 16:53So I was luckily enough I was 19, so I was a bit old for an apprenticeship but I managed to get an apprenticeship and since then I've been self employed most of my year.
- 17:03So 24 years.
- 17:04Okay.
- 17:06So I would say to people, a lot of my friends have got degrees and they're all high flyers, whether it be in finance, law, accountancy.
- 17:15And I'm jealous of those guys because they have a career pathway, you know, they did.
- 17:20I mean, yeah, but that's your age.
- 17:22I don't know if it was.
- 17:23If you were all starting out again now I think that by this stage in your lives that things would be very different.
- 17:31Yeah, well, I agree with you.
- 17:33So what I think is it depends on the person.
- 17:36Yes, for sure.
- 17:37And it depends on the course.
- 17:38James really does.
- 17:40So I've got two stepdaughters who are just leaving school, right.
- 17:43And they don't know what they want to do.
- 17:45One of them was going to go to university, but it was an arts degree.
- 17:49And I can say to her, I was like, what are you going to do at the end of this?
- 17:53You know, it's not going to guarantee a job if you're going to go and get a degree where there's quite a clear path of where you're going to go in a career, fair enough.
- 18:00But why get into debt?
- 18:01Why not go and get a job or train?
- 18:04You know, so they're really difficult for the younger generation because they don't know what they want to do and they.
- 18:09Don't know what the world's going to be like in 10 years time, never mind 20 or 30.
- 18:13And there's a part of me and the debt is the killer here, the debt is the kicker because there's a part of me that recoils slightly at what you just said because the benefits of an arts degree, a
- 18:25good arts degree, a lifelong and enormous, but they're not necessarily, as you point out, immediately translatable into employability into actual career based improvements.
- 18:37It can just improve your life, improve your inner life and yet if you're taking out tens of thousands of pounds worth of debt, that it doesn't sound as important or as impressive as it used to do.
- 18:46So Mikey, thank You.
- 18:48I mean, again, you know, heating engineer.
- 18:51We're always going to need heating engineers.
- 18:52We are not always going to need, for example, philosophy graduates, which is what I am.
- 18:57Grumps knows what I'm talking about.
- 18:59I'm an electrical crane engineer.
- 19:01He writes.
- 19:01And I've done.
- 19:02I did a full apprenticeship at 17, I'm 52 now, and I've seen the workplace go full circle.
- 19:07I could find another job in my trade tomorrow.
- 19:09My wife, who has a degree, would take months to find another job in her field, which is insurance, by the way.
- 19:15We both consider ourselves to be working class and Ollie picks up on something that you might have expected me to point out.
- 19:22So, 10 years after the Brexit vote, those who told us we could train our own haven't invested any time, effort or money in doing that while they were in power.
- 19:31And we're talking about a skills shortage that we have now that would once have been covered by EU nationals.
- 19:36You may need to put money in your I told you so tin because they deserve to hear it.
- 19:41James, you make a valid point.
- 19:42Of course.
- 19:43It just simply wasn't done.
- 19:44Up to 755,000 additional construction workers needed.
- 19:49And the freedom of movement path, which would previously have brought many, if not all of them, to this country, has been locked shut by Boris Johnson, Nigel Farage and their public school educated mates.
- 20:00Which isn't a pejorative, by the way.
- 20:02I'm public school educated.
- 20:03I'm just pointing out that you're unlikely to be very well versed in the needs and realities of the construction industry unless you've gone to the trouble of asking people in it to tell you what's what.
- 20:15Short break.
- 20:16Incoming.
- 20:16When we get back, we will continue discussing the biggest news stories of the day.
- 20:29Is ingenuous a word?
- 20:32You know how disingenuous is a word, right?
- 20:34Is ingenuous?
- 20:35Or can you be ingenuous?
- 20:36Because I want you to know that I am being ingenuous.
- 20:38If that is a word.
- 20:40If ingenuous is not a word, then I want you to know that I am not currently being disingenuous.
- 20:45You're probably not going to believe me when I tell you, but think about it.
- 20:48If you think about it, you will believe me.
- 20:50You cannot have the opposition to the government in this country consisting entirely of racist grifters and opportunists, essentially fighting with each other over who can be most obnoxious.
- 21:02That is bad for democracy, it's bad for the country, it's bad for politics, and crucially, it's also Bad for the government.
- 21:08You think back to, for example, Tony Blair probably at his best when he was up against William Hague.
- 21:15And not just in PMQS either, but you have a kind of model of scrutiny.
- 21:22I wrote a line I was quite proud of last week.
- 21:24I can't fully remember it, but it was something like the sharpness of Andy Burnham's government will be partly defined by the whetstone of substantive opposition.
- 21:35It's quite a nice little line that, isn't it?
- 21:36So, you know, that's what you sharpen yourself on.
- 21:39The opposition.
- 21:40The opposition is the whetstone, the government is the blade.
- 21:44And under Kami Badenot, I suggested there isn't any.
- 21:47There isn't any substantive opposition.
- 21:50And here's proof that what I'm talking about is both not disingenuous or possibly ingenuous.
- 21:56Is it just genuine?
- 21:57Is it genuine?
- 21:58Does disingenuous mean ungenuine?
- 22:00So I am being genuine or genuine?
- 22:03I don't know.
- 22:04Shut up.
- 22:04Get on with it.
- 22:06I wrote about how, in particular the policy for candidates, which allows a so called reformed neo Nazi to get on a candidates list, but excludes people like Grant Shapps or whatever he's calling himself today, and Penny Mordaunt, potentially
- 22:22stories a couple of weeks ago about household name Tories who couldn't get on the candidates list because Badenoch is obsessed with culture wars, I think ECH and net zero most obviously.
- 22:34So I wrote about that last.
- 22:36It was in last Wednesday's inewspaper, Sir Malcolm Rifkind, who was a Conservative MP between 1974 and 2015 with a little hiatus between 97 and 2005.
- 22:49Sir Malcolm Rifkind is writing about it in the Times today.
- 22:53So if you know the arch lefty James O Brexit can write about something and a grandee, a Tory grandee, a cabinet minister, a Tory politician of great repute, can write about the same thing in the same week.
- 23:11Then something is happening, right?
- 23:14So there is something going on.
- 23:16If two people from very, very different political backgrounds can arrive at the same conclusion about the Conservative Party, then it's probably a correct conclusion.
- 23:27And what Rifkind argues today is that it is profoundly unconservative for Badenoch to block people like Grant Shapps from the candidates list.
- 23:39And so too apparently, he writes, not me, Penny Morden.
- 23:43This approach by the party leadership has no precedent in Conservative history.
- 23:48Imagine if Chamberlain had blocked Churchill from being a Conservative MP because he refused to support Munich and the appeasement policy.
- 23:56Churchill would never have become prime Minister, imagine if John Major or David Cameron had blocked Conservatives from the House of Commons.
- 24:02Unless they pledged their support to the UK remaining in the EU, the government would have lost almost half of its MPs overnight.
- 24:09What he is arguing is that the Conservative tradition demands a big tent.
- 24:17It demands disagreement and compromise.
- 24:21And what I am arguing is that opposition needs to be all the things that Malcolm Rifkind is talking about in order to be of use to democracy and of use to the government.
- 24:32So, two stories in the newspaper today, one in the Daily Mail, move over bin face.
- 24:38And then looking at a by election that's coming up in Wandsworth and saying this could supercharge the Tory revival and signal a reshaping of British politics.
- 24:49Listen, you've thought 15 pages on the Duke and Duchess of Sussex moving house was bonkers.
- 24:55The idea that a by election in Wandsworth, a sort of south London suburb, could somehow, and I quote, supercharge a Tory revival and signal a reshaping of British politics is.
- 25:08I mean, it's beyond bonkers.
- 25:10The right wing media doesn't currently know what to do because Farage's financial shenanigans have, for the time being at least, taken him out of their off their Christmas list.
- 25:22They're no longer pretending that he could be anything other than a disastrous Prime Minister.
- 25:26And Badenot, who has been extraordinarily unimpressive in many ways, but who has.
- 25:33We have to get this correct, who has not been as bad as was feared, most people who honestly thought that Badenot would last longer than Starmer after the last general election, you can't.
- 25:47Even if you tell me you did, I won't believe you.
- 25:48I won't call you a liar because I'm being ingenuous or genuine or not disingenuous.
- 25:54But who honestly thought, after the result of the last general election and the first few PMQs, that Kemi I never make gaff Spadenock would last longer as leader of her party than Keir Starmer did as leader of his.
- 26:06So on that or by that metric alone, by that metric alone, she has actually done all right.
- 26:14But that is a bit like saying that you've done all right.
- 26:17If you get around the course, even if you are recording the slowest time in history, you still get credit for getting around the course.
- 26:27And the conversation I want to have is a tricky one.
- 26:31Rifkin doesn't really go here today in his piece in the Times, he is, as I say, talking about the necessity of disagreement.
- 26:41It's perfectly possible that Margaret Thatcher wouldn't be able to join the Conservative Party.
- 26:46Margaret Thatcher wouldn't get onto the candidates list under Cami Badenoch's leadership.
- 26:51I'll just leave that to percolate for a moment with you, because what I want to talk about is what they are, who they are.
- 27:00You can't, I'm afraid, argue with the analysis of reform and the other lot being just competing, really, over who can be most obnoxious with regard to foreigners.
- 27:09It's all they do.
- 27:10It's what they exist to do and it's our fault.
- 27:13You know, this is the context or the environment that was created by post Brexit and pre Brexit journalism.
- 27:22It gave a green light to racism.
- 27:23It allowed nativism to take hold.
- 27:26It made promises to people that couldn't possibly be kept.
- 27:29And when the people that made the promises began to contemplate the carnage that they'd inflicted upon the country, they had very little choice but to blame it all on foreigners.
- 27:37Again, just different types of foreigners, not the ones that you're told to leave in 2016, but the ones that you're telling to leave today.
- 27:43I mean, it is visible from space.
- 27:44It's absolutely transparent.
- 27:46It's disgusting and it's true.
- 27:49It's not political opposition.
- 27:51Andy Burnham stands up to make a speech about defense or Ukraine, and Farage's crew start shouting about how there's too many black faces on the television.
- 28:01I mean, it's insane.
- 28:02We deserve better as a country, we truly do.
- 28:05And you're not going to get it from the opportunists, you're not going to get it from the grifters, you're not going to get it from the race baiters, you're only going to get it from the Conservatives at the
- 28:15moment, as things stand.
- 28:17Maybe you think this is a little bit unfair on the Liberal Democrats, but that's why my phone lines are open.
- 28:23Because what I want to know.
- 28:25I've got two or three questions, let me get them clear.
- 28:27Because the other thing she's done in an interview with our very own Ian Dale, is rule out any form of coalition with Faridge's outfit, describing, indeed, the prospect of a coalition with reform as monstrous.
- 28:40I presume this was up in Edinburgh, which is where Ian has been lately on the Edinburgh fringe with his All Talk series, getting some absolutely top draw guests, as you would expect.
- 28:50But she has ruled out, I think, rightly, any prospect of a coalition with a bunch of chancellors who, many of whom, until relatively recently were in the Tory Party, but left in order to wash their hands of any
- 29:03responsibility for the policies that they introduced, culminating this week.
- 29:06Someone posted a screenshot this morning of James Cleverly, who succeeded Suella Braverman as Home Secretary, arguing over an issue that Suella Braverman clearly failed to understand was defined by the Ministerial code.
- 29:18Now, here's the thing, right?
- 29:20If it's just reform people arguing with reform people, then it's hilarious because it's rats in a sack, it's a circular firing squad, it's the ground level investors getting unhappy with the new arrivals because they're worried that their investment
- 29:34isn't going to pay off now.
- 29:35But whatever it is, it's just hilarious.
- 29:37But, you know, I've got a weird soft spot for Cleverly, and I know that you hate me for it, but I do.
- 29:42You know, I'm nothing if not honest.
- 29:46And you shouldn't.
- 29:47However left wing you are, you shouldn't dismiss all Conservatives as being beneath contempt.
- 29:53You've got so many right wingers now who are obviously beneath contempt.
- 29:56You've got your honest Bob Jenricks, you've got your Suella Bravermans, you've got your Rupert Watson sits Rupert Lowe.
- 30:02You've got people who are obviously beneath contempt.
- 30:04It's a more important time than ever to acknowledge people of the right who are not disgusting.
- 30:11Your Malcolm Rifkins, your Dominic Greaves.
- 30:15I don't know that I'd put Grant Shapps on the list because nobody's.
- 30:18I'm not made of stone.
- 30:19It's hilarious that he can't get on the candidates list, but it's also disastrous from a democratic perspective because.
- 30:26Because I have absolutely no idea what the Conservative Party stands for under Kami Badenoch.
- 30:32I could tell you some of the things it stands against, but I have absolutely no idea what it stands for.
- 30:40I have, obviously, Conservative friends.
- 30:43One of my oldest, dearest friends is the son of a veteran Tory MP who only stood down at the last election.
- 30:49You can't really grow up in the milieu that I grew up in without having friends from incredibly different and contrasting political backgrounds.
- 30:58And you can't really go to a school like the one I went to without knocking about with the children of Tory politicians.
- 31:06And I don't know what that party stands for anymore.
- 31:10Is it possible that all this talk of Renaissance or even dreadful word, chemi naissance is masking the fact that the Tory Party in any meaningful sense, is finished?
- 31:26There's something about this Daily mail, page 17, full page article.
- 31:31There's something about it that is tragically desperate.
- 31:35Move over, bin face this Obscure South London by election could supercharge the Tory revival and signal a reshaping of British politics.
- 31:45Politics.
- 31:46And what I want you from the other side of the perspective.
- 31:49So you just define yourself, you think of yourself as a Conservative.
- 31:55You are a traditional Conservative voter.
- 31:58Up until probably Boris Johnson's arrival in Downing street, you had no problem whatsoever with voting for that party, whoever was leading it.
- 32:07I'm a Tory, I am a Conservative.
- 32:10What I want you to tell me is how you're doing.
- 32:14And as if by magic, here is Tamara Intelford, who was in danger of becoming the kind of this program's equivalent of Worcester Woman or Ford Mondeo man, because you fit this category so completely.
- 32:26If I remember correctly, Tamara, you were a Conservative association chair at one point.
- 32:32Yes, that's correct, I was and I.
- 32:34Am talking about you today.
- 32:35So what's it like being you.
- 32:39Politically homeless?
- 32:40I have no idea what the Conservative Party does now, but it's not the Conservative Party that I've always supported.
- 32:47What can you, can you describe what that was?
- 32:50I mean, what are the things that would once.
- 32:52Cause I think you're in pretty hallowed company.
- 32:54I suspect Malcolm Rifkin would say that this is not a party that he recognizes.
- 32:58And plenty of other people who were either got rid of by Boris Johnson or who have detach themselves from the operation subsequently would agree with you.
- 33:10But what is it that the party is not anymore, if you see what I mean?
- 33:15It doesn't have any direction.
- 33:18I'm core a David Cameron Conservative.
- 33:23I'm a capitalist.
- 33:24I believe in growth and business, but I also believe in a very strong social system and the community element of family and everything else.
- 33:37And David Cameron was the closest to my beliefs and he always had a clear direction in what he wanted.
- 33:46But Kemi, I don't know where her capital beliefs are, her social beliefs.
- 33:51She seems to be jumping on any bandwagon that's going to make her popular, in my opinion, and that's not going to sit well with my friends who are conservative.
- 34:00So it's government by Twitter.
- 34:03Yeah, it's government by.
- 34:04Or not government because she's not in government.
- 34:06It's opposition by Twitter.
- 34:08It's whatever is getting the biggest chatter on social media or getting the most traction on there, which is how you can end up with conversations that nobody in the real world recognizes, but that appear to be top priorities
- 34:20for some particularly right wing politicians these days.
- 34:24So what do you do?
- 34:25Where do you congregate?
- 34:28I don't know, because for me what's always been Good about the Conservatives is the diversity and the opposing voices and the holding each other to account.
- 34:38If you fill a party with everything that's the same, you're not going to grow, you're not going to look at new ideas and times change.
- 34:49You have to change.
- 34:51And I don't see the diversity anymore in the MPs or.
- 34:56You mean diversity of thinking, not diversity of humans.
- 35:00You're not sort of giving us.
- 35:02Well, there's quite a diverse in terms of ethnicity and gender.
- 35:07There's quite a nice mix across the party.
- 35:09So.
- 35:09But.
- 35:10But I suppose you're saying they're all singing from the same hymn.
- 35:12She.
- 35:12And no one seems to know what they're him.
- 35:14She doesn't want people who will make her think and look at different opinions.
- 35:20My only hope is that there is still some very good, strong voices around.
- 35:24I am Tom tugging hat.
- 35:28Tom Tugginhatt would have been my leader in the last show route.
- 35:33I'm also very much a Cleverly fan.
- 35:37That's my sort of conservative.
- 35:42He was the future once, wasn't he?
- 35:43And Cleverly really would have been leader if they hadn't miscalculated the votes that they had in the bag.
- 35:49I mean, that's a great sort of moment of political comedy.
- 35:53Where do you think the party would be today if James Cleverly had won the last leadership election?
- 35:57Because he probably had more support than Cami Badenot had.
- 36:00They just.
- 36:01They just messed up the calculations.
- 36:03I think it would be much stronger.
- 36:04I don't.
- 36:05Where though.
- 36:06I think there'd be much stronger opposition.
- 36:08But where, though?
- 36:08What would.
- 36:09I mean, I don't think you'd have this ludicrous internecine warfare where people like Grant Shapps and Penny Mordaunt can't get on the candidates list, but a reformed neo Nazi can.
- 36:17So, apart from poor management, what would it be standing for?
- 36:21What platforms would Cleverly be owning, as it were?
- 36:26That would give Andy Burnham sleepless nights that Cami Bedrock just isn't and is.
- 36:31Is.
- 36:31I don't think he's ever going to.
- 36:33I.
- 36:34I think economically, okay, I would understand more about where they were going, where the money was going to come from, how the money would be invested, how we would get our services back to the level they need to
- 36:47back.
- 36:47Cleverly was always one who talked about having the right level of support that we needed as a country, and I'm not hearing any of that.
- 36:55And that's what I want to hear.
- 36:56Heading for a little break now.
- 36:58After that, I'll try and shut up for A bit while you talk.
- 37:09David's in Amersham.
- 37:10David, what would you like to say?
- 37:12Hi.
- 37:12James Long life, long supporter.
- 37:15Thank you.
- 37:16I've been a Conservative supporter all my life.
- 37:19Okay.
- 37:21Basically, I think the rot started when Margaret Thatcher came in and the right wing took over.
- 37:26I supported.
- 37:27I'm 81.
- 37:29I supported Ted Heath in the 1970 general election.
- 37:33And as your previous Conservative leader said.
- 37:37Sorry, party chairman said, it is capitalism with a social conscience.
- 37:42And ever since Margaret Thatcher came in, things have just got worse.
- 37:46Well, John Major reverse some of that.
- 37:48John Major seemed to have more of a kind of.
- 37:52I know, but the thing is, the Tory party, in order to win seats, need to go back to the center and they've gone too far to the right.
- 38:00Kenny Badlock and everybody else has gone too far to the right.
- 38:03The only people you've got are people like James Cleverly, Dominic Greave, and people like that.
- 38:08They need to get back to the center.
- 38:10And I think Kemi has got.
- 38:12Is just saying things in order to get attention.
- 38:14I think she's totally wrong.
- 38:16How bad is it?
- 38:17How bad is it in terms of existential.
- 38:19It's very bad.
- 38:20The Conservative Party's broken.
- 38:22The worst thing that happened was having Brexit.
- 38:24We lost.
- 38:25We lost out on Brexit and Britain has never recovered since.
- 38:29Everything has happened.
- 38:30You know, you lost 4 to 6% of GDP, tax revenues have gone down and there's not money enough to pay for the social services.
- 38:37And that's what.
- 38:38That's the current state.
- 38:39And Andy Burnham has got a mission impossible task.
- 38:41Yes.
- 38:42And.
- 38:42And of course, the populists or the racist opportunists or whatever you prefer to call them, awaiting in the wings to blame it all on things that are not remotely responsible for the problems that.
- 38:51You people like, are absolute scum.
- 38:55Well, I don't like that word.
- 38:57I don't like that word.
- 38:57And I appreciate you wouldn't use that normally, but that's not a word that we can.
- 39:04We can let go unchallenged.
- 39:06I, I want you to tell me whether or not you.
- 39:08You can see any way back whatsoever, because you can talk about the center ground, you can talk about the,.
- 39:15You.
- 39:16Know, the Dominic Greaves of this world.
- 39:17He's not even in Parliament anymore and he wouldn't get on the candidates list.
- 39:21David.
- 39:22No, no, that's the thing I find most incomprehensible about the current plight.
- 39:26So in terms of what it would actually mean, rather than the sort of pithy sound bite of getting back to the center ground, what Would that actually look like in meaningful digestible tactics?
- 39:38Well, basically it would mean increasing things like income tax, which Keir Sama avoid.
- 39:44Wanted to avoid at all costs because he wanted to get back in, he wanted to be Prime Minister.
- 39:49You want to raise money to fill the holes in the economy and stop pretending that they're caused by recent arrivals or arrivals from overseas because we've lost.
- 39:58Money because of Brexit.
- 40:01How far away are we from a day when a Conservative politician, let alone a Conservative leader, could actually say with their full chest, Brexit was an unmitigated disaster and it should never have happened?
- 40:13I, at least, at least another generation, it's going to take 10, 15 years to repair the damage.
- 40:22I mean, you know, I mean, I could vote for Liberal Democrat, Lib Dems.
- 40:27I think Green Party are the extreme.
- 40:30Yeah.
- 40:31Restore and reform the extreme and you need to get back to the center ground.
- 40:35Yeah.
- 40:35I mean, and of course, part of the process that you're describing probably involves the demonization of the word centrist.
- 40:41It became a great term of abuse, whether you were leaning a little bit to the left or a little bit to the right.
- 40:47Not long ago, centrists were the enemy, were the worst people in UK politics.
- 40:53David, thank you and I apologize for telling off an 81 year old man, but I don't like language like that on any political discourse.
- 41:01And I'm sure on reflection you would agree, but that idea of what it would look like, absolutely extraordinary to reflect upon the fact that you can't really find anybody to argue that everything's going all right.
- 41:14Actually, best case scenario, this is disastrous, but it will soon pass and then you're going to have to put some flesh upon the bones of what the future would actually look like.
- 41:24Brexit, Brexit, Brexit, Brexit, Brexit isn't just is, you know, whether you're a Labour politician or a Conservative politician, all of the conversations we have about improving things and making things better, that ignore the biggest driver of why things
- 41:38are worse than they need to be, are at the very, very least compromised and at worst, utterly pointless.
- 41:44I don't know, I could be wrong.
- 41:46Anyway, that's free speech, I suppose, and that is what we're talking about in a sense, the demise of the Tory party.
- 41:53Malcolm Rifkind identifies a loose umbrella under which conservatism in this country has historically or traditionally congregated.
- 42:01And I like it.
- 42:02Although, as he says, it's a risk of oversimplification here, but you're looking at the rule of law, the liberty of the individual citizen, the need to curb arbitrary government and the promotion of wealth and comfort for the population
- 42:14as a whole through free enterprise.
- 42:17And within those parameters, or beneath that umbrella, you can brook an awful lot of disagreement.
- 42:25And yet Cami Badenok is not, not presiding over a party that fits that description.
- 42:30She is not allowing you to become a parliamentary candidate unless you agree with her and disagree with previous leaderships with regards to the European Convention on Human Rights, one of Winston Churchill's proudest legacies, and indeed the net zero
- 42:46environmental policy which was brought in by Tories.
- 42:50So 2020, Cami Badenot would not be allowed to join 2026 Kemi Badenot's Conservative Party.
- 42:58And I'm just wondering how deep the rot is and whether or not the party as we know, and this is such a weird thing for someone of my age to contemplate.
- 43:07If you're younger, it's probably easier to contemplate because you're not wedded to this long and apparently or previously unassailable tradition of conservatism.
- 43:19Is it all over ever?
- 43:20It can't be, can it?
- 43:22Roland's in Chelsea.
- 43:22Roland, what would you like to say?
- 43:24Good morning.
- 43:25I'm going to give you a football metaphor.
- 43:27You mentioned football and I'm an Arsenal supporter.
- 43:30And in the last four or five years of Arsene Wenger's reign, 68, 8000 people still showed up at the stadium and they still love their team, regardless of the fact that they knew we were going nowhere.
- 43:45Now, that's really the point I'm making.
- 43:49I'm a Conservative, always have been, and we have had terrible leadership.
- 43:55You can go back to the Brexit period.
- 43:57You can go back at trying to dance at too many weddings to try and keep everybody happy, to try and keep the center forward Arsenal had, who was playing at 3 o' clock in the afternoon, then flying to
- 44:10Paris for dinner at 8 o' clock in the evening on a private jet and pissing off.
- 44:15Well, you can't say that everyone's.
- 44:17You can't say that word that you just said and you actually can't say that one.
- 44:21So we had to lose your.
- 44:23A little bit of that you're describing.
- 44:24I mean, to be honest with you, Roland, looking at the callers to this program, I'm beginning to think that all Tories are unmanageable at the moment.
- 44:31No, no, look, the point is the team became unmanageable because we were either playing attacking football or defensive football.
- 44:39We couldn't make up our minds what style of play.
- 44:44But I come back to the key point and that is that British public really want to do the very best for their families.
- 44:52Yes.
- 44:53They want to work hard.
- 44:55They don't want to be ripped off.
- 44:58They don't want to see people amongst their group putting two fingers up to the rest of society.
- 45:06They don't want that.
- 45:08So my.
- 45:08I have a hundred percent confidence in the common sense of the British.
- 45:16And ultimately, if a leader of a party can reflect that and make those people believe that they will win power,.
- 45:26They can bring it all back.
- 45:28I mean, I admire your optimism when I talk about football.
- 45:32Ification of politics.
- 45:33The idea that a scarf is tied so tightly around a supporter's neck, it cuts off the flow of blood to the brain.
- 45:40Historically, I meant it as a negative.
- 45:42It's a bit like.
- 45:42Like the way that your striker or your defender could break somebody's leg and you'll insist that the referee has been a terrible mistake by sending the person off.
- 45:51It's a blind loyalty that.
- 45:53That you're describing, but it isn't.
- 45:56But you've gone further.
- 45:57Look at Keegan and the wonderful tribute made to him yesterday.
- 46:01Yes.
- 46:02From two clubs.
- 46:03I mean, I'm sorry, I go to football every single week and I have done for many years, and I can promise you the real supporter is not like that.
- 46:14That's interesting.
- 46:15No, no, I like your analysis.
- 46:18The real supporter loves football more than.
- 46:20More than.
- 46:20Yeah.
- 46:21And, you know, and I'm a retailer and I've worked up and down this country, and I can tell you this, James, that if you walk past a shop and you're not clear about what that shop stands for, you
- 46:34do not walk in.
- 46:35You really don't.
- 46:36And.
- 46:37And there are national chains in this country that couldn't make up their mind whether they wanted to go for the teen customer or the lady in her 70s.
- 46:48And so they got neither.
- 46:50Yeah, I like both of your analogies, but neither of them lead us towards your answer to the next question, which is what does recovery look like then?
- 46:56And I want something a little bit more substantive than recovery.
- 47:00Looks like consistency, not waving from one side to the other because you think that's what's going to get you votes.
- 47:08Not supporting one element of the society as opposed to another, but going to the core of what the British public really want and stand for, freedom.
- 47:21Well, that takes us back to the Malcolm Rifkin analysis in the Times this morning, when he talks loosely about the liberty of the individual citizen, the rule of law, the curbing of arbitrary government intervention and the promotion of
- 47:37wealth and comfort for the population as a whole.
- 47:40I mean, Badenot talks endlessly about things that I would loosely describe as culture war issues or Twitter trends.
- 47:47She doesn't really seem to address any of the heavy machinery of traditional conservatism.
- 47:53Well, I don't think you know something.
- 47:55Go on.
- 47:56Who cares?
- 47:56Who cares?
- 47:57It's about dealing with and confronting what the British public really want and focusing on that.
- 48:06Don't worry about labels, names.
- 48:09No, I know, I agree with you, but that's what she's doing.
- 48:12That's what she's doing.
- 48:14Well, I don't know.
- 48:15I like her.
- 48:17I like the simplicity of her approach and what she stands for.
- 48:22I don't believe she's a waiverer.
- 48:24I don't believe that.
- 48:27And if she starts waving, she'll lose again.
- 48:29No, we shall see.
- 48:30I admire your.
- 48:32What's the word I want?
- 48:33Loyalty, Optimism.
- 48:34I'm loyal, I'm optimist, and I love this country.
- 48:37Well, that's something that we have in common.
- 48:47¾ of secondary schools in England are breaking the rules on food offered to pupils by serving chips, burgers, hash browns, two offerings and sweets and crisps at breakfast, according to a new report.
- 49:00I genuinely can't believe that this is in the news.
- 49:03I mean, I didn't think that the battle was over, but you certainly thought that the direction of traffic was positive, thanks largely to Jamie Oliver.
- 49:13And it's his organization that's undertaken this research that has come up with such grim findings.
- 49:20Bite Back is the name of the charity set up by Jamie to keep an eye on these things and to encourage healthier eating in schools.
- 49:28And shocking is the word that their chief executive uses to describe what they have found.
- 49:34About 400 state secondary schools quizzed three out of four of the menus it analyzed in England contained at least one breach of the standards, with most involving the unhealthy foods being on the menu.
- 49:48Even some things that are meant to be banned outright, such as crisps and various other deep fried snacks and.
- 49:56And sweeties sweets.
- 49:58I genuinely can't believe that this has happened, as you sort of find yourself thinking, what the heck was the point of his entire mission?
- 50:07To fix things.
- 50:08And then at lunchtime and break time, you're only able to buy things that are very, very bad for you.
- 50:13They're supposed to be only selling nuts, seeds, plain vegetables and plain fruit as snacks.
- 50:21I think this.
- 50:22Well, we know, don't we, that this is a British problem.
- 50:25This is in English research.
- 50:27But I can't imagine that Scotland and Wales and Northern Ireland are any better.
- 50:31This is a really peculiarly British issue.
- 50:34If we leave the Americans out of it and focus instead upon our European cousins.
- 50:39Why are we doing this?
- 50:42Why are we doing this?
- 50:44What is it about this country that prioritises healthy eating for children so poorly?
- 50:51I genuinely don't get.
- 50:54Makes no sense.
- 50:55Everybody knows the benefits.
- 50:56We've probably received more instruction and guidance in recent years about the importance of healthy eating, particularly for children, than we had in the previous hundred years put together.
- 51:06Right.
- 51:08And yet in England, and we'll say in Britain, because I will be absolutely staggered, scunnered, if this doesn't apply equally to the other parts of the uk, we are going backwards.
- 51:25We had a little bit of a boost, a little bit of a moment.
- 51:28And Jamie Oliver's original school dinners campaign, which is what, 20 years ago now?
- 51:32I was on the radio.
- 51:33I think I was on the radio radio.
- 51:35So I've got colleagues now who are of an age that means their school dinners transformed in front of them.
- 51:41Out went the turkey Twizzlers, in came the healthy food.
- 51:44And they still fondly remember the massive improvement in food quality that happened while they were actually in school.
- 51:50And then you find yourself hitting the reverse gear.
- 51:55These are.
- 51:56These findings are very alarming, says the chief executive of Bike Bag, Darcy Williams, and expose a system that is fundamentally failing our children.
- 52:05It is shocking to find crisps and chocolate being pushed at breakfast time or processed meats like sausage rolls and bacon baps being served far more frequently than the rules allow.
- 52:17And, I mean, there are two or three ways into this.
- 52:19The first, I suppose, is how has this happened?
- 52:24How has this happened?
- 52:26Given that the national conversation for years now has been about the necessity of improvement things and feeding our children healthier diets in school.
- 52:35And if they remember, for most of these kids, if they're not getting healthy food in school, they're not getting healthy food anywhere.
- 52:40But I think the angle that interests me most is probably the British angle.
- 52:47You know what I'm going to say now, don't you?
- 52:49Keith does.
- 52:50I heard him predicting it a moment ago.
- 52:54We did a similar conversation to this about two years ago and somebody listening in France sent me a picture of the menu that their child's school sends to every parent at the beginning of every term.
- 53:07And your average French school dinner was compared to what happens in this country, a gourmet affair.
- 53:14Not fancy food, but healthy food and diverse food.
- 53:19So a bit of fruit, something dairy, a proper meal, a snack throughout the day, everything.
- 53:24And I'll get sent it again today, I'll find it again and I will read it to you and I will marvel at the massive gulf between what we are giving our children to eat when they're in school and
- 53:34what the French are giving their children to eat when they're in school.
- 53:36And we are separated by the English Channel.
- 53:41You can swim to France if you do the training and the weather is pleasant.
- 53:46This is not some massive cultural divide that is absolutely uncrossable.
- 53:52So.
- 53:52So question number one is why have things gone backwards?
- 53:55And you might need a little bit of insight there as a parent or a teacher or someone else suitably qualified.
- 54:01What we might once have called a dinner lady.
- 54:030345-606-0973 how have things gone backwards when the national conversation in recent years has seemed to be moving everything in the right direction?
- 54:15But what I really want you to do, I want you to put your thinking cap on now and have a look at the British elements of this story.
- 54:22Because I'm afraid that the uncomfortable truth here is that we must not care enough.
- 54:30We must not care enough.
- 54:31I want to look at history, I want to look at psychology, and I want to look at.
- 54:37Is it geography?
- 54:39Not geography as in where we are in the world, but geography as in, you know, the movement of food and things like that.
- 54:45Why are we so bad at this?
- 54:48Because it must be because the grownups don't care enough, mustn't it?
- 54:52If the grownups cared enough, the children would be eating more healthily, wouldn't they?
- 54:56Did you do that thing with your children if you have them where with the first child you were really, you know, you were gonna really lay down the law.
- 55:05Similar with screens, actually, with the first child.
- 55:07There's no way we're ever gonna go to a McDonald's.
- 55:09And then by the time you got two or three children, children is just too tired to implement all of the rules that you want.
- 55:16You're buying a bag of crisps now that is roughly the size of a pillowcase.
- 55:21Where once you would have just bought a small packet.
- 55:24Just the way that the companies have increased the amount of rubbish food that children eat, I can get my head around that, but it hasn't happened in other countries.
- 55:33What is it about this country that explains.
- 55:38I hate to say this because I thought we did care.
- 55:40I thought post Jamie Oliver or post School Dinners campaign, I thought we did care.
- 55:47But we don't, do we?
- 55:49If we cared, this would not be happening.
- 55:52If you cared enough about your child's diet, they would not be having crisps for breakfast at school.
- 55:58You don't care enough.
- 56:00I can't keep doing that.
- 56:02We don't care enough, enough.
- 56:04You know, we could keep an eye on things.
- 56:07When my girls were at school, we could see what they were having and it was, it was quite healthy.
- 56:13It was a private school.
- 56:14So already they're going to be at a great advantage over the kids in the state secondary schools that this research is looking at.53%, 206 schools offering products high in fat, sugar and salt that are meant to be banned
- 56:28altogether.
- 56:29If you cared enough, that would not be happening.
- 56:33So why don't we care enough?
- 56:36The kind of social or the political question of why things have gone backwards on this front is going to involve detail and insight.
- 56:44But the much broader question, the geographic question, the population based question is, I mean, tell me I'm wrong, tell me that you do care and there's nothing you can do about.
- 56:55Because I can sit here and blame it on big business, of course I can, and up to a point I will.
- 57:01But what do these businesses exist to do?
- 57:03They exist to make as much money as they humanly can.
- 57:06And if that means persuading your kids to eat mini cheddar and chocolate bars who get mentions in this research, then they're going to do it.
- 57:15But the schools don't have to let it in.
- 57:19The schools don't have to let the stuff in.
- 57:20The schools don't have to be providing this stuff on the scale that they are are and spoiler alert, they are.
- 57:28And that has to be about us, doesn't it?
- 57:31What other explanation can there be?
- 57:32Oh, I blame it all on big business.
- 57:33Yeah, but no one's forcing, no one's forcing your children to eat this stuff.
- 57:39If, if you cared enough, if you went into your school and, and made a fuss or made a, a hoo ha, then things would, things have not changed.
- 57:50So Jamie Oliver can only do so much.
- 57:54The media could probably help.
- 57:55But a lot of the media, myself included, will rely in part on advertising for unhealthy foods to pay the wages.
- 58:02The only people that can really make a difference about what children eat in schools are parents and they simply haven't.
- 58:12Or politicians.
- 58:15Politicians could have done this.
- 58:17Politicians could have made it.
- 58:18I mean, because the rules are in place, but the rules are being broken.
- 58:21The breaches of school food standards are being described today as shocking.
- 58:26And I suppose in a way I'm doing something I try not to do on the program.
- 58:30And I'm asking Whose fault it is, because I think it's our fault.
- 58:34I don't think you get to blame it all on big business.
- 58:38I don't think you get to blame it all on politicians.
- 58:40Ultimately, what your children eat is on you.
- 58:44Right, Caroline's in Rowlands Castle in Hampshire.
- 58:47Caroline, what would you like to see?
- 58:49Oh, hello, Dave.
- 58:50Thank you so much for taking my call.
- 58:52You're very well.
- 58:53I had two points to make.
- 58:54The first one is that my daughter is currently in last year of primary school, going into last year, primary school year six.
- 59:01And we've started to look around at secondary schools.
- 59:03I looked at five secondary schools last year and one of it.
- 59:07It's really important to me what the food opportunities are, because obviously at primary school they just get their meal.
- 59:13At secondary school they often have a fingerprint and then it's like a massive canteen.
- 59:18And I couldn't believe the amount of.
- 59:20Of fridges with just different frizzy drinks.
- 59:23So many different fizzy drinks.
- 59:24So much fast food.
- 59:26And now they have the autonomy to pick themselves.
- 59:28That's what they're gonna literally go in and pick a sausage roll and take it away.
- 59:32They're not even supposed to be there.
- 59:33You know, some, some of these sugary drinks aren't even supposed to be in schools, to be fair.
- 59:39The, the, the, the, the, this research, I mean, you may have got unlucky with the schools that you visited.
- 59:45The only three of the schools they looked at were selling banned sugary drinks.
- 59:48Drinks such as Coca Cola, Pepsi, Fanta and Sprite.
- 59:50So you might be looking at the diet versions in the fridges.
- 59:53Well, they might be diet versions, but I still don't think they be there.
- 59:56I mean, my children drink water.
- 59:57They have squash on a Sunday as a treat.
- 1:00:00Yeah.
- 1:00:00And occasionally we'll have a busy drink if you go on holiday.
- 1:00:03And I feel I really want to try and keep that up.
- 1:00:05I don't think you can.
- 1:00:06You're going to be like King Canute, aren't you?
- 1:00:09Absolutely.
- 1:00:10Of course, knew that he couldn't stop the tides.
- 1:00:12But the other thing I would say is we often drive through France and we stop at the service stations and the service stations, the food is like gourmet eating.
- 1:00:23So they did the French.
- 1:00:24You mentioned the French earlier.
- 1:00:25They know how to eat, they know the foods to serve.
- 1:00:28So it actually comes from just generally going out.
- 1:00:31I mean, how many times have we been all out?
- 1:00:32And we have.
- 1:00:33But why, why do you think it is?
- 1:00:36What do you think it is?
- 1:00:37I mean, it's not enormous differences between Our economy and the French economy or our history and the French history.
- 1:00:43What is it about this country that A means we all have a pretty grim relationship with ultra processed food or fast food or junk food or whatever you want to call it.
- 1:00:53But B, even after all these years, we still, our schools are still feeding crud to our kids.
- 1:01:01Why?
- 1:01:01Yeah, I don't know.
- 1:01:03I just don't know.
- 1:01:04And I really wanted to stop.
- 1:01:06And, James, I was the person that accosted you in Leicester Square a few weeks ago, do you remember?
- 1:01:10I do, yes.
- 1:01:11I gave a shout out to your dad.
- 1:01:12Did he hear it?
- 1:01:13I did it a bit late.
- 1:01:14I did it a couple of days later.
- 1:01:15What I enjoyed about that, Caroline, was that, as I told you at the time, I was with my boss.
- 1:01:20So it's always nice when someone wanders up to me and I'm actually with my boss at the time, and he goes, God, they really like you, don't they?
- 1:01:26And I said, well, it wasn't actually Caroline that really likes me, it's her father.
- 1:01:29But I'll tell you what I can get you.
- 1:01:31I get wound up, but then I listen and then I'm hooked.
- 1:01:34And I think, oh, I've got a ring in now, haven't I?
- 1:01:36I've got to say something.
- 1:01:37And here you are.
- 1:01:38Will your dad be listening?
- 1:01:40Of course he will.
- 1:01:41Of course he will.
- 1:01:42He listens every day.
- 1:01:43So there you go now, that's it, you've made the big.
- 1:01:46That's Paul.
- 1:01:46Your dad was called Paul, wasn't it?
- 1:01:48All right, all right, thank you, Caroline, and hello, Paul.
- 1:01:51Stunwell Stone.
- 1:01:52Well, there, nice contribution, but I don't think we're going to get an answer to what it is that is peculiarly British about this issue, about this relationship.
- 1:02:00Les is in Cannock.
- 1:02:01Les, what do you reckon?
- 1:02:03Hi, James caller, but long time listener.
- 1:02:07You're very welcome.
- 1:02:09I put it down to the academization of schools.
- 1:02:13I was a governor at a school for over 20 years.
- 1:02:17Most of it is chair of governors.
- 1:02:19Yeah, we were still what's called a maintained school, which was run by the local authority.
- 1:02:27We, as a school policy, followed the national nutrition guidelines, sort of following the Jamie Oliver Turkey Twizzler situation.
- 1:02:37And we always made sure that we had a proper, balanced meal served to the children.
- 1:02:44I think we fought off academisation because I think it's been an absolute shambles for schools in a lot of ways.
- 1:02:53But you see what happened is that academies are now outside of the auspices of local authority rule.
- 1:03:00They can do Their own thing.
- 1:03:02And of course, the whole point of economisation is to generate profit.
- 1:03:07Profit.
- 1:03:08So what they're doing is sacrificing the kids dietary needs for making profit.
- 1:03:16I.
- 1:03:16I mean, I'm.
- 1:03:17I'm not going to challenge anything that you've said because I haven't got the information in front of me that I would need to do so.
- 1:03:22But I presume that there are people running academy schools who would dispute the fact that they're prioritizing profit over everything else, including, I mean, they don't charge fees, but they are funded directly via the state from central government
- 1:03:38and don't need therefore to sort of pursue local council policies or rules.
- 1:03:44So as far as you know, they don't.
- 1:03:46I mean, this research, as far as I can tell, doesn't distinguish between secondary schools that are academies and secondary schools that are not.
- 1:03:52But you would think that the ones that are academies are more likely to be ducking out of the rule system than the ones that are not.
- 1:03:59That is certainly my opinion.
- 1:04:00Opinion.
- 1:04:01Well, you are retired to doctor on everything else as well.
- 1:04:05On everything else.
- 1:04:07What do you think it is?
- 1:04:08Because, I mean, you.
- 1:04:10How much pressure from parents did you get to do the right thing?
- 1:04:14And how much of it was actually just school policy because you and your fellow governors and the head teacher wanted to do the right thing?
- 1:04:21Well, we as governors discussed it, debated it and decided it was the proper way forward.
- 1:04:27Yeah, yeah.
- 1:04:27We presented it to the parents and the only feedback that we got was totally positive.
- 1:04:33Yeah, but.
- 1:04:33But not it wasn't them generating it, though?
- 1:04:36No, not particularly.
- 1:04:37You come up to me and say, we're going to feed your children healthy food.
- 1:04:39I'll go, thanks, Les, Top man.
- 1:04:41But I'm not badgering you every 20 minutes saying, why aren't you feeding my children healthy food?
- 1:04:45I wonder why that is.
- 1:04:46It just.
- 1:04:47It's rooted in the past somehow or when.
- 1:04:50When the kitchen's closed and the most schools didn't have dinner, ladies and gentlemen, anymore, they started selling rubbish.
- 1:04:55And we've never kind of turned the clock back or something.
- 1:04:58I think they just assumed that we were feeding them healthily.
- 1:05:02Yeah, yeah, fair enough.
- 1:05:03And so there'll be parents reading this today, having a conversation with their children about what they get at school and so you don't have.
- 1:05:08You don't have chocolate bars at school, do you?
- 1:05:10Yeah, of course we do, Mum.
- 1:05:11Yeah, of course.
- 1:05:12We have one every morning.
- 1:05:12Have a Snickers for breakfast every day.
- 1:05:14Thank you, Les.
- 1:05:18What a show.
- 1:05:19Powerful, insightful, educational, right across the board.
- 1:05:23And if I feel like that, I hope you do too.
- 1:05:26If you didn't, then why not get involved yourself and increase the quality of contribution?
- 1:05:30If you think that's possible, you can call.
- 1:05:32You can WhatsApp me every weekday from 10 on.
- 1:05:3503-45-606-0973 or text 84850.
- 1:05:40I hope to speak with you soon.
- 1:05:42This has been a global production.