Latest / Conversations for Equal Pay / #1, Interview with Congresswoman Gwen Moore
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Across the board, women continue to earn less than men.
- 0:05White women make about eighty cents to a man's dollar,
- 0:10Black women earned sixty six cents, Native women and latinas
- 0:17just fifty eight cents, and Asian American women, though often
- 0:24reported higher earnings, still face wide pay gaps depending on
- 0:30ethnicity and industry. The numbers tell a story about the
- 0:38urgent need for change. I'm Juline Allen, and this is
- 0:43Conversations for Equal Pay, where we talk with leaders, innovators,
- 0:51and change makers about closing the gap and uplifting women
- 0:55of color in the workplace. Listening to Conversations for Equal Pay,
- 1:08we're talking to congress Woman Grin More today, a trailblazy leader,
- 1:13fierce advocate for economic justice, and driving force behind efforts
- 1:18to close the payout for women and women of color.
- 1:22Congresswomen More, you've been a powerful advocate for economic justice.
- 1:27From your perspective, what are the most significant legislative barriers
- 1:33preventing pay equity in the US today?
- 1:37Speaker 2: Well, thanks for having me, and I think that you know,
- 1:41there have been a lot of cultural shifts where women
- 1:45really do need to have pay equity. They're no longer
- 1:49reliant upon having a husband or can they rely on
- 1:53a husband in order to survive. And even in this
- 1:56situation where they're married, often a woman's page check is
- 2:00really vital towards the sustainability of the family. One of
- 2:06the things that is a barrier to women's pay equity
- 2:12is the composition of the United States Congress, the House,
- 2:18the Senate, the presidency. This is a very male gendered entity.
- 2:25Whenever one party or another takes full control, one of
- 2:29the first things that they do is to either provide
- 2:32reproductive freedom for women or take it from them. You know,
- 2:36it seems like the first initiative that any president takes
- 2:42has to deal with women.
- 2:44Speaker 3: And I think women not having control over.
- 2:47Speaker 2: Their reproductive freedom is a barrier because women when they
- 2:52don't when they have children and they don't work, then
- 2:55obviously they lose money in the social Security system.
- 2:59Speaker 3: Because they don't they are able to claim.
- 3:03Speaker 2: Those quarters, and of course that has an impact at
- 3:06the end of their career when they try to retire.
- 3:10Speaker 3: So from the beginning, women don't get as much as
- 3:14men get paid.
- 3:15Speaker 2: Even when they have the same jobs, the women are
- 3:19paid lesson We saw that with famous Lily Ledbetter case,
- 3:23where she worked on a job literally did the exact
- 3:26same job as men.
- 3:28Speaker 3: And got paid less.
- 3:31Speaker 2: The other thing is that the EEOC, the Equal Employment
- 3:36Opportunity Commission, which was put together during the Civil rights
- 3:41movement to monitor discrimination against groups. It's a five person
- 3:47pound and this administration, the Trump administration, has fired two
- 3:54of those commissioners, so that basically rendering them enable to
- 3:59consider any case. And even so, because it was something
- 4:04that President felt was part of DEI, they zero out
- 4:11is funding. As we know, the administration rolled out in
- 4:14executive order that weekend protections for contract workers and unions
- 4:20that represent federal workers. Women, especially black women, are disproportionately
- 4:29represented in federal government employee men. So you look at
- 4:33something like the Department of Education that was targeted for cuts,
- 4:39A third of the Department of Education employees were women,
- 4:44were women of color in fact, and women of color
- 4:48only represent what say, about six to seven percent of
- 4:52the population. So black women were disproportionately employed by the
- 4:57Department of Education and had leadership roles in it.
- 5:01Speaker 3: I do know that what we ought to do is.
- 5:05Speaker 2: To require employers to prove that paid disparities exists for
- 5:10legitimate job related reasons. You know this was some of
- 5:14the work of the EEOC that is no longer happening.
- 5:19Speaker 3: One of the things is that.
- 5:23Speaker 2: I know that Democrats are committed to closing this wage gap.
- 5:28We have just introduced a bill called a Paycheck Fairness
- 5:32Act HR seventeen. I'm very familiar, that's right, which every
- 5:37House Democrat has co sponsored this Congress. And among other provisions,
- 5:42the bill would require employees to prove that pay disparities
- 5:46exist for legitimate job related reasons, improve the EEOC and
- 5:53Department of Labors tools for enforcing the Equal Pay Act,
- 5:58and to allow these agencies the opportunity to uncover and
- 6:03remedy data discrimination, you know, to prohibit employers to rely
- 6:09on the past salary history of prospective employees, and band
- 6:15retaliation against workers who discussed their wages.
- 6:18Speaker 3: This was the job of the EEOC, which has now
- 6:22been gutted for all intentsive purposes.
- 6:27Speaker 2: In summary, let me just say, Julian, I think that
- 6:31women's pay inequity is historic. It is something that is
- 6:38a relic from the days gone by when men were
- 6:43capable of feeding a whole family with just their paychecks,
- 6:49and women could stay at home whether they wanted to
- 6:53or not. Our economy is now so complicated that often
- 6:59women are the primary providers in homes. There are a
- 7:04lot of single female headed households. Even when women are
- 7:08not female heads of households, very often their salary, in
- 7:13addition to their husband's salary, is necessary just to make
- 7:19just to keep things sustainable in their family. And so
- 7:24women's pay equity is important to men too, who rely
- 7:29on their women's salaries in order to make ends meet.
- 7:32And so it's historic. But one of the things that
- 7:36we have found that has been contributed to this pay
- 7:40inequality is that employers find sometimes will pay different wages
- 7:47where there is no legitimate reason to pay different wages.
- 7:53Speaker 3: We often find that training.
- 7:55Speaker 2: Opportunities for women that would command greater income is not
- 8:02available to them.
- 8:04Speaker 3: We find that childcare.
- 8:07Speaker 2: Is a barrier to women pursuing jobs and may pay
- 8:12higher wages.
- 8:13Speaker 3: For example, if you're in the construction industry.
- 8:17Speaker 2: And the work starts the roadwork starts at six am,
- 8:20you're going to have a hard time finding a caregiver
- 8:24that is open before six am so that you can
- 8:27get to work on time. Men don't with miswork because
- 8:30of childcare obligations, and so we're finding relics from the
- 8:36past that prohibit women from achieving pay equity.
- 8:43Speaker 1: Absolutely, and you raise an important point that women's pay,
- 8:49particularly women of color, being paid fairly. It's critical because
- 8:55women of color are more likely to support not just
- 9:00themselves or they're supporting their families with their paychecks and
- 9:04also their communities. So absolutely, you echo a lot of
- 9:10sentiments that many women and leaders are talking about, is
- 9:15that women of color, it is critical that they are
- 9:18paid fairly.
- 9:20Speaker 2: Well, Juline, I think that you make a really important
- 9:23point that we need to just dig a little bit
- 9:26deeper with women are often unpaid caregivers. They're the people
- 9:35when their mother in law or their mothers in the
- 9:38nursing home. They're the people that run to the nursing
- 9:41home to make sure that their loved one eats when
- 9:45you know, or to visit make sure that they have visitation.
- 9:49They're the people who have to pick the kid up
- 9:52from daycare by four point thirty and they can't stay
- 9:57in work over time to make extra money or to
- 10:00get that promotion that would require them to have longer hours.
- 10:06And so we have found that there's literally is that
- 10:10there is one trillion dollars of year a year of
- 10:15uncompensated care for people who are disabled, who are elderly,
- 10:21for children, and who is providing that aid and assistance.
- 10:27Two thirds of those caregivers are women.
- 10:32Speaker 3: And what that does. Women have to quit their jobs, cut.
- 10:36Speaker 2: Their hours, retire early, and that adds up to a
- 10:41lifetime of inequity. They also, you know, even if you
- 10:47have an empathetic and sympathetic employer, there's no paid family
- 10:53leave for this caregiving. So caregiving is a really big
- 11:00impediment toward women having equitable pay and equitable assets and
- 11:07equitable retirement opportunities.
- 11:11Speaker 1: Absolutely so, congress Woman, what's the specific piece of legislation
- 11:19you've championed that you believe has had the most direct
- 11:23impact on closing a payout for women of color.
- 11:27Speaker 2: One of the things that I'm working on now and
- 11:31we haven't been able to really get it in the
- 11:33Q yet, is I've been working on a modification of
- 11:37the Earned Income Tax Credit. The Earned Income Tax Credit
- 11:42was signed into law, i believe by Richard Nixon, and
- 11:45it has been one of the most successful programs through
- 11:49the tax code to reward work and to provide a
- 11:53sweetener to those people who work and they don't quite
- 11:57make enough money to have that kind of equity. But
- 12:02right now, the Earned Income Tax Credit just discriminates against
- 12:07people and women.
- 12:09Speaker 3: Who have no children.
- 12:11Speaker 2: It discriminates against people who are students, It discriminates against
- 12:16people who are over sixty five years old. And I
- 12:19have a bill called the Worker Act, which would not
- 12:23only lower the age for being able to obtain the
- 12:28Earned income Tax Credit and take away discrimination against childless adults,
- 12:33but it would provide some help for those people who
- 12:38are provide uncompensated care. It would recognize those women, those caretakers,
- 12:47two thirds of which are women who take care of
- 12:50disabled people, elderly people, elderly spouses, keeping people in their
- 12:57homes at the cost of a trillion dollars a year,
- 13:02And the Earned Income Tax Creator would recognize this uncompensated
- 13:06care and to provide.
- 13:08Speaker 3: Some minimal relief.
- 13:10Speaker 2: I think that that's been very, very important, uh, in
- 13:14terms of closing sort of the wage gap. And again
- 13:19I want to mention a bill that all Democrats have
- 13:22been on, and that literally is to enhance the powers
- 13:29of the EEOC, which of course under this administration has
- 13:34been shut down essentially.
- 13:39Speaker 1: Well, thank you for the incredible work you do. That
- 13:42example highlights the tangible difference that legislation can make, and
- 13:49I hope, I hope we move forward with that legislat
- 13:53piece of legislation.
- 13:54Speaker 2: It's called the Worker Act, the Worker Act, and the
- 13:58Worker Act.
- 13:59Speaker 3: Will we need to acknowledge uncompensated care.
- 14:02Speaker 2: Again, it's a trillion dollars and it often it means that,
- 14:07you know what we know in our lived experience. You know,
- 14:11grandmas that literally retire in order to provide childcare for
- 14:17their grandkids. People who you know, work per time so
- 14:23that they can get home because their family only has
- 14:27caretaking that's provided through medicaid or something for so many hours.
- 14:32You know, they deny themselves promotions or their employers deny
- 14:38them promotions because because they're not available.
- 14:42Speaker 3: And so, yeah, thank you for sharing that.
- 14:49Speaker 1: How can individuals and corporations work with policymakers to create
- 14:54a more equitable economic landscape?
- 14:59Speaker 2: You know, I think women add so much of the
- 15:02workforce in every field, be it engineering or law, or
- 15:12medicine or providing childcare. Women add so much to any
- 15:19workplace in terms of the quality.
- 15:22Speaker 3: Of work that is rendered. And I think.
- 15:25Speaker 2: Employers would indeed benefit by supporting paid family leave by
- 15:33providing childcare as a benefit and getting a tax deduction
- 15:39for providing that, And to provide training opportunities for women
- 15:45in areas where there is a dearth of women in
- 15:50their shops, to really provide scholarships and educational opportunities, and
- 15:54to be able to get write offs either tax credits
- 15:59or tax deductions for providing this opportunity. I think that
- 16:05not only would it help individual women rise in the.
- 16:09Speaker 3: Workforce, but it would help the company.
- 16:11Speaker 2: You know, companies have learned the value of diversity, equity,
- 16:16and inclusion despite what we're finding today.
- 16:20Speaker 3: If women want to.
- 16:21Speaker 2: Sell, say, life insurance to a family, they best train
- 16:27some women agents to talk to women who, even in
- 16:31the situation where they're not the heads of the household,
- 16:35often have a great deal of influence over how household dollars.
- 16:38Speaker 3: Is spent in retail.
- 16:41Speaker 2: Everybody knows that women are the ones who make the
- 16:45decisions about what wash or a dryer you're going to have,
- 16:49how the house is going to be decorated, So you
- 16:52want your salespeople to be people who can communicate with women.
- 16:57It's just stuck on stupid weight and undomb to not
- 17:01to arm your company with an army of women who
- 17:09are your salespersons, your front office people, people who have
- 17:14different design ideas, you know, if you're if you're an
- 17:18engineering company, architectural company. I think it's really you know,
- 17:24women are so important, you know, and I'm talking as
- 17:28a legislator, the difference that it makes here in our
- 17:32Congress to have.
- 17:33Speaker 3: Women with eyes on legislation.
- 17:36Speaker 2: I mean, we're the people who should be involved in
- 17:40consumer protection because we're the people that figure it out
- 17:44that pajamas were flammable. I mean, we're the people who, uh,
- 17:51make our family members go to the doctor, even those
- 17:54men who are reluctant to do it, to get the
- 17:56exams that they don't want to take. You know, We're
- 18:00people who find the neighborhoods that we want to move
- 18:03into because of the quality of education that that tax
- 18:08district has. And I know this is a this is
- 18:11quite off topic, uh, and I want to get back
- 18:14to to pay equity. But what I'm saying is that
- 18:17an employer who recognizes the value of the divergent views
- 18:24that women may sometimes have also will increase the productivity
- 18:30of their company, the quality of their projects, their their uh,
- 18:37the quality of their products and also the marketing of
- 18:41their product. So companies benefit and women will benefit by
- 18:47the rise and stocks and shares that the company enjoys,
- 18:51and they'll get greater pay.
- 18:53Speaker 1: Ye and in research shows that when companies think more inclusive,
- 18:59when they have an inclusive of mindset, they performed better.
- 19:03They're bo absolutely better. You've had a groundbreaking career. Could
- 19:11you share a story about a time you had to
- 19:14fight for their pay or recognition in your own professional life?
- 19:20Speaker 2: Wo so many examples in your podcasts. It's just only
- 19:25so long to leave. I could think of one example
- 19:31when an employer had me really locked into his face
- 19:36schedule despite my contribution. I remember once I was making
- 19:40two dollars fifty cents an hour. Yeah, two dollars and
- 19:45fifty cents an hour in a program that was designed
- 19:51to hire women who were pasted wldfare recipients. For I'm
- 20:00welfare recipients or at risk of becoming welfare recipients. And
- 20:06so I was a person who had been on welfare,
- 20:10and so I qualified for this two dollars and fifty
- 20:12cents an hour job because I was a past welfare
- 20:16recipient or I was all at risk of being a
- 20:19welfare recipient. Well, I went and did the job for
- 20:23two dollars and fifty cents an hour. And this is
- 20:25back in the day when we filled out the little
- 20:28bubbles and IBM cards, and my boss discovered that I
- 20:33had a lot more talent than that and started having
- 20:36me write program reviews, having me do data analysis of
- 20:43our programming. And he went to our mutual boss that
- 20:47was over us and said, look, I would like to
- 20:51give her promotion, and our boss told him no, because
- 20:55I'm paying her out of an account for actual former
- 20:59ortential welfare recipience, So no, she cannot get any more
- 21:04money even though she's doing this expanded work.
- 21:07Speaker 3: My boss then went on to explain to him that he.
- 21:10Speaker 2: Really needed somebody to do the job that I was doing,
- 21:14and so they hired another young woman who had a
- 21:17bachelor's degree to do the job that I had been doing,
- 21:22and she could not do the job so much so
- 21:25that she literally had a nervous breakdown at work trying
- 21:30to do the work. And in the meantime, I was
- 21:32doing her job, and my boss still would.
- 21:36Speaker 3: Not let me have that bay raise, you know, And.
- 21:39Speaker 2: Of course, everybody in the story was white except me.
- 21:43So that's an example of you know, being stuck.
- 21:50Speaker 3: And even though the.
- 21:52Speaker 2: Job that I was hired for, my boss had me
- 21:55doing at night filling in the little cards for the
- 21:58computer because I did program reviews that wrote proposals to
- 22:04get more federal dollars. He had really really opened the
- 22:08door for me, and it made me realize how talented
- 22:12it worth while I was, even though I wasn't getting
- 22:15paid for it.
- 22:17Speaker 1: Wow, and little did you know back then that you
- 22:21would be a congresswoman.
- 22:23Speaker 2: Had no idea I was writing proposals to the federal government.
- 22:27But you know, my immediate boss, who was a white
- 22:32boy from Georgia, opened the door and demonstrated to me
- 22:38that I really had a lot of talent.
- 22:44Speaker 1: So that is such an inspiring story, Congresswoman, which brings
- 22:50me to my next question. What advice would you give
- 22:54to a young woman of color just starting her career,
- 22:57particularly when it comes to negotiating in her salary.
- 23:02Speaker 2: You know what, I'll tell you, these are women that
- 23:06should not buy into the sociological conditioning that we have.
- 23:11Speaker 3: You know what, she should be assertive.
- 23:14Speaker 2: You know when men go in for a job and
- 23:16they say, I, you know, I'm expecting a minimum salary
- 23:20of twenty five dollars an hour. They don't stutter, you know,
- 23:25they don't lower their heads, they don't twiddle their thumbs.
- 23:29Because we're taught as women to be you know, to
- 23:33serve others, to be humble, that if we assert ourselves,
- 23:38we're going to be seen as aggressive. Men will be
- 23:41seen as assertive, will be seen as aggressive. That you know,
- 23:47we are taught we have to overcome that socialization. That's
- 23:52always our job to sacrifice and to always to not
- 23:58be a burden to others. And I just think we
- 24:02should go in with the attitude that we are qualified,
- 24:07that we deserve it. And also when I went into
- 24:11the workforce and when I ran for Congress, I used
- 24:16my experience as a caretaker and as a mother as
- 24:20a strength, not as a weakness.
- 24:23Speaker 3: That said, look, I managed the household.
- 24:26Speaker 2: You know, I managed to put food on the table
- 24:28and keep us housed for all these years.
- 24:31Speaker 3: I am a manager.
- 24:33Speaker 2: I know how to manage and keep people healthy, keep
- 24:37people housed. And we all to walk in there and
- 24:40say that this is a strength that I had. I'm
- 24:44the person who has kept everybody from dying because I've
- 24:48gleaned the refrigerator out regularly. I'm the person that has
- 24:53raised kids who are decent and educated because I look
- 25:00out or their well being, and as caregiver, I've been
- 25:04able to juggle things, managing my household, visiting my mother
- 25:09and the nursing home, getting my kids to the soccer gang.
- 25:13Speaker 3: I am ready.
- 25:15Speaker 2: To take on the challenges that you might present in
- 25:20front of me. So our strength and our femininity is
- 25:26the strength that we bring, and that we should walk
- 25:30into any situation and we should know what the pay
- 25:33range is before we walk in, and we should demand
- 25:38our fair share.
- 25:40Speaker 1: Yes, absolutely. Which also, when you stated that you were
- 25:45wearing multiple hats, that is a common denominator for most women.
- 25:53Were you juggling multiple multiple hats? And so that is
- 26:01something we need to keep in mind where we're when
- 26:05we're negotiating, is that we hold multiple leadership positions in
- 26:10our in our everyday lives.
- 26:14Speaker 3: That's exactly right.
- 26:15Speaker 2: When I ran for Congress, people said, oh, when don't
- 26:19do it, that's going to be so hard, and I said,
- 26:22it could not possibly be as hard as what I've
- 26:24already done. I've raised three How hard is this couldn't
- 26:29be that hard because I've successfully raised three decent human
- 26:33beings while I work full time, bring home the.
- 26:38Speaker 3: Bacon fried up in the path, and still take care
- 26:42of everything else. I think I can do this.
- 26:44Speaker 1: Yes, okay, thank you, Thank you for your time, congress
- 26:49womaning More. It's good having you.
- 26:51Speaker 3: Thank you, Julie.
- 26:53Speaker 1: That's it for this episode of Conversations for Equal Pay.
- 26:58To tune into more episodes, welcome to our website at
- 27:01conversations for Equal pay dot org. You're listening to Conversations
- 27:10for Equal Pay