Latest / Booked For Questioning / These One-Star Book Reviews Should Be a Crime
Transcript
- Kaci: Okay guys, welcome back. So do you guys post one star reviews anywhere or do you just ignore that the whole book ever happened? JoJo: Will not post. Marilena: I won't either. Kaci: Neither will I. I'll literally ignore it. a bad date. Marilena: As we should, I think. JoJo: I might reach out to the author but I'm not gonna post it. Marilena: Welcome back to Book for Questioning, the podcast where authors are our favorite suspects. Books are our main evidence, and no bookish topic is off limits. Today we are proving that hell hath no fury, like a person who read a book they didn't like and has access to a keyboard. I'm Marlena. Kaci: I'm Kaci. JoJo: And I'm JoJo. Marilena: Today we're talking about the most unhinged, petty and downright tragic one star reviews left on the internet for some of the biggest best selling psychological thrillers of all time. Kaci: Honestly, some of these reviews belong in a high security facility. The level of crime JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: being committed against literacy in these goodreads and Amazon comment sections is completely unprecedented. JoJo: Well, I've bought an official rap sheet today, ladies, okay? We're gonna break down exactly why these modern masterpieces apparently ruined someone's Tuesday. Marilena: Before we bring out suspect number one, a quick reminder to our jury listening at home. Hit that follow and subscribe button wherever you get your podcasts. Kaci: It's free. It enters you into our good graces. And just why not? this is a good time. JoJo: Exactly. hello. Kaci: We're a good time. JoJo: All the time. Yes, let's do it. Marilena: All right, you guys ready? So let's look at our first piece of evidence. Suspect number one is the silent patient. Millions JoJo: Mm-hmm. Marilena: of copies sold, massive plot twists, global phenomenon. Joe, read us the official charge. JoJo: Okay, first of all, I just want to say, I want to preface that The Silent Patient is the book that got me back reading. And so I do not agree with any review that is a one star. I'm gonna leave it at that. But now I'm gonna read this verified one star review from a reader who apparently felt completely catfished by the title. the book is called The Silent Patient, right? As we know. I expect a medical thriller about somebody who's physically unable to speak, right? Mutism, selective mutism. This is what we're talking about. Instead, she chose not to talk for most of the book, which we understand because obviously the silent patient. and they put that it was not silence, it was a temper tantrum. And she spent $15 to read a grown woman playing a quiet game. Do not recommend. Kaci: Wait, wait, wait, wait. So JoJo: What? Marilena: What? Kaci: they gave a psychological thriller about a deep rooted trauma a one star JoJo: A medical right. Kaci: review because she was playing the quiet game. JoJo: Yes, she was having a tantrum. U Kaci: who has the problem now? JoJo: Apparently she did not understand the premise of the book. There was a lack of comprehension somewhere. Marilena: This is the l yeah. Kaci: I feel like yeah. Marilena: This is the literal clinical definition of selective mutinism. Did they want her to have her jaw like physically shut or wired for cover art? JoJo: apparently it had to be something because they wanted maybe a dental trip thriller. I don't know. not a psychological one. I don't know what they were thinking. Maybe they went into it blind. I don't know, but it gets worse, right? The reviewer the reviewer wraps up by saying the following The twist didn't even make sense because I skipped the middle 50 pages out of protest, bro. Like, what? Kaci: No. Like, okay, you you cannot confess to destroying half the evidence and then complaining that the mystery didn't come together. That's a self-inflicted crime. Like if you are gonna tell me that you didn't read it all, but you didn't like it, so you didn't read it, and now you're giving that come on. Come on. No. No. JoJo: Bro, you didn't even you didn't even read the middle pages that was giving clues like red herrings and nuggets of what was to come in the end. it was very climactic. What do you what did she read? 'Cause clearly I read something different. So I'm not quite sure. Marilena: But imagine skipping fifty of the pages, Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: right? And then getting to the end and then you're mad at the author because you're confused. Kaci: Yeah, well no shit, you're confused. Yeah. JoJo: hooked on phonics worked for me. Kaci: Okay, and I'm not like vouching that I love the book or anything, but you that's not an evil play. That's not an evil, that's not JoJo: Well I did. Kaci: an equal playing field. Like just don't leave the review. You don't count anymore. Marilena: That's literally buying a puzzle and then turning Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: the puzzle pieces over and being like, they don't fit one star review. Kaci: Yeah. And I'm mad. JoJo: mean I don't I don't really think she understood the book clearly she missed right and then and Kaci: Clearly she didn't understand. Maybe it was in those. Marilena: Well, she skipped fifty nine pages, so JoJo: then and clearly if she would have I don't know I we deep dive into stuff if we're trying to figure out okay let is this a real thing like mutism whatever clearly we worked I we worked in mental health me and Kaci we have some background in it so clearly I knew that was a diagnosis but some people don't so it's just like inform yourself like go look See if this is a real thing before you make yourself look illiterate. I Kaci: Or you give somebody a one star review, dude, do your research. JoJo: mean, that is so rude. Marilena: I can't believe that's even published. I I would have gotten that one erased, you know what I mean, somehow. JoJo: you you have you have the right to your freedom of speech, but Marilena: Yeah, but you have the right to not be stupid too. JoJo: well, clearly she lacked comprehension. Maybe, maybe that law, no no child left behind, where they just passed you to the next grade, even if you don't know how to read, needs to be revised because clearly Marilena: That was her. Yeah. JoJo: she passed, high school or whatever, hopefully, and had no reading comprehension whatsoever, no critical thinking skills. So I digress. I move on. Kaci, hit us with the next one. Kaci: Yeah. So Marilena: We're done with that one. Wow. Kaci: the next one I do have to say is particularly a legendary book and movie. yeah, JoJo: Ooh. Kaci: that's just Luda. Every time I say ludicrous, I have to say Luda. my millennial heart. okay, JoJo: Ha right. Let's disturb the peace, DTP. Kaci: so let's look at the modern blueprint of a domestic suspense, right? Gone girl. We all know Amy Dunn is a legendary JoJo: Okay. yes. Kaci: calculated villain. But according to this one JoJo: god yeah. Kaci: star review, the real criminal JoJo: Mm. Kaci: is the formatting. Marilena: no. What did they hit Gillian Flynn for? JoJo: here we go. here we go. Kaci: Okay, here we go. Here's the review. I could not finish this book. The chapters keep switching back and forth between Nick and Amy. It's incredibly rude to make the reader change perspectives every 10 pages. I felt like I was watching a tennis match inside a dysfunctional marriage. Pick a protagonist and JoJo: Or Kaci: stick to them. My neck hurts. End of review. I swear. Marilena: Sh that's really in the review. My neck JoJo: Wait a minute Marilena: hurts. JoJo: Shut up. Kaci: literally. And I'm like, the best part about this was that it was a tennis match in a dysfunctional marriage. That was the book. JoJo: Right, and it's and it's dual perspectives. my neck hurts from reading a dual POV book. Like what? That is the whole premise. Just get different points of view. Imagine being completely defeated by the concept of two characters talking. Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: does she want her to talk to herself? Joe, you're gonna disappear. Yeah. And I'm gonna cheat on my husband. No, I'm gonna get him back. what? Who? Girl, my Marilena: Your neck's gonna be hurtin', Jo Your Kaci: Yeah, my head hurts from this review. JoJo: Girl, I want my neck to hurt from just girl, what is Kaci: what you want your neck to hurt? JoJo: wrong with you? Let me just roll my neck and go off on her. what is happening? i cant i cant That's a good book too. That's a good Marilena: my gosh. That's insanity. Kaci: Yeah. I don't I don't know. it has to be. literally it's one of those books where it's like a thriller book, people go and you don't always have to like it, but the phrase that it's incredibly rude, it just it it kills me because it's like Marilena: How is it rude how is it rude? Kaci: Yeah, you wrote a thristy twiller or twisty thriller, I read it. How dare you put two perspectives? JoJo: How dare you? How Marilena: And my neck hurts. JoJo: dare you? How dare you? And my neck hurts. What were you doing with your neck? Marilena: Could you imagine if they had a really big cast, like the multiple POVs, would that person would lose their mind? For real. Kaci: literally, I think this JoJo: I Kaci: review made me wanna read it more because it was like dual POVs, twisty marriage dysfunction. that makes me wanna read it. JoJo: I'm just trying to figure out how this heifer was holding her neck when she was reading the book. Or what was she doing? Kaci: I mean too. I'm like, exactly what position were you in, ma'am? JoJo: Yeah, 'cause Marilena: Imagine if they had five POVs, right? And they would they would be like in a neck brace by chapter three. They'd be like JoJo: boom boom boom Kaci: Yeah. Yeah. And I'm like, JoJo: boom. Kaci: I I need like the ten pages thing, that's a great pace for me. let's keep doing, let's keep moving, let's keep girlfriend, I I think that maybe she made that more people JoJo: I don't know. Kaci: want to read it. Thanks for that one star review, JoJo: think people lack comprehension and common sense. Kaci: Maybe she thought it was backwards, maybe she thought five was what. But then she threw the rude thing in there and I was like, What? JoJo: There's no way she could have thought it was. No, it's just there's just no way. Yeah. No, you're rude. You're rude, ma'am. You're rude. You're Marilena: How rude. JoJo: rude. Moving on. I can't. I can't. So Kaci: my goodness. All right. What's up with the next one, Jo Who do you got? JoJo: I mean, you know what? I I'm still like processing this dual POV. But yeah. And my Kaci: I know. Can it get better than this? Marilena: You're rude. JoJo: My neck is hurting, but you know what? My neck is hurting from that. But we're gonna move on to The Woman in the Window by AJ Finn. Kaci: Yeah, another good one, another staple. JoJo: So this is suspect number three. I gotta laugh at this because this is straight foolery, okay? Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: So agrophobia, right? We know what that is, right? Those of us who are intelligent enough to know, or look it up. Because it's a thing. Spies on her neighbors drink way too much Marlowe. I just read you the review. Agrophobia protagonist spies on her neighbors drinks way too much merlot Marilena: But there there's more. There's more. JoJo: That's part of it. Kaci: What does this jury have to say about Anna Fox? I have to hear it. Marilena: This one is a masterclass in missing the entire point of Kaci: gosh. Marilena: care of the character. Okay. JoJo: Right. Marilena: Anna Fox is an embarrassment to main characters. Kaci: Hash. JoJo: Wow. Marilena: She sits around in her bathrobe, drinks wine, and watches old black and white movies all day. She Kaci: great. Sign me up. Marilena: has no work ethic. And if she spent less time looking out the window and more time cleaning her house, she wouldn't have JoJo: Hmm. Marilena: noticed a murder in the first place. Get a job. That's the review. JoJo: Get a job. my God. God forbid. she has severe agrophobia and trauma, you idiot. literally, she cannot leave the house. What do you expect her to do? do you understand this is a real diagnosis? I don't have agrophobia, but I don't even like people sometimes. literally, I'll go to Walmart like six in the morning. Or when it opens up, so I have I'm around less people. You know, I don't like a whole bunch of crowds. But to say something like that, What is what what is wrong with you? And first of all, I wanna sit in my robe at home and be relaxed Kaci: I know Yeah. JoJo: and mind my business if I wanna wanna people watch. What does it matter, ma'am? Kaci: Yeah. And if Marilena: But Kaci: this Marilena: but think about this, the reviewer sounds like a disappointed parent, right? I don't care if you witnessed a stabbing, a brutal stabbing, go clean those baseboards. you know what I mean? Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: How you know the lady house ain't clean? How you know the lady house ain't clean? Marilena: That's how she sounds. I shh Kaci: Well, and like if the if she's a disappointment to main characters, then I'm a disappointment to women everywhere because who doesn't want to sit around in a robe and drink a glass of wine? Okay. I don't need this productivity culture JoJo: Girl said. Kaci: leaking into my thrillers, you know? Like she's Marilena: Mm mm. Kaci: like, This this mystery JoJo: Far. Kaci: is gripping, but you know, what was her step count? And is she optimizing her morning routine? Bitch, mind your business. Read the book or don't. JoJo: Yeah, I'm I'm I'm gonna r I'm gonna wear my robe all day and I work from home. So if I don't have a meeting, I'm gonna be in my robe, baby, because I'm gonna be comfortable and it's less laundry. So miss me with that. Okay? Kaci: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. JoJo: And I'm very productive. Marilena: I'm just gonna Kaci: And even Marilena: start sending guys text messages. Get a job. Get a j. Right? Kaci: if you weren't. Yeah, gosh, half of us are working two and three of them. this woman can have a glass JoJo: Ha ha Kaci: of wine. an obvious no, I can't. JoJo: Right. Girl. Matter of fact, you know what? Let me sit. Kaci: Yeah, right? Get a job, Marilena: No. Kaci: Joe. Come on with your two, three jobs over there. Get a job. JoJo: Okay. Miss me with that. Girl, go kick rocks with some flip flop song. Moving on. Kaci: I know. Right? find myself even if I didn't like the book, now I find myself sticking up for them because these reviews make no sense. Even if the book was bad. JoJo: Yeah. I but Marilena: Right. JoJo: right, but the people don't understand these if they're psychological thrillers, read up on the illness because people do have these illnesses and that doesn't make them dirty or lazy or anything. Kaci: We literally just talked about this before. Yeah. JoJo: Like how rude are you? Like you're rude. This is what I mean. There should be there should be a censorship. Kaci: Yeah, yeah. literally we just talked about this, JoJo: So my neck my neck is hurting. Kaci: how I'm going tomorrow to a group of people that I'm JoJo: Mm-hmm. Kaci: not really comfortable with and sure of that doesn't mean I'm non productive. It just means I'm uncomfortable. Yeah. Yeah. Let's be grown ups here. Okay. Yeah. JoJo: That means I'm gonna mind my business and keep it moving accordingly and speak when spoken to. That that's what that means. girlby. Kaci: All right. The fourth one. This is yet another one that I feel like I mean, also they're all divisive, but JoJo: god. Kaci: Girl on the Train by Paula Hawkins. First of all, Paula Hawkins has been writing thrillers, JoJo: Mm. Kaci: mystery, come on. and who cares if you get a one star review? But guys, this one is another JoJo: Right. Kaci: one. I'm just like, what are we doing here? So bringing in our fourth piece of evidence Girl on the Train, Rachel Wat Watson, our unreliable JoJo: Range of one. Kaci: train writing wine in a can drinking protagonist. My girl, my JoJo: Ooh. Kaci: girl, we're gonna take it low to wine in the can. But you know what? Fine. Marlena, hit us with this review. I already like her 'cause she's drinking wine out of a can, okay? Those are my people. Marilena: Right. Joe, I think you should take this one. This one's gonna come really good from you. Kaci: no, she's already laughing. JoJo: Well, first of all, first of all, I mean if her budget is wine in a box, leave that lady alone. She's staying within her budget, okay? Kaci: Yeah, yeah. JoJo: She's being savvy, Marilena: Sh JoJo: move on. But this review Kaci: We can't all have a champagne budget, okay? We're on a train. Marilena: We're on a train. JoJo: listen, this review cut deep for one star. it it's ridiculous. So reading is just so. This is what she writes. The main character spends the entire book riding a train back and forth to London. Clearly, she's a commuter, right? I mean, I commute. Listen to this. I commute on the exact same rail line every day for work. So you're a commuter, Hafa. You commute and back and forth. Marilena: What? JoJo: I listen to thrillers to escape my terrible commute. Not to be reminded of the delay at the station or how uncomfortable the seats are. The book gave me transit anxiety. Paula Hawkins owes me gas money, bruh. Bruh. Kaci: Okay, of all the diagnosis that's made up. Marilena: What she's Paula Hawkins owes me gas money. That is incredible. That is insane. JoJo: First of all, she's dumb. A train does not use gas. Marilena: But she writes it every day, she should know. Kaci: Okay, and honestly, I kind JoJo: Doesn't I try and use coal? Kaci: yeah. I can see this one, right? She's JoJo: That's what I thought. Kaci: stuck in a subway, cramped under someone's armpit, and open a book. I I don't want to read about somebody being cramped on a train under someone's armpit. I might actually throw the book at that point. Or here's an actual thought don't pick up the book. Just Marilena: Right? Kaci: move on. JoJo: I mean, this reviewer doesn't it doesn't even care about the murder conspiracy. Kaci: I know. JoJo: Like it completely glazed over. there are triggers by the rail schedule. Let me tell you, I'm not riding no train because I don't have time to wait. I don't have patience for that. I want to get in my car and get from point A to point B. I don't want to be around a bunch of whole bunch of funky people and weird people. That's just me. Not on a train, right? Unless I'm playing Kaci: Mm. I don't want that not on a train. Not at all. JoJo: f I'm paying for a private section. But you know, Business class, high class, being bougie right now, okay? But looking at the book, she noticed a clue out the window. Must be nice. My train was delayed by 40 minutes because of leaving because of leaves on the track. Come on, bro. the point is it's it's atmospheric. it's explain you Kaci: better have my money. wants that gas money. JoJo: like the claustraphobia Marilena: She wants the gas money. Dollar dollar bills, y'all. JoJo: But it's explaining the claustophobia of being all these people around you. I mean and and the delay is making Kaci: I'm like, you saw the book. Marilena: We agree that this JoJo: it worse. Kaci: I even have yeah, and Marilena: yeah. We agree that one was insane, right? Kaci: I have the book somewhere. It has a picture of a train. It's called Girl on the Train. If that wasn't your jam, don't buy it. Marilena: Yeah. Maybe JoJo: Right. Marilena: she thought it was gonna be about her and be fun and her exciting life. I don't know. JoJo: Maybe she went into it blind. Kaci: A fun psychological JoJo: See, this is why this is why I don't go into Kaci: thriller, a closed room thriller on a train? JoJo: books blind. This is why I don't go into books blind. Kaci: No, I do that, but also if I I know that I don't like trains, I'm not going to pick the book up. Marilena: Yeah, but doesn't she ride it every day? She said she rides it the same route. JoJo: Well what if you've never ridden a train? Right. She writes it every day. Kaci: Yeah. She's got beef. She's got beef with it. JoJo: So are you angry at your route or are you angry at the book? What's the real reason Marilena: She's angry at her life. Kaci: Yeah. What's the real reason here, man? JoJo: you're angry, ma'am? Marilena: Right. JoJo: Maybe you need to get another job that's closer to home. Maybe you can walk and then you can complain about the rain falling on you while you're walking and your umbrella I don't know. Kaci: the woman with the boxed wine alone. Marilena: all right, let's move on. This one. This one is another one that's gonna kind of probably ruffle JoJo: here we go. Marilena: some feathers. So let's Kaci: I love it. It's ruffle them feathers Marilena: talk about the completely divided book tok massive psychological damage to anyone who read it. Okay, so Verity by Colleen Hoover. Kaci: Okay, let this be the last time we JoJo: I'm gonna Kaci: talk about this dang book. God. JoJo: take a sip on that. Marilena: But this is you guys got you guys gotta hear this one, okay? So secret manuscripts, JoJo: Okay, hate me. Marilena: keep creepy kids and deeply disturbing staircase and all that stuff. So Kaci, take this one away. JoJo: Yeah, we we got yep. Kaci: Okay. This one star reviewer wasn't horrified by the dark plot twist. They were horrified by the lack of basic household safety. Okay. Here's the review. These are JoJo: Hey. Kaci: not my words. I'm embarrassed to even read this. I'm a licensed home inspector, and I could not get through this book. The author spends pages describing this massive. Creepy, creaking house, but nobody mentions that the handrails on the main staircase is loose. A character literally falls down the stairs later in the book. This is a code violation. If they had hired JoJo: Mm. Wow. Kaci: a contractor to fix the structural hazards, half the plot wouldn't have happened. Infuriating. End quote. JoJo: Yeah. Marilena: Th so a home inspector, right, gave th Verity a Kaci: Yeah. Yep. Marilena: one star review because the house wasn't up to city building codes. Is that is that Kaci: Yep. Yeah. JoJo: Your honor, I object. I object. Yes. This is, you know, there is some terrifying, you know, secret diary. Let's talk about the lack of drywalls and anchors. Let's talk about Marilena: even know that Kaci: Yeah. was this from the book or the movie? JoJo: Girl. Kaci: Because honestly that's a multi million dollar house. JoJo: Recall nothing in saying that the rail handrail was loose. But the point once again, this is an atmospheric book. It's giving you the description of what this house looks like in the middle of the woods, in the middle of bum fudge nowhere, where Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: your neighbors are like 10 miles down the road, and it's an older home that's spectacular, you know, with views. And you got a crazy ass lady living in it with some crazy ass keys and a crazy ass husband. what are we Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: on? Kaci: So Marilena: Do you think that was a man or woman that left that review? Kaci: okay, first of all, it was probably JoJo: I don't know. Marilena: I'd r that Kaci: a woman reading Verity, I would I would think automatically. Yeah. And not Karen It's definitely a Karen. That's a Karen that wrote that review. JoJo: I don't see a man reading very I don't see that. I don't see a man saying that. But I'm yeah, I don't know. I don't know. if she did my home inspection for a home I was purchasing, I would not want her. I I yeah, because Kaci: she literally blamed the climax Marilena: I would push her down the stairs. Kaci: of a psychological thriller on a lack of preventative home maintenance. JoJo: Honey, my point is if you can do that on a book, how do I know that you're accurate in your physical home You're delusional, ma'am. Kaci: But also, we yeah, and we've we've we if you haven't watched it, go watch our podcast on Verity on Book for Questioning. But JoJo: Right. Kaci: so we obviously have a Marilena: Yeah. Kaci: lot to say about this book, but never in any of our conversations, and we ate that book up, we went through it with a fine tooth comb. Did we ever say JoJo: Okay. Kaci: we talked about the house, but we were never like that stair railing was loose. That's why that bitch fell. JoJo: Those might fall off the wall. How do we know they're anchored in the two by four or whatever they are? who does that? Kaci: we did in that rock ass bathtub, but we didn't talk about no loose scre Marilena: Right? JoJo: Maybe she got roaches and squirrels in the attic Kaci: Ha ha. JoJo: too while we're at it and her gutters are cluttered with leaves because she lives in s by trees and girl. Marilena: remember anybody falling down the stairs though. Kaci: Actually don't but maybe it was in the book and not the mo I don't know. Either way. JoJo: Read the book so long ago. I mean, girl bye Let's move on. Let's let's move. Yeah, let's move on. These people need to be diagnosed. Marilena: All right. That one's thrown out too. That should be deleted. Okay. The next one. Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: Yes, they do. Absolutely. So the next one. Right. They should do that. I I think so. Joe, you should just start, Kaci: Yeah. You need to meet certain qualifications to leave a book review. Yeah. you have to be mentally sound. Marilena: you should be the head of that, Joe. JoJo: You know what? I think you know what I say? You know how when you post your Kaci: No, we don't want Joe after these people. JoJo: listen, you I mean, I've already gone through I went for somebody through the by the jugula. Don't play with me. Marilena: She'll kick everybody's ass. Kaci: Yeah, yeah. JoJo: Don't even get me started. Don't yeah. Marilena: Let's move on. This one's a classic locked room mystery. Kaci: Love it. Marilena: It's The Guest List by Lucy Foley. A glamorous celebrity wedding on a remote stormy island off the coast JoJo: Mm. Marilena: of Ireland. Have you guys read this one? Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: Yep, atmospheric. Marilena: Okay, same, same. Someone else or someone dies, everyone is a suspect. Stranded JoJo: Clearly. Marilena: thriller stuff, right? Not not that's not from JoJo: Right. Marilena: the reviewer, so Kaci or Joe, whichever one you guys want to take this one on. Kaci: Okay. I need I need to hear JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: why this Irish island, which sounds amazing, is getting a one star JoJo: Okay. Kaci: review. JoJo: I got you. I got you. Marilena: It's better be good. JoJo: You ready? Cle ready? Y'all ready? Kaci: Lisa Foley I meant Lucy Foley is another queen of thrillers. So I have to hear what Yeah. Marilena: And the guest list is good. JoJo: apparently this reviewer did not think so, so let me and I quote Kaci: gosh. JoJo: The setting of this book is completely unrealistic and ruined my vacation planning. Marilena: What JoJo: Wait. It gets better. It gets better. They kept talking about how cold, damp, and raining the Irish coast is. did you pay attention during geography class and Kaci: Life? Yeah. JoJo: the months? Yeah, okay. I bought this book because I wanted a fun, breezy beach read about a wedding. Instead, it made me want to buy a fleece jacket. The weather was a toxic. Character ruin the vibe. Bruh. Kaci: Wait, they're literally mad at Ireland JoJo: Ha. Kaci: for being rainy. I mean, that's like getting mad at Seattle or the West Coast for having gloomy, JoJo: Yeah. Right. Kaci: rainy weather. We know this. JoJo: Or going to Alaska and being cold at the less frontier. Kaci: Yeah, Marilena: But it's better because she wanted a breezy beach read out JoJo: She wanted a breezy yes. Marilena: of a murder mystery sat on a jagged rock JoJo: Mm. Kaci: The the cover shows you, like even if you Marilena: in the Atlantic Ocean. Like did they expect the characters to be solving a murder in the flip flops while drinking margaritas or pina coladas or something? I Kaci: Which which, does happen in DL Fisher's Five Liars. If you guys wanna Marilena: What's your? Kaci: jump into that one, that's a beachy read. JoJo: yeah, but yeah, Marilena: But this doesn't even tell you it's gonna be a beach. JoJo: but that's actually beach. They were actually in Kaci: Yeah, that's what I'm saying. yeah, wherever, but yes. No. Did you watch Outlander JoJo: what, Mexico? that was a tropical setting. Ireland is not a tropical setting, boo. It's Kaci: or read Outlander or watch anything that's ever been Yeah. Marilena: That just that that one pisses me off because I like that book. So that one makes me mad. I know. Kaci: Yeah. Hey, it's not even whether we liked or didn't like these books. they're like literally we're defending these books because the reviews are so bad. JoJo: And for and furthermore, Marilena: Are so bad. JoJo: look, and furthermore, it it isn't the saying that if it rains on your wedding day, you're blessed. Your your marriage is blessed. Kaci: yeah, it is. It does. It's money. Marilena: I never heard that. JoJo: Yes. So Kaci: Bring on the rain. JoJo: you're not worried about anything else but the weather. And then I guess you were planning to go to Ireland. Clearly you didn't do your research correctly to find out when the summer season was, because clearly I Kaci: I'm like, did she ruin the vacation planning or save your ass? Okay. You should be thanking her. Yeah. JoJo: If I married to her, I'd be getting a damn divorce because clearly Marilena: Should be thanking Lucy Foley. JoJo: she didn't pay attention to her geography class and she ain't the sharpest tool in the shed. And she's definitely not a meteorologist. She's not a meteorologist. Marilena: Surprised she didn't ask her to pay for her trip. Like the gas money. Kaci: I I don't know. we're here I like this reviewing the reviewers. Y'all better watch out for us. We are cutthroat today. Marilena: We're coming for you. JoJo: Did you know that the sky leaked on her face? my god, forbid. So unprofessional. Kaci: Yeah, I'm taking up for these authors like I'm ride or die. Say something. Marilena: I'm the I'm the same 'cause these are ludicrous for real. Luda I did. Kaci: Luta You walked right into that one again. JoJo: Well, we we about to disturb the peace some more. Now, now, now, now, now, now. We we gonna talk about my girl, right? Kaci: Here this this one is another one. We need JoJo: Before wait, Marilena: shoot, who is it? Who is it? JoJo: we're gonna talk about Miss Frida. Now don't get me wrong. I love me some Frida, Marilena: yes, Frida Kaci: Fruda. JoJo: but let me tell you about some Frida. That witch was not witching for me, but I still wouldn't Kaci: I I thought so. JoJo: have gave her I have it too, but I still would have never gave her one star. It's d yeah. I'm we gonna talk about this. Marilena: Which one's this about? JoJo: This one is the housemaid, so this is gonna be interesting. Marilena: shoot, what do they gotta say about that? Kaci: I hope I hope they say they don't like it because of Sydney Sweeney, but I don't know. JoJo: Well, Kaci, I want you to take over this one. But the final piece of Kaci: Great. JoJo: evidence for today is this book, right? Because it absolutely has dominated the charts. We know that the housemaid, you know, has an adaptation. The movie, everybody like is one of Frida's I I'm I'm not I'm a fan too, you know. Kaci: really liked it, I'm not gonna lie, okay. Yeah. Me too. Marilena: I liked it. JoJo: Yeah, you know, wealthy family, you know, Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: but the wife is cuckoo for Coca Pups, chaotic. The husband is sketchy, Kaci: Aren't we all? JoJo: but foin. Kaci: Okay. JoJo: So is the gardener. But being locked in a room, yeah. yeah, we're gonna move on from that. So Kaci, take take that away. Marilena: Let's hear this. Kaci: Okay. This review, guys, is an absolute masterpiece in pettiness. And I will say, y'all, I can get petty. Petty. I can get there. All right. You go low, I go lower. That's me. JoJo: Yes, it let's do it. Kaci: Here we go. And these are quotes again because I didn't say this and I am not proud of these things. So, quotes. Millie is supposed to be this incredible housemaid, but her cleaning methods JoJo: Wow. Kaci: are a joke. In chapter three, she says she wiped JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: down that stainless steel appliance with a regular sponge and a dish and dish soap. Anyone who actually cleans JoJo: Wow. Kaci: knows that leaves a massive streak. You need microfiber and a specialized JoJo: Ooh. Kaci: spray. I couldn't focus on the hidden secrets because I was so stressed about the smudges on the refrigerator. Unbelievable. End quote. JoJo: O C D. Marilena: What JoJo: They got O C D. She got O C D. She got O C D for real. Kaci: Listen, all three of us in this chat can be neurotic and have OCD, but I didn't even notice a damn sponge, whatever. I am like, what? Marilena: Mm mm. JoJo: my God, I'm gonna call the cleaning police to have to enter into the courtroom to defend poor Millie. Kaci: Seriously. JoJo: Because, first of all, just a tad bit that I learned, and maybe Diddy gave me this idea, but if you use baby oil and a microfiber cloth, it Kaci: No no. JoJo: will definitely clean your stainless steels. And guess what? No fingerprints or dust would collect on your refrigerator. So yeah, there's that. Kaci: First of all, don't be coming up in my book. Yeah, yeah. JoJo: So that's not necessarily true. Marilena: Well I know she's the Millie's fighting for her life, right? Millie's fighting for her life in a psychological thriller, right? Kaci: Yeah, yeah. Marilena: And this woman's like, do you see those streaks on the microwave? What? Give me a break. Kaci: Yeah, that's what I'm saying. No, no. Don't be coming up in my JoJo: Don't nobody care about no street girl? Kaci: book telling me how to clean my microwave. Just saying. JoJo: Girl, the refrigerator, the stove, what does it matter, honey? This is fictional, Kaci: Yeah. Yeah. JoJo: bro. Marilena: How come you do you notice a little theme here? Every single one of these have talked about their the house, like the the stairs, right? These people have n nothing better. They need to get a job is what they need. They need to get a job, these reviewers do. Kaci: Yeah, yeah. Yes. Is it the same person? JoJo: Or the room, these people are trapped. Bro, these people are Kaci: Yeah. Talk about the woman in the window. JoJo: trapped, and there's a psychopath on the loose, and everything is going left and right. I mean, Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: if she used Windex, who cares? If she used vinegar, baking soda, Dawn Dish soap, God forbid Dollar Tree brand soap, what does it matter? It doesn't make the story bad. Kaci: Yeah. the reviewer she literally said the plot twist was less shocking than her lack of a proper polishing rag. Riddle JoJo: Girl bye. Kaci: me that. JoJo: It's called O C D ma'am. You should see a doctor. You they give you well butrin for that to help you, Kaci: Something. Gosh. I don't think that those people should be reading thrillers with their problems. take care of yourself, guys. Marilena: I don't either. They should be reading self help books, I've been thinking. JoJo: and we're quirky. Kaci: Something. JoJo: We're quirky, but we're Kaci: Yeah, for sure. JoJo: quirky with things in real life. Come on, y'all. Be for real. Kaci: Yeah, Marilena: All right. Kaci: yeah. I don't know. Marilena: Instead of rapid fire, you guys, we're gonna do something a little bit different because well it's Kaci: This better be good if you're skipping us rapid fire. This better be good, Marlena. JoJo: what you got up your sleep. Marilena: a rapid fire, but it's gonna be I'm gonna read some reviews Kaci: Okay. Marilena: and I want you guys to tell me what book you think it is, if you think it's a real review or not. Okay. Kaci: Ooh. Okay. Okay. JoJo: god. Marilena: So I'm gonna have to read over here, but so this first one says Couldn't abide the purposeful confusion. Every character made with rubber puppets. Please don't make the mistake of thinking this is a literary masterpiece. The writing is a grand obscurity of such, an overload of words concealed, no plot with plastic characters to match. JoJo: head. Marilena: It this is that is the review. Is it real or fake? JoJo: What is this a lamb chops play along? Like I Kaci: I'm scared I'm scared that you couldn't even make that up. I'm scared that it's real, but I have zero clue what book that even is. JoJo: I have no clue what that is unless it's like the dollhouse, but that they were real people in the dollhouse. Kaci: No, that doesn't make sense. Yeah. JoJo: Yeah. That has to be fake. Marilena: Okay, so I'm gonna tell you the thriller or the reviewer's name is Karen. But it is a real one. Now the Kaci: fit fitting. Why you gotta do that to us, Karen? Why you gotta do that to us? JoJo: she a Karen. Karen Marilena: author I'm gonna say is Karen. So do you guys know who this book is yet? Kaci: I I ha yeah. JoJo: So this is a real book, 'cause I don't know what book this yeah, so this is a real Marilena: Yeah. JoJo: review. Who I don't know. Marilena: Pretty Girls by Karen Slaughter. And that JoJo: What? Marilena: was a one-star review that said it was too wordy. But did Kaci: Literally Marilena: you hear her wordy review? Yeah. JoJo: have that book. Yeah. puppets? what? Kaci: That it makes no sense. Marilena: But wordy. That's that's the main title, wordy. And then did you hear that? Kaci: it does get a little wordy. It does get a little wordy, but that didn't make sense. JoJo: all there's authors yeah, that's that puppets and what? you c Kaci: I actually really liked that book and couldn't guess it. Whatever. Marilena: Okay. JoJo: Yeah, I couldn't guess it either. Marilena: Well, I don't think that really had anything to do with it, because that was Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: just a a bit insane. So this one. Now, this one's a good one too. Ready? I hated this, but I couldn't stop reading. Now here's the review. Okay. JoJo: Okay, that makes sense. Oxymoron. Marilena: So yeah, I didn't like this book. Kaci: hate when I can't stop reading. Marilena: It was kind of all over the place and lacked in a lot of development and continued to throw twists everywhere. That made no sense. But the book was really well written, and it had me hooked the whole time, even when I wanted to scream out of frustration. Also, I really liked JoJo: What? Marilena: the ending. This book had no right to have such a good ending. JoJo: So that's an oxymoron within itself. Kaci: Wait, wait, wait. Wait. Is this a five star review or a one star review? Marilena: One one JoJo: That is a fake that has to be fake 'cause you can't be that dumb to write two Kaci: Yeah, I'm going with fake. JoJo: contract two opposite Marilena: It is real. JoJo: girl. You can't be that Marilena: And it is JoJo: dumb. Marilena: it is Final Girls by Riley Sager. That's what this the reviewer said I hated this but couldn't stop reading it. JoJo: Yeah, that's called an oxymoron. That's called an oxymoron. Kaci: I I I'm speechless. My neck Marilena: That's called a moron itself, yeah. Yeah. Kaci: hurts from where that review went. Yeah, JoJo: Girl, I have whiplash. Marilena: Okay. This one. Okay. We have like three more. So JoJo: I don't know where these people are from. God. Marilena: this says, decided I needed to conduct a background check on the person who recommended this to me. Think about what book this might be. Kaci: I could say that about either of you. JoJo: The book of confessions. Marilena: No. Think of the it's been talked a lot about. I haven't read this series. It's a series. JoJo: God. You just told us it's a book, so now we can't Kaci: Wait, that was the review? That was it? That doesn't even count that's not enough characters. Marilena: Yeah, that was the re that was it. I said I decided to conduct a become JoJo: So you just gave us the answer that is a real Marlena, you just gave us the answer that it's a real review. You just gave us the answer. Kaci: That's okay, but now I gotta figure out which book it is. Like that was Marilena: It is. The mindfuck. It said the risk by the mindfuck series. Kaci: yeah, well jokes on them because that author is not no longer with us. How about do your research? Jesus. JoJo: Yes, rest in peace. Yeah, Marilena: Right. Yeah, that's that's JoJo: like Marilena: what they wrote. JoJo: Wow. And that book was actually very good, very Kaci: That is very that that JoJo: disturbing and very dark. But that book was a five star read for me. Like, Marilena: I haven't read that one. Kaci: Yeah. Okay, what's the next one? JoJo: my God. It is very dark. It's sadistic. Marilena: Okay. Hold up one sec. wanna Kaci: Astonishing. Astonishing. JoJo: I mean, the author is passed away. Like she was literally killed during a domestic violence dispute. Kaci: But no I I have less faith in all of these people writing reviews now. Marilena: Now think older older book, okay? Kaci: Okay. Marilena: This is one star, an annoying scientist and an ugly tall man fight over who is more depressed. Kaci: What? What? That's not JoJo: Ha ha. Kaci: a plot to any book. What? JoJo: Are they baby boomers? Kaci: What the hell I Marilena: You'll know right when I Okay, an annoying scientist and an ugly tall man. Kaci: Annoy is it Frankenstein? Marilena: Yes JoJo: Yes, yes. Kaci: What? They missed that point. That Marilena: Is that insane or what? Yep, that's what it said. JoJo: No words. Kaci: no, I don't either. Like w Marilena: That's what it said. Kaci: that's not a review. That's not even a summary. I'm embarrassed that I knew Marilena: That way. my god. Kaci: it from that description. Marilena: I think it's funny that you knew it though. That was good guess. That was really good. All right, here here's one more. Kaci: I just I I don't know, I'm baffled. Marilena: That was funny though. I'm glad you I'm glad you got that. I think the ugly tall man would have given it away. I don't know. But okay. Kaci: Mm. It's because I've been practicing with your riddles. JoJo: Hey. Marilena: Yeah, my yes, for sure. my gosh. Okay, hold on. Kaci: what in the world? People I I can't with people. Marilena: Yeah, okay, this one, ready? JoJo: I just can't. Marilena: The only thing Miles should be allowed to fall in love with is extensive therapy. One star review. Kaci: We all should, JoJo: wow. Kaci: by the way. That's it? That was it? What the hell? Marilena: That's it that's it. Kaci: That's fake. Is that fake? JoJo: There's nothing wrong with therapy. Kaci: No, nothing is wrong. Everybody should. Marilena: It's real. It's real. It is Kaci: Miles. Marilena: real. So Miles, and think of an author that we've already discussed today. Kaci: So many. JoJo: so many thrillers, I can't keep all these names together. Marilena: Ugly Love by Colleen Hoover. JoJo: Colleen Hoover. I didn't like that book. I didn't read it. I didn't like the premises Marilena: I didn't read it, but I just thought it was a funny one. Kaci: So JoJo: of it. Kaci: Yeah, I don't know. and this is right up my Marilena: And then Kaci: alley. I love reading bad reviews and I think it's funny when authors can make it funny to themselves because th nobody should take any of this seriously. Marilena: No, heck especially if they have no JoJo: Yeah, we we it d we don't take it s we don't take it seriously, but it does affect the author though. seriously. Kaci: Yeah, I know. That's what I'm saying. it's horrible. I just hope they don't take it personally, 'cause they work so hard. Marilena: This one is I can't wait to read this one because I can't wait to see JoJo: God. Marilena: if you guys I don't I don't think you're gonna be able to get it by what I tell you. Kaci: You are underestimating us. Marilena: I don't know this one, they they JoJo: Mm. Marilena: just leave, but this is funny. So it's one Kaci: Okay. Marilena: star. The reviewer's name is Daisy, and she says, Who had a gun to the head of everyone who rated this five stars? JoJo: Wow. Kaci: that's bold. Marilena: I'm gonna give you JoJo: Wow. Marilena: the author's name and maybe you guys can guess the book. Kaci: Okay, yeah, 'cause that gave us nothing. Marilena: Rebecca Yarro's. Yes. Kaci: Was it the four well JoJo: The fourth wing. Kaci: listen. JoJo: First of all, it's about freedom of speech. That is what the book is about. So you're Marilena: Right. JoJo: welcome for being able to write your dumb ass review. Marilena: You've done. Kaci: review. Okay. And also I'm not a big the biggest fan of that book. But also I'm JoJo: I digress, don't come for Rebecca now. Marilena: I knew you weren't, but Kaci: not gonna like that was not a fair review in any for any book JoJo: No. Kaci: anywhere. What was it again? JoJo: You were intimidated. You were intimidated by how many pages it was and you probably couldn't put the people and the dragons and everything. No, I'm talking about Kaci: When Joe says you, she ain't talking about me. Okay? Cause I ain't never scared. Marilena: Yeah. JoJo: the one who wrote that review. Marilena: Okay, I have two more. Do you guys want them? Kaci: Yeah, let's go quick. We JoJo: I I'm I'm mad. Marilena: You won't get these ones, but this one says, I want to burn the characters alive. That's it. Kaci: Wow. Okay. JoJo: Wow. Kaci: That's a thriller book in the making you psycho. Marilena: This one is by Hannah JoJo: That's you going to jail. Marilena: Grace. It's Icebreaker. Kaci: Okay, that book was not great. It was a r it was a romance, but hey, and we're not burning anybody, JoJo: And she didn't have no grace, Miss Grace. Kaci: you psycho. Marilena: Yeah, that's what that one said. And this one I've JoJo: Let's burn your review. Let's burn your review. Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: never read either, but and I don't think it's a I don't think it's a thriller, but anyways, this one says I'm a second away from dousing myself in gasoline and lighting myself on fire just so Kaci: We we're passionate. Marilena: I never have to look at this book again. Kaci: Well here's the good news, you don't ever have to look at it again if you don't want to. JoJo: And the book don't wanna look at you, boo. It didn't ask you to buy it. Kaci: Yeah, right? No. JoJo: Like what? Kaci: First of all, you've Marilena: This one's Kaci: got problems. Marilena: I don't know it's this one. I don't know if you guys know this one, but it's a court of thorns and roses. JoJo: Yes, that's Aqatar. Marilena: shit! JoJo: You gonna come for Sarah? Like what? Kaci: No. Okay. Also did not like that book. But I'm not dousing myself or messing up anything because I didn't like a book. JoJo: Wow. Kaci: Some sentiment. I mean, I didn't like it. Hey. Marilena: She hated this girl hated it. JoJo: People people hate what they don't understand. People hate what they don't understand. Now I understand if you read the entire book and then you have Kaci: Yeah. But JoJo: some issues with it. Okay. But bro, bro. Kaci: But also setting yourself on fire is a little dramatic. It yeah. JoJo: It's not that serious. Marilena: girl, go for it. if you're that unhappy about a book, go for it. You're JoJo: Go be a pyromaniac on yourself, bro. Marilena: it's but don't post your review. Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: Douse yourself first. Kaci: Douse yourself, keep the review to yourself. JoJo: Wow, I d I didn't Marilena: Yeah. So that that was our rapid fire. JoJo: care for the Whisperman, but I still didn't do that. Kaci: No, she roasted it though. She roasted it. Marilena: He roasted the shit out of it, girl. JoJo: But I gave it a decent review and I said about the parts I did like. I didn't be like, I wanted to roll my neck and bang my head and put myself on fire and go do a Molly so I could forget what the hell I just read. What I'm just saying. Kaci: Okay, wait, that last part not as bad as the others, which the one of those didn't belong there. Marilena: Right. JoJo: I'm just saying, I don't, I don't do any of that. So what I'm saying is maybe I should say it made me want to go buy box wine. Kaci: Boxed wine. Marilena: And put your robe on and not have a job. I'm down for that too. Kaci: Sign me up, okay. Sign me up for that. JoJo: And my bonnet, and my bonnet, and just be patting my dad on head. Kaci: my god. Okay. Marilena: I don't know guys. I think that was this was a fun one because I think all these people are insane, but Kaci: Yeah. They are. JoJo: I'm over it. Marilena: anyways, so the verdict JoJo: Well Marilena: is absolute, the internet remains completely guilty of weaponized, hilarious pettiness. Kaci: For sure. JoJo: Authors, if you're listening, sleep with one eye open because it does not matter if you write a New York bestseller. Someone out here that ain't right in a mind is going to hate what you wrote. They're gonna try to find your house code. They're gonna try to talk about your format. They're gonna talk about the streaks, your train schedule, your font. Okay, the cover of your book. It don't matter. They're gonna find something. Kaci: No, I know. But if you yeah, just does some sho go and does some shoulders all girl. Marilena: And let it roll off the shoulder. JoJo: Gone, does your shoulders if you're feeling like a pimp girl, go and brush your shoulders off. Marilena: Ha ha Kaci: Going to shoulders off. Yeah. But if you want to submit your own bookish evidence or flag a criminal one star review you found in the world, JoJo: Yeah. Kaci: come find us on TikTok and Instagram at Booked for Questioning. JoJo: And look, we won't judge your reading habits, but we will question them. Kaci: All of them. JoJo: Leave us a five star, and I mean a five star review, not Kaci: huh. JoJo: no one, no two. If it ain't five, don't leave nothing, okay? So you can leave a review for us Marilena: And we're coming for you if you do leave anything less. Kaci: Yeah. JoJo: on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, unless you're switching between the three of our voices and your neck hurts. Marilena: If it does, then just go get some boxed wine and chill the hell out. Kaci: Yeah. We'll all hang out in our robes, look out the window, see what's going on in the world. JoJo: And once again, ladies and audience, you've been booked for questioning. Bye! Marilena: input for questioning. Bye. Kaci: for questioning. Bye.